Who should be PFA Player of the Year 2018-19? | BBC Sport
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 05. 2024
- Sergio Aguero, Eden Hazard, Sadio Mane, Bernardo Silva, Raheem Sterling or Virgil van Dijk... which one will win?
Gabby Logan is joined by a panel of Gary Linekar, Alan Shearer, Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink and Melissa Reddy who discuss their pick for PFA Player of the Year.
We also find out their thoughts on the PFA Team of the Year and Young Player of the Year.
Which player is your winner? Let us know in the comments ⬇️
[00:00] - Team of the Year
[12:29] - Young Player of the Year
[17:17] - Player of the Year
Find out who our other pundits winner is here: www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/...
Find all up to date football news here: www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football
From The Premier League Show. Find more episodes here: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode...
=============
SUBSCRIBE so you never miss out on our best videos
➡️➡️bit.ly/1sFodyu
Uploads every Monday - Wednesday - Friday.
=============
Find us here:
BBC Sport: www.bbc.co.uk/sport
Facebook: / bbcsport
Twitter: / bbcsport
Instagram: / bbcsport
#bbcsport #PFA #playeroftheyear
Who should be PFA Premier League Player of the Year? | BBC Sport - Sport
Did the right player win? Let us know in the comments below ⬇️⬇️
Remember to like, subscribe and hit the bell button for notifications. 🔔🔔
yes
Raheem Sterling, but no arguments for Virgil Van Dijk claiming it. Both had cases, but I guess Van Dijk's in the end was too strong.
@@iim1030 lol not even close. Van Dijk the clear winner for everyone understanding football. And the fact that Sterling is even considered when Mo Salah is not is laughable. Sterling goals and assists: 27. Salah goals and assists: 29. I rest my case.
Falx There's a reason y ppl like Shearer n Lineker picked sterling over VVD. U say they don't understand football? They're former players (both excellent in their careers) so I think they know what they're talking about more than u do I do n a lot of other ppl do. Sterling didn't disappear 4 a 15-20 game period like Salah did. Sterling has been consistent throughout the whole season n hasn't dipped in form once. Just because a plyr scores and assists more goals doesn't mean they're better. By your logic, Richarlison had a better season than Bernardo Silva due 2 more goal involvements. But we all know thats not true. Also 2 make it clear I hav no problem with VVD winning POTY.
@@iim1030 15-20 game period? You are delusional. Salah has been vital in every game he's played in. Even though he didn't score for 5 or 6 games in a row he still contributed offensively with brilliant build up and assists. He's also been doublemarked the entire season but he's still Premier Leagues top goalscorer with 21 goals. He was also the first player to reach 20 pl goals just like last season.
I just find it hilarious how Eden is on the player of the year shortlist but not in the team of the year 🤣🤣🤣
Hasselbaink saying Rice>Bernardo...are you having a laugh
Nope he is taking the piss Bernardo is hands down the best CAM in pl.
From a Liverpool fan
Crazy Solo
He doesn’t even play CAM
@@jamesharrywaters He plays versatile positions
Different positions unfair comparisons
Ok then, midfielder/ winger, but still
HAZARD gets the RESPECT.... THANK YOU
He shouldn’t be in there though cause he’s not a midfielder.
@@joshuamceneny3781 He should be in there .
HAZARD in PL this season:
Most goal contribution- 29
Most MOTM- 13
Most assists- 13
Most key passes in open play- 73
Most successful dribble- 122
Most points won- 23
Highest Match Rating- 7.81
You can't touch Van Dirk and Sterling....but nobody else deserves place in TOTY than HAZARD other than them.
But he is an attacker.
joshua mceneny the team doesn’t have to be a 433, he could easily be a winger or striker in a 442
Hazard has been the 2nd best player for me after Sterling. Keeping it aside that I am a man City fan, I just love Hazard and De Bruyne. When they are both fit and firing, the Premier League is different.
How did mustafi the goat not make the TOTY ?
Roasted....
player of the season
Because he’s a turkey
He's always so good and established such a high standard that a little dip in form made him miss the team this year, even though he's still better than the other players.
