30 Qur'ans? What do the experts say.
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 04. 2021
- I read from Understanding the Qur'an: Themes and Style by Dr Abdel Haleem, and The Cambridge Companion to the Qur'an edited by Dr Jane Dammen McAuliffe
Blogging Theology is on Instagram: / bloggingtheology1
Please consider supporting my work on Patreon: www.patreon.com/Bloggingtheol...
One Quran, One message, One God.
from the day one of mankind
@@successmanifesting Hafs and Warsh are not different books..!!
its recitation styles..it does not make the all meaning null or different..
eventhough muslims are split into different sects,QURAN is ONE SAME BOOK...!!
@@successmanifesting Come on man, Hafs and Warsh are just different style or dialects of recitation. 😀
the quran was revealed in multiple recitations...
@@janardhanparveshwar4307 YEP saytn decided to make a movement to make people do good and stay away from evil. oFcOuRse saytn would want that
subhanallah
I'm in KSA here
reciting tarawih everyday
i have 4 kids huffaz behind me
where i sweat to even hinder a tajweed stoppage because they will demolish me
that's how protected this book is brothers and sisters
🇩🇿❤️🇸🇦
MashaAllah bro
حفظك وحفظهم الله
Where is the divine Quran? In which museum?
@@tyh3120 In almost every Muslim home...
The '30 Quran attack' comes mostly from dejected Christian missionaries, grasping at straws, unable to reconcile their own book is from anonymous authors relaying different versions of the same events.
You people are still delusional? 😂🤣
czcams.com/video/88qcJOI05sE/video.html
@@brandonb1539300 years after Jesus walked the earth they were still arguing over who Jesus was.
At 6:40 he quotes the book written by the top Western experts says that "nor have scholars trying to deconstruct that image through linguistic arguments succeeded in seriously discrediting the genuineness of the Quran as we know it". This clearly shows that the Quran is not exactly the same in the past as it is today because he quotes the expert as say "seriously discrediting the genuineness of the Quran as we know it." Why did the expert say "seriously discredit the genuineness of the Quran" unless the expert knew that the Quran has been indeed been discredited in non serious ways. In other words the expert is saying the the Quran is clearly not an exact copy of of the original copy. The expert is saying that the Quran can be shown to be different now to the one in the past in non serious ways.
That means that the Quran has changed and we do not have the original wording of the original Quran. If the expert knew that we have the original Quran that expert would have said that we have the exact wording of the original. This man is not listening closely enough to what the expert is exactly saying. His conclusions are not what the experts are actually saying in the books he is quoting. He is twisting their words. This man is clearly unreliable just from the quotes that he has given on this video.
We don't have the original Quran. The missionaries at Speaker's Corner in London have conclusively proven that there are different Qurans. They brought about 30 (26 found in 2016 . Another 4 found later) different versions of the Consonental Arabic Qurans to Speakers Corner for people to see for themselves. Check it out czcams.com/video/Wa3XIfEyPVg/video.html on youtube. The two most popular Arabic versions are the Hafs and Warsh. They vary in small ways from each other so that is why the experts say that no one can "seriously discredit the Quran". They can, however, discredit the Quran in details. There are multiple versions of the Arabic Quran being printed today. The Hafs is probably the best version. The curent version was of the Hafs was published in Cairo in 1924. Prince Philip who died recently of the UK was older than it. The idea that there is only one version of the Quran is wrong. Best wishes.
@Benny Little prove me that your Bible is preserved by God, it contains a lot of contradictions
@Benny Little we have Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) words preserved in the collection of Hadith.
And just by reading and analyzing you'll yourself notice the differences between the style of words used by Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), a human style, compared to Qur'an, whose words and style is completely different!.
Qur'an is commanding and to the point, and not like any human style like ~~ Once upon a time, or Now this happened.
Yes There are stories in Quran, but none like [once upon a time, or In the beginning, or then this happened] . While as In hadith, that is the Sayings of The Prophet(pbuh) there are many such instances, which sound human. Like {there will come a time, etc}.
And Angel Jibreel is not a show piece that anyone could see him!. That's funny of you to say that, when only Prophets could see the angels.
Tho we do have certain accounts of companions of the Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) who witnessed that moment when Prophet(pbuh) was getting a revelation from Allah through Angel Jibreel(a.s).
Quran is in our heart.. If all Quran were trough in the red sea. We surely can produce exact Quran word by word. Allahhuakhbar
but which quran would you reproduce then? dont you know that there are different ones? Just go and buy a quran in Tunesia and one in Iran. Compare them and you will find major differences. One is the Hafs and one is the warsh. these are not just different spellings and sounding, but completely different words in different grammar with different meaning. The fact that this channel does not mention this appears biased to me...So the "God" of the quran was not able to perfectly preserve "his" book. Which shows that Sure 15,9 is false. (Therefore the Quran contains errors). For details on the differences check e.g.: czcams.com/video/BwSkDXXpNSI/video.html or also www.answering-islam.org/Quran/Text/warsh.html
We'll deal with haters after Ramadan. This month is meant for spiritual reflection and devotion. Let those idiots keep craving for our response.
@@tbone8119 haha you idiot just proved you dont know arabic FIRST LEARN ARABIC THEN START BARKING FOOL
@@cervezaway7049 Read it in Arabic and understand it in Arabic. When it first came out, the pagan Arabs of the time thought it was magic and impossible to make.. All I have to say to you guys is so not associate partners with Allah. Jesus called GOD Allaha and is an Aramaic word. Don’t believe me, go look it up in the Aramaic scriptures....
@@cervezaway7049 your little brain 🧠 😜 can't understand it since you have no knowledge of Arabic.
Love your contribution for Islam in such an Islamophobic world 👍🏻
@@exposingtv9903 wow what a disgusting channel “if vs but” is 🤦🏾♂️
Usual 'don't criticise' phrase but you can criticise others mmmh
We'll deal with haters after Ramadan. This month is meant for spiritual reflection and devotion. Let those idiots keep craving for our response.
@@MohamedShou Reported that account.
@@SuperKafooo good work bro
No matter how much they try, Allah (swt) will preserve The Qur’an Himself. Allahu Akbar ☝🏻.
It is certainly We Who have revealed the Reminder, and it is certainly We Who will preserve it.
~ 15:9
plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
@@fidelcatsro6948 plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
@@fidelcatsro6948 plz subscribe my channel
@@exposingtv9903 Why is the video so bad quality? I can make a much better video and sent it to you. Do you have insta? My insta is sketchyboy_772007.
I'm a muslim. Thank you very much for sharing this knowledge.
the only "proof" Muslims have Ibrahim re-build Kaaba is bc it is in the Quran. No other scripture talks about Kaaba or even Mekka. If such an important person like Ibrahim ot Ishmael were in Mekka we would have to find scriptures about it. Also Quran tells uns no messanger was send to those people in Mekka before Muhammad he was the first. This is a contradiction.The Jews lived in that area from the beginning and in Medina no Jew knew about Ibrahim or Ishmael having been in Mekka ?
They would have maybe accepted Muhammad.Muslims prayed towards Jerusalem bc they were like a judeo-christian sect in the beginning called Muhamedans or Ishmaelites.Jesus is ment all the time (24x in Quran Muhammad 4x) Virgin Mary is ment. in Quran more than even Injeel. The problem when Jews and Christians did not want to join Muhammad he went to war against them. Follow Muhammad or loose everything.That is why Muhammad changed prayer direction to Mekka.
