Why Twitch is Better Than YouTube… For Now.
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 10. 2022
- subscribe so susan doesnt fire me
follow me on twitter ► / ludwigahgren
follow me on tiktok ► / ludwigahgren
follow me on instagram ► / ludwigahgren
join my subreddit ► / ludwigahgren
LINK TO EVERYTHING ► wlo.link/@ludwig
edited by: one take jake
The pages for finding streams is definitely something that CZcams needs to work on the most and make simpler
Nostalgia guy 😢
Yeah 100%, most of the livestream pages are full of random streams, especially Minecraft with those Monster Highschool streams.
yoooo sb
for real i cant even find the live button
hi sb
The one thing that shines through in all of these videos is how passionate Lud is about improving CZcams as a streaming platform. I love how passionate he is about this.
who is lud
@@TomPi142 exactly, I only know Mogul Mail
very passion
also dont forget about how passionate he is
@@Tigeradvenchrer ya same, who is this lud person????
the fact that they still call it CZcams Gaming is proof they are years behind
Soo..... What should they call it ??
@@user-pn7un8vu6e Live?
@@user-pn7un8vu6e a large part of twitch streaming is the IRL section, not just gaming
Same problem with Meta: Facebook gaming
@T1J
Sorry If I'm wrong but wernt you like a libertarian or something a few years ago, apologies if I'm wrong.
It's funny because Ludwig is right and wrong at the same time about the first stream he sees (Kiara). She is not a Japanese streamer and streams almost exclusively in English, but her channel's region IS set to Japan just like every Hololive channel regardless if they stream in Japanese or not, so it actually SHOULDN'T be showing up in the tab for his region.
My educated guess is that the algorithm finds that she has a large US based viewers despite her channel is set to Japan region so it decided to show her stream on top.
"Oh, this 'Japanese' channel is viewed by people in your region so much, maybe you'd be interested in this channel" kinda thing.
@@cabbage_cat It says outright, right on his screen: "Sorted by most viewers in your region"
The sorting feature (at least in this instance) is clearly working as intended, and Ludwig is completely misinformed in this example.
@@SeeMyDolphin that confirms it then, what I would say is that it's a really cool algorithm to find what's popular on your area
it's a cool variable aside from sort by view count, category, etc
Probably has to do with ads. Geico and Nvidia don’t wanna spend money on impressions that go nowhere.
you mean mogul mail?
As a more passive viewer that only goes on streams to watch what is going on without ever chatting, I find CZcams way better just for the video player. Being able to pause, go back and resume where I left, even on my phone, and without addbreaks is so much more enjoyable.
idk, it annoys me more than it helps. If I quickly join a stream that is essentially a podcast, and I want to watch the whole thing later, it starts later and often resets to that point when you reload.
Despite the higher bitrate, image quality is also worse thanks to youtube's compression
@[卐]Lakehuntist ⸜⁄ you sure are kid now go back to nursery and stop typing on internet
Agreed. I find that yt has always been better to view things from than twitch. Only thing Twitch has on yt for the watching experience is the small tab video thing on mobile for free which yt makes you pay up to use. Though Twitch with its 4 30 second ads kind of negates the joy of that
Yeah, I tend to struggle with hearing things properly, so being able to go back a couple seconds and hear the funny joke I didn’t understand is a lifesaver
@@grimmb3686 literallyyyyy I am so slow and I need to rewind 😂
CZcams should hire this guy, he seems to know a lot about streaming
Facts I love my guy mogul mail
actually, i think the streamer ludwig is more experienced than this guy
Not just companies like YT/Twitch but all companies need harsh criticism to always do better. We love to hear and talk about the good points but never the bad points. These kind of comments is what can make a platform better and improve what is currently in place. So I do agree with you, YT should have Lud as a board member or give him better incentives because of his criticisms that can help YT or any other platform be better.
He doesn't want to work for yt. You don't actually know him, do you? Hire him for what?
@@moxiemaxie3543 I think he only said that because CZcams is so not in touch with what everyone, viewers and content creators alike, wants and needs. It really feels like they're not giving much to hear the voices of what runs their company.
All of KFP showing up to tell Lud that Kiara speaks English is funny
Deadass I was cringing so hard when he said japanese 💀💀💀
@@LemonCloud420 All of hololive channels are set to japan. So he is kinda right, its based on what your region is watching not only show channels from your region
@@jackg6887 yeah I guess but all of hololive EN I would say is definitely geared toward an English speaking, western audience.
