Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
In Conversation with Meenakshi Jain
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 05. 2017
- Rajiv Malhotra's Dialogue with Author Meenakshi Jain. They discuss her research on Ayodhya Ram Temple, her books, the control of the Indian Left over Academia, Travellers to India and their view of India hundreds of years back, Status of Women In Indian Society and other topics.
20th Feb 2017
New Delhi
Noor ul Hassan
Ayodhya
Hindu
Muslim
Rama
Ram
Romila Thapar
Irfan Habib
South India
Caste System
English Collector
Ram Mohan Roy
Missionaries
East India Company
Brahmins
To donate to Infinity Foundation’s projects including the continuation of such episodes and the research we do:
इनफिनिटी फ़ौंडेशन की परियोजनाओं को अनुदान देने के लिए व इस प्रकार के एपिसोड और हमारे द्वारा किये जाने वाले शोध को जारी रखने के लिए: infinityfoundat...
To Subscribe to Rajiv Malhotra Official:
राजीव मल्होत्रा ऑफिसियल की सदस्यता लेने के लिए: / @rajivmalhotraofficial
Join Rajiv's discussion (राजीव की चर्चा से जुडें): groups.google....
Irfan Habib is the Aurangazeb of Indian Historical studies. The Mughal/ British raj continues in AMU, JNU, DU History departments.
Meenakshi Jain's scholarship is absolutely astounding. Her books are overturning long established wrongly-held notions in many areas of Indian culture and civilization. It is a shame that mediocre intellectuals and historians like irfan habib, romila thapar etc have suppressed such outstanding scholars. RM's talk series is making people aware of this strain of outstanding scholarship & scholars that are there in India. Hopefully Indian institutions will soon have such people at the helm as compared to the terrible folks who have been in charge in the past 7 decades!!
Certainly Madam"s approach is admirable....but the question is why Jains are so much interested and enthusiastic for Hindu Temples... In fact Jains have broken away from Hindus and taken a minority status.... also they deny being hindus or having hindu ancestry...also there are many controversies ...in which jains have claimed Hindu temples....e.g. Jains have been claiming Girnar temple as jain Temples ...there are many more
I think this sati bill was a big hoax by missionaries to defame Hindus. This is because this is always used by missionaries in their all arguments against Hinduism.
Can any one give any factual account how many sati case were reported in 100 years of British rule in India?
So that Britishers had to ban this by rule. If this was practiced in any of the viewers family please let me know. Because my grand father never talked about this practice in India or in any society except the kshatriya sainik who killed in war during mughal era. Because they used to capture girls as sex slaves
@@suhrudpatel buai tu rahne de .. pahle apne andar. Ka jativad bahar nikal
Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism, and recent Lingayat all are the branch of Sanatana Dharma . If we go to Japan we will see Saraswati worship and Yajna happening. Because Buddhist branch of Sanatana culture worship goddess Tara, Saraswati, Matangi etc . Vajrayana Buddhism is based on tantric tradition of Shaktism or Devi worship of Sanatana Dharma
@@aadirai288it is not the question of jaativaad .. he rightly said ....jain are doing so
Both Rajivji and Smt. Meenakshi Jain must get an high govt. award for their revolutionary work !
agree .. when some idiotic artists who are not even qualified to be called as Indians are facilitated and these people who are digging up our lost glory and history and showcasing phenomenal
Awarded Padma Shri
I have the greatest respect for this woman!!
At 25:15 Rajiv Malhotra's retort: Alexander is not "Great" by the way, just "Alexander the Greek". Very good sir.
I request Rajiv Malhotra to interview Michel Danino and discuss about the lost river -- Sarasvati.
Is this quotation of Rajiv G is from this very book?
Meenakshi Jain is a wonderful person. So happy to know about her! Looking for her books right now.
