Should There Be a Limit to Gender Identities? | Good Morning Britain
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 09. 2019
- A film made by BBC Teach, designed to support school PHSE classes, explains that there are more than 100 different gender identities. The NHS currently recognises six genders but should there be a limit to how people can identify? Nicole Gibson and Benjamin Butterworth debate.
Subscribe now for more! bit.ly/1NbomQa
Broadcast on 11/09/2019
Like, follow and subscribe to Good Morning Britain!
The Good Morning Britain CZcams channel delivers you the news that you’re waking up to in the morning. From exclusive interviews with some of the biggest names in politics and showbiz to heartwarming human interest stories and unmissable watch again moments.
Join Susanna Reid, Piers Morgan, Ben Shephard, Kate Garraway, Charlotte Hawkins and Sean Fletcher every weekday on ITV from 6am.
Website: bit.ly/1GsZuha
CZcams: bit.ly/1Ecy0g1
Facebook: on. 1HEDRMb
Twitter: bit.ly/1xdLqU3
www.itv.com
#GMB #PiersMorgan #SusannaReid - Zábava
It's a very difficult process psychologically and physically to be transform from a black lesbian to a penguin... Hats off Piers
🤣🤣🤣🤣 this is hilarious
So brave!!
Not just a mere penguin, but a 2 spirit penguin, he's really courageous
when i was a kid in the 60s it was boy and girl, end off,
@@daveberry2177
IT WAS THE SAME IN THE 80s AND 90s !! This some new New NEW ish
Respect to the trans woman who actually has some common sense
We need more people like her
That's a guy BTW.
@@rogersevers123 shut up no one asked you
@@rogersevers123 that's why they said "trans woman" 😂
@@chrisleeeee7702 him
"I am not a cis anything" ,best line of this show😂😂
Morgan is just the best
not even close "can i identify as a 2 spirit nuetrois pangender penguin"
To me it was hearing how baffled he was when he said “common sense Benjamin?!” 😂
exactly, cuz cis just means 'on this line of'. aka. on this side of the mentioned item, gender, etc. So what it really means is a Cis White Man is a This Side of White Men... which makes absolutely no sense.
😂
I remember some comment, “sometimes I identify my self as ambulance, so my pronoun is wee/woo”
💀💀💀
The classic 😂
😂😂😂😂
This tickled me!!!😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
"Piers, you're a cisgender..."
-"I'm not a cis of anything! Don't call me a cis!" 😂
Yea what’s your point?
Totally agree, I'm just a man too. Not a CIS man.
@@sandyman566 Point is he knows he is a man and that what he is. I am a man and thats what I have been most of my adulthood. I don't need people from a certain very small minority group to create new labels for my gender. CIS is just made up nonsense word that is being enforced on us the majority.
It’s an annoying thing to hear
CIS? Like from Star Wars? Like the Confederate of Independent System? This gender shit is wild 💀
Did the person with the glasses just assume Morgan's gender identity by calling him 'Sis gendered male', then refused to accept Morgan's self-chosen self-identity 'I'm just a man'? Doesn't that make that person with the glasses a bigoted, disrespectful and rude hypocrite with double standards?
Yes
yep pretty much spot on
indeed.
With severe psychological issues.
welcome to the 21st centuries where hypocrisy has never been stronger
The trans woman with a sense of sanity, true respect to her.
Him
@@davideunbekannt7726hats a personal choice, if i see a transgender woman that has gone trhough an entire transition and looks like a woman i would autonatically use female pronouns with that person as well, if i see a man with no transition, that doesnt even act like a woman, but claims to be one i'll treat him like man no matter how much he indetifies as a woman, i think it is also something that has to do with how you look, most of the people would treat that trans person as a woman, even if we know he is biologically a man.
@@sebastiannicolini9005 still a man bonus hole or not
@@davideunbekannt7726she deserves the feminine pronoun
@@sebastiannicolini9005well, first thanks for saying it's a personal choice that's awesome salute to you 🫡 seriously.
And I do agree that if I see someone without any background information on that person and they look like a gender I will most probably refer to that person as to what gender most suits the appearance.
But like, what I'm saying is imagine a man with XY chromosomes of course and no intersex disorder, who did everything for the transition.
Then that alleged new woman decided to date men, so an XY individual decides to date another XY individual. Is it bigoted of me and offensive or hate speech of me in your mind if I call that gay?
Is that supposed to be a heterosexual relationship? Cause they'll still won't be able to have kids no matter how they look.