I'd like to think Kiara would deem it a compliment to be called Japanese.
@@LemonCloud420 ....exactly that's why they show up on western CZcams despite being set to a japanese channel
It still boggles my mind that CZcams has yet to make a livestreaming section next to the shorts and the explore page, if they did that it would truly be the beginning of the end for Twitch.
Lud's actually doing everything he can to bring about the best experience for his audience and other streamers of the platform. CZcams's gotta really thank him one day.
@You must know damn
This Is Really Weird I just Watched Your Cuphead 24 Hours Thing And Now I See This Comment
No, they won't thank him at all
i agree but they definitely will not give him anything in return.
Who’s lud
Opens Kiara’s stream:
“Top stream is a Japanese streamer”.
That comment is bound to affect a few people
It shows a flaw BOTH twitch and CZcams have. There are people who target split audiences. Simply by having a Japanese title in the stream for her overseas fans it caused Lud to make a huge assumption.
There's just no fucking way
Well, he unintentionally summon the KFP employees with that sentence. 😂
One small thing I really appreciate about Twitch's website is that it always accurately saves your spot in a VOD if you close the tab. With CZcams you get a 50/50 chance of whether it'll be pretty accurate or not even close.
in my personal experience with youtube recently, it saves my spot in a video pretty accurately (usually like 10-30 seconds behind where i left off after closing the tab) around like 80-90% of the time
in the past though, like back in 2016, it was still quite inconsistent though, like 30% of the time my video spot gets saved properly
A pop-up request for hosting would be great. The streamer gets a notification that someone is trying to host them and they can either accept or deny it. This would stop hate raids and still allows you to uplift smaller / not in your immediate friend circle streamers. With a 5 min expiry timer, if not accepted than it gets automatically denied. Easy.
About the raid on yt i think they can totally do like a raid request where you send a request to the streamer you want to raid and the streamer decides either to accept the request or not. That way they can avoid the hate raids better than Twitch and make it quite easier to raid someone
You can still do hate raids without that. When jidion sent his viewers to pokimane he didn't raid anyone. It was just a verbal ask
I like the idea of having a prompt pop up that asks if you'd like to accept a raid from someone!
I figure they could do it like privacy settings. By default, it lets anyone raid you, or you can change it to "People on my list" and add people to a list, or you can switch it to "No raids allowed".
I feel like that'd also help with the awkwardness of when you're just about to end stream and someone comes in to raid you
@@zaeliouss trueeeee!!
2:16 even though Kiara is actually an english speaking streamer, there was actually a different problem with the system that Lud didn't point out and it's that he actually clicked on a stream that was already done. Kinda silly for the YT "Live" page to bring you to a stream that's already ended lmao
pretty sure that happens on twitch too, it's probably that the page hasn't updated aka he opened the tab a while ago
Also unlike twitch you can watch VOD on same link as stream was iirc.
So if stream has been ended was result of link it means that it JUST ended... Like minute or 2 ago, because within 5 minutes it becomes replaced with VOD
Yeah he would have opened that tab when the stream was live and it ended before he recorded this video
He opened the tab prior to recording this video and the stream probably ended in the meantime
As much as I think CZcams does stupid stuff, from a developers perspective this is probably (don’t work for CZcams so don’t know for sure) working 100% as expected and I’m actually on CZcams’s side if that is the case. If you wanted it to have that sort of refresh, you’d be adding potentially millions of calls per second to CZcams servers, just so that if a streamer happens to go offline when you are staring at this screen (and the majority of people don’t keep this page up long), it then refreshes and grabs new streams. That is a lot of work for a case that is at most a nuisance and rarely happens.
2:29 damn if only he clicked on the number 2 stream, I think he would have liked it ;-;
nah the thumbnail says it all
GG. Was looking for someone to point you out.
If u goto the customization on your YT channel u can setup the upcoming livestream function and they will pop up whenever you schedule them. Also live chat replay can be toggled on as well so you can see your chat after your streams, its in the backend of the YT streaming setup functions.