Ibrahim and Ishmael were not Arabs.Muhammad was Beduin Arab. By islamic law you are what your father is and the line of Muhammad was Arab.Ibrahim was an Aramean. Arabs invaded and subdued the region later.
Muhammad is a title, not a name. No mention of any Arabic Muhammad in the Quran. Muhammad points to ......the Jewish Messiah.
@@SheikhAlladeen I will answer you with one statement and you can google it: Argument from silence.
@@tyh3120what??????
Go and read Al Imran ayat 144
Don’t claim something that you don’t know
This brought me to tears. It’s the word of Allah and his messenger pbuh delivered completely. It’s such a privilege for us to recite the exact same Quran that has been revealed.
It’s an absolute good. It is meaning of life itself.
You said that spot on bro.
how stupid you are
Really? Are you Muslim? Muhammad had scribes, but didn't have time to have the divine Quran written down? Why? The Quran was not important enough? The Calife Othman had burned his collection of Qurans, but was not decapitated. Why? The Quran was garbages?
Tell me what surah 19:1 says
"Indeed, it is WE who sent down the Qur'an and indeed, We will be its guardian." Noble Qur'an 15:9
Even if the whole world come together to change it they cant. Since the begining its in our heart.
hahahahahahhahahaha
@@ivonikolov2916 gone mad
@@mooktarkader3285 like your prophet when he was bewicthed and he lost his mind or?
@@ivonikolov2916 mark 3:21
When his family heard about this, they went to take charge of him, for they said, "He is out of his mind."
Before doing claims against Islam, just look at this you clown 🤡, Jesus was out of his mind
And you are the only one, who disliked this video
@@ivonikolov2916 he wasn’t bewitched and lost his mind, the prophet PBUH was kinda semi conscious for a short duration (just like one would be when they have a cold) then he became healthy again. What is that supposed to prove anyways?
Quality content my man. I took Shahadah a few years ago, I read the Quran cover to cover, it was over 1,100 pages in English and had accompanying Arabic and English in Arabic pronunciation for each word. I still have it, it's my most valued book, only second being my Bible. I've had comments from a person claiming to be Muslim that my Quran wasn't real (he didn't like what I was telling him about Islam, I can't remember the argument) but this just opened my eyes to the fact that not even most Muslims have read the entire Quran. This shouldn't surprise anyone, it's a very long and difficult to read book of Law that requires you to be more than basically literate. Most Christians haven't read the whole Bible beginning to end and the Quran is by far a more challenging read, in my opinion! Inshallah I'll wake up one day speaking fluent Arabic and become a Hafiz. I memorized a few short Surahs in Arabic so far for Salah but say I could memorize Al Baqarah, that would be amazing! 🤲
Thanks for sharing ❤
We should wait until people are old enough to drive
and then and only then be allowed to choose a religion.
Furthermore, they have to read their Holy Scripture
cover to cover as the first stage of qualification.
The Bible is about 783,137 words.
The Quran is only 77,449 words. 10 times shorter.
The Harry Potter books
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone 223pages 76,944words
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets 251pages 85,141words.
If they haven't read their Quran, they have NO excuse.
The entire 7 books 3,407pages 1,084,170words.
No excuse for Christians as well.
(If you have have read the Bible, what is the 11th
commandment that carries God's curse as a punishment?
Once they pass their entrance exam, they are admitted.
Membership fees are required annually.
If you miss 5 years, you are automatically
deregistered.
@@elye3701the Qur'an is actually 150k words approximately. And I don't know if you're counting the old testament or not but the new testament and the Qur'an are roughly the same size
@@Ahle.haq0 Can I get a reference?
@@elye3701 you didn't cite your reference
One fact that everyone should know about the Holy Quran is that its the only book that is memorised by heart, word for word, all chapters and every verse by hundreds of thousands of Students known as a "Hafiz". This practice has been going on since the time of the Prophet (PBUH) and ensures that the Quran remains the exact same as it was revealed.
Exactly, here in hindi speaking country we have at least 100k hafiz, Allah has made quran easy to memorize, since previous revelations were lost as they were not easily memorized. For Arabs it would have been 100 times easier than hindi/urdu speaking people.
why did Utman need to write his Mushaf al-Uthmani when there was a finished Quran already. Why did Aisha say that Mushaf al-Utmani had missing Surahs, Why did Umar say nobody has the complete Quran when most of it was lost. Why did Egypt feel the need to make riwaya of Hafs the "official" Quran why not use Warsh ???? Many different Qurans even Sheikh Yasir Qadhi said there are different ayaat in different Qurans ....Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. This you can not explain off by Ahruf or Qira'at useless video
@@SheikhAlladeen I am not at all familiar or aware of any of these incidents, hence can't make an intelligent reply to your "facts" stated here, will leave that to the experts... I can simply tell you this...you can go to any Muslim country anywhere in the world, pick up a Quran, then randomly select any other Muslim country and get a copy from there and so on...you will find it one and the same. I've done this is 4 different countries on three continents. They are the same. The different versions that you have pointed out may exist, but being a Muslim for 46 years, I've never come across such a copy nor heard of it. There is only one Quran that exists today and has stood the test of time. Can't say that about other holy books for sure...and I would like to add: please watch the above video again, if you did not listen and understand it clearly.
@@wildtrex my friend not even islamic scholars today claim all riwayat are the same. Every arabic Quran is a riwayah by a certain Qari and the have variants. Wh would Egypt make riwaya of Hafs the 2Official" Quran version if all Qurabns are the same this my friend is not logical right ?
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Each version has its own chain of narrators (isnad) .
When we compare these Qur'ans it becomes obvious they are not identical. There are five main types of differences between them.1. Extra Words 2. Graphical/Basic Letter Differences 3. Diacritical Differences4. Vowel Differences5. Basmalah Difference
He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ...
Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112.
Narrated Anas bin Malik: Hudhaifa bin Al-Yaman came to Uthman at the time when the Muslims of Syria and the people of Iraq were waging war to conquer Armenia and Azarbaijan.Hudhaifa was afraid of their (the people of Syria and Iraq) differences in the recitation of the Qur'an,he said to 'Uthman, "O chief of the Believers! Save this nation before they differ about the Book(Quran) ... (Sahih al-Bukhari: vol. 6, bk. 61, no. 510)3. Caliph Uthman solved this problem by establishing one text, in one dialect, and destroying the other versions. His goal was to remove the differences. My friend even in the times of the Prophet ppl had different recitations. How can we be sure the one we habe today is correct. Muslims have tried to make just one Quran version no matter if it is correct or not.
@@SheikhAlladeen 😊... I simply do not miss any Fast and not think about how many poor to feed in exchange... and once you understand what it is to be a Muslim, you'll happily feed the poor without thinking that you have to fill a certain quota. The points you are making in your comments are way out of my Islamic knowledge, and I again would ask you to aim these questions at an expert. All I know is that I myself, my circle of friends and family and beyond know only 1 Quran in existence. I'm sure all our Muslim brothers agree to this.
I have no clue who you are, But may Allah reward you for your sincerity and for taking the time to address this issue. And may Allah give you guidance and reward you with paradise in the hereafter.
