East-Pakistan to Bangladesh | Part 3
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 06. 2020
- Why did Pakistan have seven Prime Ministers within the first eleven years? Why were twenty-two provincial cabinets dismissed or forced to resign (five in East Bengal, four in Punjab, four in NWFP, and eight in Sindh)?
Find out how the constitutional crisis from 1947-58 not only created the conditions for martial-law but eroded the support for Pakistan within East Bengal.
Next part: • East-Pakistan to Bangl... - Hudba
Thanks sir...
The history of pakistan is very important in our Bangladesh history...
Thanks a lots....
From Bangladesh
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩Thanks a lots....
From Bangladesh
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Can u tell us bengladesh history 1971 to 2022
@@seeminoor7328 well there is something i know after mujeeb got to bangladesh he was killed by army and marshal law was established but i think over theyears the hovernment formed and their leader was selected a lady who is still their leader to this day thats as far as i know
It's a very good analysis. Kudos, to Dr. Rahman, because even in Bangladesh we have not analyzed the period of 1947 to 1971 in some ways the way he did.
RUBBYAT NAWAZ thank you
What did learnt is important for world
Otherwise Islamic thought will again finish the world
Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩 love our nation father Sheikh Mujibur Rahman 😍😍😍😍
Indian pretending to be a Bangladeshi
@@Faizain2pk their name is clearly written in the Bengali script
Mashallah love Bangladesh love Pakistan
@@amjadnawaz7200 nothing difference between India and Pakistan both are same when it comes to Bengalis both of you consider us inferior than you be it past, present
@@nitishsaxena1372 people of West Bengal can also speak Bangla
After watching the series , Many of the hypothetical views and rumors on my mind is now solved or wear off.
Thanks for making such videos to learn the history and not repeat it.
Sir Taimur, I am really glad and honored that I have met you in Sindh University ❤❤❤
what a great knowledge exposed .....historical facts with figures and information.
Man, you are great. I only think of the hard work you put in. Thank you.
Thank u sir for uploading this clip; I was waiting very pationetly. So thank you Sir
thank you sir, hope, u will made more analysis videos on this topic.
Love from 🇧🇩
Do you believe India helped you directly or Indirectly?
Thank you dr taimur for these videos!!
Sir, I am listening to your words from Bangladesh. You are impressive!
I feel very gloominess when I listen about the fall of east Pakistan we failed to give them there rights I m teenager but I think that most of the demands of Bengalis were right our leaders should talk with them instead of taking strict actions😓
Thanks for your positive feedback
Brother, that time I was a final year examinee of Dhaka University. This gentleman as a scholar discussing all in detail., highly appreciateable.
Former Pakistan was a unique country in world map that command our strong patriotism and honestly we whole heartedly met the demands in our distress ful living.
The country was split up Only for brutality of west pak army, where their presence on the road was enough.
Yahya and his brutal general made the plea t of armed rebellion, killed hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians mostly Muslims as Hindus fled to India with out delay. , Armed rebellion was 100 percent falsehood, from their operation they could not recover a single bullet from our possession...
Those west pak criminal military of 1971, compelled our people to fight against for their mass killing, rapimg, looting burning of houses
We aged people feel for former Pakistan, that destroyed West Pakistani military also they destroyed us.
.
Well articulated to the point, Being a student of history and politics i couldn't find anything out of context. Stay blessed. ❤
What did you leant is most important for world
Islam has ruined the world again and again
Sir your hardwork and dedication has earned you very good name.
i you sir From Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩
apkah video may sachchai hai,
Good analysis sir JazakAllah
Thanks dear sir... I am your biggest fan....
Excellent
Very good knowledge
Thank you sir . Keep uploading . We are still waiting for das capital s remaining lectures❤
Very well sir
your political analysis from 1947 to Dec 1971 is very nice your comparison specially ecomic figure is very excellent I want to know that where you got your basic education and your PhD education pl inform
Thanks sir very informative video ........we wait for your videos sir
When I get more hits, then I make more videos. Share karo na. It takes enormous time to make these videos. My only reward is to know that people are watching them.
@@Taimur_LaalDear Sir,
You created this video three years ago, and I am watching it now. You should know that people will continue to watch informative videos like this because they never become outdated. Therefore, I kindly request that you continue making such videos for us. Thanks a lot for ur efforts ❤❤
Watching your this video series after your suggestion in your latest video regarding the BLA bomb blast in karachi. You're the best teacher I've ever come across in my life I must say.
Thank you 💜
Thank you Sir
کامریڈ، اگر آپ اپنے لیکچرز کے ساتھ بکس کا حوالہ دے یا ریسرچ کا سورس بتا دیا کریں تو بہت مہربانی ہوگی۔
شکریہ۔
very well effort sir but at 2:30 given map has shown iok as part of india which is not
brother historycal subject ...thanks
Nice Sir plz make one video on critical theory in ir
I am from the south Indian state Kerala. If Pakistan was not founded ( with 2 wings )in 1947 there can never be a Bangladesh in 1971.
