The UK government backpedals on migrant salary threshold but there’s a catch
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 12. 2023
- Well... we did it!.... almost
Vlog channel / evanedinger
Thank you so much for watching! Hope you enjoyed it!
If you're new to my channel and videos, hi! I'm Evan Edinger, and I make weekly "comedy" videos every Sunday evening. As an American living in London I love noticing the funny differences between the cultures and one of my most popular video series is my British VS American one. I'm also known for making terrible puns so sorry in advance. Hope to see you around, and I'll see you next Sunday! :)
If you want to know HOW I make my videos including gear, lighting, all the tiddly bits that connect it all together, (with cheaper alternatives and kit I used to use), I've listed each item, what it's great at, and why I use it on the gear section of my website here:
www.evanedinger.com/blog/my-gear
Otherwise: here's a quick list of some of my kit without descriptions from the above link:
Camera: Sony A7siii
geni.us/Evana7siii
Main Lens: Sony 24mm f/1.4 G-Master
geni.us/Evan24
Secondary Lens: Sony 16-35mm f/2.8 G-Master
geni.us/Evan1635
Main Light: Aputure 120d mkii
geni.us/Evan120d
Shotgun Microphone: Sennheiser MKH-416
geni.us/Evan416
Really useful SSD: SanDisk Extreme Portable 2TB
geni.us/EvanPortSSD
The background music I use is all from Epidemic Sound! I highly recommend it: geni.us/EvanEpidemicSound
Store: (LUTs, Presets, & Prints) ► evanedinger.com/store
Patreon: / evanedinger
Second Channel: / evanedingertravel
Twitter: / evanedinger
Instagram: / evanedinger
Facebook: / evanedinger
Discord: / discord
Twitch:(4 days a week!) ► / evanedinger
Had to chuckle - I was in the UK on various visas for 8 years before getting citizenship and on each one of those there was in bold letters "NO RECOURSE TO PUBLIC FUNDS"
But yeah - we come here to claim benefits lol.
You'd be stupid to. Go to Germany. They'll give you £2000 a month with free accommodation. I'm thinking about becoming an asylum seeker myself.
Well that's because people believe in the schrodinger immigrant, simultaneously stealing everyone's jobs and also sitting around being lazy and claiming benefits. It's an odd position to take
Yep, plus the surcharges on top of the actual visa application fees. So actually paying into the system.
Yes! And something I wasn't aware of until I had a relationship with an immigrant, is that their spouse isn't allowed to claim benefits either. It's assumed the money will be shared so they can't get anything either. Totally mental.
Schrödinger's Immigrant - coming to take your job while lazing around on benefits.
It's an extension of the hostile environment - populist racism dressed up as sensible economic policy. It doesn't stand up to scrutiny.
Paying £300k for MP's heating bills for their second homes when MP's earn a salary of £92k. And that seems to be okay? 🤔🤨
That's because we pay the likes of the French nationalised energy company for not supplying energy to their UK customers.
The argument paying MPs that much is allow people from modest backgrounds a chance to become an MP. If MPs only received a meagre salary, you'd end up being represented by only those from wealthier backgrounds who could afford run for office. It's a little bit like London where the rich graduates/actors can afford to work for nothing for a year to get a step on the ladder because they have family wealth to support them.
@@Pixiedust8399 But why pay for MP's heating bills for their second homes after they earn 92k as a salary?
To even begin to want to be a politician a handsome sum of money is needed and well out of the reach of ordinary people😢@@Pixiedust8399
@@Pixiedust8399 You missed the point, MPs should have a large enough salary so that people are inclined to put their name in and they don't become liable to corruption. But why are we paying their energy bill? I mean for poor people, their energy bills don't get subsidiesed, they did it last year or whatever it was but that was it
The 29K aalary sounds very high as someone from Scotland, that's a high paying job. I'm a doctor and I don't make that much. let alone my spouse. I want to return to the UK but my spouse is European and earns 17k a year working from home as a translator, so they basically told us that we can't move back to the UK together. We have a small club here of British doctors who don't want to go back because of the government atm
Yep, as soon as you take certain southern areas out of the equation the average U.K. salary falls very quickly.
Scotland is supposed to have some of the best salaries outside of London and the inbred Southeast. Much higher than the dirt poor north.
Then you must be FY1...which actually increased this year from £29.3k to £32.3k basic, before additional sums for extra or out of hours uplifts and £37303 for FY2 on the 2016 contract. CT1 & 2 pay is £43923 basic, which is at 3/4 years out of university.
True I live in Scotland I work on many lines (and finance) in car insurance I earn 16k a year, so 29k is a bad number
@monkeyatemycookie I'm not sure where you live now, but I will call bs on you not being able as a Dr to earn more than the £29K in the UK. The average salary for a DR in the NHS, in the UK is £72K, DR's in training earn £32K and this moves up with with experience and moving into specialised fields. But then I would be suprised with salaries in Scotland. They are determined by the SNP.
I am a Civil Servant whose job title includes the word "executive". After 17 years on my grade I have just breached this £29,000 threshold.
And the pension not going to be as great as promised either. I left teaching for a lower salary in industry but in a couple of years doubled it and out paced it year on year.
Junior "executives" are entry-level positions in the business world. They typically work directly with senior executives and managers.
You also have a pension worth around 2 thirds of your salary so a 50k package, nearly double the average wage,
I am always dismayed by civil servants getting treated the way they are now. It was always understood that you took a civil service job knowing it was below the market value for that position, but that you would have a good pension and conditions etc. Successive governments have eroded that benefit (mainly Tory but Blair takes some blame also). Shameful.
