Nikon 50mm f/1.8G vs Nikon 50mm f/1.8D
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 10. 2017
- Nikon 50mm f/1.8G amzn.to/2wRCae4
Nikon 50mm f/1.8D amzn.to/2wRHSN6
Nikon F100 amzn.to/2wLeigf
Nikon D810 amzn.to/2htRuYN
Written review with sample photos
www.theupperleftusa.com/blog/...
Music:
TSUKI - Far
Want to support my work? Consider visiting my website and buying "Absolutely Nothing" www.HaiHoangTran.com/shop/abs...
or
Become a Patron!
/ haihoangtran
or
www.PayPal.Me/HaiHoangTran
www.HaiHoangTran.com
/ haihoangtran
www.Facebook.com/Hai-Hoang-Tr...
Official Merchandise - www.HaiHoangTran.com/Shop
My Camera Equipment
www.HaiHoangTran.com/blog/myc...
www.amazon.com/shop/haihoangtran
kit.co/HaiTran
Main Photography Camera - amzn.to/2wlpKgp
Main Videography Camera - amzn.to/2o3dRbl
Most Used Lens - amzn.to/2BG7nIX
Wide Angle Lens - amzn.to/2w5Dj4a
Wireless Mic - amzn.to/2xsv6q3
On Camera Mic - amzn.to/2dvPo6X
Video Head - amzn.to/2xsDohE
Tripod Legs - amzn.to/2kghrPw
Nikons with autofocus motor in body / Nikons that can autofocus with either lens: Df, D50, D70, D80, D90, D100, D200, D300, D500, D7xxx, D6xx, D7xx, D8xx, all flagships (D1, D2, D3, D4, D5). Models derived from those (e.g. D300/D300s, D3/D3x, etc.) also have AF motors.
Nikons without AF motors / Nikons that can only autofocus with the 50mm f/1.8G and NOT the 50mm f/1.8D: D40, D60, D3xxx, D5xxx.
I have a Nikon D7200, is it okay if I buy a 1.8 D?
I wish I saw this first before I buy 50mm 1.8D only to find out it wont be compatible with m D3500 😭😭
Sick, thanks for the info in the video and also this pinned comment, helped a bunch!
You're welcome!
How about the Nikon f100?
Brilliant review! Thank you so much. Loved the auto-focus noise test. I'm usually in quieter environments so this was REALLY helpful.
Glad you enjoyed the video!
Informative. I have both. Would say that 1.8D is significantly better for b&w, particularly on film (haven’t done any proper testing, opinion just based on results).
I've been using the 1.8D for film a lot lately and image quality aside, I just think that the 1.8D is a more flexible option for Nikon film shooters or those adapting the lens on other manufacturer's camera bodies. Having the aperture ring on the barrel just makes it usable on more bodies.
You are the best reviewer no body had explained this clearly thank you man 😘
You’re welcome and good luck with your lens 👍🏽
Thanks Hai. Great video for a beginner like me. Your comparisons are really helpful.
Glad the video helped you! Good luck with your decision 👍🏽
This was really helpful, I was on the fence about it, but I absolutely agree with you. Amazing video man, keep up the great work!!!
Thank you!
THANKS FOR THIS VIDEO! I have the classic 50mm 1.8 on my Nikon D750 and I LOVE this as an all-around lens...great info!
Thank you!
Good job on the review. The D seems to have slightly more contrast and slightly less barrel distortion in your samples. I’ve owned both and ended up keeping the D version because my Nikon bodies had focus motors and I don’t shoot video. I think if you have a consumer camera that doesn’t have an af motor or if you need the quieter af the G version is the better option.
Thanks for watching 👍🏽
Thanks for your honest analysis
You’re welcome 👍🏽
Hello! Your video helped A LOT! Thank you very much, greetings from Brazil!❤️🇧🇷
Glad it helped!
I’ve owned both the D lens is one of the sharpest lenses you’ll find. A must buy!
A great buy for the price!
This is the video that what I am looking for. Informative and straightforward.
Glad to hear it 👍🏽
Thank you so much! Now I am convinced that 1.8D is okay for beginners like me.
It's a great lens for anyone looking for a cheaper option 👍
Thank you so much for this vlog. Has answered which one to go for 👍
Enjoy the one you pick up 👍🏽
I like watching this review, straight to the point with honest opinion. Thank you
You’re welcome!
Thank you very much for this informative video! I am going to buy this lens for sure.
I hope you enjoy it!
Well explained. You cleared everything... Thanks man ❤️
You're welcome!
