The Problems With Blaire White - Misinformation And "Moderation" | TRO
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 05. 2024
- The Problems With Blaire White - Misinformation And "Moderation" | TRO
0:00:00 - Introduction
0:06:20 - Setting The Scene
0:13:50 - The Anti-Feminist
0:21:54 - The Good One
0:29:25 - The Playground
0:37:39 - A New Leaf
0:47:37 - Changes
0:56:42 - One Step Back
1:04:28 - A New Calling
1:13:19 - Ground Hog Day
1:22:23 - God I'm So Done
1:31:38 - The Moderate
1:42:06 - The Hill
1:51:12 - The Fall
2:00:34 - The Apology
2:09:47 - Credibility
2:17:32 - The Blaire White Saga
2:24:39 - It Never Ends
2:32:42 - Moderation
2:46:00 - Conclusion & Credits
Intro:
I recall back to my Q&A in March, when The Nostradamus Opinion announced that the year seemed to calming down, which in hindsight, was a slightly a misguided forecast, in fact, I’d positively say it was a kiss of death, as the world has careened towards its frankly, well-deserved armageddon.
Honestly, I’ve not handled it too well personally, to see so much going on often makes me want to curl up into a ball and hibernate, or aestivate if you consider when all this was happening. At the same time, there’s always reason within the chaos, and I’ve always lived by the philosophy that I’d emerge from hardships a wiser man, and a part of me hopes that would be similarly applicable on a macro level as well. However, we’ll never reach that if we can’t have a proper, mature discussion to understand how such discord has arisen, and at times where emotions can run high we often need voices of reason to lead that discourse forward, so that we can all learn from such adversities.
In the past few years in particular, I feel that CZcams has become increasingly integral to that conversation, introducing a new generation to the many complex, and sometimes not as complex matters facing down today’s youth, with online creators engaging audiences through fresh mediums, acquainting them with new ideas and perspectives. Although the nature of my channel can be a little biographical, I hope that people have found value in the viewpoints I have to share. And you know what? I’d say the feedback has been broadly positive. One way that people recognise the work you do is what some regard as “Year end lists”, where people compile a selection of their favourite creators, and post it to their preferred social media site.
At the end of 2019, I was once again honoured by being placed amongst CZcamsrs who put great effort into their respective hustle, however, one name whose presence I was surprised to see was a commentator by the name of Blaire White.
Want to know more? Watch the video...
Credits are here as YT being sus again in removing my pinned comments, until then, I'm off to my black hole:
docs.google.com/document/d/1OCQXyYmuMoL9JQsmDrsN9IZDob39awTumedXOwop3k0/edit?usp=sharing
I recently appeared in a podcast too :) : czcams.com/video/cxRX4eNAt_U/video.html
*Reply with Ok*
*For 69 RObux*
CAN'T WAIT WOOHOO NEW TRO UPLOAD
Nice.
thou shall mr
Woo new upload
TRO mentioning D’Angelo watches his videos is such a subtle flex
he understood the assignment lmafo
anyone who dan watches has officially made it
Well he actually said "he's probably watching" which does leave some room for error ❤️
@Conservative Loli Waifu it's not an ideology... Also her having hypocritical opinions doesn't give you a right to misgender them
@@nobetawedielikemysanity they’re a troll.
now let me repeat:
*you can criticize blaire and not be transphobic at the same time*
Go say that in a Riley Dennis comment section about Riley and allow her audience to "educate " you of the otherwise
THIS! Criticize the person’s actions, not their identity it doesnt have anything to do with their actions
Exactly. Like with the case of Nikita Dragun, she's a pretty awful person in general and is constantly trying to pit herself against cis women out of a personal sense of insecurity and she has a lot of faults to be addressed but doing that by misgendering her or saying she's not a real woman does nothing more than make you stoop down to her level
Not only you can, but you should.
Let's not play her game, because we're going to lost.
Challenging her ideas directly is the best way to go about it.
Agreed, we should see people as human beings that do stupid things, gender, sexuality and any other identifying factor have nothing to do with that
When she spoke of women being treated so nicely she neglected to specify pretty women, because if as a woman you don't conform to social beauty standards or behavioral standards treatment will not always be nice...which she herself shows by shaming the looks of many women...
thats pretty privilege not sexism
You just forgot to say that for the huge majority of men "a pretty woman" isn't actually that pretty (As a gay guy myself I know what I'm talking about). So the beauty standard bar for women are already pretty low.
It's women who are bad towards other women and even men. The whole thought of "pretty privilege" literally matches with the common thought that most women has about men's height (If you're less than 6''tall you're ugly), just proving that this type of thought is majoritaly women and you're just reproducing their prejudice, but blaming men (Like most women also do) instead.
@@pedrovitor5324 This "pretty privilege" concept sounds stupid, since the concept of pretty are very subjective for every individual. So no one can actually measure it.
OP’s comment made so much sense, what happened to the replies 😅😭
@@user-ks5ef2su9i
War is what happened in the comment
Not only she has the biggest "pick me" personality, but she's also the face for "I didn't go through that experience, therefore it's not real"
She made herself the token trans friend of the right so they can be like “we’re not transphobic! we have Blaire on our side!!”
She's the trans version of candace owens
Someone having views that differ from most others in her community doesn’t make her “pick me”. I Iove Blaire and I agree with almost everything she says. There’s only a couple other trans CZcamsrs that share the same views as Blaire. So just because she happens to be one of the only trans republican CZcamsrs she’s a pick me? That’s not what a pick me is lmao. Y’all preach love and acceptance until it’s towards someone with different views than y’all. And her views are like common sense… idk how anyone can disagree with her, like she literally just goes off of logic. People need to understand that facts don’t care about your feelings, and I don’t even mean that in a rude way, but she just goes off of logic and outs emotions aside and I think we need more of that.
@@DrTimeSCPPsych nahh Candice is awful she’s wayyy worse, I hate her. And read my comment above. Ima Blaire Stan. But Candice sucks ass. I’m not even a republican, I’m a centrist with more right leaning views, but like I’m pro choice and stuff. Blaires never mentioned her stance in abortion, but Candace is very loud about it and I can’t stand that. She’s also just wayyyy more right winged than Blair. She’s just downright transphobic, she was misgendering Blaire didn’t give a single fuck (in front of her face). She’s a right winged extremist. Any extreme is bad, left extremists are bad and so are right extremists. So yeah, while I love Blaire, Candace is vile.
@ラテちゃん right?!? It’s like they live in autopilot with no original thought, they just go around spewing new buzzwords that they hear without even putting a single thought into what they’re saying💀 I used to be a liberal in my teens, now that I’m 22 I’m a centerist with more right leaning views (I’m pro choice for life tho, as a rape survivor). I feel like a lot of ppl are liberals in their teens only to join the dark side as an adult😭
So inspirational to know that no matter what gender you're assigned at birth or how old you are, you ALWAYS have the chance to become a high school mean girl.
High school mean girl is not assigned at birth or age, it transcends those terms lol (then evolving into sorority mean and then graduating as a Karen.)
Her final transformation will be into a Karen.
Edit: Oh no someone already wrote the same thing.
flippin gold lmao
I find it quite interesting that the most “liberal” people cannot utterly stand any stance that does not coincide with their own personal beliefs regardless of the factual evidence and objectivity of the opposite opinion. Blair is simply stating that the scientific validity of trans people (demonstrated and repeated) is COMPLETELY INVALIDATED when it is in opposition of how “somebody feels”
@@scribble6229 There is a lot going on here, but I am shocked you went into the comment section of a near 3 hour long video detailing Blaire repeatedly invalidating other trans people for brownie points even if they fit into her definition of trans and then decided to accuse others of refusing to listen to others opinions when they say they don't like her lmao
not her questioning why abuse victims stay in abusive relationships???? what ?!
My parents stayed together for 15 years, the reason was because my mother was afraid that my sister and me would be taken away from her by him. I hate people like Blair who cannot even be bothered to research these things.
(EDIT) Rewatching the video(Is My Boyfriend Gay?.. timestamp 6:55), I retract my claim of her boyfriend punching her when they first met, that was a different trans woman that her boyfriend punched.
I remember when she was talking about how her and her boyfriend/fiance first met, he literally punched her in the face and left her on the beach.
@@kurotea4131 wtf when did she say that?
Yeah I was looking for that too… Then I remembered that this video was already 3 hours long lol he probably had to cut some stuff
@@kurotea4131 omg I remember that! I think it was in one of her vlogs on her blaire black channel
The fact that even the onion man was shook at her racism… wild.
It really does take a lot to shock the onion
Heartbreaking: the worst person you know has a point.
@@averyspecificdragon8780 hell never have a point
You know it's bad when the onion man is on the right side
It was probably a fake reaction 😂
Can you imagine earnestly saying the women have an easier life overall because sometimes men hold doors open for them?
Honestly, seen too many men, women, and NBs believe that very sentiment.
Although that wasnt the sole argument for her point but yeah, i dont think people should be trying to pitch the genders against each other and see who has it harder, both men and women have their own problems.
