Gary Neville & Jamie Carragher Pick Best XI's From Premier League Winning Teams
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 05. 2023
- As the title race draws to a close we asked Jamie Carragher and Gary Neville to create their ultimate title-winning XI's, during our latest Fan Debate brought to you by Sky Bet.
They have some amazing sides to pick from...
1. United 1994 Side
2. United 1999 Side
3. United 2008 Side
4. Arsenal 1998
5. Arsenal 2003
6. Blackburn 1995
7. Leicester Ranieri
8. City Pep
9. Liverpool Klopp
10. Chelsea Jose 2005
11. Wildcard pick from anywhere else but not those teams or clubs and although Gerrard didn’t win the title they still can't choose him!
Let us know who makes your XI in the comments below! 👇
SUBSCRIBE TO THE CHANNEL HERE
czcams.com/users/theoverlap?...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Follow us on social!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Facebook: profile.php?...
Twitter: / wearetheoverlap
Instagram: / wearetheoverlap
------------------------------------------------------------------------ - Sport
Gary Neville has spent so much time downplaying his career that people don't take him seriously nowadays. He was a mainstay in SAF's title winning teams where you have to be nothing but elite to be starting for all those years.
He himself admitted that he wasn't as technical and talented as some players but he was work horse and gave it all everytime he stepped on the pitch in United shirt
He’s really humble. Very harsh on himself
Not only that, but he used to get down the wing and cross it in. He did more than just defending and was playing more like a modern defender back then... over 20 years ago.
" Only RB at the club " - Roy Keane
But he wasn't good tho
“Do you understand the rules” 😂😂
I just love Buvey man ‘where’s aguero’ 😂😂 he cracks me up
Why does Robbie take everything so personally 😂
Typical gunner lol
@@WRNWRW So his argument about Henry is unvalid or ?
@@shebeshimillion7250 not invalid, just acts like Henry is his best mate 😂 other people have differing opinions and it was a task to get different players in 👍
@@shebeshimillion7250 It's invalid because of how they defined the rules, if you take Henry instead of Shearer then you have to replace an 2004 Arsenal player with a Blackburn player, so Vieira with Sherwood or Campbell with Pearce, which would be a massive dropoff in those positions.
Shearer was pretty much a guaranteed lock in this
@Shebeshi Million I mean the way he said 'you've got ronaldo in there somehow' like 2008 ronaldo didn't win the Premier league, champions league, score 42 goals, win every individual award possible. Delusional
Love this great idea. Mine would be:
GK - Schmichael - Man utd 1994
RB - Gary Neville - Man utd 1998
CB - John Terry - Chelsea 2005
CB - Tony Adams - Arsenal 1998
LB - Andy Robertson - Klopps Liverpool
CDM - Kante - Ranieri's Leicester
CM - Kevin De Bruyne - Peps City
CM - Modric - Wildcard
LW - Thierry Henry - Arsenal 2004
RW - Cristiano Ronaldo - Man utd 2008
CF - Alan Shearer - Blackburn 1995
See thats a fucking team
Henry was a striker. They said at the beginning that players should be placed in their correct position
GK - Schmichael - MU 94
LB - Le Saux - Blackburn 95
CB - Stam - MU 99
CB - Terry - Chelsea 05
RB - Alexander Arnold - Klopp's Liverpool
CDM - Kante - Ranieri's leicester
CM - KDB - Pep's city
CM - Vieira - Arsenal 98
RW - Ronaldo - MU 08
LW - Henry - Arsenal 04
CF - Kane - Wildcard
@@HamsaT12 Henry played in both LW/ST
Showing your age a bit here
@@Ebamber3 he played striker that season with Pires on the wing. He was a striker
Carras DEF is brilliant. Irwin is one of those players people forget how importatn he was to Sir Alex early 90's team.
Never had less than 8 out of 10
Great character, never injured, played with both feet left side right side could score a free kick. Oh and he roomed with Keano
There’s no athleticism in the back four at all. Forget about playing a high line
He made 1 mistake in 10 years 😂
Irwin was the one
Henry has to be in there, no matter who you support, you can’t leave out the best Premier League player. As for the Man City fan, he’s so blinkered, he’d ignore the rules and just pick his own club’s players.
ur chatting rubbish, the blackburn drop off from shearer is insane so hes the inly one you can pick, MAYBE henry over ronaldo but henry is not a must pick, and lets not act like hes light years clear of agueroand rooney either.
You clearly did not understand the rules. Shearer was head and shoulders the best player in Blackburn's side. It is compulsory to select one player from that team and therefore he has to go in above Henry. Pay attention. Otherwise you end up selecting Tim Sherwood and shoe horning him in🤦♂
@@we5t5id3gunnwhat you're about...he is the best pl player of all time..and miles clear of Aguero...Henry Rooney Ronaldo ....top 3 pl players of all time..and I'm a utd fan
@@abhishekchaudhary399 And who couldn't lead his team to holding the famous champions league trophy without moving abroad to a team that was great already?
@@we5t5id3gunn Never in my life seen aguero/shearer take the ball from the halfway line, beat the entire team to go on score - saw them score a lot of tapins in the box though in about 20 seasons - henry was there for 7. theirry henry is always the first name in an all time premier league 11 simply because he is the best player of all time in the premier league
Buvey at the end so fucking funny, hes such a natural wind up merchant i love it. You can tell he is taking the piss but also being a lil serious w his tone so it messes w everyone
From Ranieri's team no one went with Kante 😳😳😳
Stack midfield
kante is a great shout no doubt!! i love kante and im sure alottt of people do also. but come on lad
Prime Kante is incredibly underated , he was a one man midfield, best player on two different PL winning teams.I think he was also the best player in a World Cup and CL winning team.
