World Population (Old Version)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 06. 2009
  • A Graphic Simulation of the History of Human Population Growth © 2000

Komentáře • 393

  • @ryanjansen8605
    @ryanjansen8605 Před 9 lety +93

    This is what happens when an animal doesn't have a predator.

  • @DarrioDaily_
    @DarrioDaily_ Před 7 lety +12

    My teacher showed us this in class years ago. I’m scared. .____.

    • @yosefmacgruber1920
      @yosefmacgruber1920 Před 7 lety +3

      Why are you scared? More people enjoying life, is surely a very good thing.

  • @supermonk3y07
    @supermonk3y07 Před 10 lety +21

    People think that there are too many people, it's undeniable that there is a lot of people but the earth can still handle a lot. Everyone says that the earths population is growing but, actually the population growth in the future will be very low or actually be negative. Already developed countries have aging and declining populations Italy, Russia, Japan. even lesser developed or developing nations have very low fertility rates of 1.4

    • @supermonk3y07
      @supermonk3y07 Před 10 lety +2

      Low fertility rates of 1.4 or lower and a median age in the 40's or lower. And I'm not talking just about Japan or South Korea or Italy or Russia... I'm talking about Cuba, Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Venezuela

    • @hbreaker3698
      @hbreaker3698 Před 10 lety +1

      if you want to see how fast its growing go to worldometers.com

    • @Comillia
      @Comillia Před 10 lety +1

      Antonio Maldonado you also forgot to mention Mexico hon. Everyone assumes that mexicans and latinos have so many children, but this is not the case. in fact its birth rates are now at the same level of the US, and by the end of the next century, they will be even lower

    • @supermonk3y07
      @supermonk3y07 Před 10 lety

      Delia D I know that lol, I'm Mexican. That about Mexicans having large families...Well that stereotype that was more true more like in the 60's, but now fertility rates are only a little more than 2 children per family. There are still big families, but nowhere near as much as what they used to be. Nowhere near as many families with Jesus, Paco, Maria, Jose, Agustin, and Gabriela and mom and dad...BTW I'm making up the names.

    • @michaellogozzo3471
      @michaellogozzo3471 Před 10 lety +4

      Antonio Maldonado Isn't Mexico City the most populous city on the planet? Your observations appear defensive, and nieve to the degrading effects human population has had on the quality of life on this planet. Don't base your qualitative values on what you see now. It is poor compared to just 50 years ago. In another 50, we will see people fighting for water.

  • @SuperRyderBros
    @SuperRyderBros Před 11 lety +8

    No, ITS THAT CREEPY HEARTBEAT SOUND

  • @gonaagond845
    @gonaagond845 Před 8 lety +9

    Errors:
    - No baltic, black, caspian seas, great lakes
    - Overpopulated Kazakhstan, Tibet, Sahara

    • @felox1715
      @felox1715 Před 7 lety

      Gonaa Gond it said it has to spread it out to show how populated it is (They should have used one dot per million)

    • @felox1715
      @felox1715 Před 7 lety

      Gonaa Gond the again it's from 16 years ago

  • @aidanmullan7368
    @aidanmullan7368 Před 9 lety +5

    Guys each dot represents one person right

    • @felixd1002
      @felixd1002 Před 9 lety +1

      1 million people.

    • @williamcroft6468
      @williamcroft6468 Před 8 lety +11

      +Aidan Mullan If that was true there would be less than a million people on earth. I hate to say it but the higher the population is the more idiots there are.

  • @user-kz9jh5lk6s
    @user-kz9jh5lk6s Před 29 dny +2

    THE FACT THAT THIS IS 14 YEARS IS CRAZY

    • @spriitz153
      @spriitz153 Před 2 dny

      The youtube video upload is 14 years old but the actual video is from 2000

  • @bandar4U
    @bandar4U Před 11 lety +7

    I'm doing this for class...ooh yeah!

  • @mjpayne95
    @mjpayne95 Před 10 lety +29

    WE SHOULD TAKE BIKINI BOTTOM AND PUSH IT SOMEWHERE ELSE !!!

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 12 lety +3

    @goodguys9 As explained at the beginning of the video, dots represent one million people and are placed in the middle of where those million people live. You'll see that the dots in Canada are concentrated along the U.S. border, where most people live, and the dots in Russia are concentrated in the cities.

