I tried to prove YOU guys wrong... but it was ME who was wrong!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 15. 09. 2021
  • Learn more about Redux PCs at
    Get your JayzTwoCents Merch Here! - www.jayztwocents.com
    ○○○○○○ Items featured in this video available at Amazon ○○○○○○
    ► Amazon US - bit.ly/1meybOF
    ► Amazon UK - amzn.to/Zx813L
    ► Amazon Canada - amzn.to/1tl6vc6
    ••• Follow me on your favorite Social Media! •••
    Facebook: / jayztwocents
    Twitter: / jayztwocents
    Instagram: / jayztwocents
    SUBSCRIBE! bit.ly/sub2JayzTwoCents
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 1,7K

  • @dude11579
    @dude11579 Před 2 lety +1264

    Videos like these are WHY I watch this channel. "Screw it, lets see if it works" is basically the origin of scientific practice. This is the kind of argument tech nerds have been having for years, and most people don't have the hardware stash to actually test this kind of thing out properly. I love this kind of "lets find out together" approach, and appreciate that the "well that isn't how that was supposed to work" moments don't end up cut out and only in some private bloopers group chat or something.

    • @fejericktorres5539
      @fejericktorres5539 Před 2 lety +1

      Agree

    • @robert4you
      @robert4you Před 2 lety +6

      Great comment! Totally agree. These episodes are also very entertaining. More videos like these, please!

    • @wytfish4855
      @wytfish4855 Před 2 lety +26

      "the difference between science and screwing around is writing it down"
      in this case, documenting it in a video form

    • @skullhelmet1944
      @skullhelmet1944 Před 2 lety +11

      The "well that isn't how that was supposed to work" moments
      is the only reason to watch most of these types of videos
      oh and the memes ofc

    • @ron200088
      @ron200088 Před 2 lety +1

      Great video and great comment @Samebito. I totally agree. I also remember watching a few months ago a similar video, about using mismatched memory on LTT. However, I think Jay'z approach is more in depth and more explanatory . Very happy he did a follow up video.

  • @RubyRoks
    @RubyRoks Před 2 lety +1548

    I'd love to see this exact test with the AMD bench, considering AMD seems much pickier with its memory speeds

    • @billyhatcher643
      @billyhatcher643 Před 2 lety +9

      sadly amd is picky i guess intel doesnt care

    • @f688xt6
      @f688xt6 Před 2 lety +20

      Yes. This.

    • @robschmid7955
      @robschmid7955 Před 2 lety +6

      This!

    • @GimliTehDwarf
      @GimliTehDwarf Před 2 lety +3

      Yes

    • @sirmonkey1985
      @sirmonkey1985 Před 2 lety +31

      early on it mostly had to do with XMP and some of the settings in it that don't work with AMD's memory controller(that's changed over the years since first gen Ryzen released). the interesting thing is that if you manually set all the XMP timings they'll work fine, enable XMP and sometimes they don't work.. the other thing is that running 1.38v instead of 1.35v seems to solve most of the memory compatibility issues especially if you're using hynix memory modules.

  • @alexanderdimario731
    @alexanderdimario731 Před 2 lety +303

    "look at it, that's what peak performance looks like!"
    I died

    • @Rift2123
      @Rift2123 Před 2 lety +4

      Great line lol

    • @painsme2
      @painsme2 Před 2 lety +1

      Yes that was the best part of the video...

    • @BReal-10EC
      @BReal-10EC Před 2 lety +11

      Actually could be a good meme shirt. A t-shirt with a line drawing of four completely different ram sticks on a mobo and "this is what peak performance looks like"

    • @derdes4475
      @derdes4475 Před 2 lety +3

      @@BReal-10EC I'd buy it.

    • @JMUDoc
      @JMUDoc Před dnem

      So did Nic, by the sound of it🤣

  • @thedoofguy5707
    @thedoofguy5707 Před 2 lety +111

    That video can be summed up with a quote from Christopher Titus: "I don't fail, I succeed at finding what doesn't work." And to be honest, it answered a lot of questions I had about RAM speeds and timings, so it's definitely not a waste. It was educational, it was entertaining, it was JTC.

  • @frankdilauro
    @frankdilauro Před 2 lety +67

    17:44 I have a friend that used to run a build with 9GBs of RAM, one 4GB stick, two 2GB sticks and one 1GB stick. At the time he told us the whole discord channel couldn't stop laughing

    • @Felipemelazzi
      @Felipemelazzi Před 2 lety +4

      Please tell me you shared this video to your friend 😂

    • @ghadturner5645
      @ghadturner5645 Před 2 lety +2

      It tracks tho. One GB reserved for the system 8 reserved for raw performance. I’m not saying it’s not weird but I get it.

    • @Brabant076
      @Brabant076 Před rokem

      @@ghadturner5645 Yes but no.

    • @underskillednunderpaid
      @underskillednunderpaid Před rokem +1

      ​@Ghad Turner something tells me it wasn't done by design 😂 I've been there with random amounts of ram, stealing sticks out of old PCs to fuel my Frankenstein monster. But.... you do have a point with the 1 GB reserve. It's weird but not stupid!

    • @JMUDoc
      @JMUDoc Před 2 dny

      Ah, yes - 2.7 channel RAM.

  • @christophermullins7163
    @christophermullins7163 Před 2 lety +141

    "When motherboards are like.. fine, I wanna see what happens too" I died bro. Love it.