Great analysis of politics in Pakistan in initial decades of Independence.....Thanks sir....
Really sir your this pahal gives great insights on politics economy and society of the Subcontinent.... I love your videos...
Great love to you Sir ... From India...
Dactar saab bhttt mehrabani
Geographical distance was not problem. Panjabi aor urdu speaking muhajiron ka mulk thaa Pakistan. Bengali peoples are not treated as citizens of Pakistan. East Pakistan ko muhajiron se aabad karne ka mansuba thaa Pakistan govt ka. Genocide of bengali peoples continued upto surrendering of pak military. Only Punjabi Were qualified for defence service. Pathan Belochi sindhi and Bengali peoples were not qualified for defence service.
Throughout the history one may hate one character.... Iskandar Mirza....
A real life descendent of Mir Jafar.....
Search wikipedia to know who Mir Jafar was ......
A realistic restatement of most significant politico historical events of Pakistan.
میں اب تک نہیں سمجھ پایا کہ لوگ سیاست کو لیکر اتنے سنجیدہ کیوں ہوتے ہیں
Iskander Mirza was descendant of Mir Zafar.
Build a 20 mile wide corridor from Lahore to Dhaka. India will provide land and China will build road and railway line. 18:54 Ghandhi's last wish.🙏 🙏
salaam can you do english translation bro as well
❤❤❤
Sir , when will will you upload more lectures on Philosophy ?
Working on them. Soon.
dr, sir apne jis andaj aur mathodology basis tazjyah pesh kiya ager yeh surarath syasi danishwar qalamdan smaj lete pakistan tarihi tur per ala maqam pe hute .ummate mulimah ki hysyat se ham pak se behad muhabbat kertenhin . hyhat hyhat........
Right from the beginning, Popular leaders in Pakistan labeled as "Gaddar" by the establishment. AKM Fazlul Haque, who had the largest popular vote bank, who supposed to be the first elected PM of Pakistan, was labeled as the First Gaddar/Security risk.
Sir plxx make more vedio for pakistan history pllxx plxx plx sir
❤
tamour sir what about the unique geography of pakistan?dunnya main aisa kon sa mulk hai k jis ka 2sra part itna doure ho k hawi jahaz 3 ghanty urnay k baad apnay 2sray part tk phonchay?
I have covered that in the first episode of this series on Bangladesh.
America hai bhai ..aur uska state alaska !!
@@jumper030281 aray bahi Karachi to dahaka ki flight aaj bhe bowing k through 3 ghantay ki hai puray india sy uper 3 ghanty safer karna parta hai
Time for Bangladesh to apologize to Pakistan and make a new union of Pakistan and Bangladesh
It is very easy to incite and create hatred among religious line but very difficult to create brotherhood and humanity on religious line .
Pak hmy muslim league nahe bilkeh angrezo ke colonialist policy ke wajah Mila bilkeh deya gaya
یے ویڈیو سمجھنے کے لیے مجھے کم سے کم چار مرتبہ دیکھنی ہوگی
سر تیمور مشرق پاکستان سے بنگلہ دیش تک آپ کی کتاب آردو میں دستیاب ہے ؟
I have only made video lectures on this topic. I have not written a book either in English or in Urdu.
@@Taimur_Laal apka koi b book hai jo apne khud lika ho agar hai to hamko batao ham ko buhattt pasand ayga
This content should be in Matric instead of Social Studies. Social Studies is poison to brain.
WELL SAID SIR WE people are selfish
Mr. Rahman, I disagree with you on one piece of information which I either you are not aware of or ignored. Can I have your email address.
i too haha, check my other comment, is it in your mind ?
What a shame!!!!
It doesnt mean if a country is islamic republic then other religions will feel supressed because of it. You can also let them live their life as well as they want
That's why forced conversions in Sindh province
East Pakistan were more religious
Sir Lahore Resolution was presented by Zafrullah khan not by FazlulHaq, here you are misleading your viewers. And ZafrUllah made this resolution by the order of voiceroys of that time of Subcontinent.
Umar Shah no. It was drafted by Zafrullah Khan and presented by Fazlul Haq.
another one is that 'British clolonials give us Pakistan becuase of their Divide and Rule Policy, but not by the struggle of Jinnah and their friends.
i hope you will agree with my comment.
Who created divisions between Irish, French, Germans, Scottish etc? Having multiple nations isn't problematic. It can actually be healthy as it allows better development and prevents the chances of civil wars. India has much better economy than us but still scores much worse on hunger index than us.
Nd Hindustan absolutely wasn't united before British rule. In today's India, there's extreme hate towards Muslims. India committed Sikh genocide. There's extreme hatred towards dalits. Are British responsible for it?
Its sad how gullible our people are. Please stop buying Braham narrative.
