Obey GOD ... and Obey Bukhari? ft
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 08. 2023
- Sunnis love to throw at us the verse "Obey GOD and Obey HIS Messenger", showing off their lack of consistency and understanding of the Quranic Narrative.
The Simple response is "Why do you want to Separate GOD from HIS Messengers?"
Adhering to the Quran is, Obeying the Messenger...
#god #allah
#quran
#muhammad #jesus #abraham #gabriel
#sunni #sunnah #shia #uthmanlbnfaroobq #dawah
Translation of the Koran was authored by: SHUAIB ABDULLAHI
/ @bush2g9 - Zábava
The worst thing about alot of these sunni muslims is on their youtube debates they're very polite and courteous to Christians, jews, atheist, etc but the moment its another muslim whether its a shia, quranist, even different sunni school of thought etc they become the rudest people ever. Constant interrupting and casually calling you a kafir
@@Buzz727the fact that you don't see the irony of what you're saying just proves my comment
i find that odd too, it is probably Shaytan taking the muslim over, though sectanarism is haram and we have the same goal, Sunni's, Shia, whatever should stay united
@@Buzz727yeah rite! And what makes the 'Sunni' sect correct while the 'Shia' wrong? Both have their OWN hadith collections so which ones are true?? How do you prove this? It's like a football match - pick your side! 😅
@@NinjaKiller999That's how you tell who is a real believer and who is a hypocrite 😢 It's a cult tactic, with outsiders they try to be nice to attract them and convert as many as possible, but with those who believe they make sure they don't deviate from their ideals. A real believer wouldn't care about proving himself right, he would care about you understanding that we are all supposed to submit to Allah and he would respect others that believe in the same.
Why should we be polite when you are change our religion that why you are so few, i think even your parents are normal sunni
Thanks for the video brother. You are one of the few who understands the "sunnat-Allah"
And yet there's not a SINGLE verse in the Qur'an that makes mention of the 'Sunnah' of Muhammad (a.s), nor the 'Sunnah' of Nabi, nor the 'Sunnah' of the Rasool! But they want to teach us a different Sunnah!
@@negeto2460 hey some Sunnis say ما ينطق عن الهوى
So what is your opinion about that
@@yahia1000i say: please quote the verse in it's FULL CONTEXT - starting from verse 1 and up to 18! It's obviously describing prophet Muhammad's encounter with Angel Jibreel who brought the revelation down to him. And if they say prophet Muhammad does not speak of his own desire - meaning EVERYTHING he spoke was Wahi, then how would they explain Verse 66:1?? Here, the prophet get's told off by Allah for trying to make 'haram' for himself what Allah made 'halal'. So, did Allah send down Wahi to the prophet to make sonething haram for himself, and then recieves another Wahi telling him off for doing it?? 🤣
Therefore, when the Qur'an says: "he does not speak of his desire", this is in the context of his encounter with Jibreel who was bringing down the Wahi (Qur'an).
I hope that answers your question akhi?
@@negeto2460I found an easier way to debunk this,if the prophet hi is that revelation,when the prophet one time ignored a blind man in the qaurn,is that revelation?
@@negeto2460 ok thanks what about verse 33:21
Brother how the hell can all these scholars reject what you say?!?!?! It’s so clear man! They follow what their forefathers and scholars tell them and it’s like when Allah spoke about taking disbelievers as allies they’re afraid of going against the scholars because then they are “kaffirs” “or crazy” but why not only fear Allah?
Brothers & sisters,
The greatest trick that Shaytan ever pulled was to SEPERATE Allah and His Messengers! The traditional muslims claim that 'obey Allah and His Messenger' are 2 seperate / independent obediences. However, this is so far from the truth! If that was the case, then how do we interpret the following verses:
- War from Allah AND His Messenger {2:279 & 5:33}
- emigrant to Allah AND His Messenger {4:100}
- spoils for Allah AND His Messenger {8:1}
- those who lied to Allah AND His Messenger {9:90}
- respond to Allah AND His Messenger {8:24}
- do not betray Allah AND His Messenger {8:27}
- help Allah AND His Messenger {59:8}
Are these verses above referring to TWO seperate wars? TWO seperate emigrants? TWO seperate spoils? TWO seperate lies? TWO seperate responses? TWO seperate betrayals?? The list goes on...
At the time of revelation, how EXACTLY did the people of Muhammad (a.s) obey Allah in the first place? How did they obtain the Qur'an in order to obey Allah? Was the Qur'an available through anyone else other the Messenger?? Then how can obey Allah and His Messenger mean TWO seperate obediences when the Qur'an was ONLY OBTAINABLE via the Messenger?
Regarding guidance... who guides according to the Qur'an? Is prophet Muhammad (a.s) an independent guide alongside Allah? If so, then how do you explain verses 2:272 and 28:56 where it clearly states that Muhammad (a.s) wasn't capable of guiding anyone (even his loved ones)? But says: "walaakinnallaha YAHDEE man yashaa" - But rather, Allah GUIDES whim He wills!
Verse 9:33 reads:
Huwalladhee arsala rasoolahu bilhuda - is it He who sent His Messenger with THE GUIDANCE! Does Allah have a companian who guides with Him? Subhanallaah! Think about this!!
Therefore, following THE MESSENGER means to follow THE GUIDANCE (Qur'an) that was revealed / given to him! The Messenger was NOT a seperate or independent guide! And obedience to THE MESSENGER is to obey what Allah revealed to him! This is not rocket science.
Please think / reflect / ponder over the verses of Allah and stop worshipping your ulema and imams! I also have videos on my channel which details all this for anyobe who's interested in finding the truth.
Peace
Yes also 4:150 with context
Yes also 4:150 with context
The Arabic plural is different than the English one. Several other verses the arvaic itself does not indicate plural even though we see and
One thing I don't understand is that it is clear as day in Quran what to follow but why do these sunnis and shias keep denying it... what is the purpose and what are they gaining out of it?
I think the lay people think it's the way, almost like christians think its ok but no know too much about it. As for the scholars it's the idea of associating right with might. Since the big scholars believe it then it must be right! However even great scholars past and present have acknowledged flaws. It's not the average person at fault whether sunni or shia they don't know better. They are muslim and trying to do the best they can. They fear so they listen to the scholars of their sects not knowing better.
Great presentation !
may God guide us all, allah hu akbar!
İnşallah
I appreciate you and brother baba for making content to allow us to reason as the Quran asks us to. Thank you!
By the way akhi.. that hadeeth that is found in Imam Maaliks Muwatta has NO CHAIN! The one that mentions "The Book of Allah and the prophet's Sunnah". And this 'version' of the last Sermon does not exist in any of the 6 Sunni hadeeth collections (Bukhari, Muslim, etc).
Therefore, it's not to be taken as evidence according to Sunni Muslims 😅
Excellent work Brother!
Beautifully said!
You're on point brother nice lecture
mashallah my beautiful brother
stay strong
there are many millions of Muslims who have taken off their blindfolds ,
opened their eyes,
actually read the Quran ,in a language they understand and realised and accepted that the Quran is the only book they should follow
there are No shortcomings in the Quran
keep up the good work GOD willing 🙏
For future reference brother, 'Obey Allah and obey the messenger' is an example of a sentence structure called a hendiadys. A hendiadys is when two ideas are linked into one with a conjunction. For example, if your dad says 'Listen to me and clean your room' nobody would say 'Ok I cleaned my room, now how do I listen to my dad?' Yet the Sunni mushrikeen do not understand this in the Qur'an.
Let's look at the following ayah:
"And [it is] an announcement from Allah *and* His Messenger to the people on the day of the greater pilgrimage that Allah is disassociated from the disbelievers, and [so is] His Messenger. So if you repent, that is best for you; but if you turn away - then know that you will not cause failure to Allah. And give tidings to those who disbelieve of a painful punishment." 9:3
Does this mean Allah and Muhammad made the announcement together? Astaghfirullah. Yet these Sunnis think obeying Allah is something separate from obeying the messenger.
Salam
As I pointed out in another discussion with you, in some verses the Messenger refers to the Quran. Examples: Quran ayats 4: 14, 4: 59, 9: 29, 8: 20, 8: 24, 33: 36 and many more.
Spot on akhi! But the tradition bukhariyion insist that Obey Allah and His Messenger are 2 different or independant sources! They will never learn
How can we just assume The Messenger is only Muhammad ﷺ . It looks like Jibreel ﷺ is the Messenger Spirit from Allah all along.
