The Success and Failure of Operation Zarb-e-Azb
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
- Was Operation Zarb-e-Azb effective? A journalist covering areas of KP and Waziristan shares the inside story and sheds light on the viability of the military operation.
TCM’s five-year journey has been about telling stories that people want to hear which mainstream media has been neglecting for decades. We want to disrupt the status quo by delivering engaging content which empowers impassioned voices and impacts social change. We are defined by integrity, grit and ingenuity and this is what makes us do what we do.
Support independent journalism in Pakistan and get exclusive access to the full-length version of our videos: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Subscribe to TCM Original: bit.ly/2A3pOXz
Subscribe to TCM: bit.ly/2Tu6AkW
-------------------
Follow us on
Facebook: / tcmoriginalsofficial
Facebook: / thecentrummedia
Facebook: / centrumenter. .
Tiktok: / tcmoriginals
Twitter: / thecentrummedia
Instagram: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Join our Facebook community: bit.ly/35oeLVs
-------------------
Website: thecentrummedia...
-------------------
About The Centrum Media
The Centrum Media (TCM) has the credit of Pakistan’s first digital news operation specializing in visual storytelling. Being a premier online platform, TCM strives to enhance the online experience of the new generation, ranging from hard news to feature stories. TCM creates original content and curates simultaneously from multiple sources.
We will take you where the real stories happen but often go untold and unseen in the shortest possible time having more information. Unlike the traditional media, TCM aims at sharing diverse stories across multi-platforms aimed at the people who consume news through mobile and social stream. We take up the challenge in the digital arena to present the news in the most imaginative and innovative ways.
Your on-the-go lifestyle forces us to bring the news directly to your pocket devices.
God Bless Gen raheel, the Saviour of Pakistan. After Operation Zarb-eazb peace finally came for which were all yearning for two decades!
You don't know zarbi azab and etc don't comment useless material science you are ignorant about these operations...
@@rehanbabri5871 kya pura mulk ma damhaka hona band na howay?
Allah saved Pakistan dear not raheel sharif but yes he was good
@@oxfordnoi5609 jahil hain ye inko choro
@@oxfordnoi5609 bhaii ap zara pahlay ye paro ye operations kia thay ?? Keun thay ?? Reason kia thay?? Kaha say start huay kesay huay ?? Kon thay ?? Kes ky khelap thay ?? Thaliban kon thay ?? Kesay thay ?? Ap ny deka hay khud ?? Ab en sawalo ka jawab Allah ke qasam apkay pass nahe, ap nahe jantay en chezo ko isliye keh raha ho choro en baato ko, Pakistan ko Allah ny raka hay kesi nay nahe bacha ky raka, sab logo ny loota hay, apko serap ye nazar aata hay ky Raheel sharif ye nazar nahe aata ky wo kaha hy,ketnay paisay hay uskay sath, parliament ko bypass kar ky job ky liye gaya tha,bhaii choro koie asa insan nahe es country mein jo es country say muhabat karta ho, sab ky sab chor hay , ye Pakistan hay koie aor country hota to toot kay melyameet ho jata, ham mein say koie be asa nahe jo sach aor study karta ho sab ky sab mashriq news paper par ky comment kartay hay, aor ap logo ky ye jazbati aor jhoti aor jahel qesam ky comments say logo mein jazbaat peda hotay hay jo es mulk ky liye khatarnaak hay..
The people and military gave their lives for the operation.. but sadly the corruption both in politcal and military hiearchy didnt let proper rehabilitation
Congrats the motive of this malicious documentary accomplished!
@@humanclay9131 bhai dekh yes the military did its best yet cuz of some in the chain the process didnt go very well
ALHAMDULILAH Pak army under Raheel shareef gave them a bloody nose but now there are 2 things
1. The idps were supposed to return until 2020
2. The investment was to be focused
But sadly there isnt much progress due to incompetent bureaucracy
Lack of leadership
@@awaismuhammad4681 baat bhai aap ki sahi hai
aap jab tak development tezz nahi karogay , Idps per kaam nahi karogay toh yeh Manzoor Pashteen aur Faisal Dawar jese bharay kay tattoo phir ethnicity per divide paida karengay 😒
If media coverage was allowed, the Pakistanis wouldn't have suffered and loss this much.
