Odell Beckham Jr., Saquon Barkley should sit, Eli Manning's 'time is up' - Stephen A. | First Take
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 07. 2024
- Stephen A. Smith says the Giants should sit Odell Beckham Jr. and Saquon Barkley to preserve New York's future, along with making changes at quarterback, head coach and general manager. Max Kellerman and Victor Cruz agree that the Giants' season is a failure, so it is time to bench Eli Manning for rookie Kyle Lauletta and give Barkley more reps so he can be the best running back in the NFL next season.
✔ Subscribe to ESPN on CZcams: es.pn/SUBSCRIBEtoCZcams
✔ Subscribe to ESPN FC on CZcams: bit.ly/SUBSCRIBEtoESPNFC
✔ Subscribe to NBA on ESPN on CZcams: bit.ly/SUBSCRIBEtoNBAonESPN
✔ Watch ESPN on CZcams TV: es.pn/CZcamsTV
ESPN on Social Media:
► Follow on Twitter: / espn
► Like on Facebook: / espn
► Follow on Instagram: / espn
Visit ESPN on CZcams to get up-to-the-minute sports news coverage, scores, highlights and commentary for NFL, NHL, MLB, NBA, College Football, NCAA Basketball, soccer and more.
More on ESPN.com: www.espn.com - Sport
When Victor Cruz says it’s a wrap, you know it’s over for the Giants 😂😂😂
KennyD lol facts that dude always defending the Giants 😂😂😂
How was two superbowls a fluke dam did you watch any of his games
Danny Hoyt wrong comment bruh
@@jordontillman7815 my bad
😞😞 he said that!!?? Fuck! 😂😂😂
100% agree. Any time with Beckham or Barkley on the field is just asking for an injury in the middle of an unsalvageable season. Stay fit for next season. New year, new quarterback.
Dont think they ever do that in football or any sport. Fans won't come out and watch if you bench the stars.
Couldn’t agree more with you connoralpha. It’s time to move on. It’s sports, we gotta start moving forward as soon as we can. As a nfl fan seeing teams making changes for the sake of winning is what should be done. NOT massaging feelings. 1-7 and you have two of the top ten skill players in the league(possibly)
calvin Fan bruh do u watch NBA?
Connoralpha any QB would struggle behind that oline
@@MannyManhattanMusic what superstar sits for half a season when the team sucks?
I drafted both Odell and Barkley.... please don’t bench them
My fantasy team has lost three straight. 😑
Kris Kuylen Maybe you should have drafted more variety.
You are ass at fantasy. Rule 101 don't draft two people fighting for the same ball 🤦🏻♂️
@@nicksin7902 nigga you sound mad stupid, those 2 players getting high quality points in fantasy. Sounds like you don't know wtf you talking about
@@nicksin7902 I drafted them both in a 12 team league and I'm 5-2
Don’t bench Odell... I got him on fantasty lol
Me too
And I have Barkley lol
I also do but he has like 3 tds this year. This ain’t it chief😒
facts. exactly what i was thinking hahaha
No matter what you’ll have Eli as his quarterback Lmao
I thought Barkley and Saquon We're the same person max..
Ayaovi07 hes talking about Charles Barkley
😂😂 heard that too
Ayaovi07 Wrd😂😂😂I’m deaddddd
Barkley runs and catch, saquan jukes and trucks
Brooo I thought I was the only one who caught that 😂😂
Max: at the 4:43 min mark...turn the "page" on Eli?....they have to burn the book lol
David Williams BRO I READ THIS COMMENT AS HE WAS SAYING THAT
He's only playing because of his name.
@@finallyfamousjames
Me too 😂🤣
Chris Nichols sub to the channel broski 😁😂
@odysseusPerseus I don't really care for max as a host, but he was one 🔥 today lol. I love undisputed with Shannon and skip they stay turnt ha
Everybody cried last year when Eli was benched...now look!!!!
Because they replaced him with a worse qb
It wasn't that they benched Eli, that was understandable. They benched him for GENO SMITH, which was unforgivable.