Mustafi>VVD
Salah and Hazard both have the most goal contributions this season so far (29) yet they are not even in the team of the year. They do the voting at the wrong time.
Mag Tan hazard got robbed but salah didnt turn up as much against big teams for me thats why sterling and mane should be on the wings
@@musclear090 Then where were they against the 'small teams'?
@@No_body7733 he has scored 3 in 10 games against top 6 soooo i mean while mane has heck firmino has
ahmed masood memon as a person who has been all Liverpool games Salah deserves to be there over mane
I know fecking joke! Massive bias too.
Come on Bernardo Silva has been one of the best players this season, along Van Dijk and Sterling...
Saying Rice was better then Bernardo is just being bias!
the jota silva is an absolute superstar
I really like female pundits but your lying if you say her voice is not annoying
im haus I didn’t really find it annoying (not lying)
It's her tone aswell
at least she actually speaks some sense unlike most female pundits, i know that sounds extremely sexist but its just my opinion
dysfynnction I’m not saying what she’s saying is wrong but her voice pains me
dysfynnction R u dumb bruv she dk what she's talking about. She's judging plyrs based on whether other teammates can replace dem if they're not available. What a joke
So Hazard is nominated for player of the year but isn't on the team of the year? that makes a lot of sense! also Pogba there come on!
Declan rice ahead of Bernardo, are u drunk?
Listen to the way they describe why sterling should win. It’s always he’s improved so much, stands up to racism, stood up to the media, he’s a role model and he’s mature.
VVD has had a better season than anyone by far. Mane and Salah should be challenging VVD for player of the year because they’ve both had better seasons than Sterling.
@Emperor Palpatine Because I'm english and I agree that they hype our players too much.
Jimmy is clueless on Salah. Salah has been getting double marked which has freed up space for mane, hence why mane has bagged more goals lately. He has still influenced the game even when he's not scoring.
This has been the case for Hazard for years
This is the most true thing I’ve seen all day
The amount of time Salah could assist Mane this season is crazy he don't want Mane to shine
Salah has 8 assists, Mane has like 2. Over the whole season Salah has been better, but not bye much. Just going to say, if Salah and Mane were English, Alan and Gary would be jizzing in their pants, clear bias. No joke, Raheem wouldn’t get into Liverpool’s team.
@@adjam4014 Unless if they were playing a 4-2-3-1 with salah at striker
If your talking influence it will be vvd or hazard
BigBoy Steve hahahahahahaha.. to pick a influential player then it must be VVD.. hazard great but Chelsea way behind Liverpool
Beeman Chelsea every Attack goes through hazard. He is the focal point of Chelsea Attack. Not surprise he has great figures to show. But that’s not enough if his team is shit
Ask Hazard to go and play with Messi, he will be transparent
@@poolfans I don't think what you're saying is making the point it is. Because everything goes through Hazard, he is the most influential player.
Beeman salah and hazard have the same goal contributions...
@@bigmick5978 yeah but Hazard has won the most points individually of anyone in the league and in a poor team too
99%of you - The Rat in the background.
1%- I love Sterling/ Van Dijk.
Bernando Silva for me has been the best Man city player this season.
You said it right for you
should have been a nominee for ballon d'or imo
They should’ve done a Toty without the top six.... would’ve been much more interesting
Btown DJ or just without the top 2 lol
James W yeah that’s a shout tbh 😂
I'd probably go for:
GK: Fabianski
RB: Wan-Bissaka
CB: Schar
CB: Boly
LB: Digne
CDM: Ndidi
CDM: Neves
LM: Anderson
CAM: Maddison
RM: Richarlison
ST: Jimenez
@@MashiatCOD99 I mostly agree but no Foster? Bournemouth's Fraser has been a beast too!
Rooted. Fabianski has been better than Foster. And I had actually forgotten completely about Ryan Fraser.
son and hazard are at the wrong teams to be considered for team of the year. put them at liverpool or man city and they'd be team of the year every year, criminally underrated.
1:59 when did alexander-arnold switch for city
i just thought that
Yeah, Liverpool swapped him for Messi after Barcelona let his contract run out and he went to City on a free. I’m surprised you didn’t know.
