The Walking Dead's Biggest Problem...

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 13. 01. 2023
  • The Walking Dead's Biggest Problem...
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 683

  • @Lax_Axl
    @Lax_Axl Před rokem +1398

    Killing off Carl was the worst mistake the showrunners made. Carl could of become the main character after Rick left. But nope, there goes all the character development they were building up for Carl.

    • @angelsackson
      @angelsackson Před rokem

      For a little girl and black boy who didnt talk... Classic leftist takeover of something we once held dear.

    • @darkerkyo
      @darkerkyo Před rokem +155

      It was the single dumbest decision ever. If they killed of Rick but kept Carl, I would still be interested because at least with Carl, you would have some nuance to it.

    • @Arcxisph
      @Arcxisph Před rokem +55

      @@darkerkyo facts and we would see him grow up with Judith

    • @darkwoods1954
      @darkwoods1954 Před rokem +54

      I never found the character likable and the actor wasn't good either. I thought they were clearing out the dead wood by kiling him off. I was surprised how many people were upset about it.

    • @AS.02
      @AS.02 Před rokem +10

      @@darkwoods1954 it rly fekn sucked but yeah he wasn’t a great actor

  • @GumBallMan987
    @GumBallMan987 Před rokem +910

    Wonder how the show would’ve been if Darabont was never fired

    • @VincentVincent_89
      @VincentVincent_89 Před rokem +224

      It would have been as good as breaking bad. I will admit the first 6 seasons are one of the bests in all of TV but Darabont wouldn’t have done the shitty decisions the show runners did with season 7 and 8 and how badly paced they felt.

    • @litneyloxan
      @litneyloxan Před rokem +101

      I swear I say this ALL THE TIME I would pay good money to go back in time and have 11 seasons of Darabont

    • @CarsonWolford
      @CarsonWolford Před rokem +51

      Probably a lot better. Darabont was vital in the making of the show.

    • @jetla22
      @jetla22 Před rokem +92

      AMC always been the #1 problem of the show.... being cheap, being greedy. Cutting the budget but adding too many episodes, stretching storylines with filler, getting ride of Carl because of money. It wasn't Gimple he was the scapegoat! It was and will always be AMC. Thank God they never got involved with Breaking Bad writers

    • @skwisgarskwigelf7191
      @skwisgarskwigelf7191 Před rokem +34

      Frank Darabont certainly had a certain vision for the show and it sucks we’ll never get to see how it would have progressed

  • @Ericmajuco
    @Ericmajuco Před rokem +153

    I think killing Carl wasn’t “The biggest TWD mistake” I think it actually was the biggest television history mistake. Negan worded it perfectly: “that kid was the future”

    • @jimlahey3919
      @jimlahey3919 Před 10 měsíci +2

      Biggest mistake in television history? Have you watched any other shows?

    • @stevenpohl8662
      @stevenpohl8662 Před 10 měsíci +12

      Yeah nah biggest goes to season 8 of Game of Thrones

    • @BrunaOneGirlBand
      @BrunaOneGirlBand Před 5 měsíci +2

      @@jimlahey3919 I have, and I've never witnessed another TV show make a decision that caused it's fall from grace on such a catastrophic level.

    • @jungkinoid8706
      @jungkinoid8706 Před 4 měsíci

      @@stevenpohl8662 i mean yeah but GoT season 8 is the culmination of like seven quadrillion mistakes, killing Carl is one single absolute fucking disaster

  • @sillythygoose
    @sillythygoose Před rokem +190

    We needed Carl in the later seasons so badly. They killed him off literally right before he really gets his time to shine in the "A New Beginning" and whisperers arcs. If they kept Carl alive and Andy still wanted to leave the show it would have been so cool to see Carl take over the mantle and become the leader his father was.

    • @tripplebrown2132
      @tripplebrown2132 Před rokem

      Carl Sucks!!!!

    • @rickpaul8012
      @rickpaul8012 Před 9 měsíci

      the left wing system has to emasculate the man, we cannot have ricks son alive because it goes against their agenda. Why else do you think homosexuality increased as the show went on?

  • @Dan_Edittz
    @Dan_Edittz Před rokem +437

    AMC's worst mistake was to kill the character that would be one of the protagonists of the new phase of the new world (Carl) and the best decision was to let Rick be taken to the CRM and not die in an armored way by Sebastian 🙏🙏 🙏... and finally the worst mistake of the writers was letting Michonne steal Morgan's protein bars 💀💀💀

    • @rightsider
      @rightsider Před rokem +22

      poor morgan bruh 😭😭

    • @THATGIRL0121
      @THATGIRL0121 Před rokem +5

      Carl left the show to focus on his education…🙄 lol

    • @jaydenpecora2193
      @jaydenpecora2193 Před rokem +5

      Bro I’ve Literally seen you comment on every twd videos
      Bruh do you have a life😂

    • @MarcoMaximusKojima
      @MarcoMaximusKojima Před rokem +18

      @@THATGIRL0121 Not exactly. The director wanted to fire him and kill his character off the show because he demanded a "raise." I had to find out myself after I finished 11 seasons until the end, and hearing this news realizing how much of a narcissist he thinks more for himself than the walking dead, and copied what Game of Thrones achieved.
      That achievement was nothing compared to the success what Game of Thrones did, but they sure did axed the show after Netflix offered Benioff & Whise millions of dollars, so I can try make a similar comparison for bad writing.

    • @Dan_Edittz
      @Dan_Edittz Před rokem +3

      @@rightsider 😢😢😢

  • @thekingsoftyrannynetwork3275

    The fact that Andrew Lincoln was silent for so long after informed that Carl was going to be killed off. Speaks volumes for what he knows about Rick's Character.

