You torturing Mensk taughts brother. You are not honest. No 2 sources of power but only one Allah . But how you know this source only by Prophet and this is not applying for only Mohamed. For all prophets who came before him. Can you see Allah ????? But the prophets are human beings and they were living with human beings. So the way they were acting in their community, their ways of being, what they did in the way to serve their Lord even though is not mentioned in their Books, those who see that can follow the same way: this is what we call the Acts or thoughts of prophets. They told as prophet Daoud used to fast one day yes one day No, is there in the Quran, this way of fasting?????? But we know that from those who saw that and get it from generation to generation by narrative( Hadiths). If you rejecting the Hadiths automatically you rejecting how to make the Sallat. Or you have to describe first how to make sallat in Islam according to the Quran otherwise your rejections are just parth of sheytan. One more time Mensk is not telling you there 2 sources of power . Only one power Allah but we can get to know, to worship property through HIS nobles messagers and prophets.How you follow God without seeing someone doing so or get information through another books how he worshiping Allah since he is mortal?????
"if the hadith is proven to be authentic, we have to take it" - who authenticates it? LOL the last prophet had gone and he was the only one with direct communication with God to confirm or deny God's message....sometimes I think those who believe in the hadith and those in power who fought to defend it, their hearts and minds are closed by God. They can't see how wrong it is to do the same thing that were done to the Torah and Bible - modified, corrupted and using other people's words to anchor God's messages.
When you see them, their appearance impresses you. And when they speak, you listen to their ˹impressive˺ speech. But they are ˹just˺ like ˹worthless˺ planks of wood leaned ˹against a wall˺. They think every cry is against them. They are the enemy, so beware of them. May Allah condemn them! How can they be deluded ˹from the truth˺? (quran 63:4) who is god describing here?
@@AbdulRahman-vg2sk who told you the Sahaba wrote and preserved the quran? All we know is that God promised to preserve the quran and we believe him. How he will do it, is not for us to ask. Anything outside the quran is conjecture and guesswork, unless your telling me you can time travel and witness these things yourself? Only gods words can be 100% trusted. I refuse to put my trust anywhere else and ultimately we will all answer to God alone. Peace
They wouldn’t get it bro, they throw the Quran down to take the hadith, they have to, they believe the Quran is missing the details for salat example. Oh how do we pray, salat isn’t praying in Arabic at all. That’s Duaa. But anyways, Allah doesn’t forgive shirk and they have to put that in mind
stop calling youself "quranists", thats exactly what they're accusing you in first place. If you truly follow the Holy Qur'an you would understand that you are Muslim.
I think they don't, it's Sunnis who call them Qur'anists.. most of them either call themselves Muslim or 'Submitter' which is the English translation of Muslim
a very good video. No superfluous accusations, no condescending attitude. Just pure facts from the quran. Backing up claims with actual verses. It's so rare to see such a, almost scientific & empirical, analysis of quran with no emotional baggage. Keep it up
Im a quranist from indonesia, The Holy Quran is way of love and the words of god. Follow Quran alone and Allah will lead you to his heaven. Assalamualikum to all quranist
Qur’an 4:65 - But no, by your Lord, they will not [truly] believe until they make you, [O Muhammad], judge concerning that over which they dispute among themselves and then find within themselves no discomfort from what you have judged and submit in [full, willing] submission. So not really the Messanger must be obeyed as well
@@chailouai3084 brother your not following Muhammad. Your following what people said about him well after his death. Not like 1, 2 or even 20 years later but hundreds of years!! did Muhammad verify any of this himself? Did God authorise it? Its ok to use it as a historical reference but it isnt a book of guidance like the quran. That's all I'm saying. I don't outright reject it but im very careful with it.
@@user-yo9xs8tl5o you lack knowledge on hadiths and claiming hadiths arent his actual words means quran we read today is false as well and isnt the one he recited , read this short paper: drive.google.com/file/d/1dvPFufQr0yCrHZTdDfbNUyuItYNHgVAr/view?usp=drivesdk Take care
Born Sunnite, after which I studied the quran and turned it into Hanif. The best decision in my life. Unfortunately, very few of the learned people know the quran too little, and they associate hadiths with them. They would know the quran, then one would know that hadiths are forbidden. There is no verse where Hadith is positively mentioned, but always associated with it, the Prophet says this in the Quran too. 25:30 And the Messenger (Mohammed) will say (on the day of judgment): “O my Lord! My people have truly left this Koran! "
*[Chapter 5: The Table Spread with Food, Al-Maaida, الْمَآئِدَة : Verse 54]* يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا مَن يَرْتَدَّ مِنكُمْ عَن دِينِهِ فَسَوْفَ يَأْتِي اللَّهُ بِقَوْمٍ يُحِبُّهُمْ وَيُحِبُّونَهُ أَذِلَّةٍ عَلَى الْمُؤْمِنِينَ أَعِزَّةٍ عَلَى الْكَافِرِينَ يُجَاهِدُونَ فِي سَبِيلِ اللَّهِ وَلَا يَخَافُونَ لَوْمَةَ لَائِمٍ ذَٰلِكَ فَضْلُ اللَّهِ يُؤْتِيهِ مَن يَشَاءُ وَاللَّهُ وَاسِعٌ عَلِيمٌ [5:54] You who believe, if any of you go back on your faith, God will soon replace you with people He loves and who love Him, people who are humble towards the believers, hard on the disbelievers, and who strive in God's way without fearing anyone's reproach. Such is God's favour. He grants it to whoever He will. God has endless bounty and knowledge. www.quran.com/5/54 peace
You are taking that quran verse out of context just like Islamophobes take 9:29 and 9:5 out of context . Did you study why it was revealed? do you know who Allah was talking to ? did you study the Context ? have you sat down with a Good Muslim scholar?
@@maalikserebryakov THE SUFFICIENT QURAN I am a Muslim who argues for the sufficiency of the Quran and argues against the requirement of any other hadith. Below I provide proof using the Quran. ALLAH, THE SUFFICIENT JUDGE 6 114 ‘[Say], "Then is it other than Allāh I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book [i.e., the Qur’ān] explained in detail?" And those to whom We [previously] gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters.’ This verse confirms that Allah is our only Judge, we are not to associate with him a partner judge. Allah details the 4 things we cannot consume. And the word ONLY is used here. Just as it is when God says there is no God except Allah. 2:173 ‘He has ONLY forbidden to you dead animals, blood, the flesh of swine, and that which has been dedicated to other than Allāh. But whoever is forced [by necessity], neither desiring [it] nor transgressing [its limit], there is no sin upon him. Indeed, Allāh is Forgiving and Merciful.’ And finally, Allah has not left out any detail. 12:111 ‘There was certainly in their stories a lesson for those of understanding. Never was it [i.e., the Qur’ān] a narration invented, but a confirmation of what was before it and a detailed explanation of all things and guidance and mercy for a people who believe.’ But according to the hadiths, Mohammed had forbidden cats and donkeys. (Volume 7, Book 67, Number 438 : Narrated by Abu Tha'laba ‘Allah's Apostle forbade the eating of the meat of beasts having fangs.’ (Volume 7, Book 67, Number 435 :) Narrated by Abu Tha'alba ‘Allah's Apostle prohibited the eating of donkey's meat.’) So, who do we take as a judge, Allah who said 4 things are forbidden to consume in 2:173 and he did not mention cats and donkeys, OR do we take Allah and Mohammed as a judge together? Choose one. I have chosen Allah as my only judge. OBEYING THE MESSENGER Let us first confirm whether the speech of the messenger is the word of man or of God. Meaning, if the messenger were to teach us anything, would his teachings be in the words of man or the words of ALLAH? This is what the disbelievers say when hearing the Quran, ‘This is not but the word of a human being."(74:25) This is what Allah says about the Quran,’ [That] indeed, the Qur'an is the word of a noble Messenger.’ (69:40) The Messenger receives his word from Allah: ‘Indeed, We will cast upon you a heavy word.’’ (73:5) So, since we have confirmed, that the word of the messenger is the Quran, if he teaches us anything, it will be in Allah’s words. For example, when the people asked him questions, the messenger taught them using his word (the Quran) and they asked him questions because they did not know the answer. 2:151 ‘Just as We have sent among you a messenger from yourselves reciting to you Our verses and purifying you and teaching you the Book and wisdom and teaching you that which you did not know.’ 2:215 ‘They ask you what they should spend. Say, "Whatever you spend of good is [to be] for parents and relatives and orphans and the needy and the traveller. And whatever you do of good - indeed, Allah is Knowing of it."’
if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@SUN MAN if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
We r not quranist, or Qur'an alone Muslims, I am a Muslim following the Doctrine of the Quran. C2 V131 "When his Lord said to him SUBMIT, he said " I have SUBMITTED, to the lord of the World's.
We who are striving to follow the Quran alone, must truly follow it and work to shape our characters with it. We must not be against our Sunni Muslim brothers and sisters. Although they may be off course, they are still Muslims and we must never forget, that we were once in the same place that they are in. That's why we must be merciful and patient with them. We should also pray for them that Allah subhanahu wataala blesses them and ourselves with the guidance of the Quran. We should use the Quran to unite Muslims, not further divide our already fragmented world.
We are indeed merciful and patient with ANYONE who is open to God's message or at least do not show animosity and hatred towards those who uphold the Quran alone.
Yes but the same cannot be said for the sunni and shia majority that look down upon us when they barely reflect upon the word of God. They'll read the pretty Arabic but won't comprehend its meaning in a language they understand.
The same are my thoughts bro i follow Qur'an alhamdulillah and i don't hate anyone for following hadiths but the problem is that they some or idk but i watched a 'Sheikh don't know his name called muslims who are following Qur'an only without hadith are kaafir' like how easy for him to call someone who believes in one God and his prophets a kafir just wow
@@fighter.... i agree. Our monotheism is pure and we actually have much more respect for the prophet ironically as he wouldn't have wanted to be placed so high in praise to the point where it verges on shirk
@@ace9924 yes we should focus more on Qur'an instead of hadiths that were written 200-300 years after prophet Muhammad (PBUH)but we shouldn't hate the so called sects and it's not good how they're proud Sunni salafi and blah blah I'm glad that no sects believe in shirk everyone's shahada is same that's the different btw us and them they'll declare you as kaafir if you won't follow hadith but we ain't doing that we want unity and they keep dividing by how u pray how i pray ah May Allah guide us all Indeed Allah is the most merciful:)
@@safemoonking9501 I’m sure you making your sallat. So with your Quran alone describe for me how to make the sallat. I will start doing like you even I’m not Muslim I will convert to Islam and pray for you to have the benefit of bringing someone into the right parth of the Islam. Thanks 🙏...
@@submittersperspective8251 with you clamming Quran alone you already out of Islam without knowing, you doing games . Tell me your way to make the sallat . If you making the sallat the way we know doing Rakas : 2-4-4-3-4 it means you are MUNAFIKS or tell me where in the Quran it says we have to pray in Rakas. Please???????
By accepting hadith, one is admitting that the Quran, the proposed word of Allah, is not strong enough to stand on its own, and that the word of man carries equal weight with the word of Allah and is even necessary to support it.
@@OYATca "O believers! When you rise up for prayer, wash your faces and your hands up to the elbows, wipe your heads, and wash your feet to the ankles. And if you are in a state of ˹full˺ impurity,1 then take a full bath. But if you are ill, on a journey, or have relieved yourselves, or have been intimate with your wives and cannot find water, then purify yourselves with clean earth by wiping your faces and hands.2 It is not Allah’s Will to burden you, but to purify you and complete His favour upon you, so perhaps you will be grateful."
@@WaqasAfzali-ls5yi excellent, this is partial wudu, now where is a verse about a prayer? Basically imagine I told you how to cut someone’s hair. I said do a fade haircut, “get a trimmer and cut the sides short and leave the top longer” that’s the basic of fade haircut, but in detail it’s a lot longer step. That’s where the Hadith comes in
@@OYATca "Partial Wudu"???🤡🤡🤡 What are you talking about? It's partial because your Imams innovation isn't in it???? Wudu is simple according to verse I showed you: -Wash face -Wipe your head -Wash your hands -Wash your feet Regarding Salat, in the Quran there is: -Wudu -qibla(2:144) -3 positions of Salat(standing, bowing, prostating) -to only recite from the Quran(29:45) -to only praise Allah(6:162, 20:14) -only 3 salats(Salat al fajr, Al Wusta, Al Isha) - how to end your Salat It doesn't however mention commiting shirk by "sending blessings to a prophet" who doesn't know who you are. Man, you guys really are Mushriks. Allah has said that his book is complete and no outside source isn't allowed while you guys continue to add innovation after innovation.
@@OYATca Nope, the Hadith gives the wrong way of Salat. You recite a lot of unquranic verses that aren't found in the Quran and your way of ending Salat is also wrong. You (once again) commit another innovation by turning your face to your shoulders and giving greetings to angels in a worship meant to be performed for Allah! Allah has already given the correct way of ending Salat: Their prayer therein is: "Glory to You, O God," and their greeting therein is: "Peace," and the ending of their prayer is: "Praise be to God, Lord of the worlds." 10:10
Very explanatory response to the blind followers of hadiths. There are different ways of offering Namaaz in the books of hadiths which led to the establishments of various sects & mosques and affecting the Unity Of Muslims.
( quran 63:4) When you see them, their appearance impresses you. And when they speak, you listen to their ˹impressive˺ speech. But they are ˹just˺ like ˹worthless˺ planks of wood leaned ˹against a wall˺. They think every cry is against them. They are the enemy, so beware of them. May Allah condemn them! How can they be deluded ˹from the truth˺? remind you of anyone?
