Prusa MK4 Full Review: An awesome 3D printer, but is it competitively enough in today's market?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 05. 2024
  • Aurora Tech Channel:
    My 3D Printer Recommendation List with 7 Printers out of Almost 100 Machines I Have Ever Tested:
    auroratechchannel.com/
    00:00 Intro
    03:53 Setup
    05:07 First print
    06:12 WiFi Setup
    06:55 PLA 3D Benchy speed test, 1-hour, 27-mintues and 12 mintues 3D Benchy comparison with input shaper and pressure advance enabled
    11:25 Print quality comparison between MK3S+ and MK4
    13:56 How print quality decreases when printing at high speed at 200mm/s
    17:07 Functional parts test print: 2000mm/s High speed drawer tower printing test
    18:14 More tests on PETG, ABS, TPU and Polycarbonate
    21:19 First layer test on MK3S+, MK4 and BambuLab P1P
    22:26 Pros and Cons
    ** Special thanks to FlexiSpot, the sponsor of our channel! **
    The FlexiSpot E7 Desk/Bench: A dual-motor standing desk that is built like a tank.
    Save an extra 15% by using the discount code AT50.
    US: 7qy0.short.gy/TrJVmS
    CA: 7qy0.short.gy/QN9odl
    Affiliate links:
    Prusa MK4 Assembled ($1099, expect an extra $200 for shipping and import tax):
    bit.ly/prusa-mk4
    Prusa MK4 DIY Kit ($799 + $50 shipping, no import tax for the US as the value of the shipment is less than $800)
    bit.ly/Prusa-MK4-Kit
    Aurora Tech Channel:
    My 3D Printer Recommendation List with 7 Printers out of Almost 100 Machines I Have Ever Tested:
    auroratechchannel.com/
    Accessories:
    Vevor 150W 165CFM air/smoke puifier $279
    amzn.to/45vIs4H
    Filaments:
    Eryone filament (PLA, PETG, ABS, ASA, TPU as low as $12 per roll, min 10 rolls):
    auroratechchannel.com/links/e...
    $16.99 VOXELPLA Pro:
    bit.ly/3UhJpYS
    AMOLEN Sparkle PLA:
    amolen.com/?ref=jrrw8k7q
    10% OFF Coupon: AURORATECH
    Tronxy Tri-Color Silk PLA:
    amzn.to/45HQxDA
    3D Models:
    Drawer Tower w/honeycomb pattern:
    www.thingiverse.com/thing:606...
    Monitor stand:
    www.thingiverse.com/thing:380...
    Print in Place Jeep:
    www.printables.com/model/211483
    Mesh crate:
    www.thingiverse.com/thing:473...
    Robo Alpaka:
    www.printables.com/model/4364...
    Prusa filament guide:
    www.printables.com/model/4349...
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 446

  • @davecrabbe4579
    @davecrabbe4579 Před 11 měsíci +140

    Maybe the best review of the MK4 I've seen. Their firmware, especially their networking performance have really hurt them. It is not even close to the standard in today's offerings. The "fast" benchies have really cut corners in terms of infill and layer height and shows that Prusa is willing to 'bend' the rules to get a fast number they can market. I think a solid printer for a bedslinger and anyone will generally be happy with its performance.. (except for the lack of better network connectivity).. but I'm surprised they didn't stop at the MK3S+ and create a new form size like this with a 4 post frame core xy that can easily be enclosed and so they can finally get some experience with this kinematic model. . I've worked with the X1C for about a month and the local network (wireless) features are just light-years ahead of the ESP-based Prusa design.

    • @bartybum
      @bartybum Před 10 měsíci +2

      "bedslinger" lmao i'm using that term from now on

    • @omegadeepblue1407
      @omegadeepblue1407 Před 10 měsíci

      @@bartybum Yeah, i need a shirt with that.

    • @JoseAguiloworkshops
      @JoseAguiloworkshops Před 10 měsíci +4

      Next time they will claim a 8 minute benchi. With .6 layer height, 1% infill and .5 wall! 😂😂😂 Wait for it in the xl with .6 nossle 😂😂😂

