Huge Drama in the Smash Community
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 11. 2022
- CHESSBOXING TICKETS ► www.ludwig.gg
follow me on twitter ► / ludwigahgren
follow me on tiktok ► / ludwigahgren
follow me on instagram ► / ludwigahgren
join my subreddit ► / ludwigahgren
LINK TO EVERYTHING ► wlo.link/@ludwig
edited by: 15 take frank :/
#mogulmail #supersmashbros #drama
So Alan just threw the entire competitive community under the bus for his own needs?? Something needs to be done about this
Worst part is, this really throws the ENTIRE competitive community under the bus, not just for Smash, but for Splatoon and any other competitive communities on Nintendo IPs because of the precedent this all sets.
@@Mad-Goose That's a good point, I didn't think about that. Bro is actually a villain if it all turns out to be true
*… for his own greed.
All pros and viewers who value community and competitive integrity should boykott the Panda Cup. People like Alan understand only one language: money.
@@Mad-Goose You just corrected someone by CAPSING exactly what they said. Let that sink in and change your life up.
Alan seems like the type of person who would unleash a bucket of roaches in a restaurant to get it shut down, just because they got his order wrong
I'm a chef personally Nah he's the worst Version he's the type to do that because he ordered, changed his mind didn't tell anyone and then gets mad when the food he ordered arrives because now he doesn't want it and the staff should have known that....
More like just because the restaurant tells him no, we cannot make what you want if its not on the menu
not becaue they got his order wrong, because he has a restaurant next door 💀
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
Alan the type of guy to release roaches in a 5 star bistro and hopes that people will still be hungry and come to his McDonald's down the road he franchises
I hope Alan realizes that if he actually gets what he wants and push comes to shove, a lot of people will just either abandon the tournament scene entirely or retreat to a private, no-stakes one where no broadcasting or monetization occurs. There's no real version of this where he comes out on top.
Casuals... watching Smash... does not compute. But really the casuals are brought in by streamers like Lud, and it looks like most of them will boycott anything Alan does.
He wont have much, dont think viewers much less good players wanna work for a dude that deserves to be unalived.
Realistically even if some top dogs aren't gonna play in it, many lower levels will like the other commenter said. And there will still definitely be a big enough audience to make profit. boycotts just don't happen to the extent they used to before the internet, when was the last time you saw a notably large and homogenous group of people, period?
@@Nate-bd8fg they are going to be a "200 viewer andy". It will be teeth skin profits
@@BURRDAWG_ I hope so. Screw Alan (probably)
Alan really out here pulling a "i killed your boyfriend, so now you can be with me," on the Smash community. And is, similarly, going to be shocked when the community doesnt just fall into Pandas arms.
This is such a perfect analogy
Eh I just saw a videos that seems to point out the Smash World Tour did that. Well they killed Panda but they survived so good for them.
Edit: Watch "the Unsolved Mystery of Smash World Tours".
Huge props for calling out Nintendo on their BS. And huge props to being able to explain the story so completely, even though the news just publicly broke. Respect for how deep into the Smash community you still are.
well said
I’ve haven’t played smash in a while, but slightly sad that Nintendo cancelled the Smash Events.
mogul mail is a god at explaining quickly yet still getting all info across comprehensively
Hey guys, HankVenom here.
.
it’s so sad that nintendo does this everytime the smash community finally has something good going for them
literally every goddamn time they try to make a little growth that isn't under the cover of night.
big fan of the Melee Stats video on this
Not entirely Nintendo's fault this time, it's Allen's fault.
t. people who didn't watch the video
Could be that since Ultimate might be the “last” Smash game, Nintendo’s looking to events to monetize.
Shame they’re doing it in classic Nintendo fashion though.
"It's not enough that I should succeed. Others should fail as well" - Sun Tzu
Could have sworn it was Dio
Gay asf
@@thetimebeing4288 same race
@@bootleg6595 British?
Alan is gonna make himself out to be the victim and will cherry pick one or two of the responses online and say “the abuse I’ve been receiving has been making me depressed. I tried so hard to make this the best tournament ever for the community blah blah blah” Because that’s what narcissists do
But we won't listen to him
@@Pedro-ho2xj You may not but others will, this community is too ignorant sometimes. It'll probably work.
Hopefully we get an apology video with him sitting on his kitchen floor saying "guys I did a big oopsie"
@@epikhllo9767 “I’ve made a severe and honest mistake”
Welcome to the world, where entitled people only think about themselves and manipulate others into doing so as well...