This is what happens when you reject the hadiths. You are taking verses from the Quran and interpreting it to follow YOUR narrative. This is why its really important to know the context of the Ayah and its equally important to know how Prophet (SA) and sahabahs explained the verse. In your comment, you are suggesting that the ones that compiled the hadiths are 'hypocrites'. Now it's a dangerous game you are playing. Why? Cause if you are suggesting that the hadith compilers are hypocrites then you are saying that Allah Says that they are hypocrite. And if you are wrong in your assumption then you are accusing your brothers in deen. I hope you have done enough research on this topic. Jazakallah Brother.
@user-yo9xs8tl5o This verse only refers to the hypocrites who tells that they have accepted the deen but in their heart they didn't! Do your research before talking like this about a verse!
Islam is not submition , this is a hadithist view .Abraham called us Muslims the Quran says , and he also defined the name Islam by saying "I direct my face to Allah " which is " wajht my face to Allah " , which in turn explain and is equal to "aslmt my face to Allah" . اني وجهت وجهي لله حنيفا / اني اسلمت وجهي لله Islam is directing ones self to Allah .
Thank you so much, brother. I was born in a wahabi family and you know how firm this sect is about Hadith books but I'm the type of person who loves asking questions. There are so many hadiths that straight up contradict with Quran and our people are justifying it. Doesn't it seem like those times before our beloved Prophet when Christians and Jews used to follow everything but their original Scripture. I always use to ask then what is the difference between Jews, Christians and Muslims? It is still mentioned in their Scripture about Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) but they don't follow the same as Muslims who follow the hadith path but not the original book of guidance. Just think about it if Allah would ask the Muslims that "I gave you a divine book with a PROMISE of its safety you followed another book. Did I ever ask you to follow another book to understand Quran?" If it was that important for us Muslims that we wouldn't be able to understand Quran without it What didn't the messenger of Allah ask his Sahabas to collect this hadith? Let's think about the 4 caliphs's if not them at least Imam Hassan or Imam Hossein should've collected it but why didn't they? Omar(RA) even said to everyone to collect the hadith. What if Imam Bukhari had never collected hadith? My family scolded me that I shouldn't ask such questions but why? Allah gives me the right. Quran is a book of logic,reasoning and science. Even non-Muslim can't deny that. On the other hand, many hadiths have no logic and are against science. There are many problematic hadith about women. I don't care what someone thinks about me I cried in Sajdah and requested Allah to show me the right path. After salat while I was scrolling through social media I came across this verse: "And We have revealed to you, [O Muhammad], the Book in truth, confirming that which preceded it of the Scripture and as a criterion over it. So judge between them by what Allah has revealed and do not follow their inclinations away from what has come to you of the truth. To each of you We prescribed a law and a method. Had Allah willed, He would have made you one nation [united in religion], but [He intended] to test you in what He has given you; so race to [all that is] good. To Allah is your return all together, and He will [then] inform you concerning that over which you used to differ." (5:48) It was an eye opener for me. May Allah bless all of you. Amen.
@@submittersperspective8251 brother it's seems like a deja vu. People who claimed to follow Jesus(PBUH) attributed those things to him that he never said. Same goes for Muslims. When I realized that we are in the same ship as them I was so sacred. Allah will ask the same thing to both that "Didn't he give Aql to us?" We all receive his msg in different forms its upon us now to take it or not. May Allah forgive us. Imagine how disappointed would our Prophet be? Someone said the satan knew he can't misguide people from Quran so he chose the hadith way. May Allah show the right path to our Ummah brothers and sisters. Ameen.
Sister when you say you were born in wahabi family it shows how much knowledge of ISlam you have as there is no such thing as Wahabi.Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahhab was a scholar of Islam who called the people of Innovation towards the Qura n and Sunnah. Sister remember one thing no sound person will leave the Sunnah i.e. sound Ahadith of Prophet pbuh only those who face inferiority complex from todays so called civillised orientalists of west reject the Hadiths.Only those who want to follow their desires follow the Quran onlyThe Quran Only phenomon is from 19th century, So according to you all the Ummah,All ISlamic scholars till 19th century for nearly 1100 years were misguided really... And you have av very big ignorance about when Hadiths were written.Some sahaba used to write sayings of Prophet. Since you seem sincereI would request you to to that this step can be very dnagerous for you in hereafter. If you are really looking for the truth then please watch these lectures of Adnan rashid who is a historian and has the knowledge of Ilm-e-Hadees czcams.com/video/f8VvAnMl-gM/video.html czcams.com/video/qM5WvypMSvo/video.html czcams.com/video/LstwjvLlj_I/video.html czcams.com/video/YDn2Veohh8I/video.html some more sources islamqa.info/en/answers/256435/refutation-of-those-who-quote-the-holy-quran-to-reject-the-sunnah-and-justify-not-acting-upon-it islamqa.info/en/answers/604/justification-for-following-the-sunnah islamqa.info/en/answers/93111/if-the-quran-is-perfect-and-complete-and-contains- everything-needed-for-the-laws-and-regulations-of-shareeah-what-need-is-there-for-the-sunnah islamqa.info/en/answers/239540/the-science-of-hadith-is-based-on-reason-and-shari-guidelines
O you who have believed, obey Allāh and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allāh and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allāh and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result. How will you refer a matter it to messenger becoz prophet muhammad is not with us. The answer is very simple i.e. refer to his sunnah or Ahadith.
@@McAroni52 of course, that's how the cult originated in the first place, also be careful brother i read articles that muslims like you have been taken to prisons and were tortured in algeria, so keep it to yourself.
The things you have told were same in my mind like obeying the prophet and now as the religion is spread we have to believe in only quran not in hadiths. I am happy to know that I am not the only one with the same thinking may God bless you❤
Ikr but sometimes it feels so lonely, I used to follow sunnah but at the last day of Ramadan i saw some really awful hadiths talking about stoning and rape, And that day i decided to only follow Quran and reject all hadiths, But it feels really lonely since we are so few :(
@@mannenibla204 yes it is true I feel this like every time while I know that we are on the right path and others are following man made scriptures while almost forgetting the message of Allah. But m so happy that Allah gave me and a few others the chance to use our brain and learn things without following blindly that our elders taught us. Who knows tomorrow there can be more people like us Amen.
@@mannenibla204 we are increasing in numbers my friend and we have the support of many people, not sunnis but many others that want to see us take charge of islam in the world, also remember that no matter how few we are we are the righteous with a great moral compass and one day we shall enjoy each other's company.
@@hublot7952 there will be inshallah , just be careful if you live in the middle east or north africa as our people are being imprisoned and tortured in those countries. be safe brother.
@@shadygaming6523 I really hope that some day real Islam will prevail! And i have a new dream in life, I want to study arabic and master it in order to understand the Quran fully, And i really want to learn the Qurans meaning in and out in order to teach it to others, Inshallah we will have a big community in the future, Now that we know the truth we shouldn't stop here, Let's invite people to our way of life. This isn't a religion anymore but a guidance and way of life.
MM also said that "the hadiths are from Allah." But the hadiths are not from Allah. The hadiths are from people. The Quran says, "Who does greater wrong than the person who attributes a lie to Allah?" Because the hadiths are from transmitters, none of whom was a prophet and none of whom is mentioned in the Quran, any law based on a tradition is from persons and not sacred. Moreover, verses 5:44 - 47 prohibit judging by what Allah did not reveal. Whoever judges by what Allah did not reveal is referred to as a disbeliever, a rebel and a wrongdoer. In addition to the prohibition of adding to revelation in verses 69:44 - 47, there are tradition in which the prophet also prohibited the recording of hadiths, for fear that they might be confused with revelation. He never lifted this prohibition. Hence, the persons that recorded the traditions and presented them as "supplementary and explanatory revelations from Allah," flouted the prohibition of the fabrication of revelation by Allah and the recording and transmission of tradition by the prophet. Moreover, since the prophet never lifted the prohibition on the collection of tradition, none of the gatherings was personally authorized by the prophet. Hence, the collections remain "unauthorized." What is more, the hadiths are not verbatim words of the prophet; they are paraphrases, akin to rumors. Accordingly, anyone who says that "the prophet said," and follows that with a paraphrase of a hadith, already lied. The prophet did not say that. A transmitter reported it, using his words. The elevation of the traditions to revelation was necessitated by the yearning of exegetes to use tradition to "explain" revelation. The requirement to "explain" revelation by tradition resulted from a deterioration in the knowledge of revelation, resulting from a deterioration and eventual prohibition of reasoning, the shutting of the gates to ijtihad. The decline of the ability to reason was reinforced by al Ghazali's declaration of takfir on the philosophers, when he denounced them as heretics and disbelievers, recalling the anti-rationalism of Musa al-Hadi. The deterioration of reasoning was first triggered by the repression of reason, the use of which for the purpose of understanding revelation was equated - in a hadith - with kufr. The disparagement of reason ('aql) was a result of the struggle between the rationalists and the traditionists. With the suppression of the philosophers in 786 by Musa al-Hadi - five thousand perished in the purges of the free thinkers - the traditionists prevailed. But the designation of tradition as - and its amalgamation with - revelation tainted the knowledge of revelation and warped the penal law. Persons that elevate tradition to revelation appear to be attempting to fabricate revelation and replace it with "another revelation." The exegetes perpetrated a further faux pas when they declared that "tradition judges revelation," and when they asserted that "revelation requires tradition more than tradition requires revelation." In doing so, they subordinated the words of Allah to those of transmitters.
you follow hadiths haha so when you get sick do you make fly 🪰 soup ?? Mmm yummy hadiths teach also how to rotate your wives when having s .ex thats sooo important you know how could one be a noble man without knowing which wife to f** last. Just give me one Hadith JUST ONE that can be found in the Quran meaning that it relates to ANY verse in the Quran. Bukhari was also mentioned the collection of Bukhari hadiths were written around 600 years after his death. You follow horny and disgusting hadiths and you clearly need guidance of every little step in your daily life is a SHAME. You need a 10 step guide on how to sleep how to shit how to eat how to drink how to sit how to walk. We’re you raised by monkeys in the jungle far away from society ?? You seriously think prayer is about how you do it and not why you do it ??? wow you also use Quran to insult people who never insulted you in the first place. Surah 25.30: “And the Apostle will say: O my Lord! surely my people have run away from the Quran.” Surah 54.17: And certainly We have made the Quran easy for remembrance, but is there anyone who will TAKE HEED? …………… Hmmm I guess that’s why you need fake hadiths because you insist on not understanding the Quran. Even in the Bukhari hadiths it’s admitted that there is no hadith to explain 28 complete surahs or chapters of the Quran. That is 25 percent of the 114 surahs in the Quran. And the remaining hadith are sketchy, ridiculous and do not explain any of the verses of the Quran at all. People like you say the Quran cannot be understood without hadiths and that the hadiths cannot be understood either without complex debates. You really believe hadiths that claim the prophet drank someone’s water and the spit in it and gave it back? You believe in hadiths that claim that the prophet was a slave trader who slept with 9 to 11 woman every night without washing. You believe in hadiths that claim women are dogs and donkeys and most likely will go to hell!! Where In the Quran can you find these disgusting claims ???
Because that’s The focus of their career. These people don’t have real jobs. Being a religious charlatan *is* their job. You’re literally threatening their livelihood by this
You are taking that quran verse out of context just like Islamophobes take 9:29 and 9:5 out of context . Did you study why it was revealed? do you know who Allah was talking to ? did you study the Context ? have you sat down with a Good Muslim scholar?
i also dont get why hadiths show that people are already in hell and more women are there WHEN THE QURAN says that nobody is in hell until judgement day and women and men are equal..
if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@@Randomhandlename Therefore you are saying the Quran is not detailed as Allah says, thus meaning you don't fully agree with the Quran in the first place. It saddens me for real that you have to ignore a blatant statement from whom you claim to follow. If the Quran says it's detailed then it most definitely is. The wisdom of the creator is sufficient, Stand, bow and prostrate is what's important. Another explicit example is How Allah SWT tells us to recite in a tone in-between not loud nor silent, yet somehow people recite prayers some silent, some loud which contradicts the Quran clearly for those with reasoning. But if you want to be sheep and follow how your forefathers have done then more power to you. May Allah guide us all.
[17:46] We place shields around their minds, to prevent them from understanding it, and deafness in their ears. 👣💔👣 And when you preach your Lord, using the *Quran alone, they run away in aversion.* 👣💔👣 [31:6] Among the people, there are those who uphold baseless Hadith, and thus divert others from the path of GOD without knowledge, and take it in vain. These have incurred a shameful retribution.
People needs to understand that Hadiths were compiled 150 years or more after the passing of the Holy Prophet ( PBUH ). Now why did the sahabahs not compiled it themselves ? Who gave that Imam Bukhari permission to compile things in the name of Islam without the permission of Allah and his messengers.. Awaiting replies from Hadiths followers.
You would think Mufti Menk is intelligent enough to read a verse in context. I really don’t understand how the spoils of war can be mistaken from following a Hadith.
