Hi from the United Kingdom I did not know that Shell owned All public Easement and All the surrounding areas Also I did not know that you can get Arrested for being on public Easement No ID No Crime This MOOSE BRAINS will never learn with many Thanks to This Guy now has a Supreme court Ruling After him
So he pushed you on to Shell property and then Illegally searched you in order to find your ID, then illegally arrested you to make you ID, he doesn't know or care about the penal code, he then turned off your cameras and that officer should be behind bars.
Lets see that fat slob. Aka pig. Pass the fitness exam. I will bet the car he drives has a steady lean due to the weight of this obese person got to be over 300. Can’t breathe just getting out of car
Oh please tell me that you are sueing this department, and especially this officer, for their unlawful actions. I applaud you for your actions, and the courage and resolve that you display. It's brave citizens such as yourself that will help to reign in, and hold accountable, the corrupt officials throughout our nations police forces. Keep up the good work. Thumbs up, and subscribed.
Once an officer is given the information about a penal code or a law regarding public photography if they pursue an arrest than they should assume some liability for a potential lawsuit. If you get some of these hot headed cops to start paying out of their own pockets or serving time, you might see an improvement in protection of rights.
He didn't know any laws and he was so afraid he was screwing up, his voice was shaking. When asked for a penal code, he says, I'm not telling you that. Only because there wasn't any and he was lying. I hope the auditor sure! I wouldn't be surprised is Shell gives the money each time they illegally arrest someone for filming, doing their dirty work for them!
Oh yes you are 100% correct. In fact they can and will be held accountable for their actions because once they are informed of the correct case law and they still continue to arrest you they will loose their QUALIFIED IMMUNITY and once that happens they can't Crawfish back out of everything they have done.
This is old but this is exactly why those other cops standing around letting this guy get arrested should lose their jobs as well. They didn’t care what the law was and they didn’t stand up to the guy making the arrest. They all should be held accountable for not stopping the arrest.
The initial female officer said with a straight face that she was just making sure you were safe and not running into oncoming traffic. Now that you are properly briefed on the hazards of motorized vehicles running you over can I get your name? That's a different approach I haven't seen before.
@@twk21twk People that don't need a fucking grammar lesson can differentiate between a contraction and a possessive pronoun. People can think, or look stupid.
Lord please tell me that Garza is not the prototype officer for in Harris County. He can't tell the difference between commercial property and federal property, and state property.
He is there prototype, and Ybarra was the other porker in Davids arrest. both from the same mold. More then likely even after cops get sued by David and Phillip, the cops will get a promotion for violating peoples rights.Goes to show their illegal activities and practices.
Yeah his operating system must be way outta date. But it’s Texas. We won’t get a new model for at least another half decade. I bet when those kids lose their lawsuit with the county they’ll produce a bunch of these obsolete pos just for the laughs. Which is fine by me. I can outrun any of these *things*
+Karly Johnston Yes,he was the second Deputy present at my arrest the day before-for videoing the trash along the roadway. The guy arrested-that Phillip mentions-is me.
+Karly Johnston and he was also arrested because he also was under the assumption he had rights and freedoms of a former government , and believing these domestic police terrorists are Peace Officers . . . . Again .
I just can't believe that any police department would have the audacity to even approach someone standing on a street corner, let alone arrest him, for doing literally nothing. The officer should be terminated and charged with felony kidnapping. Period
One of the teachable moments in this video (and other similar ones I have seen) is that it is obvious that the police often don't know legal basics as it concerns civil liberties and legal fundamentals (RAS, PC, detainment and search thresholds). There was a time when I thought the police actually studied law but more-and-more, I see evidence that they either ignore fundamental legal concepts, or don't know fundamental legal concepts. I am also seeing a trend of police officers likely knowing they are violating the law but conduct themselves based on an assumption that they are legally and financially protected (yes, the tax payers will pay for the mistakes they make), and that the citizen won't seek legal remedies after suffering violations of civil liberties.
They are violating your human rights until they can obligate you to a PERSONS of privileges allowing you to be prosecuted and profited from with No human rights . and how do they do THAT ?
this country's fucked .... fat stupid lugs like this with no cognitive capacity to understand the 1st, 4th and 5th amendments and they're given firearms and rewarded until their lard ass croaks with pensions that are bankrupting our cities.
Auditors, never ever under any circumstance carry ID with you on an audit.. any time you hand them ID< government ID, you are creating JOINDER.. you are now in contract with them.. they consider you their employee under their statues, under their codes, under their jurisdiction.. don't do it.. never claim US citizenship or STATE OF ______ Citizenship.. only State citizenship, such as I am a citizen of Texas.. not the STATE OF TEXAS.. but of Texas.. one is a foreign owned and bankrupt Corpse Oration and the other is the land.. and if you really want to mess with them.. I would suggest you simply tell them your citizenship is in the kingdom of heaven and you are simply a sojourner.. a Pilgrim.. a traveler under the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness and under the authority of the creator.. lets see what they do with that.. lets see if they violate your first amendment right to freedom of religion..
When any cop commits a crime they not only should be getting prosecuted under existing criminal statutes and punished accordingly, they should also if found guilty stand trial for treason, these people are required to swear an oath before being entrusted with power and authority beyond that of the average citizen. They exercise that authority over citizens and ANY act that is in violation of that oath must be treated as TREASON. The constitution demands a higher standard of accountability for those who serve the people. It is to easy for that authority and power to be abused and that is exactly why the constitution was written. If these clowns are not prosecuted for dishonoring their oath, our constitution, this country, and the inherent rights of we the people, then why bother swearing an oath to begin with. This is what the constitution demands and that is exactly why we have our current out of control judicial system. Judges and lawyers all know that if they were to prosecute even one cop for treason or dishonoring that oath it would mean they would be held to the same standard and face severe punishment should they choose to betray the people, country and oath they swore. Its not that complicated, they swear an oath to insure that they understand that they are being entrusted with powers and authority from the people over the people and that those people have inherent rights that must not be ignored or violated in any manner for any reason, to let these clowns get away with standing trial and being punished as if they are just a normal citizen is a crime in of itself. They are not acting as a citizen when they are on duty nor should they be standing trial and punished as a normal citizen. That oath demands severe, harsh, and swift punishment for those who betray this country and constitution. If a soldier dishonors the oath he swore he faces a court marshal for that very reason.?
