The Walking Dead (Season 1) - What’s the Difference?
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 01. 2015
- The Walking Dead’s mid-season premiere is coming up soon, and to celebrate, we’re taking look back. All the way back to the comics that inspired the show. We’ll look at the first volumes of Robert Kirkman’s comic, side-by-side with the first season of the AMC show, and tell you: “What’s the Difference”? Subscribe: goo.gl/9AGRm
A lot changed in adapting the Image Comics ongoing graphic novel series for the small screen. From major character changes (Hi, Merle and Daryl!) to plot tweaks, we’ll go through every difference between Season One of The Walking Dead, and the comics that inspired them - get ready to get informed!
Have you read The Walking Dead Comics, or are you only familiar with the show? Did The Walking Dead show inspire you to pick up the source material? Are you looking forward to the upcoming midseason premiere on AMC? Did you enjoy our exhaustive rundown? Do you have other bits of The Walking Dead trivia you’d like to share?
What other works would you like to see us explore on What’s The Difference?
Want to know what's going on with Cinefix in the future?
Follow us Twitter for updates: / cinefixnetwork
Oh, and we're on The Facebook: / cinefixnetwork
Welcome to What's The Difference, where CineFix takes you step-by-step and page-by-page through all the differences between your favorite movies & shows and their source material. Adaptations are a tricky game, something always gets changed, added, or omitted in the process. Come back every other Wednesday for more What's the Difference! - Krátké a kreslené filmy
“Dale was the worst."
*This action will have consequences*
Dale was the guy stopping everyone from going savage and when he died what happened? They went savage
@@dunkyfunky9478 I'd say there is always a peacekeeper in the group, Dale, Hershell, Gabriel, etc. The real turning points are the loss of Ricks family, Rick was the flagship of the group, when he lost it, so did everyone else.0
@@dunkyfunky9478 Yea savage is good for our entertainment, but he was the only reasonable man in the group
@@dunkyfunky9478 he was a reasonable man with a soul.
@@dunkyfunky9478 Exactly
I'll be honest, if they remained 100% faithful to the comics, the show would not have lasted as long as it has.
Jiggie Bleu ,True ,but they diverted from it as seasons go by and now its crap.
Yeah I am probably done when they kill off rick coming up.
I highly recommend YourMovieSucks' videos discussing seasons 1 and 2. It explains how much the show's creators were fucked by AMC in order to capitalize and elongate the show regardless of its' quality. Personally, I would've much rather had the experience that I had with the first season extended only over a few seasons compared to what the show became.
It's because of Daryl probably.
Jiggie Bleu you're right but if they had the show wouldnt be the streaming hot pile of 🗑 that it is now.
"Dale was the worst"
What in the hell was that?!
Bruh Dale was like my grandfather
Lmao
Same
Dale reminds of my grandpa thats why I LOVED him
fvk your grandpa then
Bro literally had sex with Andrea, I didn’t like that.
"Dale was the worst"
*Everyone disliked that*
Because he gave the weapons to Shane? Yes, that was shit.
Everyone loves dale's that peace loving fuck I cried when dale's died spoiler alert and when Shiva died and when Carl died and most of all Henry and Rick and The reason I cried because of Henry is because my name in Henry btw did you know Shiva is another name for queen so queen and king Ezekiel and shiva
@Cruise Lover yeah
I effing hated that liberal hippy dale. Couldn't wait for him to die.
Dale was my favorite character and ever time I re-watch the walking dead I hate seeing the scene where he dies
What I loved dale? He was so innocent and nice and like a grandpa in my eyes
That is sooooo true
Finally someone agrees
Nah
Bruh HES legit so annoying
Yeet 69 same
I liked Dale. He was the voice of reason. After he died, Hershel was my favorite. I wish they hadn't killed off the older folks. T.T
NanashiTreeHouse Yea they were good strong characters in my opinion.
Bull crap
Kenny Norris To each their own.
I felt Dale's death was a little rushed imo but yea at least Hershel made it that long in the comics he dies at the farm
NanashiTreeHouse same
I still don't know how the military still failed to contain the slow walkers.
Ikr
They should've gone for the head
This is the best name I could come up with thats probably close to the truth. I feel like the cars were unrealistic everyone wouldve been quarentined, we can kinda see cuz of covid what itd be like, (not saying covid is as bad) but even with a less dangerous virus like covid people were still quarentined
@@sam-yx8fr yeah
@@sam-yx8fr I'm still going outside anyway just to buy drinks and go for grocery lol
Dale was the moral compass of the group. Reminding everyone about their humanity. I really liked him.
Still watching?
There’s reminding and there’s delusion…dale didn’t want the group to do what it takes to survive in later seasons the group does what it takes
He was hot not gonna lie🥴
Don't Dead Open Inside
+-CLM15- LOL
I cringe every time I see that
+-CLM15- yeah me too
dont open dead inside
Don't open, dead inside
I like the tv show more than the comics. Why?