Well I am from KPK my cousin was from Swat but that time TTP didn't reach that area but before army going to waziristan they kicked out many people from their homes
But because army said that the war can come in that areas and the terrorists can make you hostage
Allhamdulillah my cousin home was remain safe there were few shooting breast but his many colony houses were destroyed because of it
Operation Zarb e Azab mission was to block the supply line of TTP......................... Radd ul Fasaad was based on those areas where the TTP hiddin find them
Rehabilitation is happening but it must be done faster for the people who are living in the camps.
Where are "Failures" discussed in this video? Wrong Title just to lure audience.
Yes the war brings collateral damage. We must appreciate the rehabilitation process. I Visited the place back in 2015.
I also know the ground realities!
Stop misleading with title!
Oh dude 😒 operation was made that they will deployed the GT Road army troops to move Kpk 2014
Small army troops was sended to help the frontier core in 2006
You haven't watched the video completely I guess title is absolutely Appropriate
Ops zarb e azb was just cleaning the remaining hideouts esp in waziristan
Main work had been done
In operation rah e raast, rah e nijaat
Bajaur and kurram offensive
@@CricketDon-dn2vn pls specify the "failures" than as I couldn't find them in the video.
@@awaismuhammad4681 I agree to some extent but Zarb-e-Azab was more than just cleaning process as waziristan had the most number of important hard targets and don't forget Tirah Valley.. the most difficult part to take. took a whole div and later SSG was airdropped from behind(Afg territory).. it was a bloodshed we cant forget.
Raheel sharif would go down in history as the best army chief of Pakistan ever
Extremely heart breaking for the brave people who fought in Kashmir are now Homeless and destroyed economy!
Yaar na aate Kashmir me tum Pakistani to India b ni aata hamari galat ka zimedar tum ho bsdk
zarb e azb me puri puri migration ko migration krna pda... aur hme kashmir me bolte ho k ham atrocities krte hain 🤣🤣🤣
ارب پتی، کروڑ پتی اور سرمایہ دار دور دراز کے ان علاقوں میں کیسے تھے: جہاں نہ بجلی تھی نا روڈ نا زراعت نا صنعت نا سیاحت اور نا قانون کی علمبرداری؟
1) سمگلنگ
2) سمگلنگ
3) سمگلنگ
4) سمگلنگ
تو یہ جو زیادہ تر ریاست اور افواج مخالف صحافی یا سیاستدان اور نام نہاد این جی اوز ہیں یہ بھی دراصل کلی یا جزوی طور پر اس سمگلنگ سے ہی مستفید ہو رہے تھے یا ہیں اور یہی انکا سب سے بڑا درد بھی ہے۔
Operation zarb e azab was the best thing that happened
Successful ho ya na ho Pakistan mn aman ki surathaal to behtar hui
Aap konsi duniya mein rehte ho it was a successful operation and then another operation took place in every Pakistan area to get bombs and dismantle the plan of bombing
The last much bigger attack the terrorist took was I think Lahore 2017 Mall Road
They were not talbans they were americans who did attacks on pakistan i face of taliban for blaming talibans
Raheel sharif sirs personality was the amongst musharraf and other generals i must say a man of dignity and respect if i would have met him i would surely have given him a salute because he deserves the salute he wiped off terroism and destroyed mqm
What was Army doing before 2014? Huh?
Pakistan Army Zinda bad
Pakistan zinda baad
Baqi sab kuch es k baad
All thanks to Nawaz Shareef who decided to put that huge amount of money into this operation from Pakistan's already struggling economy instead of using that money for more Projects which would've increased his vote bank MNS made a selfless decision to do the right thing despite people like Imran Niazi criticizing the decision and calling it bad decision and what not! And also thanks to our jawans our shaheens our brave Mujahids Pride of Pakistan Soldiers who fought and many gave their lives to better the security situation of Pakistan and people living peacefully now compared to before!
Lool I thought nawaz was against the army… something is not matching … you must be stupid if you really think nawaz cares about pakistan because by now our country would’ve been destroyed by india and you that well who our enemies are and how close that bastard is with them
another Nawaz Sharif supporter. Nawaz Sharif is a thief like Zardari. neither cares for Pakistan, their loyalty is to filling their bank accounts.
Nawaz sharif is a traitor to the country, the years he and his party have stolen alongside ppp from this country will never be returned, and illiterate fools like you will never learn, nawaz Sharif supporters are no different from illiterate villagers that vote for ppp over the names of a few dead politicians while not even knowing their rights.