The £38k salary threshold was only ever a trojan horse - they knew that if they announced that the threshold was going up from £18k to £29k then there would be outrage, so they put an absolutely ridiculous amount out there first and then row back, and as if by magic people are taken in by it and think they're being reasonable about it.
Correct - and we plebs fall for it every time. They play us like the proverbial violin.
I have a Thai wife of 8 years who has been with me in the UK for about 6 years. Her English isn't great, but she communicates well with everyone she meets. Her issue is that she freezes in a test situation.
We have had to restart the spousal visa once before and are due to do the same again soon.
As you have stated, I look after her financially in everything, paying for the NHS surcharge, council tax etc. We live in private rented accommodation and don't rely on anyone. I am worried that when reapplying for the spousal visa this time, we may encounter issues with all of the increased costs.
We Don't ask for anything from the government, only a fair shot at living our lives together unhindered.
Keep up the good work and please keep reporting on this.
Thank you.
My sympathies to you both. The constant opportunistic raising of the spouse visa and Immigration Health Surcharge fees is a huge double whammy. Add to that the 50 quid per pop for the LITUK test. I believe there is some type of medical exemption you can apply for if your wife simply cannot pass the test due to medical reasons - perhaps psychological in this case? I would suggest visiting your GP to see whether this route is feasible.
I was about to suggest the same. Please see a lawyer snd a doctor and se if you can get your wife exempted from taking test. Good luck ❤
Ask her who Francis Pym was. See if she slips up.
There is no reason they should be targeting legal immigration to here since anyone who wants to and can do it legally actually will benefit the economy.
yeah even some of the more racist people aren't against legal immigration. Who on earth are they trying to please?
Not housing though?!
@@GG-hu9dn maybe if the Government wasn't insanely inadequate we'd have enough housing
@@joshuanorman2 so not enough housing is the fault of the government, but importing more people will have no effect?
Well you know In uk both amount of houses built by councils have decreased I case for councils some counties hardly build any at all and private builders realize that they don't have competition and can easily control supply to squeeze out as much profit from a single unit as possible
It's refreshing to see someone not from here talk about how insane, inept & incompetent the tories are.
I'm a chronically ill & disabled person, my health stuff will affect me for life & they also have this plan to get people who can't work to go and work and it's all just like being in some sort of twilight zone where they don't live in the same reality
You sound like a burden
I often do think leftists don't live in the same reality as normal people who want a civilized working society
My brother was born with a disability and my parents still have to prove he is disabled. He's 38 and never been able to work.
From what I understand it’s mainly targeted at people who have anxiety to try and get them remote jobs. There’s no reason why they can’t do that considering many people with anxiety still work.
I commented a similar thing on the previous video but here it is again.
I have some health issues as well and getting medical help and treatment here in Canada is just as bad as in the UK if not worse. And it’s the liberal party in power here. And Canada is perceived as a bastion of left leaning politics. The healthcare crisis and the housing crisis and the cost of living crisis are really bad here after many years of liberals in power.
So yes Tories in the UK are pretty bad at managing the country. But the alternative might not be much better. Politicians are bad in general. Most of them anyway.
Take London out then do another national wage average and I’m sure you’ll get closer to £24-25,000. London skews a lot of national averages so sometimes these averages can be misrepresented.
That’s not misrepresentative though. It’s the most populous part of the country so REMOVING London would be misrepresentative
@@evanLondon is only 13% of the country's population so it's not particularly representative
@@melitajay13% only in London is pretty big!
How the UK gov calculated £38,700:
Average uk hourly wage = £15.50
Hours one can work per week = 48 (I mean officially, we can still have a 6 day work week)
£15.5/hr * 48hr/wk * 52wk/yr = £38,688/yr round it to £38,700.
In calculating the new number, i think they reduced the requirement to allo those who only work 37.5hrs/wk and went with 36hr/wk.
I disagree with the policy but i listened to the minister and this was my interpretation of what they said was their calculation.
Hope that helps.
I mean I know a lot of people who work 48 hours+ a week but which companies actually pay their staff for a 48 hour work week?
My experience is the work week that most employers pay for is somewhere between 35 to 40 hours a week.
@@pratosaurusrex1128 Yep, even for hourly paid people, they might work 48 hours in a busy period, but that's the exception. I bet you'd struggle to find many hourly paid people who genuinely work 48 hours a week through the whole year.
@@joepiekl you do tend to get it with salaried workers, but still the employers don’t usually pay overtime so they are only paid for 35-40 hours of their week.
I'm German and have nothing to do with the UK, but I love to watch your rants. Promised - if one day you rant about German politicians, I won't be offended.
There's something cathartic in a good anti-government rant 😂
Get in line, he has to do Belgium (Flanders especially) first!
You're German of course you like watching people complain ;)
Ah Germany - the land of extremes…
First ruining Europe with war…
Now ruining Europe with smog from GreenDeal coal plants and criminality from "Wir schafen das!" nonsense…
Rants? It's facts not rants, the Tories created brexitshit so they have full sovereignty over their corruption.
As a born and bred british... agree 100% with that u say. I think they just plan to drag the uk into the bin at this point 🙄 .. on the other hand, just know there are alot of uk citizens who welcome anyone into the country! 😊
P.S, as someone with an American girlfriend who’s trying to stay in this country, I’m finding your videos really helpful, it’s genuinely concerning right now as I get the feeling it’s equally if not more difficult for me as a British guy to get into America to live and work.
My son’s uni mate (studied in the UK) also has an American girlfriend. They just entered a UK civil partnership in October. She has a job in business, but she also had a graduation visa that was coming to the end of the allowed two years. Maybe that made a difference, but she can stay in England.
