Editorial with Sujit Nair: We will send them marching off to Tihar Jail: SC
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 10. 2023
- Join Our WhatsApp Group:
linktr.ee/sujitnair
In this editorial episode, Mr. Sujit Nair addresses the recent contempt of court proceedings initiated by the Supreme Court of India against the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT). The Supreme Court took a strong stance on Wednesday against NCLAT's judicial member Rakesh Kumar and technical member Alok Srivastava for allegedly violating its order and delivering a judgment.
A three-judge bench led by Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud expressed their displeasure, stating that they were prepared to send these individuals to Tihar jail if they defied the Supreme Court's order. The Chief Justice emphasized the court's authority and stated that they believed the NCLAT members had attempted to defy their order, making them liable for contempt proceedings.
The bench has summoned the two officials to appear in person before the court on October 30, highlighting concerns about a systemic issue, describing it as a ""rot"" that has affected both the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and NCLAT. This specific case served as an example of this problem.
The Supreme Court was examining a case related to the disclosure of results from the Annual General Meeting (AGM) of Finolex Cable. On October 13, the Supreme Court directed NCLAT to issue its judgment and declare the AGM results only after receiving the scrutinizer's report. However, the NCLAT did not comply with this directive.
Upon learning of this, the Chief Justice instructed NCLAT's chairperson, Justice Ashok Bhushan, to provide a report regarding the defiance of the Supreme Court's order.
The allegation against the NCLAT bench is that they disregarded the Supreme Court's order issued earlier in the day, despite being informed of it.
The order in question was issued by the Supreme Court on Friday morning, instructing the NCLAT not to deliver its judgment in a pending appeal until the scrutinizer's report, declaring the AGM results, was available.
During the hearing, the Chief Justice expressed his astonishment at the NCLAT's actions, particularly when they were explicitly informed of the Supreme Court's instructions. He stressed that individuals with significant resources and influence should not attempt to manipulate the court, and he emphasized the court's commitment to upholding its orders.
The Supreme Court overturned the NCLAT's order and made it clear that Corporate India should understand that the court is vigilant and will act when its orders are subverted. The Chief Justice also noted concerns about a judge's impartiality and instructed Justice Ashok Bhushan to rehear the case.
#nclat #supremecourt #dychandrachud #chiefjusticeofindia #finolexcables #youth #youngindia #administration #tiharjail #HWNews
To Join CZcams Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
![tattoo printer tutorial[제품단순선물]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g40_GwEJak0/mqdefault.jpg)
I wish the SC would take concrete action instead of just reprimanding. We are waiting for the SC to restore democracy,as it's our only hope.
Upto what extent can SC take action. Can a mandate passed by the Rajya Sabha be declared null by the SC.
It's the people who voted for this government. Let them take the consequences and be satisfied with MPs like Brij Bhushan etc.
Don’t talk like a looser. I didn’t and never will, but all those who voted them in should think a hundred times before the next elections.
SC can declare any law unconstitutional.
It’s about time the Supreme Court enforced the law , and punishes the ED, and CBI, according to the laws of the land. If they behave in an unlawful manner, how can citizens have any faith in these agencies, whose salaries are paid by the public.
Absolutely high time…how long will this tyrant go about with his dictatorship…enough is enough.
How will the SC do that? To enforce it's orders it will need police . And who controls police? SC is powerless
The present union government and state governments ruled by BJP are pathetically not respecting academics/ judiciary/ constitution., interfering with the functions of autonomous institutions like CBI, ED, EC,etc reducing the values of democracy, equality etc .
How rightlly and aptly you have observed and courageously highlighted it. Hats off to you…. Keep continuing your observations 👍🙏🏻
Simply, fascist!
Yes u are right … let’s shift to Gaza
It is high time to dismantle the present dispansation to stop further deteriortion of peace and tranquility.
@@deec2564 don't make the effort. Gaza will come here.
Suprime Court should take action immediately
In stead of passing comments and giving instructions Supreme court must use directly to pass orders against the accused persons/agencies/departments in the form of certain penal actions.
The accused don’t seem to bother DC as they are protected by Govt….I really don’t know what is the next step of action by Supreme Courts. Don’t the Contempt of Court doesn’t apply to them….& SC initiate action directly….I think we have not come across such disobedience and arrogance before 2014…..!
Yea
Excellent remarks on anarchy. And good advice. Thank you.
