Video

Yes he is 100%

Btw did you know that Myrskyluodon Maija is a cover of a famous song in Finland of a same name. At least the flute melody is very similar to the original version.

Surprising reaction ....... . This band was very funny live, the singer entered the stage in the ¨rock n roll part ¨riding a bicicle or dressed as aquaman and stop just in perfect timming to sing the part. Also changes of dressing and theatrical stuff in all the singing parts ,which weren´t much as it is almost instrumental . The band had two classical contemporary players ( violin & flute ) a jazz sax player , the rest were rock musicians . They played no more than 5 concerts . The singer quit the band before recording this album and formed a rock /pop band named Suerter , with no relation to prog. The singer in this album is NOT the original singer he never played live with the band . He was hired for the record Album is from 1977 and there was no keyboard player ,although the singer played keyboards but not in this album . You should react to ¨Buenos Aires blus¨ a very unique album by la pesada in 1972 ....yes ir t says blus ,but there are some really prog in there ...

Gorguts isn't prog, its pretty much pure avant-garde technical death metal.

Nice! His music was frequently written down and sometimes not (9 Types of Industrial Polllution is basically a sped-up guitar solo over a slowed-down rhythm track playing a vamp).

you have no clue!

Shalom! Your video appeared in my 'recommended feed', probably because I've just finished watching the Prog Corner live stream where the panel select their top 10 Pink Floyd tracks. I've never liked Floyd much. I certainly can't pick 10 top tracks as there are only 5 I actually enjoy enough to keep in my CD collection: Arnold Layne, See Emily Play, Point Me At The Sky, One Of These Days and Money. After that, I lose interest. Actually I meant to leave a couple of comments weeks ago after I saw an old Prog Corner live stream on which you appeared. By the way, with regard to chap below who left a kind and thoughtful comment, our group (UNIT) is not '3 Jewish chaps from Scotland' (makes us sound like another Gentle Giant). I am the only Jew and only 2 of us are Scots (including me although I live in London). Yes, we've received a few abusive comments but the really juicy ones appear on our Bit Chute channel but then that's hardly a surprise. The Tolstoy quote is highly appropriate! PS Can we expect to see you return for a future Prog Corner live stream?

So why is the Asia debut so low? It’s one of his best covers.

PS I notice it is almost expected for people to heap abuse and harsh criticism against Israel yet it is not Israelis who hurl homosexuals off roofs, beat women to death for adultery and so on. Maybe the abuse and harsh criticism should be directed at, say North Korea, Somalia and Iran. Anyway, enough of the politics. Thank you again for making this interesting and thought provoking video.

Thank you for this video. Yes, I know I'm 11 months late but I only discovered your channel recently via The Prog Corner. I'm an Irish Roman Catholic so I don't have a dog in this race, if you see what I mean. I'm not a Pink Floyd fan - I don't hate or despise them; I just find most of their music dreary and frankly boring. Yes, I'm aware I'm a minority voice here. It does seem to me Waters doesn't like Jews very much. Well, that's rather sad but after all, he has plenty of company and I don't think it is either fair or sensible to rank him alongside Hamas or Hezbollah, for example. 3 of my favourite bands now (all discovered recently) are Tangent, UNIT and Myth Of Logic although I think Myth Of Logic is largely the work of a single chap. UNIT are (as far as I can tell) 3 Jewish chaps from Scotland. They have received a number of hateful, nasty and insulting comments on some of their videos (the ones that feature tracks based on Jewish subjects such as Yom Kippur, Pesach, Israel Is Real, Bar Mitzvah, The 613 Mitzvot, The Six Day Miracle...and another one whose title I've forgotten) which seem to show it is still acceptable to be abusive to Jews since YT had not removed the comments last time I looked. I wonder how (for example) Graham Gouldman, Peter Green and the Shulman brothers of Gentle Giant fared in the 1960s and 1970s when Jew hatred was far more open and pervasive than it is now.

Faltou "relayer"

Esto de los gustos es muy curioso. A mí me encanta el disco. pero también me gusta mucho génesis. Si no te gusta mucho genesis veo lógico que no te guste mucho este grupo

Anyone who liked this album would most probably also appreciate AP's follow up album, 'Wise Afrer the Event'. Great records.