SCOTUS ruled that cops engaging in criminal acts such as unlawful arrest, false imprisonment, kidnapping, assault and/or battery, and more can be legally killed in self-defense by citizens. If that happened more, perhaps corrupt pigs would wake up and learn that their lives are more at risk when they engage in criminal acts then those that do their jobs with courtesy and honor.
Totally agree , I think that laws should be put in place that officers can be personally sued as well for these ridiculous acts. I truly think that is the only answer to stop some of this shit. When officers are faced with the fact that they can truly be held accountable for making stupid irresponsible choices like this maybe they will start thinking twice because right now they can get away with almost anything. Between the inside buddy program and the fact that when someone sues them it's tax payers money anyhow so it doesn't bother them. It's clear as day when officers start making up BS laws and reasons to push personal agendas. It's crazy that someone's ego pushes them to this very point. Makes me sick .... I give this young man a lot of respect , and applause for doing what he is doing.
I gather that these police department didn't get the memo from the government saying that photography is not a fricking CRIME we have the same problems over here in the United Kingdom Congratulations on winning your court case in the Supreme court watched the video could not stop 😂 because they Fucked up The judge wanted plain answers to the questions Did not delivered because Driver thought he was above the law TUFF SHIT Got Caught out by the Judge And Driver got ripped to shreds PS Driver learn the law Shit for BRAINS
+nlpjohn what are you talking about man there will be lawyers lined up for this easy kind of case. Not only did he spend a night in jail which as you stated $20,000 at best... then yes of course a lawyers fee is between $10,000-$15,000 but you forgot the most important payouts my friend.... This officer violated so many constitution rights.. Lets see the officer demanding to see I.D. without articulating if this man committed a crime which he couldn't prove... 2nd the officer pretty much grabbed the guy and had him on the fence so the officer can search him for recording on public property that didn't commit a crime... 3rd the officer again demanded to see I.D. with out providing what crime the guy committed which the officer couldn't answer... then finally arrested this man unlawfully AKA kidnapping and then also took his property without a search warrant on the officer to do so... So in my own opinion this man is going to get way more then just $20,000 with his lawyer fees as you said $15,000 and walk away with $5000... no lawyers look for these cases because its easy money. Real easy money.
Your right something's don't always go as planned but when you have video evidence like this man does on what this police officer did to him from the beginning of his recording till the end.. the guy will get a good amount by suing the city department and also going after the police officer himself.
So @3:40 the officer is done with the investigation and safety check and we should be good to go. Ah...spoke to soon. @5:28 officer pork rind now has to make an issue, quote made up laws about photography and demand ID with no RAS. Now officer extra chromosome has to change the alleged violation from illegal photography to now trespassing. Now the offense changes from illegal photography, from trespassing, to now failure to show ID. Assault, battery, unlawful detainment, illegal search, and illegal arrest soon follow. And these cops want me to respect them? Fuck all.
RAS, in Texas, isn't enough to require ID from someone. Now, the cops can "demand" you ID, all they want. Texas penal code 38.02 is VERY specific on that. UNTIL a person is ARRESTED for something, you don't have to ID yourself. Some people think part (b) of 38.02 requires a person to identify themselves. Not true. Part (b) states: A person commits an offense if he intentionally gives a false or fictitious name, residence address, or date of birth to a peace officer who has: (1) lawfully arrested the person; (2) lawfully detained the person; or, (3) requested the information from a person that the peace officer has good cause to believe is a witness to a criminal offense. Note: As per part (b), you are not REQUIRED to give your ID, even if you are legally detained - only that you will be breaking the law IF you give false info.
Idiots can't even follow the law... even when someone states the exact penal code, law enforcement manages to do whatever they want. It's a real miscarriage of justice and I am ready to see it end. STOP QUALIFIED IMMUNITY!!!!
Two filmed unlawful arrests Deputy Garza has enacted or participated in. So essentially two contempt of cop arrests without even the slightest hint of an actual crime. I hope he has lost his job by now. I'm no fan of the DOJ but what evidence do they need of corruption and rights violations to step in at the HCSO?
The fence line parallel to the curb is the property line extending across the driveway. Step past the corner fence post towards the gate and you are trespassing. However, that driveway is "public place" and 1A applies.
Actually,see the line in the concrete where the patrol cars are parked?..they are on Shell Property-Public Property extends to that point. County mows the grass up to that point.
*+NNH, FILM, PHILIP* the only way we are ever going to get this abuse to stop is to file civil rights complaints with the states attorney general, get their bond lifted and SUE THE FVCKERS INDIVIDUALLY AND SEVERALLY FOR EVERY GOD DAMNED THING THEY OWN AND EVEN GO FOR THEIR PENSIONS. otherwise the taxpayer pays out, the taxpayer isn't even aware of the lawsuit, the taxpayer never knows where their money went, the police department nor the cops are punished and it just emboldens them to violate peoples' rights even more. ONLY PERSONAL LAWSUITS will send shock waves across this countries' LEO's because otherwise they just go on with tomorrow and continue to violate more rights. A DIFFERENT APPROACH MUST BE FIGURED OUT BECAUSE THEY JUST DON'T GIVE A DAMN. hell David, they're stalking you, threatening you, pulling guns on you, you're in hiding and you're in danger... do you think lawsuits matter to the rights violating cops? there has to be a different attack at this abuse. .