And my debate as you might have understood isn't about the pronouns, as I said before if you look manly enough or feminine enough and I don't exactly know your chromosomes, I will call you by the pronouns that you decide to dress as, so I'd call this trans person in this video a woman at least until before I knew his chromosomes.
So I'm just looking for your opinion on the gay or heterosexual part thanks 🙏🏻😊❤.
The irony of Benjamin demanding everyone respects the 100 different genders but the second Piers tells him he's not a Cis anything, he refuses to stop calling him cis-gendered 🤦🤦
Precisely 😊
The hypocrisy is endless from this extremists
That's how liberals work. Theirs is the only way. Everyone else is wrong. Remember that.
People think having a personality requires a whole new gender label.
I used to roll my eyes at them but when you see the wave of "female energy", people "in the feminine/masculine" and all this nonsense getting popular on social media I can understand how some people just can't take it anymore and want to create their own group.
Middlesex . It used to be a county near London .
@@luckystone2293this nonsense arose after the non-binary they/them lunatics exhausted peoples patience.
Yeah. It comes off as astrology abit. Some people are odd. And that's fine. But overidentifying with gender constructs seems unhealthy.
AGREED!!!!
It's actually so entertaining watching Piers having a go at these people
I wouldn't exactly call them ''people'' but yeah.
"We teach them how to adapt to societ and not sociey to adapt to them" Transwoman HUGE RESPECT 💙
that's the biggest problem i have with them. they expect you to walk a tightrope around their self made rules. that if we don't, we're bigots. like nobody gives a shit of they're whatever they identify as, just don't put that shit in my face and expect me to give a shit.
Identifying yourself as something doesn't make you that. I don't identify as a woman, I AM one. Period!
THIS tbh
True that!
period indeed
The job of a parent is not "to make their kids feel comfortable" that is rubbish. Thats how you raise an entitled adult baby with no accountability for their lot in life. Their job is to teach kids values, emotional control, work ethic and education. It's the parents job to teach them to work through hard things and accept that they can't always have their way!!
Comfort kills
This woke bs has gone too far. My 14 year old daughter recently came out to me as a straight girl and asked me if that was ok or of she was weird😢 Lord help us all.
that didn't actually happen did it
@@tagra_it does happen. Why do you suddenly think the number of "non binary" kids has exploded? It's certainly not something in the water that magically changed basic science. It's become a fad. All of the sudden fundamental science has become a game for kids and those who are socially awkward often don't understand it's a game.
This is the most damaging ideology in history potentially given the scale of the damage and the absolute insanity to come.
“How dare you tell me I can’t identify as that how dare you offend me”
“Look there I am”😂😂😂 I love this
If you want to identify differently, just do it. Enjoy and live your life. No need to force it on people and make it part of school agenda. Life was simple back then.
never been a fan of Piers but he's hilarious here
I'm becoming a fan, even though he's
Obnoxious, just because he's standing up to these clowns.
@@jonschlottig9584 true...stupid clown whose trying to drag others becoming stupid too
@@jonschlottig9584 he’s not obnoxious I completely agree with him.
@@Liamconneely7 Yep same
He’s an ass but he is funny asf
Screw it. Im coming out right now and saying i identify as a postbox. Tomorrow im going to paint myself red and stand outside my house all day with my mouth open.
I identify as a mailman that's doesnt deliver mail
Lol
How are people not exhausted by all of this? We've made something that once was so simple into something complicated. Adults don't even understand this ideology, how the hell do people expect children to?
Piers: “You have come to defend it and you don’t know what half of these are”.
Pronoun: “But hang on Piers, ignorance isn’t a defence”.
Piers: “You’re the ignorant one, and you’re the one defending it!”
😂😂😂
OMG. He knows nothing about what he is supporting.
Exactly!! He just made it up
@@jaymoreno20 it’s a total fabrication.
I completely agree with Piers. I actually stand by having different gender identities to identify different people. But this needs to have a rational limit. Adding more and more identities with useless definitions on the list is utterly ridiculous.
He said he doesn't agree with it.
Setting a Rational Limit after your thought would be discriminating wouldnt it? If he can Identify as a neutrum I want to Identify as a Giraffe.
@@therealchicken7151 if you think that identifying as a giraffe is completely normal, this is where irrationality walks in. Listening to logic is not discriminatory; it is called taking advice before making a decision. Unfortunately, the decisions of identifying as a cabinet or a washing machine are one's own, so no logic is included, only wild imagination persists.
