One of the sign of the Day of Judgement is that people would reject the Sunnah. The Sunnah is important to interpreting the Quran because people can interpret it however they like. Umar ibn Al Khattab talks about this. We need to follow how the Prophet peace be upon him interpreted since he is our example.
@@theyoungdaee7155 Quran doesn't need a book to be interpretated. God himself said "in the Quran they are words that have complicated meaning, the believers know that's it's from God and believe it but those who don't believe always ask what does God mean by that and try looking for the meaning while only God himself knows the meaning. ". How can you believe in a book written by people who can years after the death of the prophet, and leave the Quran that is straight from God ?
Mashallah! May Allah guide us all to revert back to Quran! In the first chapter of Quran, we ask God to guide us in the straight path! If one sincerely concentrates and focuses on the first chapter (which we should be doing if we pray five times a day) and asks sincerely to the Creator for guidance, I can’t believe that a person will not get guidance from Quran! The key is sincerity and trust in God (faith on the Creator!)! So when one sincerely asks God, the Creator provides answer right in the very next chapter (at the beginning of Chapter 2) of the Quran that, it is the Quran in which there is Guidance what you have asked for! So why go looking for guidance elsewhere while there is direct guidance provided by our Lord (the main and the only source of all guidance) the Creator Himself in the Quran and assurance provided by Him therein!
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow. QURAN 31-6 And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge. ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist. If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers. Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay. ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever. Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
If only yall put the amount of concentration while reading the Quran as you put when reading man made books, it will not be difficult to understand the holy Quran, the main source of Islam, which is alone enough than millions of man made books. No one can explain to you Allah's words better than Allah himself
I seriously don't understand how people think that quran is not enough and fully explained/detailed. Allah send the quran for whole humankind not just for "sheikhs" etc. Literally everyone at my place is being mislead by so called "imams", they believe whatever they say without using their own reasoning...
I hope you are putting your concentration on reading Quran. But I don’t understand if you did, how would you be a follower of Arijit Singh and his picture in your profile. Most of his song lyrics contains shirk, and which goes sharply against Quran- the words of Allah.
@@ashraful2010 most of his songs does not contain shirk. Some do which I avoid. And how do you know if most of the songs do if you aren’t a follower of him? How come you listen to most of his songs? Gotcha. I am not a follower of him. I am a fan. This has nothing to do with Islam. Islam did not say that you cannot be a fan of anyone. Please don’t teach me false things. And mind your own business. If you don’t commit any sins and are a saint then Allah will reward you. Don’t try to judge the faith of others because that is very haram
@furkanyilmaz8552 Qur'an is fully explained and detailed; however, Allah says in the Qur'an that Muslims must obey the Prophet SAW. How are we supposed to obey him if we don't know any of his actions and words? That's why you have to look at the sahih hadith
Oh you sure about that? So all those verses of Quran which clearly state that Allah gave the Prophet revelation that was not in the Quran is what exactly?
Mik K which revelations ?? And Bukhari his book is not the revelation from Allah the Most Highest to Prophet Muhammed (pbuh) Its a man made book and to believe it fully is too trust all the narrators and the ones who told them and from whom they heard it and bukhari plus the scholars that decide the authenticity and dont forget that satan would definitely mingle. Don’t get us wrong we trust the Prophet he is trustworthy one of the chosen but all the other people involved in hadiths make it the words of them and the best way is to go to the source of the Most Trustworthy, thats the Glorious Quran. Praise Allah the Most Praiseworthy.
@@floodworldwide5260 If you do not understand the sciences of hadith which you very likely do not, then you are not in any position to be speaking about reliability. What is fabricated and very weak is known. What is authentic and acceptable is known - everything in Bukhari meets the highest of standards in every regards as far as sciences of hadith go. It is the best of the best as far as authenticity goes. Those who attack him are ignorant modernist fools. So they resort to slandering him instead because they are not capable of refuting his work, because in order to do so, they'd need to understand Quran to the level people like him did, have mastery over the arabic language, mastery over the sciences of hadith and real eemaan and taqwa.
Mik K You have no knowledge of the Quran, I dont need the hadith alhamdulilah praise Allah the Most Highest for blessing me with understanding, knowledge and trust in Him alone. Allah the Most Wise will judge between us all. I wish you the best brother and in shaa Allah one day all the branches go back to the origin: the Quran and finally become a huge tree, in shaa Allah
I follow only the Qur'an but your logic is keen and your manner is Peaceful, and for this I am Grateful. I love your videos. Jazak Allah Khair Brother and Sister.
You cannot be a Muslim and reject all the Sahih Hadith. Allah says in the Qur'an to Obey Him and His messenger. How are you going to Obey the Prophet SAW if you don't look at the Saheeh Hadith? How are you going to know how to pray if you only look at the Qur'an? Yes, the Qur'an is Allah's words and the ultimate divine commands; however, that does not mean you can just totally not follow the Sahih hadith as that would be not following the way of Muhammad SAW which would be against Allah's command in the Qur'an.
But Allah(SWT) gave us the Quran and said to follow his messenger before hadiths existed. Hadiths came 200 years after the death of prophet Muhammad(saw).
@loveboxing162hman2 no, this is a common misconception. Hadiths were written during the time of Prophet Muhammad SAW and the right after his passing away amongst his closest Companions. Hadiths were COMPILED 200 years after the Prophet pbuh. Bulhari merely made it easier to access authentic hadith by putting them all in one book.
@@ahabarhossain773 You are right, people have been collecting hadith even in the prophets time. But the reasaon why they were not compiled is because our prophet never wished for them to be compiled. We should focus our worship on god and follow the holy scripture. The sahaba were also not keen on hadith compilation. But islam corrupted as soon as people started narrating. While some narrations may be true, a good chunk will be completely false aswell. And no human has the capacity to 100% verify the authenticity. There are also sahih hadith, that are against hadith. How do you explain those? Isn't that a bit paradox?
+Fitim Krasniqi Let him speak dear :) i've even heard more bad compliments towards my faith. it's just as usual one. But thank you for a humble support ^_^
My problem with the speaker is that he twists the Quran. Allah says obey the messenger. However when the messenger dies, he can't be followed any longer and bukhari is not a substitute. He can't let go of hadith for some reason
Wow im impressed. I wasnt expecting the kind of answer he gave. I was thinking he would say something along the lines of "you cant be a muslim if you reject hadith, only disbelievers do not follow the prophet". Instead he actually answered some of my questions and actually discussed some of my concerns. I appreciate it. Thank you for this video! Alhamduliah :D
You can NEVER be a Muslim if you made ouright rejections of Hadees, so remember that. Hadees is as important as the Prophet Mohammad Sallalahu alaihe wassalam blessed presence was and remain so, for spreading Islam and making it practicably applicable for the Ummah so we could have never known about Quran or its authenticity, had it not been preserved by the same people who actually preserved Hadees, and there are many places in Quran where Allah SWT asked us to follow the teaching as well as explanation of the Prophet (saw). Allah says in 3:164, "Allah has surely blessed the believers with His favours when He raised in their midst a messenger from amongst themselves, who RECITES to them His verses and makes them PURE and TEACHES them the Book and the WISDOM, while they were earlier in in the open error". So, why on earth was Rasool ullah sent to the mankind when Allah would have made Angel Gabriel AS do it by following the commandments of Allah SWT and just passing it on to us? But Allah chose Prophets amongst us who were sent to recite us the verses of Allah, teach their meanings, teach their wisdom (the real treasure of Quran) and purify those who were close to them to make them an example for the rest of the Ummah to follow suit.
@the Jinn and here we have another self proclaimed delusional so called scholar Remind us o great one, which aya u refering to that says hadith are not important
@@TheViperDawg www.quranaloneislam.net/hadiths-the-cancer-of-islam Here is an article which goes in depth on few aspects on this topic submission.org/Why_Quran_Alone.html Here you will find dozens of surah that make it clear that the quran is the only authentic revelation of Allah. The hadiths are not the revelations of Muhammed about Allah, but of random scholars about Mohammed,though they did not even know him. The Quran tells us to listen to Muhammed, because the Quran was revealed to us by him, not because his alleged lifestories are a better guide to live than the quran. Challenge your beliefs on this, because even if you are ignorantly wrong, you will end in hell for directly and knowingly challenging the word and authority of Allah. You idolize Mohammed instead of giving all praise to Allah. Believing and idolizing are two different things, we are told to believe in Mohammed as the prophet and revealer and in the revelation of Allah (quran).
I think the system of belief of the majority of the people could be summed up with this: [Verse 2.170] ..."They say: "Nay! we shall follow the ways of our fathers."... Hence why most people go by whatever is the prevailing system of thought in their general surroundings. Sunni Muslim in the Middle East, Christian/Atheist in the West, Buddhist/Hindu in the East and so on... In a sense they're all following the one and the same religion, "The Religion of Their Fathers". ;)
brother we all know well no one can be able to put quran into perfect order. Because it was revealed in diferent moment. Sunnah and pratice of prophet Muhammad pbuh Is quran in action and order. That why all those hadith which tell us how prophet pbuh act and do not contradict quran and where narrated by diferent companion are good hadith. And All those hadith which contradicte quran we must reject them. And All those hadith which where narrated by single narrator from one chain We must doubt or reject them. Because whaterver prophet pbuh teach He pbuh made it public.
@Eugen Lang Dont be egnorant. Read well what i have writen. This 6 year old mariage is one of hadith. Theys another hadith with diferent age. Some says it was 16 and not 6.
[Quran 7:187] They ask you about the Hour, "When will it come?" Say, "Knowledge of it rests with my Lord. None can reveal its coming except He. It weighs heavily on the heavens and the earth. It will not come upon you except suddenly." They ask you as if you are responsible for it. Say, "Knowledge of it rests with God," but most people do not know. [Quran 7:188] Say, "I have no control over any benefit or harm to myself, except as God wills. Had I known the future, I would have acquired much good, and no harm would have touched me. I am only a warner, and a herald of good news to a people who believe."
where did Allah swt command in the Quran for people to compile information about what the Prophet Mohammad pbuh said and done etc ? If it is so important and associated with our Deen wouldnt Allah swt command the Prophets companions etc to record what the Prophet was saying and doing and command it to be legislation, Allah the almighty doesnt do things halfway and surely didnt send revelation that would be unclear and leave hanging in limbo with out Deen
@@sal_strazzullo Allah ordered Muhammad (saw) to write the Quran? I can prove you wrong. Believe, then, in God and His Messenger - the unlettered Prophet who believes in God and His words - and follow him, so that you might find guidance! (7:158)
@@0m4r21o Hello, thanks for replying. I know that verse, if you look at the various English translations, not all of them translate that word to "illiterate", some say that it means "Gentile" (according to how that same word is used in other parts of the book)
An English translation of the Quran - 12:111 In their stories is a lesson for those who possess intelligence. It is not a narration that has been invented, but an authentication of what is between his hands and a detailing of all things, and a guidance and a mercy for a people who believe. 6:114 "Shall I seek other than God as a judge when He has sent down to you the Book fully detailed?" Those to whom We have given the Book know it is sent down from your Lord with the truth; so do not be of those who have doubt. 6:115 And the word of your Lord has been completed with truth and justice; there is no changing His words. He is the Hearer, the Knower. 6:116 And if you obey most of those on the earth they will lead you away from the path of God; that is because they follow conjecture, and that is because they only guess.
@@muhammedaydn8610 Also scholars use hadiths to impose their power on people, and then claim that's it's true words of the prophet, to force people into submitting to them instead of God
Bukhari collected 400 THOUSAND hadeeths according to his own book and only 7 thousand made it as "saheeh" and even those contradict each other and the quran! That tells you everything.
The quran also mention in (45:6)These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement(Hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe?
Mofi Lilee I think sister Salma Ismail is apparently more educated that the commentator who tried to degrade a fellow. It is the greatness of the lady that she did not feel essential to respond further... I appreciate the civilized behavior The aayat is clear like bright sunny day. It says "These are the verses of God We convey to you with truth. Then, in what HADITH, if not in God and His verses, will they believe?" Means any addition to these words should not be believed . Period ! In my opinion if anyone derives a meaning that it is not about Hadees e Mohammadi and is only about " any words/speeches/talks" even then it means that one should not believe anything in addition to the words of Quran. Quran assures dignity of every soul. Everyone is equally respectable. I again say that using such defamatory comments about the person who only tries to express an idea/ point of view, can not be undermined like this, nor the truth can be reduced by such an attempt. It only exposes the stature of the person who commits such an act. and who considers himself an authority. whereas no one is authority except God Almighty. regard and respect to all
lahasil100 In reference to Salama Ismail's not responding to Mofi Lilee you wrote; "It is the greatness of the lady that she did not feel essential to respond further..." Maybe, just maybe.....she cant! But you didn't confirm that with her did you? Or are you assuming again? Please, unless you confirm something, don't make up things by your own desires/conjectures. Especially since that's what you claim happened with ahadith compilation. You know what that will make you......;) And I've got to tackle this one with a question. You wrote; "no one is authority except God Almighty." Then, who is Allah referring to in the Quran when He swt, said; 4:59-{O you who believe, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and THOSE IN AUTHORITY among you}? You? Gee, I wonder.......
Sayf Oz lahasil100 hezbollahnyc [Quran 7:185] Have they not looked at the dominion of the heavens and the earth, and all the things God has created? Does it ever occur to them that the end of their life may be near? Which HADITH, besides this (Quran) do they believe in? [Quran 31:6] Among the people, there are those who uphold baseless HADITH, and thus divert others from the path of God without knowledge, and take it in vain. These have incurred a shameful retribution. [Quran 39:23] God has revealed herein the BEST HADITH; a book that is consistent and points out both ways (to heaven and hell). The skins of those who reverence their Lord cringe therefrom, then their skins and their hearts soften up for God's message. Such is God's guidance; he bestows it upon whomever He wills. As for those sent astray by God, nothing can guide them. [Quran 45:6] These are God's revelations (Quran) that we recite to you truthfully. In which HADITH other than God and His revelations do they believe? [Quran 52:34] Let them produce a HADITH like this (Quran) if they are truthful. [Quran 68:44] Therefore, let Me deal with those who reject this HADITH(Quran); we will lead them on whence they never perceive. [Quran 77:50] Which HADITH other than this do they uphold?
TO sayf Oz Read again and you will see that you are the one who talks out with no knowledge. iam only giving examples from the quran which makes it clair that this book of god is complete and fully detailed and doesnt need anything beside it of any sayings, hadith or whatever. [6:114] Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed? Those who received the scripture recognize that it has been revealed from your Lord, truthfully. You shall not harbor any doubt.
Salama Ismail 6 months later only to repeat the same Ayat but you still can not answer our questions relating to the Quran alone. How very pathetic indeed. We've heard this all before and this was no come back my dear. Get real and go away, please.
In the Quran, 4th Surah Nisa, Ayat/Verse Number 80 (Quran 4:80) من يطع ٱلرسول فقد أطاع ٱلله ومن تولى فما أرسلناك عليهم حفيظا Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah, and whoever turns away, We have not sent you as a guardian over them.
@@w00lywarriorofficial it says "obey the messenger" not obey anyone who comes in centuries later and claims to have traditions of messenger, even though those traditions are anti-Quranic. don't fix a lie on the messenger and Allah.
@@asr2009 The hadith traditions were followed widely and numerously since the prophet lived, and it continued after his death through his companions. Go check Histroy on an academic level instead of copying statements made by degenerate "Quranist" people who have no idea what they're talking about and morely contradicts themselves.
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow. QURAN 31-6 And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge. ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist. If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers. Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay. ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever. Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
Holy Quran 17:89 ------------------- And We have certainly diversified for the people in this Qur'an from every [kind] of example, but most of the people refused [anything] except disbelief.
"In the Name of God the Most beneficent the Most Merciful" This is what the suni scholar said and I Quote: "This shows the the Prophet role and function included EXPLAINING the Quran." [Quran 75:16-19] Do not move your tongue to hasten it. It is we who will collect it into Quran. Once we recite it, you shall follow such a Quran. Then it is WE who will EXPLAIN it. So God Stopped Muhammad from explaining the Quran, It was only God's duty to explain it. So I guess suni scholars make make horrible mistakes! And Following the Quran alone is following what Muhammad said. Which is to follow nothing else other than the Quran alone. He did this until he died. And corrupted suni's 250 years after Muhammad's death created hadith books and attributed to the Prophet to make a small gain. [Quran 25:30] The messenger said (on the Day of Judgment), "My Lord, my people have DESERTED this Quran." Salam.
Salaamalaikum. The verses you are referring to 75:16 -19, if put into context (really important to do that) are speaking about method of recitation of the Quran taught to Muhammad SAW through Gebrael AS. 75:19 states that clarification of the Quaran is upon US (majestic US implied) to you. This is directly addressed to the Prophet SAW. So it begs the question "is it not the Prophet SAW job to then explain to his followers upon receiving the "clarification" of verses in the Quran from Allah?
@@aehmerchant actually prophet muhammad's job was only to spread the words of God. Not all ayah, prophet muhammad knew or understand, meaning: not all ayah were explained to him. For example the first ayah "nuuun", etc.
@@gondala It seems that there is a contradiction in Quran: “(We sent these above mentioned men) with clear proofs and Scriptures. And (similarly now) We have revealed to you the Reminder that you may explain to mankind (the commandments) that have been sent down to them so that they may ponder and reflect”. 16:44
Proof from the Quran that the sunnah is actually from Muhammad? None There's only one sunnah mentioned in the Quran and that's Allah's sunnah.. :) For 300 years after rasool died. Not a single hadith's. No one needed them. So after they were complete? Why the change? Allah knows best
+😼VeganKitty😼 "There's only one sunnah mentioned in the Quran and that's Allah's sunnah" Yes, we have to do what Allah SWT does. Wait... "For 300 years after rasool died. Not a single hadith's. No one needed them." During the time of Rasulullah SAW and even after his death SAW, people asked about how he SAW did this how he SAW did that. Because they want to follow the man who they love. Let's say I'm a football player. If I see Ronaldo, I would try and become like Ronaldo. Ronaldo is like my hero or the one who made me love to play football or something. This situation is as same as that. People following Rasulullah SAW because they loved him SAW.
+Adam Zaim (OfficialAdamMZ) You just compared the prophet SAW to Cristiano Ronaldo. Ronaldo is your hero? Ronaldo himself would tell you not to copy him but to come to your own understanding of football. Similarly the prophet would tell you not to copy his every supposed action. To read the Quran and come to understand the clearest most complete book ever. He would tell you that the Hadith don't reflect his character, or even his actions. But what was said about him by people who never met him.
+AryansWerentWhite Find your own history so you misguided fool want to say that the rasulullah sallallahu alayhimwa sallam will tellmus to get our own understanding of ISLAM,,is that what you munafiqs do finding your own understanding and interpretation of ISLAM?!?!?! and you stupid fools want to say that we are making sects in ISLAM!?!?! we who want to follow only Qur'an and sunnah like the prophet alayhi sallam and the three generations of ISLAM and not to add our own personal meaning and desires into it so there can be no deviation in ISLAM!?!? and you munafiqs who say we don't need the sunnah, we don't need to follow Muhammad alayhi salam we don't need his explanation of the Qur'an, we will make our own tafseer, our own interpretation in fact everyone can interpret the Qur'an as he pleases and can do what he wants so we could have with every single individual a different sect because everyone will interpret the Qur'an how he thinks is the best for serving his desires and needs and we can be sodomites and at the same time Muslims although ALLAH destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah to the last men but we can be sodomites and Muslims, we don't need to cover our women we can let them go like the kafirah who are selling themselves in the streets walking around half naked and some of them almost naked and even some go completely naked, we can drink alcohol, we can eat whatever we want, we don't have to pray 5 times a day its too much for us, we will fight for the rights of those whom ALLAH cursed in the Qur'an(homosexuals), we will fight for our women to mix freely with men who are not mahram to them and letting our women to work with men and giving birth to a child from her boss because in 40-60 % in the western secular satanic society that what is happening, we will not kill the homosexuals and adulterers although AIDS is spread because of them and statistics tells us that homosexuals are number one in addiction to AIDS, number 2 prostitutes and pornography actors and number 3 having more sexual partners outside of marriage but NO we will fight for the rights of those scums to spread their disease in our society and even to get married and adopt children so the can make an army of Sodomites, we will let everyone to leave according to his desires and his personal views so that we can have another Urban II the pope who invoked the crusades and another Hitler, Mao ze thung and Stalin and of course another Darwin who will teach us how to continue the evolution by killing ourselves and the strong destroying the weak, the white destroying the black so that the evolution may continue by natural selection, is this the ISLAM you are inviting people!?!?!?!?! is this what you believe is the only truth!?!?! is this is the way of the prophets!?!?!? and is this is the ISLAM on which you are on!?!?!?! I'm observing you people for quite a while and this is what i found out about you and your religion you so called qurani muslims, you are the greatest weapon of illuminati AND Dajjal but be sure that Isa alayhi salam will return and you will be destroyed along with your master Dajjal!!!! May Allah punish you and guide those who seek guidance Ameen!
+Setec 2 +Setec 2 +Setec 2 1. Muhammad didnt tell us to get our own understanding. Is it nor cleared to u what Allah said in the quran that it is cleared and fully detailed? Have u read the quran btw? Or do u have doubts in the Quran? 2. We munafiqs? Allah ask us to follow what that have been revealed by him in the quran yet u choose to follow another book which is not by allah and u called us munafiqs? Who is following allah's command? 3. Sunni is a sect. Shia is a sect. Who guys have hadith. We dont, we only need the devine quran. Prophet muhammad didnt have sahih bukhari did he? 4. "We who want to follow only quran and sunnah like the prophet muhammad"? What sunnah did prophet muhammad followed? He followed the sunnah of allah which is the quran. Like i said, there was no sahih bukhari. 5. U should really read the quran.