  • @RRM693
    @RRM693 Před rokem +485

    Slowly Rick's entire family left the show and we're left with Judith and Darryl

    • @RRM693
      @RRM693 Před rokem +55

      Darryl being his brother of course

    • @cp2342
      @cp2342 Před rokem +43

      And Carol too she was there from day 1 and would be considered family to Rick but yeah everyone started leaving

    • @02sideshow
      @02sideshow Před rokem +10

      Also Maggie

    • @RRM693
      @RRM693 Před rokem +6

      Oh and not to forget RJ who is Rick & Michonne's child

    • @jonfreeman9682
      @jonfreeman9682 Před rokem +11

      And Carol. But yeah Daryl and Carol are the only two original cast left. Surprised Carol lasted as long as she has cause when she started she was a meek abused housewife.

  • @shiddlestick
    @shiddlestick Před rokem +227

    The real biggest problem was morgan being all staff ninja one minute and then getting his ass kicked on the regular

    • @jonfreeman9682
      @jonfreeman9682 Před rokem +23

      Well that's because Morgan wasn't willing to fight.

    • @TheBlarggle
      @TheBlarggle Před rokem +9

      @@jonfreeman9682 It's actually because Morgan is a poorly written character.

    • @mark-fn8tj
      @mark-fn8tj Před 6 měsíci

      @@TheBlargglenope sometimes in fear but not in the main show

    • @zacharysheriff449
      @zacharysheriff449 Před 20 dny

      @@TheBlargglesaying this shows you don’t know a thing about writing

  • @fizzychizzy
    @fizzychizzy Před rokem +316

    Danai, first and foremost, before she started acting on this show, was a playwright. Being in Atlanta for so many months out of the year is counterproductive to what her actual focus is, which is writing plays. She should be in NYC. The Walking Dead paid the bills, BUT she is an award winning playwright that has had her work appear on Broadway. The moment that Danai got casted in Black Panther is the moment I knew her days were numbered on TWD. That movie was giving her enough dough to pay the bills and the participation in TWD was not needed to meet that demand. Furthermore, the movie requires less time for her so she can spend more time playwrighting. The departure of Andrew the next season after she got the role just made it easier.
    But, I would like to point out that Danai is cowriting the Rick and Michonne spinoff so she is still doing the same thing she loves doing while participating in The Walking Dead universe.

    • @litneyloxan
      @litneyloxan Před rokem +29

      I never thought about it that way thank you for explaining that out. Danai is so fkn talented man, she deserves to make more than AMC is. AMC has been in a battle to save money for shareholders and executives ruining their shows for so long.

    • @jonfreeman9682
      @jonfreeman9682 Před rokem +2

      Absolutely. Every actor screenwriter playwright needs to balance their artistic aspirations with finances. TWD honestly was a great gig and still is. But back its heyday it was a huge success with 18 million viewers so you don't want to miss that opportunity. MCU is a huge publicity gig you don't want to miss out on as well. You do those two and you can indulge in your other passions.

    • @angelsackson
      @angelsackson Před rokem

      She is a pathetic BLM shill who is going to absolutely trash this show. We wanted a rick spin off. Not stunning and brave black girl rescuing weak prisoner white man. Go woke go broke. It's going to be pathetic with this idiot having anything to do with being in it, let alone writing it.
      Also you know way too much about her. I'd suggest putting that effort into something that matters. Not a rich black woman who claims she is a victim.

    • @orangejuice7247
      @orangejuice7247 Před rokem +3

      @Empire of the Wolves why? She a good character in MCU

    • @sayo2409
      @sayo2409 Před rokem

      @Empire of the Wolves Yep. Fall from grace.

  • @joshuapool5048
    @joshuapool5048 Před rokem +31

    Rick&Michonne: Our characters have no point any more because Carl is dead
    Judith & RJ, their literal children: Bruh

    • @mistersinister2043
      @mistersinister2043 Před 9 měsíci +5

      You can't replace a key character from the show with an infant

    • @mutemeimscared1632
      @mutemeimscared1632 Před měsícem

      @@mistersinister2043 Judith is around 13 now, and i think RJ is around 8 or 9

  • @CaulfieldBrooks312
    @CaulfieldBrooks312 Před rokem +18

    No matter her reasons for leaving, Danai put her ALL into Michonne until the very end. There's was never one single moment where I thought she was any other person on earth besides Michonne.
    She inhabited that character PERFECTLY.
    So damn ready to see her and Andy again on their new show.

  • @sketch762
    @sketch762 Před rokem +104

    Although she wasn't mentioned here, I feel like AMC screwed up when deciding to kill off Andrea. Her death was simply for shock value, but I feel like she could've done more if AMC kept her on longer.

    • @jandressss
      @jandressss Před rokem +8

      yea that was the showrunners fault at the time. That's why im pretty sure he was fired and replaced with scott gimple.

    • @goldiekoi935
      @goldiekoi935 Před rokem +11

      Personally I didn’t like Andreas death either but lots of people seemed to dislike that character so I feel it was for the best. She did make a lot of bad decisions.

    • @troypage5994
      @troypage5994 Před rokem +24

      @@goldiekoi935 I agree. She never listened to good advice. Andrea felt that she didn't have to follow rules. She could've killed the governor many times but she didn't. Her death was her own fault.

