The Best Argument For Quran Only Islam (No Hadith)
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 12. 2019
- Instagram: / the.britishmuslim
This video is on the best argument for Quran only Islam. Quran only Islam is the idea that Muslims should follow just the Quran for religious guidance. This means no Hadith. LEt me know what you think below.
All the best.
Join my discord and chat with like minded people: / discord
I am amazed that there are Muslims from Quran only internationally. I am truly happy I found this channel and would love to share knowledge as I researched this subject and still for over 15 years.
Brother please teach me! I want to learn so I can spread
@@LR-kr9sz What do you want to learn brother ? Quran is not a text like any other text. It is not an ordinary text. All language specialists, from all religions and fom cthe whole world, agree on this. So this guru who cannot read the Quran cannot teach you the Quran and the religion. They are creating a new religion, be careful.
@@LR-kr9sz Ha you want to spread ? Are you an enemy of Islam...
@@chehrazadeesmey8399 asalamaleykum 2:187 This is how God clearly explains His verses to men so that they will fear Him.
Quran is available for everyone God made it easy so we do not need any corrupt fake imam to create false explanations
We need a dating website
Also a point to note that Messenger always delivers someone ELSE'S message NOT his own... Common sense
That's a prophet. A messenger comes with a new revelation from angel jibreel. A prophet comes with an old revelation
@@Therealsob23 thats kinda silly considering Moses was a prophet and he revealed the law to the Hebrews.
@@7wardplatinumgod217 he was a prophet and a messenger
@@Therealsob23 no he's neither he is of the seed of Ishmael prophets only come through the seed of isreal by the time Muhammad was here so 🙄
@@Therealsob23 also a prophet Prophasize something that will take place in an future event how could that be an old revelation when it hasn't taken place yet ? I don't think u know what you're taking about
I am not a muslims but to me only makes sense to be quran only if you are muslim
Yes 👍
Quran 46:9
Say, “I am not the first messenger ever sent, nor do I know what will happen to me or you. I only follow what is revealed to me. And I am only sent with a clear warning.”
O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution. - 4:59
@@yelfouladi Bukhari is not the messenger. The messenger is Muhammad who only bring the Quran.
Those in authority among you. Ok, so believe in Allah, the Messenger and authority amongst us.
Where does bukhari/hadith fit amongst us? Unless you think this is the 9th century and bukharis chilling up in bukhara than yah bro follow the authority of hadith.
@@subilabi Bukhari is like Peter. He came after Christ but theologically directed Christianity.
@@mgXL7 Yeah, Obey those in authority.
Not change the religion cause they told you to.
Not believe every word they say.
Not attribute their lies to god.
Not ignoring when the Quran talks to us about this.
Not giving them credibility just cause they wrote a book based on contradiction and lies.
Not attributing them as partners to god.
I am a Muslim from Quran, and Islam from Quran is something completely different from Hadith history books written 200 years after Quran and the Prophet’s death. These Hadith truly re write another version of Islam that is satanic. I am an Arab researcher in this subject, I was born Sunni, but when I read and realized Islam from Quran ONLY I found it more talking to me and affecting me. Also and last, prayers are mentioned in Quran.
"...These Hadith truly re write another version of Islam that is satanic...."
All Islam is Satanic & Antichrist. Open your eyes!
@@doctrineapologetics why do you think that?
I have an exact thinking with you, I am from sunni who converted to quranism
Bro, we should bring all the Muslims of the world into quranism. Only then we can demolish Shia Sunni division. And Iran vs Saudi game will never happen. ISIS, AL-QAEDA, HEZBOLLAH will be totally dissolved. The TERRORIST tag will be totally withdraw from the religion Islam and it's followers Muslim.
@@benmary6453 there are no such thing as sunni or quranism make things up there's only islam
The argument that “follow the prophet” is proof for hadith, is the same argument that Christians use for Jesus being God “and through me is the path to God”
Where???
TO END THE „QURAN ONLY" SECT:
4:113 „And if it was not for the favor of Allah upon you, [O Muhammad], and His mercy, a group of them would have determined to mislead you. But they do not mislead except themselves, and they will not harm you at all. And Allah has revealed to you THE BOOK and WISDOM and has taught you that which you did not know. And ever has the favor of Allah upon you been great."
Clearly according to this verse Allah has revealed the Book which is undoubtedly the Quran! And now SHOW US THE WISDOM Allah revealed to the Prophet?
Where is it? Is it lost? Is not preserved?
Please USE YOUR INTELLECT and DON'T FOLLOW YOUR WHIMS AND DESIRES..
If you take only Quran you will miss the wisdom and become a bunch of cunfused people..I have warned you!
@@osmanle9981 So Quran is not complete according to you? Are you hearing what you’re saying? Astaqfirullah
@@osmanle9981 But what if the wisdom is in the book 🤯
the BOOK is NOT the QURAN - I will explain:
In Surat al baqara Verse 2: The BOOK is described as a "guide to the God-conscious (Mutaqeen)"
ذَٰلِكَ ٱلْكِتَـٰبُ لَا رَيْبَ ۛ فِيهِ ۛ هُدًى لِّلْمُتَّقِينَ
In Verse 185: the Quran is described as a "guide to the People"
شَهْرُ رَمَضَانَ الَّذِي أُنزِلَ فِيهِ الْقُرْآنُ هُدًى لِّلنَّاسِ
All God-conscious (mutaqeen) are people. However, not all people are Mutaqeen. Therefore, if you want to avoid the contradiction that comes with the argument: Quran = Kitab, the conclusion must be that the BOOK INCLUDES the Quran, because the Motaqeen are a specialised part of the People.
Also, if you need the definition of Mutaqeen, look no further than the continuation of Verse 2
الَّذِينَ يُؤْمِنُونَ بِالْغَيْبِ وَيُقِيمُونَ الصَّلَاةَ وَمِمَّا رَزَقْنَاهُمْ يُنفِقُونَ
For more info: czcams.com/video/VNQ8svPUo8U/video.html
Quran 32:22] Who is more evil than one who is reminded of these revelations of his Lord (QURAN), then insists upon disregarding them? We will certainly punish the guilty.
[Quran 31:7] And when our revelations (Quran) are recited to the one of them, he turns away in arrogance as if he never heard them, as if his ears are deaf. Promise him a painful retribution.
The reason why Sunni muslims will ask about pilgrimage and the way of prayer is because they think that Islam has to regulate each detail of human action. But in the Quran God doesn’t specify, so they think it would be not understandable without hadith.
It is an error in logic! If Allah swt leaves the details open, it means Allah grants the muslims freedom of choice how to perform the details of prayer and pilgrimage, as simple as that. All forms of prayer and pilgrimage are acceptable as long as they are fulfilling the criteria set in the Quran itself. Muslims can choose different ways to pray to Allah and the way Sunnis pray is acceptable too. Freedom of choice is not a gap but rather an easement granted by Allah to perform your duties.
I think the best solution is to accept the Sunnah as part of Islam in it‘s theoretical concept, but to reject the implemention of rules based on Sunnah. This means that the Sunnah of the prophet was flawless and should be followed as his life and actions can not contadict the Quran, he was indeed the best example to follow for Muslims, showing how „gaps“ such as about details of prayer can be filled in a way, that is acceptable to Allah.
Yet, what we can not guarantee is the reliability of the hadiths. Yes if we were 100% sure about the authenticity of hadiths as sure as about the authenticity of the Quran, which has never been changed, we should follow them as we follow the Quran. But the point is that the hadiths are not as trustworthy as the Quran. Even Sunni scholars accept, that there were lots of false hadith, which had to be removed by scholars. If hadiths are so trustworthy, why did scholars feel the need to identify, which are sahih?
According to ibn Qutaiba lots of fabricated hadiths came from Christian and Jewish influence, which were „sounding“ correct and therefore were circulated among muslims. How can we be 100% sure that in not even one case a supposedly sahih hadith is actually not sahih? Because of the history of how hadiths were collected, we can never be 100% sure. Maybe let’s say 99,9% but not 100% and that is not enough.
Even 0,1% of wrong sources can corrupt all 99,9% of the rest, which is why we should renounce from hadiths.
TO END THE „QURAN ONLY" SECT:
4:113 „And if it was not for the favor of Allah upon you, [O Muhammad], and His mercy, a group of them would have determined to mislead you. But they do not mislead except themselves, and they will not harm you at all. And Allah has revealed to you THE BOOK and WISDOM and has taught you that which you did not know. And ever has the favor of Allah upon you been great."
Clearly according to this verse Allah has revealed the Book which is undoubtedly the Quran! And now SHOW US THE WISDOM Allah revealed to the Prophet?
Where is it? Is it lost? Is not preserved?
Please USE YOUR INTELLECT and DON'T FOLLOW YOUR WHIMS AND DESIRES..
If you take only Quran you will miss the wisdom and become a bunch of cunfused people..I have warned you!
Typically to blame non-muslims when it is Muslims who have wrote the Hadith LOL. Btw, are you trying to say Allah do not like non-muslims and they are wrong when it comes to everything and that Muslims are perfect? Plz stop with this nonsense. Muslims are not perfect nor are they without sins or fault. Blaming non-muslims without evidence just shows how ignorant most of Muslims are. If Quran said it was non-muslims ok, otherswise no other sources out side of Quran is true. Lol
@@osmanle9981okay then why did no one started collecting "hadith" before 200 years passed by?
