Should Liverpool Keep or Sell Mohamed Salah!? - w/Neil Jones
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 30. 04. 2024
- Should Liverpool Keep or Sell Mohamed Salah!? - w/Neil Jones
WATCH OR LISTEN TO THE FULL SHOW HERE: theredmentv.com/slot-in-salah...
Use code 'SLOT' for 50% off a 'Captain' yearly subscription!
Journalist Neil Jones was in the studio for his weekly 'Journo Insight' show with Ste today to speak about all the latest news in the Liverpool world. The big story this week was that Mo Salah is expected to stay at the club despite speculation that the Egyptian would be finishing his time at the club this summer.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR LFC STREAMING SERVICE: www.redmenplus.com
JOIN THIS CHANNEL TO GET ACCESS TO PERKS:
/ @theredmentv
BUY OUR MERCH: www.redmenmerch.com/
GET TICKETS TO OUR LIVE SHOWS!
LONDON: www.axs.com/uk/events/521499/...
AWARD WINNING CHANNEL BRINGING YOU LIVERPOOL NEWS, LIVERPOOL TRANSFER NEWS, ANALYSIS OF LIVERPOOL GAMES AND PRETTY MUCH EVERYTHING YOU WANT RELATED TO LIVERPOOL FOOTBALL CLUB!
GET IN TOUCH đ bit.ly/2K8qHDS - Sport
![[Vowel]ëŹŒêł êž°ë ëŹŒìì ìŽììŒ íŽđđ€ŁFish have to live in the water #funny](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3G9MH063Cx4/mqdefault.jpg)
Nunez, Diaz and jotaâs assists and goals numbers are the biggest proof how much we need Salah, he is the definition of consistency not to mention the amount of chances he created to all of them but they couldnât finish it, what we really need is someone creative midfielder to not lose those games were we keep passing side ways and a proper 6 like Rodri who can defend and score then our team would be a dream team
I think this is Michael Edwards way of ensuring we have max bargaining power if a club does come to the table. Also, you don't want an exodus of top players out the door after Klopp. It will be hard to attract top targets if it looks like everyone is fleeing a sinking ship. Its a proactive move.
Youâre 100% right
You cannot guarantee Salah as a starter. No way. He's to earn that right by performing not what he did years back
He's a top goal scorer and a playmaker albeit a selfish one .... we're talking about his dip in the form because Liverpool are not scoring goals at the moment....there are Nunez and Diaz and jota ....none of them have the consistency and regularity of appearance as salah .... it's just few weeks of slump in form and now he's being put to sword.... remember almost any other winger in the premier having a best season is like Salah's mild performance of a season....his numbers even this year is not so bad
This guy would play salah as a 9 lol . The guy has dead right foot and he would play him as a central strikerđđđ
@@Jay.jay07 Yes we've accepted the selfishness because his stats speak for themselves - do we still have THAT Salah though?!
@@Jay.jay07numbers, good. Performances absolutely abysmal. He hasnât had many performances where heâs been really good for most of the game. Take 100m and get the next 23/24 year old
You make it out to seem that Salah is the worst forward in the squad right now.
The money tempts you to mix up quality with form.
Its kind of pathetic tbh.
Also from a business standpoint, letting him go for free does not impact them, since his signing fee is fully depreciated and you are removing his wages. Selling him for $100mil is upside, but letting him go for free isnt a bad financial decision
Heâs going to have to get used to the bench a bit more next season and I donât see that going well
Its going to get worse from here
Imagine thinking salah will be bench xD
Salah would do a better job as a no.9 than Nunez
Salah is versatile. Apart from aying in the back four, he can play well in all other positions. He's also a play maker.
He can still run faster than 90% of the players in the premiership.
What do u expect Liverpool to say. Yeah we want him gone and then get 25ml bids to take him off our hands
I love Mo Salah as much as the next person, it's time though, 12 months left on contract, cash in from a Saudi club, yes, he's been immense this season, 41 apps - 23 goals - 12 assists, but realistically it's likely to decline than rise & we risk losing him on a free, we're already in a semi rebuild anyway, the midfield got overhauled last summer, the defense is an area that needs doing this summer, center halves in particular, the money from Mo can be invested in a proper left footed replacement.
