Star Wars Hot Takes you are not ready for

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 30. 04. 2022
  • Tell me your Hot Takes in the comments!
    Here are some Star Wars Hot Takes you might not be ready for. No matter if they are about Revenge of the Sith being overhyped or Rian Johnson being a good Film maker. Is The Last Jedi bad? Is Dave Filoni the Future of Star Wars? Here are some edgy and polarising opinions about Star Wars.
    Thanks to zanny for inspiring me to this Hot Takes video!
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 170

  • @meredithsmakings3068
    @meredithsmakings3068 Před 2 lety +91

    Second hot take: I love Ewan McGregor, but James Arnold Taylor was who made me adore Obi-Wan

  • @minicle426
    @minicle426 Před 2 lety +40

    The Sequel Trilogy for me simply devolved into a pissing contest between Johnson and Abrams.

  • @meredithsmakings3068
    @meredithsmakings3068 Před 2 lety +48

    Hot take: The Clone Wars is better than two of the three trilogies

    • @TheRogueOneYT
      @TheRogueOneYT  Před 2 lety +21

      is that really a hot take?

    • @ashtonlee265
      @ashtonlee265 Před 2 lety +6

      Nah you’ve just stated a fact

    • @jagothegamer5750
      @jagothegamer5750 Před 2 lety +9

      @@ashtonlee265 plot twist: It's a hot take because the trilogies he's referring to are the Original and Prequel trilogies.

    • @lucario4486
      @lucario4486 Před rokem +2

      three

    • @janvesely1087
      @janvesely1087 Před rokem +2

      I'd say it's better than all three of them.

  • @taylornoel9169
    @taylornoel9169 Před 2 lety +73

    I don't know if this is necessarily a hot take, but, Padme didn't die of a broken heart.
    Palpatine took her life force so that Anakin would survive until Vaders suit was on him.

    • @sunanimoon
      @sunanimoon Před 2 lety +22

      even if this isnt *technically* true or whatever, i like this explanation better than the "broken heart" one. i always hated that ending for padme

    • @TheRogueOneYT
      @TheRogueOneYT  Před 2 lety +22

      i think this is actually Canon whatsoever

    • @DeepFriedKangaroo2
      @DeepFriedKangaroo2 Před 2 lety +1

      She didn't die from a broken heart, she died from a broken trachea.

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +1

      Well, death by heartbreak was mostly true. You can’t die of a broken heart, but you can lose any will to live. Without that, almost anything can kill you.

    • @beniscurious6762
      @beniscurious6762 Před 2 lety

      Nah she died of disappointment because she was present yet never witnessed the mustafar duel.

  • @wxl2562
    @wxl2562 Před 2 lety +40

    Here's a take; not a hot one, just a take:
    Star Wars literally could have ended with the first movie, later titled as "A New Hope" and later deemed Episode 4 in the series.
    It could have perfectly ended with that first movie and George Lucas could have moved on to other projects and that'd be okay.
    No extended lore, no comics, no books, no spin-offs, video games, TV show, cartoons. None of that, just imagine, all you had to work with was your imagination and what was seen in that first film. No explanations as to what the Clone Wars was, how the Force worked, never confirming that Darth Vader was really Luke Skywalker's father, not being told Leia was his sister.
    Just being left to believe that Darth Vader and Palpatine were defeated, the galaxy was saved and everyone would go on about their lives in space.
    Now it's just a bloody mess and I love it.

    • @supralytic
      @supralytic Před 2 lety +6

      sociopathic but i like it

    • @NotReal-187
      @NotReal-187 Před 2 lety +6

      I think It would have been forgotten about in a couple of years if that were the case

    • @AbsoluteBeta
      @AbsoluteBeta Před 2 lety +9

      @@NotReal-187 No, not entirely, a large amount of film critics of the time could barely describe what they saw in theaters, some called it an out of body experience, it definitely would have been remembered as a classic and as the definitive first blockbuster movie.

    • @56jklove
      @56jklove Před rokem

      @@AbsoluteBeta yes it would

    • @56jklove
      @56jklove Před rokem

      No clue the lore is really good and the world of star wars is awesome.

  • @sunanimoon
    @sunanimoon Před 2 lety +59

    "not everyone in the galaxy should be related" is a thing rian tried to establish in tlj (and you can question the effectiveness of that attempt) but jj went back on it.
    that being said though, with what we were working with in ros, i dont actually hate the "rey skywalker" thing. in universe for rey's character, i think it makes sense. she didn't need anyone, but she found people who loved her and took that name. family is the people you choose and all that.

