Hadith Fails The Authenticity Test
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 01. 2024
- Discord: / discord
Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk
Video Notes:
qurantalkblog.com/2023/12/24/...
Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw
Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE
Twitter: / talkquran
Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/
Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid
Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/
Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-in...
I’m a 30 year old American convert - may God reward you. You articulate things that i and other converts come face to face with in our study. You had the courage to put yourself out there and stand for God and for truth. May God raise generations of believers like you.
May Allah increase your iman bro. I sincerely suggest you to check out other sources since this website is in fact misleading.
yes, good effort in the video-
Everyone is supposed to read the Quran and try to understand it.
Dependencies on the sect preachers has brought the situation down around us nowadays.
Refer
//Quran 54.17
And We have indeed made the Qur'an EASY for “Zikr” (understand and remember) : then is there any that will receive admonition?
//
Whatever is required as the foundation of Deen is in the Book- which is straightforward and simple-
if something is not there then it is NOT as important as these Sect preachers try to push.
//Quran 6.159
Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - YOU ARE NOT WITH THEM in anything.
Their affair is only to Allāh; then He will inform them about what they used to do.
//
Also refer
///Quran 6.114
"Then is it other than Allāh I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book EXPLAINED in DETAIL?"
And those to whom We gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters.
6.115. And the word of your Lord has been FULFILLED in truth and in justice. NONE CAN ALTER His words, and He is the Hearing, the Knowing.
///
@@monsieurbonaparte6628 may he increase yours to a level in which you realize it’s not appropriate for a Muslim to glorify napoleon with his YT handle
@@monsieurbonaparte6628 as if this is my source of knowledge as opposed to just a video I found interesting. You think this is my sheikh?
Great video brother, may Allah be pleased with you. The survival of Hadith literature is only possible by keeping people away from the Quranic teachings, so they have made people SO AFRAID of misunderstanding the Quran that people are NOT AFRAID of ignoring it. The irony!
This is a very important topic. It CANNOT be that "oh we got it wrong" no, these hadiths must have been MALICIOUSLY fabricated for a purpose;
1: to undermine the authenticity of the quran
2: to discredit the prophet (saw)
3: to delude muslims about true history contained within the quran, and to trick muslims into thinking the quranic history is the same as biblical and secular history
4: to give muslims an apocalyptic myth which pits them against the west, which is intended to ultimately lead to war and the controlled demolition of monotheism
There is a reason that every single person that attacks islam uses the hadiths to make their attack..
Once you realize how big the lies about Islamic history actually are, you will see, it's not just this, it's ALL of history we've been lied to about, the Quran is the ONLY authentic source for sound knowledge, and true history, and it is for all time, all people, and it will continue to reveal itself to us more and more as only the authentic Word of Allah (swt) can!
Indeed I agree!
MashaAllah you addressed very good points
Missed your recordings glad to hear your voice
Thank you for all the content you make. It’s very informative and knowledgeable. I appreciate all the research and hard work you do.
Excellent explanation with evidences. Well done brother.
Salaam,
I was a sunni hanafi before, Allah ( SWT ) guided me and many brothers & sisters to follow his guidence, i do not follow any hadith's, everything is in the quran, our prophet followed the quran alone, that was fro allah, our creator. Why should i follow any other books that was not authorized by allah ( SWT )? Books that lie & contradicts & worst of all humiliate our prophet to the core. This is all Iblis & clan's work, & the umah follow blindly, how sad. May allah ( SWT ) guide the umah in shah allah. Salaam.
Brother, you're doing God's work. These videos are very valuable.
I was a sunni, now I'm a Muslim.
?
If you rejected all Hadith then you're not a proper Muslim.
@@thehand2466 says who? 😂
@@zararashraf then how you pray? How you pay zakat? How many rakat? How you know which Sura to recite when praying?
There's lot of Muslim that rejected all Hadith. But when I asked them this question, they will bring up different answer.
Some say pray 3 time a day, some say pray 4 time a day, some say the otherwise. And etc
That's what happen when you completely rejected hadith
@@zararashraf and pls note that, not all hadith is authentic, yea, we all know that, some hadith is authentic even if it was daif, some Hadith is unauthentic even if it was sahih
That's why we need to know how to classify it, which Hadith is authentic and which is don't, there's lot of way to classify it.
It must go through lot of process
God bless you
When they need the hadiths, it automatically becomes authentic.
Mashallah
Who is the speaker please? Can anyopne tell me?
If you rejected all Hadith, then tell me
- how you pay zakat?
- how you know which Sura to recite when praying?
- how many rakat?
@@steveryder1174 do you believe the existence of dajjal?
Even the Hadiths don't mention these. It has been passed down to us by the descendants of Abraham.
Wawazat, B. Ehrman's cousin?
Yea, some Hadith is not authentic (even if it sahih), and some is authentic. (Even if it daif)
You must know how to classify which is authentic and which is not, there's lot of way to classify it
It must go through lot of process
Keep exposing The mushrikun
If these people could fabricate sayings of the prophet.... how much guarantee we must have on Quran itself.... since the original manuscripts were being burnt.... how can we say for sure that there can not be omission and insertion into the Quran to fulfill the desires of blood thirst leaders during the history of Islam.
