CCI A-17 DIRTY, FILTHY AMMO! FOULING UP THE SAVAGE A-17

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 09. 2015
  • Hit the sub button for more videos on a really GREAT shooting Savage A-17!!!!!
  • Jak na to + styl

Komentáře • 80

  • @randyneal1790
    @randyneal1790 Před 8 lety +4

    Run it in my savage bolt action 17. I shoot the Hornady v-max as well. Didn't realize the A17 was that inconsistent on the speed. Pretty interesting. Thanks for posting.

  • @MylesNicholas
    @MylesNicholas Před 8 lety +1

    "Yes we can" love it.

  • @halodesolate
    @halodesolate Před 4 lety

    I have a savage 93r17 bolt action and hornady is all I shoot in it I’m currently using the Hornady 20 grain XDT’s super accurate and hard hitting round!!!! Thanks for the video

  • @1987foxl90
    @1987foxl90 Před 8 lety

    Thanks for the advice on the trigger. I will give that a go. Take care.

  • @gordonsaye9183
    @gordonsaye9183 Před 8 lety

    I just purchased the A17 this past week and have had it out at the range twice. Both days cut short due to high wind and rain. First 100 rounds of the CCI A17 ammo I had 7 miss fires and 2 failure to eject. No issues with the trigger or clip falling out if you follow instructions. Next 100 rounds, Hornady V-Max no issues at all, very accurate the last twenty rounds 18 in a 2 inch circle with 2 fliers at 100yds. All rounds lethal to sage rats. This rifle replaces my Ruger Model 96 lever action which has been a great rifle but a wrist injury and arthritis has forced me to go with a semi auto. Topped the rifle with a Bushnell 4x12x40 scope. Varmints beware. I may even leave my AR15 at home next time I chase coyotes. This is a real blast to shoot.

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      +Gordon Saye Agreed, It's a lot of fun with good ammo..

  • @gabepettinicchio7454
    @gabepettinicchio7454 Před 7 lety

    You are an excellent shot, sir!

  • @scarter176
    @scarter176 Před 4 lety

    I can tell you are having fun ! Great shooting

  • @bsdh01
    @bsdh01 Před 8 lety

    Man oh man do you make it even harder to wait on Boyd's for that stock. My brand new A17 is still waiting patiently in the safe for a proper stock and glass bedding. Keep up the fun videos.

  • @1987foxl90
    @1987foxl90 Před 8 lety

    Just got back from the range. Time got away from me so I was only able to shoot the Hornady Vmax. The groups were really good with some you could cover with a quarter . Several shots were almost in the same hole. I was in a shooting bay that maxed out at 65 yards so I will take it to a hundred next time to see what this rifle can do. There were no failure to fires or failure to extract from the chamber. This rifle is amazingly light and the recoil is non existent. Putting a Boyds stock on this would make it a tack driver. The only negative was the trigger pull which was tough. I didn't bring the tool to lessen the pull so I hope that helps. Were you able to adjust the triiger pull with the tool provided? Do you know if Timmney or Gisselle make a trigger group for this rifle? Overall impression of this rifle is that Savage has a money maker on it's hand and with a Bull Barrel and better stock and Trigger this is going to be a classic.

  • @texas15013
    @texas15013 Před 8 lety

    Tried a spread of .3 shot groups at a 100 yds with 17hmr ammo through my Marlin 17 to find what shoots best and the Hornady 17gr vmax gave me 1/4 MOA the CCI's and Winchesters were around 1" ..after seeing your chronograph of the Hornady's I can see why it's consistent.. Awesome stuff and I like the grape tomato idea, I'll have to give it a try lol

  • @tommygun6028
    @tommygun6028 Před 3 lety +1

    Nice shooting
    😎👍🤝

  • @daisymae6561
    @daisymae6561 Před rokem

    What is in the shell casings uer exploding ?? Thx. Good video

  • @geemeff
    @geemeff Před 8 lety +2

    I find it interesting that yours are probably the only reviews that speak negatively about this rifle, I own 2 of them and have never had ANY complaints!!!! They are AWESOME rifles!!!!!!!