@@retrokid62 Who cares...people still cried like Eli wasn't awful.....And now it is an atrocity!
@@xaviervega468 who cares who they benched him for....just bench him. If they would have stood by that decision last season then the Giants could have started off with a new QB. This is ridiculous and Eli has been horrific.
@@DestinyTownes Eli isn't even the Giants biggest problem. The o-line is, anyone who actually knows football can see that.
Why does Odell look like that gossiping cousin at the family bbq in the thumbnail. 😂😂
" you aint hear that from me tho "
“Guess what I heard but you can’t tell nobody else”
because the Giants has become a one demensional team..
"Oh you grown grown"
😂😂😂😂
This is the first time I've seen the comment section not roasting molly!😂😂😂😂😂
There are people still out there who are riding 2007 and 2011 like it was yesterday and will still continue to support Manning but this fool's time has been up for awhile now. Bench him, get rid of him, do whatever it takes.
Shot his time was never here bro those two super bowl was carried by the defense
MasteR BlasteR Eli is washed
@@kevinjjj5575 I agree
what makes you think Tanney and Lauletta would be better options at QB? smh
No ones saying we should stay with eli
I bleed blue , I love Eli but it’s time . The offense line is bad but he makes them look even worst .
Flex _24 you bleed blue? You should see a doctor
Flex _24 he gets 2 seconds shit is sad LOL it’s the o line
Who’s your team ?
Flex _24 lmao
@@B86RZ blood is many colors dumbfuck
I actually agree with Stephen A here tbh, let their two young stars sit the rest of the year, why risk injury when the team is going to be in the lottery next year either way?
@DrugLord Tyrone Yeah thats a good point
Kal S Dudes get paid to play, this isnt college bruh.
Stephen A is a fucking ass.
The other 49 players might have an issue benching to save them. Seriously?!? What about my F’ing health?!? These guys are gutless.
Kal S yeah, but if their backup QB if good, they can get wins with those two.
Sitting odell and Saquon is one of the dumbest ideas ever uttered, NFL is a business and those two fill seats
NYG Joe until they get injured then it’s brilliant lol
@@swatkins67 for a 5yr old
@@swatkins67 No one's ever sat their stars for the rest of the season not even half way overwith.. Dumbest idea ever..You need to replace that entire Oline. Eli aint the problem..
Because you definitely know what you're talking about lmao. I'd rather listen to the professional WR then some fanboy who probably never played a down of college FB.
Earl Thomas....hint, hint!
But when Odell spoke the truth, y’all got mad. Now y’all want them to sit?? If this was Geno Smith he was calling out y’all wouldn’t have said a damn word! But since it’s a good ol Manning boy you can’t call out their shortcomings.
Nicholas Smith it’s the o line LOL
T3AM DiViSi0N it’s all of them
T3AM DiViSi0N no... it’s Eli bum ass
I would get rid of obj or any other mf who talk sit about team or qb. Obj ain't all that anyway.
Eli is unwatchable.. it literally hurts to watch him play
4:46 - 4:52 LMFAOOOO DAWG LOOK AT HOW MAX LOOKED AT MOLLY 😂😂😂
Kyler Murray to the Giants... FACTS
he’s going to play baseball
Sam M LMAO Kyler would get wrecked
dont want him
Bruh He got baseball unless he want to bust a Bo Jackson
TheIceColdShot facts😂😂
What about Evan Engram? The guy is just as important to the offense as Barkley and OBJ
Tom Kim he dropped a HUGE pass that cost the giants a chance to come back and win.
HE HAS BEEN AWFUL!
engram sucks
He drops too money passes now sharp in the slot is a beast too
he dropped 1 fucking pass and yall are all over him. Did people forget about last season? I wish some of yall eli apologists were like that with eli
The rams are undefeated, the saints are on a six game winning streak, Patrick M is killing it...yet here we are talking about the giants....Dallas.....the Packers....
This is the funniest but truthful thing I’ve heard in a long time lol omg lmao
As I Ravens fan I would love to hear a hit piece like this on Joe Flacco, who has actually performed worse than Eli in almost every category this season. He just has one of the best defenses in the league to make him look a little better.