The Xtians are easy to refute. The 30 ''different'' Qurans are just the 10 Qiraat published by different people.
yet I'm still struggling to master one of those _qira'at._ which I believe was the qira'at of Imam Ashim of Kufa.
i remember my father teach me two different ways to recite surah ad-dhuha, (wadduha and wadduhe) but back then i was too ignorant, now i know this is important
@@user-np3cp2cb7u plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
@@von2648 plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
@no name plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
"There are more contradictions in the *greek biblical manuscripts* than there are words in New Testament" - *Bart Erhman*
😂 😂
But Christians have the holy spirit so they do not need to use obvious logic, which to them is antithetical to Jesus
But the Christians never burned the bibles. Muhammad had scribes, but didn't have time to have the divine Quran written down? Why? The Quran was not important enough? The Calife Othman had burned his collection of Qurans, but was not decapitated. Why? The Quran was garbages?
@@tyh3120 Search up William Tyndale
@@tyh3120 He’s an interesting guy
This is brilliant!!!! Great reference and narrative of the historic account and the connection with the Birmingham copy. Loved this!!! Very insightful on how to be unbiased and acadmically approach a topic.
At 6:40 he quotes the book written by the top Western experts says that "nor have scholars trying to deconstruct that image through linguistic arguments succeeded in seriously discrediting the genuineness of the Quran as we know it". This clearly shows that the Quran is not exactly the same in the past as it is today because he quotes the expert as say "seriously discrediting the genuineness of the Quran as we know it." Why did the expert say "seriously discredit the genuineness of the Quran" unless the expert knew that the Quran has been indeed been discredited in non serious ways. In other words the expert is saying the the Quran is clearly not an exact copy of of the original copy. The expert is saying that the Quran can be shown to be different now to the one in the past in non serious ways.
That means that the Quran has changed and we do not have the original wording of the original Quran. If the expert knew that we have the original Quran that expert would have said that we have the exact wording of the original. This man is not listening closely enough to what the expert is exactly saying. His conclusions are not what the experts are actually saying in the books he is quoting. He is twisting their words. This man is clearly unreliable just from the quotes that he has given on this video.
He's not unbiased. He's a Muslim
@@johnjones7293 Thanks for that. I didn't realise. I see a lot of Muslim books in the background.
No prophet was send to his people before Muhammad this is what Quran tells us. So Abraham could not have been in Mekka. No mention about Abraham in Mekka in any scripture before Islam. Al-Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem, . The mosque was built on top of the Temple Mount, several decades after Muhammad's death !!!
Muhammad and the early Muslims in Medina initially prayed towards Jerusalem, and changed the qibla to face the Kaaba in Mecca in 624 CE.
December 11 was the day when Prophet Muhammad conquered Mecca in 629. Early Muslims changed the prayer direction before conquering Mekka .If early Muslims bel Abraham re-build the Kaaba and Kaaba was the real holy site of Allah why did they pray towards Jerusalem Al Aqsa Mosque was not build yet !!! Big holes in the narrative
@@bobgriffin316: Well spotted Bob. The university has to tread a fine line, you know. Kerching!
"Until next time", is a catchphrase I always waiting to hear at the end of each video. I hope no one else use it, because it's becoming trademark on this channel.
❤️
plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
Probably will be heard in Jannah
@@BloggingTheology instead u can change it 'INSYAALLAH UNTIL NEXT TIME' JKJK
@@khaitok5314 no, it's unique one ..Englishman trademark
It is certainly We Who have revealed the Reminder " i.e. the Quraan", and it is certainly We Who will preserve it.15;9
preserve through the hand of othman ?
@@LEROIDUTENNISDETABLE you are certainly talking with your foot in your mouth.
@@alhassangangu4357 the warning is reveal to you from our allah be not the first deny it. 2:41 ☝️
@@LEROIDUTENNISDETABLE through many hands actually. And that's for the written version. Hundreds of hffaz were alive during that time. Not a problem at all.
@@g9n646 would be good to see the fragments that othman used for compiled.
What a wonderful and insightful content! Inshaallah I hope I can read and study as much as you do to be able to give non-believers among whose I live a good reason to revise their views. God bless you, Paul! Jazzak Allahu khayran! From Russia 🇷🇺
Thank you!
О, ты тут )))
Imagine the faces of the people spreading these lies on the day of resurrection - not gonna be a fun day!
Make More Vids Mr Anon Ymouse
@@muhamadsalmanjafar4578 Salam akhi! We've got a special in the works for Ramadan, so be on the lookout for that :)
@@TheAnonYmouse
waalaykum Assalam,
Nice.. Alright Akhi. . . i will be around then
why did Utman need to write his Mushaf al-Uthmani when there was a finished Quran already. Why did Aisha say that Mushaf al-Utmani had missing Surahs, Why did Umar say nobody has the complete Quran when most of it was lost. Why did Egypt feel the need to make riwaya of Hafs the "official" Quran why not use Warsh ???? Many different Qurans even Sheikh Yasir Qadhi said there are different ayaat in different Qurans ....Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. This you can not explain off by Ahruf or Qira'at useless video
@@SheikhAlladeen Get lost, shaitan.
This 7 minutes video smashes the claim of those who say the Quran has been tampered with!
Br. Paul is doing such a great job destroying the claims of those who lack knowledge by referring to world renounced experts!
Br. Paul, may Allah grant you a blessed life in the dunya and the here after.
@Kh-S, No! This 7 minutes soothes Muslims in their delusion that the thousands of textual differences in Qurans from different parts of the world being used today, have no impact on the 'only one Quran' claim; on which, if Muslims did not rely so heavily to justify their theological rightness, would free individual Muslims to do their own research and listen to the discussions between native Arabic speakers with their own brain in gear. It is troubling to Christians, who have a one-on-one personal relationship with the Creator, that Muslims are expected to put the fate of their eternal soul into the hands of third parties without question, and that when they are of an age and mind naturally to question, they are slapped down with age old traditional answers that have little or no foundation in current research, or the many existing publications that LIST many of the textual differences. As with the textual differences in Greek manuscripts where Christians have to ask themselves of the doctrinal significance of those differences (the basic questions being, 'What is the good news, and do the textual differences effectively change the message?'), Muslims could explore the same questions in an academic way, without ceasing to be Muslims or giving up Islam. Do your own homework. Are scholars telling you the truth? Will Islam save you?
@@chiaratiara2575 sorry to tell you that we asked a lot of questions to our scholars live on TV, radio, call, websites. Also, we have a lot of books available to read on different topics of our religion, we can discuss the differences, learn from different materials books, lives, masjjids. And as a bonus for you the people who memorized the Quran are better than those who don't and they made some research of the Quran affects on students, and it is noticable that the Quran had changed them to be better wither in studying or behaving well. There a great declined in criminals behavior after memorizing the Quran. So, how could that possible if it is not a Holy Book from God!!!?
@@ramiwshg If it was a Holy Book from God, it would not recommend so much violence, especially since your prophet claimed legitimacy from the message of the prophets who went before him, the last of whom was and is the Prince of Peace. So, please watch this short interview about a recent event, which is the last in a series of similar, stretching back for years. czcams.com/video/7zDAtzmpecc/video.html
the only "proof" Muslims have Ibrahim re-build Kaaba is bc it is in the Quran. No other scripture talks about Kaaba or even Mekka. If such an important person like Ibrahim ot Ishmael were in Mekka we would have to find scriptures about it. Also Quran tells uns no messanger was send to those people in Mekka before Muhammad he was the first. This is a contradiction.The Jews lived in that area from the beginning and in Medina no Jew knew about Ibrahim or Ishmael having been in Mekka ?
