Editorial with Sujit Nair: No bar from appointment as Judges for views held as party members: CJI
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 11. 2023
- In this editorial episode, Mr. Sujit Nair addresses the controversy surrounding remarks made by Victoria Gowri, who was later appointed as an additional judge of the Madras High Court. Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud responded to concerns about the Supreme Court Collegium's recommendation of Justice Victoria Gowri, emphasizing that a person should not be disqualified from a high judicial office based on their past political affiliations or the clients they represented as a lawyer.
Chief Justice Chandrachud highlighted that the judicial appointment process is a collaborative effort, with no single branch of the state having a decisive role. Justice Gowri faced accusations from petitioners in the Supreme Court, alleging that she had made hate speech against minority communities on social media. Petitioners, including Anna Mathew and senior advocate R. Vaigai, urged President Droupadi Murmu to reconsider the Collegium's recommendation.
The Chief Justice defended the idea that lawyers, over their careers, represent a diverse range of clients and should not be disqualified from becoming judges based solely on their past political associations. He emphasized the duty of lawyers to provide legal aid without presuming guilt or innocence. This perspective was shared during an interaction organized by the Harvard Law School.
#supremecourtofindia #dychandrachud #victoriagowri #judiciary #madrashighcourt #chiefjusticeofindia #islam #christianity #bjp #bhartiyajanataparty #adani #sebi #somasekharsundaresan #courts #highcourt #sc #SujitNair #HWNews
To Join CZcams Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
17 January 2023, the Collegium of the Supreme Court of India assented to her elevation as a judge of the Madras High Court. About a fortnight later, it was alleged that she had given hate speeches against religious minorities. The hearing was held before a bench of Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai and Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul on the morning of 7 January; they dismissed the case upon an oral hearing, refusing to challenge the wisdom of the collegium by adjudicating the "suitability" of a judge. The editorial erroneously mentions “if she gets selected”.
SC has assented to her elevation as only an additional judge....
Not 100years we may need another 1000years to shape this nation to give a fair governance and a fair justice.
0⁰
Her judgement is likely to be as biased as her views n beliefs.
I was Hindu but now I m Christian and I m proud to be Christian because My judge Is Jesus who never teaches violence .
Praise God
Praise GOD
Hallelujah 🙋🏻♀️ 🙋🏻♀️ 🙋🏻♀️ 🙋🏻♀️
then what is crusade wars...don't talk rubbish..Islam and Christianity both have same cruelty in their religion and they both did same genocides to spread their religions..now christianity taking kind path but we know why..
Ha ha ha Brahmdev got married his own daughter - saraswati @@blackseven1987
Yes Madam Victoria, We Christians are more dangerous than others simply because we believe in Prayers not violence. Praying For believers and non believers for Peace In our hearts, Peace in our country and Peace among people in our world. And we believe that our merciful and just God will hear our prayers and protect us. Our God has his own way of setting things right.
BS
Christianity calls all other religions as false and their Gods as demons, it has nothing but cultural genocide for all non-christian religions.
@rkpvalluru BS in your mind.
@@atharv-gautamWe all saw christian nazi holocaust of Jews
She said Christian groups who promote hatred against other communities. She didn't say Christians are dangerous. Can you for once stop listen to too much propaganda?
These are the Dark days where evil is working.Days of light will come where truth and justice will flourish.
Judiciary slowly becoming helpless for common man
No it is always against the interest of poor.
Only God can help us.
No weapon formed against Christian will prosper.... Be Silent God will Win the Battle...
This Judiciary will pay a price... She has sold Herself wat justice can She give let's wait wats going to happen God is Victorious
@@wsynrem9446If there is really the existence of God from any Relegion for that matter things will not be happening like this….. everything is Man Made…. It’s to one’s capacity only…..!
Only for common man.
This is called bold journalism. Well said Sujitji. The people who express hatred against any religion is not fit to be in Judiciary.
And also not fit for being human.
Christianity is about Love,Peace and Forgiveness.Dont pray for the rain,then you will have to deal with the mud
Christianity calls all other religions as false and their Gods as demons, it has nothing but cultural genocide for all non-christian religions.
The Judiciary must Learn to Love Peace And Forgiveness..
Christian All know that Cross Jesus is with them... And these forces are Powerful that's the Holyspirit... So Christian be strong in Ur faith... Our Victory is already WON By JESUS... Don't put Ur Trust in Men...
Christianitynis also about human rights, about good education for all, about providing good health care System, anti corruption and about bildung up a Nation in which where no one is dying from Hunger.