Not a popular opinion, but whenever we go with sentiment it doesn't end well, Gerrard, Klopp etc. logical plan is best, not thinking short term but reloading for the medium to long term success.
You canât sell him to a club he doesnât want to go to.
â@@conors4430if he wants money. No other club will offer a 1/5 in wages what the saudis will. Plus hes still one of the biggest stars from that region, hed be treated like a god
The amount of chances salah creates for his counterparts go begging is a testament to why Liverpool lack proper finishers.....yes mo isn't in the best of his form but we're taking about him more since hi other teammates are underperforming..... he's a player of elite mentality and he'll bounce back from recent setbacks....you don't expect that from Nunez and Diaz ....even van dijk didn't look better than he ever was ....the whole team is underperforming as rightly to be at number three!!
Agreed!
Other players underperforming doesnt excuse the fact hes missed more shots then any liv forward since coming back, for having zero pace, and for not helping the mids. Hell you put nunez on the right and he atleast does 2 of those 3 things
I can see Salah being a modric type player but with more goals!
So from the start can I say I love what Mo has done for LFC, he should go down as one of the best.
Having said that this year in the premiership he has scored 12 non penalty goals, two ahead of Nunez whom everyone seemingly wants to get rid of.
For me I donât want Salah to go the way of Hendo. Regardless of the LGB stuff, because Hendo stayed too long a bunch of his legacy had gone. If the a great plan to extract as much money out of the Saudis, then great, but fundamentally I feel his time has come and gone, he should go now and still be a legend.
It's just business. Teams need to move on, and re-develop. Getting a large fee is going to be essential to that re-build.
The only way he should stay is if the club is going to invest in the team without needing the cash from him.
As the highest paid on the payroll itâs time he started to produce again.
In the context of a whole season, He's always produced. Some are just so blind to see it. Compare him to any winger in Europe; no one can beat his numbers this year or, in previous years.
@@akhaliquk not recently, heâs not been performing up to expectations.
@keegan773 who has? By this logic everyone should be sold or benched.
ââ@@akhaliqukhes missed more chances then any liv forward since coming back, has no pace, cant beat players 1v1, and isnt helping the mids in defense. Heck you put nunez on the right he atleast has pace and will help the mids
Mo gave us some excitements in his first 6 years, I think these are now gone... he is just another player. Let me wish him the very best wherever he wants to go. He will be remembered as a legend for me.
Love mo Salah if he remains loyal to Liverpool then I will be loyal to him
I donât understand why heâs playing like a traditional winger this season because heâs clearly not that. Heâs the main man, and used to play with a swagger. We want him to put the likes of Ruben Dias, and Walker on their asses, and curl in a screamer and just take the chances. He just goes to the wing and crosses the ball now hoping Nunez accidentally finishes it off. Heâs adapting his game to Nunez and that is hurting the team. His passes to Diaz have been phenomenal, but idk what happened. However this new way of playing has completely taken the X factor off his game.
Most fans won't understand your analysis. For them it's "kick the ball and score "
He doesnt have pace anymore, cant beat players 1v1, cant shoot anything farther then the 6 yard box, and isnt helping the mids. These are facts, when was the last shot near the 18 yard box that looked good
Mo is great, he needs replacing at some point in the next 1-3 years. Depends who becomes available when but we may well need to cash in at some point to buy a replacement
Liverpool Formation Under Arne Slot is 4-2-3-1 Formation in Possession,Using A Midfield Double Pivot (One of them Box to Box Hard Working Midfielder)to Progress Certainly Through The First Line Of Pressure With No 10,Two Wingers and Central Striker,The Issue Is Liverpool's Resurgence. In Arne Slot We Trust.
