[Q/A] Case For Ram Mandir At Ayodhya | Dr. Meenakshi Jain |
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 06. 2017
- Main Talk: • Case For Ram Mandir At...
For over two decades, a handful of Left historians have strenuously endeavoured to stymie the Ramjanmabhumi movement. From questioning the antiquity of Rama worship and the identity of ancient Ayodhya, they have also challenged the widely held belief that Babri Masjid was built on the site of the Janmabhumi temple.
The antiquity of the Rama Katha has, however, been traced as far back as sixth-fifth century BCE, when ancient ballads (akhyanas) transmitted Rama’s story orally. Valmiki’s Ramayana itself has been dated to the fourth-third century BCE. Over the centuries, Rama’s story has been re-told in many vernaculars of the country. Rama is the exemplar of moral values for Hindu society and epitomises its aspirations above all, for dharma.
The proceedings of the Allahabad High Court have exposed the vulnerabilities of Left historians. They could proffer no evidence of continued Muslim presence at Babri Masjid, while the unwavering commitment of Hindu devotees to the site has been attested by several sources. Babri Masjid was not mentioned in the revenue records of the Nawabi and British periods, nor was any Waqf ever created for its upkeep. No Muslim filed an FIR or complained of dispossession or obstruction in his alleged use of the Masjid when the image of Sri Rama was placed under the central dome on 23rd December 1949. The Sunni Central Waqf Board entered litigation on 18th December 1961, just five days before the twelfth anniversary of the placement of the image in the Masjid, on which date any claim would have become time-barred. The Board did not file a suit for possession; instead it sought a declaration on the status of the property.
Further, excavations of the ASI revealed uninterrupted occupation of the site since the 13th century BCE. They also exposed remnants of the temple on which Babri Masjid was erected. The assertions of Left historians on Babri Masjid have all been found to be erroneous; yet there has been no public retraction. Indeed, they continue to peddle their discredited theories despite the mounting evidence against them.
About the Speaker: -
Dr. Meenakshi Jain is a Ph.D from Delhi University. She specialises in cultural studies. She is a former Fellow, Nehru Memorial Museum and Library; and presently member of the Governing Council, ICHR. She is author of The Battle for Rama - Case of the temple at Ayodhya (2017).
Subscribe to our CZcams channels:
CZcams English: / sangamtalks
CZcams Hindi: / sangamhindi
Follow Sangam Talks on social media :
Telegram : t.me/sangamtalks
Twitter: / sangamtalks
Facebook: / sangamtalks
Instagram: / sangamtalks
Website: www.sangamtalks.org
Donate: www.sangamtalks.org/donate
#SangamTalks
#AyodhyaRamMandir
Mother I bow at your feet.
Those leftist communist who gave false evidence should be prosecuted and jailed for contempt of court for giving false evidence.
She's such a hero!
We owe her so much!
Heroine - liberal outrage🤣🤣
Do not be dejected Madam. Times are changing. We, the youth, were fed lies growing up, but we are waking up to the truth now. Your voices will only get stronger hereon. Keep up your good work. And thanks you Srijan talks, for giving a platform to the truth on our side.
Ramayana may be an old story, but Rama became GOD only in 1400 AD. Ramanadar wrote Adi Grandha and Rama became GOD.
The 12 important names of Vishnu, name of RAM not found.
The first 24 names of Vishnu, name of RAM missing.
brahma lied to Lord Shiva. Yudishtrsa lied to Drona; Sage Viswamitra persuaded Harichandra to lie;
Lying is the foundation on which it is built.
India is in dire need of temples. I support you. The government must stop building schools and hospital. Please build more temples.
She is seemingly a lady with convictions, experience & honesty. Very informative Q & A . She should get more space in the mainstream media.
The Himachal guy's argument is spot on....when references of ramayan are in Mahabharata then how can the worship of Ram be a 18th to 19th century construct....what about tulsidas ramayan, or Ramayans written in Southern languages......
Yash Sandhu, because mainstream media is full of urbannaxals who supress the truth
check this how Hindus did with Buddhists: czcams.com/video/D0k-23SCIyI/video.html
Ramayan and Mahabharat are not at all fiction or fairy tales...
They are real .
Even after more than 8thousand around years to ramayan evidence s can be still found...
Even after getting destroyed by invaders and ppl it is still present...
Even after so many natural disasters ...