    • @DD-sw1dd
      @DD-sw1dd Před 8 měsíci

      Agree. The upgrade to the mk3.5 or 3.9 is so expensive it makes me believe they don’t really want ppl to use the upgrade path….but also wanted to stay in line with their upgrade philosophy. Possibly due to any issues that may arise due to how the input shaping works (no accelerometer. Just calibrated for the printer) and the fact that the hardware isn’t exactly the same as the mk4. The motor, frame, thicker Z axis rods, steel mb box, and all the other differences in structure with the plastic make a difference in printer resonance frequencies.
      I bought a MK4 kit…but mostly bc I wanted a 2nd Prusa followed by the new hot end (easy swap nozzles/heating elements, all metal tubing),and easy maintenance (love board breakout mb).
      Also, if I wanted to sell my MK3s I’d end up spending less money than an upgrade to the 3.9 which doesn’t even have the motors for the price…..and I’d have a full legit MK4 (exact same frame).
      I don’t really care about the speed thing. It’s mostly about reliability for me with these printer….but that’s not to say I wouldn’t want more speed. It’s just 4th in my list of priorities behind reliability, safe to use while developing patented designs (no cloud bs as the primary feature), largely open source parts.
      It’s my mini-van printer. Plan on building a 350 Voron in the future to be my drag race toy. That’s probably when I’ll sell the MK3S+ after I’ve printed all the ABS/ASA and got it dialed in.
      PS. Wondering if Ethernet connection helps fix the network issues. If not, I hope it’s just a software issue that will be fixed.
      Otherwise I’m sure ppl will be fabricating rpi octoprint upgrades in the future. Just really don’t wanna go that route. Haven’t even done it to my MK3s+

    • @davecrabbe4579
      @davecrabbe4579 Před 8 měsíci

      I bought a Pi4 when I got my MK3s+ kit and used OctoPrint from the start. It is amazing. Much better than the networking in the MK4, from what I read. Would never be without it now.. Was hoping the MK4 networking was better than it is.
      @@DD-sw1dd

  • @jockspice
    @jockspice Před 10 měsíci +12

    Brilliant review! This was so thorough and well done, glad you printed lots of different models using different materials instead of concentration on the high speed benchy. A proper test is what this, and any new printer, needs and you certainly did that. 👍😁

  • @misterbean29
    @misterbean29 Před 10 měsíci +30

    This was not just another fantastic review from you two, this was a very courageous review. The fact that you bought the printer tells me that you are keen to know. And that counts for a lot.
    And how you handled walking on thin ice, telling the truth without destroying, very good. Thank you Aurora and Helios, great job. *****

    • @raiuno90
      @raiuno90 Před 8 měsíci +4

      Indeed, especially given the large number of Prusa fanatics.

  • @KevOXO
    @KevOXO Před 11 měsíci +2

    One of the best reviews I have seen, pros/cons and comparison in a concise flow of information.

  • @donuthole7236
    @donuthole7236 Před 10 měsíci +2

    Your reviews are among the best I've seen, very detailed, comprehensive and unbiased.

  • @sojanarne
    @sojanarne Před 9 měsíci +1

    You guys are awesome! I am genuinely surprised by the level of quality made by yall! Keep up the good work, I found myself down a rabbithole of your videos, one of my favorite tech channels in relation to 3d printers now. You've got a sub from me!

  • @robertbarel896
    @robertbarel896 Před 2 měsíci

    your reviews are so good - especially in the comparison when you give side by side finish results . thank you for the great job

  • @BjornWarDance
    @BjornWarDance Před 2 měsíci

    Thank you for the clear and straightforward review without any unnecessary tangents and or rambles. It's very much appreciated!

  • @aberodriguez4149
    @aberodriguez4149 Před 11 měsíci +9

    Your TBD video was impressive and I always enjoy your channel's reviews on 3D printers. I am really just beginning to learn about 3D printing and have just started to print and blow up prints until I get a better understanding of this hobby. None the less I greatly appreciate your time and work and the detailed research you guys do. Thanks !

  • @avejst
    @avejst Před 11 měsíci +2

    Great walk-through of the possibilities of the printer
    Thanks for sharing your expirence with all of us 👍 😀

  • @OldManGeezuz
    @OldManGeezuz Před 3 měsíci

    The pros and cons section was so helpful. Loved this review. Subbed 🎉

  • @rabenklang7
    @rabenklang7 Před 11 měsíci +2

    Thank You - nice review, I liked the comparing remarks with the bambu lab printer.

  • @flexispotus
    @flexispotus Před 11 měsíci +12

    Flexispot E7 is really stable as a workbench for 3D printing enthusiasts。

  • @leadmuffins7565
    @leadmuffins7565 Před 11 měsíci +2

    First honest review I've seen on the MK4. Good job!

  • @freestylekyle
    @freestylekyle Před 11 měsíci

    I was waiting for your review, I knew it was going to be the most detailed review. I was not disappointed.

  • @victoraguirre5129
    @victoraguirre5129 Před 11 měsíci +5

    Now this is how you make a review! Awesome content

  • @yolo6741
    @yolo6741 Před 8 měsíci

    Best MK4 review I have seen so far. Thanks you for your great work.

  • @Glitch_Frame_3Dprinting
    @Glitch_Frame_3Dprinting Před 7 měsíci +1

    Thanks I was looking to buy a Prusa MK4 and now I know all about it
    thanks

  • @Yunthas
    @Yunthas Před 6 měsíci

    Thank you for high quality videos. Keep it up!

