Another Cover Lover Evergreen Barbara Streisand then cover by Lucy Thomas
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 07. 2023
- #react #reaction #anothercoverlover #barbarastreisand #lucythomas
This was a suggestion from Tony "Top Gun" Gunnell Good call brother!!
Both are amazing but LT really shines.
Lucy is simply amazing and it is an absolute privilege to listen to her! In my opinion easily the best singer I have ever heard!😯
Lucy can’t hold a candle to Barbra! I don’t appreciate it when a singer can’t be original and has to siphon music from a true artist. She also relies too much on her usual auto tune while Streisand never had auto-tune in the 1970’s. Next wannabe!!
@@ceegarcia3399 Pure garbage ....! FFS
You are absolutely correct about the greatness of Lucy Thomas. Lucy is not a Streisand wannabe, She is already better than Streisand.
@@wilburfinnigan2142agreed
@@wilburfinnigan2142 Wilbur, ignore this 'ceegarcia' troll on here; I've dealt with this person before on other reaction videos with Lucy and all I hear is a bunch of rubbish with NOTHING to back it up! We just saw the LIVE concert Lucy did for the Best's and their friends and family a couple of weeks ago and we all know Lucy does NOT use 'auto-tune', 'lip sync', or any other crap like that! Lucy now has 10 original performances from "Rosie" and "A Brand New Day" so this proves that people who talk down about Lucy have done ZERO research on her career!!
Simply no comparison Lucy reigns supreme !!
WOW ! WOW ! Lucy's version of this classic was absolutely perfect her tone and clarity are master class. Every song she takes on she improves and makes better , and at 19 years old that is truly amazing. Great performance Lucy .
Right on!!
Fake
@@ceegarcia3399 How so? What’s fake?
There is nothing fake about Lucy@@ceegarcia3399
@@JeffHoffman-tr8fr ceegarcia can't answer you because he really has nothing to say.
When Lucy dropped this song, after listening to it, I listened to a studio version and found that Lucy has a better rounded and fuller sound.
The last note also was so smooth.
As always when she flashes the smile at the end it was so natural.
Lucy simply gets better and better as she continues to mature and grow into her talent. This young woman is simply stunning.
Just another cover singer Barbra wannabe! Lol
Hi. It looks you were bewitched by Lucy like most of her listeners. You are doing a lot of reactions with her.
Here we have two exceptional artists. Each taking the song their way.
I love Lucy version , because her voice is "warmer", her performance more genuine and sincere. ❤🥰👍
But I cannot be objective when we speak about Lucy.😉🤗.
For me Lucy is simply the best singer .
I agree Anthony
Nice reaction to 2 top-notch vocalists. Barbra is wonderful and Lucy is fantastic and they both deserve an award for this great song!
Love your reactions👍. Comparing Lucy's voice with other singers is like comparing a full symphony orchestra to a string quartet. That's not to disparage Barbra Streisand, she was a great singer in her own right.
Agreed
Barbra had a great 60 year career, and this song was big. Lucy has a 10 year career. She is still only 19 and not in full bloom yet. What performances will she give us to enjoy in the future? I hope to see some more of it. I'm way too old but she is my favorite of all time. Her sweet tone and vibrato just melts me. Keep on the Lucy train. We'll be able to say we knew her when, thanks to Jeff and his channel, Thanks brother. 🤠
Thank You Jeff and well said. I still owe you call.
Hi Glad to see that you have recovered and a good reaction to this song. I am Lucy Thomas fan so I prefer Lucy´s version her voice is out of this world and for someone so young to have such control beggars belief .Her pitch is perfect, her enunciation is perfect her Vibrato is exquisite no one does vibrato like Lucy. In this song she holds that last note for 17 seconds and ends in a perfect vibrato. Chris Broom Award winning songwriter and owner of Cavendish records the Label Lucy is under. Said he was introduced to Lucy when she was 13 and that he knew then that she had the potential to become one of the greatest female vocalist of times ,He said she had the rare ability to bring the audience into the song. He was so impressed with her that he asked her to record his song "One Day" which is on her premier Album the following year after she was a semi finalist in the voice Kids Uk he offered her a record contract and Lucy is still with Chris today. He is Writing a musical for Lucy to star in Called Rossie which opens in London´s West End next year. Lucy has pre recorded some of the songs which you can find on her channel Lucy Thomas Music .Thanks again for reacting to Lucy.
I believe it is Rosie,. just one F!
I used to like Barbara’s version and really I still do. I don’t know what to say about Lucy. How do you explain perfection. I think this is the best performance from Lucy yet. Thank for the review and support of Lucy. One more thing Barbara your the greatest.
