If The Quran Is Sufficient, Why Do We Need Hadith? | Dr. Shabir Ally
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 06. 2023
- Hadith are reports attributed to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) describing what he said, what he did, and what happened in his presence. These reports have set a precedent for the Islamic tradition, but some still wonder whether the reports ultimately help the tradition or complicate it unnecessarily. Should we follow the Quran alone and put aside all hadith?
In the view of Dr. Shabir Ally, while the Quran gives us the basic outline of Islam’s moral and belief system, the more complex applications of its message often come to us from the hadith. While we should not hesitate to evaluate the content of hadith, we must recognize their value for rationally understanding the context from which Islam began and how to apply it practically in daily life.
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by:
Visiting our website www.QuranSpeaks.com OR
Sending an etransfer to iGive@QuranSpeaks.com OR
Subscribing monthly at Patreon.com/QuranSpeaks
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: czcams.com/users/subscription_...
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks
Where in the Quran does it say it is only the "skeleton" of the religion or only the "foundation" that needs to be "built on" more? The Quran says it is COMPLETE. COMPLETE means you don't need to add anymore details to it. Any details that Allah REQUIRES of us as Muslims surely he would have included it in his COMPLETE work. The HOLY Quran is PERFECT in its guidance, and your hadiths are not.
I guess what he means about the "skeleton" as an analogy went completely over your head. Without the hadith, you cannot establish an Islamic society."O you who believe! Obey God and obey the Messenger (S.A.W)and those in authority (uli al-amr) among you" Surah Nisa verse 59.
@@tavishkaif4651 I get the analogy, my point went over your head that the meaning of his analogy does not come from Quran it is his own creation/idea. The Quran is complete it does not need to be "built on". And the Ulu l-Amr verse doesn't have anything to do with hadiths or to give hadiths any authority.
@@tavishkaif4651 "Without the hadith, you cannot establish an Islamic society"
There were Islamic societies for ~200 years before hadith
the Islamic societies were there because the prophet(s.a.w) was still alive and after his demise, his companions(R.A) lived up to his sayings.
@@heregoes8839 your completely misunderstood the verse or you deliberately ignored the part where ALLAH is saying to obey the messenger(s.a.w). Now when ALLAH is commanding us to obey the messenger(s.a.w) that means you have to accept the hadiths .
The biggest mistake scholars made was believing in the hadeeth to legislation rather than just the good conduct of nabi saw
All the rituals prevailed from Prophet Abraham(pbuh). And Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was commanded to follow the religion of Abraham. So they came from the practices of generation to generation as the practices of the cultures. Hadith can be considered as a historical document which can be right or wrong. So it can’t be obligatory or mandatory for the mankind.
I guess what he means about the "skeleton" as an analogy went completely over your head. Without the hadith, you cannot establish an Islamic society."O you who believe! Obey God and obey the Messenger (S.A.W)and those in authority (uli al-amr) among you" Surah Nisa verse 59.
Brother, this is not the way to speak. Which hadith says that you cannot establish an Islamic society without the hadiths? Brother I’m a researcher and writer of many books on various aspects of Islam and comparative religions for last 26 years, specially on misconceptions about Islam. Of course Allah says to obey Him and obey the ‘messenger’….You should notice that Allah did not say to obey Muhammad (pbuh). Messenger is the one who bring the message. Which message he brought? Certainly the Glorious Quran. And he was instructed to convey ‘only’ the clear message of the Quran( innama alaika balagul mobeen) (Quran 16:82). You can not find a full clear structure of the Salah studying all hadiths on salah. And verse 2:125 tells us to take the salah from ‘maqame Ibrahim’ i.e. from Kaaba.
Allah knows best.
@@ahmfarooq1823 brother, let's say the PROPHET OF ALLAH(S.A.W) only delivered the Quran and after that he didn't convey the wahi to his companions(R.A) who would have taught you how to pray? How many rakats are in each prayer? How much portion of your income is zakat? What duas are recited during marriages? There are three types of Sunnah. The first is the sayings of the prophet(S.A.W)- Sunnah Qawliyyah/Hadith. The second is the actions of the prophet(S.A.W) -Sunnah Al Filiyya. The final type of Sunnah is the practices prevailing during PROPHET'S(S.A.W)
time which he did not oppose - Sunnah Taqririyyah. You misinterpreted the verse " the understanding of verse is for prophet(s.a.w) not any messenger. "Whatever the Messenger(s.a.w) has given you - take; and what he has forbidden you - refrain from. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty." (Surah Al-Hashr: 59:7)
Who would have taught you what to while going to Sleep:
1. Sleep after Isha prayer.
2. Apply Kuhl (Surma) thrice in each eye.
3. Recite 'Bismillah' (mention Allah’s name), close the door of room/house, cover the utensils, put out the lights/ extinguish any lamps and cover your food and drinks.
4. Sleep in the state of Wudhu (Ablution).
5. Whenever a person going to bed for sleep, he should dust it off thrice with the edge of a cloth and say this dua:
Bismika Rabbi Wada`tu janbi, wa bika arfa'hu. In amsakta nafsi faghfir laha, wa in arsaltaha fahfazha bima tahfaz bihi 'ibadaka-s-salihin.
6. Recite Ayat-ul-Kursi (2:255) before sleeping.
Brother I respect your knowledge and you are a researcher or a student of comparative religion but you are not a scholar of the Quran or hadith.
