Teachers of Hadith removed independent reasoning. You can see the decline in the umma as hadith become more and more refined. If Allah wanted us to have no will, he would have made us like the angels.
Farid previously left a comment wishing to engage with you. He is one of the few Sunnis who is capable of being civil, and dare I say, even nice. Definitely invite him to your channel for a discussion.
You don't know him well then, He makes videos about deviants And tries to misrepresent Quranites, And he doesn't respond always, He can't even give 4 witnesses For any of the Hadith they have. God knows better what evil he hides, I have witnessed lots of sunni evils, Even one who seems to listen a lot And who seems to be closest friend Can anytime betray if he is a sunnite And mock and spread the privacies, While even worst of the Quranites Didn't mock personal life or expose, I better have Qurani enemies Than to have sunni friends. Tho better to have Quraniy friends ofc.
No he isn't actually civil. He made edited videos against Mufti abu layth and lied about him when mufti defended the prophet's honor by rejecting the nonsensical hadiths
@cocoalfaridah5831 No, actually, Farid is a chill guy and generally respectful. I interacted with him on his livestream chat and he doesn't get nasty like most Sunnis. A conversation with him would be interesting.
Mashallah brother. You are so humble, patient and loving with your message. The way you elevate Quran to where it needs to be is unlike anything I’ve seen in a long time. May Allah reward you for your efforts
14:27 “God keeps firm those who believe, with the firm word” In this verse God tells us that he grounds the man with the firm word, so the truth is what strengthens your position… But the whole science of hadith is based on the exact opposite principle of the man is the one who grounds and gives legitimacy to the word
Omg 😂 I laughed so hard how you saying about reviewing the Quran 🤣🤣 anyways amazing work again agree with 100 % of what you saying and everything makes sense 👍🏽
Ty, brother. I recently reverted as an American atheist. I do believe much of the prophet's pbuh words/lifestyle called sunnah is admirable and worthy of consideration. But I struggle with hadith so much
May Allah bless you brother. Shaitan mixes truth with falsehood. There are for sure good hadiths which might be true. But only the Qur'an is absolute truth.
Alhamdulillah. But I suggest you do not learn from this guy, what he believed is from a false sect in Islamic view. Someone who rejects what Rasulullah did, said, and ordered, is kafir (non-believer). Because the hadits are what Rasulullah did, said, and ordered, that written and memorized. It is not for you as a revert, it is an advance knowledge. I think you do not need to learn that for now.
@@hotaryuzaki Brother Muhammad is not any s ect. Your hadiths are not from the prophet but rather falsehoods attributed to the prophet. That is why we are defending the prophet from you.
@@hotaryuzaki why you are tying to make historical claims your idol. just accept they contain good things but also false things legends and lies. don't you see accepting hadith ass a whole damagig credibility of islam. i born muslim was almost out of religion because of fairy tale collection of hadith. now when i see a hadith i do this does it contradict quran? does it add things to quran? does it contaradict common sense? if yes i reject it. if no i say MAY BE IT IS CORRECT but never 100% noone can call me "kafir" "not muslim" because of this sincere attempt to reach truth.
Here are some key verses in the Quran that condemn usury/interest (riba): "O you who have believed, fear Allah and give up what remains [due to you] of interest, if you should be believers." (Quran 2:278) "And if you do not, then be informed of a war [against you] from Allah and His Messenger. But if you repent, you may have your principal - [thus] you do no wrong, nor are you wronged." (Quran 2:279) "Allah destroys interest and gives increase for charities. And Allah does not like every sinning disbeliever." (Quran 2:276) "O you who have believed, do not consume usury, doubled and multiplied, but fear Allah that you may be successful." (Quran 3:130) "And [for] their taking of usury while they had been forbidden from it, and their consuming of the people's wealth unjustly. We have prepared for the disbelievers among them a painful punishment." (Quran 4:161) "That is because they say, "Trade is [just] like interest." But Allah has permitted trade and has forbidden interest." (Quran 2:275) These verses establish a clear prohibition on riba, usually interpreted as any kind of interest or usury, in Islam. They emphasize that it is a major sin and warn of punishment in the hereafter for those who engage in the practice. The verses also contrast riba with charitable giving and ethical trade/commerce. Interest is HARAM and must be avoided at all costs, Interest is a scam and a huge tool of the satanic jewish bankers
@@exincom4729 I aggree, if you havent already, please read Quran yourself at least once my friend, the you will see this is actually the religion of Peace in deed. Peace on you 🫶
Keep going, your belief is logic-based. There are many people who support you. May your heart never tighten when those who believe in baseless chain-narrations call you a Kaffir. God will judge all of our beliefs on the day of Judgement, bi idni Allah. We love you.
Can someone please tell me how the steps of prayer is for him? Because he was sayi g like he we do rukuu and postures, so it means he has a different style? Where can i fi d rhis video? Im really curious to know? Thanks!!
I’m glad i came across this video. I love learning about Islam through Quranists because they make the most sense. Sunni and Shia Muslims don’t understand how bad their Hadiths make Islam look. There are a lot of questionable things in those Hadiths.
Great point about time. If the Prophet lived today, the sunnah would change. Therefore it isn't meant to be a timeless teaching applied to modern times. Only the Qur'an is timeless.
@@restlessnative3818 if the prophet lived today, he wouldn’t be the prophet, you know that right? Everything happened in its prescribed time and Allah in his infinite wisdom choose for muhammed SAW to be born at that time and have those life experience. So yes, ifs and buts open the doors to shaytan. I’m not here to change your mind, we’re all free to believe what we want but what I do have a problem with are silly arguments and narrative changes of things that will never happen. What does the prophet being born in this generation have to do with his sunnah? EVEN IF he lived today, thousands of years down the line, his followers would adhere to today’s customs because it would be his sunnah. But there’s no point debating something that’ll never happen anyway
@@Colourcoateddiaries - It isn't a debate. It's a fact that You yourself just agreed with. Moreover, You claim to have a problem with "silly arguments and narrative of things that will never happen." YET you uphold garbage books that are Filled with exactly that. Silly arguments/ narrations and things that will Never happen.
Brother Muhammad, thank you so much for taking your time to make this video. I, myself, am on a journey to find the truest Islam which is nearly impossible to find when Muslims nowadays shove the Hadiths down our throat on anything. How to stand, how to sit how to do whatever. This lost the true meaning essence of the Deen. I simply ask a question to Brother Fareed on one of his CZcams video where he presented Sheikh Al Albani, I asked, “Salam brother Farid and other brothers and sisters, No doubt Sheikh Albani put much efforts on the matter of Hadiths I truly respect him, but I have some questions, so my question is No one ever grade the Hadiths before him? Did Imam Bukhari, Imam Muslim, Imam Ahmed etc did not grade the Hadiths in their own books? Why exactly Sheikh Albani felt the need to work on Hadiths? Why no one else worked on Hadiths in the past 1200 years or so why only a sheikh who was born in early 1900s work on Hadith and no one else before him? This seems like a huge jump from the time periods of those 7 authentic books to Sheikh Albani. This is where I am confused. Hope someone can help.” And bro Fareed’s reply was just “ Hadiths we’re always graded. Albani didn’t bring anything new. He simply revived the science, he didn’t create it.” My further Question is then why majority or maybe some Bukhari Hadith says graded by Albani? 🤷♀️ if Sunnis believe in graded by Albani Hadiths then sir bukhari is nullified! Then Bukhari is not 100% authentic. The science of Hadith is so bogus that no one can verify the truth like A said to B or C heard from D, the chains and then contexts Hadith people only play with these things they do not have any straight answers that’s is why I stick to the Quran which is the truth no one can deny and as you said at the end Quran is 100% sahih. Much respect and love 💕 from this sister JazakAllah khair
This video is very interesting. because he literally tell us to think critical and reasonable. He not did not tell hadist because he wanna us think with sense and logic. Good video Love from Indonesia 🙏
I'm a believer in the Qur'an and reject the fabricated hadith sects. I'm living in Sweden and in a difficult economic situation with my welfare declined, in debt, rent due, forced to apply for jobs that don't allow me to make Salah and to sell alcohol etc. Can you hire me for a righteous job in Canada? I rather even scrub toilets for the believers with a thootbrush fulltime with minimum wage rather than being stuck in this situation or get hired by the disbelievers. I'm willing to relocate.
conservatism/traditionalism/fear of change is a huge problem in humans, the ottomans fell because they didnt modernize, most muslims stick to their beliefs no matter what (scholar 500 years ago said A to muslim, muslim teaches it to child, the list goes on and the muslim almost never thinks about B) , it takes a lot for a muslim to reject hadith, while for a christian, to turn to sunnism and then to reject hadith, is an easier road, because they do not have any beliefs set in their brain since the start, i hope the ummah can find the truth in the era of misinformation.
you are right about the freedom of speech - I don't mind the Sunnis insulting and people having discussions but when people are trolling or posting none sense - I will leave it to your judgment.
@@MuhammadfromGOD i prohibit people speaking when they are outright insulting, mocking others, but when theyre a bit more openminded and try to debate, i let them speak
How can you come and talk about the history of the Ottoman , talking nonsence , they didnt fell because they were didnt modernize , they fell because they got betrayed by the people they were protecting . You can go believe you Zionist history , truth is far beyond what you think .
@@MuhammadfromGODI have a question. Not a Muslim btw. Regards to being _intoxicated_ in Quran when coming to prayer and chances of one bumbling or mumbling gibberish during prayer isn't permitted, my question is, is the meaning of _intoxicated_ means currently not being in sound mind or meaning being high as fuch on substances?
As for fasting brother , how would you explain the fasting of mariam , when Allah said clearly to her eat and drink . Bro to underatand better quran , you have to divorce completely the tradition and start from scratch , words like salah , Zakah , Sawm , Hajj is heavily corrupted . I will go as far even Nissa doesn't mean Women ..i know it's hard to swallow , but you will get there inshallah . I highly recommend to read / watch the links i habe sent you .
Salamualaykum brother, I love you for the sake of Allah and respect you a lot. However I have a couple of questions, I understand that many of the Hadiths are applicable at the time, but the example that you gave with the mishwak and eating with your right hand, it's not as if the sunnah is to eat with the right hand therefore abandon utensils, but to use it when eating, when using a utensil or drinking water, with the mishwak, it's an interesting point that you brought up but the truth is it's extremely convenient compared to a tooth brush + tooth paste + water, etc. From the way that I have learned the sunnah, it's not so much as perfectly applying everything like abandoning utensils to eat with right hand, but to take the concepts and lessons and apply them to today. As for the prayer, I understand what you are saying with the structure in the religion, but from the way that I see it is the consistent structure of the prayer is what unites us all, when I go to a masjid in a different country and pray, I should know whats going on and whats happening, not to mention that the Prophet (PBUH) said to pray how we see him pray. I would love to see a debate between you and Farid as I love both of you for the sake of Allah. Peace be upon you.
@@monaattiah3976 he takes from Surat al Isra, chapter 17 verse 78, and 110 to make the argument that the in verse 78 that's talking about maghrib, isha, and fajr only, and that asr and thuhr don't actually exist, and that 110 says don't be too loud in your 'salatika' he interprets this as prayer, while the sunni interpretation is that salat used to be used for dua before islam, so when Allah used that word, He was using it in context with the beginning of the verse that was talking about dua to Allah. He also says that there isn't any structure to prayer, that it involves the 3 movements, standing, bowing, and prostrating, but anyone can do them in any order they want, and that raka's don't really exist, his argument is that structure to religion is bad, which in some cases is true, but in this case prayer and the direction of it need to be a consistent thing with all muslims so that I can go pray with muslims in australia, thailand, japan, russia, or USA, if we all prayed differently, theres no unity in the prayer. czcams.com/video/KF_dg1PBgMQ/video.html the video i linked is the video where he speaks about this
we say that because this was the conversation between him and God during the isra' and ma'raj, also angels are the ones that carry the salam, the prophet can't hear anything, they simply bring them salam to his grave while he is dead@@AgustusAtrahasis
God states in the Quran that he does the explaining and no one else should even attempt to do so. "Do not move your tongue to hasten it. It is we who will collect it into Quran. Once we recite it, you shall follow such a Quran. Then it is we who will explain it" Nobody can intercede for you or save you … only god can. In terms of understanding the Quran.. God states that if it doesn't make sense give it time and he will show it to you in time... make dua brother.
I have so many questions after hearing that the quran ist enough...how do you even know the Quranic order or what the quran is? And how do you verify your position what the mushaf is? How do you know what naskh wa mansukh is? How do you know the Asbabul-nuzul? How do you know the character of the Prophet(s)? How do you know the Sira of prophet Mohammed? How do you understand fiqh? How do you understand the law and their usage in a state? Which school of 'aqida should I follow? Which school of fiqh schould I follow? Are their even schools and respected scholars and if so why schould someone believe them, because they would be a source of a tradition in themselfs? Those are some questions that came directly into my mind, maybe someone can answer them :)
I love your content man but I am just a little bit curious. I’ve seen you quote the Bible before in one of your reels and my question is how different the Bible authenticity would be from the Hadith. Supposedly you want to learn about prophet Jesus pbuh as a Muslim. The book you would refer to is the Quran. Why?, because the Bible contradicts the Quran and is not historically a reliable source ( due to different translations and corruptions ). Despite the Bible mentioning Good words from the prophet Jesus, we still cannot be 100% certain it is accurate as Muslims due to the fact the prophet Jesus is represented as biblical Jesus which contradicts the Quran. Thus as Muslims we should seek the Quran to learn about our prophet Muhammad pbuh instead of Hadith wether the Hadith mentions good or bad statements of our prophet. Moreover The prophet mentioned in the Hadith is a political and contradictory figure and therefore reading the Hadith to gain greater insight of our prophet Muhammad pbuh is just as reading the Bible to learn about prophet Jesus. Do forgive me for my ignorance and correct me if I am wrong brother
The ones who actually followed The messener pbuh? On whom the quran was revealed ? Or am I following an 'other thing' , stick to the basics may Allah guide ME and YOU and ALL of US Amien
The core problem at the center of hadiths is whether it's necessary or not, nothing guarantees any of it was actually said by the prophet. The sunnis always go into the debate with the assumption that everything said in it was actually said because Bukhari thinks so And yes I know about the science of Hadith. It doesn't guarantee anything. Modern courts today wouldn't accept it, they want the first degree testimony not 2nd hand let alone 5th to 8th hand which is what hadiths are
Because they wrote down all of it that was revealed on leafs, cows, pieces of sheet, etc and all of it was verified to the letter in the lifetime of the prophet, unlike hadiths which were never instructed to be written down or collected @@samhangster
I don't think anyone said you have to eat with hands, are some Muslims saying this is a must?? I don't think vast majority of Muslims think that at all. I never heard that.
Eating with your hands is a sunnah, this guy is making it seem like it’s a must and that Sunnis are barbaric for not using utensils. It’s a sunnah so you can choose to do it or not. Even to this day in 2024, there are cultures and non-Muslim people all over the world that eat with with their hands btw
The wisdom is that even halal things can be harmful somewhat like in surah sad around 28-35 when Solomon got distracted by horse riding which is halal and forgot prayer. Even we fast from food and sex because it’s down bad and can distract you from remembering god. So all these halal things can be problematic so music is the same way. So hilarious if they say music haram, talking with others, sex, food, sports. All these can be haram 😂 because there overstimulation and it won’t help much having strong rememberance in god
@@moneyheist_- learn Arabic or translate. If you're blind ask someone trust worthy to read for you etc. That's logic I just presented to you, first follow what's in the Quran then go on to Hadith and you'll know that Quran is complete. I would suggest you should learn Arabic .
@@HaiderAli-ri1gb learning Arabic is very hard. And most Quranic translations don't translate the Quran are literal as possible. Even naive Arabic speakers don't understand the Quran, cause there is some gibberish in it, for example, do you understand what "كۤهیعۤصۤ" means?
