The "Miracle" of the Pharaoh's Preservation: Maurice Bucaille Debunked [ENGLISH]
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 07. 2024
- Many modern muslim preachers often like to point out that the famous verse in the Quran (10:92) that mentions that Pharaoh of Exodus' body will remain preserved as a sign for future generations from God. According to the Bible and the Quran, this pharaoh died from drowning. Many Muslim and Biblical scholars believe the identity of this pharaoh is either Ramasses II or Merneptah.
A French physician Dr. Maurice Bucaille argued in favour of Islamic claims and tried to prove them through his "forensic" analysis. He concluded after examining that pharaoh Merneptah's mummy that he died from drowning and as a result, was the pharaoh of Exodus. He also argued that this proved the Quran to be true, and consequently he became very popular in the Muslim world.
In this video we will do our own forensic assessment, and we will learn that this is false.
Subtitles available in Hindi
#pharaoh #quran #bucaille
Freethinking need to be support
I'm a Muslim but I agree that it's not the Pharoah of the exodus, it's not miraculous, neither do the Qur'an talks about preserving it
“Today We will preserve your corpse so that you may become an example1 for those who come after you. And surely most people are heedless of Our examples!” Quran 10:92
Thanks . Your work is very informative.
Urdu version: czcams.com/video/Ymsc3sCZU_w/video.html
References for interest:
1. Deaths by drowning review paper: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31240023/
2. New York Times on Dr. Bucaille: www.nytimes.com/1991/02/03/books/all-wrapped-up-in-his-work.html
3. Merneptah's tomb robbed:
www.livescience.com/25282-largest-egyptian-sarcophagus.html
egypt-museum.com/post/190343061426/mummy-of-merneptah#:~:text=Egypt%20Museum,-Navigate&text=King%20Merneptah%20was%20originally%20buried,(KV35)%20by%20Victor%20Loret
4. Merneptah and atherosclerosis:
- www.newscientist.com/article/mg22029420-800-ancient-afflictions-mummies-got-heart-disease-too/
- www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/aug/31/mummies-pharaohs-heart-disease-arteries-egyptians
5. 50 Mummies unearthed from the valley of the kings:
www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/5/140501-mummy-royal-tut-discovery-egypt-science/#close
Amazing video bro👌
The videos just keep getting better.
Brother you are doing an amazing job, absolutely love your videos. Requesting you to start doing live shows aswell
Dont do live maybe this bloody want ur identity 👍 stay safe 👍
Love your videos
please allow adding translations, so I can translate it into Arabic
Can any Muslim provide a video of Maurice Bucaille saying the Shahada. I want to believe Maurice hardwork was not just to earn the petrodollars.
Jesus messiah a.s promise a Comforter our messenger Mohamed s a.w.s.what Ever He Brings it will not be from him but from the Havenly One so holly Quran was send that explains all problems people have the many things Jesus a.s wanted to teach us left the job for the last messenger Mohamed s.a.w.s and it was better Jesus a s to go so the comforter to come this was a promise from the messiah and this what happen in our history
You have the prove that the Quran is speaking the truth
@@ahmedmehmed8423 he promised a Spirit. Not a person
@@ahmedmehmed8423 he promised the Holy spirit to his disciples, not a Saudi Arabian
@@anonymousanonymous2319 the spirit was Alread there with you he messiah so the messiah ask the lord God to send another spirit of truth
My friend, you make amazing videos! I love them so much, they are so very well researched! Please, can you make video about nestorian christianity roots of islam. This will be very interesting! Thanks a lot for your content. I found your youtube page recently and Im absolutely amazed.
With a lot of respect
Exmuslim from Dagestan, Russia
Ohh woww dagestani murtad 😂
Ex Muslim and now ?
