Cave of Apelles
Cave of Apelles
  • 284
  • 960 364
Establishing Fine Art as a Religion of Purity: Reading Larry Shiner's The Invention of Art | Part 3
Bork Nerdrum and Jan-Ove Tuv take a deep-dive into Larry Shiner's book The Invention of Art (2001), commenting on the contents from the perspective of classical painting and culture.
Part one: czcams.com/video/pzyAwlZ1kLg/video.html
Part two: czcams.com/video/huNHIxGAMn8/video.html
👍✨ Support our show and get access to more than 200 exclusive posts:
patreon.com/caveofapelles/
Chapter markers:
00:00 Biggest takeaways so far
05:27 19th century: modernist rhetoric and “Art“ as an independent realm
08:02 Finding the purest of the fine arts
10:30 Changing the meaning of “culture“
12:12 Art as religion
19:57 Pre-modernists and Roman frog eyes
24:17 The Saint and Martyr Syndrom
27:29 “The descent of the artisan“
34:41 Architecture: art or craft…?
41:49 The term “disinterestedness“
45:00 The final consolidation of “Art“
48:47 Photography: was it ever a threat?
55:40 Modernism 1890-1930
1:06:18 The 1930´s & representational styles
1:09:00 Modernism as “anti-totalitarian“
1:14:05 Repeating the art vs craft division
1:19:25 Post-Modernism as an alternative?
1:22:51 A people without identity & a third system of the arts
This episode featured Bork Nerdrum and Jan-Ove Tuv and was filmed by Öde Nerdrum and Jikke Gruwel.
The centerpiece was a 19th century reproduction of G. F. Watts' Hope.
SHOUTOUT to our TOP SPONSORS!
Fergus Ryan
Matthias Proy
Diego
Subscribe to our newsletter. It is the only way to make sure that you receive content from us on a regular basis:
bit.ly/2L8qCNn
Check out our other channels:
czcams.com/users/SchoolofApelles
czcams.com/users/CultureWarsNow
Podcast available on SoundCloud, iTunes, and Spotify:
soundcloud.com/caveofapelles
spoti.fi/2AVDkcT
apple.co/2QAcXD6
Website:
caveofapelles.com
Facebook page:
caveofapelles
TikTok:
www.tiktok.com/@caveofapelles
Instagram:
caveofapelles
For inquiries - talk@caveofapelles.com
zhlédnutí: 1 110