@@solaquranagood question i must say
Jesus is messenger and we must follow it 43:61@@solaqurana
Excellent video very informative. Thanks for the information. Please keep it coming , even im getting sick of these hadiths
Every muslim sect has their own hadith and for that very reason we done have unity
What a great plan implemented by our enemies
Milah Ibrahim, you absolutely explained it very well
Brother please make a video on salat according to Quran so that we can answer them with it.
One Question what do you think of the prophecy's in the hadiths
U gotta understand that most Hadith’s were burned by the Mongolian invasion during Baghdad. They burned A lot of the Islamic knowledge that was kept and obviously Hadith’s were not memorized like the Miracle of the Quran is so they can rewrite Hadith’s if they really wanted to
I would love for you to debate these individuals.
Unfortunately all they do is interrupt and change the subject
There's no point in debate, we should only invite to the path of Allah
﴿٦٤﴾ قُلْ يَا أَهْلَ الْكِتَابِ تَعَالَوْا إِلَىٰ كَلِمَةٍ سَوَاءٍ بَيْنَنَا وَبَيْنَكُمْ أَلَّا نَعْبُدَ إِلَّا اللَّهَ وَلَا نُشْرِكَ بِهِ شَيْئًا وَلَا يَتَّخِذَ بَعْضُنَا بَعْضًا أَرْبَابًا مِنْ دُونِ اللَّهِ ۚ فَإِنْ تَوَلَّوْا فَقُولُوا اشْهَدُوا بِأَنَّا مُسْلِمُونَ
3:64 Say, “O People of the Book, come to terms common between us and you: that we worship none but God, and that we associate nothing with Him, and that none of us takes others as lords besides God.” And if they turn away, say, “Bear witness that we have submitted.”
As a Malankara Syrian Jacobite Christian, May God Almighty Bless You my brother.
@@fairyvalley_ I am indeed Malayali!
The challenge has been set.
Lets see who excepts.
Brother, i just want you to show me how you pray.❤ This is a request. (And i do find some of your views logical and i dont want to be arrogant)
I’m not being arrogant either but have you read the Quran? If not yet entirely please pay attention to how the messengers mentioned before Mohamed communicated with Allah pay attention to the context around what they were doing in that moment and compare with the others mentioned in the Quran and how they exalted Allah. What did they call Him again pay attention to the context around what they were doing in the moment. Did they in contrast to the ritual salat of today follow it or say the things that are being said if they don’t match we have to use reasoning. We are comparing an original (Quran) to a non original it very simple in that thought process. Nothing beats the original text of the Creator!
Allah mentions lentils in the Quran how small and insignificant to us but it was important for Allah to mention that specific food. Unfortunately we don’t understand what Allah is revealing to us. We don’t realize that if it were of great importance to Allah it would be mentioned. Instead we would say it’s not clear As if Allah can’t produce a clear statement. In that moment we are blaspheming against by saying or either agreeing that Allah left something he stated as complete now is being rendered incomplete by scholars of the past and present
Now how arrogant is that for us to take that position to a supreme being we claim to respect and have reverence for?
الله: ياأيها الذين امنوا كونوا قوامين بالقسط شهداء لله ولو على أنفسكم أو الوالدين والأقربين.
السنة: انصر أخاك ظالماً أو مظلوماً.
الله: انك لا تسمع الموتى
السنة: ما انتم بأسمع من الأموات ولكن لا يجيبون
الله: الله يحب المطهرين
السنة: الصحابة يتبركون ببصاق النبي ونخامته
الله: فأخذهم الله بذنوبهم
السنة: لو لم تذنبوا لذهب الله بكم
الله: قال الظالمون ان تتبعون الا رجلاً مسحورا
السنة: الرسول كان رجلاً مسحورا
الله: يثبت الله الذين آمنوا بالقول الثابت
السنة: يثبت التواتر القول بالرجل الثابت
الله: العسل فيه شفاء للناس
السنة: بول البعير فيه شفاء للناس
الله: وما منعنا ان نرسل بالآيات الا ان كذب بها الاولون.
السنة: الماء ينبع بين اصابع الرسول مثل العيون
الله: ولقد رءاه نزلة أخرى
السنة: ولقد رءاه صعدة أخرى
الله: فليأتوا بحديث مثله ان كانوا صادقين.
السنة: اوتيت القرآن ومثله معه.
الله: قل ان صلاتي ونسكي ومحياي ومماتي لله رب العالمين.
السنة: اجعل لك ( يا محمد ) صلاتي كلها؟ قال: اذاً تكفى همك، ويكفر لك ذنبك.
الله: كتب عليكم اذا حضر احدكم الموت ان ترك خيراً الوصية
السنة: لا وصية لوارث
الله: قل ما كنت بدعاً من الرسل وما ادري ما يفعل بي ولا بكم
السنة: الرسول يبشر عشرة من اصحابه بالجنة
الله: أنؤمن لك واتبعك الأرذلون
السنة: إن من أشراط الساعة أن يلتمس العلم عند الأصاغر
الله: وليست التوبة للذين يعملون السيئات حتى اذا حضر احدهم الموت قال اني تبت الان
السنة: من كان اخر كلامه لا اله الا الله دخل الجنة
الله: ان تبدوا ما في انفسكم او تخفوه يحاسبكم به الله.
السنة: إن الله تجاوز عن أمتي ما حدثت به أنفسها ما لم تعمل، أو تكلم.
الله: ان تطع اكثر من في الارض يضلوك عن سبيل الله.
السنة: من اراد بحبوحة الجنة فليلزم الجماعة.
الله: اولم يكفهم انا انزلنا عليك الكتاب يتلى عليهم؟
السنة: لا لم يكفنا
الله: وإذا يتلى عليهم قالوا آمنا به إنه الحق من ربنا
السنة: وإذا يتلى عليهم قالوا آمنا به إنه الحق من محمد
الله: ام لهم شركاء شرعوا لهم من الدين مالم يأذن به الله؟
السنة: نعم شركاءنا الروايات والافتاءات والشيوخ.
الله: فبأي حديث بعده يؤمنون؟
السنة: حديث الرسول والصحابة.
الله: ثم اورثنا الكتاب الذين اصطفينا من عبادنا فمنهم ظالم لنفسه ومنهم مقتصد ومنهم سابق للخيرات.
السنة: الصحابة اورثوا الكتاب وكلهم سابق للخيرات ولايوجد احد منهم ظالم لنفسه.
الله: اتموا الصيام الى الليل.
السنة: اتموا الصيام الى الغروب
الله: وظن داود انما فتناه فاستغفر ربه وخر راكعاً
السنة: قال ابن عربي انه لا يوجد خلاف بين العلماء ان معنى الركوع في هذه الآية هو السجود
الله: ادخلوا الجنة بما كنتم تعملون.
السنة: لن يدخل احد عمله الجنة.
الله: قل من حرم زينة الله التي اخرج لعباده؟
السنة: لبس الرجل للحرير والذهب حرام
الله: حرمت عليكم الميتة والدم
السنة: دم الكبد حلال
الله: ويجعل الرجس على اللذين لا يعقلون.
السنة: النقل قبل العقل.
الله: من يرغب عن ملة ابراهيم الا من سفه نفسه.
السنة: من يرغب عن ملة محمد الا من سفه نفسه.
الله: لا يشرك في حكمه أحداً.
السنة: ألا إن ما حرم الرسول مثل ما حرم الله.
الله: حق القول مني لأملأن جهنم من الجنة والناس أجمعين
السنة: الله سيملأ جهنم برجله ثم تقول جهنم 'قط قط' ( المصدر صحيح مسلم الصفحة ٢٨٤٨ + صحيح البخاري صفحة ٤٨٤٨ )
الله: إذا جاء أحدكم الموت توفته رسلنا وهم لا يفرطون
السنة: موسى يفقأ عين ملك الموت رافضاً أن يموت
الله: أم حسب الذين اجترحوا السيئات أن نجعلهم كالذين آمنوا وعملوا الصالحات سواء محياهم ومماتهم ساء ما يحكمون
السنة: يا ابن آدم إنك لو أتيتني بقراب الأرض خطايا ثم لقيتني لا تشرك بي شيئاً لأتيتك بقرابها مغفرة
الله: اذا نودي للصلاة من يوم الجمعة.
