Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Black Bay 41 (Both Black Dials w/ Nato)
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 12. 2021
- M79230N-005
41.2mm case
15.9mm thick w/ nato
49.9mm lug to lug
22mm lug width
200m water resistance
Cal. MT5602 w/ 70 hours power reserve
M79030N-0003
39mm case
13.2mm thick w/ nato
47.8mm lug to lug
20mm lug width
200m water resistance
Cal. MT5402 w/ 70 hours power reserve
I have the 41 on bracelet and luv it
Just got the 41 and it is a thick watch at about 15mm but it really doesn't feel thick at all. The lugs do turn down slightly which I'm sure helps. Overall very happy with my purchase.
I'm wearing my 3 year old 41mm right now. Over The years I've heard of some reliability issues with the newer, smaller 58 movement. I'm very glad I have the 41 rather than the 38. It wears very comfortably with the steel bracelet and the size of the case has never been an issue.
Beautiful watches, When I first bought my 41 I was thinking maybe should have been a 58; but for a tool watch (Diver) I think the 41 is the one to have, the 58 is a desk/office diver and is more 'dress' watch,; with your 6.75" I still think the 41 looks better and I have a 7.5" wrist. I prefer the contrast of the non gilt dial it looks much better and mirrors the vintage models.Just love the black dial and rose gold great combo stylish and purposeful.
Thanks for viewing!
I am looking to buy a black bay and your comment is spot on. After what seems a lifetime of research and reading too much on these pieces, I started to believe that the 58 would be better and the 41mm was just too big. However, I finally got to try both (on my 7.25" wrist) and although both wear amazing, the 41mm screams more tool watch and has more presence on the wrist (something I like). The 58 just felt too light and a tad delicate. The 41mm was not the beast/chunky/super tall/slab monster that people love to call it, it wore beautifully and with purpose.
I have and love my 41 I have 7.25 inch wrist and found 58 to be too small.I prefer white contrasting bezel txt 👍
Thank you for this video
You bet, thanks for viewing!
I tried on both sizes and bought the 58. It is one of my favorite watches and I wear it daily. I love the gilt bezel. I wear mine on the Tudor leather strap. The 41 is too tall and slab sided for my 6.75" wrist.
I would love the 58 bezel on the 41
Had the 41mm one in this colour and sold it for a blue 58. The 41mm is much too chunky. If the 41mm had the 58 movement and then the 58’s thickness it would be massively better. Look at the massive step between the lugs where the nato goes under the watch😬 it’s not very nice 🤦🏻♂️
BBB 🔵 41 Eta, 🙂 on steel bracelet, I like it on nato as well.
If the 58 had a non gilt bezel, it would wipe the floor with the whole brand and some Rolex too.
How hard can it be for Tudor to put the same thin mt 5402 movement in that 41 mm case?
Make it 49mm L2L, 21mm lug width and 12mm thick, please. Thanks.
The 41 actually looks better on you dude - sometimes bigger really is better I guess.
The 41 wears much better for me on the black Rubber B strap….particularly with the Tudor clasp from my leather strap. With a 7 inch wrist and the failing eyesight of the typical 70 year old I find the dial easier to read than my Daytona panda….more like the easy read on my Datejust2. The Tudor 41 BB is my lap swimming buddy.
I hope this may be useful to someone. I tried on both Black Bays today. I have a 19.5cm wrist and it was immediately apparent the 58 looked quite small. Feminine almost. On trying the 41mm Black Bay, my first thought was that's more like it. But you can't ignore how warm the 58 looks with it's 'bronze' (possibly beige, but that's not a sexy colour) markings on its bezel compared to it's larger brother. 2.46. You aren't crazy. Needless to say I had to walk away as I still can't decide which way to turn. I hope you enjoy your watches as much as I do.
My man came in here with a 7.7 inch wrist acting like the 41 wasn't the immediate option lmao.
@@Nick-fb4vv you may do what you will with your own arse. The hopefully helpful point I was making was don't listen to the hype, make your own mind up and buy the watch you like not the watch people tell you to buy. I ended up buying the Pelagos x
@@skullduggerysmiles8393 It's alarming to me that you took anything I said as negative hahaha. Go outside and get some sun, everything is going to be okay.
@@Nick-fb4vv not at all Nick, just a friendly bit of banter between the lads. As for the sun, I wish, it's not due to be seen here again for the next 6 months. Love, peace and happy horology.
Contrast bezel much better on the 41 for me - more like the Sub 6538
I actually own the S&G with the champagne dial. Looking to eventually get the 58 blue.
Love the champagne dial. Enjoy wearing it!
I just bought the champagne S&G and it comes in the mail tomorrow. I can’t even tell you how excited I am.
Below 7 inches go 58. Above 7 go 41.
Your comment, one year later just sold me on the 41 as my wrist is over 7 inches. Thank you so much for your input 👊🏽🇺🇸
41 looks more masculine on you thus looks slightly better than the 58.
I've got the 58 in blue and think the bracelet is the way to go. Nato makes it too thick
15.9mm thick on the 41 with the nato is obnoxious.
if only the 41mm has less thick body, it'd be very nice to me
58 guild would work for me
I had the 41 and sold it for the 58.
Me too…had the 41 GMT and sold it for the 58. Night and day difference in comfort.
Me to. Got the 58 in blue. It’s such a better watch.
Sold me 41 for a 58 but kept my GMT, can’t part with it. Been on the waiting list for the FXD 18 months now! Crazy!
Anyone have the 41 and want to trade for the 58 black. Feels the 58 is too small for my wrist. I'm in Houston.
I don't know if this message is getting across since I was putting my email in and CZcams might delete it but I have a black bay 41 with a black dial on a steel bracelet and I would be very interested in trading. I live in Tucson. I purchased mine about a year ago. I don't think CZcams lets you add contact information but we can work something out if you want. Reply to me if you're interested.
BB58 felt a little small on wrist the bb41 is really too thick on wrist. I’m actually leaning 1926
Bb58 is way nicer!
Guild works better for me.