@@ahmedmohiuddin4567 When you see them, their appearance impresses you. And when they speak, you listen to their ˹impressive˺ speech. But they are ˹just˺ like ˹worthless˺ planks of wood leaned ˹against a wall˺. They think every cry is against them. They are the enemy, so beware of them. May Allah condemn them! How can they be deluded ˹from the truth˺? (quran 63:4)
There is indeed many verses in the Quran instructing "follow the Messenger" ..but note that the affected verses only used the term "messenger" (rasool, Arabic: رسول). Note also that the Quran did indeed used the term "Muhammad" and this is used six times in the Quran, 5 times in various verses (i.e.1x used as Ahmad), and 1x as a chapter title for Ch 47. It means the Quran / God can be very specific that God uses the specific term in the Quran in those verses. However, in the verses where Quran says - follow the Messenger, none of those verses used the term "follow Muhammad", pbuh. Those verses used "follow the Messenger" Also, if we check the terms in the Quran, using the key word Abraham,pbuh, we would noticed that the Quran is very specific in saying that those "better in religion" are those who followed Abraham, not Muhammad, pbut. Despite Muhammad pbuh being the one who was trusted to convey the Quran, he did not.... in any of the verses (below) wrote, follow the religion of Muhammad, pbuh Q:3v95 Say: "God speaketh the Truth: follow the religion of Abraham, the sane in faith; he was not of the Pagans." Q:4v125 Who can be better in religion than one who submits his whole self to God, does good, and follows the way of Abraham the true in Faith? For God did take Abraham for a friend. Q:6v161 Say: "Verily, my Lord hath guided me to a way that is straight, - a religion of right, - the path (trod) by Abraham the true in Faith, and he (certainly) joined not gods with God." Q:2v135 And they say, 'Be Jews or Christians and you shall be guided.' Say thou: 'Nay, rather the creed of Abraham, a man of pure faith; he was no idolater.' Q:2v130 And who would be averse to the religion of Abraham except one who makes a fool of himself. And We had chosen him in this world, and indeed he, in the Hereafter, will be among the righteous. There are no verses in the Quran, with the same arrangement, but putting Muhammad, pbuh, as the main subject, replacing Abraham, pbuh, none. This is another point in the Quran, in plain language, which shows that we are to follow the Messenger, but not necessarily Muhammad (pbuh). We are even instructed not to make distinction of any of the Prophets (2v136), this is written in the Quran, but the Muslims have incorporated into the shahada "Muhammad", making is seemingly mandatory to include that in the declaration of faith There are likely many thousands of Messengers, which we do not really know, but this shows that the Quran provided such a flexibility. The Quran even hinted that there will be a certain time when a particular message might be explained, and it could be said such messenger will come at certain time, perhaps even in the future (after Muhammad, pbuh) Q:13v38 And verily We sent messengers (to mankind) before thee, and We appointed for them wives and offspring, and it was not (given) to any messenger that he should bring a portent save by Allah's leave. For everything there is a time prescribed The problem with the current generation of Muslims is that, they take hadith as God's word, to the point that they only go to the Quran AFTER they read hadith. Many might not even read the Quran, only listening to the clerics and their hadith obsession. The Quran should be the main reference point, not hadith. There is even a hadith where the Prophet prohibited the recording of the narration In extreme scenarios, in a significant number of poor Muslim countries, they would say it is ok to kill apostate, or to marry underage girls because hadith says so. These practices are clearly in violation of the Quranic message and shows the harm of abandoning the Quran in preference of hadith
MashaALLAH Brother Joey Ma....do you have more where we can read your thoughts or lines.... Indeed, it is very wrong to rely more on Hadith than to the Qur-an, Qur-an is preserved by ALLAH, while Hadith is not. Nowadays many Hadiths are false.
also as well I see some muslims say follow the messenger but even if the Quran was talking about Muhammad alone and not all of them we do follow him through the Quran which is where his details are laid out, sure some details are left out but same with the bible and Jesus there are no details on his middle part of life, for example with christians they follow Jesus through the New Testament alone and don't have other books written to follow him so we should do same and follow Quran alone
Thanks for this video. I hv only one minus thing about this video regarding the sound of the narrator. When Mufti Menk’s part comes, it is very clear. But, the narrator’s voice very weak.
Thanks to the Almighty Allah for the guidance,,I am really happy to find others besides me who have the same views about Islam and Qur'an..I once rejected Islam because of the baseless hadiths and became an Agnostic.I was asking so many questions and people couldnt even give me the correct answer..I was like why are this people even debating against the Christians when they are themselves doing the same thing with our Prophet..As the Christians are associating Jesus with God the Father,The Muslims are also associating Prophet Muhammad(P.B.U.H) with Allah in the Shahada and the Holy Qur'an is being compared with the Hadiths
Brother don't feel alone. There are a lot of brothers and sisters like you all around the world who are rightly guided by Allah Subhan Huwa tala. Alhamdulillah I only follow the Qur'an. May Allah bless you and all of us.
Exactly! The Hadiths are entirely baseless and it’s a shame that so many Muslims are following Hadith and not Quran, even putting Hadith on the same level as the Quran!
if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Sajada first meaning is submit second meaning is prostration. Ruku first meaning is humility Second meaning to bow. Fajr and isha (todays Maghrib) are mentioned however isn’t ritual prayer
Selam Aleykum Chapter 59 is referring to Moses the messenger and the Exodus…. So this verse 59:7 is not only cut short but also taken right out of context and applied to the incorrect Messenger, though when it comes to distribution of wealth always applies to the leader, Leaders! 25:27 That day the wrongdoer will bite on his hand and say, "I wish I had taken the path with the messenger!" 25:28 "Woe unto me, I wish I did not take so and so as a friend!" 25:29 "He has misguided me from the remembrance after it came to me, and the devil was always a betrayer of people!" 25:30 The messenger said, "My Lord, my people have deserted this Quran." 25:31 It is such that We make for every prophet enemies from among the criminals. Your Lord suffices as a Guide and a Victor. 25:32 Those who rejected said, "If only the Quran was sent down to him in one go!" It was done as such so We could strengthen your heart with it, and We arranged it accordingly. 25:33 For every example they come to you with, We bring you the truth and the best explanation. Wake up! Peace
MashaAllah very clear and understandable answer. I am surprised that how come scholars such as Mufti Myenk tries to spread the Hadith which has no basis and most of them are against Quran. There is no way that a Momin (the believer) can follow Quran and Hadith all together. You can follow Quran or you can follow hadith. I take a very small and basic example, we do ablution according to the hadith and there is a clear instruction about doing ablution in the Quran, which one to follow? Both are different. What a common Muslim must understand that if there is a command in the Quran there should not be any source that tells against that command of Allah swt, what we do is to follow hadith that is against the Quran and the command of Alllah swt. Well, 99% Muslims are trying to impose Hadith in the name of Islam, but the word of Allah is the truth. This is the criterion and Furqan. We have the word of Allah not just the word made by human.
You are correct. We follow only the quran and we ignore hadiths because we know they are all foolish and false. But these Muslims who follow hadiths criticize us for not following hadiths and also call us apostates, and the real fact is they are apostates and not we
MashAllah my brother surah Al-Imran Ayat 7 (3:7 It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muhammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific. As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allah. But those firm in knowledge say, “We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord.” And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.
Alhamdulillah brother. May Allah enhance your knowledge and wisdom. I am also a student of knowledge trying to understand the true meaning of GOD me@age without the help of hadith or tafseer. Alhamdulillah Allah has guided me. I know hadith has over shadow the book of Allah. It is a deel rooted conspiracy of the so called Ulama. The good news is that there are hundreds of thousand educated young and old muslims who are researching quraan and finding out what is the message of God. InshaAllah sooner or later Allah will open the eyes of the muslims who are living on darkness.
How can you not trust the most trusted scholars of Islam even Ibn Abbas the cousin of the prophet the ink of the Ummah ? You are making up your own personal Islam. * How about pedophilia in Quran ? chapter 65 verse 4 - Tafsir Ibn Al Kathir The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation.
@Zaak May Allah abrogate pedophilia chapter 65 verse 4 - Tafsir Ibn Al Kathir The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. pedo sxx cult
what makes me laugh at the likes of mufti manek is that they attack quran and call people who follow quran as wrong yet they claim they are muslims, so according to them : what? you mean to tell me you only follow the words of God? and don't follow people who hate islam? you are not muslim if you worship God and don't worship people who hate God. it's really dumb really something a potato would say WTF to
I have encountered Quranists myself & this is the whole point. When Quranist interpret The Quran without Hadith they draw their own delusional conclusions I have always asked them the Question which till this day have NO ANSWER Qur'an Surah 4:34 says to beat women "Wadriboona" What happens if a Quranist without hadith interprets this verse to be an agressive literal beating & abuses his Wife They have no answer Secondly:Notice he drinks Alcohol See the Law regarding Khamr in the Quran was first legal then its consumption was reduced, then abolished in 3 stages. What happens if a Quranist thinks that the first verse was too abolished then later its permissibility got introduced See this is the Problem one faces if they don't follow the Extended interpretation according to Hadith & try & feed out there own interpretations. This is one major reason, why the Hadith was introduced to protect the Quran from those who try to twist its meaning. For why Allah All mighty says in the Glorias Quran, we sent you O Muhammed to explain clearly to man the Quran Surah 75:19 The Question then arises where can we find this explanation? If it is NOT the hadith then what is it Do you know what is even more incredibly Bazaar, are the Quranist telling us that the Greatest Man in History the Prophet Muhammed has no Biography How old was the Prophet when He recieved Revelation QURANISTS HAVE NO ANSWER What were the Names of his wives How long did his ministry last 1 month 1 day or 23 Years What age did he die Who were his companions Which companions passed on the Quran to us How do we know if they were reliable since our Quran mushaf does NOT directly date to the hand of our Prophet rather 17-30 Years after him Are they suggesting that the ones who passed on the Quran. Lied to us about Hadith. Therefore how can we trust the Quran they gave to us if the same people also fabricated Hadith Did the Prophet have any Children What were the Prophet's father's & mother's names What were the names of his wives & uncles What year was the Prophet Born in Maybe he existed only 900 year ago instead of 1400 years ago What did the Prophet look like was he fit & healthy or did he look like a fat Was he a business man or was he on the dole What was his teenage life like & early childhood The science of hadith is based on reason & shar‘i guidelines The science of hadith is basically & in principle founded on rational guidelines, with a methodology based on an accumulation of experience attained by the hadith scholars on the basis of many years’ experience of narrating reports and checking their authenticity and soundness. They attained the basis of this knowledge through lengthy involvement in checking reports, seeking them out, conveying them, examining them and determining whether there were any faults in them, thus gradually developing the general guidelines and framework of the science of hadith. Al-Khateeb al-Baghdadi said: Distinguishing the soundness of hadith is a kind of knowledge that Allah, may He be exalted, creates in people’s hearts after they have spent a great deal of time in this field and have attained lengthy involvement therein
Why are people so against quranists? There is nothing wrong with following the word of God. Do the Sunni or Shia have some political interest? I see if the hadith matches the Quran then take it or else leave it and I don't think there's anything wrong with that. May Allah bless us all on the right path of the right Islam
Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): “He who obeys the Messenger has indeed obeyed Allaah . . .” [al-Nisaa’ 4:80] “O you who believe! Obey Allaah and obey the Messenger . . .” [al-Nisaa’ 4:59] “O you who believe! Answer Allaah (by obeying Him) and (His) Messenger when he calls you to that which will give you life . . .” [al-Anfaal 8:24] (And) if you differ in anything amongst yourselves, refer it to Allaah and His Messenger . . .” [al-Nisaa’ 4:59] Source Islam QA
salam, cool video, keep them coming. i sent mufti menk an email many years ago telling him about his flawed understanding / interpretation of surah 59:7 , he never replied. happy judgement day
They are Mushrikhs these muftis. How will he tell his audience that he has erred. Sunni is a parallel religion that was created by the Jewish Abu Hurairah using the prophet's ideology just like Paul used Jesus' ideology to create Christianity.
Ok i have question in my mind How do you pray From where did u learn that 5 times praying and how many raka is in praying. 2nd question is that how much percentage of zakat you are giving and from where did you learn , and if its in Quran pls show me , many more questions but i need answer for these 2
Salaamun 3Alaykum. Mufti Menk mentioned about a Nabiy and a Rasul. A Nabiy has different role as a Rasul. Obey Allahh SWT and obey Rasul. But NOT obey Nabiy!!!. Obey Rasul means obey his message, that is Al-Qur'an.
In Surah al-Nisa 59: It says "O you who believe, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you are in dispute over any matter, refer it to Allah and His Messenger if you are actually believers in Allah and the Last Day, That is better for you and more seemly in the end" Many important points may be deduced from this one verse of the Quran. First, it must be noted that Allah explicitly uses the command "to obey," not only for Himself but also for the Messenger (PBUH), that is, "obey Allah and the Messenger." this same verb (ateeu) or command does not directly precede "those in authority among you. This establishes the Messenger of Allah as an independent object of obedience while obedience to anyone else is conditional upon consistency with the Quran or sunnah. Second, this implies that obedience to the Messenger is, in a sense, something different than obedience to Allah. Obedience to the Messenger of Allah is indeed obedience to Allah. What is meant here is that obedience to the Messenger differs from simply obeying the Messenger in what he has conveyed from the word of Allah or the Quran. Muslims are commanded to take any dispute that they may have to only two arbiters; Allah and His Messenger. The Companions of the Prophet (PBUH) and later scholars have understood " refer it to Allah to mean to refer to the Book of Allah. And referring the matter to the Messenger of Allah means to refer it directly to him during his lifetime and to his sunnah after his death. Note also that the two, the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Messenger are placed together here and the verse does not say, refer the matter to Allah and then to the Messenger of Allah, nor does it say, refer the matter to Allah and if you do not find the answer there, refer the matter to Messenger. Allah states that true believers are the ones who refer their disputes not only to Allah but to Allah and His Messenger
But Allah did not say follow hadith. Allah says the Quran is complete and fully detailed. And you cannot obey someone who is not among us, and obey messenger means the message he delivered lol.
@@Leil2221That's why we follow the hadith. We can know about the Messenger through the hadith. You said we can not follow someone who is not among us. So how do you pray salah, siam, hajj, zakah ordered by Allah in Quran without the help of sunnah? The way to perform those are from hadith.