@@icantthinkofagoodnameso1954 💯
Honestly we shouldn't be fighting about who has it worse women or men, both have their own issues which are both equally important.
I was born female and ain’t no one do that around here
it's interesting how blaire seems to understand they/them pronouns whenever she doesn't want to use the correct pronouns for whoever she's bullying.
Hahaha good point!
good point
its interesting that you even say that considering 90% of “those people” are all disgusting predators. but sure, lets pretend that a predators pronouns should be respected. lol 👏😒
@@FARSIKATZ i don't think anyone is calling for her to respect a predator, in fact, the point is if she can use they/them for predators then how come she's so opposed to using they/them for people who genuinely use those pronouns? and instead disrespects them? lmao make it make sense
@@hellgirlnextdoor I’ve genuinely seen people get upset about people not respecting Jessica Yanivs pronouns for example, a good several people kept correcting her and others and felt jessicas pronouns should of still been respected. it’s gross.
I will never forget..
The young woman that Onision and Kai had groomed and abused CONFIDED in Blaire to tell their story to the internet. The girl spilled her heart out with absolutely disgusting allegations and Blaire ends the video like "Yeah, I'm really sorry that happened to you.. ANYWAYS I'm HAVING A BIG BIRTHDAY PARTY BASH THIS WEEKEND."
It really rubbed me the wrong way. She used Sarah for views.
She never really cared about "the children", only if that would bring her wievs and sell merch.
Guess it justifies why she wears clown makeup. It’s reflective of her personhood 🤡
Yes, she did. She didn't realize how that came off, I remember it too, but she cared about the girl & was very cool with her.
@@MegaTaximan You're right, a normal civilized person would know how that sounded, not a lack-of-empathy, narcissistic "My words are the only truth" kind of person. You got us there.
@@MegaTaximan I appreciate your willingness to give benefit of the doubt but no one is that clueless all the time
i was called a sjw for saying that people don't know how to sit down and just enjoy movies anymore. i then proceeded to ask them to explain how I was being a sjw. they proceeded to only repeat "okay sjw" blatantly ignoring my genuine question.
let me guess it happened on the blue bird app😃
@@yeeshieyeeshie yeah no this was on CZcams. I wish it was Twitter. At least it would make SOME sense
@Sweener amen.
How to enjoy a movie:
Sit down
Turn off phone
Watch the movie
What exactly did they think warranted the sjw aspect? Is there any kind of context to that, or were they just jerks?
@@ArDeeMee I'd bet it was related to a movie that had some progressive aspect that made the conservative internet angry, and this user said what they said about just enjoying a movie and since they were saying it about something that made the conservative user upset, it must be SJW behavior in their mind
Look. I'm a straight woman In her 30s. I've known what trans is since I was like 5 cause of my mom's coworker. They taught us what it meant. My sister's best friend when we were little was gay. It made no effect on us. It just taught us that people are different.
Yes, because children are naturally accepting. But I'm sure they didn't make you question your own gender, or asked you what your pronouns are. That is the difference between then an now. Alot of supposed woke people are literally trying to indoctrinate kids into being confused about themselves, and what is appropriate. And alot of gay an trans people don't approve that, but are demonized like Blaire.
I only discovered it around last year in 2022 ...
Exactly. I am pan and nonbinary and all my younger siblings know and understand that but it doesn't affect them at all. The only thing that changed was name and pronouns. Who I like and how I identify dosen't affect their life in any way.
@@lovelylipbonesouwwwwwwwolv2198 it is cause your parents didn't want to teach you there are different people all around us.
@@ReaderAres13 sorry but non-binary is the biggest malarkey I've ever heard in my life. I support everything else though.
I can't stop thinking about how she's so lucky she was able to transition at an early age and is cis passing. Otherwise, the side she tries so hard to please would kick her to the curve even farther
She doesn't really pass. I was watching her the other day and my husband passed behind me and asked why I was watching a transgender. It's super obvious if you actually look at her.
@@lecatnegro7113 I assume your husband thinks every woman who doesn't have a thin oval face is "a transgender"
@@skeleletonboi4533 bone structure, shoulder width, forhead width, hands, etc
@@lecatnegro7113 so.. yes?
Maybe it's a curse in disguise, if she wasn't "accepted" she might have had to really rethink her positions and become a better and more mature person.
gotta love how she talks about how trans people aren't a monolith in describing herself as a conservative and then goes on to discount other people as trans because they don't fit her exact experience as a trans person.
edit: dear lord. now i remember why i never comment on videos. shout out to the few people who are having at least somewhat civil discussions tho I guess lmao
"Trans people are a monolith wait your trans new don't pass and you are trying to like fit into my idea of what you should be you're not actually trans I know everything"- why no one really takes Blair seriously
>she
@@valinor5397 Yes, she.
@@InfiniteDeckhand this is such a simple retort but it makes me so happy to see people stand up for trans identities
@@Princetopher_ Blaire White is a shitty person for sure, but that's no excuse to say transphobic things about her. At least that's how I see it.
I will never understand why some people insist on sucking up to people who clearly hate their guts.
The life story of pick me girls sucking up to men.
That's what I keep telling "white allies" who spend all their time bending the knee to black racists who will hate them no matter how much they grovel on the knees before the altar of wokeness.
So yeah, great point.
I love blair, you hate her
@@clarabruselas8444yes yea such a valuable insight, “sucking up to people who hate you is bad for you” is such a hateful attitude. We must all hate Blair since we want her to focus on and listen to people who don’t hate her. That’s exactly how you treat someone with *hate*
Imagine basing your political opinion on whether a group of people like you or not... Not like, actual policies or anything.
Didn’t she literally say her first memory was of how she didn’t feel like a boy but like a girl? How can she say “how can a 4-year-old know??” When she herself apparently knew?
Edit: since apparently it has to be said, I’m not talking about hormone shots for kids or surgery, I’m referring to them being allowed to try out different pronouns and social transitioning.
Simple, when I was a boy, I sometimes thought I wanted to be a girl. I'm a 31 year old man now & thankful I didn't have adults around me at that time to think of transitioning me just because I acted feminine. Lots of kids want to be the opposite. Lots of kids also want to be animals and dinosaurs. It doesn't mean they should be put through permanent changes that alter their bodies. If someone has genuine gender dysphoria, than they should transition when their old enough.
@@finalshock5685 notice how you said “sometimes” and “thought I wanted to be”? To trans people, at least from what I can understand from talking and listening to their stories, it’s not “want to be” or “sometimes” it’s “is” and “always”. It’s the feeling of being one thing, but others are saying you’re something else. It’s that they know what gender they are, it just doesn’t match the one on the paper.
Like, if it wasn’t a constant, deep, almost-painful feeling, where you simply knew you weren’t what others were saying you were, to the point of hating yourself/detesting your body or crying on a regular basis, because you felt trapped and frustrated that your body wasn’t the way you knew it should be, maybe that’s why you didn’t transition? Cuz that’s what I’ve read a lot of trans people describe it. It’s not “oh, today I’m playing that in a dinosaur, cuz dinosaurs are cool, so it would be cool to be a dinosaur!”, it’s “I am this gender, I’m always this gender and I’ve never been my assigned at birth gender, and I’m not playing, this is who I am”.
Like, I’m somewhat short, slightly below average. I was told, as a child (when I was very short) that I could have an operation that would lengthen my bones a bit, but it’d need 1 or more operations and I’d need to take medication like injections for the rest of my life afterwards. Did o want to be a bit taller? Sure. But did I want to go through medical procedures and daily injections to maintain it for the rest of my life? No. I kinda wanted something, but not to the point I was willing to go through all that. In other words, I liked the idea of it a bit, but as soon as it meant working for it/going through uncomfortable things every day, I lost all interest. If someone is willing to go through all the things a trans person has to go through to feel comfortable with themselves and to reach the point where their outward appearance is who they feel inside, don’t you think it’s a bit more serious than “oh, kids play pretend all the time!” They aren’t playing and it isn’t pretending. But either way, you wouldn’t have been transitioned, cuz they would’ve taken you to a psychiatrist, maybe even two to get a second opinion, and I doubt they would’ve let you transition, unless you, as a child, actively knew exactly what to say or were actually trans. It’s not just:
Child: “Mom, today I want to pretend to be X gender.”
Mom: “Well, better get you on hormones and schedule your gender reassignment surgery, then!”
@@finalshock5685 the most that happens as a child when a kid thinks they are trans is a haircut, nickname, and a one letter diffrence form "he" to "her". Soemtimes they can go on hormone blockers, which are completely reversible and only postpone puberty. And by then, a kid is given time to think. Then they can go "oh, I was wrong I just liked to play games where ei played that role for fun!" And then go off and continue as normal. And those who ARE trans, can continue until they are adults and then make those decisions. This then preventing having to get terrifying surgeries like taking off the breasts so no "mutilation" can occur. Win win
@@TwinkleTwinkleTruly spot on
@@TwinkleTwinkleTruly exactly.