@@tavishkaif4651 Again brother, insulting anyone is not the answer of anything. No real scholar doesn’t claim himself as a scholar. Have you read my books? How do you comment about a person without studying him? If you want I can send you my books free. You study them and then comment. What did I misinterpreted? I just Quoted your quotation- “ Obey Allah and obey ‘the Messenger’ not any
messenger…(ref. Quran4:59). This is how you mislead people - you mentioned 59:7. Mention at least the whole verse and the context. It’s about the war booties. Do you know the mathematical structure of the Quran? If you don’t then study it and you will find all other answers.
God bless you.
@@ahmfarooq1823 who did I insult brother, the guy above was rude to me and was speaking arrogantly. You should also read his comments before imposing a vile accusation of misleading the people. Thank you for offering your book but sorry I am not interested in reading your books, my father is a phd is in Islamic history, and I have learned ISLAM from spending hours and hours with scholars and I respect them, unlike the guy above who was disrespectful to the scholar. Also, don't take mistake me as an unlearned layman , I am a part of the team who gives dawaah after our hospital work at times square, New York.
If the Quran is the house and Sunnah is the doors and the windows!
Then why didn't the first four Caliphs command to collect the Sunnah as a book like they ordered for the Glorious Qur'an?
Why did they leave the house of Islam without doors and windows?
it's worse than that, Caliph Abu Bakr burned his own hadith collection, and Caliph Umar ordered to collect everyone's personal hadith collections then burned them. Most Muslims ignorant of their own history
Because the Qur'an was the priority first.
The hadiths were already written and memoriesed the same way as the Qur'an, but without compilation. So hadiths were actually collected by the time of the prophet S.A.W but got compiled by Hammam and Malek which are the earliest compilations.
Then got deprecated later on by a bigger collection.
Hadiths were already memorized and some people even wrote them down, and the prophet SAW ordered not to write to not mistaken them with Quran
@@info786thats a lie but how do you know if they did that if you don’t accept hadith?
Thanks!
The question contradicts itself.
When you say the quran is SUFFICIENT, you can’t say you NEED anything else.
the video of it had explained. Hadith is much more of polishing and clarifying the contents of quran.
For example,the zakat(Charity)
hadith give much details on how much each should gave and etcs.
Another,the famous isra' miraj event alone as an example had over dozens of hadith narrations. Some said prophet muhammad SAW met 3 other prophets,some said all of it and some said he didn't met them at all.
you see,the hadith is more off clarifiying and provide much deeper details the content of Quran. Yes,it can become distortions and led to misinformations(used by many extremists). And for that,its better for us to turn back to the Quran if we aren't capable to accept some of the hadiths.
@@Daiman01 what about all the other forbidden things that are only mentioned in sahih hadith? that's basically making it an extension of Quran and Allah's word. Which means the Quran is NOT complete or detailed.
@@blumachine As i said.Hadith is never an extension but rather for clarifying it.
In Salat as example.There are a lot numerous ways explained on how or when we should pray to our lord or Allah SWT according to Hadiths but the core still said in the quran.Salat of prayer to Allah SWT 5 times daily.
Some of the forbidden for example as smoking.
Its never said in the quran that it is haram but the Quran did said something that will deteriote our health and gave negative effect should be haram.
Again.its better to turn back to the Quran if we aren't capable to accept the hadith.
Some sahih hadiths are still being debunked and questions by prominent muslim scholars till this days.Therefore,its better to return to Quran.
@@Daiman01 the quran already says it, doesn't that tell you we don't even need hadiths to begin with. salat times are in quran also.
@@Daiman01"But rather for clarifying it"
Still doesnt add up when Quranic verses like 6:38, 77:50, 12:111 etc etc seems to warn muslims for not believing the Quran is enough for them.
And I also have a problem with the traditional interpretation of the 5 pillars. How can the 5 pillars be legit when you cant find "La ilaha ilallah Muhammadur rasulullah" completely in the Quran? (Idk bout you but if u cant find that one, it proves the 5 pillars traditional understanding is wrong therefore the foundation of traditional muslim faith comes crashing down hard)
Traditionalists keep slandering Quran only people for innovating yet they're the ones doing it by combining verses that're scattered throughout the Quran
I take hadeeths with a grain of salt. If I'm going to follow books written by MEN I would CONSIDER venturing into the bible. Allah guaranteed to protect the quran. If you can show me where in the quran he promises to protect the hadeeths I'll follow them to a tee. If allah asks you on judgment day, "Was the quran sufficient enough for you?" Will you tell, "no"?
Exactly
Who do you think MEMORISED the Quran and wrote it down? The same people who were trusted to did that also narrated the authentic Hadith!
When Allah Said to "Obey Allah" is to follow the Quran and to Obey the Messenger is to follow his way and in what he does. Two different commands that when put together compliment each other.
So you would distrust Allahs commands and pick and choose what you feel like? That's not Islam. You either come into it in full or you dont.
When the words of Hajj, zakaat, Salaah and other rulings came to exist do you think people did not question like they would a teacher? Do you thino the Prophet did not speak to give guidance and a example. Or was Allah wrong when he said "“Indeed there is in the Messenger of Allah a perfect role model for the one who hopes in Allah and the last day and (who) remembers Allah much.”
To be a role mode/example to others you have to do it yourself and show what you are doing. And this is the sunnah.
The only religion that started with a prophet, where the prophet lived it and taught his people so they may keep what they learn and educate others is Islam. You know why the people surrounding the Prophet were honest and trustworthy like the Prophet himself.
I agree Hadith need to be verified hence why the science of hadith is seperate field that has stringent methods to see what was authentic and what was not.
the first time I see someone think like me ..God bless you bro
Wow what a powerful question. WAS THE QURAN SUFFICIENT FOR YOU? My answer will be ABSOLUTELY. Allah is all knower.
