Vocal Coach Reacts to Christina Aguilera Vs Perrie Edwards (Little Mix) VOCAL BATTLE
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 03. 2019
- *Support the Honest Vocal Coach
/ thehonestvocalcoach
*Request a Reaction: honestvocalcoach.co.uk/reacti...
*Do you want me to critique your singing?
www.wisio.com/TheHonestVocalC...
The Equipment I Use as a CZcamsr: (Camera, Webcam, Microphone, Ring Light Etc)
www.amazon.co.uk/shop/honestv...
*The Foundations of Singing - My Online Course is available NOW!
This course is ideal for beginners or those wanting to know more about the technique of singing and have a daily vocal routine. It includes: How we sing, The Benefits of Singing, Warm Up exercises, Registers, Range, Personal Development and so much more. 17 lessons explained in a fun, honest and uncomplicated way. Now includes some extra special content from Robert Lunte, to understand Onsets.
Take the course:
www.udemy.com/course/the-foun...
*I now know - Georgina Hill-Brown (Original Song) Stream now: open.spotify.com/track/3onNs5...
Social Media:
Twitter: / thehonestvocal
Instagram: / thehonestvocalcoach
Facebook: / honestvocalcoach
Website: www.honestvocalcoach.co.uk
Who am I?
Expert singing teacher, specialising in teaching children and young adults in singing and musical theatre. She has worked with the likes of The Saturdays for MTV, on shows such as Just the Two of Us for the BBC and many more. Throughout her years of teaching she has judged in many competitions, judging Lucy Spraggan, George Samson, amongst others who have gone onto succeed in the business.
I am the founder of Vocaltutor, (founded 2003) the UK’s largest vocal and singing tuition network and now The New Foundry Studios which opened in 2013.
I have worked with BBCTV on Just the Two of Us, with many celebrities including Natasha Hamilton of Atomic Kitten, plus has worked for ITV on many children’s TV programmes including The Worst Witch, as their vocal coach.
Go to my website for even more details: www.honestvocalcoach.co.uk
#honestvocalcoach #vocalcoachreacts
This video is for educational purposes and is not intended to infringe any copyright.
Perrie Edward's is so underrated.
Nicky Nacky Noo
Mood
No she isn’t lol
No she is not ,she is just very good ;)
I say they both are.and their both fantastic as well
HAHAHAHAHAHAH WHATTTTT???
as a fan of Perrie Edwards, it's such a privilege to see a comparison of hers and Christina's vocals. For me that only means that she can be as great as Christina when her time comes. We have our full respect to her like what we have for perrie
Lol no, perrie doesnt have what christina has and thats something that cant be taught.
Jo Ja please..
@@joja1621 perrie is my far better than xtina and if we speaking facts xtina has not made an impact on music..
Aranielle Benny wtf Christina is the most influential singer of her generation, influenced Ariana, Demi, Tori, Jojo, Jessi J Christina Grimmie and even Little Mix sang Christina song in Xfactor. Perrie is nowhere near Christina. A lot singers out there can sing with better quality than Perrie, but Christina made an impact so massively with her vocal. She create performances that Perrie wishes she could do.
@@minhvipham8850 hold up, first of all, if u haven't heard perrie's vocals, then I can understand why u r saying that, but if u have then u r very much mistaken. Perrie has strong, powerful vocals with AN AMAZING TECHNIQUE which Christian obviously doesn't have. Christina very often over does her singing vocals and she doesn't have a good technique whatsoever. While Perrie actually has lots of different tones to her voice and a flawless technique. And Perrie would never actually dream of doing any of Christina's performances because honey, her and her bandmates do way better.
Its weird that while Christina has one of the worst techniques she has done stuff with her voice not many can do.
And think what she could do if she cares to take some lessons and sing properly and not over sing EVERY time she performs
That is what always stumps me 🤔
I mean, i don't think singers don't like to grate their throats.
Sometimes I feel pretty painful from listening to her live. She’s too obsessed with showing off how powerful her voice is
Art Aspire her technique isn’t bad, because she does it on purpose and it doesn’t hurt her
I'm a simple human, saw Perrie, so I clicked
Same aha
Same lol
Ugh Perrie is absolutely amazing. Her talent and skills of singing just are incredible.