Absolutely
Thank you for watching
A classic covered by a fine new artist that should have a long career ahead of her. What a great way to keep a song alive. Streisand not only sang the original, but won an Academy Award for writing the music. (Paul Williams received one for the lyrics). Astonishingly, she was the first woman in the history of the Academy Awards to win an Oscar for composing. Btw, in the movie, John Norman Howard's (aka Kris) band was called "The Speedway". This group was definitely made up of legit musicians who not only worked with Kris historically, but other artists from Dylan to Maurice White. Off screen Kris was a member of "The Highway Men" comprised of himself, Johnny Cash, Willie Nelson, and Waylon Jennings.
Brett, hey, I'm with you on this! Barbra has won so many awards and titles; she is a legend, and rightfully so! Lucy has said on many occasions she has admired Barbra since she was young, as evidenced by this performance here! I made a huge mistake..........oh, wait, this is a good mistake.......I viewed the first 10 seconds and then fell out of my chair of Lucy's "My Heart Will Go On", by Celine Dion.........listened to the rest of this masterpiece........then a 2nd time.......then my next Lucy performance was "Hallelujah".........and then off we went into the Lucy Thomas 'rabbit hole' for the next 2 hours.......best 2 hours of my life discovering the best solo performer I have ever heard or seen.......
@@briankrames1883 Cool. But tell me where I am cuz I'm lost! 😅
@@BrettTwinSavage Brett, Lucy Thomas Music; I recommend starting with "Hallelujaah", then wherever your heart & soul will take you.......into Lucy's musical realm........just sit back and enjoy the ride......the 'magic' of Lucy Thomas
Yers, two great singer's by two great performances. Lucy has beautiful tone quality and amazing vocals. Lucy can sing any song's and makes is her own version's.
I agreed E! Please come back for more!!
I Love Lucy! Lucy held that last note for 14 seconds.
I want to see Lucy, Tina S, and Sina Drums play Pink Floyd’s Comfortably Numb. 👍🌹❤️
I do still love Barbra.😎❤️
Sadly, that is not to be. Tina is missed. :(
Love Lucy s voice, I was always a Barabara fan. But I love the purity and depth of Lucy s voice. Both different, but could listen to Lucy over and over.
I’ve never been into this type of song however I accepted from appraisals that Barbara Streisand was the legendary singer. Not that I listened to her to know. Being a Lucy fan I of course checked out her version and I liked it. Evergreen is still not my favourite song even with Lucy, nevertheless I could appreciate Lucy’s singing. But it caused some debate, so as I’m doing here I went to check out Barbara Streisand’s version. I thought it was ok, but I preferred Lucy. However now listening them together here, Lucy crushes Barbara’s version. I think people decide which is best by how long the last note can be held - which is stupid. But Barbara did appear to hold the last note for longer, however it was weak and struggled after 5 seconds, and how she continued it while kissing I don’t know. But it was a movie. Lucy held the last note controlled and clear for nearly as long. However I’ve just seen Lucy sing Evergreen live and she could not match the last note in her video, but she had sung constantly for 50 minutes about 10 songs without even a breath pause or drink. Disregarding the last note Lucy sounds to me to sings this much better. So as said in Highlander - There can be only ONE! 😄
Get ready for another slaying: Julie Covington vs Lucy Thomas ‘Don't Cry For Me Argentina’. I already know the winner. 😉
Grew up hearing this. It seemed to be my parents favorite tape every time we would go to Glenwood. Anyway, Lucy did so very good on this. Barbra’s version on this was little different sounding then the album. Enjoyed the cover and flashback.
🙏🙏🙏
Ha!! Thanks James
Lucy has the clearest and smoothest voice i have ever heard. She can go light and easy as well as loud and powerful effortlessly. There is never any fluctuation in the quality and delivery of her sound. Truly gifted and blessed with talent, she will take over the singing world and be right there at the top with the best out there. For a woman so young she can only get better if that is even possible. It is no wonder she is killing it on youtube. Anyone that actually takes the time to listen to her sing, experiences the same thing.....goosebumps This is how you know her voice is magic.
The voice of Barbra does something to me, such a special voice! Timeless!
Thx for reacting 🎤🎶💜
Thanks for watching!
Good job sir. She is amazing.
Lucy and Martha Thomas new duet what a wonderful world
I'll put it on the list!
Lucy is the only singer I have ever listened to regardless of the song she's singing. Even Karen Carpenter didn't reach that level. Lucy Thomas is one of a kind, and still only 20!
Thanks Jeff! Karen Carpenter did have an amazing voice
I guess I’m showing my age!
