Combined Manchester Derby XI | FA Cup Special Part 4
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2023
- In the final section of our FA Cup Special, we set the team on a challenging mission of selecting the ultimate all-time XI from the Premier League era Derby Day style, combining players from both Manchester United and Manchester City.
Representing the red side, Roy and Gary stepped up to the plate, drawing from their personal experiences alongside a host of incredible legends during their time at United.
On the blue side, Micah and Jill faced a similarly difficult task, having had the privilege of working alongside some incredible Man City teams and the not so incredible!
Let us know in the comments who make your Manchester Derby Day XI? 👇
SUBSCRIBE TO THE CHANNEL HERE
czcams.com/users/theoverlap?...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Follow us on social!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Facebook: profile.php?...
Twitter: / wearetheoverlap
Instagram: / wearetheoverlap
------------------------------------------------------------------------
#facup #manchestercity #manchesterunited - Sport
I love how Loyal Roy is. He'll slag the shit out of Gary but if anyone else has a go at Gary he'll back him and stand up for him
Just ask Vieira
Exactly
True Skipper
Just seems like a bitter old man who is stuck in the days when he played and nothing of note has happened since he kicked a ball...
Done a good job with Sunderland and Ipswich have done fuck all since he left. If he was English he would get Jobs. Just look at lampard done fuck all still gets jobs
"They'd be saying the same about playing with you" Roy keane so sharp with the quips
2 minutes in bro😂
He's Irish
3:08
He's not gonna shag you
@@IamTiernO more importantly, he's from Cork
Only Roy Keane could look someone in the eyes and tell them they weren't better than someone and the leave the person actually rethinking their decision.
100%!!😂😂😂😂
The silence when Micah said Joleon Lescott was super funny.
Cause Utds got at least half a dozen better CBs in Prem era lol. Bruce, Pallister, Stam, Vidic, Ferdinand, Brown
@@ffbear8078wes brown was never better then joleon lescott, the rest yes but not Wes brown
@callums3172 I was stretching it a bit to hit half a dozen but my point still stands with the first 5
@@ffbear8078 I agree 👍🏻
Yeah i think the 3 city players were lucky to be picked,utd had better players
Roy lowkey defending Gary hard.
So wholesome.
Make it sound like a romcom
@@manavsandhu584 no comedy, all romance
The Irish are loyal to the soil
Ofc since gary was way too humble and make himself looks average even tho he was not!
roy is a savage
Gary was far better than a lot of people give him credit for, including himself. Consistent, reliable, and had a brilliant read of the game. He was a winner. He's too hard on himself nowadays as he looks back in hindsight, and it runs the risk of misleading younger people who didn't get to watch him week in week out. Yes there were a few mistakes here and there, but if you're a professional for 19 years at any job, you're bound to have a couple.
100 percent agreed consist
Best right back prem has ever had up till now, some of these new right backs will overtake him before their careers are done but that’s more due to the position changing more than anything. If Reece James or Trent for example played in the 90s they would be centre midfielders.
@@TonyTynebridge yes your football knowledge is
100%. You can't compare him to any other RB in premier league history. In terms of longevity, professionalism, consistency, understanding of the game he's unmatched. And technically far better than a lot of people give him credit for, certainly better than walker
Also good at Cricket, not as good as Phil, who was a brilliant junior.
I love Micah energy but his football knowledge is shocking he’s picking Joleon Lescott omg 😂😂😂
even otamendi was better bruh
@@snazzy8767 💯
yaya over Scholes is an outrageous take
Yeah,i taught it was a joke at first,lescott ffs😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yeah,scholes over yaya all day,it should have all been a utd player,they were a better team
i love the fact that when micah says he was better than gary, gary is being humble and roy straight away defends gary and puts it very simply that gary was better
anything roy keane is in is absolute gold 😂😂
Kobe-Kawasaki,
over 2,5 goals odds: 1,90
Gary Neville has grown into one of the most underrated players in the history of the league. His crossing ability is criminally underrated.