  • @milkycat9344
    @milkycat9344 Před 3 lety +2

    Nice this channel is still active.

  • @s577151
    @s577151 Před 10 lety +5

    the UN seems to have the most credible projection data for populations and they keep revising it downwards, now it is: 8 billion on low estimate 10.5 on high for 2050. I don't think any one would expect population to double in 2009 "over the next fifty years", even on highest projected models. very curious to see where these guys got their data from.
    I do love the map :)

  • @maciejqas7515
    @maciejqas7515 Před 8 lety +24

    hey, what happened to baltic sea?

    • @English_Lessons_Pre-Int_Interm
      @English_Lessons_Pre-Int_Interm Před 8 lety +1

      +Maciej Qas It disappeared as well as the Black Sea.

    • @Halloweensmasher
      @Halloweensmasher Před 8 lety

      +inyazserg Sergey Larin And the Caspian.

    • @maciejqas7515
      @maciejqas7515 Před 8 lety

      +Bianey Velasquez Nunez really?

    • @korayacar1444
      @korayacar1444 Před 7 lety

      Maciej Qas All seas virtually disconnected to oceans are missing. In fact, the western part of the Baltic still remains.

    • @thedotgamer9592
      @thedotgamer9592 Před 6 lety

      Koray Acar But the black sea and baltic sea are connected to the ocean

  • @kagez6515
    @kagez6515 Před 9 lety +9

    The map is drawn wrong! if you look in sweden, you wont fine one of the seas (or any sea at all, all over the world)

  • @gonemushrooming
    @gonemushrooming Před 14 lety +1

    @8DJUSTINCREDIBLE
    I'm 18 too, and the thought of having kids right now is terrifying. Before modern medicine, people had more kids because they had smaller chances of living to adulthood, but that's certainly changed in most parts of the world. My AP Human geography teacher showed our class this video, it scares me: It's so chilling how much the population of the world has sky-rocketed in only the last couple hundred years.

  • @mikesmith-st8mp
    @mikesmith-st8mp Před 11 lety

    keep making em!!

  • @Neueregel
    @Neueregel Před 12 lety +2

    nice image compilation

  • @jeromecirconflexe8058
    @jeromecirconflexe8058 Před 8 lety +32

    Black sea is black. OK.

    • @korayacar1444
      @korayacar1444 Před 7 lety

      Jérôme Circonflexe So is the Caspian Sea, and other waters virtually disconnected to oceans, except for the Mediterranean.

  • @simonpeter6
    @simonpeter6 Před 7 lety

    What map projection did you use? Impressive, but an equal-area projection may have been better.

  • @christianmercado7149
    @christianmercado7149 Před 5 lety +3

    My heart is beating so my heart will go on

  • @CarbonDioxide1990
    @CarbonDioxide1990 Před 12 lety +1

    @hop208 My view is himalayas will provide future fresh water for south asia for a long time as they have a LOT of water up there so no soon water crysis I suppose

  • @brurrik
    @brurrik Před 10 lety

    Showing this in my oral presentation thanks

  • @jnixa1010
    @jnixa1010 Před 8 lety +18

    This is scary. With life expectancies rising, this map will be all white in 100-200 years.

    • @jnixa1010
      @jnixa1010 Před 7 lety +1

      But if we live longer and longer, it will still rise.

  • @GreyTheWolfer
    @GreyTheWolfer Před 10 lety

    this is the better quality than the other.

  • @vanillasparkle6899
    @vanillasparkle6899 Před 3 lety +1

    this video was made 20 years ago and the phone number still works

  • @cassiopeiaAlbascot
    @cassiopeiaAlbascot Před 8 lety +1

    There was a dot first on Edinburgh around 1250AD which could well be right but then a dot in Highland, Scotland?, the population of the Highlands is to this day around 232'000 people.
    I liked the video though it was quite unique with the sound effects, made it interesting and spooky

  • @StuartAken
    @StuartAken Před 11 lety

    Great video. I think you could lose 30 secs of the intro, though, to get people into it more quickly.

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 11 lety +1

    Each dot represents 1 million people and they are concentrated in the urban areas because that's where the actual population is concentrated.