The "wanna be white indian"
@@therealchicken7151how about identify as milfgender or cock&ballgender👀
@@anukrite.rajvanshiidentifying as anything that isn’t the GENDER YOU WERE BORN AS is not normal at all so if bro wants to identify as a giraffe, LET HIM
It’s just Male or female . You can’t actually pick one cus you’re just born one or the other.
Embrace it and love yourself just the way you are ❤
for people with gender dysphoria, it's sadly impossible to "accept who you are"
Facts
They're still male or female even if they cant accept it lol
@@tagra_ That's what therapists/psychologists were for. Too bad everyone is corrupted now
@@tagra_ AGREED
A retired school teacher told me that, each year, she used to ask the girls in her mixed-sex class of 8 and 9 year olds if they would rather have been born boys. She gave them a little time to discuss among themselves. A harmless question, surely. There have always been tomboys who would have preferred male activities and gender roles. No harm in that, surely. But she never came across a girl who actually thought she was a boy. Everyone in the class would have doubted her sanity.
But what was interesting is that the proportion of girls who said they would like to be boys was very high in some years and very low in others. Pupils did not want to go against the majority, or at any rate they wanted to give the same answer as their friends. More healthy, surely, if they thought for themselves.
Add another ten years of age, and the psychological ability to think for oneself seems to be extinguished in many individuals.
“They didn’t wanna go against the majority”? 😂
Wtf you basing that on?
Transgender people are literally an extremely TINY minority. Trust me if you’re trans or gay you’ll be trans or gay.
The idiotic method of confusing every kid into having many of them experiment or even transition bcs a TINY TEENY minority of humans globally are wired differently , is just insane.
I think the problem is that these individuals want to highlight their entire personality with just their gender identity. You can have your sexual preference, your preference in what appearance you want to have, or your characterization separated from "male" and "female" (or any new genders you come up with). The components of your personality don't necessarily need to fit into the category of "gender identity".
Make sense. Well said. 🙂
Very well said. People are confusing characteristics of personality with gender.
*"I thought I was going to grow up in a tree surrounded by nuts"*
Well..... You're sat next to one.... 😂
being born into 80s and growing up in 90s and 2000s, i don't recognize this world anymore...
“Imagine a squirrel surrounding by nuts” gosh i laugh so hard
Me too hahahahaha even the tranny who said it realized it was gay
Me too, 😢😂
Strange enough i think thats the purpose of this all: make normal people think they are weird and make them feel guilty about it.
1:05
I love how defensive Piers gets as the lad keeps repeating "cis" to him.
it cracks me up every single time 😂😂😂
@Jamie M cis lad 🤣🤣
"Cis lad" 🤣🤣🤣
8:14 "I'm being called a cissy right now and i don't like it Benjamin"
@@saucy743cissy is n word for man☕👀
He's shit at defending himself.
the world has gone nuts . this is the best comedy ever
Even squirrels like yourself can't save it.
For the time being it is a comedy....but in time one could go to jail for hurting feelings by making fun of the one whose feelings got hurt.
Really no hate for her but this was just too good 🤣🤣💜💜
"I thought I was a squirrel. I thought i was gonna grow up and be in a tree surrounded by nuts"
She's definitely surround by nuts in this video
Lol
Piers always speaks the truth!
It's ironic that schools are "teaching" about open-mindedness, but banning...
A rational transwoman! My trans friends are the same. Teachers… have no right to tell a child any.
"Common sense Benjamin??" had me on the floor
Right 😂😂
The look on the co hosts faces at the end... priceless.
Bro this world needs a reset
Children are extremely affected by suggestive ideas about themselves and others and incorporate these ideas into their identities due to this being the process of identity development which makes teaching all these different titles concerning😮
And it makes me so mad because children are impressionable even adults struggle to understand it what makes people think that children are capable of making such a broad decision
A defender of 100 Gender but cannot define even 3..... 😂😂😂😂
Piers should identify as a comedian 😂😂 dude can be hilarious some times with all this craziness going on watching these you tube videos makes my day
His relatable frustration is hilarious.
"I salute you for your common sense" lol😂😂😂😂😂😂
THE PENGUIN!!! with piers face and Music sent me.!!!!!
The whole thing has gotten way out of control. There needs to have a limit set on it. Regardless of what you decide you are - DNA wise for gender, there is only a set for male & a set for female. That is something that just is. Your DNA doesn't change just because you decide to be something different.
9:38 "Whats the opposite of evolution?" IM CRYING😭😭😭😭😭
I think the term "gender" means something different to the two camps. It's unfortunate that kids are getting wrapped up into this, especially considering how easily sexualized "gender" can become.