Blaire is literally agreeing that beauty standards are toxic but turns around and pushes her beauty standards onto people 🤨
No she is just saying that the more effort you put to look like a girl the more people will see you as that. That's a valid point but that doesn't allow her to shit on other people that don't undergo all the step for a complete transition.
@@umamisoup3335 that’s quite literally what I said. She’s pushing beauty standards onto people yet also agreed that beauty standards are toxic
@@sydneym-y if you dont want people to call you a man
when you have a dick and look like a man make yourself not look like a man with a dick its not about beauty not all women are beautiful you dont need to be just do something to not look like terry crews (he's a very masculine man)
@@DeputyFish gender isn't physical
The standards of beauties are not inherently bad or good, it is something natural that comes from the individual preferences of each one of us.
Could you explain to me or rather demonstrate, explicitly, how blaire pushed your beauty standards?
I really do not understand them or rather I see that they do not process jealousy well.
The issue of wanting to aspire to a more "feminine" scheme, if you are a man with gender dysphoria * as well as it could be vice versa * is not something mandatory but rather a personal decision to effectively engage in a "market" of personal decisions that They judge your appearance (plus other characteristics) in circumstances of relationships between people.
Please, if you do not agree with what I have written, counter-argue in a cordial way and refute the point I have made.
And if I had grammar problems, excuse me, my native language is Spanish.
I love how despite a lot of Blaire's bad takes, what bothers TRO the most is her poor research and inconsistency. Nerd after my own heart
I admire TRO's consistency in being neutral since the point of this video isn't debating Blaire's bad takes.
TRO has a rare skill for not letting his personal opinions get in the way of his objective criticisms. One of the best things about his videos, honestly
@@TamTam-rq4nc Wont it make it worse since it gives no input if the person in question is right or wrong and just jacks off the ego of 'enligthened centrist' who is above all with no real positions to hold
@@Sesshounamaru7 period.
@@Sesshounamaru7 Centrist and neutral aren't the same though. He doesn't take any stances that align with centrism, because he doesn't explicitly take any stances politically.
Blair: a fight to be feminine? What fight? Surgery? No. Name change? No. What fight?
Girl the fight of being seen as their identity. The fight you’re making them fight RIGHT NOW.
Thank you. I was thinking this but couldn't put it into words.
She was upset cause she wants to separate Trans from non binary and that person did not fight the Trans fight that blaire did
@@Stellarfront oh sure because that person definitely wouldn't have a hard time in a red state at all dressing how they want to, not even a little bit. get real dude
@ARTEZUI God, you're assuming. I never said it wasnt a hard fight. I said it wasn't the fight Blaire fought
What??
Coming from a trans male, I feel like Blair’s white is the embodiment of “I’m not like OTHER trans ppl 🥹”
Basically just a "people pleaser" "I'm different from the rest special" type of personality.
i like to call her, a transphobic trans person. she hates on other things in the trans/non binary umbrella, for example, she said that the pronouns "they/them" are stupid.
So... What does that mean? Does she has to be like the others because being different is wrong? I think what she thinks of herself regarding her difference with the rest is irrelevant, what's relevant is what she says. An ad hominem is what you're doing.
And that’s ok 😊
@@orsolyaszakacs9439 What 0 pussy does to a mf:
blaire: "boohoo people on the internet tried to prove that im not trans and that was so difficult for me--"
also blaire: *does that to every other trans person she meets*
FR she’s like the queen of truscums
actually i take that bad, the truscums would hate her
@@ikedaren_29336 Most truscum people are left leaning and actually care about transgender rights.
@@usermcskull4713 idc about them! inherently believing you need to medically transition to be trans is ableist and classist!
Are there non binary conservatives ?
@@strawbaeshortcake I heard that there's a decent amount of NB Trump supporters for some reason lol
She wants to be accepted for who she is only to deny people that right just because they're not up to her standards.
100%. If they don't look and act like her, they aren't really trans.
LOL no she just says you need gender dysphoria to be trans and that’s a scientific fact that validates transgender existence.
@@Mr.MermanPrince tell me where she ever said that. Go ahead.
@@Lola_Nico I thought not all have gender dysphoria though
@@Lola_Nico that’s neither scientific nor a fact. gender dysphoria is common but has never been a prereq for being trans
as a trans person who hit high school at the height of blaire's career, her rhetoric completely destroyed my self image and even led to me detransitioning for a few years, because blaire was this other trans person i agreed with but she didn't see trans people like me as "trans enough" and as "trenders", leading to what was the worst years of my life. kalvin garrah too.
Hey, I'm proud of you for being you.
I was uncracked egg when I started watching her and Kalvin Garrah. The content really stopped me from discovering myself sooner because they put forward the "real and only" way to have dysphoria and I didn't fit that.
I stayed uncomfortable in my own skin for so long. It was only when I left the skeptic community that I let myself understand my own feelings and engage with the trans community on a neutral level. I'm now a trans man and I'm so much happier than I was when I thought mocking people online was entertainment. All that negativity isn't harboured in me anymore.
I tick all the transtrender boxes and I couldn't care less.
Same! I was 16 at the time, an uncracked NB and a stoic 'skeptic'. I feel so much shame for the transphobia I expressed at the time, both internal and external. I'm glad you managed to get through that time as well ❤️🩹
I’m really sorry you went through that, I’m a huge Blaire fan, but I can see how her videos can have a negative impact, I’m glad that your finding yourself though 💗
How did someone that doesn’t know you destroyed your self image?
@@Skuzll That’s the thing. She didn’t know them. She made claims about how you can only be a true trans person if you tick certain boxes and as a result she kept certain trans people in the closet to continue having dysphoria and discomfort. Just because you don’t know someone doesn’t mean your actions can’t affect them.
"trans is cultural and hasbeen around forever"
whos gonna tell her that nonbinary has been here aslong as trans has been here?
as a native american, weve always had a "non gender" where someone doesnt want a masculine or feminine name. thats where alot of our tribes made it to where kids pick their own names. weve always supported trans identities (nonbinary included) even the tribes that were against transness supported selected names . blair doesnt know what shes talking about
Gay
Non binary doesn't make sense, because gender expression is subjective anyway, it's impossible to have no expression, that makes zero sense, that's like saying I have no Traits
@@tjshaver855 pretty sure gay and non-binary aren't the same, while yes you can be a gay non-binary individual, they aren't the same thing.
that's called being androgynous...? And i see people saying they're "non-binary lesbians" like, isn't it dysphoric? because lesbian is a term used by WOMEN who like other WOMEN.
@@Shrimpiiiiii_ Yup. And also, if you say you have no gender, you're agender. Which is most people lumping themselves in with the supposed "third gender," When they say they feel like neither... Makes sense.
I actually cannot wrap my head around Blaire. She’s a complete contradiction. And the ultimate “I’m not like other girls” girl.
Very "Pick Me!"
She is a black confederate.
im not done the video but theres literal proof she faked her political compass results 💀 she has a tab pulled up with her first test and then another tab wi much more far right results so im assuming her views are in part not completely real but she wants cishet approval
Ain’t she a dude?
@@Macheako huh😟 she is a girl lmaoo
Blair talking about the dangers of gender politics while simultaneously benefiting from it is just.... something else
Gives me Neeklul “yay eat the rich, now look at my 2million dollar apartment” kind of vibe
The Quisling
Sounds like a true Trump supporter though... so it kinda does make sense
You participate in society, yet you criticize it? Curious....
@@zama422 your pfp looks like the lovechild between pepe the frog and a character from a treatsforbeasts video
So according to Blaire, if a trans person didn't go throught her EXACT experience as being trans, they're not a true trans??? That if you're not taking hormones, you're a "trans-trender"? Has it ever occurred to her that there are people out there who don't have access or permission to acquire hormones? It's honestly amazing to see someone try to gatekeep an entire community that's already under a lot of oppression...
It's the no true trans fallacy
Eh to be fair it is a bit of a trend and plenty are either using it to their advantage, blair included, or outright lying about it. People lie and even for the most ridiculous reason. I mean we only considers witnesses circumstantial evidences, not direct evidences, because we are aware humans can lie out of malice or not.
Opression? Who? The people who hallucinate that they are another sex?
They are free to mutilate their bodies as they want, unfortunately.
True "trans" do not exist, unless your definition is mentally ill people.
You cannot change what you and rejecting it is the sign of a serious mental disorder.
Hormones/mutilating surgeries do not change the srx chromosomes/organs.
@ラテちゃん blair does not know you
As a transgender individual blair makes me so incredibly angry. She is the epitome of a privileged trans person, who had the ability to medically transition and has people who support her, and tne second someone has a different experience she decides it's wrong. You are not the only trans person, Blair!
something tells me she wouldn't have the same opinions if she didn't pass and fit within western beauty standards
@@queercandy1 absolutely. Her saying that she would deserve to go to women's prison but other trans women wouldnt.. horrid
Over half her family disowned her as far as I know
u know nothing about her personal life lil bro 💀 bffr😭
@@sxohlull "lil bro" "bffr" what is this chronically online language?
