The Origins of the Islamic Prayer [ENGLISH]
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 01. 2021
- Muslims are obligated to pray 5 times a day towards Mecca. However, the Qur'an does not mention 5 daily prayers, but mentions only 3 explicitly by name and in separate occasions only mentions 3 prayers (11:114, 17:78-79) instead of 5. We will learn that Muslims practice is influenced by many contemporary religions and traditions of the time.
#origin #islam #zoroastrianism
![Namaz Ki Bunyad | نماز کی بنیاد [URDU]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eGLbDgXNPDo/mqdefault.jpg)
Good video. IMHO Islam is an amalgamation of Judaism, Christianity, Zoroastrianism, and Arabian Paganism.
@Odin Lightning Emperor Are You A Jew or Zoroastrian
Exactly. Those pilgrimage, Kaba, 7 heaven and earth, that was bc Arabian pagan
even some Sabian traditions as well as Manicheasm
@@princeali4411 what is that? Sabian? Manicheasm?
@@edwardtimothy3581 Sabians were two different groups, Harranians and Mandaeans
Oh man, your videos are amazing.
It's bs
Came from ur ad and it was 🔥🔥🔥
I don't usually sit through ads, but when I clicked onto a Lawrence Krauss video I was blown away by your concise breakdown. I'm now voraciously consuming your content! I have the notification bell on to!!!
Please continue your work, it is remarkable!
Sir, dont mind any of the words of these critisizers. History is proof and witness that many great people were critisized by many people.Aristotle said "If you dont want to face critisism say nothing and do nothing. We are always with you sir. Love you.
Great video!! Keep it up brother!!
Wow, this is wild. When i knew Zoroastrianism was come long before Christianity and Islam, I've always had a thought that maybe they were the one that influence them about heaven and hell, but daily prayer too?
Religion mixed with Politics
Urdu version: czcams.com/video/eGLbDgXNPDo/video.html
twitter: twitter.com/UrduFreeThinker
It was narrated that Anas ibn Maalik said: Abu Dharr narrated that the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “The roof of my house was split open when I was in Makkah, and Jibreel (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) came down and split open my chest and washed it with Zamzam water. Then he brought a golden vessel filled with wisdom and faith and poured it into my chest, then he sealed it. Then he took me by the hand and ascended with me into the lowest heaven. When I reached the lowest heaven Jibreel said to the gatekeeper, ‘Open up!’ He said, ‘Who is this?’ He said, ‘Jibreel.’ He said, ‘Is there anyone with you?’ He said, ‘Yes, Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) is with me.’ He said, ‘Has his mission begun?’ He said, ‘Yes.’ And when it was opened we went up into the lowest heaven… Then Allaah enjoined upon my ummah fifty prayers, and I came back until I passed by Moosa who said, ‘What has Allaah enjoined upon your ummah?’ I said, ‘He has enjoined fifty prayers.’ He said, ‘Go back to your Lord, for your ummah will not be able to bear that.’ So I went back and He reduced it. Then I came back to Moosa and said, ‘He has reduced it.’ He said, ‘Go back to your Lord, for your ummah will not be able to bear that.’ So I went back and He reduced it further. Then I came back to Moosa and said, ‘He has reduced it further.’ He said, ‘Go back to your Lord, for your ummah will not be able to bear that.’ So I went back and He said, ‘(The prayers) are five but (the reward) is fifty. The Sentence that comes from Me cannot be changed [cf. Qaaf 50:29].’ Then I went back to Moosa and he said, ‘Go back to your Lord.’ But I said, ‘I feel shy before my Lord.’…”
al-Bukhaari, 342; Muslim, 163
50 prayers will stopped Pakistani workers from building Qatar stadiums
This type of hadith shows how much mockery“musilms” are making of Allah’s revelation. This unacceptable for people who claim to be followers of Quran.
