Idaho abortion case in front of SCOTUS is 'quite shocking'

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 26. 04. 2024
  • Mini Timmaraju, president of Reproductive Freedom For All, joins Jonathan Capehart to discuss the case the Supreme Court heard Wednesday on whether a federal law requiring hospitals to provide emergency medical care overrides Idaho's near-total abortion ban.
    » Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
    Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
    Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
    MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
    ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
    MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
    Connect with MSNBC Online
    Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
    Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
    Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
    Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
    Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
    #Idaho #Abortion #Reproduction

Komentáře • 684

  • @DavidJ222
    @DavidJ222 Před 18 dny +57

    Who does a woman's body belong to?
    Does it belong to the federal government, state government, or does it belong to her?

    • @playedout148
      @playedout148 Před 18 dny

      Females are cattle according to maga.

    • @ronthomas8108
      @ronthomas8108 Před 18 dny +7

      Doesn’t the Baby have the Right to Life, Liberty and The Pursuit of Happiness, instead of a Death Sentence when it is INNOCENT?

    • @skankhunt3624
      @skankhunt3624 Před 18 dny

      ​@@ronthomas8108well does the fetus have a Social Security number?

    • @kevinsmart3516
      @kevinsmart3516 Před 18 dny +2

      Women's bodies belong to God

    • @skankhunt3624
      @skankhunt3624 Před 18 dny

      @@ronthomas8108 does it have a Social Security number?

  • @PKing-px5dg
    @PKing-px5dg Před 18 dny +64

    Everyone has the right to refuse medical treatment, no one has the right to deny other's! Period!

    • @jcc9549
      @jcc9549 Před 18 dny +10

      @@Craig2142….well if you didn’t have eyes, you wouldn’t need an eye exam either, even if you wanted one.
      Nice try though.

    • @Mike-ns1ho
      @Mike-ns1ho Před 18 dny +4

      ​@@jcc9549so men can't become women?

    • @JRish22
      @JRish22 Před 18 dny +4

      @@Mike-ns1ho why mikey?

    • @JoeyHurtAshley
      @JoeyHurtAshley Před 18 dny

      Selective abortion AKA baby murder is not healthcare. It's the most unhealthy thing ever

    • @jcc9549
      @jcc9549 Před 18 dny

      @@Mike-ns1ho …your “issue” would have more credibility if you weren’t here to deliberately whine about a separate issue, in order to create faux outrage over a mere fraction of a fraction of society. Pathetic actually. Get a life man. You’ve never walked a day in the shoes of a trans man or woman. You don’t know what they’re going through. And because you don’t you shouldn’t discuss the issue. It has nothing to do with you.

  • @nonya.bizness
    @nonya.bizness Před 18 dny +84

    doctors are trained to reach the correct MEDICAL decision, not the correct LEGAL decision.

  • @PKing-px5dg
    @PKing-px5dg Před 18 dny +42

    If a State government supports forced delivery of an non-viable child then the government should pay the hospital bill and the funeral cost. Also, each child should received a State child support check until the age of 18. Pro-life doesn't end at birth!

    • @JoeyHurtAshley
      @JoeyHurtAshley Před 18 dny +2

      Define viable.

    • @abalzeris831
      @abalzeris831 Před 18 dny +12

      ​@@JoeyHurtAshley It means no chance of survival. The most common reasons for this include: A baby born too prematurely to be able to survive (before 23 weeks) A congenital defect that makes the survival of the fetus outside of the uterus impossible. A pregnancy in which the fetus no longer has a heartbeat.

    • @Domban-yj2rb
      @Domban-yj2rb Před 18 dny +1

      Those are the only reasons an abortion should be legal !

    • @andrewferrauiolo4618
      @andrewferrauiolo4618 Před 18 dny +2

      ​@@Domban-yj2rbNo, it's not. Abortion should be legal no matter what!

    • @JoeyHurtAshley
      @JoeyHurtAshley Před 18 dny

      The government does pay the social security for each child with a disability unfortunately that might go away with the Democrats trying to give social security to illegal immigrants

  • @jansenart0
    @jansenart0 Před 18 dny +35

    The only function the government should have with relation to healthcare is facilitation. Lawyers and politicians are not qualified to HAVE an opinion.

    • @justaghoulintheworld
      @justaghoulintheworld Před 18 dny +2

      Nor theologists.

    • @JoeyHurtAshley
      @JoeyHurtAshley Před 18 dny +1

      Murdering children is not health care it's completely unhealthy.
      What's next a married person is going to claim their spouse is putting their health at risk by causing them stress so they can hire a doctor to murder their spouse and define it as healthcare the Constitution proves selective abortion is murder. Either we live in a constitutional republic or we don't we can't just pick and choose parts of the Constitution that we like.
      I don't like the idea of children born in the United States to illegal immigrant parents are automatically American citizens. But I wouldn't support a state legally ignoring the fact that they are.

    • @abalzeris831
      @abalzeris831 Před 18 dny +4

      ​@@JoeyHurtAshleyand how does the constitution prove selective abortion is murder?

    • @JoeyHurtAshley
      @JoeyHurtAshley Před 18 dny

      @@abalzeris831 not just the Constitution but also the scientific method.
      The Constitution states a state cannot make a law depriving a PERSON to the right to LIFE Liberty and property without due process.
      The scientific method proves that LIFE begins at conception.
      A human fetus is a human being and a human being is a PERSON.

    • @abalzeris831
      @abalzeris831 Před 18 dny +4

      @@JoeyHurtAshley so then per your interpretation states passing laws banning abortion with no exception for the life of the person who is pregnant are infringing upon that pregnant person's constitutional rights and therefore those laws are illegal.

