Is It Transphobic To Attach "Womanhood" To Cis-Gender Women Only? | TEA G-I-F
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 07. 2023
- Claudia, Al and Funky are talking about social media going into an uproar after comments from a Trans Woman on the subject of womanhood and periods.
SUBSCRIBE to FOX SOUL on CZcams!!
👉🏾 czcams.com/users/FoxSoul?sub_confirm...
WATCH LIVE & EXPLORE MORE at: www.foxsoul.tv/
Download the FOX SOUL app to watch LIVE shows and full episodes while on the go!
Connect with FOX SOUL social:
Twitter 👉🏾 FoxSoulTV
Instagram 👉🏾 FoxSoul
Facebook 👉🏾 FoxSoul
Our Voice. Our Truth. FOX SOUL is a live streaming channel dedicated to the black culture, but consumable by all. The programs aim to entertain, educate & inspire with authentic conversations from the many diverse voices within the Black community.
#foxsoul #lgbtq #lgbtqrepresentation - Zábava
I AM NOT A CIS WOMAN I AM A WOMAN PERIOD!!!!
Facts
Point blank!
So agree
💯Facts Claudia, you should not be afraid to tell the TRUTH we are not CIS WE ARE A WOMAN PERIODS AND UTERUS IN ALL I"M UNAPOLOGETIC
Exactly!!
I think you explained it well Claudia. It’s misogyny, another subset of men telling us what we should think and feel and dare us to say something about it.
🖤
Exactly!
Indeed
Whooo chile you said it !!👏🏽
Tbh I am a gay man and not all queer people have the same opinion. With that said I never thought about like this before, it really changed my perspective
After watching this I really thought everyone was going to drag Claudia. I'm so happy that's not the case. I think she did a great job explaining how she felt. I think its very brave in this time where in.
When did it become offensive to just be a biological person 🤔💭🤨🧐….PERIOD …..literally 🩸
Right
Who is offended by that? Because I know a lot of transsexual women don't feel like that.
I’m tryna understand
I 100% agree with you.
Seriously 💯💯💯 and Calling us "CIS" Women alone, is flat out disrespectful. Let's start there!! Are we as women just going to accept this🤔🤔 and I'm lesbian. This shi is out of control, the LGBTQ+ is doing wayyyy too much. Keep adding stuff every 5 seconds and Trans women are getting on my nerves trying to BULLY people into accepting the fact that they believe that they are natural born women and they're NOT!! Trans men don't even take it as literal as trans women. And God forbid you say something that are proven FACT scientifically, spiritually and/or realistically....your labelled as homophobic and you lose your career!! This is sad and I'm sick of black women continuously getting disrespected and no one sticks up for us!! Whether you're gay, straight or Trans - stick up for US naturally born women. We are losing our voice and people with a huge platform need to stand up and stand on it!!
I AM A WOMAN NOT NO DAMN CIS WOMAN
You right cis
PERIOD! That's REAL!!
That part. They need to take a hike with these fictitious terms.
PERIODT❤
Wrong and just ignorant the opposite of transgender is cisgender. If you not transgendered you are cisgender. You are a cisgender woman ima a cisgenderd man
Claudia is absolutely right! We have to tell the truth. It’s becoming too much of a headache.
Q's "question" was so condescending and I appreciate Claudia catching it. It was posed as a question but turned into mansplaining when he gave his reasoning for asking the question.
You literally broke it down so beautifully, Claudia. It's the patriarchy, the audacity.
What's interesting is that nobody is trying to redefine what a man is but all of a sudden the world doesn't know what TF a woman is. Live however you want to live without trying to erase the biology of women. And Claudia was right, why is the word "woman" so damn offensive now?? And I don't need the qualifier "cis", I'm a woman period. At the end of the day it's men telling natural-born women how to be women THAT'S the fxcked up part about all of this.
it's another reverse psychology way of oppressing women, and labeled a TERF if u complain. They even hit women now for daring to push back. Some of these men might be plants.
I agree im not a cis im a woman it is getting weird out here
Good point. I haven't heard one word from transmen being so angry. It's wild
💯👏🏾💯👏🏾Exactly! We are Women!!! They can keep their pronouns.
They know better than to try try it.
Claudia, I agree with you. Why is being a natural woman offensive?
Because they can never be. Also who they really want (straight men) only wants us. That’s why they really hate us.
Because it's jealousy.
I agree.it’s pure delusion especially coming from someone with a prostrate.
It is offensive to them because it is a blatant reminder that they’re living a lie. They do not like anything that doesn’t help to solidify the lies that they’re trying to force themselves to believe.
@@iambrandivakingskidthey are BEYOND trying to convince they are trying to CONVINCE REAL WOMEN!
Honestly too many people have to tip toe around men in dresses about what being a woman is and what women should think feel and say. Im tired of them as a whole.
I’m so grateful to have this conversation! The next time I hear CIS it needs to be about an organic compound enantiomer! I’m a woman period!
Took us to chemistry class with this response 😂
What is CIS? Im a Woman... Period 🩸
I’m wondering also. What does that mean?
