The Abrogation of Article 370 and what it means to ‘Kashmiriyat’ | Arth - A Culture Fest, Delhi
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 02. 2020
- Intriguing. Intense. Insightful. Gowhar Geelani, Jamyang Tsering Namgyal, Anand Ranganathan, Syed Salman Chishty, Vivek Agnihotri with Abhijit Iyer Mitra discussed Article 370, a conversation that had us all engaged until the very end on Day 2 of Arth - A Culture Fest.
Subscribe to our channel: / arthaculturefest
Follow us on our social handles:
Twitter: / arth_live
Facebook: / arthlive
Instagram: / arth_live - Zábava
Who's sad that Sai Deepak is not in the panel 🖐️
,✋
🖐️
🖐
Me too
Yeah ...had sai been here he would have hammered the islamic radicals
"Kashmiriyat" died the day Kashmiri Pandits were made to leave their homeland.
kashmiriyat never existed. It is a fake propaganda.
@@abhinabasinha I would be enlightened if you could pls elaborate.
You mean 800 years ago
@@19683 Kashmiri Hindus had kept it alive even after 6 earlier exoduses . 1990 was the last when no Hindu was left there. Now these homeless Hindus are still keeping their Kashmiriyat alive like droplets of peace in every part of the country n the world where ever they have gone. God willing will establish their respectable position again in Kashmir n bring Kashmiriyat back with them.
Correct di
Vivek Agnihotri made awesome job by making the " Kashmir files" . Hats off to this man and for his guts.
He was also the one who made Tashkent files ❤️
@@aishudhomane1681 propaganda films
@@sameersrivastava3720 👀 i see.. i have some burnol stocked at home.. want some?
@@sameersrivastava3720says a typical andh nam azi without any context.....😂😂
@@sameersrivastava3720tujhe tere gharse nikal du aake Islam Islam bolke bsdk?
I am the citizen of J&k Jammu, Bilkul sahi kaha Ladakh ke MP ne ki kashmiri govt ne hmesha Jammu & Ladakh ki awaam ke saath descrimination kiya aur sbh rights & benifits Kashmirio ko diye, I support abrogation of artical 370 & 35a
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Your name is perfectly matching to your profile pic.🤣🤣🇮🇳🇮🇳
Citizen of j&k?
@@pawanprajapati6292Nationality Indian but State subject j&k
There is no Kashmir without kashmiri Hindus. It was and is the land of Sun ❤️
@Sachin arc9 right is never wrong remember till Hindus are the majority this country is secular Mark my words 😌
Right brother
@Sachin arc9 if you can't elaborate, you have nothing to say on your opinion, then your opinion doesn't matter to me.
@@ritikk1714 jo tu iss desh me dekh rhha ha beta... bkki sb theek ha bs hinduo ko galli dete rhho... hope you got it booi
@Kishan Soni not really. Kashmiri Muslims are still by and large kashmiri and are the same as pandits ethnically
We need to make a Dr. Ranganathan Fan Club.
M in
Turki sahab u are a Kp right
@@vinybhat9365 Yes Sir! I'm a indeed a KP.
@@sameerturki4317 i know turki uncle of bhagwaan Gopinathjj Ashram
Let's do it!
Where is sai Deepak sir ? Okay Ranganath sir enough for this mullahs.😂😂😂😂
J Sai Deepak, Anand Ranganathan and Vinod from Strings .. 3 hi kaafi hai hazaaro leftists aur jihadists ke liye
@@cannotthinkofoneatth Abhijeet Iyer Mitra?
@@cannotthinkofoneatth this is overkill bro🤣
Not mullas they are bullas
@@srikanthrasamalla pigs bolne me sharam aa rhi ha tujhe
Vivek agnihotri sir didn't feel satisfied with this debate so he made a movie to complete his statements 😂🔥😎
You nailed it man- "ap tou reh gye fekte patthar,humne hata diya 370".😝😝😆😆
U7
That Geelani guy was lecturing about internet shutdown for 7 months. But conveniently forgot 30 years of shutdown of own homes for Kashmiri Pandits who cannot go back to their own home. No one talks about this 30 years of shutdown of homes while shed tears for "internet shutdown".