From the ONS site..."Early estimates for November 2023 indicate that median monthly pay was £2,310". So the average annual salary is £27, 210.
Are these numbers net or gross income? Just curious since usually in Greece we talk to each other about our salaries in net income but use gross income in contract negotiations and official records and reports
Link me
@@ecodes8498 it would be gross. Realistically the take home would be around £22k 🤣🤣🤣
@@evan CZcams is unfortunately increasingly allergic to URLs in comments; it will almost always immediately automatically flag them as spam and put a mark on the commenter's account, making it even less likely in future that such comments will be accepted.
@@evan I believe the discrepancy in figures is as follows:
ONS: "Average household income, UK: financial year ending 2022": An analysis of disposable household income (that is, post-tax take-home pay, not gross or discretionary income, of _all_ household members combined, including state benefits and income from investments) from April 2021 to March 2022: Median figure is £32,300 per fiscal year. Figures for FYE 2023 have not yet been published. That the study concerns _household_ income and includes pensioners' annual reported funds easily explains the higher figure compared to the following two sources.
ONS: "Earnings and employment from Pay As You Earn Real Time Information, UK: December 2023": An analysis of each individual PAYE-subscribed employee's income (that is, data only concerning (a large subset of) employed persons, not pensioners etc.). This is a new experimental data set whose analysis and core data is being refined on a monthly basis as more RTI data comes in from HMRC via the PAYE system. The original analysis in Dec 2023 gives a median figure of £2,310 per month, which if assumed constan or equal to the mean over a given 12-month period containing it, is equivalent to £27,720 per year. It is unclear to me whether this data concerns gross or post-tax/disposable income, but if the figures are gross, then the equivalent expected post-tax figure is around £23,100 per year.
ONS: "Average weekly earnings in Great Britain: December 2023": An analysis similar to the above PAYE analysis, explicitly concerning weekly gross income during Dec 2023. Median figure excluding seasonal bonuses is £620 per week, which if extrapolated in the same way as above is equivalent to £32,240 per year, which post-tax we'd expect to be around £26,400 per year. In combination with the figures from the previous reference, this leads me to believe that the previous reference uses post-tax data.
Maybe if it's possible, you could look at the median salary based on different parts of the uk, because just a quick google looking at the midlands and this sentence - 'The median salary for female is ranging between £26.8k in Walsall and £29.1k in Birmingham' came up. Then I looked at London and it said 'The median salary for female in London is £38.3k. The UK median salary for female was £29.7k in 2022. The median salary for male in London is £45.1k.'.
So I'm sure people who are commenting from the midlands or the north who say 'most people are on less', are saying that because it's true in the area they live.
Nationally, the median salary is £27,720. So near to 50% of salaried workers are on less, including the higher salaries in London.
@@NotThatOneThisOne Median salary in 2023 is £34,963, ranging from £44,370 in London to £31,200 in the North East
@@ianjenkins1905 That's for full time work though. Plenty of people are underemployed, with fewer hours than they would like, and lots more people have to work part-time because of things like childcare commitments.
Precisely. This number is more reasonable but just on a human level such high numbers even if they are "average" have disproportionate effects regionally, racially, and by age. Basically a young person from outside London is VERY unlikely to see wages like that for some time, meaning international marriage isn't an option for them anymore. It puts a very high price tag on love for some people. Literally breaking people up I'm sure. International marriage isn't for the working class basically.
Highly populated places with a high relative cost of living, like London, definitely skew figures. There are also less-populated places with similarly high cost of living, such as York, which skew things just a little bit further. I'd be interested to see some bell curves describing the cost of living distribution across the UK and each of its sub-countries.
The funny thing is seeing the absolute desperation of UK employers in trying to find multilingual speakers in both tourism jobs and sales jobs with German, French, Spanish and Italian amongst the most requested and having to increase salary offerings because as we all know British born citizens who can speak anything other than English aren't many 😂. Those businesses are going to have to start offering salaries above the required threshold or deal with the fact their business is going to suffer the consequences.
I think the Guardian's £29k 'being higher than the median' number is based on the 2011 census. Which lists the gross median weekly salary as £498 (~£26k p.a.).
Asylum seekers are not illegal. They are entitled to make a claim for protection from the host country. They are only illegal if their claim is fairly found to have no merit and they then refuse to leave. If I was living in a country where my life was in peril, I also would want to escape and seek assistance. Thank you for the video.
That’s a bit of a grey area. They are illegal when they cross the border but as soon as they claim asylum they are no longer technically illegal.
I come from a bad country and I could’ve claimed asylum in any western country on arrival. And I know people who did claim asylum in the US based on political persecution. I immigrated legally 5 years ago though when my home country was not as bad as it became later.
But also there are illegal immigrants who never claimed asylum and just live there. I don’t think it’s a big number though.
You seem ignorant to the fact that Asylum is not a money making criminal industry.
That should read IS a money making
France ??? 😂
@bar10ml44 Perhaps if it was possible to seek asylum to the UK before arriving here (as it used to be) then it would also not be a Criminal Industry. Similarly, if a few more Civil Servants had been employed to sort the problem out in a timely manner then the entirely predictable backlog would not be so large that we can't now employ enough of them!
UK minimum wage is £11.44 per hour, so most UK salaries are typically around £20,800 per year. Most positions only allow you to work 35 - 39 hours per week.