Some mess they made up
You definitely cis women.,
@@krystala17we don’t care! “Cis” is some bs term that jealous males made up to try to equate themselves to women.
We are natural, we are natural WOMEN period!!!
I'm a Black WOMAN AND MY nickname is Sister or Sis. I'm so damn confused!!
The term CIS is a problem for me!!!!
I’ve supported, befriended, marched with, prayed for, hung out with, invited into my homes and every time I hear the word CIS, I feel like I’ve been called the nastiest name from those that doesn’t look like me.
How come you want me to call you and address you however you want to be called, but give me new scientific names?!?! Keep it, I don’t want it. I’m upset about the new names! I am Woman, don’t add anything before it. I was born that.
You can’t make the ones that support you the most feel uncomfortable with themselves to make yourself feel comfortable and accepted when we’ve been accepting you!
Yes, labels bother people, but people always find a way to do it. Trans people exist so there's really no way around it now. It is a big change but just saying a woman isn't enough.
Every last syllable of this. 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
@@J.R.sworld That's why ppl who have transitioned to something other than their original form are identified as trans-woman/trans-man.... Those of us who have not transitioned retain the original labels of man or woman without a prefix
Facts!!!!
@@J.R.sworld nope, if women don't want to be called Cis, you got to respect her wishes, same you do for Trans people.
THANK YOU CLAUDIA!!!!! From a certain place in my soul...THANK YOU so much for speaking up and standing up for us.
The Rachel Dolezal example is 100% spot on 🙌🏾
Not all natural born women have periods but ONLY a natural born woman CAN have a period.
And that’s on PERIOD !(Pun Intended)
that was good asf 🤣
Exactly 😂😂
Period... literally😂😂😂
Yes siz. U speaking facts.
Speak truth sis!!!
This is what happens when you let mental health go unchecked. The body dismorphia and delusional thinking is REAL out here for the new generation.
Facts 💯
Exactly.
Facts! Most of these trans women are just gay men who are ashamed to be gay so they waste their time trying to convince themselves and us that they are women. The world was fine when they were known as cross dressers etc, but it wasn't enough. The delusions have gone to far now.
If their hellbent on fucking up their reproductive systems to live out this delusion then let them. Better off out of the gene pool anyway.
Proof you dont understand the science behind trns people. They have dysphoria.
You are 100 correct. This country has been playing a game for the last 13 or 14 years...since President Obama. As much as we love him he has probably unintentionally caused some serious issues within the black community because we have so many single parent household and it's hard to explain things that we never imagined. The public school system, Hollywood and the music industry is behind most of this confusion that is destroying the minds of the young.
Omg Thank you so much Claudia!! You verbalized EXACTLY how I and many women I know have been feeling! Stuck between a rock and a hard place with this and so many other issues! From the pay gap, to workplace discrimination (especially after maternity leave), it’s like the world keeps beating women down and if we even groan of discontent we get mentally and emotionally lashed! The original victims of victim blaming is the woman.
Thank you Claudia. We agree with you. Thank you for being our voice, whether it is received or not. It's exhausting. We stand up for LGBT and we don't have a dog in the fight, who stands up for us? No one. We are the ONLY ones that fight for ourselves....the only, but whn we do, we slammed for it and mansplained to about how we are wrong about being the only thing that we have only known to be....a woman. It's really sad. Thank you Claudia
Trans men ain't going to men's spaces and trying to redefine manhood because they'll get laughed out the building. But Trans women can redefine womanhood and tell women how to label themselves? How Funk and AL don't see the problem
Because (like Trans women biologically) they’re men. Men, regardless of race, are controlling, aggressive, dismissive, self absorbed
and deceivers by nature. Often views Women issues as over exaggerated and over emotional when in fact they are the emotional ones. I’m wondering if any leader of the Trans community will publicly issue a statement of apology for the obvious gaslighting or will the male pride be too overwhelming
It's simple because they choose not to see the problem. They continue on with their misogyny and have already made their allegiance.
@@MsElleCee28 I don't see them issuing an apology, in fact I see them doubling down and tripling down. They going to play the oppression Olympics card, and guilt trip women.
It's hard to defend a lie . They took biology. ♥
Transconfusion🤣
The fact that Claudia has to beg on behalf of women that transgender women let us vent and speak upon ourselves. It sounds like women trying to appeal to men to treat us better. It seems misogynistic.....still.
It's because she feels trapped and she's getting sucked into this crap - imagine being apologetic about being your true natural self so that you can accommodate someone else that's an imitation of you
We don't need any body telling us ( naturally born women) what a woman is.😂
@@tiltburnndaaa5849 EXACTLY and I feel all alone on an island with this topic. Its a very tough position to be in these days!
@@claudiajordanrealabsolutely agree
@@tiltburnndaaa5849exactly what is happening?
Claudia did a wonderful job explaining a lot of things about how we feel. It’s small things being taken from us like the female symbol off of alw. Pads. Ridiculous. Thanks Claudia
I'm not apologizing for being a natural woman, a woman from birth, a real woman and we didn’t start this fight. The person who started this recent controversy tried to "check" women about periods and femininity and we responded. This is absolutely insane.
