Editorial with Sujit Nair: Numbers don't lie, interpretation could | Education | Poverty| Population
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 06. 2024
- Join Our WhatsApp Group:
linktr.ee/sujitnair
In this editorial episode, Mr. Sujit Nair discusses how India has made substantial progress in reducing multidimensional poverty over the years, but challenges persist, particularly in addressing disparities and vulnerabilities within its population.
India has seen significant changes in its poverty landscape over the years. Official poverty estimates from 2011 reported that approximately 269 million people, or 21.9% of the population, were living in poverty. This data, based on Household Consumption Expenditure Surveys, was last updated in 2011, and two rounds of data collection were missing.
However, a UNDP study in July 2023 highlighted remarkable progress, indicating that 415 million people in India escaped poverty within just 15 years, from 2005/2006 to 2019/2021. This achievement was part of global progress, with 25 countries, including India, halving their Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) values in the same timeframe. India's MPI reduced from 55.1% in 2005/2006 to 16.4% in 2019/2021. The report noted improvements in various indicators, including nutrition and child mortality.
A subsequent report by Niti Aayog in July 2023 revealed that approximately 14.96% of India's population, or 20.79 crore people, still lived in multidimensional poverty. However, there was progress, as multidimensional poverty decreased from 24.85% in 2015-16 to 14.96% in 2019-2021, representing about 13.5 crore people moving out of poverty. This index considered factors beyond income, such as education and health.
The report detailed various indicators contributing to multidimensional poverty, including nutrition, years of schooling, access to clean cooking fuel, sanitation services, housing, and asset ownership. While there were improvements in some areas, challenges remained, particularly regarding nutrition and education.
The report also highlighted regional disparities, with several states making significant progress in reducing multidimensional poverty, such as Bihar, Jharkhand, and Madhya Pradesh. However, India still had the highest number of poor people globally, including a substantial proportion of children living in poverty.
Despite these advancements, India's poverty situation remained complex, with urban-rural divides and gender disparities. Female-headed households in India experienced higher poverty rates compared to male-headed households. Moreover, India continued to have a large vulnerable population, with the potential to slip into extreme poverty.
#PMModi #Education #Poverty #UNDP #UnitedNations #Nutrition #School #Sanitation #Population #India #RahulGandhi #Congress #HWNews #SujitNair
To Join CZcams Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
People have become more poor because of demonetisation, GST, Covid etc. Economy is in doldrums, hair cuts of huge bank loans for showing NPAs are less. So nothing is shinig. Agree with you about healthcare, hunger index etc. All in all a great editorial. Thank you!
According to Modi, he has given us Ram Mandir. So we have to wait for the next life to get ACHA DINS.
Very good analysis! Please continute to give these types of insights into numbers often!
Stunning and accurate analysis and bold as ever . A journalism like this you never come across these days when many are thriving in shadows of ruling dispensation through unethical means by projecting the false hype . This is a must see video ,an eye opener . Keep it going Sir . All the best .
Saw Shekhar Gupta's video on Pew Research and thought the same thing. Numbers shows decline but headlines are twisted to show international danka. Survey of Indians cleverly being mixed with international.
Pew only interviewed around 2000 odd people and confirmed it as the entire population ! I don’t understand their formula
@@amoseannamalai4506 Right wingers and Godi media has been trumpeting the survey by Morning Consult which puts Modi's approval rating at 71%. They say their sample size is is 500 - 5000 people and conducted 100% online. I am pretty sure Pew's methodology is much better than that.
The way you analyse numbers bang on. Thank you for this Sujit
China has been able to raise its population out of poverty. India is far behind in doing this. The vision, strategy and priority is simply non existent. The present Govt is failing to pay MNREGA wages in non BJP states. They are only concerned about winning elections.
Yes and the will again and again because 80% of BJP voters are lower middle class uneducated Hindus and few higher cast well off Hindus who suffer deep inferiority complex after domination of India for centuries by Moghuls and then British... British treated Indians as coolies. Bjp used this inferiority complex and common enemy of Hindus as Muslims and that has worked for 2 terms. It Wil work also for the 3rd term after 2024 elections.