Look up trespass law. You are not trespassing unless someone trespasses you. You are allowed to go anywhere open to the public. If someone complains and trespasses you and you continue to stay then you are trespassing. Anyway, get informed, it's fun. (Not speaking to anyone specific just in general)
really they really said that people called because they were worried he wasn't going ot cross the road right and get hurt... she really couldn't think of a better line than that
have worked in petro chemical plants, nuclear plants as a pipe fitter/welder. I have built those structures from the ground up, literally, and I personally find it pretty silly that all this precautionary paranoia exists. Just because someone suffers from paranoia, doesn't deem the photography act illegal... relax folks. We're losing touch with reality here.
I applaud your courage and your conviction to demonstrate emotional restraint. Noting kills a video like this as when the subject becomes completely belligerent. Hoping you receive a handsome settlement.
Please post a composite update video of all the times you've been arrested and the outcomes of each. It would be interesting to see a timeline of where you were when arrested and whether you were prosecuted, charges were dropped, if you sued, outcomes, etc. You are one of my top 3 auditors and I'd like to know how you fared. Thanks.
I'm coming in to this a little late as I am just discovering these 1st Amendment Audits. Is there a link to the outcome? BTW, hats off to you and NNH. I am now watching videos full time. Most make my blood boil.
Excellent, excellent, excellent. I spent my teenage years in Deer Park and most people don't believe how fucked up these police are when I tell them about it. The fact you were streaming this is soooooo great. Thank you for doing this. I was in photography class at DPISD and people had their cameras and film taken for taking pictures of these places. I had been pulled over MANY times for merely walking down a sidewalk on my way home and searched without due process, and I was a middle class white kid. Kudos man, this isn't even the worst of these crooked cops. Gotta love cameras. These cops need body cams at all times.
Wow, Harris County's law enforcement is an embarrassment to all law enforcement. I'm not sure if they're basically not informed, generally not smart or just willfully willing to violate laws, and judgements determined by courts.
Huh. So many people concerned about your well-being while you're standing on the grass. Good to see that they took you to safety. They even handcuffed you in case you were a danger to yourself. I'm sure they do this all the time. Texas is such a friendly place.
Hard to believe she thought a grown ass man didn't have enough sense to cross the street to safety. She was just detaining him with BS until fat boy could get there and arrest him. You can bet this damn city is off my list to vacation to!
Protect the rich oil pricks at any cost. Times are changing because of people like you exposing this scam. She does not care about your safety, that was a terrible excuse.
Glock22Mischief I don't have anything planned right now because I'm busy helping out my neighborhood. We have been dealing with a month long issue people breaking into vehicles so a lot of my spare time has been eaten up in doing night patrols.
Ultimate007Trini I wasn't arrested in Texas unless you are trying to communicate to The Battousai in which case that he is already lawyered up on this issue. Also your comment would be best posted normally and not in the reply chain of someone else's comment that isn't related to that subject.
There are attorneys who will take the case for 1/3 your settlement so long as they feel your case has merit. Been there, done that, and won. No 15k necessary.
God bless that woman cop! She was so concerned about your safety! I wonder if she goes up to everyone she sees crossing the street and talks to them about being safe.
@Ernie Tetrault Turner vs Driver - law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca5/16-10312/16-10312-2017-02-16.html The guy in this video is Mr. Turner.
Good job. Shell is obligated to provide a sidewalk. This land goes under a double classification as private/public, but pedestrians are legally allowed to walk there. That is the law. Like everywhere. Private and public land. 10 feet from the road is city property too, Shell is obligated to protect pedestrian, not the obligation of a citizen. Shell responsible for endangering you by not building a walk area. They should place a sidewalk for its employees too. THAT IS WORK CODE, which they violated too. People do not have to drive to work, and it is the obligation of the company to unsure the safety of its employees along with the public. At least mow the lawn and clean up. Shell is obligated to mow the lawn and pick up the garbage, they have violated CITY CODE or STATE LAWS. All lawns must be mowed and garbage must be cleaned. That is the law. You can use this against SHELL, they have violate more than one LAW. Go read CITY CODE and you see that you have the right to walk there and it must be mowed and cleaned. LOOK AT THAT GARBAGE. That is a violation of the rules. HOW IS IT THAT HOMEOWNERS MUST DO THIS< BUT NOT SHELL? Homeowners pay a fine for not cleaning up and mowing. 150$ FINE. POLLUTION AND UNSAFE WORK CONDITION AND A PUBLIC DANGER TOO. THOSE ARE JUST A FEW OF THE RULES. WORK CODE ALSO MEANS THEY MUST HAVE STOP SIGHS AT THE EXITS, THEY do not have these. AN ORANGE LINE ACROSS THE PAVEMENT TO IDENTIFY THE STOP LINE for vehicles pulling out. THEY are breaking many WORK CODES, you can dig them up with ease. COMPLAIN TO THE WORKERS COMPENSATION BOARD ABOUT THE DANGER, they must follow up and reply to you. THAT IS LAW. LEARN IT!
Lol, that's like talking logic & law to a 3 year old in the middle of a full blown temper tantrum, Battman. Got my fingers crossed someone more intelligent takes his badge/gun far away from him.
If the officer was correct about it being illegal to take pictures of this chemical plant, than he had every right to ask this guy for ID. Cop: who are you? Batt: I'm a journalist. Cop: may I see ID (press credentials)? Batt: No. Looks suspicious to me. And if he was breaking the law, it was the cop's duty to arrest him. Thank you Harris County PD for keeping the public safe.
This is the shit that makes people assume all police officers are criminal. If you go along with another officer doing illegal shit, you are complicit and therefore should also be charged with whatever crime you allowed to happen. 18 U.S. Code § 241 - Conspiracy against rights. It is a real law that should be used to punish police officers and all conspiring with them. The law is the law is the law. period. It is also clear that there is no law prohibiting filming of anything that can be seen from public view. Arresting someone for doing so is a crime.
Kevin Richards I stopped buy shell 40 years ago as they supported the incarceration of Nelson Mandela in South Africa. I’ll walk before I buy gas from Shell.
