Assistant Oxford high principal who encountered shooter takes stand at James Crumbley's trial
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 03. 2024
- The assistant principal at Oxford High School at the time of the shooting takes the stand at the trial of James Crumbley, father of the Oxford shooter.
The assistant principal is not only a fantastic witness, but she is such a courageous and respectable human being.
😊❤ Yes agree she is amazing I get such beautiful positive vibes ✨ 💖 from her! Bless her precious heart.
Amen!
A bit of an egomaniac in my opinion
@@iloveschicken6527 She exhibited more bravery and protective instincts than all of law enforcement in Uvalde, Texas. Also, was more articulate in her testimony here than the special investigator hired to do a report on the massive failure of law enforcement in Uvalde.
I realize I might be comparing apples and oranges, but they are both considered "fruit" so I believe a general comparison of "school shootings" is valid.
@@Debthouse Hu? I just said Amen.
She had more guts & courage than those Ulvade police cowards. And she had no gun & no back up.
She even walked right up to the shooter with no fear or concern for herself. Her students are lucky to have someone as passionate as she is
Facts!
@@jordanleighwheatley wasn't she on the floor aiding a student?
@SC-ls3iv she said she got up and walked with him to ask him if he was okay for a couple steps, then ran back to tate
Absolutely
I sincerely hope this is the last time she has to tell this story while on the stand.
Agree. And being told not to show emotion telling this story just adds insult to injury.
It must be so hard for her 😢
This is the lady who when testifying in Ethan’s trial, He shed tears. He also obviously spared her life. She knew him since elementary school and said his name. And the way she interacted with student all friendly and caring he probably was very fond of her and embarrassed to disappoint her. I think those feeling along with her describing giving aid to Tate Myre really brought out Ethan’s emotions. Just sad all around.
I wish i had principals like her when i went to school. Most if not all of mine were not that at all, when she said the kids brought her so much joy and she wanted to interact with them.
The prosecution was rude to this witness. She looks so troubled since first trial. She is suffering traumatic after this.
The prosecutors were not interested in anything that didn't support their fantasy, the fantasy they failed to prove beyond a doubt. That's why they're out so long.
The prosecutor was having a rough time making her accusations valid. Hence, the jury is out for so long. She did not make her case beyond doubt.
She is the bravest, most selfless, courageous, caring people there could ever be for an unarmed civilian. God bless her. She has to be dealing with so much PTSD with something this horrendous and tragic. ❤🙏❤
What a brave soul she is...
Those kids are SO lucky to have her in their lives.
Before & after the shooting.
Braver yet, to return to her job.
My heart aches for her.
Ms. Gibson-Marshall is an incredibly brave person whose heroic actions may have saved other lives that day. You could feel her sincerity as she talked about needing to care for the student who was shot. I was deeply moved.
I agree.
Her actions when seeing Ethan probably saved other lives. Seems it kind of ended his rampage. 😢
Can the prosecutor please not keep interrupting the witness. she is not letting the principle get a sentence or thought completed. 😤
YES. She’s terrible
The prosecutor is starting to realize she is not making her case beyond a shadow of a doubt.
Awww she was concerned about swearing and the kids hearing....
Too bad the parents did not have the same mentality about interacting with their kid as this administrater does.
How anyone would want to be a teacher anymore is beyond me
I am a retired teacher and I asked that question everyday.
It’s sad that people have to question what was once a noble occupation. But now it’s because is my place of work safe.
For those questioning why this administrator didn't try and stop the shooter. I don't know if ALICE protocols in Michigan are taught to fight at any point. However, I do know that this lady showed incredible courage and love. Even if she was taught to fight, NOBODY knows what they'll do in that situation. And from what I understand just from what she said, and from the acronym, it sounds like she should've been out of that hallway, and not by Tate, and not talking to the killer. Let's just all pray for this lady, pray for Tate and all the families involved, and try, in our words, not to make things worse. And I guarantee that, with her personality, she is probably blaming herself for not doing more, even though she clearly did all she could.
Jamesie seems more compassionate then his witch wife Jennifer Crumbley
My main question is, If Oxfords' school thought that Ethan was a threat, why was he allowed to stay in school or at least have him searched??
In the wife’s trial, the school officials testified that they thought Ethan was only a danger to himself. The counselor begged them to take him home and get him immediate help because he was afraid Ethan was suicidal. The parents refused to take him home.
@@HereForTheComments990 Than he should of been transferred to Children's Village J Building and not sent back to class!
