Editorial With Sujit Nair | Why Did Election Commissioner Arun Goel Quit Ahead Of Lok Sabha Polls?
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 03. 2024
- In this episode of 'Editorial,' Mr. Sujit Nair delves into the resignation of Election Commissioner Arun Goel just ahead of the Lok Sabha elections. Following the Union law ministry's announcement of Goel's resignation, Election Commission officials found themselves puzzled, especially considering the remaining three years of Goel's tenure and the expected elevation to the position of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) in 2025.
According to information obtained from five officials interviewed by HT, it became apparent that Goel and CEC Rajiv Kumar had experienced differences, ranging from routine matters to more complex issues. However, these disagreements failed to provide a clear explanation for Goel's sudden decision to resign. Notably, a significant point of contention between them was the Election Commission's order on February 17, 2023, regarding the allocation of the Shiv Sena's party name and poll symbol to the Eknath Shinde faction based on legislative majority, as disclosed by four officials to HT.
#electioncommissioner #arungoel #electioncommissioner #chiefelectioncommissioner #loksabhapolls #loksabhaelections #resignation #sbi #electoralbonds #supremecourt #dychandrachud #chiefjusticeofindia #statebankofindia #HWNews #SujitNair
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
To Join CZcams Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
![[Vowel]물고기는 물에서 살아야 해🐟🤣Fish have to live in the water #funny](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3G9MH063Cx4/mqdefault.jpg)
No matter how bad Congress was, atleast they were not so desperate to remain in power through any means necessary
Modi/BJP's frustration is very evident these days. Trying his luck in south as well.
Totally agreed with your view. 👍
Yes
Congress fell at Pakistan and China feet licker
Yeah there were not spreading hatred and using communal divide to stay in power.
yes, Emergency was never sign of desperation it was sign of democracy .
Ishrat jahan case, Lathi charge on ram lila maidan
Was sign of democracy
God save our country from evil hands
babar will come to save you wait and watch
Every bit of the government functioning is fishy smell 😂😂😂😂
Fried fish!! Yummy!
Its very clear the govt is upto themselves, that what's happening.
Not fried , Rotten fish
Sir ji ..
I don’t think many of our voters understand, how the Election Commissioners are appointed..
They’re happy with Temples & Statues ..
PERIOD!!!!! Waste of saying other aspects isn't it!
Can you imagine the dignity and integrity of godi media personnel ? How do they live happily with their salary knowing they have betrayed their country. I wonder what their family thinks of them .
Godi media and integrity? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Godi media only knows chaatugiri @@RDdggrd
That is why they are given plenty of statues and temples.
Don't post like an idiot. Earlier congress used to select people of their choice. Now,the government and the opposition together are the authority to select an election commissioner.
SBI Chair will resign...following Goel?
Absolutely.. I have been saying that as well.. Next is SBI chairman.. Lot of resignations will follow in the coming days.
Superb yaar! Very well thought off!
why ?
I am sorry that i am saying this.... but congress needs to come back.
Remembering Late TN Seshan EC who cannot be forgotten ..the honest EC
Some of those who post here and in other places in CZcams might still be in their nappies they won't know about this honest officer - TN Seshan. I wish we had a commissioner like him as EC - modi, godhi, Rahul Gandhi no body would have dared so the drama they are doing today
Yes,TN Seshan.from Tamil Nadu❤❤
Ashok Lavasa tried that, but ultimately had to bow down coz of IT raids on his relatives. Late TN Seshan's time was different where there was no harassment from the then ruling govt, but now even for someone like Late TN Seshan caliber would not be taking any chances against this present govt. Modi ji and company knows how best to deal with honest people 😁
As always ...no content...only narration
@@srinivasprabhakar8068 Do u know in Tamil Nadu , for a recent bye election amount spent is Rs 250 cr as per reports ; People are caged and provided biryani and liquor ; Thats the level of corruption on the ground ; Seshan is a flash of excellence; Problem is so deep and there is blood bath during elections
Why punish SBI when the culprit who gave this job.to carry out this mission with atmost secrecy. The mastermind should be questioned if SC says E.bonds are unconstitutional and arbitrary. I am waiting for the day the main culprit is put behind bars. Otherwise no justice done.❤🎉
Thanks for your editorial always
The BJP is to democracy what termites are to wood.