  • @Trust_me_I_am_an_Engineer
    @Trust_me_I_am_an_Engineer Před 9 měsíci +1

    Thank you Aurora and Helios, for the best, most complete and unbiased review of the MK4 on CZcams. ( and yes, I've also watched the German reviewers). Looking forward to your next reviews.

  • @danieljosey7166
    @danieljosey7166 Před 10 měsíci

    Fantastic video, you have provided extremely insightful commentary, my new favorite 3d printing channel!!

  • @damngooddann
    @damngooddann Před 11 měsíci +16

    As a very technical professional, I appreciate your in depth candor so much! Glad to see your take on this one

  • @ChrisWilliams-pu8pj
    @ChrisWilliams-pu8pj Před 3 měsíci

    Great job as always! Thank you for your honest perspective!

  • @ninseineon
    @ninseineon Před 11 měsíci +1

    Wow! Now that’s what I call a proper review! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

  • @StevesRealWorld
    @StevesRealWorld Před 9 měsíci +6

    I own Prusa Minis, MK3S+, Bambu P1P and Bambu X1C, I was expecting SO MUCH MORE from Prusa for the MK4, for the price I would just buy another X1C or Two P1Ps. Love the REAL REVIEW.

  • @spinnetti
    @spinnetti Před 11 měsíci +34

    Well done. I did decide to get a MK4 to replace my MK3 to support the open source approach and continuous software development, but probably the last time I will unless they improve their competitiveness.

    • @JoseAguiloworkshops
      @JoseAguiloworkshops Před 10 měsíci +2

      The last martir died 2000 years ago. If they didn't make anything new why you will support mediocrity?

    • @spinnetti
      @spinnetti Před 10 měsíci +7

      @@JoseAguiloworkshops because without their slicer, the others would not be as good. I want to support the company that is helping everybody not just themselves. Without the open source spirit, all we would have is crappy software on crappy clones.

    • @JoseAguiloworkshops
      @JoseAguiloworkshops Před 10 měsíci +1

      @@spinnetti do you really think so? Those gummy bears have something...

  • @colinmsmall
    @colinmsmall Před 11 měsíci +13

    Possibly the best reviews on CZcams. Great job, and thank you.

    • @CodeBroRob
      @CodeBroRob Před 11 měsíci

      you say that, but i find even smaller youtubers with no sponsorships or free goodies from companies the better ones as they get the full raw experience you would get as the consumer.
      one had such a warped bed that his bed mesh showed a 0.6mm difference in the bed showing how bad the quality control can truly be, and keep in mind that the bed over time also warps meaning it will be worse than 0.6 after 6 months of decent use.
      this was either a sv06 or neptune 3 that instantly had klipper slapped onto it day 1.
      i forgot which channel/video it was tho as it's been a few months since i watched it, but such reviews did push me over the fence to just buy a voron printer.

    • @herr_rossi69
      @herr_rossi69 Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@CodeBroRob I don't trust any test not only for printers, and especially with Chinese manufacturers.
      There is too much money in the game.

    • @CodeBroRob
      @CodeBroRob Před 11 měsíci

      @@herr_rossi69 exactly

  • @GarranGossage
    @GarranGossage Před 10 měsíci

    Thanks for the great quality review! I can't wait to see your Creality K1 review.

  • @TMS5100
    @TMS5100 Před 11 měsíci +16

    @0:13, @2:42 such emphasis on the word "finally", and it's well deserved. the whole industry has been lazy for years until bambu slapped them hard. unfortunately the extreme price is hard to justify for a bedslinger with such a small print volume.

  • @awilliams1701
    @awilliams1701 Před 10 měsíci +2

    wow great review! I've seen several that feel unfinished. This is very detailed and thorough. Exactly what I was looking for. It makes me excited to get my kit (day one order so hopefully by the end of the month). My only complaint is the MMU3 for it is being delayed until august. Meaning the MK3 will be my main printer for a while longer yet. In the mean time I'll run some interesting experiments with the MK4. I've never used TPU or anything like that before. Should be interesting to mess with.

  • @jameslong4252
    @jameslong4252 Před 6 měsíci

    Great review. Thanks for your time and sharing this.

  • @bryanmiller630
    @bryanmiller630 Před 11 měsíci

    This is the best review I have seen this printer.

  • @TheStickyBusiness
    @TheStickyBusiness Před 10 měsíci +1

    I love your reviews- I would love to see more resin printed related stuff here too.

  • @bicunisa
    @bicunisa Před 10 měsíci

    Thanks for the thorough and unbiased review. 🙏

  • @fawwazallie7736
    @fawwazallie7736 Před 11 měsíci +1

    LETS GO!!!!! YOU GUYS GOT A SPONSER CONGRATS

  • @howardhamaker2708
    @howardhamaker2708 Před 11 měsíci +4

    The name of this video should be "Aurora Schools Prusa"
    Great video !!!!