*Because Daryl is in the tv show.*
i like the series more,but because of shane,carol and rick mainly
Daryl was never in the comics period. Have you actually even read them?
SAAAMMMEEE
He’s the best
reading doesn't entertain me a lot either, so I'm good with the show.
“Dale was the worst...”
Dale will remember that...
haha
I will
Dale is still my favorite
@@josephlay952 I'm your favorite 😀
Joseph Lay yeah he is the only human in that grup
"Dale was the worst."
Dale was the one that brought up clock that was counting down. Sure *maybe* someone else would have mentioned something, but Dale asked just as it hit the hour mark.
facts bruh al nassr saudio league ronaldo suiiiiiiiiiiiii
🤓
He was also the first to suss out Shane in season 2 when he killed the guy who shot carl (forgot the name)
@@JT-nw5iq I think it was Otis or Oscar or something. It had an O in it.
@@CasualVideoGamerotis
I like that the comics and tv show are so different, that way you can enjoy two different stories. If the show was just like the comics, why watch it?
Tool0GT92 good point
EXACTLY!!
Maybe see your favorite moments in action?
it really rounds out all of the characters with having the two different time parallel universes. :)
The problem isn't that show does things differently from the comics. Problem is that it does them worse.
In the TV Series, Carol has had the largest character development and that's why she remains one of my favorite characters
I'd say Carl, but she's def up there with Rick and Carl...
@@ModaFTW What’s the point of spoiling Carls death? The video is about S1😐
She looks like lesbian
Comic Book Lori felt more loving towards Rick. How she runs towards Rick when he reappears unlike the tv show where it felt like Lori was more running after Carl
In the show they messed up a lot of characters in expense of others, sometimes they just made them worse no reason at all. Like what they did with Lori, Andrea, Dale, Tyreese and even Abraham. They brought some of the things from the comics but in different characters like Dale/Hershel, Andrea/Carol, and Holly/Sasha.
@@sergiocarniel I know. Thats why i prefer the comics
@@lonely_crash2059 same. I have read up to the time jump and I'm reading all again, today I read the issue that Carl went to the factory and killed some saviors. Reading all again made me notice a lot of things that the show got right but also the things they didn't, like all the Governor's story and the impact that he had on the survivors.
The comics are mostly centered on the perspective of Rick Grimes and his family.
yeah, like she tried to legit restrain Carl when he was just excited to see his dad again lol
I like the addition of Daryl and the changes made to Carols character
I love Carol's character development in the show going from a weak abused house wife , to a cold blooded killer who does whatever it takes to survive
@@drunkenmmamaster419
Still, she looks like lesbian
@@nicolausteslaus so?
C'mon bro everybody likes the addition of Daryl
It took a *lot* of my will power to not turn off this video after you guys said Dale was the worst.
You're walking on thin ice, Cinefix. Walking on thin ice.
You’re a pretty good candidate for a green lantern ring.
I can understand you. I liked Dale in the first Season but when he gave Shane the weapons....
I dont like dale
dale sucked
boy I cried when he died, nobody should do him like that
how dare you insult the memory of dale! dale was good and pure.
dale is annoying and shounldnt have lived past the initial outbreak
@@danielcundill2709 UHHHH I LOVED HIM! He would always say what was on his mind and was hella truthful
3:42 I take that as an offense and you'll be hearing from my lawer
The walkers were actually pretty fast in season 1 if you see them. Going after Glenn and Rick. And it would be possible riots and people start freaking out if they heard the dead was coming back.
KHOORLL!! KHOOOOOOOOOOOORLLLL!!!!!!
iqbal barra 😂😂
I Bara Hey, Rick, what's that one thing in the great barrier reef? I'm doing a crossword puzzle.
COOOOORAAAAALLL
CHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORRRRRRRRRRLLLLLLLLLLL
I Bara - CORAL!!
I Bara lmao
What's up with all the hate for Dale? For me he was the best character. Nicest and wisest.
George Pan nah he looked like any cranky old man to me.
I fought he was ok
i personally take hershel over dale but he was still great!
yeah he was nice but a little bit annoying ND boring tbh...
I'll give you that.. LOL
Andrea is so damn cool and lovable in the comics, I hate how the show handles her character :/
Yea she was supposed to be a independent woman but they failed badly she was so bitchy for no reason
in my eyes, carol in the show is Andrea in the comic, and Andrea in the show, was carol in the comic
She was a badass in the comics.
7:00 carol obviousely just feels like daryl's mother and daryl obviousely feel likes carol is his mother LMAOAOAO
YOU TAKE BACK WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT DALE
+GlassGate And so is Andrea.
and andrea bc she is a badass queen lmao
I love Dale 😢
Hey man, opinions are like assholes. Everybody has one and I shove my dick into every one I see.
nah only reason you hate dale is that you love Shane .dale was a sign of hope and humanity but Shane was an asshole trying to sleep with his best friends wife dales death made me so sad actually
The only reason why the show is so different from the comics cause they wanted the comic readers from predicting the show to keep interesting diverse but still have similarities.