No 10? You can easily play a rotating mac and taa in the 10 role in a 4231. Its what i wanted klopp to do this season
This show should be called Journo Opinion
Also, did he ever say he wanted to play in Saudi Arabia? Or did everybody just make that assumption? Secondly, you canât sell a player to a club? He doesnât want to go to. I say keep him. He was our top goalscorer this year, have to try and get the other guys a bit more consistent, before we let 20 goals a season walk out the door.
time to sell , teams probaly know how to play against him too and he may have lost his pace and desire so
They canât bank on him. Neil Jones says the âlast few weeksâ, heâs been poor for at least a year. This isnât a blip, this is a huge decline and this is the player he is and that wonât change.
Genuine question, Exactly how many goals does Salah have this season and last if you you don't count penalties?
40
@@RedmenTV2 Still peak Salah...we're unsure if we're ever going to see that Salah again. A new longish-term contract paying ÂŁ15m or so per year on a player who'll be 32 next month is a huge risk...he ain't no Messi or Ronaldo despite some opinions to the contrary given by certain fan channels!
In the epl this season he has scored 5 so he would be at 12 without penalties. Past 11 penalties hes taken hes had around a 60% conversion rate also. Nunez has taken 1 penalty and missed. Without penalty goals mo would only have 1 more then nunez and he only has 1 more assist. I dont think thats worth 3 times the cost. Mac should be taking them anyways
we need the best in front to score more goals
When the team needed him most he was found wanting bigtime so go now
Niel Jones has hit the nail on the head; he's the only one who understands the dynamics of this issue; the rest have lost it and don't get it, which is shocking.
Agreed. Usually I agree with Redmen but they've all lost their heads on this imo. Disappointing.
worth paying so much for a player waiting behind defender, hoping they miss the header ?
After pooring through the numbers liv really need to make that money while they can. Without penalties salah would only have 1 more goal then nunez in epl and he only has 1 more assist. As far as stats hes not in the top 10% of anything, dribbling, sprinting, shooting, passing ect. I love him but with the wages hes on the time to sell is now, somebody offers over 100 mil take it without question. Thats just good buisness
Feels like they are just posturing and prepping the market so they can maximise the price from the Saudis
"Mo ultra professional" in his preparation yes...in his giving the ball away constantly no...in not chasing back no. In referring to goals converted to big chances subtract the penalties and his goal conversion rates go well down...whoever takes penalties is always leading scorer at every club.
Take the money and get a couple in
Recently we've played better without salah. While he was injured
& Trent
sign a new deal or leave this summer
That will ultimately be Mo's decision, not the club's. ÂŁ18m per year is a hell of a bench-warming bonus
If we get a right winger who can rotate with Salah next season and eventually take over when he leaves, I think we will see the best of Mo and be able to compete for trophies.
A discussion around Salah shouldn't even have to be spoken about. Keep him all day. Common sense knowing this if you are a genuine Liverpool fan.
Mo Salah will stay as our starter on the right hand side.
Keep
Sounds like a commercial decision
Sell him, he has outlived his usefulness.
As long as we don't lose him on a free or give him a raise, then I would be fine with him staying for another year. This whole thing won't stop Saudi from coming for him if they really want him, it just changes the fee we can demand.
Club should sell if they can get around 100m for him. Lets new recruitment team and manger get players in to build towards second/ third year.
King Mo is world class and EPL legend, so Saudi pro leauge does not suit him at all, also loyalty cannot be bought!
Move him on for $100 million buy 2 players for
$50 million each and use his $300,000 split for the 2 new players wages!
Itâs a 2 for 1 itâs a no brainer !!
Let's see what ANY offers are first ? What if he says I'm going nowhere!!!
He'll go dont worry.
Thankfully that specialist in failure, Klopp is going with him. đ
Iâd sell Diaz and Nunez! Making Salah look bad and we can get much better finishers
Liverpool canât Depend on salah need something new after Klopp
Sell him and get a new young player who will become a star for Liverpool with love from Scotland đŽó §ó ąó łó Łó Žó ż
He's either gone, or offered a new 2yr contract with a buy-out figure palatable for a 32yr old
Neil Jones always manages to give a different spin and provides a nuanced insight into all dealings regarding Liverpool football club. A brilliant analytical mind and a true journalist. đâ€ïžâœïž.x
Why!!!! If he does stay he got to get a money cut because he doesnât deserve 300gs a week
Hi lad's how is it going? Keep him Mo. YNWA
he,s done get shut
Just before Mo came back from injury back in March he told a friend of mine he didn't want to go to Saudi next season. He of course applied the caveat "of course the money". He still wants to win things.