@@Meow09090 yeah your own courts and UK courts are saying otherwise we know who the real stupid corrupt is who has brought Pakistan's economy to the verge where Pakistan can not withdraw money from it's own State Bank because of poor economic strategy and all that stupid has is that party is corrupt this party is corrupt while all the false cases have comje back as a slap on his own face
@@hsj2229 and our courts have him as an absconder and cases are pending on the rest of the sharif family, he is disqualified from entering the election what are you even talking about anyways jahil.
Mujhe buhat se fojio ny kaha tha yeh foj ke andar ki baat hai jab chiken khany waly bralar bachy officero ke ko officer barti hoty the jab woha oprations main marny lagy tu un familys ny apny bralars bachy foj main apny bachon ko barti karwana chor diya kiyu ke foj ka asool hai har new officer opration main shmil hoga. Jis ki waja aam or greeb middle class ke bachon ki bartiya shoro ki. Pakistan yehi hal hai agr baao officer hai wo har haal main bacha officer bna ly or foj kon sa asman se utri hain isi subcontinent ke log hain
4:08 چار لاکھ روپے میں کب سے مکان بنانے لگ گے پاکستان میں
Mati ki khar hoti hai bana sakte hai 4 lskh sai
Haz0or Yaaahi to Masla hai .. K Ghaaron Ko Zameen Sa Hi Mitha Diya Gaaya Hai Log Es Cheez Ki Waaja Sa Khd Ma Larr Parhy Ha K Kahan Mera Ta 0r Kahan Tera .. Jb Keeela Nooma Ghr Huwa Krta Ta 0r Establishment kitna dy Raahi .. 4 Lac Yani K Jis Ma Ak Bathroom B Nhi Ben Sakta .. 0r Ulta Hi In K LoGo Ko Dashatgar B Kaha Jata .. Mtlb That's So Unfair
Any Taliban etc, it’s all drama It's all their own production
Aman toh aagya lekin Jung mein Jo Tabahi hoi Ghar Tabah hoay aap unko theek nahi Karo gay toh khud naye dushman peda karoge
Phir unn logon ko Ali wazir aur Faisal Tattar kay paas Jaana hota hai
Phir wohi naaray suna chahtay ho
Shok sy nary lgao hum abhi zinda hn pta bhi nhi chly ga kahan ghaib ho nary lgany waly
Aman aa jaye to sb kuch wapis aa sakta hy Ghaddaro k liye koi jagah ni hy
“We do not need an external enemy, it is not that someone from outside is destabilising us, we are being destabilised through our own internal institutions.”
Nawab Akbar Bugti on establishment.
Hahaha Same as in 71 You are a Fool Wherever Armed Rebels is Going against The state India Openly Support Them.
Moreover Every Military Rule Brought Up a Huge Economic Stability See after The Musharraf What These Shits Democrats Feduals Elite Did Economy is Still Suffering Very Badly
@@MuhammadTalha-qc2de that’s the narrow mindset, all over the world military rules are backed and brought to Govt. by USA, so that the miltos can follow the USA policies, in Pakistan, in Turkey, Egypt everywhere, as for the development, during Nawaz Sharif’s govt. an England economic institution said that with this growth in economy, Pakistan would become among 20 largest economies by 2030.
Bro you are right Bugti also supported the military in the late 70s against Marri and Mengal rebelness
Problem was that he always Balochistan to be progressive like the areas of Punjab and Karachi
But Musharraf was a mad maniac who kill him and created new internal enemy
@@rohaanimemes6953 Read some history man, during his tenure, people were forced to walk on coals to judge whether they were guilty or not, now that doesn’t sound very progressive does it
@@aliyan7378 well, I am in no way suggesting he was an angel, but what he said was true, all these problems (including oppression by Nawabs) have one solution, an evolutionary process with democracy, whereby development is brought and institutions like judiciary, police and others mete our justice, not through dictatorships.
Biased video. Peace has retired in the operation area and it us also acknowledged by the world. This SOB looks like the sympathiser of indian funded ttp.
Unsubscribing this foreign funded CZcams channel tcm
This topic is too big for 5 min video
A whole 2 hour documentary can be made about Zarb-e-Azb
Why not saying something about Good Taliban … mullah Nazir and mullah Gull Bahador .. , this mess was because of Criminal and terrorist sponsor Army .
ab to aman ha na Operation success hoi i thinkk
Nhn Bhai in joutnalisto ka keera kabhi nhn marega!