+seth thorpe Yep, I believe I read Kirkman say that in the fan mail section of the comic some short time after the show came out. Maybe even before. That's why it makes me laugh when someone who loves the comics rips the show for not following them enough. It's ok if you don't like the show as a comic reader, but the reason really can't be that one.
+seth thorpe that is a very good way to make unique adaption , i applaud them for that
+seth thorpe they shoulda done what game of thrones does and say fuck it. it's way better that way.
+The Lukanator but the comic isnt better. the comic has such shitty story progression and character development. ive been reading it and after like 30 issues you can already tell who will die every issue or two. its soooooooooooo dull and predictable.
Jose Cortes I will say that the first couple issues of the comic are choppy (which is why the first few episodes of the show are so good, in that they adapt it and improve it) but after like volume three or so there's a dramatic improvement. While I've liked some decisions made by the show, such as fleshing out Shane, fleshing out the Governor and fleshing out Hershel (that seems to be a theme), most decisions were not so great. Granted this is all my opinion. I just feel like the show's writing is so much worse than the comic and at least in the comic there are so many great character arcs that never made it into the show. Plus, there are almost no annoying characters, unless they're supposed to be, Rick is a much much much stronger character, there is far more diversity in content and, frankly I just disagree with you on the predictability of it. Maybe seeing the show first has made it more so, but I've found that TWD show has some of the most insanely predictable, cliched writing in popular TV. Anyway that's my opinion, sorry for the rant XD
Imagine at the final episode rick wakes up in the hospital where Shane left him 😱😱😱
That would be the wordt
I don’t feel like editing that comment
If only you were right😱. Oh wait, you are... (in ricks final episode on the show)
And sees instead of dead inside he sees medical staff inside
Imagine in rick movies he wakes up from coma in hospital with shane lori carl all by his side and zombie apocalypse never happened
Sophia doesn’t die in the comic, compared to the show and is married to Carl. So that’s a massive change as well.
It really changed the trajectory a lot
I thought it was cute that the gangsters protect the elderly.
"I HAVE HELL HOUNDS I MAKE EAT GLENN."
Then their just his Grandma's chihuahuas XD
i wonder if they are still alive...
+Rvolution Wrestling nah they all die in a deleted scene on the dvd
adam forde is this on CZcams?
yes
Omg I'm reading this on Valentines day two years after. Lol what a coincidence. XD
Wait you’re telling me fan favorite Daryl wasn’t even in the comics 😦
Thats cause the comics came first and Daryl was created for the show
He wasn’t even meant for the show, Norman reedus auditioned for the part of Merle but the producers wanted to cast Micheal rooker as Merle, but like Norman reedus so much they made the part of Daryl for him, as Merles brother
Or Merle, Sasha, T-Dog, Jackie, Ed.
And Carol may as well be a show character too.
Sounds like a Voice crack at 5:16 it's when he says also.
personally, i liked dale. he made decent decisions and tried to stop arguments by stopping them
When Rick loses Carl at the mall XD ( 5:35 )
😂😂😂
I liked dale if he wasn't the voice of reason then Shane would of killed rick and more
Dale's death hit me the hardest
Rebecca Wutzke Dale was the most bearable character in the show tbh
Alladeen Madafaker I think it was a good death. Carl let a walker go and inadvertently killed Dale
Dale was the voice of reason, he dies and everyone goes fucking crazy.
Then Hershel grows a pair of balls and steps up, he dies, and at that point
“No going back bob.”
(I know it’s a bad joke)
LOL! At the "Carl!" part.
Vintage Rick
5:32. Just in case someone comments, I want to see it again and laugh.
Who's Carl you mean Arl?
+Eren Yeager Because he can't C :P
+Eren Yeager because he can't c? (see) 😂
I hate when people ship Daryl and Carol. They just close friends, smh
every time i see them interact i start chanting “mom figure” until my own mom tells me to stfu
@@mariellearian230 l mao, but I see them more as best friends
i shipped them at first, but they are just close friends
Literally I see them as brother and sister
it makes me feel disgusted for some reason, just let them be
Carol in the tv version is one of the best alterations they could’ve done. Love her character arc.
just look at the flowers lizzie
I think Dale is awesome. He’s my favorite, along with Rick and Daryl
@Adam Shane sucked I wanted him dead since I saw him
Same do
Adam, but, deep inside, we all know that everyone loved Dale. Even Neagan loved Dale😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Dales Dead...:(
And Glenn??
You left out one of the biggest changes between the show and the books: Rick and Lori's relationship, and Lori's character in general.
In the book, Rick and Lori are *madly* in love with each other, incredibly supportive of each other, and while they do fight sometimes (of course), you never get the sense that Lori feels any true bitterness towards Rick, because you believe she's on his side. When Rick turns out to be alive, she's just as overjoyed as Carl to see him, if not moreso. And of course, she never has any feelings for Shane. They only have sex the one time, in a fit of panic and emotional vulnerability, because they think they're going to die any second. Additionally, Lori can actually look after herself and Carl, despite having some trouble adjusting at first.