Judiciary is short of giving orders. No orders no fear. Now use of having such court. In local courts nothing what the courts say is obeyed is my experience in spite of giving it to court.
I really appreciate the CJI’s concerns about the present political situation in India. But why he is not taking any actions on those issues?.
Great editorial! Always different from others.
Only when the Honble SC court steps into action mode those kinds of people will start to listen and also others will have a fear on the Judiciary. Why is SC delaying the punishment
Supreme court should start taking action instead of just talking and complaining.
Indians are just not wired to accepting laws and rules in a personal family situation too. This lack of seriousness goes all the way to the top. Choose to live in the West and my mothers flat has been disputed for thirteen years since her death. Powerless to have any judicial justice and was told by expensive lawyers that better to arbitration but even that has failed and we will be dead and so will our children before this juggernaut judicial system is fixed
Thank you Mr. Nair for your warnings on the way the justice is administered in our country and also the way our youth are employed
Exactly, well Said.
Excellent 👍
Unfortunate. SCI IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS. UNDOUUNTEDLY
If this s is the fate of our Supreme court, I have no idea where my country is leading me.
Thanks for a clear update.
Very boldly said,Sir. ED arrests,keeps in jail for many months, without Court giving Bails and ED not filing Chargesheets. Shame,shame and I am an Advocate.
Do we say Supreme Court or “SCARED COURT”?
Keep up your good work
SC need to take contempt of court on all the prople who are taking serious on the judgment and i am sure CJI DY Chandrachut is having that guts and he will take appropriate action on all the three...🙏🙏🙏
Wonderful analysis
Sheer lawlessness! The action on contempt of Court should be taken immediately and exemplary punishment should be given to the defaulters so that the Majesty of the Rule of Law is established unquestionably. Wilful disrespect by the powerful should be dealt with, with a heavy hand. What was being attempted to in Israel, which resulted in people taking to the streets to protect the Judiciary, must be borne in mind. We just cannot have such a situation here.
Another informative analysis.
What a pathetic situation of our Supreme Court. When will we get relieved from all this. Before 2924 everything will be shattered and irreparable I suppose…. I am really frustrated Sujith Sir😩😩😩😩😩
Liked your comment but life in the world is frustrating but every country has verying degrees of frustrated people but some countries like India the world's largest democracy has a higher proportion. It is up to every individual to make a difference in the family community and wider world
Sir awaiting your thoughts on Hirandani turning approver Clearly he’s under pressure. Look how he praises a few and give a motive to Mahua’s questioning of Adani
Nice 👍
Sujitji
Very good examples Principal & CJI with NCLAT,Assembly Speaker & someone in high spirits👏👏👏
Youth needs channeling for betterment of nation
👍
Sujit I like the way of your presentations, simple and to the point.
I pray May ALMIGHTY fulfill all your noble desires and grant you success in all your endeavours......
A M E N. . . . .
Great sentiments but Almighty does not exist it is an illusion. Sorry to burst your bubble. As Karl Marx theory goes "Religion is the opium of the masses" and Mr. J. Nehru also was a firm believer of this theory
👌👌
Frightening what country we are in
Absolutely interesting edition lots to understand our young India hope our government is aware of this situation and more about our Supreme Court too.
Excellent sir.
Very sad
❤
People have to think and vote and restore democracy
It is no longer merely Contempt of Court but contempt for the Indian Constitution and the system as a whole. The present ruling dispensation is totally innocent about how a modern nation state is supposed to be governed. In the process, it makes a complete mockery of the sacred bodies or institutions, which are enshrined in our Constitution and are imperative if our nation and its citizens are to exist within the framework of a modern nation state, such as rule of law and respect for human rights.
You are still young dear.
keeping the spirit of democracy alive.....
The term 'Condemnt of court ' seems to a story of the past.
Mr Nair excellent analysis cum assessment esp the present status of Hon'ble SC n the respectable CJI chair held by Shri Chadrachud. Yes I in my personal capacity n as a citizen of democratic Bharat Shri Chadrachud has proven his incompetency, inefficiency n helpless to conduct balanced judicial proceedings thereby people's trust n confidence in highest Judiciary is going southwards.
It’s sad cause we trusted him but now we know. He is with them and for them.