I'm also a Ravens fan and I've been saying the same thing about Flacco, he's also a scrub washed up, he was never that great anyway
i thought barkley and saquon were the same person
Stephen a makes my day bruh talking about I Love the Kids
“Burn the book burn the page”
😂😂😂😂😂😭😭😭😭😭
Fantasy Owners Will Kill There-self if that HAPPENS 😂😂😂
Eli should have been gone the end of last year. Idk wtf the giants were seeing lmao
Eli still believes that he can actually win another SB to keep pace with his brother, Peyton. Did you see the expression of passive disappointment on Eli's face when Peyton won his last SB?
Deandre Battle then who would play QB for the Giants
@@skineyemin4276 lol what please know what ur talking about
Manny Manhattan Music someone else. They should of moved on period. It’s been time
It don’t matter who they put at QB . They’re still bigger problems than Eli . Watch keep the head coach and Oline the same I pray to god lol
These guys don’t need to tank any more then they naturally are, but they need to put someone in there at QB fast!
Watching Lauletta run, and scramble, and have strength to his throws, is gonna be AWESOME!! Eli has never had jet enough to dart out of the pocket to do anything but make you say "OH NO, don't FUMBLE ELI!!!!
You think Saquon is going to sit?! Check Stephen A for drugs! Saquon is trying his best for ROY. Absolutely no way he sits.
So stupid to say that the Giants could allow Eli Manning go out in a respectful manner. Eli is a washed up player who's ego won't allow him to sit. He's greedy, all he's doing is collecting an undeserved paycheck.
“Wet noodle for an arm” 💀💀 funny guy
Giants keep trying to rebuild around falling parts, and newsflash: its not working.
Man they tanking for the draft. They getting a qb in this upcoming draft
Jeremiah Hill or trade back and get a bunch of draft picks for 2020
What's tanking?
I BLEED GIANTS BLUE purposefully losing games in order to get high rated draft picks
@@russellwestbrook1951 so a professional organization should lose on purpose
@Chris Injeian we didn't tank
Why not Kaepernick? 👀
Its 2018 now bro and its week 9. You're stuck in 2016-2017
"Leave Eli in as a tackling dummy for the rest of the season" 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂. I've been laughing at that comment for hours. Lmao!!!!!
“Leave Eli out there with his tackling dummies” got me weak!!! 💯🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👌🏾
The season is over....preserve players for next year.
The season was over when John Mara committed to Eli Manning and hired Pat Shurmur and Dave Gettleman
Did Barry Sanders or Troy Aikmen give up on seasons when they didnt win more than 1 game? No? Than why do players give up now a days? Keep playing and at least try to finish with more than 1 win, let them have some dignity and not just give up.
@@brendohames6480 Troy won a superbowl the next year....but he had the best O-line in NFL history too......Barry had no choice in the matter. LOL
GRAY WOLF he only had 1 win his first year, could have easily been benched as a rookie to "Preserve the player." QB"s got destroyed back then it was not as laxed on the passing game. Defensive players were basically unchained german shepherds compaired to the caged chihuahuas todays players are limited to being.
@@brendohames6480 ummmm my name is Gray Wolf...
I actually feel like Kaepernick could make that offense work because his run threat would make Barkley even more deadly. But they’d need to really build that line up in the offseason
Emerson Sortun DUDE WAS TRASH BACK THEN 😂💀😂💀
@@t3amdivisi0n85 stop with those bullshit lie
killaman227 before he was cut he was bad not when Jim harbogh was coach
Kaep's career took a nosedive the second the rules got changed to allow QB's running read option to be tackled like running backs. Same with RG3.
And with the first pick, The New York Giants select...
Caption Odell n Quan in this thumbnail lol
Please keep Barkley playing.... he’s on my fantasy team lol
Cash King you people are fucking selfish smh..you dont give a damn if a guy gets hurt as long as you making money right?? Another one of those guys who thinks hes a footbal genius hahahaha
Eli's not the problem. You need to replace that entire Oline...As a skins fan I can't remember the last time we had 7 sacks on anyone..