Hadiths have messed up Islam. Sunnah is NOT equal to Hadith. Sunnah is the practical deeds of the prophet like Salaat, etc having come to us directly from the time of the Prophet, which has a larger consensus, but I am NOT giving even a penny to Israr Ahmed Khan to teach me how to sift hadiths. There were NO hadiths during the time of the Prophet! If YOU are a good scholar, Mr Shabbir, why do YOU allow FAKE hadiths to exist in the collection? Even before debating the Christians, why don't YOU clean YOUR house first?
39:23 God has revealed herein the best Hadith; a book that is consistent, and points out both ways . The skins of those who reverence their Lord cringe therefrom, then their skins and their hearts soften up for GOD's message. Such is GOD's guidance; He bestows it upon whoever wills (to be guided). As for those sent astray by GOD, nothing can guide them,
Allah SWT said: تَبَارَكَ الَّذِى نَزَّلَ الْفُرْقَانَ عَلٰى عَبْدِهِۦ لِيَكُونَ لِلْعٰلَمِينَ نَذِيرًا "Blessed is He who sent down the Criterion upon His Servant that he may be to the worlds a warner -" (QS. Al-Furqaan 25: Verse 1)
AsA I’m a Former ✝️ Christian 💭💭💭So Allah tells me to do something in the Quran (Allah’s Hadith) and rather then asking Allah to help me understand.... I must also seek out the Human Hadith (descriptions from mankind) to understand Allah...ok I didn’t need the Human Hadith to Revert. When I heard the Quran (Allah’s Hadith) I responded as the Quraysh did when they heard the Quran (19:58). No Human Hadith needed then. I rely on Allah azza wa Jal Alone. Like our Messiah Isa (a.s.)...or would Isa (a.s.) also read the Human Hadith if it were available to him...seriously?! 🧐 I think Jesus Christ/Isa (a.s) will know of the Quran (Allah’s Hadith) and none of the Human Hadith.
Aasiyah, so your saying you do NOT need the Hadiths, can I ask you some questions: 1) Do you recite the SHAHADA (y/n) 2) Do you pray FIVE times a day (y/n) 3) Do you encircle the Kaaba SEVEN times (y/n) 4) Do you run between As-Safa and Al-Marwa SEVEN times (y/n) If the answer is YES to any or all of these questions, please show me the verse in the Quran.
Adam the Freemason. If I am unable to do any of these things will ALLAH swt reject me? There are Muslims who accepted Allah with their hearts but were never able to say the Shahada. There are Muslims who were not able to pray or only able to pray once before their death. There are Muslims who have died before ever going on Hajj As Muslims I do not believe that ALLAH swt judges us Not by the number of our actions but rather the sincerity within them. I once asked an imam what does a one arm left handed Muslim do when they eat? Are they constantly feeding Shaytaan since their left handed with only one arm? He said ALLAH knows best. The fact that you’re asking me these questions means that your searching for things humans cannot provide.
Whose version of Sunnah? Salafi or Sufi? Ahle Hadith or Ahle Sunnah? Ahle Fiqh? Shia or Sunni? Excercise you right to judge all secondary sources according to Al Furqan.
There is only one sunnah that is of our Prophet Muhammad(pbuh).The people follow the 4 schools of thought and that is why people differ.There is only one sunnah.if a hadith goes against the Quran then it is wrong however the others are perfectly fine
Hadith scholars don't get this.... Quranic muslims DO NOT (and cannot, as true muslims) reject the TRUE sunna and what the Rasul ACTUALLY said, i.e., what we can be 100% SURE the Rasul said and did, i.e., that which is in the Qur'an, which is the ONLY hadith about which there is no doubt. What I DO reject is the hadith/sunna AS EXPLAINED by Bukhari et al. Now, it MAY be true that some of these are authentic, but a glass of juice with even the tiniest drop of poison added to it is not juice. It's poison! It is a LIE that the Rasul married a 6-year old. I reject this, and many other so-called hadith as filth!
Salamun Alaikum! The same Alhamdulillah! Coming from Christianity I quickly began to see the stark similarities between what Christians did with Prophet Isa (as) in what's known as the Bible & what Mohammadeans are doing with Prophet Mohammad (as) in what's known as Ahadith. I think it's important to study the messengers & texts that came before in order to keep from repeating the same mistakes that Qur'an was sent to correct..ie: following & emulating the messenger instead of the message.
Ohh finally found someone like me...I also come from Sunni background but now all on a sudden realized the truth about the fabrication of hadees...I also wanna start following only The Quran but I'm a little confused about prayer.... I've heard that the Qur'ans salah does not mean ritual prayer... what do u do? How do u pray "salah" ? Can u give me some advice?
@@senseisokodame9988 I still pray similar to sectarians. Only difference is I do the 3 mentioned in Qur'an and don't mention any name other than Allah during prayer. This is a topic that I highly suggest you read the Qur'an for answers to your heart.
MashAllah you are great. You make very good and strong analogies that put a lot of thoughts in perspective. Keep up the great work akhi (brother in Arabic). Jazak Allahu Khair
Brother, you stole the stage. Mashallah. May Allah reward you and continue to guide you and all the Muslimeen and those who are lost and need to come back to true Islam. Ameen.
I have great respect for Shayk Shabir, I cannot agree with what he is saying. I have been studying hadiths for about 20 years. I have been studying Quran for all my life. I study other religions for over 15 years. I am into comparative religions. Then few years, i have realized that i was reading the Quran with the Hadith Glasses. Quran is Furkan we should look at the world with Quran glass. Hadiths are just like Talmud, both are oral tradition written down. 1. Hadiths were written down 200 years after the prophet by bunch of Iranians (persians). Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawood, Thirmidi, Nasai and few others are all Iranians. 2. All of them have Da'f hadiths (lie/rejected) hadiths. I am asking if they were truly knowledgable person writing them as first account from people didn't they know that those hadiths are Da'f already? 3. If we take schools of thoughts like Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi, Hanbali, Zahiri in order; Imam Hanafi was Persian! I wonder what is this persians and Islam. As is islam came from Iran. Back in those days, Majority of the Jewish population lived in Iran. and the Hadiths are just like Talmud like I said before. Only Imam Malik was from Madina. Anywhere they might have had great technology they might have used whatsapp or something to communicate who knows. I can give you all these Imams details and even the year of hadiths that are heart and soul to the religion. I used to compare other holy books with our religious books. Now i am asking the same questions i used to ask. "Hāthu Burhanakum inKunthum Saadikēn" comparing Quran and hadiths, sadly hadiths are contradicting. You want history book maybe we can use it for that. but not good for guidance. Hadiths of Allah is the only hadith Allah is telling us to accept it. Anyone with little bit of knowledge and remember to remove the hadith glasses and look into the Quran you will see it. Even the great scholars cannot see because they are looking at the Quran and the world through hadith. Hadiths (Muslim Oral Tradition written down by bunch of Imams/Alims) = Talmud (Jewish Oral Tradition written down by bunch of Rabbais). Thafseer = Misnah (Jewish Book explaining the Tanakh mostly) Sunnis are upgraded Jews version 2.0 Shia are upgraded Jews version 1.0 25:30 "And the Messenger has said (Will say), "O my Lord, indeed my people have left/abandoned this Qur'an" Read it with the context. Start from 25:27.
Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah often. Al qur an. 33:21
200 Years after Prophet death there was no book of hadeeth or the 4 Khalifa has felt necessities of preserving hadeeth or allowed any Shahaba to narrate hadeeth. In fact Khalifa Umar was very strict on hadeeth as he feared if any Shahsba says something which is not correct or misinterpret that goes against Quran & Khalifa Umar will be answerable to Allah.. He kept Abu Hurayra house areest for narrating hadeeth...So, we should use our knowledge from Quran..
Please define Sunnah. Sunnah = Path/Way Who's path do we follow? Mohammad or Allah? Quran: sunnatullah = the path of God; mentioned numerous times. Sunnah Mohammad; never mentioned.
Chosen One The Hadith you quoted is a Hadith that the prophet Muhammad salallahu alaihi wasalam said in Mecca, the early period of Islam. In the early Meccan times, the prophet forbade writing Hadith because he feared that people would confuse it with Quran. But after that, it was permissible to write ahadith
MustBe TheMost follow the Sunnah of Muhammad salallahu alaihi wasalam. Allah commands it Say, [O Muhammad], "If you should love Allah , then follow me (by adhering to the sunnah), [so] Allah will love you and forgive you your sins. And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful." Surah Ali Imran ayah 31
James D the Sahaba followed him and they have all passed. We cannot make clear from hadith what is true and not. But from the Quran we can agree there is no confusion. I find the hadiths to have harsh and explicit aspects. And I'm speaking of Sahih Bukhari and Muslim. Leave Abu Dawud and other misc hadiths alone, which get even worse and worse. I've read these books brother, there is no defense for some of the contents.
MustBe TheMost We can find true Hadith and untrue Hadith. Abu Dawud and many other sunbath books have weak and fabricated Hadith. However, there is a whole study on finding which Hadith are authentic and which are not authentic. So we can in fact know when a Hadith is sahih
But books Muslim and Bukhari are considered Sahih. In fact all Hadith root from Al Bukhari. The very "system" you speak of is the chain of narration which Bukhari outlined for his Sahih book. Muslim was his student, as well as Abu Dawud. But I'm contending that hadiths are from chains of narration going back 8 authors deep minimum. A collection of hearsay assembled from Khorasan to Egypt, 200+ years after Mohammads death, pbuh.
Salam Alaikum. I have 12 simple questions for Traditional Muslims, and I hope you could be the first person to attempt in answering them after sincerely reflecting upon them, God-willing: *1)* Throughout the Quran, we frequently see its reference to itself as “Al-Quran”. Why then is there not a single place in the entire Quran where a secondary scripture or divine revelation called “As-Sunnah” (the Sunnah) or “Al-Hadith An-Nabawi” (the Prophetic Hadith) is likewise mentioned? Doesn’t the Quran constantly claim that it is clear & straightforward? How then could God take the time to mention something as seemingly trivial as onions and lentils (Quran 2:61), and yet fail to clearly identify the most important source of guidance & revelation that all believers for all times are forever required to follow as religious guidance? *2)* Why do the words “Hadith” and “Sunnah” nevertheless amazingly appear over and over again throughout the Quran, yet never ONCE refer to what traditional Muslims use them as? (as the inspired words & teachings of the Prophet). Not only this, but the words “Sunnah” and “Hadith” are in fact often used throughout the Quran in ways that refer to the supremacy & exclusive authority of the Quran’s message itself, thus in almost a taunting manner towards what traditional Muslims would later come to believe about the “prophetic Hadith” and this idea of ‘dual revelation’ (see for example Q 77:50, 46:5, 39:23). If there was actually a second scripture or revelation ordained by God called the ‘Sunnah/Hadith’, wouldn’t this be extremely deceptive and misleading? *3)* Why does the Quran constantly make mention of itself and it’s perfect guidance, lack of contradictions, and promise of its preservation, and so on, yet make NO such magnificent claims about the Sunnah if it is indeed a co-authoritative revelation of God to humanity? Wouldn’t we at least expect that the Quran adds something like the phrase “ والسنة” (‘and the Sunnah’) in these numerous verses where the Quran alone is uniquely mentioned as the supreme guidance & sacred revelation? *4)* Why does the so-called Prophetic Sunnah (as supposedly codified in the Hadith) contradict the Quran in so many significant ways? For example, so-called “Sahih” Hadiths tell us that tiger and other animals are forbidden to eat, whereas the Quran is manifestly clear-multiple times, in fact-that the ONLY four prohibited foods are carrion, blood, pig’s meat, and idol-offerings; nothing more (Quran 6:145). Or for example, Sahih Hadiths tell is that the Prophet will be an intercessor on Judgement Day for those in his Ummah who committed MAJOR sins, whereas the Quran clearly states that anyone who commits major sins and fails to repent will be condemned to Hell, and will have no protector, intercessor, or savior. How can these teachings be a “commentary” on the Quran (as virtually all sunni Muslim scholars posit) when they blatantly contradict it? (P.S. Ask me for any specific references if needed). *5)* Why do you say that the Sunnah (as supposedly preserved in the Hadith) is a commentary on the Quran, when we know that the Hadith is actually just a collection of isolated sayings and doings of the Prophet and his companions, with less than 1% actually being direct commentary on the Quran? How can one claim this especially when considering the massive disagreement amongst traditional sects and scholars when it comes to Hadith-based theology, as well as numerous clear & major contradictions between the Quran and Hadith as pointed out above? *6)* Why does the Quran constantly make mention of the Torah and Gospel, as well as the Psalms and other revealed scriptures of God-and call these “guidance” and “beacons of light”-while no such honorable mention is ever made of the supposed second revelation that God allegedly sent down to the Prophet as the inspired Sunnah? How could God possibly fail to prioritize the divine identification of the Sunnah/Hadith-which is supposedly INDISPENSABLE for understanding the Quran itself-and yet constantly make mention of the amazing wonder & authority of the previous scriptures & revelations, which we aren’t even required to follow anymore? Once again, wouldn’t this seem to be gravely misleading? *7)* If we got rid of the Quran and just kept all of the accepted Hadith, don’t you think that the current religion of traditional Islam would still be perfectly intact? In other words, isn’t the Hadith alone sufficient for nearly everything you need to practice traditional Islam in its current form? What then is the need for the Quran under this framework? What other essential use or practical value does the Quran actually provide that the Hadith cannot? In fact, isn’t this why the Sunni Muslim scholars of the past were forced to admit “the Quran is in more need of the Sunnah than the Sunnah is in need of the Quran”? *8)* Why is there such a massive difference between the structure of the Quran (the codified words of God) and the structure of the Hadith (the alleged codified words of the Prophet) if they are both indeed co-equal legally-binding divine revelations brought down by God? For example, the Quran is preserved word-for-word, whereas the Hadith is mainly preserved meaning-to-meaning; the Quran is unique in style and incredibly easy to memorize & recite, whereas the Hadith is clearly human literature and was not made for easy memorization; the Quran has a set ‘canon’ that is more-or-less unanimously agreed upon and was transmitted as such, whereas the Hadith consists of thousands of disjointed unrelated reports that had to be individually collected and vigorously authenticated using human-devised methods of verification; and the list goes on. If both the Quran and the Sunnah were equally divine revelations of God, why is this the case? Yet isn’t this EXACTLY what one would expect if people falsely attributed a human work of literature as being divine revelation alongside God’s true word? *9)* If you were to hand a copy of the Quran to an unbiased stranger who spoke fluent classical Arabic, and had them read the Quran for the first time, from beginning to end, and with no other source of information-would they come back to you confused and puzzled, and be asking you for the secondary scripture & co-divine revelation called the “Prophetic Sunnah & Hadith” that they were allegedly supposed to read about in the Quran? *10)* The Quran mentions that the Jinn (the beings of the unseen realm; the parallel creation to us human beings) can actually hear the Quran being recited and follow it as such (Quran 72:1); thus we learn that the Quran is even a source of guidance for Jinn themselves. Therefore, is it required for the Jinn to follow the Sunnah & Hadith? If not, why not? But if so, how so? What model do you propose for such a thing to work? *11)* We already know and agree that the previous generations before us who were given scripture & prophethood by Allah (SWT) went far astray and added all sorts of falsehoods and fake traditions to their religion, including the Talmud of the Jews (who also interestingly claim that it contains ancient traditions of Moses passed down as commentary on the Torah) as well as the writings of Paul & the early Church fathers, whom Christians have essentially given precedence over Jesus’ own words and have thereby begun to worship the Trinity and hold other serious false beliefs, that can even lead one to eternal damnation on Judgement Day. With this (frightening) reality in mind, shouldn’t we be wary that WE too might also have gone astray from the pure teachings of God in the Quran? Wouldn’t it be utterly foolish and careless of us to ignore the warnings of Allah (SWT) about the historical corruptions & fabrications of the people of divine Scripture before us, and thus fail to consider that we too might be deviating from the right path just as they once did?... Indeed, when Prophet Moses left his people for just 40 days to meet with God, he came back to find them committing no less than the most heinous & atrocious sin of worshipping a carved idol, even after they had seen all that God did for them in Egypt. That was 40 DAYS; what then do you think of the Prophet’s followers after 1,400 years? *12)* Finally, what WOULD the Quran actually have to say for you to accept that it is the only revelation brought down from God to the Prophet? The Quran already says countless times that it is clear & lucid, sufficient for guidance, detailed & self-explanatory, unmatched & supreme, and perfectly preserved-so what else could the Quran possibly say for you to realize that it is indeed what it claims to be, and that no other scriptures or revelations are mandated on us to follow? I hope you will contemplate on these questions deeply & sincerely, and reflect with a clear & open mind. I look forward to your response. Much Salam.
I have a question for you Did the Prophet sallahu alayhi wassalam receive revelation that was not in the Quran? Did the Prophet salalhu alayhi wassalam come to explain the Quran to the people or just parrot the verses to them and let them figure out the rest?
@@mikk3150 the sole duty of messanger is convey the message I know you do not believe this ayat.. Say and think whatever you want, but you are in kufr to these ayahs.. make tauba and accept this
Brother I'd like to clarify that Allah only permitted us to eat certain foods and excluded the blood, pig meat, dead etc. Dont mix that up with thinking that we are allowed to eat everything, just please re-read all the verses about what food is permitted and whats not then you will get it.
@@kherona “I find absolutely NOTHING forbidden for ANYONE to eat whatsoever, in ALL that has been revealed-UNLESS it be these four things: carrion, spilled blood, pig’s meat which is foul, or a sinful offering dedicated to something other than God. But whoever is forced to eat these out of necessity, rather than desire or transgression-then God is certainly forgiving and merciful.” - Qur’an 6:145 The Qur’an SEVERELY disagrees with you, brother. Please read carefully-our Lord is clear; and could not have been any more clear. Salam.
I know what you mean, and I dont dare to say something is forbidden where Allah says its allowed in Quran, but I want to clarify and clear the mis-understanding. Please check the following verses (where Allah specify what is allowed for us): 1- livestock (actually its birds/livestock and anything that eats grass), in arabic its called الانعام: **And permitted to you are the grazing livestock, except what is recited to you. So avoid the uncleanliness of idols and avoid false statement ** Surah Al-Hajj: Verse 30 2- permitted to us whats inside the sea or water: ** Lawful to you is game from the sea and its food as provision for you and the travelers. ** Surah Al-Maidahsurah Al-Maidah Verse 96 3- Again permitted is cattle: ** O you who believe! Fulfill (your) obligations. Lawful to you (for food) are all the beasts of cattle except that which will be announced to you (herein),** Al-Mā’idah Verse 1 4- We are permitted to eat what Jews and Christians (people of the book are allowed to): ** The good things have this day been made lawful to you. The food of those to whom the Book was given is lawful to you, and your food is lawful to them. ** Al-Mā’idah - Verse 5 Brother you have to think about this, Allah has permitted for us what is allowed, if you think everything is allowed as you say. Then we are allowed to eat Humans or anything else like insects/bats/rats etc etc. This is bad for health and for humans and Allah wouldn't want it for us. Whats dangerous is that some people take Hadiths that prohibits what Allah permitted us (some cattle or livestock) and Allah warned those people who say that. However if you want to read the Quran you have to read thoroughly through verses. If you see what Allah restricted us, is all the things that are "PART OF" the allowed things but are not permitted, i.e the blood/dead/pig are all part of Cattle/Livestock which is permitted, but these are things that are prohibited. I hope you get the point. @@celestialknight2339
You're all afraid of the Quran Because Quran supports science, critical thinking, logic, rational people,... You're all afraid to lose the right way. The hadis and sunnah are so much that you don't know all of them so you feel you're safe. And last but not least: you are a sheep, you are afraid to take another way than the majority. The way of Allah is the Quran, not the hadis or sunnah. The prophet Muhammed was a follower of Quran. Not a follower of Buhari, Davud, Muslim, Trimizi...all of them lived 200 or more years after the death of Muhammed. So Muhammed was a Quranist
well said. because the prophet only followed the quran.very good point .if mohammad didnt follow bukhari and sahy sita and the four khalifs didnt so why shoud we have to follow it . and if we need interpretaion of quran what did the first hundred years muslims do .they didnt have the bukhari and muslim so very good point
Salam people, let us please desist from putting hard-line labels on everything by calling ourselves Quranists. The Quran itself refers to the likes of us as Mumineen. It is strict definitions and labels like that which fuel sectarianism and ultimately veers us off the straight path. May Allah have mercy on us all and guide us
*"Quran Alone"* was mentioned explicitly in the Quran. وَجَعَلنا عَلىٰ قُلوبِهِم أَكِنَّةً أَن يَفقَهوهُ وَفى ءاذانِهِم وَقرًا وَإِذا ذَكَرتَ رَبَّكَ فِى *القُرءانِ وَحدَهُ* وَلَّوا عَلىٰ أَدبٰرِهِم نُفورًا 17:46 We place shields around their minds, to prevent them from understanding it, and deafness in their ears. And when you preach your Lord, using the *Quran alone,* they run away in aversion.
In the Quran, 4th Surah Nisa, Ayat/Verse Number 80 (Quran 4:80) من يطع ٱلرسول فقد أطاع ٱلله ومن تولى فما أرسلناك عليهم حفيظا Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah, and whoever turns away, We have not sent you as a guardian over them.
[Quran 7:187] They ask you about the Hour, "When will it come?" Say, "Knowledge of it rests with my Lord. None can reveal its coming except He. It weighs heavily on the heavens and the earth. It will not come upon you except suddenly." They ask you as if you are responsible for it. Say, "Knowledge of it rests with God," but most people do not know. [Quran 7:188] Say, "I have no control over any benefit or harm to myself, except as God wills. Had I known the future, I would have acquired much good, and no harm would have touched me. I am only a warner, and a herald of good news to a people who believe." I rest my case
Tammy, yes Allah has "knowledge of the Hour" (Quran 7:187), yet also Jesus has "knowledge of the Hour" (Quran 43:61), how is so if he is NOT the "son of God", hmm strange.