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      +Gavin Frampton I love to hear about great rifles. How about you give a little more detail about your awesome twins.Please let myself & the rest of my You Tube viewers know exactly how good they are, also in terms we will all understand, Like X number of shots in X inch size group. As it stands, Your post says nothing intelligent. Thanks

    • @jacobblewis
      @jacobblewis Před 7 lety

      cavedweller1959 I have shot nearly 1000 rounds out of the one I own, it's accurate, but the ammo is inconsistent at best. Failure to feed, failure to fire even with a strike from the firing pin. I like the gun, it just performs way better with Hornady ammo. I have ran almost every type of .17 ammo through the gun and Hornady is the most consistent on spread, accuracy, expectancy of fire and feed.

    • @nasedo3129
      @nasedo3129 Před 5 lety +1

      @@cavedweller1959 His post says that he likes his rifles, good for him! Why the attitude?

    • @richnoggin7524
      @richnoggin7524 Před 4 lety

      The ammo is the issue.

    • @north4961
      @north4961 Před rokem

      @@cavedweller1959 Bad attitude Bro! Easy does it.

  • @justanobserver530
    @justanobserver530 Před měsícem

    Crap ! Wish I had seen this before I sent my A17 into Savage for repair. I suspect I'll be paying dearly for that 😩
    I didn't notice the A17 ammo being so dirty but did have the identical issues. Also had the rim end of the cartridge bulging, which is what concerned me and why I sent the rifle in

  • @garoglen
    @garoglen Před 6 lety

    HHHMMM, good info , I've shot hundreds of CCI 22LR , NEVER any problems !

  • @frankwaynefrank4081
    @frankwaynefrank4081 Před 2 lety

    very good shooting

  • @roadking99jokerst60
    @roadking99jokerst60 Před 5 lety +1

    Next growing season there was a crop of volunteer tomato plants. But no sets came on. Too scared to produce fruit targets again.

  • @1987foxl90
    @1987foxl90 Před 8 lety +1

    Unfortunately I was at one of the back ranges at my local range that only went to 70 yards that I verified with a range finder. Shot off a bench rest / sand bags . Once I got it zeroed in it was basically up to me. One group was quarter size with some flyers that I attribute to me and that awful trigger press. In spite of that lousy trigger which my next time out I can hopefully adjust . I really think Savage has a great thing going here. The rifle never jammed , is super light and Boyd's wood stocks are available for it. If Giselle or Timney make a drop in trigger this rifle could be amazing. Next time out I'm going to a hundred and adjusting the trigger. I will post my results. I hope this helps.

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety +2

      +1987foxl90 I really doubt you will ever see an after market trigger for this rifle, The big IF, You do It will cost you plenty.Just learn to take up the creep, Then Stop, Then Squeeze, Once you learn this, It's not that nasty. Not great, but it is a $ 400.00 rifle. Thanks

  • @Col-Hogan
    @Col-Hogan Před 2 lety

    I was skeptical about purchasing an A17 due to the negative reviews. Not anymore! My A17 shoots flawlessly with the CCI 16grn TNT Green ammo. It will not function at all using Winchester 17grn! Mine came with a laminated Boyd stock and is a tack driver. They definitely are a finicky semi auto, but good out to 200yds!

  • @sqhunter65
    @sqhunter65 Před 8 lety

    nice

  • @texaswaddie6983
    @texaswaddie6983 Před 6 lety +1

    Welcome to my the world of rimfire !!

  • @wilmamcdermott3065
    @wilmamcdermott3065 Před 3 lety

    Nice gun

  • @1987foxl90
    @1987foxl90 Před 8 lety

    No not yet, only taken it out once. My trigger was horrible I have to use the adjustment key. Zeroed it in with Hornady v max . Really tight groups with some you could cover with a dime . That was with a horrible trigger! No jams or failures to feed. As far as the magazine issue I always loaded with the action open.

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      +1987foxl90 How long a range are you on, 100 Yards ??? Cover with a dime sounds good to me, How about the one you couldn't cover with a dime?? That tells the rest of thee story. Thanks..