  • @mmalig
    @mmalig Před 2 lety +29

    Please do a vid explaining timings and recommended timings for different applications, As always, fantastic content and keep up the great work. Thx!

  • @robmortimer4150
    @robmortimer4150 Před 2 lety +68

    I think it’s interesting that when you go to buy ram, the timings are probably the least advertised thing

    • @Dr.Spatula
      @Dr.Spatula Před 2 lety +6

      Some times they are actively hidden or misleading. For example all CLxx are not equal

    • @MrTwisted003
      @MrTwisted003 Před 2 lety +2

      Same with most big box stores advertising their PC's with how much RAM and storage space it has. A lot has been changing over time, but that used to be all it'd say.

    • @Jackpkmn
      @Jackpkmn Před 2 lety +1

      Because so few people understand timings the manufacturers can de emphasize it and actually sell ram with looser timings for higher price cus bigger megahertz numbers.

    • @wolphin732
      @wolphin732 Před 2 lety

      Because the sales staff and advertisers don't understand the tech... and think size and speed are what matters (this vehicle seats x and can do y speed in 10s... they don't care about what the engine and transmission is!)

    • @AwankO
      @AwankO Před 2 lety

      Least advertised and one of the first things I check out, along with the speed and capacity.

  • @thunderbolt10031
    @thunderbolt10031 Před 2 lety +189

    The peak performance comment Phil made had me rolling!! Great video guys!

    • @Stubbies2003
      @Stubbies2003 Před 2 lety

      Yup I LOLed my ass off when he said that.

    • @timhartherz5652
      @timhartherz5652 Před 2 lety

      Behold the abomination to rule them all. 😁

    • @DemonsCrest1
      @DemonsCrest1 Před 2 lety +2

      "this is what peak performance looks like" xD

  • @kostaskotoulas6542
    @kostaskotoulas6542 Před 2 lety +635

    Phil: I wanna see somebody with an *odd* number of GB's!
    Well Phil, it's your lucky day! In my linux box I have 3GB's of RAM (1x1GB and 1x2GB)

    • @hughdahand5711
      @hughdahand5711 Před 2 lety +18

      I have an old Asus laptop that came with 3gb of ram.

    • @Vatharian
      @Vatharian Před 2 lety +45

      I have 79 GB of RAM in one of my servers because I grabbed wrong sticks and couldn't be arsed to fetch full set of 8 GBs, so 9 8 GBs, one 4 GB, one 2GB, and one 1 GB. Runs like a champ.
      I also routinely fshsrlisdfw amount of RAM into virtual machines. KVM's balooning is on, so it uses just whatever in needs anyway.

    • @kostaskotoulas6542
      @kostaskotoulas6542 Před 2 lety +55

      @@Vatharian Take off 10 gigs to make it a "nice" amount ;)

    • @RaimarLunardi
      @RaimarLunardi Před 2 lety +7

      If you set iGPU to 1GB, any modern ram amount will be odd

    • @guily6669
      @guily6669 Před 2 lety +5

      @@kostaskotoulas6542 Agree and who needs more than that number anyway? On that number is so fast that you already go wit your tongue out :)

  • @kasper_429
    @kasper_429 Před 2 lety +12

    18:38 I am deceased. Both Phil and Nick dying laughing had me laughing my ass off! 🤣

  • @d00d628
    @d00d628 Před 2 lety +113

    Jay: Gotta prove that this is just a stupid configuration and there's no way it would work out.
    Cinebench: Hold my beer

  • @_chex
    @_chex Před 2 lety +64

    This was the best. The misfit ram setup proved everyone wrong. Loved seeing the process of discovery followed by the humility.

  • @joegober1818
    @joegober1818 Před 2 lety +252

    This would be extremely interesting to see on a ryzen system.

    • @f-ckmyr0fil788
      @f-ckmyr0fil788 Před 2 lety

      Set out before it gets hot😷😠😡😵🤪😳😱

    • @f-ckmyr0fil788
      @f-ckmyr0fil788 Před 2 lety

      of red velvet, which suited her 🤔😗😆😀

    • @f-ckmyr0fil788
      @f-ckmyr0fil788 Před 2 lety

      Do I find you here, you old er!🎏🎎🎍🎋🎊🎉🎈

    • @utsuhoreiuji2309
      @utsuhoreiuji2309 Před 2 lety +2

      I actually have a Ryzen 1700 system on A320 that I bashed together from spare parts running two different kits - I think a 2133 and a 2400? - that runs quite nicely at memory speeds in the range of 3000 MHz.

    • @bladeclanhalo3
      @bladeclanhalo3 Před 2 lety +8

      @Ladioz intel isn't better, ryzen is just picky with memory

  • @yugoprowers
    @yugoprowers Před 2 lety +8

    I remember EDO RAM where you would have 4 slots but only 2 banks, it would make the lager stick come down to the smaller one. If you put in a 16MB and a 32MB in the same bank you only had 32MB total (16 x 2). I learned the hard way because the first time I built my own PC it was on a Socket 7 platform.

  • @Arclite02
    @Arclite02 Před 2 lety +33

    It's fun, watching the logical part of Jay's brain melting down when hardware just decides to say "fuck it" and do whatever the hell it feels like...