@@Stringer_Bell70 prime kante is world class. won everything apart from the euros. even then he got to a final in 2016
What's the big surprise
GK: Peter Schmeichel (Man Utd 1999)
LB: Ashley Cole (Arsenal 2004)
CB: Terry (Chelsea 2005)
CB: Adams (Arsenal 1998)
RB: Ivanovic (Chelsea 2010)(Wildcard)
CDM: Kante (Ranieri's Leicester)
CM: De Bruyne (Pep's Man City)
CM: Keane (Man Utd 1994)
LW: Ronaldo (Man Utd 2008)
ST: Shearer (Blackburn 1995)
RW: Salah (Klopp's Liverpool)
Great team but you can’t pick Ivanovic as a wildcard. The wildcard can’t be from a club listed i.e. you can’t pick from Chelsea, Man U, Man City, Arsenal, Liverpool, Leicester or Blackburn
Fair play to Carra for giving Denis Irwin some respect, hes seriously due some from the british Media who think Cole invented the lb positon. Irwin was every bit as good as cole
It isn't so much about the media favoritism as it is about recency bias. A lot of brilliant players from the 90s have completely been forgotten. Just lazy journalism
@@amitabhsharma3916 exactly...that Blackburn team were brilliant and even players like Sherwood were top quality that Season but he diluted his legacy thru management lol
@Amitabh Sharma the Premier league, started in 92. The youtube generation seem to think it started in around 2002
@@amitabhsharma3916 this plus he was always professional and humble never made a star from himself never seeked attention, people like this are remembered by true fans. Casuals won't know
Still would have Andy Robertson over either of them.
Seaman 98
Stam 99
VVD Klopps
JT 05
Bale wildcard
Kante Leicester
KDB peps
Ronaldo 08
Henry 04
Shearer blackburns
Cantona 94
Interesting XI... But I would've gone.
GK - Peter Schmeichel (Man Utd 1994)
RB - Gary Neville (Man Utd 1999)
CB - John Terry (Chelsea 2005)
CB - Virgil Van Dijk (Klopp's Liverpool)
LB - Ashley Cole (Arsenal 2004)
CDM - Kante (Ranieri's Leicester)
CM - Kevin DeBruyne (Pep's Man City)
CM - Patrick Vieira (Arsenal 1998)
RW - Cristiano Ronaldo (Man Utd 2008)
ST - Alan Shearer (Blackburn 1994)
LW - Gareth Bale (Wildcard)
I really don't think you would find a better team than that!
Thierry Henry must have played golf. He literally finished 2 in balon dor in 2004 and arguably best player in the premier league history and u don’t include him 😂😂🤡🤡🤡
@@mr__OK who would you swap out the front three and play at left back then? That team is the best one.
@@harryhutchison4687 bale all day long. Henry had a 25 goal + 20 assist season.
Sorry but if Thierry Henry isn't in your team then you've lost all credibility 😂
@@brycefullerton1313 lool exactly. Shocking selection
Should’ve gone for Ashley Cole at left back tbh.
Instead of Gallas right
@@WRNWRW Cole wasn’t in the 05 Chelsea team mate
@@dan.808 He was part of the invincibles.
@@leemcqueen500 That’s literally my point mate? 😂
@@dan.808 So basically Gary could’ve gone for John Terry Chelsea 05, Ashley Cole Arsenal 2004 & put himself right back & Kante CDM what a muppet. 😅
GK - Schmichael
RB - Kieran Trippier
CB - Thiago Silva
CB - Kompany
LB - Ashley Cole
CDM - Makelele
CM - Kevin De Bruyne - Peps City
CM - Yaya Toure
LW - Thierry Henry
RW - Cristiano Ronaldo
CF - Wayne Rooney
I was thinking Trippier RB wildcard.
But you can't have Rooney & Cristiano. They only picked 94, 99 & 08 ManUtd teams to choose from. Obviously neither were in 94 or 99.
And I don't know how you can have 3 or even 2 City players as well lol
The team I’d go for is:
GK - Schmichael - Man Utd 1994
RB - Gary Neville - Man Utd 1999
CB - Tony Adams - Arsenal 1998
CB - John Terry - Chelsea 2005
LB - Ashley Cole - Arsenal 2004
CM - Luka Modric - Wildcard
CDM- Kante - Ranieri’s Leicester
CM - De Bruyne - Pep’s Man City
LW - Ronaldo - Man Utd 2008
ST - Shearer - Blackburn 1995
RW - Mo Salah - Klopp’s Liverpool
"why wasn't Kane your wildcard" 😂😂😂
GK Peter Cech - Chelsea 05
LB Dennis Irwin - United 94
CB Rio ferdinand - United 08
CB Kompany - Peps Man City
RB K Walker - Spurs 16/17 Wildcard
CM - Kante Leicester
CM - Viera- Arsenal 98
LW Salah - Liverpool
ST Henry - Arsenal 04
ST Shearer - Blackburn
RW D Beckham - United 99
Rather have Stam CB & that’s criminal to not have 08 CR7
Me and my mates gave ourselves 15 mins to sort our teams. When the 15 was done, we changed them again !! This is a lot HARDER than it looks. Its the multiple Man U and Arsenal teams that make it tricky. Maybe just 1 Arsenal team, 2 United teams and 2 Man City teams would be easier. There is no wrong or right answer to this. In the end somebody be crying 😂😂
Cech
TAA Adams Rio Irwin
Scholes Kante KDB
Ronaldo Shearer Henry
easy
There are definitely some wrong answers lol
@@Ebamber3 1)You have too many Man U players ( you should only have 3) and 2) you dont have a wildcard player 🤣😂🤣
@@maniackolder my 4th Man Utd player is a wildcard player
quite a few Man Utd teams weren't mentioned in their list
I’m a Utd fan
Would picked a front 3 of ronaldo, drogba, henry
All 3 unplayable at times
Incredible fifa team - may never have worked in the real world. But some serious CZcams highlight videos 🔥
That front 3 would have worked irl bro. Ronaldo RW Drogba ST Henry LW 🔥🔥
So if you don't pick Shearer, which I personally think is mental that he isn't your striker. What Blackburn player do you pick?