  • @user-ij6vg8xq2r
    @user-ij6vg8xq2r Před 18 dny +31

    Denying access to Best Practices Medical Care is not a legitimate governmental power.

    • @JoeyHurtAshley
      @JoeyHurtAshley Před 18 dny

      Selective abortion AKA murdering babies is not healthcare

    • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
      @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 18 dny

      ​@@JoeyHurtAshley The woman is the one who is getting the healthcare.

  • @niclewis9610
    @niclewis9610 Před 18 dny +25

    Nothing Pro-life about Supreme Court debating whether States can order Doctor's to let women die rather than provide life saving abortion in a medical emergency. It shouldn't have to be said!

    • @trunkmonkee1971
      @trunkmonkee1971 Před 18 dny

      Yep, this would not be an issue had it not been for tens of millions of abortions in the decades long Roe v wade era. A medical emergency is a different scenario altogether; common sense has gone the way of the Dodo...

    • @AdrianneMalden
      @AdrianneMalden Před 18 dny +2

      Isn't that practicing medicine without a license?

    • @gregpresley1466
      @gregpresley1466 Před 17 dny +2

      You have absolutely NO idea what you're talking about. There are exceptions in the Idaho law for the life of the mother. Don't believe everything you hear.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny +1

      @@gregpresley1466 Your ignorance is on full display.

    • @gregpresley1466
      @gregpresley1466 Před 17 dny +1

      @@alexwyatt2911 That's not an argument. Come with facts if you want to refute my viewpoint.

  • @kathyweis7451
    @kathyweis7451 Před 18 dny +21

    Can we sue the judge's and legislatures for practicing medicine without a license? Or sue them for medical malpractice since they are pretending to be doctors?

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 Před 18 dny +5

      Good point.

    • @MarkSmith-pb2ly
      @MarkSmith-pb2ly Před 18 dny

      Why can't Democrats be more like the average fine upstanding Trump supporter? They always remind me of those naughty kids that use to throw themselves on shop floors, rolling around screaming for a toy they couldn't get.

    • @AdrianneMalden
      @AdrianneMalden Před 18 dny +3

      THIS!!

    • @oleradiodudea.m.4735
      @oleradiodudea.m.4735 Před 17 dny

      Why don't feminists make noise about women in Muslim countries?

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      @@oleradiodudea.m.4735 Oh, please. You don’t listen to anything feminists say lol

  • @DonCarter720
    @DonCarter720 Před 18 dny +29

    You have your death panels and republicans gave them to you.

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 Před 18 dny

      It's clear which side you've taken. Both parties are culpable in the abortion issue. Neither party can truly "solve" it either.

    • @videoettaceo8900
      @videoettaceo8900 Před 18 dny +5

      ​Culpable? Of what? Wanting the right to control your own body? Pffft

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 Před 18 dny

      @@videoettaceo8900 It's all a personal decision. No one, government included, has the right to dictate to others which moral path to follow. Both sides are guilty of imposing their opinions on others.

    • @christopherhughes8402
      @christopherhughes8402 Před 17 dny

      No one is being forcing religious nuts to have an abortion, even if they need it to save their lives. Republicans ARE forcing women to flee their state or die from medical complications of pregnancy or die. Please tell me how this is a “both sides” issue?

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny +2

      @@joewoodchuck3824 No lol. Pro-choice is specifically protecting the individual’s choice to access abortion. It’s the direct opposite of imposing morality on others.

  • @windorsolarplease4314
    @windorsolarplease4314 Před 18 dny +7

    Judges are Judges...Lawyers are Lawyers...Pilots are Pilots...Allow Doctors to be Doctors let them decide. Personally, I don't agree with abortions unless it is a death situation, but not everyone thinks as I do. I'm not here to force my beliefs or my choices on anyone. With every abortion there should be education/video, so the patient can make the choice for themself.

  • @mvvpro8688
    @mvvpro8688 Před 18 dny +10

    A woman doesn't want to hear that in theory some doctor might want to take care of her in case of a medical emergency, she needs to know she WILL be taken care of under all circumstances. By all doctors.

  • @mysmith7
    @mysmith7 Před 18 dny +10

    Why do women have to be at deaths door before doctors are allowed to help them??! Vote blue 💙🩷💙🩷💙🩷🇺🇸!!!

    • @trunkmonkee1971
      @trunkmonkee1971 Před 18 dny +3

      Don't vote blue!

    • @305Alligator
      @305Alligator Před 17 dny

      Never voting blue again ‼️ Biden is spending millions of tax payer money to secure other Countries borders while failing to secure our borders ‼️

    • @webportal6659
      @webportal6659 Před 17 dny

      They dont.

  • @danpoole4915
    @danpoole4915 Před 18 dny +25

    It's about time to dismiss the Supreme Court.

    • @chucklesthered2338
      @chucklesthered2338 Před 18 dny

      Move to another country. SCOTUS serves a vital part of our Constitutional Republic.

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 Před 18 dny

      It's about time government stopped meddling in personal moral decisions. No government entity will ever adequately "solve" the abortion issue. Further, it's none of their business.

    • @rainwaterjoseph4634
      @rainwaterjoseph4634 Před 18 dny +2

      Trump just got us 3 young conservative justices. Don't dismiss yet, we are just getting cooking. That 6-3 split will serve us well the next 4 decades.

    • @MarkSmith-pb2ly
      @MarkSmith-pb2ly Před 18 dny

      No.

    • @edblasingame8139
      @edblasingame8139 Před 17 dny

      Abortion is NOT A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT!! What part of that don't you OXYMORON'S GET??!!

