Nikiya vs Gamzatti (Komleva and Terekhova)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 09. 2010
  • Fight scene from Bayadere between the best Gamzatti and one of the best Nikiyas - Tatiana Terekhova and Gabriella Komleva.
    Kirov Mariinsky Ballet 1977.
  • Hudba

Komentáře • 34

  • @Bnesque
    @Bnesque Před 14 lety +5

    This is a rare intense dramatic moment of the ballet. their charaterization, powerbalance is almost perfect. Every small moment has critical meaning.
    When can we see this magnitude of Bayadere again?

  • @karenofbethany
    @karenofbethany Před 14 lety +1

    One of my favorite scenes. I have watched it in all the versions. I like Marianela Nunez' acting. She has a convincing face and style.

  • @germannf347
    @germannf347 Před 2 lety +2

    Блистательная Терехова!!!

  • @iskander21024
    @iskander21024 Před 13 lety +5

    @Pearlaceous Yes, Altynay and Tatyana danced in La Bayadere very often. I never missed any performance with them - I loved and still love both of them and ,no doubt, I will never forget those nights at the Kirov: as a rule, they both were fantastic. Each of them wanted to be superior and the audience went crazy! What a pity that we can return to those moments - really unforgettable - only in our memory!

    • @user-ht5rw9oi3m
      @user-ht5rw9oi3m Před měsícem

      Гораздо чаще танцевали Терехова и Галя Мезенцева кроме Комлевой. Помним те времена! Прекрасные, любимые! Как жаль, что Галя не записана в партии Никии! А какая тут красавица, кстати, Аннэлина Каширина в роли невольницы Айи!

    • @iskander21024
      @iskander21024 Před měsícem

      Пересчитаем?

  • @Pearlaceous
    @Pearlaceous Před 13 lety +2

    @iskander21024 Thank you for telling me this! You were so lucky to have seen them both together in Bayadere! It's wonderful that the Vaganova has Altynai and the Mariinsky has Tatyana to pass on their wisdom to the new generation of dancers.

  • @Pearlaceous
    @Pearlaceous Před 14 lety +1

    Just wondering if Terekhova ever danced Gamzatti to Asylmuratova's Nikiya? Now that would have been worth seeing. Altynai was/is my favourite Nikiya.

  • @Pearlaceous
    @Pearlaceous Před 14 lety +1

    Goodness me, yes, Terekhova's acting as Gamzatti is wonderful here - so subtle and complex. And Komleva's Nikiya gets the nearest I've seen to actually stabbing her!

  • @Pearlaceous
    @Pearlaceous Před 14 lety

    @SuperBalletgirl101 Yes - Marianela is a very good actress with strong technique. And yet another another example of a great RB Principal who is not British! Thank goodness we have them. Where are all our Great British principals!

  • @Bnesque
    @Bnesque Před 13 lety

    @opensecret51 This is like Crash Of The Titans in Mariinsky. Great moment!

  • @Pearlaceous
    @Pearlaceous Před 13 lety +1

    @iskander21024 Thank you for replying again! Oh - if *only* I spoke Russian! Thank you so much for this information and I will try to find the site and watch the films, even if I can't understand them! :-)

  • @mariinskyfan
    @mariinskyfan Před 14 lety

    @looovecats I would like to see Somova as Gamzatti, but she would never backtrack after dancing Nikiya for so long. Osipova would be nice as a guest Gamzatti. Petushkova would be interesting...

  • @pediatrapaola
    @pediatrapaola Před 14 lety

    @Qbendanny very strong caracter really

  • @iskander21024
    @iskander21024 Před 13 lety

    @Pearlaceous I am very sorry to be intrusive but if You really love Altynay You cаn see my very short film ( 10 minutes ) about her on the site Leningrad tv. ru under the titleТелефонд - the film is called " Дуэт". You can also find there my film about Vaganva Academy ( in Russian, naturally ) with long interviews with Altynay and other teachers - it is called "Триумф классики" (The Triumph of The Classic" ). Sorry.