    • @nora7631
      @nora7631 Před 2 lety +2

      SAME omg everyone gets so upset over "rey skywalker" because "wahmen doesn't deserve luke's name >:(" but i think its a pretty good conclusion to her character, finally finding where she belongs

    • @jacobsims1175
      @jacobsims1175 Před 2 lety +7

      @@nora7631 it’s not “wahmen doesn’t deserve his name”, don’t make it a sexism thing, most people hate it because it’s not great writing.
      that said, i agree with OP in that family is who you choose

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +2

      @@nora7631 you seem way too happy to find someone that agrees with you and also has a brain so they can do the thinking and argue for you.

  • @spencej05
    @spencej05 Před 2 lety +20

    he grew up on the sandy planet of Tatooine, so it’s perfectly reasonable for the guy to not like sand 💀

    • @wxl2562
      @wxl2562 Před 2 lety +7

      I never got the meme because I read some of the books, I think its explained pretty well as to why he doesn't like sand.
      The line "I don't like sand" just sounds corny without the explanation though. He doesn't like sand because it reminds him that he was born as a slave, raised by his mother without his father around or any form of father figure, the senseless murder, thievery and crime that's an on-going problem in Tatooine, which he had to witness as a small child. The bandits, lack of security and protection, illegal trading. The list goes on and was well explained in all other forms of Star Wars media, but in Attack of the Clones, it was just narrowed down to "I don't like it"
      Which I guess is a hot take in itself;
      Tatooine, despite being a fan favorite planet in the series, but also one of the most dull and uninspired looking, has the best writing and background revolving around its history, ecosystem and agriculture, but is arguably one of the worst planets you could live on and Anakin has every right to remind others about how big of a shithole it was.

    • @spencej05
      @spencej05 Před 2 lety +2

      @@wxl2562 this guy gets it

    • @JC-cn9yj
      @JC-cn9yj Před 2 lety

      @@wxl2562 the issue is all these books were written after backlash against the line, because there was no context for the poor delivery. Not against Hayden, it’s a weird line to deliver

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem +1

      @@spencej05 I know it too but I tried to explain it to everyone and they will still call me crazy.

  • @NotReal-187
    @NotReal-187 Před 2 lety +5

    Clone Wars' Battle Droids are the best comedic element in the entire series.

  • @slendercorn46
    @slendercorn46 Před 2 lety +37

    Unlogical writing is the sequel trilogy's second name

    • @FoxCoffee.
      @FoxCoffee. Před 2 lety +9

      That's literally the coldest take possible.

    • @st.michaelsknight6299
      @st.michaelsknight6299 Před 2 lety

      Actually the prequels are great, they just suffer from some bad dialogue, and the fact that anakins character is supposed to a stupid awkward teen.

    • @persoonophetweb2891
      @persoonophetweb2891 Před 2 lety +2

      @@st.michaelsknight6299 “some”

    • @cash5512
      @cash5512 Před rokem

      @@st.michaelsknight6299 I guess you're just going to ignore the fact that it failed at its only task to do and needed a 7 season long tv show to fill all the gaps...

  • @FATMAN_tactical
    @FATMAN_tactical Před 2 lety +12

    Hot take
    Mesa likea jar jar binks

  • @hlmorfeld4499
    @hlmorfeld4499 Před 2 lety +7

    Another thing with Phantom Menace is that apparently Padme is fourteen years old, which in and of itself is par for the course with monarchies, but then in Attack of the Clones it's revealed that the queen of Naboo is an elected position? Who the hell is electing a fourteen year old to lead an ENTIRE planet. Also in Attack of the Clones Anakin is creepy af, Padme tells him to not put the moves on her and he's like "pfft oh well, guess I'm a trailblazer" and then we're just supposed to believe they have this beautiful romance?

  • @minecrafter3448
    @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +7

    For a while, attack of the clones was my favorite Star Wars movie. I’ll never forget the moment when mace windu marched up and put his lightsaber to the neck of jango fett, and then give the signal to 400 other Jedi around an enormous stadium. Then a huge battle that went back and forth between separatists and droids, to the republic, Jedi, and clones. It didn’t feel like a fan service. It showed every angle to make it feel like as though the republic had an edge, there was still a high chance that they lost.

  • @dylant400
    @dylant400 Před 2 lety +10

    the sequels just aren’t that bad

  • @dirtyboyzproductions6373
    @dirtyboyzproductions6373 Před 2 lety +13

    Respectfully agree with all these except the Kenobi one. You knew people had to say something about that lol.