As always your video is very informative, and can provide fact . 👍🥇
God helps those who help themselves. Do you think people were able to compute and understand such Mathematical numbering and sequence which could have been only with the help of a computer? Just imagine the following in Quran
Punishment 117 Forgiveness 234
World 115 Hereafter 115
Devil 88 Angel 88
Heaven 77 Hell 77
Zakah (donation) 32 Barakah (abundance) 32
summer, hot 5 winter, cold 5
Richness 26 poverty 13
Woman 23 Man 23 (we know 46 chrome. number)
land 13 ocean 32 (the same ratio as planet earth has)
Now keep denying and let us see when we die. You have only one life for test so have your pick.
@@TheMasood4724 ,
Are you drunk, or high on drugs?
@@ziarehman4421 I need some honest answer to be convinced, and not just taunting.
@@TheMasood4724 ,
Please tell me , you are Rana and Khan same time ?
And you are asking me to tell you some thing I don’t even want to took at it , Quran is a expired cult manual. It is rape culture promoting book , written by unknown poet.
@@TheMasood4724 false quran
Muslims: * falls on deaf ears * I don't want to acknowledge this.
I used to believe in claims by Dr. Maurice Bucailli and then I thought why he didn't reverted to Islam. Maybe he had an agenda.
He reverted to Islam.
was a doctor and a specialist in the field of gastroenterology[4] who was appointed as the family physician of Faisal of Saudi Arabia in 1973
Here you got reason
@@lahceno2168 he never confirmed or denied
Very nice articulation 💐
Are you The Maked Arab reincarnation? :)
I miss his videos so much. Waiting him to return like muslims wait Imam Mahdi
Muslims are not reincarnated my friend
@@priyanshugupta8299 Yes they are, they just don't know...
Yeah me too
آپ سے بات ہو سکتی ہے کال پر
Just keep doing it we need people like you i meet many Muslims who are just brain washed your video definitely will help them it bring them in reality.
Liked and commented.
Please make a video on Islamic revolution in iran.
Bhai quick make video
Funny... I only get at your channel advertisement from Islamic preachers
Bucaille is the creme-de-la-creme of professional liars
How’s he a Liar?
Great👍👏👏👏👏👏 🚩🚩👍👍👍🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳🔥✌✋
Super knowledgeable person you r bhai
So the body is still out there...
Bhai I wait for you new video
The Muslim's have very low standards for gods. the supposed creator of universe.
🔥🔥🔥Thats says it all, Thanks for the information.
Exactly. It's not that we don't believe God, but we have higher standard for him
Just one question? Your knowledge I'll totally depends upon google Or a whatsApp uni pls. Do. Some research on Maurice 's work and do come it will be more valuable 😌
All evidence shows Moses pharaoh didn’t exist and that cranial damage isn’t enough to prove drowning. Maurice’s claims have been debunked.
If the preservation of the dead was so sophisticated how come you only showed one Pharaoh's mummy
Excellent! Scientific evidence entailed throughout this video is exactly the kind of freethinkers we want! I hope you're doing well, you've supporters behind you; I'm one of them, and, I'm proud of that!
Edit: Just wanted to put this here. Muslims often use appeal to authority (in this case, appeal to false authority also applies) fallacy to forward this junk science; they use "Dr" label as if he's an ultimate authority within the fields of Egyptology, Forensic science, archaeology, neuroscience, neurology etc.
It's mind boggling that such individuals would ignore authority of Bucaille, which is restricted to gastroenterology, to expand to these many complicated fields requiring years of formal training and research.
Their (those who accept such false interpretations, based on pseudoscienctific claims) agenda was set to stone from day one; when Bucaille, a non-Muslim, created this theologically false Bucailleism, an interpretation worth selling.
Gullible are those who accepted this; rich is Bucaille. Sad reality. Indeed.
Thank you for your support and informative comment!
Let's say Bucaille is false but how it can be Quoted in Quran 1400 years back that the pharaoh's body will be preserved as a sign for those who succeeded him, When we came to know about mummification in the 18th century? I want to know the truth as well. Hope you will consider both sides of believing in the creation and not believing.
@@feelsgood3209 Bucaille is false, full of conflict of interest and unreliable due to false authority. Forget about the deception he utilises, that alone discredits him.