Proof of Ravan airport,ramsetu,ram janmbhoomi,place of Rama and Sita marriage place, the floating stones ,the rameshwaram temple,foot prints of Hanuman ,the mountain sanjeevni buti ,
The place where Ravan kept sita,
Lord Hanuman's birth place ..
All are present Even today...
And scientific and logical claims also suggest that hanuman ,a monkey can be a human and can marry a human too
So think before saying .
The kurukshetra war place,place where krishna gave Arjuna Gyan is still present ,krishna janmbhoomi,place where krishna defeated the naga is still present,dwarka , I kashmir their is a place where a utensil given to bheem is still present....
And many more...
Mahabharata and ramayan are not myth..
So jai shri ram 🙏🏻🕉️
Thanks to social media we are able to hear such a beautiful discussion
Time has come to award Meenakshi Mam a Bharat Ratna...
You still believe in the Bharat Ratna??
I believe in Meenakshi Ji - not Bharat Ratna.
+VIVEK N SHARMA Sharma sorry to say but morons like you are on every related youtube videos...... Can't you fucking get the straight message here? All she is urging , to get aware of all these issues and then contribute yourself by doing some hard work and not by clapping and distributing awards to everyone on comment sections.......
@@satyaprakashjoshi1837 You write like very frustrated man Mr Satya Prajash Joshi. You clearly do not understand the tone of Dr Jain's talk. Too many leftist scholars in India are sadly paid agents of foreign disruptors in India.
@@satyaprakashjoshi1837 why so angry??
@@paganpower1790 Correct..After realizing that the farzi nehru/ghandy family appropriating and awarding it to themselves, it's value has gone down the drain .. it may seem like the Raashtra is adding insult to Injury to the Recipient and also to the true Bharatiyas as well.. Why not innovate a new Way to Honour our Real Heroes and Heroines..??? REAL GEMS !
A telling comment from Professor Jain: "I can not give a talk like this at a university." India's academic muzzling of alternative voices has stifled meaningful discourse for decades. The BM/RJB issue is not a struggle between left and right, but a debate between scientific facts of archeological documentation against historiographical fantasies supported by academic opportunism.
Meenakshi madam ji all Hindus are very grateful to you for presenting this video.
Hindutva and Hindus are abahaari to you Madam ! Splendid work, Wish security, health and aayu !!
K.K. Mohammad the deputy archeologist , has provided evidence in Allahabad high court and also written an article in Indian express back in 1990 that the site clearly shows it is a Ram Mandir and the local Muslim population wanted to hand over the property as well as construct a temple with their own hand . The entire campaign has been hijacked by the leftist as the scholar mentions here.The archeologist worked under the well known BB Lal.He confirm the presence of 11 century Ram pillars inside the Babri Masjid when it existed and when they did the digging after the demolition even at the depth of 2 to 3 feet it was obvious that it was a temple. A practicing Muslim he concludes that the hijacking of the movement by the leftist and pseudo secularist coupled with the powerful media resulted in spilling over of the controversy.KKM concludes that the Ram temple is even more precious for Hindus than Mecca and Madina for Muslim as it is far far older and historically important. Over 50,000 temples have been done away by aggression of invaders , looted and demolished and majority community is not demanding for all but their key temples of historical significance like Ayodhya , Mathura and Kasi viswanath.He wants muslim community to ponder whether the freedom they get in this country is being reciprocated in the truncated Akhand Bharath.Hand over as a Gesture and improve the inter community relationship.
Bloody hell, Hindus have also destroyed temples!
The answer to move forward (27 min) is, if we move forward (without Ram Mandir) they will come for your next temple or house.. This is what muslim invaders did for 1000 years, our current generation still did not understand Abrahamic Religions.
Watch All Rajiv Malhotra Videos and read "Breaking India" without fail.
rajivmalhotra.com/library/videos/complete-list-videos/
True every Indian must read the book" Breaking India Forces " Rajiveji has revealed the true agenda of both of them
the local muslims wwnted to give back the land back then. but then the left intervened and the muslims boards too.reat is history
Thank you Sangam Talks to bring up these pieces of information.
Watching it after Ram Mandir judgement. Pranam to her.
What a great research done by u madam,I feel so proud of u,may god bless us with many more great souls like u, big thank to Social media.
check this how Hindus did with Buddhists: czcams.com/video/D0k-23SCIyI/video.html
She is working on Gyaanvaapi as well🤩
Superb...People like Meenakshi Madam are real custodian of Indian culture and civilization
Time has come for Dharma to rise . Now Hindus must start to stick together and lobby hard.