Whereas in the show, Rick and Lori are said to be in a totally failing marriage before the apocalypse. As soon as she thinks Rick is dead, she totally hooks up with Shane not as a one-time thing, but as an actual lover, which goes on for the whole several weeks Rick isn't there. When Rick turns out to be alive, she looks more horrified than happy, and as the series goes on they just seem to despise each other more and more. And to top it all off she just...does...*nothing* to help. Throughout her entire time on the show she is a complete liability.
Basically, the showrunners totally ruined Lori in every way imaginable to the point where she was famously one of the most hated characters on the show. Great job, guys
If she wasn't such a manipulative bitch in the show in pretty certain the show version of What e would have survived as he was acting similar to how Rick did in the comics.
I could not agree more! (But I still wanted her to live. And change.
Dale and Glenn were the only two deaths I cried at. Though, I did get a bit misty eyed when the pike victims were struggling against the Whisperers in the barn.
dale was one of my favourites his death hurt me more than anyone elses at that point he was so caring and nice and had a good heart how can you dislike him
sorry brutha 🔫
when you realise that everyone who saved rick is dead
Morgan is alive. Atleast in the show.
picklickwick yeah
Andrea still alive an she saves Rick all the time in comics
Morgan
Bradlee Apodaco Hahahah...hah...
CORAL! If we were books Would Norman Reedus? REEDUS, CORAL!
yes?
How many tickles does it take to make a squid laugh? TEN TICKLES CORAAALL.
Returded Phoenixmorph CORAL, what's Hershals favorite restaurant? I HOP CORAAAAL. I HOPPPP
Megan Ryan Coral: ....fuck....
rob theberge Stop it dad....
If I'm not mistaken, supposedly in the comics Carol killed herself because Rick didn't love her
*Glad she didn't in the show*
Melaxirayz that’s not entirely why she did it
That's not entirely true, she was dating Tyreese and he cheated on her with Michonne, after that she almost died when she slit her wrist. Then she offered to live with Lori, Rick and the kids like a big family and even kissed Lori, but both refused that idea and after a period being unhappy she hugged a walker cuz "it liked her".
Sergio LC this is smart man right here👆
@@sergiocarniel Oh okay
Oof I've only hear about the comics I've never gotten a chance to read them
No Carol was a lesbian in the comics
I always wondered why they never tell anyone one they learned at the cdc. They all saw that brain scan but it never gets mentioned to anyone who is confused about the state of the Walkers.
I am truly upset that they said Dale was the worst characters he was probably one of my most favorite characters.
Same
+Dylan Pastore Yeah, he was one of the kindest and thoughtful characters on the show.
+Dylan Pastore I think they were being ironic
+Luppercus Hey, whether they were joking or not, I still don't like what they said about him.
+Trevor Stone No shit
So a lot of people were saying Glenn is gonna live forever till the end of the show because he's a main character
aaaaaaaaaaaaaand it's gone
FoxieRoxie365 South Park reference?😂
FoxieRoxie365 now Coral is dead too.
Riasat Salmin Sami who told you that
He is bitten, what else you expect? Maybe they wont shoot Coral. They will just keep him as pet.
Riasat Salmin Sami did you saw him dying or not? don't you know what happened with Glenn when everyone thought that walkers eat him?
Just started the comics recently, (spoiler alert) dale and Andrea hooking up REALLY surprised me, being someone who only watched the show beforehand, I was not expecting that difference
Rick is hot in the show, I know am weird.
Hey, dont blame yourself for being attracted towards very attractive people.
That’s why I don’t read the comics 😭
how tf are you weird?
Its ok, itd be wirerd if it was the character, not the actor lol
Dude agreed
I liked Dale....
GAAAAAAAAY
+Hans Peter You're not alone..
+Hans Peter Same I liked Dale too, I was pissed when he died.
Dale was awesome.
Vanessa Pierce Indeed.
I often hear people use the excuse that "Lori thought Rick was dead because Shane told her so", but judging by the appearance of the flowers that Shane left for Rick in the hospital, and the age of Carl, Lori, and Shane's physical appearance after Rick woke up, I'd say that he was only in a coma for 2-3 weeks, a month at most, which means Lori, thinking he was dead, didn't even wait a month before having sex with another man.
Regardless of her stress level, or the situation at hand, or anything else, any woman with any semblance of character would have had a halfway decent mourning period, not because it was the right thing to do, but because she truly loved her husband who she now thought was dead and would naturally grieve for him. Based on Lori's actions, not just with Rick but also with Shane and even Carl, I'd say she didn't give a damn about anyone but herself.