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 12 lety

    @DCfreak87 You are correct that all population estimates are just that--estimates based on projections. We cannot know exactly how many people are on earth. We can only use the data available and make the most educated assumptions.

  • @CalvinandHobbes14
    @CalvinandHobbes14 Před 13 lety

    @ianripken Actually, the guy said that dots will increase outward to show accurately the population on the edges. Also, ND has 2 freakin dots cuz the dots can also show the population of a big area by being placed in the middle of it.

  • @Differentbutrational
    @Differentbutrational Před 10 lety +2

    I think the number of people in the Americas and Australia before the colonial event had been unintentionally underestimated by a bit.

    • @scholargnome
      @scholargnome Před 9 lety

      There is little information regarding the population of the Americas during the period prior to the Western conquests. Most of the information available are conjectures.

    • @diegoflores9237
      @diegoflores9237 Před měsícem

      Especially America. There were 100,000+ cities in America pre Columbian time. Mostly in the area that is now Mexico, Central America and Peru. But there were also at different times cities of less than 100,000 in other parts of America in pre Columbian times. In the areas I already mentioned but also what is now the USA, Colombia and other places.

  • @AthenaMinerva-bn4xf
    @AthenaMinerva-bn4xf Před rokem

    What year did history teachers show this to students?

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 12 lety

    @uncballer28 Most governments conduct a census every ten years or so. The Demographic and Health Surveys are used in many developing countries as well. We know roughly how many babies are born in each country each year. Many countries with rapidly growing populations have policies that encourage family planning, but can't afford to provide universal access to contraceptive services. Donor countries like the United States can help by funding voluntary family planning programs.

  • @GretgorPooper
    @GretgorPooper Před 11 lety

    Like I said before, to another commenter who said the same thing you did, I really wish I could be as optimistic as you about that. Unfortunately, I believe mankind is too deeply polluted with superstition, greed and ignorance for something like that to actually be thought of before it's too late.

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 12 lety

    @meralodem This is simply incorrect. Donor countries do indeed bring their technical expertise to developing countries. They teach medical professionals how to insert long-acting methods of contraception; they educate nurses about life-saving medications to stop hemorrhaging after childbirth; they help non-profit workers in developing countries run public health campaigns; etc.

  • @NEWjafan12
    @NEWjafan12 Před 12 lety

    I had to pause at 2000 A.D.
    The beating was too intense for me.

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 12 lety

    @JonaBay Those of us who support population stabilization do so in order to avoid a situation like the one you described. Most people don't want to live in a world where people are "dropping like flies" for lack of adequate food, shelter, and medicine. The purpose of population stabilization is to improve the quality of life for people. Population stabilization is the means we advocate for making life better for women, children, households, and societies.

  • @MarylandballProductions
    @MarylandballProductions Před 5 měsíci

    I remember us watching this in 6th grade science for renewable and nonrenewable resources. Good times.

  • @hitssquad
    @hitssquad Před 10 lety +2

    "when we're fighting wars for the last remaining scraps of food and clean water."
    People don't make food and clean water?

  • @paulkenny5052
    @paulkenny5052 Před rokem

    Is that the soundtrack to the space 4X game Space Empires IV?

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 14 lety

    @victormgv Education--especially for girls--is a huge influence on fertility rates, as you stated. In most cases, the better-educated women use contraception to limit their family size because they have knowledge of its existence, where to get it, and how to use it. These methods that you call inhumane (I assume modern contraception?) are the exact methods that educated women employ to reduce their fertility.

  • @hop208
    @hop208 Před 13 lety

    @thedodger2x Large scale desalination plants and the amount of infrastructure needed to make the water available to the public would cost billions of dollars and the construction would need to start immediately. Not only that, but with the current technology to separate the salt and other impurities form the water isn't sustainable on that scale. All current large scale desalination plants (like in Dubai) run on massive amounts of oil. Indian oil consumption would go up dramatically.

  • @limoboss6242
    @limoboss6242 Před 12 lety

    @DCfreak87 - They say 3 babies are born every second, the population is growing wildly, I don't think
    anyone knows how many people there are anymore, the more the population grows the harder to keep
    track of the total. Population is growing everywhere, who is counting the babies being born in remote
    areas that no one cares about, humans are procreating more than ever because we are more than ever,
    population growth is unavoidable, why worry, let it grow, we can't stop it!