@@leopardtiger1022I understand your rationale but don’t think it applies throughout. Just because the most basic need of human is Food, clothing & shelter. When these get disrupted, chances are people have lesser mindshare towards to feed their ego. People on the ground know the lowest denominator of people are marginalised and people like Adani are favoured. BJP will have to do a lot more this time to come close to victory with coalition. 😢
It is a real shame that elected governments, as narrated in this editorial, are pulled down, which implies that the will of the people in our country is not respected. It looks that the current political dispensation is bent on gaining power by any means. And, that not good for our country. India boast that is the largest democracy in community of democratic nations. But the way democracy is managed, at present, makes us hang our heads in shame.
Very true a fantastic analysis keep it up
Nair g,you are absolutely right. Your editorial is very balanced unbiased. All the development in our country is due to all the governments and all the people. It is not only by one government and one person. The the reality is that foundation stones are never visible of any beautiful building like Taj mahal . similarly who made the foundation stone people forget their names. Another considerable point is that in development of country we praise all the big names and the governments like nehruji and all the prime ministers etc but the reality the bitter growth is that people who are working very hard is IAS IPS OFGICERS and other persons from peon to minister .
all those persons to whom nobody knows even you do not know: they are pillars of development of our country on which our country has reached this stage. We Namdharis Sikhs under the guidance of our spiritual head guru Dilip Singh ji admire you and send namaskar to you for this unbiased editorial
Bjp has to go. They are outright liars.
The problem is the babus theyll leave behind are are also andh bhakts
A lost battle, indeed
The BJP in the last 9 years has made sure that although a lot of vacancies are not filled by regular intake, some vacancies are filled with kith & kin’s of BJP/RSS ministers. These people are securely placed as secretaries in various government departments. Hence even if the BJP loses which seems impossible they still have people at helm of affairs.
I am your fan Sir, the way present is amazing. People stopped listening Godi media...
Absolutely I too always say if there is a day when all will live with at least basic necessities of Life that day is a glorious day for us.🙏🙏🙏
When the government priorities are skewed then you cant expect an inclsive growth. Thank God for the Software industry we have a sizeable middleclass that can bloat these numbers but majority of the population are a left out lot. Simple example - the Petrol prices( fuel prices) are kept artificially high to feed the greed of few in Petroleum industry. Even though Russian crude was imported showing these poor this gujju government is refining that and selling to EU at a profit that is not being shared with the rest of poor in India.
A superb editorial! I live your balanced, nuanced approach.
Good analysis.
But it would be great if we compare last 10 years of BJP numbers to previous 10 years of Congress numbers. This gives us the comparison of where the actual progress was seen.
Request you to please create this numbers comparison
Excellent but Absolutely Hard Reality Figures which we can't hide or ignore 👌👍🙏✅✔️💯✔️✔️✔️✔️
Great editorial talk.
Full of meanings.
Excellent episode. Very enlightning
Only head is shinning
The actual 80-20 in India is 20 % Sawaran Jatis and 80 % rest.
A realistic statement:development and good has happened, is happening, will happen, irrespective of which government is in power..
What the statement of Sujit Nair DOES NOT day is that no one government, past or present, need not take all the credit for the good and development achieved in India.
Sujit Nair also raised a pertinent issue, which needs reflection that everyone needs to understand is: Development is no development unless it reaches the least and lost of Indian population. This is an important parameter when considering about development.
It is in this context that the significance of numbers should ba understood, and analysed.
Thank you Sujit for enabling the people in India understand the significance of development, in terms of numbers.
👌🙏
Coming to the question of healthcare, as people get older with need for affordable healthcare, the healthcare premium is being increased manifold. People in the lower age bracket are charged lower premium. This is a lopsided welfare measure. In fact healthcare premium should reduce for people who are senior citizens. Today healthcare is a rip off. Insurance companies, hospitals etc are just fiddling around with insurance . If one goes for cashless, one can be sure that with one admission, the entire cover will be exhausted . Really lopsided
Thanks
Very sensitive analysis.