  • @ondrejhettner2731
    @ondrejhettner2731 Před 11 měsíci +3

    Great review, looking forward to the Creality K1 video.

  • @ricksvideos4883
    @ricksvideos4883 Před 11 měsíci +8

    Great video Aurora! As a MK3+ owner and Prusa fan I hope Josef and his mates take your advice and change their business model or else they may end up just like Nokia as you mentioned in the vid.

  • @JennaHartDemon
    @JennaHartDemon Před 8 měsíci

    The quality of this review is exactly what I was looking for.

  • @Hoeiv
    @Hoeiv Před měsícem

    Nice video! Well done! Keep on the good work!

  • @danielrogers6090
    @danielrogers6090 Před 11 měsíci +1

    Awesome informative video buddy, good luck next year as a freshman you will do great 👍

  • @Scriven42
    @Scriven42 Před 11 měsíci +1

    We started using some Eryone (Black) PLA, and it's shockingly good, thanks for the recommendation!

  • @0MrFox0
    @0MrFox0 Před 7 měsíci

    wow! Impressive review. Subscribed.

  • @jed2055
    @jed2055 Před 7 měsíci +3

    Competitive in today's market? Hmm, I think Prusa are aiming at the print farm market and know the product is rock solid. Business's know they can defray costs through tax breaks so a bit dear but a whole lot more reliable with parts that can be readily sources at reasonable prices and easily installed. I own a Prusa and know why I bought it and know how good (read reliable) it is. I've recently bought a used one that I will upgrade and plan is to buy a third. There's my mini farm right there. They are a great printer and as everyone says, they just work. For me the question isn't are they competitive; it's are they worth the extra money. Yes, for me they are a no brainer.

  • @garthhowe297
    @garthhowe297 Před 11 měsíci

    Excellent and honest review. Thank you.

  • @zebsolaria4763
    @zebsolaria4763 Před 11 měsíci +2

    watched your grad speech and was very impressed. i come here to get the good bad and the ugly on three d printers

  • @VampireOnline
    @VampireOnline Před 11 měsíci

    Excited to see a K1 review since you referenced it!

  • @Elite1181
    @Elite1181 Před 11 měsíci +1

    As always very good, detailed, and well explained videos, you are awesome!!. Regarding the prusa Mk4 I think is a very well known quality 3d printer but I personally think is not keeping up with the new technologies.

  • @manekdubash5022
    @manekdubash5022 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Great review, thank you. Very honest.
    You could have added another criterion: my preference for Prusa is also driven by its open source foundation, which helps drive innovation. It's also a European firm and, even here in the UK on the edge of Europe, lowers shipping costs and makes a welcome change from the usual "design anywhere, build in China" model.

  • @OccultDemonCassette
    @OccultDemonCassette Před 9 měsíci +1

    Will you be doing a revisiting/update video of this after the firmware updates for faster printing and input shaping and all that?

  • @joeking433
    @joeking433 Před 8 měsíci

    I have the Anycubic Kobra and it has been a dependable machine. I'm really impressed!

  • @ThirdDynamic
    @ThirdDynamic Před 11 měsíci +32

    Great review. Unfortunately for Prusa, they are going to continue falling behind in the logistics and price categories. Two things that are extremely important to those of us with businesses to run these days. If I am going to spend that much, it will be for an X1 Carbon at $1500. I'll get way more bang for my buck.

    • @thomasnox1141
      @thomasnox1141 Před 11 měsíci +5

      I think Prusa should start manufacturing in Mexico to cover North and South American market

    • @omegadeepblue1407
      @omegadeepblue1407 Před 10 měsíci +3

      @@thomasnox1141 As a mexican i would really love that, maybe that will end with the reign of the Ender 3, because the Ender 3 has a big cult following, maybe two of the first 10 mexicans you meet are not people but Ender 3's.
      In my opinion the best place for Prusa to manufacture on México will be the state of Tamaulipas, that state is the neighbourh of Nuevo Leon (the state where Tesla is going to install) and has the biggest conection with the north american border and Texas, it also has a great industrial port for shipping and exportation. The reason why i choose Tamaulipas and not Nuevo León or Baja California is because Nuevo León is already infested with a lot of manufacturers and companies that are fighting to be on that state meanwhile Baja California is "China 2", not joking, for the same reason chinese say that the best chinese food outside China is on México.
      Tamaulipas will be a cheap and good option for Prusa, there are not really big companies there, the main drawback for that state is their bad fame, between 2006 and 2018 Tamaulipas was one of the most dangerous states (not as dangerous as Chihuahua but it was still dangerous) due to the narco wars, probably Tamaulipas is the reason why Texans have the idea that Mexicans are walking raging machineguns. However that is a thing of the past (with this i'm not saying that Tamaulipas is now heaven but now you don't need to stay in your house before 6:00 pm in order to be safe, is not like Oaxaca or Chiapas, those two are literally condemned).