Nice video man! I just purchased the Sigma 18-35. A bit tired of the prime lens as I need to move my tripod for each shot I take. It becomes really cumbersome when I shoot outdoors during winter. Now I need to decide if I want to use it with my Sony A6300 with the MC-11 adapter or with my Panasonic G7 and metabones speed booster which is crazy expensive. What would you do?
Nowadays, I use primes almost exclusively for film and some street photography when I use digital. When I record videos, it's almost exclusively on the Sony 24-70 f/2.8 GM. Zooms are definitely more convenient. As far as your situation with the Sigma 18-35, tough call but I would personally use it on the A6300. I would take the money savings. The a6300 has a better focusing system but the G7 doesn't overheat. There's pros and cons to both but I would be more comfortable having the a6300 as a main camera between the two.
The Upper Left USA thanks for answer! Always appreciate your pro advice!
No problem! Let me know how it works out for you, whichever system you decide to go with!
The D series renders warmer colors. I do like how the sky looks with it. Nice review.
Thanks for watching!
Enjoyed your video, especially since I recognized from your pictures that you live in Tacoma, where I live too!
Thanks for the support!
Sup Mr Battle 😀
Good review, very helpful. Thank you!
You’re welcome!
I just picked up a mint in the box 1.8D because I'm looking for manual lenses that I can use on my Nikon F3 as well as my F90 and N90s. Thanks for comparing the two. Helpful.
Congrats on the new lens! I’m glad to hear that my video helped out, thanks from watching 👍🏽
The ability to work on your manual Nikons is a major bonus.
Good job, very informative and correct!
Thanks a lot for watching 👍
I have the D and it is superb. Really sharp especially at ~f4. I use it for film and digital. Unbelievable bang for your buck.
Glad to hear the lens is working out for you 👍🏽
From the reference shots you displayed, the colours seem slightly different, and the D looks slightly darker too, but in shooting RAW that difference is eliminated
Buying a 1.8D for cheap on Marketplace today for my D3200. There’s no AF on my body so ofc it’ll be all manual, which I’m looking forward to given that I’m buying the lens for portraits. Great video!
Good luck with the lens 👍🏽
The D has an aperture ring that I prefer and the colors seem to be warmer with less contrast. Highlights don't seem to be as washed out with the D version. I prefer the D for those reasons.
Sounds good 👍🏽
I also do, but that's maybe because i own one myself
I just bought one yesterday. Did the autofocus noise ever annoy you?
Thank you so much for this video.
You’re welcome!
Thanks for this. I'm torn between these two. I will be getting the D, since I'm only a hobbyist. 👍
Both are great lenses so don’t stress too much 👍🏽
D lens can be used on a Nikon D90 right?
@@johnny_bravo9990 yes
the f/1.8D is perfect for reverse lense macro photography since it still has manual aperture and has great image quality, especially for the price
Yes, very versatile and hard to beat for the price.
Good stuff. Thank-you for this.
You're welcome!
Thank you so much ♥ this was so helpful
You’re welcome!
Thank you so much for a video that clearly explains the differences. I already have the 50mm 1.8D that I was using with my D3300; I was wondering if, since I bought the D750, I would need a better 50mm. As for the slightly different exposure between the two--that can be fixed in Lightroom. For now, I will just stick with what I have! : ) Thanks!
You're welcome! I would agree that if you already have the 1.8D, there is little point in getting the 1.8G. Save the money and use it for a little trip that could get you some interesting photos 👍
Hey Tess, I'm considering buying the 1.8D over the 1.8G due to price. I also own the D3300. Would you agree with that?
And how easy was it to focus? No autofocus right?
@@danocreations no autofocus on the 1.8D with the D3300
Man what a great review good info do you think I can use the 50mm D lens on my Nikon D3500
Glad the video helped you! Also, take a look at the comment that I pinned on this video. I think that should give you the answer you’re looking for.
No d3500 doesn't have AF motor in camera body.so you can use it just . manually
I have both. Hard to use but great for astrophotography
@@jeepjoseph9036 do you have the D lens on a nikon 3500??
really nice video! going to buy the D version.
Hope it works out for you 👍🏽
Thanks. This video helped a lot.
You’re very welcome 👍🏽
Nice info bro... Ive learn something from this video... Thanks
Glad to hear that!
I also noticed the exposure difference between the two. Looks like maybe the G would perform better in low light conditions slightly. When I look at your images it looks like the colors on the D are more saturated and the micro contrast is better. In summary I think your conclusion is right on.
Like I said, light transmission could’ve been lighter/darker with one of these lenses just in this instance. There is no way of telling if one is transmitting more light without testing multiple of the same lens.