  • @TakenTook
    @TakenTook Před 18 dny +3

    I'm slightly relieved that ACB is going to call these Idaho people out on their BS in this case. I would still be more reassured if she wasn't on the court of the first place, but at least she's not as hypocritical as I was expecting her to be.

  • @moonlightpixie9976
    @moonlightpixie9976 Před 18 dny +18

    The war on women must stop!!
    Abortion is healthcare plain and simple lawmakers have no business butting into medical decisions!!!!!!
    Vote 💙

    • @jomamacita1318
      @jomamacita1318 Před 18 dny +1

      you mean possible murder, right foo?

    • @moonlightpixie9976
      @moonlightpixie9976 Před 18 dny +1

      @jomamacita1318 a clump of cells isn't murder !
      Murder is what happened at Uvalde!
      My abortion saved my life and made it so my kids didn't have to grow up without a mother! So since you clearly don't understand the difference between having a clump of cells removed and murder perhaps you should keep your ignorant opinions to yourself or better yet if you don't like abortions just ignore them like you do school shootings...

    • @maharajjinkb7824
      @maharajjinkb7824 Před 18 dny

      'Women's health care' -- euphemistic language.

    • @Jedi007c6
      @Jedi007c6 Před 18 dny

      So can a man slip a woman a abortion pill and that's OK too Or can only a woman off a living thing?

    • @MarkSmith-pb2ly
      @MarkSmith-pb2ly Před 18 dny

      The war on Trump should also stop.

  • @cecilelaforce3686
    @cecilelaforce3686 Před 18 dny +14

    Ban Idaho.

  • @kimberknutson831
    @kimberknutson831 Před 18 dny +7

    Wow. Just wow. Excellent reporting, analysis, and commentary, as always. Thank you. : )

  • @johnpyle1268
    @johnpyle1268 Před 18 dny +11

    This is exactly why women's choice is the number one issue for me in November. This is evil.

    • @AngelSanchez-du8ze
      @AngelSanchez-du8ze Před 17 dny +1

      I don’t hang my hat on abortion rights, the Supreme Court already decided it’s a states rights issue. Which is the correct legal conclusion in light of it not being a constitutional right.
      But what I wanted to ask you sir, is this:
      You say it’s “evil” so my question is:
      Who decides for the child? Is ending life not evil? Please explain your position, without using fetus/medical definitions to make your argument more palatable to the human moral conscience.

    • @InfinityEightplus
      @InfinityEightplus Před 17 dny +1

      Sorry John, you don’t get to have an opinion since you’re male. Also, you’ve just been drafted, you leave for Ukraine tomorrow right after we boost you 99 times 😆

  • @Demongurl80
    @Demongurl80 Před 18 dny +3

    What do you mean seeking ballot access in Nevada??? We already voted to keep abortion rights!!!

  • @bluehealer81
    @bluehealer81 Před 18 dny +8

    Yet another reason to avoid Idaho. I mean, not that there was a reason to visit in the first place.

    • @Jedi007c6
      @Jedi007c6 Před 18 dny

      😂 so you can off a baby, please don't come to Idaho

  • @eagleinewschannel
    @eagleinewschannel Před 18 dny +3

    No doctors that can determine the situation of a patient and that is why they need more time for observation rather than applying medication immediately. The lawyers believe the opposite as if thinking it was like an essay problem to answer.

    • @Gretabpooh
      @Gretabpooh Před 17 dny

      You don't need more time for observation when a woman is having a miscarriage. They can't be stopped or reversed. By not immediately treating, it can lead the woman to bleed out of develop sepsis. Nor do you need more time to determine what to do for an ectopic pregnancy. They are always nonviable and again, not treating can cause the fallopian tube to rupture and the woman to bleed out.

  • @richyp64
    @richyp64 Před 18 dny +25

    This is why I’m so thankful I moved my family to a sanctuary state. Our city has made every effort to make abortion available to all birthing people and especially to our low income and POC communities. Vote blue to save our democracy. 💙💙

    • @TooBadThatDidntKillMe
      @TooBadThatDidntKillMe Před 18 dny +4

      Get high on your own supply?

    • @MSNBCult
      @MSNBCult Před 18 dny +5

      Guatemala isnt a state.

    • @nonya.bizness
      @nonya.bizness Před 18 dny +2

      still waiting for you to name the state, or i'm going to keep calling out your day after day copy-paste of this same bogus comment.

    • @user-ei3xv5cc5b
      @user-ei3xv5cc5b Před 18 dny +3

      Birthing people? Does that mean you are leaving out non-birthing people? You’re not being very inclusive.😊

    • @TooBadThatDidntKillMe
      @TooBadThatDidntKillMe Před 18 dny +3

      @@nonya.bizness It's a MAGA concern troll.

  • @charrio2
    @charrio2 Před 18 dny +4

    No men should decide on what women can and can not do with their bodies. They don't know.

    • @Yurrsawwwft
      @Yurrsawwwft Před 16 dny

      What about banning a medical practice relates to a woman’s choice of what to do with her body?

  • @BennyRuff
    @BennyRuff Před 16 dny

    IT IS ABSOLUTELY INSANE THAT WE AS A PEOPLE ARE DEBATING WHETHER OR NOT BABIES SHOULD HAVE THE RIGHT TO BE BORN.

  • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
    @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 18 dny +12

    Body autonomy is the basis of freedom.

    • @jomamacita1318
      @jomamacita1318 Před 18 dny

      unless your a baby that is. right foo?

    • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
      @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 18 dny +4

      @@jomamacita1318 "foo"? Babies have been born and thus have rights.