+Filming Is Legal, Moron! (FILM!) the problem is why would they care if you sue them... they actually laugh at your law suits. It comes from the pockets of tax payers. So while I don't agree with the arrest all a law suit does is take money from the community. Untill something is done about this these type of arrests will continue and accomplish nothing but taking money from the community and putting it in the pockets of one person.
bryphi77 Lawsuits, along with formal complaints serve to establish patterns and practices of both the agency and the individual officers involved. Just this year alone, we have heard over and over about 'bad cops' who have many lawsuits and complaints against them, and the news reports (some national) lament how the 'warning signs were there' about the 'bad cop'. Many agencies large and small are under federal oversight because of the number of complaints and lawsuits. To claim that lawsuits and complaints achieve nothing is just flat out incorrect.
This is one of the worst cases of wilful ignorance and stupidity from a police officer. Totally oblivious to the law, sounds like a 13 year old trying to guess what the law is. Breaking numerous civil rights in the process. Please tell me there is some consequences for this lard ass, civil rights violator? P.S Great work remaining calm under such extreme duress. I just subbed.
Okay so here's one of my favorites. Quick call for reinforcements, call SWAT, call the National Guard! There's a man on the sidewalk shooting, with a camera!!
Fucking outstanding! Ignorance about the property, false detention. illegal search and a general lack of intelligence all on display. You were respectful and had your tools in order. I never fault anyone for providing ID to avoid arrest, but goddamn is it awesome to see someone take it all the way. 100% grade A+
It's very important to tell them you dont have any weapons not even a pocket knife. Also ask them do they fear for their lives. The search or pat down can only be if they are in fear..
'Just wanna make sure you are being safe.' US, we are all gonna be over here plugging up the road and creating mass confusion with all this traffic. I give ye much credit The Battousai, for dealing with these Wastes of Space.
"We've had a lot of calls" then she changes her story to "I saw you cross the street." she's like every other cop, a liar.
She was stopped at the red light when he crossed the street, maybe use your brain
Chefcurry 1 then why did she say she received a call? Maybe learn reading comprehension.
"Kinda hard to trespass from a public street" Doubly hard to trespass him when he was never asked to leave...
Hi from the United Kingdom
I did not know that Shell owned All public Easement and All the surrounding areas Also I did not know that you can get Arrested for being on public Easement No ID No Crime
This MOOSE BRAINS will never learn with many Thanks to This Guy now has a Supreme court Ruling After him
So he pushed you on to Shell property and then Illegally searched you in order to find your ID, then illegally arrested you to make you ID, he doesn't know or care about the penal code, he then turned off your cameras and that officer should be behind bars.
I would love to see the police entrance exam. They probably hand out crayons with it.
The fat pig ate the crayons, then the instructor....
What an assine thing to say. Jeez.
LMAO
Lets see that fat slob. Aka pig. Pass the fitness exam. I will bet the car he drives has a steady lean due to the weight of this obese person got to be over 300. Can’t breathe just getting out of car
@@95bochamp lol
Oh please tell me that you are sueing this department, and especially this officer, for their unlawful actions. I applaud you for your actions, and the courage and resolve that you display. It's brave citizens such as yourself that will help to reign in, and hold accountable, the corrupt officials throughout our nations police forces. Keep up the good work. Thumbs up, and subscribed.
Once an officer is given the information about a penal code or a law regarding public photography if they pursue an arrest than they should assume some liability for a potential lawsuit. If you get some of these hot headed cops to start paying out of their own pockets or serving time, you might see an improvement in protection of rights.
The female officer did everything right Deputy Garza is the one that fucked up
He didn't know any laws and he was so afraid he was screwing up, his voice was shaking. When asked for a penal code, he says, I'm not telling you that. Only because there wasn't any and he was lying.
I hope the auditor sure! I wouldn't be surprised is Shell gives the money each time they illegally arrest someone for filming, doing their dirty work for them!
Oh yes you are 100% correct. In fact they can and will be held accountable for their actions because once they are informed of the correct case law and they still continue to arrest you they will loose their QUALIFIED IMMUNITY and once that happens they can't Crawfish back out of everything they have done.
This is old but this is exactly why those other cops standing around letting this guy get arrested should lose their jobs as well. They didn’t care what the law was and they didn’t stand up to the guy making the arrest. They all should be held accountable for not stopping the arrest.
The initial female officer said with a straight face that she was just making sure you were safe and not running into oncoming traffic. Now that you are properly briefed on the hazards of motorized vehicles running you over can I get your name? That's a different approach I haven't seen before.
lol
They just make shit up as they go along!!!
When your an Officer, at the point where you break the law, you stop being an Officer and become an armed Criminal!!!!!!!!!!!!!! People are waking up.
@@twk21twk People that don't need a fucking grammar lesson can differentiate between a contraction and a possessive pronoun. People can think, or look stupid.
Thumbs down because of all the commercials/ads.
@@troyevitt2437 I looked and saw that long ago I blocked you. Hmm. You've been an asshole for a long time, probably all your life?
@@MissionaryInMexico It doesn't change the fact that only "You're" means "You are" and these idiots look like fools using "Your" in that context.
*sigh* I hate it when people say Nevada like that. It’s pronounced Nevada. Not neh-vah-duh. Dumbass
Lord please tell me that Garza is not the prototype officer for in Harris County. He can't tell the difference between commercial property and federal property, and state property.
He is there prototype, and Ybarra was the other porker in Davids arrest. both from the same mold. More then likely even after cops get sued by David and Phillip, the cops will get a promotion for violating peoples rights.Goes to show their illegal activities and practices.
Yeah his operating system must be way outta date. But it’s Texas. We won’t get a new model for at least another half decade. I bet when those kids lose their lawsuit with the county they’ll produce a bunch of these obsolete pos just for the laughs. Which is fine by me. I can outrun any of these *things*
He is. They're steadily putting $$$ into auditors pockets! Especially people like officer Gordo Garza.
That was an exercise in intimidation for covering David's arrest.