Two great performances by two great singers. I prefer Lucy's version because she has the most beautiful voice I have ever heard. I am a senior citizen and I have heard almost all of the great singers since the 60's. Lucy is in a class all of her own.
Agreed!
Lucy is nothing without autotune and auto pitch! Sorry but that’s the truth!! A big nothing
@@ceegarcia3399 How is it that you can hear "autotune" that no one else can hear? " You keep on using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means" (from the Princess Bride). I do not think you know what autotune sounds like.
@@DonJuan-ff5hd Don Juan, please don't feed the troll, cee garcia! I've seen this person on some of the Lucy reactions before, along with a few others, and they do this to get a negative reaction out of us! We all know Lucy is the best solo performer on the Planet and her musical, "Rosie", will prove this when she travels the Globe starting late next year!!
Wow! I have not seen and heard this version in a long time. Very good but, I think Lucy has a more pleasing tone quality, control and power and she is only 19 yrs. old. Very hard to compete with Lucy.
The version released to the public was much better that the clip from the movie.
I grew up listening to Barbara Streisand, i though she was a superstar singer,but if any fan is really honest with themselves, they would have to admit that early in her career she screamed a lot more than she sang ,now listening to the comparisons between Barbara and Lucy, their is actually no competition Lucy wins easily in every department, tone,story telling,heart and soul, breathe control ,holds on to notes for longer and still has the same strength of the note at the end as the beginning, also Lucy was i think still 18 or maybe just turned 19 ,on the other hand Barbara was in her prime in her 30,s and still not as good as the young Lucy, and last but not least I'd forgotten how nasally she sounded just like Celine, but at least a lot better than her
Hi there, Just came across this reaction by you. Just wanted to tell you that I enjoyed this a lot. I am a huge Barbara fan - Always have felt she might have had the most beautiful voice I have ever heard (at least to my ears). Have discovered Lucy in the last year or so - was stunned the first time I listened to her - and have grown more and more impressed ever since. I really thought your analysis/observations at the end were VERY good and spot on when discussing their voices. They really are both unique with different pitches, Barbara as a rule uses more of a head or nasal voice - Lucy has that beautiful richness and probably uses her subtle vibrato more - she has a great low register voice also (particularly for just turning 20). Anyways, really good analysis by you, found it to be very interesting - I am now subscribed and will certainly be checking out some of your previous stuff and look for the upcoming. Thanks!
Thank you so much Keith! I certainly appreciate your analysis as well.!!
Thank you for the sun and don’t hesitate to leave comments and I will respond!
Thank you and also don’t hesitate to devs me anything you want me to react to!
Thanks again Keith!!
Hi ya - Barbara did a great job on this song in 1976 and won awards as well. However, audio technology has progressed greatly since 1976 and could also be to blame for, in my opinion, what is not a good quality sound in Barbars's version. I am not a fan of vocal gymnastics either and I think Barbara put in a couple of those. I prefer Lucy's version of this classic much more. Lucy has a way of performing her vocals in a very smooth way. Lucy has such a crystal-clear voice, a depth and warmth in the lower range and incredible quality in the upper ranges without straining or screeching like so many other artists. In my opinion, Lucy decimates this song and is still the preeminent vocalist of this age.
Sorry but Lucy’s version is much better. If you were just listening you might give Barbra a close second, but when you watch Lucy you see the feeling behind each word. All of Lucy’s videos show that her heart and soul are in every lyric she sings. At this time she is the best female vocalist on the planet and I hope she begins to do live performances. I hope it is soon because i am getting pretty old and i might miss my chance. I would give just about anything to see her do a taping of one of er videos.
As a piece of music I prefer Lucy's BUT in this case I shall add a huge proviso which is this. Barbara wasn't singing this as a rendition, she was acting and it makes all the difference. One thing Lucy still lacks (although give her, her due she isn't yet 20 years old) is the full ability to express what she's putting into her vocals into her expressions, to wear the emotions she's singing. Barbara being a hugely experienced Broad Way actress, even at this time does, and she is actually sacrificing on technical aspect of the vocals for this. It shows but at the same time what you get is a much more emotional experience overall, cause she's in character. Its something Lucy (especially as she now steps out into theatre productions in the West End, will learn)
she might not be able to to now, but roll back a couple of decades and Barbara could have done the song (technical vocalise) every bit as well as Lucy does it. The Nasal quality you speak of is an adaptation for the stage, to protect her voice rather than something she naturally needs to do, its a choice.
I am a huge Lucy Thomas fan, but I'm also realistic here. She's really good, a complete musical prodigy from a family of musical brilliance, but she's still only just setting out on her career, she's not at Barbara's level... yet.