  • @thegreatmonster
    @thegreatmonster Před 11 lety

    what happened to the 300 somewhat mio population of USA? Why don't I see it in this clip?

  • @Justo506
    @Justo506 Před 12 lety

    much better quality

  • @dbmasta
    @dbmasta Před 11 lety

    We'll never destroy ourselves through overpopulation alone. Economic reality will almost always keep us from having more children than we can afford to raise. If our population outpaces resource availability too much, prices of those scarce resources will rise, giving a clear signal for families not to further strain themselves with more mouths to feed, and the overall situation will correct itself before any chaos. If parents can afford another kid and want one, there's no reason to stop them.

  • @oobanalis6084
    @oobanalis6084 Před 10 lety

    Interesting, But I don't think there will be so much people in the area of Tibet etc. in the future!

  • @GretgorPooper
    @GretgorPooper Před 11 lety

    Does not change the fact that the Earth is finite, so even if we still have thousands of years worth of resources on the planet, they won't last forever.

  • @ChatGPt2001
    @ChatGPt2001 Před 6 dny

    Okay, here are some details about the world population as of my knowledge cutoff in August 2023:
    In August 2023, the global population was estimated to be around 7.9 billion people. This represented a steady increase from previous years, with the population growing by about 1.1% annually in the years leading up to 2023.
    The countries with the largest populations were:
    1. China - 1.41 billion
    2. India - 1.38 billion
    3. United States - 331 million
    4. Indonesia - 273 million
    5. Pakistan - 221 million
    Population growth rates varied significantly by region, with Africa and parts of Asia experiencing the fastest growth, while Europe and North America had slower growth or even population decline in some cases.
    The aging of populations in many developed countries was also an emerging trend, with higher proportions of elderly residents. This was driven by declining birth rates and increased life expectancy.
    Let me know if you need any other details about the world population as of that time period. I'd be happy to provide more information.

  • @eamonahern7495
    @eamonahern7495 Před 7 měsíci

    I can't watch this because of the heartbeat

  • @leoelliondeux
    @leoelliondeux Před 12 lety

    I hope you are mentioning that in favor of it, because thats exactly what this world needs. Literally.

  • @xodus1386
    @xodus1386 Před 8 lety

    That map was the most distorted map I've ever seen.

  • @AntFarmer47
    @AntFarmer47 Před 10 lety

    Still overcrowded to this day!

  • @GretgorPooper
    @GretgorPooper Před 11 lety

    The problem is not total biomass or area of occupation, the problem is resources. No matter how much of them we have now, they are still finite, and the higher the population, the quicker we consume them. We might be comfortably okay with resources for the next few hundred years, but that doesn't mean the resources will last forever.

  • @kiwibrasileiro
    @kiwibrasileiro Před 14 lety +1

    It's simple - reduce population growth in the main areas: China (already implemented), Asia, Africa, Coastal South America, Central America and - WAIT FOR IT - EUROPE AND USA. Despite the belief that there are 'better' people in various continents, the consumers of most of the world's resources are in the developed countries in Europe and Nth America, The video shows how Europe and the USA have as much responsibility as the standard of living is higher so the impact on resources increases.

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 12 lety

    @Mike0Powell Standing room isn't really the issue. We also need land to grow food and absorb our waste (including trees to absorb carbon emissions). We're not the only beings on this planet--wildlife needs a home as well. There are countless social and health issues related to population growth as well--the problems aren't all environmental in nature.

  • @bertalafel3607
    @bertalafel3607 Před 20 dny

    Если эти такое видео и популяцией разных животных?

  • @hitssquad
    @hitssquad Před 10 lety

    Please show your math. Would you like to see mine?

  • @patrickpierre4075
    @patrickpierre4075 Před 3 lety

    The industrial revolution really set things in motion.

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 14 lety

    If you watch the video again, you'll see that the first dots to disappear are in China, followed by the dots in Europe.

  • @Lunaholic94
    @Lunaholic94 Před 11 lety

    wow i can't just believe this. comparing 1994 (when i was born) to 2013...