The prayer is clear once you bring out the English and Arabic dictionary. It’s Sunnis who force there 5 prayer that creates issues and make Quran alone people confused. Very clear that it’s Fajr, sunsent and night
The 5 daily prayers are detailed in the Quran. 30:17: So glorify Allah in the evening and in the morning 30:18: all praise is for Him in the heavens and the earth-as well as in the afternoon, and at noon. 17:79: And rise at part of the night, offering additional prayers, so your Lord may raise you to a station of praise.
I've read his book. It makes a lot of reasonable points, issues probably not thought of by many, but I did not see any critical ones. And of course it only presents one side, i.e. does not point to the weaknesses.
23:50 I may be wrong here but I actually think that this verse is prohibiting *nal s*x, I was thinking about this other day, the verse before is talking about approaching your wives during nights in Ramadhan. I dont think that God would uses vulgar language thats why that Door analogy, because it always sounded outta context to me But I may be wrong as I never heard of anyone saying something like it before.
I think that they invented that suposed arab costume Just because they could not understand the Verses. It happens a Lot actually. And I think that's good in some sort of way, because, If It was posssible to change the Qur'an to fit their narrative they would have done, which proves that they Qur'an was not changed, otherwise they would have to fabricate all of this hadiths.😊
Islam isn't the Religion of hypocrite mushriks called sunnis and shias who worship mullas blindly, Islam is the religion chosen for us by God/ 5:3, 3:85, 22:78. And Prophet followed in vision and those who follow him/ 12:108, Quran is the vision/ 6:104, so we (Quran alone adherents) follow the Prophet and his companions, not sunnis who merely follow fabrications which have nothing with the Prophet and his companions or any Muslims.
I understand where you are coming from, but I'd say there are still some hadith's that are at the very least good to know and keep in mind. It's better when rituals are structured so there's no confusion about it. It's important to stay away from creating sects. What better way is there to settle on how these rituals should be done other than looking at how the prophet Muhammad saw did it? He is the best follower of the revelations.
people focus on the wrong things most of the time and I believe it’s party due to human nature, propensity towards herd mentality and garden variety incompetence. Most people they do NOT want to figure things out on their own but rather follow popular opinion, culture, traditions laid out by parents, peers, sheikh/priest/rabbi. Most people just don’t want to, own their own will, do the due diligence. Now when someone who thinks outside of these norms bring arguments against the popular narrative, people respond to it with either mockery or by fear. Being averse to something is a primal fear response and very very common. I left the religion Islam because there’s no religion called Islam as gods system in the Quran. Islam is a state of a person’s being and not a religion and it takes a life time of dedication, discipline and toil to reach that state and that much is very clear from the quranic guidance. Muhammad has no sunnah and his mission was not to “sunnah” people but to write down the revelation and bring that revelation to his community, which they clearly rejected. His mission was to bani Israel which makes sense because bani Israel is mentioned so many times in the Quran and muss is reference so much. Nowhere in the quran is he tasked with converting people to a new religion called Islam and contrary to popular belief the quran says had Muhammad tried to bring in a system outside from what he was mandated, his life vein would have been severed and he would be subjected to double the punishment. the Quran asks the reader several times in different ways, when will you think? When will you ponder? When will you leave the practices of your forefathers and approach this Quran trying to build an authentic connection with gos. Unfortunately people just don’t do it. I’m very content with the Quran, I read the Hadith and it’s so poorly written and an insult to human intelligence. Islam the religion never changed my life but the Quran did. There’s no praying to god, no going to a hajj, which imo is a scam to flees people off their hard earned money by the Saudi demonic system while making you worship stones, fasting is much more than a no drink no food fast, and giving charity is something you do during this month called Ramadan. I could go on and on but this much is enough. all praise to god, lord of all beings.
Mashallah, but i disagree on a couple of points some you mention elsewhere: Pork is haram because God ordains it (there are bad components in it but it’s haram because God has decreed such). Drink is not haram but a good provision for those who reason, meaning do it on occasion and not in excess for it will invalidate your prayer (16:67 and other); if you claim it’s haram be your own witness against yourself because most that say it’s haram drink. And for the record, I don’t drink at all by choice. Jesus will return (4:159) for he has yet to die. Now that you cannot refute. There is only one messiah Jesus pbh.
I have not said to them other than what You commanded me to say, that: 'You shall worship God, my Lord and your Lord.' I was witness over them for as long as I was among them. When You took me back, You were the Watcher over them. You are Witness over all things. 5:117 From this verse it is clear that Jesus was only a witness to the people when he was with them and when he was taken by God he was no longer a witness and God was the witness over the people. If Jesus was coming back he would have been a witness among the people twice. A particularly important observation is found in the words "when You took me back" which were spoken by Jesus (5:117). Those words are in the past tense. Hence, when Jesus spoke those words it was after God raised him unto Him. Jesus was no longer on earth when he spoke those words, but somewhere in God's Kingdom God said, "O Jesus, I am taking you back, raising you to Me and cleansing you of those who disbelieved." 3:55 Here in this verse again the same words are used "I am taking you back" supporting 5:117
5:75: The Messiah, the son of Mary, was nothing but a messenger. Messengers have passed away before him. His mother was a woman of truth. They both ate food. See how We make the signs clear to them, yet see how they are deluded. 3:144: And Muhammad is only a messenger. Messengers have passed away before him. So, if he dies or is killed, will you turn on your heels will not harm God and God will reward the thankful.
@@mustaphahaidar1321the Quran is incredibly precise in the choice of words. Jesus is always referred to in the past tense (was a Messenger). Trying to explain sentence structure and syntax to people who need hadith for micromanagement has been incredibly difficult.
@@comert1977 they ask you about gambling and intoxicants (not even wine), say in them are benefits for the people but also sin. And the sin outweigh the benefits. So will you not reason?! There are NO BENEFITS in idolatry. If this Book would say what you and most of the so called born “Muslims” say repeating what you found your fathers saying but not actually following, I would be disappointed for life as it wouldn’t be a Revelation from the Lord of the Worlds. But since it is a revelation from the Lord of the Worlds, it says it JUST LIKE IT IS SUBHANALLAH! Fornication is also from the play hand of the Shaytan…. Does that mean all sex is outlawed?! So will you not then reason?!?!??
@@QuranforTheWest from what i understand i believe alcohol is not haram but it contains sin. The sin is potential, occurring while under influence and varies in degree.
to be fair they did have utensils to eat back then too lol’ henxe why some hadiths mentioned its haram to have golden spoons etc the reason u eat with ur hand is for health benefits.
They did not have ustensile 🥄 That is why they hate with finger all the times few people hade them only the wealthy like the king and Jews and Christian.. They did not have chairs only few people the elite and Jew That is why Muslims sit in the floors while the imam sit in the chair ., In Jew and Christian and the elite of the time use the stool and the elite used the high chair., thst is the reason Jew and Christian sit in chair in their church and synagogue.. And Muhammad Promised them these thing in heaven.. Ustensile in gold and silver Sofa, things like this..
Mohammad I struggled to listen to you because of your cringe comedy sketches but in this video you have my ear and attention. Although I am not agreeing with you 100% I do see where you are coming from and understand your frustration. I am starting to agree with you on many things. barak allah feek
It is Muslim people with try to save their own honor who are fighting the Hadith. It is not about religion or Muhammad but about their own personal ego and honor… For 1400 years everything was fine .. until the kufar’shake it up for them.. Now they are seeing what the kufar’s saw and rejected thé aslim taslam religion
we battle hadith for Allah and the ummah, we have no reason to lie or try to be selfish, why waste time on research, debates just for ego? its better and easier to start bodybuilding, inject huge amounts of trenbolone and other narcotics and show off your muscles, the ego will be way larger
@@Modeltaok i understand! Allah used the kufar’s to reaveal the truth to you Muslims because no Muslims will dare to bring those this up without being chopped up.., ostracized but Muslims themselves., He use the kufar’s to do the work you dare not to do..
@@cocoalfaridah5831 could you elaborate? what kufars and how did they reveal the truth, though the part of being chopped up is sadly true, though i dont fear anything except Allah.
@@Modelta your god Allah used his Ennemis the kufar’s by bringing things up for you to see what you are following.. He used his Ennemi for you…☺️ If you did it yourself they will chops your head or get kicked out from your community ans ostracized but your own ummah.. Look at what this guy going through with his own people .. He used us the kufar’s to expose
@@mgXL7 by definition if you follow someone, you do what they do and do and say what they say. You follow their teachings and as we know all of the prophets (PBUH) teachings are in the hadith.
You are typical example of Google seikh guy. We follow ulama. You follow google and yourself. And yourself brought you to thousands mistake or should I call them lies. Ulama said Bukhari didnt memorize 600 000 hadeeth. Those where hadeeth, saying of sahaba, fatwas, different chains of narration. One hadeeth can have many chains. It is not different hadeeth. It is just different chain. Are you lying to your followers or you are ignorant about these facts about the myth of 600K hadeeth of Bukhari?
To reject them all is as wrong as to believing in them all in my humble oppinion, i realy try to understand the quran only and still trying to make it make sense because there are so many fabricated and disgusting and evil hadith out there that are clearly from satan and his followers and not from our beloved prophet muhammad, and it would be so easy to follow only Quran and to just leave all the hadith but i just cant believe that the Prophet muhammad never said one word of wisdom or anything beneficial to his followers outside of Quran that maybe was written down by his followers for us to benefit from them , it just makes no sense, for me its i reject every hadith that contradicts quran even in the slightest way no matter how "sahih" it is , but hadith that are in line with Quran and not contradicting the quran in any way i didnt see a reason to reject them, actually everyone who is listening to for example this Brother Muhammad from God and taking from what he says is following his " Hadith" because Hadith simply is someones talk, statement or story , so to reject prophet Muhammads Hadith but taking anyone elses Hadith makes absolut no sense, by that logic anyone listening to this brother here should reject everything he says as long as its not direct Quran in matters of religion because otherwise he would not be a Quran only follower anymore by his own definition that is to follow only and strictly the Quran in Religion and rejecting every other sources in this religion that claims to have any kind of usefull information about this religion.
the only truly acceptable way to follow hadith is for historical knowledge, following hadith in any other way is useless, better to look at what Allah said than the same human kind that corrupted Allah's word 2 times before
@TheStranger0509 When you say "reject all", you are being sensational. No one looks at the, let's say 800, or so DISTINCT reports in Sahih Bukhari and say each one is worthless. A few are interesting and reflect religious thinking by this or that group or, rarely, individual scholar. "Hadith rejection" is the rejection of the concept of Hadith, the rejection of affording Hadith a canonical status. Hadith overall, and by extension Sunni Islam, is a sour, sick, sad, sadistic joke. Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim when looked at and studied in their totality are disgusting. And yes, I am fluent in Arabic. But that doesn't matter.
At 14:00 farid is right that u should take history from Hadiths Yet it’s not reliable enough to take religious rulings from since it’s so far removed from The time of the prophet Basically just good enough to get an overview of things but to take things with a grain of salt to learn about the history Not to take religious rulings from
One of the worst thing Muslims did to the Quran is comparing it to poetry. Poetry does not have to be true, a poet can use any words that have the same connotation with the same meaning . For example, a poet would say, dad, or father, interchangeably without any distinction. Since Allah is the author of the Quran, I expect it to be precise . Not a letter extra nor a letter less. and it’s our duty as Muslims to dig deeper to try understand why this word was used in place of the other word and surprisingly sometimes you will uncover some new facts.
Peace Muhammad I hope you’re ok . Ive heard you debating Sunnis about praying the way they do and honestly brother I think that you’re trying hard to please them , if you only follow the Quran than the word salat has nothing to do with praying , salat has a completely deferent meaning and as the Quran has every detail and a complete book where did you get that the salat is praying 2,3,4,or 5 times a day and if you have me on your channel we can have a conversation about the true meaning of the word if you want .
Dont deceive yourself. If you don’t wanna pray just dont. Dont claim it is not in Quran. It is so pathetic. Because of people like you, people are staying away from Quran based Islam. You can find physical Salat in 4:102 in Quran. When you ˹O Prophet˺ are ˹campaigning˺ with them and you lead them in prayer, let one group of them pray with you-while armed. When they prostrate themselves, let the other group stand guard behind them. Then the group that has not yet prayed will then join you in prayer-and let them be vigilant and armed.1 The disbelievers would wish to see you neglect your weapons and belongings, so they could launch a sweeping assault on you. But there is no blame if you lay aside your weapons when overcome by heavy rain or illness-but take precaution. Indeed, Allah has prepared a humiliating punishment for the disbelievers.
@@Biekoe he is not following the book of Allah he is following his desires The book says obey Allah and messenger The book says we have reaveled this book and a hikmah with it what is this hikmah In surah najam verse 53 or 52 Allah says the messenger doesn't say from his own desires. And again Allah says what ever the messenger gives you take Then in surat tawbah verse 100 Allah is pleased with the companions of prophet and says Allah is pleased with them and with those who follow them and thoes so called companions that he doesnt like spread the deen far as possible died in the name of Allah after the death of prophet just to spread his deen Quran says remember Allah in abandunace But the same quran says Allah sends his blessing on prophet oh who u believe send blessing on him what to do now Allah says we have sent down this zikr and we will protect it why Allah didnt used the word book So in simple he doesnt like the restrictions of hadith and self taught where as we are ordered to understand the book of Allah with the understanding of the prophet muhammed
@@cellmicroprocessor u are twisting it all. If u want to obey the messeneger, then u must obey the message which he brought which is the quran. Quran surah 46:9 says that the prophet only followed what was revealed to him. What was revealed to him? The quran or bukhari? The quran obviously. And about the ayah that speaks about whatever the messenger has given you take it. That talks about war. Whatever is left after war. Read the whole surah in stead of taking it out of context.
@@Biekoe i m not twisting the words i believe that this book is from the most wise so it does not have unnecessary speech For example obey Allah and messenger how you follow Allah by following the quran and how you follow the messenger by following the quran what's the difference there was no need to put the messenger so if i take your understanding the verse would mean obey Allah and Allah Allah has revealed a book and a book ??yani un necessary words Double standards Allah says what ever the messengers gives take it No no you are twisting the meaning this is about the spoils of war and But when Allah says do not forbid what i have made allowed to you but when we say this is only for the food you guys would reply no no this applies on all things I gave you verses where Allah is telling you to follow the companions and other things which you ignored completely Any how my job was to tell may Allah give u and me the understanding of the reilgion
@@cellmicroprocessor oke it is clear that i am wastin my time here. U are the type of person who even when you show him verses from the quran, he objects. U just dont want to understand so there is no point in talking to you. And no where does the quran say follow the companions. You dont know what ur talking about.
Muslims today have too much time on their hands to be debating silly things. An idle mind is shaytan’s workshop. Brother, you’re leading thousands of people to jahannam, May Allah guide us all. I just don’t understand how a Muslim that claims to accept Muhammed saw as his prophet is refusing to take him as an example in his life. I don’t know about you but accepting him as my prophet means that I want to pray the way he did and eat the way he did and talk the way he did. And those things are not written in the Quran so it makes logical sense to me to follow the Quran AND the sunnah
@@mycommintmycomment2312 what are you talking about. I just asked you a question. How did prophet ibrahim, isa and musa pray. Hadiths didnt exist in their time. So were these magnificent prophets unable to pray? You are the one avoiding the question
I'm so glad I found this page... I was really losing my mind on how these hadiths are revered as if the Qur'an isn't perfect on its own... I thought having these conclusions was shaiyteen. Now I can confidently practice Islam. ❤️Alahumma barik!
@aljineerjiningjining5741 The Correctional Officer? May Allah reward him, he is a true lion of Islam and many Sunnis accepted Islam due to his dawah. However, remember to always verify and not to get all your information from one person without thinking. We can all make mistakes so we must constantly analyse everything.
Wait what? The devil didn't strip the clothes of Adam and eve... It's chapter 7 verses 18-22 He had them eat the apple and they revealed themselves to each other. They were already naked prior to eating. They had no lust so they did not see each other with lust even while bald.