Stephen, she is beyond Barbra's level, right now. You do realize there is this musical called "Rosie", where Lucy will be ACTING! You do understand this, right? This is a completely ORIGINAL musical, not one that has been re-hashed thousands of times, ad nauseum! Lucy has 9 ORIGINAL performances from "Rosie", plus the original performance, "A Brand New Day", which she did back in May of this year!
@@briankrames1883 I am a huge Lucy fan, so you don't need to sell her to me. I also know what I'm talking about here, and being objective, to listen to i do prefer Lucy's voice any day of the week but, technically Barbara was better at the time when she performed this song, simply because of greater experience, not inate talent..
I am very well aware of Rosie and Lucy's involvement.
But ok, here's the things to start noticing, let's take Broken Dreams, (which I adore btw), there's a number of moments, one very noticeable where she's concentrating a little too much on technicalities of vocal production rather than on matching up to the emotion of the lyrics. It's details that experience and maturity bring
Barbara does have a harsher tone a lot of the time, its deliberate to protect her voice on long running productions, I much prefer lucy's tone, as a piece of music Lucy's rendition is better than Barabara's. But I'm being a vocal critic not a listener and knowing just what Barbara was also capable of
@@briankrames1883 it's the difference between sonething like the Prayer, (which Lucy and Martha create one of the most beautiful sounds I've heard,) and a musical, an opera different again, they demand different choices and skills. She's an astounding vocalist, particularly for her age. But she's only just starting out on the boards.
Wykonanie Lucy Thomas jest dużo lepsze - jest genialne.
Being listening to Barbra for more than 40 years, she is doing a good job, but I would not fall in for her as I once did for Barbra.
@@wilburfinnigan2142 I think this person prefers Barbra, if I interpreted this correctly. People butcher basic grammar and sentence structure so it's difficult to comprehend what some folks actually mean.
Lucy has so much depth and control, much prefer her voice. Barbara too nasal and lacks in the higher register for me. Thanks for the mention 😁 first time for me! Enjoyed the comparison. Should add for some reason my @name has changed but am tony topgun, nickname given by work colleagues but definitely love listening to Lucy and death metal too, if it's good I'm there!
Thanks for letting prospective viewers know at 2:22 that you "didn't care much for Barbra Streisand." It made it much easier to close this tab on my browser without wasting more time.
Robert I hope you are well
I need to revisit the comment. i usually say I never cared for "insert person here" meaning their music. Not knowing the person, I would be remiss in casting aspersions on their character. If i offended in any way, I apologize.
Sincerely
Looks like people are checking in on this one. I always thought this was a good song, even those it’s sappy, and despite not being a Barbara Streisand fan either. Your brother calling while you’re recording?…. Well he “can suck it!”
Ha! Exactly
Lucy’s version imo is far better than Barbara’s
😂 you wish!
This is a no-brainer. I was never a fan of Barbara's. I just don't care for her nasaly tone. Lucy is just marvelous. Lucy for the win.
Lucy couldn’t sell out a concert of 50,000 at $500-3000 a ticket as Streisand has done many times and in her sixties! No one will ever compare, No one! Lol😂
@@ceegarcia3399 I agree that Lucy needs marketing in the US to draw an audience. Time will tell I suppose.
P.S. Never did care for Steisand's nasally tone. Personal opinion of course.
@@ceegarcia3399 Commercial success does not necessarily equal singing talent. If commercial success were the criteria for singing talent then Elvis, Madonna, Justin Bieber and Taylor Swift would all be considered better singers than Streisand as each has sold more "units" (that is what they are called now that digital sales are included) according to the RIAA ( Recording Industry Association of America).
@@user-su2ef9qy9h Please ignore the troll; I've seen this person on other Lucy reaction videos and it's the same banter, condescending, derogatory, belittling, and berating comments against Lucy. He/she knows nothing about Lucy and does not intend to look into her career so it's a waste of time, energy, and mental faculties arguing with ceegarcia. I already figured out who has the flawless, perfect vocals, the emotion, passion, and empathy in all of her performances, and the acting regimen to back it up and it's the star and co-producer in her musical, "Rosie"!
come on Lucy has a good voice but it is heavely arrange, not heart felt as barbra who wrote that song she sings it as a full expression of her feeling and Lucy spent hours in trying to copy the original like the First in class but smiling in wrong part of the song she is young she need to put emotions into her work get some durt take risk... barbra at the same age was far ahead with her understantding of a song, a song for a her is a story you need to make alive ant feel the emotion she always have an actress point of view enough so her voice is stellar with incredible range she only brings it to carry the emotion and to demonstarte that she can reach a note ... and Lucy to me is still in the showing of phase of singing note in a very pretty way ... room for her to grow to because a diva and not a good piano bar signer.