@@humanclay9131 Haan aap kay reply box mein likha hai Khwarji ki moat Pak fauj Pak fauj
Aap zaroor Afghani ho yaan punjabi Non league ho 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Army ka yeh operation bilkul successful tha abhi mein yeh comment Peshawar kay Chai ☕🍵 khana se bhej raha hoon 😂
Han g ab aman aa gaya dollars chalay gaien ab agar ajdaha be ho operations nahe hongay guranteed...
Since u r dawar so i dont epect truth, secondly why dont u name the agencies involved in working waziristan through afganistan land.how india used to operTe because u r biased and black sheep under cover by so called jouranalism.
Pakistan Army Zindabad, Pakistan Paendabad
Pakistan es ka Naam na ho ess ka Naam erfan a Abad ho Naam mehaz Naam hain ess say koe farq nahe parta
very sad to hear news ...
USA had to come to Pakistan for help in Afghanistan why not go ask your ally India lmao 🤣🤣
Not help but carry thousands of drone attacks on Afghanistan and that Pakistan fucking accepted
India is not like pakistan, pakistan for chinese money kept quite on uighurs muslims salughtered, keep quite when american drones used pakistan space to attack and kill afghans muslims. Now ask pakistan whether its a muslim country or puppet of chinese n americans
Pakistan was led by dogs that would sell us to the western powers that be if they could, how are they going to say no to the west when everything they own is in the West, how are they going to say no when cases are put on them they run to the West, Pakistan is a society of crooks and liars say what you want about india but unki Abhi ghairat nahi Mari jaisi hamari mar chuki Hain.
There are thousand of Taliban members still roaring in Waziristan. I just asked one of Waziristani guy yesterday's. according to him, this is only a part of a great game of Pakistan state. State has every kind of power so instead of power, how they cannot get rid of Taliban ? Think wisely !
sir jee , itna horror background music lagaya hay apny k bandy ki adi tawaja dar jati hy hhhhhh
Very true...
Aman kyse nh aya?
Funny part is Pakistan has no guts nor face to recognize taliban government and be the first country in the world to do so.......taliban r pashthu and so is TTP.....taliban mindset has already started in Pakistan with the maulvi in Islamabad raising taliban flag in the madrassa....500 more maulvis support him for taliban sharia in Pakistan......TTP has local support of pashtus both in Pakistan and Afghanistan......Pakistan will soon taste its own medicine.....all hail bajwa and imran nazi......
Bullshit I am from KPK no one in KPK supports TTP and we ourselves are pashtuns and we have been suffered a lot from that time ⌚
And because of the civilian support Army be able to kicking them out of Swat and most importantly there main house Tribal areas
We Pakistani Pakhtun are much patriotic then the whole punjabi Pakistanis who only know to support a man with no hairs 🤣🤣🤣
People are been beheaded by the TTP in Swat and women were been whipped till 2014 operation took place
Definitely you are watching Major Goraya video 😂😂😂
Or you are from Liberal sector
@@rohaanimemes6953 time will tell.....TTP has afghan taliban support....duran line is never accepted....attack on ttp is attack on taliban....Pakistan has played double game with taliban....taliban carefully used Pakistan this time nd taliban knows haqqanis will b used by Pakistan.....real game will start now....radicalism was born in Pakistan and will soon takeover Pakistan......
@@lovely-iu4xx what a dumb 😒 Comment
Taliban supports TTP from 2007 - 2009 and that time Taliban just want Pakistan to stop the supply line of USA.
But later Taliban main commander Mullah Omar send letter to Tehreek e Taliban Pakistan commander to stop conducting the attacks in Pakistan and attack on foreign fighter in Afghanistan
Afghan Talibans and TTP have also conducted attacks against each other. On 10 October 2013, heavily armed Afghan Talibans attacked a TTP base in Kunar of Afghanistan . The attack resulted in the death of three TTP commanders. However, TTP denied any losses.Again on 25 June 2016, Afghan Talibans and TTP clashed with each other in the Kunar province of Afghanistan. Afghan defense ministry claims that eight TTP militants and six Afghan Talibans were killed in the clash. Moreover, Some Sources also claim that TTP was behind the death of Nasiruddin Haqqani because TTP believed that Haqqani Network was behind the death of Hakimullah Mehsud as they disclosed whereabouts of to US military in Afghanistan.