EVERY civil rights violation needs to be taken to court. If there are no consequences this will never stop.
If thats "Shells property" they should be ashamed of themselves. Dd you see all that trash?
The trash is what I was videoing when I was arrested. This is the Birth Place of Texas and should be shown more respect.
+Karly Johnston Yes,he was the second Deputy present at my arrest the day before-for videoing the trash along the roadway. The guy arrested-that Phillip mentions-is me.
+Karly Johnston and he was also arrested because he also was under the assumption he had rights and freedoms of a former government , and believing these domestic police terrorists are Peace Officers . . . . Again .
These officers need to understand that the courts have ruled that officers are not required to be concerned about your safety.
where is your arrest footage
I just can't believe that any police department would have the audacity to even approach someone standing on a street corner, let alone arrest him, for doing literally nothing. The officer should be terminated and charged with felony kidnapping. Period
One of the teachable moments in this video (and other similar ones I have seen) is that it is obvious that the police often don't know legal basics as it concerns civil liberties and legal fundamentals (RAS, PC, detainment and search thresholds). There was a time when I thought the police actually studied law but more-and-more, I see evidence that they either ignore fundamental legal concepts, or don't know fundamental legal concepts.
I am also seeing a trend of police officers likely knowing they are violating the law but conduct themselves based on an assumption that they are legally and financially protected (yes, the tax payers will pay for the mistakes they make), and that the citizen won't seek legal remedies after suffering violations of civil liberties.
Officer, fast talking: "Can I get your name so you know we talked so that you're fine."
Me: What???
he is going into your pockets looking for your ID
They did the same thing to me the day before-they actually opened my shirt to get at my Press Credentials worn around my neck and tucked inside.
They are violating your human rights until they can obligate you to a PERSONS of privileges allowing you to be prosecuted and profited from with No human rights . and how do they do THAT ?
this country's fucked .... fat stupid lugs like this with no cognitive capacity to understand the 1st, 4th and 5th amendments and they're given firearms and rewarded until their lard ass croaks with pensions that are bankrupting our cities.
Auditors, never ever under any circumstance carry ID with you on an audit.. any time you hand them ID< government ID, you are creating JOINDER.. you are now in contract with them.. they consider you their employee under their statues, under their codes, under their jurisdiction.. don't do it.. never claim US citizenship or STATE OF ______ Citizenship.. only State citizenship, such as I am a citizen of Texas.. not the STATE OF TEXAS.. but of Texas.. one is a foreign owned and bankrupt Corpse Oration and the other is the land.. and if you really want to mess with them.. I would suggest you simply tell them your citizenship is in the kingdom of heaven and you are simply a sojourner.. a Pilgrim.. a traveler under the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness and under the authority of the creator.. lets see what they do with that.. lets see if they violate your first amendment right to freedom of religion..
When any cop commits a crime they not only should be getting prosecuted under existing criminal statutes and punished accordingly, they should also if found guilty stand trial for treason, these people are required to swear an oath before being entrusted with power and authority beyond that of the average citizen. They exercise that authority over citizens and ANY act that is in violation of that oath must be treated as TREASON. The constitution demands a higher standard of accountability for those who serve the people. It is to easy for that authority and power to be abused and that is exactly why the constitution was written. If these clowns are not prosecuted for dishonoring their oath, our constitution, this country, and the inherent rights of we the people, then why bother swearing an oath to begin with. This is what the constitution demands and that is exactly why we have our current out of control judicial system. Judges and lawyers all know that if they were to prosecute even one cop for treason or dishonoring that oath it would mean they would be held to the same standard and face severe punishment should they choose to betray the people, country and oath they swore. Its not that complicated, they swear an oath to insure that they understand that they are being entrusted with powers and authority from the people over the people and that those people have inherent rights that must not be ignored or violated in any manner for any reason, to let these clowns get away with standing trial and being punished as if they are just a normal citizen is a crime in of itself. They are not acting as a citizen when they are on duty nor should they be standing trial and punished as a normal citizen. That oath demands severe, harsh, and swift punishment for those who betray this country and constitution. If a soldier dishonors the oath he swore he faces a court marshal for that very reason.?
SCOTUS ruled that cops engaging in criminal acts such as unlawful arrest, false imprisonment, kidnapping, assault and/or battery, and more can be legally killed in self-defense by citizens. If that happened more, perhaps corrupt pigs would wake up and learn that their lives are more at risk when they engage in criminal acts then those that do their jobs with courtesy and honor.
Totally agree , I think that laws should be put in place that officers can be personally sued as well for these ridiculous acts. I truly think that is the only answer to stop some of this shit. When officers are faced with the fact that they can truly be held accountable for making stupid irresponsible choices like this maybe they will start thinking twice because right now they can get away with almost anything. Between the inside buddy program and the fact that when someone sues them it's tax payers money anyhow so it doesn't bother them. It's clear as day when officers start making up BS laws and reasons to push personal agendas. It's crazy that someone's ego pushes them to this very point. Makes me sick .... I give this young man a lot of respect , and applause for doing what he is doing.
Any cop who violates We The Peoples rights deserves Gitmo!
Nick Nitro AMEN, well said
“When the police break the Law, there is no law, just a fight for survival” ~Billy Jack~
How does a person that out of shape remain a cop?
He eats the current supervisor when they complain.
Assault
Battery
Kidnapping
Theft of property
Strong armed robbery
I gather that these police department didn't get the memo from the government saying that photography is not a fricking CRIME we have the same problems over here in the United Kingdom
Congratulations on winning your court case in the Supreme court watched the video could not stop 😂 because they Fucked up
The judge wanted plain answers to the questions Did not delivered because
Driver thought he was above the law TUFF SHIT
Got Caught out by the Judge And Driver got ripped to shreds PS
Driver learn the law Shit for BRAINS
should be worth a nice cash sum.