The stream you clicked on was not japanese, Hololive is a japanese company but the streamer herself does her streams in English
such disrespect towards Kiwawa won't be tolerated. Ludwig needs to be put in jail for this slander
She's also Austrian
I think the region is sorted by the main audience location. Kiara has a large US based viewers so that's why she appeared on top.
🤓
I want to share a few experiences I've had this year, I hope it helps anyone in need.
Lud, Kiara is not Japanese. She's Austrian who works at a Japanese vtuber agency. she talks primarily in English and also can talk fluently in German and Japanese
I get your point but she's I'm pretty sure she's still in Japan and also would still not be in his region
@@imaboisir7227 She's an english vtuber who streams primarily for an english audience. Her actual region should not matter.
@@imaboisir7227 she lives in Austria rn but im pretty sure her viewership is split between Japan, USA and Canada, and EU
@@imaboisir7227 she moved out of japan over a year ago iirc
@@char1194 dam i didn't know, i stopped watching around a year ago so that why I didn't know lol
The frustrating part is that CZcams used to have a ton of customization options. Setting your default video quality if it was available, changing your youtube channel link to a custom one. At one point they made a dedicated editing feature, you could do primitive video stabilization, clickable end links (that sent to outside links) all removed. The excuse for all this being consistency, but all this is doing is ensuring that the phone experience is significantly worse because they don't have extensions, that fix the glaring problems that youtube has caused trying to "simplify".
Adding a blue dot with clock markers for scheduled streams and red dot for live on the avatar should be a good suggestion
“Is a Japanese streamer” well, he is right… by like a third 😂 Kiara speaks Japanese English and German and usually puts a combination of them in her titles. No idea about that one though XD but still very right I’d insta click off that tab if I saw a bunch of other languages
damn i think you made me realize a flaw with Kiara's CZcams game
i usually never click on videos with multiple languages in the title too
Hey Lud-- just wanted to let you know, that first streamer you put on actually is an English streamer! her name is Kiara & she's a talent with hololive's english branch of talent. While holo is a Japanese company, they have branches in many different regions. Other than that, great vid as always ☺️
HE DOESNT KNOW PEPELAUGH
Kiwawa 😊
Silly you, this isn’t Ludwig! This is mogul mail, common mistake
@You must know what brah
@@Xathonn austlian
What you said in the Suzan interview is what i want to see the most. Going on a youtube channel and see a tab of "Livesteams" "Videos" & "Shorts" and (have this as a setting or not) only see "Video's" in the subscribe tab.
It’s the scroll speed that makes fast chat jarring to read. It needs to jump like twitch does, where it semi pauses then scrolls quickly, then pauses
2:15 Takanashi Kiara is an ENG streamer, but yeah that other ones are definitely iffy.
You know things have gotten bad when Lud dyes his hair the opposite color
@You must know First name Mogul last name Mail
@You must know ok
what does this even mean
this is why mogul mail is better than ludwig
Who is lud?
For me, the most annoying aspect is that I can’t switch the app and still have the livestream going like it is on twitch. I’m sure having a premium account would fix that but I wish that feature would exist for regular users too
I could see there being something combined with shorts if CZcams were to add the clips feature like Twitch has. Have Clips that people have recorded from currently available livestreams be pushed out through shorts. Helps make shorts profitable while also making it easier to discover new streamers.
You should probably look into the vtuber community, as they've solved some of the problems you've mentioned. For example, part of the directory thing is solved for corporate vtubers by having holodex, schedules, etc. Other example, the waiting room can be a 2024 stream called "free chat". (Also, kinda unrelated, but Kiara is an Austrian vtuber who streams in english😂)
no
@@lunazui5855 yes.
Killer feature is to load multiple streamers together in one tab so you can see everybody without switching back and forth between tabs. If YT is going to buy whole friend groups to move over they need to do something to foster this.
Bro that'd be so dope. I'll have Rae, Sykkuno, Ludwig, and Hasan open at the same time sometimes. It's a bit of a bother but I want to see all their reactions together.
That would be so easy! Just let the user group people, let's say the Ludwig crew or Among US crew or OTK and just let me start up all of them right from there (muted of course). Even I could program something like that in a weekend!
as for now if you want to do this manually there's a pop up feature on opera gx that basically creates a small separate window for a player and you can drag it around, just open multiple tabs, drag all of them on another monitor, and you'll get yourself a security camera kind of interface where you can watch multiple streams
you can pop up the chat too IIRC, or you can use a third party extension for this, but yeah having these without doing it manually would be cool
idk about other browsers but this should be a basic feature (I'm not paid by opera gx)
Twitch has this feature and nobody uses it
squad streaming has been a thing on twitch for a hot minute and its literal garbage. same thing with TV and showing multiple channels at once. sounds good but isn't good.