Absolutely shocking revelations. Excellent video. Thank you Rajivji for broadcasting the truths surrounding the Ayodya dispute. When I visited the Janmasthan, I had the privilege of having the Darshan of Bhagwan Shri Ram. What literally shocked me was the pillars in side the small dome which had images of Hanuman and other Hindu symbols. Thank you Meenakshyji for taking up this task of unearthing our true history.
Another excellent episode Mr. Malhotra. Good to see the likes of Meenakshi Jain In the ICHR. I have to make a comment though. Your point about the lack of rigor and scholarship in those trying to counter the Marxist or western narratives is very well taken. As necessary as your brutal criticism is, presenting the context, in the same breath, is important as well I think.
The scholars in India with the so-called 'left wing' persuasions not only had a complete stranglehold on their home turf, they also found a mountain of scholarship and collaborators in the west to bolster their work and reputation. Those who opposed them met with hostility and censure on the home turf, and complete indifference and contempt from their international peers. Mrs. Jain's Wikipedia page is an instructive example.
The right wing in the US, on the other hand finds no shortage of collaborators all over the western world. They also get patronage from the government and from the predominantly center-right establishment, which even prop up economically unviable and socially unpopular institutions. The Indian 'right' received no political or economic patronage for decades. The politicians and the institutions were a warped version of the western left-wing, and consequently the establishment also learned to lean towards the center-left (Narayan Murthy is a good example).
In a developing country like India where one cannot be ambivalent about the security of their basic sustenance, one tends to learn to bend ideologically. This is why, Irfan Habib and co. didn't need to work hard to stomp out any resistance. A resistance, with minor exceptions, never coalesced. With a playing field so skewed, a dominant narrative so out of balance, it's not hard to see why the home team for decades could never even organize a metaphorical 10-man parade.
Obviously, none of this is news to you. My point is, the right wing in India needs some encouragement as much as it needs a swift kick on their ass to stop talking about nuclear bombs and planes in the Mahabharata. You deliver both, but the good cop in your good-cop-bad-cop routine/message is a little mellow in comparison to his peer (think Colmes, from the Hannity and Colmes duo). Before the right wing can become a potent movement, it needs to be able to shrug off all the mischaracterizations (some justified, most not) that they have been encouraged by the other side to internalize. A little more nuanced judgement, a little more encouragement from you would go a long way in supporting those in our camp, and, more importantly, in the intellectual metamorphosis of those on the fence whom you are essentially preaching to.
And now Ramlalla is back to home after 491 years.. Salute to all the hindu fighters who for generations fought for this🙏🙏🙏🙏
Why more people don’t watch his videos ? This is ridiculous. This needs to be broadcasted on TV and radio during prime time.
That wouldn't feed the propaganda, would it?
Awesome Facts regarding Ayodhya
And today she got Padma Shree ! Congratulations
this is what I call an intellectual talk , sharp , precise with insights. thank you sir and mam. this lady reminded me of ubhaya bharati.
What an eye opener . Many thanks to both of you Rajiv ji and Meenakshi ji to bring out such a wonderful insight to Hindu minds and left's hegemony upon educational institutions. I don't know what Vajpayee ji and Advani ji were doing during their tenure? I think Hindus, getting away from their roots, could be the reason for their becoming enfeebled. Nehru and Indira Gandhi have destroyed the Hindu minds very cleverly. It seems we have not only to build a Hindu infrastructure but also to fight with our own people, who share the same names and surnames as ours. Difficult but not impossible. We need the govt on our side though..
+Rajiv Malhotra Official Sir, this is one of the best talk. Thanks for introducing Meenakshi Jain. I never heard of her before. I will buy and read her work. Thank you so much!
Meenakshi and Rajiv, thanks for setting the record straight. It takes years of reading Indian history from the outside to eventually figure out that what we learned in school in the 70s was not history but a concocted version with a strong bias to dim the view of India and Hindus. Most Indians do not know any better that we have been subjected to soft terrorism for hundreds of years and more so since 1947!!
I have read the concocted version from the history books.