Very well said, sir.
Ha ha ha. This one is an absolute classic.
... And we are the spectators who are just gaping at our so called leaders. The BJPs insolence has given everyone brain freeze.😁
Democracy is not good for india we need nationalist people
L@@vjy21ctra
The brilliance of Justice Chandrachud!!! Simply excellent!
There is something very fishy. Arun Goyal seems to be a Modi Chamcha
This is some game going on.As is THE wont in indian polity.
Appointing Election Commissioners by the 3-member panel will always be 2:1. Its like saying 'heads I win, tails you lose'.
What do they eat to bring in such 'laws'???
idiotic Lawas, it's a dance that we commoners should learn.
They eat Gobar day and night.
When they are thirsty, fresh gomoothra is what they drink.
Very fishy indeed!
It's not even fishy.. blatant stuff in front of our eyes
It could be a tactic to delay the publishing of Electoral bonds information
Brilliant!!! You finally got it!!!😅
If the election commission is appointed by the ruling party then forget about EVM being removed during 2024 election what ever view of the common people and opposition parties
Appreciate the courageous journalism.... We are in last days of democracy
all high court judges and all chief ministers and opposition leaders together should elect election commissioner
Thanks for your true Journalism
well said, Sir. 👏👍
What is the reason behind his resignation?
PM and HM should be resigned instead of SBI Chairman on this case
Giving a chance to pm to choose his own election commissioners
Sujitji
Brilliant episode with two topics.
✅
May the truth come out.
Grey area for reforms exist at all ends.
Looking forward.
👍
Truth revealed
The voters should decide, if they want a"Ruler" or they want a honest, educated "Administrative" body to "Govern" not "Rule" over the people, of India!
Presentation perfect.
5:33 The examinee = the examiner? Very fair situationship !!!
As usual, very informative.
I have a question though. When Mr. Goel opted for VRS, did hw not give nitice as required? To my knowledge Government employees have to give 90 days notice and then only it has to be acceoted, provided all issues pertaining to hos swrvice are clear and clean. To say that even his minister didnt know is very surprising. And to apply for VRS on one day and be acceoted the next day plus with new appointment samw day...is like SC said lightening speed indeed.
Therw is also another rule that those who opt for VRS cannot accept a paid government job for a period of 2 years. Wo unless the EC was a cotractual employee again it is flouting of another rule.
What really happened to cause such a tearing hurry? And less than 4 months later he resigns, again without informing his boss..
So like in November, he must be knowing something is in the offing....like an election ticket perhaps? Laughable but strange things are happening in our country...
All these people who are mucking with the country, are spoiling lives of the people of the nation. They are accountable to God which they are blind to. May God be the vindicator for playing with innocent lives by their selfishness.
Bruh, they have been and still are campaigning in the name of god, mocking the god himself. 😂
How come no one opposed that bill to select the EC. Its so ridiculous
You still think India is a democracy?
Excellent
Chances are the SBI will present the data in two silos (meaning isolate system, process, department, from others).
The Court, ECI and us will then have to figure out the content, scratching our heads !
We won't need much head scratching as 70% of the money went to BJP.
Once the data is public, there experts in Data analysis in all who will get to it. I am sure there will be some feature or ID used to identify the correct bonds are encashed by the intended party. The advocate was trying to complicate and confuse the Judges, which did not work.😅
yes, beacuse 70% votes goes to bjp@@Ind_u.
Teek hai. Good editorials from you daily.
Mubarak ho CAA lagu ho gaya!!
Ab toh 400 paar hai..🎉🎉
Aur mere Laal k toh ab 40 bhi mushkil lagg rahein hain😂😂
This resignation is not so simple, as it conveniently appears to the godi media !
Is any foreign power interfering or blackmailing the. ECs or even the PMO ?
Whatever it maybe including personal reasons,the matter should be a matter of huge National Security concerns and there needs to be an open Inquiry into the sudden development !
Excellent talk
Sir, whoever has been appointed as ELECTION COMMISSIONERS, it should be acceptable to all. Therefore, the names of all candidates picked up should should be circulated to all CHIEF MINISTERS giving 3 days for recommendation then the list goes for recommendation of Opposition Leader, then to PM and the last to CJI for final decision so that ot has the approval of all states too
.