It is weird how everybody is saying that Salah is having a bad season and that Sterling is having an amazing season because Salah actually has more direct goal contributions this season (goals, assists). Just saying.
Really enjoy Jimmy's critique and output in this conversation. Well spoken lad.
9:36 BREAKING NEWS: Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink is already losing it at 47 years of age
Lmao AWB is 13 months older than TAA.
hes also only played 1 year of professional football at rb and made the most tackles in europe...
VanixOwen_99 he can also actually defend, hope this helps 👍👍
I am a man united fan and I'd go with VVD for POTY
Zeeshan Hussain I’m a Liverpool fan but how is allison not the keeper he has more clean sheets
How can he disagree with Bernardo, absolutely foolosh
In Gary linekers team Alexander Arnold's had a light blue dot for man city instead of Liverpool
TheRealHarref 1 annoyed me, glad I wasn’t the only one
A panel of 3 forwards who all went for Sterling - what a surprise. Not one person as dribbled past VVD all season.
desertman1962 gnabry did
Melissa Reddy knows he football damn
She blamed Liverpool losing to City on the grass and said City's groundsmen purposely sabotaged the pitch. She really doesn't.
@@tobymorrell3987 I think they did something with the grass, but she didn't cite that as the main reason. I'm just impressed with her knowledge of stats over the other analysts, not because she is a woman.
Fabianski, Wan Bissaka, Van Dijk, Laporte, Robertson, Pogba, Bernardo Silva, Sterling, Son, Aguero, Hazard
This team will relegate
I think Gary struggles with not hosting lol
big admiration for sterling but all he's done is maintained form from last season. 17 goals is normal for a team that scores 100 in the league. Due to his needless criticism it's nice he's being viewed in a positive light now, the racism situation is off the pitch and he's won an award for it so that's irrelevant to on the pitch performances, but he doesn't even come close to winning player of the season. Him sane aguero have all scored similar amount of goals assists. it's all been maintained, when we say Player of the season it needs to be a massive influence! like salah broke the record of goals 32 (still top goal scorer 21) but even he doesn't come close to winning it again, however virgil completely transformed the defence and no one in the league has dribbled past him or dominated him. His stats are more incredible from his growth, all the attackers this season have all been on similar levels Liverpool's front 3 and man city's front 3.
Sane is Man Citys 3rd or 4th choice winger
@@chaskirby191 sane is more of a winger than bernado silva it's basically like putting lallana for Liverpool there. more of an attacking mid but pep was more defensive protection so recently playing b.silva on the wing instead of sane.
@@hhassan2985 cute. But not true. B Silva is just a much much better footballer. Saying sane is on the same level as Sterling or Aguero is equivalent to saying Lallana is like mane or Salah.
@@chaskirby191 you're clearly not understating my point, football brain wise players like b.silva lallana when he wasn't injured can play anywhere in midfield attack so you can't stereotype them as wingers or wide players. players are sane can't player in midfield Don't have the cuteness football intellect to tactically play there. the fact I to explain this shows your knowhow is limited b.silva lallana are managers dream work hard forever set tones and tempo. I never mentioned who's better, have some football sense
@@hhassan2985 Your understanding of football is as good as your English.
Hasn’t it been confirmed that VVD won the PFA AND sterling the Young PFA?
it wont be officially announced until sunday but it was leaked yes
GoatSince1997 where was it leaked
@@dharmamuthalagappan1329 FIFA lol
Thank god hazard had got some recognition.
Most goal contributions, most key passes, most assists, most dribbles complete, most man of the matches awards.
Also scored a reasonable amount of goals. It's a robbery let alone a shock that he isn't in the PFA team of the year. I think sterling is the player he is because of service, I don't mean to offend anyone but I think he doesn't have the same confidence as he did when he was at Liverpool. I barely see sterling cross or even have accurate shots. Most of the time he seems to be nervous up against a defender but he can score tap ins/rebounds. Sorry but this is based on what I've seen so don't be offended
Team of the season should be :
Alisson
AWB. VVD. Laporte. Robo
Fernandinho
Silva .B. Hazard
Sterling. Aguero. Mane
AWB
There's a simple reason why Mo Salah should be on the list: not only is he league leader in scoring with 21 goals but he also has 8 assists. So he is the most effective forward in the league with 29 direct plays leading to goals.