@@Mariam-mn7xe All christian nations are poor as hell except white nations.
Very few journalists have the spine that you have. This is true journalism.
Your comment is true, however the very fact that you say that shows how much democracy has died in India.
Judiciary needs a Very Very Principle Person, not some individu als who are in high degree of communal Prejudice. The Judiciary Office is look-up by the citizens of the country or nation as a Temple of Pure Justices not otherwise.
In this country where a student seeking admission to a college ,or change of school ,a person seeking a job are all expected to submit Good Conduct Certificate. But here a person with a history of Bad Conduct is appointed as Judge
Point
Well said 👌👍
Point is to be noted 😮
She already displayed allegiance to her leader and religion ..
Even for IAS and IPS conduct certificate is mandatory prior to their appointments.
Gauri should not be promoted to be judge in supreme court. We are bound to get biased judgement if she is promoted
@@Sanatana-Hindu No distinction. Get out, asura.
Cowdung brain
@@linabartholomeusz7192Illegitimate children of Jesus in India
@@shobhitdagur1086 half chaddis who are high on gaumutra have corrupt notions
Hats off to you Mr. Sujit Nair for expressing the thoughts and views of voiceless common ordinary citizens like me . Your expression " show me the man and I will show the law" nailed the situation in our country . No Christian can expect any justice from judges who have such views. Thankyou for your bold views and expressions on behalf of common Indian citizens.
Am Indian born and educated at an all girls Catholic school but thankfully chose to migrate in the early seventies. This lady is just spewing venom and most of the time Modi Shah with Hindu Muslim hate now all religions are more dangerous than the Hindu religion. CJI thinks it is ok and his intelligence is questionable in my opinion. Whatever happened to this highly educated man whose filthy rich parents were able to send him to one of the best Universities in the world. Even Indian universities would not churn out such a shameful student
Anti constitutional pro hindutva judges are selectively posted to Madras High Court.Victoria Gowri is one example.
Is the CJI napping? Mr. Nair has questioned the egalitarian mindset of the CJI and its lack of justice in challenging the Modi Shah appointments of certain justices who did not favour the Modi Shah duo. CJI passed a comment on Thackeray in Mumbai but did not order the change from BJP. Another Gogoi in the pipeline.
I used to have a lot of respect for CJI D Y Chandrachut and hold him in high respect.
When I listen this video i can't help but wondering how things have changed over the years. I FEEL SAD
All I can say at this moment is that I can still see a faint glimmer of hope as long as I see there is some free thinking journalists like you who swear by the ethics of fearless journalism. Otherwise things seem to have gone haywire indeed
As a human being he has some limitations, especially present situation.
@@lukedivyaprasad52
I beg to differ. Once you are in a high position in our country, one has no limitations. You just need to do what is correct. If this lawyer has hatred and is affiliated to the bjp we as citizens will never be able to get justice from a person who is already full of hatred. She will never ever do us justice. Especially now, after seeing what’s still happening in Manipur.
@@Anonymous-nt4sz I was referring to cji
@@Anonymous-nt4sz I was not referring to the lady judge
@@lukedivyaprasad52 He will have to face the consequences or blessings of all his actions for they have taken an oath.
CJI Chandrachud barks more than bites and inequality and different yardsticks for different people are very obvious. Well done Sujit!
And also this has been true for most of the other CJI preceding him. Very sad affairs for this nation that we do not have people at the helm of our affairs who have something called a spine.
I always thought he was one person who is unbiased and honest cause many spoke well about his dad. But sad to say he’s completely the opposite.
You are extremely correct👌🙏🏻
and also bold enough….
A fair comment
In the beginning the CJI commanded much respect but from recent comments and opinions expressed by the Honble CJI the same is seemed evaporating! Mr Sujit ji you have raised 3 valuable Question that any right thinking and conscientious person should be asking today!
If a criminal can become an MP or MLA or Minister, anything can happen in this incorrigible country…..
As a Catholic I definitely will not be comfortable appearing before such a judge who has such biases. Very good questions asked😊👏
Our God is judge above all.
Agree 100% Sujit ! You dare to ask . You speak for the voiceless ! Well spoken ! You speak from the heart ! You ask hard questions ! Our system is rotten. And by the way, does the leopard chance his spots ?
Spots and characters are two different things.
Who are you defending or just splitting hairs with your comment. Mr. Nair started by saying that a goonda does change his character and the expression of leopard and spots is pertinent
Good enthusiasm sir. It is good to see there exist some independent journalists like you speaking freely and frankly for the cause of common man. Loved this episode- an advocate from Hyderabad.