@@AdamtheFreemason of course the lord told his messengers everything duhhhh 61. And (Jesus) shall be A Sign (for the coming Of) the Hour (of Judgment): Therefore have no doubt About the (Hour), but Follow ye Me: this Is a Straight Way.
I love it when the believers of man made books published 214 yrs after our prophet's death insult me as a "quranist"😂 it's too funny. As if I made the rule to only follow Allah's guide and Allah himself did not warn us of it. As if our prophet did not refuse books written on him. May Allah guide these smart brothers who like to think ahead of Allah
@@maldheem I'm sure the "Salah" was passed down from the time of prophet muhammed so the method already established (no hadith needed) that's already following the prophet. Now the hadiths were written 200-300 year later, how do we know how accurate it is. It confuses me too. I don't follow any sects,I just say I'm Muslim
The thing is, i dont reject hadith outright as a science and matter of gaining historical knowledge, i just don't like associating it with the notion that those that dont follow them are no longer muslim. What i also don't understand is how can these imams such as bukhari go around collecting '300,000' hadith (a number that borders on outrageous) and then find that he could only conclude 2,602 as sahih. thats .008% of all collected. That doesn't reassure me that the remaining are true, it only scares me that they could not detect any more false ones. How can bukhari conclude as a matter of fact that the remaining ones are absolutely true. he is but a man. People can have good memories but not perfect memories. A person can remember an event 1 way but still be wrong about certain parts of it. If we take that person's hadith that he passed down as sahih, does that make the hadith itself true? none of the hadiths are said to be from the prophet himself directly, its other people saying they heard/saw him do this or that. it also scares me that every time the word 'hadith' is said in Quran, its god asking: Did they not look at the dominion of heavens and earth, and all that GOD has created?. Perhaps their time is coming near; so in which after this will they have faith? [7:185] GOD, there is no god but He. He will gather you for the day of resurrection in which there is no doubt. Who is more truthful in than GOD?. [4:87] So in what after this will they believe? [77:50] hadiths should not be used as a source of law or to denounce people who don't believe them as disbelievers.
+AFGalwayz I think you are right. Indeed, peoples' memories are not perfect, but their perceptions are also not perfect. Humans are not able to perceive events that they see or things that they hear objectively. Only God has that ability, which is why only God has the ability to compose something like the Qur'an., which can be considered the only source of objective truth for true Muslims. Imagine if one of the Prophet's (PBUH) companions saw him outside one day, wearing a red shirt. They would say that on a certain day, the Prophet (PBUH) was wearing a red shirt. But what if that person had only seen his clothing from behind, and it turned out the other side of the clothing was blue. Or maybe he was mistaken and it was not the Prophet (PBUH) at all! And yet the hadith collectors would see from the chain of narrators that all them are trustworthy and judge this information as Sahih! And then some imams somewhere would claim that all those who don't wear red shirts are not true muslims, or that not wearing a red shirt on a certain day is makruh! I think something similar occurred with many hadith ranked "sahih". If you do not have perfect perception of the world, you cannot speak for Allah whether something is true or not. All information that comes to a person through his senses is distorted, which is why we have ruh (spirit) to feel God's grace directly in our hearts (for example when we recite the Qur'an), and 'aql (reason) to assist us in discarding falsehood.
WHAT U R SAYING IS PERFECTLY RIGHT. As a matter of understanding historical events we may refer hadith but definitely not as religious guidance. Nowadays people are giving more importance to hadith rather than the primary quran. Also they are not in a position to realize that they do it so.
+mansoor shamsudeen I am very scared and confused lately. I just realised how the hadiths that we have been using might be our biggest blasphemy. First of all, no Muslim has the right TO SAY that the prophet has said...without being there and a witness. everyone is responsible of what he associate to the prophets. We forbid drawings of the prophet but we can use his sayings that we aren't sure how much authentic!!! I always thought that hadiths like in sahih bukhari were collected before the death of the prophet and he did approve it!!! they never told us that they were documented first time officially after more than 200 years after the death of the prophet!!! what is this? a new bible and call it teachings and sayings of the prophet? Yes, we obey and follow the prophet. his mission was to deliver the Quran and our mission is to use our brains to understand it and use it in our life. not to live and try to be like the prophet. I am confused. I pray Allah to guide us and protect us.
AFGalwayz what you are saying makes sense, especially with Hadiths that clearly contradict the Quran.. such as circumcising men and women, when the Quran says that man has been created in the best of forms.. wa Allah Aalam (God knows best). May we be guided to truth
God focus on the story of hypocrites for a reason !!!! Read the Qur'an without any previous thoughts and you will release that the prophet was nothing like they saying he was not like emperor ..... The hypocrites is the one's who manipulate the true image of the true religion but Qur'an is preserved and this is our main belief so we take it alone.
Even though I follow only the Quran, I love his explanations on everything . He's always very logical and well- balanced and gentle. I can't imagine Allah not forgiving any muslim since it's our hearts for Idlam that is guiding us.
The only hadith to be followed is that which tells us how to perform salah, wudu, adhaan, and all other information which would have been witnessed by thousands of people. Hadith which say "ibn hurairah said to aisha who said to bilal who said that muhammad" like chinese whispers, are to be disregarded. The hadith which talk about Muhammad's personal relations with his wives must be disregarded too. The hadith which say Muhammad married Aisha when she was 6 are to be disregarded. The hadith which say Muhammad made his adopted son divorce his wife to marry her himself, must be disregarded. The hadith which say Muhammad had concubines (sex slaves) are to be disregarded. The hadith which say Muhammad had a child out of wed lck must be disregarded. The hadith which say Muhammad would get intimate with his wives while fasting, must be disregarded. And surprisingly, all these shocking hadith are from Sahih Bokhari. Wake up people.
And we should filter Salah hadiths with Quran . For example Quran asks us to not to mention anyone's name in prayer but hadith ask us to mention Prophet's name?
Im looking the hadits which tell us how to perform salah for almost 2-3 years. And i cant find it. Which hadits teach us how to perform salah step by step? Ive read so many hadits, also asks so many people. But no one can give me satisfactory answer that Muhammad perform salah like majority of muslim today. No Hadits, No Man can explain that today Salah has not been altered.
History is not the same as Faith. The Quran contains all things necessary for guidance mercy understanding logic justice science for those who fear Allah
Brother Shabir did his best into explainig hadith even if, as muslims, we are unconsciously bound not to doubt or even talk about hadiths that are impossible to be accepted as part of prophet Muhammad(pbuh) teachings.
seif deiab Well my understanding of a complete and fully detailled Quran is not the same as yours. It is obvious that no one in the 7th century Madina would have believed that the boson is in the Quran. The real meaning is that it is the last revelation, you may accept it or reject it. if your interpretation is enough for you then be it. Peace.
seif deiab No, Quran is complete. I just want you not to tell people that they will enter Hell when you just exchanged 2 sentences with them. This is your sickeness.
For anybody interested, I recently found out about the Jewish Talmud. The entire Talmud in standard print is over 6,200 pages long and contains the teachings and opinions of thousands of rabbis on a variety of subjects, including law, ethics, philosophy, customs, history etc. The Talmud is the basis for all codes of Jewish law. Sounds familiar right? A collections of texts written by man that helps "explain" the word of God (in this case the Torah) and fill in the gaps regarding daily rituals and rules. Food for thought. (Our duty is not to be right....our duty is to think and reflect and ponder. If our intentions to seek truth are sincere and humble then already we are on the right track....the rest is for the Almighty to decide.)
True quran explains sunna and nothing is left out only those who ponder will have no problem, i do not follow any hadiths or sunna we human have enough intelligent to follow our daily activities .
I did the same and came up with the same conclusion, mankind has always twisted and changed God's message to suit their political propaganda and control people. I do not want to follow humans, I believe Quran is from God sent directly to me to study and learn from, I don't need any sheikh or other human in between. Islam started long before SW Mohammed.. I advice u to learn, study and research the Quran and then look for Hadith if you insist. Let me tell you understanding the quran requires you to invest time so be patient and ask God for guidance, peace :)
Allah says Quran is fully detailed and is complete. Did Rasoulillah followed Imam, or did he followed another Hadith other than the Hadith of Allah? Read Quran my man. Allah commands us to follow Only Quran. It is one revelation. Read Quran. Are you belying Hadith of Allah? May Allah forgive us.
6:114 - “Shall I seek other than Allah for judge, when He it is Who hath revealed unto you (this) Scripture, fully explained? Those unto whom We gave the Scripture (aforetime) know that it is revealed from thy Lord in truth. So be not thou (O Muhammad) of the waverers.” The Quran is “fully explained.” Good enough for me. I don’t need anything else
Agreed what name would you call yourself? "Historian "or "Historiyoon" ??, hadith is basically history right written by men 200 years later..... right??
I don't need to really know who wrote the Quran. Quran is a book claimed to be from God.The definition of that God is well described in chapter 112.Moreover the book itself claims to be authentic and contradiction free. In addition it challenges humans to produce a like of it. So we have things to disprove Quran from within without seeking outside sources ie hadith or history which is written 200 years after Prophets death.Where as Quran says quran.com/6/114 and again in quran.com/7/145 that the book He had revealed is with full explanation /in full detail. When the book claims to fully detailed then we don't need another book for guidance , to learn history, yes we can use hadiths. If a postman delivers a message you follow the message not the postman.Similarly great prophets were chosen to spread the message and we follow the message. Why are we not following Prophet Moses whose name is mentioned in Quran more times than others ????. He lived in a palace till he was 40 years enjoying all worldly pleasures. So following the message is more important not the messenger.
Ok brother , you are full of brains and you can follow the history which for me is a clear spam written by humans way later. Reading your writing I did not get any answer to my questions. So you have your way I have mine. For me Quran is enough and I don't need history. Have a good time.
Sorry brother your answers and proof are not convincing to me. For me Quran should be able to defend itself from within, if it can't it is not from God and I will discard it ..blind faith is not my way. You please follow what you feel good for you.Sunnah is a scam for me but you can follow it.
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow. QURAN 31-6 And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge. ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist. If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers. Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay. ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever. Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
The problem with hadith is, how do we know it is an accurate account of what the prophet did or said. Also who decides that the hadith is balanced or accurate? It's subject to bias by individual narrators or scholars.
It should be so incredibly embarrassing for those that actually try to explain away "hadith science". You are seriously equating word-of-mouth transmission (ie. hearsay, conjecture) in ancient times, with The God's *DIVINE PROTECTION* . Not to mention, so much for your "science" when even in your "authentic" hadith, there are gross contradictions and absurdities.
This is how you remembered God! Recite what is revealed to you of the Book, and observe the Salat, for the Salat prohibits immorality and evil, and the remembrance of God is of greater importance. God knows what you do. 29:45 I am God, there is no god except Me. Therefore, you shall worship Me and observe the Salat to commemorate Me. 20:14
Hi, coming from a place of wanting to learn and be educated on this topic. Any clarifications/thoughts would be appreciated. Some things I am wondering about... 1) Was the preservation of the hadith spoken of in the Quran as it was for the Quran ? 2) Isn't the hadith manmade and came much later in time? ( It is not claimed to be the word of God ) 3) When looking to the hadith, how does one know what is true/good or false/inaccurate ? 4) Why not just follow it all than? 5) If the response to 4 is what I've most come across, scholars have said which to follow and which is true and which is not. Picking which hadiths to follow and not, is this not just manmade? How can this be trusted? I came across a video on youtube about following Quran only and this comment is coming from a place of genuine inquiry. Thoughtful responses are appreciated. Thanks
@@kabakonate7716 god said in a verse that he sent the quran to explain everything he didn't say "it explained everything" he said "to explain everything" so it is true not everything is explained eg: why ppl have heart attacks? .. etc .. etc but it will explain everything in the end of the world in the judgement day
@@ljklmoiaoklmlljkajksjdklfm503 Explain everything about what is right and wrong path. Everything about guideness. That why He mention History of some pass nation. How they where mislead. Brother is that why i said people misunderstand the Quran. Allah only mention things within Quran so we may think. And Know that theys a creator.
@@ljklmoiaoklmlljkajksjdklfm503 First is believed then right path. Only our creator can show us what right and wrong. Because is law is just. Beside Him we human only want that can benefit us. We are unjust with each other. Most of us only care about our self pleasure. Conserning believed. We must believed that whaterver force created and form this world. And Then program each part of it to do their task. The owner of this force is our creator. From His power and force everything was created Then programed. All we need is upon this world. We can only used the intellect that our creator gave us to build and ruled this world according to His law. Not according to our desires. His law are revelation He sent to us.
Surah Al-Ankabut-51-Is it not sufficient for them that We have sent down to you the Book (the Qur'an) which is recited to them? Verily, herein is mercy and a reminder (or an admonition) for a people who believe. Surah Al-An'am -38- There is not a moving (living) creature on earth, nor a bird that flies with its two wings, but are communities like you. We have neglected nothing in the Book, then unto their Lord they (all) shall be gathered.
Such a sensible approach....I wish more Muslims would understand that their Hadith books are not equivalent to Quran and not everything should be taken as literal fact. This is a much more reasonable and in my opinion accurate way of understanding the Hadith literature. May Allah SWT continue to bless scholars like Shabir Ally with knowledge and wisdom and help educate this ummah.
Brother Shabir. Probably you are not aware that there was not a single historian at the time of Exalted Prophet(SAW). All that we read to day were written after 250 years later of Exalted prophet death. The writers were neither eye witness nor they had any documented papers in their hands. In my opinion this writers have invented hadees from their own minds and a number of hadees goes against Quoran. My question. Is Quoran not sufficient only or need any other book to support. If we say Yes Quoran needs Hadees then we can very well say that Allah (SWT) claim that the Deen is complete will prove wrong. There is nothing mentioned that after 250 years later hadees will be written and all believers must follow those. Quoran has all the answers no need of any other book.
Asalaamualekum sister. 4:176- {They request from you a ruling. Say, " Allah gives you a ruling concerning one having neither descendants nor ascendants." If a man dies, leaving no child but a sister, she will have half of what he left. And he inherits from her if she has no child. But if there are two sisters, they will have two-thirds of what he left. If there are both brothers and sisters, the male will have the share of two females. Allah makes clear to you [His law], lest you go astray. And Allah is Knowing of all things.} If you can tell me what is to become of the remaining half after the sister gets her share and what happens to the remaining one third after the 2 sisters gets their share without resorting to ahadith or any other 'manmade' ideas, please do so from the Quran. I'll be waiting for your answers.
Mofi Lilee If you noticed brother, she and others I presented this question to never answered my Quranic question based on the Quran alone, as she and her sect preaches. They only TALK Quran. They DONT KNOW Quran. That's one of the many problems with them. Jazak Allahu Khair.
Sister Sophia You have alhamdolillah a very clear vision. You have very well explained the shortcoming of historic evidences . Look at the nature of comment issued by Mofi Lilee ... since if we have lived for centuries in darkness then the nation should remain in darkness for all time to come He doesn’t know that the use of wisdom and rationalism for which Quran repeatedly emphasizes (7-179 is a good example) was curbed in 3rd century Hijri by the Zoarastrian/Persian Mufassir e Quran Jafar AtTabri who belonged to the defeated Persian Empire and who wrote the first Tafseer of Quran. All the tafseer is based on rewayat, stories, backgrounds and not on the wisdom that Quran offers. It would have been fine if this were his own understanding but the zulm was that this person who had the patronage of the Royal (UnIslamic Court of Abbssids ), labeled all these explaination to our beloved Prophet SAWW and that too without any reference after 300 years of the demise of the prophet. After that a number of books of tafaseer were written till MMaulana Maudoodi but who could dare apply mind over and above the explainations of Prophet himself. So all such tafaseer are one and the same with just change of words. Most were written for the sake of earning sawab and achieving credibility among followers See how the progressing mind of Muslims was locked and It remained locked since last 1200 years till today Didn’t you read the arguments of Mofi Lili , hesbullah, ninjamaster bro, etc And so the Quran became MAHJOOR See 25-30 "And the Messenger will say, “O My Lord! These are my people, the ones who had forsaken this Qur’an making it of no account.“ [Mahjoor = Disabled = Abandoned = Neglected = Forsaken. They had immobilized it like villagers who bind a cow by tying her front foot to her horn" My request to Mofi Lilli , hesbullahnyc, ninjamasterbro and others is that enough is enough, Now please liberate Quran and Sharyya from the corruptions induced by the Persian/Zoroastrian conspirators 1200 years back and now its the time to apply mind Why dont we try to find our lost history. Today the world is so advance that it has decoded the inscriptions found in the ruins under the seas yet we the poor and ignorant Muslims do not have a clue of how Mohammad SAWW and his companions used to live and how they used to implement ghe Quranic Laws, There is no evidence of any natural or other type of calamity in the Arab region , yet we dont have any record of the first ever formed welfare state of madina, no documents are with us to understand the nature of governance which could have been an example today Where has all the record gone ? Some initial investigations reveal that it is the result of a great conspiracy. Arabs World was totally distracted from the original path of Sharyya at the end of 2nd century Hijri and that these Mhadeseen appointed by Abbasi Kings , and that these people who came from the defeated empire of Persia and were having Zoroastrian religion as their previous religion, were authorized to rejected 98% of their elements of belief /rewayaat / ahadees prevailing in the practices of the Muslims of that period. Bukhari rejected som 580000 practices and inserted around 2600 as SAHIH practices /ahadees All the remaining were thrown out of their lives using the authority of Kings and that of courts. So did Muslim Ibne Maja , Nisai and others. This massive abandoning of the prevailing practices by declaring them not the Sahih practices virtually abandoned what ever was in practice at that time. Who authorized them to reject all that ? Did the Prophet SAWW or the God Almighty ? Please tell me who authorized these Persians to reject Arab practices ? ( only this part is verifyable from the books of Saha Sitta , Bukhari and others that they rejected the 98% practices but no record is available to know what they rejected ? YOU HAVE TO HAVE BELIEVE IN BUKHARI TIRMIZI AND ALL SUCH PERSIANS FOR ALL THE ADDITIONAL SHARYYA COMMANDS OVER AND ABOVE QURAN (INFACT MORE THAN 90 % OF PRESENT DAY UNDER PRACTICE SHARYYA IS BASED ON THEIR WRITINGS WHERE AS ONLY LESS THAN 5% IS BASED ON QURAN) WE DON’T HAVE ANY OTHER SOURCE … DID MOHAMMAD SAWW CHECK AND APPROVED THEIR ACTION ? DID GOD APPROVED THEIR ACTION ? There is not a single book of history or any document available today which was from 1st or 2nd century Hijri that could tell us about the actual practices as evidence except the first book of Muslim history which was written by Jafar At Tabri, at the last decade of 3rd Century Hijri. Jafar at Tabri / Tabri bin Rustom was also ex-Zoroastrian coming from same defeated Persian Empire. These were the people who according to available historic record, like the Jews, were still desperate to take revenge from the Muslims of their humiliation and loss of dignity as they were deprived by Muslims of their century old thown and power of the Great Persian Empire. They were not in a position to crush Mulim power through conventional warfare Therefore joined hands with Jews to spread intellectual corruption in Deen. That was the time when these Persian appointees of the non islamic Malookyat/ kings started writing Tafaseer, Ahadees and History of Muslims These Zoroastrians/ Persians supported and conspired to get the throne of Muslim Empire in the hands of Abbassids After gaining power Abbassids were naturally obliged to share in power with these Zoroastrians Onward history is recorded history through many sources of east and west (the historic record of 1st and 2nd century is not available except from the books written by same disputed suspected personalities of past Zoroastrians). It is verifiable fact that during Haroon Rashid, the power was in the hands of Zoroastrians with the help of whom Abbasids could gain power. His mother Khaizran was a practicing Zoroastrian, his prime miinster Yahya was Bermaki, his majority cabinet was of Zoroastrians. The court language was replaced from Arabic to Persian, Nauroze and other Zoroastrian cultural tehwaars became official celebrations in Courts etc etc Tabri’s book of history written in 13 volumes is entirely based on stories with no reference to even a single scrap of paper. And we fools follow that as the only source of the events that took place in the early period of Islam and take those events as actual event. We don’t understand that Persians were well known in the art of crating volumes and volumes of stories …Bulbul Hazar Dastaan etc are such Persian productions The same Persians who braught Abbasids in power werr also the cause of the fall of Abbasids as well They conpired to invite Hilaku khan who destroyed all libraries and books besides the massacre of muslims. No one knows what enimity had Hilaku Khan with the books that he spoiled and burned all the available literature leaving a side only books of Persian authors like the books of Persian writers including the only available book nof history written by Tabri... all remaining books were destroyed This was all deliberately done by the Zoroastrians / Persians
lahasil100 Boy, you have a lot to say about what Mofi LiLee had to say. How about you giving the answer to this; 4:176- {They request from you a ruling. Say, " Allah gives you a ruling concerning one having neither descendants nor ascendants." If a man dies, leaving no child but a sister, she will have half of what he left. And he inherits from her if she has no child. But if there are two sisters, they will have two-thirds of what he left. If there are both brothers and sisters, the male will have the share of two females. Allah makes clear to you [His law], lest you go astray. And Allah is Knowing of all things.} If you can tell me what is to become of the remaining half after the sister gets her share and what happens to the remaining one third after the 2 sisters gets their share without resorting to ahadith or any other 'manmade' ideas, please do so. I'll be waiting for your answers.
lahasil100 Oh yeah, I forgot to mention about answering my question related to 4:176, and is very important. You must do so without resorting to anyones hadith or any other 'manmade' ideas AND without the tactic of presenting other Ayat that have no relation to this particular circumstance in this particular Ayah. I'll be waiting for your answers.
"obey God and obey the Messenger" does not necessarily mean "obey the Quran and separately obey/incorporate the practices that will be attributed to the Messenger and compiled 200+ years from now." i am very interested in the life and history of the Prophet, and i hold him and the message he delivered us close to my heart. When i realized that hadith dont speak to my heart, and i understood not to include them in my religion (also for fear of attributing false things to God against my own heart), I was not rejecting the history of the Prophet : i was making a distinction between religion and history.