I feel the thing is that Twitch is mainly around streaming, so ofc it has to put in alot of effort+make streams really easy to notice, while youtube is much more about videos, so trying to balance streams into a website that is mainly about videos, it is a bit of a problem, thats also the reason why twitch doesn't struggle with it due to the fact they aren't trying to integrate videos into the site either, they have it as a side sure, but barely anybody uses it or cares about it.
I think the way it’s set up rn is that it expects you to discover livestreams through a CZcams video. Like if someone is streaming and I get algod their video, it says the person is live so I can go in
As someone who didn't start watching streamers until I found Valkyrae on CZcams, it's really interesting to hear the perspective of those who started with Twitch. I always preferred the livestream experience here because 1) no ads 2) ability to pause and return or even rewind. I never found it hard to keep up either because of notifications. But I've never been much of a chatter and I think that may be the big difference maker.
I agree. Personally, I definitely prefer twitch when chatting, but if I’m just lurking, CZcams is generally better.
Strongly prefer CZcams, due to the upvotes you generally see better quality opinions as opposed to repetitive emotes and spams from twitch chat. Also pause/rewind/play as you mentioned but also the ability to watch at faster speeds is a big thing for me
If you are a chatter twitch is better, the UI is better the chat is much more enjoyable, there is a culture in twitch chat.
I remember the first time that I watched a livestream in YT, which was Technoblade in Minecraft Mondays.
His page just showed up as I was looking for Pewdiepie vids.
One thing I don't like about YT Live is that they use the exact same designs as YT. I don't know if they do this to not pay people to create new design components, or if they just want to make the Live section have the typical YT look. But for example, the Live and Gaming section literally just uses the design as someone's CZcams Profile, and it makes me think that wanting to use the exact same design for YT videos and YT Streams could be holding them back a bit.
I'm actually all for the unified look, just my opinion. YT has been my main social media for years and I like that they just keep beefing the site with features that fit in with the exprerience
@@rowtechshio875 this tbh. It’s not the UI that is an issue, it’s pretty much just the functionality.
I don't like about YT live is that they use the exact same designs as YT
ah yes the floor here is made out of the floor
@@rowtechshio875 Yeah familiarity is actually a great component to have among CZcams's different sections to allow for seamless transitions, they just need to improve the functionality and make it easier to what you're looking for on Live
I don't understand why that matters? Are people getting confused and lost on the page?
I think it would be useful if you could rules for who can raid you. Like you can set the person needs at least 50 voewers, has had an account for one year, etc
Twitch has also messed this up somewhat by adding another button you have to click on a streamers page just to see chat, when it used to load automatically. I know everyone has a Discord now but nothing beats an active offline chat.
Lud: first stream is a Japanese streamer
Hololive[en]: ayo wtf
Kiara the Austrian Phoenix: 👁👄👁
To be fair, the GTA streamer (Takanashi Kiara from Hololive EN) is multilingual so she does eng, jpn, and German streams
She’s Austrian lol
@@NicoNicoNessieSub yeah but she streams primarily in English so it makes sense it's recommended in the context of Luds criticism. Maybe CZcams should implement a system to change primary language per stream with a default you can set
All great points and things that I’ve thought about many times. I stream on YT from PS5 sometimes and somehow I’ve popped up on peoples suggested and I’m tiny
I never knew about Playboard! Thanks for sharing it man.
Lud's journalism degree really shines through in these videos. Great videos 👍
Man knows how to clickbait people
His name isnt lud. It's mogul mail. No idea who lud is
@@MidasLich shut 🤏
just like his hair
That's mogul mail guy not ludwig your crazy
Kiara isn't a Japanese streamer Lud. She literally Hololive EN. She's an English speaking Vtuber.
unsure if you noticed or if im misunderstanding - but the raid thing has been updated. when i go to check for "live redirects", there's now a toggle for "all channels can redirect to my content" which makes things nicer - at least now we have a twitch analog alongside the safe whitelist alternative method
2:39 when I have a kid there will be a carefully selected library of gems like invader zim, early spongebob, teen titans, etc. I feel like plotlines even really early on helped develop my brain. Then I'll eventually show them some anime, then some dramas like breaking bad and what not.