They would have maybe accepted Muhammad.Muslims prayed towards Jerusalem bc they were like a judeo-christian sect in the beginning called Muhamedans or Ishmaelites.Jesus is ment all the time (24x in Quran Muhammad 4x) Virgin Mary is ment. in Quran more than even Injeel. The problem when Jews and Christians did not want to join Muhammad he went to war against them. Follow Muhammad or loose everything.That is why Muhammad changed prayer direction to Mekka.
Ibrahim and Ishmael were not Arabs.Muhammad was Beduin Arab. By islamic law you are what your father is and the line of Muhammad was Arab.Ibrahim was an Aramean. Arabs invaded and subdued the region later.
could you please provide any evidence for muhammaden or ishmalite claim??or accept that you are liar,I'm waiting but not my breath lol
MashaAllah. Very well said! ❤️The Quran is Preserved till the end to come. Absolutely. Great vid Paul as always! :)
I highly appreciate your efforts for debunking myths... May Allah bless you with good health 🤲
the only "proof" Muslims have Ibrahim re-build Kaaba is bc it is in the Quran. No other scripture talks about Kaaba or even Mekka. If such an important person like Ibrahim ot Ishmael were in Mekka we would have to find scriptures about it. Also Quran tells uns no messanger was send to those people in Mekka before Muhammad he was the first. This is a contradiction.The Jews lived in that area from the beginning and in Medina no Jew knew about Ibrahim or Ishmael having been in Mekka ?
They would have maybe accepted Muhammad.Muslims prayed towards Jerusalem bc they were like a judeo-christian sect in the beginning called Muhamedans or Ishmaelites.Jesus is ment all the time (24x in Quran Muhammad 4x) Virgin Mary is ment. in Quran more than even Injeel. The problem when Jews and Christians did not want to join Muhammad he went to war against them. Follow Muhammad or loose everything.That is why Muhammad changed prayer direction to Mekka.
Ibrahim and Ishmael were not Arabs.Muhammad was Beduin Arab. By islamic law you are what your father is and the line of Muhammad was Arab.Ibrahim was an Aramean. Arabs invaded and subdued the region later.
@@SheikhAlladeen Goodday brother, this is a good start to understand the "issue", if you are interested ;
O People of the Book! Why do you argue about Abraham, while the Torah and the Gospel were not revealed until long after him? Do you not understand? [Surat 3:65 (Al Imran)
And in the case of Pharaoh, Allah says in the Quran that he will preserve his body for future generation. The Torah and Gospel did not mention this.
“What, now! When previously you rebelled and were one of the corrupters? Today we will preserve your body so you can be a Sign for people who come after you. Surely many people are heedless of Our Signs.” [10:91-92]
And a good video also;
m.czcams.com/video/JcO6XZFIK4A/video.html
@@malinaidmy5411 I am glad Allah preserved legal prostitutionThe Verse of Mut’ah (4:24)
The most important verse of the Holy Qur’an which establishes the legitimacy of Mut’ah is verse 24 of Surat an-Nisa, known to all hadeeth commentators (Sunni and Shi’a) as “the verse of Mut’ah.” ............ So when you have contracted temporary marriage [istimt'atum] with them, then give them their words. There is no sin on you for whatever you agree to after this. Indeed, Allah is Knowing, Wise.
Al-Qur’an, Surah An-Nisa, Ayah 24----------------------Arabic word istimta’tum, which is the verbal form of the word Mut’ah
“Sabra al-Juhanni reported on the authority of his father that while he was with Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon hm) he said: 0 people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women…”
Sahih Muslim Book 008, Number 3255
@@SheikhAlladeen bull.
@@SheikhAlladeenI have refuted your comment under another comment. I'll add one more thing that the mention of Ibrahim AS in any scripture other than the Qur'an is not necessary for they are not reliable in the first place. The oldest copy of old testament is the dead sea scrolls and they are 1000 to 1500 years after Musa AS.
Ibrahim did not spent his majority of life in Mecca in fact this city didn't even exist during his early life. It was only after zamzam came into existence did he was ordered to build the kaba. He wasn't sent as a messenger to Mecca. He lived mostly in Syria. The events of him destroying idols or such encounters with the idolators were not in Mecca but in Syria area
Highly commendable simplified presentation of both sides of the scholars' point of view. Again truth triumphs for..' truth stands out clear from error.' Quran Sura 2:256
Sir you 're a beacon of light in this world of darkness, may allah almighty grant you and all the believers paradise inchaa allah
May Allah reward you with what you deserve.
Thank you for bringing scholarship and academic research to the general public.
Plz 🙏🙏 watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
i all different arabic Quran riwayat by different Qari with different ayaat. Why would Egypt see the need to choose one riwayah (1924) over any other as "official" version ??? Why not choose riwayah of Warsh or any other of the many different Qurans. Warsh Quran they read in North Africa ??? Tell me
2 of the many different things you find in Hafs vs Warsh ..Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO
There are "variations" in recitations of the Quran, but not different 'versions' of the Quran. For example, one variation reads the name 'Abraham' as 'Ibrahim" whenever it appears in the Quran. These readings have chains of transmission that goes back to the Prophet.
Which "version" says Abraham? Ibrahim is literally what every musxaf I picked up said.
Love your content, always so insightful. Wishing you all the best from South Africa 🇿🇦
Thanks a million. May Allah give you more knowledge and a long life. Ameen.
Thank you too
Masha'Allah, excellent Brother Paul! There's another excellent book by Ahmad Von Denffer called Ulum Al-Qur'an: An Introduction to the Sciences of the Qur'an. The main summary that you have mentioned in this video is certainly included in that book. It's an older book published in 1983.
You made your own unique niche among youtube channels
Thank you for taking the effort and time to bring these facts to the public. Cheers
Yeh, but Paul, you are citing honest references. They don’t count.
We have to go by heresay and anonymous claims online.
🤣
Lol
@@BloggingTheology your channel has a lot of potential bdother
@@everyislamophobenightmare2079 hopefully!
😅
Thank you brother. As Muslims we know there is only One Quran but it is fantastic how you break down with facts and analyse people's findings. Allah SWT conveyed a message to Mankind and that is the words in the Glorious Holy Quran. May Allah SWT bless you for all the hard work you do in your channel and the knowledge you give us to navigate the thoughts and views in this ever islamophobic western world. Peace.❤
i Have Been Watching Your Videos For Quite Some Time Now ... With Much Anticipation & Enthusiasm i Might Add ... The Efforts & Research You Put in What You Do Are Much Appreciated ... Thank You Sir & May God Bless You 🙏🕊🌼
The title Muhammad "praised, commendable" in Arabic, derived from the root حَمِدَ (hamida) the Arabs followed heretic judeo christian sects in the beginning but they needed an arab figure to unite Arabs when they were gaining military power. Also the reason why they changed praying dir. from Jerusalem to Mecca and started kissing the stone again.It was arabization which is going on even today. God only accepts prayer in Arabic ? Yeah righ
Just reflecting on the very first word “Iqra” chosen by Allah for the beginning of the revelation of the Recitation, is enough to those of knowledge/wisdom to understand what Islam means. Those who seek to sow division and confusion on the authorship or authenticity of the Recitation reveals their ignorance, dishonesty, hypocrisy and arrogance. We pray that Allah grant them guidance to the truth.