السنة: اذا نودي لصلاة يوم الجمعة.
الله: هل ينظرون الا ان يأتيهم الله
السنة: هل ينظرون الا ان يأتيهم عيسى
جزاك الله
رح اعمل فديوا واترجم تعليقك
الله يقويك
@@MuhammadfromGOD
جزاكم الله خير وقواكم على قول الحق 💐❤️🌹
Beautiful comment. Subhanallah.
In Quran ul- hakeem it is mentioned only few accepted islam in old generationa, only few accepted the prophet's path , only few will enter jannah. Only few will fight in the way of Allah against shaitan. Only few are gurabba not everyone
﴿١١٦﴾ وَإِنْ تُطِعْ أَكْثَرَ مَنْ فِي الْأَرْضِ يُضِلُّوكَ عَنْ سَبِيلِ اللَّهِ ۚ إِنْ يَتَّبِعُونَ إِلَّا الظَّنَّ وَإِنْ هُمْ إِلَّا يَخْرُصُونَ
If you were to obey most of those on earth, they would divert you from God’s path. They follow nothing but assumptions, and they only conjecture. 6:116
@@sal_strazzulloexactly!
I am xtian but was amazed to find that Islam has alot of what is from Hadith followed in addition to Quran .
But shariah is from hadith not Quran.
So Muslims revise Islam to march Quran and see how it changes your position
Salam
While I agree with a lot of what u said like the sunnis and their takfir tactics, how people are splitting the religion, etc. what I don’t agree is how u said the Shias and sunnis fight each other. Brother the Sunnis see us as their worst enemies while we see them as our brothers. They are the ones killing and oppressing us for so long.
What's wrong with these Sunni fellas? In India shite dudes are cool. But Sunnis tend to be violent most of the time. Violent in sense of thought, speech and action. 😅 edit: Shite I mean syiah.
bro thats not true, im Sunni and i have no enmity towards any shia,
we are all under la illaha illa lah which is sufficient enough.
what you are seeing is the political lansscape of the modern islamic era, where saudi and iran are fighting over who can dominate the most land and resources, due to this it seems as if we hate each other, meanwhile in actual fact we are all brothers😊
@@Hyundmeko Salam brother
U guys act as if we sit their all day and curse them. Honestly I could careless, what happen already happened. This doesn’t give u the right to oppress and kill us. I’m not saying all Sunnis do this ofc, I have a lot of Sunni friends but their are a lot of u guys who see us as the enemy. Regardless I’m not here to spread fitna may Allah SWT bless u.
@@Hyundmeko brother some people love to start fitna for no reason. Me personally I keep my feelings to my self and when my friends have a question I try to answer it to the best of my ability. Also that’s a misconception we don’t dislike all the sahaba.
@@Hyundmeko I agree. May Allah SWT grant all of us the highest levels of paradise
❤
it would be interesting to get w a full understanding of your positioning and what you exactly believe. I understand you don't like Hadeeth but do you only follow Quran ? or do you except other things of scholars ? Just tryinh to understand ... maybe you have a video on that.
I’d argue the Rasul doesn’t mean messenger. It’s referring to the message itself. Obeying the message is obeying Allah.
I mean, if we can go with our modern understanding of the Arabic language than rasul is messenger and message is risalleh
I have a simple question really....for those who say "how do you pray"... Do you memorise the hadiths that teach us how to pray? I myself pray like they taught me when i was a kid... Never did i memorie these hadiths... And weren't the hadiths compiled after the prophet's death by more than 200 years? How did people pray in these 200 years without the hadiths???? Simple answer really... They prayed like their fathers and there fathers like the prophet.... We Don't require the hadiths to know how to pray... Much like the quran... The difference between quran and prayer and the hadiths is that both quran and prayer were compiled and done when the prophet mohamed (PBUH) Was alive and were practiced without flaw... But the hadiths were compiled much later... And many many of them were false... And that's why a "sahih" which means "the Rights" were made in the first place... They were made in a desperate attempt to differentiate between the false and the right hadiths.... As many monafeqin "hypocrites" used to lie and say the prophet said those lies.... So it's actually admirable that they compiled the hadiths and tried really hard to know which is right and which is wrong.... But this in no way makes hadiths as preserved as quran!!! And the ones who compiled them are still human... Humans make mistakes... So from the 6000 hadiths in bukhari its understandable if like 1000 of them are wrong.... And moreover... How many people memorie all hadiths by heart.... I think less than a 100 and that's even a stretch... But how many memorise the quran? Millions! So if some writer of old was a hypocrite and decided to make up a multiple hadiths in the middle of these thousands.... They might just pass and no one notices! As opposed to the quran.... And so the argument we use that the bible is fabricated can be used against hadiths and not the quran... End of discussion...
FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT
Exactly. I pray 5x a day and do the usaly ruku and everything. All Muslims pray based on their fathers and stuff. And if ur a revert to Islam u prob learned to pray when u went to masjid not by opening Sahih Al bukhari. Even if u look at for example orthodox Christian’s, they prostrated like Muslims before the revelation of the prophet came to be. Prayer is just something we know and same for hajj
I know ibrahim he is an imam ı met hım ones for real.
He teached me to walk straight on the right path and trust in Allah.
It is insane how we sunnis have systematically been distanced from Quran. The Book says that the momineen do not discriminate between the messengers 2:285 , but we have created categories and levels? Astaghfirullah. These salafi wahabi madkhalis are the worst, they have so much hatred against everyone else without reflecting for a second how they have distorted Islam.
What these people have done is to convert Islam into idolatry by creating these mythical figures of pure infallible sahaba who need to be followed. So a muslim doesnt need to engage with the literal word of the Creator, but follow fallible people instead.
Just as a constructive suggestion, please explain your points with logic and rationality which you have been blessed in tons Alhumdulillah withiut sarcasm, it repels even well meaning sunni-shia brothers who might come closer to the Book of Allah and His deen. And victory to Filasteen inshaAllah.
That's why Muslim world is ok shambles and chaos. I realised this few years back and distanced myself from all the Soo called Sunnis or shias , it's more peaceful
11:30 why u keep long beard then?
Surah an-Nisa (4:59) O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.
Assalamu alaikum brother, pls do a video on prayer, i am really worried about my prayer.
Bruh… asking him is like asking someone with a fake math degree to solve you a complex math problem. Read what the hadith say.
dont reject all hadith, as they arent prohibited but not recommended, though heres what i gathered, prayer has to happen 3 times (dont remember the times), your positions in prayer should be standing, bowing then prostrating, you should also do wudu (act of ablution)
Salam brother. You don't have to change the way you already pray, that's how Allah and your people have taught you to pray. You only have to change what you say so that you don't associate others with Allah. May He continue to bless you with knowledge and wisdom 🙏
Key verse:
﴿٦٧﴾ لِكُلِّ أُمَّةٍ جَعَلْنَا مَنْسَكًا هُمْ نَاسِكُوهُ ۖ فَلَا يُنَازِعُنَّكَ فِي الْأَمْرِ ۚ وَادْعُ إِلَىٰ رَبِّكَ ۖ إِنَّكَ لَعَلَىٰ هُدًى مُسْتَقِيمٍ
22:67 For every congregation We have appointed acts of devotion, which they observe. So do not let them dispute with you in this matter. And invite to your Lord; you are upon a straight guidance.
@@mr.frizzyizz5058 have you read "kitab-as-salah"?
Thank you brother
Uthman ibn Farooq: How old was Jehoiachim when he ruled Jerusalem 40 or 4? See that's a numerical contradiction
Also Uthman ibn Farooq: How old was 'Aisha when she consummated her marriage to the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ?
7? 8? 9? They're all correct because 'Aisha couldn't remember how old she was!
LOL 😅
@@negeto2460 🤣
Aisha was a woman, dont make Muhammad a pdf-file. Astaghfirullah
@@Assadul-Naml you didn't understand the point of what I wrote. I obviously reject the concept of her age in traditional Sunni Islam. I just pointed out what THEY claim about her age comes from ahadeeth that contradict each other (not just the Qur'an) like the books of the Bible contradict. Astaghfirullah I would never attribute to the Prophet ﷺ a lie.
@@solaqurana
Sorry got a bit sidetracked here. But i cant hear these lies, and the so called muslims supporting them anymore. I hope you feel my standing point.