    • @videoettaceo8900
      @videoettaceo8900 Před 18 dny

      ​@@jomamacita1318foo? Cells don't get more rights than the woman they are in.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny +1

      @@jomamacita1318 Bodily autonomy does not include the right to use and/or occupy a person’s body.

    • @Yurrsawwwft
      @Yurrsawwwft Před 16 dny

      Unless you like heroin, then it doesn’t matter if it’s your body, it’s not your choice. There are laws against that.
      Oddly enough I’m sure you all support those laws banning the drug not the decision to take it. But are furious when they ban the abortion and not the decision to have one.

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny +1

    she needs to know she WILL be taken care of under all circumstances. By all doctors.
    what do you mean by that what is care to you
    they are not women
    that is not a she more like an it

  • @IOSARBX
    @IOSARBX Před 18 dny +3

    MSNBC, This is amazing! I can't stop smiling!

  • @vinotash9261
    @vinotash9261 Před 18 dny +6

    There needs to be a ban on SCOTUS. It has become corrupt, and hypocritical.

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 Před 18 dny

      That's the wrong approach. We're asking government, no matter which branch, to "solve" an unsolvable issue for us.

    • @rainwaterjoseph4634
      @rainwaterjoseph4634 Před 18 dny

      Don't ban them now. President Trump just got us 3 young conservative justices. That 6-3 split should serve us well for the next half century.

  • @t.r.campbell6585
    @t.r.campbell6585 Před 18 dny +1

    We are seeing democracy in action across the country. When the Robert’s court realized that the constitution did not mention abortion or aborted services and struck down Roe, the emphasis was then replaced on state elected officials to legislate abortion services. Activist on both sides of the issue pressured their elected officials to take whatever action was necessary. In some cases we had very progressive abortion access in other cases we had very restrictive abortion laws. What we see however, is democracy in action.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      Abortion access is a constitutionally protected *unenumerated* right. Read the 9th Amendment, goofball.

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny

    she needs to know she WILL be taken care of what do you mean by caring for who these are not women

  • @Bitdog4U
    @Bitdog4U Před 18 dny +4

    End the in fighting.
    Women have the right to choose until birth, then the child is protected by the law.
    A non existent GOD should not be forcing her to alter her chosen path.
    No body has the right to force their choices on her.
    The unborn have no rights. They don't even have a name.

  • @j.c.3800
    @j.c.3800 Před 17 dny

    states need to decide. populations differ.

    • @Gretabpooh
      @Gretabpooh Před 17 dny

      Why? Women and their anatomies are the same in all 50 states. A miscarriage is a miscarriage, no matter where it happens. All women deserve the best care possible.

    • @erincoco612
      @erincoco612 Před 17 dny

      No MAN it doesn't. A woman is a human being. A FEMALE CHILD is a human being.

  • @afry6400
    @afry6400 Před 18 dny +1

    Perhaps we should be sending those bills to congress to pay for as they are not cheep.

  • @betha8761
    @betha8761 Před 18 dny +2

    Democracy and Freedom

    • @edblasingame8139
      @edblasingame8139 Před 17 dny

      We are a CONSTITUTIONAL FEDERAL REPUBLIC!! NOT A DEMOCRACY!!! You have no Clue about This COUNTRY!!

  • @TomdeSabla
    @TomdeSabla Před 17 dny

    Since the "context" here is that abortion is a "procedure for ending a pregnancy" - what happens to the unborn baby when a pregnancy is ended?
    This result is now called "care"?

    • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
      @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 17 dny

      There's no baby, it's tissue. This is about the woman and her healthcare.

    • @TomdeSabla
      @TomdeSabla Před 17 dny

      @@wtfisthishandlebullshit There's no baby - it's tissue.
      Are you then in favor of ending the long established practice of charging two counts of murder when a pregnant woman is murdered?

    • @TomdeSabla
      @TomdeSabla Před 17 dny

      @@wtfisthishandlebullshit And exactly when does the "tissue" become a baby?
      You actually think your sophistry is effective? This isn't bandaging a wound or treating a disease. This "tissue" is destined to be one thing and one thing only - a living human being.
      I'm not personally in favor of charging murder for every abortion, but can we at least stop the gaslighting and admit there is a real discussion to be had over the killing of a living human being?
      Pretending it's some neutral tissue with no particular destiny is a dishonest construct.

    • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
      @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 17 dny

      @@TomdeSabla That's a rarely used law that has nothing to do with a woman's body autonomy.

    • @TomdeSabla
      @TomdeSabla Před 17 dny

      @@wtfisthishandlebullshit Non sequitur. It is used whenever a pregnant woman is murdered. Also it is relevant to whether it is neutral "tissue" or another human life.
      If a woman has a tumor growing in her body, no law provides for a second count of murder because the tumor died with her. Because the tumor, although it is tissue, is not destined to be a separate human being.
      Bodily autonomy is about what a person wants to do with THEIR OWN body.
      Once you are pregnant, you are carrying SOMEONE ELSE'S body.
      Please stop pretending there is no difference

  • @barbaragdisis4606
    @barbaragdisis4606 Před 18 dny +1

    the Iowa State Fair in August 2023, Kennedy said he would support a federal ban on abortion after 15 weeks of gestation, then said he would not “personally” restrict abortion but added, “I think the states have a right to protect a child once the child becomes viable, and that right, it increases

    • @susannehartl3067
      @susannehartl3067 Před 17 dny +1

      Somebody should tell Kennedy that Yoga is pretty popular in America. Nothing better prepares to bend.