Yes. Please take up one dharmic project and dedicate the next 5-10 years to it. Let a thousand Indic revolutions rise!
@Kartikeya Sharma Voice is the force. Satyamev Jayate!
We need such people on the mainstream media.
Koti koti naman evam Charan sparsh
Thank you madam.
Jai Hind
I'm very happy someone is here for hindus
Very good work Meenakshi ji
It's sincere request and advice such talk should be circulated in hindi and other regional languages so that people who with less education qualification
Please
I am sure you people must be working on it .And other such foundation working for same cause must unite and reach out to our universities and school in more modern and educative way ..
Good point at least they can put subtitles in hindi
*SrijanTalks*
its a request, *kindly make a separate channel and upload the translated versions of the videos in Hindi.*
These videos should reach as many people as possible.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I just read "The India They saw (Vol-1)". Amazing work.
@Kartikeya Sharma WHERE ARE HER BOOKS AVAILABLE /?
Real eye-opener.
Ram Janmabhumi Pujan on 5th Aug 2020 is the fruit of her efforts and efforts of all those who stuck with this through thick and thin. We must thank them all for being patient and being committed to the cause.
How can we throw out our treasurer , which is our souls without we are not even shadow , moorti after prana pradishta our vaidic
procedure....even it is a belief keep all we alive.....best work done by madam, really appreciated ...secret and sacred still Hindu have with their life experience not revealed.... like shiva geeta...
Bold group who can have the guts for truth.
So much enlightenment, thanks for your hard work
Audiences should be asked to introduce. Most of their views are so good, wood like to connect with them. Love from USA.
thank you for the video.. Best wises..
Salutes to you Madam. You represent truely the women power. That is why we respect women so much!
Excellent work mam..
When Hindus were singled out they had great courage to protect and Preserve their culture with such a difficulty and intelligence...when these left historians get single out they will not have a strong ideology basis to survive in a such a meaningful, logical and spiritual society.
Madam! Salutes for a very revealing and genuine facts. Great and excellent
It is her knowledge that she is roaring ; salute ma'am
Ma'am u should look into the Puri Jagannath Temple. the history of this famous temple is well documented as Madala Panji still carefully preserved at mutts in Puri. lot of atrocities have been done on this temple and lots of efforts have successfully been carried out to safeguard the images of dieties through centuries.
Very good work madam, I wish you also make detail study history from a point of view where Hindu temple were built destroying Buddhist vihars all over the county, then it will be a complete circle, where we can find the truth of our own religion and culture.
@@Samana358 hello, this hindu temples built on ruins of Buddhist temples is exactly the same propaganda which has been artificially created by leftist historians to create rift , confusion and justify Islamic iconoclasm...... There is no truth to such stories..... !!! It is a big fat lie !!!!! Meenakshi maam has mentioned this propaganda in her other videos . Please check her other videos..
Ordered 3 books to learn more about our history and how Left parasites are distorting the academics.
1. Rama and Ayodhya
2. Sati: Evangelicals, Baptist Missionaries, and the Changing Colonial Discourse
3. The Battle for Rama: Case of the Temple at Ayodhya
Ms. Meenakshi, Thank you.
Salute to Meenakshi mam !!!!!
नमस्कार मीनाक्षी जैन जी 🙏
Excellent analysis Dr.Jain with facts & data. Kudos to you for your phenomenal work. Will try to make it reach out to as many people as I can.
Very logically put up backed up in-depth study and knowledge
Excellent discussion
Madam salute to you ... And salute to Srijan Foundation. Due to people like you our history was saved from leftist Historians who are intellectual Goodas.
Great great work.. monumental work! This will be celebrated today and for the centuries to come, if not yesterday!
The NCERT chapter on Delhi Sultans which talks about Raziya Sultan does have very clear explanation of gender discrimination and resistance to Raziya's rule by Minhaj-i-Siraj .It talks about the ' ideal social order created by God' which (the book states) depended on birthright and gender discrimination.
let me tell you for a fact she ruled as a puppet in name. So wake up and sift through the leftist ncert bullshit. what happened after her death then? any other muslim woman rulings you recall? now how about Rani Abbakka Chowta the true queen of india (south india/mangalore/goa india)?
Mother I bow your feet..Thank you very much for very special information and proof.