Shane probably said something about the hospital being overrun and assumed Rick had been eaten
toasega Well maybe under normal circumstances of thinking her husband was dead...but at the time the entire world pretty much went to shit. Even if Rick was alive for all she knew she'd never see him again. The chances of running into someone you know in a Zombie apocalypse where everyone is constantly moving across the country to stay alive and no longer has any mobile phone contact to communicate with anyone are very, very small, in a case like that she like many others would become desperate for affection and security just as much as everyone else is also desperate for food, shelter and generally not getting eaten by walking corpses. Shane is in the same boat, (unless he knew Rick was alive and lied as he did in the show) he too would have been desperate for some sense of security in this now fallen human society.
Cal DW
That's where "Character" comes in. There are various things that are a part of character, such as integrity, honesty, courage, wisdom, etc, but what I'm talking about in response to your comment is personal strength (and integrity). The state of the world is unimportant; your husband "died" only a month ago. The saying goes "A drunk man's words are a sober man's thoughts", but this also applies to stressful situations.
If you want to know who a person truly is on a fundamental level, then put them into an extremely stressful situation, and they will always show their true colors eventually. Had Lori been a woman of strong character, she would not have run into another man's arms so quickly. Her actions show that had the zombie apocalypse never taken place, she would have eventually cheated on Rick, maybe with Shane, maybe with someone else, but it surely would have happened. We were already shown that her and rick were having problems to begin with in the first episode. It's just that the Zom-pocalypse made her show her true colors much faster.
Same thing goes for Shane, as he was willing to kill his best friend rather quickly after he found out he was alive. It seems like a longer amount of time, but again, from Rick's "resurrection" till the end of season two was only about 2 months.
There's "Moving on with your life", and then there's being an absolutely deplorable and disloyal human being. Lori didn't just gently leave behind the memory of her husband over time, she immediately crushed it beneath her heel as she ran towards his best friend, who himself did not even seem to attempt to honor the memory of his now "dead" best friend.
toasega Don't get me wrong I am not defending Lori and Shane by any means, all I'm saying is that I understand why they would indulge in comfort from each other.
The circumstances absolutely have to do with how they effect a character because given a desperate situation even the kindest, most honest and most self controlled of people can snap or the true darkness within them creeps out. It's not the zombies that are the biggest threat and source of drama in the walking dead, it's the living who are trying to survive. When the world goes to shit people may end up acting in ways they wouldn't under normal circumstances and some may even no longer care about any social norms and restraints in such a world. However at the same time, sometimes these actions are not done entirely because the individual is secretly a bad person deep down, panic, fear or believing they or someone they care about may die can make people lose the person they once were and act on instinct.
I'm not sure if you're familiar with a show called Death Parade, it's an anime which revolves around this very premise. The basic gist of the show is that when two people die at the same time their souls go to a sortof limbo with no memories of their last few moments leading to their death. Once there they are told they have to take part in a game which can range from darts, air hockey, pool or playing cards. After the game is over one of them is sent to heaven/reincarnated and the other is sent to hell/the void. It doesn't matter who wins the game, what determines whether they go to heaven or hell is their actions and conduct during the game. Naturally some people become aggressive, cheat or panic believing that if they lose they will die or that if they win the other person will die which can cause tension if the people playing the game actually know each other such as a husband and wife or best friends, at the same time because they believe they will die if they lose some may show no remorse in playing if they don't actually know the other person. The idea for those judging them during the game is that they try to create a situation in which the true darkness inside a person is shown and as such that is what you judge if they're good or not on, however as the show progresses and you see different scenarios with individual people having differing backstories and causes of death in the first place you soon realise this system is flawed as after all, even good honest people can snap if pushed enough or deceived causing them to go to hell where as someone like a murderer who simply remains calm throughout the entire scenario or has no empathy gets to ascend. If this sortof stuff interests you I highly recommend looking up the pilot episode or watching the first episode of the series.
Anyway if using a similar example to what's described in this show, good people can do bad things but it doesn't make them bad people, it just makes them human. Humans are complex and each person responds to stress, trauma, fear, love and so on differently. We may berate Shane but we don't know entirely what he went through, he is totally on his own in this world. Lori, Carl and Rick still had each other eventually but Shane's family, parents, siblings and so on are either presumably dead or have 0 chance of meeting him ever again. I still don't think what he did to Rick was right by any means but he must have gone through his own problems with the apocalypse just as much as everyone else and depending on if it's the comic or show version of him also determines how you may feel about his actions based on the scenario. Other characters are not all good or all bad either, just human and reacting to different things. Carl in the comic shot Shane and has killed many others since then but that doesn't exactly make Carl evil or without good intentions. Does this mean Carl would have eventually killed someone had the apocalypse never happened? Would he have been so quick to violence? No of course not, but the situation can certainly change a persons perspective on the world.