Alhamdulilah for the truth, same thing that got christian’s. Shaytan is smart.. he’s been alive for billions of years and he knows God more than all of us and maybe even the prophets. Take care of the mind.
As yourself this, who’s more at risk of being wrong? Someone who rejects the teachings of a prophet he claims to follow(literally a part of the shahada) and only follows the Quran OR..someone who follows both!
"to someone who called some guy kafir because of he did not follow hadith blindly" why you are tying to make historical claims your idol. just accept they contain good things but also false things legends and lies. don't you see accepting hadith ass a whole damaging credibility of islam. i born muslim was almost out of religion because of fairy tale collection of hadith. now when i see a hadith i do this does it contradict quran? does it add things to quran? does it contaradict common sense? if yes i reject it. if no i say MAY BE IT IS CORRECT but never 100% noone can call me "kafir" "not muslim" because of this sincere attempt to reach truth.
I agree Sunna is not something obligatory but are good things to base yourself and aplly in your life. They arent dispossable as you say and they carry positive things in adapty this sunnas in your day yo day life. I agree that pray shouldnt be obligatory in specific rule, just pray is ennoutgh to God but if you desire to pray in that way doesnt make you a mushirikin too you are just doing a extra. In my understanding QURAN is the LAW sunna are good behaves. This cant be so hard to be understand there is not mushirikin if you dont see the sunna as obligation. If the sunna is against the quran is simple, discart it, but so far i didnt found one that does that.
Christ YESHUA is your KING... I used to be in Catholic religion and when I found out that the Vatican worships shaytan, I left that evil religion and went against my parents for Christ... Same with the Muslims, I'm sure they are in the same boat, man made religion... Trust me Christ YESHUA of the Bible is not the same as ISA from the Quran... If you can get out of it, then you know at that moment Christ YESHUA has a mission for you...
Bro I agree with your stance on Quran, but not your opening stance, eating with hands will always be better as utensils leaves behind residue that’s harmful, all new technology is harmful in ways we don’t see, whereby miswak is scientifically the best way to clean teeth, do you know what fluoride does to you? … in all honesty technology has more cons than pros, but we grew into it as a norm, I can just assume just like you, if going according to the Qurans view of the prophet, he wouldn’t have all these luxuries, and if he did then he would have given it all away..
Very contentious question, indeed what traditionalists--hadiths deem the Khimar as a piece of cloth that put over/ bring down towards the chest region, justifies the Hijab, however in the Qu'ran the surah decrees following Modesty at its time when women wore the Khimar on their head to bring it down, it doesn't mean Hijab specifically.
This is why the Quranists/ Quran only group has nothing to stand on. There is no answer for this issue whatsoever for the Quranist. There was a time the prophet (saw) was gone and the Quran was in the hands of others; complete strangers; and not in large quantities. Actually if you can’t look at history at all (which Quranists admit they can not) we wouldn’t know if there was one copy or 2 or 3. So the question is......After the death of the prophet (saw); Who were the ones in charge and in possession of the Quran at that time? Say like a year or two after he was gone? Who were they and how do you know they didn’t tamper with the Quran.? Can you give us some names? Using Quran only you cannot. You can’t provide one name of who had it using the Quran alone as your only reference. You know how ridiculous that is? How do you know for certain, verses like ‘this is a book with no doubt’; ‘nothing is left out’ , ‘a blessed book’ ; ‘we will protect this book’ etc etc weren’t just added in by those people? Anyone with a functioning brain knows the first thing someone who tampers with a book would write down in that very book is that no one tampered with the book. That’s common sense. Even more significant and a crushing blow to every Quranist; is how can Quran only people prove some verses or entire chapters weren’t taken out??? Some try to answer this huge crisis of faith by just claiming to believe in the Quran alone just because of its message. That doesn’t work either. The message is beautiful no doubt. But still it remains things could have been removed and outright omitted while maintaining the beauty of the book. You would have no clue if there was even more in it; making that point irrelevant. To make it even worse for the Quranite; Do you people even realize that this is the exact thing that actually did in fact happen to the two previous scriptures? The Torah and the injeel. Those books had portions removed from the original.! This is even confirmed in the Quran. Some argue extremely large portions. So the possibility was very very real. And it still gets even worse for the Quranite. The Quran itself talks about the Prophet (saw) having enemies who were against him. Proving there were people who were motivated to alter and harm the message of Allah. All this being considered I find it hard to believe the true religion of Allah would have no answer to who even had possession of the literal word of God after the prophet (saw) was gone. It is illogical and borderline idiotic to think Allah would have the most important event in history (the revelation of the Quran) be unverifiable just like the previous revelations who’s messages were mangled. The Quran only sect has no way whatsoever of proving the authenticity of the Quran using the Quran alone, making the entire foundation of their faith crumble to dust. And please don’t use Abu bakr or any other sahaba. You can’t double talk your way out of this. That’s historical info. The same historical info you reject with hadeeths. Using Quran alone you have no ability to verify the Quran. I’ve done my best to explain it clearly. No Quranist has been able to answer the question. Because they have no valid answer. You will stand alone before Allah. You must reflect on this. May Allah guide us all.
The Qur'an is proven through code 19. A mathematical miracle of Allah that proves the authenticity of the Qur'an without a doubt. And not only that, but it shows that your beloved sahaba made tahreef in the mushafs, but because of the code, the Qur'an was numerically preserved. So now let's flip the question back at you. What is your evidence for your mushafs and hadiths? That a bunch of people said so?
And your piece of evidence that easily dismantles your argument is a book that came almost 300 years later and that only contains 5th degree testimonies ?
People who entered from the the back door were slaves. Allah (swt) is telling the Muslim to demand equitable treatment by entering the house the way an honored guest would enter a house, from the front door.
@@moneyheist_- CP is a grifter who is only interested getting into the bank accounts of his audience. He uses grifting techniques which are not conducive to an academic discussion. Besides, I have no interest in contributing to CPs videos from which he grifts from an audience that is ill informed to say the least.
And what you’re doing is a red herring arguement in the Quran it’s clearly states u must follow the prophet and his teachings and how else would you get that information??
@@Biekoe there’s a few places Surat Nisa stay 59 & Surat Hashr aya 7 to name a couple. These ayas are direct orders saying “ obey Allah and his prophet” he mentions his prophet in the same aya refering to obedience highlighting the important of following the prophet. Step one and two go hand in hand.
@@hamedizzy5137 it doesnt say obey they prophet. It says obey the messenger. Why do you twist the ayah. It didnt say “nabi” it says “messenger”. And the messenger is the one to whom the quran was revealed and who followed the quran. Not his own rulings in terms of religion.
@@Biekoe yes prophet mohammad. The Quran only refers to following prophet mohammad that’s who it was revealed to and he is the final messenger and prophet
And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him)) gives you, take it, and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it)” [al-Hashr 59:7] Do not treat the Messenger’s summons to you ˹as lightly˺ as your summons to one another.1 Allah certainly knows those of you who slip away, hiding behind others.2 So let those who disobey his orders beware, for an affliction may befall them, or a painful torment may overtake them. The Prophet (ﷺ) said: Beware! I have been given the Qur'an and something like it, yet the time is coming when a man replete on his couch will say: Keep to the Qur'an; what you find in it to be permissible treat as permissible, and what you find in it to be prohibited treat as prohibited. Beware! The domestic ass, beasts of prey with fangs, a find belonging to confederate, unless its owner does not want it, are not permissible to you If anyone comes to some people, they must entertain him, but if they do not, he has a right to mulct them to an amount equivalent to his entertainment. Cmon man?
@@MuhammadfromGOD أَلاَ هَلْ عَسَى رَجُلٌ يَبْلُغُهُ الْحَدِيثُ عَنِّي وَهُوَ مُتَّكِئٌ عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ فَيَقُولُ بَيْنَنَا وَبَيْنَكُمْ كِتَابُ اللَّهِ فَمَا وَجَدْنَا فِيهِ حَلاَلاً اسْتَحْلَلْنَاهُ وَمَا وَجَدْنَا فِيهِ حَرَامًا حَرَّمْنَاهُ وَإِنَّ مَا حَرَّمَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم كَمَا حَرَّمَ اللَّهُ " that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "Lo! Soon a Hadith from me will be conveyed to a man, while he is reclining on his couch, and he says: 'Between us and you is Allah's Book. So whatever we find in it that is lawful, we consider lawful, and whatever we find in it that is unlawful, we consider it unlawful.' Indeed whatever the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) made unlawful, it is the same as what Allah made unlawful." Hence the verse. Tiirmidhi 2664
@@MuhammadfromGOD أَلاَ إِنِّي أُوتِيتُ الْكِتَابَ وَمِثْلَهُ What’s the point you’re tryna make. The verse in the Quran? I agree that no one could produce anything like the Qur’an. The issue I have with you is the various verses where it says to follow the Prophet ﷺ . The Quran was revealed to Him, you don’t think he has a better idea of the religion than you and I or any Human after him.
☝️☝️☝️ Hadiths are absolutely necessary there is no on this planet who could have made people understand holy better than prophet Muhammad saww himself on whom was holy Quran was revealed. I don't need to say more.
Allah can explain Quran to us better, Prophet wasn't allowed to interpret. His only duty was the delivery/ 5:99. + your Hadiths have nothing with the Prophet. You only follow Tafsir of mullas. You sunnis have nothing with the Prophet and Qur'an and Islam.
@@moneyheist_- he's a coward who mutes people, ofcourse I can call, I already tried 2ce, both times he noticed me, first time he challenged me but didn't even mention me in his next videos while I was debating 10s of his minions under his comment section and I refuted his whole 2 hour video with a long brief response before, but he didn't even mention me in his next videos, but he mentioned some naive sunni, while my comments were like 100s, why'd he pick a weak opponent? Cuz as I said he's a coward. Next time (after a long time), I made a mess in his live comment section, as I was exposing embarrassing places of his Bible in comments and finally CP noticed and challenged me, I told him to give his link for voice chat, he claimed to give but he gave some sunni Hadith while I follow Qur'an alone, I told him that he didn't give a link to his live, he ignored, and he claimed he gave a link, I said imaginary link, and he got triggered and started showing more Hadiths, and muted me, again, he's a coward, if he can debate without muting and lying, I'm for it, but I already witnessed his coward tricks at me twice so I didn't try again.
@@AgustusAtrahasis you have just called him and speak to him like a man not hide in the comment section. CP has debated many without muting, there are honest people, for example his debate with a PhD Sheikh called Rohi from azar university in Egypt, it's one of the biggest Islamic universities in the world.
@@moneyheist_- so first he calls, then he mutes and lies, and his minions try to name call after that, you think your tricks work at me? Many of his debating opponents are his own minions, many times he got caught debating same person who each time claimed to be a Muslim and claimed to convert, his voice, tone and indian accent got familiar as he kept returning with the same trick, so CP got embarrassed after people noticed him and told him to leave and blocked, that's just one of examples, CP has many such minion actors who pretend to be Muslim and pretend to convert after the debate. And even sunni Farid exposed around 100s of lies of CP, and even challenged him to an open debate, as did Shaikh Uthman and many others even by offering CP to wear a niqab and bring guards if he's so afraid of his identity and security, CP just hides, he's the coward. He's nobody that I'd go to him, he already lost my respect the first time, and I gave him another chance, and he failed again, so if what, let him come to me and debate me, I'm here in comments, he can use comments too and text, let him come to me, he's nobody that I'd go to him.
Hajj it's not pilgrimage according to Quran , Hajj is a debate / giving good argument etc... as Ibrahim did in Quran . Plus i don't think bait Al Haram is a physical building . Ibrahim buit al qawa3ida ...the foundation of Deen MINA AL Bait ...he got the foundation from the Bait not FOR the bait . So words like Bait and masjid al Haram etc... are not buildings in Saoudia . Same as woujuhakum doesn't mean faces , instead it's direction .. al Masjid Al haram from my understanding is the Quran . Allah knows best .
Have you considered that my primary language is English And since you love your Hadith so much - isn’t there a Hadith that those that struggle with reciting the Quran get double the reward Or do you hate us for believing in GOD and rejecting what you associate to GOD
@@MuhammadfromGOD The reason I disagree with you is, that the details of many things mentioned in Quran are in hadiths. I agree that some hadiths like that about sahaba have caused fitnah and division, but hadiths which provide details of Quranic verses and commands like that of Salah,are the reason for us being United today, and of us being disciplined today. WHAT I IN A NUTSHELL MEAN IS THE HADITHS THAT SHOW US PROPHET'S WAY OF FOLLOWING THE QURAN AND ITS COMMANDS ARE THE ONES THAT WE SHOULD TAKE, BECAUSE QURAN SAYS TO FOLLOW THE PROPHET PBUH, AND HOW CAN WE DO THAT WITHOUT KNOWING WHAT PROPHET PBUH DID?
@@MuhammadfromGOD I hope you read what I have to say. Its okay that you can't recite the Qur'an properly, but you must learn. I myself am indian , but I recite the Qur'an quite properly using the signs
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah Answer this. Why did all the companions of the Prophet follow him and his ways of nimaz and everything? Was that because Quran says follow the Prophet or did they do bidah and commit kufr? I say Quran is fully detailed and it says to follow Prophet PBUH, you say no Quran is fully detailed and lets leave Prophet PBUH and his guidance.
I like to speak to you muhammed from god. Me myself can't fınd sunni islam in the kuran, a good person who is a close friend who fears allah is from a sunni background, and he also cant proof sunni islam and sunni from muhhamed (the rasul allah ) could be found in the kuran. Still he think sunni islam is from allah and that allah gave to muhammed a sunna, bla bla no proof, only ı can't proof it is for certain a default to say muhammed saws had a sunna for himself and for his followers. Still as long there is no proof for a sunna of muhammed ı reject to say something like ı am sunni ore muhammed saws had a sunna, I think what is better to be a muhtad with proof ore to be a sunni without proof. And ı thought it would be great to speak to you, because 1 reason ı fınd it locigal the most way you think and make youre video's about, If you like to react ı would be thankful, ı want to say ı know muhammed saws he is a witness over me, ı know ibrahim saws ı walked with hım, and ı was on the arsh of allah and spoke with hım, ı also saw many Angels came from the sky and ı spoke with three of them. And ı won't never lie about such ımportant things. Selam and may allah guide you himself. The Best guide the teacher the Best helper, the creator who knows everthing about his creation.