I didn't know about the "no recourse to public funds" policy for people that hold a visa. I wish this information (and others) was more widespread, it might help changing some people's views for the better
As someone who plans on heading over on an ancestry visa (grandparents were paid to leave 100 years ago), I can assure you that isn't the worst of it- there is a huge 'health surcharge'. I think the last time I looked it was around 5000 pounds for me. It's just baffling when all these people are welcome for free, without even a criminal check.
The worst part of this is nobody is fighting for the non spouse visa income change because it’s not happening to British people, I guess it really takes for it to affect British people to see a change.
I'm unemployed and looking for a job very few jobs pay the Government's required salary where someone can live comfortably on like £38,700 or £29,999. Majority of jobs pay less then that.
As someone who was in catering/hospitality £29k is kinda high..."How much does a Head chef make in United Kingdom? £33,000/Annual Based on 10000 salaries" Not to mention the lower ranks......
But for anyone who Dousnt work in retal or hospility its bugger all.
Its less than a site labourer makes emptying the bins and loading out for tradesman.
the problem is, the wages are out of whack the the cost of living. Immigration is not going to help, especially from the low cost of living economies.
Still a lot easier than getting into the US. I was rejected in the 90s because the job only paid $45k and my American wife and I couldn't find a sponsor for $80k.
Spouse visa or work visa - my friend went there on a spouse visa to join her husband and he only earned 30000 usd he was only 25
Im pretty sure it’s not a 45k income threshold for the US.
@@user-mp5cg8lt7i I'm speaking from first-hand experience (1991), not conjecture.
read the OP's comment again @@user-mp5cg8lt7i
Thank you for covering this, I didn't realise something that was going to affect me so much was happening in the country. My wife is from America through all the legal and massive amounts of money we had to sink into the government to get her here. The fact they are targeting people who want to be here legitimately is ridiculous.
Something that seems to be overlooked by those whose favourite talking point is "illegal migrants" which for them specifically refers to asylum seekers arriving in small boats. Is that there is no such thing as an illegal asylum seeker. Any person claiming asylum is fully wholly "legal" until their claim is investigated and they are found to lack grounds for asylum. It is only at this point that they become an "illegal migrant". An asylum seeker arriving with no papers is 100% as legal as someone coming with the right Visa and a £100k income.
so before they actually do claim asylum they are illegal...
Thanks for your contribution to this country Evan! ❤
Thank you. This is by far the best of yours that I have seen. The UK needs more like you. (And your mimicry is awesome!)😄
I am just blown away at all of this! I am an American who pays into the NHS and too had to pay the fee on my Visas. What they are doing seems criminal when we are paying into the NHS. This hike is insane and I would not be happily married to the love of my life had this new threshold been in place. Ohhh and we still pay taxes to the gool ol USA! Uggghhh! Have a Merry Christmas!
You mean to file right???
You only pay tax after the first 100k. If you’re over here making more than that, please let me know your secret.😅
@@user-mp5cg8lt7i > If you’re over here making more than that, please let me know your secret.
Become a specialised worker in a field such as computing, engineering, or medicine, and Bob's your uncle.
Nobody pays into the NHS thats kind of the problem. Your taxation in the UK isnt at all proportional to need. Even National Insurance isnt even vaguely like insurance in the USA its just a nonsense out of date name. Its just another tax, none of it directly has to be spent on the NHS or saved for your future pensions etc. It just goes into a giant pot used for things like Trident 3 as much as your personal NHS bill.
@@MattOatesUK Immigrants to the UK pay an additional fee proportional to the duration of their stay called the Immigrant Healthcare Surcharge, which as the name implies is notionally in exchange for access to NHS services.
The argument about National Insurance is tired and simply factually incorrect. State pension payments and eligibility for numerous state benefits such as New Style (formerly "contribution-based") Jobseeker's Allowance are tied to one's National Insurance contribution record, even if the monetary amounts involved aren't directly apportioned to such state schemes. Government budgets are complex, but the fact remains that one's ability to access UK state funds is dependent upon one's contribution history.
@@MattOatesUK Then what on earth have the government been doing with all the IHS fees? It’s called an Immigrant Health Surcharge. There’s no excuse to have record migration, with record amount of IHS fees coming in and not have a better funded NHS.
Where did all of those funds go?
The current government pull most of their ideas from the same place as that initial figure😐
I am still unsure who in his right senses will want to move to the uk. We can’t wait for the next general election so we can vote out these conservative muppet’s.
Its not going to happen. Theyre going to cancel it. They'll think of an ostensible reason. OK I'm too cynical. I'm wrong. But IF I AM RIGHT I won't be a bit surprised.
Unfortunately the choice of muppets to vote for is across the boards.
Serious topic and Evan made me laugh way too much. Thanks. Ans a merry happy holidays to you too 😀
There is not such a thing as illegal immigration in the UK. The UK has cut of legal paths for asylum seekers. The UK has stopped to processs asylum seekers applications and has built up a big backlog like in the NHS.
The plan to deport asylum seekers to Rwanda will also not be implemented as it is unreasonable. The Tory govn paid mio to Rwanda for nothing. There wont be a single flight. Airlines don't want to be negatively associated. They all denied. There are no planes to deport asylum seekers to Rwanda.
Well, two less immigrants since the Home Office - after 6 years and 3 rounds of visas - figured out that my children have always been citizens and never should have been given visas 😤🙄
Let's be clear, this is what the Tories do all the time. Announce something horrendous, but not officially, just via the media (are expected to increase the threshold), and then deliver the actual policy based on how much outrage the vague, unofficial announcement gets.
if they are not in social housing then they are renting, causing an increase in demand which does reflect on house process, when rents go up buy to let property investments become more sought after
Most people probably earn less that 29K, but a smaller number of high earners (probably working in London) has raised the average.
by definition that's not possible if the MEDIAN is £35k. Average? Yeah that's possible. Median? Nooooo
@@evanThere is a large enough portion of the population that live in London though that could skew a median too, plus the rest of the South East who also earn far more than the rest of the country that would further skew it upwards. £29k is a good salary up in the North.