The Qur'an uses the Torah's explanation made by a rabbi (you can search it up), if this were to follow, Judaism would be the one true religion. But, as you and I know: it isn't. Including Islam.
Also, the proof of mummified body was never produced by Bucaille, let alone verifying it, there should be proof of it's existence first. There's no evidence of the corpse of the "Pharaoh".
Note this as well: the Qur'an never names the Pharaoh in question, it only is able to produce a title for "Pharaoh". Nowhere is the name of Rameses ever mentioned. Feel free to point that specific surah and verse.
@@theonlyoneko4904 In Torah, it's not mentioned that the body will be preserved.
You might not know the connection between Bibel and Quran. Also, I don't think the name of the pharaoh matters here. The purpose of mentioning the pharaoh and his oppression in The Quran is to give a message that those will be punished afterlife so that we avoid oppression, genocide, and other activities that make humans suffer.
First of all, I am a believer. And you know why I am here? Because I am not obeying my duties properly as a Muslim.
I want to know Islam closely otherwise getting demotivated to obey the rules given in The Quran.
Also If I can make myself convinced that we have no creator and we will not be punished for our dids then I will be free from all the duties mentioned in The Quran.
For example, if I believe in Islam then I have to pray 5 times a day, have to fast in the month of Ramadan, and have to fulfill the responsibilities to my family, relatives, and society, I can not do such things
that might harm other people, I have to refrain from music, drugs, and other stuff which is haram and so on.
And I have to obey all those duties not to get punished afterlife. According to Islam that punishment is beyond imagination.
In my opinion, being an atheist is much easier than being a believer. I find those gullible who believe that humans and other species
came out of nothing even looking at themselves.
I found that atheist believes in science when science couldn't come up with anything close to humans or any other species.
Somehow you are using science to defy its existence.
I will request you to read The Quran. It actually gives value to your existence. In the Quran, it says that the humans are most advanced creation of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala. In the Quran, there is nothing against us.
Sorry if anything hurts you.
@@feelsgood3209 It's the nameless "Pharaoh", for the Qur'an to omit the mentioning, alone discredits it. Storytelling is the main feature of all the religious books at present, but, they don't exclude important information. Qur'an does that. It loses credibility, and, makes it easier to declare it as a false worldview.
And you haven't touched that mummy still you are doing research .
The mummy showed zero signs of drowning, any salt found was due to the mummification process…a cranial crack or hole is no example of drowning and mist archaeologists agree the exodus never happened
"how is the skin still there?"
it's called mummification!!
You know what only thing u have in this life is free will do whatever you please until you visit your grave
Make your first video in Urdu
coming soon, i'll try to release both at the same time :)
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️👊🏿👊🏿👊🏿
U have no idea of all the linguistic mircles of the quran
Dude. That ain't a miracle💀
Many things to say. Mummified or not; his body shows he was in water and that he’s preserved. Also - he’s being shown in public display which proves the Qurans point.
Allah, the one God and only God talks about nations that were destroyed before us because of their disbelief. Let’s let that sink in, the 3 main anrahamic religions are still preserved with Islam being preserved more then any.
I Remember have a very large and expensive looking Islamic book describing this as a miracle, so it's not true?
This is Allah's miracle and the evidences of Quran are true, research by yourself. Don't believe this atheist. They will misguide people. See in this world why Muslims are brutally tortured by non believers? because The Truth always face this oppression. Research by yourself, don't trust this channel
and the main claim is not about preservation.. the main point is how Prophet (SM) knew about this (preservation)in the 7th century, about 1400 years ago? While this mummy was discovered in like 18/19th century . How come he knew about the future? The Quran has all the evidences Regarding future. So surely Allah (SWT) made him known sending Jibrail(As) : angel .
Please My friend try to stay as anonymous as you can if you're in Islamic country.