  • @donnaschow613
    @donnaschow613 Před 17 dny

    Good

  • @littlenickypickletoe
    @littlenickypickletoe Před 18 dny +2

    And biden just ended title nine.

    • @richardc9634
      @richardc9634 Před 17 dny

      he has ended real female sports

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      @@richardc9634 Oh, please. You don’t give af about women’s sports lol

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      He did not such thing.

    • @littlenickypickletoe
      @littlenickypickletoe Před 17 dny

      @@alexwyatt2911 he just did an executive order last week that mandated men be allowed to participate in high school and college of sports. Thus effectively ending title 9.

    • @littlenickypickletoe
      @littlenickypickletoe Před 17 dny

      @@alexwyatt2911 I have daughters and granddaughters and friends that have daughters who are in

  • @richardc9634
    @richardc9634 Před 17 dny

    Biden needs to talk about his border policy, If Biden was concerned about abortion rights, he had 2 years to codify Roe, and he did nothing

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny +1

      The President doesn’t enact legislation, silly. That’s Congress.

    • @keithmelon428
      @keithmelon428 Před 17 dny

      He did and Senate Republicans didn't support it.

    • @erincoco612
      @erincoco612 Před 17 dny

      But they did $%^hole. But they did and Republicans wouldn't do anything. The border bill was ALSO killed by Republicans WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN. Meanwhile the women in this country....OVER 150 MILLION OF THEM.....are human beings with rights. MAN.

  • @curtisbrown5939
    @curtisbrown5939 Před 18 dny

    I've never seen any aborted people talk about abortion rights

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      It’s almost as if embryos and fetuses aren’t people.

  • @SharTegral
    @SharTegral Před 18 dny +6

    Remember, remember, to vote in November
    The Dictator has reasons and plot
    We see no reason
    Why Trump's Jan 6th treason
    Should ever be forgot…

    • @joewoodchuck3824
      @joewoodchuck3824 Před 18 dny

      What did Trump do? He asked for peace. He never said a word about rioting. It's an outright lie.

    • @maharajjinkb7824
      @maharajjinkb7824 Před 18 dny

      The Jan 6 protest rally was infiltrated and hijacked by Feds who were there solely to help foment a riot, a riot which would then be used in an 'Attack on the Capitol' disinformation campaign. There was no 'insurrection'. It was another fairytale, similar to Trump-Russia collusion.

    • @MarkSmith-pb2ly
      @MarkSmith-pb2ly Před 18 dny

      Trump for 2024.
      Why can't Democrats be more like the average fine upstanding Trump supporter? They always remind me of those naughty kids that use to throw themselves on shop floors, rolling around screaming for a toy they couldn't get. November they going to be rolling around screaming again

  • @Navarrete993
    @Navarrete993 Před 17 dny

    Mexicans for Trump!!!!

  • @flashgordon6752
    @flashgordon6752 Před 18 dny +1

    States rights...the D.C. clown show 🤡

  • @d2670
    @d2670 Před 18 dny

    Excellent reporting.

  • @archieclement2977
    @archieclement2977 Před 18 dny +3

    Eleven thousand views, and democrats think this is the issue that's going to win them the election. 🤣

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny

      Grow up

    • @videoettaceo8900
      @videoettaceo8900 Před 18 dny +1

      It already did. Remember that red wave that never appeared in the mid term? Yeah.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      _Please_ keep underestimating the importance of abortion access. It’s working out really well for the Democratic Party as well as the country.

    • @erincoco612
      @erincoco612 Před 17 dny

      😂😂😂 troll acct created a yr ago. Fafo.

  • @sandtrapwarrior
    @sandtrapwarrior Před 18 dny +12

    How is this effecting the pregnant men? 🤔

    • @nonya.bizness
      @nonya.bizness Před 18 dny +7

      effecting? 😂

    • @sandtrapwarrior
      @sandtrapwarrior Před 18 dny +1

      @@nonya.bizness Affect is usually used as a verb meaning “to influence or produce a change in something.” Effect is generally used as a noun, and refers to the result of a change, but it's sometimes used as a verb meaning “to bring about a specific change.”

    • @davidchristopher6329
      @davidchristopher6329 Před 18 dny +4

      Defining the difference only shows you’re wrong lol since you used “effecting” as a verb.

    • @nonya.bizness
      @nonya.bizness Před 18 dny +3

      @@sandtrapwarrior so you're asking how this will cause pregnant men to happen? 🤣
      better to admit your error than to double down on it. it's the civilized thing to do.

    • @Craig2142
      @Craig2142 Před 18 dny

      ​@@nonya.bizness I guess if men can give birth, effect can also identify as affect.

  • @vitalsigns2679
    @vitalsigns2679 Před 18 dny +2

    Anything on the protest outside the Correspondents Dinner?

    • @bobevans9955
      @bobevans9955 Před 18 dny +1

      Hey we don't talk about that on this channel

    • @_ULTRA-_-QMAGA-_-PARROT-_-
      @_ULTRA-_-QMAGA-_-PARROT-_- Před 18 dny

      ​@@bobevans9955🦜💨...brawk

    • @nonya.bizness
      @nonya.bizness Před 18 dny +5

      this video is titled 'idaho abortion case'. there are others regarding different topics. you might want to google it.

    • @bobevans9955
      @bobevans9955 Před 18 dny +1

      @@nonya.bizness you can't multitask

    • @Mike-ns1ho
      @Mike-ns1ho Před 18 dny

      ​@nonya.bizness where do I find a story like that on msnbc?.