What's your criteria of sufficient exactly?
The message? Yes it's complete.
Applying the message? You need hadith.
Otherwise you don't know how to apply the prayers, pay zakat, how much is zakat, how to do haj, how to apply Hudood, inheritance...etc
Also the same people who wrote and transmitted the Qur'an did the same for hadith.
So by hadith rejectors logic, is the Qur'an also fallible? How do you know that the Qur'an today is as complete as 1400+ years ago?
Why reject hadith when the Qur'an is transmitted exactly the same way as the sahih hadith?
If Allah really wanted Muslims to collect and follow the Hadiths which are more detailed then wouldn't it make sense to have perfectly preserved the Hadith so that discussions like this one wouldn't be necessary?
Exactly, I keep saying this to Muslims and they argue. Why weren't things that you claim were so important, put in the Quran? Or a second perfectly preserved Hadith book? Mohammad's life and sayings were not written down until long after he died. Did he ever instruct people to write it down? Where is the evidence he said this.
@@alexojideaguThe Arab society was oral. The way the Quran was revealed and MEMORISED the same was authentic Hadith were too. Not that hard to explain it.
The same people that memeorsied the Quran are the same people that narrated the authentic hadith. The science of hadith delves into finding if its strong or weak. It's not just hearsy. The only religion that started with prophet, lived and established a Religion and taught people is Islam and the Prophet Mohammed. The Quran and the authentic Hadith compliment each other.
Allah says that everyone would believe if He had willed it. So you take from the hadith or you don't and Allah knows who the disbelievers are.
"And never be of those who deny the signs of Allāh and [thus] be among the losers." Q10:95
"And had your Lord willed, those on earth would have believed - all of them entirely. Then, [O Muḥammad], would you compel the people in order that they become believers?" Q10:99
"It is not for any soul to believe except by Allah’s leave, and He will bring His wrath upon those who are unmindful." Q10:100
@@yelfouladiyou mention it like people who reject hadees don't belive in Allah, people who reject hadees and follow only Quran belive that Muhammad was the last messenger and got the quran from Allah. And that's it. We belive in Quran as Allah's words and follow it by trusting Muhammad as God's Messenger. And that's it. So now the people who follow everything in name of Muhammad will add Bukhari , malik or tirmidi or muwatha as his trustee becuase Muhammad didn't write the hadeeses these people did it. So I belive that the possessor of true knowledge is Allah and transgressors add those peoples to list as their trustee. Which is not Islam at all.
Allah is Great.
@@shameerakthar8785 yes i agree with you brother, do they think Allah SWT purposely left something out of Quran and put it in hadith while He clearly say "nothing left behind from this book as the book is well explained and the best tafseer". Not to mention how most of hadiths leads to Muhammad SAW being ridicule and mock as well making Islam looks violence such as Aisha RA age, killing ex-muslim, and most sunni taking the hadith as their law and salvation
we dont need hadiths from a persian man that adopted zoroastrian beliefs into islam. al bukhari was made up in 9th century and prophet pbuh died in 6th century. and god made it very clear that the quran is enough. early muslims did art and music and the albukhari made his mind and said its haram, hopefully he will rot in hell.
The one thing I don’t understand is if praying and fasting and zakat was passed down then why are there people saying “no that’s not how to pray ie. left foot laid down and the other stood up or both hands not spread apart on knees”. These “little minute details” and then if you don’t to it they claim your prayer is invalid.
While the Blessed QUR'AN is the skeletal foundation, the addition of sinews and flesh can provide the opportunity for some to make mischief, such as the Sunni- Shia divide or just plain human bigotry, which are founded on false beliefs!
I've seen this with Buddhism in the development of the Mahayana texts and sects which started putting forth all sorts of teachings, some of which were "Buddhist" in name only! This must not happen with Islam.
Quran suffices.
It's already happened with Islam.
Mahayana Buddhism has a rich history and is practiced all over East Asia. Sure, it's not the orthodox branch, but that doesn't mean it's a fringe group, as it evolved differently due to geographical distances and pre-existing cultural traditions. So no, you cannot compare the diversity of Buddhism to Sunni-Shia hatred.
@@joshygoldiem_j2799 That was just one example and yes, I can compare the Sunni/Shia issue with examples of Buddhist misbehavior, such as in Mayamar or clashes between sects whether within The Theravada and Mahayana or against each other. I used to read about this stuff years ago, and while the subject has been used in fiction and in film, such things DID occur!
Then why didn't God just dropna book?
The Hadith is not from God!
i've known of Dr. Shabir for some time, but only recently have I been watching his videos w/ more frequency, and i'm liking him more and more. the group of scholars I follow the closest are Al-Mawrid (i.e. Javed Ghamidi), who have a very similar thought of Islam - Qur'an is the primary source of knowledge, and nothing else can be compared to it, nor supersede it. The other source of knowledge/practice is sunnah (distinct from hadith), which he defines as the practices/rituals/common knowledge which have been passed on down from Prophet Ibrahim (AS) to Muhammad (saw). this uninterrupted chain of practices/rituals/common knowledge has been passed down from a VERY long time
the ahadith, according to Ghamidi, should be viewed as a historical record, some of which which may have accurate details/facts, some may not, but it shouldn't be used as an authoritative/infallible body of work which we should use for our day to day lives, nor should we implement shariah from it
In what surah does it say that the Qur'an is complete?