    • @Jjangbunbun
      @Jjangbunbun Před rokem +9

      I was so tired of Andrea at that point it made sense she died bc of the gov

    • @ATD-uc3lb
      @ATD-uc3lb Před rokem +6

      I'm currently rewatching TWD and what I've noticed in her death episode and the episodes leading up to it is that there were so many things could've done for her not to die. Personally, I find the Governor somehow finding her at every turn way too convenient. And then I got really irritated that Milton wouldn't just crawl on the ground and get the pliers for her. I suppose the Milton thing isn't convenience because I've never been stabbed multiple times and don't know how much pain that would be, but if I was him, I'd do everything I can to drag my ass across that floor and give her the pliers directly.
      I got a little off track. Anyways. I do agree. I didn't like her death, but the Andrea in the show had a character assassination. She was very different in the show versus the comics, and I think Michonne just kinda slid into her place later on.
      Another thing I've noticed with S3 is that they did have so many opportunities to kill the governor and just didn't. When Merle and Daryl were forced to fight each other for entertainment, they had every opportunity to snipe the Governor down and didn't. Then Andrea could've killed him numerous times and didn't. Then Rick could've just shot him in a second when they were "negotiating". Just too many conveniences that kept the Governor alive the entire time.

  • @littlemow
    @littlemow Před rokem +100

    The only death worse than Carl has to be Gargulio….

    • @edwinyouell6449
      @edwinyouell6449 Před rokem +28

      "Gargullio.. Hear that bird? *Gunshot* Gargullio..

    • @shadows_star
      @shadows_star Před rokem +2

      Who?

    • @edwinyouell6449
      @edwinyouell6449 Před rokem +19

      @@shadows_star Gargullio was the person Merle killed in 3x6 when he was sent after Michonne

    • @skwisgarskwigelf7191
      @skwisgarskwigelf7191 Před rokem +15

      A pretty merciful death though. Quick and painless. He probably didn’t even know what hit him

    • @itsdylanjenkins
      @itsdylanjenkins Před rokem +15

      @@edwinyouell6449 I went "who the hell?"
      and then read your comment and went "OH, GARGULLIO!!!!"
      and said it just like Rooker.

  • @darkwoods1954
    @darkwoods1954 Před rokem +13

    Jesus being killed off after his character was totally wasted was a big turning point for me. The show had lost a lot of the big characters then went on to waste what good characters they had left. Replacing them with new, boring characters like Magda and her gang.

  • @dredgenheresy
    @dredgenheresy Před rokem +28

    This show had so much potential when all of the OG characters started showing up around season 2-4 if they were able to keep a majority of those people alive or at least not hold onto useless characters, cough cough Tara. They might actually have had something to work with in the later seasons.

    • @sobersuds
      @sobersuds Před rokem +4

      Eugene was also soooo useless the ENTIRE TIME! Afraid to do anything and just dead weight. These writers were dropped on their heads as children or something.

    • @solidzack
      @solidzack Před rokem +6

      They kept introducing new character that you'd have a hard time bonding with while also killing off those characters that their audience kept growing to, mainly to "capitalize on the shock value". Beth is the prime example, who died in the dumbest way imaginable. But there's also Tyreese who was also lazily killed off after being developed quite well. Abraham was a great character but I get why Negan would choose him to die, but this made Glenns death so much worse. Enid was one of those later introduced characters that wasn't likeable for a while but eventually developed in a good way, but of course she also got killed off for shock value. Henry was the main character of season 8 and everything revolved about his romance with Alphas daughter and yet again he was killed to capitalize on "shock value".
      On the flipside you got all those new replacements you're expected to bond with now that the old cast was killed off like Terra, Rosita, Eugene, Siddiq, Magna and Yumiko, Connie and Kelly, Luke, Leah and Princess. This is way too much, of course some of them feel completely out of place. Originally the crew was realpy small up until season 5-6, but alas they kept introducing new people to replace the ones they discard. This is a horrible writing strategy if you ask me

  • @bejaminmaston1347
    @bejaminmaston1347 Před rokem +19

    They killed Carl off because they didn't wanna pay him more for being a adult

    • @RebeccaGaines588
      @RebeccaGaines588 Před rokem +1

      To be paid like an adult, you have to have acting skill like an adult and Chandler lacked in acting and hurt Carl's character.

    • @dylanroemmele906
      @dylanroemmele906 Před rokem +2

      @@RebeccaGaines588 cope

    • @moneymonkeyman8280
      @moneymonkeyman8280 Před rokem

      @@dylanroemmele906 chandler wasn’t a good actor

    • @dylanroemmele906
      @dylanroemmele906 Před rokem +2

      @@moneymonkeyman8280 no

    • @deathsaidhello
      @deathsaidhello Před rokem

      @@dylanroemmele906 its true tho. he was getting "better" throughout the seasons but he never really had that convincing character moment that made me think "yeah, no one else could do this role..." and thats not the most important thing, saying the role cant be filled by just anyone, but its something a long running show should be considering so the later seasons wont have to kill off an important character. Chandler was ok for the first 2 seasons where he was a key priority due to how innocent and unready he was for the world, even before an apocalypse, all he had to do was cry and say dad and he was set. As the show progressed and he got more solo moments it became apparent the leaning on the "cry for dad" act had held back more potential for chandler himself to get better at his craft, not just the character. He was still a kid tho, so none of it really matters in the long run considering TWD set him up for future consideration in roles we dont even know of yet.

  • @ClashedPR
    @ClashedPR  Před rokem +166

    I hope you guys are enjoying these long form videos I've been making! Let me know other cool subjects and topics you guys wanna see in an in depth long video! 🔥🙏🏻

    • @MakiMadara
      @MakiMadara Před rokem +6

      Love these videos bros also your edits been here from the start your a inspiration wish you the best,hope you reach 1 million

    • @lucille_2real713
      @lucille_2real713 Před rokem +4

      Keep doing these they're great 🔥👍

    • @Dan_Edittz
      @Dan_Edittz Před rokem +4

      These videos is 🔥🔥🔥🔥

    • @DZMBRYT
      @DZMBRYT Před rokem +1

      Definitely, very informative and interesting video bro 🙌

    • @litneyloxan
      @litneyloxan Před rokem +1

      I found you through shorts and now watch for your longer content so please keep doing it. Like twd explained channel goes into different things. There’s so much you can expand on

  • @_delirious
    @_delirious Před rokem +31

    i feel like Beth should've lived a couple more episodes or seasons 😭

    • @jessseg4100
      @jessseg4100 Před rokem +4

      I agree. I wasn’t a fan of her at first but I grew to like her RIGHT before she was killed! 🤦🏻‍♀️

    • @_delirious
      @_delirious Před rokem +7

      @@jessseg4100 should've made it to alexandria at least.. or you know. not kill her at all! 😭

    • @eddiefly1839
      @eddiefly1839 Před rokem +4

      She could have easily lived longer, i honestly dont know why she stabbed that cop... literally so silly...