Imagine being a fan of a company that literally hates its fans
Activision, EA, blizzard have entered the chat
At this point, nobody hates nintendo more than smash players lmao
@@waves9515 judging by the recent game, pokemon fans are getting there
@@undoubtedlyso4542 game freak isn't Nintendo.
but this time nintendo has an actual reason
The fact that it was more than nintendo this time, and it was Panda. This was like a twist villain! Its not surprising since the panda Cup was announced but we trusted them because it was panda.
the CEO of panda, an org that was honestly rather beloved, working on massive projects, sponsoring great personalities, making content; Panda who was founded as a Smash Bros Org, then went and did some nefarious deeds is really disappointing
Really is like a villain with twisted motives
Getting blindsided like that is what makes it feel so much worse
This sucks as a spectator that loves just casually playing and watching the game, I can only imagine what players/TOs/other affected like that must be going through
Twisted motives = money
That Alan guy never really seemed too interested in Smash
I understand that Alan may have been doing some pretty twisted things, but somehow I don’t see Nintendo of all companies getting strong armed into anything. Let alone by the leader of an esports org. I feel like they would just pull the panda cup license and leave.
@@homerobenavides5156 Capitalism, baby!
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
Honestly…..the smash community might just ignore the panda cup now that they have done this. Which unfortunately might really hurt the community going forwards. It’s pretty sad.
@@asimhussain8716 after the horrendous turnout at the 50k pot tourney recently this is verifiably and demonstrably false.
@@asimhussain8716 I know it's unreasonable to expect but I really hope the big names say fuck that shit. The short term sacrifice might be worth it and bring in more money in the long term.
@@asimhussain8716 but does it equal with the backlash they will receive after they support the villainess??i know people love money but the stain will last forever in their name so most people won't just jump in to the pool of drama without any thinking
@@shepardice3775 a lot of big names have already canceled going, and the ones that are contractually obliged to go aren't gonna try and just dick around.
@@asimhussain8716 it was in an extremely remote part of canada
“It’s not winning unless everyone else loses.”
-Alan CEO of Panda
Alan is like that kid in school that pushed the laid back teacher too far and ruined it for everyone.
Only Nintendo have been tight asses for a long time, done a lot of shady things, shut down servers, don't care for the fanbase etc
@@alexb7092but they’ve not touched VGBC streams and events until now…
@@Smashfan258 PM
@@Smashfan258 ?
I hate people in the same community that instead of lifting each other up brings others in that community down.
Like mogul mail said, its this weird cartoon villain thing where "he's actually helping by making a grand cup that will gift the smash scene a great future alongside Nintendo" when actually it's tearing down grass roots events and the community that's established itself over the last 20 years
@@kestrelynn holy shit reading it this way really does make it seem like some villain shit
@@kestrelynn yeah the plot twist
It kinda sucks
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
The worst part is this all this happened in favor of a world circuit called the "Panda Cup"
?
@@vibive It's a shitty name
Not even world it’s just NA qualifier tournaments
@@okayperson3041 makes it even worse. They got the world circuit shut down for a smaller one
It's also important to note: If you want to share your opinion on the matter definitely call Nintendo Support and leave some feedback. Do be nice though, the people that work there do not have any say in these kind of decisions and are fans as well who probably also have opinions on this situation, they just aren't able to say anything because they aren't allowed to. They do take down and pass back feedback though so definitely call if you would like to leave feedback but please be nice to the people you speak to if you do.
Proper plan this, i appreciate you and what you do
That's doesn't have anything to do with the topic
I feel like if some of these commenters would lose their shit talking to support
@@ABC-ik9vj How does it not have anything to do with the topic?
@@MrCaw77 Because why would you even contact Nintendo Support just to complain, while you know that it won't change anything??
As a smash tournament organizer who has ran 100 tournaments. thank you for using your platform to speak on this and bring attention to it.
Are you going to run 101 tournament?
@@vinylSummer haha, I am. But it’ll be about a month until then
Thank you so much for bringing this to the spotlight. Beyond disappointed in Nintendo
Get in line.
Bro posted this comment before he even watched the video
@@the_tea1917 I actually read the document before hand. I didn’t like how they handled this. Smash players have never gotten the kind of developer support that other esports enjoy
Genuinely what's new. Nintendo is the shittiest garbage gaming-adjacent company I've ever seen.
this is just what happens when an organization like Nintendo who likes to maintain a good image allows their name to be used by someone who was “trusted” like panda goes ahead and does this type of gangster type modus operandi. What do you expect Nintendo to do other than pull the plug on their life support.