Claudia: You don’t have to vocalize it. Every natural born woman understands exactly what you mean. ❤️
And she still trying to protect her costars. No tell the truth!!! These men are gay and they are about this gay agenda
Thank you Claudia ❤❤❤❤
I Think we all need to vocalize this cause these niggas don't get it Men never get it that's why they can't even chim in talking about its a touchy conversation acting soft and confused, us women will always go where they could never this is why they need to stay out of our lane imitating us!!!
Yall supported it. Deal with it
I ain't never seen funky or Al be so scared to speak about a topic. This transgender issue got them scared to say the wrong thing.
They claim to not know what to say as if they are confused.
Exactly I know they thinking of that check but geez
I get where you are coming from, but since this is such a "touchy" topic, it probably is best that they just listen instead of talk. At the end of the day, gay men and bisexual men are in close proximity to Women and Trans Women, so some of them don't want to jeopardize their relationships with either groups by taking a side. However, I know they have taken a side and are choosing not to share it.
@@bshainhunter U make very valid points. But its important to point out hypocrisy when we see it, even from our favs. The LGBTQ, Trans and BLM movements have asked for support and defense from their allies and Al/Funky have done that on many occasions for all these groups/movements but where is the support for biological women a.k.a natural women??? When are they going to come to our defense?
Right !!!!!!!
Notice how the lgbtq community wants all this support from us women but are silent when it comes to us being bullied and vilified and disrespectful pronouns at our expense pay attention to how males stick together no matter what and ladies let’s focus on and support us only.
Funky Diva always has something to say, never had a dog in a fight. I am not a CIS anything, re name yourself not me. You know biologically born men don't have periods. This fooloishness should be shut down. Jesus come back.
It's a respect issue, they want us to respect them while they disrespect and disregard us on every level...it's ridiculous
I agree with Claudia it feels like sometimes trans people scold us natural women for being natural women.
FACTS 💯✔️
I agree
Explain that... Why do you feel like you are in a battle? What is threatened on your end about themselves? I am totally unclear as to why natural Born women feel threatened by trans women's self proclamations.... It makes certain women appear to be insecure.
@@dtrn254 I think because for so long women had no voice and now that they have found it straight men and transgender women seem to say hey I want to be heard or we don't want to hear you or even some other siding with straight men and saying we are once again traditional so need no voice. We keep being pushed in a corner
@@ForbsieLaLa ? That's really not making any sense to me. Trans women describing themselves or expressing their own views about womanhood cant reasonably be responsible for how natural-born woman feel about themselves. That doesn't add up.
Trans women are describing what they want and how they feel. This can't trigger a woman if she is secure in her own body. A woman who was born with a vagina, uterus and breast still has her parts. So there's no territory to fight over. You can not feel threatened about losing something you already have unless you don't feel it is adequate.
I’m gay and I agree with Claudia period. This is so stupid.
I think the person was just looking for smoke and attention.
My brother in law in a trans man and in general terms I have noticed a big difference in trans men and trans women regarding the respect given to how they identify. Because trans men are biological women they tend not compete or try to take over or redline what a man is. They simply want to live in their truth but respect they will never have the same experience as biological men. However trans women because they are biological men feel the need to dominate, replace, and redefine what a woman is to suit their needs; when they will never truly know what a biological woman experiences. The anger is due to their lack of respect given to the very women they are trying to be. It actually proves how much of a man they really are.
@@vizeas Exactly. They did not transition out of toxic masculinity 😂
😅😅😅 my Bestfriend and sons godfather( gay and proud ❤) says this all the time 😅😅😅😅😅😅
@@vizeas Amazing!!!. It’s the remnants of toxic masculinity, and is misogynistic even if some fail to see the bloody irony of this attack. It’s truly bizarre!!!!Thanks for you comment… well, well stated.
You know it's ridiculous when you ain't authentic enough to tell these people the Truth and stop allowing their illusions to ruin society it's sick!
People get mad at the truth when they can’t accept it. 🤷🏽♀️
I gave birth to 5 girls(twins) Natural Births at that!! Been through Female Health Scares...almost died having my last two kids (postpartum) NOBODY in this world can tell me not to call myself a WOMAN. Being a woman is more than ..hair..nails..makeup..etc TRUST ME
F.a.c.t.s
Y'all are soooo scared to say the wrong thing. This is why they are not stopping, they are enjoying the thrill of the people being scared to disagree and everyone pleasing them out of fear...to the point of agreeing with insanity. They wont stop until everyone starts to be true to themselves and say STOP THAT'S JUST BS. Which is exactly what it is. You can cancel my ass I live on the other side of the globe anyway😂
Well said!!!!
Amen ♥
You can say that again..
NOTHING BUT FACTS HERE.
Exactly! Women need to stand ten toes down in what they know to be facts! Some trans women need to stay in their place. For this one in particular to say that was straight insanity to me. And since we are called CIS! HE here because of his momma having a period! Respect is given and if he not on that type of time then I’m not either! Hell out of here!