Feel like he underplays how good he was himself, he could give himself some credit
Facts Neville was fucking class don’t even know how all this shit started think it was carragher who called him shit hahah he couldn’t lace Neville’s boots
Bang average
@@TonyTynebridge Who
One great United defender of the past that I think very many underrate, is Ronny Johnsen.
I must say I am shocked by how little United fans talk about how well he played for us.
Maybe the reason for that is that he is not British.
Gary Neville puts himself down a lot, a great legend and a serial winner
He’s not in the bracket of Walker
As much as Roy banters Gary, he's still there sticking up for him, telling him he was a good player and putting him in his team! Like a true Captain 💪😎
EDIT: Neville was a better player than anyone (even himself) gives him credit for, also very reliable and very seldom injured!
Very much an older brother mentality “I can take the piss out of him, but if anyone else does it I will go after them” lol.
Watching Roy's facial expressions when Micah speaks is comedic gold
Reaction of Roy and nev when micah said clichy and kolvarov was gem 🤣
Kobe-Kawasaki,
over 2,5 goals odds: 1,90
Micah was all over the place. Yaya over Scholes or Bruno is hilarious when he had two good years, then Aguero over Rooney/Cantona/Ruud/Haaland is stupid too.
@@D3_XT3R how is yaya over Bruno ridiculous?
@@D3_XT3R lmfaooooo you are genuinely dense if you think bruno is over yaya loooool. that's actually hilarious. aguero is absolutely over rooney, cantona, ruud, and haaland as a striker looool. stop being dense you absolute donut.
Love it😂😂
Gary was such a great player, his modestly ruins his reputation. Man was an amazing full back
Overrated
He was below average at best
He was tenacious and a hard worker, but ability wise he was bang average
Jill Scott needs to be a mainstay on this show for me,gels so well,makes great points every time,love a considered take
wtf dude, go home @@themanureplough3413
She's fabulous Very funny too and knowledgeable
Gary is extremely disrespected, Sir Alex had the ability to sign almost anyone he wanted and Neville stayed in that team for years and had brilliant performances against some of the best wingers of their generation.
Can you name any standout performances?
Because how humble he is, people are now underestimating how good he was
@John Shaw good defenders don't need stand out performances. They deal with the danger before it starts. Probably couldn't name an iconic Maldini performance.
People really overhyped last ditch tackles and chasing down players when in reality all that means is you've recovered from a mistake you made in the first place
@@shanginadildo you still getting turned on by van dijk?
@@shanginadildoit's very difficult to list big performances because it's difficult to define a big performance by a defender..we look at defence as a whole..so we take clean sheets as criteria..but there will be games where your right back keeps Mbappe quite but the others on the pitch give away stupid goals ...and they lose and as a whole that seems a ghastedly performance by the team..so we can take longevity ..as a good reflection...and the number of times you went invisible through games...works in favor on defenders...if they are not the talking points in post match analysis...means as a whole the team was clinical in defending!
“There’ll be saying the same about you” 🤣🤣🤣 Legend Keano 💪🏾
is Micah aware that Pep sold Yaya twice? To think he would pick him over Scholes is madness considering he pushed Yaya out to center back for an academy player in 2009
I think Micah is only aware of Micah
That was hate. Yaya was a beast. Did what he wanted in the middle controlling the tempo etc. too many man of the match and player of the yr. He was the heart of that team. I would go for Scholes but not disrespect Yaya
He sold Yaya once at Barcelona. Yaya’s contract ran out at City, at the age of 35. Pep did not sell him, and even triggered an extension on his contract. Also Yaya was never “pushed out to centerback”, he played the UCL final against United at CB, because Barcelona had multiple injuries at centerback. Also a reminder for you, Yaya won the trophy that day and completely pocketed the United attack. So much misinformation my guy… Such an L.
Yaya won them a league title one that one year. I'm not even a City fan but he deserves respect.