Interesting
Sir Lavasa's note of deccent... let his whole family being drag by IT department at that time..
When did he apply for EC post before retirind? Is it possible with out through proper channel?
A man like Shri. Seshan should be Election Commissioner of India.
Nice talk
When they are in power they want to forget what they said.. such honesty we need to belive.. wow!
Note of dissent is an invitation to ED IT CBI
The leader of the opposition can always voice dissent on record. Earlier there was no such possibility
We'll explained sir .
Harish salve represented from London as per source 😅😅😅
He should be removed as QC !
He works from London
😂😂 lol.
who should then appoint? Can you tell how appointment done prior to 2014. Why you don't make similar suggestion for appointment of judges?
Funny interpretation, complex question answers are always logical & simple... 🤷🏼♀️ SC asked to submit the electrol bonds info to EC by end of 12th March 2024 & EC need to make the data public by 15th March 2024...if there is no head at EC, who will take responsibility to release the data.. Later once EC appointed thy will say busy with election duty will validate & publish it at later date... 🤷🏼♀️🤷🏼♀️ The electrol bond issue is put in dustbin now.. 🤷🏼♀️
🙏🙏🙏
If India continues to run as the way we are in now our country is going to be a serious concern for every individual Indian
Solvent
I would speculate this resignation is in relation to the publication of Electoral bonds.
QUIS CUSTODIET IPSOS CUSTODES -- LATIN for WHO WILL GAURD THE GAURDS ?? Will the Fence eat the Garden - Relevant for present day KALIYUG Bharat 😢
Congress getting one by one what it did during their rule
Have checked the SBI list of donors. I find that the donors name have been split with some slight differences like LTD and L T D
Its common sense that the Election commission will be selected by the 3 pillars of democracy ..loksabha, executive( Government) and judiciary. The present parliament members belonging to both ruling party and opposition were in hand and glove to pass such an unconstitutional bill. Opposition did not resist the bill like in case of other bills which they oppose by going Speaker's podium, burning the bill papers or even point of order to call for a discussion. Unfortunately the President of India also was silent and did not send it back for a review again. It appears to me this will be the first nail in the coffin of our democracy
He has already desided how to say and what to say. In my opinion electiral bond system is better and need to improve.
good one, but on the letter from LK Advani, written in 2012, did MMS do anything about it ??
BJP has said PAK so much. They became that illusion of PAK. LOL.
Sir , at this moment no one should accept his resignation,he should be first Trield in a very serious way n Sue him n give a severe Punishment against him
He must be getting ticket for election? I guess, not sure...Else, he is very responsible about his duties and wont budge to pressure to do unethical things. Believing in Indian Constitution...
May be he regrets his actions and wanted to be fair.
Watch sorry days ahead.....
Previously people used to say that government is acting slow now complains that government is acting fast 😂😂😂
Irony of standards 😅😅
The way he resigned before the election indicates that he may contest election on BJP ticket. Modi and coterie might have advised him to resign the way he did before as Secretary.
Sir, Lekin aap ek baat likh kar rakh lijiye, EVM ke rahte huwey every expectation /analysis will fail.
NDA ko 434 seat ki Landslide Victory hone wali hai.
Yeh 434 seat ke liye 16 Lakh EVM (out of total 21 Lakh EVM) ki VVPAT Units and Control Units mein dhaandhli keliye pre-programming kar ke ready kiya gaya hai to use them in 434 constituencies across the country to get 434 seats for NDA.
Yeh 16 Lakh EVM sets mein agar BJP/NDA ko bilkul hi vote nahi pade, phir bhi BJP/NDA will definitely win along with 100% matching of VVPAT papers WITH the vote count in Control Units AS WELL. It is because of SCAMMING software program already set in them.
Such is the preparation already done by the BJP-EC-BEL-ECIL Gang of fraudsters.
Now, the people of India have all fixed their eyes on the Supreme Court and are awaiting an honest VERDICT i.e. complete BANNING of the EVM.
If the EVM is COMPLETELY BANNED, the BJP Will DEFINITELY GET DEFEATED.