  • @StacyInLove1
    @StacyInLove1 Před 18 dny +1

    🩵💙🩵💙🩵💙🩵💙🩵💙

  • @williamblake827
    @williamblake827 Před 18 dny +1

    Do something on the Hamas/MsDNC/Soros Columbia University anti-American protests.😂

  • @IOSARBX
    @IOSARBX Před 18 dny +1

    MSNBC, This is perfect! I subscribed right away!

  • @davidrogers8403
    @davidrogers8403 Před 17 dny

    This lady may not be aware of selective abortion in her homeland of India. Is that a fundamental human right?

  • @achd73
    @achd73 Před 18 dny

    how does the brain exist in the mind and we do not know it
    how does thoughts exist outside of your speaking
    how do senses exist in the mind and we do not feel anything
    how does science get determined before man did man ever really discover these things

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny

    were going to allow our people an opportunity for a family and I suggest being severe

  • @_ULTRA-_-QMAGA-_-PARROT-_-

    A face a face wah wah brawk a face BRAAAAWWK 🦜💨

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny

    I believe in free birth no hospital law of the sea that is against the LORD

  • @jacknisen
    @jacknisen Před 17 dny

    It is not a fight for reproduction rights. It is a fight to legalize murder.

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny

    lets say a person felt like killing someone would that be a crime or is that ok to do that according to the protestors who are not women by the way its perfectly ok to do that I do not think that is ok but your saying its ok to do that

    • @emilydivis6369
      @emilydivis6369 Před 18 dny +2

      No one is legally allowed to use your body against your will for their own gain. Not even if it will save their life. Not even if it's just your blood and you'll fully recover. Not even if you're dead and you're not using your organs anyway.
      Why should fetuses have rights that no born person gets to have? And why should pregnant women be denied rights that corpses have?

    • @erincoco612
      @erincoco612 Před 17 dny

      What language are you speaking....word salad nonsense.

    • @webportal6659
      @webportal6659 Před 17 dny

      ​@@emilydivis6369The mother chose to get pregnant. It's against no one's will.

  • @machineutopia1619
    @machineutopia1619 Před 18 dny

    If you do not like your state law then move.

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny +2

      Um...no. You understand that we can change laws, right?

    • @emilydivis6369
      @emilydivis6369 Před 18 dny +2

      It's hard to afford to move when you've been forced to pay the medical bills associated with pregnancy and childbirth. A lot of people can't afford to move even without that restriction.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny +1

      No US state should be infringing on people’s human rights.

    • @webportal6659
      @webportal6659 Před 17 dny

      ​@@alexwyatt2911Abortion has never been a right and never will be a right.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      @@webportal6659 Abortion access is and always will be a human right. Abortion access is an unenumerated constitutional right in the US.

  • @DustyNickelz
    @DustyNickelz Před 18 dny +3

    PROTECT OUR TRANS YOUTH !!
    VOTE DEMOCRAT!! BIDEN2024 !!
    🌊🌊🌈🌈🌈🌈🇺🇦🇵🇸

    • @KagomeYasha023
      @KagomeYasha023 Před 18 dny

      No quit indoctrinating children it’s very rare to actually be trans

    • @edblasingame8139
      @edblasingame8139 Před 17 dny

      You are a VERY SICK PERSON!!!

  • @David..832
    @David..832 Před 18 dny +2

    Human rights start in the womb

    • @David..832
      @David..832 Před 18 dny

      @@Matt-1147 The truth is not popular

    • @videoettaceo8900
      @videoettaceo8900 Před 18 dny +1

      What about natural miscarriages that doctors won't treat? The woman die or lose their uterus. But you're cool with that?

    • @David..832
      @David..832 Před 17 dny

      @@Matt-1147 Human rights start in the womb

    • @David..832
      @David..832 Před 17 dny

      @@videoettaceo8900 I don't believe that happens very much, if at all, it's rare

    • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
      @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 17 dny

      ​@@David..832 Human rights start at birth.

  • @radwulfeboraci7504
    @radwulfeboraci7504 Před 18 dny +2

    Leave healthcare to the medical professionals. Tell Alito and company that nobody hired them to save anybody's soul nor hold reign over women's physical autonomy. It is also self-evident that America cannot care for the souls it already has - 12 MILLION children are living in poverty in the US. How 'bout this ... make every person over the age of 16 pass a childcare course to earn a license to breed. You would have to pay fees, pass several exams, and take training for a minimum period. Also, you should have to provide health insurance for the child for 16 years.

  • @cindyflores564
    @cindyflores564 Před 17 dny

    VOTE BLUE. BLUE IDAHO.

  • @achd73
    @achd73 Před 18 dny +1

    the LORD GOD is there and were supposed to be steadfast and not be double minded

  • @rebeccascott630
    @rebeccascott630 Před 17 dny

    Murder is murder

    • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
      @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 17 dny

      And abortion is healthcare.

    • @erincoco612
      @erincoco612 Před 17 dny

      No nut. You don't have a medical degree and your religion doesmt effect others. Foh.

    • @webportal6659
      @webportal6659 Před 17 dny

      ​@@wtfisthishandlebullshitExcept it's not in about 97% of times.

    • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
      @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 17 dny

      @@webportal6659 It's always healthcare, and it's never about you.

  • @michaelh411
    @michaelh411 Před 18 dny +8

    If I had a dollar for every gender I'd have $2 , and a lot of counterfeits.

    • @sandtrapwarrior
      @sandtrapwarrior Před 18 dny +3

      🤣🤣👍👍

    • @Schlemiel-Team-Six
      @Schlemiel-Team-Six Před 18 dny +2

      A male or female transitioning to the other gender is still 2 genders. Not really sure how this stupid 'multi gender' B.S. keeps flying.