I adhere to Qur'ān alone I don't agree with some of your claims. 1. I agree. They don't listen to us, And they attack a presupposition. 2. I don't agree, sunnah is static, God applied same sunnah for all. And what Prophet said is general, But the problem is, sunni Hadiths Are MOSTLY not from the Prophet. Maybe all, cuz who allowed Hadiths, According to their own sunni history, Prophet didn't allow to write Hadith And ordered to burn any they find + punish the rumor spreaders/ 33:60 And 4 Khaliphs didn't allow Hadiths And ordered to destroy any they find And punish whoever writes Ahadith. Only in Umayyad Khaliphate, later, Cuz of the rise of Hadith only sect Khaliph Umar the second allowed Hadiths being written, 100s of years, yet oldest known Sira to be authored Is in time of Muawiyah's khaliphate, Which is after 4 Khaliphs, "1st fitnah" Which they call tho there were fitnah Even before, anyway, and where's it? And oldest surviving Hadith known Is that which is attributed to Bukhari 5 to 7 or more generations after him, And he was claimedly 5 to 7 or more Generations after the last Prophet, So they've no original or any copies Of Bukhari, but only 500 or 800 years After Bukhari, by the Ottoman writers Which they mass produced after it, & ironically, they themselves claim That Bukhari was called a heretic In his time, so if they stick to "ijma" They should deny Bukhari actually But sunnis are hypocrite ignorants. So in short, what I wanna say is Hadiths are 11+th century books, While Qur'an can be dated earlier, Kuffar hardly agree to 9th century, But some claim it dates to earlier And even one has blood of Uthman. Yet sunnis say same people brought, Sunnis are obviously very arrogant. They didn't even have same criterion, Sunni Hadiths have no 4 witnesses, While Hafs we have has 4 witnesses Which chain back to even Uthman, So we can use it with Uthmanic, And ofc it chains to the Prophet. Plus, sunni hadiths are a bunch of Direct attacks at the last Prophet And all Muslims and whole Islam. I haven't found even 1 Hadith Which doesn't contradict Quran And I can challenge the sunnis (And I've challenged them a lot) To show me any "good" Hadith, & they all fail when I show Quran, All they say is, we don't know much Talk to "scholars", while those mullas Just hide, ignore, mute and block us, Just as much of their sunni leymen, and they just run away after that. Like saying "may Allah guide you", Qur'ān is the guidance from Allah, They're obviously the misguided, When Allah calls Qur'ān clear/ 12:1, They say, no it's not clear, rejectors. Just as you use say "I interpret", Quran is clear, what to interpret? I take Qur'ān literally, it has no error, People should stop mixing excess. & if we say it's fully detailed/ 6:114, And that it had all examples/ 18:54, They say, no, it has no detail of salah Or zakah or example of the Prophet, Just as you said it has no structure And that it has no modern examples, And that "Hadiths were necessary" For the time of Prophet? Absurd, He had no right to make sharia, Only Allah ordains religion for us. Taking sharia of others is shirk/ 42:21. ( So consider these, and fix yourself, Also fix your saying "God inspired" As you lied about wide open eyes Inventing falsehood about Allah, Allah doesn't contradict Himself, He orders us to lower our gazes, Who's worse than he who invents Falsehood about Allah or turns away? That's why I unsubscribed from you, Allah doesn't need you, remember it, He'll take your actions into account, Disbelief and misleading others Makes your deeds futile/ 47:1, Don't say warners didn't come, While you arrogantly turn away. ) That's just about the beginning I haven't watched that fully yet.
+ befriending mushrik hypocrites Like sunnis and jews and others, And not reconciling with Muslims Like how you ignored me/ 4:144, Hypocrites will be in the lowest Depth of the HellFire/ 4:145.
I didn't say a lie about GOD. You weren't present, you didn't experience what I experienced during the making of the thumbnail; and I don't agree with your interpretation on the verse about lowering the gaze. I appreciate your input; and when I was talking about the sunnah being static - I was addressing their definition of sunnah; not what GOD has explain the sunnah is in the Quran. I understand you have it in you to keep talking down to me; if you claim you know more than me and feel the desire that you constantly need to talk down at me, and what you accused me of a few times now; please go ahead and start to spread the message of GOD; and if your LORD wants to proliferate you online, then that's your blessing., Regardless, GOD said that believers are supposed to be forgiven and merciful among each other; you are addressing me like as I did shirk.
@@MuhammadfromGOD I repeat, "Who's worse" than he who invents Falsehood about Allah or denies His āyāt/ 10:17, or turns away/ 18:57. And how is that you think That I'm putting you down? I'm advising, it's to rise you up, You're putting yourself down By persisting in ignorance & nor reforming yourself. It's Haram to say about Allah That which we don't know/ 7:33. And you say that God inspired you? Who said I'm interpreting? I take Qur'an literally as it is, Cuz I don't like to fool myself. Like for example, when I read Surah (33) Al-Ahzab, verse 37, I had heard of different views, Like some even saying that It's about Prophet at war, And zaid means profit, And sunnis add absurdity, But I had removed sunni lies, & reading that chapter in context, Made me realize, it's clearly Zaid, It's about a human, Qur'an is clear, You should stop trying to interpret, Because we don't know the Unseen Only Allah knows it's interpretation. (We should read it straightly/ 2:121, And take it as a whole/ 2:26, 3:7, Quran is clear as a whole/ 12:1.) Now about sunnah of rasul, All prophets followed 1 sunnah, For which they can be no change, Why'd you use an abused Arabic Instead of correcting sunnis? And what do you mean by forgive? Am I fighting you or holding grudge? I'm advising. God orders to forgive Even those who don't even expect The meeting with Him/ 45:14-15. How do you tell me to forgive That which you didn't reform? Tho I've no grudge to forgive, I'm just advising, read 3:104. Don't follow which you don't know, You say God inspired, I was a sufi, I know how silly is your state now, If you go on thinking that whatever You think about God is true, you'll End up misleading yourself more. Alhamdulillah, God opened my eyes And I repented of that fantasy world. + how does burning hand Mean Allah orders to not Burn our hand? Baseless. That you claim you got Outside of Qur'an, right? (Allah said that He knows And we do not know/ 2:214, So you can't say that the karh Means you should avoid that.) So you don't adhere to Quran alone, While Prophet followed Qur'an alone. And ofcourse I'm more guided, I don't say about Allah excess, I advise and listen to advises, I don't ally kuffar & munafiqīn, And I believe believers unseen. And you think you're more guided Only cuz you have this platform? What makes you know my state? Besides, you try to guide kuffar? It's useless to advise them/ 2:6. So what benefit are you doing? Prophet was ordered to leave The disbelievers, read 51:54, And many verses like that. So why don't you leave them? As it's useless to advise them, So why do I need a platform? I know why, to remove fitnah, But you're causing more fitnah, So that's why I unsubscribed. I did my best to advise online, And offline, I still don't give up, Even if I'm the only Qur'an alone Follower in my city I ever know And I got harmed physically, Financially, verbally, spiritually, And online I got muted, banned, I still didn't give up on my faith, What'd you know about me? I have no financial comforts To make platforms like that, And I'm under constant threat, And pressure that I deleted a lot. So you just showed your silliness By thinking you're better by channel. + if I had a channel, I wish I'd recite Qur'an, But you can't even recite, Why don't you fix your tajweed? Read Quran properly/ 2:121.
@@MuhammadfromGOD You didn't address all my claims, You wanna guide the blind people Who see themselves self sufficient But with someone who fears God You don't even wanna discuss?
And verily in the Messenger of Allah ye have a good example for him who looketh unto Allah and the last day and remembereth Allah much. (Al-Ahzab 33:21) Chapter 16, verse 44: "and We have sent down unto thee (also) the Message; that thou mayest explain clearly to men what is sent for them," The Message = Quran, Explanation = Hadith surah 59, verse 7: "and whatever the Messenger gives you, accept it, and from whatever he forbids you, keep back", essentially meaning to follow everything Mohammad gives us, and abstain from everything he forbids.
@@zaidxdesign4744 where does Allah mention hadith of Prophet is a requirement in the Quran? Verse 33:21 is self explanatory. You already have a good example in the Messenger due to his faith in God and the Last Day and remembers God often. The "good example" in 33:21 speaks of 3 specific acts: 1- Seeking God 2- Seeking the Last Day (Hereafter) 3- Thinking about God constantly. 16:44: ..that you may make clear to the people what was sent down to them, and that they might reflect. Is this what Hadith is? Explanation of the Quran? The hadith contains inadequate amount of Prophetic commentary of the Quran. Did Allah say making clear the revelations is hadith? 59:7: you manipulatively twist and butcher the verse citing portion of it. The verse is in reference to distribution of gains from an exiled town. The Messenger cannot forbid anything as a religious law. Religious law is only defined by God. Veree 5:41 is for the likes of you people... 5:41: O Messenger, let them not grieve you who hasten into disbelief of those who say, "We believe" with their mouths, but their hearts believe not, and from among the Jews. [They are] avid listeners to falsehood, listening to another people who have not come to you. They distort words beyond their [proper] places [i.e., usages], saying, "If you are given this, take it; but if you are not given it, then beware." But he for whom Allāh intends fitnah - never will you possess [power to do] for him a thing against Allāh. Those are the ones for whom Allāh does not intend to purify their hearts. For them in this world is disgrace, and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment. 5:47: ..And those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed are ˹truly˺ the rebellious. 6:114: [Say], "Then is it other than Allāh I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book [i.e., the Qur’ān] explained in detail?" And those to whom We gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters.
@@zaidxdesign4744 60:4: You already have an excellent example in Abraham and those with him.... 60:6: You certainly have an excellent example in them for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day. But whoever turns away, then surely Allah ˹alone˺ is the Self-Sufficient, Praiseworthy.
you distort the verses well, better than shaytan could, obeying the messenger is obeying the Quran, the sole purpose of a messenger is to convey Allah's message (Quran 5:99), obeying Musa = obeying Tawrat, obeying Isa = obeying Injil, obeying Muhammad = obeying Quran, Muhammad has no other purpose but to give the message, if you think otherwise, you are rejecting Allah's clear word.@@zaidxdesign4744
Allah has guided him Alhamdullillah. I invite you to renounce Sunniism and become a Muslim. Leave behind your false traditions and shirk and submit to your creator.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah I am a revert myself and have studied Islam. I invite you back to Islam. May Allah open your heart. As far as this Muhammad bloke goes him and you are on clear misguidance.
@zaidxdesign4744 I am a revert. I was an atheist until I read the Qur'an and experienced its light. I asked Allah to guide me and he did. He protected me from the misguidance of the mushrikoon and kept me steadfast upon Islam. You're not a revert. You haven't yet accepted Islam. Islam requires the renunciation of shirk and adherence to God's law. I invite you to take the next step and accept Islam. May Allah guide you, ameen 🤲
I am sorry to say my friend that you are still on misguidance. Regardless,, my journey to Islam wasn't easy either. It is the "religion" I hated the most. Started an an atheist, studied Christianity, Hinduism then was an agnostic for a while before finally studying the Quran and becoming a Muslim. Allah guided me and in the beginning I too was confused like the Munkareen e Hadith but Allah gave me the ability to study sciences of Hadith alhamdulillah and opened my heart to the knowledge and Allah protected me from misguidance. I invite you to take the next step, accept Islam and become a Muslim. may Allah open your heart to the correct understanding of Islam. Admen@@Quran_Alone_Dawah
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
Teachers of Hadith removed independent reasoning. You can see the decline in the umma as hadith become more and more refined. If Allah wanted us to have no will, he would have made us like the angels.
can you Call Christian Prince
@@moneyheist_- Christian Princess is a 🤡
@@moneyheist_- what is this obsession with Christian peanut..?? is he your Christian scholar?
Farid previously left a comment wishing to engage with you. He is one of the few Sunnis who is capable of being civil, and dare I say, even nice. Definitely invite him to your channel for a discussion.
Siding majority of the arrogant sunnis, Farid is really trying to make sense and not just stay on takfiring like those dawah boyz
You don't know him well then,
He makes videos about deviants
And tries to misrepresent Quranites,
And he doesn't respond always,
He can't even give 4 witnesses
For any of the Hadith they have.
God knows better what evil he hides,
I have witnessed lots of sunni evils,
Even one who seems to listen a lot
And who seems to be closest friend
Can anytime betray if he is a sunnite
And mock and spread the privacies,
While even worst of the Quranites
Didn't mock personal life or expose,
I better have Qurani enemies
Than to have sunni friends.
Tho better to have Quraniy friends ofc.
No Sunni no matter how capable you think he is can debate the Quran brother and that’s a fact
@@arslaanmania1309Call Christian Prince
No he isn't actually civil. He made edited videos against Mufti abu layth and lied about him when mufti defended the prophet's honor by rejecting the nonsensical hadiths
A proper debate between these two would be really interesting. One without screaming and interrupting, respectful and informative.
They will not let Muhammad speak express himself to he his core.,
@cocoalfaridah5831 No, actually, Farid is a chill guy and generally respectful. I interacted with him on his livestream chat and he doesn't get nasty like most Sunnis. A conversation with him would be interesting.
He already debated a different guy , His name is "The Muslim lantern"
@@ngess4661 The full debate wasn't recorded
it was live , and he also has other videos on why the hadith rejectors are illogical, you should go watch it.@@Quran_Alone_Dawah
Wow you're the one who convinced me wallahi I can not believe most muslims have been fooled by this
You Hadith rejectors make no sense
@@putinsneighbor8351can you Call Christian Prince
@@putinsneighbor8351so you think all the prophets make no sense? Cause we’re following Quran alone just like them.
@@dianaa3336 You’re comparing the prophets to us?
@@putinsneighbor8351 the prophets were humans just like us…
Mashallah brother. You are so humble, patient and loving with your message. The way you elevate Quran to where it needs to be is unlike anything I’ve seen in a long time. May Allah reward you for your efforts
14:27 “God keeps firm those who believe, with the firm word”
In this verse God tells us that he grounds the man with the firm word, so the truth is what strengthens your position…
But the whole science of hadith is based on the exact opposite principle of the man is the one who grounds and gives legitimacy to the word
can you call Christian Prince
@@moneyheist_- why are you commuting everywhere to contact your chrstian leader chrstoian peanut ???
Omg 😂 I laughed so hard how you saying about reviewing the Quran 🤣🤣 anyways amazing work again agree with 100 % of what you saying and everything makes sense 👍🏽
Call Christian Prince
Ty, brother. I recently reverted as an American atheist. I do believe much of the prophet's pbuh words/lifestyle called sunnah is admirable and worthy of consideration. But I struggle with hadith so much
May Allah bless you brother. Shaitan mixes truth with falsehood. There are for sure good hadiths which might be true. But only the Qur'an is absolute truth.
There are is always the question of truth mixed with falsehood and shaitan will sow doubt, fear, confusion etc but fast to Allah alone.
Alhamdulillah.
But I suggest you do not learn from this guy, what he believed is from a false sect in Islamic view.
Someone who rejects what Rasulullah did, said, and ordered, is kafir (non-believer).
Because the hadits are what Rasulullah did, said, and ordered, that written and memorized.
It is not for you as a revert, it is an advance knowledge.
I think you do not need to learn that for now.
@@hotaryuzaki Brother Muhammad is not any s ect. Your hadiths are not from the prophet but rather falsehoods attributed to the prophet. That is why we are defending the prophet from you.
@@hotaryuzaki why you are tying to make historical claims your idol. just accept they contain good things but also false things legends and lies. don't you see accepting hadith ass a whole damagig credibility of islam. i born muslim was almost out of religion because of fairy tale collection of hadith.
now when i see a hadith
i do this
does it contradict quran?
does it add things to quran?
does it contaradict common sense?
if yes
i reject it.
if no i say
MAY BE IT IS CORRECT
but never 100%
noone can call me "kafir" "not muslim" because of this sincere attempt to reach truth.
You are such a kind hearted guy ..that when you pause the speaker...u make sure he looks good 😅😂
can you call Christian Prince
i hear this millah of ibrahim but where do you get millah of ibrahim is it like a book like sahih bukhari
Selam Muhammed, what is your opinion about, mortgage for buying a house or car, bank loans and insurances. Can you do a video about this topic?
can you call Christian Prince
Here are some key verses in the Quran that condemn usury/interest (riba):
"O you who have believed, fear Allah and give up what remains [due to you] of interest, if you should be believers." (Quran 2:278)
"And if you do not, then be informed of a war [against you] from Allah and His Messenger. But if you repent, you may have your principal - [thus] you do no wrong, nor are you wronged." (Quran 2:279)
"Allah destroys interest and gives increase for charities. And Allah does not like every sinning disbeliever." (Quran 2:276)
"O you who have believed, do not consume usury, doubled and multiplied, but fear Allah that you may be successful." (Quran 3:130)
"And [for] their taking of usury while they had been forbidden from it, and their consuming of the people's wealth unjustly. We have prepared for the disbelievers among them a painful punishment." (Quran 4:161)
"That is because they say, "Trade is [just] like interest." But Allah has permitted trade and has forbidden interest." (Quran 2:275)
These verses establish a clear prohibition on riba, usually interpreted as any kind of interest or usury, in Islam. They emphasize that it is a major sin and warn of punishment in the hereafter for those who engage in the practice. The verses also contrast riba with charitable giving and ethical trade/commerce.