    • @jakob.k_design
      @jakob.k_design Před 9 měsíci +5

      @@thomasnox1141 what they should really do is stop 3d printing parts for their printers. With their production number it is just inefficient and wastefull and one of the reasons why their printers are overpiced.

  • @brianlashomb2830
    @brianlashomb2830 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Ended up canceling my Mk4 kit order that still hasn’t shipped, for the now $599 P1P from Bambu Labs. Thank you for your detailed reviews.

  • @jadams3427
    @jadams3427 Před 4 měsíci

    Great information.Thank you !

  • @c0mputer
    @c0mputer Před 11 měsíci +65

    Considering how long this has been in development it’s a bit of a let down. Although if Bambu Lab never formed and the P1P or X1C never existed, it would actually be THE printer to beat. Unfortunately for Prusa they did and they do.

    • @kneel1
      @kneel1 Před 11 měsíci

      i mean they are both great and think its still a solid printer for any Prusa fan.

    • @TheZimberto
      @TheZimberto Před 11 měsíci +30

      If it hadn't been for Bambu, we'd still be waiting for the MK4. The fact that it still isn't finished is proof of that.

    • @c0mputer
      @c0mputer Před 11 měsíci +13

      @@kneel1 I think you’re completely right. It’s a solid printer for a Prusa *fan*. Someone who will only buy Prusa will get a great printer because it’s an upgrade. For others who don’t care or don’t know about Prusa will see what you get vs the price and I could easily see it not being worth it for them. If Prusa knows their fan base will buy anything it almost seems like they’re taking advantage of them. Prusa isn’t making it super easy to defend them against Bambu in my opinion.

    • @seanblake4291
      @seanblake4291 Před 10 měsíci +3

      I was looking for a machine for a long time that checks all the boxes the X1 does, so I bought one and it's simply a fantastic printer. I did heavily consider the MK3 given its reputation but I just couldn't justify the price, that and I have always been put off Prusa machines due to his ragging ego, he plasters his face all over his products and I see in this review even the software interface isn't spared this time.
      With my X1 I don't have to be constantly reminded of persons name and face while actually using the machine, and I also don't get a pack of gummy bears in the box that make me feel like a five-year-old, the X1 is a more professional machine that doesn't patronize its customers with gummy sweets and constant name and face bombing , and for that I'm very glad.

    • @kneel1
      @kneel1 Před 10 měsíci +6

      @@seanblake4291 i dont understand that weird Prusa-hate from everyone. Who cares if his face is on things the printers are awesome. Its so weird how people cannot control their own hate, and have no ability to ignore what doesnt apply to them. I own both Prusas and Carbon X1 - Bambu gets alot of hate too for stealing technology. It seems people pick one side. Just enjoy printing and it doesnt have to always be an "us vs them" mentality.. This was the case with Apple vs Microsoft many years ago and while everyone fought about it , I used both and still to this day use both OSX and Windows daily for different things. The people who locked themsleves into only one side, missed out on quite a bit of learning and opportunities

  • @jasontrauer
    @jasontrauer Před 11 měsíci +3

    People just getting into printing now have so many great options. Though not revolutionary, certainly better than prior generations of the i3 for newbies.

  • @Rubbernecker
    @Rubbernecker Před 3 měsíci

    This is an awesome channel!!

  • @JakeTreadway
    @JakeTreadway Před 11 měsíci

    The best 3D printer reviewer on CZcams and it’s not even close.

  • @44492611
    @44492611 Před 11 měsíci

    That comparison of the llama prints was really impressive.

  • @alex.germany
    @alex.germany Před 14 dny

    Very good and objective review. I'd like to see an update because a lot of have updated since. Most reviews are from the beginning. The software is in overall much better condition now.

  • @nikivan
    @nikivan Před 10 měsíci

    Finally a detailed and honest review of this printer and Prusa business in general. I found the comparison to Nokia on the mark.

  • @theodoreolson8529
    @theodoreolson8529 Před 4 měsíci

    I'm shopping for my first 3D printer. A friend of mine, who owns several 3D printers commented. "I know several people who bought a Prusa printer. I don't know anyone who bought a second Prusa. I'm not sure of the accuracy of his comment but this evaluation seems to support it.

  • @mohammadfaizulislam1992
    @mohammadfaizulislam1992 Před 10 měsíci

    congrats for 50k subs

  • @Jbobonline
    @Jbobonline Před 11 měsíci +2

    Aurora the wise! When will you do a voron build series? I promise to follow such a series religiously ❤

  • @mikekelley7589
    @mikekelley7589 Před 11 měsíci +8

    Thanks for the in depth review! Prusa doesnt seem to dissapoint.

  • @User7039
    @User7039 Před 10 měsíci +1

    This is a really helpful review. I have the MK3+ and was considering an upgrade. I'll be holding out for the PrusaXL or maybe just abandon my preorder and look at Bamboo Labs.