Excellent video. Let us keep in mind also that the hadiths are paraphrases and not the verbatim words of the prophet. Hence, anyone who says that "the prophet said" and then quotes a tradition already lied. The prophet did not say that. The transmitters said it, and they said in in their words, not the words of the prophet. Furthermore, those who say that the hadiths are from Allah also attribute a lie to Allah. He did not reveal the hadiths. He revealed the Quran. Hadiths are of human origin. They are hearsay. Hence, any law based on a hadith is man-made, not divine. Moreover, the Quran prohibits adding to revelation (Quran 69: 44-47). The prophet also prohibited the collection and recording of his "traditions." Hence, those who collected and recorded the traditions disobeyed both God and the messenger.
All of you are trying to legitimate your ideology - yes idelogy - by lies above lies. WHO SAYS THAT HADITHS ARE FROM ALLAH 3AZZA WA JAL ???
And ORHER GURUS METHODS. A3UDHU BILLAH !
@@chehrazadeesmey8399 I heard Mufti Menk say that "the hadiths are from Allah," in a CZcams video.
@@chehrazadeesmey8399 if hadith are wahy/ revelation from God, then Quran is not perfect as a guidance, and we need to rely on other books which is manmade and contradictory. First things first, what kind of revelation is then picked by scholars, which ones is authentic and accepted, which ones is weak and rejected? Did God gave them authorities??
If hadith are not from God, then from who? The prophet? He can't and would never make his own saying then attributing it as a part of deen. He would've been punished if doing that.
Either way, Quran 29:51 is God's allusion that His book, Quran is enough for us. Following others books which claiming this & that about the prophet certainly contradict this.
@@leslieterebessy7559 I cannot say it is or it is not true. But if an iquisotor had to decide about the thruth, he would say that it is an other lie since lying is your method to convince people.
@@ft7730 We got it !!! You don't have anyting else than this lie as a stupid argument used like a leit motiv by all of you and intenlligently refuted by many. NO MUSLIM MIXES UP QURAN AND HADITHS !!!! Miserable gurus !
I wish more and more Muslims realize this truth!
I wish less and less Muslims get into these gurus trap !
@@chehrazadeesmey8399
Do we value GOD and His words the most?:
.Who is more evil than one who lies about God, or rejects His revelations? The transgressors never succeed.
وَمَن أَظلَمُ مِمَّنِ افتَرىٰ عَلَى اللَّهِ كَذِبًا أَو كَذَّبَ بِـٔايٰتِهِ إِنَّهُ لا يُفلِحُ الظّٰلِمونَ
Which is to be? GOD s words or men s words(Hadiths)?
On the day when we summon them all, we will ask the idol worshipers( Those who took other authority beside GOD Alone), "Where are the idols you set up?"
وَيَومَ نَحشُرُهُم جَميعًا ثُمَّ نَقولُ لِلَّذينَ أَشرَكوا أَينَ شُرَكاؤُكُمُ الَّذينَ كُنتُم تَزعُمونَ
Their disastrous response will be, "By God our Lord, we never were idol worshipers."*
ثُمَّ لَم تَكُن فِتنَتُهُم إِلّا أَن قالوا وَاللَّهِ رَبِّنا ما كُنّا مُشرِكينَ
Now and forever, the idol worshipers vehemently deny that they are idolaters.
Note how they lied to themselves, and how the idols they had invented have abandoned them.
انظُر كَيفَ كَذَبوا عَلىٰ أَنفُسِهِم وَضَلَّ عَنهُم ما كانوا يَفتَرونَ
Reflection is good for the soul , or we loose it!!!
Those to whom we have given the scripture recognize this as they recognize their own children. The ones who lose their souls are those who do not believe.
الَّذينَ ءاتَينٰهُمُ الكِتٰبَ يَعرِفونَهُ كَما يَعرِفونَ أَبناءَهُمُ الَّذينَ خَسِروا أَنفُسَهُم فَهُم لا يُؤمِنونَ
GOD never lies. Men lie and make up stuff.
Up to you.
@@chehrazadeesmey8399 You are so lost.
@@sidzy79 Are you hurt by the truth dear ? Oh don't cry now, you have all the eternity to cry 😂😂😂
@@chehrazadeesmey8399 Sweetie, you wouldn't know the truth even if it hits you in the face 😂😂😂
Go worship your idols... pagan.
God needs no helper. Quran is from God. What are Hadith? Fiction.
I stopped this @ 1:03, and I can tell you this- There is no one alive who can corraborate sunnah which is based upon ahaddith!
It's hearsay and conjecture as far as we are concerned.
In the Qur'an the rhetorical question was put forward, "In what saying after this (Qur'an) will they believe?"
Also, if the Qur'an is your witness as far as how you practiced your faith- what a reliable and joyful witness that is!
You cannot be faulted for faithfully following what Allah sent!
For me- the case is closed!
So you agree that following the Quran only, a 5 year old who stole a 5c/5p can have his or her hands chopped off? And that you can roundhouse kick your wife?
Had you lived with the prophet pbuh, you would of stoped obeying him at his death? Would of you obeyed him at all? Fear Allah, indeed the Quran is a witness for or against you!
@@yelfouladi - Ah, knock it off with the canned argument.
If you obeyed the Qur'an what could the messenger find fault with?
NOTHING!
You don't make sense.
@@gr8fruitsprouts440 You act the Quran fell on you lap with a perfect translation and interpretation. How do you even know where the Quran comes from? How do you make sense of different recitations muslim have. Recitations in which the are sometimes more meanings. How do you choose between hafs, warsh, ad doori?
How do you understant the verse allowing you to strike you? spouse? Or the one commanding you to kill the mushrikeen? How do you even know what those words mean?
Mate fear Allah, He is the Most merciful and severe in punishement. I'm not here to debate you. I could care less. But people who take "Quran Only" are a danger to themselves and others.
A Salam.
@@yelfouladi - I DO understand it. THAT'S the problem with you brain-washed bots who complicate EVERYTHING- even discouraging others who do know truth. If you disagree- that's fine with me bc, the QUR'AN says- "to you be your way, and to me mine."
Just try obeying THAT! It's in the book you CLAIM to believe. Peace
The biggest argument for Quran only Islam is the verse in the Quran where on the day of judgement the Prophet will say that my people abandoned the Quran after me. If there was need for something else why did the Prophet said only Quran and not "Quran and Hadith" or "Quran and Sunnah". This is because religion only comes from Quran and anything outside the Quran is not part of Islam.
This goes against the most common sunni talking point that Quran needs hadith to be understood properly because you are arguing that the Prophet himself did not know that Quran alone is not enough and you need hadith as well to understand it.
Quran Surah 25(Al-Furqan) Verse 30
And the messenger will say, “O my Lord, my people had taken this Qur’ān as deserted.”
TO END THE „QURAN ONLY" SECT:
4:113 „And if it was not for the favor of Allah upon you, [O Muhammad], and His mercy, a group of them would have determined to mislead you. But they do not mislead except themselves, and they will not harm you at all. And Allah has revealed to you THE BOOK and WISDOM and has taught you that which you did not know. And ever has the favor of Allah upon you been great."
Clearly according to this verse Allah has revealed the Book which is undoubtedly the Quran! And now SHOW US THE WISDOM Allah revealed to the Prophet?
Where is it? Is it lost? Is not preserved?
Please USE YOUR INTELLECT and DON'T FOLLOW YOUR WHIMS AND DESIRES..
If you take only Quran you will miss the wisdom and become a bunch of cunfused people..I have warned you!
@@osmanle9981 You are just grasping at straws here. The verse is talking about wisdom in general terms that Allah gives to all human beings and not just for the prophet.The Quran is literally full of ayahs that invite ordinary human beings to ponder and use their intellect/wisdom about how Allah created the World and everything in it. So wisdom is not something special that is only revealed to the Prophet. The verse i showed clearly says that the prophet will say my people left the Quran deserted. You are the one following the wims and desires not me, I am following the Quran.
You did an excellent job explaining this.
You have summed up the quran only concept very beautifully. Straight to the point.
Thank you for your effort💛
If we agree that the Quran is the objective truth, then we must accept the contents of it from within. In turn, this allows us to deduce from the Quranic verses that the Quran is a perfect book. My contention against the Quranist movement is that although the Quran is perfect, our interpretations fall short. Now, if we can accept the premise that the Prophet SAW was the greatest human source of knowledge on the Holy Quran, then we should accept his statements. Therefore, Muslims should follow hadith literature.
@@OmarOsman98 The problem is that, how can I know that the prophet peace be upon him actually said those words and were not transmitted properly / they lied?
@@hamidman6974 You can know because if you are clever enough you can very easily follow the logic of the "chains". People spent decennia and for some all their life to establish which hadith is authentic and which is not. These people were not youtubers with channels created in two minutes. They were historians, theologists, linguists etc. You don'tcfool us by saying we follow Bukhari which is ridiculous. And if i have to follow "someone" then better Bukhari than false gurus.
@@chehrazadeesmey8399 You know, christians have their theologians who studied all their life, but still they come to conclusion that Jesus is God. (- which we both agree is not - Subhanallah)
Same, there are jews who studied for decades and decades, but still they don't accept islam.