46:00 but they will say yes he said the book is enough because the book says to follow the prophet which means Sunnah
interesting how the akbar shahada(GREATEST TESTIMONY) in Quran 6:19 mentions Quran but not Sunnah or Ahl ul Bayt.
Ahlul Bayt(as) taught the Sunnah and we have hadiths that tell us to judge hadiths by the Quran and to take that which agrees with the Quran and to throw away anything that contradicts with the Quran.
Saying "I will use dictionaries, geography books, history books, etc. to better understand the Quran but completely ignore hadith books which give us better historical context of the Quran" is just silly and narrow minded.@@davidela9022
Saya setuju. Kalau ada pilihan A, A+B, A+C, kita seharusnya pilih A karena muncul 3 kali, tapi mengikuti A+B+C menambah peluang, tapi dengan catatan, A sebagai prioritas utama. Islam itu indah, islam pengertian, dan islam itu mudah. Allah knew best and Allah the Almighty and the most merciful
Catatan persaan pribadi penulis, kebanyakan muslim sekarang hanya bodoh dan enggan mengakui dosa mereka. Padahal tinggal tiru yang baik dan tinggalkan yang buruk (｡･∀･)ﾉﾞ ☜(ﾟヮﾟ☜)
Selamat malam ❤
May Allah bless you brother, you have been given knowledge 🙏
Our Muslims don’t defend Prophrt PBUH rather they defend these Hadith books. If there was only Quran not Hadith books then there was no problems with in Muslims.
But if you say anything against Hadith it’s considered as Blasphemy especially South Asia
the numerical contrdatiction, the Prophet (SAW) had 11 wives from 9 in a short duration gap, so both statements could be true
How to pray if we dont use hadith references?
LOL! Show us a hadeeth that shows you how to pray from A to Z. Most of how to pray are found in books of fiqh and most of these hadeeths in them are not even sahih 😅
@@negeto2460 I'm learning, please be patient with me.
you can research from the Quran, though i dont recommend outright rejecting hadith, the way i do it is that i try to limit my hadith beliefs and believe in them if theyre authentic, dont contradict the Quran and seem like Muhammad wouldve said it
@@Buzz727 even by hadith it is believed only Allah knows whos Salah Will be accepted, so are you saying we know our Salah is accepted? It's much complicated, issue of the ghayb. Why impose? Hedayet of Allah comes at His Will. We have no right to divide the unman by sects.
@@Buzz727 "the problem, without following hadith, there will be 0 chance our salah is accepted" this contradicts Quran 16 :116
If Hadith was needed, why is not all the prophets sent with the Book and Hadith? The Book stays and Hadith fades.
Can we be messengers? If we hear a message from the messengers (angels) or no? Rabbigifirli astagfirullah if I’m wrong
No, Quran is the end of revelations and Mohammed is the end of prophets. You won't hear any message from angels but if you live for 3-5 billion years, you will surely meet a creature from mud which is called dabbah and he will be sent by Allah
Messangership is not over yet, Prophethood has being Finalized by Peacemaker Immortal Muhammad the Prophet.
@@magnuscritikaleak5045yes it is. Allah swt already ended the messengers. The message had been made clear since the prophet Muhammad was a mercy to all of mankind while previous messenger was only for their time. So yes, Muhammad is the final messenger and the message of the Quran had been made clear to the whole world
the calculation was done on bukhari collecting so called hadiths
considering there were no cars,planes,trains at that time only horse,
donkey,camel its been said he traveled country to country to collect
just one so called hadith for hundreds of thousands of miles he
had to have lived to age 250+..
The bottom line !!
The prophet of Islam had made it clear;
" THE SIMILTIUDE OF MY AHLILBAYT IS LIKE NOAH'S ARC. WHOEVER BOARDS IT WILL BE SAVED AND WHOEVER MISSES IT WILL DROWN AND PERISH ".
" I AM THE CITY OF KNOWLEDGE AND ALI IS ITS GATE. THEREFORE, WHOEVER WANTS KNOWLEDGE SHALL COME THROUGH THE GATE ".
" O ALI , I AND YOU ARE THE TWO FATHERS OF THIS UMMAH ".
" O ALI , NONE LOVES YOU EXCEPT A BELLIEVER AND NONE HATES YOU EXCEPT A HYPOCRITE ".
" I HAVE LEFT WITH YOU WHAT IF YOU HOLD UNTO THEM BOTH SINCERELY YOU WILL NEVER GO ASTRAY ; THE BOOK OF ALLAH AND MY AHLILBAYT ,, ".
There is much more of this sorte of statements.
AHLILBAYT are the custodians of the original Islam. Not the sahabah / any companions of the prophet , nor the narrators . AHLILBAYT are the core of Islam YOU like it or not .
Brother can you please upload a video on how to pray according to the quran.
i think you are making mistake here brother. problem about hadit narrative is not about should we follow the prophet or not. the problem is can we be sure these "hadith" are really coming from the mouth of the prophet.
I changed my mind on hadith. hadith rejectors are ignorant people. study the history of Islam. it is one of the most trustworthy histories ever. if you reject hadith, you must reject 99% of the history.
If ı am the mahdi ı met the Angels one time many of them they come from the sky only three of them ı spoke they stood still the others are ready for the hour. The spoke to me and ı ask them some questions, they told me that the will save the rightous.
That is it. Maybe allah could stop punisch me
I'm a so called 'sunni'
I don't take hadiths as devine true words, I just take some of the hadiths that sounds acceptable
like the one regarding Wudu' or prayer
otherwise I wouldn't take hadiths as source of knowledge
You are not Sunni or shia or any of that crap. You are Muslim. You believe in one complete book, one God, all messengers the angels and judgement day, you a Muslim. Done. Full stop
Salam
For future reference, brother, here is an argument against the thought that "hadith are revelation".
Quran 5:3 declares our religion to be PERFECTED. CAN YOU ESTABLISH A PERFECT RELIGION WITH NON PERFECT TEXTS WHERE SCHOLARS AND SECTS AND SUBSECTS KEEP ON DISAGREEING ON WHAT MAN-MADE LAWS TO OBEY?
Also, there is a fabricated hadith, "I was given like of the Quran, and Quran's halal/haram is not enough"(abu dawud 4604), going against Quran 17:88 and 66:1.
But how do you pray? I know the prayer is mentioned throughout the Quran but it doesn't explain how to perform it.
just stop repeating this nonsensical argument. Quran has every detail for prayer apart from number of raka'at.(also, even the so called "sunnah" recognises small variations in prayer details, shafi'is, malikis, shias etc all have different prayers). dont be like bani israil who asked too many details about the cow!(see Quran 2:65-75).@@abdemouaouia8396
@@abdemouaouia8396 Question, did you learn to pray from Hadith? No you learned from your parents or by going to the mosque. How did the people that thought you how to pray learned? Same. If hadiths taught how to pray there would not be any differences in how everyone pray yet there are differences.
@@abdemouaouia8396 u sure about that?
@@Buzz727 Can you explain this hadith then? Surely the prophet saws would not dictate to do something that goes against the Quran right...
Abu Sa'id Khudri reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said:
Do not take down anything from me, and he who took down anything from me except the Qur'an, he should efface that and narrate from me, for there is no harm in it and he who attributed any falsehood to me-and Hammam said: I think he also said:" deliberately" -he should in fact find his abode in the Hell-Fire.
Reference : Sahih Muslim 3004
In-book reference : Book 55, Hadith 92
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Book 42, Hadith 7147
Brother can you make video on
Ahlul kitab
Utul alkitab
Ataynahumu l kitab
Ahlul injeel..
These hadith followers will not listen to your verses from Qur'an.
Don't care about them....
Allah will punish them......
For any Sunni in the comments, read between 4;59 to 4;70. These verses do not say that Allah asks us to follow Muhammad's judgement. 4;59 introduces obeisance to Allah and the Messenger, which can be interpreted as either obeying Allah and the Prophet's sunnah or obeying Allah through His Messenger upon whom the Kitaab is sent. I see this verse, and others like it, as the crux of the disagreement between Quranists and Traditionalists. I interpret the verse in the Quranist understanding, so that's where my argument begins. I take this position because the Quran defines what obeisance to "Allah and the Messenger" looks like from 4;66 to 4;69. How? At 4;66, Allah introduces a hypothetical in which if He had decreed (the word is "katabna", "We wrote/decreed") that they "kill themselves" or "go forth from their homes" only a few of them would have done so. Then at 4;67 and 4;68 Allah says they would've received a great reward and guided to the straight path for following the decree. Allah sends down the Kitaab upon his Messenger, and Allah uses the word "Katabna", which means it is part of the Kitaab that is sent down to His Messenger; therefore, if the Messenger tells them "Go forth from your homes" or "Kill yourselves", they would be obeying the Messengers words, and a Messenger's words are not his own, but that of the Sender's, which is Allah, and so would in turn also obey Allah. That's why the next two verses 4;69 and 4;70 conspicuously follow:
And whoso obeys God and the Messenger, those are with them whom God has favoured of the prophets, and the men of truth, and the witnesses, and the righteous; and good are those as companions.