@SHERPHERD MASAKURE yaya was amazing but he had the ability to be so much better than he was if that makes sense. The likes of Keane, Scholes, Gerrard, Lampard, De Bruyne, Silva, Fabegas, Vieira were world class for years. Toure may have had the technical ability to have done what they did but the way things unfolded he just wasn't at that level as long as they were. Even if his prime was higher than all of them which you could maybe argue he'll never end up getting in these all time XIs. Obviously he's still an all time great but the reason people struggle to rank him is he couldve been the best of the lot but he didn't end up being that. I'd take Toure at his best over Silva and even De Bruyne but he wouldn't get in a combined XI unless it was literally "on their day who was the best".
Micah’s personality is keeping him in the job by a thread 😂
Some of his footie knowledge is shocking 😱
Awful representation for City man
Surely he should of put an argument for silva over Scholes. The guy won 2 euros and a world cup 😂
His personality is worse than his knowledge. A low iq mess
@@mikewazowski6292 Silva = overrated
@@mikewazowski6292 He barely played in their WC win. He was sat on his arse most of the tournament.
All the episodes this week have been brilliant. Fantastic camaraderie between the 4
Kobe-Kawasaki,
over 2,5 goals odds: 1,90
It feels like even gary has forgotten that he essentially made the full back role what it is today because of how good he was back then
Yaya Toure is so underrated, the man could do everything!! Ad he played his best football at City. Goals, defending, driving runs, free kicks!! What a player!!
He also won the treble in barca playing as a CB in ch league final
scholes is still miles better genuinely
Yeah, just cause he’s having an underwhelming season by the end of his career but he’s a roll royce, so elegant & dangerous
Scholes was 27 time the player. No doubt yaya was good, but that’s all he was with one outstanding season. Scholes was world class for 12
Roy Keane is brilliant
Honestly, we're all forgetting Tevez. Ronaldo, Rooney, Tevez up front (and count Tevez as a City player if you want) has proven to be devastating. That's a terrifying front line. Won the PL and CL and tore teams apart
Kobe-Kawasaki,
over 2,5 goals odds: 1,90
Tevez was better for City. This myth that Tevez was amazing for Utd is weird. He wasn’t even a set starter, played loads coming off the bench, at times looked incompatible with Rooney (due to similar styles) especially in his second year - coming from a Utd fan who remembers this period very well.
@@chriswolf1089 I agree, but I mean between Utd and City, he was better at City than Utd. But yeah, was then even better at Juve.
You are a joker
Nowhere near a combined 11 though.
Cantona, Cole, Ruud, Rooney, Ronaldo, Becks, Giggs, Aguero, Haaland are all there before Tevez
Why I love people like Roy, they will tear you to pieces 95% of the time, but the 5% when push comes to shove he has that pack of wolves loyalty.
For all the shenanigans that Roy threw at Gary this whole series, was quick to point out that he is better. That is what captains are made up of. ❤️
We had Irwin at the end of his career bout 38/39 I think and he was still unreal then ,absolute class player
He was great for Wolves.
Irwin. Shows up, puts in faultless shift, goes home and watches telly and looks after the kids. The number of interceptions he made in the CL final in 1999. Keane suspended, Irwin was drifting into midfield and sorting out Bayern.
@@stonecold6521 brilliant mate
@@RadioNul great player mate and like ya say does his job then goes home none of the bullshit with him
Brilliant Brilliant player..unbelievable..and a true gentleman into the bargain...I've never heard anyone say a bad word about him....what a player.
Roy Keane is absolute box office! 😂
Absolutely class. Jill's definitely a secret United fan 😂😂😂
She’s just appreciative of other players and she doesn’t have the biased glasses on
The quality of that midfield is unbelievable! Michael Carrick didn’t even get a mention
She said she'd played with Scholes 2 weeks ago and he's still as good ❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂
the toe nail eater still got it
What’s funny? She actually did play with him in exhibition match
@@mr__OK well derrrrr she isn't going to lie is she muppet
Dennis Irwin was such a great player.