Dear Dr Shabir
Would it be possible if the quran revealed in the format of hadith, human still regard this as a 'skeleton format', and come up with hadith to explain this skeleton? So, where is the ending?
Hadith is not scripture or the Word of God!
8:19- What do you think of the argument of charity being 20% based on Quran surah 8 verse 41. Shias do it but they treat it like income tax which is of course wrong according to the Quran.
Someone PLEASE help answer my question. If Hadith is so important to understanding Quran, when giving dawah, why dont we pass out the Quran along with a copy of Al Bukhari?
Because we don’t need hadith/sunnah to understand the most basic thing(Tawheed) and prophethood of Muhammad SAW and these are the only thing preached in Dawah because the Qur’an talks clearly about the basics. Hadith/sunnah is needed when person accepts Islam for understanding the details of the religion like: how to pray, how to pay zakat, perform hajj, implement punishments(hudud), etc. Notice how most hadiths are from Medina era when the Qur’an was talking about ahkam(provisions ) instead of faith.
I still don't understand the obsession with hadith book is evident Satan got a firm grip on those who champion it. 15% of the Book is beneficial 60% contradict what Allah says 10% of the Book is outright lie remaining 15% of the book any reasonable human being will know this are statements from lunatics. The Quran is sufficient and all basics in islam is all outlined in the Quran...1 shahada we all took directly from Allah is in the Quran 2 Salat is in the Quran and the timing is in the Quran schoolars said so how do we pray it well u also have no hadith on earth that explain how to perform salat? If Allah will take is time to talk about ablution reason that yourself..3 Hajj is in the Quran now hadith turned Muslims to idol worshippers kissing stone and stoning Satan Allah never told u to do that u just threw mockery into Allah's divine words..4 Zakat is in the Quran Allah said if they ask u what they should give =WHATEVER but they follow hadith but hadith said 2.5,3.5 yearly Allah never said yearly or even put percentage. 5.Ramandan majority of the ritual still intact. What good is hadith it lead us stray away from Truth.... Anyways Allah told us already that Majority of human will not beleive in Allah except they add something else that justify there obsession with hadith.
Here one thing is very obvious to me which is that Shabir Ally is not consistent. In one of his previous video, he mentioned that theprayer ritual came from hadith and since Abu Hanifa had a different criteria for accepting hadith (oral, though), some of the rituals in prayer is not present in Hanafi method whic is followed in other madhabs and documented in Hadith. Now he is sayiong that prayer ritual came from age old tradition and common sense. So should I understand that oral hadiths were okay as traditions and common sense and more formalised hadiths (compiled much later, albeit with limitations) are mere for reference in case of dispute? Tha sounds strange.
Quran clearly says to spend/give the excess, so no need to specify 2.5% as found in traditions
The Qur'an says pay zakat.
It's doesn't mention any amount, and what do you mean by excess? And how does one establish Salat? How to apply Hudood?
So many details not explained without the hadith.
Allah sent down the messenger for us to as he explained them.
16:44
He makes himself sound like he knows everything you would need to, but the man admits his limitations and works within them! That's why he speaks good.
When he says " relay chains and human chains are necessarily subject to error, mismemory and all of this" and still wants to keep following them based on the personal analysis, sounds like following what you wanted with Quran insted of follwing what Purely allah wanted. Just saying.
Make the Dhabeeha of those relics
Why Allah didn't preserve hadith?
Who said Hadith isn’t preserved? All the science of Hadith and you think it isn’t preserved lol. It’s not as preserved as the Quran as that’s the honor only the Quran can have and from the Hadith all we need is the meaning but even then, Hadith has been recorded verbatim rather than just the meaning.
@@slightlyopinionated8107what science in the hadith? Hadith is full of scientific nonsense. Look at this hadith, Sahih Bukhari book 65 hadith 4480
The Best Hadith has been preserved, the only one all scholars agree upon - the Quran.
why are you asking an anthromorphic question
@@slightlyopinionated8107hadith science? Really? Theres no science in distinguishing hearsay. Hadith science is an insult to academia.
Does true monotheism depend on the perfect word of God or on practising all the rules and regulations laid out by Muhammad? Pure monotheism is laid out in the Sermon on the Mount, Matthew 5-7.
Only those who were pure in heart could see God in the flesh standing before them in the man Jesus. John 14:9
@@HH-pv9ex You misunderstand. It was the Son who was speaking and revealing himself to Moses, for no one has seen the Father.
@@HH-pv9ex As eternal God, Jesus shared power and glory with the Father before the creation of the world. John 17:5
@@HH-pv9ex No, you are not getting it. Jesus is re assuring his disciples that he is not a mere human who is about to die. Through him the disciples have gained access to the one true God, of whom Jesus himself is an integral part. There is no way you can compatibilize this passage with Allah who neither begets nor is begotten. Jesus is the unique son of God! You cannot dress this up in Islamic garb.
You are reading about the death of Jesus. When a human being dies, the spirit leaves the body. This is what is being described.
Your channel is not called "Let the Quran AND HADITH Speak".
Islam does not "need" the hadith books, the holy Quran is sufficient
If that’s the case then how would you know how to pray? The Quran doesn’t mention this just that you must pray.
@@matthoffman6962 oh well answering to your questions how did previous prophets like prophet Ibrahim, prophet Nuh and more prophets know how to pray? Praying was passed down by generations our parents taught us before then our grandparents and before then our past ancestors in the time of the prophet and also tell me the hadith that include the words you have to say in your prayer/ salah
Dear Muslims this guy alongside Yaser Qadhi are the only honest scholars you have. They BOTH admit that the Qur'an IS NOT the 'perfectly preserved word of allah' as youve been led to believe
What is your yard stick when it comes to sifting? You know the answer Shabir. If we have to go to the Quran to figure out the authenticity of a hadith then why do we need the hadiths? Read this carefully until it goes into your head.