Herbert Solliday the D is a lower T stop lens and benefits from about +1/3 stop exp comp. and yes the micro contrast is definitely better on the d
hello! any suggestion of what lens would work better from these two for nikon d3400? i know nothing about photography yet and just starting to learn. thanks
If you want autofocus, then the 1.8G ( amzn.to/2CojCXA ) would be the only option. The 1.8D won't autofocus on the d3400.
Great video. I just got my f/1.8 G lens. Hopefully it will perform well for street photography
Good luck!
Hai Tran Hmm....Thanks. This is my first prime lens. Do you think I’ll have problems?
You'll only get as far as you put into it I suppose. There's plenty of potential but at the end of the day, it's the user not the lens. The lens is only a lens.
Hai Tran Thanks.
You’re welcome.
Awesome video! Thanks for you opinion & information! Do you think you can make a video or just drop the other lenses you use with your f100? I'd love to know which others I should look forward to buying! (Would also appreciate community input) thanks!
I think the other lens that I use with the F100 is this one: amzn.to/3HvOju8
I sold the F100 some time ago but those should be the only two lenses that I used with it.
Nicely reviewed will buy 1.8G
Awesome! Hope you enjoy it 👍
I got the 1.8d brand new because it's a lot cheaper and it has warranty. It's plasticky but I would say, after 3 days of use, it's actually sturdy! It's also tigh on the mount. I thought I would break lol. Also, I love the fact that I'm using it fully manual because I have a D3400. The lens is working perfectly but as a beginner, I should stop using F/1.8 because I'm still terrible at finding the right focus! It's always not about getting the shallowest depth of field, people!
Glad you’re enjoying the lens 👍🏽
Use it for potrait mainly
Hey, I have a d3300 and I am thinking about the D version since it is so cheap. Do you find the manual focusing annoying? Does it cost you to miss shots? Any feedback is welcome :)
2:58 if you switch the camera to manual focus, the AF screw drive retracts so you can manually focus
Superb video, Keep it up
Thank you very much 👍
Great video!!! Do all D and G lenses go with the Nikon F100?
I'm not sure what you're trying to ask here.
The lens over your right shoulder in the background, is that the Tokina 100mm F2.8 macro? Looks like the new one too with the all black styling.
I believe you are referring to the Sigma 35mm f/1.4 ART. This lens amzn.to/3co10qZ
Good Info Man
Glad the video helped you👍🏽
I bought the D lens because it was cheaper and sharper. But also seems to have less distortion but more vignetting. The ‘exposure’ difference might actually be down to different coatings on the lenses perhaps.
For the price, it’s definitely hard to beat 👍🏽
Thanks for this nice video. Currently deciding between these two( can not find $60 deal for 1.8D). Do U live around capitol hill, if so, can I meet and borrow the 50mm 1.8D for a try, I am a lil concerned the softness with Aperture 2.0 and 1.8. Also the flare issue.
Unfortunately, I don't go around Capitol Hill that much anymore. I won't be back in the Seattle until around January or so. If anything, you can just hit up the local Best Buy. The one in Tacoma had all the Nikon 50mm lenses the last time I went there. That's how I tested everything out.
Thanks for reply. I will give that a try.
Good luck! 👍
Bro great vid ...I've just bought a D3200 what do you think if I'm shooting video? The G ? ...
That really depends on you. Read the pinned comment under this video to help you decide.
Great bro
Thanks 👍🏽
Thank you!
You're welcome!
If we'll shoot a video from both lenses, which one has a faster autofocus adjustment time?
Ty and more power sir!
The difference seems pretty negligible to me.
Hi! I am considering getting the 1.8g lens and I have a d3000, do you know if it will autofocus with that body? I have the 1.8d right now and I have to manually focus it
Read the pinned comment under this video.
but the Nikon autofocus noise itself - isnt it dependent on the camera built-in motor?
Yes and no because some of these body autofocus driven lenses are definitely noisier than others.
Very helpful
Glad to hear it 👍🏽
LOVE my 1.8D AND the noise is reassuring.
As long as it works for you 👍
Hey, I have d7200 with which I would like to make videos not interested in photography much, so for better quality videos which one u suggest d or g??
Like I said in the video, I think they’re pretty much the same in terms of image quality.
Great unbiased review, thank you very much. I will also probably choose the D version now, and maybe go for the G later. Thx :)
Awesome! I hope it works out for you 👍
Bellissima recensione.
Thank you!
Thank you
You're welcome Paul 👍
I like them both and are both lens pics are unedited?
Yes, they are.
Hi, Can you suggest me a best Nikon full-frame DSLR from D610, D800, and D810?