"Barking dogs seldom bites" CJI and SCI is becoming a laughing stock. I really doubt whether it really works or not? Common people are seldom seen getting justice....seemingly CJI is just showing to the people of India, that he is giving justice but it's just an eyewash....God save this country from Peril
no wonder people are leaving India in droves.
They will surely have face the consequences whether good or bad because they are bound by an oath.
NAIR SIR , SUPERB and MIND-BLOWING ANALYSIS from your part .....GREAT .
These days SC/ CJI also singing to the tunes of Central Government and not acting independently.
They will have to face the consequences whether good or bad because they are bound by an oath.
I believe he is part of rss. Don’t know how true it is but I did read a review about this.
The CJI's recent judgments have certainly given credence to the review mentioned in your comment. CJI return to India after his degree from an illustrious US university also cements further this religious bias maybe not the rss but certainly a strong pro Hindu stance
Yes of late cji is changing colors.
Great editorial ,
You nailed it ❤
Keep up the good work you are doing ,
This lady can never be neutral ,
Can't expect Justice from her
Dear Nair….. your words from the heart of every Indians “ what kind of justice is this” …… it is very fair question everyone should ask. It is very unfortunate the voice of the people is ( media) is biased except you… pls keep going..
CJI has been clearly over rated . . . Some of his statements/judgments betray his limitations . . . It is really scary for the common man . . .
Especially true when Prashant Bhusan challenged the Adani double standards. Even referred to the New York Times report the country his wealthy parents paid for his Ivy League university education. Shocking and shame on the CJI
Agree with you completely Mr Nair!
For some reason, I felt emotional after this editorial...the emotion of frustration is very noticeable in the editorial...it personally felt good that someone (Sujit Nair) else feels it too. My confidence in the judiciary has not been good for a while now...this is another example to take away my belief in the system. I have always believed that a fair society will develop a nation...judiciary plays a crucial role in this development...feel despondent that our nation is regressing rather than developing.
Am Indian born and educated but chose to migrate to the West. My mother died in 2010 and spent hours with lawyers trying to get her will implement but to no avail. Was told to settle it through arbitration as it would take over 40 years by which time we would be dead and our children's children will also never get justice in India. Wonder why millions leave this broken three trillion moon landings country every day. Few legally like student visas and other student visas as a cover to flee
One Client, sold his property here in India and paid 20% to govt. The advocate and a auditor who processed all docu gave him a suggestion , Sir you have the option to invest that 20% in real estate or financial investment in India. The reply from that seller chilled every one. He said "" who wants to come back here, in this garbage Country"" .... And he asked what's the difference between Afganistan or Pakistan or India ???... He is working as a scientist in USA and a devote Hindu and a Telugu Brahmin...... We all got shell shocked and kept mum !!!!... Cuz the payment to Indian govt was nearly 50plus lakhs.
Excellent job done by Sujit Nair.
We hardly come to know such facts unless we go through HW. our Lord Jesus had said to forgive such people .....they will be judged by God ultimately .
Bible says vengeance is left to God.
What can a common man like you and me do.....
Mr Nair well explained, no point in telling them injustices and justice, clearly they belong to evil, let God rebuke them, the word of God says pray for your enemy.
How will that destroy them?
Sir a very fair and clear feeling that from a layman's point of view of a judge who will have to judge the population, BUT here it will be judged on religion., not fairplay or justice to the right person. Thanks Sujit for your projection of facts.
Very good editorial sir
As much as I want to cheer you, I would rather pray for you... For sir, you are brave to treading on thin ice.
All your points are valid and absolutely correct. CJI should reconsider his views
Excellent discussion sir 👍
I can't agree more sir. May God bless you continuously and bless you with more strength and courage. May the love of LORD JESUS CHRIST protect you all ways 🙏
Kudos to you Mr. Sujit. Your editorials expose the chronic incongruencies of our Judicial system. The death knell of Indian democracy is tolling loud as our judiciary is being filled with biased and partisan judges. The day is not far when we can only sigh with nostalgia that ours was once a vibrant democracy!
What a powerful editorial. Very complex topics but at the same time simple arguments which common people easily understand. So much truth about different issues that were covered. Such brilliant editorials can come only from S Nair.