Interest is HARAM and must be avoided at all costs, Interest is a scam and a huge tool of the satanic jewish bankers
there's no need for a video lol the Quran CLEARLY prohibits interest
i NEED to see a convo between the two of you
I like your reformist point of view and i would like to say that muslim community needs more peopl like you
Sticking with Quran is not a reform. It is going back to origin :)
@@GuideMeToTheRightPath either way His Interpretation is by far the less hostile
@@exincom4729 I aggree, if you havent already, please read Quran yourself at least once my friend, the you will see this is actually the religion of Peace in deed. Peace on you 🫶
Keep going, your belief is logic-based. There are many people who support you. May your heart never tighten when those who believe in baseless chain-narrations call you a Kaffir. God will judge all of our beliefs on the day of Judgement, bi idni Allah. We love you.
Can someone please tell me how the steps of prayer is for him? Because he was sayi g like he we do rukuu and postures, so it means he has a different style? Where can i fi d rhis video? Im really curious to know? Thanks!!
You don't need him to explain,
Open Quran and open your heart,
And don't mix ANYTHING to Qur'an.
God is the best explainer, not humans.
@@AgustusAtrahasishow did you get the Quran because the prophet never gave the Quran direct,
@@isaacjamaar4794 God preserved it using humans and objects as carriers, and sunnis brought it like caravan of cattle.
@@isaacjamaar4794 God preserved it using humans and objects as carriers.
@@isaacjamaar4794 even disbelievers keep manuscripts of Qur'ān in their museums, cuz sunnis couldn't keep it, as those mentioned in 62:5.
I’m glad i came across this video. I love learning about Islam through Quranists because they make the most sense. Sunni and Shia Muslims don’t understand how bad their Hadiths make Islam look. There are a lot of questionable things in those Hadiths.
yessirr !!! keep telling themmmm❤❤❤
Great point about time. If the Prophet lived today, the sunnah would change. Therefore it isn't meant to be a timeless teaching applied to modern times. Only the Qur'an is timeless.
can you call Christian Prince
Ifs and buts
@@Colourcoateddiaries - IF 2+2=4 There ain't no buts. The statement is a FACT which is why you ain't have nothing of substance to say.
@@restlessnative3818 if the prophet lived today, he wouldn’t be the prophet, you know that right?
Everything happened in its prescribed time and Allah in his infinite wisdom choose for muhammed SAW to be born at that time and have those life experience. So yes, ifs and buts open the doors to shaytan.
I’m not here to change your mind, we’re all free to believe what we want but what I do have a problem with are silly arguments and narrative changes of things that will never happen. What does the prophet being born in this generation have to do with his sunnah? EVEN IF he lived today, thousands of years down the line, his followers would adhere to today’s customs because it would be his sunnah. But there’s no point debating something that’ll never happen anyway
@@Colourcoateddiaries - It isn't a debate. It's a fact that You yourself just agreed with. Moreover, You claim to have a problem with "silly arguments and narrative of things that will never happen." YET you uphold garbage books that are Filled with exactly that. Silly arguments/ narrations and things that will Never happen.
Brother Muhammad, thank you so much for taking your time to make this video. I, myself, am on a journey to find the truest Islam which is nearly impossible to find when Muslims nowadays shove the Hadiths down our throat on anything. How to stand, how to sit how to do whatever. This lost the true meaning essence of the Deen. I simply ask a question to Brother Fareed on one of his CZcams video where he presented Sheikh Al Albani, I asked, “Salam brother Farid and other brothers and sisters, No doubt Sheikh Albani put much efforts on the matter of Hadiths I truly respect him, but I have some questions, so my question is No one ever grade the Hadiths before him? Did Imam Bukhari, Imam Muslim, Imam Ahmed etc did not grade the Hadiths in their own books? Why exactly Sheikh Albani felt the need to work on Hadiths? Why no one else worked on Hadiths in the past 1200 years or so why only a sheikh who was born in early 1900s work on Hadith and no one else before him? This seems like a huge jump from the time periods of those 7 authentic books to Sheikh Albani. This is where I am confused. Hope someone can help.” And bro Fareed’s reply was just “ Hadiths we’re always graded. Albani didn’t bring anything new. He simply revived the science, he didn’t create it.” My further Question is then why majority or maybe some Bukhari Hadith says graded by Albani? 🤷♀️ if Sunnis believe in graded by Albani Hadiths then sir bukhari is nullified! Then Bukhari is not 100% authentic. The science of Hadith is so bogus that no one can verify the truth like A said to B or C heard from D, the chains and then contexts Hadith people only play with these things they do not have any straight answers that’s is why I stick to the Quran which is the truth no one can deny and as you said at the end Quran is 100% sahih. Much respect and love 💕 from this sister JazakAllah khair
This video is very interesting. because he literally tell us to think critical and reasonable. He not did not tell hadist because he wanna us think with sense and logic.
Good video Love from Indonesia 🙏
As a Canadian, Brother Muhamamad, everything you state resonates with me to my core. Keep up your great work my brother.
I'm a believer in the Qur'an and reject the fabricated hadith sects. I'm living in Sweden and in a difficult economic situation with my welfare declined, in debt, rent due, forced to apply for jobs that don't allow me to make Salah and to sell alcohol etc. Can you hire me for a righteous job in Canada? I rather even scrub toilets for the believers with a thootbrush fulltime with minimum wage rather than being stuck in this situation or get hired by the disbelievers. I'm willing to relocate.
As a Canadian, you should return to Islam and leave the religion of munkareen e Hadith.
Call Christian Prince
Brother could you please do a video on how you pray?
Having trouble Hadith rejector?
@@putinsneighbor8351 but then even hadiths, there's various ways of praying, which one is the right one?
The kuffars who reject the sunnah of the prophet (saw) just don't know how to perform it.
conservatism/traditionalism/fear of change is a huge problem in humans, the ottomans fell because they didnt modernize, most muslims stick to their beliefs no matter what (scholar 500 years ago said A to muslim, muslim teaches it to child, the list goes on and the muslim almost never thinks about B) , it takes a lot for a muslim to reject hadith, while for a christian, to turn to sunnism and then to reject hadith, is an easier road, because they do not have any beliefs set in their brain since the start, i hope the ummah can find the truth in the era of misinformation.
you are right about the freedom of speech - I don't mind the Sunnis insulting and people having discussions
but when people are trolling or posting none sense - I will leave it to your judgment.
@@MuhammadfromGOD i prohibit people speaking when they are outright insulting, mocking others, but when theyre a bit more openminded and try to debate, i let them speak
How can you come and talk about the history of the Ottoman , talking nonsence , they didnt fell because they were didnt modernize , they fell because they got betrayed by the people they were protecting . You can go believe you Zionist history , truth is far beyond what you think .
@@MuhammadfromGODI have a question. Not a Muslim btw. Regards to being _intoxicated_ in Quran when coming to prayer and chances of one bumbling or mumbling gibberish during prayer isn't permitted, my question is, is the meaning of _intoxicated_ means currently not being in sound mind or meaning being high as fuch on substances?
what do you think of the guy who runs the channel "the lost truth of islam"
As for fasting brother , how would you explain the fasting of mariam , when Allah said clearly to her eat and drink .
Bro to underatand better quran , you have to divorce completely the tradition and start from scratch , words like salah , Zakah , Sawm , Hajj is heavily corrupted .
I will go as far even Nissa doesn't mean Women ..i know it's hard to swallow , but you will get there inshallah .
I highly recommend to read / watch the links i habe sent you .
Salamualaykum brother, I love you for the sake of Allah and respect you a lot. However I have a couple of questions, I understand that many of the Hadiths are applicable at the time, but the example that you gave with the mishwak and eating with your right hand, it's not as if the sunnah is to eat with the right hand therefore abandon utensils, but to use it when eating, when using a utensil or drinking water, with the mishwak, it's an interesting point that you brought up but the truth is it's extremely convenient compared to a tooth brush + tooth paste + water, etc. From the way that I have learned the sunnah, it's not so much as perfectly applying everything like abandoning utensils to eat with right hand, but to take the concepts and lessons and apply them to today. As for the prayer, I understand what you are saying with the structure in the religion, but from the way that I see it is the consistent structure of the prayer is what unites us all, when I go to a masjid in a different country and pray, I should know whats going on and whats happening, not to mention that the Prophet (PBUH) said to pray how we see him pray. I would love to see a debate between you and Farid as I love both of you for the sake of Allah. Peace be upon you.
You are a very reasonable and open minded person. May Allah bless you
These are very interesting perspective of his. Can you tell me what he said about how to pray? I didn't find it. I'm very curious. Thanks!
@@monaattiah3976 he takes from Surat al Isra, chapter 17 verse 78, and 110 to make the argument that the in verse 78 that's talking about maghrib, isha, and fajr only, and that asr and thuhr don't actually exist, and that 110 says don't be too loud in your 'salatika' he interprets this as prayer, while the sunni interpretation is that salat used to be used for dua before islam, so when Allah used that word, He was using it in context with the beginning of the verse that was talking about dua to Allah. He also says that there isn't any structure to prayer, that it involves the 3 movements, standing, bowing, and prostrating, but anyone can do them in any order they want, and that raka's don't really exist, his argument is that structure to religion is bad, which in some cases is true, but in this case prayer and the direction of it need to be a consistent thing with all muslims so that I can go pray with muslims in australia, thailand, japan, russia, or USA, if we all prayed differently, theres no unity in the prayer. czcams.com/video/KF_dg1PBgMQ/video.html the video i linked is the video where he speaks about this
"Pray as you see me praying"?
And you think he'd pray saying
"Peace be upon you O Prophet"?
we say that because this was the conversation between him and God during the isra' and ma'raj, also angels are the ones that carry the salam, the prophet can't hear anything, they simply bring them salam to his grave while he is dead@@AgustusAtrahasis
Who will understand more about the Qur'an, Muhammad and his explanation true hadish or someone in years 2020s
God states in the Quran that he does the explaining and no one else should even attempt to do so.
"Do not move your tongue to hasten it.
It is we who will collect it into Quran.
Once we recite it, you shall follow
such a Quran.
Then it is we who will explain it"
Nobody can intercede for you or save you … only god can. In terms of understanding the Quran.. God states that if it doesn't make sense give it time and he will show it to you in time... make dua brother.
I have so many questions after hearing that the quran ist enough...how do you even know the Quranic order or what the quran is? And how do you verify your position what the mushaf is? How do you know what naskh wa mansukh is? How do you know the Asbabul-nuzul? How do you know the character of the Prophet(s)? How do you know the Sira of prophet Mohammed? How do you understand fiqh? How do you understand the law and their usage in a state? Which school of 'aqida should I follow? Which school of fiqh schould I follow? Are their even schools and respected scholars and if so why schould someone believe them, because they would be a source of a tradition in themselfs?
Those are some questions that came directly into my mind, maybe someone can answer them :)
I love your content man but I am just a little bit curious. I’ve seen you quote the Bible before in one of your reels and my question is how different the Bible authenticity would be from the Hadith. Supposedly you want to learn about prophet Jesus pbuh as a Muslim. The book you would refer to is the Quran. Why?, because the Bible contradicts the Quran and is not historically a reliable source ( due to different translations and corruptions ). Despite the Bible mentioning Good words from the prophet Jesus, we still cannot be 100% certain it is accurate as Muslims due to the fact the prophet Jesus is represented as biblical Jesus which contradicts the Quran. Thus as Muslims we should seek the Quran to learn about our prophet Muhammad pbuh instead of Hadith wether the Hadith mentions good or bad statements of our prophet. Moreover The prophet mentioned in the Hadith is a political and contradictory figure and therefore reading the Hadith to gain greater insight of our prophet Muhammad pbuh is just as reading the Bible to learn about prophet Jesus. Do forgive me for my ignorance and correct me if I am wrong brother
Answer is simple. Munkareen e Hadith religion is based on desires of one.
his basically saying if one idol didn't answer your prayers go to the next one..
WAIT WHAT. David was doing music !?
How do you pray isha? And sunnah prayer? Where did you learn attaahiyaa if not from hadith? Barakallaahoufik
who says you have to say attaahiyaa if nowhere the quran says so. do you follow the quran or other thing?
The ones who actually followed The messener pbuh? On whom the quran was revealed ? Or am I following an 'other thing' , stick to the basics may Allah guide ME and YOU and ALL of US Amien
@@hanoow_2582 yes stick to the basic, stick to the quran. Cus that is what the prophet followed. Not hearsay and assumptions 200 years after his death
Soubhanallah
@@Biekoehow many salah you do for a day?
Where did he got guts to comment on the QURAN. ya Allah. my body is shaking everytime i see someone resisting the message of QURAN
The core problem at the center of hadiths is whether it's necessary or not, nothing guarantees any of it was actually said by the prophet. The sunnis always go into the debate with the assumption that everything said in it was actually said because Bukhari thinks so
And yes I know about the science of Hadith. It doesn't guarantee anything. Modern courts today wouldn't accept it, they want the first degree testimony not 2nd hand let alone 5th to 8th hand which is what hadiths are
What guarantee do you have that the Quran the way it is was what was revealed to the prophet?
@@samhangster mathematics
Because they wrote down all of it that was revealed on leafs, cows, pieces of sheet, etc and all of it was verified to the letter in the lifetime of the prophet, unlike hadiths which were never instructed to be written down or collected @@samhangster
Nice innovation
The first hadiths didn't spread till 250 years after the prophets death, so you're the innovator @@samhangster
I don't think anyone said you have to eat with hands, are some Muslims saying this is a must?? I don't think vast majority of Muslims think that at all. I never heard that.
Eating with your hands is a sunnah, this guy is making it seem like it’s a must and that Sunnis are barbaric for not using utensils. It’s a sunnah so you can choose to do it or not.
Even to this day in 2024, there are cultures and non-Muslim people all over the world that eat with with their hands btw
The wisdom is that even halal things can be harmful somewhat like in surah sad around 28-35 when Solomon got distracted by horse riding which is halal and forgot prayer. Even we fast from food and sex because it’s down bad and can distract you from remembering god. So all these halal things can be problematic so music is the same way. So hilarious if they say music haram, talking with others, sex, food, sports. All these can be haram 😂 because there overstimulation and it won’t help much having strong rememberance in god
can you call Christian Prince
How do u explain Qir'at without Hadith?
can you call Christian Prince
To recite something blindly is just dumb, Quran is to read and understand, not to dumbly recite back and forth
@@HaiderAli-ri1gb how can they understand when most Muslims don't speak Arabic?
@@moneyheist_- learn Arabic or translate. If you're blind ask someone trust worthy to read for you etc.
That's logic I just presented to you, first follow what's in the Quran then go on to Hadith and you'll know that Quran is complete. I would suggest you should learn Arabic .
@@HaiderAli-ri1gb learning Arabic is very hard. And most Quranic translations don't translate the Quran are literal as possible.
Even naive Arabic speakers don't understand the Quran, cause there is some gibberish in it, for example, do you understand what "كۤهیعۤصۤ" means?
The prayer is clear once you bring out the English and Arabic dictionary. It’s Sunnis who force there 5 prayer that creates issues and make Quran alone people confused. Very clear that it’s Fajr, sunsent and night
Fajr can also mean something else in Quran
The 5 daily prayers are detailed in the Quran.
30:17: So glorify Allah in the evening and in the morning
30:18: all praise is for Him in the heavens and the earth-as well as in the afternoon, and at noon.
17:79:
And rise at part of the night, offering additional prayers, so your Lord may raise you to a station of praise.
I've read his book. It makes a lot of reasonable points, issues probably not thought of by many, but I did not see any critical ones. And of course it only presents one side, i.e. does not point to the weaknesses.
can you call Christian Prince
why are u replying to every comment saying that u weirdo@@moneyheist_-
23:50 I may be wrong here but I actually think that this verse is prohibiting *nal s*x, I was thinking about this other day, the verse before is talking about approaching your wives during nights in Ramadhan. I dont think that God would uses vulgar language thats why that Door analogy, because it always sounded outta context to me But I may be wrong as I never heard of anyone saying something like it before.