I feel like Japanese bureaucracy also had a hand in this. The amount of red tape someone needs to go through to get ANY kind of permission or official approval is mind boggling. From even just getting a bank statement, you need to be prepared to have to talk to managers and their superiors with every single piece of documentation that could be even slightly related. And expect a big fat NO even after going through these ridiculously extensive processes.
I strongly suspect this is just Nintendo playing by typical Japanese company rules. They're uptight in general when it comes to piracy, licensing, etc. They think they're doing the right thing, fans think they're being screwed over.
crazy how this never happens with capcom
@@destituteanddecadent9106 To be fair... they kinda are being screwed over. Cause hardly any other company is THIS level of ignorant or willing to deny a whole fanbase without batting a single eye or later backpedaling on said decision.
Mogul mail just wanted to say that your degree in english literature and journalism was probably very worthwhile, your ability to analyze information, filter out fake news and just be clear and understandable when you tell it is amazing, so much better than ludwigs sincerely, love this channel keep it up!
npc
you def dont need a journalism degree to do this. anyone can do it as long as they arent an idiot
@@mrfahrenheit677 You massively overestimate the average person then
@@CarSpotter9 i didnt say "average" tho did i? i said "not an idiot". no where did i imply that "not an idiot" is the "average" person
@@mrfahrenheit677 so every average person is below an idiot?
Blizzard killed the eSports scenes for every single one of their games by doing this same bulls#*t, trying to own/control everything themselves.
Genuinely makes me sad. The amount of effort people in the community put out, not for the money, but for the love of the game and the community. Just the be led on a string and tossed to the wayside again and again. Heartbreaking and infuriating.
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
@@archeryan8404 Eh. The Pedo Bros deserve this.
Those nefarious tactics aren't going to work in a scene that exists solely because of grass roots efforts and passion from hardcore fans. People will see you for what you are, let you crumble, and find a new way to keep it going. RIP Panda if this is true.
It's insane to try to create a monopoly on culture.. and that's what it is. It's a game that has passionate fans that want to play and watch it. So any time people get together you want to have a say? This is something Nintendo tries to do again and again. Fuck them tbh.
Maybe it has something to do with the Super Smash Bros. community being jerks.
That whole thing of going to event and telling them their competition is getting cancelled like that while in negotiations could be regarded as something like Tortious interference, which the Smash World Tour could serisouly launch a lawsuit for to recover damages. I kinda hope they do just to set a precedent that this sort of behavior for Touring groups like this shouldn't be premitted.
@@dekufiremage7808 but panda was interfering in their abilities to get that official license. As Ludwig said since January they’ve attempted and based on the response provided should have had no issues yet because of willful interference the didn’t
@@dekufiremage7808 The way I read it, part of this was going on BEFORE Panda made that announcement, so there's still interference partway at least
I'd also be a bit suspect on if they claimed the tournament was "illegal" since you don't need to be sponsored to do that. Illegitimacy, I'm not sure about that since Nintendo never interacted with the tournament scene, you can't make an argument very well one way or another very well. Unless you go off of what the community thinks?
I think the big kicker is their attempts to block SWT out of the market. I can recall how someone from Marvel did this same exact thing, and that now ex-Marvel employee got smacked HARD. That might be how to dispute this.
Absolutely insane that Alan presumably just ruined an entire community just because he didn't get what he wanted
I live near Xanadu and the first time I went there to try out tournaments Gimr sat down and played a game with me to welcome me to the scene. Dude is genuinely a nice guy who cares deeply about the competitive smash scene. He deserves better than this.
Xanadu is also my local and I wanted to go there more often and go to glitch (would’ve been my first big tournament experience especially since I can’t travel.) but now that seems impossible. I loved going there.
Why does he defend a child predator tho?