Yuh im a mixer
Ikr! My favourite LM member is Jade, but I have to admit that Perrie easily tops her peers in Little Mix in terms of technique
perrie is something else and she is not comparable with others, she has beautiful and powerful voice that not a lot of singers have, it's a shame that little mix is so underrated
Look I love christina she is an icon and a legend but tbh perrie is one of the best vocalist of our generation , doesnt matter how popular she is perrie is amazing vocally christina is too but there is smth about perries voice that makes its quality amazing
Haven’t heard Pierre before not a little mix fan. She’s incredible!!!
Been a Christina fan for a long long time. Not a vocal coach so can’t comment on techniques but have always been aware she has a “poor technique” however I think she (and fans alike) like this “quality” as it has a rawness to it.
Might check little mix out now 🤣
*Perrie, not Pierre
You should, they're incredible! Check out,
Little mix "acapella queens" video,
Little mix performing "Women Like Me at the Brits 2019",
Little mix performing "Power at the glory days tour"
You definitely should! They are freaking amazing!
IT'S PERRIE ❤
you might have check it before 😑
I think your videos comparing Christina with other singers are probably always going to have the other singer as the winner because Christina has never seemed to care about using proper technique. And, since this is by far the number one aspect on which you base your analyses, it's quite natural to assume that she is going to lose haha. Love your videos and Perrie is indeed an amazing vocalist. 😍
All that is why her reaction video’s regarding Xtina are pointless. Xtina is a singer who purposely works against technical standards as she takes a more aggressive and raw approach. She’s not a technical vocalist. Never claimed she was. She’s a raw soul singer, inspired by the likes of Etta James. You can teach everyone to have great technique but it takes natural skills, talent and a god given voice to sound like Xtina. And well while there are many that sound like Perrie there is no one that sounds like Xtina which is why she’s so majorly cited as an inspiration and was awarded as “the voice of a generation”!
Jones Texx you’re so right omg!! Finally someone smart
Franco Biondo I think your comment is not good because xtina is an extraordinary singer because she use a lot of sing techniques for example head voice, chest voice, mix voice,a perfect vibrato and her musically is huge, all that including the vocal potential and the magnitude of her voice and perrie needs to be a bit less nasal in the highs, have more vocal control in the vibratos and increase their vocal power because it's poor if we talk about xtina, it's like comparing a first soprano with a light soprano the power in the voice will never be same So I think you should check your comment
Xtina knows how to use a perfect technique but she prefers to stand her style against to sound perfect
@@jonestexx4022 "while there are many that sound like Perrie there is no one that sounds like Xtina which is why she’s so majorly cited as an inspiration" - This is very true!
But I don't agree with what you said about this vocal coach not praising Christina's technique, she recently reviewed her performance of "You Lost Me" on this channel and gave her lots of praise because her technique was more controlled.
Christina Aguilera has inspired so many, i will forever love her
This video is accurate tbh...
Xtina is my favorite vocalist, but technically speaking, the Queen doesn’t use a good technique, even tho I’m obsessed with her style and sound
I'm not a fan of Christina but I love her runs and her tone when she's not lowering her larynx
she has this thing that we dont know yet we loved lmao
Yes Xtina has a bad technique but im kinda have chills whenever she hits a simple D5 note than other singers who can easily hit F5 or higher chest it just sounds boring. You cant always fucos on technique for me soul and emotions are much more fascinating.
Extacly
Exactly, for Christina I think it will be like love it or hate it. I've never heard anybody said that they like her. Either love her or hate her. And for me I love her so much.
BenBen Vlogs yes she sounds like that a lot recently but she sounded better when she was younger, if she would have properly developed her voice she probably wouldn’t sound like that now. Her voice sounds scratchy now
I love Christina's voice, her tone is very unique and so soulful and emotional.
But actually if Christina followed a bit of vocal technique like Perrie uses, then she would be able to sing the G5 in "Beautiful" live, instead of skipping that note and other ones or straining live. Christina could be even better (she's already amazing) if she used a bit better technique for at least **some** higher notes.
BenBen Vlogs bitch why are u even talking about sales?