Then on some glorious day when I deem fit, I will show them South Park.
at 2:19 you arent exactly correct. That is kiara, a hololive EN vtuber. She however does streams in Japanese sometimes which is why the title is in Japanese
there atleast haha
Lol she only has one hashtag in Japanese, the rest is in English
but she's still in Austria which is quite far away
Small criticism. That "Japanese streamer" at 2:15 is an English streamer. She's part of Hololive which was originally a Japanese streaming group, but she's part of their English branch.
Regarding 8:44, it doesn't even work properly because the Uploads option also includes all live streams, so there's no way to filter for just videos. Additionally (not related to streaming but still annoying), you can't sort videos by oldest or most viewed on music channels
CORRECTION: That top "japanese" streamer was actually Takanashi Kiara of Hololive ENGLISH. While she speaks japanese, she is Austrian and streams in English. So her stream being there was actually correct, and to anyone who sees this, she is an AMAZING streamer, easily one of the best on the platform, and you should 100% check her out sometime!
Side note: for anyone struggling to connect the dots on who she is, she is genmates with Gawr Gura, the biggest vtuber in the world, and they both debuted alongside one another.
Side side note: im surprised ludwig doesnt know who Kiara is. Shes got 1.4 million subs, and is in the top 30 most superchatted people on youtube.
Whats the real appeal to the vtubers is it cuz they act all cute and stuff? I’m not knocking I’m just genuinely curious.
@@reislinlittle4715 a LOT of vtubers don't behave that way, actually. some do, which is fine, but for the actual streamers it's a great way to still have a visual personality without having to show your face. so for people who wanna stay faceless it's really nice. there are vtubers who show their face or their face is at least known to the public, but most are 100% faceless ^^ for the viewers, i imagine it's because the models are more appealing to look at. for some people it fulfills their "anime waifu" fantasy, which CAN be dangerous but usually is pretty harmless as long as it's an adult, and for some people they just think it's a neat industry with a lot of amazing personalities and it gives jobs to a lot of artists, especially amateur artists who struggle to find a way to make money in the art industry :D
@@reislinlittle4715 the appeal is just that they're streamers, for some it's because it's a cute animated character but for most people it's the same appeal as normal streaming, you enjoy the person's personality or their content.
My mans calling Kiara a JAPANESE streamer when she's part of HOLOLIVE ENGLISH killed me.
Hololive is a Japanese company and not everyone watch Vtubers.
@@TheArrivalCyberse Her channel name includes EN for English. It was funny, it's not that serious.
Lud always hitting us with the left field takes
who is lud?
This is Mogul Mail, not Lud. Two very different people
@@circlesareround2292 they just sorta look alike whenever the lighting is right and have similar setups because of how optimal it is
@@circlesareround2292 I always get them confused
Who’s Lud? This do be Mogal Mail
I agree that youtube is bad at serving lives. they are a video site trying to do live streaming too. You can't expect youtube to look like twitch tho, they still need to be youtube. they are a video site trying to do livestreaming without completely changing the entirety of their platform. maybe add a tab thats livestreaming next to the explore tab that can change based on viewer habits but, I still do think that *relatively*, streaming is sort of its own bubble and a small one too. you don't go to twitch like you go to youtube expecting fast paced well cut content, and its going to be hard to get people on youtube to have the attention span for the slower and just different vibe of streaming, and if the bubble is small enough, maybe its not worth it to youtube to make this golden streaming platform. although they are taking on more and more creators from twitch, like you said they aren't just going for any streamers, theyre going for like otv and only bubbles because trying to make the platform as a whole more streamer friendly is a little unfair
I thought that the region sorting sorted by what's popular in your region rather than who is in your region. I know a lot of streamers that don't focus on their own region's audience. I mean (and sorry if my info is outdated, I haven't kept up with him) would it not be weird if pewdiepie only showed up in Italy for the region sorting when he's not an Italian streamer, he doesn't speak Italian in his streams, and his audience is mostly outside Italy. It makes sense to me that the region sorter shows you who your region watches. (Oh and btw that first streamer you called Japanese is an English speaking streamer, but I understand you got confused by that Japanese hashtag in the stream title)
I found it a little funny when he went to Kiara's stream and said that she's japanese. Even though she's an english speaking streamer. It made me laugh a bit.