I'm not a woman yet to hear women being called CIS is so so offensive😶 their definitely is NO argument when the TRUTH IS THE TRUTH!!!!!!! Born male or female that's just what it is! No matter the amount of surgeries NO SHADE but facts!!!! Watching my sisters and mother deal with having a period & go through pregnancy made me thank GOD that I was born male👊🏾 hats off to all the females around the world for you definitely are💪🏾💯 Claudia you said it well it's horrible that such ugliness is being exchanged amongst woman of color no matter the issues it's the fact that once again it's the ignorance of our own at each othet🤬 there is no other transwoman going after each other's throats as our own😔 this ish is crazy to be angry about truth!!!! And that is YOUR TRANS NOT BORN no disrespect but facts! Stop this ignorance and respect self & others plz especially our own💯
You know it’s bad when Claudia is the source of sense 😂
I remember when Trump was spewing racist rhetoric & the feeling I felt when my white friends were silent. I’m getting the same feeling seeing how many gay male content creators that have NO words! The silence is so loud! Smh
Yip I thought the same thing. Some of their allegiance are loud and clear.
My fiancé (a straight male) was highly pissed at their response as well. He feels like as men they should’ve checked the former male (trans woman) who spoke on the issue. But now that I’m watching it, it seems like they (Al & Q) did agree with the stance on periods.
Woman definition is totally different depending on the individual but biological women are the only ones who can have a period not all women. So having a period shouldn't be a qualification for being a woman. But I just a man so what do I know of the subject 😂
I meant womanhood definition changes depending on the individual experience
EXACTLY!!!! sO dissapointing!
I'm upset due to the fact that I'm feeling like my existence as a WOMAN is being illuminated.
elliminated and humiliated at the same time!
But shouldn't you be mad at that one particular transexual. Because not all transsexuals thinks like that and for the most part most of the transsexuals online are not trying to erase women. They know at the end of the day that they are not women and they don't have the same body parts of a woman. I think that maybe you should make it singular because they're not putting all women in a box and basting their opinions off of one person.
Eliminated?
Illuminated means to light up though, I’m assuming you mean eliminated?
illuminated? Dummy.
Why is it even a debate? all the tagging and labelling in this world is insane.
Claudia using Rachel was a good analogy to try to explain the situation.
Claudia is spot on. Trans women have a right to exist but so do we !! I support trans but can we stop the mansplaning to us women!!
Amen the jealousy getting annoying
We support them, but they’re trying to take over all our spaces and have no respect for us
Yes trans women should have all that every human being should have, but I just want to be respected just like trans women want to be.
How are trans women preventing you from existing? Seriously how can anything they say they own or want hurt you? For example, a trans woman can claim she has a 'vagina', would that bother you? If so, does it affect your vagina or your possession of it? The same with a menstrual cycle. Why do you feel a need to even have a territorial fight about this?
Trans are fckn jealous they always coming for real women they are so disrespectful
If you put 10k trans women on an island with 10k men and wait 100 years there would be no one left. If you put 10k women and 10k men on a different island and wait 100 years there would be exponential growth in the population. It is so difficult to even be an ally in the trans community.
You are quoting someone else’s comments and trying to make it yours.
@@fosterfoster6472 Umm no not at all. If anything my inspiration is from the novels on my Kindle. Currently, reading Octavia Butler Parable of the Sower. Octavia's other series Lillith's Brood is the inspiration for my quote.
So what's your point...that two people born males can't procreate? Well duh.
@@fosterfoster6472 But its biologically and factually true...regardless of who made the comment.
100%!!!!!!!!
As a security consultant, I've studied extremism and terrorism. What ppl need to know and remember is that there needs to be an understanding that when it comes to ppl in general, there will ALWAYS be an extreme few. That goes for race, religion, culture, nationality, gender etc. Those extreme few are the loud ones bc they lack the ability to place certain categories in their respective places. Yes, some categories can overlap, however, that doesn't mean you pick up Category A and place it in Category B without acknowledging ALL the differences of why there's a Category A.
Would we be having this same conversation if the trans men were in a uproar and telling men they don’t own manhood 🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️
A woman is a woman... what the hell is cis?
sounds like an infection to me. Do not let other people defined who you are. We are Women.............I go by God's definitions anyway.
@@JB-ch9gtnot an infection🤣🤣..it does!😂😂
I am a woman period. I do not Identify as cis woman
Preach Claudia. Rachel Dozel is a very good example.
RACHEL IS NOT TO BE COMPARED. SHE LIED. TRANSWOMEN DONT LIE. PLEASE DO YOUR RESEARCH BEFORE AGREEING LOL THATS LIKE A TRANS SAYING THERE WAS NO TRANSITION INVOLVED. I WAS JUST BORN FEMALE. NO TRANSWOMEN IS SAYING THST. RACHEL LITERALLY ILLUMINATED THAT SHE WAS BLK AND NOTHING ELSE. TRICKED A COMMUNITY WITH NO EXPLANATION
That is a good point.
!!!
Excellent example it's totally comparable!
But how does Rachel or a trans woman impact your own body or your sense of womanhood.... I don't care if Rachel claims she is black. And I don't care how trans decide to identify themselves. So the problem seems to be with you.