PEZ WON PEZ IS JUST INCREDIBLY TALENTEDD💙
Yuh
Perrie Is amazing!
Perrie Edwards is so underrated. Hope she gets the recognition she deserves.
It's not always about the high strained notes! Have you seen the whole video of "I love you Porgy" or "lift me up" or "Save me from myself" Xtina gives you soul, pop, rasp, whistle tones, softness, vibrato!! Come on!! 👑🎤💋 EDIT! Basically putting it all together she gives you pure RAW EMOTIONS and her stage presence sets it off.
What whistle?
Denniel Escoto “whistle tones”
Well this is vocal battle, which is about the technique
Denniel Escoto actually high falsetto’s
Christina never done whistle tones. She hit her highest notes using super head voice
X'tina voice Tone is everything.
Her voice when she was young isNatural and angelic
And now it's turn to beautiful dark dramatic raspy voice....🥰
Perrie: Belts
Xtina: HV/Falsetto and Whistle notes
And also the channel forgot to include Perrie's C5 and F6 whistle notes.
Perrie and xtina can't whistle
@@martynamilewska4736 yes she can she has the range for it and has done it she likes the rasp she fives her vocal it's a choice
@@martynamilewska4736 Perrie can but she just don't use because she learn. When she got her tonsil remove. :)
Martyna Milewska they both can. Petrie just doesn’t use it often
Most of the clips selected for this video were high notes above D5
If they had selected clips of high notes where Christina is more comfortable live (B4 - D5) Christina would have definitely scored more points. Or her lower range, which is so strong and so soulful. But yeah Perrie has much better technique for her high notes, so in relation to **that** aspect of her voice she sings in a healthier way and that's the reason she won in this case.
I actually preferred Christina's vocal style in her first couple of albums. She didn't seem to push nearly as much.
She actually pushed so hard on the earlier albums that the tone we hear today is the resulting of the damage.
João Vítor Not really. Christina could still deliver acceptable technique in the early stages of her career. It was on the Stripped era Xtina started to push a lot.
João Vítor I agree.
The problem with these videos is picking up loose pieces of Xtina performances where most of the performances are memorable, full of passion. What attracts me most about Xtina is the fact that she usually gives everything in her performances!
Perrie Edwards!
Same
Chills everytime perrie belts that note from lightning
Christina May be the voice of a generation, but she’s going to ruin her vocal cords if she keeps singing like she does.
Also, fun fact: Perrie’s voice changed drastically after she had her enlarged tonsils removed at age 19. If you sing, you know that having the tonsils removed at such a late age has the possibility of making someone never sing again. Think about that next time you bash Perrie.
Perrie is also close to 15 years younger than Christina, so for her voice to be so seasoned is incredible.
Funny how Christina just did a tour with better vocals than the last decade so 💁🏼♂️
perry and christina both have big voice but that doesnt mean perry is much amazing . perries voice is soprano while christina is mezzo.
"She's going to ruin her vocal cords..." more than 20 years in the industry and Xtina keeps gettin better...
funny fact, i did remove my tonsils at 19 and I got medicine which makes my muscles weaker. Still singing
Oops guess what Xtina still sounds the same as 20 years ago
people wont love xtina if they care about techniques but the emotions she gave us just sublimeeeee!
Perrie, my QUEEN😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😻😻😻😻😻😻❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👏👏👏she is the best
These legend stans need to back up. Perrie has an amazing voice and they most definitely are comparable.
Perrie ofc
I love Christina but she will always lose this battles.
She has no technique but I like it. ❤
The strain creates a feeling I really enjoy. 😊
yesss
@Sylvester Robinson Of course she sings that way on purpose but she just doesn't have a particularly healthy technique and causes major strain on the notes
Georgina, you are equally knowledgeable, funny and delightful. I have ultimate respect and admiration for you. I love how you have a little sip of your mug of tea as you critique and the look on your face as you hear one you like. It is utter appreciation of vocal ability. Thank you so much for doing this you total beaut xx
Perrie Edwards will be always the Best and will be always the queen 👌💚💚💝
I love that you say "it was alright" of Christina's incredible note at the end of her legendary Man's World performance that was the talk of the town at that time. You don't like her style and that's OK, not everyone wants boring straight tone but it was alright? Puh-lease!!!
and yet Perrie or the girls (Little Mix) is still underrated 😭
Can you react to demi lovato best live performances 2017-2018. It shows off her amazing vocal abilities really well
I will always be convinced that Christina willingly uses that strain. That’s what makes her so recognizable. I absolutely adore her tone.