  • @megasoniczx6960
    @megasoniczx6960 Před 2 lety +13

    The Inhibitor Chips in the Clones is not a poor/lazy writing choice TCW made. It's both a necessary evil to how well-fleshed out the Clones had become as characters, thus needing something like the chips to help explain why certain Clones turned on their Jedi without question after everything TCW showed them going through together, but taking away the free will of the Clones also adds to the tragedy of Order 66 as it shows how Palpatine viewed the Clones and Droids as one in the same. To him, they were both disposable armies, while the Clones saw themselves as unique induvials, something even the Jedi saw.

    • @michaelstark8720
      @michaelstark8720 Před rokem +1

      it was done better in Clone war multimedia where clones knew that they will betray jedi. Go listen battlefront 2 rise of the empire storyline. far better than TCW. only movie canon clone wars are those from 2003 and multimedia around it. TCW 2008 sucks and makes no sense.

    • @megasoniczx6960
      @megasoniczx6960 Před rokem

      @@michaelstark8720 Guess what? I have played BF2. I own the game. And yes, how it depects Order 66 is great. That doesn't mean TCW is bad. They're good for their own reasons, and preferring one doesn't make the other nonsensical or "bad".

    • @michaelstark8720
      @michaelstark8720 Před rokem

      @@megasoniczx6960 OK for you. I played bf2 also, still own copy and i like Clone Wars multimedia version far more. Personally i hate TCW animation style and nobody apart of Obi Wan and Grievous looks like their movie counterparts. Dooku was depicted criminally bad. They should made animation similar to The Old Republic trailers. They had ability to do that because they did pretty good animation for cutscenes in Force Unleashed games. Also Grievous was turned from feared jedi killer to just a villain who escape and was beaten by kids. Also his coughing happened just before ep3 when he had encounter with Windu on Coruscant. In TCW he cough because that is his recognizable trait just like Lando had yellow shirt in Solo because he wore that same color in TESB so that was Lando's trait. I hate when shows do things like that.

  • @aiviloo00
    @aiviloo00 Před 2 lety +24

    hot take: prequels had a good story delivered bad, if they make the lines less cheesy it would've been the best, sequels had a bad story delivered well, just fix the story
    another hot take: sequels had such a good chance to be so good, but it just missed. also the last jedi imo was the best because rey wasnt a mary sue and the visuals are amazing

    • @queenofdogs01
      @queenofdogs01 Před 2 lety +2

      The sequels are what I call a senseless spectacle

    • @moistsparky9733
      @moistsparky9733 Před 2 lety +3

      I agree

    • @56jklove
      @56jklove Před rokem +2

      @Fernando Muñoz the sequels didn't have a good story the prequels had one but it was badly executed.

    • @cash5512
      @cash5512 Před rokem

      The prequels failed completely, in the sense of failing to do what it was created for. Trust me, the story of _only_ the 3 movies isn't good. They had to come up with a 7 season long tv show to fill all the gaps.

  • @Jxwall88
    @Jxwall88 Před 2 lety +35

    Hot take. Clone wars is the best piece of Star Wars and generally makes the prequels better

    • @RianReview123
      @RianReview123 Před 2 lety +11

      This is the most generic take of them all bruh...I do agree tho, Clone Wars rules

    • @queenofdogs01
      @queenofdogs01 Před 2 lety +1

      Not a hot take

    • @cash5512
      @cash5512 Před rokem

      Especially the last part should be common knowledge

    • @joedahippie9202
      @joedahippie9202 Před rokem

      ice cold take

  • @Queldonus
    @Queldonus Před 2 lety +5

    My hot take: the Last Jedi would be a good movie if it had nothing to do with Star Wars. Every problem I have with the movie, every problem I have heard anyone have with the movie, is removed or minimized if the movie were a totally different Sci-Fi setting that happens to have a similar feel to Star Wars.

    • @TheRogueOneYT
      @TheRogueOneYT  Před 2 lety

      Never heard anything about TLJ that is so relateable... if it was Star Trek, it would be the best... but in Star Wars, it destroyed too much Lore

  • @vlonelookkilla
    @vlonelookkilla Před 2 lety +6

    Kylo Ren is my favorite dark side user. (Although he's not necessarily the best one)

  • @Brawl-eg1kz
    @Brawl-eg1kz Před rokem +2

    Anakins lightsaber isn't his, it belongs to General Grievous!