Video

Dr. Nir Buras on The Classic Planning Institute, Modern Urban Planning and The Future of Our Cities
zhlédnutí 1,3KPřed měsícem
Dr. Nir Buras is a leading new traditional architect and urbanist, founder of the Classic Planning Institute, and author of The Art of Classic Planning. He designs towns, cities and buildings, and speaks about some of the most interesting developments in the world of architecture and planning and where we might find ourselves in the future. 👍✨ Support our show and get access to more than 200 ex...
Cyclical thinking, Discontinuity and Basic Human Stories | Jon White, Sturla Ellingvåg & Jan-Ove Tuv
zhlédnutí 1,2KPřed 2 měsíci
Jan-Ove Tuv sits down with Jon White from @Crecganford and Sturla Ellingvåg from @VikingStories to discuss the nature of myths. 👍✨ Support our show and get access to more than 200 exclusive posts: patreon.com/caveofapelles/ Chapter markers: 00:00 Thinking a-historically 03:33 From ritual to listening 08:48 Replacing pagan holidays and rituals 15:39 Changes in myths 22:26 Tactius' Germania, the ...
Creation, Cows and Sacrifice | Jon White on the Motifs and Interpretation of Indo-European Mythology
zhlédnutí 2,8KPřed 2 měsíci
Jon White has studied Indo-European mythology for more than thirty years, particularly focusing on cosmogony and creation myths. As an independent researcher and lecturer, he shares this knowledge on his CZcams-channel @Crecganford. Mr. White visits Cave of Apelles to detail the major motifs or "mythologems" of the Indo-European mythological tradition and what they denote. Considering that the ...
19th Century French Bohemia and the Proto-Avant-Garde | A Review of Michael J. Pearce's Book
zhlédnutí 1,2KPřed 3 měsíci
What happened in the cultural life in 19th century France that lead to the rise of avant-garde art in America? Jan-Ove Tuv sits down with Michael Pearce to review his book Kitsch, Propaganda and the American Avant-Garde. The book is available here: www.cambridgescholars.com/product/978-1-5275-9411-1 👍✨ Support our show and get access to more than 200 exclusive posts: patreon.com/caveofapelles/ ...
Kitsch, Propaganda and the American Avant-Garde | An Interview with Michael Pearce
zhlédnutí 4,1KPřed 3 měsíci
Kitsch, Propaganda and the American Avant-Garde | An Interview with Michael Pearce
Natures of Odin, Preparing for Ragnarök and the Optimism of Poetic Edda | Norse Mythology Part Three
zhlédnutí 815Před 4 měsíci
Natures of Odin, Preparing for Ragnarök and the Optimism of Poetic Edda | Norse Mythology Part Three
Seth Fite on Sincerity in Painting, Andrew Wyeth, and Human Suffering as the Superior Subject Matter
zhlédnutí 1,7KPřed 4 měsíci
Seth Fite on Sincerity in Painting, Andrew Wyeth, and Human Suffering as the Superior Subject Matter
Mushrooms & Shamanic Wisdom, Sacred Trees and the Number Nine | Norse Mythology Pt. 2
zhlédnutí 1,4KPřed 5 měsíci
Mushrooms & Shamanic Wisdom, Sacred Trees and the Number Nine | Norse Mythology Pt. 2
Henrik Knightingale on his Debut Play "In His Own Shadow" and How to Write a Compelling Story
zhlédnutí 583Před 5 měsíci
Henrik Knightingale on his Debut Play "In His Own Shadow" and How to Write a Compelling Story
The Genius, Museum and Art vs Craft: Reading Larry Shiner’s The Invention of Art | Part 2
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 6 měsíci
The Genius, Museum and Art vs Craft: Reading Larry Shiner’s The Invention of Art | Part 2
Everything Starts With the Columns | Architect Nils Freckeus on Beauty and Classical Principles
zhlédnutí 2KPřed 6 měsíci
Everything Starts With the Columns | Architect Nils Freckeus on Beauty and Classical Principles