  • @Spideryote
    @Spideryote Před 2 lety +146

    PC mythbusting is some of my favorite content you make

    • @AntiTako
      @AntiTako Před 2 lety +4

      That should be a series.

    • @f-ckmyr0fil788
      @f-ckmyr0fil788 Před 2 lety

      so she was always😐😚😊😂

    • @f-ckmyr0fil788
      @f-ckmyr0fil788 Před 2 lety

      what a nice plump mouthful🍍🍌🍋🍊🍉🍈🍇

    • @winonesoon9771
      @winonesoon9771 Před 2 lety +2

      Honestly I feel like there alot of mythbusting these pc CZcamsrs miss out on it kinda surprises me. They really are the best videos when ya get to see something go from theory to practice ha!

  • @JohnWegner
    @JohnWegner Před 2 lety +110

    Don't forget about ranks if you're going to get into the whole number of dimms conversation

    • @jamesiepooh7337
      @jamesiepooh7337 Před 2 lety +12

      That's where 4 single rank and 2 dual rank sticks at the same speeds technically perform the same, right?

    • @whoisthatthingwhat
      @whoisthatthingwhat Před 2 lety +3

      @@jamesiepooh7337 yes but 2 dual rank is generally preferred

    • @peterletran
      @peterletran Před 2 lety

      @@whoisthatthingwhat @James DeHart I can't find any information on 8GB Corsair Vengeance RGB Pro DDR4-3200mhz. Is it dual rank or single rank? I've read somewhere that 4 and 8 GB are usually single rank, but 16 or higher is dual rank. It doesn't seem right to me.

    • @whoisthatthingwhat
      @whoisthatthingwhat Před 2 lety

      @@peterletran single rank

    • @gtijason7853
      @gtijason7853 Před 2 lety +4

      @@peterletran 4 and 8gb are almost always single rank, with the exception of old 2 x 8 kits using something like 2015 Samsung E die. Nowadays some 16gb sticks (2x16gb) can also be single ranked, I know some Micron for sure and probably Hynix as well. The Corsair kit you speak of will almost definitely be single rank and could be any number of different IC's including but not limited to Hynix (Corsair Version no. 5.31-5.48) CJR, DJR, JJR and Micron (or Spectek made micron IC's Version no 3.31-3.34) Rev E and J

  • @Sheamu5
    @Sheamu5 Před 2 lety +21

    18:35 that was the funniest thing I've heard this week.

  • @AsherLimaPapa
    @AsherLimaPapa Před 2 lety +9

    This was incredibly entertaining, and very informative. This is why I love your channel!

  • @Levi24Helvey
    @Levi24Helvey Před 2 lety +29

    Yes please do a timing video with an AMD cpu. Timings are one of the things I understand the least about PCs

    • @imadecoy.
      @imadecoy. Před 2 lety +2

      Then watch Buildzoid, not Jay lol.

    • @imadecoy.
      @imadecoy. Před 2 lety +1

      @@bronzehd6212 He holds the single GPU record in 3DMark Firestrike Extreme. What record does Jay have again?

    • @Belshazzaresque
      @Belshazzaresque Před 2 lety +6

      @@imadecoy. number of explosions in a sponsor bit

  • @hardlytech9072
    @hardlytech9072 Před 2 lety +7

    Did you guys watch my RAM videos >_

  • @Waskapmutni
    @Waskapmutni Před 2 lety +9

    "just look at it" at 18:35 made me think of that time Kramer showed Jerry his chest regarding how the chesthair would grow back thicker and fuller if he kept shaving it 🤣

  • @RaceSimCentral
    @RaceSimCentral Před 2 lety +7

    This is brilliant content. Uploading a trial and error fail video is just solid entertainment and why I absolutely love this channel.

  • @spencerhansen2927
    @spencerhansen2927 Před 2 lety +32

    Jay is so old that he remembers when his 2 cents were worth a nickel. /s
    Love this channel.

  • @darkhunterkiller4602
    @darkhunterkiller4602 Před 2 lety +138

    Jay: *determined to prove a point*
    Jay: *proves everyone else's point instead*
    Viewers: *facepalm lol* ❤

    • @wolphin732
      @wolphin732 Před 2 lety +1

      It shows that he's following scientific process... and not doing what companies want now, where they want result x (usually because sales have already been made for it) and tell you to make the data support it.

    • @MarioGoatse
      @MarioGoatse Před rokem

      No

  • @Disciple-of-discipline

    As a car guy - this explanation ( from Crucial's FAQ) was what made it click for me:
    "If we think of memory as a race car, the module speed (MH/z) would be like the raw horse power of the engine, and the timings would be the driver of the car. As the driver of the car gets better at handling turns and responding to obstacles on the race course, the car will perform faster, so much so, that you can have a car with lower horsepower outperform one with more horsepower, if the driver (timings) are faster in the lower horsepower car than the car with more horsepower."
    What an awesome video. I love that Jay keep's his hubris in check such that he not only will say "frick" it and try something like this, but also not try to hide when his initial hypothesis/notions are off the mark. It would be quite easy to shoot this video, scrap it, and re-shoot with the narrative that he's an infallible tech guru. I love you for that Jay. We all need to be more okay with being wrong and/or just not knowing something... it allows for so much more learning and even connection to take place.

  • @WBrown-ft3kz
    @WBrown-ft3kz Před 2 lety

    These videos are the reason I started following your channel :) Kepp going!