  • @makeamericagreatagain7314

    excellent caliber and rifle i have the bolt action savage l love shooting the FMJ especially on hogs rt between the eyes always drops them remember FMJ

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 7 lety +1

      17 HMR in FMJ ??? Enlighten us, Who's the manufacturer.

    • @HILUXCHAINSAW
      @HILUXCHAINSAW Před 7 lety

      CCI make a 20 g FMJ. Personally I wouldn't use any thing that wasn't either hollow point or poly tipped on game.

    • @ghostshadow9046
      @ghostshadow9046 Před 7 lety

      CCI has a 20 grain FMJ 17HMR 2375 fps advertised upc 0 7668300055 2

  • @silverwinds1955
    @silverwinds1955 Před 2 lety

    ok so it shoots how does it work in the a17 rifle?????

  • @ironworkerlarry9223
    @ironworkerlarry9223 Před 7 lety +1

    I bought two 50 round packs of ammo. Hornady and CCI . My testing duplicated your testing exactly. CCI failed to feed a few times and a overpressure round + a misfire. That's out of only 20 CCI rounds . Hornady ammo was flawless .

  • @ILicence
    @ILicence Před 8 lety

    It sounds like the 17gr Hornady Vmax is your preferred round. What kind of intervals can you go without cleaning this rifle without having malfunctions?

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety +1

      +ILicence I think the CCI TNT & CCI V-MAX have been the best lately, I am starting to think cleaning this gun to much is not good. Since running out of A17 ammo, I have only wet patch/2 dry patch cleaned the bore after about 75-100 rounds, with maybe 200 rounds after that so far. The action is still clean as a whistle, From here on I may give it some lube but it will not get cleaned until it starts to fail or the groups go to hell. Most likely next summer on the p-dog towns. Thanks..

    • @tjbelcher3144
      @tjbelcher3144 Před 4 lety

      I had a problem with the CCI TNT ammo splitting the casing. Winchester ammo split also. The Hornady rounds seems to be the best so far

  • @HILUXCHAINSAW
    @HILUXCHAINSAW Před 7 lety

    Was thinking of trying to get some of these. After watching this I don't think I'll bother, I'll stick with the Hornady.

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 7 lety

      This goes back to Sept. 2015, and were sold only in 200 round boxes. Now that they can be had in 50 rd. boxes, This summer I may buy some to see if they have cleaned them up. Thanks for Watching.

  • @donniedickerson8077
    @donniedickerson8077 Před 3 lety +1

    Beyond Any Doubt The Hornady Is The Way To Go All Way Around , Any Opinions Or Experiences Between The 17 And 20 Grain ??

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 3 lety +1

      Both of my HMRs--hands down--CCI 17gr TNT. Nothing else compares.

    • @donniedickerson8077
      @donniedickerson8077 Před 3 lety +1

      @@cavedweller1959 This Thing Is Unbelievable , Dimes Consistently At 💯 yards , Thats Actually with the 20 Grain Too ,I've Shot a
      .22Magnum For a long time ,But Recently Got One of the Older Savage 93R ,no Accu Trigger , the magnum Until now has been the most accurate thing I've ever shot , The .17 Beats it hands down , Y Most accurate thing I've ever pulled a trigger on for sure

  • @johnshipman8265
    @johnshipman8265 Před 3 lety

    What model Boyd’s stock?

  • @BallisticianX
    @BallisticianX Před 5 lety +1

    The A17 rifle, as with all blow back semi auto's, inherently blows soot back into the chamber because the bolt is opening and extracting while the barrel is still under pressure vs a bolt action gun with a expanded case sealing it off during the entire length of pressurization. Couple that with sooty rimfire priming and its going to be dirty. Take a look at any .22 LR in a semi, its filthy with crud build up within 50 shots. Wont be any different with the 17HMR. Actually with the larger volume of propellant and higher pressure in a 17HMR its potentially worse fouling than a .22 semi. So its not the ammo per say, its the drawbacks of a blowback action with a magnum bottleneck case!
    FYI: The truth is all 17HMR ammo (except Winchester) is manufactured by CCI for Brand XX. All 17 HMR made by CCI uses the same propellant under every bullet whether its the 17 gr or 20 gr varieties. The only difference is the charge weight gets adjusted for for each bullet to achieve a velocity spec while remaining in SAAMI pressure specs. The A17 obviously has a heavier charge to get another 100 fps, but it the same powder as the rest of them. I say try any other ammo in the A17 and you'll see its going to crud up at the same rate.