Maurice Bucaille was an atheist french so his opinions wasnt biased, I dont think a guy named the urdu free thinker can debunk him,thats for sure
The story of Maurice Bucaille’s inspiring conversion to Islam
The story of Maurice Bucaille’s inspiring conversion to Islam
Updated 15 March 2013D
ARAB NEWS
March 01, 2013
03:01
60128
MAURICE Bucaille was born to a French parent and, like his family, he grew up a Christian. After his secondary education, he joined Faculty of Medicine, France University. Later, he became the most renowned and cleverest surgeon ever in modern France, but a story happened to change his life completely.
France is known for its unique interest in archeology and heritage. When French Socialist President François Mitterrand assumed power in 1981, France asked Egypt, late in the 80’s, for the mummy of Egypt’s pharaoh so that it would conduct a string of monumental and processing experiments. Actually the body of Egypt’s most notorious tyrant was transferred to France, and, strangely, the French president and his ministers as well as senior officials in the country lined up near the plane carrying the pharaoh’s body and bowed down to him as if he were still alive! After the ceremonies of the royal-like reception to Egypt’s pharaoh were over, the tyrant’s mummy was carried nearly in the same red carpet reception way he received. Then the mummy was transferred to a special wing at the French Monuments Center, and renowned archeologists, surgeons and anatomists started to conduct a study on this mummy in an attempt to delve into its mysteries. The senior surgeon and the scientist in charge of the study on this mummy of the Pharaoh was Professor Maurice Bucaille. While the processors were busy making restoration to the mummy, their head (Maurice Bucaille) was thinking otherwise. He was trying to discover how this Pharaoh died when, late at night, he concluded his final analyses. The remains of the salt stuck in his body was a shining evidence that he had drowned and that his body was retrieved from the sea swiftly after he drowned; it was also obvious that they rushed to mummify his body so that his body would remain intact!! But Maurice Bucaille puzzled over a question: How did this body - to the exclusion of other mummified bodies of other ancient Egyptians - remain that intact although it was recovered from the sea?” Maurice was busy conducting a final report while thinking as to whether the pharaoh’s body was recovered from the sea and mummified immediately after he drowned. But one of his company whispered in his ear, saying “There is no need to rush about this issue, since the Muslims say that this Pharaoh did drown.” At first, he vehemently rejected this and did not believe it, citing that such a discovery would be reached only through sophisticated, modern and accurate computers. Another one accompanying him surprised him more when he told him that the Muslims’ Qur’an in which they believe narrates the story that says he drowned and that his body remained intact even after he drowned. He got more surprised and kept on asking” Where did the Muslims’ Qur’an quote these data from while the mummy was not discovered until 1898, i.e. about 200 years only, given that the Qur’an has been recited by Muslims for over 1400 years, and given also that until a few decades ago the entire mankind including Muslims did not know that the ancient Egyptians had mummified their pharaohs?
Maurice Bucaille stayed up all this night gazing at Pharaoh’s body, thinking deeply of what his fellow researcher told him about the Muslims’ Qur’an explicitly establishing that this body was recovered after drowning, while the Christians’ Gospel (Matthew and Luca) narrated only the story of Pharaoh when he was chasing Prophet Musa (peace be upon him) without mentioning the fate of his body at all.
“Is it believable that Muhammad (peace be upon him) knew about this over 1,000 years ago while I have only just known it?” he thought.
Maurice spent a sleepless night, and asked for a version of the Torah. But it only furthered Bucaille’s astonishment; since even Torah did not narrate that the body was recovered and remained intact due to the processing and restoration, which it did undergo.
France sent back the mummy to Egypt in a splendid glass coffin. But, since he knew about the story circulated by Muslims on the intactness of this body, he decided to pack his baggage and travel to Saudi Arabia where a medical conference happened to be held with a galaxy of Muslim anatomists attending.
There, told them about his discovery, i.e. that Pharaoh’s body was kept intact even after he drowned. One of the conferees opened the Qur’an and read out the Ayah in which Allah Almighty said, “So today We will (safely) deliver you with your body that you may be a sign to the ones succeeding you; and surely many among mankind are indeed heedless of Our signs.” (Yunus: 92)
In his excitement, he stood before the attendants and loudly said, “I have converted to Islam and believed in this Qur’an.”