I keep hearing women say they don't want their periods, well I'll be a rare one to say that I'm grateful to God for getting a period since 11 years old because God has strengthened me through years of that pain, building me up to prepare me to carry and birth my children. We sit around bashing our periods, research the importance of our periods and how it stregthens our bones and cardiovascular health.
It’s misogyny.
Trans women need to take a deep look at themselves because we don’t have to include them but we do because we are compassionate.
It’s crazy “they” want people to respect there pronouns but when borned women ask to be called women then it’s offensive and we have disrespected trans women. That’s why I don’t feel no ways about trans women. Do what you do but leave us borned women alone.
exactly
Them things are jealous of real women..They need to stop with the Sis shit …
It’s not about our life has changed on a daily basis. It’s about certain trans people trying to tell us about what defines womanhood and what makes a woman when they’re not even biologically a woman. It’s offensive.
Exactly it really is
I think the outrage also speaks to the possibility of trans women dominating that space in the future.
Transwomen are not trying to tell you how to be a woman -- stop lying. They are telling you how they see themselves. As a result you feel territorial and insecure about something that you say you already have. Why do you care?
@@dtrn254 Ok..Well they shouldn't care when we call them by terms they deem disrespectful.
@@dtrn254 a trans woman is a man who once again is trying to define what a woman is or isn’t. Another example of men trying to once again control women and their womanhood. Women are left powerless to defend themselves against this insanity.
I use to really like being friendly & friends not them . Always respect ... But now I find myself rolling my eyes at them and keeping my distance since I found out they really hate naturally born women . ....
Thank you Claudia. This is gone too far now. Can’t have nothing now we’re debating periods. If they knew what periods actually are and did they wouldn’t want them. Go sit down and be happy.
If I may take a stab at this. To answer Funky’s question: Black women are feeling unheard, unwanted, and abandoned. We are at the bottom of the totem pole and we are reminded in every aspect that we are. To the whites, we are feared, and dangerous. To heterosexual Black men, we are intimidating, aggressive, and angry, hence, they date and marry white women. To each other (Black women to Black women), we don't fit into other’s cliques and are jealous of one another. And now the LBGT+ community, we find reasons to complain.
I agree with Claudia, everything is happening all at once and we can't deal. We feel like there's a lack of support, instead, it's a justification. We don't want to be called “Cis”: the justification - “It's not a slur, it's a scientific word....” We don't want to be called “fish”: the justification - it's a term of endearment. Everywhere we turn, we are getting torn apart and we are tired and we are not getting the respect that we should receive but we're expected to bow down to others.
It is exhausting being a Black woman!
You need to take it up with your Kangz of No Kingdom...that's where 99% of your plight lies.
*Totem pole
He really was being funny on the cool even asking that
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Quinn dressed up as a woman name Funky Dineva
You have to accept the truth for what it is and not for what you want it to be. I think society is so focused on changing basic dynamics to appease people’s feelings. It just is what it is: trans women are not women, there is a distinction.
💯💯💯💯💯👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Calling us "CIS" Women alone, is flat out disrespectful. Let's start there!! Are we as women just going to accept this🤔🤔 and I'm lesbian. This shi is out of control, the LGBTQ+ is doing wayyyy too much. Keep adding stuff every 5 seconds and Trans women are getting on my nerves trying to BULLY people into accepting the fact that they believe that they are natural born women and they're NOT!! Trans men don't even take it as literal as trans women. And God forbid you say something that are proven FACT scientifically, spiritually and/or realistically....your labelled as homophobic and you lose your career!! This is sad and I'm sick of black women continuously getting disrespected and no one sticks up for us!! Whether you're gay, straight or Trans - stick up for US naturally born women. We are losing our voice and people with a huge platform need to stand up and stand on it!!
Thank you for speaking for us women since it seems bio women are under attack. And what is your last name so I can start practicing how to sign my new signature 😆
These comments are full of insecure women. What I think it's about is trans women are beginning to look more and more feminine and attractive to straight men. Natural born women are feeling insecure about their own bodies.
@@lizliz1657 😂😂😂😂
It may be transphobic, but man .. I’m a woman. We DO OWN WOMANHOOD. WE ARE WOMANHOOD.
So we say we don't want to be referred to as Cis and they continue to use it. Should we be equally disrespectful when it comes their desired pronouns and dead-names?!
I stand with Claudia and Jess. There is no competition we are born women they are not period. God makes no mistakes and Jess is not wrong for standing up for women. We are tired of being bullied and told we are wrong for defending ourselves when we as black women are constantly under attack for our gender race etc. Jess stated facts she will not be cancelled real women will not allow that to happen
More women need to vocalize the fact that some trans women are out right disrespectful. One of my trans woman “friend” said she hates women. Just like that. She said she doesn’t like the esthetic of a woman. I asked her “why would you say that when you are literally posing as one”? She said because she love heterosexual men and women always get in the way. I finally realized that is the root of all this anger and wanting to be included in womanhood. It’s envy
What makes that argument of “ i date heterosexual men” so stupid is that men who date trans women are not straight 😭
Exactly
Yeah. That cherry the boom one was.