Jai ram
Erudite scholar. It is her lifetime s labour. A diligent researcher. Rejected by the intolerant, rabid, toxic left. Pranam to you. She is like Gargi, Maitreyee of Vedic times
Original pillars, 8 of them from the Ram Temples are still there in the DACHA of Sita ki Rasoi mosque .( Ram Janmabhumi )
Excellent presention Hats off to Meeakshi ji
Looking forward to prasad cooked in Sita ki Rasoi in Ram Janmabhumi ..
Great work re, keep it up, the Bhagawan bless you
Thank YOU very much !!
Minutes after 16 is very enlightening, you have thrown good light on left influence in academic institutions but I think this will now gradually change over next few generations..
Madam salute to you ...Very impressive knowledge, thought and your efforts. It must be enough to understand the reality................
It's all proven! They still refuse to accept and keep lying! We need to get back our Bharat! If they are really secular, they will give back all the temples appropriated by force! It'll reinforce the brotherhood that underlies as the social fiber of India!
When i was 16years ,an old neighbor gave me a small idol of Sri Ganesh .This statue is a a copy of the original found in a river.Ms Jain really is a guru in the right place,T the right time.
Appreciable work by Srijan ..
india is the only place, where a big truth ie., Shri Ram will have to be proved, what millions of people for thousands of years revered.
India is the perfect example of secularism.
Excellent work mam.
Kudos to you mam, for the great work done by you.
Madam I too read the new books NCERT and as well as the old ones which were there in 1995- 1999. You are so right that in new books ( Ancient India / Medival ) they completely messed up with chronology.
The old books what ever information they had ( wrong / right ) at least were in well structured chronological order.
the structured chronological lies may be in order ,but, are , meant to brain-wash us.. Even when I was a student, the same fake history was taught .. But, Fortunately , I believed what me father-mother had to tell me..That helped me think for myself too .. ..we have to research and think for ourselves, to come out of our heen-bhaav and inferiority complex..
I am requesting you to Srijan talks that please upload these kind videos or discussion in hindi so it go to every comman man I want to share it with my father,mother and others but due to english they can't understand however I do try to tell others but when the people direct listen to mam it would penetrate more
Thank you
Meena amma! Pranam!
Please make this videos trending if still hindus exist in India !!!!
Meenakshi Jain is sooooooooo Right. Build the temple and then move on... Jai Sri Ram 🙏🏽
Fantastic work madam 👍👏
Jai Shree Ram
Meenakshiji , I admire the meticulous and methodical manner in which you present your case ..I first watched your interview with Rajiv Malhotraji ,and since then, I like to closely listen to your talks on this very Holy and invaluable to all of us Hindus, on Sri Ram Lala Janma Sthali .. Thank you for your advocacy and perseverance in digging down into the HISTORICAL RESEARCH and collating and co-relating so much of valuable information .
Were you an Expert Witness in The Ram Janma Bhoomi case in either the Prayagraj High Court, or, in The Supreme Court ??
Is it possible to find the arguments of the whole proceedings in both the Courts, anywhere on CZcams / /? Also, the Complete arguments of Sri K Parasaranji ??
The person speaking of moving on, building a hospital etc., does not seem to realize, that, it is of Paramount importance not only for the Society to return to Sanity from the brain-washing by the Pseudo secularist lobby and start living in harmony , BUT, Also ,for us to get de-colonized from the 1000 years old traumas , psychosis and Denials of all the atrocities committed against us as an ancient, Dhaarmic Civilization and Culture..Return to Sobriety in a true sense of the word.. and, never ever again allow this kind of massive assaults on our very Identity, happen to us.. We have to absorb these lessons in the Core of our very Being .. Ise Aatmasaat karna Atyant Anivaarya hai ..Jai Shri Ram, Jai Jai Hanuman ...
'intolerance of the left'--very good phrase.
I am speechless.
Thank you so much mam
Very informative
I don't agree with that hospital argument by communist or liberals. No one lives with dignity after loosing their pride. Ram temple mathura and kashi is about hindu pride.
Here on 29 Nov 2019 after the *Ramlala Virajmaan!* Sc verdict...
5th or I think 6th video of her, watching continuously, learning so much!! Surely gonna buy her books.... 🙏🏻
Isn't their a video-graphic of pictorial record of all excavations done? If not why this wasn't done?
Yaar Madam ne toh JNU ka mooh kala kar diya...
1st time someone saying truth
First education minister of India, Maulana Azad omitted 8 thcentury from history books.Raja Dahir of Sindh chapter was omitted.Hindu empire before muslim invasion was omitted on purpose.
ASI website doesn't have Donate link at all. What's wrong with the GoI? Here in the US, private funding is often matched by the govt funding.
