🧙 Sandor Clegane the Corpsekiller: The Windblown's Dog
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 05. 2018
- Caggo the Corpsekiller, captain of the Windblown, is another disguised character from A Song of Ice and Fire. Caggo is Sandor Clegane, Joffrey's Dog. How did Sandor end up in the WIndblown? Isn't Caggo Dothraki? What's with the Valyrian steel arakh Caggo wields? Who is Caggo anyway? Quotes read by Bookshelfstud.
Bookshelfstud Links
Fantastic Transmissions: itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/f...
Twitter: / bookshelfstud
Like what you heard about the books and want to know more about the world of A Song of Ice and Fire? Sign up for a free 30 day trial here at Audible and get a free audiobook!
audibletrial.com/JoeMagician
Subscribe: bit.ly/2EBHniX
Twitter: bit.ly/2ESrfJp
Patreon Link: / joemagician
Maester Monthly: / @maestermonthly3595
Watchers on the Wall: watchersonthewall.com/author/j...
Full text found below:
Reddit: / spoilers_extended_sand...
Blog: clankingdragon.wordpress.com/...
Buy A Game of Thrones book 1: amzn.to/2DoDACZ
Buy A Song of Ice and Fire: amzn.to/2D2rwal
Buy Fire and Blood: amzn.to/2UH4yQd
Buy Game of Thrones Seasons 1-7: amzn.to/2UF0xvG
How Brienne Became Pretty Video: • 🧙 How Brienne of tarth...
Art credits:
HBO Game of Thrones
Sanrixian
Fantasy Flight Games
Sanrixian:
Twitter: / sanrixian
CZcams: / @sanriscribbles
Website: mallorydorn.com/
Dama-May - Primal Drive by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-...
Artist: incompetech.com/
#GameOfThrones #got #asongoficeandfire - Zábava
Loving the content. You are a great addition to the CZcams community. Can’t wait too see where else you take us.
Corey Peterson My man, thank you for the kind words. I've got some weird and wild ideas to explore still. And a backlog of already written ones I could turn into videos.
Caught a few minutes of the live stream with LML Saturday. Couldn't watch the whole thing yet, hope you enjoyed what you opened. Bring on the Weird and Wild!!! Those are my favorites.
Oh my, you have a George voice!
Love the idea of Sandor as the corpsekiller and gravedigger.
Very interesting! I find this theory very credible, however due to Sandor’s true wounded (or hidden) nature, I wonder if this character is actually meant as a shadow, or foil to Sandor. As that is not an uncommon device in literature.
Interesting, that's very possible. That's close to what I posit near the end, where he's Sandor's reputation come to life almost like Peter Pan's shadow. Similar ideas I think.
Excellent GRRM voice. Not over the top, just enough.
Really enjoying this. Can't wait to see what's next. And let me say, I'm just happy poor Sandor didn't end up like this. I'm much happier for his story to end right where it is.
Steven Stark Strong agree, I like the gravedigger far more than Caggo as a plot. The next one in this series will be probably the Tattered Prince or D'enzo Dhan. Both I think are hidden main plot characters as well.
I agree. I think the Sandor and Stranger stories have a fitting end on the Quiet Isle. I suspect that helm is going to cause trouble, though.
Tattered Prince, please. I find this character to be most intriguing.
@@JoeMagician did you ever do this video? I can't find it on your channel.
@@sleekoduck he did now :)
These videos are so cool!
If there are more characters like this, keep making videos on them please!
Nothing like this exists on other channels in the community. I think you are on to something very unique.
Well there are other very insightful CZcamsrs. Appreciate the compliment :) I will be doing more.
His heart isnt beating and his blood isnt flowing...but when the Hound cleaves him, blood gushes out.....CMON GEORGE!
Love the way you say arak.
Hahaha thank you, bookshelfstud did a better job than I did.
In fairness to the cleaving, Sandor did literally cut his torso in half. It's not that Beric has no blood, more that it doesn't move anymore. You cut him in half blood will still come out.
Gotta say I was a bit doubtful at first but you really convinced me when you pointed out that Cleon was known as the „Butcher King“. Perfect parallel to Sandor killing Mycah the „butcher‘s boy“
Glad you hung on until the end! That was an insight from a friend of mine that just seemed like the cherry on top. Very smart guy that Hamfast42
I have seen every single youtube channel I could with GOT content so far. I am not a huge fan of the TV show's analysis unless it's a classic pisstake, but the universe has still got me hooked and honestly, after first watching a video of yours, I couldn't believe how small the channel still is. You're too damn underrated, man. Amazing work with this interesting and original content, I absolutely love it and I hope you keep growing more and more. Cheers and keep up the great work!
An excellent addition to the growing collection of videos. I like the content and am charmed by your delivery. Well done!
I love this. And great voice. Thank you !
Your voice is great too joe
Emilio Camacho Erice
I’m a relatively new subscriber but I’m loving these videos about Martin’s revised characters. I think you’re honestly on to something here but I think how case for Brienne and Pretty Maris than Sandor and Cago. Now I want to read the last two books to see who else may be revised lol
Any thoughts on the Tattered Prince?
Loving it!
These are great catches.
You've certainly identified similarities. For me, it suggests that after a cast of thousands over the years, GRRM has been regurgitating descriptions of previous characters.
Like it a lot! Sending regards from GrayArea 😉
Absolutely love these theories that link to the 5 year gap!