It depends on what you need. The D800 and D810 clearly have more resolving power, so if this is what you need then the D610 is out. I personally own a D810, which was just about the best at the time of release. If the price is a concern, the D610 will likely be cheapest and D810 most expensive. If it were me, I'd buy the D810 but again, I have no reference to your situation.
So just to be clear, if I want auto-focus, I'd need to get the 1.8G for my d5600?
Yes
I've had my camera nikon D5100 since 2013, mostly using it for fun. Now, I'm diving into photography more seriously, especially in commercial photography. However, I'm finding that my 50mm f/1.8D lens requires constant focus adjustments, which is becoming a hassle. Can anyone recommend a lens for my camera that would solve this issue? Your help would be much appreciated
Just got the 1.8 D but I even like the pics you took with it better, but thanks big dawg...
Hope it works out for you bro 👍🏽
Which should i buy for night photography without any lighting setup?from which lens i can get more blur?
.
Answer please sir.
If those are the things that you're worried about then it won't make much of a difference which you choose.
can u plz tell which will be better for Nikon d5300?? plz do rply
If you want autofocus, then the 1.8G ( amzn.to/2CojCXA ) would be the only option. The 1.8D won't autofocus on the d5300.
Very good video
Thank you!
Nikon 50mm f/1.8D only manual if i use the D3500 OR D3400 right
Question: I have Nikon 50mmm f/1.8 D , when I take a picture with Nikon D5500, I can not set the lens to F1.8 ? It's locked. I have to unlock and turn to f22. Can you help. Thanks,
That’s what you have to do. Set it to f/22.
i own a 1.8d and planning to buy a 1.8G what can you say shoud i buy or choose orther lens tnx been using it quite a while now and its good
My answer is essentially given in the video.
The 1.8 D can be a little bit slower with AF, and shooting in the dark if there is any pointy lightsource, the inside of the lens will reflect that weird spots on your sensor. The G is more money, but it’s a better choice for me. The 1.8D has one benefit: it goes down to f22, while the G is only to f16. :)
As long as you know why you’re buying it 👍🏽
what a cool review loved it hey man do you think this lens woould work fine as a zoom Lens (no VR)
No, it wouldn’t work as a zoom lens because it’s not a zoom lens, it’s a prime.
@@HaiTran yeah but it is 50mm like 18-55mm kit lens right
No, it’s not. You should look up the difference between a zoom and prime lens. This seems to be information that you need.
@@HaiTran ok thnks for the info
@@HaiTran Nikon F100 do you have a review about that camera?
Thanks for this video man. I am thinking of buying the D5300 and it sucks that it doesn't have the auto focus motor, but the price difference between those 2 lenses is even bigger in my country, soo.... :)) Also I probably will mainly end up shooting indoor still videos, so I wouldn't really need the autofocus....... right? :D
If you know that you can live without autofocus then the price difference definitely makes the 1.8D a good buy 👍
Thanks, man. What do you like the most about the auto-focus on a 50mm? In what kind of situation do you find yourself using the autofocus on a 50mm the most often? Like when you are taking quick photos? Or when my mom wants to take a photo with it? When is it most usable?
I don't think those questions make much sense. I think if you have a lens that lets you autofocus, you'd likely always use autofocus unless there are specific situations that you'd want to manually focus. There's little point in buying an autofocus lens to manually focus since it's not optimized to do so like a manual focus only lens.
Thanks, I guess I wanted to ask in which case you'd miss the auto focus the most... but you answered that anyways. Thanks, man, appreciate it!
You're welcome! I hope whatever you chose works out for you 👍
I have a Nikon D3400 , will autofocus work on the 1.8D or do I need the 1.8G
Check the pinned comment for this video.
Can I use 50mm f/1.8D at Nikon D3300?
Does it support autofocus or use it manually?
Read the comment I’ve pinned.
Beginner question here: if I have Nikon D3300 and I buy the D version and I use manual mode on my camera, it does focus right? I have a hard time understanding the focus part. Because without focus, it would be useles.to try and take a photo. So if I use manual mode, I will get a sharp focused image?
The lens will focus on whatever camera you can mount it on, it’s just a matter of you wanting autofocus or not.
@@HaiTran hmmm, I think that I don't know very well what autofocus is then. I thought that is was the ability of the camera to just focus... by pressing the shutter of course. I will have to also study.this
What you are referring to would essentially be autofocus but yes, I would suggest studying up on the equipment to be able to better use it.
How about Auto Focus SPEED?
Cheers for the informative video
I personally see no discernible difference.
@@HaiTran thank you very much, Hai!