He also did not get rid of the ball
And cannot run he is the problem... the team isn't one Eli can make win at this point
now that's a smart observation from a redskin fan
Eli is the problem hes tooo slow look at Russell Wilson hes been playing with a garbage o line almost his whole career yet hes always in the playoffs , Eli just too slow & flat footed he literally sits in the pocket all day & if no one is open he just takes a sack
@@Gimmemine59 Look at the history of QB's who've been sacked more than 50 times in a season. Its not good, their teams tend to suck up the place, a couple of teams have been able to deal with it but overall protecting your QB is kinda vital.. Not everyone is Aaron Rodgers. I didn't see any replays during the skins games that showed Eli holding the ball because he didn't have the arm to throw it. It was shown many times the skins just had good coverage and guys weren't getting open. couple that with good pressure and Eli gets sacked, and what happens when you get hit as much as he has. He and just about every other QB in NFL history gets happy feet..
@@KiidStacksx Put Tom Brady behind the Olines Russell Wilson has had and he'd be doing infomercials for TB12 after having been retired for 3-4 seasons.. You can't ask Eli to all the sudden bust out his best Fran Tarkenton, why not go back in time and ask 2004 Michael Vick to be Joe Montana in the pocket while your at it?? Eli is a pocket QB, you gotta protect him..
The Giants look rough but it seems their offense is only a couple moves away from being very effective. They have Barkley, OBJ, Shepard, and Engram, which is a solid ass foundation especially if they have a quality QB.
they basically wasting objs years. shoulda drafted a qb. hopefully they do it this year
Why y’all don’t talk about frank gore and AD productivity after 30
@@Willworld. Smoking DBs? AP looked like his hips haven't been loose in ten years. He was waddling down the whole field.
Cory R And they STILL couldn't catch him LMAOOOO
AP is a freak of nature. Gore is also amazing as well, Not many RBs last this long.
If Aaron Rodgers was a New York Giant, he’d get about 5 more rings. PLEASE @ me on that.
He'd have 2 no doubt.
Aaron could probably get the Giants to the playoffs but no way in hell he could get a ring with this offensive line. Any team with a good pass rush would eat him alive.
Xavier Vega I know the o-line is atrocious, but Rodgers, even with a brace, does something Manning apparently forgot how to do: move his feet. I’m not saying he has to be Wilson or Newton, but at least we see guys like Rodgers, Brees, and even Brady stepping up when it calls for it. Wilson is no stranger to garbage lines and he can adjust accordingly. Rodgers’ line is not always trust worthy(see their expose season last year for proof), but most of the time the bad man knows how to adjust. He throws a lot of balls away or he even attempts to run in for extra yards when no one is open or when the pocket collapses. It would be a bigger challenge on the Giants squad, but he can get it done. They have tons of good to decent/passable talents on both sides of the ball, even with the trades.
@@ThatOneGuy-pb8gv Aaron had an 15-1 Packers squad in 2011 and who beat him? The lowly Giants with Eli at the helm. Saying Rodgers would have 5 more rings if he had been the Giants QB is kind of laughable considering he didn't get those rings with the Packers.
GTFOH!!! The Giants are trash, You still need to get by the Eagles or the bitch-ass Cowboys!!!!
Boy the way max was looking before he called eli a tackling dummy lol
Lol max said " The reason you start barkley or saquon is".... Made my day. #RiseUp
Tank. Let Eli play and sit OBJ & Saquan.
Oh its fuck Eli huh? Lol
@@NatTurnergrandsonChrisdorner I think Eli can play with anyone similair lol. He never really had an elite reciever his whole career
@@mazizazi8412 plaxico and Cruz weren't elite???
@@mazizazi8412 and nicks!
@@NatTurnergrandsonChrisdorner I dont think they were. Cruz had like 2 good seasons when he made some nive plays. Plaxico, meh, nothing special. Nicks was good. However, no hall of fame material, none of them.