$10,000 for each IQ point of the arresting officer
You realise they are retarded , right ?
i am a bit confused on this issue, shouldn't there be lawyers offering their services like crazy for these types of cases?
+nlpjohn what are you talking about man there will be lawyers lined up for this easy kind of case. Not only did he spend a night in jail which as you stated $20,000 at best... then yes of course a lawyers fee is between $10,000-$15,000 but you forgot the most important payouts my friend.... This officer violated so many constitution rights.. Lets see the officer demanding to see I.D. without articulating if this man committed a crime which he couldn't prove... 2nd the officer pretty much grabbed the guy and had him on the fence so the officer can search him for recording on public property that didn't commit a crime... 3rd the officer again demanded to see I.D. with out providing what crime the guy committed which the officer couldn't answer... then finally arrested this man unlawfully AKA kidnapping and then also took his property without a search warrant on the officer to do so... So in my own opinion this man is going to get way more then just $20,000 with his lawyer fees as you said $15,000 and walk away with $5000... no lawyers look for these cases because its easy money. Real easy money.
Your right something's don't always go as planned but when you have video evidence like this man does on what this police officer did to him from the beginning of his recording till the end.. the guy will get a good amount by suing the city department and also going after the police officer himself.
Would love to hear what the outcome of this was. Any complaints, lawsuits or settlement.
Thank you mr. Turner awesome footage congrats on the 5th circuit decision.
This is journalism. I hope a good lawsuit comes to fruition out of this illegal search, seizure, and arrest.
So @3:40 the officer is done with the investigation and safety check and we should be good to go.
Ah...spoke to soon. @5:28 officer pork rind now has to make an issue, quote made up laws about photography and demand ID with no RAS.
Now officer extra chromosome has to change the alleged violation from illegal photography to now trespassing.
Now the offense changes from illegal photography, from trespassing, to now failure to show ID.
Assault, battery, unlawful detainment, illegal search, and illegal arrest soon follow.
And these cops want me to respect them? Fuck all.
Exactly. The dumbfuck is just making shit up as he goes along.. A disgrace to law enforcement.
You pretty much nailed it.
RAS, in Texas, isn't enough to require ID from someone. Now, the cops can "demand" you ID, all they want. Texas penal code 38.02 is VERY specific on that. UNTIL a person is ARRESTED for something, you don't have to ID yourself. Some people think part (b) of 38.02 requires a person to identify themselves. Not true. Part (b) states: A person commits an offense if he intentionally gives a false or fictitious name, residence address, or date of birth to a peace officer who has: (1) lawfully arrested the person; (2) lawfully detained the person; or, (3) requested the information from a person that the peace officer has good cause to believe is a witness to a criminal offense.
Note: As per part (b), you are not REQUIRED to give your ID, even if you are legally detained - only that you will be breaking the law IF you give false info.
Edward Hartgrove
Thanks for this, not familiar with Texas but with Florida.
So this is old footage? What ever happened, did you file a lawsuit?
I'm guessing he did but signed an NDA when paid out.
I'm going to go out on a limb and assume the answer is no
@@youllnevergetmynumbr That was for the original tool videoing.
Idiots can't even follow the law... even when someone states the exact penal code, law enforcement manages to do whatever they want. It's a real miscarriage of justice and I am ready to see it end. STOP QUALIFIED IMMUNITY!!!!
"We got calls" when he literally just stopped there?
She's willing to lie to get ID, what else is she willing to do?
Chu chu
They did in fact get calls from "concerned citizen" types, Phillip has posted the 911 audio on another video.
Lysander Spooner - 'Those who are capable of tyranny are capable of perjury to sustain it.'
At 5:29 All I can think of is "Hello Newman..."
"i need to see your ID" that is not asking that is demanding.
Shell $ go into the cops pockets for sure!
Two filmed unlawful arrests Deputy Garza has enacted or participated in. So essentially two contempt of cop arrests without even the slightest hint of an actual crime. I hope he has lost his job by now. I'm no fan of the DOJ but what evidence do they need of corruption and rights violations to step in at the HCSO?
I REALLY LIKE YOUR PROFESSIONALISM IN ALL YOUR VIDEOS
Damned freakin' amazing how cops know where ALL the property lines are.
Is being a civil surveyor now a requirement to get that shiny piece of tin?
The fence line parallel to the curb is the property line extending across the driveway.
Step past the corner fence post towards the gate and you are trespassing.
However, that driveway is "public place" and 1A applies.
Actually,see the line in the concrete where the patrol cars are parked?..they are on Shell Property-Public Property extends to that point. County mows the grass up to that point.
+News Now Houston Now I'm really mad all over again. MFers.
*+NNH, FILM, PHILIP*
the only way we are ever going to get this abuse to stop is to file civil rights complaints with the states attorney general, get their bond lifted and SUE THE FVCKERS INDIVIDUALLY AND SEVERALLY FOR EVERY GOD DAMNED THING THEY OWN AND EVEN GO FOR THEIR PENSIONS.
otherwise the taxpayer pays out, the taxpayer isn't even aware of the lawsuit, the taxpayer never knows where their money went, the police department nor the cops are punished and it just emboldens them to violate peoples' rights even more.
ONLY PERSONAL LAWSUITS will send shock waves across this countries' LEO's because otherwise they just go on with tomorrow and continue to violate more rights.
A DIFFERENT APPROACH MUST BE FIGURED OUT BECAUSE THEY JUST DON'T GIVE A DAMN.
hell David, they're stalking you, threatening you, pulling guns on you, you're in hiding and you're in danger... do you think lawsuits matter to the rights violating cops?
there has to be a different attack at this abuse.
.