    • @MiracleFound
      @MiracleFound Před 18 dny +5

      Actually you would have a minimum of 3 depending on how you define gender, by chromosones or genetalia.

    • @JoeyHurtAshley
      @JoeyHurtAshley Před 18 dny

      ​@@MiracleFoundhow many genders does it take to produce a child.

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny

      Grow. Up.

  • @AverageJoe483
    @AverageJoe483 Před 18 dny +2

    What year was murder made illegal ? Was it recent ? Who cares WHEN a law is made .

  • @NicThatOneKid
    @NicThatOneKid Před 18 dny +1

    You should have kids 👍

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny +1

    were going to preach to you openly I am not the LORD but I will preach about the LORD and keep the Commandments

  • @archieclement2977
    @archieclement2977 Před 18 dny +2

    Irresponsibility isn't a right. It's a character flaw.

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny +3

      It literally is a right. Go home. And work on your own character

    • @archieclement2977
      @archieclement2977 Před 18 dny

      @@rensinclair4218 Refusing to be responsible, and use birth control is not a right. Why don't you grow up.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      The majority of people who receive an abortion in the US were using some form of contraception.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny +1

      Making reproductive health choices-including contraception use and accessing abortion- *is* a right.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny +1

      An unplanned pregnancy isn’t a character flaw, silly. Conception is an involuntary, biological process. The “character flaw” here is interfering with reproductive freedom.

  • @paleocon777
    @paleocon777 Před 18 dny

    THEY WANT to ☠️ BABIES 😢 👶🏾👶🏻👶🏼👩🏼‍🍼👩🏾‍🍼

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      I know. Right-wingers are truly awful. They oppose all legislation and programs that provide resources and opportunities to protect and care for children.

  • @NDARYBC
    @NDARYBC Před 18 dny +1

    We got SC justices putting Politics (PARTY OVER COUNTRY)before Individual Right"s and Would likes to THANKS their Corrupt sympathy for republican downfall...

  • @richieuhh85
    @richieuhh85 Před 18 dny +2

    If the people of a state decide to ban abortion, it’s up to those people to decide and for you liberals to stay out of states business.

    • @_ULTRA-_-QMAGA-_-PARROT-_-
      @_ULTRA-_-QMAGA-_-PARROT-_- Před 18 dny

      🦜💨...

    • @archieclement2977
      @archieclement2977 Před 18 dny +1

      ​@@_ULTRA-_-QMAGA-_-PARROT-_- You got something against democracy?

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny +1

      Absolutely not, fascist. Wow. Expect HEAVY resistance

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny +2

      ​@@archieclement2977I have something against fascism

    • @archieclement2977
      @archieclement2977 Před 18 dny +1

      @@rensinclair4218 If more people in a state vote to outlaw abortion, than vote to legalize it that's called democracy. You may not care for how the people of my state vote on an issue, but if the people of my state vote for it, that's called democracy.

  • @TryAgainBudLOL
    @TryAgainBudLOL Před 18 dny +10

    Voting Red up and down the ballot in November. 😎💪

    • @JOECURR1488
      @JOECURR1488 Před 18 dny +6

      MY PEOPLE ARE IN.
      TRUMP WILL BE REELECTED.
      😊

    • @bobevans9955
      @bobevans9955 Před 18 dny +5

      I'm voting for Trump

    • @AntiTDS_Democrat
      @AntiTDS_Democrat Před 18 dny +4

      @@JOECURR1488Joes low approval rating and low poll numbers basically point in that direction, Trump 2024 for no more wars and a low cost of living economy. 💪

    • @james-rd4dq
      @james-rd4dq Před 18 dny +1

      Give me a good reason WHY, Please I dare you

    • @JOECURR1488
      @JOECURR1488 Před 18 dny

      @@AntiTDS_Democrat YOU CHANGE YOUR NAME TOO OFTEN...

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny

    what is your prerogative to play god
    what makes you think your somehow god
    what sort of creatures are these they are not women

  • @achd73
    @achd73 Před 18 dny

    there is no doubt the LORD is there start preaching the good news

  • @vitalsigns2679
    @vitalsigns2679 Před 18 dny +4

    Is the phrase...Planned Parenthood, an oxymoron?

    • @jcc9549
      @jcc9549 Před 18 dny +3

      Considering they offer everything from prenatal care, to family planning, to abortions care, no it’s not an oxymoron.

    • @MiracleFound
      @MiracleFound Před 18 dny +2

      Definitely not. They make contraception available to prevent pregnancy. Not using birth control is unplanned parenthood.

    • @wtfisthishandlebullshit
      @wtfisthishandlebullshit Před 18 dny +2

      It's Planning whether or not, and when, we want to be Parents. It's really not that difficuIt.

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny +1

      Obviously not

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      No, lol. Planning when and if to begin and/or expand parenthood is the entire point.

  • @jeffhampton2767
    @jeffhampton2767 Před 18 dny +1

    If you don't want a baby then don't get pregnant😢

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny

      Mind your own business. You talking to my wife, Cletus? Talk to me

    • @MLadyAzzera
      @MLadyAzzera Před 17 dny

      What about the woman who wanted a baby, got pregnant with twins, but one of the twins was dying and jeopardizing the health of the other one? A real story of a woman who is suing the state of Texas because she had to flee to Colorado to get an abortion just so one of her babies inside her could live, instead of them both dying, like Texas would have forced. Sometimes abortion actually saves the suffering of the unborn, but simple minded people don't ever consider complex situations, do they?