I guess the answer is No, the Quran is not enough Guidance for Muslims because without the words and actions of Muhammad (whom they are told to Obey and whom they absolutely don't worship) the guidance is not complete. Even though Allah only sent down One Quran (well actually several but that's another topic).
I respect you but I don’t need Hadiths. The Quran suffices. “These are the [only] verses of Allah. So in what Hadiths after them will you believe?” -Quran
Then why allah didn't mention regarding Hadith😊 in Quran!?
He did, there is a verse ( don't remember wich out of my head) that says" follow the teachings of your prophet"
@@JD_82 It also calls him an example to follow. That is why his ill behavior is so disturbing.
@@JD_82 follow the messenger means follow his message wich is the message of Allah, nothing else.
@@JD_82 The teachings of the prophet PBUH (the messenger) is the Quran (the message).
@@Magoo0028 There are two revelations, the Qur'an and wisdom. How do you explain wisdom?
And Allah has revealed to you the Book and wisdom and has taught you that which you did not know. And ever has the favor of Allah upon you being great.
Quran, (part of the verse (4:113))
Allah commands two things to be recited: the Qur’an and wisdom.
And remember what is recited in your houses of the verses of Allah and wisdom. Indeed, Allah is ever Subtle and Acquainted [with all things].
Quran (33:34)
Mnsha allaha 🔥🤍
As Salaam Alaakum. The Quran is direct revelations from Allah. The Hadiths are from the Memory of men what The Prophet pbuh said and did. You need both.
Bukharis original doesnt exist. He verbally narrated to 90,000 yet the only complete text available is from 12th century.
Hadiths should be only accepted on their merit
yup, and apply EXTREMELY stringent criteria to make sure they are mutawaatir (mass transmission), can be back to the Prophet (saw) and agree w/ the Qur'an (or at the least, don't conflict w/ the Qur'an). the scholars that I follow most closely say to only use them as a historical record
Bruh I hear about hadiths,,,strong ones , weak ones, how they aren’t always authentic, NEED them to understand Quran... yet I thought always the Quran itself was the miracle and the whole reason not to be Christian is because the book was corrupted and confusing.. but Muslims can’t even rely on GODS ONE TRUE HOLY NOT CORRUPTED CONFUSION BOOK without,weak,not always authentic, etc etc, man made books hundreds of years later. Joke?
A physical act passed down is far harder to corrupt than simple words.
Allah SWT says in different Amat’s I have Meade the QURAN easyITS CONCLUSIVE and it’s complete. its for all mankind and for all time so tell me why we need the Hadith
How many rakaats in fajr prayer
Prove to me from Quran?
@Hamza Kashif the hadiths don't tell the details of ritual prayers either. The way to make the ritual prayers was already known by the people. There was no need to mention it in the Quran. The hadiths were written 200 years after the death of the prophet and after the Quran was revealed. The companions of the prophet didn't need a revelation of how to make the ritual prayers.
@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 that doesn’t answer the question I asked!
@Hamza Kashif the Quran doesn't mention the number rakats because the ritual prayers were a living tradition. The details of the ritual prayers were widely known by the muslim community during the time that the Quran was revealed.
The hadiths don't have a detailed layout of how to pray the ritual prayers. I can also guarantee that you didn't learn how to pray the ritual prayers by reading hadiths.
@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 so you have debunked yourself by stating that the number of rakaats are not mentioned in Quran!
Hence proved that you cannot practically and completely act on deen without sahih ahadiths of Prophet PBUH.
Secondly it’s your lack of knowledge that you can’t find the detail of a particular ritual prayer.
Ask me and I will provide you the evidence with reference from Hadith and don’t be an ignorant!
If it says in the Quran it is fully detailed, how could you possible say it is only the "skeleton" in islam. Embarassing for a muslim scholar!!
I am leaving among you two weighty things. There first of which is the book of Allah. In it is guidance and light, and the member of my household, I remind you of Allah with regards to member of my family. Sahih Muslim According to this Hadith and the next one which is also is in the book of Sahih Moslem and is called Hadith o o Mubahila, Quran has to be interpreted only by specialists or Ahl.e.Bait of Prophet (P.B.H.H). Saad bin Abi Waqas relates when Ayatollah-Mubahila was sent down, Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) called Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Husain and said O my Allah (SWT), these are my Ahl.e.Bait. Sahih Muslim vo12, pp287
I heard there was three different versions of the hadith. One with my sunnah, one with ahl bayt and one without both of them.
@@Kzam19-ux8wg Salam
@@Kzam19-ux8wg how about this Hadith?
My ummah will divide into 73 sects. All of them will be in hellfire except one. Sahih Muslim
Or this Hadith:
Anyone who died without knowing the Imam of his time, does the death of ignorances. Sahih Muslim
How about this Hadith:
My caliphs are 12, the same as Bani Israel.
Surah al-Ma'idah 5:12
Allah made a covenant with the children of Israel and (( Appointed)) 12 leaders fromamong them and then said "I am truly with you"
Or this:
Al-isra 17:71
The day when we shall call together all human beings with their (respective) Imam.
Allah has clearly spoken through His Prophet and there's no excuse.
We have a judgement day and we have to answer.