People's Republic of Pakistan west Pakistan Bangla Republic of Pakistan East Pakistan solve problems
Muslim league accept cabinet mission with weak center because they knew with weak center india can be broken easily but when they got pakistan they want to make strong center so that they can keep diversed pakistan united. Here muslim laegue and jinnah play double stradard. So nehru and congress was right to reject cabinet mission. Thats why nehru rejcted cabinet mission which proposes weak center. Because nehru knew india needed strong center to keep india united.
Sir don't you get Fatwaa's from Mullaa's and Allegations + harassment from ISI?
Faraz Thinks all the time.
@@Taimur_Laal Sir there is no video on your channel that I haven't watched
Aap ney ji Sharia aur Fiqah py 5 lectures kiye... An year ago, mjhy sab kici Yahoodi agent ki batein lag rahi thee'n 😂😂 ( Not my fault you know🤐💯)
Mn ny ek month pehly again sunee'n, mjhy ek ek word kici barey Scholar ka experience laga
Mjhy ye btayen... Hum apne country ko kesay change karein? Abhi to mere achay khasay opponents peda ho gye after promoting left wing ideology on my Social accounts... Ye log samjhain gy kab? Jo humara academic system, esay to hum kbhi bhi move on nhi kr skein gy
@@farazthinks1209 meray pyaray dost. Jaisay aap samjhain hain. Aisay hi dosray bhi samjhain gay. Waqt lagay ga. Mehnat karni parray gi.
@@Taimur_Laal Sir mn khud BS Mass Communication kr raha hon... In topics py discussions hoti rehti hain to ek argument ye aata hai k Communism Islam k totally against hai...
Aur k China and Russia are one nation countries... Naa Pakistan jitni cultural diversity hai naa religion itna strong hai... Balky udr hai hi nhi... Iss liye Pakiatan mn Socialism possible nhi hai... We need USA's type of democratic Capitalist system... Provinces ko authorities dein aur States bnaa dein USA ki tarah... Yehi only best possible solution hai
Aap iss topic pey koi lecture ker skty hn?
@@farazthinks1209 USSR was more diverse than Pakistan. Pakistan has 4 major nations, USSR had 15. The socialist solution to the national question is the complete equality of all nations including right of nations to self-determination. Can't think of any state that gives that much autonomy.
What a circus
یہ بیچارہ ابھی تک اسٹبلېشمنت کا کیس پلے کررھے ہیں تاریخ یہ ھے ھی نہیں
Pakistan should follow Islamic democracy
Punjabion ki gulami kay liye pakistan nehi banaya thaa. Azadi Bangladeshi awam ka haq thaa. Bangladesh ka income west pakistan kay development expenditure. Deprived Bangladesh from fundamental rights. East Bengal was a coloney of west pakistan.
Why liaqut Ali Khan assassinated? Do you know budget of pakistan from 1947 to 1971? Do you know massive genocide of Bengali peoples by pak military? Pakistan air force dropped bombs in rural area of Bangladesh. Naval gun boats passing firing into both side of river.
Yeah to shkhsiyat me he tora he Bhutto me I'd her him usher tum kha thaa
Mujibur Rahman or Awami League did not split Pakistan . Actually Pakistan was broken by four power greedy people Yahya, Bhutto, General Hamid and Pirzada.
In 1971, I left out the trial of the genocide and crimes against humanity committed by the Pakistani army in Bangladesh. At least the new generation of Pakistan should, in their own interest, posthumously prosecute this four person for (1) disintegration of Pakistan, (2) imposing war on an unarmed nation (3) humiliating defeat and (4) for failure to protect the integrity of Pakistan.
Hey bro! blaming only India for the breakup of Pakistan is absurd and ridiculous. It is natural that India will take advantage of the opportunity. Because the rule of the world is
An enemy of an enemy becomes a friend" and a friend of an enemy becomes an enemy.
Therefore, you should posthumously prosecute those who were in power in Pakistan at the time for failure to protect integrity of Pakistan and for disrespecting the verdict of the majority of the people of Pakistan.
Pakistan was enemy of Bangladesh. Azadi Bangladeshi awam ka haq thaa. 1600 KM distance ka mulk thaa Bangladesh. Andaman and Nikober island is part of india.
Ya banda khud communist ha magar ethnic nationalism ko support karta ha ! Contradictory
I don't support ethnic nationalism at all. What gave you that impression? I am arguing that the best way to end ethnic natioanlism is by ending discrimination based on ethnicity and/or nationalities.
@@Taimur_Laal sir tou Sindhi aur pashtun leftist ka bara ma Ap ka kaya khayal ha .... Jab k left k movement tou ethnic ground ko negate karti han ! ..
@@asfundmuzammil8167 as I have already explained, I believe in the unity of all humanity regardless of race, religion, gender, or caste.
@@Taimur_Laal I wonder how people develop this beautiful mindset. I mean itni basic baat samjha itna mushkil keo hai logo k liaye
It's a very good analysis. Kudos, to Dr. Rahman, because even in Bangladesh we have not analyzed the period of 1947 to 1971 in some ways the way he did.