East-Pakistan to Bangladesh | Part 5
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 07. 2020
- Operation Searchlight, India-Pakistan war of 1971, and the creation of Bangladesh. The details of this history, about which we know so little, are revealed in painstaking detail. What lessons should we learn from this history? How can we ensure that we never make these mistakes again? Hope you enjoy this concluding episode about Bangladesh.
Warning: Controversial, Contains Images with Violence
Bangladesh playlist: • From East-Pakistan to ... - Hudba
![Mod Phil 9: Religion is the Opium of the Masses [Urdu]](/img/n.gif)
I as a 4 yr old was in Chittagong. We escaped i think in April of 71 on a ship to save our lives. Though overall it is clear that east Pakistan was right and west was wrong... Unfortunately Pakistan still have not learned the lesson ...
Pppppp...l..
Ll..p.
Ll.l.ppl.l
L.pl.llmlll..lo
L. .. like the other
Llp
Kp.ol.lpk
L
P
P
Pp
PPp
Pppppp...l..
Ll..p.
Ll.l.ppl.l
L.pl.llmlll..lo
L. .. like the other
Llp
Kp.ol.lpk
L
P
P
Pp
P
Pp
Bro
We need to search objectively. Your literature is pro indian.
@@goharawan7213 The literature of Bangladesh is about Bangladesh and not "Indian". stop justifying war crimes of your country by naming imaginary India. Grow up
@@tankseverywhere1492 why the many leaders of Mukhti bahni revealed the true motives of that movement. and why the felt sorry to work to indian as puppet. Our elders Muslims of whole subcontinet was much intelligent then us. They know the Indian killing ambitions therefore they struggle for Pakistan.
Hats off to you Taimur for describing the timeline concisely and non biased. It needs courage and authenticity to expose the facts
Thank you.
Sir plx recommend books of philosophy for beginner plxx sir reply me! Thank u
@@junaidkhankhattak7325 The Philosophy Book by DK Publishing is a good introduction.
Author Nasim Yousaf has changed the course of history. Dr. Asarulislam Syed, Tarek Fateh, Prof. Pervez Hoodbhoy and Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed and others are reflecting his ideas about Jinnah and the partition of India.
czcams.com/video/3_1_eJWOBm0/video.html
Love and respect from Bangladesh, Sir. It was been a long but enlightening experience. Keep uploading these kinds of lectures.
Love from Pakistan bro and sorry for what cruel military did to you….
Thanks for Being honest 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
I really appreciate the way you give lecture to audience.
And the series of “Partition of Bangladesh 🇧🇩” resolve every question in my mind.
I hope that you will continue the same method as you did in this lectures. 👍
You are absolutely right, 100% correct this history.
Author Nasim Yousaf has changed the course of history. Dr. Asarulislam Syed, Tarek Fateh, Prof. Pervez Hoodbhoy and Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed and others are reflecting his ideas about Jinnah and the partition of India.
czcams.com/video/3_1_eJWOBm0/video.html
Such an informative series. I really wish that people do listen to these types of lectures. Really really helpful.
This lecture series should be taught in every university, both in Pakistan and Bangladesh. Thanks a lot Professor for the hard work.
Got traumatised with emotional roller coaster. Very analytical, liked it so much... it’s good to know that there are still some people who have the courage to speak the truth..
I am very happy to have just watched all the parts of this very informative CZcams Video, even with my limited Urdu. My heartiest thanks to Dr. T. Rahman. As a Bangladeshi living in the US, but was a witness to those atrocities as a small boy, I loved Dr. Rahman's compassionate and accurate view of that tragic history while him being a Pakistani. He is completely honest and puts in objective analyses based on facts and authoritative sources. I wish there were more people like Dr. Rahman during 1947 and 1971 who could have averted those tragedies.
I lost three close relatives: My uncle, a DMD of PIA who contributed so much to PIA, one first cousin, and another husband (Military Colonel and Doctor) of my cousin. All were killed by the Pakistani Army in 1971 because they were Bengalis. However, I do not keep any hatred against anyone-- Pakistanis, Indians, Jews, Israelis, Ahmedis, British who ruled us, and powerful Americans. We must forgive all and move on.