I think that they invented that suposed arab costume Just because they could not understand the Verses. It happens a Lot actually. And I think that's good in some sort of way, because, If It was posssible to change the Qur'an to fit their narrative they would have done, which proves that they Qur'an was not changed, otherwise they would have to fabricate all of this hadiths.😊
I also have a different approach to hadith, more "organic", but IT's very hard to type with my cellphones broken display.
They would not have*
I don’t understand why they don’t understand 😢
Islam ie the religion of sunniism and shiaism is not in the quran. The 5 pullars of islam is not in the Qur'an. The quran stands on its own merits.
Islam isn't the Religion of hypocrite mushriks called sunnis and shias who worship mullas blindly, Islam is the religion chosen for us by God/ 5:3, 3:85, 22:78. And Prophet followed in vision and those who follow him/ 12:108, Quran is the vision/ 6:104, so we (Quran alone adherents) follow the Prophet and his companions, not sunnis who merely follow fabrications which have nothing with the Prophet and his companions or any Muslims.
I understand where you are coming from, but I'd say there are still some hadith's that are at the very least good to know and keep in mind. It's better when rituals are structured so there's no confusion about it. It's important to stay away from creating sects. What better way is there to settle on how these rituals should be done other than looking at how the prophet Muhammad saw did it? He is the best follower of the revelations.
people focus on the wrong things most of the time and I believe it’s party due to human nature, propensity towards herd mentality and garden variety incompetence. Most people they do NOT want to figure things out on their own but rather follow popular opinion, culture, traditions laid out by parents, peers, sheikh/priest/rabbi. Most people just don’t want to, own their own will, do the due diligence. Now when someone who thinks outside of these norms bring arguments against the popular narrative, people respond to it with either mockery or by fear. Being averse to something is a primal fear response and very very common. I left the religion Islam because there’s no religion called Islam as gods system in the Quran. Islam is a state of a person’s being and not a religion and it takes a life time of dedication, discipline and toil to reach that state and that much is very clear from the quranic guidance. Muhammad has no sunnah and his mission was not to “sunnah” people but to write down the revelation and bring that revelation to his community, which they clearly rejected. His mission was to bani Israel which makes sense because bani Israel is mentioned so many times in the Quran and muss is reference so much. Nowhere in the quran is he tasked with converting people to a new religion called Islam and contrary to popular belief the quran says had Muhammad tried to bring in a system outside from what he was mandated, his life vein would have been severed and he would be subjected to double the punishment. the Quran asks the reader several times in different ways, when will you think? When will you ponder? When will you leave the practices of your forefathers and approach this Quran trying to build an authentic connection with gos. Unfortunately people just don’t do it. I’m very content with the Quran, I read the Hadith and it’s so poorly written and an insult to human intelligence. Islam the religion never changed my life but the Quran did. There’s no praying to god, no going to a hajj, which imo is a scam to flees people off their hard earned money by the Saudi demonic system while making you worship stones, fasting is much more than a no drink no food fast, and giving charity is something you do during this month called Ramadan. I could go on and on but this much is enough. all praise to god, lord of all beings.
Mashallah, but i disagree on a couple of points some you mention elsewhere:
Pork is haram because God ordains it (there are bad components in it but it’s haram because God has decreed such).
Drink is not haram but a good provision for those who reason, meaning do it on occasion and not in excess for it will invalidate your prayer (16:67 and other); if you claim it’s haram be your own witness against yourself because most that say it’s haram drink. And for the record, I don’t drink at all by choice.
Jesus will return (4:159) for he has yet to die. Now that you cannot refute.
There is only one messiah Jesus pbh.
I have not said to them other than what You commanded me to say, that: 'You shall worship God, my Lord and your Lord.' I was witness over them for as long as I was among them. When You took me back, You were the Watcher over them. You are Witness over all things. 5:117
From this verse it is clear that Jesus was only a witness to the people when he was with them and when he was taken by God he was no longer a witness and God was the witness over the people. If Jesus was coming back he would have been a witness among the people twice.
A particularly important observation is found in the words "when You took me back" which were spoken by Jesus (5:117). Those words are in the past tense. Hence, when Jesus spoke those words it was after God raised him unto Him. Jesus was no longer on earth when he spoke those words, but somewhere in God's Kingdom
God said, "O Jesus, I am taking you back, raising you to Me and cleansing you of those who disbelieved." 3:55
Here in this verse again the same words are used "I am taking you back" supporting 5:117
5:75:
The Messiah, the son of Mary, was nothing but a messenger. Messengers have passed away before him. His mother was a woman of truth. They both ate food. See how We make the signs clear to them, yet see how they are deluded.
3:144:
And Muhammad is only a messenger. Messengers have passed away before him. So, if he dies or is killed, will you turn on your heels will not harm God and God will reward the thankful.
@@mustaphahaidar1321the Quran is incredibly precise in the choice of words. Jesus is always referred to in the past tense (was a Messenger). Trying to explain sentence structure and syntax to people who need hadith for micromanagement has been incredibly difficult.
@@comert1977 they ask you about gambling and intoxicants (not even wine), say in them are benefits for the people but also sin. And the sin outweigh the benefits. So will you not reason?!
There are NO BENEFITS in idolatry. If this Book would say what you and most of the so called born “Muslims” say repeating what you found your fathers saying but not actually following, I would be disappointed for life as it wouldn’t be a Revelation from the Lord of the Worlds. But since it is a revelation from the Lord of the Worlds, it says it JUST LIKE IT IS SUBHANALLAH!
Fornication is also from the play hand of the Shaytan…. Does that mean all sex is outlawed?! So will you not then reason?!?!??
@@QuranforTheWest from what i understand i believe alcohol is not haram but it contains sin. The sin is potential, occurring while under influence and varies in degree.
to be fair they did have utensils to eat back then too lol’ henxe why some hadiths mentioned its haram to have golden spoons etc the reason u eat with ur hand is for health benefits.
They did not have ustensile 🥄
That is why they hate with finger all the times few people hade them only the wealthy like the king and Jews and Christian..
They did not have chairs only few people the elite and Jew
That is why Muslims sit in the floors while the imam sit in the chair .,
In
Jew and Christian and the elite of the time use the stool and the elite used the high chair., thst is the reason Jew and Christian sit in chair in their church and synagogue..
And Muhammad Promised them these thing in heaven..
Ustensile in gold and silver
Sofa, things like this..
@@cocoalfaridah5831not Muhammad, God promised these things.
Mohammad I struggled to listen to you because of your cringe comedy sketches but in this video you have my ear and attention. Although I am not agreeing with you 100% I do see where you are coming from and understand your frustration. I am starting to agree with you on many things. barak allah feek
can you call Christian Prince
brother, genuinely curious and not meaning any disrespect. Because you do not believe in hadith how do you pray?
can you call Christian Prince
It is Muslim people with try to save their own honor who are fighting the Hadith.
It is not about religion or Muhammad but about their own personal ego and honor…
For 1400 years everything was fine .. until the kufar’shake it up for them..
Now they are seeing what the kufar’s saw and rejected thé aslim taslam religion
we battle hadith for Allah and the ummah, we have no reason to lie or try to be selfish, why waste time on research, debates just for ego? its better and easier to start bodybuilding, inject huge amounts of trenbolone and other narcotics and show off your muscles, the ego will be way larger
@@Modeltaok i understand!
Allah used the kufar’s to reaveal the truth to you Muslims because no Muslims will dare to bring those this up without being chopped up.., ostracized but Muslims themselves.,
He use the kufar’s to do the work you dare not to do..
@@cocoalfaridah5831 could you elaborate? what kufars and how did they reveal the truth, though the part of being chopped up is sadly true, though i dont fear anything except Allah.
@@Modelta your god Allah used his Ennemis the kufar’s by bringing things up for you to see what you are following..
He used his Ennemi for you…☺️
If you did it yourself they will chops your head or get kicked out from your community ans ostracized but your own ummah..
Look at what this guy going through with his own people ..
He used us the kufar’s to expose
Then how do we follow the prophet (PBUH) because in the Quran, Allah commands us to follow the prophet (PBUH)?
Quran tells you to follow the Revelations sent DOWN. The Prophet PBUH followed what was Revealed to him, follow the Prophet by following the Quran.
@@mgXL7 but you follow someone by following their ways
@@ryan6140 how so? Because i follow the Quran?
@@mgXL7 by definition if you follow someone, you do what they do and do and say what they say. You follow their teachings and as we know all of the prophets (PBUH) teachings are in the hadith.
And Allah commanded us to follow the prophet (PBUH) in: [Quran 4:59]
You are typical example of Google seikh guy.
We follow ulama. You follow google and yourself.
And yourself brought you to thousands mistake or should I call them lies.
Ulama said Bukhari didnt memorize 600 000 hadeeth.
Those where hadeeth, saying of sahaba, fatwas, different chains of narration. One hadeeth can have many chains. It is not different hadeeth. It is just different chain.
Are you lying to your followers or you are ignorant about these facts about the myth of 600K hadeeth of Bukhari?
We know you follow ulama, just like all mushrikoon. The Qur'an says Allah is the alim of the Qur'an, and that Christians worship their scholars
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah Insanity of a comment. I am mushrik now? May Allah guide you to straight path.
@@omerblagaj5107 Correct. You're not a Muslim. You commit shirk by associating the words of your scholars to Allah. May Allah guide you to Islam.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah you are insane. Seek mental help ASAP
@omerblagaj5107 "And they say,"O you upon whom the message has been sent down, indeed you are mad." 15:6
16:08 Where does it say "walk" between Safa and Marwa. You've got the translation of the verse wrong
طوفان is the same هرولة ؟
@@MuhammadfromGOD what does speed have to do with طواف??
@@MuhammadfromGOD 🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊
So, you prefer to make your own sunnah Vs the sunnah of the prophet?
Did we watch the same video?
To reject them all is as wrong as to believing in them all in my humble oppinion, i realy try to understand the quran only and still trying to make it make sense because there are so many fabricated and disgusting and evil hadith out there that are clearly from satan and his followers and not from our beloved prophet muhammad, and it would be so easy to follow only Quran and to just leave all the hadith but i just cant believe that the Prophet muhammad never said one word of wisdom or anything beneficial to his followers outside of Quran that maybe was written down by his followers for us to benefit from them , it just makes no sense, for me its i reject every hadith that contradicts quran even in the slightest way no matter how "sahih" it is , but hadith that are in line with Quran and not contradicting the quran in any way i didnt see a reason to reject them, actually everyone who is listening to for example this Brother Muhammad from God and taking from what he says is following his " Hadith" because Hadith simply is someones talk, statement or story , so to reject prophet Muhammads Hadith but taking anyone elses Hadith makes absolut no sense, by that logic anyone listening to this brother here should reject everything he says as long as its not direct Quran in matters of religion because otherwise he would not be a Quran only follower anymore by his own definition that is to follow only and strictly the Quran in Religion and rejecting every other sources in this religion that claims to have any kind of usefull information about this religion.
the only truly acceptable way to follow hadith is for historical knowledge, following hadith in any other way is useless, better to look at what Allah said than the same human kind that corrupted Allah's word 2 times before
but whats the point of following them if at the end of the day you only accept what agrees with the quran. Might as well follow quran only anyway
@TheStranger0509
When you say "reject all", you are being sensational. No one looks at the, let's say 800, or so DISTINCT reports in Sahih Bukhari and say each one is worthless. A few are interesting and reflect religious thinking by this or that group or, rarely, individual scholar. "Hadith rejection" is the rejection of the concept of Hadith, the rejection of affording Hadith a canonical status. Hadith overall, and by extension Sunni Islam, is a sour, sick, sad, sadistic joke. Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim when looked at and studied in their totality are disgusting. And yes, I am fluent in Arabic. But that doesn't matter.
To accept anything other than Quran is to accept Persian bullshit.
Doesn’t matter they can still be wrong. Accept it all or reject it all. No in between
Good Job Brother 👍❤
At 14:00 farid is right that u should take history from Hadiths
Yet it’s not reliable enough to take religious rulings from since it’s so far removed from
The time of the prophet
Basically just good enough to get an overview of things but to take things with a grain of salt to learn about the history
Not to take religious rulings from
One of the worst thing Muslims did to the Quran is comparing it to poetry.
Poetry does not have to be true, a poet can use any words that have the same connotation with the same meaning .
For example, a poet would say, dad, or father, interchangeably without any distinction.
Since Allah is the author of the Quran, I expect it to be precise . Not a letter extra nor a letter less. and it’s our duty as Muslims to dig deeper to try understand why this word was used in place of the other word and surprisingly sometimes you will uncover some new facts.
can you call Christian Prince
Peace Muhammad I hope you’re ok . Ive heard you debating Sunnis about praying the way they do and honestly brother I think that you’re trying hard to please them , if you only follow the Quran than the word salat has nothing to do with praying , salat has a completely deferent meaning and as the Quran has every detail and a complete book where did you get that the salat is praying 2,3,4,or 5 times a day and if you have me on your channel we can have a conversation about the true meaning of the word if you want .
can you call Christian Prince
Dont deceive yourself. If you don’t wanna pray just dont. Dont claim it is not in Quran. It is so pathetic. Because of people like you, people are staying away from Quran based Islam. You can find physical Salat in 4:102 in Quran.
When you ˹O Prophet˺ are ˹campaigning˺ with them and you lead them in prayer, let one group of them pray with you-while armed. When they prostrate themselves, let the other group stand guard behind them. Then the group that has not yet prayed will then join you in prayer-and let them be vigilant and armed.1 The disbelievers would wish to see you neglect your weapons and belongings, so they could launch a sweeping assault on you. But there is no blame if you lay aside your weapons when overcome by heavy rain or illness-but take precaution. Indeed, Allah has prepared a humiliating punishment for the disbelievers.
May Allah guide this brother from following his desires and give him the understanding of religion
how does following the book of Allah equal following desires?
@@Biekoe he is not following the book of Allah he is following his desires
The book says obey Allah and messenger
The book says we have reaveled this book and a hikmah with it what is this hikmah
In surah najam verse 53 or 52
Allah says the messenger doesn't say from his own desires.
And again Allah says what ever the messenger gives you take
Then in surat tawbah verse 100
Allah is pleased with the companions of prophet and says Allah is pleased with them and with those who follow them and thoes so called companions that he doesnt like spread the deen far as possible died in the name of Allah after the death of prophet just to spread his deen
Quran says remember Allah in abandunace
But the same quran says Allah sends his blessing on prophet oh who u believe send blessing on him what to do now
Allah says we have sent down this zikr and we will protect it why Allah didnt used the word book
So in simple he doesnt like the restrictions of hadith and self taught where as we are ordered to understand the book of Allah with the understanding of the prophet muhammed
@@cellmicroprocessor u are twisting it all. If u want to obey the messeneger, then u must obey the message which he brought which is the quran. Quran surah 46:9 says that the prophet only followed what was revealed to him. What was revealed to him? The quran or bukhari? The quran obviously. And about the ayah that speaks about whatever the messenger has given you take it. That talks about war. Whatever is left after war. Read the whole surah in stead of taking it out of context.
@@Biekoe i m not twisting the words i believe that this book is from the most wise so it does not have unnecessary speech
For example obey Allah and messenger how you follow Allah by following the quran and how you follow the messenger by following the quran what's the difference there was no need to put the messenger so if i take your understanding the verse would mean obey Allah and Allah
Allah has revealed a book and a book ??yani un necessary words
Double standards
Allah says what ever the messengers gives take it
No no you are twisting the meaning this is about the spoils of war and
But when Allah says do not forbid what i have made allowed to you but when we say this is only for the food you guys would reply no no this applies on all things
I gave you verses where Allah is telling you to follow the companions and other things which you ignored completely
Any how my job was to tell may Allah give u and me the understanding of the reilgion
@@cellmicroprocessor oke it is clear that i am wastin my time here. U are the type of person who even when you show him verses from the quran, he objects. U just dont want to understand so there is no point in talking to you. And no where does the quran say follow the companions. You dont know what ur talking about.
Muslims today have too much time on their hands to be debating silly things. An idle mind is shaytan’s workshop. Brother, you’re leading thousands of people to jahannam, May Allah guide us all.