@Emperor Palpatine The fact that Hazard is not on the list just proves how ridiculous the whole thing is
Schar is a very good defender but it's just an attempt to stand out from the crowd for me. Laporte is absolutely streets ahead. World class performance at Anfield and most games this season. Only blemish was the Spurs 4-3
Good to see Hasselbaink being appreciated, unlike what's happened in his homeland the Netherlands. He's been absolutely phenomenal as a striker
Why Pogba I know he has good stats but Hazard been far more consistent.
Hazard has also dragged his team more
Because Hazard doesn't play Midfield. Same way they chose Robertson over Salah for Left Back
Player of the year Bernardo or Mané and a great wow for Sterling and Virgil.
Andrew Robertson isn’t on that player of the year shortlist what is life 🏴 🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
Declan rice better than Bernardo 😂😂😂
Wow no mention for Raul Jimenez, Jota? Just because they aren't in a 'Big Team' they have both been incredible!
Sterling’s numbers? Salah has very similar numbers, not even nominated. Clearly VVD, it’s so obvious
I can't take anything Melissa says serious after she blamed Liverpools loss to City on the grass.
Didn't even talk about aguero....the best PL striker at least for the last few years
Jaivanth Arul he’s average af. Has he scored 33 goals in a season? I think not. He plays the premier league on easy with that team behind him.
Ad Jam I’m not gonna say anything as I think you’re taking the piss.
Kane has been the best for the past 3 years
Van Dijk clearly. Is there even a doubt? LOL
Funny he wasn't even considered when he played for Southampton yet he was just as good a defender. Obvious Liverpool bias
@@GuinessOriginal preach
@@GuinessOriginal no because he's improved since he's came to Liverpool and is surrounded by better players
@@GuinessOriginal im an inter milan fan for 13 years now and neutral when it comes to every other league except Croatian league (where im from) lol
@@cianrideout3139 yes, Liverpool and their shit defence from last season have improved van dijk, not the other way round at all 😂
So pogba gets in the toty over hazard but hazard is a nominee for player of the year over pogba nice one
How didn't Jenkinson make the PFA Team of the year. Fuckin' crackin' player.
Shearer says sterling because of the goals and assists but hazard has the most combined goals and assists out of everyone and he's carrying chelsea as well
Hes got something against Liverpool players it seems. Sterling over VVD, Ederson over Allison and Wan Bissaka over TAA
@@SMDOP or he's just smart. ederson miles better than Allison
wan bissaka much better stats than taa in a much weaker team
and as for van dijk he might as well not be making a difference at Liverpool because they still win no trophies
Chelsea was 20+ points behind City
i love these
In Dutch "hij is altijd zo lekker gewoon gebleven" means "he kept being
so normal".......except his defending. ;o) Thank you Groningen (called
"Grung" in dialect). PFA man and woman are Dutch players. Although it's not
Vivianne, but Vivienne Miedema. Klopp can flip from time to time but
hearing the players he must be a very good coach as well. Congrats
Virgil and Vivienne. Keep on going. All the best.
Absolutely no biased from Alan Shearer and Gary Lineker whatsoever 🤦♂️
Thumbs up for Sterling, Comment for Van Dijk
Where can I watch the whole thing?
How Pogba got into the TOTS is beyond me when u have got the likes of Bernardo silva, Hazard, Neves, Eriksen and Son who all somehow missed out
Tesco’s Finest do you mean David Silva
Most of them aren't CM's. Am I missing something?
VVD THE COLOSAL for pfa
Bernardo Silva deserves it.
Why doesn't anyone mention David Silva, not even in the comments? That City midfield is incredible, so far above everyone else's, yet David Silva is forgotten?
Salah has more goals and assists than Sterling this season but still isn't considered? Hahaha
biased english media
Hazard has to be there🔵
It's the timing of the vote that is why players like Pogba are in this team.