  • @Gayman6948
    @Gayman6948 Před rokem +120

    They definitely shouldn’t have killed Carl

  • @teatears7611
    @teatears7611 Před rokem +71

    the maggie walking sound effects got me 💀

    • @megaraptora
      @megaraptora Před rokem +7

      i just got to that point and its so fucking hilarious LOL

    • @angelinaoliver5587
      @angelinaoliver5587 Před rokem

      Meeeee 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @peakbam
    @peakbam Před rokem +8

    On top of Rick and Carl not appearing in later half of season 9, then 10. The main group for some reason stopped using guns, this took me out of it completely because all the conflicts they got into they could have easily tackled not even a season ago. Some could say they ran out of ammunition, but considering the amount of guns and ammunition there is in the USA this is unlikely. On top of that, Eugene knows how to make bullets so it really killed the atmosphere of the show for me - I could not take it seriously anymore.

    • @zacharysheriff449
      @zacharysheriff449 Před 20 dny

      You expect guns and ammo to be abundant after 12 years of being used against zombies and other people with little to no new ammo or guns being made? Yes Eugene knew how to make them but that takes a lot of resources and equipment. Keep in mind how well places like the commonwealth were armed, meaning weapons and ammo that the main group would have wanted to find had already been taken, and you can assume the commonwealth was taking the resources to make more as well with how freely they used ammo

  • @klasus2344
    @klasus2344 Před rokem +8

    As good as Negan is, it makes no sense that he is still around

  • @stumonster6091
    @stumonster6091 Před rokem +42

    I just seriously wonder, if it was so devastating to so many of the cast that chandler Riggs was being killed off how could they not fight that decision at all? Surely they could have done anything to even sway the show runners idea to kill him off :/

    • @jaye-alex4513
      @jaye-alex4513 Před rokem +14

      apparently they tried, and honestly if I were chandler I wouldn't want to stay after the showrunners did something like that even if it had worked

    • @RebeccaGaines588
      @RebeccaGaines588 Před rokem +3

      They could have recast Carl. I would have wanted him to stay had they done that

    • @karengoldenthal2889
      @karengoldenthal2889 Před rokem +1

      @Rebecca Gaines ,
      It was a Money Decision. wrong headed. Wouldn't have been a good call

    • @RebeccaGaines588
      @RebeccaGaines588 Před rokem +2

      @@karengoldenthal2889 I understand that. AMC is a SINFULLY CHEAP! They CONTINUOUSLY bring in new cast instead of focusing on the storyline. (Super annoying, especially when we were waiting for a wrap up of the the show)
      Bad managing at AMC. But Chandler was not a strong actor. Definitely not strong enough to carry the show. So, the original story would have been better than where they went with it, had it been a better actor I would have thought the same, I was just all in all sick of Chandler. Not Carl.

  • @JAAndo
    @JAAndo Před rokem +4

    Jesus seemed like the biggest underused character to me. The dude could single handidly kill a horde of zombies yet his only memorable scenes were his introduction and his death. The way he died was perfect but it was way too soon, and if they needed him to die at that time they should of used him more before his death. Everybody immediately liked his character, once people feel connected to a character they have so much possibility with it which they wasted. Yet they introduce a new group of connie, magna, yumiko, the musician dude, etc who are all still alive and get a bunch of screentime that nobody cares about.

  • @chrisbeach423
    @chrisbeach423 Před rokem +19

    Andrew Lincoln wanted to leave the show after season 4 all the way up until season 8. The cast and crew kept convincing him to stay. Jadis and the Scavengers were brought into the show mainly just to take Rick away. Also Georgie was only brought into the show for Lauren Cohan to leave. Both Georgie and the Scavengers were brought into season 8 just for those reasons 😂

  • @PandemoniumPirateRadio
    @PandemoniumPirateRadio Před rokem +7

    The show was already dead by the time Carl died. The death of Andrea was the real big one back when the show still mattered. The Negan introduction then REALLY killed all momentum of the show and it never recovered the viewership it had previously.

    • @Spitfirethedragon
      @Spitfirethedragon Před rokem

      I think each season, the show went downhill when kids get killed off and all that. I was glad to see Denise and Olivia got more time onscreen and then they took those two out. Plus, Henry's death was the last straw. Carol lost Sophia, the two sisters from the prison and then Henry. It is way too much for her.

  • @Armylady74
    @Armylady74 Před rokem +5

    AMC did Chandler Riggs wrong! I was so pissed because it’s supposed to become through Carl’s point!🤬😡After Lincoln left, I didn’t watch the rest of the seasons until now.

    • @nathangarnett9476
      @nathangarnett9476 Před rokem

      Season 9 I think was actually amazing even after Rick left

    • @whiskerstars
      @whiskerstars Před měsícem

      @@nathangarnett9476only because of the whisperers

  • @jetla22
    @jetla22 Před rokem +24

    The biggest problem is AMC! Started off killing the budget, firing the director, adding too many episodes. Those 3 things haunted the show

    • @skwisgarskwigelf7191
      @skwisgarskwigelf7191 Před rokem +1

      Season 7 had way too many filler episodes

    • @adilcn1774
      @adilcn1774 Před rokem +1

      @@skwisgarskwigelf7191 Yeah, after season 5 onwards I skip forward most of the scenes. When the characters start to share their feelings each other like they are laying on the couch of a psychiatrist, I just roll my eyes and skip forward. I skipped entire episode of Tara got left on those beach group.