They think that we are the ones that make heterosexual men not want them
Since when does men listen or do what women say
We’re not telling heterosexual men not to date them
It never clicks to them that maybe majority (not all) bio heterosexual men only want bio heterosexual women
It’s all strange
All this envy for women because of the men they want 🤦🏽♀️
Crazy thing is men don’t treat trans no better
A man mansplaining what womanhood is.
Its unbelievable.
I usually agree with Funky Dineva but he was so scared to speak against his community. That’s why he said he and Al would let someone else come on besides them to speak on the issue. They’re both scared to upset the gays.
Cluadia❤❤❤ At the end of the day its men telling women how to feal about womanhood
Facts....they need to just let that part go.
Look as a transwoman myself, this whole situation is STUPID AS HELL to me.... Some of these girls out here are taking things TOO FUCKIN FAR!!!!! We have our own lane for the most part, everything is NOT MEANT FOR US, THAT'S JUST THE BOTTOM LINE
Thanku
Thank you
You understand ❤
Thank you
THANK YOU❤
I'm a gay black man and I agree with Claudia 100%! Thank you for speaking from the heart
I’m sick of it! I’m a woman and never can a TRANFORMER tell me about womanhood!!
I appreciate you Claudia. The reason we have an issue around Trans Women Vs Natural Women is we're trying to call two sets of people who are completely different, the same. We actually have little in common in terms of gender identity, because we identify with the bodies we're in, therefore have absolutely no idea what gender dysphoria feels like . So we don't relate experientially, nor do we relate biologically. It's slogans like "Trans Women are Women," that has blurred the lines in a very unhelpful way.
Trans women are trans women. Very different but both equal & worthy of respect & dignity.
Best comment
They are men, they are males. Humans can't transition between genders, and gender isn't a stereotypical costume
Trans women literally identify as women, think like women, and feel like women and the only difference is they were not born in a female body. They often never felt comfortable in male bodies and never felt like men.
@ VenusEnergy3 .... Lol. Your just now getting it. You Democrats stay getting fooled. You supported it. Now deal with it . And don't you dare try to blame this on men? Black women were the biggest supporters of this abomination to God.
I find it offensive as a natural born woman to be labeled cis. How can you label others and you don't want to be labeled. I'm so tired and done with that whole movement of everything being shoved down my throat and acting like is wrong to be a natural woman.
That’s their agenda because they hate us because they can’t be us no matter what they do to themselves. If we speak out against their terminology against us, women, we’re labeled “Transphobic” and all women know that’s B.S.
You said it so well Claudia. Just because they twist and wear more mackup than women, it will never give you the true up and up on what a girl who grows up to be a woman is feeling. If I could I would gladly give you the Periods and the Child Births. No Fights Here Have It😂😅
Claudia explained it perfectly!
Insane to think biological women do not own periods and womanhood! When a young teen girl starts her menstrual cycle, it’s a sign from God letting her know she is growing into womanhood. It’s a miracle from God to let her know that she can now conceive, carry life that God creates, and give birth. Yes, we own periods! The years of money being spent on feminine protection! Yes, we own periods…cramps, bloating, mood swings, and all! We own it! It’s the miracle God blessed biological women with! The years of Pap smears, pelvic exams, mammograms, etc. to take care of our uterus, ovaries, fallopian tubes, cervix, vagina, and breasts! We own womanhood! We nurture and take care of it. And womanhood isn’t just physical. Biological women own womanhood. If anyone has a problem with this concept, then get on your knees and have a conversation with God…because womanhood is His power.
ALL OF THIS👏👏
I had mine at 10 so younger than a teenager you have in mind
All of this!!🎉
Well men sure as hell don’t own anything about us!
💯💯💯💯
It’s sad that we live in a society where we are forced to ignore biological, factual, realities. We are forced to affirm delusional thinking. Now you can identify as anything because of a “feeling”. We have to tiptoe around the truth in an effort to feed into someone else’s false reality. I can’t believe we are having this debate and having to defend our biological state as women. And yes Q, men entering into jail and impregnating women is an issue, men entering into women’s sport, men entering into our bathroom and society telling our children that they can change their sex because gender is not “real” is a damn big issue. God help us all.
Preach
You can tell where this is going. All the blurred lines will lead to what no one is saying.
@@darienwilliams6070 It is time. Woman have been being way too nice for way to long especially black women listening to some ignorant people that were born men bash us over and over again on this Internet.
Claudia, I have so much respect for you because you've been doing your research. You trying to be understanding of what's going on cuz we all learning and we don't want to disrespect each other but we We got to figure out how we can love and exist and respect each other till we figure all this stuff out
I’m all the way down with Claudia and what she said…You don’t get to change what I call myself to suit your narrative.
Claudia, you worded it perfectly! If natural born women are asking not to be called "Cis" gender women, please respect it. Especially in the pronoun movement we are living in.
Don’t participate in that crap, I don’t, I won’t. I will call them as I see them if they don’t like it too bad don’t converse with me! I’m not lying to feed their fantasies and delusions about themselves. They’re expecting us to lie for them and that’s the sick part. I abhor the terms cis, birthers, bleeders. We are WOMEN!