Calling Kayo Dot a Maudlin spinoff is like calling an album like Music For Airports a Roxy Music spinoff. As a genuine fan of Maudlin, Kayo Dot (specifically their first release Choirs Of The Eye) absolutely blows Maudlin out of the water. Please please please treat yourself to a Choirs listen uf you haven't already, one of the best albums ever written, in my opinion. Absolutely essential listening specifically for an avant garde metal fan. Would really recommend all of Toby's work, especially their pre-Hubardo work, my personal favorites including Coyote, In the L...L... Library Loft, Tartar Lamb II, Gamma Knife and the absolutely monstrous track Don't Touch Dead Animals. (That being said if you're a straightforward prog fan after Choirs I'd recommend Blue Lambency Downward, much more accessible than the other releases mentioned and bears some occasional similarities to Part The Second)

The time signatures in fbm is actually 4/4, they just keep tweaking it until it sounds almost unrecognisable :D

The transition from track 1 to track 2 is just sublime

I dunno, this album feels to me like dark wizard prog which I think really fits the cover quite well

i agree with the opinion about the cover since i'm the designer, this was one of my oldest designs i made 10 years ago and i also don't consider it a good artwork, the band did picked the design when it was still part of my portfolio which it isn't anymore at this point because my work has improved by now.

Steve's album "Motivation Radio" is one of my all time favourite's, Well worth checking out. Love this album too!

Time for a new video ?!?!?!!

More of these for Rock in Opposition and Zeuhl would be insanely cool

I treat this album as another early soft machine album because the line up on this album is the same line up as the first soft machine album.

The keyboard player in this album was the last original member.

Marcel Rodíguez-López is the brother of the guitarist of The Mars Volta. Also, his brothers Marfred and Rico plays in this band. They were a great band to see live, I have never done drugs, but the psychedelia takes you away if you let it.

Hey! Proud Quebecois here. Great review. First, I think it's safe to say that yes you are correct, "Si on avait besoin d'une cinquième saison" is definitely a concept album. Also, I think it's important to say that while their first album wasn't as popular as their second in term of instant reaction and sales, I believe it was still a massive success upon release in 1974 in Quebec and to this day, probably the most renowned Harmonium album in Quebec, with songs like "Un musicien parmi tant d'autres" and "Pour un instant" that are almost national anthems.

When I saw the graph, I laphed. New album any minute now!

Hey! A bit late here, but I am amazed at your capacity (but mostly willingness) to explore new genres that include elements you dislike (screaming/growling) and still enjoy the album as a whole. Little sidenote, the squealing screams are actually Steeve Hurdle's! Which is why they are not present on the following albums. One of my favorite album of all time for sure. Ill try to get some of the other 365 prog days reviews!

After 60 years- probably still my top prog album. Wolf City is probably their most popular album. If there is a better album I'm still searching for it, although there are a lot of later bands that I enjoy.

If the album was called “ Memoirs of an officer and a Gentleman “ and had a cover depicting the war referred to in that track, I believe that it would not have received such a bad critical response.

I was under the illusion that the list would be about this year’s 365 day reviews exclusively, with The Whole World Window making it into the ranking, for emotional reasons, partly.

Seen them live here in Japan at a small venue. Really enjoyable. One stupid friend introduced me to their leader when I really didn’t have anything to tell him. Vissgaquell is probably their best contribution this album. The other stuff is more obviously Magmaesque.

You should re-visit the album and the Great Adventure. They get better and better with every listen and I'm sure if you gave yourself to them, you would rank them 10/10

Trick of the Tail sits between two era and is the only Genesis album that I like. Otherwise, I've loved most of Peter Gabriel's solo music. Family Snapshot, San Jacinto, Mercy Street, great songs.

Gorguts is a technical death metal band not a prog band.

The singer who is the main songwriter is half italian (last name is Fiori), so it's interesting that you perceived the cover's art as looking Italian.

wonderful band! Some have said they produced the first neo prog with a few of their subsequent albums. But really the best work by them is live, an album simply called "Live". A few albums later, they went with German vocals and produced a couple of great albums. Superb guitar/keyboard interchanges throughout their career. You mentioned being surprised they went further. They sold a lot of albums in Germany for a prog band in the 1980s, which might explain their relative longevity

Great album, thanks for giving it some air time with your usual eloquence! BTW, worth seeking out the version that has 4 bonus tracks. It's worth it just for the last track, the 7 and a half minute "Back Home"

very good brave and reasoned analysis Naomi.

Sounds interesting😍