Giants should trade for derek carr
4:32 😂
Get ready for Kyle Murray/Jamies Winston experience 😂😂😂
Obj does not deserve this come to the falcons or panthers
Y’all forgetting he signed a 6 year 100 million dollar contract with 60 mil guaranteed
Kaepernick......just let that name sit in
Rheri he’s trash
Eddie McQuade No, your brain is trash. Clearly you can’t even see the business sense it would make as well. Sit yo $5 dollar ass down before I make change!
Totally agree. I've been a NY fan my whole life. Before LT and Otis and Phil. Bench Eli. He's not it, anymore. See what happens had to offer. What have we got lose?
@@williecatch9 i mean dude lost his job to blain gabbert and hasnt played in over 2 years so you talking shit to dude just makes you look stupid yourself.
Let that name kneel in lol
Wow the truth...
I'd run the rest of the season like preseason games. Let your 'future' play the first two or three possessions then start seeing who gets to stay on the team.
They shouldn't had let Davis Webb go. He would've been more competent
Chill... I got OBJ on fantasy, with hella money on the line!
😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
OBJ needs a qb regardless. you’re not getting more than 10 ppg out of him anyway. you can still get a productive WR off waivers
Lol you won’t be missing nothing.....OBJ is not doing good in fantasy this year. You should of been traded him. Now Saquon Barkley is a whole other story.
💀😂😂😂
I've already told y'all this before the season was even close to being here
Get this man out of here . Eli ain’t Payton he got to retire cuz I can’t see him play anywhere.
The Eli sucks narrative is just lazy analysis.
And max must be on something if he doesn't think Eli is still an NFL QB. Look at the clown show goin on in buffalo, sam bradford keeps getting jobs, jameis Winston, Mariota, bortles, CASE KEENUM, JOE FLACCO and somehow it's Eli that he is not sure of that can still play in the NFL 🤦🏿♂️lazy analysis
He washed tho.
Fullmetaljango I've watched every snap of the Giants this year and I don't think Eli is the problem
@@MannyManhattanMusic Please go on, what is the problem?
Eli, the O-line, the OC, and the HC are all the problem.
Fullmetaljango to say Eli is the main and the biggest problem is throwing him under the bus
Eli is washed up.
"WET NOODLE FOR AN ARM" BAHAHAHA😂
I wouldn't say sit, but I would definitely limit the reps they get but still making sure their getting experience
Eli YOURE FIRED
Donald Trump {OG D.Trizzy} screw Trump! Fire the entire line!!! What QB in football would do well behind this line?
FUCK U TRUMP!
Eli Shits can't complete a pass trying to be like his Brother PEYTON MANNING !
@@mardeemar6 you do realize that Eli Manning been sacked 31 times so far this year... That's as much as he got sacked the entire year last year.. so I would like to point out that the comment is 100% correct because of what quarterback could produce behind this line when they've been sacked 31 times by week 8..
@@mardeemar6 and nobody cares about your political views.. so you can take your F Trump and keep it to yourself..
They slept on Phillip Rivers, he would've gotten shit done for the Giants. Eli always been trash
dominic gomez Eli won them two Super Bowls... that’s not getting shit done?
From a former chargers fan.... Y'all got the better deal 😁
@@dominicgomez3178 Your defense did a fantastic job but Eli had his moments during those two years, stop undermining his effort.. And you can thank Terrell Cooper's Chargers for showing the blue print on how to defend NE in '07 in the Championship game when they held them to 19 pts IN NE..
dominic gomez Eli outplayed Tom Brady in both games lol you don’t know football
dominic gomez stupid fuck
I agree!!!
Eli is 4th in passing yards, if he had actual time he would be #1. Lets not forget when they get to the Red zone its Shurmer who takes the play calling away from Shanahan and his play calling sucks. Get a real line and a defense that doesnt fold in the 4th and they would actually be relivant. Tampa has QB problems why isnt Max saying hire Kaep. SMH this network has become a joke
Eli is a #HOF but he's washed now. They need a new QB. It's amazing how Odell and Saqoun carry that team
@Snatcher Claus The rings and last name. Not his talent.
Is joe Flacco HOF in ur book?