Salam brothers. It really boggles my mind, why no one challenged this narrative for centuries. It is full of loose ends. It means Muhammad (PBUH) was not intelligent and matured with wisdom enough to understand that 50 will be too much for his ummah. And he had to go back again and again as per the direction of Musa (AS). It undermines the ultimate wisdom of The Creator of the worlds as he also could not comprehend (Nouzubillah) and kept on changing. Even if we think Prophet moved through some sort of portal to travel between skies, it has to have some strict rules and Prophet could just roam around in it as if it was our city street. Why Musa (AS) was at seventh sky why not Ibrahim(AS). And why only seven rasools in seven skies, where are the rest, when we know that there are no distinctions among prophets. We know Quran was written many ages ago and kept secured at Lawhe Mahfuz. So Allah had to change every time, while decreasing the wakts. 50 wakts surely needed completely different types of rituals so was that also continuously changed? When Allah SWT says there is 'no change in my order, no change in my Sunnatallah'. One hadith says Prophet went straight from makka to the heavens while the other one says he went to Masjidul Al Aqsa first (as mentioned in Quran). Why Allah SWT needed Prophet to go to him when the whole Quran was revealed to him in earth? And since all the previous prophets were dead, so were they resurrected only to pray behind him in earth at Al Aqsa? Islam is not a mystical myth. We were even fooled for years with the concept that tashahud (which I USED to recite while sitting) was conversation between Allah SWT and prophet during me'raj. For Quran, its 'We hear and we obey' for all the rest we must ask question. Thank You
You have great knowledge
hahaha lol
Alhamthulillah thank you for the video.
Have watched this video in urdu yesterday, but came here to like n comment.
R u a real hindu
can send me link of this urdu version . please
Great job
This is sooooooo interesting!
Love your videos and brain!
Very informative
U went to lengths for the research man salute to you ❤
Can i dubbed your video in Bengali? and re-upload for Bangladeshis
yes you can, no problem
@@TheUrduFreeThinker @kitnay log roz nikal rahay hain aur tum bus Rona ro rahay ho mujhay yeh tho batao zara kabaa say yeh telecast kyon hora hai umme Hani kay ghar say mairaaj hua thaa hmm buraq ki shakal adhi aurat aur adha dar donkey ka horse kar Phillipines main yehi buraq bana hua 😊 Muslim area main hmm yeh uss raat ho kiya raha thaa 😏kiss ki riding horahi thee yeh bata do 🥺
Plz urdu free thinker we need more of your videos you haven’t uploaded anything for a year now 😔. Hope everything is all right
Very informative video. Is the rules of Prayers mentioned in authentic hadith?
Namaz started by Harun Al Rashids mother Khairozan who was zoroastrian doing taqqiya as muslim.
Haizuran was not Persian she was Berbian tamazigh
Was muslim not zoroastrian
Source: made it up
U r knowledgeable. I subbed. Keep it up
Five prayers in Three times of Prayer, in the Quran, Fajr= morning, Dhur & Asr= Afternoon, middle, Maghrib & Isha = Night, this is why when you are traveling you are permitted to join the prayers in this way. As for Israel/Jews and Muslims, it’s one Prophethood so there will be similarities because Quran says that it’s a confirmation of what went before.
These people are uneducated, not knowing that Islam did not start in 6th century AD. “There was not a nation except a Warner passed through it” (Surah Fatir).
There is no concern in Islam having similar practices to those of other religions what may have been the case most likely is that they carried on those practices from their righteous prophets from when they were sent to them even after they went astray, started associating others with Allah and denying later prophets.
@@AlwaysSoldierOn Oh no, we know that's the claim of your religion, it's just that we know it's not true. Yall think Jesus was a Muslim prophet, that Moses was a Muslim prophet, etc.
We know yall are wrong.
ALSO, the origin of the 5 daily prayers, according to YOUR religion, is when Muhammad flew to heaven on a winged horse & was originally given 50 prayers, but he negotiated it down to 5.
Your are just amazing
The word Salat doesn't mean prayer. The root meaning of Salat is commitment/duty/obligation/adherence.
The Quran gives an indication of this meaning in 75:31-32:
"And he did not confirm nor Salla,
But denied and turned away."
If the antonym for denying is confirming, then the antonym for turning away must be....? To turn towards or commit or adhere etc.
The word for prayer in the Quran is Dua.
Here we go
Still fabricated
"Surely the Salah at fixed hours of the day and night has been enjoined upon the believers." (Quran 4:103).
@@takiyaazrin7562 that’s the salat at the time of the prophet. Salat is preformed though a guide, this can be scripture, a wise man, scientific observation, etc. At the time of the prophet, this guide was the prophet himself. Through him salat was preformed by his followers.
The Quran states that at fajr and isha they were the fixed times for salat sessions, sometimes urgently during the business hours (Juma salah) ritualised nowadays as Friday salah (juma means congregation/business, not Friday).