  • @Bnesque
    @Bnesque Před 14 lety

    @looovecats That could be a epic! Selina's dramatic ability should not be wasted in the small roles.

  • @mariinskyfan
    @mariinskyfan Před 14 lety

    @looovecats I saw Golub as Gamzatti in 2008 in D.C. She was awesome, IMO.

  • @maestros17
    @maestros17 Před 11 lety

    my fav was Galina Mezentseva -Nikiya , Terekhova-Gamzatti ,Zaklinsky-Solor

  • @SuperBalletgirl101
    @SuperBalletgirl101 Před 14 lety

    @looovecats I think Novikova could be a good Gamzatti. Has she done it before?

  • @Pearlaceous
    @Pearlaceous Před 14 lety

    @looovecats I would like to nominate Victoria Brilova as Gamzatti to Stepanova's Nikiya! She has that beautiful regal, steely look, technique and line...

  • @looovecats
    @looovecats  Před 14 lety

    @mariinskyfan
    Lucky you!
    So it wasn't her debut this year, my mistake.

  • @mariinskyfan
    @mariinskyfan Před 14 lety

    @looovecats It's fun to make wishes, even when they are far-fetched.

  • @looovecats
    @looovecats  Před 14 lety

    @russianballetvideo
    Yes, only one dancer now would match Terekhova's Gamzatti. Too bad that when she will dance Nikiya she wouldn't have equally great Gamzatti, unless there's one already somwhere in the corps de ballet but we don't know about her yet. There are some dancers I'd like to see as Gamzatti but I can't say if they would be so great.

  • @palubob
    @palubob Před 14 lety

    Yes, probably the best-acted cat-fight ever captured on film. Also, Terekhova's dancing in Act II was memorable, but the same can't be said for this entire performance. Solor was forgettable and we have quite a few better Nikiyas since.

  • @Pearlaceous
    @Pearlaceous Před 14 lety

    @looovecats I'm thinking Somova and Tereshkina might not like playing second fiddle to a "mere" corps de ballet ballerina! :-) Another corps de ballet girl as Gamzatti would make more sense!

  • @looovecats
    @looovecats  Před 14 lety

    @mariinskyfan
    Somova could be interesting, and Tereshkina too. I've read that Golub made very promising debut as Gamzatti this year. And I'd like to see beautiful Kolegova.

  • @Pearlaceous
    @Pearlaceous Před 14 lety

    @looovecats It's a shame - but yes, I think Selina would be a little small ... unless she played up the spoilt Daddy's little girl element!!

  • @looovecats
    @looovecats  Před 14 lety

    @Pearlaceous
    I know that Somova and Tereshkina are Nikiyas now and not likely to be Gamzatti. But can't we make a wish? :-)

  • @looovecats
    @looovecats  Před 14 lety

    @SuperBalletgirl101
    Yes, she did. Good dancing but acting could be better. She was rather sad than proud, strong and self-confident.

  • @looovecats
    @looovecats  Před 14 lety

    @Pearlaceous
    Interesting idea but I think Selina could do better. Maybe she would be better match to Vishneva-Nikiya.
    (by the way, I love this Gamzatti discussion!)

  • @Bnesque
    @Bnesque Před 14 lety

    @looovecats Kolegova vs Stepanova would be a nice battle!

  • @Bnesque
    @Bnesque Před 14 lety

    @russianballetvideo It was a really weird experience wicked older woman tormenting beautiful good natured Anastasia!

  • @SuperBalletgirl101
    @SuperBalletgirl101 Před 14 lety

    I think that Marianela Nunez of the royal ballet is an amazing Gamzatti.

  • @looovecats
    @looovecats  Před 14 lety

    @Pearlaceous
    My two Gamzatti types are Frolova and Tiliguzova. I'd love to see Selina too but I think she would be too small for Stepanova.