No problem 👍🏽
Good work. Thanks. I prefer the D, but only with the right camera.
The results looked similar to my tests with the Nikkor 28-105mm 1:3,5-4,5D vs Nikkor AF-S18-105mm 1:3,5-5,6G Also here, I prefer a little bid the D.
Both are very capable in the right hands. Hope you enjoy your lenses 👍🏽
I have D5300
what should i get?
I am not a pro so i usually shoot in Manual settings but Auto Focus
Look at the pinned comment. That should give you a good starting point for consideration.
So i guess the G
Thanks
You're welcome 👍
I just bought the D lens for my D3500 nikon. I thought it would auto focus but I don't think it does. Is that correct? Is the G-lens the clear choice if I can't auto-focus with the D lens? Thanks for your help!
Check the pinned comment of this video. As far as the clear choice, it just depends on what you're looking for.
@@HaiTran Thank you! I guess I'm assuming it would be a clear choice that I would not want to manually focus. Maybe some photographers don't mind that challenge.
Manual lenses exist for a reason 👍🏽
As I heard D 610 has some noise issue on the image, I think 800 and D810 are better.What is your view?
Like I said, I own the D810. I can’t speak for the other cameras as I’ve never used them.
Okay, Is this D 810 a powerful DSLR?
It was the highest resolution full-frame DSLR when it came out so it is more than enough for most applications that required the resolution. That's why I bought it and I was happy with what I got.
can the filter lens of AF NIKKOR 50mm 1:1.8D be removed when damaged?
What filter lens are you talking about?
Will it work better using this lens nikkor f1.8D to my nikon d7100?
Depends on what you're looking for. Read the pinned comment.
i have a Nikon d7200 which lens do you suggest I should buy?
Watch the video. I gave my thoughts on both lenses.
Nikon D3****, D5**** users go for G for Auto Focus capability... never had the G but...
i have D onboard D5500.. i love the contrast :)
it has manual aperture, reverse it and, dang! a macro lens!
Good to hear that you're enjoying the lens 👍
Will the autofocus meter of my d3300 just kick in? When I mount the lens or need I set up something for the aperture ring?
What?
@@HaiTran like just wanted to know if autofocus would work on my crop sensor beginner body d3300
Read the pinned comment under this video.
I have had both. After a while using G and D , I decided to sell G...even if I think G is a little bit more sharp at large apertures. From 2.8 the two lenses have the same image quality level, as you are saying in your good video
Glad you found the one that works for you. Personal experience trumps external opinions any day 👍🏽
I'm not sure why people are saying the D has better contrast, when the Contrast on the G looks quite a lot better. The D looks as if you took a picture with your mobile phone, where the lighting & contast on the G looks as if it's from a professional shoot.
To each their own. Just buy the one that works for you.
I was confused wch 1 to buy bt ur suggestion realy helped me ....I will go 4 1.8d ...Thanks bro God bless u
You’re very welcome and enjoy the lens 👍🏽
In some instances the 1.8D is prefferable because of the apparture ring. It works great with my Nikon PS-4 slide copier - just make sure you bulk up because that is a HEAVY unit that is built like a battleship
There’s a time and place for everything 👍🏽
Which better on nikon d3100?
Read the comment I’ve pinned in this section and I’m sure that’ll decide it for you.
Well D version has better image contrast. I’d use it instead for that reason.
Yes, use the one that works best for you 👍
nice! thankyou!!!
You’re welcome!
Your tests show the same as my pre d lens. The old one needs about +1/3 exp comp. The old one has better micro contrast giving better depth to the photo. And it's even a little sharper than the g lens. It's a bit warmer than the g lens but that's ok and can be cooled a little in post if needed.
By pre d, are you referring to the manual focus lens?
The Upper Left USA No the pre d is autofocus the same as the d. I will have to research the difference between the pre d and the d but I seem to remember being told in the past the pre d is exactly the same except it does not have a contact on it to transfer flash info or some useless feature like that.
Never mind, I know exactly which lens you’re talking about.
Will both of these fit Nikon N90S Film camera? If so which one would you prefer?
They’re both F mount lenses so they’ll both fit. As far as which I prefer, that was featured in the video.
@@HaiTran Thanks Bro! Much appreciated!
No problem 👍🏽
I have a Nikon D200, and I'm about to purchase the 1.8D
Hope you enjoy it 👍🏽
@@HaiTran I will.
That’s good to hear.
I have a Nikon D5100 so I have to get the 1.8G if I want to get the auto focus function
Read the pinned comment under this video.
I am lucky I have both and I use both still though I do prefer my afs G lens
Whatever works 👍🏽