  • @justsomeguywashwd_jbm821
    @justsomeguywashwd_jbm821 Před 2 lety +11

    Mythbusters: forces the accelerated expansion of objects by chemical reactions.
    Jay: I'll stick to excess air pressure.

  • @slc9800gtx
    @slc9800gtx Před 2 lety +4

    Jay is hands down my favorite reviewer. I like his information ,testing methods, and personality.

  • @soulwarrior7721
    @soulwarrior7721 Před 2 lety +1

    Respect.. Every Master of a skill knows the learning is never done.. You learned something new today.. The day we stop learning is the day we start dieing.

  • @desertgecko4549
    @desertgecko4549 Před 2 lety

    Jay, this is one of your best videos that I've seen yet. And a great topic -- timely, too, as I've been studying the mysteries of RAM for my new build.

  • @yanfelt9603
    @yanfelt9603 Před 2 lety +16

    The last fully mixed setup is a clapped out civic with a laptop. Taking all the other setups to gapplebees.

  • @qwkimball
    @qwkimball Před 2 lety +14

    Proving, once more, that the single most important element of comedy is...timing.

    • @smeezer
      @smeezer Před 2 lety

      Disagree. It depends on the style of comedy. Comedians like Norm Macdonald show it can be just as much about perverting expectations or repetition. Timing won't help if it's not funny to begin with, but good timing will make funny ten times funnier.

    • @qwkimball
      @qwkimball Před 2 lety

      @@smeezer Really? Do you have a tattoo on your ear that reads, "Inflate to 30 PSI"?

    • @smeezer
      @smeezer Před 2 lety

      @@qwkimball Thank you for proving my point ;)

    • @qwkimball
      @qwkimball Před 2 lety

      @@smeezer A double whoosh. Those are rare.

    • @smeezer
      @smeezer Před 2 lety

      @@qwkimball lol

  • @RouvenZockt
    @RouvenZockt Před 2 lety

    This is a perfect example why i love this channel. SO pls Jay and the team. NEVER stop making videos. Its so awesome!!!

  • @mwheatley1986
    @mwheatley1986 Před 2 lety

    Been learning from ya for years my dude! Please continue this with timings!

  • @thecryptidkeeper9913
    @thecryptidkeeper9913 Před 2 lety +7

    The only thing missing was a bootable raid drive striped across a SSD and a 5400rpm HDD.

    • @infernaldaedra
      @infernaldaedra Před 2 lety +1

      Like intel Optane lmao. The where the OS is likely to corrupt and boot to bluescreens everytime you update 🤣

    • @Klffsj
      @Klffsj Před 2 lety

      @@infernaldaedra Well, you could always use Linux. I don't think the problem is the concept of striping as much as it is Windows' support for it. Windows is still using NTFS, perhaps one of the most antiquated, slowest, featureless file systems still being used.
      I'll be installing Linux on a ZFS mirror (RAID-1 equivalent) with 2 NVMe drives soon enough. It'll be tricky to get /boot and /root to install on OpenZFS, but certainly possible and stable (apart from a bug regarding hibernation). But for a gaming PC, you can install /boot and /root on ext4, then have a ZFS pool where you store things like games and files.

  • @nanomage
    @nanomage Před 2 lety +4

    As for the oddest amount of RAM I've used recently, I ran 56GB a couple months ago (3x16 1x8) while I waited for a stick to replace one that failed. I had a 8 stick laying around and for my workflow the 56 setup was faster than the 32 2 stick and the 48 3 stick, not a lot faster but every bit helps.

  • @stonehenge313
    @stonehenge313 Před 2 lety

    I love these kinds of videos - always learn something and its closer to the hair brained experiences I run into

  • @joecool1875
    @joecool1875 Před 2 lety +2

    Excellent experiment and thanks for taking one for the team (in the name of science)! Would really like to see you try out as many combinations of kits with 2x stix to see if it's actually not a good idea to buy one kit to start, and upgrade to 4x stix total at a later date (missmatched kits). Brands, speeds, latency, ranks etc. Either way, keep up the great work you do =)

  • @joenagel6644
    @joenagel6644 Před 2 lety +5

    You’re going to have to test higher speeds with mismatched timings as well as mismatched capacities for the heck of it. It would also be interesting to see how a matched set of 4 sticks would compare to a mismatched set of 4 where the lowest stick is a stick of the matched set.

  • @CarsCouk
    @CarsCouk Před 2 lety +3

    Thank you for the cracking videos you guys. I love the random crap you mess around with 😂.

  • @mrknighttheitguy8434
    @mrknighttheitguy8434 Před 2 lety

    Thanks JayZ, I've been wondering about this for 20 years, you've finally answered it!

  • @paulhellyer4518
    @paulhellyer4518 Před 2 lety +2

    Great video - Always good to see ""what if???"
    Looking forward to hearing a video with more on timings. Not a G-Nexus style of this is how it works 'technically' of course. More of the classic Jayz this is what happens when you do!
    Many high end Motherboards have advanced automatic overclocking options, what do they choose and is it better to just manaully set to get a better day to Day result (not NO2 levels)

  • @RaimarLunardi
    @RaimarLunardi Před 2 lety +4

    I always used mismatched ram, no complaints. Just needed to set as slowest...
    Only thing to give headache was to mix single sided ram with double sided... either didn't work, or didn't recognize all of it or didn't enabled dual channel.