I am muslim Alhamdulilah, I do believe that The Quran is revealed by The Creator of Everything to Mohammed peace be upon him whom is the last messenger. -
But I have never been intellectually satisfied in accepting all so called "authentic hadiths". Some hadiths, I don't accept, even if theologian who studied 50 years might tell me it's authentic, I believe it's not. There might have been unidentified problems like: work of Satan/mistakes by reporters/lies by reporters/political pressure etc /somethings you cannot tell.
For example, a friend of mine who I trust and who all the community trusts - might still lie to me or tell me something by mistake.
One hadith that I have problems with, is the one regarding prophet marrying Aisha at 6y - I read from other sources that the age might have been 16 or 19 or something else- but still that hadith is reported to be "authentic". I don't believe so, and it is not justified to say it was normal back then.
I did read regarding the criteria for a hadith to be authentic - and I was not satisfied.
I don't mean that I reject all ahadiths - but I won't blindly accept a hadith which I feel might be false just because someone tell me it's authentic.
Something we can ponder on:
If God wanted, He could have revealed a Quran that we all directly understand it without needing to ponder on it.
But, in the Quran itself, there's written: Do they not ponder the Quran?
God gave us intellect - reason - logic - will we use them? (read surah al insan(76), aya 2)
And surah al isra (17) , aya 36)
@@chehrazadeesmey8399 So stydying something all your life is so impressive to the intelectually underdevelopped Muslim Ummah that he must be right? There are millions and billions of people who study heir object, their profession for decades. What is so special about this? It says in the Quran that the Prophet could not know who was a munaifiq even if he was standing in front of him. But Buhari can 150 years later judge who is trustworthy of people he never met?
Love your work brother 🙏🏻
I appreciate it!
Putting this logical, simple and irrefutable argument into a concise 9 minute video as you have is a real service to those trying to explain clearly their reasons for following the Qur'an alone. I will certainly be sharing it. Keep up the great work and God bless.
Thank you. I know what you mean. I had long discussions with people, but thought it’d make things easier to make this compilation of text and the video.
All the best
@@TheBritishMuslim_ - Take it one step further - follow God without the Quran 👍🏻
@@cervezaway7049
The Quran is from God, read it and you will see but if you are not sincere with God then God will not guide you. I only followed God, then i read the Quran and all I believed was confirmed in the Quran.
Praise be to God alone
@@cervezaway7049 You can only TRULY follow GOD by following the Quran, ONLY the Quran and NOTHING BUT the Quran.
@@ebakindeji5941 Is that written in the Quran?
Brother, I watched this video and you have said the truth. I would like to add one thing, that is, if you go to Doctor and Doctor tells you to follow him that means he is telling you to follow the prescription he has prescribed for you not his personal life. The same thing is with Prophet Muhammad that we have to follow him and he is Rasool (Messenger) because he has been given Quran so follow it.
Why don't we form a International Forum integrating all the Quran Alone followers as one Group.
Take it one step further - follow God without the Quran 👍🏻
@@cervezaway7049
The Quran is from God, read it and you will see but if you are not sincere with God then God will not guide you. I only followed God, then i read the Quran and all I believed was confirmed in the Quran.
Praise be to God alone
@@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306 - god is far greater than the author of the Quran
Cerveza Way i had the same view like you a few years ago i identified as muslim on paper but i knew nearly nothing about the Islam i only believed in god the creator and hated the devil, but now I’m more educated and i know that the Quran and Hadith are very important because they told us so many things which became true! Imagine just believing in god without religion knowledge and then miss the day of judgement signs
@@mnstr2173 religion is a social order - used by those in power to subjugate and control the masses - total mind & body control - Islam is a totalitarian system - I.e. - communism with a god
This was concisely put together 💯
Exactly, i use similar logic, so simple and yet some can't see it... well done
Awal mula saya jadi Qur'an alone ketika saya takjub dengan surat Al-Fatihah dengan kalimat agung
Dari situ saya jatuh cinta dengan Al-Qur'an dan tidak mau membaca hal lain seperti hadith yang ada saya ingin mengetahui Al-Qur'an seluruh nya hanya dengan Al-Qur'an dan Sunnah
Terbaik. Tapi byk umat Islam dah hancur sebab taksub dgn Hadis sgt
Greetings from Turkey, nice job.
The Quran = God's Word
Ahadith = man's word
The Quran = 100% fact/truth/perfect
Ahadith = mix of truth and falsehood (hence weak and strong hadith)
The Quran = recorded under the DIRECT supervision of prophet Muhammad
Ahadith = not recorded under the DIRECT supervision of prophet Muhammad
The Quran = written AND memorised word for word as soon as it was transmitted
Ahadith = no-one ever claimed to record and memorise ahadith word for word as soon as it was transmitted
The Quran = protected explicitly by God Himself as stated in The Quran
Ahadith = no such explicit protection stated
The Quran = no Muslim doubts its credibility
Ahadith = each sect has its own versions, weak & strong ones etc
The Quran = in-built verification mechanism, e.g. challenges others to find inconsistancy, bring a chapter like it etc.
Ahadith = no such in-built mechanism, full of inconsistancies etc.
If you're ever in London, I'll be happy to treat you to a coffee and a chat. Love, peace and good vibes from a fellow Quran only Muslim.
I appreciate that. Some of my family lives in Hertfordshire, so if I’m ever down that way I’ll let you know 👍
@@TheBritishMuslim_ Herts is a hop, skip and a jump away from London! Would love to eventually meet up and share how God guided us to His way of life. I'll add you on IG too. Peace ✌️
This guy is a jahil and as are you for believing such. Is it Malik or maalik? If there is one Quran and if you say that one is right and one is wrong, that means some qurans are incorrect thus saying that the quran lies when it say about complete security to the letter.
@@istagfar7705 My Friend he explained everything clearly and directly. Now before you call him “Kafir, Murtad” type stuff just use your brain. I am not asking you to do so, the Quran asks you to use your reason.
When the Quran says it’s “Fully Detailed, Best Explanation, Complete, Perfected and Clear” than what really is the need of ‘Hadith’? Use your brain :)
@@Titan-ub5opDon't give me that ya akhi. Answer my question is it maaliki o mideen or Maliki o mideen (Maalik means owner) (Malik means king).
So if you say one is correct and the other isn't, your saying that there are different qurans.
If you say both well, you guys also say there is only one Quran in the world and it's exactly like the one revealed to the prophet? So how did the other one come to be?
That’s 100% correct.
Thank you
Did my hajj according to what Allah says in the Quraan
How did you do this?
@@BosomofAbraham it’s in the Quraan.
@@BosomofAbraham feeding the poor and spreading the message is the Hajj in the Qu'ran
@@commentstealer4460Do you mean hajj does not mean to go to Makkah?
Great video 👍🏽
Hello, with Quranists conclusion on hadith, some questions entail. How do people pray before hadith if you consider hadith to be fabrications? Shouldn't we have accounts of people fighting because of the differences in their prayers after the emergence of hadith? Why don't we have a surviving form of salat before hadith?
Yusuf Abdiauzan czcams.com/video/YVOnC7Fpmu4/video.html The Quran is very detailed when it comes to praying. Now show me a Hadith that is as detailed as the Quran.
God says our salat is supposed to stop you from doing evil things, if ur prayer from Hadith are true, why don't they stop you from doing sins? Salat is remembrance of God, birds do salat, SALAT HAS MANY DIFFERENT MEANINGS. Salat is you having a personal relationship with God thus, everyone prays differently. I stand, say 3-4 lines about God such as 'god has no son', 'god helps you during ur hardships' etc. Then I bow at the end.
Speaking of, do you know how the traditional salat was formed?
There are literally contradicts with the hadith about prayer too. Here is one about wudu.
BUKHARI HADITH: Volume 1, Book 4, Number 159:
Narrated Ibn ‘Abbas:
The Prophet performed ablution by washing the body parts only once.
BUKHARI HADITH: Volume 1, Book 4, Number 160:
Narrated ‘Abdullah bin Zaid:
The Prophet performed ablution by washing the body parts twice.
BUKHARI HADITH: Volume 1, Book 4, Number 196:
Narrated ‘Abdullah bin Zaid:
Once Allah’s Apostle came to us and we brought out water for him in a brass pot. He performed ablution thus: He washed his face thrice, and his forearms to the elbows twice, then passed his wet hands lightly over the head from front to rear and brought them to front again and washed his feet (up to the ankles).
What did the scholars say?
"Just wash everything 3 times except ears and hair"
Mashallah my brother very well done . Surah Ali Imran-7 It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific.1 As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.
And brother we muslim support you make such videos regarding Hadith which has many contradiction..
Do you have mosque in philippines?
Say (O Muhammad), "I am not a novelty among the messengers, nor do I know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing other than what is revealed to me (Quran). I am no more than a clear warner." 46:9 (also in 10:15).