Know the mother of Hadith. Know the Hadith of Jabril
Do you pray Salat? According to which do you pray salat? Or take ablution. etc
Stop asking the same questions. Ablution is in the Quran.
@@examinetheWORD I think you understood very well the predicament you stuck in very well. The question was very general, not limited to ablution. How do you pray salah? What time do you pray salah? What do you read in Qiyam etc? Do you want to talk about these? Let me guess, you don't. I would be more than happy if you could share with the audience how you pray salah or do other all kinds of worshipping? According to which rules and rituals? And please be kind enough to share your reference about the ablution.
@@monsieurbonaparte6628 we can take each question in order. However, you must answer one question first.
Are the Hadith infallible?
I left Christianity because of a flawed book. I believe the Quran is infallible. Are the Hadith infallible?
@@examinetheWORD No it is not. No one is claiming that either. It does not mean however that we can and should discard them. And also if you are not 100% sure that Prophet said something, but still 99%(98 and 95 also does the same job) sure about it for all practical purposes, you take it proxy to certainity. Then is it logical to discard thousands of 99% certain jewels of Prophetic teachings?
I answered. You answer now my questions. May be just couple of them as you wish. ???
You still haven't answered me what was Muslims following when there was no hadith for 250 years and Allaha says quran is fully detailed I have not left anything out of it so has Allaha made a mistake there were 6 people who wrote the hadith and they all contradict each other, bhukari, Muslim, Abu dawood,thrimidi etc, which one do you follow. And what is the conclusion of the quran what is it telling you, worship me alone do not idolise, typical Muslims today idolise mohammed they grow a beard like him dress like him where a turban like him eat like him if that is not idolising what is. quran says follow the messenger follow his message which was revealed to him from Allah.
They should g’et punished for lying to muslims those who are sincere and wanna g’et closer to God
A lie is always deliberate so your argument is nonsensical. And no one goes to hel for non deliberate acts
understand your logic, but its a little extreme in rejecting ALL ahadith.
How many times is prayer fardh ? Quran says 3. Sunnah/Hadith says 5. Which do you follow ? How do you do wudu- Quran -S Maidah ayah 6 .....O you who believe! When you intend to offer As-Salât (the prayer), wash your faces and your hands (forearms) up to the elbows, rub (by passing wet hands over) your heads, and (wash) your feet up to ankles. If you are in a state of Janâba, purify yourselves (bathe your whole body).
Is this the order you follow exactly or follow hadith?
Do you swill water into your mouth thrice and clean your nose thrice as per hadith?or no?
Quran said 5, not 3, the 3 is only for that specific time
If you read Quran and understand it, you'll pray 5 time a day. Not 3
please show quran reference for 5. @@thehand2466
You follow the word of Allah with is 100% correct or guesswork from bukhari?
@@BM8C7 it's not guessed work. It's the word from Muhammad & the others related person (and I know not all of the hadith is authentic, that's why we need to know how to classify it, which authentic and which not)
@@thehand2466 Muhammad has 0 Hadiths..
i checked out the discord channel for the first time and thought we had 3k Quran alone followers but we have another echo chamber with children instead. Discord mods at it again 😂
Thye are afraid Becouse muslims are waking up they are power hungry The sulltan imams
I have my doubts so I abstain from liking this page until some higher authority indicate the truth.
That's some npc stuff. Qur'an condemns other religions for them setting up their priests and other religious authorities as God's. You don't need a "higher authority", Allah gave you your own brain, use it. If you defer to some supposed higher authority and they are wrong, God will not accept that as an excuse.
Brother what do you want to convey in your video, refute the notion of authentic hadeeths? You do know that there is a verse in Surah Al-Najm (53:3-4), right? Imagine the following scenario: you are a convert to Islam, you have read the Qur'an. Then its time to make the daily five prayers. How do you exactly go about? In addition, you do know about a verse in Surah Al-Hashr (59:7)[And whatsoever the Messenger gives you, take it;
and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it)], right?
The Qur'an told you five daily prayers? Where?
It doesn't. So someone who reads the Qur'an and then think there's five daily prayers has their head in the cloud
The messenger gave us the glorious Quran nothing else...
And the point of the video is, you don't actually know what the Prophet said. Nobody does. It's all a guessing game.
And you're doing the Qur'an a huge disservice, trying to use it to support having to play this guessing game. Allah's religion for the whole of humanity is not a guessing game. Period.
@@BroMoe71And how many prayers exactly does the Qur'an mention?
@@BroMoe71 It's not a guessing game. If you actually do not consider authentic hadeeths to be part of divine instructions then I even do not know what you do as a Muslim. For example, Allah says in the Qur'an [Surah Al-Baqarah (2:238:] "Guard strictly As-Salawat especially the Middle Salah..." About the middle prayer how do you tell which one and how many are they?
"And the point of the video is, you don't actually know what the Prophet said".... I do know what the Prophet said. By the will of Allah, there were men of honor (Bukhari & Muslim, etc) at least close to the Prophat's time than us today, who devoted their lives to authenticate the hadeeths, in order to separate and expose myriad fabrications attributed to the Prophet SAW.
this guy is anti-muslim .... thats saw-hih 🤣
not really a "brother"