  • @1111hola
    @1111hola Před 11 lety

    How can property rights be enforced when there is no conciousness about the damage produced?
    In developing countries, the state does not enforce property rights, but the pops are ultra-concious about damage to the enviroment. Any kind of "progress" is opposed, like the build-up of factories, no matter how non-polluting they are claimed to be. In developed countries, factories go generally unopposed if someone claims them to be eco-friendly. And that is if it hasnt got inmediate notice effects.

  • @leonmacalister6555
    @leonmacalister6555 Před 11 lety

    No, they already enforce it in major cities like shanghai and beijing and are on of the only countries that enforce this rules

  • @thedodger2x
    @thedodger2x Před 13 lety

    @hop208 Let's plan for success and look at another desalinization plant, one built in Israel (Ashkelon Seawater Reverse Osmosis (SWRO) Plant ). The cost was much less at $212M. The plant's energy requirements is taken from a cleaner source, that is, natural gas to power turbine engines and not oil reserves. It is backed up by the national grid of Israel. It provides 13% of the country's consumer water demand. It has been sustaining operation since 2006. Let's keep pursuing this technology.

  • @nganbe4699
    @nganbe4699 Před 2 lety

    the video image is too poor, you need to fix it more

  • @mikesmith-st8mp
    @mikesmith-st8mp Před 11 lety

    The beating is the sound of humanity growing like wildfire, it will be unsettling when
    you can't walk because there are too many babies in your way!!

  • @jeff7037
    @jeff7037 Před 11 lety

    Australia is still a lonely place but it has the warm climate and plenty ground for plant and live.

  • @primevaltimes
    @primevaltimes Před 11 lety

    Colonization of other planets?

  • @Mr1797071
    @Mr1797071 Před 11 lety

    On the rocket ride to a population crash, then thermageddon, from overpopulation and pollution.

  • @PopulationConnection
    @PopulationConnection  Před 10 lety

    If you'd like some actual data to go with your opinions, check out the UN World Population Prospects database.

  • @BirbBoi8062
    @BirbBoi8062 Před 11 lety

    I think he means using science and the remaining resources to make artificial food when we run out of the real ones, or genetically engineer plants to meet the growing demands

  • @hitssquad
    @hitssquad Před 10 lety

    Earth has plenty of resources for a population of a trillion people sustained for millions of years.

  • @tuzzer
    @tuzzer Před 13 lety

    @populationconnection Factory farming is another thing. Organic farms are proven to be just as productive as, if not more, than those factory farms.
    What's happening right now is that some farms are actually abandoned because we can grow a whole magnitude more in the same patch of land than ever. Our productive growth exceeds our population growth.
    World hunger is a political issue, not because we are running out of food.

  • @eca1996
    @eca1996 Před 11 lety

    That isn't the problem, the problem is that people aren't dying.

  • @djeblihind8583
    @djeblihind8583 Před 10 lety

    And more people are still being born and moving in and at the same time some people die and population decreases

  • @DanielLaLiberte
    @DanielLaLiberte Před 14 lety

    We actually limit our growth to what is locally sustainable, not as if resources were infinite. Technological advances allow more growth, but we have been hiding the resource limitations. We need to instead expose the true costs, and then people will react appropriately.

  • @anubis432
    @anubis432 Před 11 lety

    and lets not forget something called the dinosaurs which are definitely proven to be older than 6,000 years

  • @eca1996
    @eca1996 Před 11 lety

    They didn't have advanced medicine back then or modern technology, that is why it wasn't so high.

  • @Ninjastripy
    @Ninjastripy Před 10 lety

    I think he meant that the Black Sea is missing (as is the Baltic and Caspian)

  • @curingaging00
    @curingaging00 Před 12 lety

    @ HenrSo whats wrong with living healthier longer lives? You have two options; Increase death rate or reduce birth rates, which is better? Today countries with the LOWEST life expectancy have the HIGHEST population growth while "healthy" countries like those in Europe and Japan have so much access to health yet some of their birth rates are below the replacement line. Clearly today pop growth is not related to Longer life, but rather, lack of access to contraception, Edu, and such.

  • @GretgorPooper
    @GretgorPooper Před 11 lety

    Oh do we? Is space mining a thing already?