@@user-eq3jn9rh8v in the Quran there is: -Wudu -to only recite from the Quran in Salat -to recite not loud or quiet -qibla -how to end Salat -3 positions of Salat It doesn't however mention commiting shirk by sending blessings to a prophet who doesn't know you. Same with Hajj. The instructions for it is mentioned in surah al Hajj. Stop being a Mushrik please
Miqdām b. Ma’d Karib (rA) reports that the Prophet ﷺ said, “Indeed, I have been given the Qur’an and something similar to it along with it. But soon there will be a time when a man will be reclining on his couch with a full stomach, and he will say, ‘You should adhere to this Qur’an; what you find that it says is permissible, take it as permissible, and what you find it says is forbidden, take it as forbidden.’ But indeed, whatever the Messenger of Allah forbids is like what Allah forbids.”43 - Quranist
Salamun Alakum. I would like to make clear InshaAllah that every person who submits to Allah, believes that the Quran is His guidance, and denounces all other books falsely attributed as holy revelation are Muslims and InshaAllah Múmeeneen. We are not Quaranists, one of them, or anything other than what Allah Himself called us, which is Muslim. I am also so excited to find so many Muslims online uniting MeshaAllah. Allahu Ta Ala unite us here and in heaven. Salam
Thank You! I have never referred to myself as a "Q'uranist", I am a Muslim. The folks who seek their guidance from other sources are the ones who need a different name (Hadithists), not us.
He is cherry picking some lines from the Quran which does not coincide with the subject matter and never says what surah and verses he is talking about.
Appreciate your support. Thank you but unfortunately I'll have to take down the video and redo the whole thing as the microphone I used for this video wasn't of good quality. Hence , I recommend using the CC captions to read what I'm saying. I apologise for this .
Assalam my brother. Alhamdulillah for highlighting the true facts. Satan will try his level best to trick many so called “muslims“ to read other books or hadist written by humans 250 years after the death of prophet Mohammed,which unfortunately majority of them have blindly followed and inadvertently declared them also as divine massages, God’s forbid, in as subtle as possible. Many especially the learned scholars and Arabs have fallen into the Satan subtle tricks. May Allah give us the guidance and light to all sincere believers to uphold the teaching of our prophet Mohammed that is to uphold the Quran and nothing but the Quran - God’s Willing.
Exactly, sunnies, Shia and all are sects... This is what Allah didn't want, we follow the word of Allah through his messenger, that's a Muslim, but may Allah forgive us all, no matter the sect or even relgion as Allah knows best 😊
why do you need instructions on how to pray? Salat doesn't mean prayer ,it's to follow closely,meaning establishing the salat means to follow closely Allah's commands. This brother breaks it down using the Quran. czcams.com/video/4APNPrfRORQ/video.html
Learned from whichever communal practice showed us. Are you implying no-one communally prayed or knew how to pray and that they only learned from a writtten compilation which was produced 200+ years after the death of the Prophet (PBUH)? Oh dear
Allah has divinely protected the Quran he has not protected the hadith. Some hadith can be accurate and true but there's no way of knowing without any doubt.
It doesn’t matter even if some of them are true because everything Muhammad ever spoke from his mouth is not divine revelation. God had him recite the Quran. How he spoke to his wives or friends in his personal life is not a divine commandment for all mankind. Yet the mainstream Muslims have tried to deify and make holy every single word he spoke and every action he took which is SHIRK. They even try to imitate his beard and how he brushed his teeth. It’s pure foolishness and idolatry.
Quran 46:9 Say, “I am not the first messenger ever sent, nor do I know what will happen to me or you. I only follow what is revealed to me. And I am only sent with a clear warning.” Prophet didn't know all! And what I like to say to help people understand. If there was no Bukhari 300years after prophet, we would not know today how to be Muslims according to sunni! Is that what you believe!!! Didn't prophet deliver the message? Look what happened to Christians! Do you think prophet would let our religion to be gather around by years and by tousends of people?????
Hadith rejectors are simply arrogant. They think they understand the Quran and Islam and how to implement it in real life better than the Messenger of Allah ﷺ. They considers they themselves their own prophethood and think their limited minds that influenced by their desires are true rather than what is revealed by the prophet Muhmmad ﷺ. "And whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger and transgresses His limits - He will put him into the Fire to abide eternally therein, and he will have a humiliating punishment." Quran 4:14 "It is not for a believing man or woman-when Allah and His Messenger decree a matter-to have any other choice in that matter. Indeed, whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has clearly gone ˹far˺ astray." Quran 33:36
You nailed brother. The worst thing about the traditional Muslims is that they are not aware that the prophet himself, Abu-bakar and Omar were all Quranites and that data is available everywhere in the traditional books. Ibn Sirin said: "They were not asking about the chain of transmission, so when the sedition occurred, they said: Name your men for us." then based on a discriminatory way they accepted the hadith from people of the Sunnah while they rejected the Ahadith from the others. If there are Ahadith why Fatima, the daughter of the prophet did not narrate any of it? Ibn Abi Hatim also narrated I heard Malik say: "The first person to chain the hadeeth was Ibn Shihab Al-Zuhri." According to what Ibn Sufyan and Ibn Mahan reported on the authority of a Zoroastrian known as Muslim bin Hajjaj. This Ibn Shihab Al-Zuhri was the companion of Satan for sure and according to Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti in his book Asmaa al-Mudalliseen (أسماء المدلسين) he was famous for fraud (مشهور بالتدليس). No Ahadith-related revelation was sent down to the Prophet Muhammad just as it was not revealed to Abraham, Moses, David, Yahya, and Jesus, and the Qur’an says, “In which hadith after God and His verses will they believe?” This is clear to those who have eyes to see and a brain to comprehend. Salam to all creatures of God (ܐܠܗܐ, الله, גדא, Godka) the greatest.
Following the Quran is following the prophet Muhammad pbuh. Subhanallah the argument that not following the hadith is not following the prophet insults the prophet Muhammad subhanallah
Also, Sunnah and hadıth ıs not same. Sunnah of prophet is: When people were askıng questıons, the prophet was waıtıng for answers from Allah. Examples: 1. They asked the prophet of Qıyamat - he waıts for ınspıratıon then answers 2. They ask about Malala - he waıts for ınspıratıon then answers 3. They ask about Ruh ul Qudus... - he waıts for ınspıratıon then answers Thıs ıs the Sunnah the prophet. So when we have a questıon, then we refer to the Quran. Fınally, people cannot caterorıse themselves as Quranısts, Sunnı, Shıa, Ahmadıya etc... We are one Ummah - we do not dıvıde
Thank you, its perfect explanation. Still trouble me that where we get the Quran ? it was a mutawatir hadiths, consensus that we understand also hadith (news). I dont believe any law or jurispredence from hadith including so called sahih bukhari.. after all He was only the collector of so called hadiths. Again how we get the quran since it was came from mutawatir hadiths
Do you accept the Quran as a divine book because it came from "mutawatir " or some trusted hands or because the message and the contents of the Quran we have today proves its divinity and preservation? What is your basis to believe in it ?
@@submittersperspective8251 I believe that the Quran is divine revelation to prophet Muhammad and recited written through some trusted people (mutawatir ahadith) reaching us. And yes I believe the message and the contents of the Quran we have today proves its divinity and preservation
@Harry Kuffal So do you believe it is due to the "trustworthy " people that the Quran reached you otherwise it wouldn't have ? And since they gave u the Quran, any hadith reported in their name is automatically true ?
Obey Allah and Obey the Messenger as articulated in AL Quran can also refer to Jibireel AS who was responsible for passing Allah's message (Al Quran) to RSAW.......so Allah commands RSAW to Obey Allah and HIS Messenger (Jibireel AS) and thereafter the Ummah needs to Obey the message of Al Quran as revealed to RSAW via Jibireel AS. The claim that Obey the Messenger as a separate entity is therefore false as the message that should be obeyed is Al Quran and NOT Ghadeeth literature as understood by most.....may Allah guide and protect us all😢
Look at Quran verse 59:7 in its entirety and youll realize it is in regards to distribution of gains from a perticular event, not in anyway does it imply hadith. However, Quran verses 5:41-42 definitely describes how these people distort Allahs verses such as 59:7. 5:41 O Messenger, let them not grieve you who hasten into disbelief of those who say, "We believe" with their mouths, but their hearts believe not, and from among the Jews. [They are] avid listeners to falsehood, listening to another people who have not come to you. They distort words beyond their places, saying, "If you are given this, take it; but if you are not given it, then beware." But he for whom Allāh intends fitnah - never will you possess for him a thing against Allāh. Those are the ones for whom Allāh does not intend to purify their hearts. For them in this world is disgrace, and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment. 5:42 [They are] avid listeners to falsehood, devourers of [what is] unlawful. So if they come to you, [O Muḥammad], judge between them or turn away from them. And if you turn away from them - never will they harm you at all. And if you judge, judge between them with justice. Indeed, Allāh loves those who act justly.
Salam alaykum Mufti lives the good life thanks to his jewish masters. Enjoy a little while longer. It's unbelievable how these so called scholars can't understand Quran that's why they need Hadith. We are not Quranist. We are real Muslims
Why do some people impose conditions which are not present in Allah's Book (Laws)? Whoever imposes such a condition as is not in Allah's Laws, then that condition is invalid even if he imposes one hundred conditions, because certainly Allah's conditions are more binding and reliable!
What people did ... Since 1400 a man declares he is last of prophets .. Where as In quran its Allah who is the awal and akhir. How the seal of prophets can be referred as last prophet
So how do the quranist pray salah, or siam or hajj? Show me from Quran. The Quran says to follow the Prophet PBUH. And without Hadith, how are we supposed to know and follow the Prophet Now?
@@mashrafi157 not just money, they also have a deep hatred for islam and or they are twisted and hadith allows them to be openly twisted, like the hadith that allows grown men to marry children .
@@shadygaming6523 True man, most of them just follow the majority of scholars and dont know any better, thus they are one big echo chamber promoting satanic rituals and innovations disguised as "Islam"
@@mashrafi157 and that's why those "scholars" say that the TV and internet are forbidden, they want to keep that echo chamber air tight, they want to keep them ignorant of the world around them
![[Vowel]물고기는 물에서 살아야 해🐟🤣Fish have to live in the water #funny](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3G9MH063Cx4/mqdefault.jpg)
Parts of video have audio issues. Please click on "cc" to see the subtitles . Thank you.
hi
Lol
You torturing Mensk taughts brother. You are not honest. No 2 sources of power but only one Allah . But how you know this source only by Prophet and this is not applying for only Mohamed. For all prophets who came before him. Can you see Allah ????? But the prophets are human beings and they were living with human beings. So the way they were acting in their community, their ways of being, what they did in the way to serve their Lord even though is not mentioned in their Books, those who see that can follow the same way: this is what we call the Acts or thoughts of prophets. They told as prophet Daoud used to fast one day yes one day No, is there in the Quran, this way of fasting?????? But we know that from those who saw that and get it from generation to generation by narrative( Hadiths). If you rejecting the Hadiths automatically you rejecting how to make the Sallat. Or you have to describe first how to make sallat in Islam according to the Quran otherwise your rejections are just parth of sheytan.
One more time Mensk is not telling you there 2 sources of power . Only one power Allah but we can get to know, to worship property through HIS nobles messagers and prophets.How you follow God without seeing someone doing so or get information through another books how he worshiping Allah since he is mortal?????
Allah does not share his legislation with anyone.....paraphrasing from the Quran.....end of discussion
@@Strong_Trustworthy and what that means ??????
I'm a Quranist Revert and I can attest to the fact that Hadithists are guilty of the same sin they accuse Christians of.
so true.I am a born muslim and some hadiths don't make any sense to me,some are illogical,contradicts quran,misogynistic.
Hadiths state that women's private parts are including her elbow what difference is a man's elbow from a woman's elbo
Absolutely true.
Same and yes! I think as former Christians we have a keen understanding and awareness of this.
Brilliantly said. May Allah bless you.
"if the hadith is proven to be authentic, we have to take it" - who authenticates it? LOL the last prophet had gone and he was the only one with direct communication with God to confirm or deny God's message....sometimes I think those who believe in the hadith and those in power who fought to defend it, their hearts and minds are closed by God. They can't see how wrong it is to do the same thing that were done to the Torah and Bible - modified, corrupted and using other people's words to anchor God's messages.
Totally agree 101% bro.
When you see them, their appearance impresses you. And when they speak, you listen to their ˹impressive˺ speech. But they are ˹just˺ like ˹worthless˺ planks of wood leaned ˹against a wall˺. They think every cry is against them. They are the enemy, so beware of them. May Allah condemn them! How can they be deluded ˹from the truth˺? (quran 63:4)
who is god describing here?
I don't understand how you people trust the sahaba when it comes to writing and preserving the verses of quran but also say that they made up ahadith?
@@AbdulRahman-vg2sk who told you the Sahaba wrote and preserved the quran? All we know is that God promised to preserve the quran and we believe him. How he will do it, is not for us to ask. Anything outside the quran is conjecture and guesswork, unless your telling me you can time travel and witness these things yourself? Only gods words can be 100% trusted. I refuse to put my trust anywhere else and ultimately we will all answer to God alone. Peace
They wouldn’t get it bro, they throw the Quran down to take the hadith, they have to, they believe the Quran is missing the details for salat example. Oh how do we pray, salat isn’t praying in Arabic at all. That’s Duaa. But anyways, Allah doesn’t forgive shirk and they have to put that in mind
stop calling youself "quranists", thats exactly what they're accusing you in first place. If you truly follow the Holy Qur'an you would understand that you are Muslim.
I agree ! People stop calling yourself quranist,
I think they don't, it's Sunnis who call them Qur'anists.. most of them either call themselves Muslim or 'Submitter' which is the English translation of Muslim
a very good video. No superfluous accusations, no condescending attitude. Just pure facts from the quran. Backing up claims with actual verses. It's so rare to see such a, almost scientific & empirical, analysis of quran with no emotional baggage. Keep it up
Thank you Sonu. Your encouraging words are much appreciated 🙏
Im a quranist from indonesia, The Holy Quran is way of love and the words of god. Follow Quran alone and Allah will lead you to his heaven. Assalamualikum to all quranist
Qur’an 4:65 - But no, by your Lord, they will not [truly] believe until they make you, [O Muhammad], judge concerning that over which they dispute among themselves and then find within themselves no discomfort from what you have judged and submit in [full, willing] submission.