Aameen Ya Rabb..
Tabari,
He came to me while I was asleep with a sheet
of silk brocade with writing thereon and said,
"Read (iqra ']!" I said, "I cannot read [mà
aqra 'u]!" but he pressed against me until I
thought I would die. He then released me and
said, "Read!" So I said, "What shall I read
[madha aqra n)?" but I only said this to be
delivered, lest he once again do to me what he
did before. He said "Read in the name of your
Lord. Who did create Did create Humanity
from coagulate| Read for your Lord is
Magnanimous Who, through the use of the
calamus Has taught Humanity that of which it
was oblivious" IQ. 'Alaq 96:1-5]. I read it, and
then he ceased and withdrew from me. I awoke
from my sleep, and it was as if he had inscribed
a scripture upon my heart (ka-annamà kataba
A galbi kitaban].
Bede,
In due time (Caedmon] stretched himself out and
went to sleep, whereupon he dreamt that someone
stood by him, saluted him, and called him by
name: "Caedmon," he said, "sing to me something
(canta mihi aliquid)!" Cadmon answered, "I
cannot sing (nescio cantere)!
" Once again the
speaker said, "Nevertheless you must sing to me
(attamen mihi cantare habes]!" What must I sing
[quid debeo contere)?" said Cadmon. "Sing," he
said, "of the beginning of the creation!" At which
answer he began to sing in praise of God the
Creator verses he had not heard before.
When
he awoke he remembered all that he had sung
while asleep and soon added more verses in the
same manner, praising God in fitting style.
The iqraa narrative was seemingly a common literary trope stemming from passages in the book of Isaiah (29:10-12, 40:6). The sirah literature was written to provide context for a book that without its fictional context makes no sense at all. Muhammad is the only legendary figure in history the study of whom has not been approached with the same level of skepticism that every other legendary account has endured
Assalamu alaykm from Uzbekistan,homeland of al Bukhari
Wa alaykum salam.
& Imam al Trimizi
I heard Uzbekistan is going to make a documentary about al Bukhari, is this true? It'd be very interesting
@@gilangthehuman7713 They are going to
@@Hassan_MMM exactly
Directly or indirectly you doing dawa
Wonderful job
Please keep going
Allah bless you
25. Al-Furqân 20. And We never sent before you (O Muhammad SAW) any of the Messengers but verily, they ate food and walked in the markets. And We have made some of you as a trial for others: will you have patience? And your Lord is Ever All-Seer.My friend you should read the Quran and learn about Islam
So Abraham could not have been in Mekka to warn the people
the only "proof" Muslims have Ibrahim re-build Kaaba is bc it is in the Quran. No other scripture talks about Kaaba or even Mekka. If such an important person like Ibrahim ot Ishmael were in Mekka we would have to find scriptures about it. Also Quran tells uns no messanger was send to those people in Mekka before Muhammad he was the first. This is a contradiction.The Jews lived in that area from the beginning and in Medina no Jew knew about Ibrahim or Ishmael having been in Mekka ?
They would have maybe accepted Muhammad.Muslims prayed towards Jerusalem bc they were like a judeo-christian sect in the beginning called Muhamedans or Ishmaelites.Jesus is ment all the time (24x in Quran Muhammad 4x) Virgin Mary is ment. in Quran more than even Injeel. The problem when Jews and Christians did not want to join Muhammad he went to war against them. Follow Muhammad or loose everything.That is why Muhammad changed prayer direction to Mekka.
Ibrahim and Ishmael were not Arabs.Muhammad was Beduin Arab. By islamic law you are what your father is and the line of Muhammad was Arab.Ibrahim was an Aramean. Arabs invaded and subdued the region later.
English man looks younger than before 😂 thanks Powl I really like watching your videos and I learned a lot from you , specially I like how honestly and academically you talk about Islam thank very much and God bless you.
No prophet was send to his people before Muhammad this is what Quran tells us. So Abraham could not have been in Mekka. No mention about Abraham in Mekka in any scripture before Islam. Al-Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem, . The mosque was built on top of the Temple Mount, several decades after Muhammad's death !!!
Muhammad and the early Muslims in Medina initially prayed towards Jerusalem, and changed the qibla to face the Kaaba in Mecca in 624 CE.
December 11 was the day when Prophet Muhammad conquered Mecca in 629. Early Muslims changed the prayer direction before conquering Mekka .If early Muslims bel Abraham re-build the Kaaba and Kaaba was the real holy site of Allah why did they pray towards Jerusalem Al Aqsa Mosque was not build yet !!! Big holes in the narrative
@@SheikhAlladeen Quran stated Ibraham PBUH build Kabbah in Makkah with his son Ishmail PBUH . Prophet Muhammad PBUH from his generation Ishmail and Isaaq PBUH another son of Ibrahim that were Israelites.
2nd Califate Umer bin Khattab conquered the Jerusalam and built the mosque Al Aqsa.
Quran said Muslims prayed toweard Jerusalam that Allah Order and Allah change the Qibla , if Allah order to pray toward some where else Muslim will do.
where is big hole it is very simple. do you know there were many Jews in Medina ? why Jews or Isralis came to Median..they know they last prophet came from Arabia. when Prophet Muhammad went to media to convery message of GOD then they rejected because of Muhammad does not from Israelites except few .
@@kamranisaaq208 my friend the only "proof" Muslims have Ibrahim re-build Kaaba is bc it is in the Quran. No other scripture talks about Kaaba or even Mekka. If such an important person like Ibrahim ot Ishmael were in Mekka we would have to find scriptures about it. Also Quran tells uns no messanger was send to those people in Mekka before Muhammad he was the first. This is a contradiction.The Jews lived in that area from the beginning and in Medina no Jew knew about Ibrahim or Ishmael having been in Mekka ?
They would have maybe accepted Muhammad.Muslims prayed towards Jerusalem bc they were like a judeo-christian sect in the beginning called Muhamedans or Ishmaelites.Jesus is ment all the time (24x in Quran Muhammad 4x) Virgin Mary is ment. in Quran more than even Injeel. The problem when Jews and Christians did not want to join Muhammad he went to war against them. Follow Muhammad or loose everything.That is why Muhammad changed prayer direction to Mekka.
Ibrahim and Ishmael were not Arabs.Muhammad was Beduin Arab. By islamic law you are what your father is and the line of Muhammad was Arab.Ibrahim was an Aramean. Arabs invaded and subdued the region later.
@@SheikhAlladeen Quran say We sent a messenger to every nation} [An-Nahl:36
] The Quran, though, also tells us about some Prophets who are not mentioned in the bible. there aren't many things in the bible as well .
Prophet Saleh lived in the region of Al-Hajr, which was located along the trade route from southern Arabia to Syria. The city of "Madain Saleh" lies several hundred kilometers north of Madinah in modern-day Saudi Arabia, is named after him
Salah said O my people, worship Allah; you have no deity other than Him. He has produced you from the earth and settled you in it. So ask forgiveness of Him and then repent to Him. Indeed, my Lord is near and responsive” (11:61).
Prophet hud PBUH also stated in Quran 200 years before Muhammad PBUH in Arabia region but not in Makkah.