I agree with you ❤️
how did muslims before bhukari practice islam hadith came 250 yrs after prophet Muhammed died , this should be enough for ur logic , u got thre hadiths thats contradicts eachother fromsame source one is i leave u Quran only. one is i leave u Quran and my family , and one is i leave u quran and sahaba
He is right. the Quran already has detailed us the criteria for guidance. Keep in mind it is fully detailed to guide us, enough to guide us in religious matters. It does give you directions on what do seek and find, study, read outside of the Quran as well. So this fully detailed book is a criteria and guidance only. It does not disallow one from learning history, science, reading other philosophies. If not it encourages us to read and find the truth. The only argument I have had from hadith followers is a lame ''how can you pray if it's not in the hadith''. Well to counter question them I would like to ask how did Muslim pray for 200 years before the hadith was written? They passed it down from generation to generation. Even the hadith doesn't fully explain how to pray. In fact there are many different ways to pray varying from region to region in the world. Allah allows for differences in culture, race, ethnicities and differences in how we do things in our religion so long as they are within the criteria of the Quran. The word ''salat'' means contact prayer. This definition is understood that it is a physical prayer including to bow and prostate to God when praying to him.
And is there a hadith which says follow my words, don't follow the Quran ??? No Muslim follows the hadiths, the hadiths have an other purpose, no Muslim in the world ever said they are sacred like the Quran. We beleive some hadiths are true, it does not mean we don't beleive the Quran is not complete.Don't let you misguide by these new gurus brother.
great answer brother. I want to ask that different hadith books have mentioned in them different methods (positions) of obligatory prayer. how can we be sure of the one the people in the gap between the revelations and recording of the hadiths had been passing to their offsprings? and their were a lots of communities of practising muslims because more than 150 years had passed .
@@sairaniz5302 Why are you so worried about the "exact" way of praying ? Stick to the way you learned how to pray , Allah 3azza wa jal will judge your faith, your sincerity when you pray. Second, All Muslims pray in the same way, except for details. Are you afraid God will judge you upon the position of your feet or your hands during salat ?
Three, what is the issue with this so poor argument of 150 or 200 years that some people come with, thinking it is clever and strong ? Hadiths started ti be written down very early, only the scholars who worked on them very much were from the first and second century hijra. People who say that hadtrhs din t count because they are transmitted orally, forget that it was one of the ways history was passed and taught back then, it was sophisticated and had its rules like nowadays book editing has its rules....
I'm worried because Allah didn't complete his deen on certain peoples assumptions and I cannot blindly follow any of these because the books claiming the sayings of prophet and his companions were not rechecked by Muhammad PBUH and are passed out to us and I'm worried that I might add something humans innovated in the holy prayer
and our way in not a golden coupon in heaven brother. we have to work and believe to achieve the bliss that some of us dream of. Deen is 100 percentage right while our calculations of general history can go wrong. scientists theories fail and fail overtime, we find people seer and then we find their predictions not coming true.
off course, we can even see the results when Muslim started following other books. It divided Muslims in sects.
Divide and rule. That's what hadith is for.
Say, "Obey Allah and obey the Messenger; but if you turn away - then upon him is only that [duty] with which he has been charged, and upon you is that with which you have been charged. And if you obey him, you will be [rightly] guided. And nothing is obligated on the messenger other than the clear deliverance (of the Qur’an)."
(24:54)
“And obey Allah and obey the messenger, but if you turn back, then obligated on our messenger is (only) the clear delivery (of the Qur’an)”.
(64:12)
The messenger is to be obeyed as he has the message. What is the message? The QURAN. Hadith came about 200 years after the prophet’s death. Hadith is hear say - it’s not a primary source. Research Birmingham Quran - it’s carbon dated & disproves all the dates etc. that come from all hadith. The messenger had a message = Quran.
Aren't there verses stating setting along the lines of "if you do not know then seek knowledge from those of understanding" ?
Exactly... and what human knows more than Muhammad peace be upon him
@@blakeemel3819 thing is, we can’t guarantee the Hadith is from Muhammad
@@1BestEnemy what about the prophecies that came true from Hadith...r u telling me a normal man was recording prophecies after Muhammad there for corrupting the Quran.. the only answer is that they were from Muhammad ... yes most arnt from him I agree
@@blakeemel3819 What prophecies? Tall buildings? War? Famine? These were all present from way before.
@@blakeemel3819 Allah knows more and if you paid attention you would realise had whatever you found amazing in the hadiths been required for us it would've been included in the Quran, if you TRULLY believe in Allah this is what you would conclude and you wouldn't question it.
Thanks for your valuable video.
You are most welcome
Salam bro, don't care more people following u. Don't worry. Some people appreciate much. Take this as sadaqqa
All we need is The Message.
Yeah no need for a messenger to deliver it. It will just pop in front of you.
@@yelfouladi Yes Sir The Messenger Gabriel can reach anywhere right? why do people always think they something else with GOD? they have hard time having a pure heart with no association with their CREATOR they think HE needs a guy that walked in markets and eat food ...etc all you need is your CREATOR HE is Sufficient for me as i am instructed to say HE IS good enough for me don't need al saoud or their sheikhs. peace
@@zakjenner8859 "The disbelievers from the People of the Book and the polytheists were not going to desist ˹from disbelief˺ until the clear proof came to them:
a messenger from Allah, reciting scrolls of ˹utmost˺ purity,"
Quran 98:1-2
The Proof of the message is the messenger pbuh who recites the Quran as Allah says it in the Quran.
The "no hadith" approach is self defeating because it is the Quran that give the command to obey the messenger pbuh. How do you obey without hadith?
This guy falsely says that if the Quran is complete we don't need hadith. The Quran is complete in of itself because it is the speech of Allah, this does not mean you can have complete understanding of it without the help of the messenger pbuh. So much of the Quran is contextual. How do you know the context without hadith? The Quran has been preserved because of a robust scholarly methodology. If one reject hadiths, he rejects that methodology and hence has no fundation to accept the Quran.
By rejecting hadith, people reject the Quran. Those who reject hadith usually have an ideological problem with it. They do not take knowledge from the revelation but from their own understanding. Thus becoming worshipers of their own passion.
"Have you seen ˹O Prophet˺ the one who has taken their own desires as their god? Will you then be a keeper over them?" Quran 25:43
May Allah guide you and guide me if our intentions are true
@@yelfouladi you seem to forget chapter 2 3 4 5 6 7.... Mohammed pbuh cannot and is not your messenger you do not see the logic in that? you never got any contact with him. furthermore if you need specific verses i will be more than glad to provide. GOD talks about Abraham as the original archetype of what you would call islam in arabic and told mohammed to follow him and GOD says he made abraham the leader of mankind also said mohammed and jesus are NOTHING BUT a messenger other messengers JUST like them has vanished before also Mohammed himself said i am no different than any other messenger and do not know what would happen to you or me and mohammed also said i was inspired this what you would call quran in arabic to warn you with and Mohammed also said i am innocent of you associating me with GOD i can go all week long bro they lied to you just like they lied to all of us we all followed our environment you think you will be supporting the sunna crap if you were born in tahran israel china or whatever you followed exactly what you found your forefathers on didn't you???? didn't GOD said DO NOT FOLLWO YOUR FOREFATHERS ????? so sunni people would call GOD a liar if the what you call quran in arabic doesn't conform to it do you think that is ok?? what do you think GOD would say to you when you tell HIM i followed my parents and al saoud...etc ???? HE will say call them........and .......wait for it.............they will not answer your call you will be by yourself. i am going to assume you read the cave chapter 18 every friday so verse 1 2 5 6 13 14 15 16 17 and a few more and the last verse 110 do not mean anything to you???? they are all contradictory to the sunna ALL OF IT. are you not aware of the bukhari so called correct hearsay 3 of them that says mohammed specifically instructed everyone to only associate him with the what you call quran in arabic????? chapter 12 Joseph check out the last verse and see how you feel about it. i can provide any verse with irrefutable proofs the question is are you looking for the truth or just playing the debate game??? everything you were told about everything is a lie this is a perpetual scientific fact i am not saying this is what IS verifiable every single day . You want to wake up to The ONE GOD's illuminating book?? you need to open it first you think this means physically open the what you call quran in arabic right??? NO my brother you need to use The Provided Key with your heart and watch that book lights up your way and all you need is a pure heart looking for HIM in HIS Sanctioned House (not in mecca it's in your Heart) not looking to confirm the bs you were fed by your forefathers you don't think The GOD that created all is capable of reaching you with HIS light??? c'mon bro use your intelligence that's what is says in chapter 18 the cave that all so called muslims read every friday with the eyes that you do not see with (again not me saying this this is your GOD).You Need to know for yourself nobody is going to answer your call on that day and remember the last verse of chapter 18 (as well as 90% of the book) tells you do NOT SAY GOD AND there is no AND(allah wa rassuloh is HIS message ask your quraishi masters they know this it's simple arabic language. there is only ONE GOD he doesn't need someone who needed guidance himself (verse and HE found you lost and HE guided you. & plenty more upon request) to help HIM this is the point your ego is not letting you comprehend this. this is not what i think this is what GOD says in HIS Message. in The Readable and here is another one all the al saoud quraishi so called sheikhs will tell you yes it is and there 2 verses to prove it THE READABLE IS YOUR MESSENGER according to your own sunnah crap bro this is insane do you think mohammed was loved by quraish?? as soon as he died they went to work and this is documented in the sunnah extensively. so conclusion your sunnah says in specific details it is bullshit. as well as The Messenger to all THE READABLE. as Moses would say Peace to those who follow THE GUIDANCE.