  • @lilrog0909
    @lilrog0909 Před 12 lety

    @Assassin2036 Actually 7,015,988,747

  • @amorbenzagouta7425
    @amorbenzagouta7425 Před 6 lety

    the nile delta was empty? strange..

  • @theviking988
    @theviking988 Před 11 lety

    Why isn't the Baltic Sea visable on the map (its in northern europe)

  • @1100HondaCB
    @1100HondaCB Před 11 lety

    For about a thousand years before WWII, the population slowly increased and stayed between one and two billion, However, after WWII the population started to rise sharply and within the last 50 years, the population has increased by more than three fold. This is very concerning. What will it be like in 2112? There is a documentary about what the world would be like if the population reached 14 billion.

  • @katoyushiromitsu
    @katoyushiromitsu Před 12 lety +1

    @conjack2378 how is the ending political propaganda? We are running out of resources at an exponential rate

  • @CalabarSweetii
    @CalabarSweetii Před 11 lety

    i can't believe people were actually born in 1994.

  • @koseku3
    @koseku3 Před 8 lety +6

    WHERE İS BALTIC SEA, BLACK SEA, CASPIAN SEA?!

  • @AsianEmperor46
    @AsianEmperor46 Před 9 lety

    why is there suddenly 20+ dots in Northern Siberia in 1910 at 5:29?
    also, after the World Wars, the map got pretty unrealistic, should've used a different color dot to indicate 10 million people.

  • @mjshephe1
    @mjshephe1 Před 14 lety +3

    heyo, i helped make a dot

  • @tawfikk3594
    @tawfikk3594 Před 8 lety

    How many people was there in the world at 600?

    • @JustVisiting_
      @JustVisiting_ Před 8 lety

      +‫زمری د افغانستان‬‎ Seems legit

  • @MsBlackcrow25
    @MsBlackcrow25 Před 11 lety

    This video creeps me out

  • @SkyeVehr
    @SkyeVehr Před 13 lety

    Actually,what we are really going to do is grow our crops on aircrarft carrier sized boats in the ded zones of the sea. This will conserve land, give us a new place to gather water, allow us to conserve water with to-the-roots watering systems, create shadows in the sea thus contributing to the end of global warming,allow us to grow huge fuel supplies which triply end global warming with forest conservation, clean fuel and ocean shadows; and we can build artificial islands.

  • @Neueregel
    @Neueregel Před 12 lety

    @lordkickenwing thx

  • @freal
    @freal Před 11 lety

    You also can't see the Great Lakes in the U.S.

  • @Mint_Mochi
    @Mint_Mochi Před 11 lety

    Yeah we were supposed to run out of oil about 10 times now in the past century...
    But we haven't because we find ways to produce more out of the same areas that would be considered "dry" just like all resources. Something is only a resource when we have a use for it. There are many minerals and other things in the earth we can't access now but will in the future.

  • @dogchow33
    @dogchow33 Před 11 lety

    Does anyone find that beating unsettling besides me?

  • @dbmasta
    @dbmasta Před 11 lety

    If "balancing" isn't profitable, how can it be ideal? What is profit, if not an indicator of resourcefully converting inputs into relatively higher value outputs? Ironically, "balancing" isn't profitable because it's not resourceful. No state authority could ever know how to properly allocate millions of various resources among the masses. Only individuals engaging in free trade, through their combined knowledge, can come closest to properly "balancing" resources according to their values.

  • @AlternativePercuss
    @AlternativePercuss Před 11 lety

    VHEMT: "The Voluntary Human Extinction Movement" Just so people understand what the initials mean.

    • @theCosmicQueen
      @theCosmicQueen Před 3 lety

      hopefully it means those people will not reproduce themselves. is it worse than that?

  • @dbmasta
    @dbmasta Před 11 lety

    You're ignoring the fact that as supply gradually falls relative to demand, prices will gradually rise. As timberland gradually decreases in availability, it will become more expensive to acquire, making replanting more profitable. Also, there's nothing stopping "conscious" people from forming a fund to buy up this "cheap" land for preservation. I think that's great if people want to do that, but it's wrong to impose those values on everyone via conservation policy & the taxes that pay for it.