The sahaba knew what the verses meant, it was they through whom Allah preserved the Quran, and spread it all over the world. It was them who taught Islam, the Quran and Sunnah. And how many times must it be said to you hadith rejectors that Hadith were not compiled 200 years after the Prophet, or that the history of hadith does not begin with Bukhari. Hadith were WRITTEN during the lifetime of the Prophet sallahu alayhi wassalam by his sahaba such as Abdullah Ibn Amr Al Aas, Abu Hurraira, Anas Ibn Malik, Abdullah Ibn Masood, Ali Ibn Abi Talib. They were all absorbed into the collections that started to be compiled decades later. You do not get to decide what verses of Quran means. That was already decided when they were revealed, to the people of that time. They knew what it meant. They understood it, they implemented it.
So Allah left a few generation of Muslims to follow an "incomplete"/"partially explained" deen after the death of the Prophet SAW till such time that the so called "Muhaddetheen" came along and collected the Sunnah and propagated this in the Muslim world thereby "completing" their deen which surprisingly Allah claims to have completed in the Prophet's lifetime.
A total straw man argument. That is what you are claiming. The Sunnah of the Prophet was followed since he was alive. The Sunnah was preserved orally, through practice and implementation in the lives of those that heard/saw the Prophet doing it and by it being written down whilst he was alive as was the case for several companions like Abdullah ibn Amr Al as, Anas ibn Malik, Ali ibn ABI Talib and several others. The Sahaba spread all across the world because of them conquering one land after another. They taught people the Quran and how to recite it as they were taught, and the Sunnah. Those that were noted to be scholars from the Sahaba would have 100s if not 1000s of students who went on to be famous in their wn right. Several of the children of famous Sahaba were another greatest scholars of their generation
Mik K which Sunnah are we talking about, there are a total of 52 books of Ahadeeth. If the Sunnah was preserved why is it that some of them are classified as Daeef and some as Moudu’. Is that what you call as preserved? Think.
References to "Wisdom" (i.e. "Sunnah") in the Quran (5 Verses) Quran 2:151 - Our verses and purifying you and teaching you the Book and wisdom ... Quran 2:231 - And remember the favor of Allah upon you and what has been revealed to you of the Book and wisdom Quran 3:164 - ... reciting to them His verses and purifying them and teaching them the Book and wisdom,.. Quran 33:34 - And remember what is recited in your houses of the verses of Allah and wisdom. Quran 62:2 - It is He who has sent among the unlettered a Messenger from themselves reciting to them His verses and purifying them and teaching them the Book and wisdom. Sahih al-Bukhari, Vol. 9, Book of Holding Fast to the Qur'an and Sunnah, Hadith 419 Narrated 'Abdullah: Allah's Apostle said, "Do not wish to be like anybody except in two cases: The case of a man whom Allah has given wealth and he spends it in the right way, and that of a man whom Allah has given religious wisdom (i.e., Qur'an and Sunna) and he gives his verdicts according to it and teaches it." (to others i.e., religious knowledge of Qur'an and Sunna (i.e Prophet's Traditions)). SOURCE: muflihun.com/bukhari/91/419 Sahih al-Bukhari, Vol. 9, Book of Holding Fast to the Qur'an and Sunnah, Hadith 381 Narrated Hudhaifa: Allah's Apostle said to us, "Honesty descended from the Heavens and settled in the roots of the hearts of men (faithful believers), and then the Quran was revealed and the people read the Quran, (and learnt it from it) and also learnt it from the Sunna." Both Quran and Sunna strengthened their (the faithful believers') honesty. (See Hadith No. 208) SOURCE: muflihun.com/bukhari/91/381 Muwatta Imam Malik, Book of The Oath of Allegiance, Hadith 3 Malik related to me from Abdullah ibn Dinar that Abdullah ibn Umar wrote to Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan, making an oath of allegiance. He wrote, "In the name of Allah, the Merciful, the Compassionate. To the slave of Allah, Abd al-Malik, the amir al-muminin, Peace be upon you. I praise Allah to you. There is no god but Him. I acknowledge your right to my hearing and my obedience according to the sunna of Allah and the sunna of His Prophet, in what I am able." Classification: No Data, SOURCE: muflihun.com/malik/55/3 Muwatta Imam Malik, Book of The Decree, Hadith 3 Yahya related to me from Malik that he heard that the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, said, "I have left two matters with you. As long as you hold to them, you will not go the wrong way. They are the Book of Allah and the Sunna of His Prophet." Classification: No Data, SOURCE: muflihun.com/malik/46/3 Jami` at-Tirmidhi, Vol. 2, Book of Hajj, Hadith 942 Salim narrated that : His father disliked making a condition during Hajj and he said: 'Is not the Sunnah of your Prophet enough for you?" Classification Sahih (Authentic), SOURCE: muflihun.com/tirmidhi/9/942
@@AdamtheFreemason wisdom comes only from Allah , that's why the messenger must recite the verses clearly , the book has the truth and it makes all things clear to those Allah wills to understand it
@@samanali4848 2 269 wisdom comes from Allah , but the people have to hear the quran first to obtain its wisdom which is from God because it came from him
I'm Sorry Shabir My Brother. The Quran Fully Says A Detailed Book. .And We have revealed the Book to you which has clear explanation of everything, and a guidance, mercy and good news for those who submit." (Qur'an 16:89)
In the Quran, 4th Surah Nisa, Ayat/Verse Number 80 (Quran 4:80) من يطع ٱلرسول فقد أطاع ٱلله ومن تولى فما أرسلناك عليهم حفيظا Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah, and whoever turns away, We have not sent you as a guardian over them.
+chakubanga1 I'm one also. Don't know if I should add the word unfortunately. Only Allah knows who's guided and one can't add guarantees to one's guidance. It essentially makes you an outcast in both western and middle eastern society. But one can't reject one's heart and reason at the end of the day. I think Khalifa ultimately actually contributed to a deterring effect to becoming a Muslim following the Quran alone, since he has added this code 19 obsession to be associated with it which just detracts from the simple and natural nature of the Quran by creating this code finding lunacy and what not. Always makes me think of this verse: [Verse 3:7] ...But those in whose hearts is perversity follow the part thereof that is allegorical, seeking discord, and searching for its hidden meanings, but no one knows its hidden meanings except Allah... Sincere people at the end of the day I think are just looking for a genuine and reasonable relationship with God, without all the added dogma that prevails in anything mainstream and established, but still feeling the need for something that grounds them firmly and which they can hold on to.
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow. QURAN 31-6 And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge. ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist. If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers. Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay. ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever. Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
All Glory and praise exclusively belong to the Creator alone. Everything outside Quran is dirty/impure including minds, hadith, other books,, language, etc.. If the Creator compels the soul to dwell in Quran, the purification process begins. The reader will impute their impure thoughts on it's verses, yes. However, by Allah's will alone, the sincere will gain understanding as one continue's to dwell in it without interference or interruption. The Quran represents the 'chamber of converse' between the reader and the unseen creator and organizer of all the worlds. The only door to this chamber must remain shut (never to be opened) to root out any interference (Satan). Following Hadith, sin, or other associates or authorities other than Allah's supreme authority of Quran, sent as a mercy, will keep a screen over the hearts, eyes and ears and minds and it will be as if they were donkeys unable to read the Holy Quran which they carry on their backs. Allah watches as one is distracted or engrossed. The Holy Quran is a two way communication screen. As Allah sees (may the All-knowing, the Omnipresent, and the Compeller forgive my imperfect speech) one coming into His chamber ( May Allah alone be praised for His gifts), He will know who, among the sincere will close the door behind him (never to open it again) or not and, by His grace, bounty, compassion and mercy, will guide, misguide, or leave in their places whomever He wills.
Sounds reasonable from Dr. Shabirs quoting surah 16:44 but there is a surah giving an other explanation what the duty of the messenger is: 5:99 "The sole duty of the messenger is the delivery (of the message), and God knows what you reveal and what you conceal!, than this: 16:89 "We brought the Book down to you providing explanations of all things", and one other surah is here relevant in my perspective, and this is: 33:62 "Such was the Sunna of God for those who passed on before. You will find that there is no substitute for the Sunna of God", an this one : 35:43 "You will find that there is no substitute for the Sunna of God, and you will find that there is no diversion from the Sunna of God". Finally, nowhere in the Quran do we read the words "the sunna of Muhammad". 46:9, This one is interesting as well: Say (O Muhammad), "I am not a novelty among the messengers, nor do I know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing other than what is revealed to me (Quran). I am no more than a clear warner." One other captivating surah in this behalf is: 5:99 "The sole duty of the messenger is the delivery (of God's message". The same message is found in 5:92, 16:35, 16:82, 24:54, 29:18, 42:48 and 64:12. And here it quotes what his sole duty is: 42:48 "But if they turn away, We did not send you as a guardian over them. Your sole duty (O Muhammad) is the delivery". And this is what our prophet piece and blessing be on him, said in the same hadith: "Do not write down anything from me except the Quran. Whoever writes other than that should delete it" (Ahmed Ibn Hanbal, Vol. 1, page 171 also Sahih Muslim, Book 42, Number 7147). For the first 200 years after the death of the prophet, and in accordance with his instructions, the writing of his hadith was forbidden. Out of the 6 'sahih' hadith collections we have today, the first to be written was the collection of Al-Bukhari. Al-Bukhari was born in the year 194 after Hijrah. What this means is that the first of what are regarded as authentic hadith (sahih) to be compiled, was written more than two whole centuries after the death of the prophet!
You see...the last part of the discussion he kind of disreputes the Hadiths. If the prophet was alive I would have no problem following him but hearsay? And then there's some hadiths which seem really bad for the prophet to have said
Why hadees were not written immediately after prophet pbuh death Why nobody took the task of writing hadees in madinah and makkah And why buqari all the way from uzbek has to come and do d work
Why would Allah SWT say He made Quran COMLETE in more than ONE verse. But let’s say He said it once, Hadith is taken as a literal supplement. This means Quran alone is NOT complete. So the Sunnis are saying two hundred years after the prophet died men complied knowledge by the prophet “from Allah” so that these Hadiths could complete our Quran?? Now we are left to deal with over 700,000 Hadiths. We must choose a “scholar” or school of thought to help us follow the “right” Hadiths. How is this easy???! Not to mention the confusion the contradiction in Hadiths and scholars cause to a brand new revert or anyone seeking to turn back to Allah! Allah, subhanahu wata'aala, said; "Allah intends for you ease, and does not want to make things difficult for you" [2:185]; and "Allah does not want to place you in difficulty" [5:6]. I’ve been seeking knowledge and the more I learn the more I’m inclined against following man made Hadiths. Does this mean Allah is actively misguiding me when I’m seeking guidance??? Muhammad), you cannot guide whomever you love, but God guides whomever He wants and knows best those who seek guidance. [Qur’an 28:56] I am not of those who wish to ignore Hadith to not pray. I love to pray and this is the main reason I can’t seem to let go of Hadith. Also music isn’t forbidden in Qur’an but even non Muslims know music is used by evil to brainwash us. I am going to Umrah the last ten days of this Ramadan. Inshallah. Believe me not believing in the beautiful motivating Hadiths is sad but I can’t accept to follow man made books when the prophet forbade them. Can I?? This subject has crossed my mind over and over again since I began seeking knowledge not too long ago. I reverted many years ago but so much misinformation and the fact that the Sunni Muslims around me don’t follow Quran, Sunna or Hadith had me feeling very lost and underwhelmed. I feel a closer connection to Allah now alhamdullah by getting to know Him through Qur’an. May Allah guide me and us all.
Is it possible in the places where Allah has placed things in the Quran that you don't understand, that it was meant to be there to show, that you would use it as a reason, to follow Prophet Muhammad's man written Hadith... therefore showing you to be one who is not following His word exactly. THERE are other words and letters in the Quran that we will never know what they mean, unless Allah reveals them. Allah does what he Wills.
Obey God and obey the messenger. If you turn away then the sole duty of the messenger is the clear delivery (of God's message). 64:12 Obey what the prophet tells you to say, when he says "Say!" Follow what has been revealed to you from your Lord (Quran), there is no god except Him, and keep away from the mushrikeen. 6:106 Shall I seek other than Allah as a 'hakaman' (lawmaker) when it is He who has brought down to you the Book fully detailed? 6:114 I'll follow nothing other than what is revealed to me 46:9 The sole duty of the messenger is the delivery (of God's message). 5:99 Or do they have 'shuraka' (partners) who legislate for them of the religion what God did not authorize? If it were not for them a decisive WORD, judgment would have already been passed over them. Indeed the transgressors shall have a painful punishment. 42:21
Very sad and foolish how those who reject the way of the Prophet sallAllahu alayhi wa sallam claim to accept the message that he worked for his entire life.
Allahu Akbar! You people never cease to amaze me. You somehow come up with something new every day.I'm not even going to bother with this one. Just one thing. I don't know where you get your information from but please verify it yourself and go through everything before posting it..
Yes. He did not only preserve the words of the Qur'an. He preserved it's practice, it's method of recital, and it's explanations all as taught by the beloved Nabi (May Allah bless him and give him peace).
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow. QURAN 31-6 And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge. ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist. If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers. Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay. ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever. Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
brothers, we all know well no one can be able to put quran into perfect order. Because it was revealed in diferent moment. Sunnah and pratice of prophet Muhammad pbuh Is quran in action and order. That why all those hadith which tell us how prophet pbuh act and do not contradict quran and where narrated by diferent companion are good hadith. And All those hadith which contradicte quran we must reject them. And All those hadith which where narrated by single narrator from one chain We must doubt or reject them. Because whaterver prophet pbuh teach He pbuh made it public.
3:19 Hadith is the yellow calf mentioned in Al Baqarah. “One sometimes FEELS the need for more details here.” God said sacrifice a cow don’t complicate by asking the age, and color, etc. God said pray in remembrance of me. Dont complicate it.
I would like to ask him a direct question...... Who were /are in the best position to apply Hadith science to scrutinize the authenticity and verify about truthfulness of chain of narrators; scholars of earliest period of compilation and classification of Hadith or common Muslims and /or scholars of this Era ?
Moderate acceptance? Not wholesale rejection or wholesale acceptance? Because there are questionable hadith, as you mentioned? Aren't they all questionable in the light of the Quran? Well, I will never do what you're doing. The Quran never stated to obey Mohammad. "Say (O Muhammad), 'Whose testimony is greater?' Say, 'God is the witness between me and you that THIS QURAN was given to me to preach it to you, and to whomever it reaches.' However, you certainly bear witness that you set up other gods beside. Say, 'I will never do what you are doing; I disown your idol-worship.'" (6:19)
+Curtis Jea Adams look I haven't read hadith or quran before learning how to pray or do fast.i learn it from common practice and my son and daughter learning namaz/salat following me.so u should learn to differentiate between hadiths and sunna.
+Curtis Jea Adams NO not "Quranists" please. It's not a sect. It's Muslims OUTISIDE of a sect. Call them what you will: Outsiders, Originals, sect-less, Pure. But never "Quranists". Peace
+truth are you Muslim? It's funny you say you learnt it following others because that's exactly what the Qur'an tells us not to do. "Following their forefathers" and not using reason and logic.
Holy Quran 2:2
-------------------
This is the Book about which there is no doubt, a guidance for those conscious of Allah -
💯. Very Clear Verse. Easy to understand.
After reading this you cannot open other books for Hidayat.
One of the sign of the Day of Judgement is that people would reject the Sunnah. The Sunnah is important to interpreting the Quran because people can interpret it however they like. Umar ibn Al Khattab talks about this. We need to follow how the Prophet peace be upon him interpreted since he is our example.
@@theyoungdaee7155 even hadith can be misinterpreted...
@@theyoungdaee7155 Quran doesn't need a book to be interpretated. God himself said "in the Quran they are words that have complicated meaning, the believers know that's it's from God and believe it but those who don't believe always ask what does God mean by that and try looking for the meaning while only God himself knows the meaning. ". How can you believe in a book written by people who can years after the death of the prophet, and leave the Quran that is straight from God ?
2:1 ا ل م
The intial source of knowledge
I've been reading the Quran for the past 4 years now and Allhamdulillah my life is complete. Allah has guided me to the truth.
Mashallah! May Allah guide us all to revert back to Quran! In the first chapter of Quran, we ask God to guide us in the straight path! If one sincerely concentrates and focuses on the first chapter (which we should be doing if we pray five times a day) and asks sincerely to the Creator for guidance, I can’t believe that a person will not get guidance from Quran! The key is sincerity and trust in God (faith on the Creator!)! So when one sincerely asks God, the Creator provides answer right in the very next chapter (at the beginning of Chapter 2) of the Quran that, it is the Quran in which there is Guidance what you have asked for! So why go looking for guidance elsewhere while there is direct guidance provided by our Lord (the main and the only source of all guidance) the Creator Himself in the Quran and assurance provided by Him therein!
Exactly. Sunnah is nice supplementary.. But Quran is thd only authentic script.
@@mariaray7614 hi are you follow Qur'an only , I'm beginner and I still confused how to pray without hadith, I mean how many rakaah each prayer
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow.
QURAN 31-6
And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment.
ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge.
ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist.
If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers.
Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay.
ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever.
Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
@@zullyfeehilly8968 How do you pray WITH the Hadith? Explain where it shows how to pray clearly in Hadith and I might agree with you.
If only yall put the amount of concentration while reading the Quran as you put when reading man made books, it will not be difficult to understand the holy Quran, the main source of Islam, which is alone enough than millions of man made books. No one can explain to you Allah's words better than Allah himself
Exactly 🙏
I seriously don't understand how people think that quran is not enough and fully explained/detailed. Allah send the quran for whole humankind not just for "sheikhs" etc. Literally everyone at my place is being mislead by so called "imams", they believe whatever they say without using their own reasoning...
I hope you are putting your concentration on reading Quran. But I don’t understand if you did, how would you be a follower of Arijit Singh and his picture in your profile. Most of his song lyrics contains shirk, and which goes sharply against Quran- the words of Allah.
@@ashraful2010 most of his songs does not contain shirk. Some do which I avoid. And how do you know if most of the songs do if you aren’t a follower of him? How come you listen to most of his songs? Gotcha. I am not a follower of him. I am a fan. This has nothing to do with Islam. Islam did not say that you cannot be a fan of anyone. Please don’t teach me false things. And mind your own business. If you don’t commit any sins and are a saint then Allah will reward you. Don’t try to judge the faith of others because that is very haram
@furkanyilmaz8552 Qur'an is fully explained and detailed; however, Allah says in the Qur'an that Muslims must obey the Prophet SAW. How are we supposed to obey him if we don't know any of his actions and words? That's why you have to look at the sahih hadith
You challenge Allah! Oh idol people: Allah himself that the holy Quran is fully detailed and complete. Our holy prophet said nothing but Quran
Yes is fully detail but can you put it into order ?
Oh you sure about that?
So all those verses of Quran which clearly state that Allah gave the Prophet revelation that was not in the Quran is what exactly?
Mik K which revelations ?? And Bukhari his book is not the revelation from Allah the Most Highest to Prophet Muhammed (pbuh)
Its a man made book and to believe it fully is too trust all the narrators and the ones who told them and from whom they heard it and bukhari plus the scholars that decide the authenticity and dont forget that satan would definitely mingle. Don’t get us wrong we trust the Prophet he is trustworthy one of the chosen but all the other people involved in hadiths make it the words of them and the best way is to go to the source of the Most Trustworthy, thats the Glorious Quran.
Praise Allah the Most Praiseworthy.
@@floodworldwide5260
If you do not understand the sciences of hadith which you very likely do not, then you are not in any position to be speaking about reliability.
What is fabricated and very weak is known. What is authentic and acceptable is known - everything in Bukhari meets the highest of standards in every regards as far as sciences of hadith go.
It is the best of the best as far as authenticity goes.
Those who attack him are ignorant modernist fools.
So they resort to slandering him instead because they are not capable of refuting his work, because in order to do so, they'd need to understand Quran to the level people like him did, have mastery over the arabic language, mastery over the sciences of hadith and real eemaan and taqwa.
Mik K You have no knowledge of the Quran, I dont need the hadith alhamdulilah praise Allah the Most Highest for blessing me with understanding, knowledge and trust in Him alone. Allah the Most Wise will judge between us all. I wish you the best brother and in shaa Allah one day all the branches go back to the origin: the Quran and finally become a huge tree, in shaa Allah
I reject Hadiths because neither the prophet nor the sahabahs were alive to testify that things written in the Hadiths are true or not.
I follow only the Qur'an but your logic is keen and your manner is Peaceful, and for this I am Grateful. I love your videos. Jazak Allah Khair Brother and Sister.
You cannot be a Muslim and reject all the Sahih Hadith. Allah says in the Qur'an to Obey Him and His messenger. How are you going to Obey the Prophet SAW if you don't look at the Saheeh Hadith? How are you going to know how to pray if you only look at the Qur'an? Yes, the Qur'an is Allah's words and the ultimate divine commands; however, that does not mean you can just totally not follow the Sahih hadith as that would be not following the way of Muhammad SAW which would be against Allah's command in the Qur'an.
But Allah(SWT) gave us the Quran and said to follow his messenger before hadiths existed. Hadiths came 200 years after the death of prophet Muhammad(saw).
@loveboxing162hman2 no, this is a common misconception. Hadiths were written during the time of Prophet Muhammad SAW and the right after his passing away amongst his closest Companions. Hadiths were COMPILED 200 years after the Prophet pbuh. Bulhari merely made it easier to access authentic hadith by putting them all in one book.
@@ahabarhossain773thank you for the clarification. Insha’Allah I will do my best to learn more and ask that Allah(SWT) keeps me on the straight path
@@ahabarhossain773 You are right, people have been collecting hadith even in the prophets time. But the reasaon why they were not compiled is because our prophet never wished for them to be compiled. We should focus our worship on god and follow the holy scripture. The sahaba were also not keen on hadith compilation. But islam corrupted as soon as people started narrating. While some narrations may be true, a good chunk will be completely false aswell. And no human has the capacity to 100% verify the authenticity.