First someone says something with sense
Excellent presentation, so well put together. So under subscribed, will post on other social media !! Hope to see your content grow.
still muslims claim quran is the most original and perfectly preserved revealation by god
@@Oussama-sabouh because muslims believe whatevet is written in it but not in the facts and truth which speak out that quran is full of plagiarism of thoughts, traditions, stories borrowed from other cultures and religions. How can such book be called as the one who gave all original thoughts and stories ? Just like what all other immature, amature, less knowledgeble authors do, Mr. Muhammad had also done the same - collected data from other people, modified it according to his desires and claimed it to be the most original piece of work and to be special , he called himself prophet of god and the book by him as revealation of god and all who will follow this book as favourate people of god. Thats it. This is job of a very immature, self centered, superiority complexed person. Such job cannot be of a wise man. All books of all religions are written by humans and are thought of humans only. God's revealations, if exist - are found in wiseness of 'live and let live others peacefully'. Almighty god cant instruct few of his creations to hate, kill and destroy others of his creation. If you dont pray me, I will give you pain are thought of self centered human being, cannot be of almighty god.
@@926prasenjit Well done bro . What a good summarization of evidence,philosophy,counter points and good thoughts. Keep it up.
Salat has been wrongfully interpreted as a “ritual” prayer thru Hadith that’s why we are able to connect it with paganism religions but the reality is salat in the Quran is not a ritual prayer. No where in the Quran does it give instruction to preform a ritual rather the word salat comes from the root صل which means to connect or adhere to something closely. When you apply the meaning of the root it becomes clear that there is no rituals but rather an abstract way of connecting with God. Not a ritual where you put your head on the ground
Thus it should be Du'a right?
@@Boi-wot yeah the word Dua is more closer to the word “pray” then any other word in the Quran
so does this mean Muslims have corrupted the original teachings of Islam? Shit, we need another prophet
@@littlemice815 yes the teaching is corrupted but no need for another prophet when you still have the book
@@user-lc5ix6qm5h I was joking. But seriously, why do the hadiths differ so much from the Quran on this matter? Is it safe to just assume that they were fabricated? I'm trying to understand from the Islamic perspective here
Nice video
Super video
Oh man ,your videos are great 👍
Peace from Indonesian muslim👌 ,am I not religious, when I have been watched your all video ,the answer is NO
I watched your video to search for truth
As long as I became a Muslim, I only obeyed blindly
Religion is like entering your room, turning off the light, closing the window, after that, close your eyes and believe that its the only truth
It strengthen islamic rhetoric that Deen/religions were the same from the beginning 💯💓
Monotheism is faith the there is no god but one. We believe that our father Adam is prophet and he told us to do good and not evil.
Sabians , Zoroastrianism, Abrahamic religions, Judaism, Christian and Muslims we all belive in the same God who created the universe and created adam.
Adam is taller than dinosaurs - Sahih Bukhari 6227
@@takiyaazrin7562 Takiya Azrin's brain is smaller than a cricket - book of knowledge 123456789
The word which is being translated as PRAYER in the Quran by some translators actually means adherence or to follow, not the ritual prayer. People who know Arabic and understands the root word system, knows this well.. Your whole argument is based on the ritual prayer, which really has no base in the Quran. Some claim that these are the sessions, where the revelations are taught to people. Please do research this. Also there is a claim that the current ritual practice of prayer was introduced by the mother of Harun Al Rashid (Harun was of Persian origin) 5th Abbasid Caliph, as literally she was the defacto ruler at that time. Allah knows best. Also you are mixing things up to show that Islam is wrong.. Islam is just following the Quran and not the rest of it which was created by man.. Nothing disproves Quran from your video. Why don't you reconsider looking into the Quran with proper translation.
YES! Salah is duties/responsibilities. It's not a daily ritual prayer. We can make duah to Allah any time we want to. He's closer to us than our jugular vein. The only Islam is in the Quran. Period.
Where are you???
Atleast you are ok if some of us watching are and stay muslim
Another demonstration: Salavat is the plural of Salat meaning more than two Salats (or Salatain). Then the number of prayers is at least 3 + 1 (salat-o-lwosta) = at least 4 prayers. Then your opinion on 3 prayers at the beginning of Islam is incorrect.
Why plus one? The plural form means its at least three.