I’m all aboard the fuck alan train (literally every other panda member is innocent here) but at the same time this is 95% Nintendo’s doing. I simply don’t see how one, primarily irrelevant man can convince Nintendo to flip from “we’re not cancelling events for not having licensing” to cancelling the biggest event of the year and any other event already announced by VGBC for not being licensed. Alan simply does not have that influence, regardless of the fact that Panda is partnered with Nintendo. The fact that Panda Cup didn’t get immediately cancelled after SWT for threatening other orgs tells me that Nintendo was lying to VGBC about either SWT having any chance of going through or about talking to Alan about his behavior. I think we need to wait and hear his statement on the matter before jumping to conclusions, unless we want another nairo situation on our hands
While I do agree with you that we should wait for his statement, current evidence is not looking too good for him. Nintendo sucks, we've always known that. That's why we support local scenes, VGBC, etc and that's why we don't bring ourselves down. Our common enemy was Nintendo so for Alan to reportedly (By numerous trustworthy people in the scene) threaten a shutdown of an event if they don't join the Panda cup, to demand broadcasting rights from Beyond The Summit, and to wield this partnership over our heads instead of with us, it FUCKING sucks. It's pretty clear that Alan made the information regarding VGBC being unlicensed more on the radar to Nintendo. So to say it's only 5% his doing isn't exactly fair imo.
@@joevent i mean the 5% is an exaggeration but still he couldn’t have had that much of an impact on the decision. Alans actions towards BTS in particular are awful but I can’t bring myself to take them seriously whenever alan tried to threaten a company way bigger than his own with a total shutdown when they hadn’t done anything worth getting C&D’s either. Nintendo partnering with him just doesn’t give him the authority to threaten anyone with a shutdown, and like i said before, if anything the fact that Nintendo let it slide is a better way bigger issue
What? Comparing this to the nairo situation is laughable. Nairo was proven to be flirting with an underage child, photographed with an underage boy on his lap, documented in the statements of countless pros who witnessed their relationship. Just because Nairo came out and said he was raped and literally provided zero evidence does not mean the situation was not his fault. This situation is in no comparison to the nairo situation
@@kyallon1213 Coming back to ask what you think of the statements made by Nintendo and Panda. To me, both feels like a complete deflection and says almost nothing for them.
This is literally how huge companies create monopolies. Look at airlines, cell providers, Amazon, CZcams, Facebook, etc. When some new competitor appears that threatens their success, the big company destroys the smaller one.
Maybe it has something to do with the Super Smash Bros. community being jerks.
I haven't played smash in a while, but god damn I always come back to the game because of drama. Rip the smash world tour for everyone who was actually anticipating it.
Thank you you have no idea how pissed of I am at these bitches
@David [DOND wii?! More like PooPoo Wii!💀] scam, 10k subs and no videos 🤓
@@deankrahling6060its a bot bro
the issue isn't the people enjoying it. it's the hundreds of thousands of dollars lost, dozens of people losing their jobs. and the potential collapse of the smash bros melee scene.
@@deankrahling6060 did it take a college degree for you to figure that out?
I was gonna read the whole announcement but I’m so glad you posted this and saved me from all that reading
Imagine not wanting to read words 💀
yeah reading makes me sleepy
@@wovoaoh is that what she said to you?
Your poor little brain
@@Drooook
She doesn't say anything, because "she" doesn't exist.
At least for me.
Didn't even know about this, good on you for calling them out.
crazy that in one fell swoop Alan has probably destroyed his org with this strong arming
I'm certainly done with Panda. If he keeps up this behavior then I hope his bottom line gets hit, hard. I just feel bad for the employees that will be affected by his potential downfall.
The fact that they waited until only 10 days before the event makes it so malicious.
nintendo way. remember metroid another remake?
Saw Ludwig talking about this on twitter, needed mogul mail to explain it to me 🙏
@Lance mogul mail is just tweeting on Ludwig’s account
We fought back against this 9 years ago at EVO 2013, we can do it again.
this shows how nintendo hasn't evolved a lick.
What all happened back then?
@@DJ_Mooster EVO 2013, the largest fighting game tournament of the year, had a charity event. You could donate and put that money to your game of choice. Melee beat out Skullgirls by about $10,000. After it was announced that Melee won, Nintendo stepped in and prevented the game from being broadcast, possible even played, but I'm not sure on that one. The Internet came together and rebelled, and after just 4 hours, Nintendo rescinded their decision, which led to, imo, one of the best Melee tournaments I've ever seen, with an amazing top 8.
I'm so glad that you covered this, bringing a lot more eys onto the problem than it might get otherwise. I hope this gets resolved in an ideal way because I love the smash community and watching all the tournaments, they are one of my favorite things to watch on the weekends and I really hope they continue to be that way, free from monopolistic clutches.
Damn, feel pretty bad for anyone that is signed to panda rn, seems as though they had nothing to do with any of this and I imagine that they’re gonna get a lot of shit off of people if they dont disassociate with panda which sucks because loads of these people have become much larger names and personalities in the scene and a lot of that is due to panda.