The Walking Dead game also has huge elements of this too where the player is forced to often make very difficult decisions that all have huge knock on effects on not only themselves but all other characters in the story, there is no right choice or wrong choice, just what they personally feel is best. Our own morale judgement of others sortof becomes moot when everyone not only has their own morale standards but also has just as complex a situation to deal with in their lives as others do so naturally would respond differently. The protagonist of the game in particular is established as a school teacher with a fairly decent life and education who killed a senator who was having an affair with his wife out of sheer rage and was on his way to prison until the police car taking him there swerved off road to avoid a Walker and killing the officer driving him. That moment of madness with Lee murdering the senator however does not mean Lee is a weak willed man. Throughout the game (depending on player choice of course) Lee is a determined man who's willing to toss aside his own safety for those he cares about, especially the young girl Clementine who he found all on her own after the apocalypse happened. He makes it his responsibility to make sure she's safe even if it means risking his own life and he realises his actions are what's going to teach her how to act in this new world, his actions determine if she will grow up remorseful, or cold, or protective, or unforgiving and so on. Integrity of character comes from more than simply one event in their life, Lee may be a murderer prior to the apocalypse but his actions as a whole determine who he really is and are what set him apart from characters like say The Governor who is also a murderer but his actions and personality as a whole make him a far different character to Lee with the two of them having different strengths and weaknesses for different aspects of life and how they handle situations.
Cal DW
I get what you're saying, but talking about Carl being a killer eventually is mistaken in my opinion. Carl is just a kid, and is at an age where his life experiences will still largely shape who he becomes when he matures into an adult. Lori and Shane don't have this luxury. Children and Adults are held to different standards, is what I'm saying.
But I'm never going to be a fan of either of those characters, no.
I understand how something can draw out a person's darkness and make them snap. I've always said that there actually isn't much at all separating normal people from becoming total murderous psychopaths, and that it is mistaken to behave as if we're so much different, and so much better than they are. But I can't agree with or accept Lori and Shane's actions. I'd have to say it's because of my own strong opinions on things like loyalty to friends and loved ones; I can accept a thief or a murderer before I'll accept a traitor to those closest to him/her.
Also, I've watched all of the Walking Dead game. In my opinion, it is far superior to the Walking Dead TV show. I can't say I've heard of Death Parade, but I've never been a huge fan of dark anime (and that sounds like a dark-as-balls anime). If we're talking zombies, I've seen most of High School of the Dead, but I stopped watching it because they ruined it with all the fanservice. It would have been an amazing show if not for all the panty shots and bouncing breasts everywhere.
I like the comics more because they can do more with the characters and don’t have as many limits as the tv show.
Yeah, they can say fuck.
I love how everyone is commenting about Dale and yet I’m just sitting here like “FINALLY SOMEONE MENTIONED THE WEIRD TENSION BETWEEN DARYL AND CAROL”😂😂
Wtf daryl not in the comics??!
@@jackproductionsrblx you do know that the comics came first right you dont actualy think that the shows (amazing) character they made up should of magicly been in the comics that came out over half a decade earlier
Hes not in the comics because the comics came out first and the show made him and a bunch of other characters to be in the show
grey21hunter he wasn’t even supposed to be a character in the show
yeah the actor of daryl met on of the staff at a comic con or something and they became friends so the dude asked the daryl actor if he wanted to be in the show cuz he was an actor so the spots were filled so they created daryl
@@sam-yx8fr he's called norman reedus
Robert Kirkman has expressed before that the reason the comic book and show's storylines are so different is so that fans who either read the comics first or watched the show first would not get spoiled for major plot elements if they decided to check out the other version of the series. After all it would kind of suck if comic book fans knew everything that was going to happen before a new season of the show even came out.
+Cal DW Like in Game of Throne
+kamil0162 Exactly.
+Jared Gingerich well until now. Until this most recent season GoT followed the books closer than any adaptation, film or tv series, that I've ever seen. They are now forced to part ways with the source material for multiple reasons, and it will be better for it, so long as they utilize the core of the books. The Walking Dead similarly follows the core story, but the comics get much stronger as the issues pile up, where as many would argue A Song of Ice and Fire's last two books are its weakest. TWD has moved closer to the overall main story arcs of the comics since Scott Gimple took over. It's quite genius to be honest, but to be fair to past show runners, Gimple has a larger to much much larger budget, the show would never have a chance to follow the comics later story arcs without heaps of money. Both GOT and TWD are in good hands, I wish I shared that confidence for ASOIAF....
+Cal DW Yep I was just telling this to someone on another site, and it was odd because they were dogging the show for not following the comics and I'm like "dude, he wrote in the fan mail section of the comics that he wanted them to be different FOR the comic reader"... Plus this isn't like most situations where an author sells rights and cashes a check, maybe gets to see screeners before the public.. Kirkman masterfully kept at least a modicum of control over his baby, a power that has only grown with the popularity of the show and can be evidences in AMC handing him a blank check to write his first ever original TV show Fear TWD. Point being, this isn't exactly a situation where you can protest the adaptation's changes from its source material without simultaneously ripping the dude who wrote that source material.
Dale was super cool. I even had understanding for Andrea, rewatching this time
You guys should bust out the rest of the seasons y’all do a great job on getting this stuff right
Wiltshire estate does appear in the how. The episode where tyreese dies.
That was the shirewilt estates
CineFix basically being the same thing, just switched around. Wiltshire
Shirewilt. Think about it.