@@ramverma6572 timestamps???
@@thenoobdashow7428 15:15
@@indranilsinha351 Yes and no one also talks about the janta party government who open handedly supported seperatist and central government under whose reign exodus of Kashmir happened.😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂
Most underrated slogan.......AAP toh reg Gaye phenkte pathar ...humne hata Diya 370....
@Harjeet Singh Brar ... spelling ki rehne de...hurriyat ki toh thuk gayi na
Abh aagey ka soachiyea. Gazwa-e-islam shuru ho gaya hai.
Koran mey sey nafrat kay kaantey aur jehrili jadh nikaalni hai. Tabhtak unki soach nahi badleygi.
@Harjeet Singh Brar Chalyea bhai, aap bhi gazwa-e-islam mey shamil ho jaaiyea.
Jab tak koran mey sey nafrat kay kaantey aur jehrili jadh nikaali nahi jaati, unki soach nahi badleygi.
Islam ko ban karo
@@sumeethiray4770 bhai, khali ban karney sey kaam nahi hoga, islam ko neuter karna chahiye. Itihass padhiyea islam kyu aur kaisey khada kiya gaya. Toh samajh aata hai ki islam aik dharam nahi balki aik khatarnaak sanghathan hai jispar dharam ka mukhota chadhaya gaya hai.
I have become a fan of Jamyang, he kills the opponent just by words. His database is so huge.
Yeah.i still get goosebumps hearing his perliamentary debate.
Yes absolutely right👍
Yes, agree with you. Jai Hind. 🇮🇳
Great debate. Thanks for bringing awareness. Jai Hind 🇮🇳.
I agree ❤️
"We celebrate diversity" is where he got me 😂😂
True
lol
Ladakh MP made a brilliant point where he said When other minorities dignity were trampled down and crushed by these same Kashmir people then these Kashmir people feel very secured. But now when other people questioned their hypocrisy and exposed their double standard then they are feeling insecure and Paranoid.
Karakoram to kanyakumari ...rather siachin to kanyakumari
He is just too good and succinct in his responses
U r lying
Good
Brothers, it is time to be more direct and "stop beating around the bush". Call a spade a spade. Make the muslims understand their misconceptions.
The muslims behave as they do because they are brainwashed and ordained to follow the tenets of islam. If we wish their behaviour to change for the better we have to have all the hateful supremacist neo-political violence-inciting parts expunged from the KSH (koran, sira, hadees). They must reform or be reformed. No half-measures or appeasement will do. Unleash gazwa-e-islam.
Tum fekte reh Gaye pathar,
Humne hata di dhara 370.
-Mr Jamyang Tsering Namgyal
lit🔥🔥🔥🔥
Follow him on Twitter. His other speech in Parliament is AMAZING
"Karakoram se Kanyakumari tak" Respect 🙏🏻
It's a very unique that Shri Jamyang ji in very beautiful traditional it's showing the real hero... Hats off 👏👏👏
He has gained fans all over India now... Hope to see him manning a ministry some day.
Emotions of Dr Ranganathan anand in his 1st remark is the emotion of every person in India.
Absolutely true
Anand ranganathan is a master piece. No one messes with anand ranganathan. And jamyang bhai ne dil jeet liya:"aap to rhe gaye maarte pathar humne hata diya 370"
What a comment by Jamyang😍
"When the truth is coming out they feel insecure"
Vivek Agnihotri,
Opening eyes for yuva....
Great sir.
Jamyang Tsering Namgya.. nice to hear from you.!!
Pleasure to hear Anand Ranganathan and Vivek Agnihotri so logically correct with facts.
But Agnihotri himself said in an interview "facts are not facts"😂
@@humanbeing6838 Gandhi said nothing is impossible
Geelani says that Kashmiris are in jail, what about us who were thrown out of our homes, killed mercilessly & looted our property. They deserve only hell for their sins.
They won't talk on this because. ..