It is particularly jarring when the CJI was educated at one of the best universities in the US. CJI must also have observed how justice is delivered and implemented! Just don't get it. Surely as an individual why not follow through with any case to show your authority in the name of justice
Nice editorial.. good humours as well😊
You are Correct
Will the politicians allow the youth to flourish or do religious divide.
You will see in 2024 before the elections whether election is based on religion, whether it costs a lot of money and if there is sufficient money left for youth to flourish.
Excellent comment!! Hope for Indian youth with your observation. STAY clear of Religion. Spirituality is a personal issue, not to please parents society and friends and neighbours
🙏
Super
Yes very interesting data
Beautiful Sujit as always
Good Evening Sujit
This is emergency without declaring officially, this is our new india developed india
Sir, I agree with you 100% when the principal office is not ok the school not. But in this case the principal's office not the office of CJ of India. The Judiciary cannot be accounted for administration I feel.
The mint has to appreciate Sujit for his beautiful analysis on its beautiful column
Can not .
Good topics. Failure of administration, legality, discipline.
Who's responsible for these chaos?
What are the remedial measures?
I am sure that people like you can educate our inexperienced Government the values of Democracy.
Supreme Court has been rendered ineffective. Half hearted decisions and inaction, delays are to my mind are the reasons. dilly dallying is so apparent in its proceedings... such a shocking state of affairs
Also the hunger index points to not so good health quality future of the country.
👍
Dear Mr Nair I am among those who greatly appreciate you , and among those who look up to all constitutional institutions with great expectancy . I feel very sad and let down when you deride Supreme Court of India and CJI . Why don't you support the Institution and expose the pressures they are undergoing and how much the executive is trying to subjugate all the constitutional institutions . We are indebted to our Nation to support all constitutional institutions ,
Objective criticism is healthy in order to right wrongs despite challenges from Governments. The CJI is the last port of call and authority to vociferously persevere in following the constitution to the letter. Mr. Nair's criticism must not be taken personally ever
We want democracy of the past.
Sir what you said is absolutely correct, we in AP are seeing this, chandrababu naidu has been arrested without any evidence and still in jail since 48 days, still no justice, this is becoz of BJP and YCP
There is lack of respect. Lets hope our #cji will fix this issue. Penalty on public servants will create respect for law of the land
Hearing is On for ElectolBond in Supreme court.I feel the same fate will occure liike the examples. Ruling party will crush others with corrupt money
Point is, respect for law, morality and ethics has overall decreased since past few years.
Sadly not just in the last few years but the last sixty years. As am old enough to remember my growing up and student days in India. One of the reasons why I chose to move to the West. Sick of lies paying bribes and this goes to close family too. E.g. If one family member has worked their socks off she or he is expected to provide for other family members who feel entitled because it is family. Indians have a lot of course correction as far as ethics go. A mindset based on the dark ages
Supreme Court has continued asking this question- when will it be seen to deliver justice? Where is the proof ased in which oeople loke Sisodia, Sanjay Singh and Umar Khalid are in jail for so long
The speaker should be jailed immediately. If he has no respect for the highest court...then he cannot hold the constitutional post. Arrest him. Let him be in tihar jail
If the Apex Court gives a direction to the executive and the the Excutive does not obey, what can the court do? In my opinion - nothing. We will see this soon.
Actually all the case this dogs are purchased time - must be take action against this dogs 🐕 before 2024 - and put them in jail
Can't the court bite instead of always barking.
You forgot that earlier CJI N V RAMANA has given directions to finish all cases against the politicians within the year. Two years are passed
❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉
I have a DV case in the Jucicial Magistrate court in Alipore, Kolkata . I got an order for interim relief after 4 years' since filing of the case , only after a high court order. Still , the next half of the HC order to fix a date on every month to finish the case, to the JM is ignored by the JM . Things are like this , and a contempt petition has to be initiated , I guess.
Not only the society but also the institutions are equally responsible and sharing the sin have been committing by the agents of darkness (imitating light) and thereby hindering the menufastation of TRUTH.
Ultimately the onus should be on the educated voters, who should take an unbiased stand towards the fundamentals of our democracy. Else the time is not far when we will be bystanders of epic collapse of biggest democracy.
Govt is not clearing list of judges recommended by collegium ,
Court is not having power to control them
SC is spineless, if ED has not making the charges, and kept innocent behind the bars with out valid reason, then who stop SC to grant bail.