I agree Hadith were written many years later. But you have completely ignored fiqh the living tradition? Prayer is established from the living tradition and not from Hadith. The prayer is also similar to early Jewish prayer.
all of this is taking place over a period of more that a thousand years, small changes occur and add up over time, especially in such a geographically expansive religion like Islam, so it's not unlikely
Love n respect for you sir🙏❤️🙏❤️🙏
Are you a true hinduu
@@jayamalathivari9318 yes
@@Harishkryadav1 if s then y did you support love and respect a Muslim video hm
@@jayamalathivari9318 he is not Muslim . He is atheist
@@Harishkryadav1 ho
Keep ur work at root level,, i am fan of ur video but think u continue ur work at grassroot level,indian muslim definitely need to come out from this islamic pit
Pakistani blasphemy law 295 was made by British time about 100 years ago,
It is about protecting all religions, not only Islam, But , 295 b , and 295 c is extremely stupid, and contradicts with real 295 , and blasphemy against Islam to protect a man named Mohammed, who was the blasphemous him self according to Islamic stories, like he broke 365 idols in temple Kabba at the time of Fatha e Makkah, first and only hajj he did and converted a temple to masjid with shiva lingam in wall. Many people don’t know, Mohammed put this black stone ( Hindu idol of shiva) him self at the age of 35 , 5 years before he claimed to be nabi of Islam.
@@frederick197 ,
Talk to me with respect, we don’t lie like you people.
If you don’t know this basic information, then go to your Mama, and learn from her.
There is no shiva in mecca, possibly its babylonian counterpart
this video is so based
Make in urdu
I don't agree with all of your opinions, but bc I agree that Is Lam is the biggest threat to human progress, I won't skip your ads👍
Can you tell what is written about kafir in quran ?? (Non muslims)
@@frederick197 because i dont have it
@@funclub6862 buy it
@@probablynotzeus936 where can i
And i dont have time to read
And waste my money
@@frederick197 i have to know stupid in my country there are many muslims so i should know good or bad things about them
You are wasting my and your time by doing this stupid debate
Quranist don't believe salat is a ritual prayer
We are muslim. True submitters to Allah his revelations only. We do not follow man made literature.
You didn't answered my questions asked in the previous video
It was
1) what do you think of Hinduism??
2) are you following any ideology
Or any religion??
3) what is the name of it ??
I am an Atheist Humanist, and I don't follow any organized religion. I base my morality on human reasoning, ethics, and try to align my opinions to empirical evidence.
I only comment on things that I am knowledgable about. However, I do have a soft corner for many teachings contained in the tradition of Buddhism, but I am not a Buddhist.
If you wanna know about real Hinduism, I request you to go to the channel- Acharya Prashant, and listen to him.
@@TheUrduFreeThinker If you wanna know about real Hinduism, I request you to go to the channel- Acharya Prashant, and listen to him.
@@aman___004 Pastafarianism and Dinkoism are much better than Hinduism
@@TheUrduFreeThinker thanks for the answer
Hope this Beautiful World will change its way of thinking in a better way
Why doesn't someone clean up this portion of Islam and go back to 3 prayers a day ? Shun the pagan roots of Zoroastrianism and prostrate down only before Allah and pray and glorify Him from the heart! From what I understand, the folding of arms, repetitive prostrations, repeating of words originated from Arabian pagan rituals along with influences of the Talmud and Orthodox Christianity origins. Seems too Roman Catholic to me to pray this way.
Does Islam teach respect to other ideology and thoughts?
Also, "shunning" Zoroastrian influence means you will have to shun down the idea of "One God", heaven and hell, The Bridge of Judgment, The Personifications of the Soul’s Deeds, The Middle Abode, Descriptions of Hell. Also, shunning down ancient Persia (Iran) and Iranians and other people who were not of Islamic origin. You can go ahead with this.
The Zoroastrian priest admits that they took the five daily prayers from the Arabs
So...why did Islam change from 3 to 5?
@@joebidet2050There are five prayers in Islam, and the Zoroastrians adopted them after the Arab invasion
@@user-vs7gv4cn8o wrong
Islam was 3
Later was 5 after hadiths
5 of 6 were written by Persians
Quran had always 5 prayers
@@BM8C7 astaghfirullah go and read the Quran again brother, you only dishonour it by lying about it or accidentally making a mistake about what it says, there are only three prayers in the Quran it is the Hadith that give us the five prayers.
Dont listen to all the supporters, hate from Michigan
Second
actually God reveals his religion to each Prophet. some legacy of each Prophet remained in religion of a particular region. that's why u find it very similar with Islam because God revealed one religion at different time.
that's appeal to faith.
Thank you, they are so hurry to attack Islam, that they missed this bus.
@@pepejulianonziema69 not at all it’s the fact about Islam and the Quran said that exactly, because Prophets were sent to all, so remnants still remained, similar to Christianity seeing similarities in Igbo spirituality, beliefs, practices and using such to bring Igbos to Christianity, is that also an appeal to Faith
@@hasananyabwile3538 then it is just claim from your belief not from historical or archaeological evidence, that's why it's appeal to faith.