Look up trespass law. You are not trespassing unless someone trespasses you. You are allowed to go anywhere open to the public. If someone complains and trespasses you and you continue to stay then you are trespassing. Anyway, get informed, it's fun. (Not speaking to anyone specific just in general)
really they really said that people called because they were worried he wasn't going ot cross the road right and get hurt... she really couldn't think of a better line than that
i bet your beautiful face stops traffic
That female cop needs some more attention from that fat piggie.... she just stood there while Batt was arrested ... fuk the police!!!
have worked in petro chemical plants, nuclear plants as a pipe fitter/welder. I have built those structures from the ground up, literally, and I personally find it pretty silly that all this precautionary paranoia exists. Just because someone suffers from paranoia, doesn't deem the photography act illegal... relax folks. We're losing touch with reality here.
Contact because of "safety issue". What a load of bullshit. Seriously. And then she asks for his name? BULLSHIT. BULLSHIT BULLSHIT.
I feel bad for you, that sigh you gave after he said you’d be arrested for not giving ID showed everything. Good luck to you!
I applaud your courage and your conviction to demonstrate emotional restraint. Noting kills a video like this as when the subject becomes completely belligerent. Hoping you receive a handsome settlement.
Please post a composite update video of all the times you've been arrested and the outcomes of each. It would be interesting to see a timeline of where you were when arrested and whether you were prosecuted, charges were dropped, if you sued, outcomes, etc. You are one of my top 3 auditors and I'd like to know how you fared. Thanks.
imagine if this was in 1774 and instead of police, it was British military
I'm coming in to this a little late as I am just discovering these 1st Amendment Audits. Is there a link to the outcome?
BTW, hats off to you and NNH. I am now watching videos full time. Most make my blood boil.
thank you for your videos I'm learning a lot about the law
have an attorney on speed dial next time, itll be very worth it
I hope they are sued beyond belief for this bullshit.
that cop looks a little slow if you know what I mean
Excellent, excellent, excellent. I spent my teenage years in Deer Park and most people don't believe how fucked up these police are when I tell them about it. The fact you were streaming this is soooooo great. Thank you for doing this. I was in photography class at DPISD and people had their cameras and film taken for taking pictures of these places. I had been pulled over MANY times for merely walking down a sidewalk on my way home and searched without due process, and I was a middle class white kid. Kudos man, this isn't even the worst of these crooked cops. Gotta love cameras. These cops need body cams at all times.
You misspelled BAGS in your last sentence.
Wow, Harris County's law enforcement is an embarrassment to all law enforcement. I'm not sure if they're basically not informed, generally not smart or just willfully willing to violate laws, and judgements determined by courts.
so what happened since then? did you file a complaint or a law suit?
sure evry time in cross the street an officer is there to make sure that I'm safe .... 😶
And arrested for COMPLETELY LEGAL ACTIVITY! How long are we going to continue to put up with this?
I'm so resentful and angry at this cop's behavior , it's totally unacceptable .
Huh. So many people concerned about your well-being while you're standing on the grass. Good to see that they took you to safety. They even handcuffed you in case you were a danger to yourself. I'm sure they do this all the time. Texas is such a friendly place.
LOL well said
Hard to believe she thought a grown ass man didn't have enough sense to cross the street to safety. She was just detaining him with BS until fat boy could get there and arrest him. You can bet this damn city is off my list to vacation to!
All camera people should carry dildos and vibrators in their pockets. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Officer McFatty probably now wishes he had learned the law BEFORE he started violating the rights of citizens.
Almost 100% of all officers that submit a Constitution of America test will fail it.
Protect the rich oil pricks at any cost. Times are changing because of people like you exposing this scam. She does not care about your safety, that was a terrible excuse.
I remember when this went down. They really screwed up on this one.
Can't wait to see the out come. You planning on any videos?
Glock22Mischief I don't have anything planned right now because I'm busy helping out my neighborhood. We have been dealing with a month long issue people breaking into vehicles so a lot of my spare time has been eaten up in doing night patrols.
Ultimate007Trini I wasn't arrested in Texas unless you are trying to communicate to The Battousai in which case that he is already lawyered up on this issue. Also your comment would be best posted normally and not in the reply chain of someone else's comment that isn't related to that subject.
+nlpjohn Iheard that the City of New York pays out about $200 million per year in lawsuits against the NYPD.
There are attorneys who will take the case for 1/3 your settlement so long as they feel your case has merit. Been there, done that, and won. No 15k necessary.
"lets have a run, if you catch me, i'll ID myself.... can't say fairer that that!"
Texan Gov says he gonna start giving harsh punishments to anyone filming or disrupting any police investigation keep on keeping on
God bless that woman cop! She was so concerned about your safety! I wonder if she goes up to everyone she sees crossing the street and talks to them about being safe.
Everybody knows if you're not doing anything wrong you have nothing to worry about, unless there's a cop around.
AKA criminal with a badge
5:34 So that's where Newman went after Seinfeld ended.
I hope that wasn't the same women that talked to you earlier in the shot when you got arrested by Garza. There was obviously no change after that.
It was. She and the other cops were bad mouthing me. They showed their true colors off camera and while I was in cuffs in the back of the car.
+The Battousai so what happened, did to go to jail. we're you charged with a crime?
Did you file a lawsuit?
+The Battousai Please tell me your suing these idiots. Garza should be fired.
***** Wow that's a shock, she sure didn't seem like an honest officer. Hope things go well.
At the end of the video, I thought I was in Gotham city. Batman was reaching for his utility belts. LOL The caped crusader comes through again!!!
HOW DID IT END UP!?? Did you successfully sue? Please put the synopsis of what happened below the video, brah. This gets old trying to find out
@Ernie Tetrault Turner vs Driver - law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca5/16-10312/16-10312-2017-02-16.html The guy in this video is Mr. Turner.
was a lawsuit filed ? and if so what were the results. I assume when a prosecutor gets the case they will realize they have nothing to go on.
"You can't film the government." Don't they understand that surveillance of government is the ESSENCE of the First Amendment?
Good job. Shell is obligated to provide a sidewalk. This land goes under a double classification as private/public, but pedestrians are legally allowed to walk there. That is the law.
Like everywhere. Private and public land. 10 feet from the road is city property too, Shell is obligated to protect pedestrian, not the obligation of a citizen. Shell responsible for endangering you by not building a walk area.