Dang…looks like the Trans community have Al and Funky SHOOK !..They were scared to death to say anything negative about all that foolishness that TW was saying, they left it all up to Claudia.
I thought the same thing!
Al and Funky punked out literally!!!!! They want to represent their LGBTQ Community! Only men and women can produce life. 🧬
Even got defensive. Funky doesn’t know what changed with women. Attempting to redo fine women nicca. Are you dumb. Stop the bs
Because they're not transgender why would they input in something they don't know about durr they had to pass on this discussion and I understand.
@@AsianNonBinaryyou don’t have to be trans to know what a woman and man is. What? Womanhood is a matter is biologically, a man can never be a woman no matter how strongly he identifies, no matter the level of hormones he takes, and that goes for women who think they are men as well. They are men, they know what a man is, they can speak but are afraid and that’s sad.
This topic is becoming so infuriating because woman have fought for decades to get equal right and pay as men and now we have men dressing up as woman telling us who we are and what we are…..I’m tired of it
That's the problem right there...yall wanted to be equal to men when you should be below men...so since yall wanna be men so bad, the men are taking your spot as women...maybe that will make you value womanhood more
This is the problem….people never want to state the facts because they are scared of the ABCEF backlash. So sad…
I find it funny for gay blk men to say they don't have a dog in the fight but have always wanted allyship from "cisgender" women. Make it make sense.😂
But I thought I didn't want to be called cisgender?
@@krystaldouglas1305 hints the quotations
Come on guys let’s back up the ladies I’m gay and all these trans bashing biological woman is uncall and unfair we need to protect and back up our woman.
💯🎯
Thank you! The fact that Q said he doesn’t have a dog in this fight really illuminates the core issue, natural black women remain unsupported, unprotected, and under constant pressure to meet the highest standards/expectations.
I am a woman, not a cis woman. Just because people want to appease transgender women, it doesn't mean we need to adjust the name we are called.
Claudia keep speaking truth we real women still exist
I enjoyed Claudia's explanation. It was a measured expression of her frustrations and I understood where she was coming from.
I'm confused, you are a transgender woman and they are biological women. What's the argument about.
Chiiile you ain’t the only one “confused”. 🫤🤦🏽♂️
Facts!
No confusion. Cisgender women are creating an imaginary issue. Trans women never said they have the same type of monthly hormonal changes as cisgender women.
The confusion is on their part they just expect the rest of us to co-sign it
@@ww8407no transgenders is creating the probably acting like they have monthly hormones themselves. You cant sit there and say some stupid shitt like women do own periods. That don't make sense.
Claudia❤ you're on point ! If you're not a woman you can't understand the feeling of a woman . I'm in my 50's started my period at 9 and stopped at 46 I hated my period all my life partially because I got it at such a young age I didn't understand my body at that time .
They are doing the exact thing that they don't wont done to them. They are trying to define us in terms that we don't want to be defined as. They are taking the word "woman " accepting as their own, and trying to relabel us.
I swear, Claudia is my spirit sista 🙌🏾🙌🏾! She said exactly 💯 what I think and feel. And it’s pushing me to the point of not given a f*** what the trans community feels anymore. I’m sick and tired that I now have to defend my womanhood and experience as a biological woman to those that weren’t born biologically female that at the end of the day are men mansplaining to me of what it means to be a “real” woman! And I have been a very liberal black female voter for many years, but it’s now making me become less liberal and more moderate in moving forward with my vote and who’ll I support. A Trans woman will never know how it FEELS that having your right to bodily autonomy of your reproductive rights stripped away and have to worry that at any point if I get raped, I will now be forced to bring a life into the world with ZERO regard of my womanhood and or humanity. ZERO!!!! So forgive us for thinking that “womanhood” should only apply to biological women that would have to make that life/death choice. At the end of the day we would be the ones going to jail, and or losing our lives in childbirth. Thank you.
Beautifully said.
This made me stop voting on the liberal side. because a bio man will never...............Glad you guys are starting to wake up
Yea I'm to that point where I really don't give two shits to advocate for them anymore. They are disrespectful, misogynistic, delusional, and dismissive af.
Funny how women are fighting for womanhood, yet only women can get pregnant and ya'll get angry people won't let you kill your babies.
Claudia, you did a great job of explaining it.
It’s always a dude telling a female what to do lol
Q... the idea of that show was perfect. The townhall type of DISCUSSION hopefully would give people a space to learn and to teach. If the panel and the audience walk away with RESPECT for one another then hopefully this subject would lessen the toxic and divisive emotions to a point that other panels/people would occur to help start the healing process.
And Claudia I have been a fan for a long while .... your take on this subject shows that there is room for all at The Table that's in The Room. Bravo! With allies like you across the board there's a mustard seeds weight of Hope brought into this dung pile 🖤🖤
Wth is CIS woman? I'm a woman
Basically its a real woman a heterosexual woman thats the term used in the community for non trans women
YES YOU ARE AND DON'T EVER LET ANYONE TELL YOU ANYTHING DIFFERENT 🙌🏿
A cisgender woman is a woman that is born with a vagina. It is the opposite of a Trans woman. It really not that serious lol. Stop playing victim.