(4:69)
That is the bounty from God; and sufficient is God as knower.
(4:70)
That is an excellent point - as many of us believe the word The Kitab is "The Judgment or Outcomes" in the Quran, while The Hikma "The wisdom" of what to do or not to do, like in chapter 17.
why do they follow ibn-kathirs tafseer these scholars -
Angels still on the clock
I definitely see many of your points about some of the inherent weakness in relying on Hadith too much. There had to be lots of forgeries but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try to extract good ones. It is problematic on certain levels but the hadiths are definitely necessary in some areas and they cannot all be forged. The native Arab speakers who lived in Mecca with the prophet, spoke Arabia without the need for any diacritical marks still needed the prophets explanations on how to properly demonstrate the Islam in the Quran. How can we expect to understand it 1400 years later living in a totally different time and era without the wisdom of the prophets Tafsir. You are actually giving tafsir on your CZcams’s yet we should not try to find the tafsir of Mohammad? It would definitely be fitnah if everybody used their own understanding of the verses. This is how lots of Islam is in USA and that has led to lots of offshoot ideas and organizations with all kinds of Cookey interpretations of the Quran.
What you are speaking makes sense, but can you tell me why are you wearing beard, but you don't believe in sunnah
We're men. Even I used to have beard , now I have a goatee. Each to every one of them depends on their liking.
Okay, hear me out for a second. Why is it that literally NOBODY, FOR THE LAST 1400 YEARS DENY nor rejected Hadith, but now 2023, these hadith rejectors are showings out of nowhere! It Truly is the end of times! May God guide us all.
Your dreaming buddy! It is well known that the Hanafis and Malikis rejected DOZENS of hadeeths because they contradicted the Qur'an. We also had the Mu'tazilah which some of them outright rejected hadeeths. A few mentions are Abu Mansur al-maturidi, abu bajr al-jassas, and abu ja'far al-tahawi (well known hanafi scholars) who rejected numerous hadeeths but these hadeeths slipped through the cracks and made their ways into the 6 Sunni hadeeth collections (bukhari, muslim, etc).
@@negeto2460yea, but this guy rejects all of the science of Hadith. And I know that certain scholars rejected certain Hadith, but they didn't completely deny the science of Hadith.
@@Buzz727hadiths are filled with absurdaties like prophet Muhammad (a.s) married a 6 year old, he was once bewitched, and he recieved satanic verses. Do you believe this rubbish bro? Does the Qur'an support any of this garbage??
The Qur'an is never enough for you people so you have to resort to these lahwal-hadeeths. The Qur'an is described as the BEST HADEETH (ahsanal-hadeeth) and even states which HADEETH after IT (the Qur'an) will you believe?
If you want to believe in HEARSAY which is what hadeeths really are, then goid luck to you akhi.
And did you know that 99% of the hadeeth corpus (in sunni islam) is classified by your scholars (muhadditheen) as Zann Daleel? Meaning 'speculative' proof! How do you follow and dedicate yourself to knowledge that is speculative???
What does the Qur'an say about following Zann (speculation)??
Let that sink in...
i mean it couldve been that some hadith tell us to kill apostates, if there was a hadith rejector, ope and his head is gone because people couldve believe he is a kafir, the internet allows hadith rejectors to safely tell their beliefs and opinions, but do not worry, every muslim, whether theyre a sunni, shia or quranist have the same goal and we shouldnt divide ourselves over this
@@Buzz727 yet in Sahih Muslim 42:7147 Muhammad says to not take anything down from him except the Quran, there are also many Quranic verses warning against hadith, so i believe hadith can be followed but arent a must.
After seeing youre video ı think that the sunnat of allah says that the people only listen to a rasul ore maybe also to a shahid a witness.
And allah will sen a rasul before yaume elkiyame ı think.
The light is kuran maasallah, ıt is kuran then he created the human
55 kuran
Then he teached the human so if the kuran is the light it must be in the eyes of the human allah gives light.
Let say
But! Hoooowww do you prayy brother??
How did they pray BEFORE the Hadiths 250 yrs later😂😂😂
My bad mabad u think he is really in a joke mood
How can you prove that the Qur'an that you have is the same that was revealed to the prophet Muhammad (S)?
We have carbon dated copies from that period in time, but Allah has also promised to preserve the Quran, and also all the righteous people know that it is the word of God
@@sal_strazzullo yeah but how do you verify that not a single word has been altered or tampered with? How do you reconcile between different readings? Older manuscripts don't have i'rāb. So how do you know if it is read Alif Lām Mīm or Alam? How do you know if it's maliki yawm ad-Dīn or Maaliki yawm ad-Dīn?
@@mhholmez2547 "Indeed ( Inna ) , upon Us ( Älai'naa ) is its collection ( Jam'ä - hu ) and ( Wa ) its reading"-Quran 75:17
"So ( Fa ) when ( Izaa ) We read it ( Qura'naa - hu ) , then ( Fa ) follow ( Ettabi ' ) its reading ( Qur'aana - hu )"-Quran 75:18
"Then ( Thumma ) indeed ( Inna ) , upon Us ( Älai'naa ) is its clarification ( Bayaana - hu )"-Quran 75:19
@@shajonpaithalmalaend of story! But the Bukhariyoon have a different story 😅
what do you think sanaa manuscript is?@@mhholmez2547
Also the hadiths say that you should make the sajdah with your nose or face or forehead, that's completely wrong muslim brothers for Allah's sake once again for Allah's sake put the whole head the whole brain on prostration as much as you can that magical feeling connected with the divine. You have nothing no effect zero effect with the forehead or the nose or the face like dogs just put the whole head the whole brain on the sajdah rotate the head and how the muslims are praying Wallahi Wallahi that not sajdah. And whoever follows me my message is mine and whoever doesnt follow me indeed Allah is independent of everybody Selam Alejkum ve Rahmetullahi ve Berekatuhu to you brother on the channel and to the good muslims
وَإِذَا ذُكِرَ ٱللَّهُ وَحۡدَهُ ٱشۡمَأَزَّتۡ قُلُوبُ ٱلَّذِینَ لَا یُؤۡمِنُونَ بِٱلۡـَٔاخِرَةِۖ وَإِذَا ذُكِرَ ٱلَّذِینَ مِن دُونِهِۦۤ إِذَا هُمۡ یَسۡتَبۡشِرُونَ﴿ ٤٥ ﴾
Whenever God is mentioned on His own, the hearts of those who do not believe in the Hereafter shrink with aversion, but they rejoice when gods other than Him are mentioned.
Az-Zumar, Ayah 45
I always ask people who believe in hadith, if they truly believe it is a second revelation why don’t they recite it as much as they do recite the Quran? Why don’t they read it in their salah?
And I also ask them, if you truly believe the Prophet Muhammad pbuh can hear you, why is it that when you struggle or are suffering, you quickly dedicate your prayer to God alone, instead of praying to him as your hadith claims you should do to earn the prophets blessing and intercession.
Please talk about having opposite gender friends with maintaining boundaries.
Any other stupid rules like:
Playing with dice,without beting money.
Shaking women's hand normally,for some reason people think that is wrong.
Yess!!!
@@offline__literally having friendship with girl won't always turn into love vice versa
@@yahia1000 yes exactly ikr
Well you see these "silly" things are a part of the religion.
It was narrated that Ma’qil ibn Yassaar said: the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “For one of you to be stabbed in the head with an iron needle is better for him than that he should touch a woman who is not permissible for him.”
Now if you don't like it or think it's silly, that's your problem
You cannot make non mahram friends, period.
@@yourmuslimahukht3352 That's hilarious. What's wrong with shaking a woman's hand? Seems like you get turned on just by touching a woman's hand.