@@mark7foran Tim flowers for GK is the shout in that instance
People easily downgrade Renaldo 2008 season , it was and is the greatest single achievement ever in prem
Won golden boot , baland'or, puskas , UCL , PL
That's what People forget
He was already a goat of a footballer before moving to Madrid
I actually think he was better at man united... more complete, versatile - apart from maybe his first 2-3 years in Spain. After that, he converted himself into an out-and-out goalscorer (to compete with Messi and his ridiculous numbers), and in so doing lost something from his game.
@@Nathan-sc7hs more than competing with Messi, it was because of the bad injury he had in 2014. His knee forced him to change his playing style. Nonetheless, an absolute genius and goat of the game.
@@YuvrajSingh-eb4mv thanks, i didn't know that
@@Nathan-sc7hs he was not better at united
Point is, Henry did it for longer at the highest level too. Yes, Ronaldo was obviously brilliant but you can easily argue one brilliant season isn't as impressive as 6/7 great seasons. For me, Henry get its but if you take RM CR7, its not even close.
GK Schmeichel - 94
RB Neville - 99
CB Adams - 98
CB Terry - 05
LB Robertson - Liv
Cdm Vieira - 04
CM Kante - Leicester
CM De Bryune - city
RW Bale - wildcard
LW Ronaldo - 08
ST Shearer - Blackburn
Very good vid idea juss wish it was longer tbh with a 3rd guest also would make for some great content✅✅
Carragher is Hilarious n funny 🤣😂🤣 the Valencia thing 😅
This joke is older than Jesus christ
@@WRNWRW how olds she
@@ljm.jft9722 we're 15 years old
It's amazing how everyone agrees with the magic of Kevin De Bruyne. You can definitely argue him being the best midfielder that Prem has ever seen
They did a similar exercise where it was greatest prem XI without these restrictions and debruyne didn’t make anyones XI
Wouldn't go that far he should've won something with Belgium and he's never won the ChampionsLeague.
KdB just gets put in there because of recency bias and there’s greater legends at CB and Striker that overshadow Kompany and Aguero.
KdB hasn’t even once performed in a big game (UCL final flopped, flopped for Belgium vs Italy at the Euros).
Whatever kdb is doing now Beckham was doing it years ago
@@barrymckenna8547 well KDB has more goals & assists in lesser games than him in Premier League .
these are so much fun to watch haha!
My team:
GK: Petr Cech (Chelsea 05)
RB: Gary Neville (Man U 99)
CB: Virgil Van Dijk (Klopp Liverpool)
CB: Tony Adams (Arsenal 98)
LB: Ashley Cole (Arsenal 04)
CM: Kevin De Bruyne (Guardiola Man City)
CM: Roy Keane (Man U 94)
CM: Ngolo Kante (Leicester 16)
RW: Cristiano Ronaldo (Man U 08)
ST: Alan Shearer (Blackburn 95)
LW: Gareth Bale (Wild Card)
I think this is one of the best or most balanced teams possible. I went with Ronaldo on the right because not only is that where he played at United but I could instead get Kante instead of Mahrez (although either would be great) and then change the wildcard from Modric to Bale, Modric is elite but Bale was better IN the Premiere League.
Of players that have scored over 100 PL goals, no player has a better goals per game ratio than Thierry Henry.
Sergio Aguero
Peeps taking the piss with Garry’s Danny Simpson selection, he was absolutely brilliant in that title winning season him and Huth on that right hand side was literally the best and most consistent right side defensive duo in the world in that season especially when you remember all those 1-0 wins toward the end of that season. Who else would you pick besides Trent and himself which are way to obvious picks. It’s good to give these guys a shout out now and again and give them some acknowledgement for what they achieved even if it was just for a single season.
Kyle Walker's a good shout if you've got someone who can replace KDB in midfield
@@Ebamber3 I had a version that had Walker, with Kante, Vieira, and Modric in midfield. Ended up taking Bale as my wildcard and putting De Bruyne in midfield after shuffling things around.
GK Peter Schmeichel - Manchester United 1994
RB Trent Alexander-Arnold - Klopp’s Liverpool
CB Jaap Stam - Manchester United 1999
CB John Terry - Chelsea 2005
LB Ashley Cole - Arsenal 2004
DM N’Golo Kante - Ranieri’s Leicester
CM Patrick Vieira - Arsenal 1998
CM Kevin de Bruyne - Guardiola’s City
RW Cristiano Ronaldo - Manchester United 2008
LW Gareth Bale - Wildcard
ST Alan Shearer - Blackburn 1995
Ivanovic
So far I have Karius in goal, Grimandi as one of my CBs, Alexei Smertin and an injured Bryan Robson in Centre-Mid. Torn between Winston Bogarde and Ali Dia for my wildcard.
Building a Misunderstood XI from that pool is a tricky exercise.
This is the best team if anyone was wondering
Henry Shearer Salah
Modric Kante De Bruyne
Irvin Terry Ferdinand Dixon
Schmeichel
You could probably swap Salah + Ferdinand for Ronaldo + Van Dijk depending on preferences
Buvey on the wind up even here I actually love him
Carraghers team for me wins that match up. Tough to do this actually but I went with Alisson (20), Walker (17), Stam (99), Terry (05), Irwin (94), Kante (16), Vieira (98), KDB (18), Ronaldo (08), Henry (04), Shearer (95). Its tough! Bit strange giving Pep teams a number of years to choose from, I chose the centurion team from 2018 to be the focus. Walker is the Wildcard from Spurs 16-17 season with 86 points in second, I get the point about Modric but at that time he was a decent player but not yet the Modric he would become. Id actually scrap the Wildcard and instead enter the Arsenal 2001-02 team (which some pundits have claimed was better than the Invincibles) in which case it would change the RB to Neville (99) replacing Walker meaning a change at CB to Campbell (02). Just to point out that Ronaldo keeps being picked as LW for 2008, but his main position that season was actually RW/RM like 95% of the time. Hence why Ive got him in there at RW, Henry takes LW simply because he cannot be left out and Arsenals team was so fluid that season he was mostly found on the LH side with Cole and Pires forming a deadly trio.