Never injured, always fit
@@rottenpotato4733 ain’t it and look who was in that 99 team and he was taking pens for Utd 🤣🤣
As a Liverpool fan, have to agree, one of the best I've seen
@@RickJames-wf2rm yeah him and Ashley Cole are probably the best that’s been in the league
@@MJ-420. agreed
Gary Neville has struck gold with this format, I think Sky are going to end up buying the show out.
They already own it
@@craigchristian344 no they don't, this is Neville's channel, it's sponsored by skybet but Sky Sports doesn't have anything to do with it. Please don't talk about topics you don't understand.
@@brettpilkington9539 thick bellend lmao
And put thogden to host it lmfao
@@brettpilkington9539is that actually your name or do u listen to the podcasts😭
Roy Keane was like prime Vader. "I have altered the deal, pray I don't alter it further"
3:03 lmao when they explode into laughter! 😂😂I could watch hours of this.
Keano roasting Gary and Gary just taking it because he knows Roy is right lol
The fact that when you look back at Man Utd's PL era and Gary Neville is the only man you think of at RB, is FACT that's he's THE legend RB of the PL.
Thank you Jill for giving David Silva the the respect he deserves. An all time Great.
Content is better than anything on Netflix.
2:22 "Should've took you off at half time that night, bloody hell, felt like you've took a bribe" 🤣
Neville underrates himself so much, great player, great captain
That's a brilliant team.... But just imagine it with Haaland instead , like just the shear amount of goals that Haaland and Ronaldo would score is insane with De Bruyne and Giggs to supply them 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
"You look like you took a bribe that night" - Never change Roy, never change
Incredible. All these segments have been great. Could've listened to this for hours 😂
Even as United fan i love watching Jill tho. Her views on United players is remarkable. The way she would not write-off the players is a great watch. And Gary Neville surely one of the most disrespected RB in history tbf. Love seeing Roy backing him and still chose him for his team. Like a true captain he is. Great episodes all over. Overlap is great.
What a fantastic conversation. It's full of debate, some contention, good points by both sides. Really enjoyed this
Roy Keane bringing the Irishness out of him with the more of these overlaps coming out 🤣👏
Gary always plays down his achievements but he had a longer, more successful and especially more consistent career than a lot of supposedly best right backs. He played for United for almost 20 years and won 8 PL titles. Only two players have more, Scholes and Giggs. He also won the CL twice and appears on lists of top 10 right backs of all time, but not just in the PL, he appears in those lists with the likes of Cafu, Zanetti, Dani Alves and Lahm. Show some respect!
Keane is so bloody witty, his little one liners are hilarious
again , world class content , loving it guys. keep up the great work !
Legend has it roy and gary are still drinking their mugs of coffee
Need more of these, this is class Roy is phenomenal
Guys Dennis Irwin looked like an accountant...but gaaaaaad damn as an Arsenal supporter that man was underrated!!!
As a united fan glad roy backed nev i agree with what ppl said Gary was a very good full back kept it simple he was consistent.
This is awesome... 😂😂😂😂 I'm 2 years younger than the class of 92 I watched all the greats.. The United team back then was immense. I mourned for years when Beckham left GUTTED what a player he was. Was hardly ever injured as well.
Aw man when Beckham left it was like a death..madly underrated, his work ethic and commitment to the cause were second to none
@@Jimboslice35 totally mate Massively underrated
Roy little "awkward" comment on the midfield Dou debate is absolute gold
Jill has some really good football knowledge and is a great conversationist. Great guest
This line up is golden. Great chemistry
David Silva...so underrated.
Thinking exactly same, on top scholes never got 1 balondor vote 😅
I had a miniature figure of Gary too from the PG Tips back in the day haha. Had others like Zola, Campbell, Leboeuf, Colin Hendry lol
Micah saying pep would like Yaya he literally sold him twice 😭😂
Class was this. Hard to leave players like Pali and Eric out, on the other side Silva and Aguero too. Enjoyed it
Best show ever...should be on every month!!!