  • @jeremymatthies726
    @jeremymatthies726 Před 2 lety +4

    I'd love to see a video on manually setting ram timings etc. I still use an older system (2600k and 32 GB ram) that runs just fine. Going over ram timings is a chore to find decent info on.
    Love the fun you guys have too.

    • @CouchCit
      @CouchCit Před 2 lety

      Yes, this

    • @NotThatGuyJD
      @NotThatGuyJD Před 2 lety +1

      It's really not that hard to find good info. There's plenty of channels just on CZcams with good videos explaining ram timings. BuildZoid has a series explaining some of the basics on ram and such, GN has had part one of their ram explanation out for a couple years at this point I think, can't remember the specifics now.

    • @jeremymatthies726
      @jeremymatthies726 Před 2 lety

      @@NotThatGuyJD Thanks

  • @garretthazlett9116
    @garretthazlett9116 Před 2 lety

    Thoroughly enjoyed this video. You can for sure do more of this. Would also be interested in goofball ram setups on a Ryzen platform.

  • @omarastacio3939
    @omarastacio3939 Před 2 lety

    With the thumbnail subtitle I thought you were going to discuss how you measure wall thickness. But love this type of material. Keep up the good work

  • @stephenmerrins5910
    @stephenmerrins5910 Před 2 lety +68

    Jay regarding merch... I need a shirt with Phil's face on it surrounded by a subtitle if his laugh... As long as Phil is cool with it of course.

    • @Kellywho5
      @Kellywho5 Před 2 lety

      This would be fantastic.

    • @ronnie3044
      @ronnie3044 Před 2 lety

      Ill buy two if Phil isnt cool with it lol

    • @pnwscitech1589
      @pnwscitech1589 Před 2 lety

      Yes please!

    • @nl9963
      @nl9963 Před 2 lety

      And on the back of it a picture of mismatched ram stating "this is what peak performance looks like" 😂😂

  • @devneko9511
    @devneko9511 Před 2 lety +3

    Think it would be interesting to see these tests on a APU since integrated graphics depends on ram as well.

  • @aaardvaaark
    @aaardvaaark Před 2 lety

    Simple sanity check type experiments like this are super informative, thanks Jay.

  • @juliansutare935
    @juliansutare935 Před 2 lety +1

    Great video! *Engine block case update when?*

  • @lunsmann
    @lunsmann Před 2 lety +4

    Hey, in the end, great video - now I know my next PC upgrade is going to focus on LOW timing RAM sticks rather than purely on baseline OC speed. This is the sort of information us old idiots thrive on.
    I've been building my own PC's since 1992, and have also ALWAYS used matched sticks of ram.

  • @rjnegative
    @rjnegative Před 2 lety +17

    Kinda amazing though, regardless how your timings or capacity is, mixed brand or same brand, you still get decent performance.

    • @whoisthatthingwhat
      @whoisthatthingwhat Před 2 lety +2

      because the brand doesnt matter if theyre all some c die ic dogshit

  • @Al_Proper
    @Al_Proper Před 2 lety

    Yo Jay, That ‘Office’ Reference Was GOLDEN!!!
    🤣🤣 U shld use more analogies of funny crap like that… love to hear one on animals or politics 😂

  • @LordApophis100
    @LordApophis100 Před 2 lety +1

    I like the discovery approach of many of Jays videos, seeing all the small steps, surprises and conclusions rather than a scripted conclusion of the final result. Never knowing where he may end up.

  • @BigColton
    @BigColton Před 2 lety +28

    I think I speak for the entire community when I ask "WHERE IS THE ENGINE BLOCK BUILD?????" Day 1 of asking Jay for this. I will be dropping this comment on every video until our demands are met.

    • @TheOriginalFaxon
      @TheOriginalFaxon Před 2 lety +2

      I second this, though i cannot guarantee i will remember to ask next time xD. WHERE IS IT JAY?!?!?!

    • @JUSTINTHEGREDMAN
      @JUSTINTHEGREDMAN Před 2 lety +2

      Where the block jay?

  • @casedistorted
    @casedistorted Před 2 lety +60

    I mean tbh I used two diff sets of RAM once and the only thing that changed was the lowest I could get my timings down was the lowest in the pair (one pair was CL 14 and one CL 16, so I had to use CL 16) but otherwise it worked

    • @nanoflower1
      @nanoflower1 Před 2 lety +6

      That's what I have now. Has worked well enough for the past few years. Yes, I'm probably losing a bit of speed but it's worth it for the extra 8GB giving me 24 GB of RAM.

    • @emorphien
      @emorphien Před 2 lety +3

      Generally that's how it goes!

    • @Killerjack007
      @Killerjack007 Před 2 lety +4

      yep works ram will work at highest latency and lowest speed. so 3200 14 and 3600 16 it would run 3200 cl16.
      Is it efficient? nope
      Does it work : Yep (except some rare cases)

    • @insanemal
      @insanemal Před 2 lety

      You can always run slower timings. Even if you decrease the frequency you often can't run faster timings. That was Jay's mistake. He needed to stick to the slowest timing. The slower ram (with the faster frequency) just can't do 15's.

  • @scootertrashtx
    @scootertrashtx Před 2 lety

    wow... totally not what I was expecting... Thanks for sharing!