Ibrahim and Ishmail PBUH was itself prophet founded Makkah and built Kabbah when there WERE NO PEOPLE except they and there family , how it contradicts ? Why GOD send messenger to unpopulated area?
***The problem when Jews and Christians did not want to join Muhammad he went to war against them.***
If you check even your historian Muhammad PBUH involved in war in defense or one can break accord . Jews are monttheist but they dont belive in John, zakaria, Jesus and Muhammad PBUH that is major diffence with Muslims.
Allah said all east and west belongs to GOD , Muhammad cannot did on its own he follow what he revealed. Quran , GOD wants to expose some people called Hypocrites but they claim itself Muslims. After getting change of direction they were exposed.
Jesus PBUH is our beloved prophet like Muhmmad , Maryam is our mother and respected as more then Prophet Muhammad PBUH wife. but it does not means we start worship him and considered as GOD.
All messanger from Adam, Nuh, Ibrahim, Joseph, John, Jesus, and last messnager Muhammad have one message
Worship only GOD he is creator of us, heaven and earth and in between them, that the true path.
@@kamranisaaq208 Quran say We sent a messenger to every nation} [An-Nahl:36) Yes and that messanger was Muhammad so Ibrahim and Ishmael were never in Mecca bc Muhammad was the first one. Why would Allah send messangers if there were no people. Big waste of time. Messangers of God never wasted time building houses for God where there was nobody.
When you mix funny stories with Quran ayaat Islam becomes a funny story,
I (Muhammad) have been commanded to fight people until they say there is no God but Allah and Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah…
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 25, Grade: Sahih. It does not say when people make war against Muslim.
Muslims went to Persia in self-defence ? They conquered Egypt in self-defence ? Went to war in Spain in self-defence ?
Only Quran invented the story of Ibrahim in Mecca no other scriptures you can find that story.
narrated by al-Bukhaari (6146) and Muslim (2952) the Prophet was asked about the last Hour. He looked towards a young boy and said, "If he lives, he will not grow very old before he sees the Last Hour coming to you." This Hadith is "correct" (Sahih)] false prophecy we are all still here.Muslims in the day of muhammad bel they were living in the last days.
Comprehensive and well sourced, silencing all the arguments against the Preservation of Quran. Thank you!
Paul, although i'm not a muslim and probably will never be, but the way you present content is highly commendable. I appreciate that as a researcher.
I love your videos and the useful information you give us. May Allah rewards you for your efforts.
Many many thanks
Alhamdulillah, that was short and to the point with tremendous benefit!!! Not to leave out the most important factor, that he brought the proof and evidence!!! Shukran and Jazzakallahu Khairan Ameen!
Brother this is so precious. Alhamdulillah. May Allah swt reward you good, increase your faith and knowledge and keep you away from anything wrong. Salam / Peace.
No prophet was send to his people before Muhammad this is what Quran tells us. So Abraham could not have been in Mekka. No mention about Abraham in Mekka in any scripture before Islam. Al-Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem, . The mosque was built on top of the Temple Mount, several decades after Muhammad's death !!!
Muhammad and the early Muslims in Medina initially prayed towards Jerusalem, and changed the qibla to face the Kaaba in Mecca in 624 CE.
December 11 was the day when Prophet Muhammad conquered Mecca in 629. Early Muslims changed the prayer direction before conquering Mekka .If early Muslims bel Abraham re-build the Kaaba and Kaaba was the real holy site of Allah why did they pray towards Jerusalem Al Aqsa Mosque was not build yet !!! Big holes in the narrative
Grateful for the academic integrity of your videos, السلام عليكم
Bless you Paul. May Allah reward you for disseminating the truth and not being swayed by the hysteria of hate mongers.
God chooses whomever He pleases for His noble work, MashaAllah respect for you Sir!
Great presentation as usual.
You're always eloquent.
Love your channel very interesting topics thank you very much.
God bless you
Thank you for sharing. Now this is called a proper study. Unfortunately some people just likes to jump to conclusions without it.
The Verse of Mut’ah (4:24)
The most important verse of the Holy Qur’an which establishes the legitimacy of Mut’ah is verse 24 of Surat an-Nisa, known to all hadeeth commentators (Sunni and Shi’a) as “the verse of Mut’ah.” ............ So when you have contracted temporary marriage [istimt'atum] with them, then give them their words. There is no sin on you for whatever you agree to after this. Indeed, Allah is Knowing, Wise.
Al-Qur’an, Surah An-Nisa, Ayah 24----------------------Arabic word istimta’tum, which is the verbal form of the word Mut’ah
“Sabra al-Juhanni reported on the authority of his father that while he was with Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon hm) he said: 0 people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women…”
Sahih Muslim Book 008, Number 3255
Damn!! the camera gets better quality
@H2O Gaming nah its the camera
أوكسفورد وكامبردج وهارفارد وكل الجامعات الأوروبية الصليبية ما هي إلا جحور للأفاعي الصليبية التي تنشر سمومها ضد الإسلام والمسملمين تحت مظلة وغطاء الأكاديمية، ولا يمكن لأي مؤمن أن يتخذ الأفاعي مصدرا موثوقا به أكاديميا.
أظن أن الصليبية لا تزال منقوشة على قلب پول ومن الصعب أو المستحيل أن يدخل الإيمان قلب الصليبيين.
من مسلم سمع بوجود 30 قرآنا؟ اذهب إلى أي مسجد في الصين أو الهند أوالسند أو نيجيريا وستسمع نفس القرآن يرتل ترتيلا.
@@MidnightxCrow اقرأ التعليق جيدا ياهذا!
وهل تظن أن أوكار الدعارة الفكرية في أوكسفورد يبحثون عن الحق والحقيقة؟ الجامعات الصليبية الأوروبية مدعومة بملايير الدولارات لنشر الدعارة الفكرية والكذب والحفاظ على التفوق الصليبي الغربي، هذا هو هدفها الأول والأخير.
نعم، لا يزال قلب الصليبي پول مطبوعا بالصليبية والوثنية والشرك. ولو لم يكن صليبيا لما وضع ذاك العنوان ولما استشهد بعاهرات أوكسفورد.
You people are still delusional? 😂🤣
czcams.com/video/88qcJOI05sE/video.html
@@brandonb1539 poor Christian. That is why no body ever care to go to any church anymore. Go to church or all will be vanished and people will think no more Christianity
Clarity by Paul is there for all to see !!! Much appreciated...
Beautifully put bro, maşallah. Allah reward you !!!!!!!! Respect !!!!!!!
It's orally protected & corrected till now.
Salaam! Excellent "Mumtaz" Awesome post, Thanks for sharing...
My pleasure
czcams.com/video/-e9kZtHFTeU/video.html
BarakAllah feek brother Paul. Excellent video.
Many thanks Ron
You people are still delusional? 😂🤣
czcams.com/video/88qcJOI05sE/video.html
May Allah (swt) bless you my dear brother. Alhamdu'lillah your vloggs are very precise and to the point
Stay blessed and stay safe ❤️
Many many thanks
Just discovered this channel, think it's. Brilliant. Thank you
God bless you Paul and thank you for the information.
It’s good to know that the Quran has been well preserved.