  • @amysunday0
    @amysunday0 Před 2 lety +3

    I always love randomly finding a fellow german on the internet lmao

    • @martinruppenstein8945
      @martinruppenstein8945 Před rokem

      Er ist Österreicher, aber wen juckts.
      Sorry, dass ich nen riesen Stock im Arsch hab und Leute, die vor 9 Monaten auf irgendnem Video kommentiert haben auf so etwas unnötiges berichtigen muss
      Falls du das trotzdem liest, schönen Tag dir noch

  • @thatmangoman
    @thatmangoman Před 2 lety +9

    Honestly im ok with these hot takes

  • @oteri_
    @oteri_ Před 2 lety +2

    i want a solo sequel / standalone maul movie detailing his fall from being the leader of crimson dawn

  • @endman105
    @endman105 Před 2 lety +2

    Here's a hot take, the more star wars continues with content in the prequel and imperial era, the more unnecessarily smart, competent and sometimes dumb the emperor becomes. The recent comics showed that Palpatine was planning and building his sith fleet on exogul months, years even before RTJ took place, if he cared about the empire he could've deployed the fleet early and wiped out the rebel alliance with star destroyers WITH PLANET KILLING WEAPONS!!

  • @pikpikgamer1012
    @pikpikgamer1012 Před 2 lety +5

    IM SO WITH YOU!!!
    SOLO WASNT THAT BAD!!!!

  • @optillian4182
    @optillian4182 Před rokem +1

    My own takes:
    The Hyperspace ramming scene is a brilliant use of the Hyperdrive.
    The way Prequel fanboys complain about "memberberries" to the OT, yet cream themselves whenever Duel of the Fates is played is pathetic and blatantly hypocritical.
    Much of the old canon sucks and I'm glad that we won't ever see it again.
    We need an alien protagonist.

  • @IARESMART8
    @IARESMART8 Před 2 lety +9

    Hot take: Rey is a good character and she gets too much hate

    • @thegoodreylo4749
      @thegoodreylo4749 Před 2 lety +1

      She’s my favorite character

    • @3DInnovations70
      @3DInnovations70 Před rokem +3

      Yeah I think her lightsaber is cool especially what it means

    • @martinruppenstein8945
      @martinruppenstein8945 Před rokem +2

      She's good and I also don't hate the sequels, but the problem manny had with her is just her not having any character growth or developement similar to Luke or Ahsoka etc.
      While they were learning from their mistakes and actions Rey always did everything right, saved everyone without even facing minor consequences
      Still love Rey and Daisy Ridley as her actress tho and she could've become a great star wars character next to Anakin, Luke etc., but due to the reasons I listed (and maybe smth else idk just my POV) she became an overhated star wars Protagonist of an already overhated Trilogy tbh

  • @nyx8823
    @nyx8823 Před 2 lety +3

    "Revenge of The Sith is overhyped and not as good as you remember it"
    Ok. Closing video

    • @thenamelessone528
      @thenamelessone528 Před 2 lety +2

      Did you not read the title of the video? It's "Star Wars Hot Takes you are not ready for"
      It seems you weren't ready for them

    • @3DInnovations70
      @3DInnovations70 Před rokem +1

      I mean it really is at times it’s just blatantly stupid

  • @rebelfriend42yearsago34
    @rebelfriend42yearsago34 Před 2 lety +8

    folks realy oughta shut up about the sequels, they happened, they sucked, move on

  • @burakbeyy216
    @burakbeyy216 Před 9 měsíci

    "Obi-Wan is overrated" I was so ready xD

  • @adog8524
    @adog8524 Před rokem +1

    Hot take: I think the only good things that came out of the sequel trilogy was the first order and the BB series astromech droid

  • @thatguybob6088
    @thatguybob6088 Před 2 lety +4

    Your prequel hot takes I disagree with a fair amount, but Last Jedi being the most visually pleasing movie is something I've been saying since it came out. I personally think it's the best Sequel move, and Rian Johnson is a good director, while JJ Abrams is a hack. Look at their other work

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem

      Are you disagreeing with him because you think that the prequels are as bad as people say?

    • @thatguybob6088
      @thatguybob6088 Před rokem

      @@prequeldefender 10 months later I don't remember the video contents lmao. Prequels are goated is my take, Phantom is a fun adventure, AOTC big battles but shit writing, Revenge Top Tier.

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem

      @@thatguybob6088 I totally respect it but I think that Phantom is not really good because of some pacing issues and Clones and Revenge are great solid films.

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem

      @@thatguybob6088 I rank them 3,2,1.