The quote from you:SHOW ME THE MAN , I WILL SHOW (PRONOUNCE) THE LAW is the sum and substance of the video. Great salute to you for your bold and impartial views 👌👍💕
Very good and valuable views by Sujith Sir. His views are an eye opener to the collegiums blind decision to elevate a person as a judge who spews venom against minorities created communal hatred in the society. Surprised to see our CJI's justification. When a person who is affiliated to a political party like BJP will never change their mindset (carrying their ideology) which is hardcoded in their brain. Such people are very dangerous for the society and one can not expect fair judgement. President Marmu should intervene and must take a stern decision.
She is just a puppet in BJP. Uska koi kuch nai suntha.
What you said is totally right, common man is just watching helplessly.
Powerful episode this!
About the person changing while having a position that requires to be neutral....well, we already have the answer.
Look no further than Lok and Rajya Sabha chair.
Thanks for speaking on behalf of the voiceless.🙏🙏🙏
There is no hope for this country
Justice is different for Rich and the poor
Very sad
Somehow this video should be sent to CJI, he must see and repent for his actions and be honest to the law and his own conscience, great job Sudhir 👏🏻👏🏻
I’m a fan of Kunal Kamra because he said wonderful things about Supreme Court… Corruption in lower Judiciary is an acceptable fact in the whole country but I now believe the same people in higher Judiciary continue the same ..
One of the best editorial hats off to sir . Our ondian judiciary will never improve . I don't have any faith in judiciary
EMOTIONAL EDITORIAL IN DEJECTION OVER THE INJUSTICE IN THIS COUNTRY. THAT IS WHAT A COMMON MAN CAN HAVE.
Rightly said Sir.
Looks like there is absolutely No Hope when we see and hear such things.
But we do hope, pray and believe God will bring justice and righteousness.
A police case filed against a person for a domestic dispute / violence disqualifies him for a government job though the issue has nothing to do with his job. Courts are considered as temples of Justice where judges are supposed to be totally unbiased. And no one can expect justice from such judges. It is unfortunate to see our judiciary being crippled by religion / caste based governance.
Hold on mr.sujit Nair.
Can u please tell me how Gowri with soooooo much of hatred towatds christians can have the previlege of having a christian name VICTORIA?
Hats off to you mr.nair.may ur clan increase.country is badly in need ofoutspoken people like you.
@@matildalobo7267There are many wolves in goats hide nowadays. 😡
Excellent questions raised......justice has to be seen to be done in order to create trust in the system. The system clearly needs fixing....
Complete destruct of our judiciary.. Hippocracy ki bhi sima hoti he..
Hats off to you with folded hands for your analysis and report and journalism sir... 🎉🎉Part and parcel of saffronism cadre are encouraged openly... Journalism of all sides eg electronic, print, social and air has already been crushed... Gali or..... Is the fate of journalism 😢😢😢
Very valid point. May Almighty bless you.
Please continue the good work sir.
A good analysis of the facts of life and I totally agree.
Sir, you have raised such an important point that many journalists ignore or don't want to discuss for their own benefit. But hats off to you Sujit sir. I pray what you have said will reach the ears of the Chief Justice and the entire panel and make a righteous decision to appoint the Madras High Court Judge. 🙏
Excellent presentation Sir! The clarity with which you addressed such vital issues is commendable. Thank you for speaking up so boldly and wisely!
Yes, it is a debatable issue. How can one expect her to be totally free from all her prejudices, opinions, beliefs, etc., when she was a politician? Is there a foolproof method to prove that she is actually free from all that?
This lady is not above our Lord Jesus Christ., I feel pity for her.
God give her Sence.
Good editorial. Sir, the core qualities of a person cannot be changed. What we see the behavior which is dictated by attitude and attitude is shaped by principles and values. Behavior is the tip of the iceberg. We cannot change the behavior without changing the attitude or belief system.
The CJI is only human and as such, holds his religious views in a way many others belonging to his community do. Secondly, he makes all the right noises but hardly delivers. He has his owns reasons for riding the waves, going with the flow...
He will surely have to face the consequences whether good or bad because they are bound by an oath.
Gods justice is slow but sure
@@oswaldmoraes3176Hallelujah Amen Amen Amen Amen
Justice will surely come heavily on the unjust
@@oswaldmoraes3176 Humans are here to speed up God's work!
@@ColtraneTaylor Spiritual beings those who have come to know the truth through Gods written word.
Sujit ji, agree with you 💯%. I too am very disappointed by the judgements and observations by our Courts. With no disrespect to the honorable courts, it's baffling to find different yardsticks. Like your example of Adani and Newsclick. Even the observation in Manish Sisodiya's case: "it won't stand in the court for even two minutes, when it comes to trial"..... but bail can't be granted????? Courts are are last and maybe only hope.... justice needs to be served and also seen to be served...