Secularism
Vivek Agnihotri Has Well Exposed To Sufi's.. 👍👌👏👏
Muslims are a smart people. The moment they saw Hindu unity they gave a slogan Jai Meem,Jai bheem.Hindu beware, Baba साहब हमारे the, है और रहेगा.... JAI Shree ram, jai भीम. Meem की औलाद अरब jaye
@Shah Shah is ambedkar support Ed aryan theory?
@Shah Shah most of the aryan dravidian supporter's R converted abrahamist
@Shah Shah bro....read Ambedkar's view on Islam. I think he was completely right.
@Shah Shah you see baba saheb ambedkar views on Muslims and on article 370
Shah Shah poor guy Ambedkar clearely said there is Aryan invasion theory
Isn't this ironical that only person speaking in proper Hindi is the MP from laddakh
BJP ka admi hai
Becoz of ur love for Urdu and bollywood.
@@ks12253 its Hindi not Urdu.
No. Infact Ladakhis speak excellent Hindi. My best friend (and my bro) is Ladakhi and speaks very good Hindi!!! 😍😘 Shout-out to Jiggy agar dekh liya tune!!❤️❤️
@arv er .... needless tension mat lo....even my mother tongue is not hindi.....it was only to bring out the irony.....and btw people from Arunachal also speak very good hindi....
Being a kashmiri hindu i am very thankful to vivek agnihotri sir
Dr. Rangnathan was outloud And clear... Salute to him!
Huge respect to Jamyeng sir from Telugite🙂💙
😍❤
That ladakhi Guy is incredible
Try to mention name. you dont have any intention to hurt anyone but still try to name an be specific instead of just any adjective. Be inclusive
He's a BJP MP from Ladakh; Jamyang Tshering Namgyal
@@dineshganyarpawar5441 sorry I don't know his name
@@rsr201 He is soon going to be a PM candidate.
He should the vice-President of India or the foreign minister.
I wonder if Gilani was schooled at a Madrasa.
Yeh but a international one
That Geelani guy was lecturing about internet shutdown for 7 months. But conveniently forgot 30 years of shutdown of own homes for Kashmiri Pandits who cannot go back to their own home. No one talks about this 30 years of shutdown of homes while shed tears for "internet shutdown".
I think u don't have proper knowledge about kashmir Geelani was CM of Kashmir in 1967 but he left that because he was not willing anytime to live under India and u should also known Kashmir had PM also at that time, probably u should go with Shimla Agreement and everyone knows Kashmir is disputed region globally
@@beingkashmiri145 kashmir is integral part of Bharat Varsh from Satyug and it is not a disputed region 🚩
It's not their fault, they are brought up with lies. Blame their ancestors.
Abrogation of article 370 was one of the greatest moments of independent India.
JAI HIND 🔥🙏
Dr Anand,you are a star,you have exposed those thief’s on the other side,who have come on the show to spew the same old narrative,with a Muslim bias agenda.
Vivek Agnihotri made a profound point, on the one hand is culture on the other hand Islam.
You should have asked these "Kashmiris":
Who are Kashmiris in their views? And what future prospective they see of Kashmiri Hindus in Kashmir? Also, why were Kashmiri Hindus drove out of Kashmir?
Love ❤️ Jamiyang👍💐💐
There is nothing like kashmiriyat, There is always one thing in today's Fully Muslim kashmir JIHAD.
This is what Islam is.
After 70 dark years of Congress rule, India has finally broken free of foreign rule -- directly by Islamists and British, and indirectly through Nehru and his family.
1st rule of debate: Never Ever Insult the Audience.
Gowhar was loosing the debate, and arrogantly insulted the Audience.
0th rule of debate : Don't bring an audience which is totally biased. Arth always brings full rw audience.
I don't have opinions about this particular debate, just that the audience is really tilted.
@@amishbhat3560 tickets are available to all idiot. Anyone can go to the event. They don't choose their audience.
@@starc_4907 lol true that
@@amishbhat3560 as far as india is concern whole India is right wing. - by ajit doval. nations interest comes first regardless.
@@amishbhat3560 lol audience is'nt a group of puppies and kittens to bring them and make them seat. RW supporters are more tolerant than LW who are hypocritic to the core and believe 'if you aren't with me, you are against me'. Those LW who middle-finger and cancel RW speakers from US to India, how could a sane person could expect them here.