The Æsir, Vanir & Jötnar | Bronze Age Blending, War and Trade | Norse Mythology Pt. 1
zhlédnutí 2,8KPřed 7 měsíci
The Æsir, Vanir & Jötnar | Bronze Age Blending, War and Trade | Norse Mythology Pt. 1
Kaja Norum on Beauty, Sentimentality and the Pleasure of Imitation
zhlédnutí 4KPřed 7 měsíci
Kaja Norum on Beauty, Sentimentality and the Pleasure of Imitation
Fine Art’s Expulsion of Craft and Sensuality: Reading Larry Shiner’s "The Invention of Art" | Part 1
zhlédnutí 3,6KPřed 8 měsíci
Fine Art’s Expulsion of Craft and Sensuality: Reading Larry Shiner’s "The Invention of Art" | Part 1
Belief in Progress: Blessing or Curse to Classical Painters? | Nerdrum, Hicks and Tuv
zhlédnutí 4,4KPřed 8 měsíci
Belief in Progress: Blessing or Curse to Classical Painters? | Nerdrum, Hicks and Tuv
The Art of Fiction | Using Ayn Rand's Ideas to Become a Good Storyteller
zhlédnutí 1,7KPřed 9 měsíci
The Art of Fiction | Using Ayn Rand's Ideas to Become a Good Storyteller
Making Dystopia: James Stevens Curl Exposes Totalitarian Modernism and the Falsification of History
zhlédnutí 15KPřed 9 měsíci
Making Dystopia: James Stevens Curl Exposes Totalitarian Modernism and the Falsification of History
Sturla Ellingvåg on Vikings, Norse Myths, Genetic Memory & Connecting the Longer Lines in History
zhlédnutí 9KPřed 10 měsíci
Sturla Ellingvåg on Vikings, Norse Myths, Genetic Memory & Connecting the Longer Lines in History
Employing Symbols in Paintings - What to Do and Avoid to Make a Credible Story on the Canvas
zhlédnutí 2,7KPřed 11 měsíci
Employing Symbols in Paintings - What to Do and Avoid to Make a Credible Story on the Canvas
How Immanuel Kant Undercut Classical Culture and Led to Postmodernism | Stephen Hicks
zhlédnutí 26KPřed 11 měsíci
How Immanuel Kant Undercut Classical Culture and Led to Postmodernism | Stephen Hicks
Getting People Interested in Classical Architecture | Ruben Hanssen, Hoff-Andersen & Michael Diamant
zhlédnutí 2,9KPřed rokem
Getting People Interested in Classical Architecture | Ruben Hanssen, Hoff-Andersen & Michael Diamant
How to Bring Back Beauty to a Confused Modern World | Michael Diamant & Carl Korsnes
zhlédnutí 7KPřed rokem
How to Bring Back Beauty to a Confused Modern World | Michael Diamant & Carl Korsnes
Studying with Odd Nerdrum | Jannik Hösel & Hjalmar Hagelstam
zhlédnutí 2,4KPřed rokem
Studying with Odd Nerdrum | Jannik Hösel & Hjalmar Hagelstam
In the Name of Melancholy | Odd Nerdrum & Jan-Ove Tuv
zhlédnutí 8KPřed rokem
In the Name of Melancholy | Odd Nerdrum & Jan-Ove Tuv
Why did Plato Wish to Exile Writers, Painters and Sculptors? | Einar Bøhn, Nerdrum & Tuv
zhlédnutí 1,6KPřed rokem
Why did Plato Wish to Exile Writers, Painters and Sculptors? | Einar Bøhn, Nerdrum & Tuv
Ruben Hanssen on How Urban Planning can be Beautiful, Transforming Dystopian Future into Bliss
zhlédnutí 2,6KPřed rokem
Ruben Hanssen on How Urban Planning can be Beautiful, Transforming Dystopian Future into Bliss
Beyond Tragedy: How Masterworks Unite Calm-Inducing Mandalas, Opposites and "Divine Comedy"
zhlédnutí 1,4KPřed rokem
Beyond Tragedy: How Masterworks Unite Calm-Inducing Mandalas, Opposites and "Divine Comedy"
Jannik Hösel on How He Taught Himself to Paint and His Take on the Role of Symbols in Storytelling
zhlédnutí 8KPřed rokem
Jannik Hösel on How He Taught Himself to Paint and His Take on the Role of Symbols in Storytelling
From Violent Rejection to Adoration | Öde Nerdrum Shares his Whole Beat Experience with Wim Winters
zhlédnutí 2,3KPřed rokem
From Violent Rejection to Adoration | Öde Nerdrum Shares his Whole Beat Experience with Wim Winters