I think Gary has actually become underrated with time; I take him over Kyle Walker because he read the game so well that he didn't need to get into those mad 1-on-1 duels. No disrespect to Walker but Gary was the smarter player and he did very well in an incredibly stacked era against world class opposition for both club and country.
Kobe-Kawasaki,
over 2,5 goals odds: 1,90
Spot on. Micah’s argument of him playing in a great team is rubbish aswell. He played in a great team because he was a great player
He could also use his left foot unlike Walker
I’m a united fan but the best player I ever seen for city before there takeover was Kinkladze in fact I think he would be worth about 150m in todays market. No joke, the guy was a freak.
Kinkladze with good players around him would be amazing. He was up there with the best
Great point Kinkladze was truly superb....Elano for City was phenomenal for a good few matches, had he maintained that level consistently, it would have also been big-time
@@bermudafruitElano was way too inconsistent.
I always feel for Kinkladze for having to play in this rubbish City team of the 1990s. He was the only player out of the squad that got relegated in 1996 to come out with credit. Everyone else, average
Wazza was the most complete footballer I’ve ever seen
Lol you most not watch football.
@@nickjames1496 you must not have attended English classes
Blud said Lescott 😂😂
Never have I heard Roy Keane laugh like he does at 23:52… somehow makes him even more terrifying
14:40 even Roy had to chuckle at the thought of going up against Yaya lol He put up great fights againts Vieira but Yaya Toure in his pump was physically just a completely different beast. If he started his runs the guy was unstoppable.
Big Meeks is as loyal as Roy to his mates. Love it. And Jill is constantly trying to moderate a compromise.
😂 love the banter and vibes
Micah's mood is so infectious, amazing lad!
Micah is the definition of a great personality hire
Irwin was a brilliant player, he could pretty much play anywhere on the field. If he was playing today, he would be levels above anyone in the world
In defence he would be the best yes.
Yeah left or right and set piecces he was the bes
Roy needs his own show/programme
Micah's lucky he has a contagious laugh or he'd be nowhere near this table if it was based purely on how former players dissect and interpret the game
As much as Roy ribs Gary I loved that he instantly came to his defence when Micah said he was better than him with absolute sincerity
This was a high level segment! 👏🏾🤣
Micah is so deluded, it’s hilarious! Thank goodness for Roy 🤣🤣🤣
As a side note, Jill is also hilarious!
Goes to show how underrated Aguero is and he doesnt get the praise he deserves. Pound for pound Aguero has been the best ST in prem over the years despite his injury problem
We all rate him, its just that he's up against Rooney mate.... Who had everything a player could have
@@sergeantbarnes4109 if u still think Rooney was better, then u r clearly delusional as ever
I rate Aguero over Rooney
@@tauseeful Sure, delusional, Only has more goals, more assists, more trophies, even after having dropped deeper to a number 10 role, more goals for his country too... 😂😂😂😂 You are the delusional one, because that up there is just fact
@@tauseefulits you who delusional bro
A genuinely entertaining video, great chemistry across them all
Micah looks sick in a united shirt🤣🤣😭
Gary needs to be more confident of his ability when he played, unreal player one of the best full backs of the prem era. Just be more sure of yourself, don’t underplay how good you were…
Its because of Carragher he is this shy about his own abilities.
Carragher was England 5th choice
Don’t think Gary really cares. His medals are probably good enough for him
It's because he knows he's superior and has nothing to prove. Unfortunately carragher and Micha think they're on his level which is embarrassing
didn't want that to end! quality
This video is infectious 😂got me laughing throughout
“Let’s get the elephant out of the room I was better than you”- what’s scary is I don’t think Micah is joking.....