  • @Red-hs2gl
    @Red-hs2gl Před 2 lety +1

    I think the reason that mando and luke had their own episodes in boba's show is because the writers ran out of stuff for Boba to do

  • @Error-bo5kg
    @Error-bo5kg Před 2 lety +3

    rebels is underrated but had a poor start
    its good Disney yeeted the old canon to make it legends and start from nearly 0
    the sequels are good movies but a bad trilogy. which is the complete opposite to the prequels
    the original trilogy is overrated
    the holdo "crash your ship in lightspeed" tactic isnt that bad if u give it a further explanation instead of saying "it was 1 in a million" just to show the same thing in the same movie (Ros ship over Endor)
    Finn got wasted

  • @dybo3793
    @dybo3793 Před 10 měsíci

    I also personally don’t like TPM, and I’m fine with AOTC, but not because of the story, but because of the memes. I do still think that ROTS is a cinematic masterpiece and definitely deserve at least one cult though.

  • @deathsquad8891
    @deathsquad8891 Před rokem

    Alternative title: Rogue Edits showing his powers of 🧢 and cringe for 4:42

  • @kierandixon7236
    @kierandixon7236 Před 2 lety +2

    the jedi deserved to be destroyed. but definitely not the younglings

  • @minecrafter3448
    @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +1

    Hot take: Star Wars rebels was a great show, it was just overly ambitious and fell short of what it promised.

  • @thegoodreylo4749
    @thegoodreylo4749 Před 2 lety +1

    I have so many hot takes for both Marvel and Star Wars that they honestly outnumber the Grand Army of the Republic, so I’ll just hit you all with my Star Wars ranking…
    1. The Last Jedi
    2. The Force Awakens
    3. The Empire Strikes Back
    4. Star Wars
    5. Solo
    And the rest are just… I don’t like ranking movies I dislike

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem

      What about Rogue One? Why do you dislike it?

    • @thegoodreylo4749
      @thegoodreylo4749 Před rokem

      @@prequeldefender It doesn’t develop it’s characters before throwing in all the fan service and killing them off.

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem +1

      @@thegoodreylo4749 understandable. I don’t like it as much either.

  • @queenofdogs01
    @queenofdogs01 Před 2 lety +4

    I agree with all of these wut
    Hot take: Rebels in a lot of cases can be better than Clone Wars. They have similarly spectacular and emotional highs, but the Clone Wars had more plummeting lows than Rebels did

  • @CadeLand011
    @CadeLand011 Před rokem

    I love this man's videos. The prequels were just for the most part a wholesome experience with a cool vision. And super awesome feminine and masculine characters with strong villains and emotional scenes.

  • @MarcanMC
    @MarcanMC Před rokem

    Hot take: I like Rex more in rebels than in clone wars

  • @mary2800
    @mary2800 Před rokem

    Hot take: some people hate the prequels but they made star wars 90% more fun. Also Ahsoka is the best character. Trust me I'm 1000% based about Ahsoka LOL joking, but thats my opinion.

  • @SmallKingCrab
    @SmallKingCrab Před rokem

    yeah i can agree with most of the-
    "obi wan is overrated"
    and thus begins the 1 year long response post

  • @romram7984
    @romram7984 Před rokem

    Honestly it could just be because I grew up with them, but I've always liked the prequels and happily watch them whenever someone asks me to. I think with the sequels it's less about bad writing for me and more I think they could have done better than rehash the first 3 movies (4-6) and mandalorian, solo, and rogue one show they can make a story if they try. It's just with the sequels they seemed to enjoy killing the characters I actually liked for their not likable characters. And Rei being able to beat Kylo first try will always be the worst star wars scene for me, no contest

  • @Gamegedon.900
    @Gamegedon.900 Před měsícem

    here's my hottest take: a new hope is very overrated and luke in that movie kinda annoys me.
    my second hottest: the sequels are good, and last jedi is the best of them, and rise of skywalker is very good, just a 5/10 because of the amount of plot conveniences and nostalgia tripping.
    here's my third hottest take: the prequels are consistently good, and revenge of the sith is near perfect. [please note i said near]
    and finally: i'm EXTREMLY happy Luke and Leia are twins, because if they were shipped it would make han and leia developing a cute romance in empire feel extremly pointless because it would have wasted a small scale of the movie.

  • @TrashyKings
    @TrashyKings Před 2 lety

    I agree on alot of these, but trying to cover up TST''s bad writing with showing off The Prequels isnt a great argument, its just two movies with bad writing.

  • @asswhip
    @asswhip Před 2 lety +1

    Half of the hot takes in the comments are colder than a month old corpse

    • @seansmith6255
      @seansmith6255 Před 7 měsíci

      Jokes on you
      In one month that corpse Is getting cremated

  • @pastaphilias
    @pastaphilias Před 2 lety +1

    1:06 wrong, babu frik is the best

  • @theoneaboveall4533
    @theoneaboveall4533 Před 2 lety +8

    I do have to disagree with you on the “sequels did not ruin Star Wars.” Technically, as long as you ignore them and pretend they aren’t canon, they won’t really ruin it. But due to the fact that Disney forces them to be canon, it’s usually not possible to simply avoid the Sequels anymore. So much lore and story was essentially invalidated by the Sequels.