I did my first redirect today! I turned it on for myself today too! I'm glad that someone made more people aware of redirects in this video. I wish it was easier to find people in the game I play so I can redirect them to similar people and potentially make connections with the people I redirect to, but with CZcams's current discoverability system it's just really difficult.
I think it might be a good idea to have a tab for clips/shorts/videos specifically from creators that are currently live, that way youtube can take advantage of their already pretty good video algorithm to show people streams. It would also provide a solution to the issue of it being difficult to know if you want to watch a stream or not without watching for quite a while.
8:00 the user can look at their past chat messages in other streams (I just noticed this a few days ago) but yeah I don't think streamers can see past chat in streams
Hits the banger one take and then immediately starts a stream on Twitch. What a legend
They really need to fix the comment bot problem. All your replies are just bots… 😅
Twitch is like that one ex you keep coming back to: no matter how bad they hurt you, it's still better than the alternative.
hell no it ain't
hell no I rather be single
Fuck twitch that shit garbage af
Easiest solution is to have a Live Recommended shelf right under recommended, that would then lead into a live feature page.
Live Page would feature 4 shelves, top, recommended, rising, and a clip shelf on the bottom. Scrolling down would be the same recommended.
i agree with this live stremaing on youtube is a pain in the arse and it stunts growth for those youtubers
Kiara isn’t a Japanese streamer she’s an English streamer
Technically she's an Austrian streamer. Still, streams in English.
She pretends to be an anime girl, ergo idrc
@@knuteknoll6747 Her anime girl is more convincing than your human, I must say.
I remember one day back in 2018, the CZcams home page had an entire section for livestreams for some reason, which I thought was really cool. I noticed one of the streams it was recommending me was of a blind playthrough of Kingdom Hearts 1: Final Mix, so I clicked on it and thus discovered a channel that I came to enjoy. All because CZcams briefly had a section for livestreams for some random reason. I don't know why it was there or why they removed it, but they should add it back.
There was a funny moment in the H3 leftovers podcast that I tried to clip to post to twitter but yeah there was no way to just download the clip on its own (unless there's a third party thing but I didn't want to search around for that)
Small correction. You were highlighting Takanashi Kiara when saying that youtube recommends "japanese videos instead of regional content". But Kiara streams basically only to an english audience, so that's the algorythm actually working as intended.
She sets her region to Japan, so no, it isn't the algorithm working as intended.
@@undeadman7676 It's "Sorted by most viewers in your region" so nope. Most people from the US were watching her stream in this category. It is the algorithm working as intended, Ludwig just misunderstood how it worked.
You should make a video on Michael DiCostanzo and how his bracket live streams are taking over TikTok, it's a super interesting and fun concept and I'm surprised other creators haven't replicated it yet.
Once again, great video Lud!! Also this came on a really good timing for me! I've been doing a crazy research on which platform to livestream on and I'm just going nuts with all the crazy drama and settings of each platform
8:52 "But the Upcoming live stream section should probably just be always there"
You can literally do that by adding Upcoming live streams in your Featured sections in Channel customization. With the lobby, you can schedule a second stream far in the future where everyone can chat at any point. Both will be visible from your Home page.
One thing I despise about Twitch that CZcams (luckily) doesn't do, is that Twitch puts your VODs on a timer for how long you get to keep them before they're gone forever. It used to be two weeks for non-partners and/or people who don't have Twitch Prime, but recently they decided to be worse to non-affiliates and slice those two weeks into one week. Found that out the hard way due to only recently going back to streaming, and lost a four-hour stream that I put a lot into.
I guess it doesn’t go for everyone but I’ve always LOVED scheduled streams. My streamer doesn’t always pre-plan their week or make announcements before a stream goes live but they’ll always schedule streams beforehand and when I see it, it allows me to plan my day around it and never miss a single second by making sure I’m not caught off guard by anything coming up while I watch
Yeah I don't think anyone thinks scheduled streams are necessarily a problem in a vacuum, they're just a notification really. The problem is that its being used instead of other features rather than in addition to, and limiting peoples access to the livestream page and chats. If they just kept it as a notification system but added the functionality Ludwig mentions here I think it would be better in that regard
"The top stream is a japanese streamer"
Kiara's in HoloEN. The actual crazy part is that it still says "Live" for a stream that ended 6 hours prior.