You have inspired me to read more in order to gain more knowledge not only on Islamic subjects but general knowledge especially when l saw your library ( books).
the only "proof" Muslims have Ibrahim re-build Kaaba is bc it is in the Quran. No other scripture talks about Kaaba or even Mekka. If such an important person like Ibrahim ot Ishmael were in Mekka we would have to find scriptures about it. Also Quran tells uns no messanger was send to those people in Mekka before Muhammad he was the first. This is a contradiction.The Jews lived in that area from the beginning and in Medina no Jew knew about Ibrahim or Ishmael having been in Mekka ?
They would have maybe accepted Muhammad.Muslims prayed towards Jerusalem bc they were like a judeo-christian sect in the beginning called Muhamedans or Ishmaelites.Jesus is ment all the time (24x in Quran Muhammad 4x) Virgin Mary is ment. in Quran more than even Injeel. The problem when Jews and Christians did not want to join Muhammad he went to war against them. Follow Muhammad or loose everything.That is why Muhammad changed prayer direction to Mekka.
Ibrahim and Ishmael were not Arabs.Muhammad was Beduin Arab. By islamic law you are what your father is and the line of Muhammad was Arab.Ibrahim was an Aramean. Arabs invaded and subdued the region later.
greetings from morocco 🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦✌️✌️✌️✌️
Salaam! Is it possible for me to contact you in Morocco, brother? I am from Singapore.
plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
@@Jaffar540 plz subscribe my channel 🙏
@@Jaffar540 plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
Another excellent video Jazzah Allah Khayran Paul
Love and respect from Pakistan for defending the oneness of Quran.
Thanks for the beautiful info, Mr.Paul!
Plz 🙏🙏 watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
Plz subscribe my channel plz 🙏🙏🙏
Why is nobody talking about the extensive library behind him.. it takes up the whole screen. No wonder he’s so knowledgeable. Lol
25. Al-Furqân 20. And We never sent before you (O Muhammad SAW) any of the Messengers but verily, they ate food and walked in the markets. And We have made some of you as a trial for others: will you have patience? And your Lord is Ever All-Seer.My friend you should read the Quran and learn about Islam
So Abraham could not have been in Mekka to warn the people
@@SheikhAlladeen Mekka was empty when Abraham start to construct Kabba..who come in desert.
Kabbah is the center of Universe not only world
@@kamranisaaq208 Akhi you are really brainwashed. Beduins bel this stuff in the 7 cent. Why would Ibrahim build a house of God for nobody in the middle of nowhere ? People have buildings to worship. Also Islam says Ibrahim re-build Kaaba bc Kaaba wa first build by Adam who came to do hajj all the way from Sri Lanka. Ibrahim has nothing to do with the Kaaba because when he traveled from Haran (today in Southern Turkey) en route to Canaan, the Kaaba was not even constructed. when Mohamed was alive, the present day site of Mecca in Saudi Arabia did not even exist. The qiblah’s did not point to Mecca (Saudi Arabia) until the late ninth century. Before this date virtually all the qiblah’s faced Petra in Jordan.Mecca is not mentioned in the Korans even once (some Muslim scholars believe ‘Bakka’ was Mecca ) but why would Allah not preserve the real name of the place of revelation of the Quran. If you are honest also to Allah you have the obligation to research not just regurgitate what your Imam tell you. Quran literally meaning the recitation.
May Allah increase you knowledge and accept your good works for all back ground of humanity. From Burma.
Brother Paul Allah bless you and reward you with Jannah (paradise)
Thank you so much for this information. May Allah SWT be pleased with you. Ameen
Plz 🙏🙏 watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
As usual, a very compelling argument for the authenticity of the Quran ! I think the time has come to dive into it, headlong, and hopefully wrap it up before Ramadan is over cuz I am also fasting ALHAMDULILAH
Where is the divine Quran? In which museum?
@@tyh3120 You should easily find it at your local library or bookstore !!! Unless you live on Mars
Brilliant, as always! May you will be rewarded in this life and the next.
Thanks for your intellectual honesty. Appreciated 👍🏼
czcams.com/video/AAcBxYyFpcA/video.html
Great findings.. Quran is original and remains the same since the first time of compilation.
May Allah reward u for your efforts in this world and hareafter. JazkAlllah
Very clear info. Thank you for the input. Alhamdullilah.
May Allah bless you for your true hearted love and firm belief on Almighty and His messenger/s. I am being a born Muslim, regularly watch your research on very important issues which are creating doubts on new reverts and those who are learning about Islam to revert.
🌿 الَلَّهُِــمََ صٌَـــلَِّ وََِّسَـــلَّـِمَْ عٌَلَـَے َّسَيِِّـــدِِنِْا مَُحٌَمََّــدٍِ 🌿 🌹وَِعٌَلَـَےآلَِ َّسَيِِّــــدِِنِْا مَُحٌَمََّـــدٍِ وصحبه 🌿🌹 الَطَّيِِّّبِيِّــنِ الَطّّاهِرِيِّن عدد ماذكره الذاكرين وعدد ماغفل عنه الغافلين 🌿🌹
تحياتي نضالية والسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته وتحياتي لكل الاحرار في المغرب الأقصى
plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
جزاک اللہ الخير من بريطانيہ
Did the Qur'an come from Muhammad?
The simple answer is no
Theoretically after Uthman burnt the Qurans he didn’t like (652), there was one canonised Quran. However, there is no Uthman Quran, and there never was. But if there had been (no evidence except tradition) surely such an important document from the 7th Century would have been preserved?
Dr. Shady Nasser; he has researched the five stages of canonisation of Quranic texts and says;
A. It was not a static text
B. The text underwent changes
C. Variant readings were local, so those in Kufa, to those in Damascus, to those in Medina, to those in Mecca would all be reading localised variations etc.
C. The Quran went through seven different readings, these seven different masters of the Quran decided on how the Quran should be read. However, the students then did a different reading to what they were taught, and this happened with their students as well, so the variations of the Quran kept on multiplying.
D. This eventually led to the Hafs being canonised by the Cairo Education Authority in 1924. Extra; this was because the high school students kept on giving different answers to the questions about the Quran. The Cairo Education Authority collected the other 29 Qurans being used, put them on a boat and sunk them in the Nile. Then Egypt canonised the Hafs in 1936, further to that the Saudis in 1985.
But there is no original Hafs, so which of his many students wrote his version of the Hafs, that is used by the vast majority of Muslims today? It is said that Hafs was a liar and not trustworthy, and that his hadith should not be learned. It has been discovered that there are seven variations of the Hafs.
E. That originally Muslims were more relaxed and accepting about the variations of the Quran. But this began to change after 1400.
Mashallah, may Allah bless you and give you true peace of heart
ameen!
Aminn🤲
ameen
Congratulations Paul for this wonderful channel that teaches us a lot about religion in such an academic and grounded way.
Regarding the subject of this video, I have to admit that the arguments of individuals like Jay Smith about the number of quran's and the existence of Mecca should be further discussed and opposed by leading academics, something that has not been seen.
It is not enough to make a paragraph in a book saying that one does not agree with the view of some skeptics or that there is no congruent evidence.
These arguments should be discussed point by point, rather than a simple generalization denying them.
The truth is that some of Jay Smith's arguments seem to be well-founded and it takes more than simple quotes to contradict them.
I think one should have the courage to discuss these points clearly for the sake of all scholars of religion. Keep up the good work.
Keep up the good work.
Great work. Keep it up!