There are also sahih hadith, that are against hadith. How do you explain those? Isn't that a bit paradox?
I am quranist Muslim but i liked the way he has tolerance to explain instead of other people simply started barking and calling us hypocrites.
+Fitim Krasniqi Let him speak dear :) i've even heard more bad compliments towards my faith. it's just as usual one. But thank you for a humble support ^_^
My problem with the speaker is that he twists the Quran. Allah says obey the messenger. However when the messenger dies, he can't be followed any longer and bukhari is not a substitute. He can't let go of hadith for some reason
May Allah guide you
@@bilalamarumosi8282
in. his. live. time. u. beliving. obeying him. (saw)
but . not. after. his dead. ( saw)
woow. ur. logic. is. beyond. binadam belive.
btw. i. m. not
agnist . any1. its. opinion. or. belive like others. do
in. my. belive. if. i belive. obeying prophet saw his. life. time. why. not. obeying. him. saw after. his. dead. saw
u. my. reject. some. bad. hadeeth. but. not. all. hadeeth. is. bad.
but plz
dont. reject. obeying
Rasool. lullaah . (saw)
quraan its. self. saying.
OBEY. ALLAH. AND. OBEY. RASOOL. LULALAH. SAW
ADEE. ULLAAH.
ADEE. URRASOOL.
(SAW)
quraan. didnt. say.
obey. prophet. (saw) his. life. time. only
if. u. have. prove show. . me. prove. from. quraan.
i. m. waiting thnks
@@bilalamarumosi8282
acording. to. u . there. is. some fake. hadeeth that.
u have. rejected.
but. u. know. there. is. many. hadeeth. talking. about. good
and. positive. islam
and. prophet. saw. and. righteouse. sahaaba. ahlul bayt
atleast. dont. reject.
5piller. islam. towheed. salaat
ramadaan. hajj zakah from. hadeeth
axplained
1QUESTION. DO. U. BELIVE.
( SHAHAADA TEYN )
TO. BECOME. MUSLIM.
LAA. ILLAAHA. ILLALLAAH MUHMMED. RASOOL. LULLAH. (SAW)
and. atleast. dont. deny. quraan. say.
OBEY. ALLAH. AND. OBEY. AND RASOOL. LULLAAH. (SAW)
REMEMBER.
QURAAN. DINT. SAY
OBEY . PROPHET. SAW. IN. HIS. LIFE TIME. ONLY. (SAW)
QURAAN . DIDNT. LIMITED. HOW. LONG TO OBEY
RASOOL. ULLAAH.
(SAW)
THIS. POINT. DESERVES. TO. RESEARCH. IF. U
ARE. SINCERE.
Wow im impressed. I wasnt expecting the kind of answer he gave. I was thinking he would say something along the lines of "you cant be a muslim if you reject hadith, only disbelievers do not follow the prophet". Instead he actually answered some of my questions and actually discussed some of my concerns. I appreciate it. Thank you for this video! Alhamduliah :D
You can NEVER be a Muslim if you made ouright rejections of Hadees, so remember that. Hadees is as important as the Prophet Mohammad Sallalahu alaihe wassalam blessed presence was and remain so, for spreading Islam and making it practicably applicable for the Ummah so we could have never known about Quran or its authenticity, had it not been preserved by the same people who actually preserved Hadees, and there are many places in Quran where Allah SWT asked us to follow the teaching as well as explanation of the Prophet (saw).
Allah says in 3:164,
"Allah has surely blessed the believers with His favours when He raised in their midst a messenger from amongst themselves, who RECITES to them His verses and makes them PURE and TEACHES them the Book and the WISDOM, while they were earlier in in the open error".
So, why on earth was Rasool ullah sent to the mankind when Allah would have made Angel Gabriel AS do it by following the commandments of Allah SWT and just passing it on to us? But Allah chose Prophets amongst us who were sent to recite us the verses of Allah, teach their meanings, teach their wisdom (the real treasure of Quran) and purify those who were close to them to make them an example for the rest of the Ummah to follow suit.
Truth prevails and who made u partner of Allah?
@the Jinn and here we have another self proclaimed delusional so called scholar
Remind us o great one, which aya u refering to that says hadith are not important
@@TheViperDawg
6:114 onwards
@@TheViperDawg
www.quranaloneislam.net/hadiths-the-cancer-of-islam
Here is an article which goes in depth on few aspects on this topic
submission.org/Why_Quran_Alone.html
Here you will find dozens of surah that make it clear that the quran is the only authentic revelation of Allah.
The hadiths are not the revelations of Muhammed about Allah, but of random scholars about Mohammed,though they did not even know him.
The Quran tells us to listen to Muhammed, because the Quran was revealed to us by him, not because his alleged lifestories are a better guide to live than the quran.
Challenge your beliefs on this, because even if you are ignorantly wrong, you will end in hell for directly and knowingly challenging the word and authority of Allah.
You idolize Mohammed instead of giving all praise to Allah.
Believing and idolizing are two different things, we are told to believe in Mohammed as the prophet and revealer and in the revelation of Allah (quran).
I think the system of belief of the majority of the people could be summed up with this:
[Verse 2.170] ..."They say: "Nay! we shall follow the ways of our fathers."...
Hence why most people go by whatever is the prevailing system of thought in their general surroundings. Sunni Muslim in the Middle East, Christian/Atheist in the West, Buddhist/Hindu in the East and so on...
In a sense they're all following the one and the same religion, "The Religion of Their Fathers". ;)
brother we all know well no one can be able to put quran into perfect order.
Because it was revealed in diferent moment.
Sunnah and pratice of prophet Muhammad pbuh
Is quran in action and order.
That why all those hadith which tell us how prophet pbuh act and do not contradict quran and where narrated by diferent companion are good hadith.
And
All those hadith which contradicte quran we must reject them.
And
All those hadith which where narrated by single narrator from one chain
We must doubt or reject them.
Because whaterver prophet pbuh teach He pbuh made it public.
@Eugen Lang
Dont be egnorant.
Read well what i have writen.
This 6 year old mariage is one of hadith.
Theys another hadith with diferent age.
Some says it was 16 and not 6.
[Quran 7:187] They ask you about the Hour, "When will it come?" Say, "Knowledge of it rests with my Lord. None can reveal its coming except He. It weighs heavily on the heavens and the earth. It will not come upon you except suddenly." They ask you as if you are responsible for it. Say, "Knowledge of it rests with God," but most people do not know.
[Quran 7:188] Say, "I have no control over any benefit or harm to myself, except as God wills. Had I known the future, I would have acquired much good, and no harm would have touched me. I am only a warner, and a herald of good news to a people who believe."
@@kabakonate7716 medium.com/@talalrafi/was-aisha-9-years-old-when-she-married-the-prophet-muhammad-20ae7516e428
@@kabakonate7716 www.discoveringislam.org/aisha_age.htm Hadiths aren't all legitimate, I was told 10 out of 100 are false and contradictory
25:52 “So do not obey the disbelievers, and strive against them with the Qur'an a great striving.”
I see no Hadith mentioned here.
Another good verse. Funny how the Muslim "sects" label Muslims who follow the Quran only "Quranists" when we are all Muslims... Salam
Follow the whole Quran not just 1 verse
Rango Hamid
It would be a good idea if you followed the Quran instead of Hadiths as guidance.
LOL You hm
@@senseisokodame9988 The Quran supports following ahadith of the messenger SWS
Quran 4:59 and many other places
where did Allah swt command in the Quran for people to compile information about what the Prophet Mohammad pbuh said and done etc ? If it is so important and associated with our Deen wouldnt Allah swt command the Prophets companions etc to record what the Prophet was saying and doing and command it to be legislation, Allah the almighty doesnt do things halfway and surely didnt send revelation that would be unclear and leave hanging in limbo with out Deen
What you said makes no sense you contradicted yourself because indeed Allah didn't command those things so what's your point?
M. F Öztoprak
Allah revealed the Quran to Mohammed in this exact order and ordered him to write it down.
@@sal_strazzullo Allah ordered Muhammad (saw) to write the Quran? I can prove you wrong.
Believe, then, in God and His Messenger - the unlettered Prophet who believes in God and His words - and follow him, so that you might find guidance! (7:158)
@@0m4r21o Hello, thanks for replying.
I know that verse, if you look at the various English translations, not all of them translate that word to "illiterate", some say that it means "Gentile" (according to how that same word is used in other parts of the book)
@@akaishasophie7730 you are exactly right
This channel should be named "Let Bukhari Speak".
Absolutely. He does more to reference hadith than anything. On top of that he twist ayat to make it seem like Allah is referring to hadith books. Smh
But brother can you put quran into order ?
Best hadith are those which put quran into order and do not contradicted it.
Search for those hadith.
@@kabakonate7716 Quran was in order b4 the prophet died. Allah refers to the Qur'an as a book. What the hell you need hadith for?
An English translation of the Quran - 12:111 In their stories is a lesson for those who possess intelligence. It is not a narration that has been invented, but an authentication of what is between his hands and a detailing of all things, and a guidance and a mercy for a people who believe.
6:114 "Shall I seek other than God as a judge when He has sent down to you the Book fully detailed?" Those to whom We have given the Book know it is sent down from your Lord with the truth; so do not be of those who have doubt. 6:115 And the word of your Lord has been completed with truth and justice; there is no changing His words. He is the Hearer, the Knower. 6:116 And if you obey most of those on the earth they will lead you away from the path of God; that is because they follow conjecture, and that is because they only guess.
Meersad hm
My question. How reliable is a book written 214 years after the last verse of Quran was revealed upon our Prophet pbuh?
@@muhammedaydn8610 Also scholars use hadiths to impose their power on people, and then claim that's it's true words of the prophet, to force people into submitting to them instead of God
Bukhari collected 400 THOUSAND hadeeths according to his own book and only 7 thousand made it as "saheeh" and even those contradict each other and the quran! That tells you everything.
@@pranav5183
He collected 600,000
@@pranav5183 wtf are you on about ??? not a singl3 bukhari hadith contradicts itself
@@dang7096 shows your'e just another blind follower. Google it and enjoy mate.
One of the most balanced and open minded scholars around. Barak Allah!
The quran also mention in (45:6)These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement(Hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe?
Mofi Lilee
I think sister Salma Ismail is apparently more educated that the commentator who tried to degrade a fellow. It is the greatness of the lady that she did not feel essential to respond further... I appreciate the civilized behavior
The aayat is clear like bright sunny day. It says
"These are the verses of God We convey to you with truth. Then, in what HADITH, if not in God and His verses, will they believe?"
Means any addition to these words should not be believed . Period !
In my opinion if anyone derives a meaning that
it is not about Hadees e Mohammadi and is only about " any words/speeches/talks" even then it means that one should not believe anything in addition to the words of Quran.
Quran assures dignity of every soul. Everyone is equally respectable. I again say that using such defamatory comments about the person who only tries to express an idea/ point of view, can not be undermined like this, nor the truth can be reduced by such an attempt.
It only exposes the stature of the person who commits such an act. and who considers himself an authority. whereas no one is authority except God Almighty.
regard and respect to all
lahasil100 In reference to Salama Ismail's not responding to Mofi Lilee you wrote; "It is the greatness of the lady that she did not feel essential to respond further..." Maybe, just maybe.....she cant! But you didn't confirm that with her did you? Or are you assuming again? Please, unless you confirm something, don't make up things by your own desires/conjectures. Especially since that's what you claim happened with ahadith compilation. You know what that will make you......;) And I've got to tackle this one with a question. You wrote; "no one is authority except God Almighty." Then, who is Allah referring to in the Quran when He swt, said; 4:59-{O you who believe, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and THOSE IN AUTHORITY among you}? You? Gee, I wonder.......
Sayf Oz lahasil100 hezbollahnyc
[Quran 7:185] Have they not looked at the dominion of the heavens and the earth, and all the things God has created? Does it ever occur to them that the end of their life may be near? Which HADITH, besides this (Quran) do they believe in?
[Quran 31:6] Among the people, there are those who uphold baseless HADITH, and thus divert others from the path of God without knowledge, and take it in vain. These have incurred a shameful retribution.
[Quran 39:23] God has revealed herein the BEST HADITH; a book that is consistent and points out both ways (to heaven and hell). The skins of those who reverence their Lord cringe therefrom, then their skins and their hearts soften up for God's message. Such is God's guidance; he bestows it upon whomever He wills. As for those sent astray by God, nothing can guide them.
[Quran 45:6] These are God's revelations (Quran) that we recite to you truthfully. In which HADITH other than God and His revelations do they believe?
[Quran 52:34] Let them produce a HADITH like this (Quran) if they are truthful.
[Quran 68:44] Therefore, let Me deal with those who reject this HADITH(Quran); we will lead them on whence they never perceive.
[Quran 77:50] Which HADITH other than this do they uphold?
TO sayf Oz
Read again and you will see that you are the one who talks out with no knowledge. iam only giving examples from the quran which makes it clair that this book of god is complete and fully detailed and doesnt need anything beside it of any sayings, hadith or whatever.
[6:114] Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed? Those who received the scripture recognize that it has been revealed from your Lord, truthfully. You shall not harbor any doubt.
Salama Ismail 6 months later only to repeat the same Ayat but you still can not answer our questions relating to the Quran alone. How very pathetic indeed. We've heard this all before and this was no come back my dear. Get real and go away, please.
We have brought them a Scripture - We have explained it on the basis of knowledge - as guidance and mercy for those who believe." (Qur’an 7:52)
In the Quran, 4th Surah Nisa, Ayat/Verse Number 80 (Quran 4:80)
من يطع ٱلرسول فقد أطاع ٱلله ومن تولى فما أرسلناك عليهم حفيظا
Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah, and whoever turns away, We have not sent you as a guardian over them.
@@w00lywarriorofficial it says "obey the messenger" not obey anyone who comes in centuries later and claims to have traditions of messenger, even though those traditions are anti-Quranic. don't fix a lie on the messenger and Allah.
@@asr2009 The hadith traditions were followed widely and numerously since the prophet lived, and it continued after his death through his companions. Go check Histroy on an academic level instead of copying statements made by degenerate "Quranist" people who have no idea what they're talking about and morely contradicts themselves.
Thank you for another excellent video. I love your approach to a middle path, just like what is instructed in the Quran...
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow.
QURAN 31-6
And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment.
ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge.
ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist.
If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers.
Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay.
ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever.
Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
God says the Quran is fully detailed how can you say you need more details bro ??
Because they follow what was said to them by others..
@@Quran-Life exactly
Holy Quran 17:89
-------------------
And We have certainly diversified for the people in this Qur'an from every [kind] of example, but most of the people refused [anything] except disbelief.
I’ve been Quran (mostly) for 4 years and I’ve never been happier
Hamid M Quran only is way to go.
Brother how quran say namaz is farz but how to pray is hadith
@@sufiyanshaikh7550 if you would have read the Holy Quran you would know how to pray correctly!
@@dra7582 never. Find plz cote verses if u read whole quran prof kay saath baath karo bhai
@@sufiyanshaikh7550 don’t we muslims learn to pray by watching other muslims pray?
"In the Name of God the Most beneficent the Most Merciful"
This is what the suni scholar said and I Quote:
"This shows the the Prophet role and function included EXPLAINING the Quran."
[Quran 75:16-19] Do not move your tongue to hasten it. It is we who will collect it into Quran. Once we recite it, you shall follow such a Quran. Then it is WE who will EXPLAIN it.
So God Stopped Muhammad from explaining the Quran, It was only God's duty to explain it.
So I guess suni scholars make make horrible mistakes!
And Following the Quran alone is following what Muhammad said. Which is to follow nothing else other than the Quran alone. He did this until he died. And corrupted suni's 250 years after Muhammad's death created hadith books and attributed to the Prophet to make a small gain.
[Quran 25:30] The messenger said (on the Day of Judgment), "My Lord, my people have DESERTED this Quran."
Salam.
But brother can you put quran into order ?
Best hadith are those which put quran into order and do not contradicted it.
Search for those hadith.
Salaamalaikum. The verses you are referring to 75:16 -19, if put into context (really important to do that) are speaking about method of recitation of the Quran taught to Muhammad SAW through Gebrael AS. 75:19 states that clarification of the Quaran is upon US (majestic US implied) to you. This is directly addressed to the Prophet SAW. So it begs the question "is it not the Prophet SAW job to then explain to his followers upon receiving the "clarification" of verses in the Quran from Allah?
@@aehmerchant actually prophet muhammad's job was only to spread the words of God. Not all ayah, prophet muhammad knew or understand, meaning: not all ayah were explained to him. For example the first ayah "nuuun", etc.
Mojee140x uP
@@gondala It seems that there is a contradiction in Quran: “(We sent these above mentioned men) with clear proofs and Scriptures. And (similarly now) We have revealed to you the Reminder that you may explain to mankind (the commandments) that have been sent down to them so that they may ponder and reflect”. 16:44
This is a gem of a video ♥️🇬🇧
Proof from the Quran that the sunnah is actually from Muhammad?
None
There's only one sunnah mentioned in the Quran and that's Allah's sunnah..
:)
For 300 years after rasool died. Not a single hadith's. No one needed them.
So after they were complete?
Why the change?
Allah knows best
+😼VeganKitty😼 "There's only one sunnah mentioned in the Quran and that's Allah's sunnah"
Yes, we have to do what Allah SWT does. Wait...
"For 300 years after rasool died. Not a single hadith's. No one needed them."
During the time of Rasulullah SAW and even after his death SAW, people asked about how he SAW did this how he SAW did that. Because they want to follow the man who they love.
Let's say I'm a football player. If I see Ronaldo, I would try and become like Ronaldo. Ronaldo is like my hero or the one who made me love to play football or something. This situation is as same as that. People following Rasulullah SAW because they loved him SAW.
+Adam Zaim (OfficialAdamMZ) You just compared the prophet SAW to Cristiano Ronaldo. Ronaldo is your hero? Ronaldo himself would tell you not to copy him but to come to your own understanding of football.
Similarly the prophet would tell you not to copy his every supposed action. To read the Quran and come to understand the clearest most complete book ever. He would tell you that the Hadith don't reflect his character, or even his actions. But what was said about him by people who never met him.
+AryansWerentWhite Find your own history so you misguided fool want to say that the rasulullah sallallahu alayhimwa sallam will tellmus to get our own understanding of ISLAM,,is that what you munafiqs do finding your own understanding and interpretation of ISLAM?!?!?! and you stupid fools want to say that we are making sects in ISLAM!?!?! we who want to follow only Qur'an and sunnah like the prophet alayhi sallam and the three generations of ISLAM and not to add our own personal meaning and desires into it so there can be no deviation in ISLAM!?!? and you munafiqs who say we don't need the sunnah, we don't need to follow Muhammad alayhi salam we don't need his explanation of the Qur'an, we will make our own tafseer, our own interpretation in fact everyone can interpret the Qur'an as he pleases and can do what he wants so we could have with every single individual a different sect because everyone will interpret the Qur'an how he thinks is the best for serving his desires and needs and we can be sodomites and at the same time Muslims although ALLAH destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah to the last men but we can be sodomites and Muslims, we don't need to cover our women we can let them go like the kafirah who are selling themselves in the streets walking around half naked and some of them almost naked and even some go completely naked, we can drink alcohol, we can eat whatever we want, we don't have to pray 5 times a day its too much for us, we will fight for the rights of those whom ALLAH cursed in the Qur'an(homosexuals), we will fight for our women to mix freely with men who are not mahram to them and letting our women to work with men and giving birth to a child from her boss because in 40-60 % in the western secular satanic society that what is happening, we will not kill the homosexuals and adulterers although AIDS is spread because of them and statistics tells us that homosexuals are number one in addiction to AIDS, number 2 prostitutes and pornography actors and number 3 having more sexual partners outside of marriage but NO we will fight for the rights of those scums to spread their disease in our society and even to get married and adopt children so the can make an army of Sodomites, we will let everyone to leave according to his desires and his personal views so that we can have another Urban II the pope who invoked the crusades and another Hitler, Mao ze thung and Stalin and of course another Darwin who will teach us how to continue the evolution by killing ourselves and the strong destroying the weak, the white destroying the black so that the evolution may continue by natural selection, is this the ISLAM you are inviting people!?!?!?!?! is this what you believe is the only truth!?!?! is this is the way of the prophets!?!?!? and is this is the ISLAM on which you are on!?!?!?! I'm observing you people for quite a while and this is what i found out about you and your religion you so called qurani muslims, you are the greatest weapon of illuminati AND Dajjal but be sure that Isa alayhi salam will return and you will be destroyed along with your master Dajjal!!!! May Allah punish you and guide those who seek guidance Ameen!
+Adam Zaim (OfficialAdamMZ) that just proof that it the same as idoltary.
+Setec 2 +Setec 2 +Setec 2
1. Muhammad didnt tell us to get our own understanding. Is it nor cleared to u what Allah said in the quran that it is cleared and fully detailed? Have u read the quran btw? Or do u have doubts in the Quran?
2. We munafiqs? Allah ask us to follow what that have been revealed by him in the quran yet u choose to follow another book which is not by allah and u called us munafiqs? Who is following allah's command?
3. Sunni is a sect. Shia is a sect. Who guys have hadith. We dont, we only need the devine quran. Prophet muhammad didnt have sahih bukhari did he?
4. "We who want to follow only quran and sunnah like the prophet muhammad"? What sunnah did prophet muhammad followed? He followed the sunnah of allah which is the quran. Like i said, there was no sahih bukhari.
5. U should really read the quran.
All you need is Quran
Quran doesn’t need anything else, quran is a miracle of allah
Hadiths have messed up Islam. Sunnah is NOT equal to Hadith. Sunnah is the practical deeds of the prophet like Salaat, etc having come to us directly from the time of the Prophet, which has a larger consensus, but I am NOT giving even a penny to Israr Ahmed Khan to teach me how to sift hadiths. There were NO hadiths during the time of the Prophet!