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
@@archeryan8404 They already have this anti-consumer, anti-player reputation. Nintendo simply doesn't care, they'll put out a new game and earn their billions because everyone will go buy it. Nintendo already has a reputation as being the most anti-player and anti-community of the big three. They're simply too big and too well-known to fail
@@totalawesomeness2310 there's only a small percentage of people who even know the crap Nintendo has done... if a entire smash tournament people are looking forward to that don't know, gets crippled, by Nintendo, it will raise awareness. Especially someone like Ludwig. He can stand firm on an unpopular opinion like no other.
@@totalawesomeness2310 Nintendo only strongarms us because they think we won't do it back.
@@archeryan8404 hey dude. I think you should copy-paste this reply to 30 more comments. I haven't seen it enough yet.
I can’t wait for the “Fuck Panda invitational”
Nintendo is doing something every manufacturing company does, you would just hope that they could read the room and see that a passionate fan base is a positive.
Fan base full of pedos and insecure gamers
20 years of a passionate fanbase unfortunately hasn't changed their minds. They're willfully ignorant.
End Users and Experience has always been at the bottom of Nintendo's priority list
Okay, allow me to play Devils Advocate for a moment. Bearing in mind that I don't agree with Nintendo's decision to shutter the event, is the Smash Community specifically a positive for Nintendo?
Any time I hear stories of the Smash 'community' it's almost always in a negative light, whether due to inappropriate behaviour, allegations of misconduct or just some truly toxic behaviour being par for the course. I don't think it'd be surprising if the child-friendly company Nintendo wasn't all too keen on the Smash community to begin with, especially when a significant portion of them openly hammer the most recent iteration in favour of a 20 year old game that's not going to make Nintendo any more money.
With this in mind, take what we know. Nintendo was working with Alan, and it has since come to light that Alan would pass on concerns, possibly falsified, to Nintendo to get his rivals shut down. Imagine he'd levelled an accusation of grooming, the kind of stuff the community is sadly known for. Nintendo do not want to touch that with a ten foot pole; their primary market is kids and parents of kids who wouldn't like the idea of their little Jimmy being contacted by predators while playing a Nintendo game. So, air on the side of caution and shut it all down. Smash has brought terrible PR before, why not again? It even aligns with their tweet, which mentions vague 'Health and Safety' concerns. The safety of minors is something companies are VERY wary about and Nintendo is never going to be explicit about even a potential association with grooming on a public channel, so... Health and Safety it is.
This is just speculation and even if it did happen this way it still sucks, but I don't see it as implausible that a man who we know lied about his competition might have falsified an accusation of misconduct and Nintendo immediately smacked down the entire thing because that kind of thing happens in the Smash Community with WORRYING regularity and they weren't willing to take chances.
In short, the situation sucks and Nintendo didn't handle it well, but I do think the Smash community also likes to assume themselves worthy of the benefit of Nintendo's doubt when their whole brand really doesn't align with Nintendo at all.
@@richardlee3679 good read.
Thanks for bringing this to light.
you literally could not have written this as fiction and gotten away with it
they really shut down the smash world tour just before the finale
Thanks for always sticking up for the Smash fam, Lud is a real one
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
This has the dark triad written all over it. That man really said if you Gonna run away and not fight me directly, then nobody’s gonna fight.
Thank you for shedding light on this in the way you have!
Thanks for using your platform to put more eyes on this. Nintendo and Panda need to feel the pressure.
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
@@archeryan8404 Stop spamming.
very cool of the panda ceo to help sabotage the smash scene with the help of Nintendo
it's crazy how mogul mail still remembers his smash roots, I just wish Ludwig was the same
I’m so disappointed in these events being shut down, was really hyped for this event but now ITS JUST SADNESS
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
@@archeryan8404 I’m doing my part to help this video reach everywhere in the algorithm for more people can be aware of this, fighting Nintendo at this point will not do anything but make the game I truly enjoy watching dead.
@@si3p3r not fighting Nintendo will result in them killing your game too. You're making the assumption that we're less powerful than that corporation. That's just not the case You're giving up your power.
@@archeryan8404 what can we do beside bring awareness, and that’s not an assumption it’s the sad truth that they would soon shut down every tourney that melee has if we tarnish the relationship. They don’t care about this game at all and its been showing since these past years
@@si3p3r I'm telling you what we can do. We can tell Nintendo we'd rather hold a smash tournament without the gameplay being broadcast than watch something they endorse to try and make money for their shareholders.
thank you so much for making this video. i hope it goes a long way towards making this known everywhere in the gaming scene.