  • @euphienator
    @euphienator Před 2 lety

    I think this was an amazing video. I would love a video about timings. I never really understood how these things work and what all the timings mean. please explain in yet another great vid.

  • @cassiothird
    @cassiothird Před 2 lety +18

    Cinebench is not a good benchmark for memory, it mostly uses CPU cache.
    Also 4 stick combinations will (most of the time) have the benefit of running dual rank while 2 stick usually run single rank.

    • @mmmdawe
      @mmmdawe Před 2 lety

      isn't single rank better

    • @NVMDSTEvil
      @NVMDSTEvil Před 2 lety +1

      @@mmmdawe only if you have two single rank sticks on the same channel so you then have dual rank.

    • @Cypeq
      @Cypeq Před 2 lety

      @@bronzehd6212 no.

    • @Sp4rKzTV
      @Sp4rKzTV Před 2 lety +4

      @@mmmdawe Yes/No. A lot of testing has been done on this. There's also contradicting information online as well. But basically from testing (I personally did with my current computer) and research I did on the topic and looking at other channels who tested different scenario and configuration (Like GamersNexus and ActuallyHardcoreOverclocking) I think we can conclude that :
      - At same timing and frequency (so let's say 3600Mhz CL16), Dual Rank is better than single rank (note that Memory rank =/= channel, those are 2 different things).
      - However, single rank will usually allow you to get better timing and higher frequency than dual rank. So at a certain point it MIGHT, be better. But we're usually looking at really high frequency (like above 4000Mhz).
      Since most people don't buy crazy high frequency RAM (most people will shop between 3200Mhz - 3800Mhz. In that range it's possible to get pretty good timing on dual rank (getting single rank RAM that does better is going to be very expensive) so dual rank will usually perform a bit better. The difference is NOT that significant however and I wouldn't worry too much about it. We're talking a few percents in synthetic benchmark.

  • @Badanon
    @Badanon Před 2 lety +4

    This sounds like frequency is important to a point and timings are more important after that

  • @travisbischoff9782
    @travisbischoff9782 Před 2 lety

    HAHAHAHA! This is the greatest channel. An unbelievable source of ridiculously useful, common sense information with a nice humble comedic flare. I’m a mechanic and that whole Honda Fit turbo to supercharger bit was great! I was freaking dying! Keep up the good work

  • @mscottie73
    @mscottie73 Před 2 lety

    Yes! Let's look at timings please!
    Would be nice to see summary screen of all the scores just for reference

  • @edwarda.tokash8166
    @edwarda.tokash8166 Před 2 lety +14

    Hey Jay, you forgot to mention if each DIMM was Single-Rank or Dual-Rank.

    • @randomuser6306
      @randomuser6306 Před 2 lety

      8gb sticks these days are all single rank.

    • @lordmentalton6736
      @lordmentalton6736 Před 2 lety

      I was just going to say the same thing, this explains some of the "weirdness".

  • @dirg3music
    @dirg3music Před 2 lety +7

    The main takeaway: "If It Looks Stupid, But It Works, Then It Ain't Stupid" lmfao

  • @nukedathlonman
    @nukedathlonman Před 2 lety

    No worries Jay - it's all good. Just a big thanks for testing it out and doing a video on it. :-)

  • @the_shuck
    @the_shuck Před 2 lety

    i had mismatched sticks for so long but they were both 8gb each. I've now got a Klevv Cras X kit @ 3200 tightened to 14-16-16-32-427. Pretty happy with that. Thanks for the video Jay!

  • @PointerPapa
    @PointerPapa Před 2 lety +4

    This has been an episode of cursed PC configurations, see you next week when we try to create a raid with an nvme and msata m.2 set of SSDs

  • @JanneAirDotCom
    @JanneAirDotCom Před 2 lety +6

    Another curve ball to the conversation would be: How would all this testing turn out if you'd take into account that Ryzen benefits hugely from 4 sticks instead of 2.

    • @Dr.Spatula
      @Dr.Spatula Před 2 lety

      Really? Last thing I saw was ryzen benefited from single channel

    • @malphadour
      @malphadour Před 2 lety

      @@Dr.Spatula This is totally down to what you are doing with your ram (and what ram you have used). For overclocking then single channel is generally better, especially if you are using a daisy chain motherboard (which most X570 and B550 boards are). For raw bandwidth then dual channel is better because this will guarantee you are running in dual rank. This can leverage about 10% more performance in certain workloads, but is is generally a lot harder to overclock 4 sticks of ram than it is 2. This can of course vary from board to board and ram kit to ram kit. You can of course also get dual rank sticks of ram (16gb micron Rev E for example) and in this scenario you can have best of both worlds with dual rank and also potentially better overclocking. (Edited - sorry Dr Spatula that was very confusing)

    • @Dr.Spatula
      @Dr.Spatula Před 2 lety

      @@malphadour why are you talking about number of sticks per channel?

    • @malphadour
      @malphadour Před 2 lety

      @@Dr.Spatula Christ I wrote that all arse about tit, need to edit that. I meant single channel or dual channel, not dimms per channel, let me fix it with coffee...

    • @Dr.Spatula
      @Dr.Spatula Před 2 lety

      @@malphadour ok. Most people still don't know the difference between channels and sticks so i was concerned you were in that same place

  • @Adam-qs5ir
    @Adam-qs5ir Před 2 lety

    You guys have so much fun doing these videos. When I need a laugh, I can be guaranteed one with your vids.