    • @ss0073
      @ss0073 Před 3 lety

      I want to believe what you are saying, but I’m skeptical
      I zero in my A17 or my bolt action 17HMR at 100 yds with Hornady VMax
      I now shoot CCI’s 17 gr (same manufacturer of Hornady right??), and my groups are high and to the left with both rifles. Not just a bit, but about 4” high, 2” to left. Why? Same manufacturer, propellant, etc, right??

    • @BallisticianX
      @BallisticianX Před 3 lety

      @@ss0073 lot to lot variation can cause POI shift. Rimfire shows this more so than center fire. Biggest issue from lot to lot that can cause POI shift is;
      the Bullet itself. Several different dies are used to make the same Bullet. What die is used within a manufacturing run will have slight differences. The other and more profound affect is applied case crimp. Some lots are crimped more than others. That definitely affects velocity and POI.

    • @ss0073
      @ss0073 Před 3 lety

      @@BallisticianX
      👍 I can buy that explanation, makes sense to me. There is a certainly a difference on my 17 Hornet and 220 Swift between crimping the necks and not crimping them....

    • @BallisticianX
      @BallisticianX Před 3 lety

      @@ss0073 my 17HMR (CZ 457 with a Lilja 4 groove barrel) likes the 17 gr TNT loads best. In my opinion the Achilles heel of 17 HMR ammo is the over crimping in general. Deforming a Bullet detracts from accuracy potential no matter the caliber with sealing and balance issues. This is worse the smaller the caliber. With that said some lots shoot better than others. So I pulled Bullets to weigh charges and inspect Bullets to try to find the variable. I noticed the better shooting lots had less crimp than the worse shooting ones....no surprise. Powder charges were within a couple tenths. In all the rounds pulled even the lightest crimped specimens had too much crimp on them crushing the Bullet well under the groove diameter. I’ve called CCI to discuss why they crimp so much, can’t get an answer.

  • @1987foxl90
    @1987foxl90 Před 8 lety

    The CCI A17 doesn't sound anywhere as good as it was hyped and the chronograph showed a lot of variation in speed. When it functioned how was the accuracy on the CCI A17 ammo? That you had a lot of failure's to feed with that ammo is troublesome. I just purchased that rifle and I have a box of CCI A17 so will see what kind of results I get . Fortunately I have several boxes of Hornady V Max so I will get a chance to experiment with the different ammo. Did you notice a big difference with the Boyds stock? Thanks for all the videos, lots of great information!

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      +1987foxl90 Prior to this video, I had a box or 2 of most of the ammo on the shelves. When I went range shooting, I would shoot 5 shot groups of this, 5 shots of that, 5 of the other and so on. The A-17 ammo, being sold in 200 round box's, was shot more than most. Time to clean, it was always dirty--ok--nature of the beast, It is a semi-auto. Then this video, 60 rounds fired, Maybe 25 made the video, Because of jams & fail to feeds. At home, time to clean, the action was beyond dirty, all the way into the trigger group. Since then I have shot over 100 rounds of the ammo that's been here for 10 years and it's still clean. Go out and run 50 or so A-17 rounds and let us know how it works, Thanks.

    • @1987foxl90
      @1987foxl90 Před 8 lety

      +cavedweller1959 I will do just that , I will run the CCI A17 and the Hornady V max and I will let you know what happened. Thanks for the response.

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      +1987foxl90 Forgot about the stock, Yes it made a huge difference.

    • @Paulbeck
      @Paulbeck Před 8 lety

      +cavedweller1959 Some videos I have seen on the A17 they had some trouble with the magazine not being all the way seated which created the failure to feed or pickup the next cartridge.. They ended up leaving the action open then inserting the magazine which made it seat properly which seemed to take care of their problem. Just curious if you think that could have been happening to you?