As always with Neil, a lot of dunno and maybe.
How does this guy make a living knowing nothing?
All good and well saying keeping him and not taking money is a football decision, but paying a player 350k a week and having no width on right, because he doesn't run any more, is a football decision.
He's scored goals, but not really offered much else for last two TWO years
It was always a trade off during this period, as he scored goals, but he's not getting any younger, so unless he's moving central under new manager, then it's only going in one direction
Furthermore, in two years, you are not getting 100 million to invest in new stars.
Unless the manager has a new role and position for Mo, and feels he's essential to that, let him go
The club should avoid too much change all at once.
Ferguson and Pep both sold players whilst they were worth something.
More than "worth something"...multiple examples of players at their peaks but causing issues.
He needs to go there is no such shit as keeping him under the badge of Liverpool not after what he has done in last game after that disgracefull argument with boss. Really? Mo beeing bigger than the club? than the Klopp? Than the Kop? He's had a screw or two set loose in his head, alright we know this. But that is the reason to let him go and get a good quality replacement for the money from the Saudi's. Also Nunez needs to go. Im done defending him. Way too many chances missed one of the lowest if not the lowest goal rate conversion and big chances missed this season he is probably a leader in all of that.
YNWA !!!
Salah must stay.
Mo Salah Liverpool Legend đ
And The best player in the world â€ïž
First statement - agreed
Second - not by a long shot, pal.
If Salah stays it holds Liverpool back and then sets them back 2years. He must go now for the good of our beloved club
You would not be here without him, did you see Nunez misses November December, you would have been 10 points off and in TV blackout, then who would have paid
we will see when salah leaves if LP gets better he is happy to go đ
Seven years of supremacy. First bad injury this season. Perspective required.
He never passes when player's in better position. He's not gone past a defender in 18mth including Ashley young, he misses so many chances and even his pens, I don't want him on pens as hes missed half of his last 10
Totally agree
Sadio Mane just liked this comment...đmaybe
Lmao the amount of chances he has created for Diaz and Nunez is crazy. If only they knew how to finish!!
Fans are living in lala land who think anyone is going to come in and take over from where Mo leaves it. Nunez was a sure bet wasnt he? Lol still hasnt come good. No LFC player can match Mo's numbers in any department. Go figure.
The question is can we get a replacement with guaranteed goals cos we canât bank on any of the other forwards unfortunately. Diaz, Nunez and Gakpo arenât scoring enough and Jotaâs injury record is a concern.
If salah was scoring nice goals ide say yea hard to replace but he only gets scrappy goals these days and pens. On top of that the pace and ability to beat players 1v1 is gone. Not what you want from wingers
@@junioradult6219 my point is heâs still our best chance of scoring. I agree heâs probably on the downward part of his career now but Iâm not sure Iâd ship him off this summer. If one of the other forwards had stepped up Iâd be more open to the idea, especially if we can get decent money for him. Unfortunately none of our current attackers seem up to the task (as much as I like their different qualities) so do we swap the one player that can get 20-30 goals a season for another âmaybe?â
Heâs out of form, as is the rest of the team but I believe he can still do a job for us and will probably be our top scorer again next season.