😂😂Girl..I know, the terms!!!But someone below explained it well! The Cis part is Latin, used to explain sameness. Same as I was born is how I identify now. But, you are a Woman…no need to define yourself any other way, and I agree!
The nerve of a trans woman to talk down to biological woman on their own bodies😅. We've been saying it for the longest time that these alphabet letter people are out to get biological women and only now people are seeing it
Yall are fake victims. The fact that yall think Trans women are your enemy is wild. Lol
This is what happens when you go along with delusions
@@alexprovence9379That's right
The fact that both Funky and Al was being obtuse spoke volumes. I was really disappointed in Al's non response. Funky on the other hand didn't surprise me....pretending not to understand why women are offended. Funky Dineva do not like women (especially black women)! We are good for a keke or to be gossiped about, but never to be taking serious or protected. Why do you think he hates Flame Monroe? It's because he tells the truth and Funky knows this, but would never acknowledge it. Women need to be more selective of the men we support because it's obvious from this clip that both Al and Funky don't give about biological women. Sad that Claudia had to stand alone and say what's already known.
First of all, it’s very disrespectful to say, sis Women we are not sis Women we are Women PERIOD!!!
The way Claudia had to tip toe and search for the right words to articulate her feelings is very telling and extremely sad. Natural born black women can't do shxt. We can't own who we are without being beat in the head...everyone piles on us and piles on us and when we break all of a sudden we are the problem. All we do is support support support and everyone from ALL walks of life don't support us and oppress and bully us into what they deem submission. I don't care that the term CIS is a medical term that's been in existence since however long. If a natural born woman does not want to be referred to as CIS then respect that. Leave us tf alone and let us live and show us the same respect you would want for yourselves...we can't do shxt if we even breathe it's a problem.
You said that right
Yup she tiptoed her ass off. I prefer Jess Hilarious's approach. Claudia and all of them on the show were scared. Just keep it 💯
Yes to keep protecting these “men”. And they think it’s funny and cute. This shh is scary
They can’t. They are men who want to control!!! Misogynist
I know that's right, but my problem was the two dudes saying they wants no parts of it they don't want to really speak on it. Bro ya'll men why ya'll not standing with these women. Am I the only guy that's standing on women side. Fuk the gay shit stand in the right is what you are supposed to do to protect our women wtf. It's shouldn't matter if you're not trans still stand up for what's right. It's said you go live with these men ans they not really standing up for women like come on you a man man that shit for once dam. I honestly hate when weak men get scared and not speak fuk that I'm gone speak my mind. The gay community is horrible and separated. The young gays do think their running it at times. I don't agree with calling women cis women, they're women. Technically you should be calling Mrs, Miss, Ms or Ma'am to be respectful. Ya'll really scared of the young trans that are men you joking right. Chile ladies I got ya'll back fuk that I'm on your side with this one.
Having a period is a beautiful thing! You get to give birth. It’s a gift. It’s painful sometimes but it makes us creators
I agree.
Exactly. And Im not giving it away to ANYONE!
And they wish they had them! IDC what they say! They wish they could have that whole women experience
OMG! 6:12 is so accurate. I told my GF this just two months ago. Remember they are still men, men like to dominate there spaces
Im fedup with everyone saying the sex is assigned at birth. Sex of a baby is determined at the moment of conception. I knew I was having a boy months before he was born as I had a scan. A biological man cannot have a period. That man is delusional
Lets start with this....
Im CIS nothing.
I'm a WOMAN. PERIOD!
@Claudia- Do you see how those 2 men refused to speak out against their community. (When what was said was clearly wrong) We as black women may need to start rethiinking who we lend our support to. The biggest artiist on the planet has a whole tour out that is dedicated to that community, and this is how little they think of us.
Amen
They never speak out against their own. They see it blatantly and don’t hold them accountable. Instead they bombard their way into women’s spaces and never help fight for things women are fighting for. I’m starting to wonder if they are just infiltrators who want to end feminism movement. So dress as women infiltrate the spaces posing as women and realign the laws language and legalities to affect real women. They are just posing as women anyway because they know when to use their convenient male card when it’s time to expose men for having a sexual relationship with them. Then all the sudden the world needs to know that they are not born a woman. They help perpetuate their own stigmas and play victim when they are met with violence and when women tell them they are not women. This is lunacy!!! Then after they successfully change women’s rights to suit men they can take off their costumes again when it’s convenient and women will be left to pick up the pieces and fight for our next step.
Y’all ask for this calling us heterosexual men “toxic”
@@spade2187 Yall are toxic. Has nothing to do with this
@spade2187 these are two gay men. You aren't a woman but if you want to talk about this then go ahead.
Who wants a seven day curse!!
-excruciating pain
-throwing up
-mental and emotional breakdown
-physical exhaustion and worse!!!
It’s trying to be in competition with us for straight men is what I gather why there’s tension. Tension mostly coming from the transwomen and sometimes gay men who try to date/approach straight men. side to be honest. It’s the disrespect for me… like how can you hate the very group of people who birthed you into this world and then turn around and want to imitate us?! That’s what I don’t get.