I prefer my team
Schmeichel - 94
Trent Alexander Arnold - Klopps
Tony Adams -1998
John Terry - Chelsea 05
Irwin - Man U 99
Kante- Ranieris Leicester
KDB - peps City
Modric - wildcard
CR7 - Man U 08
Shearer - Blackburn 95
Theiry Henry - Arsenal 04
Surely Neville could have just gone Terry and Cole rather than Campbell and Gallas 😂
Innit lol man chose the worse options
Nah Campbell & Gallas was fine 😀
@@tris87don16 gallas was the maguire back in 008,
Honestly, Carvalho was better than Terry.
@@finalfrontier001 He was good when Chelsea won the league anyway I’d rather him than Cashley 🤣
Robbie asking why Ronaldo is in the team 😂. Messi and Ronaldo get in pretty much any team ever (depending if they are available for selection of course).
@@LukasOfTheLight Warra UCL and balon d’or whilst playing in the prem for Henry
@S Bailey They're taking 2008 Ronaldo who was the best player in the world though, 42 goals all comps, won Premier league champions league and all individual awards
@@LukasOfTheLightno offence, I have all respect for Henry, bit cr7 won three premier leagues in the row, UCL and ballon dor, none of which Henry could do. Cr7 clear
@@LukasOfTheLight No he wasn't
@S Bailey Tf you saying bollocks for, he literally spoke facts
It's actually really hard to do this fair okay, what I could come up with is:
KASPER Schmeichel- Ranieri's Leicester City
Trent Alexander Arnold - Klopp's Liverpool
Tony Adams-1998
Carvalho-2005
Irwin-1994
Viera-2004
Modric-Wildcard
De Bruyne-Pep's Man City
Shearer-1995
Ronaldo- 2008
Beckham-1999
Schmeichel
Neville Terry Adams Robertson
Grealish(with Villa) KDB Sherwood Mahrez
Ronaldo Henry
Courtois-Chelsea 17
Walker-Peps City
Terry-Chelsea 05
Rio-United 08
Irwin-UTD 94
Gerrard-Wildcard
Kante- Leicester 16
Henry-Arsenal 04
David Silva-Mancinis City
Salah-Klopp LFC
Shearer-Blackburn
I swear people forget Ronaldo won his first ballon d’or off the back off scoring 42 goals in all comps in 07/08 breaking and breaking the prem record for goals in a season on the way as well as winning the league and champions league
People forget and it’s really sad he was also a winger
I think those arsenal fans stopped watching football during those years when arsenal were doing bad because they don’t know what they’re talking about
As a midfield for over half the games as well😂
@@LukasOfTheLight Ronaldo was a winger and he won balon d
Ronaldo was absolutely incredible in that season but remember he came to the league young and didn’t start off good straight away. Henry over the course of his time in the premier league was better than Ronaldo season by season
Honestly the hardest part is fitting in a Blackburn and a Leicester player without taking out such amazing options from elsewhere. And keeping an actually workable formation.
just pick kante for leicester. solid option
@@circle2867 Kante and Shearer are both great players that aren’t out of place but it limits what you can pick elsewhere round the pitch as part of this
Not really difficult choosing a Blackburn player when they had the PL’s best ever striker..
P Schmeichel
Trent, Kompany, Terry, Ashley Cole.
Kante.
Roy Keane, Scholes.
Modric.
Shearer, Henry.
The playing in the right positions made it hard. Otherwise Ronaldo (drop Scholes) walks into the RW slot and Henry goes into the LW. Can't get away with playing Kane CAM, so has to be Modric.
This is the best team.. 4-2-3-1
Man Utd 94 - Schmeichel
Man Utd 99 - G.Neville
Arsenal 98 - Adams
Chelsea 05 - Terry
Arsenal 04 - Cole
Leicester - Kante
Wild Card - Modric
Liverpool - Salah
Man City - De Bruyne
Man Utd 08 - Ronaldo
Blackburn - Shearer
Got me thinking about combining title rivals (6 from 1, 5 from the other) from different eras.
I reckon the City & Liverpool one of the era just gone would take some stopping. It would have everything, ball possession, creativity from all over, solidity, killers up top
Aguero Salah
Silva De Bruyne
Robertson Rodri Fernandinho Trent
Van Dijk Kompany
Alisson
United arsenal rivalry.
Schmeichel.
Dixon, adams, ferdinand, iwin,
Keane, vieira, Scholes.
Bergkamp, Cole, Henry.
Would be one hell of a match
United - Chelsea rivalry of 07-09
Cech
Neville Ferdinand Vidic Evra
Carrick Scholes Lampard
Ronaldo Drogba Rooney
Front 3 all interchanging - only the right back is a weak point
wrong
trent would get raped every game
Ronaldo won 3 prems, a UCL, a balon d’or, had a 42 goal season and those aftv clowns are laughing at him being put in😭
Aftv clowns know nothing about Ronaldo
He rinsed them in the CL semi. That 40 yard free kick alone was humiliating enough.
Nobody is debating if Ronaldo was good but in terms of premier league, Henry was simply better during his time in it... Shearer in the Premier League was better than Ronaldo... not saying Ronaldo was bad but he wasn't in the league long enough at his peak!