Her getting upset that people only want to hear from one type of trans person when at the same time she discredits anyone who isn't trans the way she is, is very hypocritical.
edit: mention the word 'trans' and you are bound to have people fighting in the replies ig
@Lady Joker ??
@@eak4889 ???
@@Danny13Green ????
@@Crabernacker ???
@@kanzkat420 ???
"I'm not like other trans girls." -Blair White, probably
Lol this trans woman just told me that earlier and told me I can't be trans because I'm still saving up for surgery🙃
That summarizes her pretty well
This needs more likes.
Why? Because she’s a normal trans woman with normal trans women views?
@@TheCosmicCleaner you clearly didn’t watch the video 💀
watching this video was difficult. As a trans person who used to love her videos and who allowed my young teenage mind to be kind of molded by her views, it's hard to rewatch these clips, remembering the person I used to be. Her views on being trans stem from "Oh you're only trans if you-" but I realize now after learning from others that if you're trans, then you're trans. There is no criteria to be trans. Yes dysphoria is an integral part obviously but in societal ways, you don't have to get surgery, do hormone therapy, dress based on what society deems appropriate for the gender you align with, to be trans. You are still you. It took me a really long time to stop hiding my more feminine side (im trans ftm) because I wanted to be perceived as masculine. But ive grown to the point that I do not give a crap about what others see me as. If I want to wear a crap ton of jewelry, makeup, heels, that does not make me less of a man.
that's amazing :')
Omg same! Its was so hard unlearning all the stuff she said
@@milliecipher818 It takes a lot to unlearn this kind of toxic stuff, cheers to you!
You can’t blame yourself for what you believed as a teen. Our perspectives on life are so small at that age, we tend to just believe whatever our idols say, even without hearing the other side of the argument.
she's the ultimate 'pick me' girl, every time I watch her videos I roll my eyes constantly cos it's like girl, who are you trying to impress? The very people that don't even think you should have ever been given the right to transition?? Weird flex but ok.
Honestly, as someone who used to watch Blaire consistently and agreed with a lot of her views, this video really does put it all into perspective. I've not watched her in ages, and my views have changed a lot, but watching such a well constructed video on her as a topic really puts into perspective how...misguided her content can make people.
No one per is the be all and end all on views points but that doesn't mean they didn't have valuable take aways. Humans have a problem with trying to fit everything neatly in a box. Nothing is ever black or white. Simple minds don't grasp to this.
its a little insane of her to think that her own idea of gender, which invalidates most others, is somehow right and not in need of self critique. Blaire has become just as bad as the people who treated her viciously during her early transition - codifying gender further isn't the solution to feeling disillusioned with your own gender. She merely falls into Right Wing extremist traps over and over. Calling BLM a terrorist organization is another trap just like it.
@@babymoon5282 exactly. Blaire herself probably does think she’s doing the right thing and it’s probably a good thing that young republicans are turning to her since she at least changes their minds on transgender people by showing they can say things they agree with.
I’m a liberal and heck there are points and vids she made that I genuinely liked from her. But yeah she did disappointed me a lot and it was difficult for me to respect her.
Honestly if the premise she laid out was true I would still agree with a lot of what she was saying. A lot of bulletpoints here had me question "What's wrong with that" only for TRO to lay out the actual facts.
You forgot to add that one horrible conservative panel where Blaire was being dragged by a scary conservative lady and she still tried to appeal to the conservatives in the panel despite almost everybody treating her like a subhuman. I don't like Blaire, but omg, I really felt bad for her in that one panel. I'm sure she cried after that debate and in some parts, you can clearly see her disassociating and regretting her life decisions.
yeah i only really felt bad for her insofar as i would feel bad for any transgender person having to deal with shitty conservatives, and people like those on the panel are part of why I didn't come out as nonbinary trans for a long time, out of fear.
That being said, I do hope she regrets all her life decisions leading her to that point, I find it hard to have any real empathy for someone who spent a significant part of her online career telling people like me that we're insane and that we are whats wrong with transness
And just to clarify, I wouldn't wish that treatment on anyone whether or not I agree with them politically or societally because I do hate overall how we're treated by people who refuse to see us as equals, as valid people, but I'd like to think I'm allowed to not feel bad for specific people
If it were any other trans person, I'd agree with you 100%, but really, how bad am I supposed to feel for Blair? This wasn't just some innocent, unsuspecting trans person being piled on and dehumanized by a bunch of conservatives, this was pure karma at play, the logical conclusion to all of Blair's actions and the things she's said over the years being parroted right back at her. This is what happens when you try to be "the one *good* trans girl" because you want to sit with the popular conservative kids SO badly, and maybe you convince yourself that they actually like you... but then, after years of turning your back and shitting on people just like you, you realize that the popular kids will NEVER accept you no matter how "good" you are because they'll *always* see you as a degenerate and nothing more.
And honestly, if that had been Blaire's "Come to God" moment on that panel, and she had finally realized the harm she's been doing to other trans people all this time and vowed to stop simping for conservatives who think she's a token at best and an abomination at worst, then *absolutely* I would have felt bad for her. What did she do though? No introspection, no questioning her life choices, she just went right back to making the same garbage anti-trans videos she always has. Keep in mind, none of this makes the horrible things the people on that panel, especially the evil blonde lady, said to Blair right, and they're still *disgusting* human beings with abhorrent views and ugly hearts, but I find I have very little sympathy for a self-hating trans woman, in all likelihood a grifter, who's merely reaping what she's sown.
The life of a pickme is made only as hard as they want to make it for themselves. Lol
I didn't. This is the company she kept courting and carrying water for. It was high time she got to see them mask off for a change.
As a trans women it’s so sad to see another trans person just become a desperate conservative pick me girl 😂
“Pick me girl” is just a name weak minded people give to others who don’t share their opinions.
@@AS-ri1mb "pick me girl/boy" is a term used when people will say anything for attention and appreciation.
Ie: "Wow, Tyler! You're sooo good at basketball! You're literally so good looking today, omg (twirls hair) you deserve everything. That's why we're such good friends hehe!!"
You’re a man. Accept it
@@AS-ri1mb that’s what you wish it meant
@@mantis-manthegreat your example is pretty much the opposite of what Blaire says lol, it would make ALOT more sense for her to act politically correct she’d get a lot less hate. She’s just saying what she believes
As a trans woman, I wouldn't be surprised if she just hated being a man and thought her life would be easier as a woman and she has pretty privilege so it's safe
blaire “being trans is valid unless you dont meet *my* standards” white
This is completely unrelated to the topic but oh my god who is the character in your profile picture from?
@@ceaselesswatcher3707 I could be completely wrong, but it looks like a human version of Vampire Cookie, from the Cookie Run games.
@@behelblitz6224 ohhh could be it yeah! I never associated it with him cause I use the ugly lion costume for him in Ovenbreak lol
Is...is that supposed to be a bad thing?
@@thebigdawgj the fact that she subjectively deems people as valid or invalid based on how similar they are to her? Yes, I suppose invalidating someone's existence for self validation is bad.
Blaire was both my example you can be part of a community and not agree politically, and an example that even being part of a community doesn't give you the right to be a d**k.
@Conservative Loli Waifu they didn't say her pronouns. But just cause you disagree with someone doesn't mean you get to misgender them.
Have a good day 🥰
@Conservative Loli Waifu her pronouns are she/her. You dont have to agree with someone to respect them.
@Conservative Loli Waifu they didn't even say she/her lmao
It's honestly kinda sad how far she goes to cater to an audience that would drop her in a heartbeat and call her every transphobic slur and insult in the book the moment she stops parroting the ideas they want. Truly the 'Not Like Other Girls' of the trans community.
@Conservative Loli Waifu imagine responding to someone to falsely correct them when they didn't even put her pronouns originally.
TRO. Your videos are painful as all hell and I can't stop watching. Your receipts, coverage, and content have always made me go "As long as my ass doesn't end up on this channel, you haven't F'd up THAT bad."
I’m cis and if somebody told me that I look like a linebacker, I would cry! That would devastate me and I would carry that with me for the rest of my life. I can’t imagine how painful that would be for a trans woman to hear.
Damn maybe try getting a thicker skin or else life is gonna be very hard for you.
but do you?
Damn bro, cry a river or smth
if u would carry an insult from a stranger on the internet for the rest of your life, your the problem lmao not the person insulting u
Cis is so offensive you are a biological adult woman ffs.
Blaire once made an entire video called "addressing my haters" or something like that and she got upset in that video because in Contrapoints' video called "cringe" she was mentioned for a brief moment (it wasn't even hate, it was literally just "Blaire gets views from making videos about things that are cringe, which is genius" like i kid you not, Contra literally complimented her)
at that moment i suddenly realized Blaire is pretentious and she isn't any less of a _triggered snowflake_ than the people she talks about.. and from that moment i felt kinda stupid for not having noticed that earlier because she's surprisingly bad at hiding red flags
Sounds like she has more in common with the people she actively downplays than she realizes. Which isn't really surprising, welcome to tribalism.