One thing I will point out is that if anyone asks me one word to describe why Bangladeshis disliked Pakistanis and broke away from it, it will be "Attitude". In addition to racism, religion was also used by Middle Eastern mindset Pakistanis (Not Shia or Ahmedi Muslims, though. For disclosure, I am a Sunni.) to denigrate Bengalis who are closer to the Asiatic/ Hindu culture. Dr. Rahman put it nicely at the end, "Where was compassionate politics"?
To Dr. Rahman: Please also take into account Sharmila Bose's book "Dead Reckoning" for the number of people killed by the Pakistan Army. Her brother might be married to Dr. Ayesha Jalal. So she had access to Pakistan files. Also. you could indicate job disparity. My father was a member of E. Pak Civil Service (EPCS) and showed me a Civil List which showed even in E Pakistan, there were more non-Bengali Civil Servants. That also had to do with the fact that there were fewer educated Muslim Benglis compared to Urdu Speaking migrants to Pakistan. You may like to read my blog where I touched on the 1971 crisis: marufkhan2016.wordpress.com/2016/03/02/muslims-must-abandon-anti-western-rhetoric-to-solve-their-present-crisis/
As a Sufi, I will end by saying: Only God Knows the Best and God Bless Dr. Tamiur Rahman and people like him. "Blessed are the peacemakers: for they shall be called the children of God. [Matthew 5:9; N.T]
Thank you for that wonderful review. Warmest regards. Hope to meet you some day.
Religion is still used here in pakistan to manipulate the public but still nobody learnt a lesson instead they are intent on making pak a country ruled by terrorist to achieve the goal of conquering the whole world which is a lost cause and we are suffering because of our govt's decision so much for the people's govt.
I have watched lots of videos on this topic but I found you the best. I have completed watching the playlist. it's 4:15 am here
Thank you, sir
Thank you for the detailed presentation. As a Bangladeshi, I appreciate the honesty, the truthfulness and the sincerity with which this tragic period of our lives was presented.
My good wishes for our Bangladeshi brothers and sisters. May your generations prosper and be compensated by almighty Allah.
Very sincere effort and is true to humanity without being anti Pakistan.
If we think sensibly it will be so clear that both India and Pakistan are basically of same stock who should be working together to support each other instead of getting exploited by people of different ethnic stock like China or European/USA /Russia ...May Allah the almighty grant us the wisdom to realize this sooner and find a way to join hands without the feeling that we are losing our freedom choices for our own way of life with respect for others having the same..woh subah kabhi to ayegi...
G bilkul
Hats off to brave people of Bangladesh. Inspite of such atrocities by Pakistani army and natural calamities, they have overcome such odds and progressed rapidly. Today Bangladesh is ahead of Pakistan in every economic parameters. Great courageous people deserve a salute
You are saying all that in the hate of Pakistan. But we still love our brothers.
I have seen 71 don't like non bengalis
A brilliant objective analysis. Your charismatic narration does not allow one' to leave in between. Regards
Sir, thank you for sharing the story of 1971. I'm a son of a freedom fighter, and grandson of a retired connel from EPR. My mom's family is full of freedom fighter, they moved to Dhaka after my grandfather retired from pakistan's military around 1960s. My mother's elder brother was born in Lahore but he was one of the student killed by pakistan's military in Dhaka, even though, he told the military who he was, a muslim and his father was a retired officer. They hung his body upside down after death because he was Bangali. So my other uncle joined the freedom fighters to gain freedom for Bangladesh. Pakistan's military Raped and Killed MILLIONS of Bangali people, we know the history. They sabotage every where, killed unarmed people ruthlessly. Our rivers in Bangladesh were full of blood and dead bodies. Our freedom fighters fought pakistan's military any way they could to win the war. Pakistan finally surrendered with 95 thousands pakistan's trained arm soldiers. Still today, people all around Bangladesh have the night mare of what pakistan's military did in Bangladesh. Its unforgettable for many people. We respect you for not hiding the truth entirely. Just want to THANK You for finally talking about it to pakistan's people and making them aware of what happened. Because many people in pakistan has no clue of what really happened. So again thank you from Bangladesh for telling the truth to pakistan's people. Peace be on you. Bangladesh Jindabad...