  • @nicedev8189
    @nicedev8189 Před 11 měsíci

    Great review!

  • @EEEEMMMMKKKK
    @EEEEMMMMKKKK Před 11 měsíci +4

    That Nokia example was funny 😂 But i can’t agree. While Klipper is now a synonym for speed if you ask a electrical engineer if he want a hardware(printer) to be controlled by a firmware running on specialized board or a python application running on a general purpose operating system talking to a microcontroller over usb(klipper) i bet he chose the former. I am not saying the klipper is bad i like it but the closed environment like on device running marlin has a lot of advantages over general purpose os. And marlin based printers are running slower only because they are running on budget cpus. We can’t know but bambu lab printer’s probably not running a general purpose os either.

  • @foundlost5583
    @foundlost5583 Před 11 měsíci

    Awesome review. Thanks.

  • @microhaxo
    @microhaxo Před 11 měsíci

    Excellent summary.

  • @Marlon-bk3cs
    @Marlon-bk3cs Před 10 měsíci

    Thanks for the video

  • @santiagoblandon3022
    @santiagoblandon3022 Před 11 měsíci

    Excelent objective review!

  • @YAMIKAN99
    @YAMIKAN99 Před 10 měsíci

    Looking forward to your creality K1 review

  • @n0vaph0enix
    @n0vaph0enix Před 11 měsíci +20

    A very detailed and very honest review. It’s impossible not to compare it with the competition and it really just doesn’t add up, unfortunately. I think the Nokia comparison is a real stinger - I think you’ve hit the nail on the head here, it really does ring on a company riding too strongly on a legacy and not continuing to innovate or adapt to the market.

    • @Peardropsldn
      @Peardropsldn Před 11 měsíci

      How

    • @oleurgast730
      @oleurgast730 Před 11 měsíci +4

      Actually I am not so sure. While Klipper is a very powerfull firmware, for many users the functionality is overwhelming. Actual Marlin supports Input shaping (and Linear Advance was supported even on the mk3 without s and +). Yes, you have more options in Klipper. But what matters is not the options you have - but the result you get and how comfortable it is to get it. Esp. for persons getting into 3d-printing.
      As the Bambulab printers show, it does not matter, if you use Marlin, Klipper or reprap - they use neither but their own closed source firmware. Successfuly.
      I am quite happy, there are multiple firmwares - esp. the open source ones. Thei all have their own advantages - and ideas from one are transfered to the other.
      So comparing Marlin to Symbian does not realy fit.

    • @atienne_navarre
      @atienne_navarre Před 11 měsíci

      @@oleurgast730 The Bamboo labs FW is open source.

    • @herr_rossi69
      @herr_rossi69 Před 11 měsíci

      @@atienne_navarre Really? Where can I download the source code. And I don't mean the slicer. They had to do it open source after came out that they used the Prusa Slicer.

    • @oleurgast730
      @oleurgast730 Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@atienne_navarre Bambu Labs own website sais:
      "4. Firmware and circuit board: This is closed source.
      For this part, we decided to keep these items as property of the company. The firmware is 100% developed in-house and we would like to keep it that way to be competitive on the market. We do have 100+ employees, and this number is growing. We want to make our business successful so that we can provide for each of our employees."
      You might have mixed up the firmware and the slicer (later one based on Prusa Slicer which is based un Slic3r)

  • @electricalnguyen
    @electricalnguyen Před 6 měsíci

    very nice video. Among 3D printers up to now, which one has the best accuracy in X-Y printing?

  • @Thepitbull9911
    @Thepitbull9911 Před 11 měsíci +4

    Yeah Just like I thought. This model is great but Not quite worth it for me. I will be looking for the K1 review within the next few weeks. Please test that Extruder tension switch issue that keeps popping up online about it. Thanks and keep up the great work.

  • @brycejeannotte7699
    @brycejeannotte7699 Před 11 měsíci +20

    Another great review. I think the worst part of the MK4 is the file transfer speed. A number of people are using Octoprint to get around this poor network performance.

    • @kneel1
      @kneel1 Před 11 měsíci +1

      i manually added wireless adapter to my Mini+ and its ABYSMALLY slow. it was previously working great just really slow, but recently it often wont even finish transferring any .gcode over 5MB it just hangs

  • @blockhead3654
    @blockhead3654 Před 10 měsíci

    Supper awsome work.

  • @PutTheKettleOnGromit
    @PutTheKettleOnGromit Před 11 měsíci

    I like the use of the same music Dankpods uses in his headphones comparison videos.