The school had no reason to search his belongings. They have to have a reason. They did not know he was just given a gun from his parents. They did not disclose that to the school.
Ethan's counsel requested the parents take him home seriously getting him professional help and they declined. The mother claimed she had to go back to work which is false her boss excused her from work under the circumstances.
if you watched that trial you would no why
Why did the judge rule, no description of suffering? To not distress the defendant???? Good grief.
There were victims in the room.
But I agree its frustrating.
Seems to sugar coat it somehow.
She kept her composure. What a hero she is to all the kids.
Oh, ok
Omg! I missed this in mom’s trial. There was an adult on site with a weapon who didn’t even know there was an active shooter?!?
Pathetic isnt it?? They have police at the school daily. Seems someone maybe should of had a cop in the meeting with the kid and parents. As far as I can tell there are two cops at the school daily??? Guess thats for nothing🤷♀️
She said that woman worked in the lunch room. She was retired PD I believe or something to that effect but was not working at the school in a security aspect.
I watched her testimony at the Mothers and she didn’t say anything about the other woman.
@@klouvry
I guess she can only answer what they ask..
But yes, there were several new aspects that I heard today.
I feel for these people that have to testify again and relive the nightmare. I know the nightmare wont go away, just having to talk about it again. Prayers for you all. Im so sorry❤💔🙏🙏🙏🙏
I really don’t like the prosecutor here. Her questioning has no flow, she cuts off the witness, she asks irrelevant questions, and she’s improperly conducting the examination (like using leading questions)
The prosecutor is annoying as f. Constant interruptions.
She is an amazing prosecutor and I will vote for her time and time again what’s sad is she has to do this over and over he should take the deal plead guilty. His wife was found guilty he will be found guilty.
@@jeffreysix1306
I agree Jeffrey.
If he pled, there would be no more testimony.
Proves once again, the parents first concern is themselves.
Dad seems to get it, even if he’s late to the party. Unlike the mother.
Exactly what I thought too
22:58 there was a "good guy with a gun??" I can't believe having even more guns didn't help! Wow. Much shock. Yep we definitely don't need change. Just more thoughts and prayers
All because James bought Ethan a gun . Not a smart parent .
Ast. Pricaple she is one of the bravest carying people, 90% of Americans are individuals but she is community based person & thats rare esp. With princapals-most princapals dont follow protocal & ignore students who complain of bullies or bad teachers to avoid getting suid
Get that Judge a better mic!
Get a better Judge...
The lawyer asking questions in the beginning, (I’m not keeping up with this case so don’t know who she represents) gives me the impression this line of questioning was off the seat of her pants. She seems so ill prepared and stuttering through questions. Not well worded questions either…
I bet it was difficult to stay in the perimeters set out by the prosecution?
I notice she had to "adjust" her questions so as not to depict the anguish & the gore that she dealt with... Seems unfair, sugar coating-ish.
Why did the person asking questions laugh when they said the judge said don’t describe suffering what’s funny about students dying and suffering???? Disturbing
Don't look at the map. YUCK
Its so sad the parents and their families, the witness's have to go through again. He is not innocent and if he had a sense of empathy he would have plead. His crying, I am sure he was told to grandstand, Threatening witnesses is enough to find the creep guilty. Defense lawyer or not. They have not once shown any empathy towards those poor innocent souls he helped kill. Shame on them
The prosecution has not been able to prove all the accusations of the parents. .About anything. That is why the jury is struggling.
that is pretty dumb of a reply
They are sure struggling now. Going to the big house
I watched the Mothers Trial and the Vice Principal never said anything about the lunch lady and she having a gun or swearing which is no big deal!
the defendant cries for himself. If he had sincere empathy his son’s mental health would have meant more to him.
So f$ck sad when she is describing Tate's faith! so heartbreaking.
So Ethan spared her life. The vice principal ( or principal) ❤To Christy your time on earth was not over you are so brave and committed, to confront and yet he spared you , god bless your courageous soul all the days of your life
This schmuck making these people go through all this again, gonna get more time than his bloated sow wife. 🗑️ 🗑️ 🗑️.
Mr. Crumbly take responsibility for your actions in this matter and don’t make all these hero’s retell their story.
Plead guilty!
Crazy how she has to pretend and elaborate like it’s the first time she’s answered the same questions, sub name.
They bought him the gun did they ever think that there kid would do this
Better question did they care?
Did they LOOK at the anguish their son was going through?