Joy Bangladesh
from Hindustan : we will with u always ... as a friend country ...
@@maheshladdha4745 thank you brother
I am from Pakistan(Punjab). Whatsoever happened during 1971, was absolutely free from the adulteration of any consent or ambition of most of the Politicians and General Public of West Pakistan. Certain Politicians issued their narratives for handing over the regime to Mujeeb, only the best option for the Unity of country and I remember that MNAs of West Pakistan began to reach to Dacca to attend the Assembly session scheduled on 2n March 1971.
It was democratic right of Mujeeb to be handed over the rule of Country, but Bhutto was Power hunger and Yahya was his Puppet. At that time, if Mujeeb was accepted as PM of Pakistan, the following unpleasant stances could easily and successfully be avoided.
1) Assassination/ Killings of innocent Beharis, Bengalis, Hindus, Urdu speaking and West Pakistani families.
2) Crossing over border of India by 9.7M inhabitants of East Pakistan to get shelter.
3) Till date the Camp life of Beharis.
4) Dismemberment of country.
5) Opportunity for India, an everlasting enemy of Pakistan, to interfere.
6) Historical surrender.
My love to my departed brothers and sisters of Bangladesh.
@@maheshladdha4745 love for you. Bangladesh will never forget Indira ji and people of india for their help and support in 1971. I was born after several yrs of independence war. My mother told me if indira ji would not help them then Pakistan army would brutally kill them. Love and respect for great indira ji and her country....long live Bangladesh ...long live India....
Superbly structured, well analysed and well delivered series.
Thanks n kudos to you, Dr. Rehman.
Very nicely explained all the concepts. I am truly humbled that this series clear my perceptions on two major issues.
1. The idea of independence from West Pakistan was a conspiracy by the Bengali people and they were not ready to live with us from day one. Now its cleared that was the result our mistakes and brutal decisions imposed on Bengali people.
2. If your political parties and institutions are weak than military is the ultimate solution to strengthen the country. Hamood ur Rehman commission report clear that point as well.
Hats of to you Sir Taimur Rahman and definitely it will help me in competition exam as well.
As Salamu Alaikum. I'm from Bangladesh. I heard the playlist. It's very informative. Thanks.
Now this is how history should be presented!! Great research...Fantastic story boarding... Absolutely lived (no typo) it!! Thank you doctor saab...for one of the best series of lectures on YT!!
Really informative series,sir. Learning a lot from you, stay blessed and happy.
Thank you very much Mr Taimur Rahman. I am a retired Commodore from Bangladesh. I have watched your all five lecture series. You have cronologically and very efficiently covered all the root causes of separation of pakistan. The lecture has logically unvailed all the aspects, like social, economic, politics etc. It would be more enriched if you could mention discrapency in employment of west and east pakistani personnel in govt, civil and military services. Over all it is a commendable job you have done.
I had lots of pakiistani friends. They are very cordial, cooperative, affectionate and lovely pesonnels. But I observed that pakistanies are less interested to know the history. This is my personal observation. Thank you again.
Thank you for that feedback Kutab sb. You are right that statistics on employment could also have been included.
@@Taimur_Laal Thanks dear Mr. Rahman for noticing my commment, and your reply. my mail address is mkbakhtiar@gmail.com. If you wish you can communicate with me for sharing informarions.
Best Rgards.