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
This video absolutely aged like milk. Everything that Alan said would happen absolutely happened. VGBC and BTS are defuncted (and no one should have trusted BTS given they got kicked to the curb by Valve before). And now we find out the real reason Panda died was because someone decided to have their tournament the same day as Panda's. Nice job getting 150 people to lose their job. The irony is these people (yes you included) ended up doing more damage to Smash
I’m really enjoying how Lud cares about gaming community. I would also enjoy if he could show us ending of the story with such cases, I.e. Bethesda drama, this one etc. maybe I just hope that there is always happy ending and I’m looking forward to see it
It brings so much warmth in my heart seeing Panda get completely and utterly roasted on Twitter right now 🤣 I can’t wait to see there whole platform fail now
Panda should focus on making the panda controller. Then they will actually be useful
@@joe564338 I am friends with someone who panda contacted to help with the panda controller. It was never going to be a thing. They made one prototype. The one in the video. That's it. It was dead before the video launched. Panda was just out for publicity. Seems like a trend now.
@@outdatedboat do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
We dont want/care about panda really, we just want our community back..
Im so glad you put this out so soon! Smash's scene deserves better
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
Ironically the smash bros community seem to get the most hits from Nintendo
Thank you Ludwig. Your continued support and speaking on our behalf for the better is an amazing thing to witness. Youre a true gem of a person.
Ludwig?? Who's that? This is Mogul Mail
Damn I think all the top players should DQ from Panda Cup for this. That is total bullshit. But we need a December tournament now
We’ll see. From what I heard from some on Twitter, they are contractually obligated to make an appearance and play as scheduled. So many have come up with the idea of stalling, footsies, etc. just make the tourney awful to watch lol
But while I do feel very bad for all the participants, I feel just as bad for the Panda players. I couldn’t imagine feeling blindsided from this betrayal from your own leader, someone you trust. And then to have to worry about your financial future too!? Nah, that’s depressing…
this whole situation is basically just the saying “if it sounds too good to be true… it probably is.”
4318 141 0
The Smash community just keeps getting more and more screwed over by the creators of there own game
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
@@lettuce3052 there will be no viewership or no sponsorship if THE EVENT IS CANCELLED BY NINTENDO.................
@@lettuce3052 yeah sacrifices necessary right now. If all you're worried about is money then you're as bad as Nintendo
@@lettuce3052 Plus they could just be straight up with the sponsors and be like yo we're doing this as a protest to Nintendo. You in?
*their
One thing for sure, these draconian copyright(and patent) laws have to change.
People are getting closer and closer to a breaking point from this to insulin price gouging.
When the bank runs start, you’ll know it’s all going down.
Exactly, the SWT is its own thing. Yes the players are playing smash bros but why does Nintendo have the right to shut people down just because they're playing the game? It's not like watching a tournament stream is a replacement for playing the game, it's a totally different experience. And in terms of creativity/originality there is so much added by tournaments that are not part of the game itself and which IMO Nintendo has no business interfering with.
@@damandatwin like someone in Twitter and another YT’ers comments mentioned, it’s because they can, legally. They hold all the power to their IPs. So they’re well within their rights to say, “hey, stop broadcasting our game”. And from what I heard from others in YT and Twitter, Capcom let this get out of control in a big problem. Essentially them letting orgs broadcast/make tourneys of their games, without the proper licensing. And because of that, the FGC community in general has gotten away with so much in doing things the improper way. And that improper behavior spread like the plague. Again, this is just what I’ve heard, so idk how much truth there is to it, since I don’t know the specifics with capcom’s licensing requirements.
@@carlospolk5033 Does 'improper' in the way you're using it mean anything other than 'without licensing from the publisher'? I understand the way copyright law is set up they can do it. What I'm saying is that this application of copyright law is without merit and shouldn't exist for the reasons I mentioned.
@@damandatwin yeah I agree with you, and yes, that was exactly what my scenario was depicting. Essentially broadcasting or setting up unofficial tourneys without licensing from the publisher(s).
Huge props for calling out these guys, something needs to be done here.
The most shocking plot twist is Leffen making a tweet I agree with
Straight Fax
One way or another I think Alan's gonna be losing more sleep over a video game than he's been planning on
Keep us in the loop mr. mogul mail!
I actually look forward to every Mogul Mail. Keep it up Lud!