Otherwise, the opposition SHOULD unitedly decide for a COMPLETE BOYCOTT of the ELECTION.
WHY NOT INDIA ALLIANCE parties participating IN THE PROTESTs against EVM.????
Why was he forced to quit? People have understood this😢😢😢😢😢
Kal ctrl + F karna,
Kahi Arun Goyal ka naam b Electoral bond purchaser mein na ho, election commissioner banne se phele 😂
The whole narrative is stretching. It can be explained in a simple way.
We want to know the truth somebody did some dirty work
There could be some sort of pressure on him which he couldn't bear.
Indian judiciary is a mess. Different laws for different people. Just tell us why this SNC LAVLYN case in the SC changed their dates 38 tines? Do you have any answer? What is the CJI doing in the SC? Its not under him? What is this BLA BLA BLA.
What about supreme court judge. Who appoints them. Discuss that.
Timing is all...
Hv been wondering where aarti ghargi disappeared from HW .... just discovered that shez made a career move .... she will be missed as a HW anchor
This discussion do not hold any water, why Mr Nair not questioning about appoint of Judges, is there any country where judges are appointed by Judges only? Why the Judges should be included in Administrative matter.
EVM go. Yes to Ballots Box back.
Is there no notice period for IAS officers to take voluntary retirement? Clearly rules were flouted.
Sir you never told the reason for the resignation of Mr. Arun Goel?? 😂
utharavittilla?
Why didn't the court order SBI to submit the documents directly before SC instead of ECI ?
In spite of all the talk, Mr Sujit Nair, you have not concluded WHY Arun Goel resigned as an EC.....
If a judge is included then his say shall be final. Appointment of higher position officers should be the responsibility of Executive, Govt or PM and oppn. . Leader knows these officers and his conduct in office and their integrity, You want politicise Mr Goyals resign.
etc
How can they do all these in a democracy!!!!
If the members of selection committee for selecting Election commissioners are from the ruling party in the centre, there will not be any point to be discussed,either by the media or Supreme Court.It will be construed that it is the decision of the government approved by the parliament.
Sir is there any law in constitution which gives Gov't right to appoint retired Govt officials,judges on important posts
The current EC selection panel can be made in a way where it has to be a unanimous decision.
Pl tell us,Why Sonia run away from UP to Rajasthan, for rajia saba MP ?
THE PRESENT LAW RECENTLY ENACTED TO BE RECALLED. INSTEAD OF 3 IT SHOULD BE ADDED 2 MORE A RTI ACTIVITIES AND ANOTHER REGINAL PARTY CM ALONG WITH CJI, PM OPPOSITION LEADER OF LOKHSABHA
The reasons behind the resignation of Arun Goel are still not disclosed although he has stated as 'personal ground .' .The reason is not convincing to be the real reason there must be much more which he doesn't want to disclose. However, he should have boldly disclosed it by taking press conference in the present situation for the benefit of country men's and own so that the clouds of suspicious would never crept again .
He should have stood up for his nation even against the biggest enemy and threats, not resigned.
Firstly take necessarry action to the SBI Chairman.
You have given your assumptions only. The appointment of EC is the prerogative of the Govt since long
I donot understand what point is being made by Nair. Election bond as per rules will not disclose the names of Donors and that is why persons like me donated. And this law was passed by the Govt who has majority. So how can the SC over rule the elected govt just to support disgruntled elements. More than this case the matter of freebies announced by political parties just before elections for catching votes should have been taken up and decided. But SC has no time for national interest.
Sir,
Democracy is being dragged towards destruction. And corruption zindabad in India Incorporation by the so-called flag bearers of honesty ( ! )
The whole system is a blunder.
What is the point if your views is correct by submitting the electrol bonds details to the election commission?
Confused & lost look in Salve,s face facing S. Courts questions.
Time for retirement Salve.
It is quite clear the purpose of having PM and Union Minister deciding the appointment of Election Commisioners and it is preposterous to have a leader from opposion for name sake... It is no- brainer to understand that two will silence one in this case.. The word transparency is in the dock and it has lost his essence long back
The CJI cannot be a appointment committee
Why did he resign is the topic...nothing on that.
but for us, VRS candidates must give one month advance notice - most of us common people cannot resign with one day notice.