Utd fan here... I'll concede Micah's on his best day was individually better than Gary's but Gary had a lot more better days than Micah.. a lot more... It's becoming the biggest misconception in football that Gary Neville wasn't a great player
The disgust in Roy's face when he said that 😂
@@kieranguill4122 what? Who even was Michael Richards??? He was no one. Gary neville was a great RB people forget cause he wad surrounded by super stars how good he was
@@adolfryan1930 No idea who Michael Richards was. Micah Richards wasn't too bad though
@@adolfryan1930 I think you missed the point of what I was trying to say.. sounds like we are agreeing.
A whole week of Manchester Derby talks. Would love to see this for other Marquee games
Tbf there is literally no other games going on in England so they have to talk about this
@@Godofmanu Could still do it in the future for games throughout the year but it shouldn't be all the time cos then it's no longer special
It’s because it’s a final
Lol, wow just realized I've got those exact same mugs. Anyway, this is wholesome content!!
Kevin de bruyne on the right, silva in the middle, aguero upfront.
De Bruyne on the right is wasted there, I know he has played there at times, but he’s a central playmaker, you just have to have him in the centre dictating that midfield/play.
"I don't mean to demean or criticise any of the great or very good footballers who played for me during my 26-year career at United, but there were only four who were world class: Cantona, Giggs, Ronaldo and Scholes. "And of the four Cristiano was like an ornament on the top of a Christmas tree." - Sir Alex Furguson
That was fergie with an axe to grind.
All the players Ferguson got along with, giggs was never ever world class
Roy won Fergie all his titles but Fergie is too bitter to credit him
@@joshkirk3851 Giggs was never world class?
@daggaboom your never any sort of class, slamming your brothers missus, let be real
How can Gary put Walker ahead of himself. He is just underrated.
Walker is better man stop it
Walker the best rb in prem history bro 😂
Walker is arguably the best right back in the prems history. Gary isn't far behind though people forget how good he was.
@@samthomas2757lmao I’d take Ivanovic over walker all time
Walker is a good RB but not as good as Gary and Ivanovic. Gary was the first choice RB for England and Man Utd for 20 years can you say the same about Wlaker???
Roy keane is brilliant 😂
i can watch this all day 🙃
Wayne Rooney has to be there always. He scored the most goals in Manchester Derby history, and he also scored the greatest and most iconic goals in Manchester Derby history.
Well said.
Rooney is number 1 player on my team sheet
City will not only beat Real Madrid
City will blow them away
Rooney never said that for any Utd
Best PL Team - Utd,City?🤔
realistically De Bruyne is the only one that could get into an all time combined 11.
@@Nightsu Walker over Neville too in my opinion but yeah just him and De Bruyne
I didn't know Jill until today but I am sooooo in LOVE with her now. She is so wholesome.
Face like a bend shovel mind.
Wholesome is a good term. Seems humble to know she can't compete with opinions/knowledge like 99% of female pundits. Micha Richards is the exact opposite - completely clueless, but stays on TV because he's a laughing baboon with bantz.
She's great.
Overlap is the best thing on Sky!
Gary Neville was a great player. Too humble.
Micah tying himself in knots hahaha
It's hilarious that Micah Richards thinks he was better than Gary Neville is unbelievable! Gary was playing for England before Scholes and Beckham and in Manchester United first team before them and became captain, Neville was a brilliant player and Gary has to stop putting himself first and it annoys me that Jill thinks she can be disrespectful to him just coz his friends are, hate people like that join in but don't know you enough
Its because Carragher has made making fun of Neville popular.
Neville has 10x the legacy Carragher has
Someone is sensitive.
By your logic Micah is better then. Youngest defender to play for England. As a City fan I would never take Micah over Neville. But I would never take Neville over Walker. Walkers decision making and pace has been outstanding for defence to the point not many are succesful coming from that angle. Pep made the greatest team in football history with Barca and he may even do it again with Walker being part of that plan, put respect on his name.
This is awesome I love it