According to you...what is the actual history that you believe happened
Meenakshi Ji is a real Vidushi. Rajiv Ji knows who is scholar and who's not. His choice of selecting real scholars for the dialogue of this kind is very much appreciated
That was quite wonderful and hugely informative. Kudos to Meenakshi Jain for standing up for all these years to the Leftists bullies.
HERE IS THE REAL HEROINE THAT OUR YOUTHS SHOULD FOLLOW
Thanks Rajiv ji!
From all accounts, it is amply clear that, Irfan Habib was not a secular leftist/marxist scholar or intellectual. He was rather a "Muslim first' intellectual, who used his leftism and misused his position of clout in the academia, to whitewash the gory history of Islamic era of atrocities , on Hindu people. R.C. Mazumdar and Jadunath Sarkar were real scholars and researchers free from biases and prejudices. The same cannot be said of Irfan Habib. So many skeletons are now tumbling out of the cupboards of Irfan Habib and company. Even when their bluff is out, they try to kill truth by brazen falsehoods, conspiracy of silence and other such diversionary tactics. How shameful of them to brazenly make false allegation of theft of inscriptions from Lucknow museum? Even When their false theory was exposed , they tenaciously stick to their mischievous theory. Shameful...
"Returning awards" was another gimmick of theirs, which has boomeranged on them. In this context, Works of Sita Ram Goel too are valuable as counter-literature, Sitaram Goel's works are based on extensive research. His works should be republished and publicised. The burden of delivering Indian History from the sinister leftist stranglehold lies on the serious scholars. Average layman is not expected to have the deep knowledge or insight to effectively and credibly refute the falsehoods perpetrated by Leftists. Dedicated scholars ready to mine truth from original sources are needed to work. And their work needs to be disseminated for common folk on a larger scale . Works of Dr Malhotra, Nagaswamy, Meenakshi Jain and SitaRam Goel are hardly known to average intellectuals or among the main stream media guys.
Radheyshyam Sahadeo Poddar Kannan Gopinathan's resignation is one such ploy of the leftist . *If* congress come back to power this guy will shoot the ladders in lightning speed.
Now it's the time to put pressure on our government for restoring our lost identity. first of all our text books need to be changed from leftist self concocted ideas. U people r the heroes of bharata. I appreciate your efforts. During my school days i was getting confused the way our history is being taught. Now i find those answers.
Why don't you begin yourself? Tell your friends, family, children around them, of these things... instead of telling "people to do this & that...?"
Bhagyajit Dalei , first change your , environment and have a connectivity with your own surrounding , spread the wisdom and knowledge for the greater hindu unity .
I think this sati bill was a big hoax by missionaries to defame Hindus. This is because this is always used by missionaries in their all arguments against Hinduism.
Can any one give any factual account how many sati case were reported in 100 years of British rule in India?
So that Britishers had to ban this by rule. If this was practiced in any of the viewers family please let me know. Because my grand father never talked about this practice in India or in any society except the kshatriya sainik who killed in war during mughal era. Because they used to capture girls as sex slaves
one of the bests intellectual discourse :) Thanks for sharing this :)
Yet another eye-opening conversation, as always. History needs to be re-written.
Excellent conversation!
Ms jain is so clear in her knowledge !
Very enlivening discussion. Sad that our political class is mired in Grade A ignorance. Despite so much information put out by SRM, we still have no traction. What a wonderful corpus of books Meenakshiji has produced. Like SRM keeps parroting, we need more such scholars.
I have followed Meenakshi ji since 90s . Feel fortunate to see her face and listen her voice .
Thanks a lot Infinity Foundation.
Sir, request you to have a discussion with Padmashri Dr.Bannanjee Govindhacharya. He is a great great scholar and philosopher from Karnataka.
Thanks to Rajiv Malhotra Ji for his tireless efforts in bringing in all these intellectuals on one platform.
Sir , Ram Mohan Roy was called Raja by Mughal emperor Akbar II for fighting his case in England. no indian scholar called him Raja, he was very good friend of Lord William Bentick.