@@evan The 50 percentile is £23,800. 30 percentile is £19,000. The 75 percentile is £38,800. Figures for 2020/2021 from the office of national statistics. Not seen provisional figures for 2023.
Pointing out that migrants tank housing prices by making areas less desirable for purchase is not a winning pro-migration argument, my guy...
I love it! You tell 'em Evan! That certain section of the British public should be shown your videos about immigration because it's rational, logical, backed by credible sources and data. Its important you tell them the true situation & figures, again and again until it sinks in.... Might take awhile. Merry Xmas to you!!
The main reason they need to see him, let's be honest, is because he's a well spoken white American. The anti immigrants crowd only imagine immigrants to be poor Eastern Europeans or non-white people from Africa and Asia who they "have nothing in common with." People like Evan are the only people they truly see as people even if they'll never admit it.
Merry Christmas, Evan. Thanks for this follow up video.
Its almost like they have no idea what they are doing.
Cause they don't and don't care, all they do is react to situations in order to stay in their job for another few weeks
rishis plan is to ruin Britain and hes succeeding
£29,000? The Tories need to pay more attention to what a lot of regular UK citizens are being paid..
I mean, cut out all the billionaires and millionaires, and then see what the rest are actually getting. Even 'just' £20,000 is considered standard..
"Average income" is always terribly skewed. If you look up the average income of a specific town, you'll see how drastically things change.
Brit here. Was absolutely disgusted at this policy from the start. You’re only allowed to fall in love with someone from abroad if you’re rich? BS. Tories out.
You think if i fell in love with an American, i could just go live there for cheap?? pahahah are you actually this naive???
@@Believer3_ Its expensive in both countries. BTW this thing doesn't include immigrants with permanent residence so I'm happy about that at least.
@@blooky102 so then how is it tory fault that its expensive to move to a first world country (unless you come on a dinghy boat and get put in hotels)... meaning the original comment is a total braindead one. 👍👌
Kinda yes. Also why should you be allowed to come to a country if your only qualification is being in love with a citizen? Visas by marriage always annoyed me a bit. It’s a super easy way to get into a wealthy country. I think all visas should be evaluated based on the merits of a particular individual and not their marital status.
Family immigration already works like that in many other countries. If you want to bring your children or elderly parents along you need higher income to support them. Kinda makes sense tbh
To answer some of the comments - there are plenty of people in the UK earning less than that and having to make do supporting their family. It’s okay to be poor as long as you’re from round here. Foreigners are okay but only if they’re rich. Sunak looking after his own.
"Happy holidays, Evan! I've noticed that your accent is becoming more British than American."
Yes, while spouses have no recourse to public funds, illegal immigrants do. The government is after the wrong type of migrant.
Found my way back to this video as the salary threshold for the skilled worker visa of £38.7K will come into effect next month. Sadly, no backpedaling in sight for that and it will most likely mean that my stay in the UK will end next January when my current visa runs out.
All of this makes me wonder why the Tories don't migrate to the US where what they want is already basically done with impunity, just even more cruelly and straightforwardly.
Which Tories? If you mean the voters then they probably should. Obviously the politicians wouldn't do that because they want to be on top and if they moved to the US the top spots are already taken.
Yep take up that green card he was granted and leave.
Newly qualified nurses are only on £28,704 are they going to send all the migrant nurses home? Ridiculous
Also, contrary to what the far right propagate, the largest families in the UK are not of foreign origins, they are British. Moreover, the Guardian had an article yesterday telling us there were more empty houses than people in need of housing (yesterday's 25/12/2023) . Of course, they might be sub-standard or in the wrong places, but it shows that the UK housing situation is chaotic and needs government intervention. Better local government, but they have no money.
Taxation and immigration is the hugest source of revenue to the UK government.
The immigrants on visas have no recourse to public funds(benefits) and visa fees/ ILR fees, IHS(Immigration health surcharge) keeps going up.
There are many “criminal” forms of extortion in the UK, but people can’t complain/revolt as they are boxed into tight corners.
The system doesn’t encourage hardwork. The harder you work, the more tax you pay(PAYE,NI contributions) while those who earn much less or not earning live off the benefits of your labour. In the long run, people find ways to avoid working hard and get into benefits system. Who doesn’t like the soft life afterall?
If things must get better, the government should be talking about ways to ensure that the major source of revenue isn’t taxation and immigration. There should be motivation to drive people into the workforce.
Unlike the USA, which has very little native people in it, countries in Europe are still national countries with social help system. Therefore, there are bigger mindset differences between the USA and European countries. The taxpayers in Europe don't want to pay into a system where most people from other countries get to use it. For example, in Germany after 8 years, more than %70 of refuges and Asylum seekers are still lives from social help system...
When you kill off most of the native population and steal their land. What was your point?
The rules across Europe on the benefits an immigrant gets when living and working here are strict. They don't get all the benefits that a citizen does. In the UK they have to pay for NHS care. But if they are on low income then some working tax credits may apply because the UK government supports UK business to pay non-living wages. Refugees (non German guest workers) might have additional issues fitting into work in Germany although they seemed to contribute a lot in the factories I worked in as a student.
British immigrants have no recourse to public funds but we have to pay into NI which funds the public from our payslip. Why can’t we be exempt from that tax ?