Totally agree! The fact that people still think Christina doesn’t have a good technique baffles me, she’s so amazing! This coach should take out some personal preferences when she critica singers.
Perrie Edwards x
Perrie is undoubtedly the best and her voice in acoustic melts
it might be strain but it's giving her a raspy effect to her voice and it sounds amazing, that's why she does it. I could never pick out perries voice, but you know its xtina right away. If you only care about technique then yea, but if you care about originality, passion, power and versatility, xtina wins
*Perrie* is the better vocalist in terms of healthier technique 🌌 but in terms of originality, creativity, musicality & artistry, *Christina* is a better vocalist! 🌟
(Plus low notes weren't added, & Xtina would undoubtedly win that).
She will undoubtedly lose most of these vocal battles when technique is being evaluated, but being a vocalist isn't solely about technique, it transcends that.
She wasn't given the title *"Voice of her generation"* for a trivial reason.
*P.S.* Incredible reaction, once again; it's always enlightening & entertaining to watch your videos. Plus I admire that you attempt to remain quite objective yet explain why certain technical/non-technical aspects of singing may be preferred ✨💕✨
I knooow there’s something about Christina’s voice that draws me in and I don’t get that from perrie. She’s still great tho
GarageStudio czcams.com/video/aRrAtWJtriw/video.html that is all
I agree with you on all this 🙌
Can you tell me why Christina titled "The Voice of Our Generation"? Don't bully me lmao i'm just asking, okay?
Akmal the people titled her as it, she was praised by Celine dion, Aretha Franklin, patty labelle, Etta James, and many others do I thinks she is more than deserving
My gosh, I just love you. I do, you’re so sweet and funny!! Please stay on CZcams! X from Holland
Those were some of the worst examples for Christina I've ever seen... The randomness is real...
The vídeo is made bby obviously someone that doesnt like Xtina or a perry fan
TSC gaming that’s what i thought. the only good one was lift me up.
Exactly my thoughts! Even though some of these were some of my fav performances of hers
What? Then you are deaf. You only say these things because she didn't win. But the main reason she didn't win is because this vocal coach doesn't like her at all. These are all good clips from Christina.
Even in her best videos
Perrie will be winning too
Her voice is unlimited
Love them both, both women are such strong vocalists
It amuses me how people get insulted by simply saying they don't like Christina. "She's a legend!!! You are so dumb!!", I mean, yeah! She IS a legend! But still... She strains so much it hurts MY throat to hear it!!! I get that it's on purpose, but she's gonna ruin herself with that... Either way, just wanted to say that even if you don't like Christina, you shouldn't be shamed for it. So whoever you think won, just chill out and be nice!
I see people hating on perrie or bashing her... First you should know that she is one of the best vocalists of our generation (in top 5 for sure).. I have seen so many vocal coaches reaction to her voice...tbh every LM member have voices that can just melt your heart..
So before hating on some one get your facts clear hun and don't forget to get a life..
Christina Aguilera vs sia vocal battle
Oh that must be so good🎀👍
...... Christina has her one technique that nobody else can do, which in other word, if you sounds boring... u will never get to the fame that Christina is in now
3:30 omfgggg
We should start comparing them in clips where they’re the same age.
I love it when Xtina strains but sometimes she strains little bit too much, it kinda sounds painful but her head and whistle are awsome, Perrie’s belting never dissapoints me she’s sooo talented i love of them ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Perrie is a much clearer and powerful voice
React to ariana grande vs perrie edwards
Id have to agree, Pierre for me, as well... you just hear so MUCH growl and strain from Xtina... sorry but Pierre chest votes are pretty much STRONG and sustained without issues
Perrie Queen Edwards.
So the point of your scoring is bout techniques well xtina never gonna win that thing!!!! If u know what i mean
As a non singer, I don't really care about a proper techinque as long as it sounds good so for me they're both fantastic 😊
You have to listen to Christina perform that same song “At Last” when she was younger during her stripped concert when she had black hair
"The tongue is back again in her mouth"
😂👅
Where did it go?