RAM MOHUN RAY, S SISTER in law self emulated after her husband died which affected Ram mogul Roy badly and inspired.Rammohun As s reformer as.am educator he had no match among his contemporaries He fought for the freedom of press He never bowed to any p
ressure I am proud of Rmmohum and. Vidyasagar who fought for women's right their edu atiom their right to remarry Please.rember only recently Roop Kamwar is not working because no has become.Satee and peoplr pay I h homage to her shtine
r
Excellent............informative........conversation between great people.
Many thanks for sharing with us.
वंदे मातरम् ।
🚩🙏🇮🇳🚩🇮🇳🙏🚩🇮🇳🙏🚩🇮🇳🙏
Would request Meenakshiji to make her publications available electronically (Amazon etc) so more can have access to them.
Thanks Meenakshi ji for valuable information. I shared this video to my daughter who is graduating in history from SNU.
i can understand Meenakshi......sometimes its very difficult to convince ur closest people even though u jave the power to convince the whole outsidde world...
Excellent interview. Thanks a lot !
namaste
nice video sir
hats off to u MR Rajiv malhotra.great conversation
a very informative discussion. especially on the ayodhya issue and continuing dominance of the left in the intellectual discourse. hope people in the govt see this video.
Very Insightful discussion.
We need more young Indians taking a serious note of Indian History (true history, untainted by anyone or any vested party /religion). History, as it happened is not taught in schools, colleges etc.. But people like Sri Rajiv Malhotra are doing yeoman service in awakening Indian especially so called Hindu who are truly living under a rock or with buried head in sands of ignorance!
Here sir
I think one should know what happened in Tamil Nadu Temple such as Srirangam, Madurai where Murthy was moved from Temple several years. Lots of people died protect Swamy’s Murthy
Thank you to both Rajiv and Meenakshi. This was an eye opener for me. As a layperson I found it fascinating to learn about the EIC versus evangelical camp and the leftist academic stranglehold over some of the Indian historical narrative.
Sir tapasya is the only thing missing. I meet people around 18 yrs of age. They want to do so many things. They feel that they can counter this Grand Left narrative without doing any extensive research. They see few CZcams videos. For example your videos and not even all videos and then they say that they know everything. I feel your videos should be an inspiration for our generation to study and research more. I have been studying for so long but still i feel that im not ready even for battles of Debates and they think that they can demolish them. If we call them as a Enemy then i must say that these people are not aware of how strong and big these people are whom they want to fight. So usually when they come in the battle they are defeated so badly that they never come back again.
This is a very interesting and informative conversation. I have known about Meenakshi Jain's work on Ayodhya, the others I came to know now. Checking on line, I found her books are priced very high- and some vendors even charge Rs.200 for shipment! I think popular editions of these books must come out at a more reasonable price- not necessarily cheap paperback. More people should read these books to get properly informed. Very grateful for this conversation.
The way Rajivji is trying to reveal the actual scenario by inviting such a honest and truthful person like Meenakshiji is just mind boggling.
meenakshiji jain -strong proof of Ramjanma boomi[temple] mentioned in her book- waiting for temple opening ceremony thanks a lot Meenakkshiji jai hind.
Though I am tiny before Meenakshi Mam, however, I may only add that almost entirety of the explanations and commentaries offered by Romila Ji on Mahabharata and Ramayana are childish. Having read some of her essays on Mahabharata, I have been able to locate countless mistakes in her totally feeble understanding. No quotations, no logical rebuttals to claims of Vyasa (by the way, there can't be any), no reference to any Sanskrit commentary on Mahabharata, no corroboration with allied vedic or agamaic literature.... I mean, one can go on and on to enlist the weaknesses of Mrs. Thapar's essays. I wonder if such people can even be inducted into PhD programs, let alone rise to become professors. And Irfan Habib!!! Less is said, the better. If any one person is responsible for anti-Hindu tirade in history schools of universities, then, it's got to be this man. Highly politically connected with congress party, he has done an absolute dis-service to the very profession he claims to pontificate upon. These idiots, as any wise person would like to call them having read their ridiculous and wrong literature, can even sell the soil of the nation to safe-guard their secessionist thoughts.