Back to France, Maurice Bucaille spent 10 years conducting a study as to how far the recently scientific facts match that mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, trying to reassure himself that the Qur’an has never contradicted with any single scientific fact, so that he eventually came up with the conclusion that Allah Almighty said of the Qur’an, “Untruth does not come up to it before (Literally: between its two hands) it nor from behind it; a successive sending down from (One) Ever-Wise, Ever-Praiseworthy.”
He came up with a earth shaking book on the Holy Qur’an which jolted the entire Western states, with the title of the book reading, “The Bible, The Qur’an and Science, The Holy Scriptures Examined In The Light Of Modern Knowledge.”
The book sold out and even hundreds of thousands of it were translated from French to Arabic, English, Indonesian, Persian, Turkish and German, extending to include nearly all East and West bookstores; one has come to see it with any Egyptian, Moroccan or Gulf person in the US.
In the preface of his book, Maurice Bucaille said, “These scientific areas which Qur’an established to the exclusion of other Scriptures filled me with deep surprise early on, since it never struck my mind to see such a large amount of scientific issues in such a variable and accurate way that they are a mirror image of what has recently been discovered in a book which has existed for more than 13 centuries.!!
The Bible, The Qur’an and Science, The Holy Scriptures Examined In The Light Of Modern Knowledge was such a marvelous piece of writing that, in the year 1988, the French Academy awarded him its prize in history.
- Courtesy of www.quranandscience.com
@Ayushman Sharma Please read the text; Quran says that "Badanek (your body)" - and not your skeleton - "is rescued" [and then mummified and preserved] "for the forthcoming/coming people", while Muslims surely didn't know about mummifying. Meanwhile, it's possible that the head of France group in the 80s couldn't differentiate between sea salt and common salt?! emsalt.com/egypt-salt/
After all, what's the reason for the good preservation of this corpus despite other Egyptian mummified corpses?
@Ayushman Sharma The antiquity is not the matter; the fate of the Ferown - who said: "I'm your greater lord" - like some pagan gurus - is the matter for forthcoming people.
Surely France archeology - surgery team was aware of the construction of mummification and could differentiate between the Nile and desert salt.
This mummy is the best - preserved BETWEEN EGYPT MUMMIES.
The head injury may be from trauma in the Nile or from throwing - as Quran says -.
@Ayushman Sharma Please pay attention; the corpse/fate of ferown teaches many things to human generations.
@Ayushman Sharma God is tough with tyrants.
American Heart Association (AHA): "They most likely died with atherosclerosis, not of it." (consumer.healthday.com/cardiovascular-health-information-20/misc-stroke-related-heart-news-360/aha-news-the-mummies-message-take-steps-against-heart-disease-762349.html)
NY Times author should consider hard objects too; it's possible medically that a drowned or near-drowned one has head trauma too.
@@shabahramdorost4412 what fake history Islam brings us. Egypt at the time of rameses II and his son was the most prosperous of all time- there was no ruin, no downfall and the king by all accounts did well to govern his people. Complete Fail Islam. Try again.
Not so, Pharaoh Ramses the Second took the throne of Egypt in his early twenties (around 1279 BC) and ruled for 66 years until his death (1213 BC). Pharaoh Ramses ll was Pharaoh nearly 200 years after the exodus of Moses time. The true Pharaoh of the exodus was the greatest Pharaoh in history of Egypt was Pharaoh Tutmoses lll who died in the sea on March 17, 1450 BC as written at his tomb in the Valley of the Kings Egypt.
Either way, Maurice still false
@@edwardtimothy3581 he got money for lie
@@voiceinmyhead7483 I would say the first lie isn't intentional. He just confused and somewhat incompetent to look for more evidence. But bc of that, his ego kick in and there's no way he would admit he was wrong 😂
@@edwardtimothy3581 he worked in saudi royal family and lied about pharaoh body
@@voiceinmyhead7483 i see
There is no god but Allah ♥
No real evidence for your imaginary friend as expected. Do care to provide anything of actual evidential value instead of wishful thinking and arguments from ignorant and obstinate emotions you have for your favourite story book.