    • @zacharysheriff449
      @zacharysheriff449 Před 20 dny

      @@adilcn1774ironically, the episode you skipped was the first one I ever watched

  • @ryanelliott71698
    @ryanelliott71698 Před rokem +17

    Didn’t know Heath’s actor didn’t want to leave. You learn something new every day.

    • @skwisgarskwigelf7191
      @skwisgarskwigelf7191 Před rokem +6

      And they never resolved that part. Was Heath dead or alive? What the hell happened there?

    • @RebeccaGaines588
      @RebeccaGaines588 Před rokem +3

      @@skwisgarskwigelf7191 Apparently, we will find out of we keep watching. It may take another 10 years to find out though.
      But, the CRM took him. Same people that have Rick.

  • @yeattwizzyrichbitcointikok1120

    I don’t think Maggie leaving is outrageous, she couldn’t be around people that were keeping Negan alive it was too much

    • @vivs9314
      @vivs9314 Před rokem +3

      But she was the one who let him live first…She was going to bash his head in when he was in confinement, but then realize him living was the best punishment for him.

    • @yeattwizzyrichbitcointikok1120
      @yeattwizzyrichbitcointikok1120 Před rokem

      @@vivs9314 yo ur right

  • @thezoinksguy
    @thezoinksguy Před rokem +18

    Nothing is worse than the departure of Bob Adams

    • @boop004
      @boop004 Před rokem +1

      can't go back bob

  • @ciocancristian-vasilegrupa8564

    Wow! It's so nice to hear your voice after watching so many of your edits! Keep it up!

  • @magicpyroninja
    @magicpyroninja Před 10 měsíci +4

    I think one of the biggest problems in the show was they never looked into any mass zombie, killing traps or anything. It was one scene and one instance where they rolled some logs down a hill and took out a whole group of them but they never did anything cool like that again really
    It's not hard to find a way to take out large groups of extremely slow moving zombies, especially when they have all that equipment available to them

  • @chelseav291
    @chelseav291 Před rokem +27

    you forgot to mention this, but Jesus also left the show due to Tom Payne's request, because he felt that the character had become stale and i think at that time he was working on his show Prodigal Son

    • @Blackfireproduction1
      @Blackfireproduction1 Před rokem +11

      From what I understand it was less that he felt his character had become stale and more that he felt his character was being underutilised

  • @OddGuysOfficial
    @OddGuysOfficial Před rokem

    Love all your fullscreens man keep it up homie

  • @aurteekay6339
    @aurteekay6339 Před rokem +34

    I think michonnes character very much had some things to do still. She still had Judith, some people forget how much of a mother she was and how close her and Judith are. They just basically pawned her parenthood off on Daryl because it was easy but I would’ve loved to see some more michonne and Judith

    • @Legion852
      @Legion852 Před rokem

      Ignore Judith She had R.J her actual Son...Judith wasnt hers i could see MAYBE pawning her off But R.J is actually hers like no mother would leave there child to find there Husband and as a father of 2 and a Husband If my wife left my 2 kids behind to come find me i would kill her myself.

    • @MandoF
      @MandoF Před rokem +6

      And her own kid which she seemingly abandoned

    • @Iletyoulive
      @Iletyoulive Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@MandoFyou're acting like she left her kids in the woods when they are safe with family 😂😂😂

    • @MandoF
      @MandoF Před 6 měsíci

      @@Iletyoulive define safe in the walking dead universe LOL

    • @Iletyoulive
      @Iletyoulive Před 6 měsíci

      @@MandoF those kids live in a community where they go to school,where they can be kids and with people that would protect them with their lives,saying michonne abandoned her kids is not only disingenuous but trolling

  • @jimmyd4282
    @jimmyd4282 Před rokem +6

    I’m having a really hard time finishing season 11 on Netflix. I’ve been a huge fan for over 10 years. Seasons 1-6 is some of the best TV I’ve ever seen. Watched numerous times. Season 7-8 were bad. Season 9 was amazing. Season 10& 11 have been boring. Too many characters, too much stuff going on, the characters aren’t as interesting , all my favorites are gone, not enough focus on the l horror aspect ect. It’s actually been a struggle finishing this show. What a shame. Rick leaving & them killing off Carl were the 2 biggest blows to the show. I’m keeping my fingers crossed for these spin off shows but not getting my hopes up too high.

  • @Omendrix
    @Omendrix Před rokem +4

    I always go back to my main statement -
    “ At least it isn’t Fear The Walking Dead “.

  • @TaliEpshtein
    @TaliEpshtein Před rokem +5

    For me Carl’s death was the last straw, too.

  • @mistersinister2043
    @mistersinister2043 Před 9 měsíci +2

    Carl was the end of the show. That's when I stopped watching.
    No one was left to carry the original story after that.
    What's the point of telling a story, if halfway through you're going to kill off all the characters we followed and replace them with new ones? You should have just told the story starting from the 2nd group of characters.
    All the ended up doing was having a revolving door of new characters that no one wanted to bond to because we knew they would die of for stupid reasons.
    At least Game of Thrones was smart enough to keep the core members of the original cast around.

  • @DynamowydShorts
    @DynamowydShorts Před rokem +3

    I've never seen TWD but gonna watch this vid in full, clean editing so far btw

    • @MonoKard
      @MonoKard Před rokem

      Your videos are worse than mine

  • @isaacraid9975
    @isaacraid9975 Před rokem +7

    I hope they reboot TWD one day with Frank Darabont on the project. I know they can't really use the same actors but they should reboot the show and follow the original show events perfectly maybe change a few deaths like Hershel maybe idk but then when it gets to All Out War they DONT kill Carl off and they make sure whoever plays Rick actually stays on the show. End it perfectly.