Jam yang sir full respect to you. You speak only when asked and hit on very point
this MP is joy to listen, so young (not so called young) and well aware of surrounding, coming from grass root level and having knowledge of the same and orally is also amazing, I am really looking forward how he will take more responsibilities in upcoming years for the people and for the nation!
Anandragnathan is my favourite intellectual
Then you are the biggest Bhakt
@@biebersucks27 and u are the biggest jaheel
@@biebersucks27 u r biggest chamcha😂😂😹😹
@Ven Param Jab inse Facts ke basis pe Reply nahi diya jata ,toh dusro ko Bhakt aur Islamophobic ka tag de dete hai
@@biebersucks27 Abe ja na gandu
Jamyang "secure" reply is direct punch on Swine.
Vandemataram, Jai Hind
The best moderator I have seen in a while. Taking questions from every side, being ears to all of them and keeping them in check. ❤
I respect Ranganathan, he is collected, informative person who argues with pure facts. He is an awesome political analyst and a true scientist( which he is in biology).
"Umra bhar yehi bhul karta raha,
Dhul chehre pe thi, aayna saaf karta raha"
You have to admit, Mr Ranganathan is way too witty for his opponents. No matter how much you hide the facts, Ranganathan will expose it. BRUTALLY.
That Geelani guy was lecturing about internet shutdown for 7 months. But conveniently forgot 30 years of shutdown of own homes for Kashmiri Pandits who cannot go back to their own home. No one talks about this 30 years of shutdown of homes while shed tears for "internet shutdown".
What's the meaning of it?
Good debate. Gilani was bitter over "Indian oppression", but never repentant about Kashmiri Pandit genocide. Chishti was more interested in taqiyya. Vivek was worried over the future of brainwashed children born after 1990. Anand was in his usual logical best. But, the debate was won hands down by Tsering for brevity & logic... excellent speaker & surely the best face for Ladakh.
Moderator Abhijeet was super strict, unfortunately due to time constraints.
Keep up the good work, Arth.💪👍🙏
DNA
Geelani as the name suggests is the cause of the mess in Kashir with the other illegitimate momins. There is no room for Secular and kashmiriat at all. Get the toxic elements out immediately please
Hi Prof. Wow, excellently summed up.
That Geelani guy was lecturing about internet shutdown for 7 months. But conveniently forgot 30 years of shutdown of own homes for Kashmiri Pandits who cannot go back to their own home. No one talks about this 30 years of shutdown of homes while shed tears for "internet shutdown".
Yeah he took the least time to spoke yet made the most to the point comments.
Dr. Anand is Bharat’s treasure 🙏
MP from Ladak Mr. Jamyang is fantastic.. amazing replies and punches
DR Anand great, eyeopening facts, logical thoughts, BJP should make him adviser, Agnihotri and Jamiya tooo good, please come put in community and spread your thoughts, it is very essential postive , assertiveness (no surrenderness for hindus) is needed
Abrogation of 370 is right step against Jihadists.
What has changed lol🤣🤣🤣everything is worse than before
Agreed
@WILEY CRONZ true
Without delving deep into it, one thing is certain it liberates kashmir from the grip of a handful of self serving greedy politicians limited to a privileged family.
I know a person from an online game ,who is playing that game for more than 3 or 4 years now and he lives in shrinagar kashmir. And they say people don't have internet over there what a joke.
I like the way Jamyang presented LADHAK. Looking forward to visit
How important it is to notice, how beautifully Abhijit conducted this panel. 😊
AMIT BHATTACHARYYA 🤗
@@Iyervval da you rocked as always
Amazingly
@@Iyervval panelits and opinions will always be different..and subject to it, we may like it or not.. But this panel was conducted so well.. 🙈
When he gave one word for the opening remarks of all the panalists that was very good
Namgyal sir and anand sir talks and the world listens!
The way Jamyang sir speaks hindi is so awesome!!
Audience cheer a lot when Jihadis exposed. They love Kashmir as much as any other part of India. Jihadis are saying Kashmiriyat is not reality. Real Kashmiriyat is inclusive of Bharat. Bharat mata Ki jay.