So not really the Messanger must be obeyed as well
@@chailouai3084 how can muhammad do that today when he is dead? that was for when he was alive and amongst the people. use your common sense brother.
@@user-yo9xs8tl5o dead people dont despair, they have their sayings and actions preserved in sources in this case, " hadiths"
@@chailouai3084 brother your not following Muhammad. Your following what people said about him well after his death. Not like 1, 2 or even 20 years later but hundreds of years!! did Muhammad verify any of this himself? Did God authorise it? Its ok to use it as a historical reference but it isnt a book of guidance like the quran. That's all I'm saying. I don't outright reject it but im very careful with it.
@@user-yo9xs8tl5o you lack knowledge on hadiths and claiming hadiths arent his actual words means quran we read today is false as well and isnt the one he recited , read this short paper: drive.google.com/file/d/1dvPFufQr0yCrHZTdDfbNUyuItYNHgVAr/view?usp=drivesdk
Take care
Quran alone, victory Is near.
Insha Allah
Born Sunnite, after which I studied the quran and turned it into Hanif.
The best decision in my life.
Unfortunately, very few of the learned people know the quran too little, and they associate hadiths with them.
They would know the quran, then one would know that hadiths are forbidden.
There is no verse where Hadith is positively mentioned, but always associated with it, the Prophet says this in the Quran too.
25:30 And the Messenger (Mohammed) will say (on the day of judgment): “O my Lord! My people have truly left this Koran! "
Peace ! Thank you for your engagement. Please support this humble effort by subscribing to this channel :). Your input is highly appreciated.
welcome to the family, be safe.
*[Chapter 5: The Table Spread with Food, Al-Maaida, الْمَآئِدَة : Verse 54]*
يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا مَن يَرْتَدَّ مِنكُمْ عَن دِينِهِ فَسَوْفَ يَأْتِي اللَّهُ بِقَوْمٍ يُحِبُّهُمْ وَيُحِبُّونَهُ أَذِلَّةٍ عَلَى الْمُؤْمِنِينَ أَعِزَّةٍ عَلَى الْكَافِرِينَ يُجَاهِدُونَ فِي سَبِيلِ اللَّهِ وَلَا يَخَافُونَ لَوْمَةَ لَائِمٍ ذَٰلِكَ فَضْلُ اللَّهِ يُؤْتِيهِ مَن يَشَاءُ وَاللَّهُ وَاسِعٌ عَلِيمٌ
[5:54] You who believe, if any of you go back on your faith, God will soon replace you with people He loves and who love Him, people who are humble towards the believers, hard on the disbelievers, and who strive in God's way without fearing anyone's reproach. Such is God's favour. He grants it to whoever He will. God has endless bounty and knowledge.
www.quran.com/5/54
peace
You are taking that quran verse out of context just like Islamophobes take 9:29 and 9:5 out of context .
Did you study why it was revealed?
do you know who Allah was talking to ?
did you study the Context ?
have you sat down with a Good Muslim scholar?
@@maalikserebryakov THE SUFFICIENT QURAN
I am a Muslim who argues for the sufficiency of the Quran and argues against the requirement of any other hadith. Below I provide proof using the Quran.
ALLAH, THE SUFFICIENT JUDGE
6 114 ‘[Say], "Then is it other than Allāh I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book [i.e., the Qur’ān] explained in detail?" And those to whom We [previously] gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters.’
This verse confirms that Allah is our only Judge, we are not to associate with him a partner judge.
Allah details the 4 things we cannot consume. And the word ONLY is used here. Just as it is when God says there is no God except Allah.
2:173 ‘He has ONLY forbidden to you dead animals, blood, the flesh of swine, and that which has been dedicated to other than Allāh. But whoever is forced [by necessity], neither desiring [it] nor transgressing [its limit], there is no sin upon him. Indeed, Allāh is Forgiving and Merciful.’
And finally, Allah has not left out any detail.
12:111 ‘There was certainly in their stories a lesson for those of understanding. Never was it [i.e., the Qur’ān] a narration invented, but a confirmation of what was before it and a detailed explanation of all things and guidance and mercy for a people who believe.’
But according to the hadiths, Mohammed had forbidden cats and donkeys.
(Volume 7, Book 67, Number 438 :
Narrated by Abu Tha'laba
‘Allah's Apostle forbade the eating of the meat of beasts having fangs.’
(Volume 7, Book 67, Number 435 :)
Narrated by Abu Tha'alba
‘Allah's Apostle prohibited the eating of donkey's meat.’)
So, who do we take as a judge, Allah who said 4 things are forbidden to consume in 2:173 and he did not mention cats and donkeys, OR do we take Allah and Mohammed as a judge together? Choose one. I have chosen Allah as my only judge.
OBEYING THE MESSENGER
Let us first confirm whether the speech of the messenger is the word of man or of God. Meaning, if the messenger were to teach us anything, would his teachings be in the words of man or the words of ALLAH?
This is what the disbelievers say when hearing the Quran, ‘This is not but the word of a human being."(74:25)
This is what Allah says about the Quran,’ [That] indeed, the Qur'an is the word of a noble Messenger.’ (69:40)
The Messenger receives his word from Allah: ‘Indeed, We will cast upon you a heavy word.’’ (73:5)
So, since we have confirmed, that the word of the messenger is the Quran, if he teaches us anything, it will be in Allah’s words.
For example, when the people asked him questions, the messenger taught them using his word (the Quran) and they asked him questions because they did not know the answer.
2:151 ‘Just as We have sent among you a messenger from yourselves reciting to you Our verses and purifying you and teaching you the Book and wisdom and teaching you that which you did not know.’
2:215 ‘They ask you what they should spend. Say, "Whatever you spend of good is [to be] for parents and relatives and orphans and the needy and the traveller. And whatever you do of good - indeed, Allah is Knowing of it."’
Thank you so much brother for bringing light into the Quran once again
if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@@Randomhandlename ....no, but it's in your beloved Hadith though. There's only 13,000 or so volumes for you to go through....
@@Sum_Ting_Wong yes hadith explains Quran in detail
@SUN MAN if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@SUN MAN yet you non muslims changed the the Quran by removing 2 verses. And added himself a messenger.
We r not quranist, or Qur'an alone Muslims, I am a Muslim following the Doctrine of the Quran. C2 V131 "When his Lord said to him SUBMIT, he said " I have SUBMITTED, to the lord of the World's.
I agree . Which is why I say Quran aloners to identify ourselves as those who take the Quran alone as our guide.
Sorry bro was not referring to u, directed more to mufti menk n his kind, u have made a brilliant reply, Weldon🙏🙏
We who are striving to follow the Quran alone, must truly follow it and work to shape our characters with it. We must not be against our Sunni Muslim brothers and sisters. Although they may be off course, they are still Muslims and we must never forget, that we were once in the same place that they are in. That's why we must be merciful and patient with them. We should also pray for them that Allah subhanahu wataala blesses them and ourselves with the guidance of the Quran. We should use the Quran to unite Muslims, not further divide our already fragmented world.
We are indeed merciful and patient with ANYONE who is open to God's message or at least do not show animosity and hatred towards those who uphold the Quran alone.
Yes but the same cannot be said for the sunni and shia majority that look down upon us when they barely reflect upon the word of God. They'll read the pretty Arabic but won't comprehend its meaning in a language they understand.
The same are my thoughts bro i follow Qur'an alhamdulillah and i don't hate anyone for following hadiths but the problem is that they some or idk but i watched a 'Sheikh don't know his name called muslims who are following Qur'an only without hadith are kaafir' like how easy for him to call someone who believes in one God and his prophets a kafir just wow
@@fighter.... i agree. Our monotheism is pure and we actually have much more respect for the prophet ironically as he wouldn't have wanted to be placed so high in praise to the point where it verges on shirk
@@ace9924 yes we should focus more on Qur'an instead of hadiths that were written 200-300 years after prophet Muhammad (PBUH)but we shouldn't hate the so called sects and it's not good how they're proud Sunni salafi and blah blah I'm glad that no sects believe in shirk everyone's shahada is same that's the different btw us and them they'll declare you as kaafir if you won't follow hadith but we ain't doing that we want unity and they keep dividing by how u pray how i pray ah May Allah guide us all
Indeed Allah is the most merciful:)
Great video brother, I am from Mauritius and there are also many Quran Alone Muslims.
Thank you for the appreciation Sir. Ramadan Kareem to you and others in Mauritius 🇲🇺
Good to hear that!
This is the only way if all Muslims back to the Quran alone
Peace
@@safemoonking9501 I’m sure you making your sallat. So with your Quran alone describe for me how to make the sallat. I will start doing like you even I’m not Muslim I will convert to Islam and pray for you to have the benefit of bringing someone into the right parth of the Islam.
Thanks 🙏...
@@submittersperspective8251 with you clamming Quran alone you already out of Islam without knowing, you doing games . Tell me your way to make the sallat . If you making the sallat the way we know doing Rakas : 2-4-4-3-4 it means you are MUNAFIKS or tell me where in the Quran it says we have to pray in Rakas. Please???????
Really? I must visit soon 🥰
Thank you so much ❤️ may Allah reward you for your videos
By accepting hadith, one is admitting that the Quran, the proposed word of Allah, is not strong enough to stand on its own, and that the word of man carries equal weight with the word of Allah and is even necessary to support it.
Where in Quran it shows you how to pray ? How to make ablution wudu and ghusl?
@@OYATca "O believers! When you rise up for prayer, wash your faces and your hands up to the elbows, wipe your heads, and wash your feet to the ankles. And if you are in a state of ˹full˺ impurity,1 then take a full bath. But if you are ill, on a journey, or have relieved yourselves, or have been intimate with your wives and cannot find water, then purify yourselves with clean earth by wiping your faces and hands.2 It is not Allah’s Will to burden you, but to purify you and complete His favour upon you, so perhaps you will be grateful."
@@WaqasAfzali-ls5yi excellent, this is partial wudu, now where is a verse about a prayer?
Basically imagine I told you how to cut someone’s hair. I said do a fade haircut, “get a trimmer and cut the sides short and leave the top longer” that’s the basic of fade haircut, but in detail it’s a lot longer step. That’s where the Hadith comes in
@@OYATca "Partial Wudu"???🤡🤡🤡
What are you talking about? It's partial because your Imams innovation isn't in it???? Wudu is simple according to verse I showed you:
-Wash face
-Wipe your head
-Wash your hands
-Wash your feet
Regarding Salat, in the Quran there is:
-Wudu
-qibla(2:144)
-3 positions of Salat(standing, bowing, prostating)
-to only recite from the Quran(29:45)
-to only praise Allah(6:162, 20:14)
-only 3 salats(Salat al fajr, Al Wusta, Al Isha)
- how to end your Salat
It doesn't however mention commiting shirk by "sending blessings to a prophet" who doesn't know who you are.
Man, you guys really are Mushriks. Allah has said that his book is complete and no outside source isn't allowed while you guys continue to add innovation after innovation.
@@OYATca Nope, the Hadith gives the wrong way of Salat. You recite a lot of unquranic verses that aren't found in the Quran and your way of ending Salat is also wrong. You (once again) commit another innovation by turning your face to your shoulders and giving greetings to angels in a worship meant to be performed for Allah!
Allah has already given the correct way of ending Salat:
Their prayer therein is: "Glory to You, O God," and their greeting therein is: "Peace," and the ending of their prayer is: "Praise be to God, Lord of the worlds." 10:10
Very explanatory response to the blind followers of hadiths.
There are different ways of offering Namaaz in the books of hadiths which led to the establishments of various sects & mosques and affecting the
Unity Of Muslims.
( quran 63:4) When you see them, their appearance impresses you. And when they speak, you listen to their ˹impressive˺ speech. But they are ˹just˺ like ˹worthless˺ planks of wood leaned ˹against a wall˺. They think every cry is against them. They are the enemy, so beware of them. May Allah condemn them! How can they be deluded ˹from the truth˺?
remind you of anyone?
They call me Murtad and wanna kill me.
Because I follow only Quran.
This is what happens when you reject the hadiths. You are taking verses from the Quran and interpreting it to follow YOUR narrative. This is why its really important to know the context of the Ayah and its equally important to know how Prophet (SA) and sahabahs explained the verse. In your comment, you are suggesting that the ones that compiled the hadiths are 'hypocrites'. Now it's a dangerous game you are playing. Why? Cause if you are suggesting that the hadith compilers are hypocrites then you are saying that Allah Says that they are hypocrite. And if you are wrong in your assumption then you are accusing your brothers in deen. I hope you have done enough research on this topic. Jazakallah Brother.
@user-yo9xs8tl5o This verse only refers to the hypocrites who tells that they have accepted the deen but in their heart they didn't! Do your research before talking like this about a verse!
Keep doing good work👍
Happiness is Submission to God alone!
Peace from 🌷the Netherlands 🌷
Thank you . God bless u . Peace ✌
Islam is not submition , this is a hadithist view .Abraham called us Muslims the Quran says , and he also defined the name Islam by saying "I direct my face to Allah " which is " wajht my face to Allah " , which in turn explain and is equal to "aslmt my face to Allah" . اني وجهت وجهي لله حنيفا / اني اسلمت وجهي لله
Islam is directing ones self to Allah .