If YOU are a good scholar, Mr Shabbir, why do YOU allow FAKE hadiths to exist in the collection? Even before debating the Christians, why don't YOU clean YOUR house first?
Why is it theres a negative connotation when one is called a Quranist? but not a Hadithist?
39:23 God has revealed herein the best Hadith; a book that is consistent, and points out both ways . The skins of those who reverence their Lord cringe therefrom, then their skins and their hearts soften up for GOD's message. Such is GOD's guidance; He bestows it upon whoever wills (to be guided). As for those sent astray by GOD, nothing can guide them,
Allah SWT said:
تَبَارَكَ الَّذِى نَزَّلَ الْفُرْقَانَ عَلٰى عَبْدِهِۦ لِيَكُونَ لِلْعٰلَمِينَ نَذِيرًا
"Blessed is He who sent down the Criterion upon His Servant that he may be to the worlds a warner -"
(QS. Al-Furqaan 25: Verse 1)
AsA I’m a Former ✝️ Christian
💭💭💭So Allah tells me to do something in the Quran (Allah’s Hadith) and rather then asking Allah to help me understand.... I must also seek out the Human Hadith (descriptions from mankind) to understand Allah...ok
I didn’t need the Human Hadith to Revert.
When I heard the Quran (Allah’s Hadith)
I responded as the Quraysh did when they heard the Quran (19:58).
No Human Hadith needed then. I rely on Allah azza wa Jal Alone.
Like our Messiah Isa (a.s.)...or would Isa (a.s.) also read the Human Hadith if it were available to him...seriously?! 🧐
I think Jesus Christ/Isa (a.s) will know of the Quran (Allah’s Hadith) and none of the Human Hadith.
Shahid Imran Hussain
All thanks be to Allah! 🥰
Ashiya Rodriguez Carter hm
Aasiyah, so your saying you do NOT need the Hadiths, can I ask you some questions:
1) Do you recite the SHAHADA (y/n)
2) Do you pray FIVE times a day (y/n)
3) Do you encircle the Kaaba SEVEN times (y/n)
4) Do you run between As-Safa and Al-Marwa SEVEN times (y/n)
If the answer is YES to any or all of these questions, please show me the verse in the Quran.
Adam the Freemason.
If I am unable to do any of these things will ALLAH swt reject me?
There are Muslims who accepted Allah with their hearts but were never able to say the Shahada.
There are Muslims who were not able to pray or only able to pray once before their death.
There are Muslims who have died before ever going on Hajj
As Muslims I do not believe that ALLAH swt judges us Not by the number of our actions but rather the sincerity within them.
I once asked an imam what does a one arm left handed Muslim do when they eat? Are they constantly feeding Shaytaan since their left handed with only one arm? He said ALLAH knows best.
The fact that you’re asking me these questions means that your searching for things humans cannot provide.
Adam the Freemason.
czcams.com/video/0F6f6osL-Ms/video.html
MAY ALLAH GUIDE US ALL.
Whose version of Sunnah? Salafi or Sufi? Ahle Hadith or Ahle Sunnah? Ahle Fiqh? Shia or Sunni? Excercise you right to judge all secondary sources according to Al Furqan.
There is only one sunnah that is of our Prophet Muhammad(pbuh).The people follow the 4 schools of thought and that is why people differ.There is only one sunnah.if a hadith goes against the Quran then it is wrong however the others are perfectly fine
He is just a Muslim
Hadith scholars don't get this....
Quranic muslims DO NOT (and cannot, as true muslims) reject the TRUE sunna and what the Rasul ACTUALLY said, i.e., what we can be 100% SURE the Rasul said and did, i.e., that which is in the Qur'an, which is the ONLY hadith about which there is no doubt.
What I DO reject is the hadith/sunna AS EXPLAINED by Bukhari et al. Now, it MAY be true that some of these are authentic, but a glass of juice with even the tiniest drop of poison added to it is not juice. It's poison!
It is a LIE that the Rasul married a 6-year old. I reject this, and many other so-called hadith as filth!
Seems there are many QURAN ONLY followers here. Thanks to God for guiding me. I converted from sunnism to ISLAM.
Salamun Alaikum! The same Alhamdulillah! Coming from Christianity I quickly began to see the stark similarities between what Christians did with Prophet Isa (as) in what's known as the Bible & what Mohammadeans are doing with Prophet Mohammad (as) in what's known as Ahadith. I think it's important to study the messengers & texts that came before in order to keep from repeating the same mistakes that Qur'an was sent to correct..ie: following & emulating the messenger instead of the message.
Ohh finally found someone like me...I also come from Sunni background but now all on a sudden realized the truth about the fabrication of hadees...I also wanna start following only The Quran but I'm a little confused about prayer....
I've heard that the Qur'ans salah does not mean ritual prayer... what do u do? How do u pray "salah" ? Can u give me some advice?
@@senseisokodame9988 I still pray similar to sectarians. Only difference is I do the 3 mentioned in Qur'an and don't mention any name other than Allah during prayer. This is a topic that I highly suggest you read the Qur'an for answers to your heart.
@@winig5558 ohh ok, tnx bud 👍
MashAllah you are great. You make very good and strong analogies that put a lot of thoughts in perspective. Keep up the great work akhi (brother in Arabic). Jazak Allahu Khair
Brother, you stole the stage. Mashallah. May Allah reward you and continue to guide you and all the Muslimeen and those who are lost and need to come back to true Islam. Ameen.
Holy Quran 6:115
And the word of your Lord has been fulfilled in truth and in justice. None can alter His words, and He is the Hearing, the Knowing.
I have great respect for Shayk Shabir, I cannot agree with what he is saying. I have been studying hadiths for about 20 years. I have been studying Quran for all my life. I study other religions for over 15 years. I am into comparative religions. Then few years, i have realized that i was reading the Quran with the Hadith Glasses. Quran is Furkan we should look at the world with Quran glass.
Hadiths are just like Talmud, both are oral tradition written down.
1. Hadiths were written down 200 years after the prophet by bunch of Iranians (persians). Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawood, Thirmidi, Nasai and few others are all Iranians.
2. All of them have Da'f hadiths (lie/rejected) hadiths. I am asking if they were truly knowledgable person writing them as first account from people didn't they know that those hadiths are Da'f already?
3. If we take schools of thoughts like Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi, Hanbali, Zahiri in order; Imam Hanafi was Persian! I wonder what is this persians and Islam. As is islam came from Iran. Back in those days, Majority of the Jewish population lived in Iran. and the Hadiths are just like Talmud like I said before.
Only Imam Malik was from Madina. Anywhere they might have had great technology they might have used whatsapp or something to communicate who knows. I can give you all these Imams details and even the year of hadiths that are heart and soul to the religion. I used to compare other holy books with our religious books. Now i am asking the same questions i used to ask. "Hāthu Burhanakum inKunthum Saadikēn" comparing Quran and hadiths, sadly hadiths are contradicting. You want history book maybe we can use it for that. but not good for guidance.
Hadiths of Allah is the only hadith Allah is telling us to accept it. Anyone with little bit of knowledge and remember to remove the hadith glasses and look into the Quran you will see it. Even the great scholars cannot see because they are looking at the Quran and the world through hadith.
Hadiths (Muslim Oral Tradition written down by bunch of Imams/Alims) = Talmud (Jewish Oral Tradition written down by bunch of Rabbais).
Thafseer = Misnah (Jewish Book explaining the Tanakh mostly)
Sunnis are upgraded Jews version 2.0
Shia are upgraded Jews version 1.0
25:30 "And the Messenger has said (Will say), "O my Lord, indeed my people have left/abandoned this Qur'an"
Read it with the context. Start from 25:27.
Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah often. Al qur an. 33:21
200 Years after Prophet death there was no book of hadeeth or the 4 Khalifa has felt necessities of preserving hadeeth or allowed any Shahaba to narrate hadeeth. In fact Khalifa Umar was very strict on hadeeth as he feared if any Shahsba says something which is not correct or misinterpret that goes against Quran & Khalifa Umar will be answerable to Allah.. He kept Abu Hurayra house areest for narrating hadeeth...So, we should use our knowledge from Quran..
Please define Sunnah.
Sunnah = Path/Way
Who's path do we follow? Mohammad or Allah?
Quran: sunnatullah = the path of God; mentioned numerous times. Sunnah Mohammad; never mentioned.
Chosen One The Hadith you quoted is a Hadith that the prophet Muhammad salallahu alaihi wasalam said in Mecca, the early period of Islam.
In the early Meccan times, the prophet forbade writing Hadith because he feared that people would confuse it with Quran.
But after that, it was permissible to write ahadith
MustBe TheMost follow the Sunnah of Muhammad salallahu alaihi wasalam.
Allah commands it Say, [O Muhammad], "If you should love Allah , then follow me (by adhering to the sunnah), [so] Allah will love you and forgive you your sins. And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful."
Surah Ali Imran ayah 31
James D the Sahaba followed him and they have all passed. We cannot make clear from hadith what is true and not. But from the Quran we can agree there is no confusion. I find the hadiths to have harsh and explicit aspects. And I'm speaking of Sahih Bukhari and Muslim. Leave Abu Dawud and other misc hadiths alone, which get even worse and worse. I've read these books brother, there is no defense for some of the contents.
MustBe TheMost
We can find true Hadith and untrue Hadith. Abu Dawud and many other sunbath books have weak and fabricated Hadith.
However, there is a whole study on finding which Hadith are authentic and which are not authentic.
So we can in fact know when a Hadith is sahih
But books Muslim and Bukhari are considered Sahih. In fact all Hadith root from Al Bukhari. The very "system" you speak of is the chain of narration which Bukhari outlined for his Sahih book. Muslim was his student, as well as Abu Dawud. But I'm contending that hadiths are from chains of narration going back 8 authors deep minimum. A collection of hearsay assembled from Khorasan to Egypt, 200+ years after Mohammads death, pbuh.
Salam Alaikum. I have 12 simple questions for Traditional Muslims, and I hope you could be the first person to attempt in answering them after sincerely reflecting upon them, God-willing:
*1)* Throughout the Quran, we frequently see its reference to itself as “Al-Quran”. Why then is there not a single place in the entire Quran where a secondary scripture or divine revelation called “As-Sunnah” (the Sunnah) or “Al-Hadith An-Nabawi” (the Prophetic Hadith) is likewise mentioned? Doesn’t the Quran constantly claim that it is clear & straightforward? How then could God take the time to mention something as seemingly trivial as onions and lentils (Quran 2:61), and yet fail to clearly identify the most important source of guidance & revelation that all believers for all times are forever required to follow as religious guidance?
*2)* Why do the words “Hadith” and “Sunnah” nevertheless amazingly appear over and over again throughout the Quran, yet never ONCE refer to what traditional Muslims use them as? (as the inspired words & teachings of the Prophet). Not only this, but the words “Sunnah” and “Hadith” are in fact often used throughout the Quran in ways that refer to the supremacy & exclusive authority of the Quran’s message itself, thus in almost a taunting manner towards what traditional Muslims would later come to believe about the “prophetic Hadith” and this idea of ‘dual revelation’ (see for example Q 77:50, 46:5, 39:23). If there was actually a second scripture or revelation ordained by God called the ‘Sunnah/Hadith’, wouldn’t this be extremely deceptive and misleading?
*3)* Why does the Quran constantly make mention of itself and it’s perfect guidance, lack of contradictions, and promise of its preservation, and so on, yet make NO such magnificent claims about the Sunnah if it is indeed a co-authoritative revelation of God to humanity? Wouldn’t we at least expect that the Quran adds something like the phrase “ والسنة” (‘and the Sunnah’) in these numerous verses where the Quran alone is uniquely mentioned as the supreme guidance & sacred revelation?
*4)* Why does the so-called Prophetic Sunnah (as supposedly codified in the Hadith) contradict the Quran in so many significant ways? For example, so-called “Sahih” Hadiths tell us that tiger and other animals are forbidden to eat, whereas the Quran is manifestly clear-multiple times, in fact-that the ONLY four prohibited foods are carrion, blood, pig’s meat, and idol-offerings; nothing more (Quran 6:145). Or for example, Sahih Hadiths tell is that the Prophet will be an intercessor on Judgement Day for those in his Ummah who committed MAJOR sins, whereas the Quran clearly states that anyone who commits major sins and fails to repent will be condemned to Hell, and will have no protector, intercessor, or savior. How can these teachings be a “commentary” on the Quran (as virtually all sunni Muslim scholars posit) when they blatantly contradict it? (P.S. Ask me for any specific references if needed).
*5)* Why do you say that the Sunnah (as supposedly preserved in the Hadith) is a commentary on the Quran, when we know that the Hadith is actually just a collection of isolated sayings and doings of the Prophet and his companions, with less than 1% actually being direct commentary on the Quran? How can one claim this especially when considering the massive disagreement amongst traditional sects and scholars when it comes to Hadith-based theology, as well as numerous clear & major contradictions between the Quran and Hadith as pointed out above?
*6)* Why does the Quran constantly make mention of the Torah and Gospel, as well as the Psalms and other revealed scriptures of God-and call these “guidance” and “beacons of light”-while no such honorable mention is ever made of the supposed second revelation that God allegedly sent down to the Prophet as the inspired Sunnah? How could God possibly fail to prioritize the divine identification of the Sunnah/Hadith-which is supposedly INDISPENSABLE for understanding the Quran itself-and yet constantly make mention of the amazing wonder & authority of the previous scriptures & revelations, which we aren’t even required to follow anymore? Once again, wouldn’t this seem to be gravely misleading?
*7)* If we got rid of the Quran and just kept all of the accepted Hadith, don’t you think that the current religion of traditional Islam would still be perfectly intact? In other words, isn’t the Hadith alone sufficient for nearly everything you need to practice traditional Islam in its current form? What then is the need for the Quran under this framework? What other essential use or practical value does the Quran actually provide that the Hadith cannot? In fact, isn’t this why the Sunni Muslim scholars of the past were forced to admit “the Quran is in more need of the Sunnah than the Sunnah is in need of the Quran”?
*8)* Why is there such a massive difference between the structure of the Quran (the codified words of God) and the structure of the Hadith (the alleged codified words of the Prophet) if they are both indeed co-equal legally-binding divine revelations brought down by God? For example, the Quran is preserved word-for-word, whereas the Hadith is mainly preserved meaning-to-meaning; the Quran is unique in style and incredibly easy to memorize & recite, whereas the Hadith is clearly human literature and was not made for easy memorization; the Quran has a set ‘canon’ that is more-or-less unanimously agreed upon and was transmitted as such, whereas the Hadith consists of thousands of disjointed unrelated reports that had to be individually collected and vigorously authenticated using human-devised methods of verification; and the list goes on. If both the Quran and the Sunnah were equally divine revelations of God, why is this the case? Yet isn’t this EXACTLY what one would expect if people falsely attributed a human work of literature as being divine revelation alongside God’s true word?
*9)* If you were to hand a copy of the Quran to an unbiased stranger who spoke fluent classical Arabic, and had them read the Quran for the first time, from beginning to end, and with no other source of information-would they come back to you confused and puzzled, and be asking you for the secondary scripture & co-divine revelation called the “Prophetic Sunnah & Hadith” that they were allegedly supposed to read about in the Quran?
*10)* The Quran mentions that the Jinn (the beings of the unseen realm; the parallel creation to us human beings) can actually hear the Quran being recited and follow it as such (Quran 72:1); thus we learn that the Quran is even a source of guidance for Jinn themselves. Therefore, is it required for the Jinn to follow the Sunnah & Hadith? If not, why not? But if so, how so? What model do you propose for such a thing to work?
*11)* We already know and agree that the previous generations before us who were given scripture & prophethood by Allah (SWT) went far astray and added all sorts of falsehoods and fake traditions to their religion, including the Talmud of the Jews (who also interestingly claim that it contains ancient traditions of Moses passed down as commentary on the Torah) as well as the writings of Paul & the early Church fathers, whom Christians have essentially given precedence over Jesus’ own words and have thereby begun to worship the Trinity and hold other serious false beliefs, that can even lead one to eternal damnation on Judgement Day. With this (frightening) reality in mind, shouldn’t we be wary that WE too might also have gone astray from the pure teachings of God in the Quran? Wouldn’t it be utterly foolish and careless of us to ignore the warnings of Allah (SWT) about the historical corruptions & fabrications of the people of divine Scripture before us, and thus fail to consider that we too might be deviating from the right path just as they once did?... Indeed, when Prophet Moses left his people for just 40 days to meet with God, he came back to find them committing no less than the most heinous & atrocious sin of worshipping a carved idol, even after they had seen all that God did for them in Egypt. That was 40 DAYS; what then do you think of the Prophet’s followers after 1,400 years?
*12)* Finally, what WOULD the Quran actually have to say for you to accept that it is the only revelation brought down from God to the Prophet? The Quran already says countless times that it is clear & lucid, sufficient for guidance, detailed & self-explanatory, unmatched & supreme, and perfectly preserved-so what else could the Quran possibly say for you to realize that it is indeed what it claims to be, and that no other scriptures or revelations are mandated on us to follow?
I hope you will contemplate on these questions deeply & sincerely, and reflect with a clear & open mind. I look forward to your response. Much Salam.
I have a question for you
Did the Prophet sallahu alayhi wassalam receive revelation that was not in the Quran?
Did the Prophet salalhu alayhi wassalam come to explain the Quran to the people or just parrot the verses to them and let them figure out the rest?
@@mikk3150 the sole duty of messanger is convey the message
I know you do not believe this ayat..
Say and think whatever you want, but you are in kufr to these ayahs.. make tauba and accept this
Brother I'd like to clarify that Allah only permitted us to eat certain foods and excluded the blood, pig meat, dead etc. Dont mix that up with thinking that we are allowed to eat everything, just please re-read all the verses about what food is permitted and whats not then you will get it.
@@kherona “I find absolutely NOTHING forbidden for ANYONE to eat whatsoever, in ALL that has been revealed-UNLESS it be these four things: carrion, spilled blood, pig’s meat which is foul, or a sinful offering dedicated to something other than God. But whoever is forced to eat these out of necessity, rather than desire or transgression-then God is certainly forgiving and merciful.” - Qur’an 6:145
The Qur’an SEVERELY disagrees with you, brother.
Please read carefully-our Lord is clear; and could not have been any more clear.
Salam.
I know what you mean, and I dont dare to say something is forbidden where Allah says its allowed in Quran, but I want to clarify and clear the mis-understanding.
Please check the following verses (where Allah specify what is allowed for us):
1- livestock (actually its birds/livestock and anything that eats grass), in arabic its called الانعام:
**And permitted to you are the grazing livestock, except what is recited to you. So avoid the uncleanliness of idols and avoid false statement ** Surah Al-Hajj: Verse 30
2- permitted to us whats inside the sea or water:
** Lawful to you is game from the sea and its food as provision for you and the travelers. ** Surah Al-Maidahsurah Al-Maidah Verse 96
3- Again permitted is cattle:
** O you who believe! Fulfill (your) obligations. Lawful to you (for food) are all the beasts of cattle except that which will be announced to you (herein),** Al-Mā’idah Verse 1
4- We are permitted to eat what Jews and Christians (people of the book are allowed to):
** The good things have this day been made lawful to you. The food of those to whom the Book was given is lawful to you, and your food is lawful to them. ** Al-Mā’idah - Verse 5
Brother you have to think about this, Allah has permitted for us what is allowed, if you think everything is allowed as you say. Then we are allowed to eat Humans or anything else like insects/bats/rats etc etc. This is bad for health and for humans and Allah wouldn't want it for us.
Whats dangerous is that some people take Hadiths that prohibits what Allah permitted us (some cattle or livestock) and Allah warned those people who say that.
However if you want to read the Quran you have to read thoroughly through verses.
If you see what Allah restricted us, is all the things that are "PART OF" the allowed things but are not permitted, i.e the blood/dead/pig are all part of Cattle/Livestock which is permitted, but these are things that are prohibited. I hope you get the point.
@@celestialknight2339
You're all afraid of the Quran
Because Quran supports science, critical thinking, logic, rational people,...
You're all afraid to lose the right way. The hadis and sunnah are so much that you don't know all of them so you feel you're safe. And last but not least: you are a sheep, you are afraid to take another way than the majority.
The way of Allah is the Quran, not the hadis or sunnah.
The prophet Muhammed was a follower of Quran. Not a follower of Buhari, Davud, Muslim, Trimizi...all of them lived 200 or more years after the death of Muhammed. So Muhammed was a Quranist
oguzhan just watch the video again
well said. because the prophet only followed the quran.very good point .if mohammad didnt follow bukhari and sahy sita and the four khalifs didnt so
why shoud we have to follow it . and if we need interpretaion of quran what did the first hundred years muslims do .they didnt have the bukhari and muslim
so very good point
so how to follow sunnah
napoleon , you smacked the entire hadith-sects with one post😂❤️
Salam people, let us please desist from putting hard-line labels on everything by calling ourselves Quranists. The Quran itself refers to the likes of us as Mumineen. It is strict definitions and labels like that which fuel sectarianism and ultimately veers us off the straight path. May Allah have mercy on us all and guide us
*"Quran Alone"* was mentioned explicitly in the Quran.
وَجَعَلنا عَلىٰ قُلوبِهِم أَكِنَّةً أَن يَفقَهوهُ وَفى ءاذانِهِم وَقرًا وَإِذا ذَكَرتَ رَبَّكَ فِى *القُرءانِ وَحدَهُ* وَلَّوا عَلىٰ أَدبٰرِهِم نُفورًا
17:46 We place shields around their minds, to prevent them from understanding it, and deafness in their ears. And when you preach your Lord, using the *Quran alone,* they run away in aversion.
❤❤❤❤
In the Quran, 4th Surah Nisa, Ayat/Verse Number 80 (Quran 4:80)
من يطع ٱلرسول فقد أطاع ٱلله ومن تولى فما أرسلناك عليهم حفيظا
Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah, and whoever turns away, We have not sent you as a guardian over them.