@@yelfouladi i just saw this so news flash Mohammed is not the only messenger where is your logic anytime you read the word messenger you think it's mohammed go read the chapter again and use any platform to translate the words and forget the bs they taught you and see what YOU get out of it. or are you afraid to think for yourself because you have not said a single word of your own intelligence you are just parakeeting cheap lip service you copy and paste a verse you have no idea what it says you just saw messenger and that's it it mohammed lol. i'm beginning to think your right maybe GOD is full of shit and al saoud are right? what you think?? wtf dude wake up and use your head not the memory that was uploaded by your environment that you had no say in accepting or rejecting you didn't even know what was happening
I agree 100% but i heard in your other videos you believe in the hadith as well
Thank you.
Does anyone know of a community of Quranists? Where can I look? I desire to find others!
Righteousness is not in turning your faces towards the east or the west. Rather, the righteous are those who believe in Allah, the Last Day, the angels, the Books, and the prophets; who give charity out of their cherished wealth to relatives, orphans, the poor, ˹needy˺ travellers, beggars, and for freeing captives; who establish prayer, pay alms-tax, and keep the pledges they make; and who are patient in times of suffering, adversity, and in ˹the heat of˺ battle. It is they who are true ˹in faith˺, and it is they who are mindful ˹of Allah˺.
Jibireel AS was Allah's Messenger responsible for passing on the message of Al Quran to RSAW which is the same message the Ummah is to obey.....so if we claim to obey the Messenger as articulated in Al Quran, why are we NOT exclusively following the message (Al Quran) revealed by Allah to RSAW via Jibireel AS ? Interpreting "obey the Messenger" as obey Ghadeeth literature is absurd. May Allah guide and protect us 🤲
Can someone answer how we got Quraan?
Allah sent to jibril aleyi salaam then delivered to prophet Muhammad aleyi salaam which job was to deliver it to us. That's it.
The word 'simplistic' is not s synonym for 'simple'. It means 'dumbed down' or 'overly simplified'.
Bro Assalam, look at Rashad Khalifa’s written English authorised translation of Quran.
I mostly agree with you. The one hole in your argument is if the prophet taught the people and spoke to the people as he understood the Quran then his teachings become a secondary source of guidance. The problem then becomes proving what is verifiably from the prophet. But this can be solved in 2 ways. Use the same method of verifying the Quranic readings that were undeniably taught by the prophet. Secondly, only accept the statements that are wise and in line with the Quran based on our levels of reasoning.
before jumping to conclusion that "we need another source i.e. prophet's teaching", firstly, could you provide proof from Quran that we (Muslims) should follow the prophet's teaching? Because as far as I know, what the prophet did is to deliver the words of God (or messages) and not interpret them. Furthermore, the prophet Muhammad was never instructed by God as guardian over his people (as compared to the prophet Moses).
Quran 16 44
˹We sent them˺ with clear proofs and divine Books. And We have sent down to you ˹O Prophet˺ the Reminder, so that you may explain to people what has been revealed for them, and perhaps they will reflect.
So tell me how do you make namaaz?
Give me more details about Salah from any Hadith , Bukhari muslim.etc
I'm quranist from Myanmar(Burma)
There is not two possibilities, that's duplicity belief like trinity. There can only be an intelligent creator which outside the norms of creation and its Its instructions to you, one criteria is, it has to be fully detailed. If this statement is correct nothing else is needed
The word baghya " بغيا " and albigha " البغاء"
in the Qur’an and according to religious heritage means prostitution and fornication but according to my understanding, and the evidence from the Qur’an means seek or ask something
The linguistic root for the mentioned words is a bugha " بغى" that did not come in the Qur’an nor one time with the meaning of fornication and its derivatives, it came to bear the meanings of seek or ask something
verse 19.20
الايه [قالت أنى يكون لي غلام ولم يمسسني بشر ولم أك بغيا] مريم 20
the vers [qalt 'anaa yakun li ghulam walam yamsasni bashar walam 'ak bghaya] maryam 20
The vers [she said how come I have a boy ( ghulam) , and no human has touched me ( yamsasni ) and I have not ask or seek for this. Mary 20
when she said [no human has touched me] this includes touching in a legal or illegal manner or assaulting her to result in pregnancy and when she said [ and I have not ask or seek for this] and I did not ask or seek for this pregnancy or the boy.
Also see the consistency between the verses in the words of Mary and the words of God in response to the words of Mary
﴿قالت أنى يكون لي غلام ولم يمسسني بشر ولم أك بغياقال كذلك قال ربك هو علي هين ولنجعله آية للناس ورحمة منا وكان أمرا
مقضيا﴾
[Maryam: 20-21]
﴿qaalat 'anaa yakun li ghulam walam yamsasni bashar walam 'ak bighya
qal kdhlk qal rabuk hu ealaya hayin walinajealah ayatan lilnaas warahmatan minaa wakan 'amrana maqdia﴾ [Maryam: 20-21]
The vers [she said how come I have a boy , and no human has touched me and I have not ask or seek for this. [Maryam: 20]
said as well as Your Lord said
this is easy upon me , and we will make him a sign for people and a mercy from us. And that was decided
[Maryam: 21]
when she said
"how come I have a boy , and no human has touched me"
The Lord Answered
"this is easy upon me , and will make him a sign for people"
also when she said
"and I have not ask or seek for this"
The Lord Answered
"And that was decided"
now you can see clearly the consistency between the verses
I tried my best to translate from Arabic to English but I think and hope the picture is clear
Also the word " البغاء "albigha in the next verse ,It does not mean fornication or prostitution, but rather means those ask or seek to marriage .
According to my understanding Surat Al-Nur, verses 32 and 33, speaks about marriage, and to encourage , motivate and helping unmarried to get married but not forced them to get marriage for your own benefit
this is my understanding there is on prostitution it is all about marriage
﴿وَأَنكِحُوا الأَيامى مِنكُم وَالصّالِحينَ مِن عِبادِكُم وَإِمائِكُم إِن يَكونوا فُقَراءَ يُغنِهِمُ اللَّهُ مِن فَضلِهِ وَاللَّهُ واسِعٌ عَليمٌ﴾ [An-Nûr: 32]
And marries ( urge upon marriage ) the unmarried among you and the righteous from your Eibad and your Emaa (male and female under your care and supervision ) . If they are poor, Allāh will enrich them from His bounty, and Allāh is all-Encompassing and Knowing.
﴿وَليَستَعفِفِ الَّذينَ لا يَجِدونَ نِكاحًا حَتّى يُغنِيَهُمُ اللَّهُ مِن فَضلِهِ وَالَّذينَ يَبتَغونَ الكِتابَ مِمّا مَلَكَت أَيمانُكُم فَكاتِبوهُم إِن عَلِمتُم فيهِم خَيرًا وَآتوهُم مِن مالِ اللَّهِ الَّذي آتاكُم وَلا تُكرِهوا فَتَياتِكُم عَلَى البِغاءِ إِن أَرَدنَ تَحَصُّنًا لِتَبتَغوا عَرَضَ الحَياةِ الدُّنيا وَمَن يُكرِههُنَّ فَإِنَّ اللَّهَ مِن بَعدِ إِكراهِهِنَّ غَفورٌ رَحيمٌ﴾ [An-Nûr: 33]
walyastaefif ( abstain from sexual relations ) those who cannot find means for marrage until Allāh enriches them from His bounty. And those who seek keytab (marriage contract) from among whom your right hands possess ( right hands possess meaning those who under your care and supervision )then katibohm (than make marriage contract) with them if you know there is within them goodness and give them from the wealth of Allāh which He has given you ,but do not compel your girls If they wanted to be fortified ( meaning they don't want to marry those that came to make the marriage contract with her ) to seek for yourself temporary interests of worldly life. And if someone compel them ( Perhaps the girl does not want to marry because of his disability, fear, or .... in the girl herself, in this case, the guardian may force her to marry in the interest of the girl, not in the interest of the guardian. ), then ,Allāh after their compulsion, Forgiving and Merciful
it's hard when this breaks up a family because they make it very personal when you want to worship god alone without hadiths.
I find that when people make a discussion Personal and try to turn it into an argument, it’s often because they lack the knowledge to have a proper conversation. I’m sorry about your situation. But God willing they’ll come around
I am a Quranic centric Muslim but there is a problem with the Quran only community they don’t have movement that articulates how to practice Islam for example they can except the living tradition of the prophet or the suna which is the prayer the hajj etc which is different than Hadiths because it doesn’t contradict the Quran also it’s not written it’s based on action father teaching his son and on on there was no reason people corrupting it’s mainly spiritual.
Who was the first quranist?
Surely it was Prophet Muhammad. I’m sure he didn’t follow Hadith 😂
Even after Muhammad, Quran only Muslims got killed and imprisoned and a bunch of stuff.
Because hadith says you can kill "apostates".
Exactly this.
Only the Qur'an movement is very common in turkey I hope it spreads to the whole world
How do you pray?
Same way any and every human that learnt to pray salat; from those amongst us.
Original Bukhari Hadith Text:
Saheeh al-Bukhaari was heard by ninety thousand men from Imam al-Bukhaari himself (may Allah have mercy on him), as was stated by one of his most famous students, namely Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Farbari (d. 320 AH). See: Tareekh Baghdaad (2/9); Tareekh al-Islam (7/375). Al-Farbari’s narration of Saheeh al-Bukhaari was famous because he lived for a long time and was precise in copying it out. He heard it from al-Bukhaari (may Allah have mercy on him) over three years, then a number of trustworthy narrators learned it from him, and from them this book became well-known.