smokescreen
Sell Mo.Its downhill from here
Salah said he wants to retire at Liverpool, yet fans don't like this loyalty. When Gerrard wanted a move to Chelsea the fans where crying about disloyalty same with Torres and Suarez but now they want to boot one of the best ever Liverpool players. The question is this, Salah is 31 and this season in what was meant to be a bad year at right wing he has far more goals than any other player in any of the top leagues. Who do you replace him with ? You need at least two players because apart from Palmer who has mainly penalties no one else whose younger comes anywhere close to Salah's numbers and everyone is forgetting the 10 assists he should have if the others didn't miss sitters, yes he has been out of form the last few months but he has had a major injury, VVD was bad for ages until he regained his confidence. People should be pointing at Gakpo and Diaz who are younger but are not showing their value at all. There needs to be a good rw player brought in so that it keeps Salah fresh throughout the season because there is no one who fills that gap effectively with g/a. Most of the forwards I watched growing up never tracked back, Shearer, Ronaldo, Ronaldinho etc and NO ONE criticized them even Henry. This new expectation of everyone is only good if they run after the ball and link the ball up compared to actual g/a is actually ridiculous. People where critical of Haaland its an absolute joke, a strikers and forwards main job is to score and assist and Salah's numbers are way above everyone else and His season average throughout his entire Liverpool career has been 28 goals a season and this season he is 4 behind that so yeah he has really regressed, these fans need to wake up. NO ONE is getting those numbers and its evident throughout World football right now.
City would sell him in a heartbeat, reinvest and win again. Your to loyal like klopp. You spend on players and then keep them till they are worthless. Thats not a good buisness model
@@junioradult6219 City still have De Bruyne, they kept Aguero, Silva etc for years and years.
If mo stop playing international football we get more out of him
Very very disingenuous by the bald fella to suggest Salah would take the money like a dry shite, Neil handled that well, silly observation
' we expect him to stay " = We will protect our asset and we want the maximum amount of money.
no way salah leaves on a bosman in jan
neill jones piece should be called journa opinion doesnt offer any insight at all
Salah is fit 90% of the time and a consistent goalscorer. Why sell someone like that, especially when you look at our current options. If he dont sign a deal in the next couple months, sell because we need money. But if we wants to sign then keep
Look at his goals. They are almost all just scrappy around the 6 or pens. His shot has been gone for a while now thats my biggest issue. On top of that hes lost his pace and his ability to beat players 1v1 95% of the time. His goals these days are like paul scholes goals were
i just hope fsg back slot in the transfer market, we need 2 new defenders, 2 strikers, and sell jones, matip, salah, nunez, and gomez
Do we sell player now for let say 60 milion euros or we get nothing for him next year? Of course we sell a player. Also lift for massive wage bill.
Sell him. Not having his petulance towards Klopp,, he fully deserved dropping. Was fortunate it didn't happen earlier.
100%. If he'd apologised straight away...no issues at all but he hasn't! It's more than just a heat of the moment flare-up.
Another delusional person. Salah is past his best
Give him a 3 year contract. Absolute God â€
The Rammy Abbas character isn't thick, and he's all about money. Salah will see out his existing contract and leave for free, and there's nothing Liverpool can do about it.
Mo and Abbas will then get a huge signing on fee, rather than the Saudi money going under pikey John Henry's bed.
Should sell him ASAP!!!!!
Another season of him moaning, no thanks time to sell
be quiet you muppet
SELL SELL SELL. Mo gave up on the team and the fans last summer. Ship him off to Saudi and replace him with someone who actually cares about the club and city.
Sell him obviously he's WASHED
His best days are well behind him, and is more known for scoring penalties than amazing goals. He is paid too much for what he delivers now. Stop living in the past and cash in
FSG DONT WANT SALAH THEY WANT A BIG OFFER FROM SAUDI BUT DON'T WANT SALAH TO WALK OUT ON A FREE SO MAKING IT LOOK LIKE THEY WANT HIM ALL SO GET A GOOD OFFER.
SALAH HAS BEEN SHIT AND NEEDS TO BE SOLD
Salah has been average for a while now. He is becoming more and more individualistic. He is also very predictable and gets bullied so easily on and off the ball. Worthless 6 packs Iâve seen
Could not sell last year. U talk crap. Unable to replace as our windows closed, think before u just say crap and expect us life long reds not to question u
Stop letting all these players grow old on our watch
how have you already got slot on the channel? fair doos