+Shayla Jewell nope nope. totally coincidence. nyahaha
+CineFix wiltshire appeared in season 2 when Andrea and Shane searched for Sophia
Yeah they just flipped wilt and shire
omg, Andrea and Dale sleep together in the comic? 😂😷
PS4-MsSheHulk When I read it in the comic, I was blown away. lmao. xD In the show, he was more of a father figure so I didn't expect in the books.
PS4-MsSheHulk Dale trying to tap that ass since season 1 😅😅
PS4-MsSheHulk Theres a lot of sex in the comics. Maggie & Glenn are always sneaking around. Carol & Tyresse too lol
Don't forget Michonne and Tyresse that one time which pissed off Carol. xD
They're together for quite a long time in the comics, until Dale's death, which was the death that Bob had in the show. Nowadays, Andrea's with Rick, which Michonne takes now in the show.
"Putting their attraction, *to action."*
That part made me chuckle for some reason lol
Season 10, I wonder if that fire is still burning.
Hm
don't dead open inside
jasonface 32 inside don't dead open
Evsbear1 lol
Open inside don't dead
Inside open don’t dead
I think they wrote it that way so that if one is destroyed, the message would still make sense
Actually Andrea is super depressed in the comic, and with draws from the group before eventually recovering when she gets with Dale. And Jim's story is revealed, he is not much more mysterious, in fact, his weird dreams and crazy digging make him more mysterious in the show.
1:29 that is the 7th Calvary art who Custer led to a defeat at Little Bighorn
Haha Dale seemed like the old guy that watches you through the curtains waiting for something to complain about; but he was a good guy.
And alongside Rick the most loved guy character Daryl, weren't even in the comic, that's interesting, glad he was added.
Hey now, Dale is not the worst. He's like, the best.
+FoolsGil Comic Dale and Andrea are the best...only Comic Carol sucks
+Yutaka5000 Andrea is the absolute worst. Oh wait I mean "was" the worst. Oh that makes me so happy.
+Darrell Gulseth yes the tv version was a useful as carol but. Her comic counterpart is way better.
Yutaka5000 I haven't read the comics (yet), but in the show she makes everything worse than it already is.
+Darrell Gulseth I agree with you there didn't like her much. I recommended you read the comic and consider it an alternate universe to the show. Andrea is way better.
"Don't hurt my daddy ever again! **gunshot**"
Damn, in the comics, Carl was a badass. As they say, like father, like son.
chandler riggs done dirty tbh
So true i was always so confused about carols and Daryl's relationship, Lol even their name rhymes.
Comic is 100 times better, no contest even
Dale was the worst??
Dale?
Peter Petersmann Dale was my favorite lol
Phenom4ever100 I cried a little when he died.
Hugo Hakvoort me too D:
It was a joke
+Peter Petersmann i loved him ;_;
Ok I completely agree about Andrea but you never ever say anything bad about Dale. EVER.
YES!!!!!
yea I love dale
God I remember watching this as a kid and then reading all the compendiums my parents had (1 & 2), then BEGGING my mom for compendium 3. I’m rewatching this as I start compendium 4, thank you for defining my childhood even if I started reading these comics much too early.
5:34
CAAAARL
COOORAL
CORAAAAAL
CAAAAARWH
Am I the only one who thought it said don't dead open inside?
+Grammar Police nope xD
+Rick Dunnigan good, I thought I was alone. XD
+Grammar Police
I originally saw it as don't open it, dead inside but after watching it again I saw it as don't dead, open inside :D
+Grammar Police i did
Yeah, I thought it was too. I read it horizontally and I was like "What?"
Carol seems to be more of a mother figure for daryl.
Nack Jicholson but there has been times where u could smell the sexual tension in the air
Don't we all lust for our mother at times.RikXtreme4
+Nack Jicholson what the fuck man
Nack Jicholson WHAT THE FUCK BRO
Nack Jicholson I agree with the mother figure thing but fact that U said people have feelings for their mothers is straight up fucked up
comics are great because characters dont die due to them being unhappy about directors being fired, or they dont die for dramatic effect or character reduction, its just up to robert kirkman who wants them to live or die how he chooses. besides, while daryl isnt in the comics, a lot of the characters are better in the comics like hershel and andrea.
I went into the show from the comic expecting them to be two different things, I didn't want to do the thing where you don't enjoy something because it's not like the source material.
That was my hope, but honestly, the extra group tension and whatnot just left me rooting for the zombies.
Please continue this series! It's not only a refresher course for me, but it's a helpful tool that I can share with others to show the differences in the comics and the show.
we will! we're not just doing TWD (we did RAMBO last time) but we will def keep TWD ones going too if you guys all want it!
CineFix DO WANT!
Are you going to mention how badly Frank Darabont, his friends and the show's budget was fucked over by AMC?
or the prequel series that was going to give that grenade a backstory?
did that not happen in the comics? :P
CineFix This is the first thing I thought of too. Hope you guys can squeeze it in there. As Originality Daniel said, YMS sums it all up really well. Great video BTW. I hope there's another.