Please react to Ariana’s best vocals!! Please like that she see it ☺️
Luka Savic tour vocals for sure
@@tibu4760 Yessss. SWT proves that Ariana really is the best vocalist of this generation (after Tori and JoJo obvi, as far as this generation of vocalists goes, no one tops these two).
How did I not realise how good perrie was?!
Side note: as an adult with a tongue tie, it would make a lot of sense to me if Christina perhaps had one too? Since I obv can't get my tongue over my lips more than a few mm, it makes life easier to learn to have it in the back of your mouth otherwise it kind of makes a hill
For me it will always be Christina. Perrie is great no doubt. Both are great vocalists but Christina's voice is just so special. Like there is no other singer who sounds like her.
I'm an Xtina fan and as to technique, she will somehow always lose, but after 20 years in her career (with that wrong technique) she still managed to sing beautifully. Xtina is a soul singer that's why she always tends to show more emotions than correct techniques. Sometimes following a correct technique makes the song boring. That's why i love xtina cause she's unique and a risk taker.
Would have loved to hear the lower register compared. I love Christina’s rich notes down there.
Love them both anyways.. both pretty and talented and amazing vocals..😍😍😍
There is no way Christina shouldn't get more if these are her best. She is a power house.
I prefer Perrie, let just remind one thing: Christina is 15 years or more older than Perrie, when you got the old videos from Whistles and Falsettos, Christina wbetter. I love both, but the years when they pass by, especially singing, the voice gets tired for some singers, maybe Perrie’s will change just like Christina’s or will stay the same...
But, God! They are soooo Good
Hi Georgina, I just discovered you and I'm already a Big fan of the way you judge vocals ! I'm french and there's a french songer that sings in inglish Marina Kaye, I would love you to react on acoustics version on "Homeless" "Dark star" and "Dancing with the devil" I would love so much you to react on her !!
Love this. Love both of them, love seeing them compared… not sure you listened to Christina as well as you should’ve though at 4:02… beautifully sustained note from her here and her descending notes were balanced as well.
I keep imagining Perrie, Christina and Demi singing together, because the three scream more than anything, They would break the Stage, they are so good they are❤️ i love them😍😍
Are u kidding me? I love Christina because she’s all about soul and she gave u real pain when she sings, there’s sooooo many songs of her that I can’t listen without crying, and her lives omg she was born with the best gift that a singer can have, soul and feelings that touches you even when u don’t wanna be touched. The most unique and beautiful voice too.
Dear this video is not about emotional quality
She’s giving real pain because she’s in pain trying to carry that note. Lol
I love your videos but I’m just curious to know surely if Christina has been straining all her career how can she still sing so well? Maybe it’s just the way she sings her voice has had that rasp her whole career and she still does it now..... not disagreeing just curious that’s all ❤️
Wondering the same. And even after 30 years using that (alleged) wrong singing style that according to critics it was supposed to ruin her vocal folds, she never had surgery, or had nodules or smth like that. Singing in that "unhealthy way" she keeps on delivering some really nice vocals (just watch her tour last year). Still better than 90% of today's singers!
I feel like it's just a style choice and she's doing it correctly or she would be mute by now. People love criticizing her for it but the truth is she's better than most other singers out there even to this day and a lot of those haters are just jealous cause their fave could never, strained or not.
if i would i choose between the two of them... I would rather Perrie's voice😍
She Doesnt Like Xtina I Can See That Now
Man are u hearing the other woman? She sounds better, both are great but Perrie sounds more enjoyable
She didn't make the video and the reaction is about vocal technique not enjoyment of the note. Therefore Christina Aguilera lost.
Christina: *If you sing it all soft and lovely nobody cares...*
Honey have you met Billie Ellish
gurl have you heard say something
You should react do Dinally duo powerhouse, they were from Fifth Harmony and they're so good.