Honestly, though, when I was a little kid, I would pretend to be a dinosaur or a weasel or other such things. I didn't believe I actually was one, but I thought it was fun to imagine what it would be like to be different creatures. I feel like this is similar, just to a bit of an extreme.
Also, I COMPLETELY agree with what Piers said and I think it should be way more highlighted. One of the essential roles of a parent is to simplify the complexities of life to a level that a child can comprehend and will bring them to a place of balance and understanding in society. By convoluting their identity and suggesting that other people identify as things they could never comprehend you achieve the complete opposite of that.
Furthermore, I'm pretty sure that all of this hundred-gender agenda is perpetrated by people who are confused themselves and don't have kids. I'm raising a daughter who I expect will probably become a tomboy (since I'm into sports and lots of "manly stuff" and the value in masculine hobbies), but I'm going to raise her as a girl and try to mitigate any confusion to the greatest degree possible because I feel that's the healthiest thing for her.
And just to throw it out there, I've worked with literally multiple thousands of kids of all ages (4 and up) and gender is not something they should generally be at all concerned about.
Gender means personality to these people.
well then one camp is wrong and its called the left... gender and sex are not different, my passport says gender and it mean sex lmao.
Remember growing up we all thought we were special? The whole thing about daring to be different is now lost. I think the entire gender identity thing got taken so far down the road that it's going to backfire on everyone spectacularly.
I have a B.A. Biology and a B.A. Chemistry. Please compensate my expenses and time for my education if everything has changed. Accruing. Thank you.
all of this gender identity stuff should just be treated the same way we treat emotions in people, cause that's what it seems to be to me
"how dare you offend me" 😂😂😂 he should have added "that is a clear violence against me, you're a violent person" 😂😂😂 that person is clearly confused of their own b.s
That's the best thing I've ever seen 😂 I love you Piers
"To put it another way, shes talking complete cobblers..." - proceeds to end the interview. That cracked me up.🤣 🤣
Piers, you got to understand that sometimes people just make stuff up to get attention.
There should be ZERO discussion on this subject…limit and then some. YOU ARE RECRUITING, face it and clean your mind. Children should not be exposed to this kind of criminal activity EVER.
can we bring back hospitals for insane people?
Its the song they play for the penguin😭😭😭😭😭😂😂
This is the funniest conversation I've ever heard.
I’m impressed the guy came onto the show in the first place. He got eaten alive by the very thing he’s supposed to be specialized in. I still can’t stop laughing at Morgan’s two spirit penguin bit, just like the old classic “I identify as an attack helicopter”.
Piers must be be nominated for the penguin of the year
Piers should be nominated for "Dumb F**got of the Year".
I remember being a princess on Monday, an astronaut on Tuesday and a boy on Wednesday evening paying with my cousins but it doesn't mean I wanted
eeded to transition to any of it 😂
"You can't convince someone to be certain identity "OK so how did I end up believing that I was a Gynesexual. It took me a few months to realize that I put myself into this box only because of my lgbtq friends. People are easy to manipulate especially the desperate ones. Which, let's be real, are mostly kids, teenagers, and young adults.
“We got the world expert here” -Piers 🤣🤣🤣
i identify as a transformer..now let me change to a superbike "khuk khuk khuk khuk khuuk!". 🏍️
There is a big difference between offensive and insulting. If truth is offensive then take that offence back to what that means for you.. question it.. be brave to face it and in your own night time of quietness to truly seek
Do you see? Its all ideological, he doesnt even know the 100 hundred types of gender he is defending to teach in classrooms
Also when Piers says it exposes transgenders to needless mockery, and the trans person agreed while the straight man shakes his head in disagreement. This guy is a piece of work.
The western society have lost their mind
There is no need to limit the number of various deviant groups.