Commodore Bakhtiar
@@Taimur_Laal chotey bhai.Assalamu Alaikkum. I am from the south Indian state Kerala.I was 1st year BA student when the civil war started in East Pakistan subsequent on the general election of Pakistan in 1970. When the mandate of the people were neglected by the bureaucracy and establishment of Pakistan a section of Awami league wanted total seperation from Pakistan. When the unity and territorial integrity of Pakistan was challenged and questioned by some secessionist elements the State of Pakistan was constrained to initiate stringent action against secessionism. But in the name of preserving the unity and integrity the Pakistani defence forces had committed devilish brutalities against their own people of its eastern wing. Similar ferocious atrocities were also committed by the so called Mukhti Bahini secessionist hooligans against the West Pakistani people and their families residing there at that time and against the Urdu speaking Biharis and against the the Bengalis who favoured the unity and integrity of Pakistan. It is to be noted that Awami league leader sheik Mujib was once the prime accused in the Agartala conspiracy case which was later with drawn due to political pressure.Further the 6 point program of Sheik mujib in the final DNA was the secesion of east Bengal from Pakistan. So perhaps these were some of the reasons why Mujib was denied to form the next Government. It is also to be noted that the people of east Pakistan never gave mandate to seceed from Pakistan..Anyway Bangladesh is a political reality.
Kutub uddin Bhakhtiyar. Assalamu alaikkum. I am from the south Indian state Kerala. I was 1st year BA student when the civil war started in East Pakistan subsequent on the general election of Pakistan in 1970. The civil war in course of time turned into an Indo Pak war in which Pakistan was defeated on both fronts and its eastern wing seceeded from Pakistan and became another country known as Bangladesh. If there was No India Pak war in 1971 there would never be any Bangladesh at all. Anyway Bangladesh is the reality. But there is another side. By becoming a separate country the present day Bangladesh has lost their legitimate right over each and every inches of their former western wing comprising of 4 provinces and having more than 6 times larger land area than their present country for ever. A much more greater loss than Pakistan which has lost only one of their provinces. This was the net result of the so called liberation. Think it in that way also.
@@kassimka123 Thanks Mr. Kassim. Birth of Bangladesh was obvious regardless of India's involvment in 1971 Bangladesh war of independence, may be it would take some more days. If you notice the progress of Bangladesh, you are to acknowledged that we better to be independent and got seperated from Pakistan.
God bless you for imparting this valuable and unbiased version of the history. Impressive!
Thank you very much, Mr.Dr. Taimur Rahman Bhai. I have seen your all series of videos about the fall of East Pakistan. A full set of beautiful educational and history-based documents. I was present there to watch the last sunset of East Pakistan at the Ramna Racecourse Ground in Dacca on 16th December 1971 at the local standard time of 4:35 pm. I was a prisoner of the Bangladesh independence war in 1971. A member of Mukti-Bahini.
Congrats
More power to you brother 🙌
People here in Pakistan have a huge misconception that the Pak Army is solely responsible for the National unity and stability of the country.
However if Pakistan is ever further divided then it is safe to say that it will definitely be due to the actions of the Army
This Army has totally hijacked the system and don't ever respect the constitution and democracy
A man and his love can change the world 🌍. Thanks for your contribution
The biggest lesson the whole of subcontinent irrespective of any religion can learn from violence during partition in 1947, kashmir problem, operation bluestar in golden temple, east pakistan crises, is the political party and the common man should be shown high level of responsibility to maintain the peace and stability of the society. We must respect each other's sentiments.
Amarji I agree and I HV the same opinion.When the 2 Germany's can unite can we 3 countries if not unite , can we not live and work together in peace and harmony?
@@nandakumark2433 We can not work together until two of these happens-
1. We become enoughly capabke to destroy each other completely. (This requirement has already been fulfilled by India and Pakistan)
2. We have a common national interest or threat near to tangible in existence.(which none of us have fulfilled and if it goes on like what it is now then this is not going to happen any day)
@@mdits249 Dear Isfar Ji.,the hatred we have been developing and still continue to develop against each other should go only if peace prevails in the erstwhile Indian Sub continent now split into 3 can the all 3 nations grow in all ways, political, economical & socially .will it ever happen? .
Thank you sir. Love and respect for you from Bangladesh.