I think £18.6K is the annual salary for minimum wage workers in the UK. So £29K is way above that.
Minimum wage is not average wage tho so
£18,600 is at the 30 percentile by income. 30% of those earning an income don't reach that level of earnings. Minimum wage from April 2024 is £11.44 or £23,795 per annum which brings it to the 50 percentile point of 2020/2021. At the minimum wage might have some sense, but not when 50% of the population fail to earn that.. I have not seen figures for this year (2023).
The whole thing is still confusing since the CURRENT INCOME is a COMBINED INCOME (sponsor and applicant) not only the sponsor's income. If the current rules are to be applied to the new minimum income, that would also be a combined income.
£29,000 is very high for most people, I’ve never earned that much in my life, and neither has anyone I know
Strange because the average salary for a standard full-time job in UK is £34,963, so you are either a loner or you are trying to blow smoke up this guys backside. Choose one.
And that's standard jobs. High skilled professionals who earn a lot more (which is what legal working migrants would come to do)
Who tf do you know earning that much working in a shop or something outside London? And blowing smoke up who’s backside exactly?
@@Believer3_master degree grad architect assistants don't earn that even in london
@@Believer3_ How much does London skew that though?
England lost one John Oliver and gained one Evan Edinger: Bizarro Oliver
So here is the real kicker: the fear of migration feeds from a scarcity mindset, that if there are more of us, we will have less to share. In reality though, you can't get growth without more people. The scarcity of housing is not down to migration, it's the inadequacy of house building and government policies that have continued for decades, and it is the rich and powerful who are robbing us. Communism isn't the answer, but feeding this vicious cycle with the Tories sure isn't. Wealth inequality needs to be kept in check, or we end up with this corrupt dystopia, too much of anything is bad.
So correct me if I'm wrong, but at 4:13 that gross salary figure of £34,963 is stated by the ONS as the "median" and not the "average", which are separate stats.
Both are measures of central tendency, but the average (calculated by taking the sum of all salaries and dividing by the population) tends to be skewed upwards by high income earners. So the average salary is likely higher than this quoted figure. That said, the median is probably a better representation of the average joe (the median is defined as the 50th percentile, or the literal middle of the salaries if they were organised in a huge list in numerical order).
All that said, I would be interested to dig deeper into how the ONS gather data as it does seem personally surprising to me that a median UK salary is as high as that. This might have more to do with my area and social network though which doesn't represent the population at large.
I think using the mode would be a better representation. The income that most brits are on.
50 percentile gives the figure of £23,800 per annum. 75 percentile is £38,800. 30 percentile is £19,000. Most of the country do not earn anything close to the average salary.
@geraldmcmullon2465 What source is this from? (Note: I'm not saying you're wrong, I just have multiple sources with conflicting info and I'm trying to create this mini database of different figures and sources).
One obvious thing I'm finding is that some take the full population (including those part time or zero hours contract), others only take full time employees, others take the hourly pay and convert it to annual pay regardless of the hours worked per week. It's confusing as hell to reach an agreement because no-one can agree what data to collect 🫠 Some of its political cherrypicking some of it's just innocent differences in approaches.
It always surprised me that whenever the newspapers quoted a pay scale that no-one I knew was on it!
I was dying for a video listen to, and Evan provided🙌🏻
“brexit will only be racist to eastern europeans! we’re safe”
also brexit:
Evan Not all foreign people are even foreign! My grandson is a British citizen through my daughter but he was born in Tokyo. So he’s a foreign born Brit
That natives leave an area and that makes prices go down in area calling it a good counterpoint is bad, they will have to move somewhere, prices increase there. It also makes it worse for those people who move because they will probably have to commute for longer, which obviously is bad for quality of life.
I beat you many different ministries (education, medicine, construction etc) complained cos they wouldnt get enough qualified people to fill jobs at that $37,000+ pay price. I'm a biomedical research scientist who spent the last 3 years in the UK on a visa. And no one is paid more than $33,000 (out side of London) as a starting salary. And many research scientists are immigrants. Would have been a huge loss to an international field such as science.
This why I like you as a fellow Labour voter you don't accept anything they say as gospel. You're right they'll say anything the Tories say is chaos and you have to decide for yourself. Personally I'm not a fan of the guardian I find them very alarmist.
working salary is minimum wage which is around 19k
£11.44 from April 2024 so £23795 if you can find work at all.
Excluding service charge, the salary of a waiter working at a 5* hotel is around £21,500
Yeah but in fairness waiters aren't exactly skilled workers are they. 5* or not it's still the job you give to local teenagers to help them afford to go out on the weekend.
@@Sku11King77 They did write a 5* hotel, I think you will find that is not entry-level. Also, Teenagers may need to support themselves, this is the equivalent of saying that you can pay some employees less because they happen to be women!
@@Sku11King77This is a huge misconception about a lot of industries. These are often full time jobs, so not done by school age teens.
It's the same in retail or fast food. If you've worked in any of these areas, you quickly see that it's in large part adults doing it full (or almost full) time.
£29k is above the living wage, based on the National Living Wage of £12ph (for outside London) for a 40h week over 52 weeks, which is £24960 before tax. For Londoners, it’s £27352 before tax.
I wonder if they’ve meant this instead of the average (which still makes it bad writing/ factchecking but at least it’d make sense).
But the housing figures he quoted are exactly the point immigrants move to a town . The natives leave that town .
House prices in that town go down but the places those natives moved to go up.
Like where i live in Cornwall theres hardly any none British. But housing here is insanely expensive because all the brits move here to escape the immigrats . The British are living in smaller and smaller parts of the island and in a bidding war for those parts .