“आप को फेकंते रह गये पत्थर,
हमने हट दी 370 “
😂--------Jamyang Tsering (MP Ladakh)
This Debate is incomplete without Sai Depak
Love you Jamyang Tsering Namgyal. Love to come to Laddakh. My Great Country with Great places. Jai Hind.
As a Tamil i admire Jamyang ji Hindi..
Dam too dravidian politic...
There is neither dravid nor Aryan, this was politically motivated propaganda, Dravid means meeting point of three Coast. Study debate between Adi sankara & Mandana mishra. Then realized what is the meaning of Dravid, & Arya is not a race Arya means civilize. All Indian are Arya because we r a civilized nation of 12 thousand year
I don't get it either. I have stayed in 14 states in India at different times, including TN. I have never seen such a hang up about speaking hindi anywhere else. I mean, if you don't want to, it's fine. We can talk in English maybe. But what is the issue with Hindi? Do you not realize that other states in India have a mother tongue too? But they are so chill about speaking hindi
None in Tamil Nadu will abuse you if you speak Hindi.
Tamil nadu does not want to Ban Hindi. Proof? You can find many Hindi prachar Parishads in Tamil Nadu. NONE of them were ATTACKED upon even until today.
You can open even a 100 more Parishads in Tamil Nadu. You will not be stopped.
Tamilians do not want Hindi to be forced upon them, or, making it compulsory in central government jobs. English is fine.
Hope you understood?
@@satishnithyanandam why bro English why can't Sanskrit
I don't have any problem if govt decided Tamil language learning mandatory in syllabus.
@@sonitabh this mind set is politically motivated.
Anand Ranganathan has done a great job. Well explained by Vivek Agnihotri also. Jamyang Tsering Namgyal had come to talk for Laddakh. He has done his job. Why Syed Salman Chishty was not asked about Sanyogita's fate in the hands of Salim Chisti after Prithviraj Chauhan was captured by Mohd. Ghori to whom he had sent invitation to loot India? Why no reference was made to History? Gowhar Geelani had also come with Pakistani-Kashmiri agenda. He did his job but started drinking water when his theory was nicely demolished by Anand.
24:40- Your most welcome 🔥🔥🔥
Jamyang Tsering Namgyal
Member of the Lok Sabha
Thank you, Sir,
💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐✌✌✌✌✌✌
Jay Jay Shree Ram🙏🙏
That's how a debate should be conducted. Anand sir, you have a new fan. Thank you.
Namgyal is amazing, Short and Strong replies.
He will definitely be a Cabinet Minister in Future.
Great Respect to you Anand SIR
PURE BRILLIANCE
Vivek had the best opening remark!
Wow!
What a discussion!
Kashmiriyat died the day Kashmiri Pandits were banished from the land that was theirs for centuries.
I am from Jammu and I agree with the opening remark of agnihotri sir..
The kind of thought gilani brought while speaking when he said indians enjoy humiliation of kashmiri is the same thing what local politicians did to the young population there. While they don't know rest of the Indian personally but still they think as if they met every one in person.
The representative of Ladakh is my favourite
Jamyung, Anand, atul just rocked.
Atul ?
I feel "Nund Rishi" is a taqiya conversion tactic. It happened in Bengal too. Islam was taught by taqiyya Muslim clerics, posing as priests and teaching Islam as another sect of Hinduism. And four to five generations down the line, they were able to convert them.
Trojan Horse
no bro. nund rishi was a kashmiri hinud. A large sect of muslims say he is a muslim but the fact is he was a kashmiri. they changed his name to sheikh somthing. and its not just him, a lot of hindu baba type persons were claimed to be muslims. very typical. i am a kashmiri pandit sir.
as an exMuslim and former Jihadi I 100% agree with you.. you got it 100% right...
@@niaamul Congrats on getting your life together. Best of luck with your future bhai!!
@@niaamul well done bro, let's change this country together.
I could root for Jamyang as PM for the future!