The income to expenditure ratio is gravely unfair!! There is only expense happening even from the meagre earnings ! If there are is not increase in wages people will remain poor
Bank interests are also very low comparatively low, both savings deposits and fixed deposits.
The work done for BJP on the last mile connectivity to bridge the gap between the haves and have nots is reflected on your numbers. The cumulative time the Congress have been in power and the lack of basic infrastructure and resources building effort for the rural and poor has been exposed.India has been pushing back poverty and is reflecting in the numbers. Thanks for the explanation. Good attempt in narrative building but people will see through it 🤗
Hindu religion is the most capitalist religion in the world. For example, In Bhagwat Gita, self-Karma is more critical than the public good.
Agree all the temple gold and constant pujas with lights flowers and the priests. Thought God and money must be separated. In Catholic teachings "it is easier for a poor man to enter heaven than a rich man
Thanks for this beautiful editorial n God Bless You always
Buy 1 get 3 free CMs
Hearing these reports, I am reminded of Vir Das's two india.
Research guy me, hence I always like your editorials & opinions.
🙏
Please insist on the debt that India is burdened with, no one is bothered about that, if that is cleared we never need to be under slavery. Hope the Political party x or y can make it an agenda in 2024, or else people will be more burdened. Please do not take it easy, days are going to be very dark and evil.
Vir Das ... 2 Indias ....
GOVT MAKES PEOPLE SMART PHONE & PETROLE TWO WHEELER ARE ESSENTIAL TO SURVIVE FOR FOOD ITSELF. U MAY NOT NEED ANY OTHER FACILITIES BUT PHONE PETROL VEHICLE ARE ESSENTIAL
GOOD😢
Number of foreign companies have already left India and more are leaving. We keep on patting our own back and do not look at the reality. Highest unemployment,highest number of poors
Numbers can be cooked up. It is so easy to stare numbers to prove a point or justify a case.
Difficult to fadom that we have 65 crore smartphone users and 80 crore people fed through free of cost food subsidy.
Are they overlapping?
Excellent. Please also look at labor force participation rate for women. It is only 9% comparable with Saudi Arabia.
Very fact that 80 cr people are living on 5 kg dole says it all. Govt own admission
Numbers don't lie. But, numbers can also be misleading or meaningless. I have never seen any party use vanity metrics as a big achievement as the BJP does. Let's all admit it, all political parties cherry pick the metrics that make them look good and don't always give full picture. But, the way BJP uses Vanity metrics is whole another level.
Let's take the 5th largest economy claim as an example. One has to be living under a rock to not have heard about this "achievement". In 2004, India's GDP was $700B, 2014 GDP was $2079 Bn. Under UPA, the economy grew $1.3 Trillion, but we went from 12th largest to 10th largest economy. in 2022, India's GDP was $3393 Bn. In 8 years under Modi economy grew by ~$1.3 Trillion, but we went from 10th largest to 5th largest economy. As you can see, the position in the world is based only on how other countries are growing. Most of the countries in Top 10 are already developed economies and they grow at a slower rate. Some of them haven't grown at all for quite some time. UK, which India surpassed to become Top 5 hasn't grown its economy much since 2007.
The fact of the matter is that under the UPA, both the GDP and GDP per capita PPP grew at a much faster rate than under Modi Govt. But, all we hear about is that India is the 5th largest economy and that is because of Modi. There is absolutely no basis for the claim that somehow economy is drastically growing faster under Modi.
Is India the 5th largest economy in the world? Yes. Does that mean a significant increase in growth in the last 9 years as compared to the previous 10 years? Absolutely No. Numbers don't lie, but they can be meaningless.