@@strangejune I think it's more projection. Cause she might actually see the things she hates about others in herself.
Sounds like the overwhelming majority of those types tend to be snowflakes huh? Who woulda thought.
I mean the 6000 different identities that they make up on the spot on tiktok are so heckin brave and valid.
@@menthols4625 What do you mean by that and what on earth does it have to do with Blaire?
@@strangejune a lot of the comments I've been reading border on being transphobic :/
Between this and D'Angelo, it's good that she's being challenged in the public sphere.
don't forget contrapoints! i completely agree!
@@iamporkychops yes, our dark mother! But I'd argue that it's one thing for someone to be challenged by someone who focuses largely on queer issues and politics versus someone like TRO, who might reach a different audience.
@@iamporkychops contra is ridiculous, and this video so far has made no salient arguments.
@@watchonjar silence, conservative
Yes, even without the full context something about Blaire rubbed me the wrong way. Its good to see her being put on the cutting table for her ideas.
Best example of Blair today is her saying because she doesn’t know anyone who died from covid it didn’t happen. She had to delete it because of the backlash.
Which is typical right winger BS. Screw those people, I lost three friends from COVID.
I saw her tweets being anti mask, under the excuse "my body my choice", and another one saying how disgusting someone on tik tok is because they refer themselves as multiple people, without precising that this person has D.I.D. I don’t understand why so many people listen to her when she lacks of scientific and medical knowledge.
I feel like she just assumes everyone in the world is as awful as her and takes their actions from that malicious placr
Stop projecting
Your people are the ones coming from a malicious place
You are disgusting
I’m a trans woman, and an ex-fan of blaire. She singlehandedly caused me to have trouble feeling comfortable in my own skin, because when I would question my identity, I’d think back to her whole “you can’t be ugly and trans” thing and I’d keep myself closeted for a few more months. She hurts more trans women than the people she claims are the actual problem with the community. Unsubscribing from her was one of the best decisions I ever made, and I hope any other trans girls who idolize her will do the same.
ok that’s all have a great day everyone :)
I'm so glad you unsubscribed, I hope you feel more comfortable now!!
I'm a transmasc person and I was incredibly cruel to myself back when I watched her and others like her. It led to a lot of internalized teansphobia. Glad I'm not the only one who got "free" of it.
I'm glad you're doing better for yourself
because being a forever victim and being manipulated by the alphabet cult is a way better option hahaha
@@MemeSupremeCookiesNCream lmao look at you with your lack of understanding 🥰
When I hear Blair talking about how people started treating her better as a woman and women's privileges I wonder if she ever acknowledges that there's a huge difference between the way that women that are "attractive" are treated.
I'm not even halfway through the video and I'm already sick of her constantly saying "MY experience MY experience ME ME ME" like her personal experiences are the only ones that can exist, and that was one of the ones that REALLY bothered me. Everything she pointed out about being treated "better" as a woman were extremely superficial things that didn't debunk anything she was trying to debunk. She just seems extremely unpleasant all-around.
Or attractive _white_ woman
@@DMCpawn Exactly those female “privileges” only exist for feminine, thin, women who are closer to Eurocentric beauty standards. So ofc Blair the thin, white feminine woman experiences “female privilege”. If she wasn’t any of those things her experiences would be a whole lot different. People are extremely cruel to women who exist outside the beauty standard, almost like they think these poor women deserve such vile treatment for not being attractive to them.
also, has blair just forgotten about female based violence, and how commonly women are murdered and raped compared to mem?
Just because what she says is true doesn't make her wrong. Male or Female, attractive people get treated better in society. Nobody said life was fair....
it made me really sad actually seeing that drag queen with the beard who did literally nothing wrong and was talking about teaching kids that people are different get conflated with that real life registered predator. blaire has a strange proclivity for slanderous commentary and imagery. obviously the predator should be condemned; that's disgusting but to drag an innocent person in is horrifying
As one of the non-binary people she attacked back in the day (along with Leafy) I really appreciated this in-depth nuanced take and the fantastic quality of this production. Just subbed and ready to do a deep dive into your back catalogue!
its so hard to watch that part bc i’m non binary and it’s such a huge attack on my personal identity and i already get enough of that and so do my other nonbinary folks all of us are valid 🏳️⚧️🏳️⚧️🏳️⚧️💛🤍💜🖤
@@fruitlikerw it still isnt a real thing btw
@@Crownslayer013 maybe you should do what your username says and log off
@@fruitlikerw there's no obligation to watch something upsetting to you. Your mental health is more important
@@Crownslayer013 how are you gonna be a hollow knight fan where the knight is literally nonbinary and still be enbyphobic lol
She gives me "I'm one of the good ones." Vibes.
Edit: Never mind, she literally is "I'm one of the good ones."
>she
@@valinor5397 Look she's got shit takes but that doesn't mean we need to start questioning her gender identity.
@@kiwi3085 They're commenting everywhere they're probably just a troll
@Rachel Forshee that kind of discourse often comes out of a place of extreme alienation plus the fractalization that occurs on the internet. Because people don't have space in their real life to experiment with their identity but there's infinite space to do it online and a lot of these people are probably rather young and not super familiar with queer history etc., it is very easy to deconstruct things to such a high extent like that and then rest your fragile identity on it. The trauma of being disregarded, called delusional, faking it, etc. for years causes people to lash out sometimes. The discourse is pretty toxic sometimes, but there are aspects of it that are super important- people need to share their experiences for others to understand what their deal is. That's especially important for nonbinary people since that's Advanced Transness, it's a concept where explaining it through the reductive lens of "a female soul/brain in a male body" will not cut it so there needs to be more in depth conversation about it.
Gotta say, if it's just her dishonesty and not her overall cruel and unsympathetic rhetoric towards other people who she, by all accounts, does not seem to put any effort in even trying to understand that would keep you from being radicalized, you should see if your insides are in order.
@@kiwi3085 And this is why transgender people are inconsistent. At the very core of the modern transgenderism lies the arbitrary redefinition of pronouns "she" and "he" to refer to the somewhat nebulous concept of gender, while there are no good arguments for the sex/gender distinction to begin with.
Blaire: is mad the current trans community isn't open minded and their views are too extreme
Also Blaire: is mad and isn't open minded and takes her views to the extreme
I’d argue she’s mad the wider trans community is TOO accepting because her ideal is everyone being perfectly Cis-passing like her and anyone who isn’t like her get lambasted
If anything the trans community is too open minded. Trans medicialism means that only those who get hormones are trans people. So those who don't do hormones aren't truely trans. But there are some people who can pass (like streamer f1nnster who's a man but can pass as a girl with a bit of make up).
@@blasphimus How do your last two sentences relate at all to the first? They're non-sequiturs.
@@Tid55584 transmedicalism is believed by trans people who think that others aren't real and it's often times a reaction to trans people who don't pass or even wish to pass. But it also ignores people who do pass but aren't on hormones.
@@blasphimus ah, could you specify/clarify how much of your original statement is your own opinions you hold? I think that’s causing a bit of confusion
this video shows that even though someone may be right rarely, they are NOT exempt from criticism, especially when they doctor false information ON PURPOSE and make fun of other people based on their own head cannon. Great work TRO!
I am so thankful I wasn’t on the internet around this time. However, Blair’s channel was a huge driving force in promoting a good portion of the hate that the right now levies at the lgbtq community. Hell, I remember in middle school kids were saying these exact same things to me all the time and using her points to bully the shit out of me. While I do feel bad for her at times, I don’t think I can forgive her for what she helped to create
🤓🤓🤓
@@-Dazai- um okay then?
@@aspen4786 you’re a nerd mate, literally named after a tree
@@-Dazai- yes cause I like trees, picked out the name myself ☺️
maybe im looking at different videos but her recent stuff isn't really that bad. Stuff like detransitioning force transitioning are topics that should be talked about
She just seems like one of those people who thinks their experience is the only correct experience (so everyone should have the same experience as them) and if anyone dares have a different experience they are automatically wrong.
Precisely. Which, seems to me, is symptomatic of the right as a whole.
@@unrulysimian3897 As a whole? Really? Between liberterian right and authotarian right, on the whole spectrum, everyone is egoistical? And it doesn't matter how far into the right you are, so even Joe Biden is in your "as a whole"? My friend, please start viewing people as people again. A label makes live easier, but label are not people.
The center is constantly shifting. As an european, I can promise you what we view as right and americans view as right is very different.
Oh please how is joe is left ? He’s more right wing than most Democratic Party politicians than normal. left includes socialism and communism (wich I will admit is incredibly flawed but better than capitalism) right is capitalism in general The USA has devolved into hey so vote for the lesser of two evils and basically come from the same part but one is more extreme than the other note not meaning to be offensive unless you’re joe Biden or a politician (I also don’t like the republicans ether ) I’m from a country that ain’t the USA ether thankfully
Part was a typo it’s party
@@sebastiangibson9671 I think you misread my comment my friend, I also called Joe Biden right.
