Is History The New Battleground? | Arth - A Culture Fest, Kolkata
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 01. 2020
- Meenakshi Jain and Amal Mukhopadhyay engage in a captivating conversation with festival director Vikram Sampath discussing the times, leaving us wondering 'Is History the New Battleground?' at Arth - A Culture Fest, Kolkata powered by Mongia Steel Limited & Special Partner Future Gaming Sikkim Dear
*Lottery ticket will be available for sale in West Bengal, Maharashtra, Punjab and in states where sale of lottery is permitted. - Zábava
It's always nice to hear meenakshi ji. She is a gem. She should be given responsibility to re write our history in correct way,.lots of respect for you mam.
16:45.....hearing this i suddenly realized that people who were living in ayodhiya during ram mandir demolition were left there with a mosque( babri masjid) and they couldn't go inside the mosque
but they still worshiped lord ram outside the masjid wall....
I got goosebumps thinking about their devotion....
As a Bengali, I felt shame after hearing Mr Arun.He was misleading people by using Bengali literature. This type of mindset has destroyed West Bengal and entire India with Congress. Some time I think Swami Vivekananda's view point about Marxist is universal truth, He said "Marxist should have been more educated".
The Marxist have dominated and destroyed Bengal. They have also tried to destroy Swamiji, Rabindra nath and many others.
But madam minakshi tell that they where no sathi pratha in Bengal bjp people are abusing ram mohon Roy
मीनाक्षी जी बहुत असाधारण प्रतिभा एवम व्यक्तित्व की धनी महिला हैं... 💐👏👏🙌
#28:57 Vikram's Expression won my HEART .
Oldman is part of the problem in history writing.
Desh me sab nanga si baktho ke papa changa si 😂
The lady speaker Meenakshi Jain spoke what the discussion demanded of her... the other person just rambled and was not even clear in his articulation - most irritating expostulation... suits the people of his state perhaps... quite representative at that!
Let us have more speakers who speak like the lady... and keep track of the time we spend listening to such talks... one half of it has been a total waste...
We don't care of you hindi Patti she is bjp rss stooge
The best and open literary festival.
it seems to be as if meenakshi jain has real and authentic point of views. what she is talking about is what she actually found as it was. the bengali guy is only summarizing western point of views and worse than that he is talking about communist point of views.
Because he was vice chancellor of Calcutta university during cpm rule and appointed by cpm.
She is bjp propoganda women
@@gauravdey4163 you are a propaganda women you laughable joke. when we have real academians like meenakshi jain, ppl like you come around to talk shit.
@@gauravdey4163how you idiot...
She told truth...She is not making story like Bengali guy...she quoted what she has found
Meenaksh nice
She is lying she doesn't know sathi Partha she is insulting ram mohan Roy
Absolute coherence and absolute incoherence on either side of Vikram Sampath😊😊
Kudos to Meenakshiji !
From when Arun Shourie has become an eminent historian, he is just a journalist
wvfsd070 listen 👂 carefully before reacting. It is the name of a book 📖 that AS had written.
The anchor didn't say Arun Shourie was an eminent historian, he wrote a book named 'Eminent Historians of India'.
History replaced by UPA produced kahnyakumars ,and Asiya ghoshs,stop teaching Auragazeb as secular
Minaxi Jain said in her discussion with Rajiv Malhotra that Sati was not there in Bengal but Ram Mohan Roy concocted it to benefit the Christians. She also does not know why Ram Mohan Roy was called Raja.
Yes historians should not have their ideological biases.
Amal Mukhopadhya is right History is not to be used for any ulterior motive. History is a search and record what actually happened.
Meenakshi jain should get a better publisher for her books.
curse on Thaper, habib , nehru etc for giving wrong history.
Who is this man and why is he invited ?
You are such a man who doesn't know mr. Amal k mukhopadhhay..... Hay hay
@@avijitmajumdar3206 cry some more , buffoon.
@@avijitmajumdar3206 who is he?
@@avijitmajumdar3206 is he a communist dog or a Neech Namazi?
@@avijitmajumdar3206 The problem with us Bengalis is that nowadays we become butthurts quite easily.
The old chap already agreed on that he doesn't know much about Indian history and a dammn politician.
I don’t know why the organisers selected Amal Mukhopadhyay for this debate. He was least bothered about the questions which were asked to him and was on a trip of his own. Complete nonsense.
Desh me sab nanga si baktho ke papa changa si
Actually this panel is bias they should have brought a historian to counter history, not political scientist with all due respect to gentleman
Amal M. claims that all historical narratives are motivated: but he does not explain his own motive. He is amazingly shallow and full of high school level aphorisms.