This is an amazing platform...@Arth
Mr Gohar has to defend genocide. It's really tough job. Had it not happened I mean abrogation of article 370 he would have been declared champion of democracy.
Correct 😁
. That is fully arranged scripted fake Drama , Showing Abhijit , Vivek etc. up .
This is the culture that biriyani khao aur rasta roko........
Great discussion, kudos to the mediator!
Awesome work by Arth ❤️
Sufism is a trojan horse...
A muslim is one who follows the tenets laid down in the koran.
Corollary: unless he renounces the koran in toto, he must be considered a muslim.
India has 15 crore Pakistani Trojan Horses
@@19683 So any pragmatic solution how do we identify each one of them and neuter them?
Uday Sheorey
Troy fell because the Greeks attacked the Trojans when they were sleeping.
It is for us to be ever vigilant which we are not most of the time.
The prognosis is poor for Hindus.
@@19683 You are right, brother, the prognosis is poor unless we do something about it, now.
I have been reading about the plight of the British. It is said that by 2035 UK will be a majority muslim country. And they do not seem to know what to do to stem the tide.
Over here we can of course increase the pace of the gazwa-e-islam movement. Any better solution?
You Geelani are completely out classed.
...is that you in the DP....cute 😊
I was glued to the debate n amused with the hot issues ,as long as the young MP Tamyang Tsering Namgal a local born of Ladakh ,who seems to know much History will stand for the country ...god bless him n India..Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Kashmiri people are our brothers & sisters in our endeavors of development.
Dr.Anand & Vivekji sweepout the whole debate....
Terror is the reason for the restrictions; don’t you get it Gowhar Gillani !
That Geelani guy was lecturing about internet shutdown for 7 months. But conveniently forgot 30 years of shutdown of own homes for Kashmiri Pandits who cannot go back to their own home. No one talks about this 30 years of shutdown of homes while shed tears for "internet shutdown".
MP from Laddakh answered brilliantly superb and spot on….
I request to ARTH plz debate with only RANGANATAN SIR n gouhar geelani all Indian will be thankful. Thnx
what happened to Kashmiri Pandits who became refugees in their own country is a big shame
Anand Ranganathan. Love you for your analysis and talks. Ladle of True Bharath!
Let's remember the good words of
Dr. B.R.Ambedkar quoted by Shri Anand Ranganathan.
"Islam is a close corporation & the distinction that it makes between Muslims & Non Muslims is very real, very positive & very alienating distinction, their brotherhood of Islam is not the Universal brotherhood of man, it is the brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity, but it's benefit is confined to those within that corporation, for those who are outside thr corporation there is nothing but Contempt & Enemity"
Dr. B.R.Ambedkar ( Jai Bheem Jai Meem).
Salute to JTN,His one line just killed it.
Anand & Vivek are rockstar!!! 🤟🏻
It’s the most fantastic and heroic decision that any PM in this entire world, had ever taken.
I’m so glad and happy 😃
Long live Modi !!!
Remove 370 and 35A
Do u think Kashmiri people like u
@@beingkashmiri145 no panic about kashmir ...kashmir is part of india...
24:39 Anand Ranganathan sir 🔥🔥🔥
Sai Deepak makes a huge difference to any panel.
Dr. Ranganathan and Tsering Sir need a fan club :)
Gowhar Gilani , you want people to know the ground reality ??? Let me tell all that Kashmir is are crying as they didn't see internet for last 6 months. But Kashmiri Hindus hv not seen their homes for last 30 years because of these internet deprived radicals.
only internet seems to be the issue for gilani for obvious reasons
Kashmiri Hindus gotta speak louder! And we all are with you!
Well said
Abi toh chlaa do internet 4g 😂😂😅😋😋😅🤣
Full support to Pandits. Jai Sharda Scripts.
Beautiful discussion about Kashmiris 🙏🏼❤️
That Geelani started playing victim card, not answering real questions because he has no answers
That Geelani guy was lecturing about internet shutdown for 7 months. But conveniently forgot 30 years of shutdown of own homes for Kashmiri Pandits who cannot go back to their own home. No one talks about this 30 years of shutdown of homes while shed tears for "internet shutdown".