@@MrBuurh but Ronaldo 2007/08 season beats shearer and Henry best season in epl that’s what I’m trying to say
@@tylergriffin2499 I don’t think it does
442: Wildcard (Spurs' Walker)
Kasper Schmeichel
Walker-Terry-Van Dijk-Irwin
Beckham-De Bruyne-Vieira-Ronaldo
Shearer-Henry
GK - Van Der Sar (United '08)
RB - Neville (United '99)
CB- Adams (Arsenal '98)
CB - Terry (Chelsea '05)
LB - Irwin (United '94)
CDM - Kante (Leicester '16)
CM - De Bruyne (City)
CM - Modric (Wildcard)
RW- Salah (Liverpool '20)
ST - Shearer (Blackburn '95)
LW - Henry (Arsenal '04)
I feel like this should be the team.
after this season haaland over shearer
Henry is the only player in the history of English football to record a 20/20 league season (to score at least 20 goals and recorded at least 20 assists)
He had 24 goals and 20 assists during the 02/03 season
Messi is the greatest player ever and he’s only recorded one 20/20 league season during his career (during the 19/20 season) he had 25 goals and 22 assists
That’s how difficult it is to do
Suarez did it in one season in Barcelona too. Maybe even Neymar when they had MSN. Those are the only 3-4 players that have achieved something like that in the top 5 leagues in the world i think. It is a travesty that they both did not pick Henry.
Imagine how immense Shearer would be in todays game. Guy was a machine.
Its always forgotten with Shearer that he wrecked his ankle ligaments in 1997 which destroyed his pace. Few people are old enough to properly remember him before then, but he was an absolute beast 1992-96. Utterly unplayable.
Shearer was shite
Kevin Nolan was the man
Cech (05)
Parker Adams (98) Stam (99) Robertson
Kante (16)
De Bruyne Modric
Henry 04 Shearer 95 Ronaldo 08
Cech
Parker
Adams
Van Dijk
Irwin
Kante
De Bruyne
Modric
Ronaldo
Shearer
Henry
I really enjoyed this. So much nostalgia. People under 30 have no idea how great the quality was back in the 90s and noughties.
Always one to look back with rose-tinted specs, the quality is always great there's legends in the making now, nobodies forgotten how good the quality was back in the 90's and 00's give up
@@stlmiles2000 People who lived through it haven't forgotten, but people who weren't around will never have a true understanding of just how great so many of the players at the time were.
@@Revelian1982 It is always hard to compare, but I am pretty sure many weren't as good as we give them credit, and some were better than we give them credit. It's all kinds of biases happening at once. Same thing with the current players. So, I think the debate will never end.
@UnKnown I'm just feeling nostalgic. You're probably right. But back then, players had fire in them and matches were like battles. Teams hated one another. They weren't taking selfies and swapping shirts at half-time.
@@Revelian1982 derbies were certainly far better then I'll give you that, quality wasn't far better tho
Ronaldo 2007/08 is the best player to play in a single PL season that makes him the best player end of story
facts, the disrespect
FACTS
13/14 saurez >>>>
GK Schmeichel
RB Neville
CB Terry
CB Adams
LB Robertson
CM Gerrard
CM Kante
CM De Bruyne
RW Ronaldo
ST Shearer
LW Henry
GK - Schmeichel 94'
RB - Trippier (Wildcard)
CB - Terry 05'
CB - Vidic 08'
LB - Irwin 99'
CDM - Kante Ranieris Leicester
CM - Veira 98'
CM - De Bryne Peps City
LW - Henry 04'
ST - Shearer Blackburn 95'
RW - Salah Klopps Liverpool
Never fails to amaze me how people act like ronaldo was bang average in his first spell at united 😂
@@dylanbyrne1265 he is agreeing with you
@@dylanbyrne1265 that’s my point
@@liveitwisely Completely misread your comment my bad lol
@@dylanbyrne1265 haha no worries
Ashley Cole walks in at left back
My XI - 1. Peter Schmeichel (94) 2.Kyle Walker 3. Ashley Cole (Chelsea) 4. Van Djik 5.Colin Hendry 6. Keane (99) 7. Kante (Leicester) 8. Viera (98) 9. Ronaldo. 10. Henry (2003) 11. Gareth Bale
Mine would have been:
GK: Petr Cech (Chelsea '05)
RB: Gary Neville (Man Utd '99)
CB: Tony Adams (Arsenal '98)
CB: Virgil van Dijk (Klopp's Liverpool)
LB: Denis Irwin (Man Utd '94)
CDM: N'golo Kante (Ranieri's Leicester)
CM: Kevin De Bruyne (Pep's Man City)
CM: Luca Modric (Wildcard)
RW: Cristiano Ronaldo (Man Utd '08)
ST: Alan Shearer (Blackburn '95)
LW: Thierry Henry (Arsenal '04)
-
Had to fit Henry in somehow
Haaland over shearer
The Gallas shout wasn't so bad actually
I've got to give it to Carragher, he's still somehow manage to downplay Ronaldo career. Henry better than CR7? my goodness 😩
I'm United fan and he is right. CR was great, but he had Rooney and Tevez who played for him while Henry was the main man. He is much better football player then CR
@@swvi9459 That's a WILD take. Henry had the one of, if not THE best midfield around him serving him the ball as well.
Carragher is correct in saying that Henry is the great PL player, because Ronaldo only had 3 great seasons and then moved on, while Henry had more incredible seasons.
But Ronaldo is obviously the better overall player. That's not even debatable.
And I am saying that as a French.
@@X5J2UY CR cant be a better player then Henry. CR doesnt have that level of technical ability
@@swvi9459 lol you're hilarious
@@X5J2UY And you are too young to even know who is Henry. You know him as "that guy in the suit"
BEST XI
GK: LLORIS (WILDCARD)
LB: IRWIN
CB: TERRY
CB: DIJK
RB: DIXON
CM: DE BRUYNE
CDM: KANTE
CM: KEANE
LW: HENRY
ST: SHEARER
RW: RONALDO
It's pretty bloody difficult.