I LOVE the Ace-Attorney style "The Blair White Sage" section has. AA is one if not my favorite game series so it's really cool seeing it be incorporated into a TRO video in this way. Huge props to Bucci for that!
Agreed! ^^
yes it was the best part of the video
“The Blair White Saga”*
That was my absolute favourite part! Totally lightened the mood!
yeah i was so excited when i saw that
"Won't somebody PLEASE think of the children"
My sister in Christ, thinking too much about children is what got us here in the first place.
I'm kind of worried for my mother I said I was watching someone talk about blaire white and she said "omg I love blaire white!"
I saw a clip of Blaire in some debate with some (cisgender) conservatives and they basically spent the entire time ripping her apart for being trans, invalidating her identity, and telling her that they would never respect her. The whole time, she never stood up for herself. The situations she puts herself in where she's trying to appease blatant transphobes are borderline self harm. I don't like her and she's been the source of a lot of pain that many other nonbinary people and I have gone through, but I can't help but feel bad. She has spent her entire CZcams career trying to make herself seem like a rational, respectable, "sane" trans person, and for what? Transphobes will still never respect or value her beyond the fact that she parrots much of their rhetoric. The only people who will (for the most part) unconditionally respect her are the people she has been hurting for years.
Was that when she was debating Candace Owens?
@@bonniebellaxoxo8853 nah, Lauren Witske. It’s horrific how quickly Witske beats her down with transphobia and how Blaire is unable (or unwilling) to defend herself.
Yeah, I saw that. I can't even bring myself to laugh as in "ha you had it coming." After all, I'm not sure anyone should have that happen to them and I'm definitely not rooting for Witske. It was horrible. The worst part is the way that she would not stand up for herself. I don't like Blair, but I would never speak to her that way. I have to assume with the anti-feminist stuff, as a woman, that may come back to her too.
I don't know how to think about that part, cause I remember a previous debate she had with the black conservative woman, and she did a similar strategy where she called Blaire a man, and it threw her off so much she got aggressive and didn't debate properly.
I wonder if she was trying to make it not affect her to look gentler and more reasonable than those crazy conservatives, since people were negative to her reacting strongly to it in the past.
But I don't know. Can only speculate.
@@violetsonja5938 No sympathy here. This is the audience she wanted. This is who she carried water for. This is who she wanted around her. Now she has it, and she saw what happens. The even bigger insult is that she learned NOTHING from it and went back to the same old content.
I know I'm hella late but what Blair is describing in the female privilege, if she were not as appealing to the eye she wouldn't get the "female privilege" she claims exists...
I used to be very overweight and the difference in how I was treated then and how I am treated now that I'm thin is extremely different. It should be called an "attractive privilege" and not a "female privilege"
The question is whether attractive men get the same treatment, and i would say probably not as much.
@@crystalnelson314 I'd say attractive dudes get just as much pretty privilege imo
@@bearj7140 I think it depends what you mean. I think in the areas blaire brought up, no. But since attractive men are much rarer than attractive women, they have an advantage on the dating market
the official term for that,, well gen z term, or the term we zoomers use is "pretty privilege" :D
@@crystalnelson314 oh the ”privilege” of someone opening the door for me, what a dream
listening and agreeing with blaire white is a lot easier than others who talk about the same topics as her. it's a lot easier to say "nonbinary doesn't exist and all trans people should look like this :D" than to look at the issue as the nuanced issue it is, and actually do some critical thinking.
I actually watched her a bit a couple years ago because I had no idea people that were trans were sometimes also so conservative
I do think she makes good or thought provoking points but it really does get buried in her extremism
I watched Blaire during 2015-16 and enjoyed some of her content then, but just stopped watching her naturally after that. It's kind of disturbing seeing it all compiled like this.
>her
@@valinor5397 You keep doing this throughout the comments. Do you have a problem with women? Use your words.
@@rampant9310 her
@@mechanomics2649 Trans-women not women. There’s a difference.
@@QixTheDS Not much of one, really
Blaire shutting Riley down for not medically transitioning almost made me pop a blood vessel.
She should have known that not everyone has access to Trans medical supplies, whether it be because of money, area, legality, fear or otherwise. (I'm glad that Riley shut her down even harder, by opening up about how she's going to transition, and that Blaire apologized, but it just shouldn't have happened IMO)
I still find it so god damn hard to believe that a "Trans activist" who IS A TRANS WOMAN would shut down ANOTHER trans woman for her decisions on how she chooses to transition,
I'm fucking baffled.
Edit: Before you assume, no I'm not Cis, I'm a Transguy.
I feel for Riley because I don't pass whatsoever, and have no real want for surgery other than top surgery, however it's incredibly expensive and a very long wait list so the urgency to get it is low.
To Blaire, "trans enough" is however trans SHE is. No more, no less. She's so desperate to be accepted by the right, who control.the narrative about who counts as a real woman, that she'll throw anyone else under the bus to earn a crumb of respect from them.
ive said the same thing in response to another comment about blaire's comment on the trans community being a "monolith", but i felt its relevant to repeat it here
I TOTALLY AGREE. not everyone needs to get a penis, a vagina or whatever to "pass". its simply not feasible for most ppl, the cost, legality (everything you mentioned) is such a huge factor
some ppl might just be satisfied being referred to w the correct pronouns, names and w their general social circle accepting their choice of clothes, and thats totally ok!! it feels like blaire white is the only trans person that thinks this way
Not to mention some people have medical conditions and CANT get these surgeries to transition. Blaire is so ignorant it’s infuriating
Didn't she say sorry to riley? Saying that she didn't know at the time? Too be fair you can easily assume that because riley is trans. It still makes blaire look immature.
@@saydey3804 yeah, or if they can't afford the expenses
I had this video saved since it came out, only watched and it's worth every second of the runtime. Beautifully produced
Ya know these issues would go away if people would stop sexualizing children.
Straight people are the ones putting their babies in print outfits with like “I love tits” and “mature sperm”
I don’t like that people use suffering as a competition. I acknowledge that I’m a hypocrite because I’ve definitely used this tactic, but you know what? It’s good to just show empathy and not have to one-up each other.
you're not a hypocrite because you once thought a certain way but since grew and evolved
it doesn't make you a hypocrite if you learn and grow from your past.
@@shell9918 In the words of the great Dalinar Kholin: Sometimes a hypocrite is just a man in the process of changing his mind. I think we misuse the word "hypocrite" WAY too often, it's definitely okay to change your mind. I agree with your comment, if that isn't clear lol
The “Sad-lympics” approach
Doesn't matter, you're still a hypocrite.
It's so confusing how she's so cruel to riley even though she was once just like riley. Blaire once had a deep voice, even if she had hormones. She should be the understanding one yet she's the bully.
I think it's not confusing at all since Blaire is 5'5''-5'6'' and her voice never dropped despite transitioning after puberty. Someone with an easier (not easy, it's never easy) transition sometimes cannot really understand that a certain look which is "only" feminine but not passable female yet, is everything that could be done for now and the rest is kinda still a work in progress. Riley did everything Blaire did but Blaire could not see it because she assumed the result should be the same or comparable. It's a human failing but really showed her uglier side
@@idechnjbm that’s not exactly accurate, in some very old video content Blaire did have a deep voice, maybe not the deepest in the world but definitely a male voice. She has also been privileged enough to have access to facial feminisation surgery and cosmetic surgery. It’s not fair for her to mock trans people who do not have that privelage. In a lot of their videos it comes across as though she wants to be accepted by right wing white men and doesn’t really care about biological women or trans women - Blaire just seems to care about Blaire.
She apologized. She’s grown.
@@LasPhoenix777 The entire point of this video is that no, she hasn't grown.
@@KaseyWynne exactly
That was awesome I will say by far you're the only channel that can convince me to watch an entire 2 hour plus video without skipping That was well research that was well educated that was well explained all of that is exactly why I subscribe to your channel keep up the good work awesome video.
I think of her case as an example of malicious negligence: if you did painstaking research, you'd know your narrative is false and that you're intentionally lying. So you choose to be sloppy to preserve the veneer of "just making mistakes" and "I'm just messy", and when someone calls you out for one of your many "mistakes", you can be like, "Oops, I made *one* mistake," and hope that people get so focused on that mistake and your response to it that they ignore everything else.
Also, I think that she seems to feel that anyone who hasn't struggled like she has, who haven't transitioned as completely and successfully, who haven't dealt with family opposition, who she doesn't see as "doing the work" to successfully pass, hasn't "earned" the label of trans. She basically has a bootstraps attitude toward transitioning.
@@MoonlightCircus Blair's sky high standards for what a transition should look like are the crux of that particular problem she has with people she feels haven't adequately transitioned. But let's be honest, can you tell me your a marathon runner if you haven't ever run a 5k before? I think transitioning needs to be taken as a far more serious step akin to puberty and definitely not as some afterthought as if putting on gendered clothing and changing up your hairstyle was ever going to be enough
I hope this girl has a strong set of keys for all the gatekeeping she's doing...