जय सनातन धर्म,,जय जैन धर्म जय सिक्ख जय सिक्ख धर्म,,, जय हिंद जय भारत जय मूलनिवासी भारतीय
Ashish Dhar in the audience!! How can we be a part of such talks??
You are doing great work by finding the reality of our culture ,the damage done by the leftist must be restored in the same manner. I openly supporting you Mam👍👍❤❤
What is the name of the book...I want to buy it online
its good that babri mosque was demolished.. should have been done long back in pre independence india
Where can we finds this book?
I have never seen a video where this issue is detailed in a proper flow. She did an amazing job. Can I pls know the name of the book that she is using to show the pictures ?
The name is mentioned in the video it self... Look over that portion.
Wt is name of book??? Pl tell
Dear Madam,
Thanks for exploring the facts, I am NZ based and want to buy this book. Where can I buy from?
Ritesh Patel
Read SriRangam Kovil ollugu(Ozhugu) khan it talks about malik kafur, Delhi sultan& ulagh khan invasion to SriRangam& Madurai Meenakshi temple
very informative. Texts books should be modified to reflect the true history.
Can some one please tell me how to attend these lectures and where are they held ?
To get updates on talks follow Srijan twitter profile - @SrijanFn . Today Sai Deepak's talk on Rohigya issue is happening in Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan, KG Marg, New Delhi at 6 PM.
Hospitals can also be built in Mecca and Bethelham. We will build hospitals on some of the other 39000 mosques.
Why the Hindu temples should be under government, why not free our temples from government control.
Please please upload this video and all of in Hindi and other languages
Mam your work inspires.
I never knew about this findings until I heard and saw videos like this and from in Muhammad which proves things more factfully. But we need more tools to educate this to today's and coming generations about the told lies and the real truth. Generation these days are looking trip on what really had happened to India and they are more leaned towards easy to understand ideology.
Even supreme court clearly told temple was never there and there for mosque was not built on top of temple. So if the archeological findings were so clear why will sc give verdict on shaky grounds??
20:18 & 26:10 super point mam.
Is it possible to get the copies of your work on posts? Or let us know the stock keepers in Thanjavur, Tiruchirapalli etc of Tamil Nadu.
It is available online for purchase. Book name "The Battle for Rama"
Moving forward does not mean not respecting our identity! We have a past, a culture and a philosophy that is unparalleled in the world and from which all the other present civilizations drew their inspiration and learning from when they were in their infancy. Why are we so happy to disown it? For what purpose? Disrespecting our heritage is the same as disrespecting our parents and grandparents. Let us please not be so modern that we continue to be seen as people who have no substance, no worth, as compared to people of other cultures.
Our misrepresentation has happened for long enough by rulers from other countries and the colonial era. I hope we have not lost our self respect so much that we have totally forgotten who we are and would not mind our cultural subjugation to continue!
I feel very sorry to see the amount of misinformation and ignorance of the profundity and high ideals of our native culture, religions and philosophies among our present younger generation. There are so many lies and misinformation spread by vested interests who are, I think, afraid of our revival. What a pity that they are believed rather than our own people! How perniciously this mind control game has been played till now, even after our independence! Those responsible for this have to be called to account and the records set right.
Our younger generations have to be saved from the hell that awaits those who are made to feel inferior to others, so much so that they even adopt their 'Johnny come lately' oppressors' cultures, values and beliefs, without even being aware that the fountainhead of all that lies in our own ancestors' culture, that had been home grown and organically developed over the millenniums!
More and more leading experts of the world are becoming awed by our past achievements in the sciences and the arts, while our own poor youth aspires for the foreigners' approval for their self esteem! Wake up, my dear family members! Love and respect yourselves and reclaim your glory! We are second to none, but are so far ahead of the rest that we can teach them! Please research and build on our own knowledge and you can astound the world once more and make it a happy place to live in for all of humanity!
Thanks, Rajesh!
Very true Auravbhai.. Knowing the Truth about ourselves , is THE WAY FORWARD.. OUR TRUTH IS GAURAVSHALI .. WE HAVE TO RECLAIM IT .. THE ONLY WAY TO REGAIN IS , SELF-EDUCATION AND REALIZING AND ACCEPTING THAT WE WERE COLONIZED AND SUBJUGATED... THAT ADMISSION TO OURSELVES, GIVES US THE COURAGE, VALOUR, AND MENTAL STAMINA TO STEP FORWARD..INTO OUR OWN GLORY .. VANDE MATARAM