  • @highonsugar6273
    @highonsugar6273 Před 5 měsíci +1

    I feel like there are so many characters from the walking dead that died too early whether or not the actors left the show: Andrea, Beth, Carl, Dale, Enid, Tara, T-Dog, and I could name so many more, I feel like less thought was put into the deaths especially in later seasons and a lot of deaths were just used for shock factor and laziness

  • @joeb.evrythngEclectic5571

    Andrew Lincoln actually stated he regretted leaving the Walking Dead.

  • @Itz_Puxe
    @Itz_Puxe Před rokem +3

    Broooo . Just imagine if Frank was still the showrunner from the get-go 😭

  • @Mr_van_Der_Linde
    @Mr_van_Der_Linde Před rokem

    This channel grew so big very fast, as one of the first subscribers l congratulate you my friend

  • @UndeadShorts
    @UndeadShorts Před rokem +2

    Your #1 Fan Clash. Keep up the great work! 🧟‍♂️

  • @georgejennings8743
    @georgejennings8743 Před rokem +1

    The Negan and Maggie series will be an insult to Glen

  • @derekc1289
    @derekc1289 Před rokem +4

    I would’ve loved to see badass Carl in whisperer getup walking amongst the dead

  • @ViveXR
    @ViveXR Před rokem +7

    non of this would've happened if michonne didn't take the protein bar

  • @wolverineiscool7161
    @wolverineiscool7161 Před 7 měsíci

    Andrew leaving as rick grimes and glenns death is the biggest mistake

  • @angelicvega7040
    @angelicvega7040 Před rokem +3

    At the end of TWD, I wasn’t even sad or nostalgic because literally every main character that is important that is left alive is getting their own spin-off of some sort anyways, smh. I doesn’t even feel like the show is over.

  • @Tradeofjane
    @Tradeofjane Před 10 měsíci +2

    Scott Gimple's ability to gimp every show he touches is amazing. What's even more amazing is the fact that AMC hasn't fired his a**.

  • @RebeccaGaines588
    @RebeccaGaines588 Před rokem +2

    I think I would have been more upset about Carl had the actor, Chandler Riggs, done a better job.
    He just wasn't a strong actor, he hadn't really grown from the beginning, he had a bit of a chip on his shoulders I could always feel.
    He always felt like he was reading a script rather than BEING the character. (Kind of like, he assumed his character was safe, so he didn't really have to try.)
    But, all in all, he just isn't a strong actor, Carl should have been cast to a much stronger actor.
    He was annoying, but I respected his character, but he sucked as Carl, and really held him back IMO.

    • @sansn7261
      @sansn7261 Před rokem

      I AGREE SO SO SO MUCH WITH THIS!! he wasn't a great actor and Carl (comic wise) was a really STRONG character to begin with. Chandler Riggs in my opinion doesn't bring anything to the table, Carl (in the series) didn't grow for me, he started to "grow" in the 8th season but it was really slow and not really important tbh, he was going to die anyways. for me he wasn't annoying cause he wasn't there lmao, he was like a ghost and really feel like he was the shadow from Rick and I get why but that's AMC fault
      i'm mad at the series cause Carl in the comics is such a great character, and it's really important through the entire series, but i don't get why they didn't try to accomplish that?
      The try to make importance to every single character, and i get why, but that doesn't make sense at all, why make an entire arc about Rosita trying to kill Negan? like, yes, it makes sense but they could still make an arc about Rosita but with the help of others with they OWN sense, like they really make weird choices with 7th-8th seasons, they really didn't what to do

  • @malcolmferguson4869
    @malcolmferguson4869 Před 9 měsíci +1

    There was also Kevin Carroll who played Virgil. He just... vanished after S11E8, and was never seen or mentioned again. I have no idea what happened there.

  • @FractalKrystian
    @FractalKrystian Před rokem +6

    Nah. Judith and Negan made it special anyways. Whisperers were the scariest ones and both Maggie and Rick weren't a part of it. Daryl, Negan and Carol played it nicely. Honestly, didn't miss anybody during that time.
    About Andrew. Some people have no idea how psychologically exhausting is this type of acting that Andrew went through. Do you think that his realism was just an empty act?? Get it first that you have to force a lot of emotions on yourself and you can cause serious trauma to yourself. Andrew went grey in just few years. Now think about why so many actors etc ends up addicted and relying on other weird stuff.

    • @daddyshome275
      @daddyshome275 Před rokem +1

      Yes for me I was more interested in relationship of Negan and Judith then Daryl and Judith, not complaining though. When Negan saved Judith and Dog from winter storm in season 10 it felt heartwarming.

    • @FractalKrystian
      @FractalKrystian Před rokem

      @@daddyshome275 Exactly. For me Judith to survive and her importance in this show was obvious since Laurie's death episode. From the scene when She helped Luke and the rest after Rick's disappearance, everything became interesting on a different level. They did it well.

    • @ysmdylan3023
      @ysmdylan3023 Před rokem

      @@daddyshome275that was the season 9 finale actually

    • @Jimmy-iy9pl
      @Jimmy-iy9pl Před rokem

      The show was just disgraceful post Carl's death.

    • @FractalKrystian
      @FractalKrystian Před rokem

      @@Jimmy-iy9pl 🤣Then you should just stop watching and get on with your life. Fcn simple.

  • @magiccookies420
    @magiccookies420 Před rokem +1

    My main problem is it just fell victim to what most long-running shows do. With 16 and THEN 24 episodes a season, it started to feel like a chore to watch..