I just don’t understand how a Muslim that claims to accept Muhammed saw as his prophet is refusing to take him as an example in his life. I don’t know about you but accepting him as my prophet means that I want to pray the way he did and eat the way he did and talk the way he did. And those things are not written in the Quran so it makes logical sense to me to follow the Quran AND the sunnah
Good points
If you don't believe Hadith then how you pray?
How did ibrahim pray? Did he have sahih al bukhari? No he didnt. Neithet did isa and musa peace be upon them. So how did they pray?
@@Biekoe bro you where not there how do you learn to pray I use Hadith. You are trying to run in circles
@@mycommintmycomment2312 what are you talking about. I just asked you a question. How did prophet ibrahim, isa and musa pray. Hadiths didnt exist in their time. So were these magnificent prophets unable to pray? You are the one avoiding the question
How did people pray before Hadith was compiled?
THINK.
@@mycommintmycomment2312
Muhammad never met those ppl in the hadith
When are you going to tell them, not to say Ameen after Surah Fatiha during salaat?
Haha yeah when i was still n hadith i always say amiin even now i still say it accidentally. May Allah forgive me.
I'm so glad I found this page... I was really losing my mind on how these hadiths are revered as if the Qur'an isn't perfect on its own... I thought having these conclusions was shaiyteen. Now I can confidently practice Islam. ❤️Alahumma barik!
May Allah bless you brother. More and more Sunnis are accepting Islam Alhamdullillah. And it is happening from people using their reason.
Me too brother im was lost whole mylife when i was just listening to hadith, like the quran is just reciting book. But now Alhamdulillah,
@aljineerjiningjining5741 Alhamdullillah, welcome to Islam brother
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah Alhamdulillah sheik shuaib taught me by the will of Allah. Alhamdulillah. It's all in the Quran.
@aljineerjiningjining5741 The Correctional Officer? May Allah reward him, he is a true lion of Islam and many Sunnis accepted Islam due to his dawah. However, remember to always verify and not to get all your information from one person without thinking. We can all make mistakes so we must constantly analyse everything.
Wait what? The devil didn't strip the clothes of Adam and eve... It's chapter 7 verses 18-22
He had them eat the apple and they revealed themselves to each other. They were already naked prior to eating.
They had no lust so they did not see each other with lust even while bald.
You may have some good points, but, you can't even read the quran without making serious mistakes, that actually change the meaning of the ayah.
can you call Christian Prince
Based
salam my dear bro! i’m new to islam and following quran only ❤ can you teach me how to pray? can i contact you on instagram or somewhere?
My brother you don't need to be taught how to pray beyond what Allah says in the Qur'an. Welcome to Islam and may Allah increase your iman
The punishment to adultery is prescribed by Allah and stoning, even if it was added at that time it was transgression, period.
MA Sha Allah brother is very consistent 😊
can you call Christian Prince
Who preserved the Quran ?
GOD
I hope Farid sees this and responds. As someone else has already said in the comments, A proper debate between these two would be really interesting
Farid is a smart guy, he exposed christian prince, Muhammad is also a smart guy
@@Modeltacan you call Christian Prince
@@moneyheist_- i dont call liars, so no i wont call him
@@Modelta you can give dawah to him
@@moneyheist_- he'll find a great lie and then lie more and nothing good will happen, how about he calls farid again?
Alhamdulilah for the truth, same thing that got christian’s. Shaytan is smart.. he’s been alive for billions of years and he knows God more than all of us and maybe even the prophets. Take care of the mind.
As yourself this, who’s more at risk of being wrong? Someone who rejects the teachings of a prophet he claims to follow(literally a part of the shahada) and only follows the Quran OR..someone who follows both!
"to someone who called some guy kafir because of he did not follow hadith blindly"
why you are tying to make historical claims your idol. just accept they contain good things but also false things legends and lies. don't you see accepting hadith ass a whole damaging credibility of islam. i born muslim was almost out of religion because of fairy tale collection of hadith.
now when i see a hadith
i do this
does it contradict quran?
does it add things to quran?
does it contaradict common sense?
if yes
i reject it.
if no i say
MAY BE IT IS CORRECT
but never 100%
noone can call me "kafir" "not muslim" because of this sincere attempt to reach truth.
I agree Sunna is not something obligatory but are good things to base yourself and aplly in your life. They arent dispossable as you say and they carry positive things in adapty this sunnas in your day yo day life. I agree that pray shouldnt be obligatory in specific rule, just pray is ennoutgh to God but if you desire to pray in that way doesnt make you a mushirikin too you are just doing a extra. In my understanding QURAN is the LAW sunna are good behaves. This cant be so hard to be understand there is not mushirikin if you dont see the sunna as obligation. If the sunna is against the quran is simple, discart it, but so far i didnt found one that does that.
You’re watching someone that’s very premature in knowledge
Christ YESHUA is your KING... I used to be in Catholic religion and when I found out that the Vatican worships shaytan, I left that evil religion and went against my parents for Christ... Same with the Muslims, I'm sure they are in the same boat, man made religion... Trust me Christ YESHUA of the Bible is not the same as ISA from the Quran... If you can get out of it, then you know at that moment Christ YESHUA has a mission for you...
Return to Karaite Judaism! Qu'ranites are actually Jewish beliefs
@@magnuscritikaleak5045 Yeah it's a same religion the Abrahamic religion. What are you trying to propagate here?
2 minutes in and you're ATTEMPTING to patronize him by assuming his personal history. What an embarrassing attempt at philosophical bullying
i disagree if the prophet came back and saw these times with tall buildings and women dressed and yet naked he would ask Allah to take his soul
Bro I agree with your stance on Quran, but not your opening stance, eating with hands will always be better as utensils leaves behind residue that’s harmful, all new technology is harmful in ways we don’t see, whereby miswak is scientifically the best way to clean teeth, do you know what fluoride does to you? … in all honesty technology has more cons than pros, but we grew into it as a norm, I can just assume just like you, if going according to the Qurans view of the prophet, he wouldn’t have all these luxuries, and if he did then he would have given it all away..
Is hijab mandatory?
Very contentious question, indeed what traditionalists--hadiths deem the Khimar as a piece of cloth that put over/ bring down towards the chest region, justifies the Hijab, however in the Qu'ran the surah decrees following Modesty at its time when women wore the Khimar on their head to bring it down, it doesn't mean Hijab specifically.
@@magnuscritikaleak5045 was the khimar a piece that covers the head? *That went over the head?
This is why the Quranists/ Quran only group has nothing to stand on. There is no answer for this issue whatsoever for the Quranist.
There was a time the prophet (saw) was gone and the Quran was in the hands of others; complete strangers; and not in large quantities. Actually if you can’t look at history at all (which Quranists admit they can not) we wouldn’t know if there was one copy or 2 or 3. So the question is......After the death of the prophet (saw); Who were the ones in charge and in possession of the Quran at that time? Say like a year or two after he was gone? Who were they and how do you know they didn’t tamper with the Quran.? Can you give us some names?
Using Quran only you cannot. You can’t provide one name of who had it using the Quran alone as your only reference. You know how ridiculous that is? How do you know for certain, verses like ‘this is a book with no doubt’; ‘nothing is left out’ , ‘a blessed book’ ; ‘we will protect this book’ etc etc weren’t just added in by those people?
Anyone with a functioning brain knows the first thing someone who tampers with a book would write down in that very book is that no one tampered with the book. That’s common sense.
Even more significant and a crushing blow to every Quranist; is how can Quran only people prove some verses or entire chapters weren’t taken out??? Some try to answer this huge crisis of faith by just claiming to believe in the Quran alone just because of its message. That doesn’t work either. The message is beautiful no doubt. But still it remains things could have been removed and outright omitted while maintaining the beauty of the book. You would have no clue if there was even more in it; making that point irrelevant.
To make it even worse for the Quranite; Do you people even realize that this is the exact thing that actually did in fact happen to the two previous scriptures? The Torah and the injeel. Those books had portions removed from the original.! This is even confirmed in the Quran. Some argue extremely large portions. So the possibility was very very real.
And it still gets even worse for the Quranite. The Quran itself talks about the Prophet (saw) having enemies who were against him. Proving there were people who were motivated to alter and harm the message of Allah.
All this being considered I find it hard to believe the true religion of Allah would have no answer to who even had possession of the literal word of God after the prophet (saw) was gone. It is illogical and borderline idiotic to think Allah would have the most important event in history (the revelation of the Quran) be unverifiable just like the previous revelations who’s messages were mangled.
The Quran only sect has no way whatsoever of proving the authenticity of the Quran using the Quran alone, making the entire foundation of their faith crumble to dust. And please don’t use Abu bakr or any other sahaba. You can’t double talk your way out of this. That’s historical info. The same historical info you reject with hadeeths. Using Quran alone you have no ability to verify the Quran. I’ve done my best to explain it clearly. No Quranist has been able to answer the question. Because they have no valid answer. You will stand alone before Allah. You must reflect on this. May Allah guide us all.
The Qur'an is proven through code 19. A mathematical miracle of Allah that proves the authenticity of the Qur'an without a doubt. And not only that, but it shows that your beloved sahaba made tahreef in the mushafs, but because of the code, the Qur'an was numerically preserved.
So now let's flip the question back at you. What is your evidence for your mushafs and hadiths? That a bunch of people said so?
And your piece of evidence that easily dismantles your argument is a book that came almost 300 years later and that only contains 5th degree testimonies ?
He still won't understand, believe me
Why are you keeping a beard is you don’t follow the sunnah
People who entered from the the back door were slaves. Allah (swt) is telling the Muslim to demand equitable treatment by entering the house the way an honored guest would enter a house, from the front door.
can you call Christian Prince
@@moneyheist_- CP is a grifter who is only interested getting into the bank accounts of his audience. He uses grifting techniques which are not conducive to an academic discussion. Besides, I have no interest in contributing to CPs videos from which he grifts from an audience that is ill informed to say the least.
@@hollyaldahir5116what happened to giving Dawah to your brothers
@@moneyheist_- My dawah is my posts on web sites like this one.
@@hollyaldahir5116 my friend, call Christian Prince is a good 👍 way to give dawah to your Christian brothers and save them from going to hell?
Talmud levels.
Ignores all context of Civil Wars
This is laughable, lm pretty sure that there’s no mention of dressing in the Quran So is it Permissible to go out naked ya shaykh??
And what you’re doing is a red herring arguement in the Quran it’s clearly states u must follow the prophet and his teachings and how else would you get that information??
can you call Christian Prince
where does the quran say follow the teachings of the prophet?
@@Biekoe there’s a few places Surat Nisa stay 59 & Surat Hashr aya 7 to name a couple. These ayas are direct orders saying “ obey Allah and his prophet” he mentions his prophet in the same aya refering to obedience highlighting the important of following the prophet. Step one and two go hand in hand.
@@hamedizzy5137 it doesnt say obey they prophet. It says obey the messenger. Why do you twist the ayah. It didnt say “nabi” it says “messenger”. And the messenger is the one to whom the quran was revealed and who followed the quran. Not his own rulings in terms of religion.
@@Biekoe yes prophet mohammad. The Quran only refers to following prophet mohammad that’s who it was revealed to and he is the final messenger and prophet
You are definitely a Quranist...
And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him)) gives you, take it, and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it)”
[al-Hashr 59:7]
Do not treat the Messenger’s summons to you ˹as lightly˺ as your summons to one another.1 Allah certainly knows those of you who slip away, hiding behind others.2 So let those who disobey his orders beware, for an affliction may befall them, or a painful torment may overtake them.
The Prophet (ﷺ) said: Beware! I have been given the Qur'an and something like it, yet the time is coming when a man replete on his couch will say: Keep to the Qur'an; what you find in it to be permissible treat as permissible, and what you find in it to be prohibited treat as prohibited. Beware! The domestic ass, beasts of prey with fangs, a find belonging to confederate, unless its owner does not want it, are not permissible to you If anyone comes to some people, they must entertain him, but if they do not, he has a right to mulct them to an amount equivalent to his entertainment.
Cmon man?
GOD is challenging people to bring some the like of Thq Quran
@@MuhammadfromGOD how does this relate to the verses i provided.
You quoted a Hadith saying “I was given the Quran and something like it”
GOD is challenging the whole world to being something like the Quran.
@@MuhammadfromGOD أَلاَ هَلْ عَسَى رَجُلٌ يَبْلُغُهُ الْحَدِيثُ عَنِّي وَهُوَ مُتَّكِئٌ عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ فَيَقُولُ بَيْنَنَا وَبَيْنَكُمْ كِتَابُ اللَّهِ فَمَا وَجَدْنَا فِيهِ حَلاَلاً اسْتَحْلَلْنَاهُ وَمَا وَجَدْنَا فِيهِ حَرَامًا حَرَّمْنَاهُ وَإِنَّ مَا حَرَّمَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم كَمَا حَرَّمَ اللَّهُ "
that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "Lo! Soon a Hadith from me will be conveyed to a man, while he is reclining on his couch, and he says: 'Between us and you is Allah's Book. So whatever we find in it that is lawful, we consider lawful, and whatever we find in it that is unlawful, we consider it unlawful.' Indeed whatever the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) made unlawful, it is the same as what Allah made unlawful."
Hence the verse.
Tiirmidhi 2664
@@MuhammadfromGOD أَلاَ إِنِّي أُوتِيتُ الْكِتَابَ وَمِثْلَهُ
What’s the point you’re tryna make. The verse in the Quran? I agree that no one could produce anything like the Qur’an. The issue I have with you is the various verses where it says to follow the Prophet ﷺ . The Quran was revealed to Him, you don’t think he has a better idea of the religion than you and I or any Human after him.
☝️☝️☝️ Hadiths are absolutely necessary there is no on this planet who could have made people understand holy better than prophet Muhammad saww himself on whom was holy Quran was revealed. I don't need to say more.
Allah can explain Quran to us better,
Prophet wasn't allowed to interpret.
His only duty was the delivery/ 5:99.
+ your Hadiths have nothing with the Prophet. You only follow Tafsir of mullas. You sunnis have nothing with the Prophet and Qur'an and Islam.
@@AgustusAtrahasiscan you call Christian Prince
@@moneyheist_- he's a coward who mutes people, ofcourse I can call, I already tried 2ce, both times he noticed me,
first time he challenged me but didn't even mention me in his next videos while I was debating 10s of his minions under his comment section and I refuted his whole 2 hour video with a long brief response before, but he didn't even mention me in his next videos, but he mentioned some naive sunni, while my comments were like 100s, why'd he pick a weak opponent? Cuz as I said he's a coward.
Next time (after a long time), I made a mess in his live comment section, as I was exposing embarrassing places of his Bible in comments and finally CP noticed and challenged me, I told him to give his link for voice chat, he claimed to give but he gave some sunni Hadith while I follow Qur'an alone, I told him that he didn't give a link to his live, he ignored, and he claimed he gave a link, I said imaginary link, and he got triggered and started showing more Hadiths, and muted me, again, he's a coward,
if he can debate without muting and lying, I'm for it, but I already witnessed his coward tricks at me twice so I didn't try again.
@@AgustusAtrahasis you have just called him and speak to him like a man not hide in the comment section. CP has debated many without muting, there are honest people, for example his debate with a PhD Sheikh called Rohi from azar university in Egypt, it's one of the biggest Islamic universities in the world.
@@moneyheist_- so first he calls, then he mutes and lies, and his minions try to name call after that, you think your tricks work at me?
Many of his debating opponents are his own minions, many times he got caught debating same person who each time claimed to be a Muslim and claimed to convert, his voice, tone and indian accent got familiar as he kept returning with the same trick, so CP got embarrassed after people noticed him and told him to leave and blocked, that's just one of examples, CP has many such minion actors who pretend to be Muslim and pretend to convert after the debate.
And even sunni Farid exposed around 100s of lies of CP, and even challenged him to an open debate, as did Shaikh Uthman and many others even by offering CP to wear a niqab and bring guards if he's so afraid of his identity and security, CP just hides, he's the coward.