They should place a sidewalk for its employees too. THAT IS WORK CODE, which they violated too.
People do not have to drive to work, and it is the obligation of the company to unsure the safety of its employees along with the public. At least mow the lawn and clean up.
Shell is obligated to mow the lawn and pick up the garbage, they have violated CITY CODE or STATE LAWS. All lawns must be mowed and garbage must be cleaned. That is the law. You can use this against SHELL, they have violate more than one LAW. Go read CITY CODE and you see that you have the right to walk there and it must be mowed and cleaned. LOOK AT THAT GARBAGE. That is a violation of the rules. HOW IS IT THAT HOMEOWNERS MUST DO THIS< BUT NOT SHELL? Homeowners pay a fine for not cleaning up and mowing. 150$ FINE.
POLLUTION AND UNSAFE WORK CONDITION AND A PUBLIC DANGER TOO. THOSE ARE JUST A FEW OF THE RULES. WORK CODE ALSO MEANS THEY MUST HAVE STOP SIGHS AT THE EXITS, THEY do not have these. AN ORANGE LINE ACROSS THE PAVEMENT TO IDENTIFY THE STOP LINE for vehicles pulling out. THEY are breaking many WORK CODES, you can dig them up with ease. COMPLAIN TO THE WORKERS COMPENSATION BOARD ABOUT THE DANGER, they must follow up and reply to you. THAT IS LAW. LEARN IT!
Lol, that's like talking logic & law to a 3 year old in the middle of a full blown temper tantrum, Battman. Got my fingers crossed someone more intelligent takes his badge/gun far away from him.
is this what cartman will look like when he is adult? respect my authority!!!!!!!!
Lol
Holy crap, how incompetent can one cop be? Now I have to go search how this turned out.
PLEASE tell me you sued the F outta this guy/TX Tax payers!!
Was there a lawsuit?
i think he was searching for a piece of chicken or a candy bar
If the officer was correct about it being illegal to take pictures of this chemical plant, than he had every right to ask this guy for ID.
Cop: who are you?
Batt: I'm a journalist.
Cop: may I see ID (press credentials)?
Batt: No.
Looks suspicious to me. And if he was breaking the law, it was the cop's duty to arrest him.
Thank you Harris County PD for keeping the public safe.
It's not illegal to take pictures of a chemical plant.
This is the shit that makes people assume all police officers are criminal. If you go along with another officer doing illegal shit, you are complicit and therefore should also be charged with whatever crime you allowed to happen.
18 U.S. Code § 241 - Conspiracy against rights. It is a real law that should be used to punish police officers and all conspiring with them. The law is the law is the law. period. It is also clear that there is no law prohibiting filming of anything that can be seen from public view. Arresting someone for doing so is a crime.
hope you sue
officer fred flintstone should learn more about laws instead of eating away to many donuts.
Hi, I'm in the u.k. after seeing what she'll does to you guys filming in public, I will never use a shell fuel station ever again
Every since David got arrested I haven’t bought shell gas
Lol
Kevin Richards I stopped buy shell 40 years ago as they supported the incarceration of Nelson Mandela in South Africa. I’ll walk before I buy gas from Shell.
is there a lawsuit pending?
Big one-yes 😎
+News Now Houston Yay!
+Filming Is Legal, Moron! (FILM!) the problem is why would they care if you sue them... they actually laugh at your law suits. It comes from the pockets of tax payers. So while I don't agree with the arrest all a law suit does is take money from the community. Untill something is done about this these type of arrests will continue and accomplish nothing but taking money from the community and putting it in the pockets of one person.
bryphi77 Lawsuits, along with formal complaints serve to establish patterns and practices of both the agency and the individual officers involved. Just this year alone, we have heard over and over about 'bad cops' who have many lawsuits and complaints against them, and the news reports (some national) lament how the 'warning signs were there' about the 'bad cop'.
Many agencies large and small are under federal oversight because of the number of complaints and lawsuits.
To claim that lawsuits and complaints achieve nothing is just flat out incorrect.
Then community aka voters need to take action?
update?
It's one of those deals if you were bullied in school you apparently are GUARANTEED a job as a cop
This is one of the worst cases of wilful ignorance and stupidity from a police officer. Totally oblivious to the law, sounds like a 13 year old trying to guess what the law is. Breaking numerous civil rights in the process.
Please tell me there is some consequences for this lard ass, civil rights violator?
P.S Great work remaining calm under such extreme duress. I just subbed.
They don't get much dumber than that
Lol
So, what was the outcome?
Did you sue?
Andrew Farrow I
Another cop who doesn’t know the law
Okay so here's one of my favorites. Quick call for reinforcements, call SWAT, call the National Guard! There's a man on the sidewalk shooting, with a camera!!
arrested for standing in public with a camera... MURICA! land of of the free
Thank you Philip Turner 🙏💛
Fucking outstanding! Ignorance about the property, false detention. illegal search and a general lack of intelligence all on display. You were respectful and had your tools in order. I never fault anyone for providing ID to avoid arrest, but goddamn is it awesome to see someone take it all the way. 100% grade A+
Please tell me there was a lawsuit.
Please sue.
Hopefully, you get paid plenty for their ignorance.
Great Vid.
"thanks for your concern officer, but i will take responsibility for my own safety."
sickening. swap "I need to see your I.D" with " Show me your papers"....
What was the result of this encounter? Any legal action?
Since when did Shell become a federal property?
It's very important to tell them you dont have any weapons not even a pocket knife. Also ask them do they fear for their lives. The search or pat down can only be if they are in fear..
please tell me you got a settlement from this encounter. ?????
'Just wanna make sure you are being safe.' US, we are all gonna be over here plugging up the road and creating mass confusion with all this traffic. I give ye much credit The Battousai, for dealing with these Wastes of Space.
That cop didn't have to do any police training. He was welcomed into the fold on looks alone.
Lacks the obligatory tyrant tats, though.