Pls 🙏 wright down everything and publish tem we need ppl like u
scholars. though few in numbers, are there .... I guess this so called pro hindu govt should encourage them and bring them forward to give importance their work
cos they are the only people who will defend us from the very dangerous leftist etc foreign ideologies and these scholars are precious to us
Hanuman murthy in Patmanabhaswamy temple, Thiruvananthapuram was also buried in the earth in fear of being desecrated.
Really bro
The India need these true historians
Strategy Plan for all Rajiv Malhotra Fans !
==================================
1. understand the nature & extent of damage done to hindu dharmic identity in the last 70-100-250 yrs
due to wrong notions planted in indian minds abt indian civilisation culture society
2. overturn these wrong notions established , decolonize your own mind & restore our lost identity-pride by research
3. expose-name-shame-sue-punish anti india, india hating intellectuals academicians researchers political parties
institutions
classify these people into 4 categories 1) Leftists 2) Islamists 3)Christians(Western) 4) Others / Recent hindu
converts
4. economic & political boycott of ALL anti india, india hating media completely & permanently & those who control them
5. spread message on internet,social media,youtube completely bypassing mainstream media
6. unite hindus economically & politically
7. give the current hindu awakening a long lasting intellectual foundation not temporary sentiments!
8.Develop the required intellectual foundation talk by sharp clear precise discourse & sharing of hindsights-insights-
foresights about our civilisation & its enemies.
on temple displacement thing i want to inform that most of the modern krishna temples of jaipur are the one which were moved very secretly from mathura when mughal rulers ordered for destruction ..the biggest example is "goving deo ji" temple in jaipur.some temples around jaipur hv same story..even nathdwara deity is a displaced one from mathura...
Eye opener. Grateful for sharing this awesome knowledge.
I am proud ❤️ both of u 💖,tears in my eyes 💔😭 we hindus are cheated from 70 years we all are so ignorant due to that distorions
Eye opening talk..
Thank you Meenakshi for your directness ,sensitivity, your careful processes ......they have helped me find my truest answers.
Sir i started watching the videos like the one here, thank you for the great work with views and information which you are sharing. It makes us to think what is our contribution to our society.... Thanks for making us to realize and remember our duty towards our country...
thanks sir, to opening our eyes.
Excellent! Excellent!
Ram Mohan Roy was a true Villain and we were taught the opposite by Left Historians!
Imp point: Sloganeering have taken high place than the hard & silent work to produce counter authentic literature.
Meenakshi ji please guide and mentor as many as possible competent scholars, who can place our culture and national interest first.
Simply Awesome. God bless you
Shame on Hindu organisation s for not supporting these great eminent persons
Excellent interview! Adds to Arun Shourie's work.
This is such a thought changing conversation.
The point: Most of us are seldomly well informed, infact we genuinely know nothing. And that makes moat right wingers following vandalism.
Learning our culture is the need of the hour.
jnu is officially a muslim univ as it is named after maulana nehru
Rajiv make 100s of menakshi jain to protect our culture...
Wowwww Rajiv ji and Meenakshi mam, hailed to your work and contentment. Half the battle is already won.
The left ecosystem is so comprehensive.. something to learn from them too..
Dear it is easy to be comprehensive, when you don't have too much to handle. They only have agenda to oppose, hence can be very comprehensive. But the true events is diverse and need time and space to gather evidence and present with sources.
Great talk.. Very inspiring..
Great job sir thanq so much it helped me soo much...
Meenakshi Jain! salute you, Mam! We are indebted to you for your services for the nation! it is high time that whole Indian history is reviewed and honestly written
again in its right perspectives!
It is our paramount responsibility, to restore pride and history of India. Be rational, search for truth and importantly show it to world.