  • @winstonsmith6607
    @winstonsmith6607 Před 18 dny +6

    Try all you want, people don't care about abortion. Stick to 24/7 Trump gossip

    • @boombasett6038
      @boombasett6038 Před 18 dny +2

      YOU ARE STUPID OR BLIND.

    • @Remember_when
      @Remember_when Před 18 dny +1

      Try me.

    • @sandtrapwarrior
      @sandtrapwarrior Před 18 dny

      @@Remember_when🤣🤣🫵🤡🤡

    • @householdhacks
      @householdhacks Před 18 dny

      it's not gossip if there is proof it's called evidence and facts of a crime.

    • @winstonsmith6607
      @winstonsmith6607 Před 18 dny

      @@householdhacks Yes, his tiny hands, his smell, his weight, his hair, his supposedSTD. the fact that he looks 'less orange' etc., etc. is all 'evidence'. This network is all about lies and smears against Trump. And I'm saying that as someone who doesn't even like Trump! It's goofy

  • @user-ei3xv5cc5b
    @user-ei3xv5cc5b Před 18 dny +3

    How often does this happen exactly? You are picking and choosing what the worse case scenarios are. And there are less than 1%. And that’s the same as it was when the government set laws for abortion. This is a non-issue!

    • @jcc9549
      @jcc9549 Před 18 dny +7

      The problem is this is just one type of issue as it pertains to reproductive health.
      The laws in these states don’t just deal with these instances, but every other nuance of reproductive care.
      So please stop making excuses trying to justify these archaic laws.
      There shouldn’t be laws that force some women to go one way or another as it pertains to reproductive care.
      It should be total body autonomy for all women. Period.

    • @MiracleFound
      @MiracleFound Před 18 dny +5

      It happens way more than you think. Preeclampsia is pretty common and the only fully effective treatment is to deliver the pregnancy. Do some genealogy on your family, most of your great-great-grandfathers had at least 2 or 3 wives because of pregnancy and delivery complications. Definitely not rare. I would guess that 30-40% of all pregnancies have some sort of complications.

    • @AmyEugene
      @AmyEugene Před 18 dny +4

      They said that one hospital was transporting pregnant women to another state every other week. The hospital would have to see 100+ pregnant women every two weeks for that to be 1 percent and given the low population of Idaho, not likely. Even if some freak medical thing happened and the only person it had ever happened to in the entire world was you, and you were at risk of dying within the hour, would that still be a non-issue?

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny

    I believe in mandatory emphasis on that birth policy I believe the government is obligated to help citizens be put together and make children that is my policy

  • @thefabuloussaneone
    @thefabuloussaneone Před 18 dny

    I'm a Republican and feel that Abortion should be legal for poc only.

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny

    so murder is not a crime what they are saying so you do not go to jail so if someone wanted to they can murder someone and its legal according to what standard these fake women are speaking that is not from me that is from them

  • @ius1141
    @ius1141 Před 18 dny

    those are not women not she but it
    I could understand if they were actual women no but these are objects not real women remember not her not she but it

  • @josephsonora3787
    @josephsonora3787 Před 18 dny

    The question still remains...has Dumeecratic Justice Katangie finally figured out the definition of the word "WOMAN" yet?! 🤣

    • @susannehartl3067
      @susannehartl3067 Před 18 dny +1

      Still haven't figured out yet?

    • @josephsonora3787
      @josephsonora3787 Před 18 dny

      @@susannehartl3067 You haven't?

    • @susannehartl3067
      @susannehartl3067 Před 17 dny +1

      @@josephsonora3787 You are the one that constantly asks this question, not me.

    • @josephsonora3787
      @josephsonora3787 Před 17 dny

      @susannehartl3067 but you just sent a message saying YOU still haven't? Read your message.

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 Před 17 dny

      @@josephsonora3787 Yeah, the other user is asking _you_ if _you_ still haven’t figured it out yet.

  • @evolutionistheflyingspaghe2702

    It’s compassionate and reasonable to assume every developing human still in the womb is zealously pro life.

    • @jcc9549
      @jcc9549 Před 18 dny

      Until IT miscarries or develops a malformity. Lol
      Just stop with your attempts at creating narratives. Geezus.

    • @redefiningmyself8598
      @redefiningmyself8598 Před 18 dny

      When abortion was legal how did women having abortions affect you personally? The frontal brain lobes create and control "zeal" and zygotes and invitro babies are incapable of being zealously prolife or zealous about anything for that matter.

    • @user-lw9dr6lo9w
      @user-lw9dr6lo9w Před 18 dny +2

      No. You are wrong.

    • @evolutionistheflyingspaghe2702
      @evolutionistheflyingspaghe2702 Před 18 dny

      @@user-lw9dr6lo9wObjectively, how am I wrong?

    • @rensinclair4218
      @rensinclair4218 Před 18 dny +1

      It's not logical AT ALL

  • @SpaceBethC131
    @SpaceBethC131 Před 18 dny

    Go Idaho. Protect the babies. From your Washington neighbor and gun buyer

  • @MrWideballs
    @MrWideballs Před 18 dny

    Ma and Pa always says if you kills it you gots to eats it.😂

  • @KedijaABAnezif
    @KedijaABAnezif Před 17 dny

    Hacaaluu.biruu

  • @TooBadThatDidntKillMe
    @TooBadThatDidntKillMe Před 18 dny +2

    United Russia got mad at Ireland for legalizing abortion. They wish there were more Savita Halappanavars in the world.

  • @KedijaABAnezif
    @KedijaABAnezif Před 17 dny

    Acaluu.biruu

  • @KedijaABAnezif
    @KedijaABAnezif Před 17 dny

    Hacaaluu.biruu