The Last Man Standing - CJI CHANDRACHUD❤
You could have concluded as to what will happen when the youth which you referred to in the second part look upto the institutions , which you mentioned in the first part for guidance!
The caption is misleading with respect to the editorial
In guj even trial courts, drts, do not obey judgements of sc.
Cji not capable for the post and citizens suffering after paying him.
For India to grow you need two things, law & order and infrastructure. Look what happened to Vodafone & The BBC. It's not the job of the government to go after companies, it's the job of the regulator and the decision is made by the courts. This also happens at State level. It's easier to do business in other countries even if you're Indian.
That’s the reason hundreds of our businesses have left our country. I just hope God saves us from these tyrants.
Sadly God cannot save you from these tyrants as God doesn't exist! Religion and God provide Hope to humanity but people at an individual level have to analyse the pros and cons of any religion. Religion has never been a force for good unfortunately but to divide people. God has never provided an egalitarian system of altruism
I will agree all your points but when the ruling party wants to over power SC and not respecting our constitution what we can expect, we don't want such ruling or ruling party in our country, let us wait upto 2024 lokasabha election results truthfully majority people wants that.
Young Country with Highest Unemployment. 😂
Sujit Ji should encourage population in India to increase faster then we have many young Indians and foreigners can invest in India exploit the abundant labour market thus make huge profits. Aaa haaa... What a Logic..
We don't take care of our youth... Will such an establishment worry about the elderly?
Brought a smile to my face. Spot on. Politicians do not care about the youth so the elderly have zero hope. Politicians are in power to line their own pockets and boost their Jupiter-size Egos.
Judiciary is the custodian of constitution and should ensure its values are adhered but it's unfortunate that our SC always play safe instead of issuing concrete judgement/verdict. In spite of misuse of ED, CBI and such investigation agencies being used to settle score with opposition parties by the ruling BJP Govt, the Supreme Court is mere mute spectator.
This is called dictorshtip
Supreme judges
Ref court : everyone try to follow Mody
Yes it true that the principal is in shambles. But does the incumbent principal responsible for the mess? Is he to be blamed for the present state of affairs? I raised the question when things started going awry. How can things whether it is bcoz of politicians or conmen, are allowed to happen that are in defiance of the constitution of the country when we have SC to ensure and to safeguard it? Bcoz the SC was manned by unfit men for the past several years. Now the situation in the country is that the IT Cell of the political parties have taken the control of the judiciary and made SC a mere entity. It is the biggest shame shame for the biggest democratic country. I think and expect DYC to change the course and set the things right but will he able to do in his tenure? At least the country must learn lesson from this shabby state of affairs.
11:25 they are busy creating chaos due to this ruthless govt...
Everything in the doldrums😅
Channel, income, percentage, infrastructure, elderly, population, ageing, 65 age, warning signal, SAAB JARGONS!!😂
Sorry for the typos
Shame on our SC. You have FAILED the Citizens in so many ways. Only big ‘Bhashan’, no actual action on those who scoff or scorn against YOU.
We are good in corruption. Who cares about our youth and old generation.
Our government just think about few corporates and Politicians just think about their families.
God bless our country!
When seemingly ( sic) Executive, & Legislative starts collaboration together with Media,the fourth ( supposedly) pillar , against the public interest The Judiciary is supreme to step- in to break the Nexus for the sake of Democracy ...
Sir, It is the executive arm of the Govt and not the SC responsible for the rot. A muscle man goes about molesting young women, the Police do not make an FIR despite complaints before the Magistrate. The matter reaches the Higher Courts, still no action. Then it reaches the SC and the police make the FIR but do not make the arrest or even the charge sheet. The muscle man roams about undeterred while the victims face jails. Do our citizens want Kangaroo courts and mob justice. We are not talking about school administration but the very Rule of Law. Today it is the Courts, the turn of our bureaucracy and political masters will be next.Then nobody will listen even to elected politicians..
It may not be right to say that people as they age, become victims of physical infirmities, become idle or unproductive or compulsorily need to be confined to care centers and old age homes. In India there are countless number of senior citizens, who remain active way beyond the age of 65, are independent, live a life of dignity and do not need any assistance from their own progeny or the State. The anchor seems to have invested a disproportionate amount of optimism in the power of the youth, which in any case does not corroborate or be endorsed on what is happening in the real world. Ageing is not a sin but a natural process. We have no power to avert it, as much as we have no power to avert the grave.