I hoped you guys were going to move in the world cup, love from UK :)
I take the wock there
Who's Lud? Theres no Lud here
Thanks lud for everything you do for the smash community 🙏. It’s miraculous that we help fostered someone like you and your efforts will never go unnoticed
do the tour and dont broadcast the gameplay, just the people playing. when chatters and social media wonders why, blame nintendo. tell them the evil people at nintendo are making it this way. beat them at their own game. make their reputation be a reputation of corporate evil
Christian Pulisic got hurt
@@archeryan8404 what. Are you saying Nintendo is not corporate evil...
Cause even if you hate ludwig you cant be sayin that
@@Noah-lj2sg I said the exact opposite of that..... I want more people to realize how shitty they are. Most of Nintendos audience are kids that don't care about this stuff yet. So Livestream a smash tournament they're forced to not see the gameplay of and they'll finally care about Nintendo and use the Twitter account they set up on their mom's phone number to go tell them how much they disapprove.
@@Noah-lj2sg currently, to most of Nintendo's consumers, their reputation is not "evil corporation focused on money"
you rock mogul mail for having brought this much more attention to this because of your platform!
Thank you!
My heart weeps for everyone who will be adversely affected by this. This is historically tragic in our beloved community.
It’s video games, they gon be alright
@@bigyoppa3403 it can be someone's livelihood.
@@Mark-sk6om *it is* many peoples livelihoods and the people hosting SWT are losing thousands of dollars because of this as well.
Jobs are easily found. A community built over decades of good times... that's priceless.
Maybe it has something to do with the Super Smash Bros. community being jerks and incompetent.
The chess player is Anna Cramling, the wholesome and chronically online daughter of gm Pia Cramling. She's quite active on twitch and youtube and regularly hangs out with the Botez sisters.
I love Anna ❤
Since it was announced and panda cup got licensed, I feel like we've been scared for the world tour. I really thought it was gonna happen too. Unfortunate that Nintendo treats smash like this and that Alan would hurt the scene in the way he did.
2022 has been such a comeback story for Melee and to lose SWT and have all of this controversy is just an absolute heartbreaker
Alan sounds like an absolutely delightful human being
Bro as someone who has no idea how this smash stuff works, I'm glad lud is good at explaining cuz this stuff on its own is so confusing
Nintendo trying to help the community and IP grow and flourish challenge *IMPOSSIBLE*
I'm curious how this will impact local game stores. I don't play Smash, but gaming has been a huge part of my social life but this is pretty damn insane to see happening. I feel for the Smash community as a whole, and if this turns out to affect local game stores that ain't trying to make huge money to just hold a get-together centered around Smash, I'm going to be very, very upset.
It definitely only applies to live-streamed events, so that’s probably ok
@@alcor3372 Yea, Nintendo almost definitely isnt going to bother shutting down a local event with like 30 people and 100 views on youtube. Even if they did shut down the streams, local events dont really care that much and will just continue playing anyways since the people there play for the fun of playing rather than to be streamed.
Dude be realistic lmao Nintendo isn’t going to go after locals it makes no sense.
Come for the upload, stay for Ludwig
Alan putting a target on his back
Smash Community: Damn, Nintendo! You’re kinda doing a good job with this for once!
Nintendo: Wait, we are? Hold up, one sec.
I'm glad his shirt says "Mogul" because I could have sworn, for half a second, I thought this guy was Ludwig. Crazy
This doesn't just affect smash or splatoon, but this will affect ALL Nintendo games
how so?
@@ayar2 they've tried to make people pay them 100% revenue before, for streaming any of their games, the licensing also could become a thing for all Nintendo games to be a requirement to have in order to stream them, it's like playing monopoly with content creators and their fanbase
@@alexb7092 and non monetized videos? could those be affected?
Can the event organizers of Smash World Tour sue Nintendo for letting them know and making them cancel the event such short notice (just weeks before)? According to Kotaku, they're losing hundreds of thousands of dollars becasue of Nintendo's actions.
Most likely not. They made an event out of using Nintendo's property and never got a clear allowance to do so (which would be licensing). They technically could've all been cancelled in the same fashion. Smash events are using Nintendo property without their licensing. That's why Nintendo is in the right before court.