Community knowledge about what Quran says about Adam-Eve story till today is wrong. The real story is like this (Sultan-Bin Translation of the Quran):
Quran Chapter 17 verse 60 And [remember, O Muhammad], when We told you, "Indeed, your Lord has enclosed the people [with a cyclic pattern of History]." And We did not make the vision [Al-Isra, your night journey] which We showed you [before] except to be a test [homework] for the people [to uncover its prior cycle in history] in connection with the tree [whose fruit Eve-Adam ate], the accursed [Ibless, who whispered Adam to eat] mentioned in the Quran. And We threaten the people [to uncover night journey of Eve-Adam from Al-Isra of Prophet Muhammad (saw)], but it [the lesson emanating from: Eve-Adam were created on earth, living on earth then Allah took them to heaven like Prophet Muhammad only to send them back with or without honour (clothed or naked) after setting up their status] increases them not except in great transgression.
Quran Chapter 20 verse 117: Then We said, “O Adam! This [naivety of yours, 20:115] is an enemy to you and to your wife. So do not let it drive you both out of Paradise so that [O Adam] you experience [a naked (humiliating) return in contrast of a clothed (honoured) return].
Quran Chapter 20 verse 118: “Indeed you will not be hungry nor be naked [herein, that you used to be] therein [on earth before].
Quran Chapter 20 verse 119: and you will not suffer thirst nor from the heat of the Sun [herein that you used to] therein [on earth before].
Quran Chapter 20 verse 120: But Satan whispered to him, saying, “O Adam! Shall I show you the tree of eternity and a kingdom that does not fade away?”
Quran Chapter 20 verse 121: And Adam and his wife ate of it, and their nakedness [sense of humiliation] became apparent to them, and they began to fasten over themselves from the leaves [remnant honour] of Paradise. And Adam disobeyed his Lord and erred.
Quran Chapter 20 verse 122: Then his Lord chose him and turned to him in forgiveness and guided [him].
Quran Chapter 20 verse 123: [Allah] said, “Descend [naked instead of clothed], both of you, from here together [with Satan] as enemies to each other. Then when guidance comes to you from Me [to realize Quran 2:30], whoever follows My guidance will neither go astray nor experience disgrace [ever].
Quran Chp 7 Verse 20: But Satan whispered to them to show what was hidden from one another of their nakedness [sense of humiliation]. He said, "Your Lord did not forbid you this tree except that you become angels or become of the immortal."
Quran Chp 7 Verse 22: So he made them fall, through deception. And when they tasted of the tree, their nakedness [sense of humiliation] became apparent to them, and they began to fasten together over themselves from the leaves [remnant honour] of Paradise. And their Lord called to them, "Did I not forbid you from that tree and tell you that Satan is to you a clear enemy?"
Quran Chp 7 Verse 24: [Allah] said, "Descend [naked instead of clothed, adornment], being to one another enemies. You will find in the earth a residence and provision for your appointed stay [so you won’t suffer again there from the heat of the Sun, hunger, thirst, nakedness]."
Quran Chp 7 Verse 26: O children of Adam, We have bestowed upon you clothing [sense of honour] to conceal your nakedness [contrasting the sense of humiliation] and as adornment. But the clothing [honour] of righteousness - that is best. That is from the signs of Allah that perhaps they will remember.
Quran Chp 7 Verse 27: O Children of Adam, let not allow Satan to tempt you as [such naivety, 20:117] drove your parents out from paradise stripping of them from their clothing [honour] to show each other their nakedness [humiliation]. He and his tribe watch you from where you cannot see them. We have made satanic forces allies to those who do not believe;
Quran says do motta
The Quran is complete because it guides us about things that we follow without the actual Quran, hence pray, marriage, we don’t marry the Quran or pray to Quran… same with Hadith… it tellls us obey the messenger and he doesn’t speak out of whim… thus obeying authentic Hadith is obeying the complete Quran which tells us that is the guidance as well
Alhamdolillah for Islam
How do we know it's authentic?
@Joo O hmmm... are you trying to say if islam was the religion of adam (which it is), why don't we have had a hadith already explaining this and other things
@@jooo7011 57:27
We sent other messengers to follow in their footsteps. After those We sent Jesus, son of Mary: We gave him the Gospel and put compassion and mercy into the hearts of his followers. But monasticism was something they invented- We did not ordain it for them- only to seek God’s pleasure, and even so, they did not observe it properly. So We gave a reward to those of them who believed, but many of them were lawbreakers.
This shows that Allah swt sends messengers to be followed by the people, but the people invent religions
@@jooo7011 I’ve given you a clear response to your first question, clearly you don’t appreciate the fact that you were trying to be critical yet the Quran actually had an exact response for you; thus, I’m lead to believe you wouldn’t accept anything I say with any level of appreciation… therefore, I will close by saying this- Allah SWT reveals that it was made to appear to them as if he died, this is a clear declaration that their dilution that they have the power to kill the messiah with any certainty is misplaced. Furthermore, as they were delusional in their claiming Jesus pbuh claimed to be Allah, it is also clear they were allowed to continue in their delusion. May Allah swt guide you. I can’t read the entire text for you… Allah guides whom he wills and allows to go astray whom he pleases. Alhamdolillah for Islam
To know how to pray, quran doesn't say.
Allah didn’t make us robots. We can directly speak to that which caused us to speak. It’s pretty simple.