In my opinion the best way to tackle illegal immigration is to make legal immigration more accessible we can keep a heavily modified version of the current system for already educated migrants and have a separate system for lower skilled migrants and refugees where we can provide temporary basic accommodation and give them access to education on important things such as language, cultural values and specialised skills it would allows to direct the flow of immigrants away from the streets and social housing and instead allow the government to encourage immigrants to specialise in roles that will help fill in the gaps in our economy. Ultimately most illegal immigrants move due to desperation and the desire for a better life and the vast majority would prefer to doe so under a legal framework we have already proven trying to stop immigration does not work so why not try helping both the British economy and immigrants at the same time.
How many years in employment, say as a teacher do you have to work to get enough for £29K or £38K in a year or so.
30% of the UK don't earn £19K, 50% don't earn £23.8K and 75% don't earn £38.8K.
How many from the UK apply to bring in a foreign national as spouse? According to the National Statistics office about 52K per year 2006-2015 when it was published in 2017.
Most of the 750k immigrants are the huge rise of foreign students who come here for 5 to 7 years, pay inflated fees and go back home having spent a fortune to live here and contributed to the NHS and GDP. This is a success story as they a funding higher education in the UK and paying to fund the NHS.
I am an EU national who left the UK 9 years ago because of my British husband's job. Prior to that I had lived in the UK for 15 years, working there for 10 of those and had 4 British children. While I was gone, Brexit happened. Now, it looks like I will never be able to go back to the country where half of my family is (yes, I consider my in-laws my family and I also have relatives there).
That's your fault it was easy to apply for settled status
6 million EU citizens applied and nearly 6 million got it.
You should have filled in the forms
@@user-xq6se9uc1gsettlement was not available to those who were living out of the country for a certain amount time or not residing in Uk due to work or family needs at the time. This has happened to British citizens living abroad for work. They are now essentially Brits who have had the door closed on them. Who other countries are allowing them to stay on their soil.
So sad that you are having to deal with this unnecessary torment. 😢
You should blame yourself for not applying British citizenship in those 15 years 😂😂😂
At least Evan did apply 😂😜
I cried for days when this originally happened. I'm just sorting my marriage papers out after being with my future husband for over 4 years. I'm a teacher, so I don't make a whole lot. I just want to be together now. Spent a long time trying to figure out more sources of income - trying to make a tutoring business work, freaking out.
I can afford the new salary threshold to sponsor his spousal visa, but I'm really considering leaving the country now thanks to all this. It's stressing me out and I just don't know if I can do this anymore. Unless my business takes off and I can make a fair income from tutoring, it's just not going to work.
The worst part is that my husband would have been able to come here for free a couple of years ago. He's French.
maybe you should leave and go to whatever country your husband is from
@@firstname4337 I said where my husband is from in the comment. I also said I was considering leaving. Didn’t you read before commenting?
It'll change when tory vipers are OUT!! Don't read nasty gammon troll comments
On here? Horrible sad hateful individuals - all of them! Don't stress?!
@@andthatsshannii cool, fuck off there then
Can your husband support himself in the UK? I don’t know what to think about this new law. On one hand you can’t put price on love. But on the other hand marriage is the easiest way to get into the country. I tried immigrating to the UK in the past and it’s bloody hard to get a visa.
So putting restrictions on who can come into the country makes some sense to me. Immigration by marriage always annoyed me a bit. Maybe I’m jealous because it’s a super easy way to get into any wealthy country that way. And I come from a poor country and wanted to escape desperately. I spent several years trying to get in via the regular work related channels. Eventually I was able to get a work visa to Germany.
Bone to pick with you, how dare a Yankie immigrant make me laugh so much. 😄😄😄😄 Thank you Evan and Happy Xmas.
thank you for saying what is on my mind. I am an international student in the uk, the audacity that the government have to accuse legal migrants for using up taxpayer dollars is insulting and plain disrespectful. I paid before I came not jst for student visa but NHS surcharged for the number of years I study in the UK (not to mention I am a med student so I technically pay to work for the NHS during placement) and have an understanding when I apply for my visa that I do not have any right to any of the benefits within the UK. I have to proof I have enough money in my bank account to fund myself and any dependents that comes with me to the UK (living expenses + housing) and to leave once my visa expires. Please do tell me, which part of this entire thing includes using up tax payer's money?
Perhaps they told you the really bad,bad news so when a week later they told you the just bad news it would sound good,merciful,kind,aw you let us off.
Is illegal immigration a big problem in the UK? I don’t know the numbers but what percentage of immigration to the UK is illegal? I thought it’s a pretty low number compared to the US.
Legal immigration is good if it’s managed carefully and not overdone like in Canada for example
yes it has been a major political sticking point in elections here for years and is the main reason why Brexit was proposed and eventually voted for. The majority of them are asylum seekers/refugees entering via dangerous small boats across the English Channel from France which has a very high fatality rate. In the past year, there were 52,530 illegal migrants detected entering the UK, 17% increase on 2022.
@@laramorrison597353k is not a small number but if I remember correctly the total immigration was at least 10x of that. So the number of illegal immigrants is less than 10%? That can’t have that big of an impact on the economy.
So if you stop all illegal immigration it will reduce the total impact by 10%. Not sure if that’s super significant in the grand scheme of things
@@laramorrison5973 the UK has 67 million people. Surely 53k people coming to it illegally won’t have a big impact. So I was wondering how much of it was a real problem and how much was just political populism.