Agree! Aman nahi aya. Still hamari forces k log shaheed hotay hai aye din news ati hai
TTP is a big problem and afghan taliban will support them as they both r pashtuns.. ....its gonna b punjabis vs pashtuns in Pakistan next......taliban influence of sharia is soon to come to north of Pakistan which is pashtun dominated....pindi will dare not attack taliban
bhai sahab TTP ka target ab hamari security forces hain sheri nahi
2007 - 2016 tak dhamakay fouj per hotay thay kay civilians parr
Aman tabhi aye gaa jab Taliban ki hakumat tasleem hogi warna phir Afghanistan ki government collapse kar gayi 2001
phir yahi azab dobara musalat hoga
Problem is the local soft corner for Taliban and then our local tribals become human shields for them this was the biggest problem Nawaz Shareef and Raheel Shareef faced when they made this very difficult and expensive decision after the operation was activated Pak Military went in and realized TTP is very weak and not that big in numbers themselves but they have infiltration among the locals and are spread into the locals with married into locals etc and obviously often faced human shields situation when local women and kids were being used as human shields and Pak military could do nothing TTP was pushed back and a lot of their future plannings were exposed caught and neutralized and after seeing so much loss in man power TTP decided to go on back foot and take a breather now they can only attack Pak army in those areas with installed devices which happens or they out of nowhere see a good open chance and attack Pak army Paakistan army can go no mercy mode and eradicate 100% TTP insects but problem is it will effect lot of Pakistani families locals of those areas and many women and kids will be killed if Pakistan military decides to start closing their eyes to locals used as human shields and kill anyone and every one even related to TTP it's a tough decision to make.
@@lovely-iu4xx the north is not pashtun dominated there is hazara division, chitral, gilgit and other ethnicities but you are right pashtuns are ready to attack pakistan at any time
Will Taliban 2.0 be different ?
Predominance of the Haqqani representatives within the Taliban government may appear to help control the policies from Pakistan , the Qatar influence via Mullah Baradar cannot be dismissed !
More strife means more refugee flux into Pakistan !
Then history may repeat once again !
Pakistan has no control over the Taliban. Neither have the Taliban accepted the Durand Line as the official border nor have they listen to Pakistan when Pakistan asked them to not destroy the Buddhas of Bamiyan.
@@tahir7832 Then why did ISI chief go to Afghanistan few days BEFORE the Taliban Cabinet was announced?
How then Haqqani form the largest chunk of the cabinet?
There is a reason for Imran khan Niazi's happiness and that is not just for the shackles of slavery being broken by Taliban !
Ofcourse the other factions/ stakeholders within Taliban will not allow Pakistan to dictate them in every matter and Pashtun identity will be obliterating the line dividing them !
@@ygcg8696 Learn a little history and you will see why there is some "happiness" within the Pakistan government. Afghanistan, since the foundation of Pakistan, always tried to interfere in Pakistan's internal matters. From not accepting Pakistan to the UN, to supporting and aiding Pashtunistan and Balochistan terrorists, to invading Bajaur in the 1960's they always tried to destabilise Pakistan. The only peace time on the Pak-Afghan border was when the Taliban was in power. That is why some elements in the Pakistani government are happy about the Taliban takeover. And again, read what I wrote. If Pakistan had any influence on the Talibam then they wouldn't have destroyed the Buddhas of Bamiyan to recoocnizing the border. And yes, the ISI chief went to Afghanistan after the Talibam invited them, it's not like he went there without any invitation. And even India held secret talks with the Taliban before they announced the new government, nothing outstanding what the ISI chief did
@@tahir7832 Still the Taliban , some say TTP fellows removed the Pakistani flag and desecrated it , pulling out of the vehicle carrying them aid !
The convoluted relationship between Taliban and Pakistani establishment is perplexing , isn't it ... despite all the emotions of an Islamic Republic being cozy with a new Emirate neighbour would elicit !
U will suffer as long as u follow an evil book
any one in particular or are you referring to the mahabharat, or the other ones being followed by the RSS and it's child the BJP, and your behaviour towards the minorities in India. first look to yourself you kam bakhts.
Lol...dwaram-pudi.
we don't follow the gita or whatever its called.
Oh srinivas you talking about your book which is fake and Man written . Ha ha 🤣 dumb shit you guys are biggest EVIL but time coming for you guys just wait and see.