  • @themachodolphin7565
    @themachodolphin7565 Před 2 lety +1

    Hot take: if your favorite Star Wars movie isn’t Revenge of the Sith, then your opinion is meaningless
    Not salty because it was mentioned, I’ve been thinking about it for a while

    • @thegoodreylo4749
      @thegoodreylo4749 Před 2 lety +1

      Thanks… it’s one of my least favorite Star Wars movies of all time

    • @3DInnovations70
      @3DInnovations70 Před rokem

      That’s not a hot take it’s just being an annoying fan

  • @prequeldefender
    @prequeldefender Před rokem

    Don’t worry, I see ROTS ranked as the 3rd worst Star Wars movie before.

  • @seansmith6255
    @seansmith6255 Před 7 měsíci

    My favorite prequel is attack of the clones

  • @minecrafter3448
    @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety

    My ranking of the Star Wars movies: (everything is controversial)
    11. Rise of skywalker
    10: the last Jedi
    9: return of the Jedi
    8: attack of the clones
    7: the phantom menace
    6: a new hope
    5: solo
    4: the force awakens
    3: empire strikes back
    2: revenge of the sith
    1: rogue one

    • @TheRogueOneYT
      @TheRogueOneYT  Před 2 lety

      Nr1 Nice try bro

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety

      @@TheRogueOneYT actually that really is my favorite Star Wars movie I didn’t notice your channel name🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @ayankhanayankhan2012
    @ayankhanayankhan2012 Před rokem +1

    My Hot Takes
    1. Prequel Trilogy > Original Trilogy
    2. Return Of The Jedi is better then Episode IV
    3. Kenobi was Meh
    4. Yoda Vs Palpatine is one of the best duels
    5. Episode 1,2 & 3 are well written and could be improved with 4 BIG Fixes
    6. Clone Wars Movie is not that bad
    7. The Originals without the Prequels are basically nothing but cheesy fun space movies theyre not masterpieces or the best things ever
    8. The New Lego Star Wars game was Boring and Disappointing

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem

      1. Agree
      2. Eh, they’re both really good
      3. Agree
      4. Definitely agree
      5. Kinda disagree, I think they don’t really need big fixing. They need to be understood more.
      6. Agree
      7. Disagree. They are not just “cheesy space movies” but they are a 6-act tragic melodrama about human relationships and family. It’s about saving what we love and not fighting what we hate. They are masterpieces but definitely not the best things ever.
      8. Definitely agree. The Complete Saga, even thought the graphics are very dated is more interesting and better.

  • @popdop0074
    @popdop0074 Před 2 lety +1

    Hot take: I agree with nearly all of these

  • @56jklove
    @56jklove Před rokem +1

    Hot take while the prequels do mirror some scenes of the originals, they are the most original and the best of star wars, when it comes to lore and worldbuilding. Hot take 2, empire strikes back is kinda of overrated, and return of the jedi is the best of the original trilogy. The kenobi show is the best star wars show, and darth vader is at his best In the show, while in the original trilogy vader is only good in empire. Attack of the clones has the most interesting story and the prequels aren't bad they are decent movies.

    • @TheRogueOneYT
      @TheRogueOneYT  Před rokem

      Agree on many of them but ROTJ was not the best oft the OT

    • @56jklove
      @56jklove Před rokem

      @@TheRogueOneYT I do see why empire is rated high and it's a great movie, but return has the conclusion that wraps up everything, we see luke as a jedi knight, we get the name of anakin skywalker, we find out that leai is Luke's sister. Jabbas palace and the throne room scene is great. I'll give the ewoks, but they didn't bother me as much.

  • @felipesalvatierra805
    @felipesalvatierra805 Před 2 lety +1

    Cad Bane is a very plain and boring character. Fight me!

  • @Happysecret180
    @Happysecret180 Před 7 měsíci

    Hot take: The old republic era is overrated

  • @TheDan744
    @TheDan744 Před 2 lety

    I like Solo, but it's got the worst cinematography and lighting out of all the Star Wars movies and shows

  • @Abegilr_Dragonrider
    @Abegilr_Dragonrider Před 2 lety +3

    Hot take: Star Wars has grown too much and is now collapsing on itself. Like a star at the end of it's lifetime.