Awesome. Also like when u did GRRM's voice haha
Exciting new theory! How did I miss that on Twitter?
Is Twitter's algorithm keeping us apart?! :O
Marwyn is Moqorro! I have proofs! His glamor is malfunctioning due to torn clothes, and it gets worst when Vic gets him to remove his top, leaving him only his pants. Reread Mel’s Mance-glamor chapter. Plus the corpse in brine was definitely Aemon’s. But this isn’t due to a five year gap. Curious what Marwyn is planning.
Do you think that valryian steel arakh was an older sword reworked into a Dothraki style sword, or made to order for some khal?
The VS Arakh seems highly unlikely. The skill needed to melt and rework a valerian steel blade is something only a handful of people in the world have the skill to do.
The rework of Ice into the two Lannister blades (if I recall) required a smith from Essos who was the only person capable of doing the work (book recollection, not tv)
The Arakh is a bastardized khopesh I think, with an inverse sharp edge, I question if this weapon would actually be an effective hand to hand weapon as depicted on the TV. The khopesh is sharpened on the outside edge and is descended from a battle axe the Arakh as portrayed in GOT is a combination sword/scythe with the inside edge to be utilized mounted against infantry.
I am not a bladed weapons knowledgeable person particularly, but in spite of looking quite cool, I think this weapon would not be effective the way it is shown to be used in the show. I think ahorse it would be effective, but hand to hand, I think it would be a grossly ineffective weapon.
Dude, are you really saying that The Hound and Brienne are in Essos? Because, I can think of all kinds of huge people in ASOIAF. Hodor, Greatjon Umber, Smalljon Umber, Shagga just to name a few
No :) I'm saying these are drafts of those two characters post five year gap he reworked into their own characters. But their roots tell us a lot about where Grrm was thinking of taking Sandor and Brienne.
Joe Magician oh, ok. Now I get what you're saying
Your narrator seems to take sadistic pleasure in navigating the word 'Arakh' lol
If pronounced with a middle eastern CH, similar to the Hebrew letter chet, it's not a sound in the english language, closest you can get it ugh, if you draw out the end. Chanukah and Challah transliterated to english use this sound as do words arabic, farsi and urdu.
The Dothraki are culturally similar to middle eastern nomad cultures, mixed in with some mongol and other cultures. The language is a mélange of all these cultures as well.
Cleon the great. clegane gregor. Those name appear to be almost a perfect anagram. Almost)
And he was dead so being a corpse fit.
Nice theory
Ned Stark's mother is Lyara.
Was that a George RR Martin impression you did there? 😂
The rolling of the “R’s” in arakh is so distracting😂. No one says it like that
I meanit just a bit long for an RR sound, but as a Native Spanish speaker I think is well pronounced.....
Well Sander Being The Corpse keeper is a good theory their isn’t enough proof that he is.
The Corpse Keeper is basically another character that’s to look similar to Sandor Cleagane.
Much like Pretty Maris looks almost like Brianne Of Tarth.
And who do ye think is the Tattered prince?
💓🔥💓
"Clegane bowl"" 💀 ☠️ 💀
Does this mean jon is a walking zombie and when he went north at the end..seeing how ice preserves targayrens does he become the dead living white walker king
I am not sure I agree with the idea of Beric/Jon being "fire wights"
To me a wight is a zombie. if these characters are undead (like coldhands) they are not "wights" but re-animated people with agency, which "the army of the dead" is not.
There is a loss of some element of conscious that we saw with Beric, as a cost of being reanimated, but I am not sure "fire wight" is the right concept.
These are NOT zombies, they have agency, same with lady stoneheart. she has agency and an agenda, whatever it is, not the same as the ice bear.
I might have missed this but I wonder if the tattered prince has a doppelgänger ?
I think he does :)
So who is the tattered prince? Rhaegar?
If Beric is a fire wite and his blood doesn’t flow, why did black blood rush out when Sandor killed him?
The blood is still in his body, it just doesn't go anywhere. So if you cut him open, the blood would come out.
Joe Magician thanks man 👍
@@JoeMagician This is intersting, but Beric is not characterized as rotting, he is alive, and can be killed, each time he comes back he loses what made him Beric, but it's not stated or described that he is dead (unlike the ice wights, which are undoubtedly "dead" in that a severed hand is still animate.
There is a distinction between the last kiss, which restores the person, while not retaining everything, and the resurrection of the white walkers which is not restorative.
We see the same with the description of "coldhands" who may or may not be Benjen Stark.
Jon, as well as Beric are the same people as they were before they were killed, perhaps with some parts of them damaged or gone, but they are not zombies the way the risen dead are.
Do fire wights have agency but ice wights don't?
Can you make the music in your videos a little less creepy?
But what about his skin complexión? Dothrakis are dark. Sandor isn't potrayed like this...
Mary Hill right, it's more of a disguise from George to hide how he is using his discarded version of Sandor. If he makes it too obvious the audience would get confused about If it is actually Sandor in Essos or not. That actually happened with Brienne and pretty Meris, some fans wondered if Brienne had somehow traveled to Essos.
Joe Magician But still I'm confused....
The idea is that when grrm was writing the five year gap he had the hound character in the story but when he scrapped it he made some changes( like name and making him dothraki) but kept the character in the story as a new character
Helen O'Grady Good. I listened to it in a hurry