Why do you keep saying God and Not Allah..?
its literally the same. God is the english word, and Allah is the arabic word for god. so since he speaks english, why is it a problem if he says god
Did you miss this verse?
//Quran 17/110
Say: "Call upon Allah, or call upon Rahman: by whatever name ye call upon Him, (it is well): for to Him belong the Most Beautiful Names.
Neither speak thy Prayer aloud, nor speak it in a low tone, but seek a middle course between."//
Selam Aleykum, we need to call it what it really is, to simply call it Hadith is misleading and may cause confusion, The Quran is identified as a Hadith and the best Hadith. So it’s important to win this word back from the hijackers!
Obey God, Obey the messenger does not equal Bukhari, Tirmidi, ibn kafir etc etc, so to identify that as Hadith only binds them altogether hence why one must separate and keep them separated for what they are specific to the names on the front covers of the books…
Calling them and identifying them only as Hadith can be misleading, use the names given to them by the authors.
Help lift the Hijaban .
Peace🕊️
Muhammed ı have pain, so ı ask you to pray to Allah for me is that possible?
Second question, what allah says of the ahd and misaq.
Allah will fullfill his light, this is stil unknown for us till it happens, ı have assumption it must be a good thing surely.
I ask you what about the imam concept in 2 124
And in furkan rabbana icalna lil mutakinna imaman.
Because ı also have some information from allah, When ı testify about allah behind a veil on his trown over the water in the heavens.
And ı testify about muhhamed and ibraheem and carefull about eesa and you won't care about imam ali the servant and student of muhammed.
And ındeed is muhamed a great teacher.
And then ı have much more proof only if you hear and see.
And only by the will of allah.
Still ı am in pain and ilness so pray for me if it could help me, ı pray for you because you make this strange sjeik the crazy man in my understanding who lied about allah and about the deen allah.
I makes me sometime angry, and why he says mabad at the end of his intro.
34:40 haha
Obey the messenger means when you are with him. When this ayat was reveal the believers alive are with the messenger. Unfortunately majority of the Muslim followed what people wrote about 1 messenger. The Truth will guide you to Jannah not the authentic hadith.
Reply and messenger is not only limited Muhamad. The Quran itself has the exact same thing that God told Muhammad to recite
So really both are the same messenger. One was human , other is book left with us after Muhammad left.
Thank you for exposing this sheytan
Why do u have a long beard and trim moustache if u reject hadeeth/sunnah
Because he likes the style
Just because something is written in the hadith books and mentioned in the sunna doesn’t mean we can’t do it.
@@Buzz727 haha who’s running
By your logic Because he isn't a Sunni He needs to eat with his left hand.
he probably likes it, i have always wanted a beard since i was young boy, with EVERYBODY in my country being clean shaven due to the bolsheviks banning beards in the early days (i am lithuanian)
Do you reject chain of transmission for everything but Quran?
Even though many of these chains are the exact same as quran?
So by definition you are calling the preservers of quran that Allah hinself had chosen as liars?
So what conclusion can that lead to about the quran you read?
Could you please tell us which Ayaat or Surah's of the Qur'an are 'Daeef', 'Hasan', or 'Sahih'? Since you people love to make CLAIMS, let's see you answer this one.
their belief in Quran is pretty much daif though, they use verses to target other religions and neglect their own duties.@@negeto2460
“Our favorite street dawah guy” 😂
if we use the same logic that you apply to hadiths .. then cant we say quran of God or Quran of Usman (ra). because he standardised it. How can we then trust anything that is being passed onto us?
The Quran is from GOD because of the context, not because of who gave it to us.
The Hadith isn't from GOD because of the context.
@@MuhammadfromGOD Well if we say Hadiths arent from God. Then how can we explain way of praying , , way of burying, way of performing wudu, way of behaving with wives, way of leading a state etc .. if we assume that these things are not from allah then what ?
are we going to say Muhammad (saw) made these things up ?
the folly is in asking too many details. basic prayer method and rules includind wudu are detailed in the Quran, only stuff like raka'at is not. Also, Quran does say that you must be just and fair and a bunch of other moral principles and economical principles(zakat, sadaqat, no riba etc.) VERY USEFUL in leading a state. Quran also emphasizes kindness with wives.@@ahraanhassan6299
@@ahraanhassan6299praying, wudu, how to treat ur wife,leading etc are mentioned in the Quran. you need someone to teach u how to bury?lol..
Salah didn’t start with prophet Muhammad rather Muslims were praying since Abraham’s time!
@@kooshin6180 so please tell me how to pray ? full procedure please.
also tell me how should I bury a dead? actual procedure from quran .
All Read And Follow Quran Its Easy Complete Perfect Understandable Have Healing And Mercy For Us
Fact ; All The People Born With Blindness or Other disability Dont Like There disability To Be Cure Awesome Right Thats is My Mercy Of God
Fact : Quran Is The Only Book That Is Fully God's Words
Fact : All The Problems We Get is Because Of Our Sins
Fact : Islam Of Quran And Islam Of Today,s Era Is Different
Fact : Allah Is Genuinely Merciful And Answers All Your Question Is Quran Like Why I Got Suffer Why Animals Suffer Every Question Has Answers In Quran
Fact : Allah Is The Only God And Allah Will Give You Miracles Not Simple Miracles That Can Be Classified As Coincidence By Others But Undenieable Miracles Which Is
Undenieable By Any Sane Person Just As He Given Me If You Like I Can Show
Fact : In Quran Allah Says Quran Is Free From Doubts As It Is
Fact : Islam Is The True Natural Religion
Peace
You’re the one who wants to separate the prophet from The Quran! What’s the point of a messenger?
To deliver a message.
@@lauran7744 right but these hadeeth rejectors think all the message they need is in the Quran… so just relieve the Quran if we’re not meant to follow the prophet…….
Quran and Hadith were both collected after the death of Prophet Peace be on to him, exactly the same way. People had different parts of the verses and they were compiled through chains of transmission
Bring your evidence if what you say is true!
Not true, not the same way. Quran was not transmitted with "chains of transmissions", but it was memorized in mass by basically everyone. The Hadiths were banned and nobody was allowed to transmit them or write them down for a long time, until when enough time had passed they started writing them down. Most Hadiths had to be filtered out as fabrications, that's why we have Sahih Bukhari and the "Sahih al Sitta" (for Sunnis, because Shias and Ibadis have other collections).
so your faith is on chains of transmission rather than reading the miraculous text.
think: Why do many people revert after reading the Quran translated in their language? None of them ask for chains of narrations going back to Hafs, yet they believe in the message because the message itself is miraculous.
Tell me truthfully if you can dare use the above logic for hadiths. maybe, give a non muslim a complete copy of sahih bukhari and ask them if they want to convert to bukhariism.
@@asr2009well said Aman! 😅
@@asr2009 "Every one of the children of Adam has been created with three hundred and sixty joints; so he who declares the Glory of Allah, praises Allah, declares Allah to be One, Glorifies Allah, and seeks forgiveness from Allah, and removes stone, or thorn, or bone from people's path, and enjoins what is good and forbids from evil, to the number of those three hundred and sixty joints, will walk that day having saved himself from the Fire." Sahih Muslim 1007
No brother obey the messenger is not obey the books of hadith but its obey the authentic sunna of the prophet asws, every source besides the quran can be true or faulty or just completely fake , we have to use the Furqan to distinguish between a truthfull source " hadith" and a fake or wrong " hadith" Allah says in the Quran :
" Then do they not reflect upon the Qur'an? If it had been from [any] other than Allah , they would have found within it much contradiction. " sure Al nisaa. From this verse we know that when something is NOT from Allah it will contradict itself, there are many hadith that contradict each other or even contradict with the Quran , this Hadith we should reject them all , but there are many authentic hadith out there that have absolut no contradictions and are in line with Quran and other hadith without contradicting, we have no justification to reject that hadiths after the verse of the Quran that says obey Allah AND the Messenger. I understand why one will become a Quranist after knowing that there are so many fabricated hadith i realy do , but we cant just reject ALL and EVERYTHING just because its not in the Quran , instead we should try to take the good and leave the bad hadiths even if it is very hard to implement because the enemys of Allah fabricated and manipulated so many books of hadith but still we have to try and Allah knows best and may he guide us all to the truth.
Brother, let me ask you a question:
What do you mean by 'authentic Sunnah' exactly?