Very well said bro. Figures per se are meaningless.The question is who is benefitting from this so called development. The proof of the pudding is in its eating. Only the rich & wealthy comprising around 10 percent are benefitted & growing massively. The govt.itself admits that it it is giving free rations to more than 80 crore poor people under BPL which translated means around two thirds of our population are living BPL living below sustenance levels . Then where is the development happening. Data of International agencies like UN & World Bank portray very grim picture of India where hunger, poverty, child mortality etc.are concerned where we stand below 130 or so in some cases out 190 odd countries in the world. These statistics dished out really " hides more than what it reveals"...
We request you to make all the editorials in your words and your voice in Hindi also because more people can understand Hindi than in English. nobody speaks unbiased like you.
You missed out important things
Lpg connection.
New vehicle registration (2 and 4 wheeler)
New school/ college admission ratio
EB connection
Smart ratio card
Ofcourse Numbers can lie. It jsut depends on how you show them. Every second big company claims they have been awarded as best company to work or show some numbers showing their greatness, yet the reality is different. So Yes *NUMBERS CAN LIE*
Mr Nair, numbers also lie. Numbers represent something. It matters how are those numbers are created, and whether those data was collected correctly. If you say the average height of a person is 175cm, the number 175 does not lie, but whether that number represents the average height depends on how the data is collected. What is more important is not the number but what it represents and how accurately that representation (or data association) is done.
Why the politicians are given permission to jump from one party to another
Hope all get the right part of share for a better society and humanity living.
Voters on their own have no voice. Though we vote for one party our vote may be used by another party that we don't prefer if the MLA decides to go to another party . There is no way we can make certain that our vote goes for the party of our choice.
Hillarious Political Parties
it is true, caste system, corruption, and superstitious beliefs and practices are main reasons for many of these banes in India. current govt can only aid these factors fueling further disparity!
Is it the same @VeerDas's two India
Common people life still the same struggling
Development of India can be compared to manipur.
Only in imphal valley all the thing are available but the hills are deprive of everything. valley has only 10% of land but everything is there with it. This exactly the gap between the rich and poor in India.
Sabka saath (Dhono ka saath)
Sabka vikaas (Dhono ka vikaas)
Sabka vishwas (Dhono ka vishwas)
Patha hai na kaun dhono 😆😆🤣🤣🤣
Since there is a lot of Cash transactions with the aggrigators is there some money laundering.
Highiest numbers in internet and mobile sibscriber is fine, but what abour ARPU? Ask telecom companies , they say their margin is very very less compare to other small countries like south korea, kuwait etc., whose ARPU is highest in the world. My point is we are very poor in per capita incom;)
People from middle income group are facing great difficulty to survive under the prevailing condition if this continues there will be only super rich and poor ,middle income group will be totally wiped out
They'll still vote Modi😂
These people who talk about Swiggy and UPI, keep them hungry for a week and see what they will be talking about after.
Because v have large population every no will b big!!
Left Indian in early 70s because of poverty and lack of any job opportunities. Although I follow the news and developments, life for the poor has hardly improved. India's rocket launch BRICS two trillion economy G20 summits and Modi's in your face travels to the West is always considered India's success!! Reality is completely differerent. Every day thousands of people migrate from India mostly illegally in search of a better life. Politicians even Modi begs for visas in the West and also uses the migration as a condition for signing trade deals. India refuses to take back illegals from the UK. So Mr. Nair's analysis are correct and critical thinking is not part of The Indian education syllablus
Cherry picking if data has to be learnt from the current rulers.. .
Why don't you put same data during your favorite congress area and compare.