Thank you so much, brother. I was born in a wahabi family and you know how firm this sect is about Hadith books but I'm the type of person who loves asking questions. There are so many hadiths that straight up contradict with Quran and our people are justifying it. Doesn't it seem like those times before our beloved Prophet when Christians and Jews used to follow everything but their original Scripture. I always use to ask then what is the difference between Jews, Christians and Muslims? It is still mentioned in their Scripture about Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) but they don't follow the same as Muslims who follow the hadith path but not the original book of guidance. Just think about it if Allah would ask the Muslims that "I gave you a divine book with a PROMISE of its safety you followed another book. Did I ever ask you to follow another book to understand Quran?" If it was that important for us Muslims that we wouldn't be able to understand Quran without it What didn't the messenger of Allah ask his Sahabas to collect this hadith? Let's think about the 4 caliphs's if not them at least Imam Hassan or Imam Hossein should've collected it but why didn't they? Omar(RA) even said to everyone to collect the hadith. What if Imam Bukhari had never collected hadith? My family scolded me that I shouldn't ask such questions but why? Allah gives me the right. Quran is a book of logic,reasoning and science. Even non-Muslim can't deny that. On the other hand, many hadiths have no logic and are against science. There are many problematic hadith about women. I don't care what someone thinks about me I cried in Sajdah and requested Allah to show me the right path. After salat while I was scrolling through social media I came across this verse:
"And We have revealed to you, [O Muhammad], the Book in truth, confirming that which preceded it of the Scripture and as a criterion over it. So judge between them by what Allah has revealed and do not follow their inclinations away from what has come to you of the truth. To each of you We prescribed a law and a method. Had Allah willed, He would have made you one nation [united in religion], but [He intended] to test you in what He has given you; so race to [all that is] good. To Allah is your return all together, and He will [then] inform you concerning that over which you used to differ." (5:48)
It was an eye opener for me. May Allah bless all of you. Amen.
*OMAR(RA) told everyone to not collect the hadith(sorry I forgot to write not)
Ma sha Allah I wish more Muslims were as awakened like you are my dear sister ❤ God bless you and keep seeking the truth 🙏 ❤ 😊
@@submittersperspective8251 brother it's seems like a deja vu. People who claimed to follow Jesus(PBUH) attributed those things to him that he never said. Same goes for Muslims. When I realized that we are in the same ship as them I was so sacred. Allah will ask the same thing to both that "Didn't he give Aql to us?" We all receive his msg in different forms its upon us now to take it or not. May Allah forgive us. Imagine how disappointed would our Prophet be? Someone said the satan knew he can't misguide people from Quran so he chose the hadith way. May Allah show the right path to our Ummah brothers and sisters. Ameen.
Sister when you say you were born in wahabi family it shows how much knowledge of ISlam you have as there is no such thing as Wahabi.Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahhab was a scholar of Islam who called the people of Innovation towards the Qura n and Sunnah.
Sister remember one thing no sound person will leave the Sunnah i.e. sound Ahadith of Prophet pbuh only those who face inferiority complex from todays so called civillised orientalists of west reject the Hadiths.Only those who want to follow their desires follow the Quran onlyThe Quran Only phenomon is from 19th century, So according to you all the Ummah,All ISlamic scholars till 19th century for nearly 1100 years were misguided really... And you have av very big ignorance about when Hadiths were written.Some sahaba used to write sayings of Prophet. Since you seem sincereI would request you to to that this step can be very dnagerous for you in hereafter.
If you are really looking for the truth then please watch these lectures of Adnan rashid who is a historian and has the knowledge of Ilm-e-Hadees
czcams.com/video/f8VvAnMl-gM/video.html
czcams.com/video/qM5WvypMSvo/video.html
czcams.com/video/LstwjvLlj_I/video.html
czcams.com/video/YDn2Veohh8I/video.html
some more sources
islamqa.info/en/answers/256435/refutation-of-those-who-quote-the-holy-quran-to-reject-the-sunnah-and-justify-not-acting-upon-it
islamqa.info/en/answers/604/justification-for-following-the-sunnah
islamqa.info/en/answers/93111/if-the-quran-is-perfect-and-complete-and-contains-
everything-needed-for-the-laws-and-regulations-of-shareeah-what-need-is-there-for-the-sunnah
islamqa.info/en/answers/239540/the-science-of-hadith-is-based-on-reason-and-shari-guidelines
O you who have believed, obey Allāh and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allāh and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allāh and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result.
How will you refer a matter it to messenger becoz prophet muhammad is not with us. The answer is very simple i.e. refer to his sunnah or Ahadith.
Subhan Allah .... very appropriately worded answers to the false claims against QURANIST . May God guide us all to the right path 🙏
Subhanallah
I’d say Shytan Menk makes false statements against God and the messenger to divert believers from the path of God.
Salam ☮️
@@McAroni52 Be careful my friend God told us in the Quran backbiting is wrong.
@@McAroni52 of course, that's how the cult originated in the first place, also be careful brother i read articles that muslims like you have been taken to prisons and were tortured in algeria, so keep it to yourself.
@@mannenibla204 what's backbiting? and how did he backbite or say anything wrong?
The things you have told were same in my mind like obeying the prophet and now as the religion is spread we have to believe in only quran not in hadiths. I am happy to know that I am not the only one with the same thinking may God bless you❤
Ikr but sometimes it feels so lonely, I used to follow sunnah but at the last day of Ramadan i saw some really awful hadiths talking about stoning and rape, And that day i decided to only follow Quran and reject all hadiths, But it feels really lonely since we are so few :(
@@mannenibla204 yes it is true I feel this like every time while I know that we are on the right path and others are following man made scriptures while almost forgetting the message of Allah. But m so happy that Allah gave me and a few others the chance to use our brain and learn things without following blindly that our elders taught us. Who knows tomorrow there can be more people like us Amen.
@@mannenibla204 we are increasing in numbers my friend and we have the support of many people, not sunnis but many others that want to see us take charge of islam in the world, also remember that no matter how few we are we are the righteous with a great moral compass and one day we shall enjoy each other's company.
@@hublot7952 there will be inshallah , just be careful if you live in the middle east or north africa as our people are being imprisoned and tortured in those countries. be safe brother.
@@shadygaming6523 I really hope that some day real Islam will prevail! And i have a new dream in life, I want to study arabic and master it in order to understand the Quran fully, And i really want to learn the Qurans meaning in and out in order to teach it to others, Inshallah we will have a big community in the future, Now that we know the truth we shouldn't stop here, Let's invite people to our way of life. This isn't a religion anymore but a guidance and way of life.
MM also said that "the hadiths are from Allah." But the hadiths are not from Allah. The hadiths are from people. The Quran says, "Who does greater wrong than the person who attributes a lie to Allah?" Because the hadiths are from transmitters, none of whom was a prophet and none of whom is mentioned in the Quran, any law based on a tradition is from persons and not sacred.
Moreover, verses 5:44 - 47 prohibit judging by what Allah did not reveal. Whoever judges by what Allah did not reveal is referred to as a disbeliever, a rebel and a wrongdoer. In addition to the prohibition of adding to revelation in verses 69:44 - 47, there are tradition in which the prophet also prohibited the recording of hadiths, for fear that they might be confused with revelation.
He never lifted this prohibition. Hence, the persons that recorded the traditions and presented them as "supplementary and explanatory revelations from Allah," flouted the prohibition of the fabrication of revelation by Allah and the recording and transmission of tradition by the prophet.
Moreover, since the prophet never lifted the prohibition on the collection of tradition, none of the gatherings was personally authorized by the prophet. Hence, the collections remain "unauthorized."
What is more, the hadiths are not verbatim words of the prophet; they are paraphrases, akin to rumors. Accordingly, anyone who says that "the prophet said," and follows that with a paraphrase of a hadith, already lied. The prophet did not say that. A transmitter reported it, using his words.
The elevation of the traditions to revelation was necessitated by the yearning of exegetes to use tradition to "explain" revelation. The requirement to "explain" revelation by tradition resulted from a deterioration in the knowledge of revelation, resulting from a deterioration and eventual prohibition of reasoning, the shutting of the gates to ijtihad.
The decline of the ability to reason was reinforced by al Ghazali's declaration of takfir on the philosophers, when he denounced them as heretics and disbelievers, recalling the anti-rationalism of Musa al-Hadi. The deterioration of reasoning was first triggered by the repression of reason, the use of which for the purpose of understanding revelation was equated - in a hadith - with kufr.
The disparagement of reason ('aql) was a result of the struggle between the rationalists and the traditionists. With the suppression of the philosophers in 786 by Musa al-Hadi - five thousand perished in the purges of the free thinkers - the traditionists prevailed. But the designation of tradition as - and its amalgamation with - revelation tainted the knowledge of revelation and warped the penal law. Persons that elevate tradition to revelation appear to be attempting to fabricate revelation and replace it with "another revelation."
The exegetes perpetrated a further faux pas when they declared that "tradition judges revelation," and when they asserted that "revelation requires tradition more than tradition requires revelation." In doing so, they subordinated the words of Allah to those of transmitters.
Very interesting point that you raised. Keep on posting such nice things that defend Qur'an alone.
you follow hadiths haha so when you get sick do you make fly 🪰 soup ?? Mmm yummy hadiths teach also how to rotate your wives when having s .ex thats sooo important you know how could one be a noble man without knowing which wife to f** last. Just give me one Hadith JUST ONE that can be found in the Quran meaning that it relates to ANY verse in the Quran. Bukhari was also mentioned the collection of Bukhari hadiths were written around 600 years after his death. You follow horny and disgusting hadiths and you clearly need guidance of every little step in your daily life is a SHAME. You need a 10 step guide on how to sleep how to shit how to eat how to drink how to sit how to walk. We’re you raised by monkeys in the jungle far away from society ?? You seriously think prayer is about how you do it and not why you do it ??? wow you also use Quran to insult people who never insulted you in the first place.
Surah 25.30: “And the Apostle will say: O my Lord! surely my people have run away from the Quran.”
Surah 54.17: And certainly We have made the Quran easy for remembrance, but is there anyone who will TAKE HEED? ……………
Hmmm I guess that’s why you need fake hadiths because you insist on not understanding the Quran. Even in the Bukhari hadiths it’s admitted that there is no hadith to explain 28 complete surahs or chapters of the Quran. That is 25 percent of the 114 surahs in the Quran. And the remaining hadith are sketchy, ridiculous and do not explain any of the verses of the Quran at all. People like you say the Quran cannot be understood without hadiths and that the hadiths cannot be understood either without complex debates. You really believe hadiths that claim the prophet drank someone’s water and the spit in it and gave it back? You believe in hadiths that claim that the prophet was a slave trader who slept with 9 to 11 woman every night without washing. You believe in hadiths that claim women are dogs and donkeys and most likely will go to hell!! Where In the Quran can you find these disgusting claims ???
Because that’s The focus of their career.
These people don’t have real jobs. Being
a religious charlatan *is* their job. You’re
literally threatening their livelihood by this
You are taking that quran verse out of context just like Islamophobes take 9:29 and 9:5 out of context .
Did you study why it was revealed?
do you know who Allah was talking to ?
did you study the Context ?
have you sat down with a Good Muslim scholar?
Assalamualaikum How can I reach you sir? I would like to learn from you
i also dont get why hadiths show that people are already in hell and more women are there WHEN THE QURAN says that nobody is in hell until judgement day and women and men are equal..
A very good point !!
Can be used in a debate!!
Can not Allah show his Prophet a part of the future??
People tend to cherry pick what they like 🤦🏻♀️ thank you for making it clear!
Well said. To much cherry picking.
if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@@Randomhandlename Therefore you are saying the Quran is not detailed as Allah says, thus meaning you don't fully agree with the Quran in the first place. It saddens me for real that you have to ignore a blatant statement from whom you claim to follow. If the Quran says it's detailed then it most definitely is. The wisdom of the creator is sufficient, Stand, bow and prostrate is what's important. Another explicit example is How Allah SWT tells us to recite in a tone in-between not loud nor silent, yet somehow people recite prayers some silent, some loud which contradicts the Quran clearly for those with reasoning. But if you want to be sheep and follow how your forefathers have done then more power to you. May Allah guide us all.
@@illmatic1official560 Quran never once mentioned that Quran alone or only is detailed if it was it would tell us how to pray in detail
@@Randomhandlename Surah 6:114-116
O my Allah increase my knowledge, to reply anti Quran scholars.
Keep it up brother Allah is with you ❤️
They're not anti quran the quranists are anti Rasoolullah SAW
[17:46] We place shields around their minds, to prevent them from understanding it, and deafness in their ears. 👣💔👣 And when you preach your Lord, using the *Quran alone, they run away in aversion.*
👣💔👣
[31:6] Among the people, there are those who uphold baseless Hadith, and thus divert others from the path of GOD without knowledge, and take it in vain. These have incurred a shameful retribution.
People needs to understand that Hadiths were compiled 150 years or more after the passing of the Holy Prophet ( PBUH ). Now why did the sahabahs not compiled it themselves ? Who gave that Imam Bukhari permission to compile things in the name of Islam without the permission of Allah and his messengers.. Awaiting replies from Hadiths followers.
You would think Mufti Menk is intelligent enough to read a verse in context. I really don’t understand how the spoils of war can be mistaken from following a Hadith.
He didn't quote the entire verse. This is called selective emphasis with the intention to derive a specific meaning that isn't really there.
We can conclude that he is not very clever or he is dishonest; using the quotation to support his view despite knowing otherwise.
@@abdollahsalleh2502 he is clever he is actually fooling People just to prove his aqida is right he is dishonest
@@ahmedmohiuddin4567 When you see them, their appearance impresses you. And when they speak, you listen to their ˹impressive˺ speech. But they are ˹just˺ like ˹worthless˺ planks of wood leaned ˹against a wall˺. They think every cry is against them. They are the enemy, so beware of them. May Allah condemn them! How can they be deluded ˹from the truth˺? (quran 63:4)
@@user-yo9xs8tl5o very well said.