Heartfelt gratitude to Meenakshi mam for her relentless effort to bring this truth to people which is no less than Tapas and thank you to rajivji for his contribution to dharma which is also no less than a tapas too.
Amazing discussion... thank you
Always amazing to hear you Mr Malhotra. Thanks for enlightening us on variety of issues . Also thanks for awakening the souls of Hindus and Hinduism
Thank you Ravi & Meenakshi Ji for sharing your knowledge. At least now I know few facts about India that have been suppressed for so long.
Whenever Hindu kings faught with each other, the winner king used to take away KULDEVATA or popular Deity of thd defeated king ( with full honour) and do it's Pranpratishtha in his State.
Hindu kings did not destroy and loot temples they did not desicrate thd idols.
It was commonly perceived that thses deities are protectors of the kingdom and also kings derive power from these deities so the winner kings used to take away the idols.
Also loosing your Deity in the war was perceived as ultimate insult.
Beautiful. Thank You Rajiv Sir. Meenakshi Ma'am thank you.
knowledgeable.
Superb video. I love ur work...
Thankyou for Introducing Meenakshi Jain sir...... Meenakshi Jain should be a new age historian.
These contributions should come out in print and in all major Indian languages. Common man should know how our history has been cooked !
One Radhakrishnan Pillai has written a lot on Chanakya and arthasastra. He has also given corporate management classes based on arthasastra. Hope this nformation is useful.
I laughed out loud on this one:
Enfeeblement - euphemism
Moronization - Putting it bluntly
Thank you for the fascinating discussion!
Congratulations Dr. Jain for winning Padma..!! Much deserved.
Great talks, very inspiring. Yes, we need to be serious in our research with facts and evidence. I regularly follow your videos as you don't talk from the left or right side but only what is RIGHT.
i appreciate the work and i agree that the new government hasnt done much except for promoting sanskrit "culturally" but i dont think we can underestimate the hard work done by swayamsevaks on ground....they are the ones who are basically getting rid of the caste equations in the villages and the forgotten corners of the country.....their discipline and patriotism is great but yeah they should also be trained in this as the intellectual battle also has to be faught....but a wide dismissal of these organizations wouldnt be the right thing to do
Very interesting to learn few things about Aayodhya. Will certainly look for a book from Dr Meenakshi Jain on this subject.
It was nice conversation
Thank u soooooo much
great work by meenakshi mam!!
A Jain is working hard and successfully expose left for Ram temple is delightful to see!
Thank you madam.
Jains also believe in Rama..in Jainsam mentioned about Rama
This Manthan (Meenakshi/Sandhya) is inherent in (almost) every family in India. As long as they are alive our civilization will be alive. The most infected state (tamilnadu) has produced / saved most treasure of our civilization. Out of this manthan comes out all Acharyas from South !!
We don't have to feel so bad (as become moronization) as it is the "degree of exposition" and karma place a role which side you see. Only karmically elevated sees both side clearly. This is time for those elevated person to join the action.
Only 1500 likes for this video is very sad thing. People must circulate this video.
One has to really appreciate the relentless focus of Rajiv ji when it comes to denying the historic narratives, passed on to us by the various writers with leftist/Western PoV or scribes accompanying invading armies. It was evident when he corrected Ms. Jain: "...not Alexander the Great, Alexander the Greek". Indian history books should bestow greatness to Indian kings who spread dharma, built great temples, promoted sciences & mathematics, arts & literature etc. The great Gupta kings, Samudragupta, chandragupta; that valiant Chandragupta Maurya; Maha Rana Pratap; Sri Krishna Devaraya, chatrapati Shivaji....these were some of the greatest rulers under whose rule India prospered and dharma was protected. People enjoyed stability & prosperity. It is time to glorify them, write books, make movies, name cities/institutions/awards etc. That's what it takes to motivate and inspire the young generation, instill pride, build new India on Indian ethos, not some borrowed alien system.
RAJIV SIR, TAKE SOME BREAKING INDIA SERIES CLASSES IN KOLKATA ALSO
They both are doing very good job ...well done..