He's nobody that I'd go to him, he already lost my respect the first time, and I gave him another chance, and he failed again, so if what, let him come to me and debate me, I'm here in comments, he can use comments too and text, let him come to me, he's nobody that I'd go to him.
Hajj it's not pilgrimage according to Quran , Hajj is a debate / giving good argument etc... as Ibrahim did in Quran .
Plus i don't think bait Al Haram is a physical building .
Ibrahim buit al qawa3ida ...the foundation of Deen MINA AL Bait ...he got the foundation from the Bait not FOR the bait .
So words like Bait and masjid al Haram etc... are not buildings in Saoudia .
Same as woujuhakum doesn't mean faces , instead it's direction .. al Masjid Al haram from my understanding is the Quran . Allah knows best .
oh are you the same person who knows Quran so much at the same time but isnt properly able to recite
Have you considered that my primary language is English
And since you love your Hadith so much - isn’t there a Hadith that those that struggle with reciting the Quran get double the reward
Or do you hate us for believing in GOD and rejecting what you associate to GOD
@@MuhammadfromGOD The reason I disagree with you is, that the details of many things mentioned in Quran are in hadiths. I agree that some hadiths like that about sahaba have caused fitnah and division, but hadiths which provide details of Quranic verses and commands like that of Salah,are the reason for us being United today, and of us being disciplined today.
WHAT I IN A NUTSHELL MEAN IS THE HADITHS THAT SHOW US PROPHET'S WAY OF FOLLOWING THE QURAN AND ITS COMMANDS ARE THE ONES THAT WE SHOULD TAKE, BECAUSE QURAN SAYS TO FOLLOW THE PROPHET PBUH, AND HOW CAN WE DO THAT WITHOUT KNOWING WHAT PROPHET PBUH DID?
@@MuhammadfromGOD I hope you read what I have to say. Its okay that you can't recite the Qur'an properly, but you must learn. I myself am indian , but I recite the Qur'an quite properly using the signs
@@CommonManMTahoorHAllah: The Qur'an is fully detailed
You: Details of Qur'an are found in hadiths
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah Answer this. Why did all the companions of the Prophet follow him and his ways of nimaz and everything?
Was that because Quran says follow the Prophet or did they do bidah and commit kufr?
I say Quran is fully detailed and it says to follow Prophet PBUH, you say no Quran is fully detailed and lets leave Prophet PBUH and his guidance.
I like to speak to you muhammed from god.
Me myself can't fınd sunni islam in the kuran, a good person who is a close friend who fears allah is from a sunni background, and he also cant proof sunni islam and sunni from muhhamed (the rasul allah ) could be found in the kuran.
Still he think sunni islam is from allah and that allah gave to muhammed a sunna, bla bla no proof, only ı can't proof it is for certain a default to say muhammed saws had a sunna for himself and for his followers.
Still as long there is no proof for a sunna of muhammed ı reject to say something like ı am sunni ore muhammed saws had a sunna,
I think what is better to be a muhtad with proof ore to be a sunni without proof.
And ı thought it would be great to speak to you, because 1 reason ı fınd it locigal the most way you think and make youre video's about,
If you like to react ı would be thankful, ı want to say ı know muhammed saws he is a witness over me, ı know ibrahim saws ı walked with hım, and ı was on the arsh of allah and spoke with hım, ı also saw many Angels came from the sky and ı spoke with three of them.
And ı won't never lie about such ımportant things.
Selam and may allah guide you himself. The Best guide the teacher the Best helper, the creator who knows everthing about his creation.
May Allah bless you brother. Allah is showing you the true light of Islam.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah thank you and may allah guide you himself the best guide the best teacher the Best helper.
I adhere to Qur'ān alone
I don't agree with some of your claims.
1. I agree. They don't listen to us,
And they attack a presupposition.
2. I don't agree, sunnah is static,
God applied same sunnah for all.
And what Prophet said is general,
But the problem is, sunni Hadiths
Are MOSTLY not from the Prophet.
Maybe all, cuz who allowed Hadiths,
According to their own sunni history,
Prophet didn't allow to write Hadith
And ordered to burn any they find
+ punish the rumor spreaders/ 33:60
And 4 Khaliphs didn't allow Hadiths
And ordered to destroy any they find
And punish whoever writes Ahadith.
Only in Umayyad Khaliphate, later,
Cuz of the rise of Hadith only sect
Khaliph Umar the second allowed
Hadiths being written, 100s of years,
yet oldest known Sira to be authored
Is in time of Muawiyah's khaliphate,
Which is after 4 Khaliphs, "1st fitnah"
Which they call tho there were fitnah
Even before, anyway, and where's it?
And oldest surviving Hadith known
Is that which is attributed to Bukhari
5 to 7 or more generations after him,
And he was claimedly 5 to 7 or more
Generations after the last Prophet,
So they've no original or any copies
Of Bukhari, but only 500 or 800 years
After Bukhari, by the Ottoman writers
Which they mass produced after it,
& ironically, they themselves claim
That Bukhari was called a heretic
In his time, so if they stick to "ijma"
They should deny Bukhari actually
But sunnis are hypocrite ignorants.
So in short, what I wanna say is
Hadiths are 11+th century books,
While Qur'an can be dated earlier,
Kuffar hardly agree to 9th century,
But some claim it dates to earlier
And even one has blood of Uthman.
Yet sunnis say same people brought,
Sunnis are obviously very arrogant.
They didn't even have same criterion,
Sunni Hadiths have no 4 witnesses,
While Hafs we have has 4 witnesses
Which chain back to even Uthman,
So we can use it with Uthmanic,
And ofc it chains to the Prophet.
Plus, sunni hadiths are a bunch of
Direct attacks at the last Prophet
And all Muslims and whole Islam.
I haven't found even 1 Hadith
Which doesn't contradict Quran
And I can challenge the sunnis
(And I've challenged them a lot)
To show me any "good" Hadith,
& they all fail when I show Quran,
All they say is, we don't know much
Talk to "scholars", while those mullas
Just hide, ignore, mute and block us,
Just as much of their sunni leymen,
and they just run away after that.
Like saying "may Allah guide you",
Qur'ān is the guidance from Allah,
They're obviously the misguided,
When Allah calls Qur'ān clear/ 12:1,
They say, no it's not clear, rejectors.
Just as you use say "I interpret",
Quran is clear, what to interpret?
I take Qur'ān literally, it has no error,
People should stop mixing excess.
& if we say it's fully detailed/ 6:114,
And that it had all examples/ 18:54,
They say, no, it has no detail of salah
Or zakah or example of the Prophet,
Just as you said it has no structure
And that it has no modern examples,
And that "Hadiths were necessary"
For the time of Prophet? Absurd,
He had no right to make sharia,
Only Allah ordains religion for us.
Taking sharia of others is shirk/ 42:21.
(
So consider these, and fix yourself,
Also fix your saying "God inspired"
As you lied about wide open eyes
Inventing falsehood about Allah,
Allah doesn't contradict Himself,
He orders us to lower our gazes,
Who's worse than he who invents
Falsehood about Allah or turns away?
That's why I unsubscribed from you,
Allah doesn't need you, remember it,
He'll take your actions into account,
Disbelief and misleading others
Makes your deeds futile/ 47:1,
Don't say warners didn't come,
While you arrogantly turn away.
)
That's just about the beginning
I haven't watched that fully yet.
+ befriending mushrik hypocrites
Like sunnis and jews and others,
And not reconciling with Muslims
Like how you ignored me/ 4:144,
Hypocrites will be in the lowest
Depth of the HellFire/ 4:145.
I didn't say a lie about GOD.
You weren't present, you didn't experience what I experienced during the making of the thumbnail; and I don't agree with your interpretation on the verse about lowering the gaze.
I appreciate your input; and when I was talking about the sunnah being static - I was addressing their definition of sunnah; not what GOD has explain the sunnah is in the Quran.
I understand you have it in you to keep talking down to me; if you claim you know more than me and feel the desire that you constantly need to talk down at me, and what you accused me of a few times now; please go ahead and start to spread the message of GOD; and if your LORD wants to proliferate you online, then that's your blessing.,
Regardless, GOD said that believers are supposed to be forgiven and merciful among each other; you are addressing me like as I did shirk.
+ remove your tattoos.
@@MuhammadfromGOD I repeat,
"Who's worse" than he who invents
Falsehood about Allah or denies
His āyāt/ 10:17, or turns away/ 18:57.
And how is that you think
That I'm putting you down?
I'm advising, it's to rise you up,
You're putting yourself down
By persisting in ignorance
& nor reforming yourself.
It's Haram to say about Allah
That which we don't know/ 7:33.
And you say that God inspired you?
Who said I'm interpreting?
I take Qur'an literally as it is,
Cuz I don't like to fool myself.
Like for example, when I read
Surah (33) Al-Ahzab, verse 37,
I had heard of different views,
Like some even saying that
It's about Prophet at war,
And zaid means profit,
And sunnis add absurdity,
But I had removed sunni lies,
& reading that chapter in context,
Made me realize, it's clearly Zaid,
It's about a human, Qur'an is clear,
You should stop trying to interpret,
Because we don't know the Unseen
Only Allah knows it's interpretation.
(We should read it straightly/ 2:121,
And take it as a whole/ 2:26, 3:7,
Quran is clear as a whole/ 12:1.)
Now about sunnah of rasul,
All prophets followed 1 sunnah,
For which they can be no change,
Why'd you use an abused Arabic
Instead of correcting sunnis?
And what do you mean by forgive?
Am I fighting you or holding grudge?
I'm advising. God orders to forgive
Even those who don't even expect
The meeting with Him/ 45:14-15.
How do you tell me to forgive
That which you didn't reform?
Tho I've no grudge to forgive,
I'm just advising, read 3:104.
Don't follow which you don't know,
You say God inspired, I was a sufi,
I know how silly is your state now,
If you go on thinking that whatever
You think about God is true, you'll
End up misleading yourself more.
Alhamdulillah, God opened my eyes
And I repented of that fantasy world.
+ how does burning hand
Mean Allah orders to not
Burn our hand? Baseless.
That you claim you got
Outside of Qur'an, right?
(Allah said that He knows
And we do not know/ 2:214,
So you can't say that the karh
Means you should avoid that.)
So you don't adhere to Quran alone,
While Prophet followed Qur'an alone.
And ofcourse I'm more guided,
I don't say about Allah excess,
I advise and listen to advises,
I don't ally kuffar & munafiqīn,
And I believe believers unseen.
And you think you're more guided
Only cuz you have this platform?
What makes you know my state?
Besides, you try to guide kuffar?
It's useless to advise them/ 2:6.
So what benefit are you doing?
Prophet was ordered to leave
The disbelievers, read 51:54,
And many verses like that.
So why don't you leave them?
As it's useless to advise them,
So why do I need a platform?
I know why, to remove fitnah,
But you're causing more fitnah,
So that's why I unsubscribed.
I did my best to advise online,
And offline, I still don't give up,
Even if I'm the only Qur'an alone
Follower in my city I ever know
And I got harmed physically,
Financially, verbally, spiritually,
And online I got muted, banned,
I still didn't give up on my faith,
What'd you know about me?
I have no financial comforts
To make platforms like that,
And I'm under constant threat,
And pressure that I deleted a lot.
So you just showed your silliness
By thinking you're better by channel.
+ if I had a channel,
I wish I'd recite Qur'an,
But you can't even recite,
Why don't you fix your tajweed?
Read Quran properly/ 2:121.
@@MuhammadfromGOD
You didn't address all my claims,
You wanna guide the blind people
Who see themselves self sufficient
But with someone who fears God
You don't even wanna discuss?
They are not only necessary but a requirement as well. Nice try but failed!
Hadith is a requirement? Prove it by citing the Quran!
And verily in the Messenger of Allah ye have a good example for him who looketh unto Allah and the last day and remembereth Allah much. (Al-Ahzab 33:21)
Chapter 16, verse 44: "and We have sent down unto thee (also) the Message; that thou mayest explain clearly to men what is sent for them,"
The Message = Quran, Explanation = Hadith
surah 59, verse 7: "and whatever the Messenger gives you, accept it, and from whatever he forbids you, keep back", essentially meaning to follow everything Mohammad gives us, and abstain from everything he forbids.
@@zaidxdesign4744 where does Allah mention hadith of Prophet is a requirement in the Quran?
Verse 33:21 is self explanatory. You already have a good example in the Messenger due to his faith in God and the Last Day and remembers God often.
The "good example" in 33:21 speaks of 3 specific acts:
1- Seeking God
2- Seeking the Last Day (Hereafter)
3- Thinking about God constantly.
16:44:
..that you may make clear to the people what was sent down to them, and that they might reflect.
Is this what Hadith is? Explanation of the Quran? The hadith contains inadequate amount of Prophetic commentary of the Quran. Did Allah say making clear the revelations is hadith?
59:7: you manipulatively twist and butcher the verse citing portion of it. The verse is in reference to distribution of gains from an exiled town. The Messenger cannot forbid anything as a religious law. Religious law is only defined by God. Veree 5:41 is for the likes of you people...
5:41:
O Messenger, let them not grieve you who hasten into disbelief of those who say, "We believe" with their mouths, but their hearts believe not, and from among the Jews. [They are] avid listeners to falsehood, listening to another people who have not come to you. They distort words beyond their [proper] places [i.e., usages], saying, "If you are given this, take it; but if you are not given it, then beware." But he for whom Allāh intends fitnah - never will you possess [power to do] for him a thing against Allāh. Those are the ones for whom Allāh does not intend to purify their hearts. For them in this world is disgrace, and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment.
5:47:
..And those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed are ˹truly˺ the rebellious.
6:114:
[Say], "Then is it other than Allāh I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book [i.e., the Qur’ān] explained in detail?" And those to whom We gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters.
@@zaidxdesign4744 60:4: You already have an excellent example in Abraham and those with him....
60:6:
You certainly have an excellent example in them for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day. But whoever turns away, then surely Allah ˹alone˺ is the Self-Sufficient, Praiseworthy.
you distort the verses well, better than shaytan could, obeying the messenger is obeying the Quran, the sole purpose of a messenger is to convey Allah's message (Quran 5:99), obeying Musa = obeying Tawrat, obeying Isa = obeying Injil, obeying Muhammad = obeying Quran, Muhammad has no other purpose but to give the message, if you think otherwise, you are rejecting Allah's clear word.@@zaidxdesign4744
Debate Hassan Allahyari
can you call Christian Prince
Repeating nonsense a hundred times won't make your arguments rational or logical. Return to Islam before it is too late.
Allah has guided him Alhamdullillah. I invite you to renounce Sunniism and become a Muslim. Leave behind your false traditions and shirk and submit to your creator.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah I am a revert myself and have studied Islam. I invite you back to Islam. May Allah open your heart. As far as this Muhammad bloke goes him and you are on clear misguidance.
@zaidxdesign4744 I am a revert. I was an atheist until I read the Qur'an and experienced its light. I asked Allah to guide me and he did. He protected me from the misguidance of the mushrikoon and kept me steadfast upon Islam. You're not a revert. You haven't yet accepted Islam. Islam requires the renunciation of shirk and adherence to God's law. I invite you to take the next step and accept Islam. May Allah guide you, ameen 🤲
I am sorry to say my friend that you are still on misguidance. Regardless,, my journey to Islam wasn't easy either. It is the "religion" I hated the most. Started an an atheist, studied Christianity, Hinduism then was an agnostic for a while before finally studying the Quran and becoming a Muslim. Allah guided me and in the beginning I too was confused like the Munkareen e Hadith but Allah gave me the ability to study sciences of Hadith alhamdulillah and opened my heart to the knowledge and Allah protected me from misguidance. I invite you to take the next step, accept Islam and become a Muslim. may Allah open your heart to the correct understanding of Islam. Admen@@Quran_Alone_Dawah
this guy quran alone dawah is mentally ill person, dont interact with him.