As promised by Allah Quran will be preserved Alhumdulilah. Brother Paul thanks for sharing the knowledge may Allah bless u for good deeds.
@Christina Adam Paul no idea if he can read or write but Zakir Naik and Ahmed deedat can read and write wrong allegation. But same time not every one is scholar and have knowledge of Quran.
No prophet was send to his people before Muhammad this is what Quran tells us. So Abraham could not have been in Mekka. No mention about Abraham in Mekka in any scripture before Islam. Al-Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem, . The mosque was built on top of the Temple Mount, several decades after Muhammad's death !!!
Muhammad and the early Muslims in Medina initially prayed towards Jerusalem, and changed the qibla to face the Kaaba in Mecca in 624 CE.
December 11 was the day when Prophet Muhammad conquered Mecca in 629. Early Muslims changed the prayer direction before conquering Mekka .If early Muslims bel Abraham re-build the Kaaba and Kaaba was the real holy site of Allah why did they pray towards Jerusalem Al Aqsa Mosque was not build yet !!! Big holes in the narrative
@@SheikhAlladeen I agree some but some are your writing rubbish…
@@jalilalbalushi930 what about this ? No prophet was send to his people before Muhammad this is what Quran tells us. So Abraham could not have been in Mekka. No mention about Abraham in Mekka in any scripture before Islam. Al-Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem, . The mosque was built on top of the Temple Mount, several decades after Muhammad's death !!! Why did early Muslims pray toward Jerusalem ?
Muhammad and the early Muslims in Medina initially prayed towards Jerusalem, and changed the qibla to face the Kaaba in Mecca in 624 CE. still all 360 idols were in the Kaaba.
December 11 was the day when Prophet Muhammad conquered Mecca in 629. Early Muslims changed the prayer direction before conquering Mekka .If early Muslims bel Abraham re-build the Kaaba and Kaaba was the real holy site of Allah why did they pray towards Jerusalem Al Aqsa Mosque was not build yet !!! Big holes in the narrative
No prophet was send to his people before Muhammad this is what Quran tells us. So Abraham could not have been in Mekka. No mention about Abraham in Mekka in any scripture before Islam. Al-Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem, . The mosque was built on top of the Temple Mount, several decades after Muhammad's death !!! Why did early Muslims pray toward Jerusalem ?
Muhammad and the early Muslims in Medina initially prayed towards Jerusalem, and changed the qibla to face the Kaaba in Mecca in 624 CE. still all 360 idols were in the Kaaba.
December 11 was the day when Prophet Muhammad conquered Mecca in 629. Early Muslims changed the prayer direction before conquering Mekka .If early Muslims bel Abraham re-build the Kaaba and Kaaba was the real holy site of Allah why did they pray towards Jerusalem Al Aqsa Mosque was not build yet !!! Big holes in the narrative
Again and always inshallah wishing you and people who put effort and time to show the truth, may Allah bless you all protect you all and grant you highest places of both lives. AMEEN
Ma sha'Allah. Still an underrated channel!!!
Comprehensive yet so simply explained many thanks for the positive input
Another great video on board !
I’m arab
The reading of the Quran are not different from the symbol or the letters point of view
Is only same word can be read in different way
If u are Arab or know Arabic u will understand-what I have said ...!
For example I will give one :
We have in surah Fatiha word ملك can be read for example :
Mlk or if u add sound A u will pronounce it as Malik >>> so
Mlk means king , Malik means lord >> we say that it’s actually a miracle.! Cuz with one word u have two proper meaning ! That’s why Arabs didn’t bring a book in Arabic in the level of Quran since 14th century
So the reading are written the same letters , but the way u read it is different , and every reading give proper same meaning , and it’s a miracle , but the written Quran is the same in all in Arabic :)
In English of course different translation, but not new versions as some liars try to say ..
Thank mrs Paul 🌹🌙
Finally someone gave a perfect example because for a short while even the Arab Christians got me confused a bit... not that they can ever weaken my belief but it created a small question in my mind. Thanks for it brother!
Once again, great work brother.
Thank you! Cheers!
Good point!
Highly appreciate your opinion. Always, Thank you 🙏🏽
Why are people disliking this video. What is there to dislike! Simply facts were being reported.
Those are Islam haters
Thank you Bro Paul.
From Morocco.
Welcome!
زيد هانا معاك
ta ana :)
@@BloggingTheology plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
I appreciate your video, thank you for sharing your knowledge.
Glad it was helpful!
May Allah SWT bless your channel...
I realy pray for you sir
You are doing a wonderful work sir
Peace be aupon you
Thkyou
Paul, you’re an inspiration, thank you for everything you do.
I appreciate that!
why did Utman need to write his Mushaf al-Uthmani when there was a finished Quran already. Why did Aisha say that Mushaf al-Utmani had missing Surahs, Why did Umar say nobody has the complete Quran when most of it was lost. Why did Egypt feel the need to make riwaya of Hafs the "official" Quran why not use Warsh ???? Many different Qurans even Sheikh Yasir Qadhi said there are different ayaat in different Qurans ....Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. This you can not explain off by Ahruf or Qira'at useless video
Very nice topic I enjoy your programs may alah give you a blessing and hidaya and rewards you for your good work towards him
Beautiful epistemic method paul, may God give you a reward that exceed the reward of years of good deeds
Great book, highly recommended. Clarifies many issues used my Islamaphobes.
Jazakallah khair brother Paul, the haters will still spew their nonsense.
Watching your stream with brother Muhammad @cov a bit later
the only "proof" Muslims have Ibrahim re-build Kaaba is bc it is in the Quran. No other scripture talks about Kaaba or even Mekka. If such an important person like Ibrahim ot Ishmael were in Mekka we would have to find scriptures about it. Also Quran tells uns no messanger was send to those people in Mekka before Muhammad he was the first. This is a contradiction.The Jews lived in that area from the beginning and in Medina no Jew knew about Ibrahim or Ishmael having been in Mekka ?
They would have maybe accepted Muhammad.Muslims prayed towards Jerusalem bc they were like a judeo-christian sect in the beginning called Muhamedans or Ishmaelites.Jesus is ment all the time (24x in Quran Muhammad 4x) Virgin Mary is ment. in Quran more than even Injeel. The problem when Jews and Christians did not want to join Muhammad he went to war against them. Follow Muhammad or loose everything.That is why Muhammad changed prayer direction to Mekka.
Ibrahim and Ishmael were not Arabs.Muhammad was Beduin Arab. By islamic law you are what your father is and the line of Muhammad was Arab.Ibrahim was an Aramean. Arabs invaded and subdued the region later.
Peace be upon you Paul. Thank you for your research work and recommendations of books. Your words are highly regarded cuz I never smelt anything fishy in there.
On your recommendation I have ordered 2 books of Abdul Haleem, the Quran of Oxford University press and understanding the Quran themes and style.
Great contribution indeed. May Allah reward you
You're an honest Scholar and God Almighty loves honesty at all times and circumstances.
Are u revert
Greetings from Tema Ghana .Paul thanks for your truthfulness I asked Allah to guide you to Islam Aamen.
He is already a Muslim Akhi
plz watch this video, it is necessary for all Muslims
czcams.com/video/sV2fj0H9410/video.html
Paul Williams thank you once again!
❤️🙏
Love you man, you are doing such an awesome job.
Thank you so much 😀