100%@@malenomadiclion2030
In Quran 15:9, Allah promised to protect the Quran from corruption - from human interference (or input): “Verily, it is we (Allah) who have sent down the Quran, and surely, we will guard it from corruption.” Allah further explained that the Quran is written in pure Arabic language with no foreign words in it: Quran 41:44 reads, “Had We (Allah) sent this Quran (in a language) other than Arabic, they would have said: "Why are its verses not explained in detail? What! - a Book in a foreign tongue, and not in pure Arabic language?”
*
Within Allah’s Quran that was hand-written on preserved tablet in the eternity past (before creation) by Allah, himself, the following are few non-Arabic words - (or foreign words):
The word “Pharaoh” in Quran 2:49 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Egyptian language.
The word “Injil” in Quran 57:27 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Greek language.
The word “Jinn” in Quran 6:100 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Persian language.
The word “Al-Kifl” in Quran 57: 28 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Abyssinian language.
The word “Ghassaq” in Quran 78: 25 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Turkish language.
The word “Qistas” in Quran 17:35 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Greek language.
The word “At-Tur” in Quran 2:63 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Syriac language.
The words “Haroot” in Quran 2:102 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Persian language.
The word “Sijjil” in Quran 15: 74 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Persian language.
The word “Malak” in Quran 2:30 is non-Arabic - it is derived from the Ethiopic language.
@@jooo7011 Quran 27:18-19 tells us about the talking ants: It goes something like this: Imagine this much: Today, we know some things about Julius Caesar, great Romans Emperor, who lived a long time ago. Now, let’s suppose next week somebody says to us, “Julius Caesar was given the ability to know the languages of animals (i.e., birds, ants). As he (Julius Caesar) was on one of his military conquests, he came upon a valley of ants. One ant announced to the colony of ants: ‘O ants; hide into your homes so that Julius Caesar does not crush you under his horses and chariots.’ Then when Julius Caesar heard what the ant had said, and he (Julius Caesar) smiled.”
*
This incident in the Quran, according to Muslims, is one of the scientific miracles of the Quran - because, before the 7th century A.D, no human being knew that animals communicated with one another. The fact that Mohammed, an illiterate (un-lettered) desert dweller, was the first to bring this information to us and to the scientific community makes Mohammed a true prophet of God.
*
However, as to your question: “Do ant speak?”, no one knows the answer. But it has been known from the beginning of creation that social animals (fish, wolves, ants, etc.) do communicate with one another.
Quran and Hadith is both important🕋☪️☪️☪️
and this is the same guy that said adam as is not the first human
where did he say that? link please
Imagine if all of the Quran, sirah, hadith, and tafsirs were written right after the death of Muhammad, verified by his companions, preserved for all time as the word of God, and used universally by all Muslims. Then you would have the New Testament!
What's the point of telling me this? looks like you're clueless
@@santa_is_communist Clueless about the twisted origins of Islam or about the New Testament?
I think the Prophet had knowledge of the Bible from his engagements with Christians and Jews, since there are stories narrated in hadith which are not detailed in the Quran but are in the Bible. The liklihood of that is in Quran verses that say, this revelation confirms the scriptures of past. (paraphrasing)
Actually this is better, because it gives Muslim the leeway to interpret things
The new testament has been changed many times it has by no means been preserved.
My dear friend you need Jesus!
We Muslims have Jesus but not just Jesus
my friend you need to prove your religion
There is but 1 man, Paul, who wrote both "hadith" of the Holy Bible and wrote "sunnah" of Jesus Christ, the Son of GOD. And Paul's writings are right there in the Holy Bible.
Now how many authors of hadith and sunnah of Muhammad are there in Islam over hundreds of years, beginning years and years after Muhamad died? And the books of hadith and sunnah are not in the Quran. They are all separate books numbering over 100!
nice try christian
@@HH-pv9ex
They are not part of the Gospels. The Gospels are Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. There is no "Paul" Gospel.
However, Paul did experience the Resurrected Jesus and that experience led Paul to think about the question the Resurrected Jesus asked him: *“Saul, Saul, why do you persecute Me?”
“Who are You, Lord?” Saul asked.
“I am Jesus, Whom you are persecuting,” He replied."
As a result, the former 'Saul' became Paul, whose experience led him to believe Jesus is GOD, to be born-again. With the Holy Spirit dwelling inside his heart, Paul became a great scholar whose insight and writings were given to him by GOD.
@@HH-pv9ex
Who else witnessed Muhammad in the cave talking to what Muhammad's WIFE (who was never in the cave with Muhammad during his apparitions) said was angel Jibril??
The men riding with Paul saw or heard something very unusual and knew when Paul fell from his horse he had experienced something.
@@HH-pv9ex
First, Paul WAS a prophet. He prophesied End Times about 13 years before the Book of Revelation was written:
2 Thessalonians 2: "For the secret power of lawlessness is already at work; but the one who now holds it back will continue to do so till he is taken out of the way. And then the lawless one will be revealed, whom the Lord Jesus will overthrow with the breath of His mouth and destroy by the splendor of His coming. The coming of the lawless one will be in accordance with how Satan works. He will use all sorts of displays of power through signs and wonders that serve the lie, and all the ways that wickedness deceives those who are perishing. They perish because they refused to love the truth and so be saved. For this reason GOD sends them a powerful delusion so that they will believe the lie and so that all will be condemned who have not believed the truth but have delighted in wickedness."
Second, Paul was a disciple of Jesus. A disciple of Christ is one who believes Jesus' doctrine, rests on His sacrifice, receives His Spirit and imitates His example. Evangelical Christians throughout history were and are disciples of Christ.