I really love your channel. ❤️
The growls in xtinas voice is called a False growl and it doesn't hurt her voice and the false growl doesn't damage her voice
I TOTALLY agree with you
Perrie is amazing
I would love to have a singing voice like Christina. I grew up with her music, so she’d be my winner. Thanks for the video
Perrie Edwards is so underrated, little mix deserves way more credit because actually all 4 of them are amazing. I feel like fifth harmony became the “famous girl group” just because they were more problematic and their management worked them so hard to keep them relevant leaving little mix out of the spotlight. But they deserve just as much, if not, more recognition. I know this video isn’t about fifth harmony but I couldn’t help but bring them up because I feel like people always compare two although it’s obvious that fifth harmony was more famous, they certainly aren’t more talented and I hate how so many talented people don’t get the credit they deserve.
Restraurant singers are underrated. Or teachers, scientiests. Superstars getting millions are overrraited, i believe. No hate, just true of life
I love both
3:36 am i the only one who saw the mic leave her mouth but she was singing the same volume?
Xtina has a tone that just is very pleasing to ear. Some people just have a better sounding voice. And christina is right. No one cares about perrys voice. She underated. Where as people do xtina and has been called the voice of a generation for that delibrate technique.
Those little mix girls aren't to be messed with... Any of the LM members can out do xtina vocally, they are ofc British... Usually British singers are by far better vocally than Americans..
I was born impressed by Perrie's belts and Christina's head voice!
Love Christina Aguilera!!!❤️🎵🎤
Personally I dislike Christina’s Belts. I like her low notes but her Headvoice is what sells me every time! Like it is simply one of the best! I am a fan of perrie and she is amazing to!
I think she likes Perrie
I'd just like to say that, although Christina IS able to use some whistle register, she mostly uses her super high falsetto to mimic whistles notes. Also, just an opinion(that I may be totally wrong about), most of her falsettos that sound like the whistle register, are relatively low as far as true whistle notes are. Even though I know that the whistle register can also be used in lower notes, for example C6-E6. And again I know Christina can access her whistle register, especial now, and with more control. But I feel she uses her high falsetto notes more often than true whistles. Just my thoughts, I'm no expert at all. So I could be completely incorrect. If anyone disagrees, please feel free to let me know if I'm totally wrong here.
How can you listen to Christina's album or see an entire show of hers ? That must be tiring hearing her pushing and pushing.
She doesn't strain in her albums dude!! I guess you never heard one. That's not a read, Christina choose to strain during live performances to give extra!!!!
Hi, I am a new subscriber to your channel. I would love to see a vocal battle between Kelly Clarkson and Mariah Carey. They are both phenomenal singers in my book.
In my honest opinion, no one can beat Christina’s raw, unique, soulful tone. I, as a fan of music, don’t care about the technique, it’s boring honestly. Christina is cited as the voice of our generation by many. Legends like Whitney, Patti, Aretha, Celine, have all praised her and her vocals. Her music career & accolades speak for itself!
Any one else notice at 7:54 the count went from 4 to 6???
i dont care for a technique. if i like the song i like the song. christina was alaways my n.1 and this will continue bc her music touches my heart everytime and thats the important thing for me!
Thing is Christina's voice is so stunning that she makes this sound work but with many singers they have to rely heavily on technique because they don't possess that stunning voice.
For me Xtina voice are so much better, this is personal
Renan Tavares yeah her voice is soulful... while others just sing hahaha
This is why I always feel that being a technical vocalist is one thing and being an impactful voice that will be remembered forever is a totally different territory. Christina has once in a lifetime voice. The way she sings is overtly emotional and expressive and totally unforgettable. Although Perry is a good technical vocalist, yet she doesn't have that special soulful tone that Christina has. Explains why Christina's voice has been called exceptional by legends like Whitney, Celine, Etta, etc. I doubt Perry will ever have that status.
Both perrie and cristina has distinct voice. Both have deep voice.
React to sezina From the voice kids holland❤️❤️
Perrie is always my top artist ❤️
You should react to Ariana Grande “The Wizard and I” live🙏🏽 I think you would love it and I would really like to see your opinion on it😌
Stop reacting to these videos because all these singers compared to christina focus on technique! Christina doesnt on purpose. Also if the lows were included. Xtina wouldve won.
Jo Ja even xtina sing with good technique perrie is still better
@@poeticallydamaged8372 u wish