  • @scottthomas8475
    @scottthomas8475 Před 2 lety +4

    Hot take from a Star Wars fan: the whole franchise is kinda bullshit and the writing can be really lazy, when there’s no explanation for something they just fill it in, I get that they can but the amount of videos on ‘why blah blah blah didn’t just do this’, or ‘why this worked’ just shows how little thought went into the story from its beginning and it’s still trying to make up for it

  • @ivanoo507
    @ivanoo507 Před 2 lety

    I'm joking for the record

  • @CadeLand011
    @CadeLand011 Před rokem

    That was the worst opinion I've heard though saying the SEQUELS did not ruin the series and are canon. They are definitely NOT canon.

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem +1

      Here is a better take. All the legends do not deserve to be considered canon.

  • @tingedfaune
    @tingedfaune Před 10 měsíci

    What about Star Wars rebels?

  • @Evanr_
    @Evanr_ Před 2 lety

    Sorry, but the movie Solo broke the time line by showing dearth mall alive and not halved yet, Solo being like in late 20s-early 30s and at the time of darth mall not being halved, Anakin was like really young. So how is it ok for Laia and Han to be a couple?!?

    • @davity9000
      @davity9000 Před 2 lety

      Clone wars is canon

    • @Evanr_
      @Evanr_ Před 2 lety

      @@davity9000 but then Darth Mall got killed for real years later by Obiwan right?

    • @Evanr_
      @Evanr_ Před 2 lety

      @@davity9000 besides that event at the end of Solo is supposed to be before he gets halved

    • @thegoodreylo4749
      @thegoodreylo4749 Před 2 lety +1

      @@Evanr_ Solo takes place way before that

  • @michaelstark8720
    @michaelstark8720 Před rokem

    Revenge of the sith is best Star Wars. TESB is worst of original six with only Vader scenes good while rest hiding in asteroids and Luke training in the swamp. TESB should show much more universe like ep2 did and plot should have been Leia gathering support for rebel alliance but instead we got them hiding in asteroid field

  • @sailorfox4548
    @sailorfox4548 Před rokem +1

    a new hope is way overyhyped i dont like the mandalorin i think its trash and grogu is not cute hes ugly i like book of boba feat

  • @hellomax9511
    @hellomax9511 Před 2 lety +2

    Hey

  • @smobblkop
    @smobblkop Před 2 lety +2

    Here are some of mine:
    The Prequels are overrated and the Sequels are overhated
    In comparison with the Sequels, the Prequels are the worse films (except Ep.3 ofc)
    The OT are the best directed movies of all of them
    Disney destroyed Boba Fett as a character
    You only like Mando S2 for the Cameos, not the show itself
    The Clone Wars S7 is only fan service
    The Sequels are not even that bad (they had MUCH wasted potential though)
    The Book Of Boba Fett is a terrible show
    You don't want to see original stories with new characters
    The entire Legends storyline is not canon, neither are deleted episodes (therefore we don't know how Boba got the dent in his helmet)
    The Martez sisters aren't as bad as you think
    Rose Tico wasn't a bad character, she just didn't work, because Finn didn't work, whose counterpart she was supposed to be (seriously, stop blaming the actress)
    Maul vs Obi-Wan And Qui-Gon isn't a good choreography, as you can see that it is a choreography and not an actual fight
    You don't like the Prequels, you only like the memes and Ep.3
    The final episode of Book Of Boba Fett is the worst piece of Star Wars we have ever gotten
    I like Episode 4 and 5 more than everything else we ever got to see from Star Wars

    • @jd1800
      @jd1800 Před 2 lety

      Some of these are hot but TBH I think your Book of Boba Fett takes range from cold to lukewarm.

    • @smobblkop
      @smobblkop Před 2 lety +1

      @@jd1800 Also kinda true

    • @st.michaelsknight6299
      @st.michaelsknight6299 Před 2 lety

      The Prequels are overrated and the Sequels are overhated
      No. The prequels are good movies that just suffer from bad dalogue writing. The sequels are visionless produced for mass consumption shit with no artistic merit as a whole.
      The OT are the best directed movies of all of them
      Agreed, but then EP. 5 is up there for some of the best directing ever.
      The Clone Wars S7 is only fan service
      You don't know what fan service is then. Clone wars s7 was fantastic.
      The Sequels are not even that bad (they had MUCH wasted potential though)
      Yes they really are that bad. Hack film makers, shit acting, schizophrenic directing.
      You don't want to see original stories with new characters
      WHAT? No thats what people are literally starving for. Just we are in a cultural decline and it has been very difficult to get original things made.
      The entire Legends storyline is not canon, neither are deleted episodes (therefore we don't know how Boba got the dent in his helmet)
      Sadly
      The Martez sisters aren't as bad as you think
      I actually liked that arc, as it gave a look at how the working poor of galaxy live and see the jedi
      Rose Tico wasn't a bad character, she just didn't work, because Finn didn't work, whose counterpart she was supposed to be (seriously, stop blaming the actress)
      Your right finn doesnt really work. However rose's character was basically just a blatant insert to push the film in china. Basically badly written chinese fan service.
      Maul vs Obi-Wan And Qui-Gon isn't a good choreography, as you can see that it is a choreography and not an actual fight
      It's amazing because it uses the fight to tell a sotry, without needing words, and its great. Like for one it shows us just how much like later anakin Obi wan is.
      You don't like the Prequels, you only like the memes and Ep.3
      I actually do like the prequels and ep 2 is my favorite.