Looking back china also started same with India the only problem was modi if not for modi we would have crossed China economy
Cm mela😂
What is India? A gigantic country that has experimental democracy. Historically , the best form of govt for India is a benevolent autocracy with astute ,ethically ruling machinary. That need great Avtar, well , let it rest at imagination! 140 crores polulation.!!!! Every Indian politican will Speak about" the suffering " of people. Honestily no body has any answer to full employment. Employment in Indian concept is a work of choice well paid , leisurely and prestigious , There is a lot of work ,needing working hands, in agriculture, service industry. But who cares? Dire poverty only force people to take that kind of employment! Then we have the minority " ills". This is mostly farce and political propaganda to exploit differences through ethnic differences. Manipur is the latest example, Nasty media!!! , See how a good agriculture bill failed, How unifirm civil code pended, failed. ? How Adani issue deleberated by the paid media, How George Sorous who is banned , is indirectly supported by our media??? . In reality India has no comparison,it is a unique experience on the earth. !!! But those who feed comparison is western well supported by confused media , Any western media uttering is goespel in India! ! Latest you will hear is ABOUT OCCRP, A CHARITY ORGANISATION OF MARYLAND, SPREADING ADANI STORY'! Court verdict is farce but foreign news paper is gospel.
Over 77 percentage of people doesn't have bare necessities, it is not pathetic, let us be positive that so almost mobile subscribers are equal to our population.😂
We are mocking at democracy, Our job is to vote politicians job is to play with my vote😂
We shouldn't worry about hunger index, it is propaganda to defame India 😂
Wait till you are the one going hungry. Then it will hit home
200 rupees cut on cylinder and none of you are happy? So anti national?
All are upset over this discount because after elections in December cylinder willbecome 400 more which is worse than present time.
1 doctor attends 11K patients...? Where did you get this from...? Hope not from Rahul Gandhi.
NO USE TO COMMENT : YOU HAVE LOTS OF ANDHBHAKTS TROLLING YOU !
Yeh banda aakoh se andha.
Mr Nair, you look like a well-fed person indicating that you are consuming more food than what your body needs. If you are so much interested in improving those in poverty, why don't you give a part of your money that you spend every day on food to the poor people ? If everybody does that, the poverty will be eliminated in India. Talking and broadcasting on your channel is easy, (and maybe doing to make more money or with bad motives, ) but not easy to sacrifice something and to contribute to solve the problem.
Numbers don't lie that's true. It applies to congress
Congress never defeated modi neither in Gujarat or lok sabha elections. So modi will win 2024 hands down
Well , it’s up to the people to decide ! They get who they vote for !! Modi had shown his vision and it’s harmful !
Only by EVM
@@isabelladcunha4499 only because of evm congress won by huge majority in Karnataka great
@@user-cu3cj5rn2r it was the BJP government in centre and state during Karnataka elections so is there any logic in your statement MR.
@@isabelladcunha4499 - When congress wins evm works fine, when loses suddenly EVM becomes culprit.
India has always had mostly poor people.......but what nehruvian socialism did was make everyone in india equally poor.......abd you support that nehruvian india😂
That secular, socialist Nehru had disastrous economic frowth figures and everyone mockingly called it the hindu rate of growth!!
@@ashishkulkarni4165that same congress changed it.. its a matter of time and Soviet communist model was also famous that time.. if that time where nobody had anything.. the capitalists would've eaten the country whole.
British Raj was better?
Do you have numbers to prove your statement or just gassing of BJPs election rehtorics? What are you employed ?, or doing business? How poor did your family become between 1947 to 2013?
I dont kow to what extent you are aware of the industrial foundation laid by Nehru, and followed by Congress. But are you aware that the Capitalists of that day excepting TATAs had ulterior motive to keep our nation poor. We had to pay advance money in post office and book reservation for a Bajaj Scooter , or Ambassador/ Premier Padmini car Only when Indira gandhi started this Maruti project these so called capitalists started manufacturing more numbers otherwise they always complained to government not to issue fresh licences for manufacture So dont blame Congress or Nehruvian policy blame the present day your capitalist friends @@ashishkulkarni4165
India is shining. That's what going to happen to Modi.
Don't see any in proportion money is spending.. Don't understand where this big loans , taxes going
Why dont u compare these data before 2014 and after 2014 will show how much truth u speak😂😂😂
@nainitalism, then you suggest a party and leader who is better than Modi. Nepotism in BJP is far less than other parties.Take statitics. You will know
🙏