Komentáře

  • @ikravchik
    @ikravchik Před 2 dny

    This is so painfully familiar. Kristin is laughing and being coy about it, but this sort of public, directed hatred and bullying at a young age can really destroy a person and literally drive them to suicide. Something very similar happened to me when I went to art school. It almost brings me to tears listening to her account.

  • @ikravchik
    @ikravchik Před 2 dny

    Honestly I can only listen to Odd and Tuv, they are revealing their heartfelt thoughts and opinions. Hicks sounds like a polished summary of a Wikipedia page. He is about as interesting and original as ChatGPT.

  • @conorsheehan9929
    @conorsheehan9929 Před 3 dny

    I have been unimpressed with modern architecture for years but I assumed that I was just old fashioned and not cool or modern minded . Now through videos like this I realise that modern architecture realy is tasteless brutalist and anti-beauty and I was right all the time . Wonderful to see taste and beauty is being re-awakened .

  • @KL0098
    @KL0098 Před 4 dny

    Stephen Hicks is a glorious example of a non-specialist parroting an idea well known to specialists (art has stagnated more or less since the 1910s) but blaming it on narrow, politicized scapegoats in a way that no serious specialist would make. The idea that, deep down, Kant alone is to blame, is an unhistorical fantasy. In this sense, he's just the conservative Mark Fisher, who also argues that culture has stagnated, except the Marxist Fisher blames capitalism. If you're tired of reductive cultural warriors and truly want an education, a more complex, nuanced, comprehensive explanation of this phenomenon can be found in Jacques Barzun's 1973 book "The Use and Abuse of Art". it's very short but packs a lot of info.

  • @user-oo6ug6xo6l
    @user-oo6ug6xo6l Před 4 dny

    Very good thought process of higher band width and bringing to reality too.!!!

  • @SusScrofaVulgaris
    @SusScrofaVulgaris Před 5 dny

    Sounds like neo paganism.

  • @nayankrishnatiwari7543

    you damn people read her with open mind , and you will gonna be fan of her

  • @yhvhsaves5197
    @yhvhsaves5197 Před 7 dny

    These knuckleheads laugh at something that was meant to be a joke.

  • @Procopius464
    @Procopius464 Před 8 dny

    The Hyperboreans were Iranic, not Germanic. The ancient Germanic culture was a neighbor to the Hyperboreans, but they were not Hyperboreans. When the climate became hostile, as attested to in the Avesta, the Aryans moved south. Some eventually went into the area that we call India today. After they were gone, Finno-Ugaric groups moved in, some of them became the Sami.

  • @tommore3263
    @tommore3263 Před 9 dny

    "If it is against reason, it is sinful."- Saint Thomas Aquinas 13th century. Human rights and individualism arose with the church's rejection of cousin marriage and this led to the end of tribalism and the idea of the "person" which literally means "voice sounding through". and Catholic natural law which is literally the preamble to the US Constitution. Catholic universities spread Socratic realism and reason which flowered into the "enlightenment" and modern science like at the U of Paris and Bologna. Catholicism really built the west. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_and_the_Catholic_Church

  • @abcdef27669
    @abcdef27669 Před 11 dny

    "So, tell me more about your hobbies". His answer:

  • @hankjwimbleton
    @hankjwimbleton Před 13 dny

    did he just refer to the raft of the medusa as a delacroix?😅

  • @John-mz8rj
    @John-mz8rj Před 16 dny

    Power cut then

  • @mariacaceres4312
    @mariacaceres4312 Před 16 dny

    What is all this? The devil was there when adam and Eve were in the garden of eden.

  • @RussellWestcoast
    @RussellWestcoast Před 19 dny

    The Egyptian portraits he's talking about are Fayum portraits made under Roman rule, in the first few centuries CE. They don't represent a deviation of style within traditional Egyptian representational work, which was fairly constant for 3,000 years.

  • @RussellWestcoast
    @RussellWestcoast Před 20 dny

    Michelangelo’s most well-known works are, in their subject matter, based on the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament. To simply say he was copying the Greeks is what the moderns call a “hot take.”

  • @RussellWestcoast
    @RussellWestcoast Před 20 dny

    Who the hell would say that their own dad is the best painter ever? That's hilarious

  • @RussellWestcoast
    @RussellWestcoast Před 21 dnem

    The antiphoto angle is ahistorical. Photography is only "a copy machine" if the artist treats it that way. I encourage you to look at how Gauguin, Degas, and Delacroix used photography. Of course many of the Old Masters, Baroque, and Neoclassical painters used optical and measuring devices, and once photography came on the scene, nearly all of the greats referenced it or worked from it in some way or another. Start here: "The Painter and the Photograph: From Delacroix to Warhol," and then here: "Shared Intelligence: American Painting and the Photograph."