Off the top of my head I'll go:
Schmeichel
Simpson
Terry
King (wildcard)
Le Saux
Keane
De Bruyne
Ronaldo
Bergkamp
Mane
Henry
Ancelotti’s 2010 Chelsea team should’ve been here, 103 goals in a season doesn’t get talked about enough
City centurions scored 106 goals, why the hell would Chelsea 2010 be there 😂
@@sp3ckedout224all while playing beautiful football too
@w7n690
3 games to go of that season there was only 3GD & 1point separating Chelsea & ManUtd after Chelsea cheated home&away in head-to-heads ManUtd would've already won the title & had better GD than Chelsea had they got what they deserved in those head-to-heads. It stayed 1 point the margin ManUtd won their last 3 games & added a further 7GD to their tally yet Chelsea in last 3 games gained a further 10GD on ManUtd which was fishy, Chelsea had everything on their side numerical advantages, fouls in build-up to goals unpunished, soft pens etc...given emphatic scorelines to help cover up the controversy of the title win. The PL wanted a new winner that year to prevent same champion 4 years in a row as it's branded most exciting unpredictable league in the world, same champion again makes it look boring.
It was also the first year ManUtd could go above Liverpool on total league title's hence Gerrard deliberately backpassing to Drogba on the penultimate game. Given so much help just to stumble over the line. ManUtd break a winning points margin record if given half the help Chelsea got that season.
ManUtd team of that season isn't "talked about enough" either, nor is the following season ManUtd who won PL at a canter and weren't far away from the treble. So why would Chelsea be?
@@w7n424 lol stfu you Clown, city still have 5 games to play 😂😂😂
@@FootkerSnookball Nobody’s reading that shit mate
Ashley Cole not making in to this team is criminal from both
He only nicked 1 title in 8 years at Chel$ea which was the bare minimum anyone could do.
Irwin was clearly better but Cole may have got in by putting Irwin RB but even then P.Neville should technically be ahead of Cashley as well. Double the PL titles & another who's good with both feet...and Evra was better than Cashley.
@@FootkerSnookball Holy shit this is a bad opinion.
@@shehrozamar4644
Evra & Cashley same age
Evra & Cashley played for ManUtd & Chel$sea from 2006 to 2014
Evra dominated the PL and beat Cole in the CL final 2008 and had the better game. I belive Evra was in more TeamOfTheYear's in Cashley's Chelsea days as well than Cashley.
Evra & Cashley both moved to SeriaA in 2014 and Evra continues to win the league while Cashley doesn't.
Evra made more CL finals, including for Monaco in the year Cashley's invincibles couldn't get past QF
Evra has got to a major final at International level, Cashley never got to a semifinal.
Cashley couldn't even win with the most famous team in the MLS.
@@shehrozamar4644 he’s an arsenal that’s why, He don’t like cole 😂
@@FootkerSnookball Deffo a salty Assna fan🤣
Schmeichel
Neville Terry Adams Robertson
KDB Kante Modric
Ronaldo Shearer Henry
GK - Alisson (Liverpool)
RB - Gary Neville (United 99)
CB - John Terry (Chelsea)
CB - Tony Adams (Arsenal 98)
LB - Ashley Cole (Arsenal 2004)
CDM - Keane (United 94)
CM - Kevin DeBruyne (Man City)
CM - Luka Modric (Wildcard)
ST - Alan Shearer (Blackburn)
RW- Riyad Mahrez (Leicester)
LW- Cristiano Ronaldo (United 08)
The rules make this very difficult. But for me, this is the most efficient combination.
Lampard should have been in. Either a Chelsea option or wildcard. Icon
Wildcard can only be from clubs not already included. They went with Spurs, but could've been any other club outside of the "big 6". A name that springs to mind is Payet.
People forget Ronaldo is the only player to ever win the ballondor in the prem along with 3 premier leagues in a row and a CL
Michael Owen won ballon dor when he was at Liverpool
Henry would won but it was robbed ,they gave that nedved guy
@@franedujmovic7091 'if'..Ronaldo 2008 season was better than any Henry season anyway
@@GoGetYourShinebox but he didn’t win fifa world player of the year and balon d or the same season did he
@@GoGetYourShinebox Only God know's how..
Love these videos man. And Jamie was right, it's literally a live version of twitter 😂
Peter Schmikhel 1994
Tony Adams 1998
Jhon Terry 2005
Denis Irwin 1999
TAA. Kloop Liverpool
Kante (Ranieri Leichester)
KDB (Pep’s Mancity)
Gerrard (Wildcard)
T. Henry (Arsenal 2004)
Ronaldo (Manutd 2005)
Shearer (Blackburn 1995)
Henry over Salah for me & then switch the wings with Cristiano.
Henry had a better PL legacy than Cristiano but not a better season than 2008
Henry barely played on the wings in the PL and the rules say that you couldn't change their normal position.
Salah is phenomenal. He gets in over anyone imo. Him and Ronaldo surely aren't debatable
@@jackcollins6218 No chance Salah gets in over Cristiano or Henry but everyone else, yes
@@TP-pq9xx Oh I didn’t realise that, fair enough
@@daany8700 salah easily gets in over Henry on the wing. You can't change the position of the player so it's salah no question for me
The disrespect on Ronaldo is mad. All you need to do is look at the stats from his first ballon d'or-winning season with us.
As a winger for crying out loud.
salah as a winger has better stats
@@RafPos13stats doesn't mean better player. Ronaldo did way more - dribbling, skills, chance creation, free kicks, headers, assists
Salah at his best season at Liverpool,,Salah don't win UCL,PL and balon'dor
I'm a ManUtd fan but it means nothing to me when I hear people say "as a winger" to try and make it sound more impressive.