Excellent views and very pertaining questions mr Nair. But we will never get the answers. That is the sad part. 👍
I see ,feel & experience that the pillars of Indian democracy is shaking relentlessly and Minority communities r helplessly watching.
A true hearted person must be placed in the place of A Judge., Who is impartial in every aspect.
Speaking truth, boldly, to the powerful and the not-so-powerful.
Where are we heading I wonder ! As usual a wonderful episode keep it up
I love your analysis on important things. I find it quite legit.
Well said! Kudos to you for speaking fearlessly. In my eyes the CJI has fallen
I appreciate your boldnese and courage in bringing the truth out. We need people like you live long and serve. Thank you for your service. Our country moves forward because of the people like you are active.
I as a citizen have almost zero confidence on judiciary so I’m working to become slightly rich to be safe in our country.. because if we don’t have money we can’t even get things registered
You pinned it, point blank !
Justice is for the rich, famous and influential people only. They can manipulate Justice as they please not only for themselves but for others also who are either their supporters or standing against them. Andhbhakts can be even highly educated people also.
if the committee to look into the sebi adani matter seems so skewed in favour of the respondents and the SC is convinced - where does the common man go?
They will NOT be spared for they have taken an oath. Gods justice is perfect slow but sure because He is a just God.
Sadly your comment is just fantasy. Do you know of anyone who has not received justice in real life but has received justice from God. God is just hope and hope is what keeps people interested in God.
@@agnescraig2912 lt may seem a fantasy to you .l have experienced it .His ways are not our ways. We serve a true living God His name is Jesus.He is true to His word.
If he has promised you something it has to come to pass.
Very well expressed Sir. Yes. Many people like us feel the same way uncertain about our legal system as you said. Great job Sir.
Judiciary is the last hope of our dying democracy. Will it survive? History will remember these Chief Justices.
Thank you Mr. Nair for highlighting various issues related to the appointments made to judiciary and appointments to committees that have legal ramifications.As a Christian I can least expect justice from Justice Victoria. Now I have lost faith in the collegium which made that decision.
Well spoken journalist.I salute you sir.Rear to find this type of person in the house of media
Well done keep it up Almighty God bless you
I had high hopes on the CJI but all I find is that while some questions are asked ..the judgement remains the same ..😢
Brilliant episode! You’re asking all the right questions, but where are the answers?
Excellent views and voice for commons based on truths. Appreciate your bold comments.
Hats off to you Mr. Nair, for your frank and brave Journalism.
May God bless you and protect you from every evil.
Thanks for speaking the honest truth.
Thank you Editor ji.
"One can change their skies, but not their soul."
"What is sauce for goose needless to be a sauce for gander."
It's great to see that all Indians are not corrupt and that honest journalist are still at work. Mr Nair you are a beacon of hope to those who are given no voice .
Wonderful points raised. Hats off to you. There is clear differentiation being done here.
Hat's off to Mr Sujit Nair,how can a Judge ,who is not secular can give a fair and true ruling,God help the common man.
Thanks Sujit for highlighting these devious activities that are going on this nation. Unfortunately Corruption and politics go hand in hand and needs no logic . But these things can’t go on forever. Seasons always change. Fortunately after winter, there will be Spring and we are eagerly looking forward to that change .
We live the new india, Sujit!! It’s no longer the same!! Democracy and equality and all these concepts will be moved to museums!!
Brilliant. Love the logical dissection of facts that strips the grey area of its veil.
Had lots of hope from the CJI. But now I feel things are changing.
Superb episode...Mr Nair has very clearly presented that justice is not the same for all.
Very true well said
Completely agree with the points you have made.
Very strong points in context.
The judiciary is considered as the third pillar of Democracy. When that itself makes blatant & erroneous decisions of these sort how can one ever expect to get justice ? The very fence which is put up to protect the crop itself eats the crop. How good may be a constitution, if those who are out there to implement it are not fair & square what is it worthy of ? 👍
Thank you for standing up for the rights of the citizens, very good questions, and very wise request made for the classes we have in India. ❤
I thank Sujit Sir for a raising these pertinent questions in the public domain.
Unfortunately we have 2 courts on earth which are distinctly different for the rich and famous, vs the poor and ordinary...
You are correct.
Sir you are 💯👍 spot on..
Admire your strength and courage 🙏❤ God bless and always keep you safe
You have raised a very important question Sujit sir. This CJI is highly doubtful. I liked him at first, but now i can see what game is playing. All his decisions are going in the favour of the central government. He is a very cunning person. 😢😢