  • @nl9963
    @nl9963 Před 2 lety

    This is the kind of quality content I subscribe for 😂 I've been running mismatched ram for a while with lowered frequency and tighter timing. It's a weird world

  • @F80MGod
    @F80MGod Před 2 lety +4

    The Office reference, the turbo/supercharger reference, computer nerds. This is why Jay is GOATED

  • @FatherOfStupidMeow
    @FatherOfStupidMeow Před 2 lety +96

    Yay, Jay's 2 cents has lost value due to inflation. It's at least a dime now. Jusskiddin :)

    • @thetalesofdaneandco
      @thetalesofdaneandco Před 2 lety

      JayzDime. I feel like Jay would make joke about Mrs. Jay here.

    • @kentorourke
      @kentorourke Před 2 lety +2

      Jayztwobits, two meanings computer terms and 2 bits is 25¢

    • @kasai7272
      @kasai7272 Před 2 lety

      Do have mo
      Moo

    • @kasai7272
      @kasai7272 Před 2 lety

      O
      M
      L
      O
      O
      Om
      L

    • @kasai7272
      @kasai7272 Před 2 lety

      @@thetalesofdaneandco
      O
      Lo
      L
      Lo
      Om
      Mooop

  • @taegoLake
    @taegoLake Před 2 lety

    This crew work is awesome. Could you do same kind of test ram video for a modern high end gaming laptop too, to see if the results follow ?

  • @Strattos4
    @Strattos4 Před 2 lety

    Great video and would definitely been keen on another one focused on timings, which tbh I've never understood, but after this vid realise I probably should have taken more time to understand.

  • @Jarick_G
    @Jarick_G Před 2 lety +7

    Lost performance isn’t typically the concern with mismatched RAM, rather the errors that can occur to cause crashes. That’s the main reason matched RAM is greatly important in servers, as they need the utmost amount of uptime and data loss is a great concern.

  • @JUSTINTHEGREDMAN
    @JUSTINTHEGREDMAN Před 2 lety +4

    Phil's laugh makes these videos for me. If he ever leaves, I'm gone too.

  • @chenming91
    @chenming91 Před 2 lety

    Total agree on this. This did
    Happen to me i bought the same ram didn't see the timing but same speed. Had this problem couple of time than just bought another set than have no issue.After looking at the timing had to be the same than it works great.

  • @MrMurdock86
    @MrMurdock86 Před 2 lety +1

    For real, though, my rig is running the same ‘model’ (XPG Spectrux D41) ram all around with the same timings, but with channel A packing 16 gig sticks, and B with 8 gig sticks. Funny enough, each using a different controller in the pair. I might actually try tweaking the timings and slowing the xmp clock after work just to see if it’ll boot and run tighter

  • @Lukiel666
    @Lukiel666 Před 2 lety +3

    My takeaway is that from now on I will be paying more attention to timings on my ram kits.

  • @oldteefgaming5517
    @oldteefgaming5517 Před 2 lety +10

    Jay I was tripping about FPS and about to replace either GPU or CPU and then forgot the ram having a cl18 is probably really why

    • @whoisthatthingwhat
      @whoisthatthingwhat Před 2 lety

      overclock it yourself

    • @Stubbies2003
      @Stubbies2003 Před 2 lety +1

      CL18 is definitely hurting. Hopefully it isn't CL18 at like 2400 speed to add insult to injury.

    • @oxfordsparky
      @oxfordsparky Před 2 lety

      @@Stubbies2003 my ram is cl18 and it makes zero difference to FPS.

    • @randomplayer6461
      @randomplayer6461 Před 2 lety +1

      @@oxfordsparky probably because you are gpu limited

    • @bafon
      @bafon Před 2 lety

      I have a Ryzen 9 5900X, TUF 6800XT, and 32Gb Corsair Rgb Pro 3600Mhz CL18 (four sticks), tightened the timings to CL17 at 3600Mhz and also tried CL16 at 3200Mhz, was virtually no difference. If you have 3000Mhz CL18 or something like that, you will not get a major uplift even if you get 3600Mhz CL16..keyword being major..small uplift yes, but i would rather have overclocked the ram you have to the best speed and timings it will do and settle for that.

  • @dewaldesterhuizen3018
    @dewaldesterhuizen3018 Před 2 lety

    Great video .. I am runnnig with 7 gig all the sticks are different brands its a very old setup but still runs if you put the sticks in the correct slots

  • @rustynail6363
    @rustynail6363 Před 2 lety

    That was a grin! :))
    I would have liked you to try to XMP that last config.

  • @jeffb.6642
    @jeffb.6642 Před 2 lety +9

    how did you saying "compacity" not get picked up in the editing room lol

  • @Guitarsince1993
    @Guitarsince1993 Před 2 lety +11

    In college my professor wouldn't even use RAM that was from different lots

    • @CompproB237
      @CompproB237 Před 2 lety

      That professor is a dunce.