Al-Mustamli (d. 376 AH) - one of those who narrated it from Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Farbari - said: I copied the book of al-Bukhaari from its original text that was with Ibn Yoosuf, and I saw that he had not completed it yet; there were many blank pages there, including some isnaads after which he had not written any hadeeths, and some hadeeths for which he had not written any isnaads. So we tried to complete that.
End quote. Narrated by al-Baaji in at-Ta‘deel wa’t-Tajreeh (1/310)
The Saheeh was narrated from al-Farbari by a number of trustworthy narrators, among the most famous of whom were the following:
Al-Mustamli (d. 376 AH), whose name was Ibraaheem ibn Ahmad
Al-Hamawi Khateeb Sarkhas (d. 381 AH), whose name was ‘Abdullah ibn Ahmad
Abu’l-Haytham al-Kashmeehani (d. 389 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Makki
Abu ‘Ali ash-Shabwi, whose name was Muhammad ibn ‘Umar
Ibn as-Sakan al-Bazzaaz (d. 353 AH), whose name was Sa‘eed ibn ‘Uthmaan
Abu Zayd al-Mirwazi (d. 371 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Ahmad
Abu Ahmad al-Jarjaani (d. 373 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Muhammad
Among the trustworthy students of al-Bukhaari who heard his Saheeh directly from him and transmitted it to the people with its isnaads in written form was the imam, hafiz, faqeeh and qaadi, Abu Ishaaq Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil ibn al-Hajjaaj an-Nasafi (d. 295). The copy of an- Nasafi was transmitted by Imam al-Khattaabi (may Allah have mercy on him), as he said in his commentary A‘laam al-Hadeeth (1/105): We heard most of this book from the narration of Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil an- Nasafi. Khalaf ibn Muhammad al-Khayyaam told us: Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil told us, from him.
This is the most famous way that the scholars of hadith had: they would read their books to their students, or their students would read their books to them. Then those books would become well-known through the students and narrators, not through the original manuscript of the author, which was one copy that he kept for himself. There were no printing presses or publishing houses at that time; instead of printing presses there was the narration of students with strong isnaads.
What would any researcher find more authentic than the transmission of trustworthy narrators narrating from the manuscripts that were read to (and checked with) the author himself and approved by him, as they said concerning the copy of as-Saghaanni: He copied it from the manuscript that was read to the author (may Allah have mercy on him)”?
See: Fayd al-Baari by al-Kashmiri.
If you want to ask about how old the manuscripts that are extant today are, the Orientalist Manjana said in Cambridge in 1936 CE that the oldest manuscript he had come across up to that point was written in 370 AH, according to the narration of al-Mirwazi from al-Farbari. See Tareekh at-Turaath by Fu’aad Sizkeen (1/228).
It‘s easy to learn if you just listen to Allah for once.
I’ve always questioned why is there a Hadith. Now I see
Thanks
Beautiful god perfected the Quran and completed it
O ye who believe! Obey Allah, and obey the messenger and those of you who are in authority; and if ye have a dispute concerning any matter, refer it to Allah and the messenger if ye are (in truth) believers in Allah and the Last Day. That is better and more seemly in the end. - Surah An-Nisa: 59
Do you also believe that there can come new Messengers since the Quran doesn’t say Mohammed is the last Messenger but the last Prophet? Do you believe that Dr. Rashad Khalifa was a Messenger of God since he meets all the conditions required for someone to be a Messenger of God? Are you familiar with the mathematical code based on the number 19 in the Quran?
Following the messenger means following the messenger as messenger. In so far as he is acting as the messenger of God, follow him. If the messenger acts as a messenger when he receives and retells revelation, then that is when he is being a messenger, and that is when he should be followed as messenger.
Original Bukhari Hadith Textbook:
Saheeh al-Bukhaari was heard by ninety thousand men from Imam al-Bukhaari himself (may Allah have mercy on him), as was stated by one of his most famous students, namely Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Farbari (d. 320 AH). See: Tareekh Baghdaad (2/9); Tareekh al-Islam (7/375). Al-Farbari’s narration of Saheeh al-Bukhaari was famous because he lived for a long time and was precise in copying it out. He heard it from al-Bukhaari (may Allah have mercy on him) over three years, then a number of trustworthy narrators learned it from him, and from them this book became well-known.
Al-Mustamli (d. 376 AH) - one of those who narrated it from Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Farbari - said: I copied the book of al-Bukhaari from its original text that was with Ibn Yoosuf, and I saw that he had not completed it yet; there were many blank pages there, including some isnaads after which he had not written any hadeeths, and some hadeeths for which he had not written any isnaads. So we tried to complete that.
End quote. Narrated by al-Baaji in at-Ta‘deel wa’t-Tajreeh (1/310)
The Saheeh was narrated from al-Farbari by a number of trustworthy narrators, among the most famous of whom were the following:
Al-Mustamli (d. 376 AH), whose name was Ibraaheem ibn Ahmad
Al-Hamawi Khateeb Sarkhas (d. 381 AH), whose name was ‘Abdullah ibn Ahmad
Abu’l-Haytham al-Kashmeehani (d. 389 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Makki
Abu ‘Ali ash-Shabwi, whose name was Muhammad ibn ‘Umar
Ibn as-Sakan al-Bazzaaz (d. 353 AH), whose name was Sa‘eed ibn ‘Uthmaan
Abu Zayd al-Mirwazi (d. 371 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Ahmad
Abu Ahmad al-Jarjaani (d. 373 AH), whose name was Muhammad ibn Muhammad
Among the trustworthy students of al-Bukhaari who heard his Saheeh directly from him and transmitted it to the people with its isnaads in written form was the imam, hafiz, faqeeh and qaadi, Abu Ishaaq Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil ibn al-Hajjaaj an-Nasafi (d. 295). The copy of an- Nasafi was transmitted by Imam al-Khattaabi (may Allah have mercy on him), as he said in his commentary A‘laam al-Hadeeth (1/105): We heard most of this book from the narration of Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil an- Nasafi. Khalaf ibn Muhammad al-Khayyaam told us: Ibraaheem ibn Ma‘qil told us, from him.
This is the most famous way that the scholars of hadith had: they would read their books to their students, or their students would read their books to them. Then those books would become well-known through the students and narrators, not through the original manuscript of the author, which was one copy that he kept for himself. There were no printing presses or publishing houses at that time; instead of printing presses there was the narration of students with strong isnaads.
What would any researcher find more authentic than the transmission of trustworthy narrators narrating from the manuscripts that were read to (and checked with) the author himself and approved by him, as they said concerning the copy of as-Saghaanni: He copied it from the manuscript that was read to the author (may Allah have mercy on him)”?
See: Fayd al-Baari by al-Kashmiri.
If you want to ask about how old the manuscripts that are extant today are, the Orientalist Manjana said in Cambridge in 1936 CE that the oldest manuscript he had come across up to that point was written in 370 AH, according to the narration of al-Mirwazi from al-Farbari. See Tareekh at-Turaath by Fu’aad Sizkeen (1/228).
Please explain how to pray step by step from Quran
Why do people need an exact step by step form of prayer to connect with Allah (swt) on a spiritual and practical level via prayer? The Quran has a lot to say about prayer, don't you think it can be ambiguous instead of rigid about precise form of prayer so people don't lose the meaning via making sure there right toe is pointed to the kaaba? Also, don't you think your argument implies that the Quran is an insufficient source of knowledge when it comes to Islam?
Alhamdulilahi I'm soooooo glad I came across this brother and his arguments. Suddenly wham! The penny dropped with a loud clang! I suddenly fully appreciated and understood Dr Jonathan Brown, Us Numan Ali Khan and the brother in "the equaliser" was trying to impress upon us the absolute impossibility of following the Holy Koran, and to Submit to Allah swt 💯 % without the Koranic Injunction to follow the Prophet pbuh - In All mattters. Mashallah The Holy Koran is sooooo Easy to Understand! its absolutely clear! And the Koran tells us in no uncertain terms how to do so? ie .. By heeding what God Almighty Revealed to His Final Messenger Prophet Muhammad pbuh.
Thanks bro! For opening my eyes to the truth, that there cannot be Obedience and submission to Allah swt except accepting n bowing down to Allah swts injunctions! ❤ In this scheme of things set by Allah swt, there isn't room for ones nafs or ego.
Alhamdulilahi!!' What a Merciful God Allah swt is that He sent down His Final Messenger pbuh!
Thankyou brother this is all true hadith has corrupted islam
We have to follow prophet Muhammad and all the prophets exemple which was to follow the Quran only not any fake and falsehood hadith. We worship Allah not human being.
People are just blind at heart with the veil because Quran is so clear and complete.
Thank you for this video
Quran is available for everyone God made it easy so we do not need any corrupt fake imam to create false explanations:
[3:7]It is He who revealed to you the Book containing verses both clear and precise
[2:187] This is how God clearly explains His verses to men so that they will fear Him.