    • @hmx8694
      @hmx8694 Před rokem

      @@st.michaelsknight6299 Sequels had bad acting and directing? Seriously? Go back and watch some of the shots in TLJ, especially the salt planet climax. Say what you want about Rian's writing but he knows how to work a camera and is the farthest thing from a hack possible. And literally every single actor gave their all in the trilogy, you don't get ever get the impression that they're fake or anything. Opinions are fine but you are literally misrepresenting them to fuel your bias.

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem

      1. Since the prequels still get a lot of hate today, I’m sorry that I have to disagree with the first one but it’s totally valid. However I have to agree with the fact that the sequels are overhated.
      2. Strongly disagree.
      3. That’s not unpopular.
      4. I would have to disagree because Disney did not ruin him. IMO Boba Fett is originally not a good character either.
      5. Strongly disagree.
      6. Strongly disagree.
      7. Agree.
      8. Agree.
      9. Strongly agree.
      10. I agree with the fact that you should stop blaming the actress because she is fucking amazing. But the character, eh, probably disagree (just a little bit)
      11. Disagree
      12. No.
      13. Not sure since I haven’t watched all the episodes yet.
      14. The best from SW is KOTOR II.

  • @KadenJ-ie1ji
    @KadenJ-ie1ji Před 9 měsíci

    The Force Awakens is better than A New Hope and Revenge of the Sith is as good as Empire Strikes Back.

  • @Geezyprod
    @Geezyprod Před měsícem

    Ok I’ll give you that obi wan is overrated, it’s just the actors are *the greatest in the saga* (my opinion)

  • @aaronrollins835
    @aaronrollins835 Před 2 lety

    Tcw animated series is overated I love it but definitely a lot of nostalgia talking, though the story telling is pretty good the animation is odd and a little bad for the time

  • @thereal_itsmehere
    @thereal_itsmehere Před 2 lety +1

    Why is your channel name oddly similar to the worst movie ever?

  • @arayannaidoo1924
    @arayannaidoo1924 Před 2 lety +2

    The rise of Skywalker was a good movie, not perfect but enjoyable and saved the sequels for me

    • @jacobsims1175
      @jacobsims1175 Před 2 lety +3

      i’d argue that it’s the worst, but to each their own

  • @iownornot1
    @iownornot1 Před 2 lety +1

    star wars is meh overall.

  • @gemstonegojira24
    @gemstonegojira24 Před 2 lety +3

    Star Wars Rebels Sucked

  • @minecrafter3448
    @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety

    0:43 is this scene supposed to prove that they prequels were mediocre? It doesn’t. This is two people that trained for months for their role and this fight going ham against each other. Of course we have a predetermined winner, but they were both trying their absolute best to really sell it.

  • @FoxCoffee.
    @FoxCoffee. Před 2 lety +11

    Hot take: Most of the Sequels (7, 8) are better than most of the Prequels (1, 2).

    • @swausgebouwen143
      @swausgebouwen143 Před 2 lety +9

      What the fuck? No

    • @Jxwall88
      @Jxwall88 Před 2 lety +5

      Nah ya lost me lmao

    • @thegoodreylo4749
      @thegoodreylo4749 Před 2 lety +1

      I mean 7 and 8 are the best and 1 and 2 are the worst

    • @hmx8694
      @hmx8694 Před rokem

      @@swausgebouwen143 Lol they're both bad for different reasons dude. One's boring, one's frustrating. Prequels have the clone wars making them better in retrospect which is an unfair advantage.

    • @prequeldefender
      @prequeldefender Před rokem +1

      @@thegoodreylo4749 that’s fair.

  • @ScoptOriginal
    @ScoptOriginal Před 2 lety

    A New Hope is shit, it has the worst pacing of any movie I've ever seen and everything that happens in it is inconsequential, though it is the best, and does have the most important events in all the original trilogy.