    • @magiccookies420
      @magiccookies420 Před rokem

      With most of the arcs in TWD they easily could’ve done 8 episode seasons. So much time is spent dicking around and talking.

    • @JAAndo
      @JAAndo Před rokem

      100 percent, they make us fall in love with a show than fuck it all up by dragging out episodes for money grabs and we all keep watching because of the hope that it'll get as good as it was during seasons 1-6

  • @augustus7975
    @augustus7975 Před rokem +3

    I wish I could go back in time to fix the show before it turned into this.

  • @datguy3581
    @datguy3581 Před rokem +2

    Honestly I think they should've ended the story at season 8 or 9 with as much of the cast as possible. I know the comics keep going and they could've kept going in spin offs but I would've preferred if they had given the main show a proper ending focusing on its oldest characters instead of having it just keep going and losing all its most important characters along the way. They could've kept a spin off going and adapted more comic parts after that but they should've had a proper ending for the entire cast.

  • @DSBJR22
    @DSBJR22 Před rokem

    Im really curious to see Rick’s reaction to finding out about the whispers i hope Michonne brings it up in future conversation.

  • @NathanJ3
    @NathanJ3 Před 7 měsíci

    The biggest issue with the walking dead after some stupid writing decisions is season length. There are way too many filler episodes throughout the seasons, which don’t particularly add anything to character development or story progression. 10 episode seasons would have suited this show more in my opinion

  • @FlowerKnight2
    @FlowerKnight2 Před rokem +1

    I stopped watching after season 9, with Carl dead and Rick gone the show felt hollow..
    It felt like a corpse of it's former self, and I tried getting into season 10 several times but just couldn't.
    I just barely started watching the show again this week, and I've managed to get through half the season so far, it's been decent, I like seeing more of Negan, but I feel really disconnected with everyone else's stories, and find myself not caring or feeling bored.
    Going to try and finish the entire series though, I'm hoping season 11 will be good.

  • @megamoron1598
    @megamoron1598 Před rokem +1

    it would’ve been cool to see how dales character would’ve changed in the seasons moving forward

  • @user-us5dr2qi2r
    @user-us5dr2qi2r Před rokem +4

    Like any show based on a written material, when you make changes that are major you will get back lash and it changes the momentum of the show as well.

    • @zacharysheriff449
      @zacharysheriff449 Před 20 dny

      Funny how sticking to the comics is what lost them the most viewership

    • @user-us5dr2qi2r
      @user-us5dr2qi2r Před 20 dny

      @@zacharysheriff449 lmao, tell me you did t read the comics without telling me you didn't read the comics..
      People left the show because they killed Carl as he is the one who was doing most of the things ricl and Darell were doing. After they got rid of him.

    • @zacharysheriff449
      @zacharysheriff449 Před 20 dny

      @@user-us5dr2qi2r actually, the show had one of if not its biggest drop off in viewership when Glenn died, which was accurate to the comics. Don't come at me again until you know what you're talking about

    • @user-us5dr2qi2r
      @user-us5dr2qi2r Před 20 dny

      @zacharysheriff449 lol oh, you're one of them, Glenn's death was known from the start. His death, yes, did cause some noncomic fans to leave it wasn't the biggest, Carl's death was the biggest decline because it went off script, and by the time of his death there were a few good cherectures left from the comics, and when the future lead of the story is killed off it kinda kills the viewer ship.
      And I dont need to 'come at you' as you have nothing to come get.

    • @zacharysheriff449
      @zacharysheriff449 Před 20 dny

      @@user-us5dr2qi2r I’m “one of them” for naming a literal fact? Do facts hurt your feelings or something? Look up any data or article talking about viewership and Glenn’s death is a cause for one of the highest drops in tv show history. You got angry over a simple comment and can’t admit to being wrong, I’m almost embarrassed for you. Also if you’re calling me one of those people to imply I stopped watching after his death, that’s plain wrong and a horrible assumption on your part. His death is actually why I STARTED watching the show because everyone kept talking about it

  • @J.F.331
    @J.F.331 Před rokem +2

    Honestly, if they would have ended the show at the end of season 8, Negan defeated, Rick having a mortal wound and slowly bled out (kind of like the end of The War of the Planet of the Apes” knowing that there is le peace. I would have been okay with that.

  • @hrkov
    @hrkov Před 8 měsíci +1

    when all those characters left at the same time it felt like we were forced to love connies group after 1-2 episodes. connie was cool but the rest were so bitchy and dramatic

  • @roarmbee7045
    @roarmbee7045 Před 8 měsíci

    Lost of themes, Carl's death, and filler episodes are the problems of the walking dead

  • @R3FL3X84
    @R3FL3X84 Před rokem +3

    ive just watched season 8-9 and 10 and they killed so many off, you could just tell it was coming to an end.

    • @eddiefly1839
      @eddiefly1839 Před rokem

      but still they pushed on with a few more seasons lol

  • @autonomous8108
    @autonomous8108 Před rokem +1

    Rick was the final nail in the coffin, but I had been losing interest in the show for a while. It just started feeling.... Weird. By the time the final season was out, it seemed like all the original characters were gone, and we were left with a bunch of new characters, or newer characters that we either had no time to connect with, or they just weren't enough to fill the shoes of the ones who left. Like I said, even tho I think the show was going down hill already, it really felt like Rick shooting that last shot turned it into an avalanche. "I found em" BOOM *show crumbles, as flaming zombies walk off the edge, and everyone cries*

  • @fnafboy1014
    @fnafboy1014 Před rokem +1

    I love how the intro and thumbnail looks like SunnyV2

  • @lorenwoirhaye4687
    @lorenwoirhaye4687 Před rokem

    Andrew Lincoln brought his family to Atlanta but his kids got older and he wanted them to be in school I think so he wanted to be home more. I guess he didn't want to move to the states and have them in American schools or home school them.