Thank you doctor, idk but I have tears in my eyes right now. Hope we learn from the mistakes that we committed in past
@@Neel71
پبلک کا کوئی قصور نہیں ہے پبلک سے نفرت کرنے سے کیا ہو گا
when i see and hear people like you, it gives hope that pakistan has hope. admitting past mistakes is first step to moving on to finding current mistakes.
bangladesh has managed to move on and is at the beginning stage of becoming a economic power. bangladesh holds no grudges, but its whole identity is linked to the pakistani era past and its rather dark.
a state level simple admittance of mistake can begin new chapter in history for both countries. its not that we'll suddenly become friends; theres too much complicated geopolitics about, but both countries can work on shared interest.
As a Pakistani. I am extremely sorry for what happened. I hope more people would learn about it. I am very hopeful for the future of both nations.
Nd would love to visit Chittagong one day. In urdu literature that I've read, its description is really of a fairyland. 😍
@@xyz-fq5nm chittagong isnt what you may have read. its still a run down city, but give about five years it will be a city to marvel at.
bangladesh has found its feet after 50 years, but the main thing is it has found it and a lot of work is in the process to modernise the country.
we look forward to see people of pakistan visiting bangladesh.
LOVE YOU, MY DEAR TEACHER. You told true picture of history.
It was shocking and informative at the same time , thank you sir
You guys killed 3 million unarmed civilian, and raped 200 thousands women, and still now Pakistan didn’t apologised to Bangladesh, shame!
Truth has been spoken. Thanks Taimur.
Sir.... Please make more such informative videos... U are doing a great service by documenting the truth and facts
I acknowledge and praise your efforts of explaining one of the dark period of Pakistan...I hope that your journey will not end here and i wish to see more of lectures in future.. thank you
Awesome series, beautifully narrated 👍 👍
Very informative and detailed video.
Great series..
You are great teacher.
Heartiest congratulation to you for ur brave attempt and detail description of history of Independence of Bangladesh.
@@channels663 actually India did nothing it was Pakistan who did operation search light which killed so many people in dhaka then sheikh mujib declare independence of bangladesh .then India took it as an opportunity and gave arms to our freedom fighters and trained them .and in 3rd December when Pakistan attack India then India directly started military operation .in this 9 month of war Pakistan killed around 3 million people and raped around 2lakh women . sorry to say but Pakistan has no one to blame except themselves
Why Sekh Mujeeb was killed with family. Again 4 leaders were killed in the Jail after around 2 months. Why people did not go to the jail to release them!! Too sad!!
Great sir..
Fabulous work
Thats very great effort sir... kmal baat ki apny
Thanks a lot for your honest review. You earned my respect and love.
it is clear that on 3.12.1971, Pakistan attacked India and war started. Bhutan was the first country to recognise Bangladesh.
Thank you very much dear sir for educating us.
Please can you upload this video in English?
Unfortunately, we don't know Urdu :(
Very true history of East Pakistan. From Chittagong, Bangladesh. Thank you Sir.....
Alhamdulillah. We got independence.
It is a common phenomenon to examine the accuracy of any such works which try to describe the reasons behind our liberation struggle is to put it under a test of 4 factors. Nationalism, Democracy, Secularism and Socalism- the four pillers of our constitution. This series fulfills all the 4 factors.
For socialism- it shows the economic exploitations from the very root cause, adoption of naked capitalist principles at the very begining of Pakistan.
nationalism- it shows the validity of the position of nationalism inside an (ought to be) religious confedaration like Pakistan,
democracy- the bad impact of military dictatorship is almost illustratively described here affirmimng Hamudur R.'s opinion.
secularism- although poorly addressed but at least the reasons behind Bengali politics being more secular in nature is described here.
So, I personally found your work quite exhaustive, within its limitations of course.... Dispensing gratitude from Bangladesh.
Thank you.