They seem like they bought the gun hoping it would shut him up from asking...
James does not have the RIGHTS TO CRY he still has a living son.
I'm wondering how many guns exactly were in that school, the lunch lady had a weapon ON HER in the school??? She is retired police, not active, that's NOT OK.
Yeah, what the f??
James crumbly is in tears in shock at what his son did to
His mother had very few tears
Why would anyone let a person with a gun in his hand, and that person has shot someone lying on the floor, walk away and you not try to stop him, jump on his back, tackle him to save all of the other students that could be shot, I would not want her to be in charge in another emergency situation, the Principal had a duty to the other students
My republican neighbors are infuriated (as usual) over all this. But they can’t seem to pinpoint exactly who and what they think that they’re supposed to pretend to be angry at!!
From what I can gather is that they hate everyone involved with case and think they should be punished severely, including the judge and lawyers for both sides. Witnesses too-especially if they’re school teachers.
They can look up the investigation done on the school after this if they want to do some reading.
Lol! But in all seriousness, if your Republican neighbors are anything like my Texas Republican family members, it's probably because they're viewing this as an attack on the second amendment without bothering to learn any of the other facts here. This isn't about the right to bear arms; it's about two parents who KNEW their son was disturbed and struggling with serious mental health issues, and they just ignored it. Even when he kept asking for help. The fact that they bought their son a gun in his mental state is just one piece of the evidence against them. They almost certainly could have prevented this had they intervened and got him the help he clearly needed. I'll admit that even I was kind of leery about the parents being charged here, until I looked at the other evidence and saw the pattern of apathy and disinterest and failure to do anything a parent is expected to do.
Weird.
@@julesthecat.
Yes. They’re definitely weird, in terms of regular people and reality, but pretty typical of the MAGA crowd.
Don't get Republicans confused with MAGAts!
Why didn’t she stop the shooter when she was walking with him?
Why? Because he was armed with a 9mm. She was unarmed. She did the next best thing to not get shot and that is to connect with him. She did so on personnel level not to agitate him imho.
He probably held her in high regard and that is why he could not look at her. He most likely respected her and the kindness she displayed to him and other students.
Stop getting on the lawyers it’s there job both are doing good prayers to the families and the teachers who were involved
The assistant principal is a courageous woman! A true hero! I wish there were more people like her in the world.
But even she, based on her testimony, did not see that the shooting was foreseeable.
The parents are guilty of child abuse child, neglect, etc. and they should be punished because of that.
To say that both of the parents should have foreseen that their son was going to shoot up the school is incorrect. The way the involuntary manslaughter law is defined- they should not be convicted for that. Yes, they deserve to be punished but not for involuntary manslaughter as defined by law.
I don’t understand the judge. why she can’t keep it together? Maintain the order and decorum of the courtroom for God sakes. She needs to tighten on the reigns.
The male prosecutor needs to stop asking leading questions. If I was the defense attorney, I would keep on objecting.
Defense attorney you’re doing a great job. You keep doing what you’re doing!
I would love to know if she wished she was armed?
I would guess that would be a no.
She cared more about trying to SAVE lives.
@@melsafken764 Did he shoot anyone else after that?
How dumb this principle. When u go on lockdown u should not do the opposite
It shows her priority was the students.
She being there & speaking to Ethan probably saved lives & more bloodshed.
@@melsafken764 yes but that is not a good example to give. Yes I want to save lives but ur putting urself in danger. N’imagine if this shooter shot her? She would not be able to help the kids.
Uummm, she should have taken cover like everyone else. I am not impressed that she walked towards the killer.
Ethan's both parents equally Failed him, injured and lost schoolmates children, teachers and staff, Principal, and community...
Ignoring his cries 😢 for clear mental health issues, supplying him with a gun 🔫 to commit horrendous crimes against others!!!😪
Parents and Everyone is Responsible for Our Community Children...
It takes a Village to Raise a Child!" 😭 😭 😥 😔
There is so much blame to go around.
No not really.
Only blame for being sh*tty parents and blame for purchasing a weapon for their child. Their child who couldn't legally purchase a weapon on his own.
This judge should retire she's a dud
Throw her in PRISON!!! Complicit 100%
Psssstttt, she's not on trial.
What!!! She actually saved students’ life by getting them to safety and checked for a pulse of another starting CPR to another. IMO she’s a very brave woman who thought nothing of her own safety but cared enough about students to try to save theirs.
what a brain-rotted comment