I don't really fucking care about the grenades back story.
OMG, when I first heard about the canceled backstory I was really disappointed and wished that they would maybe make it one day.
TheDocsScalpel
"Stop liking what I don't like"
"Total badass glenn"
Too bad he's dead
@6:38 you mention Wiltshire Estates never makes an appearance on the show but it in fact does when Shane and Andrea go in Season 2 Episode 6 “Secrets” and later makes a little Easter egg appearance in Season 5 when they visit Noah’s old neighborhood named Shirewilt Estates. Just a cool little thing I thought I’d share lol
i knew nothing about the comics so a lot of this was first time knowledge, so wait Daryl and Meryl are soley products of the show they aren't in the comics at all?
Yep.
Yes.
seems like a big liberty to take on behalf of the writers to make such a drastic change but it does seem to work, pretty sure Daryl is one of the most popular characters on the show
I used to like Daryl but his fanbase is so annoying that made me hate him
NTINOS PRODROMIDIS I can understand that, the whole "if daryl dies we riot" thing got pretty annoying
Carol is an amazing character i love the character evolution.
Great video brush!
Pretty accurate for the video minus Jim's back story. The show was spot on with Jim. In the comics reason he got away was because the horde was too busy eating his family except it was much more detailed on who was eaten..
I like the fast pace of the comics, it doesn't make you wait around, it throws you straight into the action.
Unfortunately, that did give the characters less development.
The show does have some pretty decent action, too, and the fact it is more drawn out makes it more worthwhile.
Everyone was celebrating when Andrea died! Am I right?
I was happy but felt bad for Michonne.
***** She was my favorite in the Comics but not the TV adaptation.
She was annoying and in the way right
***** ikr
+Jania Russell My sister cried, but I was stoic
Fun fact: If you read the Novels, you discover it was the Governor who wrote the Do not Enter note at Wilshire estates
I think the Wiltshire Estates is more referenced to in I think season 5? When the group take Noah back to his home....at least thats what it reminds me of!
3:43 how dare you say that about Dale!!! he was my absolute fave character
Same he was moral and trying to help everyone
Daryl sees Carol as a mom.
Carol helped kids who were kicked out of their home/abused.
Daryl and Merle were abused as kids by their dad.
***** definitely see that, but sometimes it's also smoochie woochies feeling
CineFix I don't think so. Kirkman did say that Daryl is mostly asexual.
She invites him to screw around with her in the season 3 premiere episode when inside the prison, it's romantic dude
Eddie Perez No it's fucking not
I love how the title says (season 1)... Even though he just spoils major events from other seasons
I miss these days. Back when the walking dead was good.
The Walking Dead is better than ever now!
@@isakdahl7054 I agree, it got really slow. But picked put in the recent seasons. Plus, Negans backstory episode was amazing.
It’s still good
I think they made CDC up because they weren't expecting a second season. They wanted to give us an ending and to be honest, i think they did--telling us that there's no cure, that everyone's infected and will turn whether or not they get bit. I loved season 1 so much, it's so underrated haha
Not really cos that would be a waste of the rest of the comics
It makes sense
But it doesn’t
I love the Season 1 so much I think it's so funny except the death parts
CDC helped move the narrative too, they needed a way to expel a bunch of exposition that a lot of the other characters couldn't do for the audience
Why Glenn 😭
Fuck Glenn
Ye, fuck Glenn.
MrJulienator Glenn had nine lives he had to run out eventually
What are you? A time lord?
ItsPillow BR no im not doctor who.
Funny how daryl wasn’t even originally a character in the comics but is now a staple to the franchise
Great video guys
what was so bad with dale and andrea? they were great and interesting characters. It was nice seeing a few people not being able to take the zombie apocalypse great and living through depression/suicidal thoughts, was really sad to see them go.
The main difference between the comics and the show - in the comics Carl isn't a annoying little prick.
Also Rick only has one hand.
CAAAAaaaaaaAAAAAAaaaaARRRRRLLLLL!!!!
+CineFix Corral*
I like Carl a lot now, do people still hate him?? I think he's finally grown up, as soon as he became useful I approved.
I'd say he isn't an annoying prick *anymore* he's starting to grow up
comic = glenn is dead
comic = carl is badass
When I recently started reading the comics I completely forgot Daryl wasn’t in it and was waiting for him to pop out when they found the deer had died from the walker and I got sad because I remember he wasn’t in the comics:((😪
So for those who are wondering why the Military failed, when you go through training you are trained to hit centre mass, this happens because bullets are surprisingly expensive to make, this also means you’re less likely to miss, there would be the occasional Walker killed, this is because stray rounds hitting Walkers in the head, but at this point it’d be a case of “Maybe it’s just the bullets.” That’s be logical since Zombies aren’t a thing in pop culture in TWD universe. So the Military failing actually is pretty realistic, but there would probably be more soldiers alive still, mostly snipers, tank drivers/crew and pilots.