In typical muslim style, you corrupt the text of 1 Corinthians 15:10 where Paul says, "But by the Grace of GOD I am what I am, and His Grace toward me was not in vain. On the contrary, I worked harder than any of them, *though it was not I, but the Grace of GOD that is with me."* Amen! It is not Christians under their own power who share the Good News of the Gospel message-- It is GOD's gift of His Grace working within us.
Third, Matthew 11:27 states, "All things have been committed to Me by My Father. No one knows the Son except the Father, and no one knows the Father except the Son and those to whom the Son chooses to reveal Him."
The Gospel is rooted upon the Shema which begins in Deuteronomy 6:4-9,
“Hear, Israel! The Lord is our GOD, the Lord is One! And you shall love the Lord your GOD with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength."
Every believing Christian attests to the fact that the Lord GOD is One.
The Old Testament affirms One GOD as Father and Holy Spirit. The New Testament affirms One GOD as Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
If you, a mere human, can easily understand your deity, then it is not the GOD of Abraham, Isaac, Moses, David and Solomon.
@@HH-pv9ex
First-
So if this is such common knowledge, then you must know who Paul is referring to when he prophesied in 2 Th 2:6, "For the secret power of lawlessness is already at work; *but the one who now holds it back will continue to do so till he is taken out of the way.*
*So, HH, who is holding back the lawless one"?*
And you wrote, "Jesus alerts his disciples not to be deceived by the false prophets, who will claim themselves to be the Christ". Muslims claim the person referred to in certain Bible verses is Mohamed when they are about Jesus Christ. Thank you for proving that Mohamed was a false prophet.
You said that Paul was about abolishing the law. He was not. I suggest you study the following terms about Paul and the law.
Paul reveals the law in three ways: by 1-polemical repudiation; 2-through radical replacement; and 3-re-appropriation of law as both prophecy and wisdom.
And as far as your interpretation of the definition of disciple, apparently Muhamad had not even one disciple nor did he even bother to plan for his death, leaving no successor. When he died, his arrogance was so great that his companions and family fought to the death of who would run his business when he died.
Second-
Your argument against Paul is simply not true.
James (the just) is the brother of Jesus. And James wrote the book of James. James 1:1 reads "James, *a servant of GOD and of the Lord Jesus Christ.* James 2:1 says, "My brothers and sisters, *believers in our Glorious Lord Jesus Christ* must not show favoritism."
@HH- So if James did not believe Jesus is GOD, why did he use the word "Glorious" referring to Jesus which is a word for GOD Alone? And why did he call himself a *servant of Jesus?*
Jesus appeared to His brother James after His Resurrection, resulting in James believing Jesus was, indeed, the Son of GOD. James was
Paul's teachings focus on our justification with GOD, James’ teachings focus on our works which show our justification. James emphasizes that good actions will naturally flow from those who are filled with the Spirit and he suggests that you may or may not have a saving faith if the fruit of the Spirit cannot be seen. *Paul described this similarly in Galatians 5:22: "But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law."*
Jesus stated He is GOD in the New Testament:
! *“Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, Baptizing them in the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age.”*
! When He asked them why they were attempting to stone Him, they said, *“For blasphemy, because you, a mere man, claim to be GOD”* John 10:33. Stoning was the penalty for blasphemy Leviticus 24:16.
! In John 10:30, Jesus said, *“I and the Father are ONE.”*
! *“Very truly I tell you, ... before Abraham was born, I AM!”* John 8:58.
Jesus says HE IS the great “I AM” in Exodus 3:14.
! Thomas the doubting disciple understood Jesus’ deity, declaring Him to be *“my Lord and my GOD”* John 20:28. If Jesus were not Lord and GOD, He would have corrected Thomas, but He did not. Thomas spoke the truth. ! After seeing Jesus walking on the water, His disciples worshipped Him Matthew 14:33.
! When He appeared to them after the Resurrection, they fell at His feet and worshipped Him Matthew 28:9. Again, Jesus accepted their worship.
! Father GOD referred to Jesus as GOD: “About the Son He says, ‘Your throne, O GOD, will last for ever and ever’” Hebrews 1:8, quoting Psalm 45:6.
*HH- Jesus is called LORD in the New Testament over 600 times. Quran 1:1 reads "All praise is for Allah-lord of all worlds". Why is Allah called "lord"?*
Once again Shabir gives another convoluted answer for a convoluted Quran! Dear Muslim friends, please consider the fact that the Christian Bible is complete and needs no hadiths. The Christian Bible has been proven to be accurate historically,scientifically, geographically,prophetically, etc. Please listen to the plain teachings of the Christian Prince, Dr Jay Smith, or Dr. David Wood to learn the truth about Islam. Thank you.
Laughable. The Bible is mostly unreliable due to way too many changes. It is the word of man, not God.
That's a good one, i appreciate the humor
They've all been refuted and there are many different versions of the bible and you probably have multiple ones on your bookshelf
@@islamicclips2103 sounds a bit like hadiths. why are there different versions of prophet muhammad's last sermon? witnessed by thousands and yet..
try proving your religion
Let the Qur’an speak:
• And We have indeed made the Qur'an easy to understand and remember: then is there any that will receive admonition? 54:17.
• We have explained in detail in this Qur'an, for the benefit of mankind, every kind of similitude: but man is, in most things, contentious. 54:18
• …Nothing have we omitted from the Book, and they (all) shall be gathered to their Lord in the end. 6:38.
• These are the Ayat (proofs, evidences, verses, lessons, revelations, etc.) of Allah, which We recite to you with truth. Then in which speech [hadith] after Allah and His Ayat will they believe? 46:6.
They criticise the Quran but they are two Yazidis