Sterling should win sports personality, not pfa
Sterling should be both.
Agreed. VVD IS the reason that Liverpool are title contenders. City can replace sterling with sane and he’ll do a similar job.
Melissa knows what she doing as a pundit so articulated
Anyone who puts Hazard in a Midfield role in Team of the Year - doesn't understand how Team of the year works.
The arguments they're putting sterling aren't backing him for player of the year. His numbers aren't that great level to mane, salah hazard. His off the pitch influence shouldn't matter although it's great and yes his improvement is good but doesn't make him pots. Van dijk transformed Liverpool, 20 goals conceded, you take him out and Liverpool still look suspicious. Van dijk should win player of the year and sterling should win sports personality of the year
Afrokid 10 completely agree
sterling transformation from a snake to a human
Luis Suarez was so right when he went out in public and said English Media is 1 big BS and thats why he is leaving PL for La Liga, such bias everywhere, numerous players have done what Raheem Sterling has achieved over the years and even this season few have been better than him, I know no one who has been as good as VVD this season and even if that is subjective , show me someone who has not been dribbled past for an entire year against such great forwards in the opponents , ridiculous to even think beyond VVD
The fact that Fernandinho isn’t in everyone’s team is shocking; once he came back city were back to winning ways. Fernandinho is the anchor for that team
Sterling - mane for midtfielders/wings kandidats. And Aguero -Salah for striker kandidats. As a City fan I would say sterling. But All 4 have had a great season.
Typical pundit... When Melissa pointed out that Salah was still influencing games when he wasn't scoring and Hasselbaink just says "was he?" "he tries too hard" as if that is a valid counter argument... Smh.
Melissa Reddy smashing it! Keep striving, keep climbing girl! 🔴
Dont understand how their all saying its a two horse race, totally forgetting that hazards got the most goal contributions&is leading in most stats but lets overlook that for a tap-in merchant cool👊🏾...
9:13 as an Irish person I justed wanted to die🤣🤣😫
Its not even a debate. VVD all day. The guy hasnt been dribbled past yet ffs! His impact on Liverpool is matched by noone. If he doesnt win its bs! Then how good must a defender be to win??
Dolphin Godfather It's easier 4 VVD 2 stand out in the Liverpool back 4 than 4 Sterling 2 stand out among Man City's array of attacking talents. The impact a plyr has made isn't the most significant aspect as it concerns what was there b4 the player arrived or came 2 form, which has nothing 2 do with the actual plyr itself, hence Sterling should b POTY even b4 u consider what he's been through off the pitch
@Banter FC Fair enough salah and mane has scored more then sterling but he is not shit
@@iim1030 If it's harder to stand out then he does not deserve to be POTY, messi plays with coutinho and suarez yet he still stands out because he is a phenomenal player.
Huzz 1st of all that's the whole point u twat, Sterling is a phenomenal plyr, he DOES stand out. 2nd, it's the other way round u idiot (Suarez still gets a lot of recognition even tho messi always steals the show). Coutinho is dead so don't mention him he's not top tier. Also don't even use messi 2 compare the 2 situations coz 1 that's unfair n 2 he is probably the best plyr the world has ever seen so y mention him in a conversation with raheem sterling. Sterling will nvr reach those heights nobody will. Ppl r so quick 2 find excuses 4 sterling POTY argument. I guess u got what u wanted as VVD won n sterling won the young POTY.
He has been dribbled past, sane done him and he fouled him for a penalty, so unlucky mate haha
Whose Schar? Forget him now name sounds familiar though anyway not wrong Melissa there with Van Dijk- he is just the definition of commanding
i think of TAA as a 20 year old...
He is 20
What in the fuck was that noise at 10:02!! LMAO
nice thanks
jimmy floyd really likes young players ;)
VD and for cutest pundit Melissa Reddy x
The reason Alisson deserves to be in TOTY is because Alisson have more saves, better saves percentage, more clean sheets than Ederson and Brazil number 1 goalkeeper ahead of Ederson because he's better than Ederson.