There is indeed many verses in the Quran instructing "follow the Messenger" ..but note that the affected verses only used the term "messenger" (rasool, Arabic: رسول). Note also that the Quran did indeed used the term "Muhammad" and this is used six times in the Quran, 5 times in various verses (i.e.1x used as Ahmad), and 1x as a chapter title for Ch 47.
It means the Quran / God can be very specific that God uses the specific term in the Quran in those verses. However, in the verses where Quran says - follow the Messenger, none of those verses used the term "follow Muhammad", pbuh. Those verses used "follow the Messenger"
Also, if we check the terms in the Quran, using the key word Abraham,pbuh, we would noticed that the Quran is very specific in saying that those "better in religion" are those who followed Abraham, not Muhammad, pbut. Despite Muhammad pbuh being the one who was trusted to convey the Quran, he did not.... in any of the verses (below) wrote, follow the religion of Muhammad, pbuh
Q:3v95 Say: "God speaketh the Truth: follow the religion of Abraham, the sane in faith; he was not of the Pagans."
Q:4v125 Who can be better in religion than one who submits his whole self to God, does good, and follows the way of Abraham the true in Faith? For God did take Abraham for a friend.
Q:6v161 Say: "Verily, my Lord hath guided me to a way that is straight, - a religion of right, - the path (trod) by Abraham the true in Faith, and he (certainly) joined not gods with God."
Q:2v135 And they say, 'Be Jews or Christians and you shall be guided.' Say thou: 'Nay, rather the creed of Abraham, a man of pure faith; he was no idolater.'
Q:2v130 And who would be averse to the religion of Abraham except one who makes a fool of himself. And We had chosen him in this world, and indeed he, in the Hereafter, will be among the righteous.
There are no verses in the Quran, with the same arrangement, but putting Muhammad, pbuh, as the main subject, replacing Abraham, pbuh, none. This is another point in the Quran, in plain language, which shows that we are to follow the Messenger, but not necessarily Muhammad (pbuh).
We are even instructed not to make distinction of any of the Prophets (2v136), this is written in the Quran, but the Muslims have incorporated into the shahada "Muhammad", making is seemingly mandatory to include that in the declaration of faith
There are likely many thousands of Messengers, which we do not really know, but this shows that the Quran provided such a flexibility. The Quran even hinted that there will be a certain time when a particular message might be explained, and it could be said such messenger will come at certain time, perhaps even in the future (after Muhammad, pbuh)
Q:13v38 And verily We sent messengers (to mankind) before thee, and We appointed for them wives and offspring, and it was not (given) to any messenger that he should bring a portent save by Allah's leave. For everything there is a time prescribed
The problem with the current generation of Muslims is that, they take hadith as God's word, to the point that they only go to the Quran AFTER they read hadith. Many might not even read the Quran, only listening to the clerics and their hadith obsession. The Quran should be the main reference point, not hadith. There is even a hadith where the Prophet prohibited the recording of the narration
In extreme scenarios, in a significant number of poor Muslim countries, they would say it is ok to kill apostate, or to marry underage girls because hadith says so. These practices are clearly in violation of the Quranic message and shows the harm of abandoning the Quran in preference of hadith
MashaALLAH Brother Joey Ma....do you have more where we can read your thoughts or lines....
Indeed, it is very wrong to rely more on Hadith than to the Qur-an, Qur-an is preserved by ALLAH, while Hadith is not. Nowadays many Hadiths are false.
also as well I see some muslims say follow the messenger but even if the Quran was talking about Muhammad alone and not all of them we do follow him through the Quran which is where his details are laid out, sure some details are left out but same with the bible and Jesus there are no details on his middle part of life, for example with christians they follow Jesus through the New Testament alone and don't have other books written to follow him so we should do same and follow Quran alone
Excellent vid thank you for this.
May Allah guide Quran Alone people. Ameen
Thanks for this video.
I hv only one minus thing about this video regarding the sound of the narrator. When Mufti Menk’s part comes, it is very clear. But, the narrator’s voice very weak.
Thank you brother. This was very educational this is the same thing Dr Hany Atchan is teaching just using and depending on the Qur'an itself.
Thanks to the Almighty Allah for the guidance,,I am really happy to find others besides me who have the same views about Islam and Qur'an..I once rejected Islam because of the baseless hadiths and became an Agnostic.I was asking so many questions and people couldnt even give me the correct answer..I was like why are this people even debating against the Christians when they are themselves doing the same thing with our Prophet..As the Christians are associating Jesus with God the Father,The Muslims are also associating Prophet Muhammad(P.B.U.H) with Allah in the Shahada and the Holy Qur'an is being compared with the Hadiths
Brother don't feel alone. There are a lot of brothers and sisters like you all around the world who are rightly guided by Allah Subhan Huwa tala. Alhamdulillah I only follow the Qur'an. May Allah bless you and all of us.
Exactly! The Hadiths are entirely baseless and it’s a shame that so many Muslims are following Hadith and not Quran, even putting Hadith on the same level as the Quran!
Masha Allah bro, thank you for you uploading the truth.
Thank you Brother. The TRUTH ALWAYS PREVAILS.THE QURAN THE WHOLE QURAN AND ONLY QURAN FOR RELUGIOUS LAW.
if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@@Randomhandlename your asking these questions because you follow Hadith. There is no ritual prayer in the Quran.
Sajada first meaning is submit second meaning is prostration. Ruku first meaning is humility Second meaning to bow. Fajr and isha (todays Maghrib) are mentioned however isn’t ritual prayer
They are upholding to god laws meaning reading Quran- reflecting pondering and trying to apply to it
@@missqueen354 answer my question how do you pray
Thank you sir
Selam Aleykum
Chapter 59 is referring to Moses the messenger and the Exodus….
So this verse 59:7 is not only cut short but also taken right out of context and applied to the incorrect Messenger, though when it comes to distribution of wealth always applies to the leader, Leaders!
25:27 That day the wrongdoer will bite on his hand and say, "I wish I had taken the path with the messenger!"
25:28 "Woe unto me, I wish I did not take so and so as a friend!"
25:29 "He has misguided me from the remembrance after it came to me, and the devil was always a betrayer of people!"
25:30 The messenger said, "My Lord, my people have deserted this Quran."
25:31 It is such that We make for every prophet enemies from among the criminals. Your Lord suffices as a Guide and a Victor.
25:32 Those who rejected said, "If only the Quran was sent down to him in one go!" It was done as such so We could strengthen your heart with it, and We arranged it accordingly.
25:33 For every example they come to you with, We bring you the truth and the best explanation.
Wake up!
Peace
May Allah swt Bless Mufti Menk for Guiding us to Allah swts Deen. ❤
MashaAllah very clear and understandable answer. I am surprised that how come scholars such as Mufti Myenk tries to spread the Hadith which has no basis and most of them are against Quran. There is no way that a Momin (the believer) can follow Quran and Hadith all together. You can follow Quran or you can follow hadith. I take a very small and basic example, we do ablution according to the hadith and there is a clear instruction about doing ablution in the Quran, which one to follow? Both are different. What a common Muslim must understand that if there is a command in the Quran there should not be any source that tells against that command of Allah swt, what we do is to follow hadith that is against the Quran and the command of Alllah swt. Well, 99% Muslims are trying to impose Hadith in the name of Islam, but the word of Allah is the truth. This is the criterion and Furqan. We have the word of Allah not just the word made by human.
Masha Allah....such a clear and logical explanation.
Thank you for this video.
You're welcome. Please subscribe and support this channel dear sister. Thanks 😊
You are correct. We follow only the quran and we ignore hadiths because we know they are all foolish and false. But these Muslims who follow hadiths criticize us for not following hadiths and also call us apostates, and the real fact is they are apostates and not we
MashAllah my brother surah Al-Imran Ayat 7 (3:7
It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muhammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific. As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allah. But those firm in knowledge say, “We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord.” And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.
Alhamdulillah brother. May Allah enhance your knowledge and wisdom. I am also a student of knowledge trying to understand the true meaning of GOD me@age without the help of hadith or tafseer. Alhamdulillah Allah has guided me. I know hadith has over shadow the book of Allah. It is a deel rooted conspiracy of the so called Ulama. The good news is that there are hundreds of thousand educated young and old muslims who are researching quraan and finding out what is the message of God. InshaAllah sooner or later Allah will open the eyes of the muslims who are living on darkness.
You are not a student of knowledge
You are almost upon the road of kufr
Naudubillah
How can you not trust the most trusted scholars of Islam even Ibn Abbas the cousin of the prophet the ink of the Ummah ? You are making up your own personal Islam. *
How about pedophilia in Quran ? chapter 65 verse 4 - Tafsir Ibn Al Kathir
The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses
Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation.
@Zaak May Allah abrogate pedophilia chapter 65 verse 4 - Tafsir Ibn Al Kathir
The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses
Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. pedo sxx cult
Thank you for exposing mufti menk
Thank you so much
Brother wat you expect hi and others like him have made career out of Hadiths .
what makes me laugh at the likes of mufti manek is that they attack quran and call people who follow quran as wrong yet they claim they are muslims, so according to them : what? you mean to tell me you only follow the words of God? and don't follow people who hate islam? you are not muslim if you worship God and don't worship people who hate God.
it's really dumb really something a potato would say WTF to
@Carlie Morales did i offend you?
I have encountered Quranists myself & this is the whole point. When Quranist interpret The Quran without Hadith they draw their own delusional conclusions
I have always asked them the Question which till this day have NO ANSWER
Qur'an Surah 4:34 says to beat women "Wadriboona" What happens if a Quranist without hadith interprets this verse to be an agressive literal beating & abuses his Wife
They have no answer
Secondly:Notice he drinks Alcohol
See the Law regarding Khamr in the Quran was first legal then its consumption was reduced, then abolished in 3 stages. What happens if a Quranist thinks that the first verse was too abolished then later its permissibility got introduced
See this is the Problem one faces if they don't follow the Extended interpretation according to Hadith & try & feed out there own interpretations. This is one major reason, why the Hadith was introduced to protect the Quran from those who try to twist its meaning. For why Allah All mighty says in the Glorias Quran, we sent you O Muhammed to explain clearly to man the Quran
Surah 75:19
The Question then arises where can we find this explanation? If it is NOT the hadith then what is it
Do you know what is even more incredibly Bazaar, are the Quranist telling us that the Greatest Man in History the Prophet Muhammed has no Biography
How old was the Prophet when He recieved Revelation
QURANISTS HAVE NO ANSWER
What were the Names of his wives
How long did his ministry last
1 month 1 day or 23 Years
What age did he die
Who were his companions
Which companions passed on the Quran to us
How do we know if they were reliable since our Quran mushaf does NOT directly date to the hand of our Prophet rather 17-30 Years after him
Are they suggesting that the ones who passed on the Quran. Lied to us about Hadith. Therefore how can we trust the Quran they gave to us if the same people also fabricated Hadith
Did the Prophet have any Children
What were the Prophet's father's & mother's names
What were the names of his wives & uncles
What year was the Prophet Born in
Maybe he existed only 900 year ago instead of 1400 years ago
What did the Prophet look like was he fit & healthy or did he look like a fat
Was he a business man or was he on the dole
What was his teenage life like & early childhood
The science of hadith is based on reason & shar‘i guidelines
The science of hadith is basically & in principle founded on rational guidelines, with a methodology based on an accumulation of experience attained by the hadith scholars on the basis of many years’ experience of narrating reports and checking their authenticity and soundness. They attained the basis of this knowledge through lengthy involvement in checking reports, seeking them out, conveying them, examining them and determining whether there were any faults in them, thus gradually developing the general guidelines and framework of the science of hadith. Al-Khateeb al-Baghdadi said: Distinguishing the soundness of hadith is a kind of knowledge that Allah, may He be exalted, creates in people’s hearts after they have spent a great deal of time in this field and have attained lengthy involvement therein
No prophets followed any Hadith only the word of God.
👏 thank you for this very good
Please do not call yourselves QURANIST.
We are only submitters to the one Creator. Abraham named us Submitters (Muslims)
Why are people so against quranists? There is nothing wrong with following the word of God. Do the Sunni or Shia have some political interest? I see if the hadith matches the Quran then take it or else leave it and I don't think there's anything wrong with that. May Allah bless us all on the right path of the right Islam
Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): “He who obeys the Messenger has indeed obeyed Allaah . . .” [al-Nisaa’ 4:80]
“O you who believe! Obey Allaah and obey the Messenger . . .” [al-Nisaa’ 4:59]
“O you who believe! Answer Allaah (by obeying Him) and (His) Messenger when he calls you to that which will give you life . . .” [al-Anfaal 8:24]
(And) if you differ in anything amongst yourselves, refer it to Allaah and His Messenger . . .” [al-Nisaa’ 4:59]
Source Islam QA
You copied and pasted from IslamQA
salam, cool video, keep them coming.
i sent mufti menk an email many years ago telling him about his flawed understanding / interpretation of surah 59:7 , he never replied.
happy judgement day
They are Mushrikhs these muftis. How will he tell his audience that he has erred. Sunni is a parallel religion that was created by the Jewish Abu Hurairah using the prophet's ideology just like Paul used Jesus' ideology to create Christianity.
Ok i have question in my mind
How do you pray
From where did u learn that 5 times praying and how many raka is in praying. 2nd question is that how much percentage of zakat you are giving and from where did you learn , and if its in Quran pls show me , many more questions but i need answer for these 2
Salaamun 3Alaykum.
Mufti Menk mentioned about a Nabiy and a Rasul. A Nabiy has different role as a Rasul.
Obey Allahh SWT and obey Rasul.
But NOT obey Nabiy!!!.
Obey Rasul means obey his message, that is Al-Qur'an.
Its difficult for them to grasp this. It's almost as if their hearts are veiled.
Every Messenger said Obey Allah and Obey me.