He took pens, free-kicks, was in the box for corners and even when the starting lineup is mapped out with him supposedly on the wing, he always played a free-role he never tracked back he left big spaces for opposition to run into, didn't tackle, everyone else did his dirty work and he didn't put many crosses in like actual wingers do. I used to hate Thierry but he wasn't just individually brilliant he was a team player and would also congratulate the player who assisted a tap-in for him where as Cristiano would 9 times out of 10 run the opposite end of the pitch pointing to himself.
They were both ones for the gamesmanship hence why I've disliked both for large periods but can still gibe credit where it's due.
Cristiano has reached bigger heights as a player and 1of the reasons is Thierry was poor in the air but he was still a better PL player overall because he joined at a more developed age & played for more PL seasons. Cristiano had 1 better season but Thierry had 7/8 high level seasons. Cristiano had 1 very poor one (05/06), one ok one for his age (03/04), one not that good (04/05) 2 very good (06/07 & 08/09 although the latter he was a nuisance with his behaviour) and 1 magnificent (07/08).
Cristiano also had a more patient manager, I don't think Cristiano would've developed his game in other clubs especially Arsenal it was all about team play they were arrogant as a team but even their most gifted players didn't have individual egos. Thierry didn't need Arsenal to turn world class either he was already successful player for France, he became better while at Arsenal than the clubs he played for but that's just natural he joined them at age 22 & played for 8 years he's going to improve but he would've done so in other clubs where as Cristiano I think needed Ferguson&ManUtd otherwise he wouldn't have become a player he became statistically in terms of goals without a team willing to give him the chances he was given practicing on free-kicks for about 3 years before he even became good at them when there was better takers in the team, not having to defend and all sorts like that.
@@RafPos13 Ronaldo was a midfielder in the old 442 system which is pretty much a midfielder. Salah is a "winger" in the modern 433 wich is more of a forward/striker. Nice try tho.
😎 My Team ⚽ Schmeichel, Trippier, Ferdinand, Terry, Robertson, Kante, Scholes, KDB, Bergkamp, Henry & Shearer 🏆
Another best XI show, bloody hell.
Ancelotti's 2010 Chelsea would murder Leicester and Blackburn
That team is very underrated.
@mnb9162
No, that was the season Chelsea were given everything all season because the PL didn't want the same winner 4 years in a row it's branded most unpredictable exciting league in the world, same winner every year doesn't advertise that so they gave Chelsea all the decisions, favorable fixture sceduling etc...but they still only stumbled over the line by 1point and even that was because also Gerrard deliberately backpassed to Drogba on Liverpool's last home game because Liverpool didn't have anything to play for apart from preventing ManUtd overtaking Liverpool on league title's it was the first year that was possible.
And people don't look at the ManUtd team from that year or even the following season that they won at a canter as that great (even though their record was still very good) so for Chelsea to have to cheat against them home&away to only nick it by a point isn't impressive. The Blackburn team at least were competing with a great ManUtd team who also got a couple of dodgy wins vs Blackburn that season so it's more impressive if you've been unlucky in the head-to-heads and still managed to win the title because you've got a lot more work to do vs the rest of the teams & if you'd had the luck in those head-to-heads you could've won it at a canter meaning you were clearly the best team overall, rather than having to win/cheat vs the closest rival home&away just to nick it.
Leicester also took zero pts off 2nd in 15/16 and 1of the games they were unlucky to lose but they still won by 10pts so they were worthy winners plus the little amount they spent it would've been a great achievement for them with a tiny margin but we know how expensive Chel$ea's team was.
Chelsea 09/10 had to win by at least 12pts for me to even begin to justify being worthy of the title that year with the amount on their side but they couldn't even manage 2pt margin. Even that ManUtd 09/10 who at least "on paper" were the weakest they'd been for about 5 years after CR7 & Tevez had just left they still win that season by a record points winning margin if they are given half the help Chelsea got.
And ManUtd had impressive record vs the Top teams that season, the best record despite being cheated home&away vs Chelsea, especially Stamford bridge game ManUtd were by far the better team but ironically it was these head-to-heads that Chelsea didn't deserve anything from that won them the title.
How can they not include Thierry Henry on an all time XI list? He is the first name that you should write on your list
Well then you cant put Campbell or Vieira in, nor can you put Cristiano in the team.
@alperyldrm6385 what, ahead of PL, CL and Ballon d'Or winner Ronaldo?
fan debate is goated
Best team I can think of 3-4-3
Alisson
Walker
Adams
Terry
Beckham
Keane
Kante
Bale (Played LWB for Spurs)
Henry
Shearer
Ronaldo
If City win the treble this season you really need to do a treble winners XI btw
Trent should be the Liverpool pick. In the title winning season he was pfa young player of the year and was absolutely insane. Salah had his lowest scoring season at Liverpool and even Mane had a better year.
It's between Salah and Mane for me.
@@trekunda for performance in a specific season, id argue Trent, Alisson, Mane and even Fabinho were better than Salah in 19/20. And I love Salah but just saying.
Salah still made most assists of the front three and was vital for title. More than Mane.
GK - Kasper Schemichel
RB - Trippier
CB Adams & Terry
LB - Irwin
CM - Keane, Viera, De Bruyne
RW - Salah
CF - Shearer
LW - Ronaldo
Why does it have to be 4-3-3 ? The most title winning formation is 4-4-2 so I'd go :
GK - David Seaman (Arsenal 98)
RB - Kieran Trippier (Wildcard)
CB - Vincent Kompany (City)
CB - John Terry (Chelsea 05)
LB - Andy Robertson (Liverpool)
RW - Cristiano Ronaldo (Utd 08)
CM - Ngolo Kante (Leicester 16)
CM - Roy Keane (Utd 99) (C)
LW - Ryan Giggs (Utd 94)
ST - Thierry Henry (Arsenal 04)
ST - Alan Shearer (Blackburn 95)
Everyone keeps forgetting that Gary Neville was not only the main starter in one of the best teams in world football, but was also the captain.
To start for more than a decade in that United side is phenomenal.