[Quran 7:187] They ask you about the Hour, "When will it come?" Say, "Knowledge of it rests with my Lord. None can reveal its coming except He. It weighs heavily on the heavens and the earth. It will not come upon you except suddenly." They ask you as if you are responsible for it. Say, "Knowledge of it rests with God," but most people do not know.
[Quran 7:188] Say, "I have no control over any benefit or harm to myself, except as God wills. Had I known the future, I would have acquired much good, and no harm would have touched me. I am only a warner, and a herald of good news to a people who believe." I rest my case
Good sis
Tammy, yes Allah has "knowledge of the Hour" (Quran 7:187), yet also Jesus has "knowledge of the Hour" (Quran 43:61), how is so if he is NOT the "son of God", hmm strange.
@@AdamtheFreemason of course the lord told his messengers everything duhhhh 61. And (Jesus) shall be A Sign (for the coming Of) the Hour (of Judgment): Therefore have no doubt About the (Hour), but Follow ye Me: this Is a Straight Way.
tammy Gallant So the prophecies in the Hadith someone is just guessing them all? Are you serious?
@@pmpm1841 www.google.com/amp/s/raseef22.com/article/amp/1076059/the-secret-history-of-hadith-the-prophet-refused-it-and-abu-bakr-burnt-it
I love it when the believers of man made books published 214 yrs after our prophet's death insult me as a "quranist"😂 it's too funny. As if I made the rule to only follow Allah's guide and Allah himself did not warn us of it. As if our prophet did not refuse books written on him. May Allah guide these smart brothers who like to think ahead of Allah
Exactly! I started a islamic channel to tell the truth about that and more
Salam from Dagestan brother. May Allah protect you.
@@gagarigagarin9037 god bless you
How do you perform the prayer?
@@maldheem I'm sure the "Salah" was passed down from the time of prophet muhammed so the method already established (no hadith needed) that's already following the prophet. Now the hadiths were written 200-300 year later, how do we know how accurate it is. It confuses me too. I don't follow any sects,I just say I'm Muslim
The thing is, i dont reject hadith outright as a science and matter of gaining historical knowledge, i just don't like associating it with the notion that those that dont follow them are no longer muslim.
What i also don't understand is how can these imams such as bukhari go around collecting '300,000' hadith (a number that borders on outrageous) and then find that he could only conclude 2,602 as sahih. thats .008% of all collected. That doesn't reassure me that the remaining are true, it only scares me that they could not detect any more false ones. How can bukhari conclude as a matter of fact that the remaining ones are absolutely true. he is but a man. People can have good memories but not perfect memories. A person can remember an event 1 way but still be wrong about certain parts of it. If we take that person's hadith that he passed down as sahih, does that make the hadith itself true? none of the hadiths are said to be from the prophet himself directly, its other people saying they heard/saw him do this or that.
it also scares me that every time the word 'hadith' is said in Quran, its god asking:
Did they not look at the dominion of heavens and earth, and all that GOD has created?. Perhaps their time is coming near; so in which after this will they have faith? [7:185]
GOD, there is no god but He. He will gather you for the day of resurrection in which there is no doubt. Who is more truthful in than GOD?. [4:87]
So in what after this will they believe? [77:50]
hadiths should not be used as a source of law or to denounce people who don't believe them as disbelievers.
+AFGalwayz
I think you are right. Indeed, peoples' memories are not perfect, but their perceptions are also not perfect. Humans are not able to perceive events that they see or things that they hear objectively. Only God has that ability, which is why only God has the ability to compose something like the Qur'an., which can be considered the only source of objective truth for true Muslims.
Imagine if one of the Prophet's (PBUH) companions saw him outside one day, wearing a red shirt. They would say that on a certain day, the Prophet (PBUH) was wearing a red shirt. But what if that person had only seen his clothing from behind, and it turned out the other side of the clothing was blue. Or maybe he was mistaken and it was not the Prophet (PBUH) at all!
And yet the hadith collectors would see from the chain of narrators that all them are trustworthy and judge this information as Sahih! And then some imams somewhere would claim that all those who don't wear red shirts are not true muslims, or that not wearing a red shirt on a certain day is makruh! I think something similar occurred with many hadith ranked "sahih".
If you do not have perfect perception of the world, you cannot speak for Allah whether something is true or not. All information that comes to a person through his senses is distorted, which is why we have ruh (spirit) to feel God's grace directly in our hearts (for example when we recite the Qur'an), and 'aql (reason) to assist us in discarding falsehood.
WHAT U R SAYING IS PERFECTLY RIGHT.
As a matter of understanding historical events we may refer hadith but definitely not as religious guidance. Nowadays people are giving more importance to hadith rather than the primary quran. Also they are not in a position to realize that they do it so.
+mansoor shamsudeen I am very scared and confused lately. I just realised how the hadiths that we have been using might be our biggest blasphemy. First of all, no Muslim has the right TO SAY that the prophet has said...without being there and a witness. everyone is responsible of what he associate to the prophets. We forbid drawings of the prophet but we can use his sayings that we aren't sure how much authentic!!! I always thought that hadiths like in sahih bukhari were collected before the death of the prophet and he did approve it!!! they never told us that they were documented first time officially after more than 200 years after the death of the prophet!!! what is this? a new bible and call it teachings and sayings of the prophet? Yes, we obey and follow the prophet. his mission was to deliver the Quran and our mission is to use our brains to understand it and use it in our life. not to live and try to be like the prophet. I am confused. I pray Allah to guide us and protect us.
AFGalwayz what you are saying makes sense, especially with Hadiths that clearly contradict the Quran.. such as circumcising men and women, when the Quran says that man has been created in the best of forms.. wa Allah Aalam (God knows best). May we be guided to truth
The prophecy in 25:30 will come to pass for sure.
God focus on the story of hypocrites for a reason !!!!
Read the Qur'an without any previous thoughts and you will release that the prophet was nothing like they saying he was not like emperor ..... The hypocrites is the one's who manipulate the true image of the true religion but Qur'an is preserved and this is our main belief so we take it alone.
"See how We explain the revelations, perhaps they may comprehend." (Qur'an 6:65)
It is such that We clarify the revelations to a people who think." (Qur’an 10:24)
Akaisha and Sophi....thanks for such an eloquent reply .
Even though I follow only the Quran, I love his explanations on everything . He's always very logical and well- balanced and gentle.
I can't imagine Allah not forgiving any muslim since it's our hearts for Idlam that is guiding us.
Check out my Shorts for related Qur'aan proofs
The only hadith to be followed is that which tells us how to perform salah, wudu, adhaan, and all other information which would have been witnessed by thousands of people. Hadith which say "ibn hurairah said to aisha who said to bilal who said that muhammad" like chinese whispers, are to be disregarded. The hadith which talk about Muhammad's personal relations with his wives must be disregarded too. The hadith which say Muhammad married Aisha when she was 6 are to be disregarded. The hadith which say Muhammad made his adopted son divorce his wife to marry her himself, must be disregarded. The hadith which say Muhammad had concubines (sex slaves) are to be disregarded. The hadith which say Muhammad had a child out of wed lck must be disregarded. The hadith which say Muhammad would get intimate with his wives while fasting, must be disregarded. And surprisingly, all these shocking hadith are from Sahih Bokhari. Wake up people.
Eesa Blanco exactly and theres alot more that should be disregarded !
And we should filter Salah hadiths with Quran . For example Quran asks us to not to mention anyone's name in prayer but hadith ask us to mention Prophet's name?
Im looking the hadits which tell us how to perform salah for almost 2-3 years. And i cant find it. Which hadits teach us how to perform salah step by step? Ive read so many hadits, also asks so many people. But no one can give me satisfactory answer that Muhammad perform salah like majority of muslim today. No Hadits, No Man can explain that today Salah has not been altered.
@@bravo23yearsagoand63 u won't find it brother because it don't exist.
History is not the same as Faith. The Quran contains all things necessary for guidance mercy understanding logic justice science for those who fear Allah
To follow hadith form Bughari, Muslim and co is SHIRK. To follow Bughari and co...than you add things to The Word of The Almighty. SHIRK
This is how We explain Our revelations in various ways” (Qur’an 6:105)
Brother Shabir did his best into explainig hadith even if, as muslims, we are unconsciously bound not to doubt or even talk about hadiths that are impossible to be accepted as part of prophet Muhammad(pbuh) teachings.
seif deiab Well my understanding of a complete and fully detailled Quran is not the same as yours. It is obvious that no one in the 7th century Madina would have believed that the boson is in the Quran. The real meaning is that it is the last revelation, you may accept it or reject it. if your interpretation is enough for you then be it. Peace.
seif deiab I hope you will enter Janah inchallah, but only if Allah wills.
seif deiab No, Quran is complete. I just want you not to tell people that they will enter Hell when you just exchanged 2 sentences with them. This is your sickeness.
seif deiab I don't. May be you did not understand my first comment.
For anybody interested, I recently found out about the Jewish Talmud. The entire Talmud in standard print is over 6,200 pages long and contains the teachings and opinions of thousands of rabbis on a variety of subjects, including law, ethics, philosophy, customs, history etc. The Talmud is the basis for all codes of Jewish law.
Sounds familiar right? A collections of texts written by man that helps "explain" the word of God (in this case the Torah) and fill in the gaps regarding daily rituals and rules. Food for thought.
(Our duty is not to be right....our duty is to think and reflect and ponder. If our intentions to seek truth are sincere and humble then already we are on the right track....the rest is for the Almighty to decide.)
Yup, history repeats itself. It is corrupt which is why we follow the Qur'an alone
True quran explains sunna and nothing is left out only those who ponder will have no problem,
i do not follow any hadiths or sunna we human have enough intelligent to follow our daily activities .
Yes i am following five pillars of Islam and quran alone period,
Yousef Ghanimeh
Quran chapter and verses
3.18
20.14
7.156.
2.185
22.27:28
2.177
I will follow three prayer instead of five.
I did the same and came up with the same conclusion, mankind has always twisted and changed God's message to suit their political propaganda and control people. I do not want to follow humans, I believe Quran is from God sent directly to me to study and learn from, I don't need any sheikh or other human in between. Islam started long before SW Mohammed.. I advice u to learn, study and research the Quran and then look for Hadith if you insist. Let me tell you understanding the quran requires you to invest time so be patient and ask God for guidance, peace :)
Excellent program
Allah says Quran is fully detailed and is complete.
Did Rasoulillah followed Imam, or did he followed another Hadith other than the Hadith of Allah? Read Quran my man.
Allah commands us to follow Only Quran. It is one revelation. Read Quran. Are you belying Hadith of Allah? May Allah forgive us.
6:114 - “Shall I seek other than Allah for judge, when He it is Who hath revealed unto you (this) Scripture, fully explained? Those unto whom We gave the Scripture (aforetime) know that it is revealed from thy Lord in truth. So be not thou (O Muhammad) of the waverers.”
The Quran is “fully explained.” Good enough for me. I don’t need anything else
Follow the message not the messenger ..period
Agreed what name would you call yourself? "Historian "or "Historiyoon" ??, hadith is basically history right written by men 200 years later..... right??
Ok then tell me who wrote the Hadith's....and when?
I don't need to really know who wrote the Quran. Quran is a book claimed to be from God.The definition of that God is well described in chapter 112.Moreover the book itself claims to be authentic and contradiction free. In addition it challenges humans to produce a like of it. So we have things to disprove Quran from within without seeking outside sources ie hadith or history which is written 200 years after Prophets death.Where as Quran says quran.com/6/114 and again in quran.com/7/145 that the book He had revealed is with full explanation /in full detail.
When the book claims to fully detailed then we don't need another book for guidance , to learn history, yes we can use hadiths.
If a postman delivers a message you follow the message not the postman.Similarly great prophets were chosen to spread the message and we follow the message.
Why are we not following Prophet Moses whose name is mentioned in Quran more times than others ????. He lived in a palace till he was 40 years enjoying all worldly pleasures. So following the message is more important not the messenger.
Ok brother , you are full of brains and you can follow the history which for me is a clear spam written by humans way later. Reading your writing I did not get any answer to my questions. So you have your way I have mine.
For me Quran is enough and I don't need history. Have a good time.
Sorry brother your answers and proof are not convincing to me. For me Quran should be able to defend itself from within, if it can't it is not from God and I will discard it ..blind faith is not my way. You please follow what you feel good for you.Sunnah is a scam for me but you can follow it.
Quran itself very clear to understand no one need to tafseer it
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow.
QURAN 31-6
And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment.
ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge.
ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist.
If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers.
Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay.
ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever.
Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
The problem with hadith is, how do we know it is an accurate account of what the prophet did or said. Also who decides that the hadith is balanced or accurate? It's subject to bias by individual narrators or scholars.
It should be so incredibly embarrassing for those that actually try to explain away "hadith science". You are seriously equating word-of-mouth transmission (ie. hearsay, conjecture) in ancient times, with The God's *DIVINE PROTECTION* .
Not to mention, so much for your "science" when even in your "authentic" hadith, there are gross contradictions and absurdities.
This is how you remembered God!
Recite what is revealed to you of the Book, and observe the Salat, for the Salat prohibits immorality and evil, and the remembrance of God is of greater importance. God knows what you do. 29:45
I am God, there is no god except Me. Therefore, you shall worship Me and observe the Salat to commemorate Me. 20:14
Hi, coming from a place of wanting to learn and be educated on this topic. Any clarifications/thoughts would be appreciated. Some things I am wondering about...
1) Was the preservation of the hadith spoken of in the Quran as it was for the Quran ?
2) Isn't the hadith manmade and came much later in time? ( It is not claimed to be the word of God )
3) When looking to the hadith, how does one know what is true/good or false/inaccurate ?
4) Why not just follow it all than?
5) If the response to 4 is what I've most come across, scholars have said which to follow and which is true and which is not. Picking which hadiths to follow and not, is this not just manmade? How can this be trusted?
I came across a video on youtube about following Quran only and this comment is coming from a place of genuine inquiry. Thoughtful responses are appreciated.
Thanks
Isn't the Quran fully detailed.
Detail conserning what is right path.
And
Not conserning everything.
@@kabakonate7716 the right path is all you need then you do whatever you want as long as you are in the right path
@@kabakonate7716 god said in a verse that he sent the quran to explain everything he didn't say "it explained everything" he said "to explain everything" so it is true not everything is explained eg: why ppl have heart attacks? .. etc .. etc but it will explain everything in the end of the world in the judgement day
@@ljklmoiaoklmlljkajksjdklfm503
Explain everything about what is right and wrong path.
Everything about guideness.
That why He mention History of some pass nation.
How they where mislead.
Brother is that why i said people misunderstand the Quran.
Allah only mention things within Quran so we may think.
And
Know that theys a creator.
@@ljklmoiaoklmlljkajksjdklfm503
First is believed then right path.
Only our creator can show us what right and wrong.
Because is law is just.
Beside Him we human only want that can benefit us.
We are unjust with each other.
Most of us only care about our self pleasure.
Conserning believed.
We must believed that whaterver force created and form this world.
And
Then program each part of it to do their task.
The owner of this force is our creator.
From His power and force everything was created
Then programed.
All we need is upon this world.
We can only used the intellect that our creator gave us to build and ruled this world according to His law.
Not according to our desires.
His law are revelation He sent to us.
Surah Al-Ankabut-51-Is it not sufficient for them that We have sent down to you the Book (the Qur'an) which is recited to them? Verily, herein is mercy and a reminder (or an admonition) for a people who believe.
Surah Al-An'am -38- There is not a moving (living) creature on earth, nor a bird that flies with its two wings, but are communities like you. We have neglected nothing in the Book, then unto their Lord they (all) shall be gathered.
Such a sensible approach....I wish more Muslims would understand that their Hadith books are not equivalent to Quran and not everything should be taken as literal fact. This is a much more reasonable and in my opinion accurate way of understanding the Hadith literature. May Allah SWT continue to bless scholars like Shabir Ally with knowledge and wisdom and help educate this ummah.
Brother Shabir. Probably you are not aware that there was not a single historian at the time of Exalted Prophet(SAW). All that we read to day were written after 250 years later of Exalted prophet death. The writers were neither eye witness nor they had any documented papers in their hands. In my opinion this writers have invented hadees from their own minds and a number of hadees goes against Quoran. My question. Is Quoran not sufficient only or need any other book to support. If we say Yes Quoran needs Hadees then we can very well say that Allah (SWT) claim that the Deen is complete will prove wrong. There is nothing mentioned that after 250 years later hadees will be written and all believers must follow those.
Quoran has all the answers no need of any other book.
Asalaamualekum sister.
4:176- {They request from you a ruling. Say, " Allah gives you a ruling concerning one having neither descendants nor ascendants." If a man dies, leaving no child but a sister, she will have half of what he left. And he inherits from her if she has no child. But if there are two sisters, they will have two-thirds of what he left. If there are both brothers and sisters, the male will have the share of two females. Allah makes clear to you [His law], lest you go astray. And Allah is Knowing of all things.} If you can tell me what is to become of the remaining half after the sister gets her share and what happens to the remaining one third after the 2 sisters gets their share without resorting to ahadith or any other 'manmade' ideas, please do so from the Quran. I'll be waiting for your answers.
Mofi Lilee If you noticed brother, she and others I presented this question to never answered my Quranic question based on the Quran alone, as she and her sect preaches. They only TALK Quran. They DONT KNOW Quran. That's one of the many problems with them. Jazak Allahu Khair.
Sister Sophia
You have alhamdolillah a very clear vision. You have very well explained the shortcoming of historic evidences .
Look at the nature of comment issued by Mofi Lilee ... since if we have lived for centuries in darkness then the nation should remain in darkness for all time to come
He doesn’t know that the use of wisdom and rationalism for which Quran repeatedly emphasizes (7-179 is a good example) was curbed in 3rd century Hijri by the Zoarastrian/Persian Mufassir e Quran Jafar AtTabri who belonged to the defeated Persian Empire and who wrote the first Tafseer of Quran. All the tafseer is based on rewayat, stories, backgrounds and not on the wisdom that Quran offers. It would have been fine if this were his own understanding but the zulm was that this person who had the patronage of the Royal (UnIslamic Court of Abbssids ), labeled all these explaination to our beloved Prophet SAWW and that too without any reference after 300 years of the demise of the prophet. After that a number of books of tafaseer were written till MMaulana Maudoodi but who could dare apply mind over and above the explainations of Prophet himself. So all such tafaseer are one and the same with just change of words. Most were written for the sake of earning sawab and achieving credibility among followers
See how the progressing mind of Muslims was locked and It remained locked since last 1200 years till today Didn’t you read the arguments of Mofi Lili , hesbullah, ninjamaster bro, etc And so the Quran became MAHJOOR See 25-30
"And the Messenger will say, “O My Lord! These are my people, the ones who had forsaken this Qur’an making it of no account.“ [Mahjoor = Disabled = Abandoned = Neglected = Forsaken. They had immobilized it like villagers who bind a cow by tying her front foot to her horn"
My request to Mofi Lilli , hesbullahnyc, ninjamasterbro and others is that enough is enough, Now please liberate Quran and Sharyya from the corruptions induced by the Persian/Zoroastrian conspirators 1200 years back and now its the time to apply mind
Why dont we try to find our lost history. Today the world is so advance that it has decoded the inscriptions found in the ruins under the seas yet we the poor and ignorant Muslims do not have a clue of how Mohammad SAWW and his companions used to live and how they used to implement ghe Quranic Laws, There is no evidence of any natural or other type of calamity in the Arab region , yet we dont have any record of the first ever formed welfare state of madina, no documents are with us to understand the nature of governance which could have been an example today Where has all the record gone ?
Some initial investigations reveal that it is the result of a great conspiracy.
Arabs World was totally distracted from the original path of Sharyya at the end of 2nd century Hijri and that these Mhadeseen appointed by Abbasi Kings , and that these people who came from the defeated empire of Persia and were having Zoroastrian religion as their previous religion, were authorized to rejected 98% of their elements of belief /rewayaat / ahadees prevailing in the practices of the Muslims of that period. Bukhari rejected som 580000 practices and inserted around 2600 as SAHIH practices /ahadees All the remaining were thrown out of their lives using the authority of Kings and that of courts. So did Muslim Ibne Maja , Nisai and others. This massive abandoning of the prevailing practices by declaring them not the Sahih practices virtually abandoned what ever was in practice at that time.
Who authorized them to reject all that ? Did the Prophet SAWW or the God Almighty ? Please tell me who authorized these Persians to reject Arab practices ? ( only this part is verifyable from the books of Saha Sitta , Bukhari and others that they rejected the 98% practices but no record is available to know what they rejected ?
YOU HAVE TO HAVE BELIEVE IN BUKHARI TIRMIZI AND ALL SUCH PERSIANS FOR ALL THE ADDITIONAL SHARYYA COMMANDS OVER AND ABOVE QURAN (INFACT MORE THAN 90 % OF PRESENT DAY UNDER PRACTICE SHARYYA IS BASED ON THEIR WRITINGS WHERE AS ONLY LESS THAN 5% IS BASED ON QURAN) WE DON’T HAVE ANY OTHER SOURCE … DID MOHAMMAD SAWW CHECK AND APPROVED THEIR ACTION ? DID GOD APPROVED THEIR ACTION ?
There is not a single book of history or any document available today which was from 1st or 2nd century Hijri that could tell us about the actual practices as evidence except the first book of Muslim history which was written by Jafar At Tabri, at the last decade of 3rd Century Hijri. Jafar at Tabri / Tabri bin Rustom was also ex-Zoroastrian coming from same defeated Persian Empire. These were the people who according to available historic record, like the Jews, were still desperate to take revenge from the Muslims of their humiliation and loss of dignity as they were deprived by Muslims of their century old thown and power of the Great Persian Empire. They were not in a position to crush Mulim power through conventional warfare Therefore joined hands with Jews to spread intellectual corruption in Deen.