[5:92] Obey God therefore! Obey the Prophet! (Follow his exemple Which is to practice only Quran no sunna of any early prophet)
Take care! But if you turn away from the Lord, know that Our Prophet HAS NO OTHER mission than to clearly convey the Message to you. Know that the Prophet's only mission is to convey the Message to you clearly. (Not his sunnah or any conjuncture)
Prayer is so easy you stand, kneel and prostrate just like all the prophets did and not any fake mandatory rakat and falsehood words during prayers only Quran and Duas, Allah made you his prayer easy because he loves you. Fake prayers has been infiltrated from haters of Islam and kabbalist wake up before death bell rings:
[25:64] those who spend the night, prostrate or standing, praying to their Lord;
[22:26] We said to him, "Give Me no partner!" Take care to keep My Temple in a state of purity for those who come there to perform the ritual turns, or to make their devotions there, standing, kneeling or prostrate!
[39:9]"Are they equal, those who have received knowledge and those who have not received it?" Only beings endowed with intelligence are able to think about it.
Hadiths is prohibited:
[45: 6] These are verses from God which We recite to you in all truth. What other hadith will they believe if they remain insensitive to God's Word and His proofs?
[77:50] What other hadith will they believe, if they do not believe the Word of the Lord?
All different prophets are equal then why following hadith (which are mainly fake)?
[4: 152] Those who, on the other hand, believe in God and His prophets without making any distinction between them, God will grant them their retribution, for He is Merciful and Merciful.
Real kalimat is: Lah ilaha ila Allah
Not joined with Muhammad, Abraham, or Jesus. Because all equal for Allah:
[3:64] Say, “O people of the scriptures! Let us agree on a formula valid for us and for you, namely to worship only God Alone, not to associate anything with Him and not to take each other for masters apart from God. "
Minority is always right just see today the people fighting against vaccines lies and tyranny is a minority and Allah will always give victory to minority Allah bless you all ❤️
[6: 116] If you trust most of the inhabitants of the Earth, they will lead you astray from the Way of God, for they are only guessing and forging lies.
You have good knowledge, majority will go to hell, we are the minority, simply worshiping God alone is a huge blessing.💛
@@wolfblockstrike2924 yes true
True. Also remembers in English sujud and ruku have been translated to Bowing and prostating however their first meanings are submit and humility . Second meanings is the physical act like bowing and prostrating
Maybe bowing and prostrating can also be ritual prayer however according to the Quran there is no ritual prayer nor is it prohibited. As long as we call out to Allah alone
Quran 48 29
Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah; and those with him are forceful against the disbelievers, merciful among themselves. You see them bowing and prostrating [in prayer], seeking bounty from Allah and [His] pleasure. Their mark is on their faces from the trace of prostration. That is their description in the Torah. And their description in the Gospel is as a plant which produces its offshoots and strengthens them so they grow firm and stand upon their stalks, delighting the sowers - so that Allah may enrage by them the disbelievers. Allah has promised those who believe and do righteous deeds among them forgiveness and a great reward.
2:12 doesnt make sense when how to offer prayer the correct way is left out.
If someone thinks that the Quran is incomplete then he or she has not understood the purpose of the Quran. It is a book of non human intellect from Allah for the expansion of the human intellect and consciousness. Human beings do not have inner guidance as they have free will. The Quran serves as an external guidance. Read the book What is Islam? By G A Parwez. 5 pillars of Islam do not have the Quran.. why?
Personally, I actually do believe us humans have an "inner guidance" beside our free will. God gave us reasoning. The ability to distinguish between truth and falsehood. That way we also have the ability to distinguish between justice and unjustice (Golden Rule). God also equipped us with a heart (qlb) to feel emotions.
I dont think that free will and guidance clash against each other. It is rather the free will that allows us to choose what path we want to follow. And the paths were already set by our ability to distinguish between right and wrong, just and unjust. If we choose to stay truthful there is only one way which is the way of truth. If this way leads a person to the knowledge of one creator or not is a different matter. On the contrary if werent for Truth (or righteousness) one would follow other things such as one's own desires (Quran 45:23). At the end the human is always following something. Be it desires (not only "bad" desires), reasoning or what others dictates (etc.), the human is always a servant of a principle he chooses to follow. Something we choose to adhere to/follow to always guides us.
So I dont believe that the only thing God gave us is free will also since having a free will still doesnt give the human a drive (e.g. Why am I doing so and so, for what purpose etc.). It is only because of our free will that we choose to submit to any principle we want to follow.
This is also why I believe that God doesn't count the belief in Him as a condition for entering Jannah or not. It is not for no reason that God expects the good deeds to outweigh the bad deeds. Believing in the concept of God or being aware of His Holy Scriptures does not equate to actually following His laws and being righteous. But since his laws are based on being righteous and truthful any mature human (aware of God or not) can be held accountable for his own deeds. So basically anyone who strives to be a good human being is at the end unknowingly submitting to what God expects.
Of course the person who is not aware of God and his Scriptures is not the same as the person who does. God will judge accordingly.
And of course our level of knowledge and our resulting concept of justice are always limited. A person only knows as much as the person knows. And God knows this. God is also the one who knows our intentions. And since God is All Knowing and The Just he will judge every person accordingly to one's abilities. And God knows best.
Clear as day.
The Time is Near.
The Qoraan is The Perfect and fully detailed Word of
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty.
Woe to the man made ahadith followers and claim it's from
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty.
This is SHIRK SHIRK SHIRK.
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty Will INTERVENE.
If you need further details your book isn't fully detailed.. this is a contradiction therefore it's a.. prayer and pilgrimage is fully detailed in Quran but if you want to do it another way kl
Even you as a Muslim see the contradictions. Can you explain chapter 3 verse 3?
God confirming to Muhammad PBUH the Book Quran is indeed from God Himself as He had revealed the Book of Torah & Injeel for the ones before Muhammad PBUH.
Yusuf 12:106
وَمَا يُؤْمِنُ أَكْثَرُهُم بِٱللَّهِ إِلَّا وَهُم مُّشْرِكُونَ
English - Sahih International
And most of them believe not in Allah except while they associate others with Him.
English - Yusuf Ali
And most of them believe not in Allah without associating (other as partners) with Him!
Al-Mursalat 77:50
فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۭ بَعْدَهُۥ يُؤْمِنُونَ
English - Sahih International
Then in what statement after the Qur'an will they believe?
English - Yusuf Ali
Then what Message, after that, will they believe in?
Why are you reading the translation? Rely on the QURAN only so no more translation as that way you rely on translator. Ya jahil al Muslim, answer why there are two maalik (owner) and Malik (king) in surah al fathiah.
@@istagfar7705 r u mad ur one of those people?
We can go with you aproach and say quran alone is the way because it is perfect and complete otherwise it is false religion. But then when we look at some of quranic verses, quickly we will find that the verses are not clear nor complete therefore not being perfect which creates contradition making it false religion,
or,
take another approach, take quran alone as the only law source but understand that quran didn't come to us in a vacuum. Quran refers to things which are sometimes explained with prophe's tradition/sunnah and sometimes explained in previous scriptures. So with all this together quran is then truly perfect, clear and complete and religion is legit.
There are about 420 Hadith which goes against Qur'an.
You don’t have to read any hadith to see if it’s against the quran ,, the concept of hadith is all against the quran ,, so all hadith is wrong, simple as that.
probably more lol
@@abdulmajedkurdi5691hadiths teaches to drink camel urine as medicine. Ridiculous.
But don't you think the Messenger ﷺ is the best follower of the Qur'an?
It is claimed by some scholars that the Quran on its own is not sufficient and that the hadith and sunna of the prophet completes the religion for us and provides us with what is not in the Quran.
Sadly, many accept this claim without verifying its truth in the light of the Quran. Others, thinking they are better guided say that they do not follow except what has been proven to be the authentic sunna of the prophet.
This is what God has to say about the claim that the Quran is not sufficient on its own and that it is completed by the sunna:
Today, I have completed your religion for you, perfected My blessing upon you and approved Islam (submission) as the religion for you. 5:3
This glorious Quranic verse was revealed near the end of the Quranic revelation and confirms that the religion of God is completed in the Quran. And in another verse, God assures us that:
The Word of your Lord has been completed, in truth and justice. None can change His Words. He is the Hearer, the Knowledgeable. 6:115
All who insist that the Quran on its own is not complete, and that it is completed by the sunna of the prophet, are rejecting the truth in the above verses.
Salamun alaykum, correction the best way is not to be argumentative, do not come near the shajarah means an argumentative group, groups are misleaders. Period, Allahh is the one and only judge. Who gave you the authority to argue at the first place! Did Allahh send you some divine message or you appoint yourself. The greatest miracle of our beloved prophet is the Quran. During prophet SAW life time is there any other specific books that he refers to other than Quran! Please name one! Are you trying to argue that your path is the most closest path to our prophet! Who told you that! Is it Allahh himself or you dream of the prophet SAW telling you so? Or it’s just your wishful thinking?
Peace
Recently, I have explored your videos and ı want to help you as far as ı can.
I am turkish and ı want turkish people to learn the truth.
I dont think that it will bring a huge change but ı want to do it and maybe while doing it my english improves a little bit. :)
Can you please open your videos to community contributions for translation?
Salam,
Ill do this now. I appreciate the help.