  • @matxalenc8410
    @matxalenc8410 Před 8 měsíci

    I know this was not the point, but god do I miss Whiskey Cavalier!

  • @realest92
    @realest92 Před rokem +1

    My biggest problem with the walking dead was killing off characters for shock value.

  • @dittohead7044
    @dittohead7044 Před rokem +1

    The excuse “No one is Safe” got real old, really fast

  • @jamesm2078
    @jamesm2078 Před rokem +1

    There were some facts here I never knew until now. I also agree that they should’ve kept Carl alive

  • @stumonster6091
    @stumonster6091 Před rokem +9

    “Michonne had no reason to stick around anymore.” Bro what do you mean? How about he son she had with Rick and Ricks daughter who she said was never going to leave behind? She had plenty of reason to not leave

  • @elijahiscozy
    @elijahiscozy Před rokem +1

    You should make a twd edit with (talking to the moon x fantasy) music

  • @Dubbascus
    @Dubbascus Před rokem

    there was also rumors of AMC getting rid of chandler riggs because he would have to sign a new contract that would cost AMC millions

  • @FGB9127
    @FGB9127 Před rokem +22

    I think the biggest problem of TWD is the CGI 😂

  • @jimmyallgood781
    @jimmyallgood781 Před rokem +1

    I'm just hoping all roads in the spinoffs and FTWD connect back to Rick Grimes and the CRM in a grand crossover event. That would be the smartest thing to do to try and save this beautiful franchise they've run into the ground, right???
    I'm probably gonna be left disappointed but one can dream right?
    Rick Grimes is The Walking Dead and his ending should close out this franchise.
    But we all know within 10 years we'll be following adult Judith in season 5 of "The Next Generation" lol.

  • @hakkzii3863
    @hakkzii3863 Před rokem +1

    All I think they wanted is to make the series as real as possible so that not everyone can survive like Glenn or people that had no training to kill but most of them learnt it from Rick and Shane

  • @aquariusspirit4210
    @aquariusspirit4210 Před rokem +1

    If they kept Shane alive he could have came back to fight Carl for Judith, kinda like carls coming of age.

  • @soundken1
    @soundken1 Před rokem +1

    Carl was killed off due to disagreement with the show runners, Lincoln left as a result of the treatment of Carl...

  • @joncolunga673
    @joncolunga673 Před 4 měsíci

    What's sad is you can tell Carl's death came from issues in real life with the show runners. Since Chandler Riggs parents bought a house close to the set after he signed a huge contract extension. That's what you had as leaders for the show at the time, fighting with a teenager like children.

  • @MrDeathChicken
    @MrDeathChicken Před 6 měsíci

    I heard a rumour that they killed of Carl because Chandler Riggs turned 18 meaning he was entitled to a higher wage now that he was an adult. AMC did not want to renogogiate a higher salary so they cut him loose. The show had/has a long running issue with funding and people getting paid properly. (AMC was in multiple lawsuits during the run of the series.)

  • @PearsHoney
    @PearsHoney Před rokem +1

    CORAL stop hitting the gritty in front of the walkers. They don't like that

  • @CjayTheKidd
    @CjayTheKidd Před rokem

    yk how hard would it be considering multi-verse theory exists, to make a spin off but fix the issues
    for example, if its an alternate timeline, we could get a future with carl, rick and even glenn.
    Imagine how different it would be if they actually killed negan
    edit: I would just like to have a show that would have given us carl as the main character after season 8.

  • @DingleJingle69
    @DingleJingle69 Před rokem +1

    Bro ur editing is amazing

  • @wrecclessescobar6252
    @wrecclessescobar6252 Před rokem +1

    That Maggie edit 😂😂

  • @kvnbckmn3637
    @kvnbckmn3637 Před 9 měsíci +1

    Lincoln: I am leaving caus carl died, i have no meaning in my character anymore
    Diane: I am leaving caus carl died, i have no meaning in my character anymore
    Judith: am I a damn Joke to you ?!?!?!?

  • @mingoplayz9926
    @mingoplayz9926 Před rokem

    Not sure if the is 100% correct but I've also heard carl was killed of because he was turning 18 in 2 weeks and they didn't want to give him more pay considering he would be an adult

  • @Mythical.History
    @Mythical.History Před rokem

    Awesome editing!

  • @hrkov
    @hrkov Před 8 měsíci

    this video ended very abruptly

  • @02sideshow
    @02sideshow Před rokem +1

    I love The Walking Dead finished season 11 kinda got me sad but yes killing off Carl was the biggest mistake ever

  • @bread_cuh5054
    @bread_cuh5054 Před rokem

    I almost stopped watching after officer lams exit, but the final nail in the coffin for me was bob adams death. Not to mention einsenburg being killed off, honestly wasted potential

  • @RedTitan10.
    @RedTitan10. Před rokem

    Ok this is off topic but can you do a video about what if michone never saved Andrea because then, rick never finds the Govonor so then never finds Alexadrea so no hiptop to tell them about Negin so then Glenn still alive and Herschel and Carl but then there's also no RJ and michone. 🤯😱
    (Ps sorry for this being so long it just blows my mind)

  • @Dravenscrypt
    @Dravenscrypt Před rokem

    Carl apparently was telling people leaks of the show on reddit,they were pissed. His dad told cause Carl signed a nda.

  • @Spider-Man62
    @Spider-Man62 Před rokem +1

    Andrew actually wanted to leave at the end of Season 8 but it was delayed BECAUSE Carl died.

  • @admiralhowdy
    @admiralhowdy Před rokem

    2:03 was that the final show runner? She was awesome.

  • @maccheesey2746
    @maccheesey2746 Před rokem

    I’ve watched a lot of your videos here and follow you on tiktok and just now realized you are the same person