  • @leinadreign3510
    @leinadreign3510 Před 11 měsíci +1

    I will buy a prusa instead of a chinesium printer.
    I like their products, support is very good, upgradeability of your device (instead of buying a complete new one), open source 8which brings a lot to the 3D printing community, even if "others" use prusas work to build upon and then put a patent or TM on it to cash in), no "always online" drm, easy to connect with octoprint (prusas own system is still in beta as far as I know...), the only company which has put out a sustainability report and even company accident statistics (very rare)...
    I proudly finance the prusa company instead of a state own chinese one.
    The review is still interesting. And I still find that "first perfect layer" amazing (having a prusa mini here, so I dont know the struggle of adjusting the bed at all), which runs entirely automatic.

  • @corlissmedia2.0
    @corlissmedia2.0 Před 11 měsíci +26

    This is a fantastic review of the MK4. After 8 weeks and not an email or text from Prusa I cancelled my order. By then I knew it wasn’t going to impress me like the X1 Carbon has. The MK4 was going to be my first Prusa. I have seen the price of their giant Prusa and have already decided I can do better with 2 grand. I love this review. You are very honest in a very professional way. My Kobra 2 arrives today thanks to your recommendation. Now I will congratulate you on completing the Eighth Grade. Are you entering MIT in Boston, or going to Stanford on a full-ride scholarship next fall?

    • @Feibie
      @Feibie Před 11 měsíci +7

      wait what, 8th grade? Oh my lord, I'm starting to become insecure with my intelligence

    • @corlissmedia2.0
      @corlissmedia2.0 Před 11 měsíci +2

      @@Feibie Indeed, you're not alone in that feeling. But she is very kind about being so intelligent. Hence my comment about the two Mit's.

    • @misterbean29
      @misterbean29 Před 10 měsíci +1

      @@Feibie, you are not alone

  • @ltraltier6009
    @ltraltier6009 Před 6 měsíci +1

    I would definitely take this over any creality shit. They bricked the Ender 5 pro with their last firmware update about a year ago and GLHF finding any real answers on solving a reversed stepper motor and an extruder wheel that fell off because the screw isn't long enough and was the source of filament outright not being moved after a year.

  • @thomasnox1141
    @thomasnox1141 Před 11 měsíci +7

    Prusa has one huge advantage. It’s extremely reliable machine and it is easy to fix. I just moved from Europe to Mexico and three of my printers were destroyed in a shipping process. I could fixed them all by myself. I can’t do this with Bambu. When you do printing as a business you need reliable printers and Prusa definitely delivers here.

    • @schrodingerscat1863
      @schrodingerscat1863 Před 9 měsíci +1

      Bambu labs provide inexpensive spares for their printers so repairs are cheap and easy. Even the carbon rod assemblies hot ends and extruders are available as spares and they are available ex stock in Europe.

  • @josephmama9657
    @josephmama9657 Před 8 měsíci

    Is that Vevor also good for when you are resin printing?

    • @AuroraTech
      @AuroraTech  Před 8 měsíci

      Yes, I think so, the smoke purifier works pretty well on both FDM printing and laser wood cutting, but I didn't try it on resin printing.

  • @mitchib1440
    @mitchib1440 Před 7 měsíci

    12:26 oh my goodness, that material is beautiful! Tronxy? Hmm, i may have to try this...

  • @Tom_videa
    @Tom_videa Před 11 měsíci +2

    It does have a capacitive touchscreen, it is just not implemented in firmware yet (maybe it will, maybe it will not, but the hardware is there).
    edit: okay, nevermind. It gets mentioned at the end of the video.

  • @neotekz
    @neotekz Před 11 měsíci

    Great review as usual. Where did you find that hex drawer stl? I tried looking on printables and thingiverse but couldnt find it.

    • @AuroraTech
      @AuroraTech  Před 11 měsíci

      I made it years ago with Tinkercad, if you like it, I will share it on Thingiverse later.

    • @neotekz
      @neotekz Před 11 měsíci

      @@AuroraTech That would be great. I see a lot of models on your videos that i like but couldnt find. What's your thingiverse link?

  • @tvideo1189
    @tvideo1189 Před 11 měsíci +38

    I think of Prusa printers like I think of Simplify3D slicing software. Top of the heap in the past... but that was the past. There are WAY too many printers out there now giving Prusa performance at 1/3 the price. As for slicers, Simplify3D sat on their hands for literally years before updating and when they finally did update it was actually laughable. Really just pathetic when you see how far beyond Simplify3D all the FREE slicers are nowadays. Ironically, I now use PrusaSlicer as my go-to slicing software although none of my five printers are Prusa.

    • @theglowcloud2215
      @theglowcloud2215 Před 11 měsíci +9

      The slavish adherence to the Prusa brand among a certain number of people really perplexes me. I bought a Prusa Mini in 2020 because it seemed like a fair value, but then I discovered its shortcomings: namely, the extruder and hotend. Add to that the 3D printed parts, which on the hotend weren't holding up well until I reprinted them in ASA, and I come away feeling that Prusa makes mediocre products. The MK3S is probably better, but it doesn't justify its price anymore. I appreciate Prusa's commitment to open source, but the value proposition of their hardware just isn't there.