  • @VisibleTrouble
    @VisibleTrouble Před 21 dnem

    Aye, nice work doc. Kant was the Albedo of the Magnum Opus of Plastic Reality. He trashed understanding. Vouched for his philosophy with Ethics and Morality. Turned Aesthetics into a mind job... Good discussion, fellas.

  • @stevechmilar1215
    @stevechmilar1215 Před 21 dnem

    I generally side with this philosophy and enjoy that this platform exists, but I have a question: What would happen if support for the talent to produce realism came to dominate in the coming years and suddenly we had complete reversal from what happened at the peak of the Art era? I'm not sure if a drastic increase in the amount of realism that already floods my instagram bubble would be a good thing. I mean, it gave me so much purpose to pursue realism when it was even less common than the beginning of the social media. It "makes us look good" by comparison to be surrounded by people doing finger-paintings?

  • @1k5uv13
    @1k5uv13 Před 21 dnem

    This was great, thanks for sharing!

  • @anthonydimichele837
    @anthonydimichele837 Před 22 dny

    Did he say: "Invisible Art"? Who put the "CON" in conceptual art?~!

  • @mettelyngholm4541
    @mettelyngholm4541 Před 23 dny

    Tusen takk ❤

  • @aidanm.655
    @aidanm.655 Před 24 dny

    This video is painful to watch. Stephen Hicks completely misunderstands Kant. The irony is that he would actually agree with Kant, if only he understood him. Kant believes in objective morality (categorical imperative) and objective reality (noumena/phenomena). Hicks basically thinks Kant is Nietzsche, which is ironic because Hicks famously hates Nietzsche (and Nietzsche hated Kant).

    • @StephenHicksPhilosopher
      @StephenHicksPhilosopher Před 7 dny

      Read the Kant's 2nd Preface to *Critique of Pure Reason*, in which Kant goes out of his way to say explicitly and repeatedly that objectivity must be rejected. Read the second half of the *Groundwork of Metaphysics of Morals*, in which Kant says explicitly and repeatedly that the CI cannot be objectively grounded and must be taken on faith and/or as a mere regulative idea. Do not confuse Kant's hoped-for universality with objectivity.

    • @aidanm.655
      @aidanm.655 Před 7 dny

      @@StephenHicksPhilosopher Kant is a transcendental idealist, his philosophy is that we get as close to objective phenomenal truth as possible. Whether it’s noumenally true is irrelevant. Your argument is that he’s not making the metaphysical, but rather phenomenological, assertion. But this doesn’t disprove his claims on objectivity, just that it’s not metaphysical. What’s worse is that Hegel rejects this and argues we CAN understand the noumena. So modern philosophy is predicated on transcendental idealism’s assertion of objectivity, whether it be phenomenally in the case of Kant, or noumenally in the case of Hegel. Post modernists reject both thinkers, because they disagree on objective truth entirely. So I repeat, Kant and Hegel are complete ideological opponents to Schopenhauer and Nietzsche, who inspired the post modern tradition. You really don’t know what you’re talking about, it’s embarrassing.

    • @StephenHicksPhilosopher
      @StephenHicksPhilosopher Před 6 dny

      @@aidanm.655 : You're repeating the same mistake in your very first sentence here -- mis-using "objective" in a way Kant explcitly disavows. You need to re-cast the rest of your reconstruction once you get the fundamental terminology straight. Bxvi is precisely the section you must read carefully and integrate the terminology of "object" and "subject" Kant uses there.

  • @BearsArms45
    @BearsArms45 Před 29 dny

    The brain is a wildly powerful computer of sorts… just dont ever consider it its ability for pattern recognition. All that…. Must be cast aside. No patterns outside of your daily march to the mines, the return to your pod, and the eating of your bugs. Patterns. Are racist. Architecture is a hoax. Art is the toilet that I’m sitting on right now.

  • @BearsArms45
    @BearsArms45 Před 29 dny

    I have found my kin. Thank god, and the gods above, that these people and ideals and centers of exploration… still exist.