@@jrheeeee fuck no. He hasn't done what Eli has done
hassan haulcy what has Eli done u wanna be real let’s be real real quick those two Super Bowl was all defense beside those two super bowl run that was carried by the DEFENSE what’s has Eli done to be a hof
Like I’ve been saying. They can get rid of Eli , keep the Oline and OC and HC it’s going to be the same shit .
Fire shurmur. Fire gettleman, and retire eli. Next season draft a qb, and bring in offensive linemen. Problem solved.
if it were that easy every team would have a superbowl win.
@NatarisX ok kid
@@jesusgill1207 I respect your opinion bro
The Giants should trade a 4th or 5th round pick to the Eagles and pick up Greg Ward JR he was great in college you should check out his highlights.
It would be a nice start
Damn my squad so trash right now it's like preseason over there
BURN THE BOOK BAAAJAJAJAJAJAJAJA i died on that one Max jajajaja
Use this as a The giants need to draft Tua button.
Tua is not eligible until 2020.
Eli Manning been trash, 2 fluke Super Bowls
Casey Zachariah Baker you dont win a super bowl by luck let alone two
im a skins fan not an eli fan. but giants defensive line with their nascar package was wreaking havoc on tom brady both times so cant say those were flukes. giants were just ready to play.
Sorry fam those superbowls were not flukes they were defensive wins. Both games the Giants held the Pats to under 21 points.
Now that’s just fucking stupid
You don't win 2 Super Bowls on a "fluke" sorry. Yeh he sucks now but don't denigrate his prior play.
2:07 max leave eli in as a tackling dummy LMAO
If they sit my fantasy championship goes bye bye( they both on my squad) but in the end I get it. They have to think about the future
Not one time did you blame the offensive line he's been sacked over 35 times this year alone. And if anyone says he's not letting the ball out quick enough look at the games again because he never gets the chance to breath. I say cut 3 from the team on the o line. Get a new GM, and give Eli a vacation for the rest of this year so he can improve for next season because his time is not up every qb has a bad year a point in their career. This will also have the backup qb prove why he's part of the team and how he can come in and win when the time is most crucial
Does Colin Kaepernick have a team ? Oh that’s right America calls him a threat
no he just such now cause he rather Sue and practice his protest than practice playing the game
He said Barkley and sequon 😂😂😂
You can't just sit them. Put then both on pitch counts and see what else is on the roster. And now what to do with Lauletta after his arrest?
Calling it now Hue Jackson will be the next Giants HC
Shutcho aaahhh up
I'm sorry , I don't talk like that. But that comment was just crazy, young man
Gtfoh!
Great idea 😂😂😂😂
2high4thelow 😂😂😂😂
Max is right, they can’t bench Saquon and Barkley
We need to see what we have in Lauletta because this QB draft class coming up is weak.
Great job max you my friend is a genius
I think they should sit Eli and see what they have in Lauletta.. if that doesn't help, then sit Barkley and OBJ so they wont get hurt.. Better yet, sit the starters, period!
Should've kept Tom Coughlin(spell check)
Hardcore facts SA...
Eli gots to go. Season is over. Put rookie QB's in or backups to see what else they got now!!! Damm giants!!!
The just got a new coach man damn
Stephen A. talking out the other side of his mouth! He lambasted the 76ers for tanking, but it's ok for the Giants to do it! He thinks the owner is paying Beckham all that money to sit out half a season? FOH!
Cowboys fan here passing thru
As a fan that's trying to see the Giants win a ring. Sit them. Sit them until the 2019 regular season, because if one of them gets hurt all of these "fans" that want to see a nice run or a one handed catch just to end up 2nd last in our division (AT BEST) are gonna feel reeaaalll stupid.
Amen.....
Imagine a 1-7 team getting this much press
This is blasphemy. You don't tell a team to give it up mid-season. STOP IT.
2:57 "The reason you dont seat Barkley or Saquon..." whaaaaaat?😂
Whoever picked the thumbnail to this video is a genius.
I was just saying this I fully agree!!!
Put Lamar Jackson on that offense and you got problems.
The real problem : the play calls within the red zone!