I feel like it’s disrespectful for the movements before her time the trans women that have worked hard to make their voices heard and then here she goes tearing others of the community down like huh??? Exactly I hope she has keys too
😂💀
I'm stealing this comment for future use. Thanks!
TRO: "So that was the case right? Well...let's talk about it."
Me: "Oh...it's not gonna be the case."
She said she's lucky because she passed so well for female and hasn't had to endure a lot of the negativity that more masculine appearing trans women face... wonder what she'd be like if she actually had to face the same struggles.
She’d probably face it with resolve. Unlike your leftist friends who would whine and complain. Or make it someone else’s problem.Like they always do.
I think she would at least shave her beard and not throw fits at total strangers.
blaire's the type of girl to bully someone in high school for looking or dressing "weird" only for her years later to pick up on that exact same thing because it's trendy again. classic pickme girl
As someone who used to watch both Blaire White and Kalvin Garrah, I've just now realised that Blaire would most often go after amab people while Kalvin went after afab people... compensating much?
(similar vibe to some women being misogynistic to try and separate themselves from women and appear as 'the good ones')
i cant say much for blaire white since I'm a trans man and have dealt with way more kalvin discourse but a lot of the stuff he is transphobic about seems to be things that he himself struggles with (such as insecurity about what he calls the "[t slur] voice"), like. imagine hating yourself so much that you bring forward a new wave of transphobia.
Sooo true. I did the same. So depressing
This is painfully accurate
Blair White has a similar vibe to Ben Shapiro (who says he's not like other Jews) and Gabi in AoT who keep saying she is 'the good ones' and not like other Eldians
im sorry for asking but what does amab and afab means?
“Whenever someone says to refer to *them* with they/them pronouns it’s like *they’re* saying *they* have multiple personalities” … Blair …
I mean....
what's wrong with that?
@@dragames she uses singular they/them pronouns, as in they/them to describe one person while saying it doesn’t sound natural or that it’s weird
@@Strawtebby they/them in english since it's been used as like Shakespeare wasn't as a singular. It's when the sex/gender was unknown or addressing an idea more than the person espousing it which was used more to demean the person who had the idea.
But then, the use of a singular they/them because someone is "neither" is very new
i think they them is also just a neat gender neutral pronoun
honestly why do we even have gendered pronouns, lots of asian countries had single gender neutral pronoun (korea still has) until the colonization
She's a pioneer! A first trans pick-me!
fully obsessed with the ace attorney format for this part its so good 2:17:32
Blair really said "This person has had a different experience in life than me, therefore their story must be false" ...
Link the qoute
I missed that but if they did say that, it was out of sarcasm
Right? I get that she had an upbringing that tried to reenforce her as an AMAB person, but she can't assume a parent is abusive if they're respecting their kid's perception of their gender. There's no evidence for the stuff she claims the parent is doing beyond "they're supportive and that makes me irrationally mad"
@@souleaterevans4589 when I was a child I thought I was a robot, should my parents have respected my perception and allowed me to swallow batteries like I claimed I needed too? If a parent fails to do what their surpose to and the child unknowingly harms themselves that's abuse no matter what way you try and spin it, or let me ask you it in a different way, why arnt 6 year old kids allowed vote? Or take out a bank loan or drink booze or get a job and pay taxes
@@souleaterevans4589 Lmao are you hearing what you're saying??? Wtf
Blair has the biggest case of "not like other girls" that ive ever witnessed. the amount of self awareness she lacks is shocking.
She has gender dysphoria, that literally means she lacks self awareness to the highest extent.
@@MrGFloyd That is quite literally (a word you need to learn the definition of) not what that means.
See what we're not gonna do is be transphobic for the fuck of it....we all don't like Blair....let's let the legit reasons stay in the forefront
Is it because she’s allowed an independent view? Should all trans people be put in their place and think like an NPC?
@@TheCosmicCleaner there’s a difference between having another opinion and invalidating someone’s identity because they didn’t have the same experience????
@@MrGFloyd wouldnt trans people have more self awareness than the average person? most cis people never have to challenge any of their views of who and what they are as far as gender whereas most trans people have fully explored that and know more about themselves
Seeing the evolution of this channel has been crazy.
Massive props to the editors ❤
Watching older videos of Blaire like this one is crazy, Blaire's face has changed so much in the last 3-4 years it's fucking crazy. Her face used to be flat, now it's so full of botox it looks like a completely different person. She uploaded a video of her showing videos of her as a man 10+ years ago and I nearly fell over. It's honestly crazy how much someone can completely change not only their face but their entire body.
Something I noticed that Blaire does (maybe unconsciously, maybe not) is that she refers to the trans community as “they” rather than “we.” She is a part of the trans community! It’s as if she’s trying to separate herself from the rest of the trans community.
That's cause that's what she's doing, bud.
But she isn’t like OTHER trans girls /s
I mean I think she's just. Done so much shitty stuff to the trans community that we don't exactly "claim" her either.
Tbh as a trans person myself it's still surprising how many people didn't know she was this shitty. Like, she's _always_ been "the transphobic trans woman", and none of this kind of behaviour ever surprised me.
@selenite. Interesting. I also do it when I refer to the people in my home country, but because I do not lived there for 10 years now and do use it as a way to separate myself. Not because I am too good or anything like that, but because I do not fit the usual mould/my life is too different to my peers back in my homeland. I didn’t even realise I am doing it till I saw these comments and it made me think. Maybe she does it subconsciously too 🤷♀️
She did mention that in one of her videos. She doesnt want to be associated with them because of the sex-focused crowd esp. during pride events.
That's what she doesnt like. She's disturbed that adult scenes can be seen by children. And she mentioned even some of the parents bring their young children to these events.
After an hour into this documentary, Blaire's overall demeanor started to stick out. She portrays herself as an elitist and constantly finds areas to speak her "opinion" in order to flame up controversy. Then, she proceeds to gaslight any criticism she receives over her actions. I've seen similar actions from other creators and other people I know personally on twitter. I don't know a way to really describe this cycle but the "Flame starting-Gaslight response-Redemption" cycle summarizes a lot of these grifters.
I try to avoid the term “gaslight” because it gets overused so much. But in the case of Blaire and many other grifters it fits perfectly! They really are the types of kids who would start shit then cry and run to the teachers when their target retaliates
The most concise term I can think of is a shit-stirrer. Just stirrin' up that shit for the hell of it and then acting like it's got nothing to do w her.
The reason Blaine brought up her being prettier, is because the day before the stream Jessica tweeted that she was more attractive than Blaire than in the beginning of the stream Jessica says she’s not as pretty but then blaire was like ok then why’d you lie, and she also said that Jessica has a creepy predatory aura and that they make people uncomfortable it wasn’t just like haha your ugly. Like yeah she kinda ripped on her for her wig and stuff but idk why you wouldn’t rip on a predator…. They deserve it completely, the point was also that Jessica wasn’t making much of an effort to present as female and that they would go into female bathrooms dressed completely as male and took photos with kids in the background
It's strange how people are so focused on Blaire's blunt speech. Not the fact that Jessica is the actual bad guy.
Yeah lmao, Jessica has been exposed for preying on multiple minors and tried to arrange a "topless pool party" for literal children where the parents wouldn't be allowed to attend. She deserves to be publically humiliated and insulted.
It's just a political hit piece. Anybody with two brain cells can see it.
@@user-xl7ns4zt6z this channel does it quite often lol
It’s weird how you address very criminal behavior and then go “and also she’s a woman who doesn’t look womanly enough” as if that’s just as bad
I love how one of the biggest arguments for terfs which ironically Blair is, is sports. Like "male athletes male athletes blah blah blah" as if monetized sports is not the biggest waste of time and money that exists
Also the mother in the custody battle and her son wanting to be called Luna? That's directly stolen from a book about a trans woman in the beginning of her transition. Luna was her chosen name and the name of the book
Ngl the entire Riley situation really pissed me off. She's completely right in nobody having ANY right whatsoever to her personal life and decisions on how she transitions.
I remember Blaire basically calling Riley a narcissist when Riley vaguely criticized Blaire’s “apology” to her. Real sincere apology there…
Pretty ironic, considering Riley said having personal preferences is transphobic and had the audacity to give rpe victims "permission" to get over their trauma before liking trans people.
@@kirikakirikakirika Personal preferences in general, no, but when that ‘personal preference’ is liking cis people over trans? Yes, that is very much transphobic. As long as your reason for not wanting to date someone isn’t “they’re trans”, then it’s not transphobic.
I understand that a rpe victim who’s scared of men and treats a trans woman the same way is technically transphobic. I believe that what she may have been trying to say is that before we call someone like that transphobic, we should allow them to heal first. After their fear is mostly gone, they may be able to change their views and be more accepting. If their views still haven’t change, and they still treat Trans Women like men, then well, they’re transphobic.