  • @BearsArms45
    @BearsArms45 Před 29 dny

    Brutalist architecture- Bourne from a movement populated by communists. No wonder were told by our national museums that paintings of rolling hillsides “evoke dark nationalist feelings” It appears the commies are correct about this. Don’t want people embracing heritage, culture, common foundations, history or nation? Well then adorn their classical works of art with disclaimers that only nazis like the English countryside and remove their genetic memory from existence by replacing the locations of their heritage with structures that assault the senses. Thus, our grandchildren will never know any different. To them, the brown masses plodding through centuries within dreary sameness, free of any uniqueness that threaten their multicultural inclusivity… will be the world their fathers inhabited. And their great great grandparents before them. They won’t know things were ever any different. Just like today we aren’t meant to know things could ever be different. The grey world of boxes is the real world- the world of classical beauty is just a fascist myth.

  • @BearsArms45
    @BearsArms45 Před 29 dny

    And thus, Henry Ford was the problem. Which is a conclusion I refuse to accept.

  • @BearsArms45
    @BearsArms45 Před 29 dny

    No, no… I need someone to point me to this interview, or the peoples names. Please. For the sake of all things hyperborean Edit: Nevermind, I forgot I know how to internets.

  • @KoshNaranick
    @KoshNaranick Před měsícem

    so what books did he reccommend?

  • @beverlykandraceffinger3764

    Such an interesting interview, with a wonderful painter who has learned how to be lighthearted and continue....I've also seen the full spectrum available in art education, but was fortunate enough to attend an Academy where two different personalities were strong and present. One painting master focused on very formal techniques, another great teacher concentrated on gestural work and individual development. But the shared personal values: concentration on drawing skills, the need to work from life, and knowledge of materials and methods- were always present with both mentors. My first art school experience had been also at a University, and I'd always felt cheated by my time there until I'd heard Kristine's story. At least I'd received a bit more attention and instruction, but not enough to satisfy. Many times I was alone at the end of a three-hour studio class along with one or two other students (at least 30 had been at the start)--the professor absent after the first half-hour...a situation which I could never have imagined in my later Academy years. Staying for a reason had helped- even at University, I'd connected with a graduate teaching fellow who was an interesting and diligent painter. We'd formed a sort of small community with one another, and shared ideas and knowledge in the way I'd later come to know as typical of Academy approach. I'm so glad to have this reminder, through the interview, that it's important to keep working even when an educational situation isn't settling well. Continue to learn from every new situation. Search for the new situation if the current one doesn't satisfy. ...and when I'd had renewed contact with an Art Department where teachers encouraged students to "learn painting by practicing on oak tag (cheap board)", and to use student-grade paints because they're less expensive... I was there to suggest that it's not a good idea to grow accustomed to inferior materials. Or inferior methods. ... it's always possible to draw. That seems to be the beginning and end for me, no matter how much else I've learned along the way. Drawing is the core skill in all visual arts, and is available for everyone who wants to become a better painter. Begin with the best, and it will carry you a very long way.

  • @jenniferarnold-delgado3489

    One must always remember that the human brain is what is experiencing and filtering - and that the male mind is asymmetrical, and the female mind is symmetrical . So the male will actually become energized by symmetry , and the feminine will -- for example, more likely enjoy a male with his hair parted to the side , than down the middle, and a male will more likely enjoy a female with her hair parted down the middle . In my opinion , the male female conversation has been totally ruined during the last 100 years , and is the primary place of therapeutic healing that needs to be brought into EVERY conversation . If it is not , it will come into the conversation through the back door , or worse , through the chimney !

  • @jenniferarnold-delgado3489

    Believe me there is a reason why the messengers of Dystopia all work VERY hard at dressing and coiffing and sculpting their physiques to maintain serious contact with the masses . Beauty is a primary memetic connector , which can be used as a Trojan horse of content . To me , beauty is balance in motion . Pretty is balance , beauty is something that is so perfectly balanced that it can be moved by a feather .