Very informative and great lecturer Allhamdulillah we are much better now
The main reason for the break up of Pakistan was that Pakistanis did not respect Bengalis. They did not want to give them their fair share. Bengali officers were not recruited in the armed forces in proportion to the population. Education did not contribute to the development of health and social infrastructure. Foreign currency was used to make mills and factories in West Pakistan by selling Bangladeshi tea jute. And the biggest reason is the inability to hand over power to the elected representatives
Helo
its really awesome sir. I love your way of explanation
Thank you Dr. Tamuir for explaining it. In schools, we were tought that it was all India's and bangladesh's fault.
Thank you Dr Taimur Rahman for your candid opinion & description about operation searchlight in which the then Pakistani army committed genocide in Bangladesh in 1971.
Informative series...
Jazak ALLAH sir!
Always stay blessed.... Ameen!
Sir yeh white paper Kiya hota hai?
Very thought provoking and well balanced and many of the facts were unknown to me. Thank you Dr Taimur for uploading such an informative and difficult chapter of the history.
Very very honest review. You are a good human
Mr Taimur Rehman such a detail report u presented , really its ur commitment towards humanity
great job apriciate ur honest nd unbias approach .
Mukti bahini was formed by general bengali people. You cannot separate them from general public.
Sir, Thank you for sharing informative knowledge with us.
Well. professor sahab. Past is past. But, I will tell that Bangladesh is moving ahead. Future young generation love Bangladesh more than anybody else.
I wish and I pray that we start to learn from history. Thank you for this wonderful lecture series.
Hats off Sir...Mashallah... may Allah give you a blessing life
Sir it is humble request, actually I also requsted that you with respect, should make vedios on the four martial laws of Paksitan... but I shall wait for ur answer as this is ur discretion but we will be in great debt to ur honourable work... May God grant u happy life
Dr sb, where can we get Hamood ur Rahman Commsion report?
Available online.
Just brilliant Sir!
Thanks sir for this
Sir, you are really an inspiration, the way you teach is exceptional.
I really enjoyed this series and it has cleared me of every aspect regarding the partition of East Pakistan.
Great work for humanity...
may Allah bless you more and more...!
Incorrect information! Check how Rashid Jajua was killed in Chittagong in front of his wife!
@@iqbalahmed5979
May be,
but I was appreciating the efforts of sir taimor rehman to present all about partition, which he know, in such an amazing and impressive way...
That made me clear a lot about this partition.
Sir please tell us about problems going on in fata and afghan border problems with pak
very informative
What ever happened in November, should have happened in March Or April 1971 , in that case life and tragedies could be avoided. As I realized that Bangladesh was destined so less violence would be better option.
Sir agr apky lecture use reference ko agr nechy bda dain tw behtr rahy ga e.g ICJ-1972 report, Hamood ud rehman commission especially
ak dum sas bola dher sare guptu gu suna suna . a sob se behetar bola thank u. so mach
The fact that a vast amount of your people are still ignorant about our liberation war explains the mindset up of Pakistan. As someone has already said, you're doomed to repeat the same thing if you don't learn from your history.
Today I just finished this long pending series.
Found it factual and eye opening as all your content is ... ✔️👍
Many Thanks Sir. You have enlightened us on an important issue. May Allah bless us.
Dr. Taimur sir..
Apka 5 parts history bilkul acceptable documents about Bangladesh liberation....
I have just finished these parts....
Bangabondhu tried to permanent Pakistan by based on lahor regulations.
Yes.... !
Even Bangabondhu declared the independence after 25 march army attack......
We can not blame Mujib for breaking up pakistan .its the vutto's did as well as Mr Yaahiyaa khan.
......
In our Bangladesh we were poor before 71....
And after war we became the poorest as you mentioned.
In that poorest position there were no food, clothes.
So the leadership was not worked...
In this time Bangobondhu alonge with his family killed...
Pakistan (our willing country in 47) treated with ours as a step son... You know...
Even after war they blame ours.
We are a kind nation.....
If pakistan wanted apology then you remember that we are so kind.
We have no hatred fo common people of pakistan (our formar country)
But we faced the bloody reality.
From বাংলাদেশ।
No man. No Pakistani blames Bangladeshi people. We made mistakes nd we paid the price. I am extremely sorry for what happened.