In Surah al-Nisa 59: It says "O you who believe, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you are in dispute over any matter, refer it to Allah and His Messenger if you are actually believers in Allah and the Last Day, That is better for you and more seemly in the end" Many important points may be deduced from this one verse of the Quran. First, it must be noted that Allah explicitly uses the command "to obey," not only for Himself but also for the Messenger (PBUH), that is, "obey Allah and the Messenger." this same verb (ateeu) or command does not directly precede "those in authority among you. This establishes the Messenger of Allah as an independent object of obedience while obedience to anyone else is conditional upon consistency with the Quran or sunnah. Second, this implies that obedience to the Messenger is, in a sense, something different than obedience to Allah. Obedience to the Messenger of Allah is indeed obedience to Allah. What is meant here is that obedience to the Messenger differs from simply obeying the Messenger in what he has conveyed from the word of Allah or the Quran. Muslims are commanded to take any dispute that they may have to only two arbiters; Allah and His Messenger. The Companions of the Prophet (PBUH) and later scholars have understood " refer it to Allah to mean to refer to the Book of Allah. And referring the matter to the Messenger of Allah means to refer it directly to him during his lifetime and to his sunnah after his death. Note also that the two, the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Messenger are placed together here and the verse does not say, refer the matter to Allah and then to the Messenger of Allah, nor does it say, refer the matter to Allah and if you do not find the answer there, refer the matter to Messenger. Allah states that true believers are the ones who refer their disputes not only to Allah but to Allah and His Messenger
But Allah did not say follow hadith. Allah says the Quran is complete and fully detailed. And you cannot obey someone who is not among us, and obey messenger means the message he delivered lol.
@@Leil2221That's why we follow the hadith. We can know about the Messenger through the hadith.
You said we can not follow someone who is not among us.
So how do you pray salah, siam, hajj, zakah ordered by Allah in Quran without the help of sunnah?
The way to perform those are from hadith.
@@user-eq3jn9rh8v in the Quran there is:
-Wudu
-to only recite from the Quran in Salat
-to recite not loud or quiet
-qibla
-how to end Salat
-3 positions of Salat
It doesn't however mention commiting shirk by sending blessings to a prophet who doesn't know you.
Same with Hajj. The instructions for it is mentioned in surah al Hajj.
Stop being a Mushrik please
I used to see these people as good people but now I see clearly how manipulative they are
Miqdām b. Ma’d Karib (rA) reports that the Prophet ﷺ said, “Indeed, I have been given the Qur’an and something similar to it along with it. But soon there will be a time when a man will be reclining on his couch with a full stomach, and he will say, ‘You should adhere to this Qur’an; what you find that it says is permissible, take it as permissible, and what you find it says is forbidden, take it as forbidden.’ But indeed, whatever the Messenger of Allah forbids is like what Allah forbids.”43 - Quranist
Very interesting appreciated 🌺🌹🤲
Salamun Alakum. I would like to make clear InshaAllah that every person who submits to Allah, believes that the Quran is His guidance, and denounces all other books falsely attributed as holy revelation are Muslims and InshaAllah Múmeeneen. We are not Quaranists, one of them, or anything other than what Allah Himself called us, which is Muslim.
I am also so excited to find so many Muslims online uniting MeshaAllah. Allahu Ta Ala unite us here and in heaven. Salam
Thank You! I have never referred to myself as a "Q'uranist", I am a Muslim. The folks who seek their guidance from other sources are the ones who need a different name (Hadithists), not us.
He is cherry picking some lines from the Quran which does not coincide with the subject matter and never says what surah and verses he is talking about.
Very nicely explained through Divine Truth. JazakAllah Brother
Ma sha Allah . God bless you brother . Thank you for your support
Would you be able to fix the volume in this video? Thanks. This is an invaluable resource.
Appreciate your support. Thank you but unfortunately I'll have to take down the video and redo the whole thing as the microphone I used for this video wasn't of good quality. Hence , I recommend using the CC captions to read what I'm saying. I apologise for this .
Assalam my brother. Alhamdulillah for highlighting the true facts. Satan will try his level best to trick many so called “muslims“ to read other books or hadist written by humans 250 years after the death of prophet Mohammed,which unfortunately majority of them have blindly followed and inadvertently declared them also as divine massages, God’s forbid, in as subtle as possible. Many especially the learned scholars and Arabs have fallen into the Satan subtle tricks. May Allah give us the guidance and light to all sincere believers to uphold the teaching of our prophet Mohammed that is to uphold the Quran and nothing but the Quran - God’s Willing.
We aren't quranist ,
We are muslim!
Exactly, sunnies, Shia and all are sects... This is what Allah didn't want, we follow the word of Allah through his messenger, that's a Muslim, but may Allah forgive us all, no matter the sect or even relgion as Allah knows best 😊
You are correct brother. Keep it up.
Following the messenger means following the Quran
The messenger has brought the message and the message is the holy Quran. Period. Mufti Menki should tread carefully.
Excellent video, jzkl for sharing
Thank you. Appreciate the support
Very good response and follow Al-Quran correctly.. good luck..
How do you submitters do your prayer, audu?
why do you need instructions on how to pray?
Salat doesn't mean prayer ,it's to follow closely,meaning establishing the salat means to follow closely Allah's commands.
This brother breaks it down using the Quran.
czcams.com/video/4APNPrfRORQ/video.html
Learned from whichever communal practice showed us.
Are you implying no-one communally prayed or knew how to pray and that they only learned from a writtten compilation which was produced 200+ years after the death of the Prophet (PBUH)?
Oh dear
Allah has divinely protected the Quran he has not protected the hadith. Some hadith can be accurate and true but there's no way of knowing without any doubt.
It doesn’t matter even if some of them are true because everything Muhammad ever spoke from his mouth is not divine revelation.
God had him recite the Quran. How he spoke to his wives or friends in his personal life is not a divine commandment for all mankind. Yet the mainstream Muslims have tried to deify and make holy every single word he spoke and every action he took which is SHIRK.
They even try to imitate his beard and how he brushed his teeth. It’s pure foolishness and idolatry.
I have subscribed you brother I want to ask you more questions personally where can I contact you?
what questions do you have?
Excellent, very candid, yet simple! Thanks.
Quranist here in the USA. Hadith is lies
Quran 46:9
Say, “I am not the first messenger ever sent, nor do I know what will happen to me or you. I only follow what is revealed to me. And I am only sent with a clear warning.”
Prophet didn't know all!
And what I like to say to help people understand. If there was no Bukhari 300years after prophet, we would not know today how to be Muslims according to sunni! Is that what you believe!!! Didn't prophet deliver the message? Look what happened to Christians! Do you think prophet would let our religion to be gather around by years and by tousends of people?????
i wish mufti wenk would see your response
Yes we have to answer all their questions.quran is enough.
I enjoyed it thank you. Salam.
Hadith rejectors are simply arrogant. They think they understand the Quran and Islam and how to implement it in real life better than the Messenger of Allah ﷺ. They considers they themselves their own prophethood and think their limited minds that influenced by their desires are true rather than what is revealed by the prophet Muhmmad ﷺ. "And whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger and transgresses His limits - He will put him into the Fire to abide eternally therein, and he will have a humiliating punishment." Quran 4:14 "It is not for a believing man or woman-when Allah and His Messenger decree a matter-to have any other choice in that matter. Indeed, whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has clearly gone ˹far˺ astray." Quran 33:36
Brother can you please make a video on how to perform umrah according to the quran alone.
😂
You nailed brother. The worst thing about the traditional Muslims is that they are not aware that the prophet himself, Abu-bakar and Omar were all Quranites and that data is available everywhere in the traditional books. Ibn Sirin said: "They were not asking about the chain of transmission, so when the sedition occurred, they said: Name your men for us." then based on a discriminatory way they accepted the hadith from people of the Sunnah while they rejected the Ahadith from the others. If there are Ahadith why Fatima, the daughter of the prophet did not narrate any of it? Ibn Abi Hatim also narrated I heard Malik say: "The first person to chain the hadeeth was Ibn Shihab Al-Zuhri." According to what Ibn Sufyan and Ibn Mahan reported on the authority of a Zoroastrian known as Muslim bin Hajjaj. This Ibn Shihab Al-Zuhri was the companion of Satan for sure and according to Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti in his book Asmaa al-Mudalliseen (أسماء المدلسين) he was famous for fraud (مشهور بالتدليس). No Ahadith-related revelation was sent down to the Prophet Muhammad just as it was not revealed to Abraham, Moses, David, Yahya, and Jesus, and the Qur’an says, “In which hadith after God and His verses will they believe?” This is clear to those who have eyes to see and a brain to comprehend. Salam to all creatures of God (ܐܠܗܐ, الله, גדא, Godka) the greatest.
Quran is the true hadith of ALLAH
Following the Quran is following the prophet Muhammad pbuh. Subhanallah the argument that not following the hadith is not following the prophet insults the prophet Muhammad subhanallah
Also, Sunnah and hadıth ıs not same. Sunnah of prophet is: When people were askıng questıons, the prophet was waıtıng for answers from Allah. Examples:
1. They asked the prophet of Qıyamat - he waıts for ınspıratıon then answers
2. They ask about Malala - he waıts for ınspıratıon then answers
3. They ask about Ruh ul Qudus... - he waıts for ınspıratıon then answers
Thıs ıs the Sunnah the prophet.
So when we have a questıon, then we refer to the Quran.
Fınally, people cannot caterorıse themselves as Quranısts, Sunnı, Shıa, Ahmadıya etc...
We are one Ummah - we do not dıvıde
we are one, but don't make the mistake of thinking that sunnis or shias or anyone else is in the same basket as us.
Thank you, its perfect explanation. Still trouble me that where we get the Quran ? it was a mutawatir hadiths, consensus that we understand also hadith (news). I dont believe any law or jurispredence from hadith including so called sahih bukhari.. after all He was only the collector of so called hadiths. Again how we get the quran since it was came from mutawatir hadiths
Do you accept the Quran as a divine book because it came from "mutawatir " or some trusted hands or because the message and the contents of the Quran we have today proves its divinity and preservation? What is your basis to believe in it ?
@@submittersperspective8251 I believe that the Quran is divine revelation to prophet Muhammad and recited written through some trusted people (mutawatir ahadith) reaching us. And yes I believe the message and the contents of the Quran we have today proves its divinity and preservation
@Harry Kuffal So do you believe it is due to the "trustworthy " people that the Quran reached you otherwise it wouldn't have ? And since they gave u the Quran, any hadith reported in their name is automatically true ?
And Allah swa knows best.
Obey Allah and Obey the Messenger as articulated in AL Quran can also refer to Jibireel AS who was responsible for passing Allah's message (Al Quran) to RSAW.......so Allah commands RSAW to Obey Allah and HIS Messenger (Jibireel AS) and thereafter the Ummah needs to Obey the message of Al Quran as revealed to RSAW via Jibireel AS. The claim that Obey the Messenger as a separate entity is therefore false as the message that should be obeyed is Al Quran and NOT Ghadeeth literature as understood by most.....may Allah guide and protect us all😢
Look at Quran verse 59:7 in its entirety and youll realize it is in regards to distribution of gains from a perticular event, not in anyway does it imply hadith.
However, Quran verses 5:41-42 definitely describes how these people distort Allahs verses such as 59:7.
5:41
O Messenger, let them not grieve you who hasten into disbelief of those who say, "We believe" with their mouths, but their hearts believe not, and from among the Jews. [They are] avid listeners to falsehood, listening to another people who have not come to you. They distort words beyond their places, saying, "If you are given this, take it; but if you are not given it, then beware." But he for whom Allāh intends fitnah - never will you possess for him a thing against Allāh. Those are the ones for whom Allāh does not intend to purify their hearts. For them in this world is disgrace, and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment.
5:42
[They are] avid listeners to falsehood, devourers of [what is] unlawful. So if they come to you, [O Muḥammad], judge between them or turn away from them. And if you turn away from them - never will they harm you at all. And if you judge, judge between them with justice. Indeed, Allāh loves those who act justly.
Masha Allah❤
Salam alaykum
Mufti lives the good life thanks to his jewish masters. Enjoy a little while longer. It's unbelievable how these so called scholars can't understand Quran that's why they need Hadith. We are not Quranist. We are real Muslims
how do Quranits perform their acts of ibadat such as Salat who can demostrate the salat steps in the Quran in order ?
Please watch the Salat video in the channel
The same way the steps were taught physically before any written compilation.
How did Ibrahim and Musa and Isa perform salat? They didn’t speak Arabic or have Quran.
Why do some people impose conditions which are not present in Allah's Book (Laws)? Whoever imposes such a condition as is not in Allah's Laws, then that condition is invalid even if he imposes one hundred conditions, because certainly Allah's conditions are more binding and reliable!
Can you just listen to The Mufti and how he sees following Allah alone a problem? We know they Like who’s not like them.
What people did ...
Since 1400 a man declares he is last of prophets ..
Where as
In quran its Allah who is the awal and akhir.
How the seal of prophets can be referred as last prophet
So how do the quranist pray salah, or siam or hajj? Show me from Quran.
The Quran says to follow the Prophet PBUH.
And without Hadith, how are we supposed to know and follow the Prophet Now?
Why are these peope obsessed about hadiths??
These "scholars" make money by misleading the majority of muslims
@@mashrafi157 not just money, they also have a deep hatred for islam and or they are twisted and hadith allows them to be openly twisted, like the hadith that allows grown men to marry children .
@@shadygaming6523 True man, most of them just follow the majority of scholars and dont know any better, thus they are one big echo chamber promoting satanic rituals and innovations disguised as "Islam"
@@mashrafi157 and that's why those "scholars" say that the TV and internet are forbidden, they want to keep that echo chamber air tight, they want to keep them ignorant of the world around them
@@kanizfatima1377 yep exactly.
Good on you to illustrate the misuse of verses.
Quran alone Mashallah
Why?
Brocade that’s the order of GOD spoken by the prophet