@@hasananyabwile3538 tell me if there were Chinese prophets, Aztec prophets, aborigin prophets, Nubia prophets, Mongol prophets and etc. Because extraordinary claim require extraordinary evidence. I do not trust claim with just believe "because my holy book said it". Because it's bias
You sound like muscle man
why bro sound like yoda
If you read the Quran you will come to know the true massage of Allah. Believe in one God.. so to all the religions out there all you have to do is believe in one God while keeping your culture alive... so yes the zoroastrian keep their culture while accepting ones of God.
Monotheism has been around since as far back, some are asking for proof of this on here, we know in the original Torah prophets like Adam noah etc preached it long before, considering we place him in eastern turkey, a place that eventually became part of persia centuries later, no telling if this served as motivation , even Hinduism started as a monotheistic faith, Judaism as an example featured things like the ablution and prayer far before zoroastrianism did. the zoroaster himself travelled when he left home at 20 so he may well have adopted various principles. Moses abraham jesus are all mentioned as falling on theyre face and praying, isnt it ironic that christians dont pray like this depsite all the biblical prophets doing so and the advent of christianity before muahmmads arrival? have the completion of islam in makkah and medina that adopted the same practice as mentioned throughout the christian and jewish world.
You simply cannot rule out that this could have been the other way round
This Video didn't exposed Islam.
Infact it's a proof that Islam is not a new Religion and it was followed from a very long time.
Thanks for the information
that's appeal to faith fallacy, the claim is from your belief not from historical evidence
@@pepejulianonziema69There are five prayers in Islam, and the Zoroastrians adopted them after the Arab invasion
Everyone from Iran is not Persian. Stop labelling all Persian.
Magis
Iranians are aryans 😎😎....not Persians....
There have been two prayers custom in Zoroastrianism; 1- 3 times of prayers and 2- 5 times of prayers. I think that the 5-times custom is derived from the Islamic prayers, as its texts are newer. Even it seems that they have plused the translation of Besmellah arrahman errahim to their xshnaotra Ahurahe mazdaav. Meanwhile, in Shi'a jurisprudence, the noon and afternoon prayers are recited together, and the dawn and night prayers are recited together too. Please stop your probably jwish misleading. jews should change themselves after thousands of years.
Do you follow Zoroastrianism???
@@khanbro6455 I'm a Shi'a Muslim.
Where can I get this information?
@Shabahram Dorost, where can I get this information?
I think you don't know the
Benefits of namaz 😔😔
@@user-ww6ep6qh7o perfect bro 👍🏻
@@user-ww6ep6qh7o I can't stop thinking whoever wrote this must be a teenagers. Ugh, that words just full... I'm gonna be honest but someone with dyslexia actually write better sentences than you can ever be 👁👄👁
What's it ?
Actually we debunked such fallacies like your videos. So sorry pal you failed to disprove islam byee.
اسلامی احکامات کو جو تم دوسری کتابوں سے جوڑ کر دکھا رہے ہو. پہلے سورۃ یونس آیۃ 37پڑھ کر دیکھ لو. یہ بات ذہن میں رہنی چاہیے کہ قرآن گذشتہ تمام کتابوں کو درست کرتے ہوئے چلتا ہے جو بعد میں انسانوں کے ذریعے داخل کی گئی .
False video. Prophets were sent to every nation
claim is not evidence
No prophet in Scandinavia
No prophet in aztec empire or other native American
No prophet for aborigines
No prophet in asia or japan
Yet 99% of the geographic world was pagan before 'Christ'.
Extraordinary claim require extraordinary evidence
Tum logon ki wajah se kitne he non muslim log hai jo islam me dakhil ho rahe hai quran ka mutalla karne lagte hai aur tere failae jane wale pakhand ka parda fas hojata hai, maine kitno se he suna hai jo kahete hai atheist ki wajah se hum islam ko jaan pae hai aur ye atheist sirf barin wash karte hai, spring(islam) ko jitna tej dabaoge utni tej unchai par jaega insaAllah.....
Sukriya urdu free thinker supporting for islam
@Saif Ali kitnay log roz nikal rahay hain aur tum bus Rona ro rahay ho mujhay yeh tho batao zara kabaa say yeh telecast kyon hora hai umme Hani kay ghar say mairaaj hua thaa hmm buraq ki shakal adhi aurat aur adha dar donkey ka horse kar Phillipines main yehi buraq bana hua 😊 Muslim area main hmm yeh uss raat ho kiya raha thaa 😏kiss ki riding horahi thee yeh bata do 🥺
Ask Allah to give you to give you hidaya
U mean ask "something that doesn't exist" to give him hidaya on something that never exist but created by human?
sure