Edip yuksel, Sonia Cihangir, Gürkan engin , cubbesiz Mahmut , Caner Taslaman, bunlar iyi
@@ociabi dostum edip yüksel dediğin adam pkk sempatizanı. Fikirlerini doğru ya da yanlış bulabilirsin fakat kendi gibi düşünmeyenler dışındaki insanlara ha bire saldırıyor, hakaret ediyor, kaba konuşuyor.
Edip Yüksel pkk - czcams.com/video/qkTZZepuBkQ/video.html
Tidak di pungkiri bahwa ada bebrapa hadist yg memang benar dari Nabi Muhammad
Tapi kebanyakan saya meragukan
Maka dari itu hati saya lebih condong ke Al-Qur'an
Mudah-mudahan saya berada di jalan yg lurus.
Amin 🤲
Catatan : Saya tetap melaksanakan shalat seperti kebanyakan muslim tergantung di mana dia lahir,dan saya membayar zakat dan mudah-mudahan segera pergi ke tanah suci Mekah !
Can a Christian from Saudi start a channel named the Saudi Christian??
Of course 😂
Brothers and sisters, not only Bukhari was passed forward thru hearsay, the only lasting manuscripts are in Europe. Muslims dont even house manuscriptts of Bukhari original and the book is gone....what have we become.
bro we need the hadith so then we know how to pray allah told us to also follow muhammad pbuh and without muhammad pbuh we would not know how to perform salah/namaz.
Yah ok... did salaat not exist for 200y? It did? How? Oh becsuse it transceded thru the masses, so wouldn't have doneso with or without hadith? Tell me did u learn salaat thru family or hadith?
Do you follow the hadith, or just scholars and tradition?
Contradiction with hadith about wudu:
BUKHARI HADITH: Volume 1, Book 4, Number 159:
Narrated Ibn ‘Abbas:
The Prophet performed ablution by washing the body parts only once.
BUKHARI HADITH: Volume 1, Book 4, Number 160:
Narrated ‘Abdullah bin Zaid:
The Prophet performed ablution by washing the body parts twice.
BUKHARI HADITH: Volume 1, Book 4, Number 196:
Narrated ‘Abdullah bin Zaid:
Once Allah’s Apostle came to us and we brought out water for him in a brass pot. He performed ablution thus: He washed his face thrice, and his forearms to the elbows twice, then passed his wet hands lightly over the head from front to rear and brought them to front again and washed his feet (up to the ankles).
Allah AND His messenger not OR the messenger
The so called Quranists are correct, so far as the Hadith have been authorized without approval of Muhammad, or even his companions, centuries after canonization of the Quran, and rejecting the Hadith for the sake of argument is necessary to prove the Quran as a complete and self-sufficient book, but after all, the Quran itself remains a vague and disorganized book, either because people who supposed to transmit its data have died before the canonization, or because Muhammad himself have died before the book was fully revealed and organized, so the Quran is now incomplete, or absolutely dependent on other books like the Hadith, which makes up for those loses, including the missing context for the Quran, most of practical guidance, and all data about Muhammad and founding history of Islam.
Who made Bukhari an Authority over the religion? He’s not a prophet or messenger. Didn’t he even reject 99.999% of all the Hadiths he collected 😂 God never told him to compile a bunch of narrations and hearsay.
Hadith means a saying. And in these verse it refers to the hadith of God. My argument is simple look at sura annisa verse 87: وَمَنْ أَصْدَقُ مِنَ ٱللَّهِ حَدِيثًۭا
"And whose word (hadith) is more truthful than Allah’s? We don't need hadiths we need only quran, and the messenger pbuh know his job, he knew that the practil things like salat.. is gonna stay in society inherited from a father to son.. the most important thing is unity because more we get away from the revelation of God the more the muslim society get divided from the straight path. Read verse 2 of sura muhammed. Good luck.
You covered some really strong points on why we should follow the Quran alone, but where is Islam in the Quran?
Myself being a person who follows the Quran alone I would be more inclined to say I am a Monotheist or a submitter. I wouldn’t say I was part of Islam, what is Islam? I don’t find it in the Quran, I just see people who follow Hadiths saying their Faith is Islam, which is not what I follow. So yes I would say Islam is the wrong way or at leased the wrong word. Peace Bro
That’s a good thought. Essentially, Islam is the name given to the believers of the Quran. The Quran does say not to create sects, but as long as Islam simply means those who follow the Quran, I don’t see an issue with it. I guess it just help when we give something a label. It’s easier to say Islam rather than the monotheistic religion of those who follow the Quran but also believe in the previous prophets and their messages etc 😂
All the best brother!
Monotheist or submitter works fine, but it’s quite broad in what it might encompass. It just makes it harder when discussing with others
The word Islam is mentioned in the Quran, i've seen it. But the meaning of it is different from the Islam as it is known widely.
Naureen Pocoyo so true.
@@naureenpocoyo6400 Can you tell me which verses where the word islam is mentioned or used in Quran. Thanks. Peace.
It's not rocket science.? What did I prophet taught, the quran which was revealed to him so obey the messenger just follow the message, The quran if our creator is saying this is a complete full detailed message thats enough for me I don't need anything else, nothing else matters.
Isn't the Qu'ran assuming that at the time it was written down, revelation is perfect/complete (including the Torah and Gospel)?
And since Muslims claim that the Jewish and Christian Scriptures are lost and/or corrupted, wouldn't the line of revelation now be incomplete? Al-Mahida.47-48
Or is God not able to protect his revelation? [Matthew 24:35] [Mark 13:31] [Luke 21:33]
God had not promised to protect any of his revelation books except in the Quran. And we can see the miracle of God's promise !
@@chehrazadeesmey8399
Not quite,
If you listen to the qur'an, it says to let christians judge it (Al-mahida47-48).
So a christian will judge by the gospels which say, "heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will never pass away' - Jesus, Mat24:35
So either the gospel is corrupted and the qur'an is wrong, or the gospel is true and the qur'an is still wrong. Right?
@@louiscorbett3278 You are writing a quran of yourself because you are quoting whatever "meaning" but certainly not what the Holy Quran says. Check it out , i have no time to teaching you.
@@chehrazadeesmey8399 No. I'm quoting your Qur'an (Surah Al-mahida, ayat 47)
"let the People of the Gospel judge by what God has revealed therein."
So, since I am a person of the gospel, the Qur'an tells me to judge it by what God has revealed in my scriptures. Correct?
So the Gospel says; "my words will never pass away" - Jesus.
So, either the Gospel is correct, and the Qur'an is wrong (because they contradict eachother about many things). Or, the Gospel is wrong, and the Qur'an is also wrong (Because the Qur'an claims the gospels are revealed by God).
That's my argument, still waiting for a Muslim to understand it and debate it.
My hope is that you'll read on,
What's the only thing which can save someone? The Apostle says, "For I decided to know nothing except Jesus Christ and him crucified.".
That's it! You need to know Christ and him crucified in order to be saved. But the Qur'an denies the only thing which can save you (that Christ was crucified).
Were we warned of people like Muhammad? Yes, the apostle John warns of him and others.
"Who is the liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the antichrist, he who denies the Father and the Son."
Yet Muslims arose in the seventh century denying that! They deny the Father and the Son...
There's nothing a sinner can do to please God, every good work is tainted by sin. The only hope is that our sins are forgiven - but how can God forgive and still be just? A sacrifice, that's the only way.
Repent of your sins, and trust the perfect death of Christ on that cross. Amen.
@@louiscorbett3278 listen I'm not here to begin an argument or something but just to explain by the way I understand what Quran meant
So basically it says "Judge by your own book"
Doesn't the Gospels have contradictions?
Than this is simply what Quran meant with "Judge by your own books" See the contradictions and by this we understand wich book is true and wich is not Quran doesn't have contradictions like I said I don't want to begin an argument with thousands replies in a comment section so I hope u understand what I mean
👏👏👏👏👏👏👍
*SALAAM BELIEVERS!*
Allah says in the Qur'an to not take the disbelievers as allies in preference over the believers. We read that in the Qur'an 3:28. And I'm in a difficult economic situation here in Sweden where I'm in debt and tied to the welfare system and forced to apply for every possible job like selling fake halal labeled meat in restaurants owned by disbelievers, to sell pork, to sell alcohol etc. And this is deeply troubling my peace of mind. Please, if there's any believer who may hire me please let me work for you instead of the disbelievers who have taken Allah s.w.r. as their enemy. For the sake of Allah please help me out!
Is there such a thing as a closet quraan only muslim? 🤫
As in you don’t let others know?
@@TheBritishMuslim_ yeah…
@@isaamrafee9902 Same.....I can't actually tell my family 😬
@@StudiesoftheQuran use verse 7:3 on them.. the word unzilla is a singular masculine verb so it can only refer to one item. (Not Quran and hadith), besides, verse 7:2 defines whats being unzilla which is the kitaab aka the Quran. Aulia is a broard term that means allies of which prophets also fall under, since he is neither an enemy of Allah nor indifferent. Its all about exclusivity. Allah alone i worship and The Quran alone I accept as a source of guidance.
Obey messenger mean message of "Allah" aka "Quran". Quran haven't any prophet hood , Toora had. As our Rasool is prophet for Bani israel too , so Phrophet for bani israel messenger for humankind ....
See Mrvelous Quran channel