@@kevinmathew6520 The abrahamic “God” of Judaism, Christianity and Islam is by far the angriest and most “evil” deity. I don’t believe they’re worshipping “God” they’re worshipping an idea conjured up by people from long ago, which was indoctrinated into them generation after generation. I don’t even reject the idea of there being a “something” but this isn’t it 😂
As the saying goes
“I don’t know what God is, but I know what he isn’t.”
Bro what do you guys think you are? Gods? You guys are nothing but slaves to god and you will see you think this world started on its own? There had to be a creator a energy way bigger then anything
@@kyliereed200 agree
@@tahaniahmad8159 you think God don't have a better way of handling female thieves than just cut off their limb? Or find a better rule than just some desert rule a long time ago?
Vidalan
SubhanAllah
Jay hind
We know real hind is Sindhu River Pakistani area. 👍🙏❤️
Fake islamic Propaganda
The main claim is not that preservation of the body is miracle or not, but the main claim is that how prophet muhammad (pbuh) knew about it? Who told him? When no one was known about this preservation. All was talking that it was drawned. This preservation proved that God told prophet through angel. This proves prophethood of prophet muhammad (pbuh).
Everyone at that time knew Egyptian pharaohs went through mummification. And he’s wrong because that exodus didn’t occur according to vast majority of historians. No evidence any pharaoh drowned.
Egyptians were one of the most influential people in history. You find it amusing that Arabs knew about their rituals?
According to all the clips on this Pharaoh, sea-salt had been found in his lungs, during forensics, leading to the finding of drowning at sea!!! . Also, the location of his found corps was reportedly, on the Egyptian side of the Red-Sea, across from the Moses-Landing (in Arabia), found in this, and in several other explorations, in youtube::: ("The Search For The Real Mt. Sinai | Full Movie | Robert Cornuke | Larry Williams")
Where do you get these garbage from ? Both Ramses and Merneptah were buried at the valley of the kings, later they were found at different tombs. How I know ? Because all the mummies were covered with Royal linen and priests recorded every movement in hieroglyphs on those linen. No one was found near the red sea. As for sea salt, dude, salt is the main ingredient of mummification. What else they would find, pepper ? Read about mummies from credible sources, or even the Egyptian Museum websites, not stuff from religious yahoos like Robert Cornuke.
@@jamieammar6131 This former priest explained it in this clip in YT:: ("The Miracle Of Pharaoh in the Quran")
@@kareemsalessi He's a former priest. He's not a scientist. He has no idea how salt works. He's not even an archaeologist. Again, stop watching zealots.
@@jamieammar6131 Probably like you, that former priest used to believe that several hundred years after Moses, his GOD was born in Nazareth, until he discovered the contents of the Quran about Jesus!!!
@@kareemsalessi Who cares about Jesus ? We are talking about mummies and their discoveries here, not religious nonsense.
Yes, they would have left their king to decompose underneath water just like ordinary people?? What a joke!! You had one pick and you have that to believe or not, it is up to you but Isalm is a Ph.D. guide for all. PERIOD!!
There's no proof of massive Population drop in the time of that pharaoh
islam not real
That's not what he mean. He saying there's no clear proof that this mummy is the same pharaoh that was told in exodus🤦.
No evidence the exodus is real. Or the pharaoh is real.
@@DhukuAC it's a self proclaimed evidence. And a self fulfilled prophecy
Science has proven that the cause of the Pharaoh King's death was drowning. This information was mentioned in the Quran over 1400 years ago, indicating that the Quran is the word of Allah the unique God who knows everything. I advise you to read this book and get to know the words of the Lord who created you from a drop of semen and gave you the mind to read these lines. I wish you success.
Where is the scientific source you are talking about?
Source😂?
Who was the tyrant Pharaoh at the time of Moses?
www.quran-islam.org/articles/part_6/pharaoh_of_moses_(P1550).html