    • @kaziwill
      @kaziwill Před 2 lety

      @@CompproB237 back in the day, you had to be that picky. So.. he's just set in his old ways

  • @hugoalois3117
    @hugoalois3117 Před rokem

    ive seen many "movies" of ya, everytime I'm learning and laughing my ass of , djeez jayz keep on doing that stuff :) :) :)

  • @philipingram1563
    @philipingram1563 Před 2 lety

    Never too old to learn something new Jay

  • @pocketlint82
    @pocketlint82 Před 2 lety +7

    Yes do a timings video. I'm about to get 64gb for my girlfriends pc and would love to know if 3600 with a little looser timing is worth more money or if it'd be better to get 3000

    • @kaseyboles30
      @kaseyboles30 Před 2 lety

      In my case about the same. Don't recall the specs exactly for the ram, but 4x8 @3000 vs 2x32 @ 3600. Very very close scores on firestrike and cinebench23.
      This with a 3900x on a msi b540 tomahawk max.

    • @sirmonkey1985
      @sirmonkey1985 Před 2 lety

      depends on the system setup whether it's AMD or Intel since there is a slight performance increase running 3600 over 3000 that may offset the performance loss due to timing and what the systems being used for.. it's likely that overall there's no significant benefit to running 64x3600 vs 64x3000 but saving a couple 100 dollars might be worth it.

    • @tchlin
      @tchlin Před 2 lety

      I just built a top end pc and felt/feel I overspent on the ram. Feel a little bit better now. Paired an AMD 5900x with 4 sticks of Trident z Royale 16gb 3600mhz 14 14 14 34. Going to running some benchmarks now.

    • @whoisthatthingwhat
      @whoisthatthingwhat Před 2 lety

      @@tchlin it pains me to see you buying overpriced ram and not manually overclocking it.

    • @ArtisChronicles
      @ArtisChronicles Před 2 lety

      @@whoisthatthingwhat if I ever understood subtimings properly I'd probably do all manual overclocks. For some reason I enjoy tuning things more than actually using them.

  • @trick0502
    @trick0502 Před 2 lety +12

    I think buildzoid needs to tech jay about b die, cjr/djr, micron revs. Just just went full mormy. Does jay know about ram ranks?

    • @crisnmaryfam7344
      @crisnmaryfam7344 Před 2 lety +2

      Yep, but in the general sense that just contributes to a particular set (or stick) of ram being able to achieve tighter timings. He showed that today without losing a lot of the more casual users with technical jargon.

    • @sandmann521
      @sandmann521 Před 2 lety +4

      This video is a nightmare. I'm gonna have to stop trying to explain to redditors how RAM works, because they're gonna keep referencing this monstrosity. Jay is way too big to be putting out a video about something he's THIS uninformed about.

  • @justinforeman7714
    @justinforeman7714 Před 2 lety +1

    I bought 2 kits of G.Skill Trident Z series 3600 15-15-15-35. Had a pretty good time getting 3600 to boot on all 4 sticks. But easily overclocked them to 4000 15-16-16-36. Had to bump voltage on my system agent to about 1.25v to stop random crashing.

  • @registeredblindgamer4350

    Jay Patriot make some very good memory. Their Viper Steel series is great for overclocking and is cheap for high frequencies.

  • @gunnarsandberg8132
    @gunnarsandberg8132 Před 2 lety +3

    x8 ,faster than x16! x4 speed = server !!

  • @PolskiJaszczomb
    @PolskiJaszczomb Před 2 lety +4

    What's really happening with mixed RAM is if you have mixed capacity, when you exceed capacity of the less capable kit you go into single channel.

    • @Klffsj
      @Klffsj Před 2 lety

      That makes a lot of sense!

  • @PurpleKnightmare
    @PurpleKnightmare Před 2 lety

    My old out of warranty MB B channel stopped working. When I upgraded, I replaced the two sticks with a larger size. I just used those old two sticks later in a media PC I built. I needed more RAM for media art 2D and 3D stuff. My MB also supports RAM cache for the storage.

  • @nascarben
    @nascarben Před 2 lety

    Phil and Nic dying in the background made this video epic.

  • @Herbertti3
    @Herbertti3 Před 2 lety +8

    Synthetic tests are really poor way to measure ram performance. It starts to matter at higher fps. CS Go would be perfect for example.

    • @malphadour
      @malphadour Před 2 lety

      Jay is not the guy to go to for proper scientific stuff like this. The video, whilst entertaining, is a shambles from a testing perspective. Steve would pull him to pieces on his methodology :) And you are absolutely right - and using Cinebench was utterly pointless.

  • @simonsund
    @simonsund Před 2 lety

    yes please! talk about memory timing in a video! i need to learn what whats!

  • @johnscaramis2515
    @johnscaramis2515 Před 2 lety

    14:45 quite easy to explain: the IMCs act smart and use dual channel for the first 8GB and go to single channel, if they have to use above 16GB. So as long as your RAM requirements stay within the limit of the chnalle with less RAM * 2, you get dual channel bandwidth. If you need more RAM, above the dual channel limit, your scores will decrease.
    So it's no wonder that you see the same score in CB. Not sure what amount CB requires, but if you fill up the memory, so that CB is forced to access the single channel area, you will see a decrease in performance.
    However: Even that decrease is better than swapping to HD or SSD.

  • @tvw4951
    @tvw4951 Před 2 lety

    This was a fun video, I've been building for awhile now (10 years or so at this point)
    Timings still confuse me a bit, I understand a lower CL will be "typically" better but with DDR5 approaching and it have some crazy timings in comparison to some of the faster DDR4 kits (4400mhz etc) makes you wonder with lower tighter timings.