Now Bangladesh's economy is doing fairly well. I m really happy for our Bangali brothers
Thank you Dr Taimur!! 🙏
so good.
A great anaylysis of the fall of Dhaka in all these episodes, Sir. The East Pakistan fell because of constitutional breakdown, economic collapse and political disintegration. First the one Unit Act should never have been brought. It should never have been revoked suddenly in 1969. Even we violated the 1962 constitution when power was transferred to Yahya Khan. I hope all these lectures are carefully watched by army officers and the families of army officers.
We did not fall. It was our rise and your fall. We rose from being the third class citizens of an oppressor state that treated us as slaves. You on the other hand, lost half of the country, the more fertile, productive, kind, secular and intellectual half. Who has crossed you now almost in every index and you are still in the past being the warmongering fanatic nation who knows nothing but brutality and atrocities towards it’s own people. Balochistan today is prime example of that.
Very well 👍
Excellent
Excellent Sir
Superb very well composed. It was a very informative and unbiased talk. We need to be more responsible in accepting the truth. God bless and keep on doing the good work
Thank you so much Sr, for your logical reports sharing. I completed all 5 lectures with notes... Now I'll try to persuade jingoistic friends over east Pakistan
Keep stmy out
Well explained sir
There is no need of any enemy when pakistan friend.
Dearest sir, Do you take politocal science classe for css ? If yes so plz sir i need contact , and if not plz sir it's an humble request arranged classes 🙏❤
Where did you get the footage from
CZcams.
Great job professor.
A very comprehensive analysis on fall of East Pakistan.
Dear sir, you are a brave person and a rare personality who speaks unbiased truth. I am extremely benefited from your five episodes. Please keep your spirit high and educate people to appreciate and contemplate the truth and learn from mistakes. Thank you from Bangladesh.
shamsul wares thank you
Great lecture series sir! Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it. Thanks for providing such a factual analysis. I hope you'll continue such highly informative lecture series (on other topics) in coming future. Thanks again!
Gd one sir
Sir your great
And what I learned from all of your lectures, not one single person can be blamed but entire policy.( racism?? Language, political supremacy?? ).
Great lecture.... It's a request please also make more lectures on das Kapital...
Thank you so much Sir for this very informative series……I am not going to say that I enjoyed this program BUT we must face the facts and we must learn from our mistakes……Bulochistan and other smaller provinces are on my mind now …..😢
Sir plz make lecture on political science subject css point of view.
We Bangladeshis can never forget what happened in 1971. But if Pakistan wants to improve relations with Bangladesh in the future, it is being heard now that Pakistan wants to improve relations with Bangladesh. Then Pakistan should first of all apologize to Bangladesh. Which Pakistan has never wanted on its own.
Bro ! I was not born at that time. But I apologise to you. Khush rho.. stay blessed.. "Hum kaay thehree ajnaabi , itni mulakaatoan kaay baad...
brother i say sorry to you and all bangladesh 😊
Qoum sharminda ha
But still West Pakistan didn't learn a thing from this mournful event
I apologise on the behalf of subject
My baba still tells me how awaam used to weap when they came to know about the separation of east Pakistan
Root level Civilians still dont have anything against bengalis
We apologise
@@sameeralmas1088 yes Sameer! I meet several bengalis , they are so kind. In middle east they hardwork too much, some odd jobs. But they are good. In my office I talked to him and I want to say sorry to my bengali driver, office boy. One days I talked and tell me very gently ❤️ the misbehave of our army and politician. Dr Qadir khan, roidaar khan, Mustansar hussain tatar, Roidaar khan, ashgar khan,khursheed kasori, Imran khan and many more admitted our faults. Still some Pakistani used word bengali as a ridiculous way. Shane on you guys, u still did not learn and same behave with Muhajirs Urdu speaking.
@@sameeralmas1088 agree
Well done.
excellant presentation...i was eye witness of the situation from indian border town haldibari.
Lectures full of information
بہترین لکچر ۔ جناب سلامت رہو۔