Also makes lots of silly mistakes and hasn't got 4 assists like ederson
@@GuinessOriginal first, it's his first season of course he made mistakes even Ederson made a lot of mistakes when he first came to PL. Second, Ederson only got 1 assists in PL. Third, gk job is to SAVES SHOTS and keep CLEAN SHEETS which Alisson is better than Ederson. Fourth by your "he made assists" logic you're saying Paul Robinson and Jussi Jaaskelainen is a better goalkeeper than Ederson because they have more assists than Ederson when they're playing.
Guinness 2 mistakes which have not cost Liverpool a single point. As for assists I don't think it's something to bring to the table to display how good s goal keeper is. I'd rather have my keeper make more saves, more clean sheets and have a higher save rate, like alisson does.
@@wadeyone12 yeah well in that case you should go for been Foster cos he's got the best save ratio in the league. Allisons made at least half a dozen mistakes and yeah you've been lucky he's not cost you yet, but it could've easily been you on the other end of the goalkeeping errors you benefited from at Everton, Fulham, Tottenham and Palace. As for ederson, Pep preferred a keeper who can play with his feet and who's distribution is top class, after breaking every record going last season and scoring 157 goals to Liverpools 100 in this, who am I to argue with him? In any case, it's a mute point because ederson got the nod
Dont terrorist TOTY with your Alisson and didnt mention VVD infront of him
Of course Lineker brings up his Messi fantasy.
Melissa is usually a Liverpool shill but respect for picking up Heung-min Son
Loving the inclusion of Declan Rice
I don't no how u could ever choose Allison over Ederson because its vvd who is the crucial player in that squad. Georginio Wijnaldum over Fernandinho you must be having a laugh awb is a solid player as well
Face Griffo ederson is a better goalkeeper
Because he is the better keeper
im sorry i havent watched every man city game this season but what about Sterlings numbers that everyone keeps bringing up is so great? They are pretty good yes but he doesnt have the best stats in league. Mohamed Salah has 21 goals and 8 assists, thats only two assists less than Sterling and 4 goals more than him. Same with Aguero who has 19 goals and 8 assist what he lacks in assists he makes up for in goals.
-Madmoe- makes no sense he hasn’t been better that much better than the other attackers, Hazard has 16 goals and 13 assists (29 goal contributions) in a much lesser side. Sterling is only getting hyped up because he’s English
@@Bpl76300 Yes i forgot to mention Hazard as well.
I agree with jimmy about salah
Maybe do one based on stats?
1:57 why has Alexander Arnold got a blue Man City icon???
Sterling running around at the back! 2:17
1:54 Trent plays for city of course
Alexis Sanchez no doubt
Why isn't there a PFA Player of the decade? My nominees for 2010s would be Hazard, Silva, de Gea and Aguero.
Not Pogba
Does anyone else think that if Gomez didn't get injured before Christmas it would be a complete LFC back 4?
10:52 gets me excited
No one said a word about Aguero?
Why is everyone saying it is a two horse race when sterling has got a combined goals of 27 but both Salah and hazard have a combined goals of 29 and who says sterlings has even been the best city player cause aguero has also got the same combined goals in less games and people are saying he is always peps go to man the whole season but Bernardo Silva has played more games. I’m not saying he doesn’t deserve to win as he has had an incredible season and I know he has been helping fight racism. I just feel that they are excluding other players who have in my opinion performed aswell if not better that sterling in the premier league this season
I hate the disraspect Eden gets, mans arguably prem player of the decade
Van dijk all day....everyday
He's overated , panics all the time, Scored so many own goals, just crap !!
What does aming and aring mean at 19:45 please I need to know 😂
They're the sounds you make when you're not sure about something and can't decide.
I think Ederson is a bigger shock than Pogba for me. He’s in top 5 all time pl clean sheets for a season and could even finish as 2nd of all time. Also there is such an English bias over sterling. 2nd in poty and in the toty over Salah who is gonna win the golden boot and is supposedly having a bad season, which is still better than sterling’s best lol
Why is there no love 4 Ryan fraser
He has been absolutely Great this season.
And Declan Rice are u insane m8.
Sometimes i dont get their choises.