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      pnpbec No, not in this vid. The only Mag problem I had was not fully seating it, Then it falls out. Slow learners will have difficulty here. Thanks For Watching.

  • @lipton4453
    @lipton4453 Před 8 lety

    I have an a17 I can't empty a whole mag without it messing up far from impressed won't eject and if it does it fails to feed

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      +Lipton This ammo or the other stuff. Cuz if your burning this, just give the rifle a really good cleaning & lube and start over.Save the A17 ammo for a bolt gun.

    • @perroblanco49
      @perroblanco49 Před 3 lety

      @@cavedweller1959 the cci A17 does the same thing in my 93R17, fail to eject and fail to feed and that's a bolt action rifle. very dirty but is bery accurate in my rifle and with Hornady ammo no problem at all.

  • @lipton4453
    @lipton4453 Před 8 lety

    It's been cleaned and sent away for warranty and the A17 rounds work the best I've tried hornady Winchester Remington and they are worse

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      +Lipton Let us know how it works when you see it again, Good Luck.

  • @davidjanuszewski5020
    @davidjanuszewski5020 Před 8 lety

    Shoots like a laser beam, too bad it can't be silent... You can shoot the eye out of a squirrel.

  • @erinmccord7315
    @erinmccord7315 Před 7 lety

    This is totally true! this ammo is the worst! it reminds me of Magtec. lots of misfires and very dirty. I am surprised because this was supposed to be made for the A17. Hornady is much better

  • @ghostshadow9046
    @ghostshadow9046 Před 7 lety +2

    damn over 100fps variation in velocity with the CCI A17 ammo is not good, that will really screw your accuracy.
    damn going to screw up some 45-70 cases, use 410 shotgun shells instead.

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 7 lety

      The FPS spread sure didn't help, But i really think the massive fouling was to blame

    • @ghostshadow9046
      @ghostshadow9046 Před 7 lety

      large velocity spread and the fouling could be bad powder or contamination of the powder.
      I stopped using Remington ammo due to having sticky residue in action and around the end of the barrel when I did use it in semi auto rimfire and centerfire.

  • @samp1394
    @samp1394 Před 6 lety

    You have let me see enough. I would not have a gun that miss fire for any reason.

    • @nathanadams371
      @nathanadams371 Před 5 lety

      Sam P so far mine has not at all.. Knock on wood

  • @jbhodj2012
    @jbhodj2012 Před 8 lety +1

    So I take it that your not a fan of this gun or its ammo. You have been pretty consistent in trashing it and the ammo

    • @jbhodj2012
      @jbhodj2012 Před 8 lety +1

      I should expand what I was trying to say. Your def hate the ammo and gun as is out of the box which is a 400 or less unscoped 17. Tweet with a few hundred dollars worth of goodies and like any gun it gets better. As saying goes you get what you pay for

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety +3

      +Jon Roorda In it's factory stock this rifle was nothing special, in a after market stock that is good and stiff, With ammo that has been around for a long while, It is proving itself to be very accurate and reliable. If a rifle and/or ammo, or anything else need trashing, I will trash it. On the other hand, If I can make it shoot the way I think they should, I will be there showing you just that. If you have watched the rest of the videos on this rifle, You should have noticed that. Thanks for Watching.

    • @jbhodj2012
      @jbhodj2012 Před 8 lety

      I get what your saying and that was my point I was trying to convey. I just purchased this gin and looking for more accuracy too. Thanks

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před 8 lety

      +Jon Roorda What kind of accuracy are you getting with your A-17? Best ammo??

  • @gerrigamble4950
    @gerrigamble4950 Před 7 lety +1

    this weapon will not hold up

  • @josephrush8380
    @josephrush8380 Před 5 lety

    The CCI a17 are very bad rounds any other CCI round is a lot better they always blow holes in the cases

  • @robertgallegos9359
    @robertgallegos9359 Před rokem

    17 was not meant to be in a Semi auto

    • @cavedweller1959
      @cavedweller1959  Před rokem +1

      Nothing but the 5.56NATO was meant for the black rifle, but look how that turned out.