It ended just before he clicked. It says streamed 6 hours ago, meaning the stream started 6 hours ago. And if you look at the vod length, it's exactly 6 hours long.
youtube once upon a time had an “offline chat”-ish system. they’ve tried reinventing it with yt communities. imo it doesn’t work. like one of the top comments on this post, i usually watch streams to see what’s going on/to have something on; i don’t chat much even on twitch. but for those who do want to chat both when in stream and in offline chat, there should be a more accessible and cohesive way to merge that.
If you want an offline chat room, you can schedule a stream that starts somewhere in the very far future.
The one thing this mogul mail guy got wrong is that Kiara IS an english streamer. She streams under Hololive's english branch. Hololive is a japanese virtual entertainment company. If ludwig made a news/drama channel I knew he would've gotten that right. screw this mogul guy
lmfao KFP seething rn?
@@nabe4320 Not really. Just pointing out a DIFFERENT issue both twitch and youtube have. People who target 2 languages tend to get screwed.
@@oQuindo1 that's true you brought it up, I agree. The way it came off, wasn't sure if the comment was sarcastic or a seriously malding KFP, which was kinda hard to distinguish. I do admit though, that this advice of having only English in the title to increase viewers is an interesting thing to tell Kiwawa since she wants to grow, so that's pretty cool
this comment was meant to be a joke sorry if i confused anyone :p
I actually love Lud’s idea that from CZcams shorts you are recommended streams, I think that would be crazy and really help streamers discoverability, making CZcams a much more desirable platform for creators.
I found a couple of streamers from their Shorts so it's definitely an option
As someone who sometimes watches shorts, no I hate that idea and it would make watching shorts suck. Keep everything where it needs to be, unless they want to add random streams to the stories cause I don’t care about those
I don't watch shorts but i think this is dumb idea
In page, where all content is about minute long you suddenly get absolutely not fitting few hours long lasting stream without context and result.
People who look shorts won't.be interested in long content, otherwise they would've not been looking for SHORTS specifically
i hate it, i want to watch shorts and not watch live, dont recommend me that shit i didnt ask for. sane with tiktok, i always press don't show again whenever i see a live
Think they started doing that already with that QR-code looking UI option to link to the original stream (…and Super Thanks).
Dk, i always use sub box first to watch people I'm following before ever going to recommended, cuz usually i get straight up shit there and rarely new vids from my subscriptions
I remember CZcams streamers talking about directly working with engineers on the CZcams team and how excited they were about the features that were coming…. 3-5 years ago….
Thank you Mr. Mogul Mail for having your video be the perfect length for eating a whole extra large bacon and sausage pizza in one sitting alone on a Saturday night crashing at my parent's house without their knowledge while they are on vacation and watching the Netflix Dahmer special.
You ate an entire extra large bacon and sausage pizza in just over 10 minutes? Are.. are you Kirby?
@@bblvrable No. Just depressed
When I’m in a clickbait competition and my opponent is Mogul Mail 😮
One thing that really shines through in these videos is the light through Lud's window
One thing about YT pre chat that I find mainly lots of JP Vtubers do is have a live stream scheduled a year ahead to act as a pre chat that’s alway up
this is a great follow up to ludwig streaming on twitch yesterday
Im assuming a lot of people told you, but Kiara streams in English (she's European tho so tecnically still not your region)
Also, love how you said Twitch when u meant Yotube multiple times, this is why we love Mogul Mail Guy
One thing I have also noticed is the terrible notifications from youtube. If a streamer schedules a stream less than 30 minutes before they start, I often don't get notified at all, some times I get notified after the stream ends or 2 hours into the stream. This must be fixed asap.
RIGHT omg it's not just me
Clips on YT don't seem as bad as you're putting it. You can't download clips on Twitch either natively but there's extensions that will let you do it for both. Other than that the clip only existing unless the vod is privated makes sense for me at least in case the streamer wants to get rid of all clips of something that happened for privacy reasons (if you want to avoid that, download the clip before it gets taken down).