Do you mean authentic hadeeths? Do you mean the Sunnah of the khulifa rashideen? Or the practices of the people? What exactly?
Regarding the verses saying 'obey Allah AND His Messenger'. Do you really THINK that it means obeying 2 SEPARATE sources? If yes, then bow would you interpret the following verses:
- War from Allah AND His Messenger {2:279 & 5:33}
- emigrant to Allah AND His Messenger {4:100}
- spoils for Allah AND His Messenger {8:1}
- those who lied to Allah AND His Messenger {9:90}
- respond to Allah AND His Messenger {8:24}
- do not betray Allah AND His Messenger {8:27}
- help Allah AND His Messenger {59:8}
Are these verses above referring to TWO seperate wars? TWO seperate emigrants? TWO seperate spoils? TWO seperate lies? TWO seperate responses? TWO seperate betrayals?? The list goes on...
At the time of revelation, how EXACTLY did the people of Muhammad (a.s) obey Allah in the first place? How did they obtain the Qur'an in order to obey Allah? Was the Qur'an available through anyone else other the Messenger?? Then how can obey Allah and His Messenger mean TWO seperate obediences when the Qur'an was ONLY ACCESSIBLE via the Messenger?
Please reflect upon this!
@@negeto2460 yes i will reflect on this and come back to you .
@@negeto2460 Salamun ‘alaykum
The term Sunni is used by many groups and individuals, some of whom say what I said (that we must reject Hadith that contradict the Quran). When I say Im Sunni, I DONT mean the 4 madhabs, nor do I mean the Sufis who today pretend to be Sunnis, nor do I mean all these groups that have appeared only a few hundred years ago such as Salafis and others. Im talking about Sunni as in those real Sunnis who were killed by the Abbasid and Umayyad kingdoms, such as Abu Hanifah (not the Hanafis of today). The term SUNNI is used for a very large group of people, Im Sunni in a very general sense meaning that the Hadith that I use to practice Islam is from SUNNI BOOKS instead of the books of Khawarij or 12 Imamis or Ismailis or the Bible, although I do quote from those books too if they contain words of wisdom, but not when it comes to how to perform Salaah for example.
For exampel we have Hadith in SUNNI books against circumcision, so a Sunni can be against circumcision, but a Shia cant since Shia books are 100% pro-circumcision.
So a Sunni can follow the truth or follow falsehood, but other sects are based on falsehood at their core.
The Sunnis were infiltrated by Sufis/Shias/Yahoodis and Majoos, but the real original Sunnis are those who follow the Sunnah of the prophet himself which is the Sunna of Allah and the Sunnah of the Prophet does NOT contradict the Quran, so thats the type of Sunni I am. Im a Sunni who follows the SUNNAH of the Prophet and Allah, not the Sunnah/tradition of the Abbasid kings, Umayyad kings, Sufi mystics, Persians, Pakistanis, Arabs etc.
Sunnah means tradition, we must follow the original tradition of the Prophet, not just any tradition.
And for your other questions i have to reflect upon them like you suggested and i will try to understand more then we will talk again inschalah brother.
@@TheStranger0509brother, you are still not thinking! Does 'Sunnism' have anything to do with the Islam which was ordained to Adam, Noah, Lot, Ibraheem, Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad (peace on them)???
Did Moses, Ibraheem, and Jesus preace 'Sunni' islam to their people?? Please reflect on the following verses my brother:
"" So direct your face [i.e., self] toward THE RELIGION (liddeeni) inclining to truth. [Adhere to] the fiṭrah of Allāh upon which He has created [all] people. No change should there be in the creation of Allāh. That is the CORRECT RELIGION (addeenu alqayyimu) , but most of the people do not know."" {30:30}
The verse continues...
""[Adhere to it], turning in repentance to Him, and fear Him and establish prayer and DO NOT BE OF THOSE WHO ASSOCIATE OTHERS WITH ALLAH (wala takoonoo minalmushrikeen)."" {30:31}
Look at what it says straight after this:
"" [Or] OF THOSE WHO HAVE DIVIDED THEIR RELIGION AND BECOME SECTS (Mina allatheena farraqoo deenahum wakanoo shiya'an), every faction rejoicing in what it has. "" {30:32}
Notice it says "[or]" in the translation above but it DOES NOT say that in the verse! These sneeky bastards try to interpolate words into the Qur'an!! The verse says "THOSE WHO" (minalladheena) which is joined to the verse just before it. Therefore, THOSE WHO divide their religion abd become sects (sunni / shia / ibadi) are of the MUSHRIKS!!!!
Please refelect upon these verses and think TWICE about calling yourself a 'Sunni' my brother.
Do Keto Diet With Good Calories This Is Good For You
The muslim lantern ate you in the live debate that you guys did lol
We obey Allah through the Quran and we obey the Prophet PBUH through the narrated authentic hadiths that were collected by the imams and scholars, if we didn't read the hadiths we wouldn't know how to pray !, it's is not in the Quran for how to pray a salat, brother open your mind because for becoming a Muslim you must accept hadiths (which are the authentic ones) because these are sayings and orders of our beloved Prophet Muhammad PBUH
Sunnah teached us how to pray.
here he answered this question in a debate
czcams.com/video/N1HP8ZnQDtQ/video.html
Also I pray like most Muslim do today cuz it is traditional it is passed down through family
Who's sunnah?
@@shajonpaithalmala he means hadith books
@@yahia1000 You should pray salah properly and not just follow majority.
@@riaz694 yea I was born a Muslim of ahl alsunni and rejecting hadith makes more sense
I DARE YOU TO OBEY SHEIKH UTHMAN OR MUHAMMAD HIJAB OR ALI DAWAH
Obey??? Why would he want to obey them ? Did u mean debate?
You mean debate?
What a genius, right! you’re just a guy that discovered for “himself” few hadith errors not for the world! There’s people who dedicate their hearts, sweat, tears, blood and life to the religion and not to their desires or blindly following/accepting ahadith. These people exist and if you were true in your pursuit you would seek them and document your journey, instead of standing on this illusional pedestal of yours
if there would be only 1 error in the quran, would it be from god? no. so why is errors in the hadith then not enough to you to say this is nonsense and we dont need it
Sorry bro… Bukhari didn’t make these Hadith up he collected them he was hadith collector and he’s not the only one. There are older collections.
some hadith's couldve been misattributed to Muhammad, similarly how the Injeel was corrupted, people thought Isa said that he was a God, but Isa never said that, which can be the same for hadith, i take a more careful stance on hadith but i dont reject it
@@Modelta why would it??? God made a promise to preserve this religion. Is your lack of faith in God preventing you from taking hadith?? Why do you think we have grades in hadith?? So people don’t misattribute anything to prophet Muhammad ﷺ
Allah did make a promise to preserve Islam but he never commanded us to follow hadith, i dont outright reject hadith but try to limit it and only follow if it fits all of the criteria@@mr.frizzyizz5058
@@Buzz727 Muhammad was alive when the Quran was sent down, while hadith was written down 200 years after Muhammad, human memory is weak and 200 years was around 4-7 generations of people.
Hadith collection, hadith 'science' It's a complete farce!!!
Bukhari was the biggest hadith rejector 🤣 From 600,000 collected ahadith, he only kept 7563 of them. (2000+ are repetitions 🤦♂️)
I asked ChatGPT what that is in percentage terms and this was the answer: (You can all check yourselves if you want!)
"Therefore, the percentage of ahadith that you threw out is 98.7395%. That means you only kept 1.2605% of the ahadith that you collected. That’s a very small fraction!" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤦♂️
Very small fraction indeed! The hadith rejection is strong with these guys!! Thanks for the confirmation ChatGPT!
So Bukhari himself rejected almost 99% of hadiths! Making him and his followers the biggest hadith rejectors on this planet!
Also, Qur'an alone submitters are not actually hadith rejectors because we don't acknowledge them to be anything in the first place! Just erroneous conjecture and fabrications.
Sooooo the biggest hadith rejectors are in fact the sectarians and their super scholar, Bukhari! 🤦♂️
Just think about that guys! Think about how ridiculous this is. 1% from 600,000 collected ahadith with a rejection rate of 99% with 2000+ of the 1% ahadiths being duplicates just to pad up the volume! Then on top of that hadiths in so called sahih book are then classified strong to weak! This garbage is from the messenger??? They must be joking!