@@johnbishop9621 but according to the medium letter, nintendo had given them the right to do so and then okay to do so which is how it all started underway in the first place. If they have that okay in emails and documented that should be evidence of Nintendo fucking them over shouldn't it?
it's so weird to me that the developer gets the broadcast rights for their games. seems like a terrible system
Well tortious interference is grounds for a lawsuit. If they were in talks to secure licensing and Panda stepped in saying their tournament will be canceled it could be considered tortious interference and grounds for a lawsuit for damages. Hopefully people boycott panda and make them lose the same money they are making other tournaments lose and then slap a lawsuit on top to really prevent this in the future
@@cosmey449 I mean it's theres. They made it, who else would it go to. Fans? So they could make thousands of dollars off of the creators hard work. The system now is working just not when corporate assholes come in and whisper in executives ears.
This hurt me so much, I was super excited for Swt seeing the best of the best compete for a massive prize pool
Wow, that's wild. Fr, so many of us smash players have been anticipating the SWT and me personally especially beacuse of the upsets between both games.
I will not jump on a hate train but it really seems that Allan tried to undermine these events. This officially licensed circuit will not be the same, the trust and community built over the past decades are too much to just drop like that. The fact that this happened is ridiculous.
I send out my prayers to the smash players who are a part of panda, I hope that things work out for them.
The Smash community is like Detroit you can't have shit.
Perhaps if you are going to run a smash event, send a request for permission an hour before the event, it should be over before you hear back from them.
I think that NIntendo handled this poorly, but that Panda Cup CEO guy is slime.
Wow, its almost like trying to get Nintendo to handle any Smash Tournaments would inevitably end in a Nintendo Moment
Who could've guessed!
you know shits gon down when a person has 20 tabs open
Panda has just had its reputation absolutely destroyed there not really any way back without removal of alan
No related to the drama, I love how Ludwig have every tab ready like a teacher with his power point presentation
"Thank you vgbc for paying for a semester of my college."
*doesn't follow vgbc on twitter*
saw a tiktok about this been waiting for the mogul mail to drop a vid and give me the full scooooop
Nintendo doing the try to make your community happy challenge(impossible)
Me reading title “HUGE DRAMA IN SMASH COMMUNITY”
Me to myself - Here we go again
putting that journalism degree to use.
"The Rest can come later" - Leffen
Big L for panda kinda needs to be boycoyted. Although I liked the company so far it's sad that it has to be this way. Maybe they let the CEO step down from this which I kinda hope they will.
The company needs to go under and the CEO will be the one who did it. Then he won't be allowed back in the industry
This situation is so fucked up. I feel for the TOs who are now having to deal with the fallout of this, with people likely losing money. I feel for the players who travelled throughout the year to attempt to qualify for SWT and whose effort was wasted - never mind that they likely already had plans to prepare and travel for next weekend. I feel for the Melee community, who has not only been burnt by Nintendo and been betrayed by an org who claimed to have their interests at heart - but have also been robbed of the race for the number one, which was one of the most hyped up series of events of Melee's history.
If I remember correctly, Panda was in another controversy at one point in the Destiny 2 community during year 2 of the game (2018-2019). If my memory serves me right, it had something to do with boosting people in the Competitive PVP Playlist and DDOSing. A Playlist where if you reached the highest rank, you would be awarded with unquestionably the best gun in the game (mainly on console).
Needless to say this was incredibly hard. Only the best players in the game were (supposed to be) able to do this. Naturally, some people were paying so called 'carries' a lot of money to carry them to the highest rank to get this gun (and the clout). Panda also dove into this business. They had partnered streamers advertise the boosting service on their Twitch/YT. However, they were DDOSing people to get their carries to the highest rank to maximise profit. It would've otherwise taken them forever to just get one guy to the highest rank if doable at all.
Personally, I grinded to the highest rank 3 times during that year to get the coveted title that would be rewarded called Unbroken. Not only was this incredibly time consuming (don't recommend), but DDOSing near the top was incredibly common. It would happen once every like 3-4 games near the end of a season. Also legitimately carrying was incredibly hard. Essentially playing 3 vs 4 at the high ranks meant you would get stomped by the stacked teams at the top. I never ran into people that would win a 3 vs 4 against my team during my time ranking.
Glad to see aimen doing a mogul mail, he made some good points on the smash community and nintendo as a whole.
Thanks Lud for all you've done and continue to do.
Welp, just boycott the panda cup for eternity. Problem solved. Either smash dies permanently meaning Nintendo, VGBootcamp, and Panda Cup lose tons of money or Nintendo cooperates with VGBootcamp and the status quo remains.
No one should support VGBootcamp until they stop defending Nairo
@@dildino6199 I really don't care what smash players do. You are all filthy degenerates. Just entertain me