  • @justinl.3587
    @justinl.3587 Před 11 měsíci +14

    Honestly I love the MK4 and the Bambulab equally. However, I will always refuse to print so fast on either of them. I have set them very low with print speed. Hopefully this will allow them to last a lot longer with less maintenance.

  • @Traitorman.14.3
    @Traitorman.14.3 Před 7 měsíci

    Comparing a full 1 layer sheet from a textured bed to a 1 layer sheet from a smooth sheet, is simply not fair.

  • @lienmeat
    @lienmeat Před 8 měsíci +3

    I'm so torn. I'm a happy Prusa Mini user, and am looking to get a larger format printer. I was hoping the MK4 would be that printer. There's just so many downsides though. It's half baked IMO, and not as good as it could be at all, especially for the money. That said a Bambu is hard for me to consider, as I'm very much opposed to having to use Bambu's cloud to have a functional printer. That alone is nearly a dealbreaker for me. It doesn't work with Octoprint, at all, which is IMO stupid, given how flexible and awesome Octoprint is. It also feel like they are getting free use of PrusaSlicer and Slic3r's hard work without really giving back at all. Those 3 things make me very feel almost bad about considering a Bambu at all, but the features, quality, and price are appealing despite those IMO extreme negatives.

    • @Traitorman.14.3
      @Traitorman.14.3 Před 7 měsíci +2

      The Bambu extremely large ENCRYPTED log files is my primary deal breaker. No control of what information they leech from my computer.

  • @hodanotyoda
    @hodanotyoda Před 11 měsíci +2

    I see that you have the new K1 sitting on your Flexi Desk, a review video coming very soon?

    • @AuroraTech
      @AuroraTech  Před 11 měsíci +3

      Yes, coming soon... want to do more tests on it before I release the video.

    • @madogheli6372
      @madogheli6372 Před 11 měsíci

      I can’t wait to see that K1 review 🙏🏻🙏🏻💨💨

  • @tomyocom5886
    @tomyocom5886 Před 11 měsíci

    Part of the failed print (black basket) at 20:13 may have also been from the VEVOR drawing extra air (cold air) across the bed!

  • @BOYVIRGO666
    @BOYVIRGO666 Před 10 měsíci

    did they fix that issue where the mk4 was hitting the bed witht he nozzle when testing live z making dents?

  • @KevinOsborn
    @KevinOsborn Před 6 měsíci

    I agree with many others here, that this is a most excelllent, fair and balanced review. I personally didn't do the math and did buy the upgrade (and came to the same conclusion that I should have bought the mk4 kit) but I do like my new Mk3.9. The usablity is dramatically increased.
    Also agree that Network setup and performance is a serious disappointment. Also, a perennial problem is the filament sensor which is or can become quite finnicky

  • @Average3djoe
    @Average3djoe Před 11 měsíci

    where did you get the stl for the jeep ?

  • @JGW5000
    @JGW5000 Před 22 dny

    As much as I wanted to get the MK4, the dismal Wi-Fi capabilities are a deal breaker and have me leaning towards looking elsewhere. Thank you for the excellent review

  • @Drd4all
    @Drd4all Před 7 měsíci

    One huge remark i would have is that beside the huge price, the printer looks like a garage DYI project. All those printed parts have a huge cost reduction. You have no tooling costs, no QA or very small production problems. This is insane that they actually charge you so much for the printer. The X1 in this case is a no brainer to me.

  • @thegps7197
    @thegps7197 Před 11 měsíci

    Would be keen to see how the prusa, bambu, creality compare when moving to different materials. Does speed printing translate when using petg, abs, nylon. Has core xy have an advantage as there naturally enclosed.

    • @ulforcemegamon3094
      @ulforcemegamon3094 Před 8 měsíci

      In both Nylon and petg you need to reduce speed , also applies with abs but not as much

  • @BrbrRmrm
    @BrbrRmrm Před 11 měsíci +1

    thank you for your in depth review
    I ordered MK4 kit 2 weeks ago which is the first 3d printer for me unfortunately it'll be shipped at the beginning of August.
    I was hoping to buy Bambu lab X1C since it has a very good reputation but unfortunately they didn't ship it to my country so I just ordered MK4 even I know that I buy a close price to X1C
    However, beside Bambu lab I don't think there's any printer can compete with it.

    • @isaackeller90
      @isaackeller90 Před 10 měsíci

      use a reship company :)

    • @BrbrRmrm
      @BrbrRmrm Před 10 měsíci

      @@isaackeller90 it's too expensive
      It's not worth it at all
      The cheapest I found is 350$+

    • @isaackeller90
      @isaackeller90 Před 10 měsíci

      @@BrbrRmrm oh I agree then sorry