  • @fuanon3441
    @fuanon3441 Před měsícem

    how can someone say there is no craft to cubism as practiced by Picasso that is absurd. how can someone say there has been no new art ideas since Duchamp in the teens that is absolutely absurd.

  • @RichardLucas
    @RichardLucas Před měsícem

    The most important part of the story of I1 probably involves I2. I2 is probably Cro Magnon (Early Modern European). Either I1 or I2 seem to be the population in whom the D-allele emerged that is connected to microcephalin regulation - brain size. That gene surfed to high frequency quickly, meaning it conferred an advantage of some kind. More important is the fact that Cro Magnon's larger body and brain (compared to either Neanderthals or Homo Sapiens of the time) came from something called _hybrid vigor,_ and millennia later, when the 5'10" Yamnaya came in and made babies with the daughters of I1, it looks like these hitherto separate populations enjoyed another bump of hybrid vigor, resulting in the Vikings. I1s are all over the world, but still remain mostly where they started, in Scandinavia. That suggests to me that what ever drove the Yamnaya to invade and colonize Europe, it may have been somehow linked to y-DNA rather than autosomal DNA. If that's the case, then the term "colonizer" would be a poor fit for I1 males, lol. That's probably asking too much from the data, but it would be hysterically funny to me if proven. I'm an I1 male but stand 5'10".

  • @suhnih4076
    @suhnih4076 Před měsícem

    Yeah and the khoisan came from south america

  • @williamwhitten7820
    @williamwhitten7820 Před měsícem

    *It takes personal revelation to finally believe that the world is real in an empirical way.*

  • @sphynxmaine
    @sphynxmaine Před měsícem

    Have more kids.

  • @austinmackell9286
    @austinmackell9286 Před měsícem

    Wonderful set. Wonderful poncho.

  • @anyakosta364
    @anyakosta364 Před měsícem

    I have read in the translated work of Papus about a fair skin tribe moving into India and creating a cast system.....😢...The story was that this tribe has separated from their own group due to the Matriarchal rules...so they came to India and creating different rules, to each of its it's own was the main original idea.....i used to think it was a conspiracy theory.....

  • @crabb9966
    @crabb9966 Před měsícem

    💯

  • @riddhigupta7379
    @riddhigupta7379 Před měsícem

    Plato is sht😀

  • @BrunildaLibera
    @BrunildaLibera Před měsícem

    I am so grateful for this full book review, it has been helping me a whole lot to navigate the Art world and not get damaged by it, in fact, makes me stronger and clearer to speak out to focus on rescuing human vitality and get rid of Art altogether. This channel has been an huge help in understanding the differences, to embrace the classical values, without hiding, nor resignating but to actually boldly embrace what i am doing,

  • @RDWstudio
    @RDWstudio Před měsícem

    We need an alternative… thank you for this series of videos.

  • @user-fk4cp9kp9n
    @user-fk4cp9kp9n Před měsícem

    I’m allergic to walnuts

  • @lalahohoable
    @lalahohoable Před měsícem

    What a waste of time, with a theory that doesn't make any sense in musical, emotional and historical terms. Here it seems more hysterical than historical

  • @christianschmitz5261
    @christianschmitz5261 Před měsícem

    So infantile to "bleep" out certain figures' names, because one's ideology doesn't match with theirs.

  • @kelvinize
    @kelvinize Před měsícem

    I wish you guys would continue your beautiful work for decades to come. It's sad that this is the last video. Thank you for all the contributions you've given to true meaningful art.

  • @73elephants
    @73elephants Před měsícem

    "People learned to accept..." -- this is indeed how art has been appreciated, or at least _feigned_ to be appreciated, since the WWII.

  • @captainfrodotheshowman
    @captainfrodotheshowman Před měsícem

    Thank you for all the wonderful and inspiring conversations you’ve hosted it has been a powerful voice. You’ve helped me understand art (my own and others) in a more nuanced and deep way. I arrived to understand Nerdrum and Jan Ove’s use and meaning of kitch and as I went deeper into the cave with you all I gained a better understanding of why I have always like figurative painting and classical architecture.