Don't ever let any mushriks tell you guys hadith came from the messenger or even worse is revelation equal to ayahs of Qur'an. They know not what they speak!
Qur'an was NEVER transmitted like this thank God and companions had absolutely nothing to do with this forgery, this book of fantasies and nonsense tales known as hadith. Bukari is the Shakespeare of the 'Islamic' sectarian world!
Were you ever diagnosed with a mental illness or psychological condition growing up?
Are you insluting him or seriously asking
Did your mother ever teach you respect growing up?
decievers who can't respect Allah's Ayaat(for example, half quoting 59:7, not understanding so many verses where Quran is called complete, not avoiding fallacies of older people, quoting hadith contradictory to the Quran), how do you expect them to respect us mere mortals?@@Quran_Alone_Dawah
I'm sure you were diagnosed with both so that might be a reason why you're asking.
Childish, you sectarians cannot respond without attacking someone.
Were you?
Why did every single muslim obey the sunnah until the quranist came out 1400 years later
Caliph Umar banned the hadith books and had them burned! lmao shows how much you even know of Islamic history
Are you a hadith/sunnah rejector?
No! we are Bullshit / nonsense rejectors! Pretty much what the hadith literature is 😊
@@negeto2460 what?
@@negeto2460 Auoodhubillah!
You're sick individuals
Hadith is sickening. We reject pagan filth.
well instead of criticizing individuals, maybe read the texts themselves and tell us your views.@@m.a1153
Muhammad. You should be thankful to the islamophobia because it is through them that you are obligatory lead to check your own sources and ponder over everything you believed blindly before they point them out publicly!
Those in church wouldn’t even know these things because they believe that verses like like
Quran 5:51) will never exist in a religious book because they hand nothing equally to their book!
It is unbelievable that
5:51 verse can exist,,these are Thor love like because you can easily full
Them that,
Such verse don’t exist in the Quran about Jew and Christian!
But the islamophob are those to went through your sources and huge you to go in their sources as well and bring it out !
You don’t like them
Because they own all your book but you are afraid to own their books because you believe you already know it all!
Foolish is the one who believe he already know!
They will bring it to you as helper not ennemy!
The ennemy is the one within who hide those things and embellished them so you don’t recognize them!
They might be jobless, titless
lol you can't fool him, an arabic speaker with mistranslations of Quran 5:51.
AWLIYA means PROTECTORS/GUARDIANS not friends.
@@asr2009 someone who protect you cannot be your ennemi
Someone who is your guardian, like a bodyguard cannot kill you unless you are threaten him badly poorly and miserably.. like Muslim do to Christian in Egypt Syria Yemen pakistan!
@@asr2009
someone who protect you cannot be your ennemi
Someone who is your guardian, like a bodyguard cannot kill you unless you are threaten him badly poorly and miserably.. like Muslim do to Christian in Egypt Syria Yemen pakistan!
@@asr2009 someone who protect you care about you,
Someone who guard your and family
Care about you safety
A friend is some who care protect and guard you as well!
It is the same thing
@@asr2009 haha 😂 are you saying that your neighbor who protect you but is not Muslims is not your friend in disguise??
What a blind men
You mother is your gardien and protector but not your friend also??
This guy's lost may Allah SWT guide him. He claims to believe in the Qur'an. How did he come to know about the Qur'an existence ?
It was revealed 1400 years ago. Clearly people told people who told people who told others until it came to him that something is called the Qur'an.
So already you believe what other people have said but you don't believe in ahadith.
Quran is a wing and ahadith is a wing. A bird flys with both wings.
You are comparing the book of Bukhari with the book of GOD
As if they are two wings which means they are equal in importance
May GOD pardon your shirk if you go back on what you said
Yeah reject the Hadiths😂 then how can you pray the Salah? Does Quran says how many rakah is fajar?
Allah clearly says in the Quran "atiullah ua rasulallah" aka Obey Allah Obey the messenger and how can we Obey messenger? By Hadiths right 👍.
You have alot to learn! If OBEY Allah AND OBEY the Messenger are referencing 2 sources of authority, then how would you interpret the following verses from the Qur'an:
- War from Allah AND His Messenger {2:279 & 5:33}
- emigrant to Allah AND His Messenger {4:100}
- spoils for Allah AND His Messenger {8:1}
- those who lied to Allah AND His Messenger {9:90}
- respond to Allah AND His Messenger {8:24}
- do not betray Allah AND His Messenger {8:27}
- help Allah AND His Messenger {59:8}
Are these verses above referring to TWO seperate wars? TWO seperate emigrants? TWO seperate spoils? TWO seperate lies? TWO seperate responses? TWO seperate betrayals?? The list goes on...
At the time of revelation, how EXACTLY did the people of Muhammad (a.s) obey Allah in the first place? How did they obtain the Qur'an in order to obey Allah? Was the Qur'an available through anyone else other the Messenger?? Then how can obey Allah and His Messenger mean TWO seperate obediences when the Qur'an was ONLY OBTAINABLE via the Messenger?
Are you saying that the Quran is incomplete? Obey Allah and OBEY the messenger , you ask how? You Obey Allah by obeying his message which is the Quran brought to you by the messenger. Also, it is stated to OBEY not FOLLOW. Obeying the messenger means you obey the message the messenger is providing you from the source. Our creator. The only hadith you need is Allah's hadith. Not bukharis hadith or your hadith or my hadith. God bless.
@@e-leven7407 why I would say it? I mean Quran give orders and messenger of Allah shows how to full fill the task (order). Quran says to pray, but how to pray? For that we need to go to Rasulallah.
Have a good day and check my video
@@negeto2460 It means first Obey Allah by knowing his commandments and second Obey messenger by knowing how to do (full fill) those commandments.
@@FuzioEsitamado u still hold the view that 'Obey Allah AND Obey the Messenger' are 2 SEPERATE obediences??? Then could you please explain me the following verses:
- War from Allah AND His Messenger {2:279 & 5:33}
- emigrant to Allah AND His Messenger {4:100}
- spoils for Allah AND His Messenger {8:1}
- those who lied to Allah AND His Messenger {9:90}
- respond to Allah AND His Messenger {8:24}
- do not betray Allah AND His Messenger {8:27}
- help Allah AND His Messenger {59:8}
Are these verses above referring to TWO seperate wars? TWO seperate emigrants? TWO seperate spoils? TWO seperate lies? TWO seperate responses? TWO seperate betrayals?? The list goes on...
At the time of revelation, how EXACTLY did the people of Muhammad (a.s) obey Allah in the first place? How did they obtain the Qur'an in order to obey Allah? Was the Qur'an available through anyone else other the Messenger?? Then how can obey Allah and His Messenger mean TWO seperate obediences when the Qur'an was ONLY OBTAINABLE via the Messenger?
Jew
He is not a jew
He is a Quranist and I wonder how they pray?
Abraham is the grandfather of the Jew, so he is descendants of Abraham not you!
Muhammad is not where to be the descendants of the Jew, ismaél is the son of Abraham the patriarch of Jew!
Yes he is Jew
@@abdemouaouia8396 here he answered this question in a debate
czcams.com/video/N1HP8ZnQDtQ/video.html
Also I pray like most Muslim do today cuz it is traditional it is passed down through family
@@cocoalfaridah5831 glad you admit it
Subhanallah this man has no wisdom.
he used so many verses of the quran to back up his statements. and then you he has no wisdom. do you even realise what you say?
@@Biekoeif we can only refer to the Quran by not just bring down the Quran why a messenger? You can’t answer this logically.
@@hamedizzy5137 to deliver the message and to be a clear warner. [5:99] The sole duty of the messenger is to deliver the message, and GOD knows everything you declare and everything you conceal.
ur question is idiotic.
@@Biekoe Man U just don’t get it. If we didn’t need explanations and elaborations there would be no need for a prophet. The only way to follow Allah swt commands to his up most pleasure is to follow the prophets sunna for is compliments what Allah swt asks from us. Too much ignorance from hadeeth rejectors so you follow this guy but not your prophets words???
@@hamedizzy5137 the quran itself is the explanation. It explains how we should live as muslim. Only mushriks associste other things to god and use other than sources than god for religion.
About the camel urine- i was in this one sunni group where they were justifying the use of urine by hindus and showed me this camel urine hadith. Long story short i just asked them " Do you drink camel urine as a practice " And i was kicked out of the group. 😂😂😂. A madina uni student was in that group as well who certified the hadith as sahih