Fans are so fragile it's embarrassing. "whERe's tHe pLAyEr fROm ThE tEaM i SUpPorT?!"
GK - K Schmichael - Leicester
RB - G Neville - Utd 94
CB - Stam - Utd 99
CB - Van Dijk - Klop
LB - A Cole - Chelsea
RW - Ronaldo - Utd 08
CM - De Bruyne - Pep
CM - Vieira - Arsenal 98
LW - Bale - WC
ST - Henry - Arsenal 04
ST - Shearer - Blackburn
Fresh take on dream team selections 👍
Ronaldos SINGLE 07/08 was better than anything Henry produced. PL, CL, Golden Boot, Ballon D'or.
Henry's Premier League career as a whole was better than Ronaldos.
Shout out to Tim Flowers from the Blackburn team 🙋♂️
Hard to pick a team without Henry tbh, but i get the rules
Just do Ronaldo shearer Henry front three
GK - Alisson - Liverpool 2020
RB - Kyle Walker - Man City 2019
CB - Tony Adams - Arsenal 1998
CB - John Terry - Chelsea 2005
LB - Denis Irwin - Man Utd 1994
CM - Michael Carrick - Man Utd 2008
CM - Luka Modric - Wildcard
AM - Dennis Bergkamp - Arsenal 2004
RW - Riyad Mahrez - Leicester 2016
LW - Ryan Giggs - Man Utd 1999
ST - Alan Shearer - Blackburn 1995
Here is my team:
GK: Cech(Chelsea)
RB:Trent(Liverpool)
CB: Adams(Arsenal 98)
CB: Campbell(Arsenal 04)
LB: Irwin(Man Utd 94)
CM: De bruyne(Man city)
CM: Kante(Leicester)
CM: Scholes(Man utd 99)
RW: Bale(Wildcard)
ST: Shearer(Backburn)
LW: Ronaldo(Man Utd 08)
Another very good team 👍
Obviously Buvey had to make it about himself
only way to not put gerrard in the team, otherwise he'd be one of the first names
Trueee!
My team:
P Schmeichel
Trent AA
J Terry
J Stam
A Cole
Viera
Modric
KDB
Mahrez
Shearer
Ronaldo
Think I’ve nailed it (4-3-3)
GK - Cech (Chelsea 05)
RB - Neville (United 99)
CB - Van Dijk (Klopp Liverpool)
CB - Vidic (United 08)
LB - Irwin (United 94)
CM - Kante (Ranieri Leicester)
CM - Viera (Arsenal 98)
CM - De Bruyne (Pep’s City)
FW - Henry (Arsenal 04)
FW - Shearer (Blackburn 95)
FW - Bale (Wildcard)
Boom.
Whatever the rules are, Henry HAS to be in that side - arguably the greatest ever player in pl history
Which Blackburn player do you go with? Maybe Shearer and Henry in a 442 ?
Could swap Mahrez and Vieira for Henry and Kante in Carragher's team.
So which Blackburn player do you swap out for Shearer then?🤦♂Tim Flowers????
@@mediacenterman8583 bossman, you can play with two strikers una
@@mediacenterman8583
Tim Flowers did play a key part in that title and he won Tournoi de France 1997 with England (playing in the 2-0 win vs Italy) as well as being in the England squad at Euro96 & WC98.
I've seen multiple people in these comments have chosen Nigel Martyn as their GK which is worse.
A PL title winning number 1 GK isn't too much of a drop off to allow the world's best outfield players in the team.
I saw another chose HenningBerg from Blackburn 95 quite clever because really you're putting him in as an ex ManUtd treble winner, that person also had Stam beside him.
No John Terry in Gary's team is absolutely criminal - 15 goals conceded all season and club captain for arguably the most dominant defensive campaigns in PL history. Feel he has to have his bias UTD goggles on considering they were his biggest rivals then - Terry has got to be one of the first names on this team sheet
Wasn't Gallas part of same team
@@WRNWRW yh...my point is how is that the player he's picked out from the team
Carvalho was better that season
I'm a Liverpool fan and Terry gets in all day long
@@RickJames-wf2rm English bias, carvalho was better that season
GK: K.Schmeichel 2016
RB: G.Neville 1999
CB: V.Kompany 2018
CB: J.Terry 2005
LB: A. Robertson 2020
CM: R.Keane 1994
CM: P. Vieira 1998
CM: G.Speed WILDCARD
RW: C.Ronaldo 2008
ST: A.Shearer 1995
LW: T. Henry 2004
Gk - Peter Schmeichel (1994)
LB - Ashley Cole (2005 Chelsea)
CB - Van Dijk (Klopp Liverpool)
CB - Rio Ferdinand (2008 United)
RB - Kyle Walker (Man City)
DM - N'Golo Kante (Leicester)
CM - Patrick Vieira (1998 Arsenal)
CM - Keane/Scholes (1999 United - couldn't decide which one)
LW - Thierry Henry (2004 Arsenal)
ST - Alan Shearer (Blackburn)
RW - Gareth Bale (Wildcard)
Should have had Rooney as wild card. When he went to Euros still on Everton’s books he was best European player at that stage and probably best in the world even at 18
Looool he was not best in the world in 2004. What weed u smoking. 04 Henry had lead arsenal to invincibles. Ronaldinho was ripping up the world. Zidane was still playing. The list goes on. You smoking rocks if u think Rooney was best player in world on 2004. Like seriously
They can't have rooney coz he played for man united, the wildcard had to be a player not from thr clubs already mentioned. It's why they were pretty much only considering spurs players for wilscard
@@thecro2060 y can they put spurs wildcard but not Liverpool?
@@mr__OK Liverpool won the league, that's why.
@Mr Ok Because the wildcard has to be from a club that wasn't listed at the start. Klopps Liverpool mean you can't have a Liverpool wildcard. Only reasonable option is spurs coz they haven't won the prem