That was the time when these Persian appointees of the non islamic Malookyat/ kings started writing Tafaseer, Ahadees and History of Muslims
These Zoroastrians/ Persians supported and conspired to get the throne of Muslim Empire in the hands of Abbassids After gaining power Abbassids were naturally obliged to share in power with these Zoroastrians Onward history is recorded history through many sources of east and west (the historic record of 1st and 2nd century is not available except from the books written by same disputed suspected personalities of past Zoroastrians).
It is verifiable fact that during Haroon Rashid, the power was in the hands of Zoroastrians with the help of whom Abbasids could gain power. His mother Khaizran was a practicing Zoroastrian, his prime miinster Yahya was Bermaki, his majority cabinet was of Zoroastrians. The court language was replaced from Arabic to Persian, Nauroze and other Zoroastrian cultural tehwaars became official celebrations in Courts etc etc
Tabri’s book of history written in 13 volumes is entirely based on stories with no reference to even a single scrap of paper. And we fools follow that as the only source of the events that took place in the early period of Islam and take those events as actual event. We don’t understand that Persians were well known in the art of crating volumes and volumes of stories …Bulbul Hazar Dastaan etc are such Persian productions
The same Persians who braught Abbasids in power werr also the cause of the fall of Abbasids as well They conpired to invite Hilaku khan who destroyed all libraries and books besides the massacre of muslims. No one knows what enimity had Hilaku Khan with the books that he spoiled and burned all the available literature leaving a side only books of Persian authors like the books of Persian writers including the only available book nof history written by Tabri... all remaining books were destroyed This was all deliberately done by the Zoroastrians / Persians
lahasil100 Boy, you have a lot to say about what Mofi LiLee had to say. How about you giving the answer to this; 4:176- {They request from you a ruling. Say, " Allah gives you a ruling concerning one having neither descendants nor ascendants." If a man dies, leaving no child but a sister, she will have half of what he left. And he inherits from her if she has no child. But if there are two sisters, they will have two-thirds of what he left. If there are both brothers and sisters, the male will have the share of two females. Allah makes clear to you [His law], lest you go astray. And Allah is Knowing of all things.} If you can tell me what is to become of the remaining half after the sister gets her share and what happens to the remaining one third after the 2 sisters gets their share without resorting to ahadith or any other 'manmade' ideas, please do so. I'll be waiting for your answers.
lahasil100 Oh yeah, I forgot to mention about answering my question related to 4:176, and is very important. You must do so without resorting to anyones hadith or any other 'manmade' ideas AND without the tactic of presenting other Ayat that have no relation to this particular circumstance in this particular Ayah. I'll be waiting for your answers.
1:1 In the name of GOD, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
>>>>>36:6 To warn a people whose fathers were not warned, for they are unaware.
Anything contradict with preserved word of Allah must be rejected even it seems all goodness and no harm.
I agree
This verse is also recited very beautifully in the beginning of that clip so if nothing else you will be able to appreciate the recitation :)
"obey God and obey the Messenger" does not necessarily mean "obey the Quran and separately obey/incorporate the practices that will be attributed to the Messenger and compiled 200+ years from now." i am very interested in the life and history of the Prophet, and i hold him and the message he delivered us close to my heart. When i realized that hadith dont speak to my heart, and i understood not to include them in my religion (also for fear of attributing false things to God against my own heart), I was not rejecting the history of the Prophet : i was making a distinction between religion and history.
The sahaba knew what the verses meant, it was they through whom Allah preserved the Quran, and spread it all over the world. It was them who taught Islam, the Quran and Sunnah.
And how many times must it be said to you hadith rejectors that Hadith were not compiled 200 years after the Prophet, or that the history of hadith does not begin with Bukhari.
Hadith were WRITTEN during the lifetime of the Prophet sallahu alayhi wassalam by his sahaba such as Abdullah Ibn Amr Al Aas, Abu Hurraira, Anas Ibn Malik, Abdullah Ibn Masood, Ali Ibn Abi Talib.
They were all absorbed into the collections that started to be compiled decades later.
You do not get to decide what verses of Quran means. That was already decided when they were revealed, to the people of that time. They knew what it meant. They understood it, they implemented it.
So Allah left a few generation of Muslims to follow an "incomplete"/"partially explained" deen after the death of the Prophet SAW till such time that the so called "Muhaddetheen" came along and collected the Sunnah and propagated this in the Muslim world thereby "completing" their deen which surprisingly Allah claims to have completed in the Prophet's lifetime.
A total straw man argument.
That is what you are claiming.
The Sunnah of the Prophet was followed since he was alive. The Sunnah was preserved orally, through practice and implementation in the lives of those that heard/saw the Prophet doing it and by it being written down whilst he was alive as was the case for several companions like Abdullah ibn Amr Al as, Anas ibn Malik, Ali ibn ABI Talib and several others.
The Sahaba spread all across the world because of them conquering one land after another. They taught people the Quran and how to recite it as they were taught, and the Sunnah.
Those that were noted to be scholars from the Sahaba would have 100s if not 1000s of students who went on to be famous in their wn right.
Several of the children of famous Sahaba were another greatest scholars of their generation
Mik K which Sunnah are we talking about, there are a total of 52 books of Ahadeeth. If the Sunnah was preserved why is it that some of them are classified as Daeef and some as Moudu’. Is that what you call as preserved? Think.
[Quran 77:50] Which HADITH other than this do they uphold?
References to "Wisdom" (i.e. "Sunnah") in the Quran (5 Verses)
Quran 2:151 - Our verses and purifying you and teaching you the Book and wisdom ...
Quran 2:231 - And remember the favor of Allah upon you and what has been revealed to you of the Book and wisdom
Quran 3:164 - ... reciting to them His verses and purifying them and teaching them the Book and wisdom,..
Quran 33:34 - And remember what is recited in your houses of the verses of Allah and wisdom.
Quran 62:2 - It is He who has sent among the unlettered a Messenger from themselves reciting to them His verses
and purifying them and teaching them the Book and wisdom.
Sahih al-Bukhari, Vol. 9, Book of Holding Fast to the Qur'an and Sunnah, Hadith 419
Narrated 'Abdullah: Allah's Apostle said, "Do not wish to be like anybody except in two cases: The case of a man whom Allah has given wealth and he spends it in the right way, and that of a man whom Allah has given religious wisdom
(i.e., Qur'an and Sunna) and he gives his verdicts according to it and teaches it." (to others i.e., religious knowledge of Qur'an and Sunna (i.e Prophet's Traditions)).
SOURCE: muflihun.com/bukhari/91/419
Sahih al-Bukhari, Vol. 9, Book of Holding Fast to the Qur'an and Sunnah, Hadith 381
Narrated Hudhaifa: Allah's Apostle said to us, "Honesty descended from the Heavens and settled in the roots of the hearts of men (faithful believers), and then the Quran was revealed and the people read the Quran, (and learnt it
from it) and also learnt it from the Sunna." Both Quran and Sunna strengthened their (the faithful believers') honesty. (See Hadith No. 208) SOURCE: muflihun.com/bukhari/91/381
Muwatta Imam Malik, Book of The Oath of Allegiance, Hadith 3
Malik related to me from Abdullah ibn Dinar that Abdullah ibn Umar wrote to Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan, making an oath of allegiance. He wrote, "In the name of Allah, the Merciful, the Compassionate. To the slave of Allah, Abd al-Malik, the amir al-muminin, Peace be upon you. I praise Allah to you. There is no god but Him. I acknowledge your right to my hearing and my obedience according to the sunna of Allah and the sunna of His Prophet, in what I am able."
Classification: No Data, SOURCE: muflihun.com/malik/55/3
Muwatta Imam Malik, Book of The Decree, Hadith 3
Yahya related to me from Malik that he heard that the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, said, "I have left two matters with you. As long as you hold to them, you will not go the wrong way. They are the
Book of Allah and the Sunna of His Prophet." Classification: No Data,
SOURCE: muflihun.com/malik/46/3
Jami` at-Tirmidhi, Vol. 2, Book of Hajj, Hadith 942
Salim narrated that : His father disliked making a condition during Hajj and he said:
'Is not the Sunnah of your Prophet enough for you?"
Classification Sahih (Authentic), SOURCE: muflihun.com/tirmidhi/9/942
@@samanali4848
You keep telling yourself that.
@@AdamtheFreemason wisdom comes only from Allah , that's why the messenger must recite the verses clearly , the book has the truth and it makes all things clear to those Allah wills to understand it
@@samanali4848 2 269 wisdom comes from Allah , but the people have to hear the quran first to obtain its wisdom which is from God because it came from him
@@samanali4848 I'm slowly rejecting the hadith and becoming Quran only muslim ,
I'd rather blindly follow my Prophet as the Quran instructs me to than commit disbelief by rejecting him.
I'm Sorry Shabir My Brother. The Quran Fully Says A Detailed Book. .And We have revealed the Book to you which has clear explanation of everything, and a guidance, mercy and good news for those who submit." (Qur'an 16:89)
In the Quran, 4th Surah Nisa, Ayat/Verse Number 80 (Quran 4:80)
من يطع ٱلرسول فقد أطاع ٱلله ومن تولى فما أرسلناك عليهم حفيظا
Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah, and whoever turns away, We have not sent you as a guardian over them.
+chakubanga1 I'm one also. Don't know if I should add the word unfortunately. Only Allah knows who's guided and one can't add guarantees to one's guidance. It essentially makes you an outcast in both western and middle eastern society.
But one can't reject one's heart and reason at the end of the day.
I think Khalifa ultimately actually contributed to a deterring effect to becoming a Muslim following the Quran alone, since he has added this code 19 obsession to be associated with it which just detracts from the simple and natural nature of the Quran by creating this code finding lunacy and what not.
Always makes me think of this verse:
[Verse 3:7] ...But those in whose hearts is perversity follow the part thereof that is allegorical, seeking discord, and searching for its hidden meanings, but no one knows its hidden meanings except Allah...
Sincere people at the end of the day I think are just looking for a genuine and reasonable relationship with God, without all the added dogma that prevails in anything mainstream and established, but still feeling the need for something that grounds them firmly and which they can hold on to.
your words are so relatable and touching .
may God guide us .
InshaAllah.
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow.
QURAN 31-6
And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment.
ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge.
ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist.
If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers.
Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay.
ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever.
Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
All Glory and praise exclusively belong to the Creator alone. Everything outside Quran is dirty/impure including minds, hadith, other books,, language, etc.. If the Creator compels the soul to dwell in Quran, the purification process begins. The reader will impute their impure thoughts on it's verses, yes. However, by Allah's will alone, the sincere will gain understanding as one continue's to dwell in it without interference or interruption. The Quran represents the 'chamber of converse' between the reader and the unseen creator and organizer of all the worlds. The only door to this chamber must remain shut (never to be opened) to root out any interference (Satan). Following Hadith, sin, or other associates or authorities other than Allah's supreme authority of Quran, sent as a mercy, will keep a screen over the hearts, eyes and ears and minds and it will be as if they were donkeys unable to read the Holy Quran which they carry on their backs. Allah watches as one is distracted or engrossed. The Holy Quran is a two way communication screen. As Allah sees (may the All-knowing, the Omnipresent, and the Compeller forgive my imperfect speech) one coming into His chamber ( May Allah alone be praised for His gifts), He will know who, among the sincere will close the door behind him (never to open it again) or not and, by His grace, bounty, compassion and mercy, will guide, misguide, or leave in their places whomever He wills.
Sounds reasonable from Dr. Shabirs quoting surah 16:44 but there is a surah giving an other explanation what the duty of the messenger is: 5:99 "The sole duty of the messenger is the delivery (of the message), and God knows what you reveal and what you conceal!, than this: 16:89 "We brought the Book down to you providing explanations of all things", and one other surah is here relevant in my perspective, and this is: 33:62 "Such was the Sunna of God for those who passed on before. You will find that there is no substitute for the Sunna of God", an this one : 35:43 "You will find that there is no substitute for the Sunna of God, and you will find that there is no diversion from the Sunna of God". Finally, nowhere in the Quran do we read the words "the sunna of Muhammad". 46:9, This one is interesting as well: Say (O Muhammad), "I am not a novelty among the messengers, nor do I know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing other than what is revealed to me (Quran). I am no more than a clear warner."
One other captivating surah in this behalf is: 5:99 "The sole duty of the messenger is the delivery (of God's message". The same message is found in 5:92, 16:35, 16:82, 24:54, 29:18, 42:48 and 64:12. And here it quotes what his sole duty is: 42:48 "But if they turn away, We did not send you as a guardian over them. Your sole duty (O Muhammad) is the delivery". And this is what our prophet piece and blessing be on him, said in the same hadith: "Do not write down anything from me except the Quran. Whoever writes other than that should delete it" (Ahmed Ibn Hanbal, Vol. 1, page 171 also Sahih Muslim, Book 42, Number 7147). For the first 200 years after the death of the prophet, and in accordance with his instructions, the writing of his hadith was forbidden. Out of the 6 'sahih' hadith collections we have today, the first to be written was the collection of Al-Bukhari. Al-Bukhari was born in the year 194 after Hijrah. What this means is that the first of what are regarded as authentic hadith (sahih) to be compiled, was written more than two whole centuries after the death of the prophet!
You see...the last part of the discussion he kind of disreputes the Hadiths. If the prophet was alive I would have no problem following him but hearsay?
And then there's some hadiths which seem really bad for the prophet to have said
follow only quran hadith is man made scriptures
Why hadees were not written immediately after prophet pbuh death
Why nobody took the task of writing hadees in madinah and makkah
And why buqari all the way from uzbek has to come and do d work
@Mohamud Ahmed brother i am in process of learning
But u just go through verse 30 of surah Al furqaan
@Mohamud Ahmed
May Allah guide me and u to straight path
Why would Allah SWT say He made Quran COMLETE in more than ONE verse. But let’s say He said it once, Hadith is taken as a literal supplement. This means Quran alone is NOT complete. So the Sunnis are saying two hundred years after the prophet died men complied knowledge by the prophet “from Allah” so that these Hadiths could complete our Quran??
Now we are left to deal with over 700,000 Hadiths. We must choose a “scholar” or school of thought to help us follow the “right” Hadiths.
How is this easy???!
Not to mention the confusion the contradiction in Hadiths and scholars cause to a brand new revert or anyone seeking to turn back to Allah!
Allah, subhanahu wata'aala, said; "Allah intends for you ease, and does not want to make things difficult for you" [2:185]; and "Allah does not want to place you in difficulty" [5:6].
I’ve been seeking knowledge and the more I learn the more I’m inclined against following man made Hadiths.
Does this mean Allah is actively misguiding me when I’m seeking guidance???
Muhammad), you cannot guide whomever you love, but God guides whomever He wants and knows best those who seek guidance. [Qur’an 28:56]
I am not of those who wish to ignore Hadith to not pray. I love to pray and this is the main reason I can’t seem to let go of Hadith. Also music isn’t forbidden in Qur’an but even non Muslims know music is used by evil to brainwash us.
I am going to Umrah the last ten days of this Ramadan. Inshallah. Believe me not believing in the beautiful motivating Hadiths is sad but I can’t accept to follow man made books when the prophet forbade them. Can I??
This subject has crossed my mind over and over again since I began seeking knowledge not too long ago. I reverted many years ago but so much misinformation and the fact that the Sunni Muslims around me don’t follow Quran, Sunna or Hadith had me feeling very lost and underwhelmed. I feel a closer connection to Allah now alhamdullah by getting to know Him through Qur’an.
May Allah guide me and us all.
Is it possible in the places where Allah has placed things in the Quran that you don't understand, that it was meant to be there to show, that you would use it as a reason, to follow Prophet Muhammad's man written Hadith... therefore showing you to be one who is not following His word exactly. THERE are other words and letters in the Quran that we will never know what they mean, unless Allah reveals them. Allah does what he Wills.
Obey God and obey the messenger. If you turn away then the sole duty of the messenger is the clear delivery (of God's message). 64:12
Obey what the prophet tells you to say, when he says "Say!"
Follow what has been revealed to you from your Lord (Quran), there is no god except Him, and keep away from the mushrikeen. 6:106
Shall I seek other than Allah as a 'hakaman' (lawmaker) when it is He who has brought down to you the Book fully detailed? 6:114
I'll follow nothing other than what is revealed to me 46:9
The sole duty of the messenger is the delivery (of God's message). 5:99
Or do they have 'shuraka' (partners) who legislate for them of the religion what God did not authorize? If it were not for them a decisive WORD, judgment would have already been passed over them. Indeed the transgressors shall have a painful punishment. 42:21
kudos to the lady for asking good questions.
Let the sections of Shi'as and Sunnis debate on hadiths. I being a Muslim believe only Qur'an.
So then you are not Muslim .
Very sad and foolish how those who reject the way of the Prophet sallAllahu alayhi wa sallam claim to accept the message that he worked for his entire life.
His entire life? Wth u talking about? He became messenger around 40yrs old. SMH
The ‘message’ is the Quran! What is so difficult to understand?
We have sent down to you a Book containing your message. Do you not understand?" (Qur'an 21:10)
Allahu Akbar! You people never cease to amaze me. You somehow come up with something new every day.I'm not even going to bother with this one. Just one thing. I don't know where you get your information from but please verify it yourself and go through everything before posting it..
Yes. He did not only preserve the words of the Qur'an. He preserved it's practice, it's method of recital, and it's explanations all as taught by the beloved Nabi (May Allah bless him and give him peace).
What HADITH after it [QURAN] will they believe .QURAN 77-50. Meaning after QURAN the best HADITH there is no other HADITH to be believed in ISLAM 'this is a clear commandment from ALLAH to follow.
QURAN 31-6
And of the people is he who buys diverted HADITH [LAHWAL HADITH] to mislead [others] from the way of ALLAH without knowledge and who takes it [i.e., His way] in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment.
ALLAH has used the words LAHWAL HADITH in verse 31-6 'the word LAHWAL in Arabic means diverted and HADITH means narrations. ALLAH is clearly telling you 'to not! follow HADITHS after QURAN and also not to follow diverted HADITH 'which will divert you from the best HADITH the QURAN without knowledge.
ALLAH says in QURAN the SUNNAT of ALLAH 'the way of ALLAH 'and there is no change in the SUNNAT [way] of ALLAH QURAN 48-23. Meaning the SUNNAT of ALLAH is the only SUNNAT in QURAN and this SUNNAT cannot be replaced with another SUNNAT 'the prophet P.B.U.H also followed the SUNNAT of ALLAH. There is no mention of SUNNAT of MUHAMAD P.B.U.H in the entire QURAN 'it does not exist.
If you claim to be pious 'then follow the clear commandments from ALLAH 'and stop following LAHWAL HADITH, BUKARI, S.MUSLIM, DAHWOOD, TRIMEDI, and only follow ASNAL HADITH [BEST HADITH] the QURAN if you claim to be believers.
Now these verses have been revealed to you 'how would you act upon them? or will you just ignore them and carry on with your life following hearsay.
ALLAH says in verse 5-44::........And those who do not judge from what ALLAH revealed then those are the disbelievers. [example] If you perform ablution from manmade HADITH and not QURAN then you are the disbeliever.
Follow up on the verses above and do your research concerning QURAN 'this book is for all mankind including you 'stop relying on others study 'and read QURAN with understanding before death comes to you. Being pious on camera 'might fool the mases 'but does not cut it for ALLAH 'read QURAN with understanding and implement this book before you die 'make it quick and delay it not tick tok tick tok.
brothers,
we all know well no one can be able to put quran into perfect order.
Because it was revealed in diferent moment.
Sunnah and pratice of prophet Muhammad pbuh
Is quran in action and order.
That why all those hadith which tell us how prophet pbuh act and do not contradict quran and where narrated by diferent companion are good hadith.
And
All those hadith which contradicte quran we must reject them.
And
All those hadith which where narrated by single narrator from one chain
We must doubt or reject them.
Because whaterver prophet pbuh teach He pbuh made it public.
Kaba Konate uP
if hadith was so important why do we find prohibition during Abu bakr time omar n uthman
But brother can you put quran into order ?
Best hadith are those which put quran into order and do not contradicted it.
Search for those hadith.
@@kabakonate7716 what do you mean put it in order?
@@rabih1978
Like commands and act of worship
@@kabakonate7716 Quran was complied during time of prophet
3:19 Hadith is the yellow calf mentioned in Al Baqarah. “One sometimes FEELS the need for more details here.” God said sacrifice a cow don’t complicate by asking the age, and color, etc. God said pray in remembrance of me. Dont complicate it.
I would like to ask him a direct question...... Who were /are in the best position to apply Hadith science to scrutinize the authenticity and verify about truthfulness of chain of narrators; scholars of earliest period of compilation and classification of Hadith or common Muslims and /or scholars of this Era ?
Moderate acceptance? Not wholesale rejection or wholesale acceptance? Because there are questionable hadith, as you mentioned? Aren't they all questionable in the light of the Quran? Well, I will never do what you're doing. The Quran never stated to obey Mohammad.
"Say (O Muhammad), 'Whose testimony is greater?' Say, 'God is the witness between me and you that THIS QURAN was given to me to preach it to you, and to whomever it reaches.' However, you certainly bear witness that you set up other gods beside. Say, 'I will never do what you are doing; I disown your idol-worship.'" (6:19)
This video isn't satisfactory, Quranists have good counter arguments for all these points.
+Curtis Jea Adams look I haven't read hadith or quran before learning how to pray or do fast.i learn it from common practice and my son and daughter learning namaz/salat following me.so u should learn to differentiate between hadiths and sunna.
+Curtis Jea Adams NO not "Quranists" please.
It's not a sect. It's Muslims OUTISIDE of a sect.
Call them what you will: Outsiders, Originals,
sect-less, Pure. But never "Quranists". Peace
+Curtis Jea Adams
There is no such thing as "Quranists". It's like you call the followers of Allah - "Allahists". That's inappropriate.
Daniel Friese
lol I know right
+truth are you Muslim? It's funny you say you learnt it following others because that's exactly what the Qur'an tells us not to do. "Following their forefathers" and not using reason and logic.