The entire reason anyone is labelled transphobic, is because they discriminate against or separate trans people from their proper sex. Either lumping them in with their aab sex, or just believing that they aren’t truly (x) sex because whatever reason.
@@sirmoriarty8230
It is absolutely not transphobic to not be interested in trans people. The vast majority of people look for partners to procreate, and the fact of the matter is, you can't naturally do that with someone who is trans if they have the same genitalia as you. Most men aren't into dxcks and most women aren't into vxginas. It's not transphobic to not want that. Moreover, someone's personal preference, much like Riley's transition, is none of your business.
"Allow" them to heal? Do you hear yourself? Thank God they have your permission. Rpe victims are not transphobic. It's not that they don't want to be around someone who's trans, it's that they don't want to be around someone who has a dxck. And FYI, some rpe victims _never_ heal from their trauma. Not entirely. Expecting everyone to inexplicably be interested in trans people is ridiculous. It's like expecting a gay man to be interested in women, or more to the point, expecting a gay man to be interested in a trans man who has a vxgina. That's not what he's interested in, and he's not wrong for not wanting that.
@@kirikakirikakirika it’s a big straw man to say that. The person above seems to have explained it but I recommend you look into that argument more? No one in the world thinks that preference is tramsphobic
One of these days he’s gonna talk about the problems of CZcams, and the episode is gonna break the Avicado Record
Man watching a full 24 hour video will be exciting, can't wait for part 2.
@@alvarorey9308 I’ll be waiting for the directors cut if it’s 24 hours per part
@@jackdamascus4506 that will be a long day
I'll reserve an entire day just for that.
I think that would be extremely helpful. I hope he covers all the censorship in that video as well
Remarkable how interconnected the channel's content feels when I see glimpses of past/future subjects in the saga. Spotted CreepshowArt references/features twice now, cute little surprise.
She’s such a pick me. I know what she’s doing, she’s just trying to get conservatives and straight guys (all things she couldn’t be a part of pre transition) to pick her. It’s a huge front to make herself seem like the “exception”. I’m trans and she just reminds me of the trans girl who really just wants the attention of straight men and conservatives. She wants to be the only “trans” in their group.
yeah she literally had a video where she said she wouldn't be making political videos anymore and said that other conservatives don't belive in what they say but she walked back on that within a week
@@imnotnotgameiacmaniac5327 Yep, probably because her view count started trending down. 😂 She and people like her are only controversial for the money and popularity. They’re sell outs all day long.
TRO really said 'trans rights' and meant it with his whole chest in this one.
We love him for it!
i mean he himself is apart of the LGBT community soooooo
@@Diordollies. well, blaire is too, unfortunately
king 👑
@@Diordollies. Transphobic gays/lesbians/bisexuals aren’t unheard of unfortunately.
I guess Blair is making up for lost time, she clearly wanted to be a high school mean girl all her life.
honestly though...
Ok. And why is that less valid than Riley Dennis' desire to be an odd, revolting trans radical who attacks people for not using correct language
@@Masckerdoom hmmm. Is this a Riley video or a Blair video?
@@Masckerdoom whataboutism?
@@Masckerdoom Riley didn’t get an entire hour long documentary made about them showcasing their faults lol, TRO doesn’t make videos on just anyone. Idk about you but I don’t think Riley corrupted the way an entire generation of trans people viewed themselves
People like Blaire make it so much harder for the young people who haven't quite figured out their sexual orientation, gender etc, looking for information, acceptance to become more confused, more misinformation and more garbage. I appreciate commenters like yourself calling out other content creators like Blaire. When there are so many people out there who haven't figured out their sexual orientation or gender etc, my daughter is one of these people. While I like to learn more about things my daughter is experiencing, people like Blaire should never be considered a person to go for information.
Seriously!
It’s so frustrating to watch!
I am so lucky to not have went down that path when searching for my own identity
I was luck to have seen creators who encourage others to use whatever labels they like and go whatever journey they need to to find their true self.
I have talked to so many people who say that creators like her and Calvin Garrah caused them so much pain and self invalidation because they thought they weren’t trans enough or dysphoric enough etc. or that they weren’t allowed to use certain labels for themselves or do certain things they wanted to do.
It makes me so sad to hear those stories and how common they are
It hurts my heart every time.
I hope we get more counter information and encouragement to just be you and do what feels right and makes you happy instead of performing for a false medicalisation of who you are.
At the end of the day only you can know who you are anyways
I think your point on common sense being a product of being informed is rather well put. One should never make decisions or statements based on tradition, biases or an expected response to fit an alignment/group. Never go a direction only because it's the prescribed path, never celebrate something just because everyone always has -- question your and others actions and motivations, learn about the situation through varried sources. And even then, hold each conclusion and opinion only as tightly as it is worth, once it's value is in question; you should be ready to abandon it in favor of the new information should it prove substantial enough.
I understand that she wants to show "hey, not all trans people think this way and can be conservative", but I highly dislike her approach. She acts like she is better than "those" trans people and her opinion is more valuable despite just being an opinion and nothing more. She had good points sometimes but there are people who brought those points across better, more factual and less demeaning.
It seems that most trans channels discuss topics as if their opinion is the right way. And, any opinion contrary to these opinions will normally lead to personal attacks and insults. Many, many examples throughout youtube showing this
I think this issue is very common. Left and right, people are very certain that their opinion is right. And how could they not, when they want to teach other about those issues? If you think you are right about something, it's very hard to be intellectually honest enough to be self-reflective and actually think about what you are about to say.
not to mention she acts like she's the only trans person with a dissenting voice to what the mainstream portrays trans people's opinions as. so ironic.
She is 100% better than those trans people.
Are we gonna pretend like there aren’t just as many (actually infinitely more) trans people on the left who act like they’re so much better than “those” trans people on the right? Also I don’t even think that’s what Blaire believes about herself. She thinks she has the more logical & defensible point of view compared to radical TRAs, and definitely calls out their actions and opinions (someone needs to, glad she’s doing it), but I highly doubt she thinks of herself as more valuable than them. It’s also especially funny because there’s people all over this comment section talking about “Blaire is so insecure” “She hates herself so much” “It’s all projection”, but at the same time she thinks she’s better than everyone else? Which is it? Does she hate herself or does she see herself as the most valuable trans
Her whole "all other trans activists are insane and I'm the only reasonable one" thing has some high level "I'm not like other girls" vibes
@@Primilex I don't think that's true. There have been a lot of trans activists who've actively accomplished things. Blair White comes across to a lot of people I know as being quite rude and self-centered, so I'm not sure where the idea comes from that she's the one not making us out to seem rude or annoying
It's also not any individual trans person's responsibility to be a good ambassador for cis individuals and make us all look good. Some trans people are flamboyant etc, they shouldn't have to tone themselves down to keep other people happy.
Always seemed like she wanted attention, felt off to me. Wasn't surprised with the news to her, other, activities.
@The Stammering Dunce what's sad is despite being a token for them, many of them still don't respect her identity at all.
@@Primilex guess you never heard of contrapoints.
@@kennethcases6952
Contrapoints rubs me the wrong way
As I sit here watching this video, rethinking of all of the times I watched Blair white and everyone else at the time of my past, now that I am older and hopefully more mature, I'm thinking of all of the times I allowed myself to be manipulated into so many ideals and thoughts as a fresh 18 year old in my freshman year of college, away from home, warping my sense of reality. While I still consider myself a liberal, especially considering I am from the south, I definitely am much calmer now than I was when I was younger.
Amazing video!! i wasn’t bored for one second of it
“What circumstances?” Well, not all things labelled as sex offences necessarily involve children. Say someone is arrested for lewd behaviour in a restroom, trying to hook up with other adult men. Or say that they solicited as either an escort, or someone looking to hire an escort.
Someone wanting to have sex with adults of the same gender isn’t an accurate predictor of sexual assaults on children.
Also in many places, being a sex worker can put you at risk for being classed as a sex offender. Which is particularly fun, considering how specifically vulnerable sex workers are to having offences committed against them.
Even just being homeless can put you at risk of being put on the register. Things like "public indecency" are a lot harder to avoid when you don't have a home, and police are often incredibly antagonistic towards homeless people.
Thoses facts are too complicated for Blaire White. It's either all black or all white. Nothing in between.
@ironfang bigheart I disagree. I think all children should be taught about it and what the risks are. Abstinence education leads to high rates of teen pregnancies, so why would this be any different? The only way to protect children from breaking the law is to teach them about it and why it exists. Ignorance just leads to them figuring it out on their own, and by doing that they'll make mistakes that could harm them.
The sad part is people like Blair know that and run with it to show their narrative. She talks about facts and actual arguments/debates yet uses shit like this to twist facts.
howly damn! 2 hours and 50 minutes, guess I have a movie to watch^^
Turtle approved
@@kristoffseisler2163 scarce still a thing?
At least it's shorter than the nikado video
Nickicado’s video is like the Snyder cut. Took me a week to finish it lol
@@P-C-Principle entertained my commute for several days, I appreciated it
enjoyed the variety in each section editing gg to the editors and artists