Also the spiffing brit has a great video about how the schedule live system on YT can be exploited since it recommends your stream to a lot of people if you perpetually keep delaying the broadcast. It explains the system very well but is a very niche "feature" and exists as an unintentional bug so it probably doesn't deserve much credit.
Other than that I'd say all of your criticisms about the CZcams streaming experience are pretty on point, but I doubt things will change drastically any time soon.
I know people have already touched on this, but I also wanted to chime in on the GTA stream Lud highlighted. That yes, the tags she was using included Japanese tags but as others have noted she herself is part of an English branch of that Vtuber company and the stream was primarily in English (she speaks several languages and has fun flexing them a bit, with German being her mother tongue iirc). Also the rest of the title and description was in English, but I also understand you were taking a quarter second glance at it to prove your point and move on (which I also agree with).
So while yes, that stream was inclusive of people outside of Lud's region that it was appropriately placed in the browser. That being said, I would love to see CZcams make a lot of improvements so keep it up :)
yo mogul mail, thought i'd let you know that there is a way to have offline chat albeit a bit inconvenient, what you can do is set up a livestream now and schedule it for like a year from now and title it free chat or whatever, a lot of vtubers that i know do this and although it doesn't disprove your point it's a good way to combat that problem.
The very most CZcams can do about the algorithm thing is making a tab or something on the side that shows you when the channels your subbed to are live. I know they will put a live icon next to the live channels on the normal sub list on the side, but that includes all channels your subbed to so it can be hard to see them all. So at least a list deticated to live channels.
It also places the currently live channels at the top of your subscription list. That basically acts as a separate list.
7:55 Chat spamming no is peak comedy
From the viewers side, by far the best thing about CZcams's streaming is the ability to go back in a stream. This makes an especially big difference for watching gamers and things like valo tournaments. You can easily go back 10 seconds to rewatch a pop-off moment that you missed. The only way I've been able to do this on twitch which is super annoying to do every time is to clip it right away and watch that, but then you've just missed part of the livestream. You can pause and do something then come back, fast forwarding and skipping through breaks and timeouts to catch up while not missing anything.
Being able to go back in a stream while it happens also allows you to watch a game they were playing earlier in the stream that they aren't now.
Apart from this one thing (which is enough to make me watch Valo tournaments on youtube rather than twitch), Twitch is better in practically every way for streaming imho.
the main thing is youtube needs to separate the video and streaming side because right now it’s all mashed together in a weird way. If they had a better separate page for streams it go a long way. People you are subbed to for vids and people who are streaming are all put together and even though the live channels are first it’s in such a weird place I forget about it constantly and I only notice ludwig being live when I randomly get the stream recommended while browsing vids
I rarely get recommendations for live streams. They should definitely have sections for all three formats
I think like YT music they might just make a separate app for it. You can still watch live on reg YT but if you want a better experience you go to the app
again with the one take video. idk how this man does it. massive props honestly.
@You must know bruh, that dog shit wasn't even funny
Problem with the 1 take video is that he didn't do quite enough research and made an assumption about Kiara being a japanese streamer when she bilingual and primarily english.
@@pj-wille doesnt change his point tho, sort by region doesnt work
@@galador8089 I believe it's not working properly, but presenting evidence that is supposed to mean one thing but it's another isn't gonna help. It only serves people already in the echo chamber and not people who don't know about the issues.
I do think his ability to do it is impressive, but it does his pride in doing it lets in some mistakes like the above and like him calling youtube by twitch's name
Jake the editor is really the king of seamless transitions
On the topic of no "waiting rooms", what I've seen done in the past by some corporate vtuber channels is they'll have a stream scheduled for way out in the future and use that as a waiting/chatroom.
You can see live streamers in your subfeed. Idk why people consider the subfeed gone, I still use it every day.
I think part of it is that live streamers are set up to compete with algorithmically curated content that, comparatively, appeals to the reduced attention span of the modern audience. Whereas on twitch the only things there, are live streams sorted exactly how you mention in the beginning of the video.
Bruh that Japanese streamer is Kiara, she speaks English. Most of her content is English.
Ayyy shoutout to NL!! Super cool to see Lud mention he watches him too
i really feel like live streams should be a tab on the channel next to videos and playlists. You click on the "Live" tab and it brings up the offline chat and has past streams below the stream window.