Create a label just fort them - female / male / OTHER
The weather that day in Wrexham was quite pleasant
This was a real treat to watch
IDK why but this cracked me up lmaoo 9:15
This is like a crazy game you are playing during a nightmare! 😂
I identify myself as an alien , and I got a problem I cannot find my UFO
there are many things I could touch upon here from the video, but one that I very rarely see discussed in ALL spaces, is two-spirit. There is severe lack of awareness of Indigenous identities and the importance of them in their respective cultures. Two spirit is something that is only applicable to Indigenous people, so to hear it used multiple times in this video to mock the lgbtqia+ community AND in doing so harming Indigenous people and practices is heart-wrenching. Intersectionality is once again needed in this discussion, because of lack of knowledge or representation. I work in the field of anthropology in a museum. I research Indigenous knowledge, history and culture on a broad scale but have done so on more specific areas within this for a few years. Two spirit is included in this. I also find interesting that comment by Nicole "why is this stuff coming up now" when talking about the lgbtqia+ community in an attempt to suggest these intricate and diverse topics of discussion are some new idea that people have made up. I find it interesting because unfortunately it is very misinformed and limited way of viewing the world past and present. Gender identities beyond the binary and sexualities beyond "well-known" have been existed for quite literally, THOUSANDS of years within human AND other animal species. Just because you are unaware of these doesn't mean you get to negate their existence. Did you know the gender binary (And I say this from a position of a researcher) has sufficient and compelling evidence to be a tool or ideal to forcefully use when North America and the Indigenous people were colonized? In simpler terms, I found out, that in addition to other assimilations that were forced onto people (e.g. speaking English, wearing settlers clothing, going to boarding schools, privatisation. The list can go on), limiting gender identity to the binary man and woman was used as a controlling tool. You may have noticed I have not explained what two-spirit IS. This is because I would rather you did your own research and not just take it from me, a random youtube commenter. This is also because I am NOT two spirit or actively part of an Indigenous community, although I have Berber heritage. I am not claiming to be an expert, but I have learnt alot in my work and education that I do, as well as from Indigenous people themselves.
Nicole said "I thought I was going to grow up surrounded by nuts" .... Well you did love!.. Just slightly different ones!.. Lol😂
Well, of course children might feel differently at some point, especially when puberty begins, that's how human are: unique in their individuality. This isn't about gender, it's about knowing yourself as a human
I love you Piers, thank you for being our voice‼️‼️
how are there only 2 comments... did they purge the comments or is my yk glitching??
idk i'm confused too
they turned on comments yesterday im pretty sure
the gays are deleting our comments
Pierce: "common sense Benjamin 😖"
😂😂
This should've been a 5-10sec video:
Q: Should There Be a Limit to Gender Identities?
A: Yes and the genders are - Male, Female, Trans gender
I identify as a male gender and I have male responsibilities to provide for my family, wife, closest friends. My duty is to be the dominant figure in figuring out other's problems and provide a solution that fits them and in return gives me favors, up-rise in confidence and knowledge gains.
Lol good one
"You can't convince a child something that they are not" ..... "children are impressionable, i wanted to be a squirrel"
The one with long black hair deserve a lot of respect ❤
Piers wiped the floor with that poof! 😂 He doesn't know any of these terms that are made up in a moment's notice that we are supposed to learn and respect.
You can't support something and have no idea of what it is you're supporting. He should just identify as confused.
am i old for saying: since when is it a teachers job to "confirm" their sex, gender? what happened to: good morning kids, lets do some math/ geography/ history/ chemistry
"HOW DARE YOU ASSUME MY SEXUALITY!"
... "DONT USE MY OWN SPELLS AGAINST ME POTTER!"
i love that he always askes the questions that eveybody else is thinking
Nobody chooses or identifies with gender because it's a set human aspect with no winding twists or turns but a straight fact and physical form. People identify with their personalities or who they are and who we are has nothing to do with our bodies but how we think,act,and feel about different things
Benjamin didn't do his research, he just wanted to be on TV...Facebook, Tiktok and other media wasn't enough.
What did they do to this comment section bro 💀
they turned it on two days ago
verified person 😱
Completely agree with Nicole and glad she has the senses in her. Proud she knows there are two sex, and if you like or feel any other way that’s on you, however the whole world does not need to accept 100 gender identities for a small amount of people in the world. We have been Woman and Man since the world was created, if you get offended with the truth, you are the problem. This generation needs to stop being overly sensitive and keep it to the facts.
The irony of Benjamin trying to impose the "cis" noun on Piers, when quickly calling out mis-gendering is laughable.
Respect to Piers, f@#kn legend
Ever since people have started gays and lesbian same sex marriage the world has gone mad
I really don't see this kind of debate going anywhere...
Look at the background, so many labels… it’s crazy!! 😓
Totally love Piers :))) He is brutal while maintaining respect with a sense of wit.
Piers has become a wise man!
Jeremy Clarkson did him a favour by knocking sense into him!
I wouldn't have a problem with this if they didn't call all these identities "genders", but just "personalities" or "identities" instead.
That would make too much sense.
@@DarkMirria1 😅
I swear if this was never brought up kids would still say they're a boy or a girl not battle ship, attack helicopter and etc. In Piers Morgans words: This is just ridiculous
Piers: common sense?! Benjamin!😅
9:24
its beyond me how we got into this debate about gender.