@@nicktankard1244 inflation, recession, Brexit, strains within the UK relations e.g. calls for Irish reunification and Scottish independence, cuts to devolved government budgets, ageing population, COVID and a health service on the verge of collapse have all fueled racist and anti immigration sentiment among sectors of the population here. Illegal migrantion is costing the government significant funds which are required elsewhere. But it has mostly just been used by the right wing who feel that their idea of what the UK was/should be is under threat as it looks more and more likely that Scotland and Northern Ireland will leave in the coming decades and as the monarchy becomes more and more redundant/unpopular to encourage extremist and racist policies and public sentiment which is forcing the government to respond. It is more of a social issue than economic.
@@laramorrison5973 that makes sense. It’s not much better here in Canada. All the same problems basically
You could argue that they actually wanted to raise it to £29,000 in the first place. But, as frequently happens, they throw a really high number out there, so when they propose the number they want to use, it looks reasonable by comparison.
In terms of the average salary, it’s possible the guardian is using statistics which either don’t include the inflated London salaries or are compensating for them. National minimum wage is around £22k p/a for a full time 37.5hrs a week job. So the figures of £27k being an average would track because while national minimum wage has risen, most salaries have not risen along with it.
This country is such a mess! It’s only taken 13 years for the conservatives to realise austerity doesn’t work. The experts told them that back in 2010, but what do the experts know! 😭
and a very merry christmas to you sir.keep on doing what you do.
It should be Illegal to have more than one home. So everyone can have a home.
You present it well❤
£29000 is not average Salary in UK I think £23000 is.
People don't find a job so it is Immigrants' fault.
NHS going down the drain It is Immigrants' fault.
Rising Living cost is Immigrants' fault.
Economy going dow the drain is Immigrants fault.
It is Not Immigrants' fault It is actually the people who are running this country, it is their fault because they don't care about the people they just want stay in power so they can manupulate the system to get rich themselves Nationally and Internationally. Rishi Sunaks Father-in-Law is A Billionair but he Needs Rishi to Support Genocide of Palestinian so they can clean Gaza because they found Gas and Oil there so Rishi's Father-in-Law can get the oil.
Win Win for the rich and powerful.
They have no concern for people of UK they are just in it for themselves. They all stick together the BBC and the powerful. This is why yoy will never find out the truth. Maintream media Brainwashing people with lies, they always blame everything on Immigrants. Sad but True.
I don't disagree but the Tories would drag their feet at that suggestion. A progressive tax where you pay more per house you own, so single home owners will pay the lowest on their property might be easier to gain general support for. Everything else you've said though, right on the money. If immigration was actually a problem they'd shut it down tomorrow but they haven't, Brexit just opened up the doors for more immigration from outside of the EU so the wealthy elite can benefit from cheap labour and have a scapegoat to point to when anyone questions why shit is tough for the average person.
Gahhh my partner and I have been going crazy because this is literally impacting me right now because I’m waiting on my spouse visa to be approved 😅 this has been an emotional rollercoaster and flurry of texting family members to create plan B and plan C just in case the visa gets rejected from all this chaos.
that sketch of the tories running a supermaket - genius, thank you!
That's stuffed junior doctors chances of a spouse visa for a partner.
Especially when the government think £14 an hour is adequate for them.
The median household income typically where everyone on the low side its two adults working is 35k a year. The number you quoted from ONS is fulltime professionals. Most of the country arent even in fulltime work!
Good rant! As a lifelong Conservative I have finally reached the limit of my tolerance. I will seek a more sensible alternative at the next election, erring towards the Green or Democratic candidate, as nobody sensible should vote for Keir Starmar.
If all sensible candidates went independent we could have the sensible national party forming a UK government. LOL.
@@geraldmcmullon2465 First Past The Post voting ensures that never happens. If the referendum on proportional representation had passed, the Brexit disaster would never have happened, because Cameron wouldn't have been PM.
@@colinmorrison5119 I know, but it is Christmas and I have nothing else to wish for LOL.
If the Government give out the numbers, I make a point of not believing it. We welcome everyone who comes over to work and puts back into our society. We also welcome the people who embrace our culture and values, who do not try and change them but enrich them. I have worked alongside many migrants and most of them just want to live a happy life, give back to the country they live in and get along with everyone. Sadly the narrative is to cause division and it is clearly working. Instead of blaming each other maybe they should blame the people causing it!
I hate this government, so stupid and incompetent it makes me sick!
I just love you John Oliver mode. You're good at this!
I don’t know the actual statistics but in all circles i move in 29k is regarded as a very well paid job and no one i know except my rich siblings earn above that
MPs get more for not working , actually for doing FA.
Im not sure if pwople understands what average means, average is not the minimum at all, average means:
I earn 1000 you earn 3000
Averahe is 2000
I still only earn 1000.
It means putting together rich with poor and then dividing it to give you a sum that means basically nothing
You're killing me with the accents.😂😂😅
Great channel! 🎉😊
Merry Xmas to you, too, Evan. 🎄
6:21 seems to be some confusion between the percentage of immigrants in social housing and the percentage of social housing taken up by immigrants in this section
MPs create and approve laws - and some laws are to benefit themselves. They all agree and nobody can stop them.
My first salary when I moved to the UK was 26K GBP, back in 2001, as a junior Software Engineer. It was a good salary back then. I doubt you can live in Cambridge with that salary anymore. I feel sorry for skilled workers who will have to compete with cheap labor at 29K GBP, while that is not a bad salary for low skilled jobs, it's not worth studying hard to get payed that.
They got it from the Ogre under the Old London Bridge.
That line about "if the tories planned it, the number would be higher" sent me lmfaooo
It’s “like tearing off a plaster” or “ripping off a plaster”. We do say that!